Chimera Investment Corporation (CIM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 2, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Real Estate Mortgage Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) earnings 23 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Victor Falvo

executive
#1

Thanks, operator, and I appreciate all of you joining us for Chimera's earnings conference call covering the third quarter of 2023. Prior to getting started, I want to go over the safe harbor statements. On this call, forward-looking statements will be made, meaning predictions, projections, or other remarks regarding future events. Such statements rest on present expectations and assumptions that carry risks and uncertainties, all of which are described in the Risk Factors section included in our latest annual and quarterly SEC filings. Actual events and results could differ materially from those forward-looking statements. We urge you to review the forward-looking statement disclaimer contained in our earnings release, along with our quarterly and annual filings. Also, non-GAAP financial measures may be discussed today. For a reconciliation to the most comparable GAAP measures, please see our SEC filings and earnings supplement. In addition, what is said on this conference call could include time-sensitive information that holds true only as of the date of this earnings call; we do not undertake and specifically disclaim any obligation to update or revise this information. I'll now hand the call over to our Chief Executive Officer, Phil Kardis.

Phil Kardis

executive
#2

Hello everyone, and thanks for joining us for Chimera Investment Corporation's call covering the third quarter of 2023. On the line with me today are Choudhary Yarlagadda, who serves as our President, Chief Operating Officer and co-CIO, along with Subra Viswanathan, our Chief Financial Officer, Dan Thakkar, our co-CIO, and Vic Falvo, who leads our Capital Markets. Once I finish my comments, Subra will walk through the financial results, and after that we'll take your questions. First, I want to welcome two new people to Chimera. Susan Mills was elected to our board of directors, effective November 13. She most recently joined Academy Securities, which is a veteran-owned investment bank. Prior to that role, she worked at Citibank for 36 years, holding a range of senior management roles in businesses tied to North American residential mortgages. Her depth of knowledge and experience in the residential mortgage market is substantial, and we couldn't be happier to have her on the team. In addition, Miyun Sung will come aboard next week as our Chief Legal Officer. Her legal career spans more than 23 years, covering both external counsel and in-house positions. For the past seven plus years, she served as Senior Vice President, Chief Legal Officer, and Secretary of Urstadt Biddle Properties, Inc., an equity REIT listed on the New York Stock Exchange. We're thrilled that she's joining us. Turning to the third quarter, the fixed income market saw both greater volatility and rising rates. In July, the Federal Reserve raised its Fed Funds target rate by 25 basis points, which was in line with expectations. And although the Fed held off on rate hikes at its September meeting, it trimmed its projected rate cuts for 2024 by half, meaning 50 basis points. The subsequent move higher on the long end of the yield curve pushed the ten-year Treasury rate up 73 basis points across the quarter, to 4.57%. That ten-year yield kept rising after the quarter closed and touched 5% briefly in mid-October. These elevated interest rates have modestly lowered the value of our portfolio; our GAAP book value per share fell quarter-over-quarter, from $7.29 to $6.90, which is a decline of 5.4%. Given the market backdrop, we stayed cautious and largely on the sidelines, so our investment portfolio was relatively flat for the quarter. That said, we kept our attention on liquidity and liability management. During the quarter, we brought on three new repo counterparties, and after the quarter ended, we refinanced a high fixed rate, non-mark-to-market facility into a new two-year limited mark-to-market facility. Over the next 12 months, we anticipate this facility will reduce our interest expense by roughly $16 million. So what's our outlook? As we look toward the fourth quarter and into 2024, we're planning for rates to stay high. Inflation has come down since last year, but it's still well above the Fed's 2% target, and while the Fed seems to be approaching the end of its hiking cycle, the recent data appears to justify one more rate hike. The U.S. The job market is still robust, third quarter GDP rose to just about 5%, and in September, consumer spending went up by more than anticipated. Beyond the Fed Funds Rate staying elevated throughout 2024, we're also seeing long-term rates climb fairly quickly, which several things have driven, among them the economy's strength and the Fed postponing rate cuts. On top of that, the federal deficit expanding along with the interest expenses tied to it, combined with worries regarding China's and Japan's involvement in Treasury auctions, plus the Fed essentially doing quantitative tightening, has produced supply and demand mismatches, and those mismatches have contributed to pushing long-term rates upward — and in our view, for a longer stretch. As a matter of fact, we can't rule out a persistent rise in 10-year Treasury yields past 5%. This year's home sales pace looks like it will be the slowest since the Great Financial Crisis. Prices for homes staying high, housing inventory being limited, and mortgage rates sitting at elevated levels together form a trio of obstacles, which keeps the housing affordability crisis going. Beyond volatility tied to data, there's also a growing danger of a government shutdown and an intensifying Middle East war, either of which could make capital markets even more volatile. So how are we approaching this? We keep running our business based on the conviction that interest rates — short and long term alike — are going to stay higher for longer. Strengthening our balance sheet and handling our liabilities stay at the center of what we do. To assist in lowering the different risks that come with recourse financing, we often pursue longer dated maturities, secure non- or limited mark-to-market terms, and make use of financial derivatives like swaps, swaptions, and futures contracts to lessen the effect of rates going up. Thanks to these efforts, across the first nine months of 2023, we've cut our recourse financing by over $800 million. Non- or limited mark-to-market financing covers 57% of the recourse financing we have outstanding. We've hedged $1 billion, which is around half of our floating rate financings, at a weighted average swap rate of 3.26%. We hold $1.5 billion in swaptions, giving the company the right to pay a fixed rate of 3.56% for one year, starting in the second quarter of 2024. Despite this higher rate setting, our assets keep performing nicely. Our interest income is roughly flat both quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year. When it comes to credit, our portfolio has performed better than what we initially expected from our investments. We think our portfolio stands apart. Roughly $11 billion of reperforming loans, featuring low LTVs and an average seasoning of 17 years, back the majority of our securitizations, and we anticipate those will keep performing well across a variety of economic conditions. Our securitizations keep delevering, and subject to future interest rates, we'll have the ability to terminate and pull out cash at the right moment. Alongside our emphasis on liability management and liquidity, we plan to optimize our investment portfolio, and we'll look for chances to buy assets that boost our returns and liquidity. Lastly, so that we can strengthen our liquidity and be better situated to pursue investment opportunities, our dividend has been cut down to an amount in line with what we anticipate earning by the close of next year. In this macroeconomic climate, resetting the dividend strikes us as prudent and serves the long-term interests of our shareholders best. Conditions in today's market are difficult, yet we stay optimistic regarding what lies ahead. Strong performance continues across our portfolio, in both credit and income generation. Our securitizations keep delevering: 14 deals can be called in 2023, an additional four turn callable in 2024, and six more in 2025. As our financing costs come down, we expect our economic performance to improve considerably; the steps we're taking strike us as prudent and will benefit Chimera shareholders over the long term. I'll hand the call to Subra now so he can review our financial results.

Subra Viswanathan

executive
#3

Thanks, Phil. I'll walk through the key financial results for Chimera in Q3 2023. At the close of the third quarter, GAAP book value stood at $6.90 per share, while our economic return on that GAAP book value came in at -2.9%, calculated from the quarter-over-quarter change in book value plus the Q3 dividend paid on each common share. Looking at the first nine months of the year, economic return was 0%, measured by the shift in book value from year-end plus dividends on common shares across the first three quarters. GAAP net loss for Q3 totaled $16.3 million, equal to $0.07 per share. Measured as earnings available for distribution, net income for the third quarter was roughly $29 million, which works out to $0.13 per diluted common share. Economic net interest income in Q3 reached $66 million. During the third quarter, average interest-earning assets yielded 5.8%. Our funds carried an average cost of 4.5%, producing an interest spread of 1.3%. Total leverage in Q3 was 4.1 to one, and recourse leverage finished the quarter at one to one. Turning to financing and liquidity: the company closed the quarter with $606 million in total cash plus unencumbered assets; on our outstanding repo arrangements, $1.5 billion carried either non- or limited mark-to-market features; floating rate exposure on our outstanding repo liabilities was $1.9 billion; as a hedge against our liabilities, we held a $1 billion pay fixed interest rate swap at 3.26%. We also held $1.5 billion in swaptions to pay fixed for one year starting in Q2 2024, at an average rate of 3.56%, as a hedge for liabilities. For the quarter, economic net interest income return on equity was 10.4%, while GAAP return on average equity was 0.3%. Finally, Q3 2023 expenses, once servicing fees and transaction expenses are excluded, came to $12.6 million, a bit below the second quarter. That wraps up our remarks, and now we'll take questions.

Stephen Laws

executive
#4

Hello there, and good morning. Phil, I wanted to pick up on a few points from your earlier comments — specifically, I believe you mentioned staying rather careful and largely on the sidelines. Could you speak to whether you feel satisfied with the liquidity you have right now, which comes across as fairly defensive? How are you weighing your willingness to buy back more shares, or perhaps do something different within your capital structure? And if you choose to put that capital to work aggressively, what kind of returns are you seeing on fresh investments?

Phil Kardis

executive
#5

Hey Stephen, appreciate you asking that. So, at this moment, our liquidity situation is something we feel good about, but given that rates are staying elevated for a longer stretch, we figure it makes sense to strengthen our liquidity. When we think through what takes priority, liquidity is what we're focused on first right now. In the near term, we believe some investment opportunities will present themselves to us, and to the degree we've got the liquidity available, we'd want to put it to work then. Then we also consider buying back stock, whether that's common or preferred, depending on a range of factors. But for the near term at least, that's likely our third choice. Our attention is more on liquidity and potential investments. And we believe those are... And I'll hand it over to Dan, who can speak to where some of those opportunities are showing up.

Dan Thakkar

executive
#6

Yes, absolutely. Dan Thakkar here. Regarding where we see opportunities, our main capital deployments, as we see it, will go toward non-QM — particularly DSCRs, BPLs, and Jumbo Prime, insofar as we can source it. Through those securitizations, we aim for mid-teens returns. I should note that when it comes to securitization economics, conditions are quite steady, above all in non-QM, with freshly originated high gross WAC loans carrying coupons of roughly 8.5%. That being said, on recent deals, the AAAs are pricing in the high 100s. During the third quarter, we observed mid 100s, so further underperformance in that area would compress the spreads. That makes us quite wary. Naturally, the widening we've witnessed on non-QM AAAs has expanded alongside Agency RMBS; as a result, it looks fairly steady and attractive right now, yet it could shift for the worse very fast given the macro backdrop we're facing. I'm not certain whether that addresses your question.

Stephen Laws

executive
#7

Yes, that's useful detail. Thanks for the commentary. I just wanted to confirm one point. I believe you referenced $16 million in interest expense savings stemming from the refinancing of a higher cost facility. A $0.06-$0.07 annual benefit. Is that accurate, or does something offset it elsewhere?

Phil Kardis

executive
#8

Well, I believe, um, yeah. What I mean is, that figure is what we anticipate we'll be able to save; however, um, as I'm sure you know, early on in the coming year, 2 of our preferreds are set to switch from fixed to floating. Or at least, that's our expectation, given what we currently know about how the federal law applies to those specific instruments. So, I think, when you consider all this, we feel that this financing—this refinancing—has been quite beneficial for us, though it's really going to be largely canceled out by what we anticipate will occur with our preferred stock.

Stephen Laws

executive
#9

Gotcha. Great; that makes sense. Thanks very much.

Trevor Cranston

analyst
#10

Hello, and thanks. Good morning to everyone. Could you share some perspective on conditions within the bulk loan market, especially as they relate to banks? And also, are you observing any meaningful rise in volume coming from institutions that want to move before new regulations take effect? Thank you.

Phil Kardis

executive
#11

Yeah, I think at this moment, you know, as far as the bulk goes, there isn't much we're seeing; we have to, you know, hold off until the term facility concludes, so given the present circumstances, that hasn't really been a space we've been, you know, putting much attention on right now.

Trevor Cranston

analyst
#12

All right, understood. Then regarding that loan facility you refinanced — shifting it away from the non-mark-to-market structure over to a limited mark-to-market one — could you go into a bit more detail about what actually changed in that facility's terms, specifically around the protections that give you folks? And beyond that, perhaps you could say whether you see additional chances right now to refinance any of your remaining facilities into something with a lower cost. Thanks.

Phil Kardis

executive
#13

Right. So for us, this was a big facility when it came to what we wanted to do with refinancing it. It was a facility with a longer term, and that gave us the chance to refinance once a year had passed. And because of where we could secure financing, doing it at this point was logical. I think, on a few of the specific terms, since this happened after the quarter closed, we'll provide additional detail in our upcoming statements that will walk through it. But it does involve a limited Mark-to-Market along with a rate cap, and that's where we expect the savings to originate, because it sits significantly under where our financing had been. When it comes to other opportunities, at present the market has been operating normally; we can roll. Really the next facility I'd describe as high-cost, where a refinancing opportunity exists, will arrive in early 2025... helpful. Thank you.

Bose George

analyst
#14

Hello, everyone, and good morning. So, what would the additional return on equity be for the fresh capital you're deploying? Also, considering the current yields, assuming interest rates hold steady, at what point does that transition into the updated ROE? I suppose a piece of this involves the expense of refinancing those maturities you mentioned, but yeah, just sort of consider what the portfolio yields would look like if rates basically stay unchanged.

Subra Viswanathan

executive
#15

Okay, so regarding the existing portfolio — this is Subra. I appreciate the question. As I noted in my prepared comments, at present the net economic returns, or ROE, on the portfolio come to roughly 10.4%. That figure leaves out hedge expenses, as well as other administrative items and our G&A and compensation costs, correct? So 10.4% is the number we're observing, and it reflects this high rate environment. Naturally, if you acquire assets generating yields above what we hold now, that 10.4% could rise. That's our situation.

Bose George

analyst
#16

Right, got it. So then, when we talk about reaching a more typical ROE, does that mostly hinge on interest rates declining, or is it more about gradually reworking certain liabilities? Just, yeah, I'm sort of exploring the paths by which this arrives, on a net basis, at a double-digit ROE.

Phil Kardis

executive
#17

Right, it's Phil once more. Like I said, there was a single facility with especially steep costs that we managed to refinance, and the following one isn't due until around the opening month of 2025. So honestly, when it comes to our capacity for financing, specifically reworking expensive debt, a substantial portion of that work is already behind us. What remains will depend on some easing of rates.

Bose George

analyst
#18

All right, excellent. Thank you.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#19

Hi there, thanks a lot. Good morning. I apologize in case I overlooked it, but was there any mention from you folks regarding the book value as it stands now, through October? And then, turning back to liquidity, I mean, how should we properly frame merely the additional liquidity coming in, you know, perhaps each month or each quarter, simply from pay downs, correct? Just the ordinary sort of CPR. Thanks.

Phil Kardis

executive
#20

Oh, my apologies. Phil here. Regarding book value from quarter-end onward, I'll hand things off to Dan Thakkar.

Dan Thakkar

executive
#21

Yeah, yeah, Eric. So in the investor deck we put out last night, I believe we said approximately down to 10%. But because of that big rally we saw in the rates market after the Fed, we're nearer to down, you know, at 2% rather than 3%.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#22

Okay, great.

Phil Kardis

executive
#23

I think you asked relative to pay downs. Is that correct?

Eric Hagen

analyst
#24

Okay, so regarding the liquidity that gets produced on an incremental basis, really just as a result of, well, the ordinary, you know, paydowns.

Phil Kardis

executive
#25

Sure, so at this moment, I'd say the portfolio's pay downs are coming in at roughly six CPR. Hopefully that gives you what you need.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#26

Alright. Yeah, so when it comes to the option value from calling and resecuritizing the portfolio we already hold, how are we looking at that? And really, how sensitive do you think that optionality is to where interest rates go from here?

Phil Kardis

executive
#27

Right, so interest rates do play a role in this. Clearly, when rates go down, the economics improve. Beyond that, it hinges on the pace at which those transactions have been paid down — the senior size, the deal size — since those determine the timing of any refinancing. So all of those considerations come into play, and at present, the longer things remain outstanding, the more favorable that is given the current conditions. And then, clearly, once CPR accelerates, the accretion only grows. So we currently hold this optionality, and in our view it carries a lot of value, though over the short term we intend to stay careful. As rates start to ease, however, we'll examine this with increasing attention.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#28

Fine, got it. Appreciate it, everybody.

Phil Kardis

executive
#29

Thanks. I appreciate all of you joining us for this call on our results for the third quarter, and we're looking forward to talking with you in February on the call about fiscal year 2023.

Operator

operator
#30

That wraps up today's call, and thanks for joining us. You're free to hang up now. Have a great rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Chimera Investment Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Chimera Investment Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Chimera Investment Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.