Chimera Investment Corporation (CIM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 14, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Victor Falvo
executiveThanks, operator, and I appreciate all of you joining us for Chimera's call covering the fourth quarter and the full year 2023 results. Ahead of getting started, let me go through the safe harbor statements. On this call, forward-looking statements will be made, meaning predictions, projections, or other statements regarding events in the future. Such statements rest on present expectations and assumptions that carry risks and uncertainties, and those are described under the Risk Factors section of our latest annual and quarterly SEC filings. Actual events and results could differ materially from those forward-looking statements; we urge you to review the forward-looking statement disclaimer included in our earnings release as well as our quarterly and annual filings. Also, non-GAAP financial measures may come up during today's call. For reconciliation to the most comparable GAAP measures, please see our SEC filings and earnings supplement. In addition, what is said on this conference call might include time-sensitive information and holds accuracy only as of the date of this earnings call. We do not undertake, and specifically disclaim, any obligation to update or revise this information. I'll hand the conference over now to our Chief Executive Officer, Phil Kardis.
Phil Kardis
executiveHello everyone, and thanks for joining us for the Chimera Investment Corporation call covering the fourth quarter and the full year 2023. Joining me on the line are our President, Chief Operating Officer and Co-Chief Investment Officer, Choudhary Yarlagadda; our Co-Chief Investment Officer, Dan Thakkar; our Chief Financial Officer, Subra Viswanathan; and Vic Falvo, who leads Capital Markets and Investor Relations. Once I finish my remarks, Subra will walk through the financial results, and then we'll open things up for your questions. Before anything else, I'd like to recognize Choudhary Yarlagadda, who has let us know he plans to retire. Known affectionately by everyone as C.Y., he has been part of this company since its very beginning. His impact has been felt across the entire company—whether it was designing our securitizations and specialized financing arrangements, or overseeing operations and the information technology teams. Filling that role is no small task, and I have full confidence that our transition will go smoothly with C.Y. on board. It saddens us to see him go, but we're glad for him as he embarks on this new chapter. Our very best wishes go out to C.Y. Reflecting on the past year, Maxine Nightingale's tune "Get Right Back to Where We Started From" comes to mind. At the close of 2022, the 10-year Treasury stood at 3.87%. Then, when 2023 came to an end, the 10-year was at 3.88%. Even though we ended up returning to our starting point, the path we traveled was extremely unpredictable and full of twists. At one stage during the year, in early April, the yield on the 10-year Treasury fell to 3.3%, then climbed to almost 5% by October, and ultimately closed out the year at 3.88%. A full-blown banking crisis was nearly triggered when Silicon Valley Bank, along with a number of other sizable regional banks, collapsed. Four separate interest rate hikes were implemented by the Federal Reserve, amounting to 100 basis points in total, while 30-year mortgage rates peaked at 8% — something that hadn't happened since 2000. On the geopolitical front, the conflict in Ukraine kept grinding along without resolution, and fresh hostilities broke out in the Middle East. Even with those challenging market circumstances, we managed to notch several notable wins over the course of the year; in our view, the portfolio held up nicely amid all the turbulence, which is reflected in interest income for 2023 coming in at $773 million, basically flat versus 2022, while our credit metrics remain on par with or ahead of what we had initially projected at acquisition. We brought our total recourse financing down by roughly $1 billion, and we also refinanced $250 million of expensive debt through a new facility that delivers meaningful savings. We kept executing on our plan to buy mortgage loans and package them into securities. Across 2023, the loans we acquired came to $1.4 billion. Seasoned reperforming loans made up half of that, DSCR investor loans accounted for 33%, and business purpose loans represented the rest. Of the reperforming loans, we securitized $841 million, and of the DSCR loans, $475 million. Six existing deals were called, and we issued four new ones worth a combined $1.2 billion, which let us recapture $133 million. We raised about $74 million by issuing shares through our ATM program. That money is now being deployed into non-Agency securities with high coupons, purchased at a discount, which generate unlevered returns in the low to mid-teens. We've also agreed to acquire roughly $150 million in business purpose loans offering levered returns in the mid-teens. So how do we view 2024? Our stance remains aligned with the Fed's higher-for-longer approach, particularly in light of Chairman Powell's recent remarks, the exceptionally strong January jobs report, and core CPI that came in at 3.9% yesterday — every one of these supports our higher-for-longer perspective. We'd love to see the Fed lower rates before summer arrives, yet our base case assumes reductions happen further out—probably once the election is behind us—followed by additional easing during 2025. Our view is that this is the right time to begin ramping up and acquiring assets with strong yields before those anticipated Fed moves occur. As I mentioned earlier, we are already in the process of adding assets. Beyond that, forward contracts have been executed, loans had to be purchased, and throughout 2024 we anticipate expanding both our forward buying activity and flow arrangements. Furthermore, since cuts are anticipated before the year is out, purchasing loans today and holding them within warehouse facilities until securitization makes more consistent economic sense is a possibility—one that would ultimately generate stronger long-term portfolio returns for us. To wrap up, we had 14 securitizations still outstanding and eligible for calling as of December 2023, plus another 4 that will reach callable status during 2024. A variety of considerations determine when we choose to exercise that call option, which we've covered previously. Worth pointing out is that our non-REMIC transactions carry certain distinctions that set them apart in some ways from the bulk of our securitizations. To illustrate, the better the economics of calling tend to become as the share of loans qualifying for REMIC treatment increases within those deals. Given that rate reductions appear fairly close, I feel good about our prospects going forward. Our team is strong, our assets are excellent, and our business is well defined. At this point, I'll turn it over to Subra, who will walk through our financial results in greater detail.
Subramaniam Viswanathan
executiveThanks, Phil. I'll walk through Chimera's results for Q4 and the entire 2023 fiscal year. On a GAAP basis, net income came to $12 million, equal to $0.05 per share, in Q4; for the whole year, GAAP net income reached $52 million, or $0.23 per share. GAAP book value stood at $6.75 per share when Q4 closed. The decline in value during the quarter came primarily from a modest realized loss tied to asset sales made in that period, along with higher marks on 2 distinct liability facilities and dilution caused by ATM issuance. Our economic return on GAAP book value for Q4 was negative 58 basis points, calculated from the quarterly book value change plus the Q4 dividend on common shares. Across the full year, economic return came in at negative 53 basis points, a figure that reflects $0.70 in dividends declared during 2023. Turning to earnings available for distribution, net income for Q4 totaled $31 million, or $0.13 per share, while the full year figure was $119 million, or $0.51 per share. Economic net interest income was $68 million in Q4 and $271 million across the full year. During Q4, average interest-earning assets yielded 5.9%, our average cost of funds came to 4.4%, and net interest spread was 1.5%. Total leverage in Q4 was 4:1, and recourse leverage closed the quarter at 1:1. On the financing and liquidity side, during the quarter we moved $250 million of high-cost debt into a new facility through refinancing, cutting interest expense by over 600 basis points. At year-end, the company held $599 million in total cash and unencumbered assets; we also had $1.7 billion of floating rate exposure on outstanding repo liabilities. As a hedge against our floating rate liabilities, we held a $1 billion pay-fixed interest rate swap at 3.26%. Those swaps come due in Q2 of 2024. We also held $1.5 billion in swaptions to pay-fixed for 1 year starting in Q2 of 2024, at a weighted average strike rate of 3.56%, hedging our liabilities. On our outstanding repo agreements, $1.5 billion carries either non- or limited mark-to-market features, which amounts to 60% of total recourse funding. For the full year, economic net interest income return on equity was 10.5%. GAAP return on average equity was 4.9%, while EAD return on average equity was 7.2%. Finally, full year 2023 expenses, excluding servicing fees and transaction expenses, totaled $55.7 million, a drop of $16.3 million versus full year 2022, which works out to a 23% year-over-year decrease. That wraps up our remarks; we're now ready to take questions.
Bose George
analystMy first question relates to what you said about the change in book value and the mark on the liability side. Was there no matching mark on the asset side for a portion of those holdings?
Subramaniam Viswanathan
executiveSubra here. I appreciate the question. No, on the whole the portfolio saw a mark-to-market benefit in the quarter. What I pointed out was that there were in fact reasons why certain items caused book value to decline. Yet on the whole, the residential credit portfolio had a sizable mark-to-market gain.
Bose George
analystAll right. So at that point, the actual factors were simply the ATM issuance plus that single realized loss you brought up?
Subramaniam Viswanathan
executiveYes, a realized loss exists; on top of that, there are 2 liability facilities, so to speak. The first is a prime jumbo facility, and it contained a number of embedded swaps, which carried — frankly speaking — a mark that was higher, yet since that higher mark applied to our liability, our book value came out lower; the second factor was that we had 2 — before this, we held 2 unsold securities left over from earlier securitizations, and those had been funded through our repo facilities; during the quarter just ended, we sold them off. As a result, they turned into sec debt. Therefore, for the sec debt, starting when it turned into sec debt and continuing to where we sold it, up to the period-end mark, there was an additional rise in value, and that pulled our book value down.
Bose George
analystAll right. All right. That's useful; and then when it comes to the ATM issuance, what did that average out to price-wise?
Phil Kardis
executiveHold on 1 second. Let me verify that.
Executive
executiveIt's a low 5, confirm the exact. Low 5.
Trevor Cranston
analystSo, to piggyback on what was asked regarding the ATM issuance during this quarter — could you walk us through how you weighed issuing at today's valuation against the possibility of repurchasing shares, and what factors feed into that choice?
Phil Kardis
executiveAbsolutely. As we noted earlier, with an eye on Fed rate cuts arriving later this year and chances to pick up higher-coupon assets at a discount, our view was that the present moment was right for it. On a current basis, these assets exceed what's needed to cover the dividend tied to that stock, and they offer potential upside once rates start declining. So we felt this was an opportune time to move forward and acquire assets of this kind.
Trevor Cranston
analystOkay. And when it comes to adding more assets, with 2024 arriving before any rate reductions, could you discuss the amount of unrestricted capital you believe is at your disposal for that purpose — through putting existing cash to work as opposed to perhaps relying on additional capital raises to acquire fresh assets in the near term?
Phil Kardis
executiveYes, certainly. So what we'd examine is — a few different sources might exist. Obviously, we hold cash, and how much of that cash along with other liquidity we'd be prepared to deploy will depend on, sort of, our read of market swings and interest rates. And once those decline, we could see putting a portion of it toward new assets. Also, as I noted, subject to a range of considerations, we hold callable securitizations. I gave the example of those non-REMIC securitizations, since those — especially those — carry very high sec debt. Thus there are chances to call and collapse them, and they contain a greater share of performing loans, and we're able to turn them into REMIC and a different non-REMIC. Consequently, the sec debt on those, on a blended basis, might be reduced; that could serve as yet another capital source; so beyond the capital markets, we have multiple possible sources of capital available to us. And we are — we're always reviewing those possibilities.
Steve Laws
analystAlright, just a final item regarding the ATM, or a follow-up there. I believe your comment was that we should aim for the low 5s. Right now the stock sits at $4.5. So what would you say about your sensitivity on valuation? You brought up the yield against mid-teen returns. Is the dividend yield the hard constraint? Or in what way do you folks approach valuation sensitivity when it comes to further issuance under the ATM?
Phil Kardis
executiveYeah. What I'd say is it's those things combined; and given where the share price stands at present, I think we're — there's a ceiling on the dilution we would be prepared to accept even if the dividend yield could be covered. So those considerations do get weighed by us. Thus it's a combination. We've got to be certain the dividend yield is covered, plus we require upside beyond that point, and how much upside is required hinges on the degree of dilution. That means we'll need to strike that trade-off. And roughly that's our approach. Clearly, when we sat in the lower 5s that was 1 calculation. Sitting in the mid-4s gives you a different calculation.
Steve Laws
analystGreat. Then, to follow up — when you consider your outlook and where things could go better, I'm not sure whether that's the long end, the short end, spread tightening, or every one of those. Still, if rates were to fall by, let's say, 100 basis points, in what way does the return expectation shift relative to the mid-teens sort of present return on these new investments?
Phil Kardis
executiveSo would you like to add?
Dan Thakkar
executiveYeah. Yeah. When we discuss this, it's mainly — particularly, as Phil said when he talked about buying the non-Agency subs, which aren't funded at this point; so if funding costs decline and we can get them financed, that would push the returns up even more; so it's mainly driven by funding rates, not really by the long end coming down. Clearly, and Phil also said this in his remarks, as the securitization markets get steadier, which we observed in how deals were priced in January. And yesterday, we sort of hit a bump. If they do become steady and we're able to build up loans and securitize them in a stable macro backdrop, that's the sector that stands to gain from the long end of the curve.
Steve Laws
analystOK, so if we're talking about the possible gain, it would depend on the short end coming down when it comes to those new investments?
Phil Kardis
executiveYeah, I'd say that's more or less right.
Eric Hagen
analystWhat's your outlook on how things stand in the securitization sector given short-end rate policy? In what ways do you expect that demand picture to shift on the part of securitized debt investors, along with their willingness to take on additional debt, particularly when you consider potentially calling some of the debt already sitting in your securitization pipeline?
Dan Thakkar
executiveAs I mentioned a moment ago, Eric, we'd prefer to see somewhat steadier conditions in the securitization markets before we re-enter them. So our plan is to keep accumulating loans. In January, particularly within the non-QM space, the AAA came in priced somewhere between 143 basis points and 150 basis points. And like I said, should we gain a bit more clarity during the first half of the year, those loans we've accumulated are the ones we intend to securitize.
Eric Hagen
analystAll right. But what's our current thinking regarding the state of the debt pipeline you hold that can be called at this moment? And also, where might you be able to issue some of that debt and perhaps free up some capital?
Choudhary Yarlagadda
executivePerhaps <<inaudible>>. Right now, if we secure the sec debt at today's rates, it stays locked for an extended duration. So we're watching for front-end rates across the broader market to decline, which would let us secure improved funding rates over a longer horizon; however, that also hinges on what the market offers. Consequently, it can occasionally be worthwhile to incur a modest funding cost when we're acquiring highly accretive assets in the market.
Eric Hagen
analystRight. No, that really is logical. In what ways are we considering the preferred shares with fixed-to-floating rates? I mean, it appears those are set to reset during this year. Are there scenarios or circumstances in which you'd consider calling or redeeming them once they shift into their floating-rate portions?
Phil Kardis
executiveYes. All of those possibilities get assessed by us. And as we said earlier, we believe that with rate reductions anticipated later in the year and continuing into the following year, although we anticipate the floating rate will adjust upward, we foresee it declining gradually, and we'd likely prefer to put money to work acquiring fresh assets instead of, at this juncture, paying that off; however, that's an evaluation done individually and grounded in facts that we continuously review. So circumstances might shift, and we might conclude it would be wiser to begin buying it back. Yet that forms one element of how we consider allocating capital toward new investments versus lowering that cost.
Trevor Cranston
analystJust one more thing I'd like to ask. Have you fellas revised your figure for where book value sits at this point in the first quarter?
Dan Thakkar
executiveYeah, absolutely. Although that latest Fannie RPL deal changed hands fairly strongly, given how rates have sold off since the quarter closed and particularly yesterday, when things sped up, I'd put us at about a point lower, give or take.
Phil Kardis
executivePercent.
Dan Thakkar
executive1%.
Phil Kardis
executivePhil Kardis here. Thanks to each of you for joining the call covering our fourth quarter and full year results. We're eager to talk with you on the earnings call for Q1 2024.
Operator
operatorThanks. That wraps up the teleconference and webcast for today. At this point, feel free to disconnect your lines, and we hope the rest of your day is wonderful. We appreciate you joining us today.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Chimera Investment Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Chimera Investment Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Chimera Investment Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.