Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 10, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Eileen McLaughlin
executiveHello, everyone, and welcome to the first quarter 2021 earnings call for Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. Present with us today are William Eccleshare, who serves as Chief Executive Officer of Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc., along with Brian Coleman, the company's Chief Financial Officer. They will walk through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. and Clear Channel International BV performed operationally during the first quarter of 2021. Once we've gone through the introduction and reviewed our results, the lines will be opened for your questions, and Scott Wells, Chief Executive Officer of Clear Channel Outdoor Americas, will be part of that Q&A session. Before getting started, I want to remind all of you that forward-looking statements are part of this conference call. Management's expectations, beliefs, and projections regarding performance are included in these statements, and they reflect what management currently believes. No guarantee exists that management's expectations, beliefs, or projections will come to pass, or that actual results won't deviate from expectations. Kindly look over the risk statements included in our earnings press release and our filings with the SEC. Throughout today's call, we'll present certain performance measures that don't conform to generally accepted accounting principles. As part of the earnings press release and the earnings conference call presentation, which is located in the financial section of our website, investor.clearchannel.com, we've supplied schedules reconciling these non-GAAP measures with our reported results on a GAAP basis. Be aware that our earnings release and the slide presentation can also be accessed on our website and form an integral part of our earnings conference call. A detailed breakdown of foreign exchange and non-cash compensation expense items, plus segment revenue and Adjusted EBITDA, along with other important information, is provided in them. Because of that, we ask that you view each slide while William and Brian comment on them. Also, be aware that what's provided on this call reflects only management's views as of today, May 10th, 2021, and might no longer be accurate when a replay is heard. With that said, please turn to page three in the presentation, and I'll now hand the call over to William Eccleshare.
William Eccleshare
executiveHello, everybody, and I appreciate you spending part of your day with us on this call. Through Q1, we kept carrying out our strategic plan, aiming to get the most out of short-term results while also bolstering our capacity to bring in a growing share of ad spending once the worldwide rebound takes hold. Our Q1 top-line figures matched the outlook we had given earlier, and within our American segment, they faced a difficult comparison to how well we did in the initial three months of 2020, a period barely touched by COVID-19. Consolidated revenue came to $371 million, a 32% decline versus the same period last year, leaving out China and FX. After I finish, Brian will take you through the specifics of how we performed in Q1. Going forward, we stay upbeat about how the vaccination effort is progressing, the rising mobility we see in a number of our markets, and the favorable feedback coming from advertisers. As we anticipated, our business is now returning to year-over-year revenue growth for the remainder of the year, fueled by recovery in multiple markets. Above all, thanks to the strategic investments being made in our business, we think our position is now stronger for generating revenue growth as the worldwide recovery builds momentum. These investments mainly focus on boosting our capacity to monetize our expanding digital platform along with our print assets, and on raising our value proposition across the wider advertiser universe. More specifically, we keep growing and folding our RADAR suite of data analytics products into our portfolios, while deliberately expanding our footprint in programmatic. We keep providing advertisers a larger and more valuable collection of actionable insights, while stressing the sale of creative concepts aimed at particular audiences. To phrase it differently, our conversations with clients now stretch past merely the spots where our outdoor footprint sits, reaching the worth of particular audiences we connect with through those assets. The pandemic has given us the chance to show how useful our data is as consumer journeys shift, with agencies and brands trying to reach them in a seamless way. While we concentrate on bolstering our capacity to generate revenue growth, we have likewise stayed disciplined about controlling our costs and cash flow. Brian will give an update regarding our cost savings initiatives. Let me offer a quick update on every one of our business segments, starting with Americas. Drawing on what we know, for Q2 we anticipate Americas revenue landing between $265 million and $275 million, with Adjusted EBITDA margin rising sequentially compared to Q1. As May gets underway, we are noticing a clear increase in bookings, since advertisers feel more at ease about the prospects for a more lasting reopening of the economy as vaccination rates climb. Looking at what our data tells us, it's clear that people are getting out more as things recover, but ad buying hasn't quite caught up with those shifting mobility trends. The main reason, as we see it, is that certain important advertising categories — amusements and restaurants among them — are still facing headwinds from capacity limits, and our expectation is that they'll rebound as the year goes on and those restrictions come down. On top of that, our transit segment has improved somewhat yet remains a laggard in the recovery, and that is dragging on our results. Made up largely of airports, this segment stands to gain significantly once travel volumes rise. Going forward, the count and the dollar value of RFPs keep climbing. Beverages, insurance, and business services are among the categories displaying notable momentum. The current quarter is also bringing the start of a theatrical rebound, an encouraging development tied to how the economy is reopening. One illustration of a major opportunity built around capitalizing on the economy's reopening is the partnership we announced not long ago with Resorts World Las Vegas. Alongside the resort's summer debut and the resumption of convention business, we introduced three full motion digital out-of-home displays, which give advertisers premium exposure along the Vegas Strip. These feature state-of-the-art digital signage and rank among the biggest exterior LED building displays anywhere in the U.S., providing more than 135,000 sq ft of digital signage. On the technology investment front, 14 new digital billboards went up during the first quarter, bringing our nationwide count to over 1,400 digital billboards. We're likewise pressing ahead with making our RADAR platform stronger via partnerships designed to sharpen our data analytics and to measure how our assets shape consumer decision-making. Partnering with Kochava — the top real-time data solutions provider for omnichannel attribution and measurement — has made our premier audience attribution solution, RADARProof, even stronger. What our creative joint offering does is give brands a clearer picture of how out-of-home advertising moves key metrics like user engagement, website visits, and app downloads. Data of this caliber is what lets us show how powerful our platform is at influencing consumers while they're on the move; notable strides are also being made on the programmatic front. First quarter programmatic revenue grew compared with a year earlier, though from a small base. Thanks to integration with multiple SSPs, digital buyers can reach our digital out-of-home ad units more and more easily through the very buy-side platforms they use to deploy their sizable digital budgets. Our programmatic expansion is still at an early stage, but the headway we're achieving is a good sign for what lies ahead. Now to Europe, where, using what we know as of today, we anticipate second quarter segment revenue of $200 million to $220 million, before any foreign exchange effects. Just like what we're seeing in the Americas, how quickly things bounce back differs from one part of Europe to another, shaped by uneven vaccination progress and varying levels of comfort with the virus depending on where you are on the continent. Some of our European markets are gaining steam when it comes to reopening, but at the same time volatility remains a factor, and activity levels aren't consistent across countries. Take France, our biggest market — at the end of March, the French government put additional mobility restrictions in place after cases rose and worries grew about new variants, which pushed the start of the recovery back to the middle of the second quarter. Those restrictions have begun to loosen, with every school now open and non-essential retail set to reopen on May 19th. At the same time, encouraging signals keep showing up in certain other markets of ours, especially the U.K., which is our second largest market, where the reopening is progressing in phases, backed by a nationwide vaccination rate above 50%. During the past six weeks, bookings generated by our U.K. business came in above what we saw in the equivalent stretch of 2019, as pent-up demand from advertisers works in our favor. Our U.K. business kept gaining from the premium spots within our roadside inventory, along with the broad scale and audience reach that our digital networks deliver. I'd also like to say, with pride, that our U.K. team recently took home Commercial Team of the Year at the highly sought-after Campaign Media Awards.
William Eccleshare
executiveThe judges acknowledged Clear Channel's remarkable results, which stemmed from proactive initiatives aimed at helping advertisers navigate the extraordinary difficulties brought on by the pandemic. Turning to the remainder of Europe, Switzerland and Spain are among the other nations making solid strides when it comes to reopening. Just like in the U.K., advertising expenditure is bouncing back in those markets as infection numbers fall and limitations get relaxed. European advertisers broadly feel quite optimistic, which mirrors accumulated demand and the desire to reach consumers directly. Much like the recovery we began to witness during last year's third quarter, after restrictions were loosened — something that turned out to be short-lived — we expect the advertising market to recover once more as curbs are lifted in further markets over the coming months. Our digital presence keeps growing across Europe. During the first quarter we installed 355 digital displays, bringing the total to more than 16,500 screens currently operating. Backing these assets, our RADAR deployment keeps gaining favorable customer response in Spain and the U.K. We are additionally piloting RADAR in Sweden before a launch during the current quarter, with further rollouts planned afterward in France and Belgium; we continue to introduce our programmatic service throughout Europe. We just debuted a branded programmatic solution named Clear Channel LaunchPAD, which will act as a customer entry point, linking our premium digital out-of-home inventory to SSPs and digital buying platforms, thereby integrating out-of-home into the omnichannel purchasing ecosystem. Clear Channel LaunchPAD is currently operating in the U.K., Switzerland, Spain, Finland, and the Netherlands, and preparations are in motion to bring it to France, Italy, Belgium, and Scandinavia. As is the case in the Americas, our programmatic platform in Europe will develop gradually, streamlining how buying is done and giving us a key channel to harness our scale and technology for attracting new advertising partners; to sum up, we stay dedicated to carrying out our plan to grow the revenue potential of our worldwide portfolio and sharpen our capacity to fully capitalize on the economic rebound. We are now observing a resumption of year-over-year revenue growth in the second quarter, with signals suggesting ongoing gains in advertiser demand as the year moves forward. I would like to hand things over to Brian so he can go over our first quarter 2021 financial results.
Brian Coleman
executiveThank you, William. Good morning to all of you, and I appreciate you being on this call. As William pointed out, the quarter proved difficult, exactly as we had anticipated, because COVID-19 affected our operations and because comparisons were tough against the strong Q1 2020 showing in Americas; even so, we are starting to observe a recovery across many of our important markets. We have not returned to where we stood in 2019, yet the progress is definitely encouraging to witness; in addition, we keep working to lower expenses and to fix our capital structure, while still putting money into the business, so that we will be better positioned once the economy improves and our business starts to gain from it. Before we get into our results, let me remind all of you that while going over our GAAP results, I will also address results adjusted for foreign exchange, which is a non-GAAP measure. Our view is that this gives you better comparability when assessing how we performed. On top of that, we have broadened our disclosure to provide more detail on Americas revenue, such as separating out transit revenue. We have likewise introduced disclosure regarding site lease expenses for both the Americas and Europe segments. Now to the results on slide four; during the first quarter, consolidated revenue fell 32.7% to $371 million. Once foreign exchange is adjusted for, revenue declined 34.8%. When China is excluded and foreign exchange is adjusted for, revenue dropped 31.7%; these results matched expectations. Consolidated net loss for the first quarter came to $333 million, versus a consolidated net loss of $289 million in Q1 of 2020. Consolidated Adjusted EBITDA stood at negative $33 million in Q1 of 2021, compared with consolidated Adjusted EBITDA of $51 million in Q1 of 2020. With FX excluded, consolidated Adjusted EBITDA reached -$27 million in Q1 of 2021. Kindly go to slide five for a look at Americas first quarter results. Revenue for the Americas segment totaled $212 million in the first quarter of 2021, a drop of 28.4% from the prior year, with revenue falling across every one of our products. National declined by roughly 33% and local by roughly 25%. Revenue remains under pressure because of the effects of COVID-19, and the decline was somewhat larger than in Q4 2020 owing to harder year-over-year comparisons. As I mentioned before, the Americas team produced an outstanding quarter in Q1 of 2020, with 8.5% revenue growth versus the prior year. Direct operating and SG&A expenses decreased 21.1%, partly because of lower site lease expenses, which fell 22.6% to $83 million, tied to reduced revenue and renegotiated fixed site lease expense. Furthermore, compensation costs came down thanks to a cost savings initiative and lower revenue. Segment Adjusted EBITDA was $64 million, a decline of 40.5% from the first quarter of last year, with an Adjusted EBITDA margin of about 30%. Please go to slide six. As I just mentioned, we are now separating out our transit revenue, which mostly consists of our airports business. Transit fell 61.5%, while airports dropped 62.4% to $20 million, and billboard and other declined 20.7%. If you'd turn to slide seven, we'll walk through a little more detail on how billboard and other performed on revenue in Q1. Rent has continued to hold up somewhat better than digital, coming in down 19.1%, while digital was off 24.2% versus the first quarter of 2020; moving to slide eight, inside transit, print was down 52.5%, and digital fell 72.8%. Now let's go to slide nine, where we'll review how we did in Europe during the first quarter. Just a reminder that Q1 is, proportionally speaking, the year's smallest quarter, because revenue is seasonally low. European revenue came to $150 million, a decline of 29.4%, and once you exclude foreign exchange, revenue in the first quarter was down 35.2%. As we had anticipated, extended mobility restrictions kept pushing back the recovery, and the biggest revenue declines happened in France, the U.K., Sweden, and Spain. Digital revenue, when you exclude the foreign exchange impact, was down 38.9%. Adjusted direct operating and SG&A expense declined 11.6% versus the first quarter of the prior year, again excluding the foreign exchange impact. In most of the countries where we operate, both direct operating expenses and SG&A expenses came down, with France, the U.K., and Sweden seeing the biggest decreases. The biggest factors behind the drop in direct operating expenses were lower site lease expense, which fell 10% to $93 million on a foreign-exchange-adjusted basis. That decline came from lower revenue along with the renegotiated site lease expense. On top of that, SG&A expense declined because of lower compensation tied to lower revenue, cost savings initiatives, and government support and wage subsidies. Segment Adjusted EBITDA came in at negative $62 million on a foreign-exchange-adjusted basis. That's against negative $14 million in Q1 of 2020. Our Europe Segment is made up of the businesses run by CCIBV and its consolidated subsidiaries. So the revenue for our Europe Segment equals the revenue for CCIBV. Europe Segment Adjusted EBITDA, which is the segment profitability metric we report in our financial statements, leaves out an allocation of CCIBV's corporate expenses that get deducted from CCIBV's operating income and Adjusted EBITDA. As we covered above, Europe and CCIBV revenue fell $62 million in the first quarter of 2021 versus the same period of 2020, landing at $150 million. Once you adjust for a $12 million impact from foreign exchange rate movement, Europe and CCIBV revenue declined $75 million. CCIBV's operating loss was $100 million in the first quarter of 2021, compared with $46 million in the same period of 2020. Let's head to slide 10 for a quick review of other, which includes Latin America. Just a reminder that the prior year results include Clear Media, which was divested in April of 2020. Latin American revenue was $10 million in the first quarter, down $9 million from the same period a year earlier as a result of COVID-19's impact. When it comes to our Latin American operations, direct operating expense and SG&A came to $13 million, which is $3 million lower than the first quarter a year earlier, partly because of reduced revenue and initiatives aimed at saving costs. Adjusted EBITDA for Latin America stood at a negative $4 million. Turning to slide 11, where we look at capital expenditures: in the first quarter, CapEx came to $18 million, down $18 million from the same period a year ago, since we remain focused on preserving liquidity amid the operating conditions we currently face. Furthermore, CapEx was lower partly as a result of the Clear Media sale. Now to slide 12: as of March 31st, 2021, consolidated cash and cash equivalents for Clear Channel Outdoor came to $642 million. Our debt totaled $5.6 billion, rising a bit because of refinancing the senior notes. During the first quarter, cash paid for interest on the debt was $145 million. As of March 31st, 2021, our weighted average cost of debt was 5.9%. Let's move to slide 13. As I said, we're still concentrating on managing our cost base while strengthening liquidity and financial flexibility. In April 2021, we revised the Europe portion of the international restructuring plan that we started in the third quarter of 2020, largely as a response to how COVID-19 has affected us.
Brian Coleman
executiveWe think most of this plan will be wrapped up by the end of Q1 2023. For the Europe piece of the international restructuring plan, we figure total charges—counting the $10 million we've already taken—will land somewhere around $51 million to $56 million. Almost all of the charges connected to this plan were, or are going to be, severance benefits and costs tied to them. We're looking for the Europe portion to produce pre-tax annual cost savings of more than $28 million. On top of that, we're continuing to negotiate savings on six site leases, and on a consolidated basis we've secured $23 million in rent abatements during Q1. In addition, we got $5 million during the first quarter from European government support and wage subsidies tied to COVID-19. Now let's discuss what we're doing to stay financially flexible. Back in Q1, we finished an offering of $1 billion in 7.75% senior notes maturing in 2028, which we'd already told you about. The net proceeds from that offering went toward redeeming $940 million of our 9.25% senior notes due in 2024. Then last week, we signed a second amendment to our senior secured credit agreement. This pushes the suspension of the springing financial covenant out to December 31, 2021, and moves the step down even further, to September 30, 2022. Let's turn to slide 14 for our guidance. Looking ahead to the second quarter of 2021, we anticipate revenue for the Americas Segment to land somewhere between $265 million and $275 million, with Adjusted EBITDA margin showing sequential improvement relative to Q1 2021. For our Europe Segment, revenue should come in between $200 million and $220 million, leaving aside any foreign exchange effects. On top of that, cash interest payments are projected at $216 million across the final nine months of 2021, and at $334 million for all of 2022. For 2021, we're looking at consolidated capital expenditures somewhere between $155 million and $165 million. Our outlook is positive, and depending on how the recovery unfolds, we might decide to speed up CapEx spending later in the year as conditions warrant. Excluding China, we project that consolidated revenue for the back half of 2021 will come in at roughly 90% of what we saw in 2019. Driving this rebound are mainly our billboard operations in the Americas, along with several European markets — our U.K. roadside business among them. And finally, when 2021 wraps up, we expect liquidity — that's unrestricted cash plus what's available through the company's revolving credit facilities — to land in the neighborhood of $425 million to $475 million. That figure might shift depending on when cash comes in or goes out. That wraps up what I had prepared to say. I'll now hand things back to William.
William Eccleshare
executiveThank you, Brian. As we look forward, the speed of the vaccination effort is encouraging to us, along with the rising mobility levels observed throughout most of our footprint. As a result, advertiser interest is coming back, and in a number of U.S. and European markets we're seeing booking activity that surpasses 2019, which is a favorable sign for the coming year. Our focus stays on making strategic investments in our technology, which includes growing our digital platform and further bolstering our data analytics and programmatic resources, all aimed at getting the most out of our digital board. By improving our capacity to show how effective our assets are at shaping consumer decision-making and by continuing to make our inventory simpler to purchase, especially for digital ad buyers, we intend to grow our revenue growth potential. While we put money into our technology, we will also keep taking action to tightly control our costs and protect our liquidity as we work through the changing macroeconomic environment and concentrate on generating profitable growth over the long term. I'll now hand the call to the operator for the Q&A session.
Scott Wells
executiveI think you might be on mute, Steve.
Steven Cahall
analystNo worries about that. Yeah. Many thanks for the additional detail. You mentioned an uptick in RFPs along with theatrical. Might you provide a bit more insight regarding the Americas segment? What's the revenue size for that segment currently? Is it the big city signage, major metropolitan markets, spectaculars, things along those lines? My guess is that's where you're witnessing much of this rebound. If you could perhaps offer some context regarding those major metropolitan revenue categories and the kinds of patterns you're observing, and possibly the identical question regarding Europe. Brian, I appreciate that financial information. Perhaps if you could go a bit further into what the covenant holiday signifies given that you're finishing with liquidity between $425 million and $475 million, which I believe I heard correctly. Does that leave you in compliance with the covenant? Does that incorporate perhaps a portion of your bank debt reduction or revolver repayment before the year ends? Thank you.
Scott Wells
executiveBrian, would you like me to handle the spectaculars item first? All right. Steve, the inquiry regarding theatrical is a solid one. To be clear, they do purchase spectaculars, yet that isn't the bulk of their purchases. They're actually significant users of our digital networks and purchase fairly extensively across the footprint. I don't believe we've revealed the size of the spectaculars business, though it falls within that bulletin and other category that was disclosed. It's certainly displaying indications of a comeback, but theatrical isn't the only thing returning. I trust that provides you with a sense of it.
Steven Cahall
analystIn that same vein, could it be that big cities, or maybe sizable metro regions excluding transit, are beginning to recover? Some of the local TV businesses we track have shown us that.
Scott Wells
executiveYes, I'd say it varies depending on where you are in the country, but that's certainly happening. As we look at Q2 and past that, we are absolutely observing it. It seems the further south you go, and the more you move toward somewhat smaller places, the stronger the situation is. I suspect this is something we'll be asked about, so let me address it immediately. Roughly 1/3 of our markets — that's 1/3 of markets, not 1/3 of revenue — are on track to surpass 2019 during this year. Broadly speaking, we anticipate a remarkably robust back half, and truly the second quarter along with the second half, especially when it comes to the traditional segment.
William Eccleshare
executiveSteve, you also brought up Europe, I believe. It's hard for me to make a broad statement about how the recovery is going there, since conditions truly vary so much from one country to the next. If the U.K. were the only subject, I'd say we could paint quite a favorable picture, given that most of the restrictions are coming off nearly every day, and the rebound is tracking that trend quite closely. In other markets across Europe, it has taken a longer time for the pandemic to be brought under control, so to speak. Limits have stayed in force for a greater stretch. The pace of recovery we're witnessing in the U.K. hasn't shown up there. The picture is mixed. One thing that holds steady is that with each passing week, lockdowns are easing, and with each passing week, as they ease, revenue returns — and returns quite robustly. This recovery will be unfolding over the course of the second quarter. What I'd say is that if you take an average across Europe, April remained weak. May is definitely gaining more momentum. Come June, our expectation is that in essentially every market we operate in, the recovery will have taken hold. For Europe, I'd view the second quarter as a transition period, with a strong, durable recovery anticipated in the second half as vaccination rates rise. As I mentioned, one single Europe doesn't exist in this scenario.
Brian Coleman
executiveSteve, let me jump in and tackle that covenant question right away. First off, I want to say we're happy to be delivering yet another amendment, and it definitely shows our bank group is still behind us, so we're pleased about that. The second point I'd make is that this is a springing covenant — it kicks in only when there are outstandings under our cash flow revolver, and as of today, there are. What the second amendment really boils down to is that there's effectively no financial covenant, which is a secured leverage test, in place until year-end. In exchange, we'll keep maintaining minimum liquidity of $150 million. It carries forward the first amendment as far as the secured leverage test goes. That test, whenever it's active, sits at 7.6x. Then there's a step-down to 7.1x. Because the application of the financial covenant has been pushed back, the step-down has been pushed back as well, and it's now been pushed back to September 30th of 2022. Again, we're glad to report the second amendment, and I think it's sort of rooted in how we see the recovery unfolding, and we believe we do have adequate means to satisfy that test. You raised a question about the liquidity guidance — whether it's adequate, or what it reflects, is kind of how I interpreted it. When we give liquidity guidance, it covers cash and availability. Whether or not we pay down the revolver doesn't really matter — it would be counted either way, whether as availability on the revolver or cash on our balance sheet; we do believe it's adequate; we've worked hard to build up that cash cushion. We have more visibility now than we used to, but we're also very mindful of where our liquidity stands, and we'll take further steps if appropriate, should we need to make any kind of changes on that front. Hopefully that answers your question. Let me know if it didn't.
Steven Cahall
analystNo, that's great. Thank you.
Ben Swinburne
analystHi, good morning. Brian, I believe that remark regarding the year's latter half was yours — apologies if it came from someone else — about hitting 90% of 2019 revenue adjusted for. Could you revisit that and walk us through it once more? It went by rather quickly. Also, would you share some detail on how you're viewing the various segments of your portfolio against the backdrop of that second half? Perhaps Scott could speak to the programmatic area: what are your intentions as this year progresses into the next, when it comes to expanding that channel further — whether through technology spending — and are advertisers showing even greater interest there, including on the local side? That would be interesting. Thanks a lot.
Brian Coleman
executiveYeah. I'll say a few words about the revenue guidance remark, then hand things to Scott and William to discuss what they're observing across their respective markets. The guidance we gave was meant to offer some reassurance, grounded in the trajectory of the rebound we're currently experiencing in our business, about where we believe the business can stand at year's end regarding revenue compared with 2019 — based on what we see now and what we expect across the second quarter and, really, the latter half, as recovery unfolds in the different parts of our business. Circumstances might shift, but I think, based on what we're seeing now, we feel a robust recovery is within reach, and by year's end, we could return to 90% of pre-COVID-19 levels — 2019 levels — on the top line. Hopefully that provides some high-level indication of what we're seeing now, and hopefully that recovery will materialize. Scott, William, color on the operating units?
Scott Wells
executiveOn the programmatic side of things, I'll handle the U.S. piece, and then William, if you'd like to speak to what's happening in Europe, we can get into that too. To start, programmatic has been recovering quite strongly; results are solid, and at this stage it's outpacing 2019 by a fairly significant margin. Advertisers across the board are showing greater interest in this channel; as far as what we have planned, I believe you'll see us bring on no fewer than one additional SSP — that stands for Supply-Side Platform. These function as the big distribution platforms at scale that connect you with various DSPs, meaning Demand-Side Platforms. Those are what advertisers themselves actually work with. Right now our lineup is fairly diverse and strong, though we're continuously seeking ways to improve it, and we're continuously seeking to expand. I believe you'll also observe us developing greater and greater capability around how we manage the content side of the operation. We're putting investments into our content management system, plus other development efforts we're pursuing in that area, all aimed at making our tool set stronger and capable of continuing to scale well. Turning to your question about local, a handful of local customers have purchased programmatically; that hasn't been the main focus of our business. I think once you see the demand side — with some of the more mainstream demand-side platforms that conduct substantial business at that level — coming online, I think you'll see us gain more traction. Up to this point, that hasn't been the central emphasis. William, I'm not sure whether there's anything you'd like to add regarding Europe.
William Eccleshare
executiveNo, what I'd say is this — I believe I mentioned at the very beginning of this year that programmatic would be a central element of what we're focused on throughout the entire company. The work Scott has been leading in the U.S., in my view, has served as a blueprint for expanding what we can do with programmatic. As I noted in the script earlier, we would have gone live in 5 major European markets with our branded programmatic offering, which is currently, as I mentioned, in those 5 key markets to begin with. The name we use for it is Clear Channel LaunchPAD, and it links our premium digital inventory to SSPs as well as to digital platforms. That's a meaningful beginning. Europe lags the U.S. somewhat when it comes to embracing programmatic at scale, but I have no doubt at all that over the coming 2 to 3 years, we'll watch it capture a fairly substantial portion of our business. It represents an important move forward.
Ben Swinburne
analystThank you all.
Lance Vitanza
analystHey, everybody. Appreciate you fielding our questions. I've got one for Brian, plus one for William. Let's perhaps begin with William. The market-by-market detail on Europe was quite useful. I realize that how quickly limits get removed differs from one nation to the next. But what about the delay between viewers coming back and advertising spending coming back? Broadly, if I'm following you correctly, it seems there isn't much of a delay this time. That seems unlike what happened last autumn. Is that accurate?
William Eccleshare
executiveLance, it truly hinges on the amount of digital inventory available to us in any given market. In the U.K., where digital screens now generate more than 60% of our revenues, once limits are removed, our revenue bounces back almost immediately. As soon as people return to the streets, advertisers are eager to connect with them, and we're able to put those ads right up on digital screens, with traditional inventory following shortly afterward. Take France, for example, where our digital inventory is considerably smaller — there, the rebound may take somewhat more time. That said, if we revisit Q3 of last year, when France lifted its limits, revenue did return quite quickly. Not as quickly as it would with a bigger digital footprint, I'd admit, yet I believe that's the key variable. Another element worth considering is how clearly the government communicates its intentions regarding easing restrictions. In the U.K., I'd say we gained from an extremely transparent roadmap consisting of five weekly stages for reopening. In Spain, what that process would look like was far less obvious. In France, I think we'd say they waited a long while before responding. They've responded now, and we're seeing infection rates decline, vaccination rates climb, and limits being removed. As I mentioned, I feel quite positive about where things are heading. I'm positive about how swiftly recovery arrives once limits are removed, though it does differ somewhat from market to market. Does that answer your question?
Lance Vitanza
analystYes, absolutely. Thanks. Brian, this one's directed at you: is it still the case that the business carries $40 million-$45 million in LCs that remain outstanding? And if that's true, I'd assume that's already baked into the liquidity guidance. Put another way, it acts as a deduction against whatever you could otherwise draw down on the revolver. Is that accurate?
Brian Coleman
executiveYes, that's right. My recollection is that we do disclose the availability figure, meaning the revolver's size minus any commitments of that sort, LCs included. The precise number escapes me. It's possible it sits somewhat above $45 million, but LCs are something we use heavily; that portion gets subtracted since it can't be tapped for liquidity, meaning it wouldn't show up in the liquidity figure.
Lance Vitanza
analystAll right, thank you fellas.
Stephan Bisson
analystMorning. I appreciate the extra detail you provided today. Would you mind discussing profitability and what direction it ought to take across the remainder of the year, and maybe further out, for both the Americas and Europe? Is our goal supposed to be the levels we saw before the pandemic, or is something altering the expense framework that would move things in either direction?
Brian Coleman
executiveI'll give that a try, and then William and Scott can add their perspectives if they'd like. So, I believe profitability is recovering; regarding the Americas, we mentioned improvement from one period to the next. In Europe, we're somewhat early in the turnaround to make that promise for Q2. Once economies begin to improve, once Europe begins to sort of catch up and truly gain momentum in the rebound, we'd anticipate that better profitability will be present. This is a business with substantial fixed expenses and significant operating leverage; we will observe that benefit flow through when the recovery happens. Should it not occur during Q2 in Europe, we'd anticipate it during the back half. The second portion of what you asked — do we ever anticipate profitability reaching the levels seen before COVID-19? Well, the business evolves as time passes. I believe the response hinges on several factors; there are certain favorable elements; we've removed some expenses from the operation. We keep removing expenses in Europe; that will require somewhat more time; we are acting with great care; we don't anticipate every one of those expenses returning. Conversely, the portfolio itself shifts. Should we, down the road, carry greater weight in transit, or greater weight in airports, or additional capital city contracts, which carry thinner profitability, that might alter the overall profitability picture. We currently have a portion of that business mix disparity. I wouldn't anticipate that once revenues return to the 2019 mark, you ought to presume profitability would sit at the identical level. It will mirror certain fundamental shifts within the operation. Broadly speaking, additional dollars put into this operation will drop through. We're heartened that we're beginning to witness a bit of that and, once more, I believe across the remaining portion of the year, we aim to produce it. Scott, William, I'm not sure whether you have anything more to add, but that's my starting point.
William Eccleshare
executiveScott, do you want to make any comment for the U.S.?
Scott Wells
executiveThe one point I'd make is that things will be uneven across the coming few quarters, and that unevenness could cut either way. The reason behind it is that talks are ongoing and approvals are still pending for a number of relief initiatives, plus we'll begin to see certain snap-backs occur as the relief obtained while the crisis was at its worst runs its course. Most likely the path won't be a tidy straight line across the next two quarters, though over the medium to long term, I believe a healthy margin profile will come back.
Brian Coleman
executiveScott, I appreciate you bringing that up. You're raising something completely valid. When I talked about the recovery over the longer term, I was working from the assumption that everything here had fully unwound. I believe your read is correct. Over the coming few quarters, given how uneven some of those deferrals and abatements are, things could turn out — just as you put it — quite uneven. I'm grateful for that.
William Eccleshare
executiveRight. The one thing I'd tack on — and I'm afraid I was about to reach for "lumpy" too, since it fits Europe just as well; things there are quite uneven. And to pick up on what Brian said regarding Europe, another observation: we've been upfront that we're carrying out fairly substantial cost-cutting efforts across Europe, and within certain specific markets there. As you're aware, in a number of those European markets, such programs take a while, since you have to work through lengthy negotiations. So even though we're tackling cost-driven pressures in Europe very aggressively right now, the effect won't arrive immediately; several quarters will pass before we genuinely observe it showing up in margin.
Stephan Bisson
analystExcellent. I really appreciate the additional detail.
David Joyce
analystThanks. I was wondering if you might share additional detail regarding how much of your revenue and what share of your advertisers currently originate from RADAR. How much of your footprint has been switched on, and additionally, how far are you connecting with other media organizations through that comprehensive omnichannel purchasing initiative for the advertisers you serve? Appreciate it.
Scott Wells
executiveWilliam, would you like me to try addressing this initially?
William Eccleshare
executiveYeah.
Scott Wells
executiveSure. Across the U.S., RADAR covers 100% of our footprint, and giving you a real answer here is genuinely tough, since clients don't purchase RADAR as such. What it is, rather, is a service provided alongside whatever they do buy. A client could be using RADAR — plenty of ours currently rely on it for planning — yet never run an attribution study. Perhaps they sell no additional media via RADARConnect, and perhaps they don't incorporate our data at all. Conversely, an advertiser could be engaging with all four RADAR offerings we have in the U.S. Judging things by what share of revenue flows through it isn't really how we look at it. On omnichannel, let me address that, because I believe the question could be answered in 2 ways. First, whenever RADAR studies are run, analytics covering all out-of-home in use get included — not only our own. That probably isn't the omnichannel meaning you had in mind, though. My guess is you mean omnichannel DSPs — a programmatic way of thinking — so feel free to clarify once I've given you this explanation. Omnichannel DSPs arrived fairly recently within out-of-home programmatic; they're unquestionably a channel that's growing, and we're clearly observing advertisers putting out-of-home into their digital campaigns, where alongside digital out-of-home they may purchase other digital advertising products. Within these omnichannel DSPs' workspace sit click boxes letting them add digital out-of-home next to display ads, search, or similar items; that remains the minority of our programmatic revenue right now; we see enormous promise in it, but it's an emerging channel. Hopefully that addressed your questions.
David Joyce
analystSo, everything you just said applied only to the United States, right?
Scott Wells
executiveThat's right; every bit of it concerned the U.S.
William Eccleshare
executiveTurning to Europe and RADAR — we only brought that product to the U.K. and Spain during the previous year. Our plan is to expand it into additional European countries before this year is over. To echo what Scott said, we employ it as a signal of the market, both for audience size and for how audiences move around, which lets us show advertisers the reach they can get via a set or network of boards or screens; typically it isn't tied to any particular advertiser campaign.
David Joyce
analystAll right, thank you. For a follow-up, could you make it clear — once conditions return to normal in 2022 or 2023, would margins come in stronger because of all the cost reductions you've made, or would the differing shifts in revenue mix complicate margin comparisons somewhat relative to before COVID?
Brian Coleman
executiveMy sense is that none of us has that answer yet. My sense is that cost savings are being delivered, and our view is that a portion of them will persist, and clearly, with expansion in the business, we'll need to revisit that. That's a tailwind. Meanwhile, what we are is a collection of contracts, and we'll keep pursuing contracts that are profitable, and that mix can move as time goes on. Should we move further into transit, that might alter what the business is made of. Whether we have that answer, I'm not sure. My sense is that we'll keep concentrating on making margins better to the greatest extent we can. Ultimately, what we're after is producing positive free cash flow, and incremental positive free cash flow at that, and we'll run the portfolio in whatever way we believe adds the most to shareholder value.
David Joyce
analystAll right. I just want to get a clearer picture of those <<inaudible>> contracts that were renegotiated. Were these changes or abatements only for a short time? Will the revenue come back to what it was before? What sort of timing should we expect?
Brian Coleman
executiveWell, it varies, and I think you begin at the point when the impact from COVID-19 was at its worst — that's when you began deferring payments on everything and talks got triggered. These are times unlike anything we've seen. Our counterparties mostly understood that too, and occasionally those deferrals become abatements. Occasionally there is government backing for it. Occasionally you're working with private landlords, and it becomes more of a conversation, and perhaps it's a deferral, and in the end, it will need to be paid. There's a broad range of conversations, and they are still going on. I think that as soon as we've verified something is a permanent abatement, we disclose it, and anything else counts as a deferral if payment hasn't happened. A portion of those deferrals might turn into abatement. A portion of them will be deferred and eventually unwind as the recovery goes on; it's a mixed bag, and we do disclose separately the site lease abatements we received during the quarter and across all of last year. I hope that provides a bit of color regarding the site lease negotiations. It's a major initiative. The operators have performed very well, and they will keep doing whatever they can for as long as COVID is hurting the business.
David Joyce
analystThanks a lot.
Avi Steiner
analystGood morning, and thanks for fitting me in. Just a few quick questions. TSA figures suggest domestic travel is recovering. I'd like to know how crucial it is for your company that business travel comes back, compared with what looks like leisure travel. Could you also remind us how long the airports business lags between rising travel activity and revenue returning to prior levels? I have a couple more. Thanks.
Scott Wells
executiveOf course, Avi, thank you. You're right that travel is rebounding well. Historically, airport advertising was mostly built around business travel. Throughout this crisis, we've brought on board many advertisers whose focus isn't B2B, which means our portfolio mix is shifting somewhat. To address what you asked, one thing is clear: it matters a great deal that international travel especially begins to come back, since international terminals are typically among the most premium spots you have, whether the advertiser is going after business customers or consumers. As for business travel overall, I don't believe it has to return to pre-COVID levels for it to remain a strong audience and a strong opportunity. On that lag question, if you look back at last year — and with the information we're now disclosing, this may become somewhat clearer on transit — there wasn't an immediate sharp decline. The reason is that many airport contracts tend to be structured over longer terms, so what you saw was a gradual unwinding. The same dynamic applies in reverse: advertisers first have to become convinced that the audience recovery is solid, and only then will they commit, so they can lock in locations and protect their positioning. This situation is unlike anything we've faced before, certainly not in the recent past. Probably the nearest comparison would be 9/11, though that event differed quite a bit when it came to how quickly things moved, the way traffic recovered, and how everything played out. The truth is we can't say for certain how long the delay will last, but our expectation is that it's likely to stretch across several months. One thing we're clearly observing is that advertisers — including some of the strategic ones who place a real premium on airports — are returning for the back half of this year. My expectation is that the headlines from us will improve substantially as we move through the year. As for pinpointing the precise moment we return to run rate, my honest view is that it will trail the roadside business by several months.
Avi Steiner
analystThanks for that detail. Brian, regarding what you said about liquidity — that was quite useful — setting aside CapEx interest, how should we look at working capital, with certain of those deferrals returning, plus whatever else shifts in there, and then restructuring, the cash restructuring, if you could?
Brian Coleman
executiveYes. That's partly why we provided a year-end liquidity figure, since I genuinely believe there are movements, especially with the deferrals. Our operators are pushing extremely hard to postpone those payments and turn them into permanent abatements. So, for liquidity reasons, in the stretch between now and normalization, we must select windows when they will land. Thus, we believed it mattered to extend through the close of the year and give liquidity guidance. Based on what is visible to us now, we feel fairly confident about that range. Restructuring charges — sure, look, I'd say several items are in play. Looking at certain cost savings efforts, by and large, we have already incurred and are now gaining from the restructuring steps taken across the U.S., Latin America, and a large portion of corporate. The European piece will require somewhat more time, and we've shared certain data points regarding that; it truly depends on the nations where we run operations in Europe as they move through their process. In fact, we've adjusted the program, making it bigger and more meaningful; that will need a bit more time, yet from a cash outflow standpoint, given that much of that expense is tied to severance, they ought to be mostly aligned. To phrase it differently, you won't see a massive amount leave on day one and then wait to get it back until 2023's first quarter. From this point forward they should be matched funding; we do have some costs upfront. Mostly, they ought to correspond moving ahead. I hope that answers things on the working capital and restructuring fronts. Tell me if anything else comes up.
Avi Steiner
analystAlright, that sounds good. Perhaps just one more — I haven't come across this in some time, though it's possible I simply overlooked it. Is there anything new regarding the billboard business in Los Angeles? My recollection is that earlier this year, there was talk of possible new regulations emerging there. Do you have anything to share on that, and I appreciate your time.
Scott Wells
executiveThank you, Avi. That's another one I can handle. What you probably saw was the City Planning Commission issuing its reply to certain ordinance wording that had been prepared by the city council. At this point it has gone back to the land use committee of the city council, and they're actively addressing it. I wouldn't venture to predict when that political procedure might produce a result, but I am aware they are working on it. It certainly fell lower on the priority list amid COVID; during the early portion of last year, we'd been feeling fairly optimistic that progress would occur, and I genuinely believe the city council is involved and takes quite seriously the goal of producing an ordinance that functions for the industry in that area, yet no specific schedule exists.
Avi Steiner
analystAppreciate all the time. Thank you.
Scott Wells
executiveThanks.
William Eccleshare
executiveThanks. I appreciate everyone taking part in today's call and for standing behind us through this stretch. To wrap up, I'd like to say that I believe we'll eventually view the second quarter of 2021 as the point when the company changed direction — the pivot quarter, so to speak — when we returned to growth and began witnessing the genuine rebound from COVID-19; obviously, that hinges on certain elements beyond our influence, such as whether additional COVID variants emerge and how vaccination efforts play out across various markets globally. Every indicator we're observing is genuinely heartening regarding our company's capacity to recover from COVID. To touch on a few of the inquiries raised earlier today, once those limitations are removed and audiences return to the streets, we do anticipate that rebound arriving. The delay differs from market to market, depending somewhat on quantities of digital inventory and somewhat on particular situations. As I mentioned, Q2 is the crucial quarter for us as we make that turn and aim toward the latter half of the year to truly show the company returning to complete growth. I'm grateful for your backing. Thanks for the excellent questions, and we're eager to speak again over the next weeks and months. Many thanks.
Operator
operatorThank you. This concludes today's conference call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.