Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 24, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Communication Services Media earnings 55 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Eileen McLaughlin

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thanks for being with us on the Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings 2021 Q4 and full year earnings call. Joining us are Scott Wells, Chief Executive Officer of Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc., along with Brian Coleman, Chief Financial Officer of Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. They'll walk us through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. and Clear Channel International B.V. performed in Q4 and the full year of 2021. We'll take your questions once we've gone through the introduction and reviewed our results, and Justin Cochrane, Chief Executive Officer of Clear Channel Europe, will be part of the Q&A portion. I want to remind you before we start that forward-looking statements are part of this conference call. Management's expectations, beliefs, and projections regarding performance are included in these statements, and they reflect what management currently believes. There's no guarantee that management's expectations, beliefs, or projections will come to pass, or that actual results won't deviate from those expectations. Kindly look over the risk statements included in our earnings press release and our SEC filings. Some performance measures we'll discuss today don't conform to generally accepted accounting principles. A schedule reconciling these non-GAAP measures with our reported results on a GAAP basis is provided as part of our earnings release and the earnings conference call presentation, both of which are available in the financial section of our website, investor.clearchannel.com. Please be aware that the earnings release and the earnings conference call presentation on our website are integral to our earnings conference call; they offer a detailed breakdown of foreign exchange, segment revenue, adjusted EBITDA, and adjusted corporate expenses, including the impact of share-based compensation and restructuring charges, among other important information; therefore, we ask that you view each slide as Scott and Brian comment on them. Also, note that what's provided on this call reflects management's views only as of today, February 24th, 2022, and might not be accurate anymore when a replay is heard. With that, please go to page four in the presentation, and I'll hand the call over to Scott Wells.

Scott Wells

executive
#2

Hello, everyone, and I appreciate your time in joining us on this call today. It's a pleasure to speak with all of you for the first time since I took on the CEO position at Clear Channel Outdoor at the start of this year. The handover from William has been seamless, and I want to thank him for the leadership he provided previously, as well as for the strategic input he continues to offer in his new capacity as Executive Vice Chairman; backed by our skilled and committed team, we are carrying out this leadership change from a position of strength as we keep working to turn the oldest advertising medium in the world into a visual media powerhouse driven by technology. I'm happy to share that we delivered robust results in Q4 of 2021, especially considering the difficulties we encountered earlier in the year. As reported, consolidated revenue rose 37% versus 2020. Our revenue also comfortably exceeded what we generated in the Q4 of 2019, leaving out China and fluctuations in foreign exchange. Brian will walk through our results in detail after my comments. I take particular pride in the way our organization handled the significant COVID-related headwinds we confronted over the past year. The whole CCO team has my heartfelt gratitude for overcoming the countless obstacles we encountered to produce these results. All through the pandemic, we stayed focused and intensified our efforts on the strategic plan. Because of that, we bolstered our standing in the advertising community during this time. Our markets reopened, and we experienced steady gains with every quarter that passed, leading to our exceptionally strong Q4 performance; we've built a dynamic, intelligent, addressable platform that we expect to expand and get stronger over time, enabling us to serve advertisers in ways that were unimaginable just a few short years ago. We are engaging advertisers where they most need us and proving we can precisely reach their target audiences, even while consumers change how they move about and make purchases. The outdoor sector as a whole has resumed growing, and we believe we can increase revenue beyond real GDP and traditional media thanks to our business transformation efforts. The resilience our business has shown during the pandemic is definitely a strong and concrete data point. This resilience is further reinforced by the macro environment, in which advertisers are overexposed to digital and face difficulties with non-sports linear TV. Our ongoing effort to incorporate intelligence, addressability, and attribution will help reinforce out-of-home's position as the final mass visual medium. Our capacity to generate cash conversion completes the reasons we are enthusiastic about the future. As our 2021 results show, additional revenue produces robust cash conversion, especially in our Americas business; we believe we possess a powerful engine for generating cash as we push revenue growth while continuing to run efficiently. As we look forward, our belief is that the long-range picture stays quite encouraging, and we're dedicated to the strategic roadmap we've laid out. That roadmap covers speeding up our digital transformation, getting better at putting customers at the center, and pushing for excellence in how we execute. Today, I want to break down the three main initiatives within that digital transformation effort. First, we've kept expanding our digital footprint, and that footprint sits at the heart of how we plan to grow over the long haul. To give you a sense of scale, digital drove the recovery in 2021, rising 66% during the Q4 and 41% across the full year. Within the US, we brought 94 larger format digital billboards online, which brought our 2021 total to more than 1,500 digital billboards. Add in the smaller format digital displays we have in airports and on shelters, and that puts us above 4,000 digital displays throughout the United States. Over in Europe, 1,361 digital displays came online during 2021, bringing the number now live to over 17,500. Looking at the year ahead, our aim is to roll out a comparable quantity of digital billboards in the US and digital displays in Europe, and that will keep widening how addressable our portfolio is. We're putting money into the team and the infrastructure needed to speed that effort up. Second, we've kept raising the level of our RADAR offering by way of a variety of partnerships, and those have lifted both our analytics capabilities and our capacity to measure what our assets actually achieve. RADAR has become firmly established in the US, and over the past year we rolled out RADAR for audience proximity planning across our major European markets. Our view is that this has helped drive the recovery in our business. RADAR gives advertisers a simpler route to capturing what out-of-home advertising is worth, taking methods and tactics traditionally used in the online world and applying them to the physical world's biggest screens. Because we can hand advertisers a valuable set of actionable insights, our sales team is able to concentrate more on selling creative ideas that effectively hit the demographics advertisers are after. As time goes on, we anticipate bringing in new advertisers and widening our conversations with customers past the locations of our outdoor assets, so that the worth of particular audiences and consumer behaviors is part of the discussion too. We're showing that we can shape purchasing decisions even while consumer mobility patterns shift; that result is a crucial one, and it comes from the investments we've put into our platform. Third, we keep growing our programmatic presence. Thanks to our integration with multiple DSPs and SSPs, digital advertising buyers can increasingly reach our digital out-of-home platform through the very same buy-side platforms they use to spend their digital budgets. This shows our digital transformation and customer centricity pillars operating side by side, leaning on technology and partnerships to open our assets up to new buyers and budgets. It's still a modest piece of our results, but programmatic revenue climbed significantly over the past year, and we anticipate further gains in the year ahead. What we anticipate rests on solid proof that marketers see worth in the programmatic choice, judging by how they act with digital display, video, and, more lately, CTV. I'll talk about the rest of our strategic pillars — customer centricity and executional excellence — on upcoming calls; however, looking at slide five shows several instances of campaigns that worked, powered by each of our three strategic pillars. To sum up, as we keep carrying out our initiatives, we think we'll boost our capacity to draw additional advertisers onto our platform and take share away from other media while generating expansion within the out-of-home medium. Simultaneously, we stay committed to showing even more of the operating leverage inside our model via profitable growth as we chase accretive possibilities and reinforce our balance sheet. Last, as was stated in December, we've likewise started the work of assessing strategic alternatives for our European business, which fits with our emphasis on refining our portfolio. Europe did extremely well across the second half of 2021 and stands in a good spot for our strategic review, which includes a potential sale. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Brian so he can go over our financial results and our guidance.

Brian Coleman

executive
#3

Thank you, Scott. Good morning to all of you, and I appreciate you being on this call. As Scott said, this last year has been remarkable, since we went from a really tough first quarter to a fourth quarter where revenue and segment adjusted EBITDA for the Americas and Europe came in above the fourth quarters of both 2020 and 2019. Let's turn to slide six for our results. Before we get into those results, I want to remind everybody that while going through our GAAP figures, I will also cover our numbers excluding foreign exchange movements, which is a non-GAAP measure. In our view, that gives you better comparability when assessing how we performed. So I don't repeat myself, the amounts I cite are for Q4 2021, and the percentage changes are Q4 2021 versus Q4 of 2020, unless I say otherwise. Consolidated revenue came in at $743 million, which is a 37.2% gain. Leaving out foreign exchange movements, revenue rose 38.8%, and even more significantly, it was 4.9% above the Q4 of 2019, excluding China and excluding foreign exchange movements. Consolidated net income reached $66 million, versus a net loss of $33 million a year earlier. Consolidated adjusted EBITDA was $222 million, a substantial increase from $101 million in the Q4 of 2020. Leaving out foreign exchange movements, consolidated adjusted EBITDA came in slightly higher at $223 million; across the full year, consolidated revenue grew 20.8% to $2.2 billion. Leaving out foreign exchange movements, consolidated revenue in 2021 rose 19% versus 2020. Consolidated net loss across the full year was $433 million, versus $600 million in 2020. Consolidated adjusted EBITDA in 2021 was $423 million, a substantial increase from $120 million in 2020. Leaving out foreign exchange movements, adjusted EBITDA reached $431 million across the full year; now please go to slide seven, the quarterly view of Americas Q4 results. Americas revenue came in at $371 million, a gain of 44%, and even more significantly, that was 7.6% above the $345 million of revenue we posted in Q4 2019. Revenue rose across every product, with airport digital displays, digital billboards, and print billboards standing out the most. Digital revenue, representing 41% of Americas revenue, climbed 83.7% to $153 million, powered by both airports and billboards. That digital rebound stems in large part from how flexible and easy buying digital is, along with the new airport inventory in New York and New Jersey in programmatic. Advertisers want to be able to place ads nearer to the campaign date and change content with ease. National rose 48.6% and is getting back to pre-pandemic levels, making up 39% of revenue, while local gained 41.1% and made up 61% of revenue. Direct operating and SG&A expenses rose 21.6%. Part of that increase reflects an 18.2% rise in site lease expense to $112 million, driven by higher revenue and higher compensation costs stemming from improved operating performance. Segment adjusted EBITDA was $170 million, up 80.3%, with a segment adjusted EBITDA margin of roughly 45.8%. That adjusted EBITDA margin came in higher because of a few one-time expense benefits tied to COVID. If we set aside those one-time gains, the segment adjusted EBITDA margin would land at roughly the same level as Q4 2019, which came in at 42.3%. Let's move to slide eight. On that slide, we break our Americas revenue down between billboard and other versus transit. The billboard and other category — mainly bulletin, posters, street furniture displays, spectaculars, and wallscapes — rose 26.7%, reaching $294 million. Gains in every one of our regions fueled that result, and the Northeast stood out in particular. Transit climbed 200.9%, while airport display revenue jumped 214.9%, hitting $73 million. Two things lifted airport revenue: the recovery in airline passenger traffic and the new advertising and sponsorship contract with the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. Now let's go to slide nine for a little more color on billboard and other. Digital revenue came back strong in Q4, rising 45.3% to $107 million, and it now represents 36.4% of total billboard and other revenue. Non-digital revenue rose 18.1%. Next, please turn to slide 10, where we review how Europe performed in the Q4. My remarks cover results adjusted to remove foreign exchange movements. Europe revenue grew 33.1%, powered by gains across every product — street furniture most of all — and by improvement in most countries, with France leading the way. Digital made up 39% of total revenue and grew 52.4%; on top of that, the strength of our digital footprint pushed overall revenue higher in a number of markets during the quarter versus 2019, among them the UK, Belgium, Sweden, Finland, and Ireland. Direct operating and SG&A expenses rose 15.6%. The main driver was higher site lease expense, which climbed 36.1% because of fewer negotiated rent abatements and greater revenue. On top of that, compensation was higher given better operating performance. Those pressures were partly offset by falling costs tied to the restructuring plan aimed at reducing headcount. Segment adjusted EBITDA came to $86 million, an increase of 131.8%. Higher revenue during the period drove that, with a segment adjusted EBITDA margin of about 24%, well above the Q4 in 2020 thanks to strong pull-through from a cost base that is relatively fixed, along with the benefits of cost reductions and one-time savings. Let's turn to CCIBV. Our Europe segment is made up of the businesses run by CCIBV and its consolidated subsidiaries. As a result, the revenue for our Europe segment matches the revenue for CCIBV. Europe segment adjusted EBITDA — the segment profitability metric reported in our financial statements — leaves out an allocation of CCIBV's corporate expenses, which are subtracted from CCIBV's operating income and adjusted EBITDA. As I mentioned earlier, Europe and CCIBV revenue rose $81 million during the Q4 of 2021 versus the same period of 2020, reaching $350 million. Once we exclude an $8 million impact from foreign exchange rate movements, Europe and CCIBV revenue grew $89 million during the Q4 of 2021 compared with the same period of 2020. CCIBV operating income was $51 million in the Q4 of 2021, versus operating income of $1 million in the same period of 2020. Moving along to slide 11, here's a brief look at "other," which is made up of our Latin American operations. Revenue for other came in at $22 million, which is $7 million higher. If we set aside FX movements, revenue rose 50.9%, with every country contributing to the improvement. Direct operating expenses and SG&A came to $18 million, an increase of $3 million. Segment adjusted EBITDA reached $4 million, up $3 million. Let's now go to slide 12 for a look at capital expenditures. In Q4, CapEx came to $56 million, which is $35 million more than the same period a year earlier, reflecting our stepped-up spending, especially on digital. For the entire year, CapEx reached $148 million, which is $24 million above full year 2022. This higher full-year CapEx was also mostly attributable to our digital investments. Beyond capital expenditures, I'd also like to point out that in 2021 we completed several asset acquisitions worth a total of $20 million, mostly tied to permits and easements within our Americas segment. Turning to slide 13 now. As of December 31st, 2021, Clear Channel Outdoor's consolidated cash and cash equivalents came to $411 million. Our debt stood at $5.6 billion, a slight increase over the prior year. As we said earlier, during the first half of the year we refinanced our 9.25% senior notes, and a non-guarantor European subsidiary of ours took on an unsecured loan of roughly $34 million via the State Guarantee Loan Program. In Q4, we paid down $130 million of the outstanding balance on the revolving credit facility. Interest paid in cash on the debt amounted to $122 million in Q4 and $388 million for the year ended December 31st, 2021. The Q4 cash interest payment ran about $100 million above the prior year, mainly because of when interest payments fell. Our weighted average cost of debt went from 6.1% at December 31st, 2020, down to 5.6% at December 31st, 2021. Now to slide 14, where we'll cover our outlook for the business. As of right now, we expect consolidated revenue to land between $520 million and $550 million in Q1 of 2022, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. Americas revenue should come in between $290 million and $300 million, matching Q1 of 2020, which, as you'll remember, was an exceptionally strong quarter, 8.5% above Q1 of 2019. Europe's revenue should land between $220 million and $235 million, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. For 2022, we expect consolidated capital expenditures in the range of $190 million to $210 million. In keeping with our plan to speed up digital transformation, we expect roughly 60% of that figure to go toward digital assets throughout our portfolio. We also expect to have cash interest payment obligations of about $324 million in 2022. With that, I'll hand the call back to Scott for his closing remarks.

Scott Wells

executive
#4

Thanks, Brian. To sum up, we began 2022 in a robust spot, ready to keep carrying out our plan. As I mentioned, we aren't merely resuming from the point we reached before the pandemic. Instead, we think we can boost our results by using the investments being made in our platform to drive our digital transformation and widen the pool of advertisers we're able to serve. Also, as we keep putting money into technology, we stay dedicated to tightly controlling our expenses and showing more of our operating leverage via profitable growth, while we assess strategic options for our European assets and shore up our balance sheet. Now, I'll hand the call to the operator for the Q&A session. Justin Cochrane, who serves as our CEO for Europe, will be with us on this call.

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#5

Hi, I appreciate you answering my questions. I had a couple. First, might you share additional detail regarding the verticals that haven't bounced back yet? Second, is there anything new you can tell us about the European strategic M&A? Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#6

Thanks. We figured this one would come up. In fact, we have a bit of a prepared

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#7

Whenever you've given guidance, it's usually skewed cautious. Obviously, it seemed like Q4 was — even taking into account that December update. I'm just wondering how we ought to frame the Q1 guide given that pattern. Do you think you're playing it safe? Is the market moving so fast that it's simply hard to predict? Any detail there would help. On a related note, could you take us back through the operating leverage — perhaps what share of costs is fixed across each of the Americas and Europe? That would help us get a sense of what the EBITDA consequences might be for the Q1 guide. Scott, apologies if I overlooked this, but given what you've observed regarding CapEx and cash interest, do you expect to be free cash flow positive this year? Any thoughts on free cash flow would be useful. Thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#8

Fine, Steve. That's quite a bit, and I'm hopeful I can get through it, but should I not, we can definitely come back to it. I-

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#9

Yeah.

Brian Coleman

executive
#10

Since I was moving through this, I never put any of it in writing, so.

Scott Wells

executive
#11

Q1 guidance.

Brian Coleman

executive
#12

Q1 guidance.

Scott Wells

executive
#13

Playing it safe.

Brian Coleman

executive
#14

Right. That was going to be my final point, but Scott mentioned it first. So, I believe it makes sense for us to lean cautious, and I'd prefer that over the alternative. With that said, when we typically issue our guidance, it represents our finest projection of what lies ahead. For Q1, I believe that holds true. Both segments definitely experienced some weakness, especially Europe, due to the Omicron variant throughout the quarter. We believe we've moved past that, and the figures, I think, show where we expect to land. On a consolidated basis, you know, ours aren't drastically different from what we're observing, what we observed in Q1 of 2019. America might be somewhat stronger, having been less affected. Europe, somewhat weaker, more affected by the variant. Still, I think we feel quite confident about the guidance. Once more, it's the finest we have when we give it. Um, I think-

Scott Wells

executive
#15

Operating leverage.

Brian Coleman

executive
#16

Yes. So, there are quite a few fixed costs in our business. Rent is our biggest single expense; across both the Americas and European segments, most of that cost is fixed. I'm not sure we gave much additional segment-level breakdown regarding which parts are fixed versus variable. My estimate is about 75% fixed and 25% variable. Those proportions do move around from time to time. Compensation is our second-biggest expense. After those two, I believe it falls off quite sharply. I hope that offers some directional sense of our operating costs and how they split between fixed and variable. The third item, as I remember, was free cash flow guidance. We aren't giving annualized free cash flow guidance. I'd suggest using how we performed in Q3 and Q4, plus our Q1 guide, as a reasonable proxy, since that spans what amounts to a post-COVID recovery stretch. Knock on wood, but I'd say the business has regained its footing. It's still recovering. If you annualize that performance, strip out the one-timers, the rent abatements, the credit write-off reversals, and various other items, then on the other side make an adjustment for the COVID impact in Q1, I think what you arrive at is a baseline that looks fairly predictive and fairly representative of 2019 levels. From there, we hope to make progress. That doesn't directly answer the question, but I hope it gives you some color on how we're thinking about the business. Scott, I don't know whether you'd like to add anything on top, but

Scott Wells

executive
#17

No, I think that covered it. Yep.

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#18

Thanks, Steve.

Brian Coleman

executive
#19

Great. Thank you.

Analyst

analyst
#20

Hi there, good morning. Jonathan here, sitting in for Lance. Nice work on the quarter. From what I gather, the airports brought in roughly $72 million across the quarter. I'm just curious how much of that total originated from the New York, New Jersey, PA contracts?

Brian Coleman

executive
#21

Hey, Jonathan. As we've mentioned before, commenting on specific contracts isn't something we normally do. I get that what you're really asking is how broad the airport recovery is. I'd say I can describe it comfortably as broad. We're witnessing a solid, robust rebound. The trends we've talked about in prior quarters — those busiest international airports being among the slowest to recover — have persisted; though not to a dramatic degree. What I mean is, airports essentially tripled compared to the same period last year in Q4. That growth was widespread. No single contract was responsible for it.

Analyst

analyst
#22

All right. I've got a couple more things to ask. First off, regarding that Q1 guidance of $520-$550, how does it stack up against Q1 of 2019, if you take China out of the picture?

Brian Coleman

executive
#23

Yeah. I'd say we're in a similar ballpark. Perhaps slightly weaker when you look at it on a consolidated basis. The reason is that we expect better results in the US during Q1, while Europe should come in somewhat softer. Once again, the Omicron variants that emerged early in Q1 had a bit more of an effect. I believe that phase has passed, and our guidance points to a Q1 that's fairly comparable to what we experienced in 2019, excluding China.

Analyst

analyst
#24

Understood. One final thing from my side: how much of the debt right now carries a fixed rate as opposed to a floating one? And out of the $324 guidance for cash interest expense, what portion stems from interest rate hedging?

Brian Coleman

executive
#25

Well, we-

Analyst

analyst
#26

Thanks.

Brian Coleman

executive
#27

Our goal is to keep roughly one-third fixed and two-thirds floating. And, well, once more, I believe that holding a sizable portion of bank debt that can be prepaid early makes sense given where we are right now. Low rates have definitely worked in our favor, though we're also aware that rates are climbing, and we also keep in mind that our company, at least looking back, has tended to do fairly well under those kinds of conditions. As for hedges, well, when we separated, or during the 12 months following that separation, we essentially took the company through a recapitalization, and that let us set our fixed and floating proportions in a natural way. Right now, there are no interest rate hedges on our books. Does that clear things up for you, Jonathan?

Analyst

analyst
#28

Yes, that answers it. I really appreciate it, and congratulations once more.

Brian Coleman

executive
#29

Wonderful. Thanks a lot, Jonathan.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#30

Thanks, and good morning. There are a few things I'd like to ask about. Scott, perhaps I could begin with one of those strategic initiative priorities you mentioned. You brought up programmatic and a few of the efforts in that area, but could you put a size on the opportunity and perhaps, you know, what the timeline might look like to reach what you believe the TAM ultimately is?

Scott Wells

executive
#31

The chance with programmatic is a big one. I mean, if you examine the digital arena, really throughout all the various forms of digital advertising, programmatic represents over Q3 of the revenue in that arena. You know, in our arena, it remains you know, single digits. I think as marketers adopt it, there's potential for you know, some meaningful growth. Conversely, there are significant portions of our assets that people purchase for other reasons and/or you know, can't be converted. It isn't a one-to-one. You know, I'm referring to the printed type assets, many of the iconic type assets. You know, people may not really purchase programmatically because they're truly attempting to really own a location, if you will. Look, I think we're at the very early innings of it; it's expanding very fast. Marketers have clearly demonstrated that they enjoy the experience of being able to purchase flexibly with data. I'm very bullish that this is a strong opportunity for our arena.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#32

Thanks, that's helpful. Let me switch over to costs. Inflation, as we all know, is hitting quite a few industries, though outdoor appears somewhat shielded. Brian, I believe you mentioned that fixed versus variable costs split 75 to 25. Could you discuss any inflationary pressure you might be noticing?

Scott Wells

executive
#33

Pressure from inflation.

Brian Coleman

executive
#34

Right. I'd say the main point is that a fairly large share of our leases are fixed. That's the biggest single thing we spend on, and it does give us some protection; with certain European contracts especially, there may be escalators in there, but overall I'd say that's one of the edges we hold over other players when inflation is running high. The next-biggest expense line for us, pay, is something we need to watch closely, and we have been watching it. Honestly, if the past tells us anything, it suggests the outdoor sector and our company have both handled inflationary periods quite well. We're hoping that holds true down the road, but we don't want to sit still, and we want to make sure we're positioned as strongly as we can be, and we've done that, especially when it comes to pay.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#35

Alright, that's great. Final thing — I realize there's a limit to what you can say, but this marks the first call since the strategic review for Europe was announced. Let me put two questions out there and see whether you're able to respond. Great. If you can't, well, at least I gave it a shot. First, I'm not sure whether you could assist us in any way in thinking about the tax base for those assets. Second, when it comes to Europe, can you somehow size, by percentage or another means, how much of that $127 million of adjusted corporate might be connected to that region? Thanks to all of you for taking the questions.

Scott Wells

executive
#36

Those two are for you, I believe, Brian.

Brian Coleman

executive
#37

Right.

Scott Wells

executive
#38

That was a clever way to try to get details about Europe — nice try.

Brian Coleman

executive
#39

To start, I'll go back to what Scott said. Regarding Europe, there's not much we want to discuss. If anything comes up, you know, in terms of something the board decides — if they ever do decide — and if a decision needs to be made, we'll report it at that point. I suppose I'll wrap up by saying it would be speculative to discuss tax bases on a hypothetical disposition, since you don't know how it would look. I'd just say that we have a tax department. They have experience with international activity, and we clearly recognize how important it is to minimize any tax leakage and to maximize net proceeds from any potential sale. I think we'd handle that well. We haven't really discussed the allocation of corporate expenses. I believe we report on a consolidated basis. I think previously we've said that, roughly in proportion to revenue percentage, we've removed some costs in Europe, so it might be somewhat lower than that. I think that's the only guidance we've provided historically. We wouldn't want to elaborate further. Hopefully that's better than nothing, Avi.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#40

I'll take it. Thank you, everyone.

Scott Wells

executive
#41

Thanks, Avi.

David Joyce

analyst
#42

Thanks. Could you give us a bit more detail on the digital side of things? You've put up plenty of digital displays across Europe, yet relative to the US, your digital top line didn't climb nearly as much. Is that mostly because you already have a larger base of digital inventory in place in the US and could therefore push revenue higher there already, or because American marketers are shifting a bigger share of their budgets into digital out-of-home? Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#43

Thanks, David. I'll take that one; there are a few drivers, though the single largest one is really how big the signs are and how much punch they carry. When it comes to large format billboards, comparing one of them against a single screen isn't really apples to apples, since most of what we're rolling out in Europe is, you know, a screen the size of a bus shelter. One of our big roadside billboards might be the equivalent of six or seven of those in terms of both size and impact, and so the money follows too. You can sort of observe this in the US relationship, where the revenue we report on digital billboards is far greater than what we report on, you know, transit assets, even though we have, you know, many times more screens in transit relative to billboards. So that's the number one driver. As for the other points you raise, about US advertisers being further down the digital road or marketers being ready to commit more spend, that's really specific to each country. You've heard us mention before that our UK business sits at 70% digital, the highest share of digital we have anywhere in the world, and, you know, about double the US proportion of digital. So US marketers and the US market are definitely not ahead of the UK on that front. A few other European markets are slower to develop. You're right about the installed base effect, we've had the digital footprint and the digital playbook for a somewhat longer time, you know, over here in the US. All of those play a part, but the main underlying one is simply the raw value of those very large signs that comes into play. Hopefully, that answers your question.

David Joyce

analyst
#44

Appreciate it. Thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#45

Thanks, David.

Jim Goss

analyst
#46

Okay, thanks. Given what we’ve discussed regarding that 75, 25 split between fixed and variable costs, it’s clear there isn’t a lot of room to maneuver when it comes to reducing expenses. Still, you managed to improve margins in both the domestic and European businesses. I’d like to hear more about which specific cost and expense areas helped keep expense growth behind the revenue growth you’ve achieved, and how much of that can be maintained going forward? Because I think the idea tied to some of the COVID situation is that you could see revenues bounce back and possibly achieve some longer-term savings on the expense side, which would boost profitability. Could you go into that a bit?

Scott Wells

executive
#47

Do you want me to start off on this?

Jim Goss

analyst
#48

Yes, we can. Either way works.

Scott Wells

executive
#49

Yes. Thank you. Thank you, Jim. I think the situation differs somewhat depending on which part of the portfolio you look at, and the matters we've been discussing in these questions definitely play a role. First, as you'd expect, and as we've said on earlier calls, our costs during and throughout the initial stages of recovery from COVID are uneven. The relief we received didn't arrive in a straight line; it didn't necessarily arrive promptly, but arrive it did. We got fairly substantial relief in Q4. I'll let Brian address some of the additional factors that showed up in Q4, but especially in the US, the relief was very substantial. I think if you look at the European business, there was very strong operating leverage, to the degree we were discussing as well. Some relief was present there too, but in Europe you truly had the business performing at its peak from a revenue standpoint. If you simply examine the pattern of our margins in Europe, you'll notice that Q4 is typically the high point. I think Q4 of 2021 was an especially strong illustration of that, thanks to pent-up demand. Let me pass it to Brian to add other points, because there were other contributors.

Brian Coleman

executive
#50

Much of what Scott mentioned lines up with my view. Sure, in Europe there's a seasonal element to consider, yet Q4, I believe, genuinely demonstrated both the rebound and the operating leverage this business carries. Across every region, though especially in the US, that uneven pattern showed up during Q4. It came from rent abatements, which are common both in the US and throughout Europe. Then you had credit loss reserves being reversed — a leftover effect from the COVID period. On top of that, certain temporary cost-cutting programs were beginning to taper off. Those three categories of activity propped up margins. Strip out those categories, since they're temporary or one-time in nature, and margins land quite near where they stood in 2019. My view is that once you account for those one-timers, so to speak, the link between revenue and margins does still hold. The thing is, throughout last year, each quarter came in uneven regarding when abatements arrived. Our teams keep pushing as hard as they can, and they've done a tremendous job across the past year and a half securing those abatements, but they'll gradually taper off, and that unevenness should diminish down the road. Essentially, you'll get back the revenue-to-margin connection from 2019, with certain headwinds and tailwinds attached. That isn't to say 2019 revenue automatically produces 2019 margins. The business mix has shifted. Certain cost reductions act as tailwinds. Still, on the whole, that broad relationship ought to return to a normal state.

Jim Goss

analyst
#51

All right. The next area I was hoping to get into relates to something you mentioned right at the start of your presentation — turning the advertising medium that's been around longer than any other into a visual media powerhouse driven by technology. That's been a focus for several years now, both through digital transformation and through RADAR. I believe one of the slides had some remarks about RADAR tied to millennials, and about possibly using cell phone data to modify what gets displayed. I was hoping you could talk a bit about how something like that would function and what effect it could have, for instance, on screens at airports, where you'd potentially know the flight, know who's on that flight demographically, and whether you'd use programmatic or other advertising and tailor those display ads specifically to fit the audience you're reaching, becoming more sophisticated in that way.

Scott Wells

executive
#52

Sure. That's quite a bit in there, Jim. What I'd begin with, I suppose, is that marketers aren't at the point yet — in terms of creative assets being available and in terms of, you know, their capacity to spend — where they'd be, like, changing the signs live. Our infrastructure, and honestly the cell phone data infrastructure, can't do it; we don't live in a Minority Report-type world, and with any luck, we'll never actually reach that world, because on many levels that world is quite frightening. What we can do is examine data across time, and we can accomplish a range of things through RADAR. Advertisers turn to it for planning purposes. Take the scenario you're describing — suppose they want to have a presence, you know, at South by Southwest, and we've got the Austin Airport; they may do fairly aggressive things to establish that presence, you know, such as having a real-life presence, you know, placing a car on the floor, you know, doing things with the signage to back that up; honestly, that's something where, you know, RADAR isn't necessary; but RADAR becomes necessary when, say, we've got an advertiser trying to reach coffee enthusiasts, and that's a demographic where we can get at the data quite easily. We can match people to our signs, whether at airports or along roadsides, who over-index for coffee enthusiasm, and shape the campaigns to fit. There are other capabilities RADAR gives us; that covers the planning side. Beyond that, we can also go back and examine how exposed audiences behaved, once again linking it through the cell phone data infrastructure; we can go back and check whether people visited retail locations; we can plug into you know other data sources. Many advertisers have invested heavily in creating their own first-party data. We're able to access their loyalty programs, and by way of privacy-compliant methods, link everything back and examine whether your campaign actually shifted things with your audience. That's the attribution component. The most intense form of this involves us integrating our data directly with theirs, once again following privacy-compliant practices, through something like LiveRamp or a comparable provider, and then they carry out the analysis themselves. As one illustration, we did exactly this alongside Twitch, which drew on exposure data we supply via RADAR to evaluate how the campaign performed. You can find that in the presentation. Regarding digital transformation, the sign itself is merely the initial element. The sign, the data, the purchasing experience, the fulfillment — every one of those is undergoing digital transformation, and that represents a major catalyst for this business over the years ahead.

Jim Goss

analyst
#53

All right, I really appreciate that. I find that quite useful.

Scott Wells

executive
#54

Appreciate it, Jim.

Brian Coleman

executive
#55

Thanks, Jim.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#56

Hello, everyone. I appreciate you letting me join. A few things I wanted to ask. Scott, could you discuss the way yield is bouncing back compared with how things stood before the pandemic, both in the US and more broadly? And if there are any distinct patterns or contrasts worth pointing out between digital and non-digital on that subject, please do so.

Scott Wells

executive
#57

Thank you, Aaron. Sure, so, a few points. To start with, I'd tell you that yields are recovering quite strongly and are likely, on the whole, above the level we saw before the pandemic. That will differ to some degree depending on geography and the kind of asset. But taken together, yield has recovered strongly, and advertisers place a great deal of value on our media. As you've heard us say previously and heard our competitors say too, our CPMs are extremely reasonable next to many other media outlets; that allows for a value-based conversation about what we deliver. Yields have recovered strongly; when it comes to digital versus non-digital, we do sell off a large share of our printed inventory. The yield discussion there is far less dynamic, since you're signing deals covering six months, 12 months, multiple years. Those could include fixed escalators; the pricing environment simply isn't usually very dynamic. Compare that with digital, where participants enter and exit the market rapidly; in programmatic, the most extreme case of that, you see people entering and, you know, competing on bids for the space. That's typically where your overall yields wind up highest. You know, digital as a whole is a premium product, and programmatic is then a premium product inside digital. You know, that's a major fundamental driver in. The reason it works that way is the value it provides to the advertiser. Nothing besides that is what drives it. As we grow more digital, as we bring more data and more insight into our campaigns, we'd anticipate yields continuing to get better.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#58

All right, that's useful. Thanks. Brian, I believe I caught you mentioning that the Northeast region was especially robust for you. Could you share anything else about just the large markets compared with, you know, a few of your smaller ones, and how the rebound is developing recently?

Brian Coleman

executive
#59

Yes. In fact, I'll hand that question to Scott. He likely has a better view of how operations are performing across the Americas.

Scott Wells

executive
#60

Yes. I mean, on the whole, the country has performed well. If you examine it from a percentage growth standpoint, you know, there's the COVID factor that entered the picture. You know, we had quite a few markets that COVID didn't hit all that hard, especially our smaller ones, and those are largely located in the South and West. Those markets, you know, in percentage terms aren't expanding all that much, but they aren't expanding as quickly; they're above 2019 levels and for the most part have stayed above 2019, you know, all the way through COVID. Then you've got certain large cities where we suffered really severe blows, or the airports business, where in the aggregate we took a major blow, you know, and there we truly saw a rebound during the back half of last year, you know, fairly much across the board. It's not. There isn't much of a narrative beyond the fact that the locations hit hardest are bouncing back quickest. You know, if you look at it, if you adjust it against 2019, things are returning approximately in keeping with, you know, the point at which we went into COVID. Once again, a lot of the markets sit above where we stood in 2019. Hopefully that gives you a sense of it. I don't know, Brian, whether there's anything you'd want to add.

Brian Coleman

executive
#61

No.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#62

All right. That sounds good, Scott. One final item from me — probably more of an administrative matter, and I believe it's directed at Brian. Thanks for the useful details on CapEx and interest guidance for this year. Is there anything regarding cash taxes that we ought to keep in mind for this year? Or is it going to stay fairly in line with what we've observed?

Brian Coleman

executive
#63

My expectation is that it stays fairly in line. I think, you know, the choice management made to go with the election we pursued keeps our US taxes to a minimum, in fact removes, you know, federal taxes within the US at least, and at least given the present setup. Historically, what we've faced is a bit of state and local in the US and, you know, our taxes abroad, and I think that stays fairly in line. I mean, as recovery comes, as we produce, wouldn't anticipate any significant shifts during the coming year.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#64

And on a similar note, is there anything you're able to tell us regarding how large any NOLs you've accumulated might be, or?

Brian Coleman

executive
#65

There's nothing to add past what was included in the 10-K. I don't believe there's anything-

Aaron Watts

analyst
#66

Oh.

Brian Coleman

executive
#67

anything new or dramatic.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#68

All right, okay. I really appreciate you giving me a few minutes.

Brian Coleman

executive
#69

Of course.

Scott Wells

executive
#70

Okay, that appears to be all the questions we have. We truly appreciate both the questions and the level of engagement, and everyone taking the time to be with us this morning. I'll wrap up by saying that we are extremely excited about this business. We believe our position is very strong when it comes to achieving success and generating meaningful growth. Thank you for your time and attention. Have a great day.

Brian Coleman

executive
#71

Thank you.

Operator

operator
#72

That wraps up the conference call for today. We appreciate everyone taking the time to participate. At this point, you're free to hang up your lines.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.