Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 8, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Communication Services Media earnings 57 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Eileen McLaughlin

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. Joining us on this call are our CEO, Scott Wells, and our CFO, Brian Coleman. Scott and Brian will walk through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. and Clear Channel International BV performed operationally during the third quarter of 2022. We suggest you download the earnings conference call investor presentation, which can be found in the financial section of our investor website, and follow along with it during the call. Following some opening remarks and a look at our results, we'll take your questions. Also participating in the Q&A portion will be Justin Cochrane, CEO of Clear Channel Europe. Before we get started, I want to remind everybody that we may make forward-looking statements on this call about the company, including statements regarding its future financial performance and its strategic goals. All forward-looking statements carry risks and uncertainties, and there's no guarantee that management's expectations, beliefs or projections will come to pass, or that actual results won't differ from expectations. Please take a look at the risk statements included in our earnings press release and in our filings with the SEC. During today's call, we'll also reference certain performance measures that don't conform to generally accepted accounting principles. As part of our earnings release and the earnings conference call investor presentation, we provide schedules reconciling these non-GAAP measures with our reported results on a GAAP basis. Also, please be aware that what's shared on this call reflects only management's views as of today, November 8th, 2022, and might no longer be accurate when a replay is heard. Please go to slide four in the investor presentation, and I'll hand the call over to Scott Wells now.

Scott Wells

executive
#2

Hello, everyone, and I appreciate you spending part of your day with us on this call. The solid results we posted for the third quarter landed at the top end of the consolidated revenue outlook we shared on our previous call, and they demonstrate how resilient our platform is, how committed our teams are across the entire company, and how we keep executing the strategic plan we laid out at our Investor Day in September. Third quarter consolidated revenue came in at $603 million, which represents an 8% increase, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. Building on what we observed during the first half of the year, broad-based advertiser demand drove our performance, with particularly notable strength in our digital footprint throughout the Americas and Europe; we're making progress and delivering to our advertisers the experience they anticipate from digital media, which we think fuels our growth both currently and down the road. We're making our solutions quicker to launch, simpler to purchase, and more driven by data. Consequently, we believe we're doing quite well at a time that's challenging for numerous ad delivery platforms. As we pointed out at our Investor Day, we see digital as more than just a growth driver — it's a revenue multiplier. When the third quarter ended, digital made up under 5% of total inventory, and yet digital revenue contributed 40% of our consolidated revenue while climbing 20% for the period versus the third quarter of the prior year, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. Turning to our digital footprint in the U.S., during the third quarter we deployed 34 large-format digital billboards, which brought our total to over 1,600 digital billboards. Along with our smaller format digital displays located in airports and on shelters, that gives us over 4,700 digital displays in the domestic market. Over in Europe, we installed 366 digital displays during the third quarter, bringing the total to 19,200 digital displays currently live. While we grow our digital footprint, we keep enhancing our data analytics offerings and developing a more sophisticated operational back-end for the customer experience; through these investments we're able to draw a larger pool of advertisers, which is a good sign for our longer-term outlook. To illustrate how dynamic our platform is, I want to recognize our airports team for their efforts in creating a multiyear, multimillion dollar partnership and sponsorship with PenFed’s Credit Union. This brand takeover — the first of its kind — of the Concourse C Connector at Washington Dulles features the 4,000 square foot digital media tunnel. It's truly a sight to behold, and we're pursuing additional opportunities with PenFed. Regarding the fourth quarter, our business is still healthy, and we expect to deliver results consistent with the full-year guidance we gave during our Investor Day in September. Brian will share more on our guidance during his prepared remarks, but I'd like to take a moment to highlight what we're observing. Like we said in the full-year guidance, growth should slow down in Q4 compared with the past several quarters, because we're up against tougher comps from a strong fourth quarter a year ago. Since September, advertiser behavior hasn't shifted in any meaningful way. Demand for advertising in the U.S. is still healthy, and we're still on pace to beat our record revenue in Q4 2021. Airports and digital keep fueling that gain; in Europe, our business is also still healthy and on pace to beat Q4 2019, and it's consistent with a very strong Q4 2021, excluding FX rate movements, since we keep gaining from growth in our digital platform and the rebound in transit. Bookings and pacing remain strong in Northern Europe, especially the U.K. and Scandinavia, against pre-COVID levels in 2019; even so, a few markets, mainly in parts of Southern Europe, still haven't completely recovered. Looking further ahead, we're watching business trends closely across our markets. And so far, our 2023 upfront in the U.S. is going well, and we're still optimistic about our business. Lastly, we're still reviewing strategic alternatives for our European business, aiming to optimize our portfolio in the best interest of our shareholders, with the resulting greater focus on our core Americas business. We'll share more details when we're able to. With that, let me hand it over to Brian to talk about our third quarter financial results and our fourth quarter guidance.

Brian Coleman

executive
#3

Thanks, Scott. Morning, everyone, and I appreciate you being on the call. Like Scott said, we delivered another strong quarter, and we feel our business is positioned to hit the full-year guidance we shared at our Investor Day, which you can see on slide 14. Now, turning to slide five and our third quarter results. Before I get into those numbers, I want to remind all of you that while I discuss GAAP results, I'll also cover our results excluding foreign exchange rate movements, which is a non-GAAP measure. Our view is that this gives better comparability when assessing how we performed. Also, just a reminder that direct operating expenses and SG&A expenses include restructuring and other costs, and those are excluded from adjusted EBITDA and segment adjusted EBITDA. So I don't repeat myself, the amounts I mention are for Q3 2022, and the percentage changes are for Q3 2022 versus Q3 2021, unless I say otherwise. Consolidated revenue came in at $603 million, which is a 1.1% increase. Excluding foreign exchange rate movements, consolidated revenue rose 7.8% to $643 million, at the high end of our consolidated revenue guidance range of $625 million to $645 million. Net loss was $39 million, a modest improvement from $41 million a year earlier. Adjusted EBITDA was $129 million, a decline of 5%, versus $136 million in Q3 2021. Excluding foreign exchange movements, adjusted EBITDA was $131 million, down 3.8%. Please go to slide six for a look at the Americas third quarter results. Americas revenue was $347 million, up 9% and within our guidance range of $340 million to $350 million. And what's even more notable, we keep exceeding pre-COVID revenue levels, with revenue rising 6% compared to Q3 of 2019. Revenue grew across every major product category, with airport displays standing out the most. Digital revenue, which made up 39% of Americas revenue, rose 16.6% to $134 million, fueled by both airports and billboards. National sales, which represented 39.7% of Americas revenue, were up 8%, while local sales made up 60.3% of Americas revenue and rose 9%. Direct operating and SG&A expenses increased 12.1%. That rise is mainly attributable to a 10.2% increase in site lease expense to $114 million, driven by higher revenue, primarily in our airports business, partly offset by a small increase in negotiated rent abatements. Segment adjusted EBITDA was $145 million, up 4.1%, with segment adjusted EBITDA margin of 41.8%, lower than Q3 2021, mainly because of mix and, as expected, consistent with Q3 2019. Moving to slide seven. This slide splits our Americas revenue into billboard and other and transit. Billboard and Other, which mainly includes revenues from bulletins, posters, street furniture displays, spectaculars and wallscapes, rose 2.6% to $280 million; this result was primarily driven by strength in our California, Southwest and Midwest regions. Transit was up 44.7%, with airport display revenue up 45% to $62 million, driven by growth across the portfolio, including Port Authority. Turning to slide 8, I'll give you a little more color on billboard and other. In Q3, billboard and other digital revenue kept recovering, rising 6.8% to $98 million, and now accounts made up 34.8% of total billboard and other revenue, which is up from Q2. Non-digital billboard and other revenue came in slightly higher. Now let's go to slide 9, where I'll walk through how we did in Europe during the third quarter. My remarks cover results adjusted to remove the impact of foreign exchange rate movements. Europe revenue rose 6.1% to $279 million, landing at the top end of our guidance range of $270 million to $280 million. The gain came from better transit and street furniture display performance, with revenue higher in most countries, above all Sweden, partly offset by a drop in France. Europe revenue also climbed relative to the comparable 2019 period, and that growth rate exceeded the increase we recorded in the second quarter of 2022 against the second quarter of 2019, after adjusting for FX rate movements. Digital represented 40.8% of Europe's total revenue and grew 22.4%, fueled by more digital assets and a sharp demand rebound in Scandinavia, including on our transit assets. Direct operating and SG&A expenses rose 5.6%. That gain was mainly the result of higher site lease expense, which climbed 22.1% because of a $9 million decrease in negotiated rent abatements, along with reduced governmental rent subsidies and greater revenue. Segment adjusted EBITDA came to $18 million, and the segment adjusted EBITDA margin was 6.5%, with both figures lower than the prior year, partly because of the one-time site lease expense reduction in the prior year. Segment adjusted EBITDA margin was modestly above the Q3 2019 segment adjusted EBITDA margin. Let's turn to CCIBV. Our Europe segment is made up of the businesses run by CCIBV and its consolidated subsidiaries. So the revenue for our Europe segment equals the revenue for CCIBV. Europe segment adjusted EBITDA, the segment profitability metric shown in our financial statements, excludes an allocation of CCIBV's corporate expenses, which are subtracted from CCIBV's operating income or loss and adjusted EBITDA. Europe and CCIBV revenue fell $23 million in the third quarter of 2022 versus the same period of 2021, coming to $239 million. After adjusting for a $39 million impact from foreign exchange rate movements, Europe and CCIBV revenue rose $16.1 million. CCIBV's operating loss was $14 million in the third quarter of 2022, versus an operating loss of $26 million in the same period of 2021. Let's go to slide 10 for a quick look at other, which is our Latin American operations. As with Europe, my remarks cover results adjusted to remove the impact of foreign exchange rate movements. Other revenue rose 19.1%, driven by gains in most countries. Direct operating and SG&A costs rose 5%, mostly because of greater site lease expense tied largely to increased revenue. Segment adjusted EBITDA came in at $3 million, which is better than the prior year's breakeven segment adjusted EBITDA. Turning now to slide 11, where we look at capital expenditures. CapEx reached $43 million, up $11 million from the third quarter a year earlier, as we accelerated spending, especially on digital displays in the Americas. Beyond our capital expenditures, I'd also like to point out that in the third quarter we completed several asset acquisitions totaling $28 million within our Americas segment. Moving to slide 12. On a year-to-date basis, cash and cash equivalents fell $83 million, landing at $327 million as of September 30, 2022. And in the third quarter, cash and cash equivalents grew $13 million. Adjusted EBITDA of $129 million, along with shifts in net working capital, added positively to our cash balance during the quarter, and that was partly offset by cash interest payments and net capital investment. As of September 30th, 2022, our debt stood at $5.6 billion, a modest decrease from 2021 year-end, mainly because of scheduled quarterly principal payments on the term loan facility.

Brian Coleman

executive
#4

Interest payments made in cash on our debt totaled $56 million in Q3, which is $4 million more than what we paid in the comparable period a year earlier. That rise stems mainly from increased floating rate interest tied to our term loan B facility. The weighted average cost of our debt came in at 6.5%, higher than where it stood at year-end, driven by LIBOR rates moving up. As of September 30th, 2022, we had $543 million in liquidity, a decrease from the year-end figure, largely because our cash balance came down. Our first lien leverage ratio stood at 4.98 times as of September 30th, 2022, which is comfortably under the 7.1 times covenant threshold. Now let's go to slide 13 and discuss our new metric, AFFO. During our Investor Day, as you're probably aware, we rolled out a fresh measure for the company: adjusted funds from operations, or AFFO. For Q3, we produced $24 million of AFFO, and on a year-to-date basis, $91 million, in each case excluding FX rate movements. Let's move to slide 14, covering our guidance for Q4 and the entire year of 2022. As Scott noted, advertiser behavior hasn't shifted in any material way, and we can confirm that our Q4 revenue guidance should land inside the range we gave at our Investor Day on September 8th. The sole revision to our fiscal year 2022 guidance is consolidated net loss, which grew mainly because of FX rate movements. I'm not going to walk through every line item on this page, but I would like to call out a handful of updates to our guidance. We expect consolidated revenue to land somewhere between $740 million and $765 million in Q4 of 2022, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. For the Americas, revenue should come in between $370 million and $380 million. On top of that, we expect Americas segment adjusted EBITDA to fall at the low end of the range we provided, chiefly because of uncertainty about when certain anticipated rent abatements will occur, along with weaker performance in programmatic. Europe's revenue should be between $345 million and $360 million, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. Using monthly and October exchange rates, foreign currency might create a 15% headwind to Europe's year-over-year reported revenue growth in Q4. In addition, our cash interest payment obligations for 2022 will stay at $341 million, which includes $124 million across the rest of this year. That said, cash interest payment obligations for 2023 should climb to $404 million, driven by higher floating rate interest on our Term Loan B facility. This guidance presumes interest rates hold at present levels and that no refinancing or extra indebtedness takes place. Finally, I want to say a few words about 2023. How much visibility we have into 2023 is limited, and we're quite mindful of the worries out there about the macro environment next year. Even so, we've shown before that we can change direction when recessions hit — 2020 and the pandemic being one example — and we're confident we understand the way to cut costs rapidly and safeguard our cash position should that become necessary down the road. At this point, I'll hand things back to Scott so he can share his final thoughts.

Scott Wells

executive
#5

Brian, thank you. Things are still solid across our operations, we have faith in the plan we've laid out, and we see plenty of room to grow going forward. I want to express appreciation to everyone on our team for the commitment they've shown in carrying out our strategic priorities — among them speeding up our digital transformation, becoming more customer-centric, and pursuing executional excellence; in our view, these initiatives are helping us bolster where we stand competitively and take a bigger portion of advertising budgets down the road. At this point, I'll hand things over to the operator so we can move into the Q&A portion. Justin Cochrane, who leads Europe as our CEO, is also with us on this call.

Steven Cahall

analyst
#6

Thanks. Morning, everyone. Could you discuss how much overlap you're observing in the Americas between print subscribers and digital ones? The digital spend appears to be expanding quite well toward that roughly 40% mark, so does that come on top of what existing out-of-home advertisers were already spending? Or can you tell whether new buyers are entering the market who are digital — sort of digital-only. And given that growth, are you expecting to raise your digital CapEx in 2023? Then I have a follow-up.

Scott Wells

executive
#7

All right, thank you. Steve, appreciate the question. Digital is a fascinating topic. And every one of those possibilities is true. We certainly have — I mean, I believe what has drawn new-to-the-category buyers in more than digital is programmatic. I think that's the area where more new-to-the-category buyers have come to us; yet digital, honestly from the moment we began offering it, has been partly additive, while also partly amplification. So many clients purchase print campaigns, then turn to digital to complement those campaigns, to drive calls to action, and to accomplish things only digital is capable of; and much of the present momentum you're witnessing with digital stems from the fact that in our modern airport build-outs, digital plays such a central role in what we do, and it's truly taking off in that airport sector. So really — with the customer base, it's tough to attribute it to any single factor, but it's fairly broad. Regarding your second part on CapEx, we really — on the road side portion of the business, we haven't really held that back. That's been paced more or less by our capacity to navigate regulations and secure the ability to complete the conversions; it is something that comes up regularly in our discussions; and if you spoke with our regional managers and branch presidents, they would say there's considerable emphasis on locating great sites to convert to digital, though that isn't really especially different from how it's been. But let's continue with the next part of your question.

Steven Cahall

analyst
#8

Yes, thank you for that. For the next portion, I just wanted to ask about revenue from airports. Do you happen to have any historical information on how airport tends to hold up during a recession? My sense is that it's still recovering toward roughly where it was before COVID, so travel still appears fairly robust. If the macro environment shifts, is your expectation that airport outperforms the remainder of the portfolio? Is it somewhat more cyclical compared to the rest of the portfolio? And then perhaps finally, I'm just curious whether you anticipate a significant amount of rent abatements in 2023. Thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#9

Sure, sure. Regarding airports, that's a really good question, since the airports as we currently have them are quite unlike any previous cycle except perhaps COVID. What I mean is that, as I mentioned earlier, digital has become such a central component of them — if you look back at the great financial crisis or 9/11, which were the two major disruptions to airports in recent history, print played a much bigger role in the business. And as we've observed across the spectrum, it simply behaves differently from digital. I do believe what has emerged from COVID is that advertisers who returned early have genuinely seen impact from their airport campaigns. And I suppose what I'd really stress is that not only are the assets different, but the way we sell them is structurally different. A meaningful chunk of the revenue in airports is coming from our local sales team. That was not the case in prior recessions. And one of the questions I get as I go around the country is people asking for airports and their communities, because it's becoming an attractive area for account executives to find big customers who want to do bold things; and I think that — so we're selling a good part of it through our local branches; so it's a more diversified sales base. And we're also doing a lot more like what I referred to in the opening comments like with PenFed, where we're actually doing things that are more akin to sponsorships than advertising; and so I think that there are — the degree to which it's digital would be something that you could look at and say, well, that's going to be responsive in a recession. It's going to be reactionary in a recession; on the flip side, the broader sales base, the broader customer base, because we've done a good job expanding that. And the proliferation of sponsorships makes it a bit more sticky, so hopefully, that gives you a flavor. And on abatements, we are still working through some. I think we characterize that as — in Europe, we probably are done with anything that's going to be forthcoming relating to COVID. Within America, there's a remaining set of items we're continuing to address, though nothing will resemble the scale seen during 2021 or even what occurred this year. So I hope that clarifies things for you, Steve.

Steven Cahall

analyst
#10

Thanks, guys.

Ben Swinburne

analyst
#11

Thank you. Good morning, everyone. Scott, I was wondering, you talked about programmatic being a key tailwind to digital adoption, digital growth. But I think you also cited it as maybe a source of weakness among your channels this quarter, which we've heard that from a number of players around media. Is there anything more to that in your mind than just that's where it's easy to dial it up, dial it down? Or do you think there's other things that are either — that's telling us about where the broader business is headed? Or are there things that you think you can do with your programmatic channels to maybe improve either their market share or sort of the stickiness of the money. I'd love to get your thoughts on that, we're all trying to read the tea leaves.

Scott Wells

executive
#12

Yes. And Ben, that's the exact right characterization; it's still very much in the tea leaves stage with programmatic. I don't think that we are anywhere near — we are not near a steady state. Just this year, the Trade Desk and DV360 have gotten involved in out-of-home programmatic in a meaningful way. And as a couple of the biggest omnichannel DSPs, what their impact is going to be on this space, I think, is still very much an unknown. When I look at what's going on this year, I think there is a few things that have happened in out-of-home programmatic. I mean, I think first and most obvious is what you said, which is — it's the super easy channel to turn on and turn off and where people are doing more promotional spend, that's something that they've maybe dialed back quicker. And that we've seen in some of the mainstream digital advertising parties that they've seen that impact; on the flip side, you have a lot of — the programmatic space in out-of-home greatly expanded this year in terms of the number of screens. So if you looked at the screens available for digital out-of-home, in January of this year and you looked at it now, you would see a massive amount more screens available. And a lot of those screens are in places that were hit extremely hard by COVID; and so part of why I think what, kind of, happened is that the roadside programmatic came back first; and then over the course of this year, you've had mall-based and elevator-based and gym-based, all the other kind of locations that out-of-home happens has had a better run. And that was particularly true in the first half. I'm not sure — I don't have my finger on the pulse of exactly what they're seeing. But that proliferation of screens is something that I think has to get normalized and the marketplace has to sort out how it thinks about the different types of out-of-home programmatic. Also, we remain, once more, at a really early stage when it comes to how well people grasp this. Then the final item I want to mention is that besides roadside being the first area to genuinely surge once COVID eased within programmatic, the fourth quarter of the prior year was simply an enormous quarter. Given the kind of year we've just been through on the macro side, plus every worry that has surfaced — war, inflation, recession, interest rates, take your pick — it's tough to pull that together or even recall it at this moment; even so, in last year's Q4, programmatic was truly and unmistakably blazing. And that is — that's likely, you know, I'm certain we'll spend a bit of time on how our pacing compares as we move toward Q4, yet that stands among the major reasons we aren't witnessing. The situation isn't that it's contracting, or contracting significantly. Whether it will expand by much remains undecided, but it definitely isn't enjoying the sort of favorable push it did a year ago; so with any luck, that offers you a bit of clarity regarding what's happening with programmatic.

Ben Swinburne

analyst
#13

Yeah, yeah. No, that's a big help, actually. And, Brian, I'm not sure — I don't recall you bringing this up during your prepared remarks. But at this point, since we've got 3 quarters of the year behind us, is there anything new on what we should expect for free cash flow across the full year? I suppose what I'm really asking about is working capital, with 3 months still to go, or anything else that ought to be on our minds?

Brian Coleman

executive
#14

Yes. I'd say there's nothing further I can offer beyond the guidance and details we've already shared. What I'd say is that we keep demonstrating operational progress. Interest rate increases have created something of a headwind for us, since we do carry some variable rate exposure; as a result, that could push back when free cash flow turns positive; even so, our aim is to keep growing the business despite the headwinds present out there, and my view is that 2023 is going to be a big year for us.

Ben Swinburne

analyst
#15

Thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#16

Thanks, Ben.

Lance Vitanza

analyst
#17

Hello, and thank you all for fielding the questions. Great work this quarter. I'd like to revisit the topic of airport advertising. Across the whole industry, would you say that ads have come back more quickly or more slowly than the actual level of airport travel? What I'm really asking is simply this: do you believe there's still a significant tailwind remaining? Setting aside the possibility of a recession, do you think there's still a lot of tailwind left as international business travel keeps recovering?

Scott Wells

executive
#18

Thank you, Lance. It's a solid question. I believe you've heard every out-of-home, transit-focused operator mention that the audience need not return to 100% of its prior level for ad spending to recover; it varies somewhat among the different categories of transit, yet I'd say that has held true. Our numbers certainly would confirm that has held true at airports. At many of our airports, we're now at 2019 levels. Yet ad revenue has likely recovered. It has recovered somewhat more quickly than passenger counts have. I think airport advertisers are quite savvy about this when it comes to examining anticipated passenger patterns and anticipated travel patterns; and I think one point, especially for airports, that has struck a chord with people is that even when they aren't business travelers on business trips, the audience at an airport typically includes plenty of business decision-makers. And so for the B2B audience in particular, that has been a strength, so I'm not sure I'd describe it — I mean, if you examine it purely mechanically, our airport comps are now overlapping. In Q4, really, it's essentially overlapping a full-throttle kind of quarter in terms of airport performance; so whereas we had even triple-digit growth at airports earlier this year, you won't be seeing that going forward. And it will be part of our overall percent growth decelerating somewhat as time goes on. But that doesn't actually mean we're taking a step backward. It simply means the relative growth rate is smaller.

Lance Vitanza

analyst
#19

Okay. And then, if I may, just one final question from my end: over in the Americas, on the static side, there was hardly any growth this quarter. So I'm curious — was there some specific factor weighing on growth there? Or is that basically the new baseline for static? In other words, is it just minimal to no expansion from here on out? Or did the third quarter represent something of an outlier? Or is this simply softening advertiser demand, plus global macro news?

Scott Wells

executive
#20

It's certainly not that last one. What I'd tell you is — throughout this year we've discussed, and I believe I've spoken with you a couple of times, about insurance. A couple of those insurance companies that have been drastically, drastically, drastically lower this year, Q3 included, compared with 2021 — that was big print advertising, advertiser. So that's been a drag on that kind of inventory for the entire year. We're feeling good about our efforts with our printed assets. We believe advertiser demand is solid. There's a chance for us to backfill part of that; perhaps we didn't capture as much of it during Q3 as we'd have preferred. When I look across the whole system, we're in a more — I dislike using the term normal, since not much is normal in these times, but the dynamic is somewhat more normal in the sense that you've got big city against small city against medium city dynamics. You've got East Coast against West Coast against Southwest dynamics; and in this situation, when you look at print, the story is very different in the Northeast, where it isn't a good story, compared with, let's say, California, where it's a pretty good story; so I'd say the fact that it's roughly flat is merely a bit of an artifact of this particular moment and probably isn't something to interpret as a trend.

Lance Vitanza

analyst
#21

Very helpful. Thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#22

Thanks, Lance.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#23

Hi, everybody. I appreciate you letting me join. Brian, I want to ask a follow-up about how comfortable you are with liquidity as we head into 2023, given the macro worries and the higher debt service you pointed out. And could you also say whether you expect working capital to come back to more normal patterns in ‘23; and on a related note, now that your revolver loans are gone, you brought up your 7.1 covenant. Can you remind us what limits exist for you to tap those facilities?

Brian Coleman

executive
#24

Absolutely. On liquidity, we still feel good, I'd say. Clearly, we'll watch liquidity levels closely. We discussed rising interest rates and greater cash interest expense a bit; so that's definitely a headwind we need to stay mindful of; but from an operations standpoint, things feel good, all things considered; so I'd say we feel good about where our liquidity stands. I also believe that as we move into 2023, you'll see working capital normalize back to — broadly back to levels before COVID. Keep in mind, though, we have meaningful seasonal swings in working capital. To build on a question asked earlier, Q4 is a strong quarter for us, yet we actually don't bring in a lot of that revenue during Q1, which is a weaker quarter for us. So you'll see a large working capital movement there. So I'd say, broadly, we feel pretty good, but this is a volatile environment; so we want to be sure we stay on top of things. The key to that is availability under our revolvers. Right now they're undrawn; we'll use them for letter of credit purposes, but we have significant undrawn liquidity capacity there; and we have only one financial covenant, which is the one you mentioned. So that first lien leverage ratio, we're just under 5 times the covenants I think, 7.1 times currently. So there's plenty of room there. So we've got liquidity capacity in the form of cash; we have liquidity capacity in the form of availability under our cash flow and our ABL revolver. And I think we feel pretty good about where we are, all things considered.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#25

Okay, that's genuinely useful, Brian. I appreciate it. Then, Scott, I'm not sure whether I'll be able to learn anything here. Still, when it comes to the strategic review, is the attention still on chosen European markets rather than, in a sense, everything? And even with the clear obstacles in the capital markets and the macro environment, have any discussions progressed to a later stage?

Scott Wells

executive
#26

Yeah, that's accurate. There isn't much I'm able to share on that topic. What I would simply say is that the guidance we provided at our Investor Day, and which we, in a way, touched on in the discussion during the earlier part of the prepared remarks, still holds: we are examining a portion of the operations, with our emphasis on maximizing shareholder value. As for the reality of conditions for completing deals, yes, this is a difficult one, yet if you possess assets that draw interest and you have counterparties who are eager, anything can happen; and I cannot address any particulars, though we are dedicated to providing the Street with updates whenever there is something material we are able to disclose.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#27

Okay, thank you. Appreciate the time.

Scott Wells

executive
#28

Thank you.

Richard Choe

analyst
#29

Hi, I was hoping you could expand on programmatic. In past quarters, you've described it as tending to come in stronger toward the end. Did it actually stay weaker across the whole quarter rather than being weighted to the back half?

Scott Wells

executive
#30

With programmatic, the seasonal pattern shifts somewhat from one quarter to the next. Certain months during the year tend to be spikier — for example, in terms of demand, May could turn out to be a bigger month than June. In Q4 especially, December sets the tone for how the quarter's seasonality plays out, so to speak; even so, we've reached a stage where our daily sales let us grasp a fair amount about what the demand picture looks like. What I mean is, this is a business quite different from the rest of the outdoor business; think of it as more of a volume retail operation, in a sense, where you're able to check your weekly sales and get a read on things — okay, this week is far under what it ought to be, or this week is far over what it ought to be — and tease out the trends from there. And on top of that, we gain extra visibility from having a sales force engaging with people about campaigns, which gives us at least a small sense of a pipeline. That said, it does tend to be heavier at the close of quarters; this year things have been more muted, yet we've had months that topped 2021, and we've had months that trail 2021, so through this year so far they're producing a roughly flat result overall for us. Honestly, that's as much detail as I believe I can offer — likely more than I ought to.

Richard Choe

analyst
#31

Thanks a lot for explaining that. Regarding the static billboard sector, could you share some observations about your leading markets — Tier 1 cities compared with some of the smaller ones? Does demand or pricing differ between them?

Scott Wells

executive
#32

It's a fascinating thing. When you consider Tier 1 cities and begin working your way through DMAs, the assumption is that performance will rise in steps based on size and level of development; in reality, the market doesn't work that way at all. The intriguing aspect of the current environment — and this isn't a first for out-of-home — is this: L.A. and New York operate in a category of their own. Out-of-home and media mix penetration in both exceeds what other cities have. Both are markets that shape the economics of at least certain large participants in the industry, and their performance is very robust. Once you reach the following group of large cities, however, many of those aren't performing as well. There's a demand component here — you simply cannot undervalue what it means to have the combined weight of media, social influencers, and entertainment concentrated in those handful of truly top markets. Then, if you examine the lower end of market size in our portfolio — we don't go that small — our best results, especially in printed, come from smaller markets, the smaller and midsized ones. That reflects supply and demand, and it reflects the fact that those economies remain quite healthy and keep performing. So in our figures, you saw a very balanced local national performance. At some level, that's likely simply because we hold less inventory in the mega national locations — New York in particular — than we would ideally want, in order to capture the strength of those top two markets. Still, it's a fascinating market. I believe another participant mentioned this — midsized beats the smallest of the small. The sweet spot is always shifting. At present, it sits in that upper midsized type of city, which simply has a favorable demand environment.

Richard Choe

analyst
#33

Great. And one final item from my side. During the Analyst Day, the long-range outlook given was 4% to 6%. Is there any basis for expecting that the coming year might fall outside that range?

Brian Coleman

executive
#34

Yes; aside from what we've already stated, Richard, no changes have been made to that guidance, so —

Scott Wells

executive
#35

Yet we aren't providing a projection for 2023 either. I believe it matters that we avoid committing ourselves too firmly, since there remains a great deal still for us to discover. We are genuinely at the beginning stages of our upfront; it is progressing nicely, as I mentioned during the prepared remarks. However, once we speak again in February, we will be in a position to offer you a far more complete view of how the year is shaping up.

Brian Coleman

executive
#36

That's fair. I didn't realize it was 2023.

Scott Wells

executive
#37

I believed his question concerned 2023, correct. You're probably right. Yes, I apologize for that. So our discussion was about 2022. As for 2023, we won't be releasing anything until a later point.

Richard Choe

analyst
#38

Yeah, that was 2023. Thanks. That's all I have.

Jim Goss

analyst
#39

Okay, thank you. I actually wanted to discuss upfronts. Could you describe the different elements of that and how you handle it—specifically the portion of the revenue base that's tied up, when it happens, the span of values you might sell at, and the pricing? And if they create this kind of exposure, how do you address that?

Scott Wells

executive
#40

Sure. There are a lot of data points packed into that, Jim; it's a big question. I'll begin by noting that we use the term upfronts because nothing better comes to mind; however, for the media analysts listening, this bears no resemblance whatsoever to the TV upfronts. There's no single week when everyone gathers in town with major events and a slew of announcements about new content; what this actually is, is the period when we handle our perm renewals. I'm not sure we've provided extensive detail about the perms, but I believe you can more or less infer it from—and this is something specific to the U.S. Let me make that point very clearly as well. So this applies to the U.S. and it's completely unlike what happens with TV. We've never really offered much in the way of specifics on it. But approximately speaking, it represents half the business, and that's roughly the stuff with contracts longer than six months or so. This isn't something where we'll begin providing significantly more disclosure, but I don't see much downside in giving you a rough sense of it; what occurs is that we follow a cycle, and for most of our marquee assets, which are the ones most pertinent to perms, we have backup customers waiting in line, and there are multiple routes to filling occupancy on them. So when—suppose the renewal falls on December 1st, we'll begin working on that December 1st renewal during the summer and attempt to gauge whether the advertiser currently holding it will continue for the following year, find out their reaction to the price increase we plan to propose, which is typically something we evaluate against economic conditions and traffic growth rates, which by and large only trend upward. So you'll go through that process with them; occasionally they'll choose not to continue, and then you'll turn to your backup advertisers and essentially reprice the asset, which generally works out better for us than sticking with the current customer. Still, we do aim to have the existing customer absorb the costs tied to underlying cost growth. So it's really such a varied mix. What I'm getting at is that you might be dealing with a perm tied to a single location bringing in six figures of revenue per period, all the way down to a perm worth four figures. So when it comes to negotiation — there are separate sales forces involved, different segments of the team, and varying degrees of executive participation that factor in. That's essentially what goes on throughout our upfront, and we monitor very closely especially the top 15%, 20% of our inventory. We also examine trends to see whether we're achieving solid rate increases, solid renewal rates, and so on; and when I describe things as going well, roughly a month in, that's truly what I — that's my meaning, which is that we're observing healthy increases. We're seeing healthy demand, and we'll be tracking this and pushing on it very hard across the coming months.

Jim Goss

analyst
#41

All right, that's quite useful, since it definitely boosts how much trust we can place in the forecasts you provide to everyone.

Scott Wells

executive
#42

That's the reason we tend to wait until February before sharing an outlook for the entire year — by that point, a solid chunk of our business will already be on the books.

Jim Goss

analyst
#43

All right. Perhaps one more item, but let's not venture too deeply into how you might eventually separate the assets. So I was curious whether some organizational setup could look different. Say you end up with fewer international markets — might each one stand alone as its own market, since given how your business works, they likely don't have much interconnection? And could that represent a management layer and expense that you'd be in a position to turn into savings? Also, does whichever structure you land on affect the international debt you carry?

Scott Wells

executive
#44

Sure; a few reflections on that, with all the caveats I shared with Aaron about how limited we're able to say; it's certainly too early to discuss structure in much depth before we have divestitures. But I'd reassure you that a plan exists on our side. Should we manage to complete the divestitures we're pursuing, structural savings will absolutely be there. It probably wouldn't run the way you're describing, because it makes sense for whatever asset base remains to have an in-region CEO; this won't be some teeny tiny stub. It'll be a meaningful chunk of business and a meaningful — I'll stop there. If we're successful in the endeavors we're in; so yes, I do believe savings would be there, though it's certainly too early to speculate on the structure. And there was another piece to your question. I think I misplaced it while I was trying to figure out how to respond to that first part without landing in too much trouble, possibly even regarding it.

Brian Coleman

executive
#45

That BV figure?

Scott Wells

executive
#46

Yeah, yeah. Is that something you'd like to address?

Brian Coleman

executive
#47

Correct. My view is that every step we take will align with the indenture, so I don't expect any major structural shifts, since the intention would probably constrain things for as long as debt remains outstanding. The sole additional point I'd make is that if and when matters do carry on, some reporting discrepancies might arise. Yet before that occurs, I don't picture that happening either.

Jim Goss

analyst
#48

All right. And one final item — we haven’t touched on M&A yet, not that it ought to be your top priority at this moment; still, how do you see property availability at this point in the cycle and the economy? And what’s your sense of your ability to capitalize on chances you may spot?

Scott Wells

executive
#49

So I’m taking it that this is in the U.S.

Jim Goss

analyst
#50

U.S. Yes, yes.

Scott Wells

executive
#51

So, sellers who are willing are certainly still around, and so are buyers who are willing. I believe you've noticed that every out-of-home company headquartered in the U.S. has pursued a fairly busy M&A strategy. On our end, we must monitor that liquidity issue, which has surfaced in a few separate manners along the way. Naturally, anything tied to the balance sheet factors into it. In my view, it's still a solid market in which to do deals. Yet clearly, given the state of credit markets and the macro situation as it stands, we intend to watch things very closely. Regarding the words you used, this isn't at the top of our list of things we need to be doing. Still, we also want to make sure we don't pass up assets that would fit our platform really well.

Jim Goss

analyst
#52

Alright, thanks very much.

Scott Wells

executive
#53

Thanks, Jim.

Scott Wells

executive
#54

Alright, thank you so much. We’re grateful for the questions. We’re grateful for everyone’s interest. We feel positive regarding the business, and we’re looking forward to closing out the year on a strong note and positioning 2023 to be a growth year for us. So we’re quite optimistic about where things are going, and we’re grateful for everybody’s time. Have a wonderful day. Thank you all for being with us.

Operator

operator
#55

That does conclude today's call. Thank you. You may now disconnect your lines.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.