Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 28, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Communication Services Media earnings 41 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Eileen McLaughlin

executive
#1

Hello everyone, and thanks for being with us today. Joining us are Scott Wells, who serves as our CEO, along with Brian Coleman, our CFO. Scott and Brian are going to walk through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. and Clear Channel International BV performed operationally during the fourth quarter of 2022. We suggest you go ahead and pull up the earnings conference call investor presentation, which you can find under the financial section of our Investor website, and follow along with it while we speak. Following some opening remarks and a look at our results — we will then take your questions, and Justin Cochrane, who is CEO of Clear Channel U.K; and Europe, will be part of the Q&A session. Prior to getting started, I want to note for everyone that we might share forward-looking statements on this call concerning the company, which include remarks about its financials, how it expects to perform financially going forward, and the strategic objectives it is pursuing. Every forward-looking statement carries risks and uncertainties, and we cannot guarantee that management's expectations, beliefs or projections will come to pass, or that actual results will not differ from expectations. I encourage you to look at the risk statements included in our earnings press release and in the documents we file with the SEC. Also, on today's call we will mention some performance measures that do not perform to generally accepted accounting principle; schedules reconciling these non-GAAP measures against our reported results on a GAAP basis are provided as part of our earnings release and the earnings conference call investor presentation. One more thing — the information shared on this call reflects only management's views as of today, February 28, 2023, and might not be accurate anymore when the replay is heard. Please go to Slide 4 in the investor presentation, and I'll hand things over now to Scott Well.

Scott Wells

executive
#2

Hello, everybody, and I appreciate you spending part of your day with us on this call. The results we posted for the fourth quarter wrapped up a robust year for the company, since we made a solid recovery as the pandemic receded and gained from solid appetite for our digital assets. Not counting fluctuations in foreign exchange rates, we brought in consolidated revenue of $750 million, which matched our guidance and represented a rise of roughly 1% against the exceptionally strong showing we had in the same quarter a year earlier. Setting aside foreign exchange movements in China, our consolidated revenue likewise exceeded the fourth quarter of 2019. For our Americas segment, we turned in the best revenue quarter on record, even when measured against a record-setting fourth quarter a year ago. Despite turbulence in Europe and the continuing strategic review of our European operations, our European segment likewise posted solid revenue figures. Across the entire year, consolidated revenue grew 16.5%, again excluding foreign exchange movements. I want to express my gratitude to our team throughout the company for their commitment and effort in carrying out our strategic plan and helping produce these results over the last year. We performed at a high standard as we moved forward with becoming a technology-driven visual media powerhouse, connecting with an expanding base of advertisers, all while achieving better productivity. Ours is a story that is operational — meaning our work to grow revenue, generate additional productivity gains, and lift operating cash flow — and it is also one about capital structure, meaning our determination to review every possibility for enhancing our leverage ratio and lowering our debt. On the operational front, putting money into our digital transformation stays at the heart of our strategy, which includes broadening our digital presence, bolstering what we offer in data analytics, and constantly enhancing how customers experience us. We think we are boosting our capacity to give clients the experience they look for from digital media, paired with out-of-home's broad reach. And what we have seen so far indicates these moves are producing growth. Digital represented 43% of consolidated revenue in the fourth quarter, and that figure climbed 4% versus the same period last year, once foreign exchange movements are excluded. While we broaden our digital presence, we keep building an operating platform that is more addressable and efficient. Our solutions are becoming increasingly data-driven, simpler to purchase, and quicker to roll out. Through these efforts, we can turn a greater share of revenue into cash flow and make better use of our scale and reach, while showing results in a manner that makes out-of-home advertising more appealing. We think these efforts underpinned how we outperformed most other traditional media platforms over the last year. As we carry out our plan, we are confident we can generate better operating cash flow in time, thanks to the operating leverage and solid fundamentals built into our model, as reflected in the long-term guidance we gave last September and are reaffirming today. In addition to how we run the business day to day, we remain dedicated to examining ways that let us put in place a capital structure we consider suitable and that we believe gets the most out of the value built into our operations. When the year ended, we disclosed the definitive agreement to divest our Swiss business for $92.7 million, and that deal is still subject to closing conditions already made public. Our plan is to apply the net proceeds we expect to receive toward strengthening our liquidity, and meanwhile our strategic review of European businesses that carry low margins and low priority continues. Our stated aim for Europe is a perimeter whose adjusted EBITDA minus CapEx margins are substantially greater, and this should support better leverage in time via operating cash flow generation along with net sales proceeds from possible divestitures. We have stressed before that we are unable to promise the timing or the success of these efforts, and we will keep sharing more specifics whenever we can. Now to the coming year. Things look healthy for our business, with revenue projected to land somewhere between $2.575 billion and $2.7 billion, leaving out foreign exchange rate movements; within the U.S., the best upfront since we began tracking is nearing completion, and our premium locations remain robust, though a handful of categories are scaling back or postponing campaigns. Keep in mind as well that the first quarter is up against difficult comparisons with the equivalent period a year ago. To be precise, looking nationally, the first quarter is showing weakness because crypto and emerging tech companies are cutting back on sizable spending compared with the first quarter of 2022. So as of now, no significant shifts tied to a macro slowdown have appeared to us. Instead, what we are experiencing comes down to dynamics inside particular categories. Talks with advertisers are still highly constructive; in fact, we keep building out new categories and widening the pool of advertisers we are able to target. In Europe, part of the momentum from Q4 has carried over, and demand looks healthy with nothing suggesting a macro-driven pullback. From what brand owners have told us in our conversations, they plan to keep advertising since they see both the necessity and the chance to stay visible. I should point out that Europe also gives us an easier comparison, because not every market had completely recovered during last year's first quarter; all in all, Europe has begun well, and January performed slightly above what we had anticipated. While carrying out our plan, we are watching market trends closely and stay positive on our business. Brian will walk through guidance for the first quarter as well as the full year. With that said, I'll hand things over to Brian now.

Brian Coleman

executive
#3

Thank you, Scott. Good morning to all of you, and I appreciate you being on the call today. If you would, please go to Slide 5; our business has had a strong year. So prior to walking through what happened in the fourth quarter, I'd like to make a few brief remarks about the results for the entire year. As you're aware, we gave detailed guidance for 2022 at our Investor Day, and that was refreshed on November 8. I'd like to highlight that for each metric contained in that guidance, our actual results came in at or above it. From my perspective, that makes plain how resilient our business is and how well the team has stayed the course and recovered from the pandemic. Let's move on now to the reported figures for the fourth quarter. Just to remind you, while we go over GAAP results, I'll also discuss our results without the impact of foreign exchange rate movements, which is a non-GAAP measure. Our thinking is that this delivers better comparability when assessing how we performed. Direct operating expenses and SG&A expenses contain restructuring and other costs, and those are left out of adjusted EBITDA and segment adjusted EBITDA. The figures I cite cover the fourth quarter of 2022, and unless I say otherwise, the percentage changes compare the fourth quarter of 2022 with the fourth quarter of 2021. On top of that, Switzerland, now treated as an asset held for sale, will keep being reported in revenues and adjusted EBITDA up until the sale is completed. In the fourth quarter, we increased the number of segments in our reported results. There are now 4 reportable segments. America, made up of our U.S. operations, with airports excluded. Airports, which brings in revenue from U.S. and Caribbean airports. Europe North, made up of operations in the U.K., the Nordics and a number of other countries across Northern and Central Europe, and Europe South, made up of operations in France, Switzerland, Spain and Italy. The rest of our operations in Latin America and Singapore are shown as other. Because the guidance we gave alongside our third quarter results followed our earlier reporting format, both this morning's presentation and our fourth quarter earnings release rely on the prior segments so comparisons can be made. That said, the 10-K we filed this morning contains results for the fiscal years ended 2022, 2021 and 2020 under the new segments. Consolidated revenue for the quarter came to $709 million, a 4.5% decrease; stripping out foreign exchange rate movements, consolidated revenue rose 0.9% to $750 million, which sits at the midpoint of our consolidated revenue guidance range of $740 million to $765 million. Net income reached $99 million, better than the $66 million of net income in the prior year. Adjusted EBITDA came in at $205 million, a decline of 7.6%. Without foreign exchange rate movements, adjusted EBITDA was $214 million, a drop of 3.5% as anticipated, mainly because of lower rental maintenance following the rebound in the business. AFFO, a metric we rolled out not long ago, was $84 million in the fourth quarter, or $93 million once foreign exchange rate movements are excluded. Kindly turn to Slide 6 for a look at the Americas fourth quarter results. In the Americas, we brought in $374 million, which represents a 0.8% increase. That falls within the guidance range we provided of $370 million to $380 million. What's perhaps even more notable is that we keep beating the revenue figures we saw before COVID, with an 8.5% rise versus Q4 of 2019. As Scott pointed out, this quarter set a revenue record, coming on top of a record-breaking fourth quarter last year. The growth came from airports and digital, though it was partly counterbalanced by a decline in printed formats. Digital revenue made up 42.1% of Americas revenue and rose 2.8% to $158 million across every display type. National sales represented 40.6% of Americas revenue and fell 2.7%, largely because of difficult comparisons—last year's fourth quarter gained from pent-up demand and several big campaigns from brand owners who were cutting back on spending. Local sales made up 59.4% of Americas revenue and kept growing, rising 3.4%. Direct operating and SG&A expenses climbed 8.1%. That rise stems mainly from an 18.2% jump in site lease expense to $132 million, which reflects higher airports revenue, new contracts, and fewer rent abatements. This was partly offset by reduced variable incentive compensation. Segment adjusted EBITDA came to $156 million, a drop of 7.9%, with a segment adjusted EBITDA margin of 41.8%, lower than Q4 2021 mainly because of mix and one-time items. Still, as we anticipated, the Americas margin was closer to what we saw in Q4 2019. Moving to Slide 7. This slide shows our Americas revenue split between billboard and other, and transit. Billboard & Other, which mainly consists of revenue from bulletins, posters, street furniture displays, spectaculars, and wallscapes, reached $295 million, a slight increase over last year. Transit grew 3.7%, with airports revenue climbing 5.2% to $77 million, fueled by growth throughout the airports portfolio, including Port Authority. Now let's look at Slide 8 for additional detail on Billboard and Other. Billboard and other digital revenue kept recovering in the fourth quarter, rising 3.6% to $111 million, and it now makes up 37.7% of total Billboard and Other revenue. Non-digital billboards and other revenue declined 1.9%. The biggest gains came in travel, food, and hotels, while insurance, media, and retail saw declines. Next, please go to Slide 9 for a look at how we performed in Europe. My remarks cover results adjusted to remove the impact of foreign exchange rate fluctuations. Europe revenue rose 2.1% to $357 million, at the top end of our guidance range of $345 million to $360 million. That growth was powered by our new Europe North segment, especially from new transit contracts in Denmark, along with gains in other Nordic countries, the U.K., and the Netherlands. Within our new Europe South segment, revenue was higher in Spain and Italy, while it was lower in France and Switzerland, the latter due to losing certain contracts. Europe revenue also increased 4.7% relative to the comparable period in 2019. Digital made up 41.6% of Europe's overall revenue, rising 7.4%, fueled by fresh digital inventory plus the strong performance of our programmatic platform LaunchPAD. Among the biggest growth drivers were Denmark, Spain, the U.K. and Norway. Direct operating and SG&A expenses climbed 2.6%, and the primary factor behind that was higher site lease expense. Segment adjusted EBITDA came to $86 million. Segment adjusted EBITDA margin reached 24.1%, matching the prior year and surpassing Q4 2019. Now turning to CCIBV. Our Europe segment is made up of the businesses run by CCIBV and its consolidated subsidiaries. As a result, revenue for our Europe segment equals revenue for CCIBV. Europe segment adjusted EBITDA — the segment profitability metric historically reported in our financial statements — excludes an allocation of CCIBV's corporate expenses that get deducted from CCIBV's operating income and adjusted EBITDA. Europe and CCIBV revenue fell $33 million in the fourth quarter of 2022 versus the same period of 2021, landing at $316 million. Once you adjust for a $41 million impact from foreign exchange rate movements, Europe and CCIBV revenue rose $7 million. CCIBV operating income totaled $27 million in the fourth quarter of 2022, versus $56 million in the same period of 2021.

Brian Coleman

executive
#4

Turning to Slide 10, here's another perspective on capital expenditures. In Q4, CapEx came to $60 million, which is $5 million lower than the same period a year earlier. In the Americas, it rose by $7 million as we increased our spending, especially on digital displays. In Europe, though, CapEx fell by $13 million, largely because of the timing of new contracts and foreign exchange movements. Beyond our capital expenditures, I'd also like to point out that we kept closing several additional asset acquisitions in the U.S. during the quarter, amounting to $10 million. With our renewed emphasis on liquidity given today's macro uncertainty, we're taking a more selective approach to acquisitions; let's turn to Slide 11. In the fourth quarter, cash and cash equivalents fell by $41 million. Part of that decline came from adjusted EBITDA being more than offset by cash interest payments, CapEx, and asset acquisitions, along with working capital changes driven by an increase in accounts receivable. As of December 31, 2022, our liquidity stood at $501 million, which is $41 million lower than at the close of the third quarter, mainly because of the cash reduction. As of December 31, 2022, our debt was $5.6 billion, essentially unchanged from September 30. Cash paid for interest on debt during the fourth quarter was $124 million, a modest increase versus the same period last year, chiefly because of higher floating rates on our Term Loan B facility. Our weighted average cost of debt reached 7.1%, up from the weighted average cost of debt as of September 30, 2022, as a result of increases in LIBOR rates. As of December 31, 2022, our first lien loan ratio came to 5.2x, a slight increase from September 30, 2022; the credit agreement covenant threshold is 7.1x. Now to Slide 12 and our guidance for the first quarter and the full year of 2023. At this moment, we expect our consolidated revenue to land between $540 million and $565 million in Q1 of 2023, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. Using month end January exchange rates, foreign currency could create a 3% headwind to year-over-year reported consolidated revenue growth in the first quarter. For the year overall, we anticipate revenue between $2.575 billion and $2.7 billion, with adjusted EBITDA between $540 million and $600 million, both excluding foreign exchange rate movements. The factors driving revenue guidance relative to adjusted EBITDA guidance involve mix, the impact of onetime items, and the renegotiation of a large existing site lease contract. AFFO guidance is $75 million to $125 million, excluding foreign exchange rate movements, down from fiscal year 2022 primarily because of increased interest expense. Capital expenditures should fall in the range of $185 million to $205 million, with a continued focus on investing in our digital footprint in the U.S. Also, we anticipate that cash interest payments during 2023 will come to roughly $413 million, which is more than what we saw the year before, driven by a higher floating interest rate tied to our Term Loan B facility. The assumptions behind this guidance are that no refinancing takes place and no new debt is taken on. Looking at the outlook we've given for the entire year, it's clear we expect revenue growth to keep going. That said, we'll keep watching things carefully — though we've demonstrated we can pivot when necessary, and we're confident we understand how to make rapid expense adjustments and safeguard liquidity down the road if that becomes necessary. At this point, I'll hand things back to Scott so he can offer his closing comments.

Scott Wells

executive
#5

Appreciate that, Brian. We've gotten off to a solid start, and we think 2023 is going to be a favorable year for the company, even with certain macro-related uncertainties. With an excellent team and assets behind us, we're staying focused on carrying out our strategic priorities, which include speeding up our digital transformation, becoming more customer-centric, and pushing for executional excellence. Our view is that these efforts are letting us lift both the experience and the outcomes we provide to clients, while widening the set of advertisers we're able to go after. Simultaneously, we're still dedicated to tackling our capital structure, divesting the European businesses that carry lower margins and hold lower priority, and doing what's needed to bolster cash generation from our core operations and, in the end, bring down our debt. So at this point, I'll hand the call to the operator for the Q&A portion, and Justin Cochrane will be on the line with us.

Ben Swinburne

analyst
#6

Scott, perhaps we could start with you on an easy note. Could you share some thoughts on how you see the year taking shape? You brought up the first quarter, especially in the U.S., facing certain category-specific headwinds, but tell us about your visibility into Q2 and past that, and it sounds as though you anticipate the year getting better from a growth standpoint as we progress. And then, given that we now have your Airport segment, which posted enormous growth last year, with Port Authority clearly contributing, maybe you could discuss the outlook for that business as we head into '23 and '24? What sort of expectations ought we to hold? Also, are there additional businesses you might be bidding for that could be material? If you could tell us anything about the airport outlook, I think that would be useful as well.

Scott Wells

executive
#7

Regarding how the year takes shape, Q4 and Q1 represent something of a pause in the momentum the business has shown across the prior 5 or 6 quarters. I believe a few factors are responsible. The impact is fairly narrow and fairly account specific; so especially when I look at Q1, it involves the emerging tech companies and the crypto companies. Our exposure to sports betting was never really significant, but that was always — that was another one — there were merely a handful of categories that were somewhat ephemeral in Q1 of last year, which have — well, shown themselves ephemeral, — we did know they were ephemeral in Q1. And that is producing a bit of sluggishness at the end of last year, the start of this year; but that is balanced by what I mentioned in the prepared comments, that we enjoyed our best upfront ever, and our visibility for the remainder of the year is strong; so what we think is taking place is that you had many companies issue announcements regarding layoffs and similar things. And generally people aren't inclined to advertise heavily while layoffs are occurring. You had the companies experiencing the dynamics I just described; so it's a market that has thinned out somewhat compared with a year ago. Yet the laydown for 2023 is strong and the dialogues and plans people have are strong. I suppose the other thing I would point out is the film release schedule was not stellar in the later part of last year, early this year, and that clearly matters a great deal for us, especially in a few of our bigger markets. Alright, taking all those factors together, we believe the slight softening we're observing as the year gets underway won't reflect how the full 12 months will unfold, and our guidance was set with that in mind; so our guidance, as I see it, genuinely captures the best data available to us right now. On your Airport segment question, there are a few points worth highlighting. I believe we've touched on this before, and we definitely brought it up during our Investor Day in September, but the way we market airports today differs from how we may have done it 5 years ago. We've become more inventive, exploring sponsorship-style opportunities. Consider naming rights and similar arrangements; that area has become far more digital, and since emerging from COVID, it has enjoyed a powerful tailwind as travel has surged. In fact, travel has ranked among our stronger verticals across the last few quarters. And we're clearly seeing that reflected in airports. Yet when it comes to Airports, we don't typically discuss contracts, since none of them — except possibly New York — would qualify as material, and they tend to come and go fairly regularly. There's nothing I'd flag regarding our renewal schedule for the coming year that would be significant. I would point out, though, that we just launched at Newark Terminal A in Q1 of this year, and build-out continues on the New York Port Authority contract. So there's still runway left there. I'd be remiss if I failed to bring up the other major innovation we've introduced, which has proven meaningful: having the Americas sales force do more selling into the airports; so cross-selling occurs between the Americas sales force and the Airport sales force. That has become fairly significant, and 5 years ago it was nearly negligible — so I think all of this gives us runway to further expand that Airports business.

Steven Cahall

analyst
#8

Perhaps to begin, diving a bit further into part of what Ben asked about: you mentioned certain areas of weakness inside the U.S. I believe your comment was that in Europe you faced reduced headwinds along with a simpler comparison. So how should we approach, within the growth guidance — whether that's Q1 or the entire year — the split between the Americas and Europe? Is it possible that Europe grows faster than the Americas, which typically isn't what happens on an organic basis? I'd really appreciate your thoughts on that. Then, Scott and Brian, you've begun providing the AFFO metric, and it certainly appears that future potential for a REIT structure might generate substantial value for the company. My sense is that debt remains the primary hurdle. And Brian, if I may infer something from a few of your remarks, it sounds as though you could still have certain ideas for actions available this year, past the Swiss divestiture, to steer the balance sheet. So I'm simply wondering which options you believe exist this year to begin reshaping the balance sheet toward somewhat reduced leverage.

Scott Wells

executive
#9

Thank you, Steve. I'll handle the first portion, and Brian can take the second. Keep in mind that it feels like distant history now, yet Q1 of the prior year was when the notorious Omicron was present, and it struck Europe far more severely than it struck the U.S. Therefore you get a — it's somewhat merely an arithmetic matter at play. And in particular, certain nations in Europe were hit unevenly by Omicron, so regarding Q1, you ought probably to anticipate that Europe will grow faster than the U.S. Once more, excluding currency effects. I mean, currency constantly muddies precisely how those figures will turn out; yet that's likely a reasonable approach to consider it. And that holds somewhat when you consider the entire year as well, since Q1 clearly forms part of the entire year. And certain geographies in Europe have still not completely bounced back from COVID; some regions of Europe have bounced back and sit far, far beyond 2019, though not every region does. So there's likely a slight tilt toward Europe within that revenue mix; it isn't huge. Yet we were extremely precise in providing consolidated guidance simply because so many shifting elements exist throughout the portfolio. However, we did construct it clearly in a sort of bottom-up manner, yet it grows quite unwieldy to attempt guidance across numerous tiny subsegments. Thus that's the reason we did it in aggregate; but ideally, that provides you a sense of the mix; and I'll pass it to Brian to ask — to tackle the second question.

Brian Coleman

executive
#10

Okay, thank you, Steve. Yes, I believe there are two elements to our route toward REIT optionality: first, bringing down leverage, and second, clearly, building the portfolio of readable assets up to the appropriate scale. The strategic review underway in Europe is plainly a key piece of that. And although the final result, should it come through additional asset sales, likely won't lower leverage directly — or at least not in any significant way — it does bring with it less capital expenditure, a simpler business, and reduced corporate costs. So I do believe that clarity on how that ultimately turns out will matter a great deal as we consider further ways to reduce leverage, and further ways may well be required. Every option remains available, but I think it would be too early at this point to truly dig into them. The company simply has some runway. We have this process in motion, and we will keep an open mind regarding what we can and must do to bring down leverage on the balance sheet. But that, along with getting the asset base into the right position, represents the 2 hurdles, if you will, standing between us and eventually reaping the benefits of this business.

Jonnathan Navarrete

analyst
#11

This is Jonnathan calling in for Lance. My first question concerns the new segment reporting. I'm just wondering what prompted the new breakout?

Brian Coleman

executive
#12

That's something management decided, based on how these businesses are actually run and where we direct resources. So the 3 elements we're breaking out Airports. And I believe how large that business is also played a part in the choice to break it out. The second element involved splitting Europe North from Europe South, and I think the figures over time reflect the distinctions between those businesses, along with the sensible management and differing resource allocation. And the third element is moving Singapore out of the Europe category and into other, a choice that probably needs no explanation. But it truly is a management call made against those criteria.

Jonnathan Navarrete

analyst
#13

Looking ahead, should we anticipate a significant amount of rent relief across both the Americas and Europe? Based on that slide in your deck, it seems like things have mostly wound down in Europe, and though there's still a bit happening in America, I'd really like to understand the direction better for '23.

Brian Coleman

executive
#14

Yes, you're correct that rent relief has mostly wound down in Europe, and my sense is that a similar winding down ought to happen on its own in the Americas. What I'd highlight is that this is clearly something we choose to do, and we'll keep at it — we'll aggressively chase down any chances where we believe it makes sense, and there are still a few remaining in the Americas that we'll keep chasing. Even so, those will mostly keep shrinking as time goes on.

Jonnathan Navarrete

analyst
#15

All right, and for my final question — with rates running higher, does that force any adjustment to what we're prioritizing strategically, since at some point refinancing will have to happen at those elevated rates? Does that alter the picture in any way, or not?

Brian Coleman

executive
#16

It's definitely something we weigh heavily. Our interest expense is higher, but perhaps more significant is the fact that the rate you'd expect to refinance at now likely sits above where it would have been roughly a year back, so it absolutely factors into what we examine. It works against our free cash flow generation. That said, we still have a runway, and the business currently involves plenty of moving pieces, so I wouldn't claim this has caused our strategic approach to shift — yet it is unquestionably a key item, and one we're actively weighing.

Scott Wells

executive
#17

Yeah. I mean, Jonnathan, the sole point I'd tack onto that is: twelve months back, who could have predicted rates sitting at today's levels; plus we're still 2 years away from the point where we'll need to step in. So it's a case of slow being smooth and smooth being fast, to steal a line from my special operations buddies — we'll be keeping a very close eye on the market here, and once our window gets nearer, we'll take the right steps.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#18

Just a few quick items from me. First, regarding the guidance for the entire year, it appears that, at the midpoint at least, margins are down slightly compared to last year; I simply want to confirm I grasp the positive and negative factors versus '22 — obviously, some rent abatements played a role, or rather fewer of them, I presume, plus growth in Airports. I'm wondering whether anything else is slipping my mind; and I have a few additional questions.

Brian Coleman

executive
#19

Right. I believe we discuss the decline in abatements, as you noted, along with the mix as Airports expands. And another item I think we've brought up is that a significant contract in the U.S. has undergone renegotiation, which has created somewhat of a drag. So really, those 3 factors represent pressures on EBITDA margins; thus I think your understanding is on the right track, Avi.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#20

All right, that sounds great. Then one of the companies you compete with mentioned that the Programmatic channel, I suppose, has gotten somewhat weaker. I realize it doesn't represent a huge portion of the business. Still, I'm wondering what you're observing in that area and how you expect it to unfold during this year?

Scott Wells

executive
#21

Yeah, absolutely, there's no doubt that 2022 didn't deliver the level of growth in Programmatic we would have expected going into that year; however, as our proxy shows, we still met what we had planned in spite of that; which brings me to your second point, that it simply isn't a very large piece of the overall mix. Honestly, I'd say the programmatic market at this moment looks fairly healthy. Once more, comparing a Q1 with a Q4 is never easy; even so, it definitely is demonstrating reasonable growth at present; therefore, while we aren't depending on it to account for a huge share of the guidance we provided, nothing suggests it's in a troubled spot, I suppose, would be my way of describing it.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#22

Great. And the final one from me concerns what you'll do with the money from the Switzerland divestiture, given that it can be put back into the business. I'm simply wondering whether we ought to eventually view it as aimed at the CCIBV notes along with upcoming asset sales from that entity?

Brian Coleman

executive
#23

Yes. I believe we've discussed our intention to put those proceeds back into the business, something the various bond indentures allow, CCIBV included, and that in turn will unlock cash flow from the European operations that otherwise would have gone toward funding those investments. I think at present, with the sort of environment we're in, we'll likely shore up liquidity using those proceeds — using those — using that cash, provided it isn't needed elsewhere once the Switzerland sale happens and wraps up. Yet that may shift as time goes on, and they'll be there to deploy across Europe for further reinvestment and other purposes, debt repurchases of the CCIBV notes among them. But really it's likely too soon to head in that direction. I think as of now, it's about optimizing liquidity once the transaction truly shuts.

Richard Choe

analyst
#24

Regarding the guidance, I simply wanted to ask: should Airports be up for the year, with digital also up and non-digital flat? Is that roughly what the guidance implies?

Brian Coleman

executive
#25

Richard, we gave consolidated guidance, and we don't actually break it out. Airports, I think, is doing well. There's still some room to run in Airport, as Scott said earlier. So I think we will — we're positive on that business. Scott, I don't know about the digital, non-digital color going forward, whether there's anything to say to that.

Scott Wells

executive
#26

Yeah, regarding the dynamics — you've witnessed our operations turning increasingly digital at a steady and accelerating pace. The penetration figures, I believe, will be quite revealing for certain people, showing just how deeply digital has reached into various segments of the portfolio, with airports across Northern Europe really standing out in that regard. So yes, digital represents a growing portion of the narrative. Yet we've been happy with the resilience shown by our non-digital side. A good deal of the 2022 results in non-digital was essentially category-related, stemming from certain mix shifts within our advertiser base. That ought to even out as 2023 arrives. So I don't — our consolidated guidance and our consolidated guidance, simply aiming to offer you a bit of color on some of the dynamics underneath.

Richard Choe

analyst
#27

Understood. And when it comes to Europe, does Southern Europe have a bigger chance to bounce back than Northern Europe? Or what's the right way to look at that 2 for the year? I'm not asking for guidance here, just thinking about the opportunity compared with last year.

Scott Wells

executive
#28

Yeah. I mean, it's interesting when you consider a rebound, but overall, I'd say yes to that; and there are certain contract puts and takes. That's a constant dynamic in Europe. And I believe we highlighted a few of those in the comments, regarding where things stand. But yeah, broadly speaking, Southern Europe has been slower to recover from COVID, and that ought to mean an opportunity in those markets this year.

Jim Goss

analyst
#29

When it comes to separating Europe into North and South, is that due to similar geographic operations? Or does it affect how you'd choose to market the properties while doing this evaluation and growing the U.S. core?

Brian Coleman

executive
#30

Yes. Jim, accounting factors and the manner in which we run the business truly drive this segmentation choice; so that's correct. Now, some of that management distinction and distinction in resource allocation could relate to other matters. But mostly — and incidentally, I believe the segment reporting and the contrast, especially within Europe between the North and the South, sheds some light on the varying operating traits across those regions; but it genuinely stems from how we run the business, who runs the business, what sort of resources we give those businesses, which is what drives segment reporting, not what you're aiming to sell or not. I hope that's helpful.

Jim Goss

analyst
#31

All right. Yes. You brought up a moment ago that Europe is likewise a leader when it comes to digital. Digital accounts for about 42% of sales in both the U.S. and Europe. I'm curious whether that holds fairly steady across regions and categories, and in what way does that shape the growth chance ahead as you decide where capital goes?

Scott Wells

executive
#32

Digital varies a great deal depending on region, depending on the contract, depending on the particular circumstances. We genuinely think that continuing to digitize this operation represents a chance, and we have a high level of digital penetration at U.K. airports, which have grown more and more digital. And when you move into more recently built airports, those are also increasingly digital. So roughly speaking, whenever you renew agreements in any of those locations, digital will show up as part of the growth. Clearly, within the America business, that is where the major regulatory restriction exists, and certain European nations also impose regulatory limits that prevent digital from being done. Yet we are discovering, as time passes and a growing number of locations gain the kind of experience U.K. airports have had, that we can raise digital usage, and clients genuinely appreciate how immediate it feels; they appreciate how flexible it is. They appreciate how creative it is, the capacity to split messages by daypart so that a different message runs in the morning versus the afternoon, that kind of thing. So those characteristics, in our view, are what customers appreciate. Therefore we will keep moving in that direction wherever we're able. That said, it differs greatly from one region to another, and there isn't really a simple, summarized way for me to respond to what I believe you're asking about, though it certainly does differ by region.

Jason Bazinet

analyst
#33

I've got a fast one about organic growth — for the prior year, and also how much organic growth you've baked into the current year's guidance? Specifically, I was curious whether inflation, in the prior year and in what you expect now, plays any part in your capacity to push rate, and in how you set that organic growth expectation.

Scott Wells

executive
#34

Thanks, Jason. A strong rate environment is definitely something we saw, and honestly we keep seeing a good one. Once more, any softness is somewhat idiosyncratic at present; it isn't broad-based. Consider the — a driver behind that really strong upfront we've discussed is that we've been witnessing solid rate increases; inflation alone doesn't explain it, though it certainly makes the conversation somewhat easier. Clearly, moving from the COVID period into the period we occupied in roughly the second half of 2021 and the first half of 2022, toward what I'd describe as us nearing a more "regular" — and regular is a risky word — but we're entering more of a regular trading period. Consequently, rate increases will likely grow harder as time passes, since it isn't — it's not as simple as inflation is X, therefore rates climb Y. Our assets are heavily segmented by location, and this has been a very premium market when it comes to advertisers seeking the very, very best locations; that generates a rate. So what I'd say is that rate is a major focus for us. We aim to — yield is a major focus, with rate being a key component of producing yield. And we anticipate being able to keep driving yield in 2023. I hope that answers you. I'm not certain that matched the exact spirit of your question.

Jason Bazinet

analyst
#35

Alright, so it appeared to me that you folks — well, really the whole sector — possessed fairly strong pricing power, yet from what I'm hearing, that will ease somewhat. Even so, you should still be capable of producing organic growth, I suppose that's the main point for '23.

Scott Wells

executive
#36

Correct. And personally, I count our digital conversions as organic growth as well, since those aren't acquisitions and the payback periods look really appealing. So the point I'd offer is that growth isn't derived solely from rate.

Scott Wells

executive
#37

Excellent. Thanks a lot. We're grateful that everyone could be with us on today's call; our outlook on the coming year is positive, and we're encouraged as we anticipate sharing progress reports with you as the months pass regarding the different strategic and operational efforts we mentioned. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.