Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 9, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Eileen McLaughlin
executiveHello everyone, and thanks for being with us today. Joining us are Scott Wells, our CEO, and Brian Coleman, our CFO. Scott and Brian will walk through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc; and Clear Channel International BV performed operationally in the first quarter of 2023. We suggest you pull up the earnings conference call investor presentation, which you can find under the financial section of our investor website, and follow along while we speak. Following some opening remarks and a look at our results, we'll take your questions. Justin Cochrane, CEO of Clear Channel UK and Europe, will also be part of the Q&A session. Before we get started, I want to remind you that we might make forward-looking statements on this call about the company, including about its future financial performance and its strategic goals. All forward-looking statements carry risks and uncertainties, and we cannot guarantee that management's expectations, beliefs, or projections will come to pass, or that actual results won't differ from expectations. Please look over the risk statements included in our earnings press release and our filings with the SEC. We'll also reference some performance measures today that don't conform to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. As part of our earnings release and the earnings conference call investor presentation, we offer schedules reconciling these non-GAAP measures with our reported results on a GAAP basis. Also, be aware that what's shared on this call reflects only management's views as of today, May 9, 2023, and might no longer be accurate when a replay is heard. Please go to slide 4 in the earnings presentation, and I'll hand things over to Scott now.
Scott Wells
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for making time to be on today's call. The strong execution our team keeps delivering, along with generally healthy advertiser demand — especially for digital properties — is what our solid first quarter consolidated results reflect. Consolidated revenue came in at $561 million, excluding foreign exchange rate movements, matching our guidance and rising roughly 6.6% versus the same period a year ago. Much of what we observed in the fourth quarter carried over into the new year, and the out-of-home sector is showing its resilience. Advertisers want to reach our expanding audiences and they see the advantages that come from our industry's adoption of digital technology. I want to recognize our team for their dedication and hard work as we keep making progress in using the scale of our platform and our technology strategy to make our solutions more data driven, simpler to purchase and quicker to bring to market. Combined with how broad our footprint is, we think these efforts have made us better able to generate business even while portions of our operations face pressure from engaging a larger and more varied set of advertisers. Within the quarter, revenue in the US showed some softness stemming from a handful of particular problems affecting certain national accounts. Those include accounts carrying out layoffs, specific categories such as crypto and emerging tech, and specific markets such as San Francisco and Chicago — not broad macro events. Even so, we are not satisfied with how the US performed and think improvement is possible as the year goes on. One reason for that confidence is the solid headway we've made expanding our footprint in the CPG space, and also in pharma, where the America segment still has room to grow. Business services, QSR and amusements likewise remain categories that are notably strong. On top of that, in Europe North, demand for our digital assets and our programmatic platform remains healthy. Digital made up 51% of Europe North's revenue, with growth of 16% versus the first quarter of last year, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. So we feel we're gaining from a business platform that is more stable and appealing as we fold the appropriate digital technologies into the way we run things and serve customers. In the first quarter, digital represented 38% of consolidated revenue and increased 9.7% versus the first quarter of last year, excluding foreign exchange rate movements. While carrying out our operating strategy, we keep assessing options that we think will let us strengthen our balance sheet and get the most value out of what our business holds. We just finished divesting our Switzerland business, which produced $94 million in gross proceeds, and we intend to apply the net proceeds from that deal toward improving our liquidity position. We are also still examining our European businesses that carry low margins and low priority. Now for what lies ahead. Like I said earlier, we aren't detecting any widespread pullback tied to macro conditions in our sector, and demand from advertisers is still solid. That said, when you look country by country, the pace of growth will likely differ as we move through the year. Within our America segment, conversations with advertisers are still constructive, and the patterns we're observing give us confidence, which is a good signal for the remainder of the year. So far, Q2 revenue is shaping up stronger than Q1 when it comes to year-over-year growth, and we expect Q3 and Q4 to do better too. We also think airports revenue ought to bounce back sharply from Q1 and deliver strong results for the rest of the year and afterward. Alongside the recovery in leisure travel, business travel keeps improving; and a study we ran recently verifies that frequent fliers engage heavily with our advertising platforms; we give brands a highly effective and efficient way to reach these sought-after audiences while they're traveling. Over in Europe, we likewise keep witnessing robust demand throughout most of our markets, with nothing suggesting a deceleration stemming from macro worries. Europe North, which posted a robust revenue result in Q1, driven by ongoing strength in select markets plus a post COVID resurgence in our transit business, is up against harder comps and, as a result, a slower growth rate in Q2. And Europe South, which likewise turned in a solid top line revenue result in Q1, faces tougher comps largely because of the Switzerland sale, along with business trends returning to normal amid the unrest in France. All things considered, in spite of the sluggish beginning to the year in the US, on the whole, we're pleased with what we're witnessing right now, especially considering the macro uncertainties. Our full year guidance stays inside the range we gave in February, except for a tweak reflecting the Switzerland sale and a reduction in capital expenditures. As we carry out our plan, we're watching trends closely throughout our markets and stay optimistic regarding our business. Brian will walk you through our guidance for Q2 as well as the full year. And with that, I'll hand things over to Brian.
Brian Coleman
executiveThanks, Scott. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being on the call. If you could go to slide 5. Like Scott said, the results we posted for the first quarter came in right on our guidance, and we continue to feel good about what the rest of the year looks like. Just a quick note, while we go through the GAAP numbers, I'm also going to cover how we did without the effect of foreign exchange rate movements, which is a non-GAAP measure. Our view is that this gives you a cleaner comparison for judging how we performed. You'll find restructuring charges and other related costs sitting in two places: they're included in direct operating expenses as well as in SG&A, but they're stripped out when calculating adjusted EBITDA and segment adjusted EBITDA. The numbers I'm referencing are for Q1 2023, and unless I note otherwise, any percentage comparisons are between the first quarter of 2023 and the same period in 2022. One more thing: our Switzerland business sale was completed on March 31, 2023, so its results are baked into what we reported for Q1, but going forward it won't appear in our numbers anymore. And as we mentioned during the Q4 earnings call, we expanded our segments in conjunction with the results we reported. Our segment structure has been updated to include four reportable areas. The former America segment is now divided into America and Airports. Europe has been separated into Europe North and Europe South, while Singapore now falls under Other, together with Latin America. This quarter is the first time we are presenting quarterly results using these new reporting segments. On our investor website, under the Financials tab, we have added a new feature: the Interactive Analyst Center. That resource lets you find our reported results for fiscal years 2019 through 2022, as well as 2022 quarterly results, all organized by the new reporting segments. The same information appears in our SEC filings. Turning now to the reported results for the first quarter: consolidated revenue for the quarter was $545 million, representing a 3.8% increase. On a constant currency basis, total revenue increased 6.6% to $561 million, which put us at the top end of our guidance range of $540 million to $565 million for consolidated revenue. We recorded a net loss of $35 million, an improvement over last year's net loss of $90 million. Adjusted EBITDA came in at $52 million, down 20.6%. Excluding the effects of foreign exchange rate movements, adjusted EBITDA was $51 million, representing a 22.3% decrease. That decline is due to higher fixed site lease expenses driven by a number of factors — new contracts, fewer abatements, and the renegotiation of a large existing site lease contract — along with revenue mix. In Q1, AFFO came in at negative $57 million, or negative $58 million when you strip out foreign exchange rate movements. The America segment's first quarter results are on Slide 6. America revenue totaled $236 million, down 1.3%, which reflects a pullback in media plus an addition to telco and banking; even so, as Scott mentioned, we continue broadening our customer base by capitalizing on our technology investments. Those efforts helped partially counterbalance the hit to our overall America performance for the quarter from the category-specific reductions noted earlier. Digital revenue reached $78 million, up 3.6%, and accounted for 33.1% of America revenue. However, declines in our print products erased that gain. National came in at 33.1% of America revenue and fell 8.7%, mostly because of difficult comparisons. Local made up 66.9% of America revenue and kept growing, up 2.7%. Direct operating and SG&A costs rose 11.1%, reaching $155 million. That climb stems largely from a 13.3% rise in site lease expense, which hit $83 million, pushed by new and amended contracts along with fewer renovations. Higher credit loss expense came from specific reserves tied to certain customers, and in our view it doesn't signal broader weakness. On top of that, higher compensation costs resulted from more headcount. Segment adjusted EBITDA came to $81 million, a 19% decline, while segment adjusted EBITDA margin was 34.5%, lower than Q1 2022. When you strip out the impact of reworking a sizable site lease agreement with an existing client — something we flagged during the last earnings call — margins would be roughly in line with where they stood before COVID. Now, if you go to slide 7, you'll find our first quarter review for Airports. Airports brought in $54 million in revenue, a drop of 3.7%. What mostly pushed revenue lower was the timing of certain campaign spending. Digital revenue made up 55% of Airport revenue and fell 3.3%, landing at $30 million. National sales represented 60.1% of Airport revenue and rose 4.9%. Local sales, at 39.9% of Airports revenue, declined 14.4%. Direct operating and SG&A expenses came in at $48 million, up 3.4%. This rise mostly came from site lease expense going up 4.7% to $36 million, partly because airport payment terms returned to normal. Segment adjusted EBITDA came in at $6 million, a decline of 36.9%, and segment adjusted EBITDA margin was 11.6%. Now let's move to slide 8, where we'll look at how we did in Europe North. When I talk about Europe North and Europe South, those results have been adjusted so that foreign exchange rate movements are taken out. Europe North revenue grew 14.9% to $140 million. We saw revenue climb for every product and in every country, with Belgium, Sweden, and the United Kingdom standing out the most, thanks to stronger demand from new contracts. Digital made up 51.1% of total revenue for Europe North, rising 16.1% to $71.6 million. Growth in most countries drove this, and the UK saw the biggest gain. Direct operating and SG&A expenses for Europe North climbed 15%, reaching $133 million. Site lease expense rose 13.6% to $62 million, largely because of higher revenue and new contracts. On top of that, several other operating expenses went up this quarter, partly from higher prices and more sales activity. Adjusted EBITDA for the Europe North segment increased 11.1% to $8 million, and the segment's adjusted EBITDA margin came in at 5.5%, matching the prior year. Let's move to slide 9 now for how we performed in Europe South. In the Europe South division, we saw a 25% rise in revenue, reaching $112 million. As this segment continues to recover from the downturn caused by COVID-19, we've posted gains in revenue, driven by stronger demand across all of our product lines, particularly street furniture, and in each country where we operate. Digital accounted for 20.3% of total revenue in Europe South and grew 35.3% to $23 million, supported by increases in every nation, with Spain seeing the largest gain. Direct operating and SG&A costs for Europe South rose 12.8% to $125 million. Site lease expenses were up 13.2% to $58 million, mainly due to new agreements and higher revenue, as well as other operating costs. For the Europe South unit, adjusted EBITDA landed at minus $13 million, an improvement over the previous year's minus $22 million. Now let's look at CCI B.V. on slide 10. Clear Channel International B.V., referred to as CCI B.V., acts as an indirect, fully owned subsidiary of the company and issues our 6.625% senior secured notes due 2025. Its business covers our Europe North and Europe South segments, along with Singapore, which, following the reporting segment changes we implemented in the fourth quarter of 2022, is now included in Other. CCI B.V.'s revenue rose 11.7% to $242 million, compared with $217 million. Once foreign exchange fluctuations are removed, CCI B.V.
Brian Coleman
executiveRevenue was up 18.8%, and the reasons behind that were greater demand plus, though to a smaller degree, newly signed contracts. For the three months that ended March 31, 2023, Singapore accounted for under 3% of CCI B.V. revenue. CCI B.V. operating income came in at $66 million, versus an operating loss of $48 million during the same stretch of 2022, and that shift was mostly the result of a $96 million gain from selling our Switzerland business. Let's turn to slide 11 now, where we'll review capital expenditures. In the first quarter, CapEx reached $38 million, which is $3 million more than the prior year. Our spending went up in America, Airports and Europe North, mainly tied to digital investments. CapEx spending in Europe South fell because we invested less in France and Spain, mostly involving street furniture assets. Moving to slide 12. Cash and cash equivalents rose $53 million during the first quarter. That improvement came partly from cash proceeds we received on the Switzerland sale, adjusted EBITDA contribution and reduced working capital use, though higher cash interest and capital investments offset some of it. As of March 31, 2023, our liquidity stood at $545 million, which is $44 million higher than liquidity at the close of the fourth quarter, thanks to the cash increase, partly offset by seasonality in our borrowing base. Our debt totaled $5.6 billion as of March 31, 2023, essentially unchanged from December 31. Interest paid in cash on that debt amounted to $72 million in the first quarter, up from the same period a year earlier, chiefly because of higher interest rates on our term loan facility. Our weighted average cost of debt came to 7.2%, a modest rise from the weighted average cost of debt as of December 31, 2022, driven by higher floating rates. As of March 31, 2023, our first lien leverage ratio stood at 5.25 times, a slight uptick from December 31, 2022. The credit agreement covenant threshold is 7.1 times. Let's go to slide 13 and our guidance for the second quarter and the full year 2023. Right now, we think consolidated revenue will land between $635 million and $660 million in Q2 of 2023, excluding movements in foreign exchange rates; we've updated full year guidance to account for the Switzerland sale. Aside from that change, our guidance stays within the range we gave in February, except for a lower projection for CapEx spend. We expect revenue between $2.5 billion and $2.625 billion, with adjusted EBITDA between $525 million and $585 million, both excluding movements in foreign exchange rates. AFFO guidance is $65 million to $115 million excluding movements in foreign exchange rates, down from fiscal year 2022 due primarily to increased interest expense. Capital expenditures should fall in the range of $165 million and $185 million, as we continue focusing on investing in our digital footprint in the US. Also, for 2023, we anticipate cash interest payments of roughly $414 million, which is up from the previous year because of elevated floating rate interest tied to our Term Loan B facility. This outlook presumes no refinancing and no new debt being taken on. At this point, I'll hand the call back to Scott for his closing comments.
Scott Wells
executiveAppreciate that, Brian. As we move forward, our expectation remains that this will be a good year for the company, and when it comes to the annual guidance Brian mentioned, we're still very much on schedule. Operationally speaking, our attention stays fixed on better execution, putting money into our digital transformation, and making the customer experience better all the time. Alongside that, we're still dedicated to strengthening our balance sheet, which includes actions aimed at bolstering cash generation across the business and, in the end, bringing our debt down. Prior to opening things up for Q&A, I'd like to draw attention to the new Clear Channel Outdoor website, which you can see on slide 14. A powerful lead funnel for our sales teams is what this site was built to be. Beyond that, because the user experience has been improved, visitors can easily locate the useful information they want from CCOA. Our new branding gets showcased on the site, the strength of our medium is displayed visually, and users are told how partnering with us delivers more than working with other media companies would. I'd urge you to go online and see the site for yourself. With that, I'll hand things over to the operator so we can begin the Q&A portion. Justin Cochrane is going to be joining us on this call.
Richard Choe
analystI'd like to spend a moment on the segment revenue guidance you provided. Could you give us a bit more detail on the Americas business and the Airport? Should we expect those categories to rise in <<inaudible>> fashion across the full year?
Brian Coleman
executiveSure, I'll give it a try, Scott, and you can jump in on top of that; we don't give segment guidance looking ahead. That said, I think when you examine how both businesses in the Americas performed in Q1 — so America and airports — some of the headwinds each of those segments faced will probably fade from here. And my expectation would be growth in both the Americans business and the Airports business. On airports, one of the headwinds hitting Airports is the timing of campaigns. Our hope is that those campaigns return across the remainder of the year, and that we can fill the pipeline with other items. So I think we do anticipate improvement in the Airport segment; and I'd say the same about the America segment. It had some headwinds in the first quarter that we expect to fade. And we do expect top line improvement. The first quarter isn't the strongest quarter for this business. It's highly seasonal; and then we've got some quarterly impacts. But I believe both of the segments in Americas, America and Airports, will keep improving as the year goes on.
Scott Wells
executiveOne thing I'd mention, Richard, is that our guidance is being reaffirmed. To make that possible, the figures we've provided showed increases almost everywhere, you know. Specifically, the EBITDA expansion we're referring to wouldn't be achievable if the US weren't going to deliver. While we're not going to start guiding each separate segment, ideally this provides some idea of our perspective.
Richard Choe
analystI'm not sure what latitude you have to address this, but given that Europe North and South are sort of, I suppose, settling down and performing better, with figures that look more measured, at least from our vantage point, are you noticing greater appetite for those operations? Also, do you believe there's stronger opportunity to divest additional pieces of those segments, whether individually by nation or collectively as one bundle?
Scott Wells
executiveRichard, that's an excellent question. I think when you consider Europe overall, at the moment we made public that this process was beginning, honestly we were still dealing with COVID. Omicron emerged after our announcement, and COVID hit a number of the European markets quite severely. So if you reflect on our starting position and the point when we shifted toward a country-by-country approach, essentially we had a single solid quarter, the fourth quarter of 2021, available to us along with a strategy. What has unfolded since then is that the operation has in fact done pretty well, and results have varied from one country to the next, yet on balance, we now have six quarters of experience behind us — not quite six yet, though it will be shortly. And I genuinely believe that will be beneficial once the moment arrives for us to take to market the portion of Europe we've described since the middle of last year as destined to deliver higher margin, generate cash, and so on. I really do think it assists. However, you must acknowledge these processes, as all of us have observed, move slowly. And when you're working at the level of individual countries, you encounter a tremendous amount of fine detail that generates a great deal of back and forth; and quite possibly you'll have settled on a price much sooner in the process than the point at which you finally reach closing. So the takeaway is, this isn't real time bidding. This is sophisticated negotiation regarding the assets that are genuinely on the market at present. So, with luck, that provides you with a bit of color without my revealing anything more granular that could land me in trouble.
Avi Steiner
analystTwo quick items. First, could we spend a bit more time unpacking America? You described that as weakness in national accounts instead of a wider macro issue. Could you give us more context on that, especially since you all stay confident about the year there?
Scott Wells
executiveThere are a few dynamics at play, I think. During our Q4 call we mentioned this, though it's possible not everyone caught it. Still, the year got off to a fairly difficult start. January and February were fairly difficult months, especially within the national account segment, especially in crypto and emerging tech. What we've observed since then is a consistent pattern of improvement month by month. On the Q4 call you heard us mention that we've had the strongest upfront since we began tracking it. That's how the upfront built up. That's what fuels much of the confidence we hold, together with the conversations we're having. Outdoor does tend to get planned fairly far ahead. So we have a fairly solid sense of which brands intend to pursue things in the back half of the year; and so, when you combine all those various data points and you combine what's currently on our books, that's what gives us the confidence to state what we're stating about how things are shaping up; so many data points feed into it. Regarding what actually occurred, I think we attempted to present this quite granularly in the script. But we carry substantial exposure to San Francisco. And San Francisco was an extremely difficult ad market in Q1. I believe that if you speak with any of the other participants tied to it, that would ring true. And it's our second largest market. So that hits us hard; and that's true both nationally and locally. On the national side, emerging tech, once again, overlapping with the San Francisco situation mattered a great deal, particularly compared with the prior year, when that had been an extremely vibrant category in Q1 of the year before. So, I think those are the elements behind what took place in Q1. And looking ahead, we do possess a number of data points. Like everyone else, we recognize the economy is somewhat murky and it's somewhat unclear where the macro is going. But I'm encouraged, since as we've absorbed the shocks over time involving various financial services, institutions and so on in the headlines, we've kept up good dialogue with advertisers and we keep booking business; so we feel good about how the year will unfold.
Avi Steiner
analystOn free cash flow, the implied usage seems perhaps somewhat improved in this instance, while CapEx production appears somewhat higher relative to the EBITDA figure. Does Switzerland account for all of that? Or is there another element inside it?
Brian Coleman
executiveAvi, I'm not certain I tracked what you asked. I realize the topic was cash flow, and then it sort of concluded with the changes…
Avi Steiner
analystA $20 million cut in CapEx, and $15 million at the midpoint for EBITDA, if I've got that right — maybe my math is off. I just want to confirm I'm…
Brian Coleman
executiveDo you mean the adjusted guidance? I'm still not following.
Scott Wells
executiveI think that's what he's saying, your free cash flow…
Avi Steiner
analystregarding the outlook for the entire year.
Brian Coleman
executiveAh, right. Fine. So, my view is that Switzerland is indeed factored into it. As for the capital expenditure figure, it likewise takes into account a lower expected level of CapEx outlay.
Avi Steiner
analystJust a couple of fast questions. For site lease expense during Q1, at least within America, should we take that as the proper run rate for the year? And I'm sorry if this was already covered.
Brian Coleman
executiveOur margins — EBITDA margins, adjusted for one-time items — I'd say are fairly close to those we saw in 2019. And I believe that's a reasonable run rate.
Scott Wells
executiveOnce more, keeping in mind that this business has quite a bit of seasonality. For us, the first quarter is always the weakest one annually, so margins will be at their lowest, since when you push additional dollars through, that operating leverage kicks in.
Avi Steiner
analystThis will be my final question. At this point, the money from Switzerland has come in. Does that alter anything about what you said earlier regarding your approach to liquidity?
Brian Coleman
executiveNothing has changed. That money will stay on the balance sheet as a way to bolster liquidity. And as you're aware, under the terms of our debt documents, we are required to put it back into the business, and that effort is ongoing. So nothing has changed.
Daniel Osley
analystDan Osley here, filling in for Steve. Perhaps a single question for Scott — or really for Brian. In America, the digital conversion has now been included in the top line; yet what's the right way to consider how the expanding mix shift affects margin? And has your view on operating leverage in the business shifted in any way?
Scott Wells
executiveThe two of us can likely take that one.
Brian Coleman
executiveMy view is that digital should help our margins. We're still putting money into it. I've sort of forgotten what the other half of your question was.
Scott Wells
executiveI believe, as you do, that when it comes to the margin side of this question, plenty of factors are involved, since it matters whether you're operating on the ground beneath the sign, whether your lease is fixed, or whether your lease is variable — every one of those elements plays a role. Still, in the long run, our view is that digital ought to serve as a tailwind for margins. That said, how much of a tailwind it provides — the very thing Avi and I were addressing — will look somewhat different in Q4, our heaviest quarter, compared with Q1, our lightest one. Yet viewed across time, it ought to be a tailwind, though I'd say likely not a transformational one — that's how I'd put it.
Cameron McVeigh
analystWhen you talked about the geographic mix — big markets compared with small ones — did you get into how that's fueling growth? And maybe what visibility looks like this far into Q2?
Scott Wells
executiveSo from that question, I'm taking it that your main interest is the US. Is that accurate? Or do you want me to answer on a worldwide basis?
Cameron McVeigh
analystBoth are of interest, though I'll go with the US.
Scott Wells
executiveOur company operates mostly within the top 20 markets. Roughly 80% of our revenue comes from the top 20 DMAs across the US. If you look abroad, the majority of the countries we're in tend to be capital-city focused; not exclusively, though. Once you reach larger nations such as France — France would resemble the US somewhat, with some concentration in the biggest cities, yet you'd find us in many more cities. Still, I'll concentrate on the US, since that strikes me as the most helpful way to discuss this. Considering the out-of-home sector in the US, you've got the top two, Los Angeles and New York, and our presence in Los Angeles is extremely strong. In New York we're fairly strong too, mainly at Times Square and the airports; so at street level in New York we don't have much. Those two markets, however, are the ones national advertisers affect the most. The remaining 18 of the top 20 DMAs tend to be somewhat more idiosyncratic regarding what an advertiser wants to accomplish and whether they enter. One thing that's quite distinct between out-of-home and television is this: you won't find buyers who purchase on a genuinely national basis, acquiring 200 DMAs and running their campaign in every place; with out-of-home, it's far more — they aim to be targeted regarding which markets they'll enter; and it shifts depending on the product and the campaign; so in Q1, the softness in national affected us more than, let's say, Lamar, which leans toward smaller markets and toward low or local sales. Our situation is similar, like OUTFRONT, and perhaps even a bit tougher than OUTFRONT since our footprint in New York may not be as good; so that's roughly how it unfolds. That said, in this business you must build up those national accounts. At the same time, you must build up regional and local accounts. You simply can't lean on a single piece of the mix to propel the business; so, hopefully, that provides a bit of color.
Cameron McVeigh
analystOne more thing I wanted to ask about. You brought up building out the CPG business in pharma categories — I'm interested in hearing more about how you're approaching that, what the value proposition looks like, and what would make an advertiser in one of those spaces pick Clear Channel rather than a different out-of-home company.
Scott Wells
executiveIf you're thinking about running ads through out-of-home, the question that comes first is probably why a company would go with out-of-home at all instead of other media — whereas what makes someone pick one media owner over another inside out-of-home tends to come down more to whether that owner has inventory in a location where a person actually wants to advertise. So if the New York airports are where you want your ads, working with Clear Channel becomes necessary. If the New York subway is where you want your ads, then OUTFRONT is the one you'll have to work with. That's just how this business operates. And that contrast is the sharpest one there is. Still, when we bring up category building, the point is that we're focused on delivering the insights and the data those categories require so they can feel confident their marketing is paying off. In CPG, for instance, that could mean examining sales within specific retail channels, or it could mean examining case sales from IRI and lining that up against where their campaigns actually ran. For pharmaceuticals, it would mean examining script generation. This sits right at the frontier of where out-of-home is headed — being able to deliver the same insight and the same confidence in marketing spend that made digital so successful across the last decade. That's the idea behind it. It's not so much that we're out to displace other out-of-home companies; it's more that our aim is pulling dollars in from the digital side and the TV side. I mean, all of it matters to us; but ultimately, when it comes to how much gets spent on out-of-home, spending tons of time crushing the other out-of-home players wouldn't really do much good, since that isn't a particularly large slice of ad spending.
Aaron Watts
analystAaron, you're asking about pricing and occupancy trends throughout our US markets, and whether we're getting more resistance on rates than in the past 2 years, given what's happening with the macro picture.
Scott Wells
executiveIt's a fascinating situation. We've touched on this pattern during some of our recent calls, yet we remain in what is clearly a premium marketplace—meaning that for the top-tier spots, demand outpaces what's available. That applies not only to us but to every media owner out there. Agencies tell me all the time that they simply cannot get their hands on those iconic spots in major cities. So that force is extremely powerful. Occupancy is extremely powerful, and pricing is extremely powerful too. When you move to the following year—think largely of your big highway and arterial signage—that's a good, robust market. We aren't really encountering much resistance; the issue isn't so much rates as it is whether brands are spending. Where we're having conversations with folks is when they say, I'm not certain I'll kick off my campaign this month since I don't know how demand will look, but I'd like to be positioned to start it the following month if things seem improved. That really described the nature of the discussion during January and February. Part of the reason those 2 months were so difficult was that many people were essentially waiting for the green light; and I believe once we reached March, and especially April, and as we consider the remainder of the year, we're more confident that they'll go ahead and place those. So our yields have risen. The increase comes more from rate than from occupancy. Still, it differs depending on the product. And it differs depending on your geographic position within a market. I hope that provides a bit of insight.
Aaron Watts
analystAnd then, if I may, one more thing. Let me return to what you said before regarding costs and margin — when connecting the first-quarter margin to what your full-year guidance implies, is the primary factor simply that additional revenue growth you anticipate, layered onto a somewhat higher cost base? Or do other significant levers, perhaps more heavily weighted toward costs, also come into play there?
Brian Coleman
executiveI believe it does capture sales growth across the rest of the year. And I also believe it captures, as you progress quarter by quarter, a degree of easing in the cost comparison. Since those abatements began diminishing, that will become a smaller obstacle. During Q1, it was an obstacle. So when we discuss comparisons, as we move through the 2023 quarters against the 2022 quarters, those are likely among the most significant factors.
Aaron Watts
analystBrian, could you remind me whether any additional significant lease renewals were on the horizon, comparable to the one you mentioned, or was that truly an isolated situation?
Brian Coleman
executiveIn terms of size, I'd call it an isolated situation. Naturally, plenty of leases reach their expiration and get renegotiated; however, looking at the remaining ones as a group, I don't see them having a material effect on the business when their renegotiation time arrives. That said, we do still have some leases reflecting COVID relief; this wasn't an abatement; rather, the lease conditions were tied to factors perhaps affected by COVID. And once we move past COVID and reach those comparative periods, that will remain an expense item we'll need to contend with. But to respond to your question straight on, nothing there reaches the size of that single lease renegotiation we flagged in the prior quarter.
Jim Goss
analystFirst off, I'd like to know whether the European improvements came mostly from currency effects or from bouncing back after COVID, or if they reflect genuine organic expansion.
Brian Coleman
executiveI'd call it a story with two distinct parts. Let me address that, and perhaps Scott or Justin will want to jump in afterward. In Southern Europe, I'd say it's mostly about COVID and securing certain contracts. Yet in Europe South, that operation hadn't gotten back to where it stood in pre-COVID 2019; even so, I believe they're working their way up and getting close to that mark, and in certain markets they're at it or beyond. So a great deal of it, I'd say, comes from COVID recovery, though I don't want to overlook certain wins we achieved in those nations, especially in Spain when it comes to new contracts. So I'd describe it as a combination of the two. Northern Europe, by contrast, has, I'd say, mostly bounced back from COVID. Some of our transit agreements would be the outlier; that's rather concentrated in Scandinavia. That one has been a rebound, especially during Q1. Yet there, I believe, you're seeing expansion across northern European markets. In markets such as Belgium and Denmark, those contract wins have been instrumental in fueling the growth. In the UK, it's simply ongoing usage of the digital network we operate there. Scott or Justin, I don't know if either of you had anything further you'd like to contribute?
Scott Wells
executiveNothing for me. Justin, anything for you to add?
Justin Cochrane
executiveThat strikes me as an excellent recap, Brian. In my view, that's precisely the situation — some COVID rebound returning across the South and in transit. Other markets are showing underlying growth; still, I'd say Brian nailed it.
Jim Goss
analystKind of changing topics here, I found the conversation you just had interesting regarding the gains over those past 4 to 6 quarters, that kind of info for every market. And I'm curious whether some of the strong performance in Europe is making you take a slower approach to looking for purchasers, or does it end up making you push harder on what price you expect? Or perhaps you've decided which markets to retain versus which ones you may want to divest, and maybe that has moved around a bit?
Scott Wells
executiveJim, I believe the key point is that we have been very clear and very consistent that over the long term, we view ourselves as a business focused on the US. However, that does not mean that — while we make that shift, our goals number one, two, and three are about delivering value to our shareholders. So you are completely correct, as additional data comes in and as these businesses perform, it will give the other parties greater confidence to buy, and it will give us greater confidence to sell. So we will make our way through that; yet the results we are getting there are not actually a shock to us. And we feel positive about the assets we hold, we feel positive about the teams operating them. The only problem is how you handle your route through the process that we navigate in a setting where there is a great deal of complexity. So we are working on it, we stay dedicated to that vision of being a US focused business; yet we will not act foolishly by doing deals that are not appealing.
Jim Goss
analystAnd lastly, when you look at the chance of a downturn using your bottom-up method, it seems somewhat more positive than what a number of macro watchers are saying — would that be a reasonable way to put it?
Scott Wells
executiveI honestly can't speak to what's going on inside other macro observers' minds. What I'd say is that we see ourselves as guided by the data. And given the facts in front of us, Jim, we've heard since March of 2022 that doomsday was coming; yet we've kept operating our company and pulling in the greatest amount of revenue and EBITDA we possibly can. And that, I believe, is the attitude that describes us. Our aim is to grow our business and generate as much revenue and EBITDA as possible. Ultimately, that's what matters to our shareholders, rather than our macro projections specifically. Naturally, folks expect us to be candid about what we're seeing, and that's what we're trying to accomplish with the details we're providing today. But I'm not in a position to say much about how our perspective compares with that of other macro forecasters.
Lance Vitanza
analystOne quick thing about expenses, and after that I want to discuss the domestic M&A landscape. On the expense side, though, just to make sure — you don't give quarterly guidance for expenses or EBITDA. So how did expenses and EBITDA for the first quarter come in compared with what you had expected internally?
Brian Coleman
executiveWell, taking Europe first, I'd say there was a bit of outperformance. That's positive; and the rebound in Southern Europe compared with the COVID quarter, reflecting some new contract wins, beat what we expected; of course, we did anticipate COVID recovery. So perhaps it's how fast the recovery came; but when it comes to Europe, you also need to keep in mind, Q1 is actually tiny compared with the business. And so, you've got a log with small numbers or large numbers that you have to place in the proper context. We discussed Europe North; that business is simply performing very strongly. And so, it isn't a surprise, but it was nice to see the transit business in Scandinavia recovering. We don't have much underground transit; but that's where our exposure is. And it's returning; but much of that growth is really, again, new contracts and the use of our digital networks, especially in the United Kingdom; so I think both Europe North and Europe South beat expectations. In the Americas, we were disappointed. I can't claim it was totally unexpected. We've known we have some tough comps. Scott may want to comment on the top line, but on the expense side, I think the abatement is rolling off, we have some credit charges that we don't think reflect the larger environment there, two or three unique situations that we do not expect to happen again; that was a headwind. We have some contracts that are adjusting for the post COVID environment. So I think I'd say the headwinds in the Americas and Airports were not unexpected, but we're disappointed. So I'll stop there. Scott, I don't know if you have more to add.
Scott Wells
executiveI believe we covered this; in the script we made a real effort to state plainly that this wasn't what we had expected, that we're unhappy with what America and Airports delivered in Q1, and that we expect to see things get better as the year progresses; and when we set out to identify what was driving the bottom line, that revenue piece — operating leverage, we bring it up constantly since it matters a great deal; so when your best market fails to produce the revenue you're targeting, that becomes a major factor. And once more, we made a real effort to lay out clearly where those gaps showed up. Regarding domestic M&A, it appears you keep making somewhat smaller purchases, presumably inside the US. I notice you spent roughly another $6 million during the first quarter. Could you describe what kinds of assets? And perhaps, if you could just give me approximate figures, what you spent on US assets in 2022, and then just discuss where or what type — national versus local, rural versus big city, airport versus billboard, anything at all about the strategy, essentially what you're seeking as you keep adjusting the portfolio. I'll let Brian handle the quantity question regarding spend and so forth. I'll give him a moment to bring that up. But as far as philosophy goes, it's completely US roadside. When we discuss acquisitions, what we're doing is completely US roadside. It's completely US roadside. And we are making acquisitions — for the most part these aren't companies we're purchasing, they're a few signs here and there; we aren't taking on much staff or much of — generally — if things go really well, you get some easements where you hold the ground beneath the sign. But we're seeking things that add to our footprint and add to our P&L overall. Brian, do you want to handle the quantity question?
Brian Coleman
executiveOkay, so for the quarter and for 2023, we're going to show CapEx plus acquisitions of roughly $38 million. On capital expenditures, our guidance is a range of $165 million to $185 million for the entire year. If you look at acquisitions alone, this quarter it was around $6 million, mostly in America. A bit happened in Northern Europe, while Southern Europe saw a decrease, so it was mainly digital. Across both Northern Europe and the Americas, what we spent on acquisitions — sorry, the CapEx went into acquisitions — was largely in the US and mostly digital. Regarding acquisitions, I don't think that's part of the CapEx guidance we provided; it's going to stay modest. There are a few things in the pipeline that we'll probably close. Given where the business environment is right now, we'll hold on to liquidity. Anything we keep going after would need to be especially accretive, though I expect it will mostly stay in that smaller tuck-in range, unless things shift, in which case we could get more aggressive.
Scott Wells
executiveOkay, thanks a lot. And I appreciate all of you for your questions. Well, when we gaze ahead toward the year, we're optimistic regarding the direction our business is taking; we're optimistic regarding our capacity to generate revenue and to fuel expansion throughout the year; and looking ahead, it's our hope that we'll be able to share some updates regarding our European process during the quarters to come, and we're grateful for everyone's involvement, but the key takeaway is that as we look ahead, we're optimistic regarding our business. Everyone, have a wonderful day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.