Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 8, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Eileen McLaughlin
executiveHello, everyone, and welcome to today's call. Joining us are Scott Wells, our Chief Executive Officer, alongside Brian Coleman, our Chief Financial Officer. They're going to walk us through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. and Clear Channel International B.V. performed operationally during the third quarter of 2023. We'd encourage you to pull up the earnings presentation, which you can find under the Financials section on our investor website, and follow along as we go. Following some opening remarks and a look at our results, we'll take your questions; and Justin Cochrane, who heads up Clear Channel U.K. and Europe as CEO, plus Dave Sailer, the CFO of Clear Channel Outdoor Americas, will be with Scott and Brian for that Q&A segment. Prior to getting started, I want to remind all of you that we might make forward-looking statements on this call about the company, including remarks concerning its future financial performance and its strategic goals. Any forward-looking statements carry risks and uncertainties, and there's no guarantee that management's expectations, beliefs or projections will come to pass, or that actual results won't deviate from expectations. Please take a look at the risk statements included in our earnings press release and in our filings with the SEC. We'll also be referencing some measures today that don't conform to generally accepted accounting principles. As part of the earnings presentation, we offer schedules reconciling these non-GAAP measures against our reported results on a GAAP basis. Also, be aware that what's shared on this call reflects only management's views as of today, November 8, 2023, and might not still be accurate whenever a replay is heard. Please go to Slide 4 in the earnings presentation, and I'll hand things over now to Scott.
Scott Wells
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for making time to be with us this morning. We are happy to share that our consolidated revenue came in at $517 million during the third quarter, when you set aside foreign exchange rate fluctuations, which works out to a 2.7% gain over the same period a year ago. That top line falls inside the guidance we gave, once Europe-South is excluded, since that unit has been reclassified into discontinued operations. Airports and Europe-North were the standout performers, while the America segment trailed, which is exactly what we told you to expect when we issued third quarter guidance back in August. Brian will walk through what drove the America results in more detail, but the softness came from a mix of weak national sales and the composition of our markets; domestic trends are getting better, and we think the U.S. will post stronger results in the fourth quarter. We understood going in that 2023 would bring difficulties on a number of fronts, among them the unwinding of COVID rent abatements and the absorption of elevated costs tied to a sizable roadside contract, all of which we've described before, yet we still anticipate that our full year 2023 results will land inside the guidance issued in February, excluding Europe-South, and we're eager about the path we're traveling as 2024 approaches. As mentioned in the past, driving substantial deleveraging across the near to medium term is where our management team and Board are concentrating their efforts. Two main levers get us there: first, keep carrying out our operating plan to grow adjusted EBITDA organically and boost free cash flow, which includes steps to further optimize our cost structure; and second, work deliberately to monetize our European assets while keeping our attention on the markets with higher margins. Thanks to the recently closed sale of our business in France, our portfolio work this year has advanced considerably, with every business in the Europe-South segment now sold or under agreement to be sold. On top of that, we've kicked off the process to sell the businesses within our Europe-North segment, and prospective purchasers are currently examining preliminary information. We've likewise begun a strategic review of our Latin American businesses and brought on an adviser to evaluate the options for them. We can't promise how either process will end, but we're confident that once these assets are sold, we'll operate as a more focused, U.S.-centric out-of-home company carrying less debt and holding greater optionality to convert into a REIT. We're also aware that adjusted EBITDA has to rise if we want to bring our leverage multiples down in a meaningful way. So alongside running our international divestiture processes, we're at the same time keeping our energies directed at executing the operating plan, which means growing adjusted EBITDA organically, widening our advertiser base, optimizing how we deploy capital and trimming corporate expenses. Among these efforts are expanding key verticals in the U.S., building multiple channels to reach advertisers, fixing underperforming markets, running a zero-based budget review of corporate expenses as our portfolio gets simpler, and using the proceeds from our divestitures to strengthen our liquidity position and lower debt. According to our view, these steps lay out the path toward substantially reduced leverage ratios across the coming couple of years, and that should in turn let us produce better free cash flow that backs additional debt reduction and releases shareholder value. Let me offer several evidence points backing our confidence in what we can accomplish; during 2022's second quarter, I said we had shifted our approach regarding the sale of all of Europe, aiming to divest the European properties with lower margins and lower priority first, while the businesses left over ought to show much greater adjusted EBITDA minus CapEx margins. Slide 5 sets fiscal year 2022 actuals for the combined Europe-North and Europe-South segments against the fiscal year 2023 guidance for Europe-North, and as that comparison shows, the operation we hold today is more digitized and carries larger segment adjusted EBITDA minus CapEx margins than the European businesses we combined back in 2022. What these figures show is that our team can carry out our strategy, which includes growing both our digital footprint and our programmatic platform, and they highlight how robust the out-of-home sector is. Our view is that the Europe-North business is now far more valuable and appealing. And though we remain dedicated to divesting these properties, we will act with discipline so as to get the greatest value. Next, some observations about the fourth quarter. Within the U.S., pharma and packaged goods should be 2 of the verticals expanding most rapidly for us. We have flagged these verticals as opportunities across multiple quarters, and in both areas our sales teams are gaining solid ground in developing business. Beyond that, we keep achieving success as we grow our programmatic platform. After a robust September, October stands as our strongest month so far. Last, let me circle back to my opening point and note our expectation that 2023 results, once the Europe-South segment is excluded, will land inside the guidance range we gave in February. Going forward, we think we are set up for considerable organic adjusted EBITDA expansion in 2024, and a thorough 2024 outlook will come on our Q4 call in February. Thus we recognize plenty of work lies ahead, yet we trust the right team and strategy are in place for us to capture the complete value that we see as intrinsic to our business. On that note, I want to express our gratitude for everything our worldwide team is doing as we concentrate on hitting our targets. With that, I'll turn the call over to Brian.
Brian Coleman
executiveThanks, Scott. Hello, everyone, and I’m glad you could be with us today. Please go to Slide 6. As Scott mentioned, Europe-South is included in discontinued operations at this point, a change we made public on October 31, 2023. During 2023’s third quarter, our intention to divest the businesses comprising the Europe-South segment met the criteria for reporting as discontinued operations. Because of that, all businesses in the Europe-South segment have been moved into discontinued operations in our financial statements for every period shown, and this led to adjustments in the way some prior-period figures are presented. Before we get into the numbers, a quick note: alongside our GAAP figures, I'll be talking about how we performed when you strip out currency fluctuations — that's a non-GAAP metric. Our view is that it gives a clearer picture for judging how we're doing. There are restructuring charges and other items sitting inside both direct operating expenses and SG&A expenses, and those get excluded from adjusted EBITDA as well as segment-adjusted EBITDA. Everything I cite relates to Q3 of 2023, and any percentage shifts I give compare that quarter against Q3 of 2022, unless I say otherwise. With that out of the way, let's turn to what we reported for the third quarter. Revenue on a consolidated basis reached $527 million for the period, up 4.7%. On a constant-currency basis, we saw consolidated revenue increase 2.7% to $517 million for the quarter. When we provided third quarter consolidated revenue guidance back in August, it covered a range of $70 million to $80 million tied to France and Spain, along with the Europe-South segment. If you set aside the Europe-South segment, our third quarter consolidated revenue landed inside the adjusted guidance range of $500 million to $520 million. With the Europe-South segment factored in, consolidated revenue, again excluding foreign exchange rate movements, would have come to $596 million, which likewise matches the August guidance range of $570 million to $600 million. Continuing operations produced a $51 million loss, which is larger than last year's $19 million loss from the same category. Our consolidated net loss came to $263 million, and that figure includes a $201 million net loss on asset disposals tied to the France sale. Adjusted EBITDA reached $139 million, a 0.9% gain. Once you strip out foreign exchange rate movements, adjusted EBITDA declined modestly. Our results show that rent abatements remained a drag, falling $11 million during the quarter. Third quarter AFFO totaled $25 million, a 27.3% decrease. With foreign exchange rate movements excluded, AFFO fell 33.5%. Let's move to Slide 7, where we cover the America segment's third quarter results. In the Americas, we brought in $279 million, which represents a 1.9% decline. The drop was primarily due to softness in our media entertainment vertical as well as the San Francisco/Bay Area market. Digital came in at $98 million, up just a bit, and made up 35% of Americas revenue. National sales declined 14.9% and represented 32.7% of Americas revenue. Local was a bright spot — it rose 6% and accounted for 67.3% of Americas revenue. Direct operating and SG&A costs reached $157 million, a 1.7% increase. The main driver of that increase was site lease expense, which climbed 10.4% to $90 million, lifted by lease renewals and amendments along with fewer rent abatements. That was partially offset by lower property taxes related to a legal settlement and a decrease in credit loss expense. Segment adjusted EBITDA came in at $121 million, a decline of 6.4%, and the segment adjusted EBITDA margin landed at 43.5%, lower than what we saw in Q3 of 2022. Now please go to Slide 8, where we'll walk through third quarter results for Airports. Airports revenue reached $76 million, an increase of 21.2%. This strong revenue gain was fueled by rising demand stemming from air travel's ongoing recovery following COVID-19, along with investment in digital infrastructure. Digital revenue made up 55.3% of Airports revenue and rose 15.6% to $42 million. National sales represented 56.8% of Airports revenue and grew 25.1%, while local sales made up 43.2% of Airports revenue and rose 16.6%. Direct operating and SG&A costs rose 27%, reaching $60 million. That gain mostly comes from site lease expense, which increased 47.9% to $47 million, as a result of fewer rent abatements and higher revenue. Segment adjusted EBITDA came in at $16 million, a 3.1% increase, and segment adjusted EBITDA margin was 20.5%, which remains a bit above normalized levels thanks to rent abatements. Now, moving to Slide 9, we'll look at our Europe-North performance. When I discuss Europe-North, I'm referring to results adjusted to strip out movements and foreign exchange rates. Revenue in Europe-North was up 4.5% to $142 million, primarily due to stronger revenues in the U.K., Belgium and Denmark, partially offset by weaker revenues in Sweden and Norway. In Europe-North, digital made up 55.8% of total revenue and rose 8.5%, reaching $79 million. Direct operating and SG&A expenses for Europe-North climbed 3.7%, hitting $115 million. The reasons behind that rise include pricier electricity, leasing costs for more digital displays, and an increase in property tax. A renegotiated contract allowed site lease expense to fall 0.7%, landing at $53 million. Segment adjusted EBITDA for Europe-North grew 9.2% to $26 million, while the segment's adjusted EBITDA margin came in at 18.7%, up from the previous year. Now let's turn to CCIBV on Slide 10. Clear Channel International B.V., or CCIBV as we refer to it, is an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of the company and acts as the issuer of our 6.625% senior secured notes due 2025. This section addresses how our Europe-North and Europe-South segments performed, along with Singapore—which, following the reporting segment changes made in Q4 2022, now falls under "other." Because the Europe-South businesses count as discontinued operations, their results appear as a distinct component of consolidated net loss in CCIBV's consolidated statements of loss for every period shown, and we've excluded them from the discussion that follows. Below is how CCIBV's continuing operations performed in Q3 2023 versus the equivalent quarter of 2022. Revenue at CCIBV climbed 10.3% to $154 million, compared with $140 million previously. If you set aside the $8 million effect from foreign exchange fluctuations, CCIBV revenue was up 4.6%, and that was mostly because of stronger revenue in our Europe-North segment, which I mentioned earlier. For the 3 months ended September 30, 2023, Singapore accounted for under 3% of CCIBV revenue from continuing operations. CCIBV operating income came in at $9 million, versus $3 million during the same period in 2022. Let's turn to Slide 11 now for a look at capital expenditures. CapEx came to $33 million in the third quarter, which is $5 million lower than the prior year, driven by less spending on Airports and Europe-North CapEx. The reduction in Airports CapEx is a result of the sizable digital network investments we made during the prior year. Turning to Slide 12: in June, we modified and prolonged our revolving credit facilities. After that, during August, we brought to market $750 million in aggregate principal amount of 9% senior secured notes due 2028. Using a portion of the net proceeds generated by that note offering, we paid down $665 million of outstanding principal under the term loan facility, which we repurchased at a 1% discount. On top of that, we took on $12 million in debt issuance costs connected to these transactions, and our intention is to direct the approximately $76 million that remains toward general corporate purposes.
Brian Coleman
executiveAlso, the upcoming maturity on our debt is the CCIBV notes totaling $375 million, which comes due in August of 2025, while the following maturity involving our term loan arrives in August of 2026. As of September 30, 2023, liquidity stood at $531 million, which is $80 million higher than what we had at the close of the second quarter, thanks to growth in cash and cash equivalents. Throughout the third quarter, cash and cash equivalents rose by $85 million, reaching $313 million, while our debt totaled $5.6 billion as of September 30, 2023, marking a $71 million rise from June 30. These gains came mostly from the note offering I referenced earlier. In September, we bought back on the open market $5 million of the CCOH 7.75% senior notes along with $10 million of the CCOH 7.5% senior notes at a discount, which produced a $3 million gain on extinguishment. Those repurchased notes are still outstanding. Interest paid in cash on debt amounted to $81 million in the third quarter, up $25 million versus the same quarter last year, largely because of elevated interest rates on our term loan facility and the scheduling of accrued interest payments. Our weighted average cost of debt came to 7.5%, a bit higher than the weighted average cost of debt as of June 30, 2023. As of September 30, 2023, our first lien leverage ratio stood at 5.59x, computed from continuing operations, a modest rise from June 30, 2023. The covenant threshold in the credit agreement is 7.1x. Turning to Slide 13 and our outlook for the fourth quarter and the entire year of 2023. All consolidated guidance and Europe-North guidance leave out foreign exchange rate movements, except for capital expenditures and cash interest payments. Keep in mind, our consolidated guidance has been modified to remove the Europe-South segment. For the fourth quarter, we anticipate consolidated revenue ranging from $591 million to $618 million. We forecast America revenues between $293 million and $305 million, while Airports revenue should land between $100 million and $105 million, which is another very strong quarter relative to last year. Europe-North revenue is projected between $170 million and $180 million, which is a gain over the previous year. Now to our full year guidance. Because of the shift resulting from the Europe-South segment being reclassified to discontinued operations, we figured it would be useful to lay out the specifics of how we revised the guidance we gave in August. As the slide shows, since we are nearing the end of the year, we have narrowed the range for consolidated revenue. We anticipate consolidated revenue falling between $2.091 billion and $2.118 billion. As Scott noted, this remains inside the guidance range we offered in February, excluding discontinued operations. America revenue should come in between $1.095 billion and $1.107 billion. Airports is finishing the year stronger than we anticipated, with revenue projected between $300 million and $305 million. For Europe-North, we're looking at revenue somewhere in the $604 million to $614 million range, which is also better than what we told you back in August. When you put everything together on a consolidated basis, adjusted EBITDA should land between $520 million and $542 million — a modest bump up from the August guidance, once you set aside discontinued operations. For AFFO, the guidance sits at $67 million to $80 million. On capital expenditures, we're anticipating somewhere between $143 million and $161 million, and we'll keep prioritizing investments in our U.S. digital footprint. Beyond that, cash interest payment obligations for 2023 should come in at roughly $405 million, which is higher than last year because of increased floating rate interest on our term loan B facility, though it's lower than the August guidance thanks to the timing of interest payments tied to the transactions I mentioned earlier. In the fourth quarter, we anticipate paying $121 million in cash interest expense. This guidance is built on the assumption that we won't refinance or take on any additional debt. At this point, I'll hand the call back over to Scott for his closing remarks.
Scott Wells
executiveThanks, Brian. As we look forward, our confidence in the guidance for the year remains solid. We're still carrying out our strategy to simplify operations, focus on assets here at home, and get the company ready for expansion and better profitability. The actions we're taking to bring our organization up to date and raise our standing as a powerhouse in visual media should, in our view, only make us better at generating revenue and growth in adjusted EBITDA. While we move ahead with the divestiture of our Europe-North businesses and the strategic review of our Latin American operations, and while we work on growing adjusted EBITDA organically, we expect that eventually we'll start bringing down our debt and produce stronger free cash flow, creating significant equity value along the way. So at this point I'll hand the call to the operator for the Q&A session, and Justin Cochrane and Dave Sailer will be joining us on the call.
Avi Steiner
analystLet me begin with the advertising landscape, if that's alright, and perhaps you could talk about, leaving San Francisco aside, what's showing up in Q4 and whether Airports differ materially from your usual city boards. Then I have a few follow-ups.
Scott Wells
executiveAvi, I appreciate that. The ad market has been quite odd during this year; because of that, I'm somewhat reluctant to offer overly broad generalizations. If you simply compare the national figures we gave for our American roadside operation with the national figures for Airports, one of the odd patterns at play becomes visible, something that has persisted through the entire year — the intense emphasis on superpremium assets. Premium has dominated this year, and that appears to be carrying into Q4. Broadly speaking, we believe media and entertainment, now that writers have returned to work — and I realize actors have not yet, though hopefully there will be movement there — is a factor. Clearly, the auto strikes are resolved. That vertical isn't major for us and doesn't move the needle much. We're reaching a stage where tech firms are discussing spending on their brands somewhat more boldly. A variety of signals point toward a favorable trajectory; where we specifically are concerned, I do believe the patterns observed so far this year — difficulties in the Bay Area and, honestly, California and the Midwest, which have been weaker markets — contrast with considerable positives in Texas, Florida, and the East Coast. Yet it's far more — I believe I mentioned this on previous calls — it's a far more typical market, with ordinary local forces shaping events. So generalizing about this market is difficult, Avi. Still, on the whole, I would describe it as firming up, with signs of strength in categories that had retreated this year; and, as we noted during the call, we're seeing expansion in areas where we've put money to work, namely pharma and CPG. Hopefully that provides you with a sense of it.
Avi Steiner
analystThat's a big help, thank you. Now, may I shift over to costs and the corporate line, please? My understanding is adjusted corporate expenses fell by nearly 14% during this quarter — feel free to set me straight if that's off. Still, when we look ahead at that line item, I realize Europe-South has been discontinued now and several things are in motion. So how are we meant to model corporate? Also, please refresh us on the corporate savings that should materialize after Europe-North gets sold. I have a few other questions after that.
Brian Coleman
executiveOf course, Avi, I'll handle that. Much of the drop you're observing in this year stems, regrettably, from variable compensation costs, since the business hasn't delivered what was anticipated, especially in America. However, the more significant matter regarding corporate expense is that we intend to bring it down. We examine chances to achieve savings, and this holds true no matter what activities are occurring inside the business. You brought up divestitures; that will serve as a trigger for taking a closer look at corporate expense. As we've previously stated, once the international businesses are divested, we would anticipate a reduction of no less than $30 million in corporate expenses. That figure excludes shared cost and embedded cost within the corporate center. Those too will require review, though pulling them out of the business could take a longer stretch of time. That's the reason we include the "at least" qualifier. That said, I think as time goes on, we'll face some modest headwinds next year, since we're hopeful the business rebounds somewhat in that variable compensation expense — something we'll gladly pay should a rebound indeed occur. Pushing in the opposite direction, though, will be an intense focus both on lowering corporate expense broadly and on capturing corporate expense that is tied or related to the divestitures.
Avi Steiner
analystThat's really useful, and I'm with you on that final point — I'm glad to make payment once the revenue starts flowing. I've got 2 additional items. However, Brian, my recollection is that you'd previously stated buybacks of bonds would happen only once you felt good about both liquidity and the outlook. I simply want to confirm I understood that correctly, and that the buyback ought to be interpreted that way; and while I realize it isn't a large figure, $15 million is the first instance we've seen in some time. And regarding the repurchase, what I'd like to understand is the reasoning behind leaving those bonds outstanding rather than retiring them. Is there a covenant, a liquidity issue, or some other factor at play?
Brian Coleman
executiveRegarding the repurchase, I believe you've got it right when you describe it as an expenditure of liquidity we'd only make if we judged the return to be worthwhile; and repurchasing bonds depends on several factors, among them the return available, how comfortable you are with liquidity, whether bonds can be obtained, and how liquid those bonds are in the market. We must also stay highly attentive to the windows of opportunity available to us given the various strategic activities underway, among them the divestiture process for Europe-South and now the process started in Europe-North. Only a handful of windows exist in which we don't hold MNPI and would feel at ease repurchasing bonds. And I believe that too — the disciplined stance toward an acceptable return combined with those limited windows tends to cap how many bonds you're able to repurchase. That's partly why the repurchase amounts to just $15 million. As for not retiring them, no requirement forces that. In other words, retiring them is an option we hold; doing so is permanent. After retirement, there's no way to reverse it. So I think simply keeping them for the time being provides us with greater optionality. Whether that eventually results in something further is, in my view, still undetermined as of now. From an accounting standpoint, they'll be removed when we consolidate; accordingly, you'll observe a positive effect in that the debt leaves the balance sheet and the related interest expense likewise departs the income statement. I believe that covers everything you asked. But if there's anything I missed, please feel free to...
Scott Wells
executiveAvi, let me add one more point regarding confidence and the liquidity picture. In terms of the mechanics of how that term loan got retired, we ended up producing roughly $6.5 million in savings from it, and on top of that we sidestepped amortization payments amounting to around $20 million each year. That's the right way to view the sources and the uses — and clearly, we're carrying out all the things Brian just walked through.
Avi Steiner
analystGreat. For my final question — and I truly value the time, Scott, and Brian, you as well if you'd like to chime in — it's obvious you've got a disciplined roadmap in place to, so to speak, advance the ball. Yet as I try to connect where Clear Channel stands right now with where the company hopes to be on the leverage front, even after the asset divestitures, the EBITDA improvement in the core U.S. operations, and the debt repurchases you reported today, it feels as though a bit more effort may still be required. So I'm wondering: out of the numerous possibilities you're evidently reviewing and weighing, has the company spoken with any of its larger debt or equity holders about potentially issuing equity-like instruments or considering debt-for-equity swaps? Or is that simply premature at this stage? And once more, I appreciate the time as always.
Brian Coleman
executiveYes. Avi, I'll give that a try, and then Scott or Dave can jump in if they'd like to add more detail. Look, you've touched on a number of the items we're examining. So stepping back, our approach, I'd break into 3 categories. First is EBITDA growth. You brought that up; it's definitely something we're concentrating on. It sits at the heart of all our efforts. And in the end, we must generate growth across the businesses to alter our leverage profile down the road. You brought up M&A; so I'd say another category is M&A, though I'd view it broadly, in a wide sense. It encompasses not just what we've completed in Europe-South, the process we've started in Europe-North, the strategic review we've made public in Latin America. But it might stretch further into, okay, thinking regarding U.S. markets, which we've discussed and are quite attuned to. Possibly the manner in which we approach future investments. Possibly we pursue that through a partnership requiring less capital. So its meaning can be far wider than certain items we're discussing; it's somewhat harder to discuss the third bucket, liability management activities, since that can encompass many things, and perhaps some of them you'd rather not mention prior to carrying them out; but you've witnessed some initial moves in the debt repurchases we've described; we'll clearly receive proceeds flowing in from certain divestitures and what are the most — what are the best methods to deploy those proceeds, whether to pay down debt or otherwise put money into the business. But to reach the — I suppose, the crux of your question, have we held discussions with our investor base regarding other options, I believe the honest way to respond, Avi, is that we're constantly in discussions with our investors; and a number of those have been incoming inquiries, and a number of those have simply been the questions and answers and working through ideas that exist. There isn't anything concrete enough that would obligate us to disclose it. Nothing has really gotten to a level where it deserves discussion, but I believe we're continuously talking with our investors, and that isn't — the company has always been receptive to that. So we're glad to keep that conversation going, hear out imaginative suggestions, and should anything prove interesting, we will definitely consider it. Scott or Dave, I'm not sure whether either of you wants to chime in.
Scott Wells
executiveNo, I'd say you've got the picture.
Richard Choe
analystI'd like to ask a follow-up. Your guidance suggests a build through the fourth quarter. I was hoping to hear what you're currently observing; and I realize it's somewhat early, but what's your feeling regarding the America and Airports business as we head into next year?
Scott Wells
executiveAll right. Appreciate that, Richard. I'll handle this one; and once more, should Brian or Dave have something to contribute, we're happy to hear it; back in August we discussed at length that a couple of items we were watching for were whether we'd witness a rise in cancellations, which clearly would be a negative, and whether we'd truly see folks re-enter the market after Labor Day, which matched what the chatter had indicated. And I'm happy to say we saw no increase in cancellations, and people did come back into the market; and the market today is more constructive than the one we faced in August; so all of that is favorable. Regarding the latter portion of your question, when it comes to examining 2024, we've only just started our up-front process. The conversations we've had so far are encouraging. I mentioned during Avi's question that we're hearing from certain tech companies that had grown somewhat more cautious about spending now returning. We're enthusiastic about the headway we're making in a few of the categories we've been striving to break into, and we're feeling good about developments in the programmatic marketplace. And there's certainly chatter among CMOs that programmatic out-of-home will be a thing in 2024. I won't fully believe it until I witness it, since we've certainly heard encouraging things previously. But I think in a climate where you have an advertising market that will have political absorbing a great deal of the scatter and up-front markets along with other media, I think out-of-home will be positioned quite well given that we've done sufficient test and learns with brands indicating they're achieving solid return from using our out-of-home assets in that manner, which could be a plus. But that's speculation right now, Richard; we don't have sufficient money in the books to declare anything, though I'd describe the 2024 outlook as positive. Anything to add, Brian or Dave?
Richard Choe
analystGreat. On the programmatic front, is there anything you might do to get ready for demand that's higher? Or does that sort of handle itself?
Scott Wells
executiveWhat makes programmatic so appealing is just how scalable it is. If you recall the early days, when we kicked this off, far more of it required hands-on work from us to get it running. It isn't flawless yet, but we're positioned to take on demand as it comes; and I imagine a scenario in which capacity is so tight that I have to inform programmatic folks we can't meet their demand, since that would only benefit our direct business.
Richard Choe
analystNo, that would put us in a fantastic spot. For my final question, Europe-North keeps beating expectations and performing strongly. What effect does that have on the strategic review, on how other potential buyers might view the process, and on how you see the business right now? It certainly appears to be performing quite well.
Scott Wells
executiveIt is indeed performing quite well. Honestly, I think it's worth having Justin perhaps explain the reason behind that, but allow me to address your question first. When we made the shift midway through last year toward tackling the difficult markets initially and tidying up the portfolio, that came with an agreement with the Europe-North team that the emphasis they would place, along with ongoing digital conversion, ongoing investment in LaunchPAD and programmatic tools, and similar initiatives, would enable them to reach what has been accomplished, as you can see on Page 5 of our slide deck. I cannot say what prospective purchasers may be thinking as they observe it, but the general feedback we've received is that people value that we have adjusted our portfolio. They value the effort we've put into our portfolio, and they are impressed by how Europe-North has exceeded expectations compared with the SIP we released in January of '22; and that's really all I can share about the process right now. We're still in the early stages. But Justin, why don't you take just 30 seconds to walk us through the drivers of this performance? Because it has been quite remarkable.
Justin Cochrane
executiveYes. Of course. Thank you, Scott. So, in my view, the primary thing pushing this forward would be the ongoing expansion of digital, particularly in relation to our work with roadside properties—chiefly street furniture—and in places such as the U.K., where we've stayed on course with the strategy and keep seeing improvement. Programmatic doesn't represent a large piece, yet its effect has been fairly significant. The reason is that the majority of the money we generate in that area is additive. And if you combine that with an expanding digital presence, it genuinely benefits the operation. Thus, I'd say a handful of factors truly contributed to driving that. I'd imagine this can only be positive for the process. But yes, so a robust, uninterrupted digital build-out, with programmatic providing a little something extra on top.
Cameron McVeigh
analystJust two things from me. Regarding that Europe-North topic — right, I'm aware that more than half of revenue comes from digital. I'm just wondering how you're viewing digital conversions, I suppose, in the U.S. moving forward, and what the optimal revenue share would be, both for the U.S. and for Airports.
Scott Wells
executiveAppreciate it, Cameron. Let me begin with the America segment. The U.S. is genuinely a patchwork when it comes to regulatory environments. Several markets we have resemble our Europe-North operation in profile, generating 40% to 60% of their revenue through digital means. Then there are markets sitting at 0 due to the regulatory environment. The way this has unfolded across the years — I believe there's a long-term trend toward being able to digitize. But my sense is the probable result in America likely won't reach as high as the global figure until you consider a very long time from now, purely because of regulatory constraints and the difficulties there. With Airports, I'd say it's a different story; and you've watched our digital business expand extremely quickly. Anyone who has passed through the New York airports, which represent our most modern airport implementation, has witnessed just how extensively we deploy digital within it. And it truly suits the airport setting. That's not to claim there aren't opportunities for static and spots where static might work. Yet the operational flexibility that digital offers, along with its immediacy, is highly appealing in that setting; so we're already in the 50s at the airport when it comes to digital penetration, and I could certainly envision that climbing further. And the timing on that will hinge on airport refreshes and, honestly, where it's sensible. Because although digital has become less expensive, the sorts of implementations we're carrying out at JFK and LaGuardia won't be viable at regional airports. So a balance needs to be found. Still, I do believe you'll see digital account for a greater proportion of that airport space. Hopefully, that answers your question.
Cameron McVeigh
analystThat certainly makes sense. Then for my final question, regarding those rent abatements — how much more time do you anticipate continuing to get them?
Brian Coleman
executiveI'll give it a shot, and then perhaps you can speak to the Americas. My sense is these are working their way through the cycle. Nothing has come up for us in Europe. My impression is that we're finished there. When it comes to the America side, we keep chasing whatever is available, though we're likewise watching that work through the business cycle. My understanding is that the bulk of them sit in the airport business, but I'll hand things over to Dave Sailer, CFO of Americas, to address that.
Dave Sailer
executiveAbsolutely, happy to. Let me begin with the Airports segment. Those benefits are certainly beginning to taper away now that we've put more distance between us and COVID. That said, I'd note that during Q3 of 2022, the amount was quite substantial — we saw a considerably larger degree of relief once 2023 arrived. Over time, that will phase out. Even so, the Airports group will still see a bit trickle in during Q4 and a portion into 2024, though we are unquestionably near the very end of it. On the America side, from a COVID perspective, the relief is clearly wrapping up. And if you consider our somewhat — really, I'd call it our largest headwind entering this year, which we've referenced previously, it was essentially that single big contract we reworked. That one phases out once Q3 concludes. So heading into next year, there's a little more remaining on Airports, but from the America standpoint, I believe we've reached the limit of what that can give.
Lance Vitanza
analystGood work on the quarter. Scott, I believe you mentioned October might have been the strongest month of this year, following a solid September. Could you restate what you said back then, and then share your view on whether that's simply the normal seasonal pattern we'd anticipate heading into Q4? Or would you argue there's genuine improvement — if we tried to look at it as a seasonally adjusted type of series, would we still conclude October is more or less the top month so far this year?
Scott Wells
executiveLance, that remark referred to programmatic; programmatic had its greatest month on record for us; so it wasn't a reflection of the whole business; so it was somewhat more limited, I think, than the way you may have taken it.
Lance Vitanza
analystThen that momentum you're picking up — the one you're observing — does it come from pulling business away from other out-of-home advertisers? Or does the out-of-home channel itself happen to be pulling business away from other media? Or could it just be that you're detecting a broader uptick in ad spending compared with what you'd projected?
Scott Wells
executiveWell, I'd say out-of-home, when set against traditional media, definitely is picking up share versus traditional media. You've seen the digital companies' reports, and their results have been fairly strong. So I won't claim we're pulling a great deal from that channel. Still, I think this comes down to optimization. Within the media ecosystem, we occupy a comparatively modest slice, and advertisers are working hard to determine the ideal media combination. What we offer is a medium with high reach that works hard, and plenty of advertisers are familiar with us and rely on us for exactly that. Plus, they keep noticing the synergies we've highlighted with digital media, especially, on a fairly consistent basis. As a result, we find ourselves folded into campaigns next to that kind of media. And I believe that represents a significant growth engine for us down the road. That said, generalizing across thousands upon thousands of advertisers is extremely difficult. I do believe our position is strong as a medium that works hard and delivers high reach.
Lance Vitanza
analystThen the final item from my side, returning briefly to Airports. You said the year is finishing out more robustly than anticipated, so I want to explore what's fueling that. My read is there are 3 possible sources of upside, correct? Either you installed a greater number of displays than planned, or higher passenger volumes moved through the terminals than expected, or advertisers simply took to the medium more than you had budgeted for. Given those 3 — or perhaps additional ones I haven't identified — how would you break down the relative momentum you're observing compared with your assumptions from earlier in the year?
Scott Wells
executiveAppreciate it, Lance. Honestly, I'd say every one of those 3 plays a role, though let me break it down a bit. There's a fourth factor I'd throw in — simply the schedule of getting inventory deployed. We anticipated a robust year for Airports given the extremely substantial build-out. Consider the CapEx we put into Airports during earlier periods. The build-out has been extremely substantial, especially within our New York franchise; therefore, a portion of this is merely bringing into the mainstream a great deal of inventory that has launched over the past 12 months. Still, when I consider it, airport traffic has risen by double digits compared with 2022. By now it has genuinely surpassed 2019 by a wide margin. That's the figure we previously obsessed over. Today it's expanding on its own terms. So it's climbed by double digits. Digitization has kept advancing, as we discussed moments ago. As for advertisers, the medium has fit the advertising climate well. I've noted repeatedly how 2023 has been an ultra-premium market — meaning spectaculars. That means airports; that means iconic locations in iconic places, be it New York, Miami, L.A., or Vegas. That segment of the market has been scorching hot, and Airports has gained from that trend. Still, I believe those 3 factors you listed each played a part, together with our launching a great deal of excellent inventory in New York.
Steven Cahall
analystSteven, if I didn't address this before, apologies. Could you discuss how things are going in Los Angeles, which is by a wide margin our biggest market? On a related note, M&E has clearly been weighing things down — everyone understands why, given the strikes — and it appears they'll be settled fairly soon. So when we consider 2024, how should we think about the possible upside if both M&E and L.A. return to more typical conditions? Then, picking up on the earlier Europe-North questions: if that process does reach a good conclusion, apart from whatever assets you may be selling in Europe-North, are there further corporate or overhead expenses you could take out once that asset is finished? I'm simply attempting to grasp the broader effect on EBITDA.
Scott Wells
executiveThanks, Steve. The L.A. matter is quite particular. I'll do my best to respond, and I'll do so within the limits of what I can say. After that I'll pass things to Brian for the corporate costs. Regarding L.A., the strikes in media and entertainment — both the writers' strike and the actors' strike — have affected not only media and entertainment itself, though they certainly did affect it, but also the broader level of activity across L.A. With so many people affected by those strikes, advertisers — local ones as well as national ones — have perhaps been somewhat less willing to launch campaigns into that climate. We're observing that ease in Q4. Still, I'd frame L.A. within California as a whole; California is quite complex when it comes to auto insurers. California matters for technology, and technology has been a weak category for much of this year. Add the media and entertainment effects, and a great many factors have been hitting it. You're correct that it's our biggest market. San Francisco ranks as our third biggest market. So if you put together the effects from those verticals and the effects from California's dynamics, that accounts for the overwhelming share of the difficulties we've faced this year. And we're seeing indications that these things will head in a more positive direction ahead. I believe getting the writers back to work will be a real help. With luck, the actors will reach a resolution, and we can recover from there. It's always tough to identify the bottom, in my view, yet I think Q3 shows signs that it may be the bottom for the difficulties we've had in California and L.A. Brian, let me turn the corporate costs portion over to you.
Brian Coleman
executiveAbsolutely. Thank you. We touched on this subject a bit before. However, I believe what you're asking about gets at the fact that we've stated it would be possible to remove no fewer than $30 million once the international divestitures are complete. My view is that you should look at it this way: those $30 million represent, more or less, the costs that are straightforward to pin down and that will depart at roughly the same moment as the divestiture. Beyond that, the phrase "no fewer than" points to additional chances we have identified. So, digging into that, suppose you consider the situation where a portion of corporate overhead ties directly to the European operation — that piece exits, it's simple to conceptualize, simple to separate out. What remains, then? What remains consists of expenses that are somewhat tangled up in, or baked into, the upper-level corporate organization. Take corporate treasury personnel as one illustration. Those individuals wouldn't automatically be required anymore. They'd exit alongside the business, yet they don't count as direct corporate overhead tied to that business. There could also be staff handling international matters, though situated at the corporate level. And perhaps once those arrangements wind down after some period, those roles would also have to be eliminated. I believe it's worth highlighting some fresh wording we added to the script regarding zero-based analysis, cost-based analysis, as we examine this. Thus, following the divestiture, we intend to scrutinize things rigorously; we'll construct the picture starting from the ground up. We'll ensure we account for every one of those expenses contained within that structure.
Aaron Watts
analystOnly 2 things from me. You've addressed quite a bit already today; here in the U.S., which main elements are causing print to be comparatively weaker than digital? Is it coming from certain verticals you mentioned that currently aren't performing well, or from particular markets you referenced that perhaps carry a heavier print weighting?
Scott Wells
executiveThat's really a granular question. Given the time, I'll respond at a broader level, and honestly I'm not sure it'll be all that useful. What's behind the print situation comes down to the general forces at play for us. Markets that have declined tend to carry somewhat more print weighting than others. I'd say auto insurance not rebounding to the degree we'd anticipated during this year has held print back; that's really the one additional item I'd point to amid the broader difficulties in the U.S; still, we examine this carefully from one market to the next, and those big-picture descriptions are the main ones.
Aaron Watts
analystAll right, understood. Moving on to the second point — as we wrap up '23 and move into '24, with digital only growing more significant, could you walk us through how we should view the margin picture for digital compared with the traditional static boards on the Americas platform? And given where we are in the rollout, ought we to consider every additional digital board as margin accretive? If that isn't the case, what factors offset it?
Scott Wells
executiveYes, so, with digital, quite a bit is bundled into that too. That said, whenever we convert them, we always make an effort to lock down the ground beneath our digital signs and/or obtain a long-term lease. As a product, they carry a higher margin by nature. That said, outside of the spectaculars and a handful of urban sites, our roadside business — our America business — is overall a high-margin product. So view it as a margin tailwind, though not a tsunami. That's probably the pithy way of saying it.
Scott Wells
executiveAlright, and thanks to each of you for being here with us today. I realize we can now state that our guidance is being raised because of how well Airports and Northern Europe are doing, though what our investors care about most is America. Looking at America on a year-to-date basis, there are a few points I'd like to flag for everybody. Where revenue is concerned, over 50% of our markets have posted growth this year, while a single market is responsible for close to two times our overall decline year-to-date. That same market is driving twice the total decline. Beyond that, programmatic is delivering double-digit growth for the first time since early this year, and category <<inaudible>> is trending the right way; when it comes to EBITDA, we are emerging from the lengthy absorption period tied to the big contract we renewed this year, and we have nearly finished lapping the one-time abatements connected to COVID. So when you combine that with proof of our capacity to accomplish difficult things across our portfolio, the results delivered by our Airports and Northern Europe teams, and the priority areas we discussed during this call, we see plenty of grounds to expect better days for CCO going forward. That brings us to the end. Thanks to all of you, and we'll be speaking with you again next quarter.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that wraps up our session for today. We appreciate your participation. At this point, feel free to leave the call.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.