Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 26, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Communication Services Media earnings 54 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Eileen McLaughlin

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. Present on this call are our CEO, Scott Wells, along with our CFO, Brian Coleman. They're going to walk us through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. and Clear Channel International B.V. performed operationally during the fourth quarter of 2023. We'd encourage everyone to pull up the earnings presentation, which you can find under the financial section of our investor website, and follow along as we go. Once we've finished the introduction and gone over our results, we'll take questions, and at that point Justin Cochrane, who heads up Clear Channel U.K. and Europe, plus David Sailer, the CFO of Clear Channel Outdoor Americas, will be on hand with Scott and Brian for the Q&A part of the call. . Prior to getting started, I want to remind all of you that forward-looking statements about the company may be made on this call, including things related to future financial performance and strategic goals. Risks and uncertainties come with all forward-looking statements, and we can't guarantee that management's expectations, beliefs or projections will be realized, or that actual results won't turn out differently than expected. I'd ask you to look over the risk statements included in our earnings press release and in our SEC filings. Also, some measures we'll reference today don't conform to generally accepted accounting principles. As part of the earnings presentation, we've provided schedules reconciling these non-GAAP measures against our reported results on a GAAP basis; one more note — what's shared on this call reflects management's views only as of today, February 26, 2024, and could be outdated by the time a replay is heard. Please turn to Slide 4 in the earnings presentation. And now I'll hand things over to Scott.

Scott Wells

executive
#2

Hello, everyone, and thanks for spending part of your day with us. For the fourth quarter, we brought in consolidated revenue of $623 million, leaving out foreign exchange rate movements, which works out to a 10.8% gain over the same period a year earlier and came in above the guidance we had given for Q4. Those results show solid performance from Airports in Europe-North along with better business momentum in the Americas segment, where America has gone back to growing. Looking back over the last year in our Americas segment, following a very encouraging upfront in the U.S., what defined things for a lot of our clients was putting off decisions while they looked for signals about where the economy was headed. We additionally encountered weakness in certain markets, especially the San Francisco Bay area, and in certain categories too, with media and entertainment, technology and auto leading the way; those elements, taken together with the trouble we had fully staffing local sales teams, added up to a difficult year. The encouraging part is that business began turning up later in the year, with demand strengthening after Labor Day and carrying over into the quarter we're in now; in California, we're noticing some pickup in demand. Within the verticals we've been targeting, we've posted solid growth. And on the hiring and onboarding of salespeople in our local markets, we've moved forward. Although a degree of uncertainty persists in the market, advertisers are growing more at ease when it comes to making decisions, and across key verticals and markets we keep witnessing better trends in the present quarter. After a sluggish beginning, our Airports team turned in a record fourth quarter and an outstanding year, powered by the investments we've made in digital, mainly those tied to the New York airports, though strength was evident throughout the portfolio. Premium inventory is what advertisers want, and that plays to the advantage of our airports business given the strength in travel and transportation, telco and banking, along with other categories. And the Europe-North team keeps producing, with revenue up across our products in the majority of countries where we do business, helped in part by greater demand, the rollout of more digital displays, and robust programmatic growth; we stay committed to executing our strategic road map, which is designed to boost our business's profitability, with a focus on our higher-margin U.S. markets and a transformation into a technology-fueled visual media powerhouse that reaches an expanding audience. Providing a digital media experience stays at the core of how we invest, both when it comes to growing our footprint in the U.S. and when it comes to bolstering our capacity to serve a wider array of advertisers and generate revenue growth. We're making headway and providing the sort of experience advertisers look for from digital media, paired with the mass reach and creative impact that out-of-home offers. On top of that, our investments in data and analytics and in programmatic let us connect with advertisers that historically haven't put money into out-of-home. We're also trying out AI capabilities to create ads, which lifts productivity and lets us assist more customers in envisioning their brands on out-of-home than traditional tools would allow. We think that over time, this may turn out to be something that drives growth. Taking a closer look at how we're pursuing growth in America, the national sales group keeps pushing into new verticals and refining the way we sell directly to clients, and early wins are showing up in both pharma and CPG. Last year, revenue from our pharma vertical was twice what it had been, and it played a big part in the growth of America revenue in 2023, largely because we concentrated on building the insight and campaign measurement capabilities that pharma needs; that stands as a great illustration of what applied data can do for out-of-home. A further strong illustration is the headway we're making with programmatic, which delivered a record fourth quarter and has fueled the success we've seen lately in the CPG vertical. Making inroads into CPG would not have been possible — that category historically hasn't been a major out-of-home user in the U.S. and likes data alongside its impressions — had we not put money into our programmatic infrastructure. Meaningful revenue has also begun coming in via our new U.S. website, and over time we see solid growth potential in these added revenue streams; we're likewise intent on getting our sales teams fully staffed, since our staffing levels have stubbornly trailed the recovery in our business after COVID. Our onboarding capability has improved considerably, and so has our training, matching the broader set of solutions we now provide. When it comes to M&A, the sales process for our Europe-North segment businesses is moving ahead. Plus we've kicked off the process to divest our Latin America businesses, while also assessing related ways to make our cost structure as efficient as possible. What we're aiming for is a leaner organization centered on our U.S. markets, with operating leverage in the business made even stronger and cash flow improved; our teams who are in the middle of these processes deserve a shout out for keeping up their strong performance even with the distraction. Now to our forecast. Consolidated revenue for the full year should land somewhere between $2.2 billion and $2.26 billion, which works out to a mid-single-digit gain versus last year, leaving out foreign exchange rate movements. Brian will walk through our guidance in detail shortly. We're off to a good start in the first quarter, and the business is growing. Within the Americas segment, conditions look better across most of our markets, among them our biggest markets in California, where the San Francisco Bay Area is showing signs of improvement. Business Services, our largest vertical, is still strong, and so are Amusements and Retail. Also welcome is the fact that the strikes have ended, which is helping the entertainment vertical in California and elsewhere. Airports keeps producing excellent results, and that business stays strong thanks to the premium character of our inventory. Europe-North has likewise started well, with the U.K. and Sweden — our biggest Europe-North markets — continuing to be strong, which offsets the effect of contract losses, one of them a contract in Norway. We're pleased by the momentum we're observing and the chances we're chasing to generate growth in the coming year. Now, prior to handing the call to Brian for the financial review, I want to express gratitude to him for his numerous years of dedication to Clear Channel. Through the frequently challenging work of handling the capital structure that came to us when we separated from iHeartMedia, he played a key role in setting our financial direction. He has likewise added to our strategic plan and guided our finance team through numerous deals, refinancing initiatives and similar matters. I'm eager to keep collaborating with him as a consultant, together with our Board, management team and financial advisers, as we fulfill the next phase of our plan. David Sailer, who takes over from Brian as Clear Channel's CFO on March 1, is a demonstrated leader who has supervised the financial strategy and operations of our America and Airport segments. He has additionally been essential to our work to streamline our portfolio through the duties he's held as Head of Corporate Development. I think this background will prove vital for us as we turn into a more focused U.S.-centric company. So, let me pass the call to Brian.

Brian Coleman

executive
#3

I want to thank you, Scott, and wish everyone a good morning—I'm grateful that you've joined this call. This may be the last time I speak with you in this role, but I genuinely feel we're entering this change with a great deal of forward momentum, and you'll hear about that in a moment as we walk through how the company has performed and what we expect ahead. Let's look at Slide 5. As a reminder, Europe-South now sits within discontinued operations. And as I walk through GAAP figures, I'll also discuss our results excluding movements in foreign exchange rates, which is a non-GAAP measure. From our standpoint, that provides improved comparability when evaluating our performance. Direct operating expenses along with SG&A expenses contain restructuring and other costs that are left out of adjusted EBITDA and segment adjusted EBITDA; and the numbers I cite cover Q4 of 2023, while percentage changes reflect Q4 2023 against Q4 of 2022, unless I note otherwise. Let's now dig into the reported fourth-quarter results. Consolidated revenue for the quarter totaled $632 million, up 12.4%. Excluding movements in foreign exchange rates, consolidated revenue for the quarter climbed 10.8% to $623 million, which included a 5.8% contribution from our digital operations. Income from continuing operations was $25 million, down from the previous year's income from continuing operations of $106 million. Consolidated net income of $26 million includes income from discontinued operations. Adjusted EBITDA came to $190 million, a gain of 9.2%. Excluding movements in foreign exchange rates, adjusted EBITDA was up 8.1%. AFFO totaled $73 million in the fourth quarter, a 30.2% gain. Excluding movements in foreign exchange rates, AFFO increased 27.3%; let's now turn to Slide 6 for the Americas segment's fourth-quarter results. America revenue was $299 million, up 0.5%, driven by digital deployments and programmatic growth. The Business Services and Pharma verticals recorded gains in the quarter, while auto and media and entertainment fell. Growth occurred in the majority of our markets, and the South Central and Southeast regions delivered the strongest performance. Northern California has improved relative to earlier in the year, despite still being down for the quarter. Digital revenue, which made up 38.2% of America revenue, grew 2.4% to $114 million. National sales, accounting for 37.1% of America revenue, increased 0.3%. Local sales represented 62.9% of America revenue, up 0.6%. Direct operating and SG&A expenses edged higher to $163 million. Site lease expense grew 2.1% to $90 million, due to fewer rent abatements. That was offset by lower property taxes related to a legal settlement, along with maintenance costs and credit loss expense. Segment adjusted EBITDA was $136 million, up 0.6%, with a segment adjusted EBITDA margin of 45.6%. Kindly turn to Slide 7 for a review of the fourth-quarter results for Airports. Airports revenue was $111 million, up 44.3%. Revenue increased across most airports and verticals, another very strong quarter, with the revenue gain driven by higher demand and ongoing investment in digital infrastructure. Within this segment, banking and financial services, plus travel and transportation, ranked among the strongest verticals. Digital revenue on its side totaled $73 million, up 57.9%, accounting for 65.7% of Airports revenue. National sales increased 42.4%, making up 58.9% of Airport revenue. Local sales accounted for 41.1% of Airports revenue and were up 46.9%. Direct operating and SG&A expenses grew 44.8% to $81 million. That increase is primarily attributable to a 46.4% jump in site lease expense, which reached $65 million, driven by higher revenue as well as increased variable incentive compensation costs. Segment adjusted EBITDA came in at $30 million, up 42.7%, and the segment adjusted EBITDA margin was 27.1%. Now, if we turn to Slide 8, let's examine our performance in Europe-North. My comments regarding Europe-North relate to results adjusted to exclude foreign exchange rate movements. Europe-North revenue was up 13.4% to $185 million, reflecting stronger revenue across all products and countries, particularly the U.K. and Belgium, driven by growing demand, the deployment of additional digital displays, and new contracts. Digital accounted for 57% of Europe-North total revenue and increased 17.9% to $105 million. Europe North's direct operating and SG&A expenses were up 14.5% to $135 million, resulting from a 12% increase in site lease expense to $62 million, driven by higher revenue along with increased property taxes and compensation costs. Europe-North segment adjusted EBITDA increased 13.1% to $50 million, and the segment adjusted EBITDA margin was 27.3%. Let's proceed to CCIBV on Slide 9. Clear Channel International B.V., or CCIBV, is an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of the company and the issuer of our 6.625% senior secured notes due 2025; it encompasses the operations of our Europe-North and Europe-South segments, plus Singapore, which is included under Other. Singapore's financial results are immaterial to CCIBV's results. Additionally, the revenue and scale of the company's business in Singapore will contract further in 2024 as a result of the loss of a contract that ended on December 31, 2023. Because the businesses in the Europe-South segment are treated as discontinued operations, their results are now reported as a separate component of consolidated net income and the CCIBV consolidated statement of income for all periods presented, and they are excluded from the discussion below. CCIBV results from continuing operations for the fourth quarter of 2023 versus the same period of 2022 are as follows. CCIBV revenue increased 17% to $198 million, up from $169 million. After excluding the $7 million impact of foreign exchange movements, CCIBV revenue grew 12.6%, driven by higher revenue in our Europe-North segment, as I mentioned earlier. Singapore represented approximately 3% of CCIBV revenue from continuing operations for the 3 months ended December 31, 2023. CCIBV operating income was $31 million, compared with $22 million in the same period of 2022. Now let's go to Slide 10 for a review of capital expenditures. In Q4, CapEx was $48 million, which is $4 million lower than a year ago, driven by timing as well as a decrease in spending; let's turn now to Slide 11. Our liquidity as of December 31, 2023 was $486 million. Compared with the end of Q3, that represents a decline of $45 million. This decrease resulted from lower cash, partially offset by greater availability under the credit facilities. During Q4, cash and cash equivalents declined $62 million, finishing at $252 million. A number of factors caused this: interest payments, capital expenditures, cash sent to the buyer related to the divestiture of our France business, and changes in working capital. As of December 31, 2023, our debt totaled $5.6 billion, basically flat versus September 30, 2023. In Q4, cash interest paid on debt was $121 million. Compared with the prior-year period, that's a decline of $3 million, largely due to variations in the timing of interest payments, partly offset by increased interest rates. Our weighted average cost of debt was 7.5%. And our first lien leverage ratio as of December 31, 2023 was 5.54x. The covenant threshold in the credit agreement is 7.1x. Let's now go to Slide 12 and discuss our guidance for Q1 and the full year 2024.

Brian Coleman

executive
#4

When it comes to all our consolidated guidance and the guidance for Europe-North, changes in foreign exchange rates are left out, except for capital expenditures and cash interest payments. For Q1, our expectation is consolidated revenue ranging from $465 million to $490 million, which would mark a 6% to 12% rise compared with the first quarter of 2023. America revenue, we believe, will land between $245 million and $255 million, while Airports revenue should come in somewhere between $74 million and $79 million. For Europe North, revenue is projected to fall between $130 million and $140 million. Now turning to what we expect for the full year: consolidated revenue should be somewhere between $2.2 billion and $2.26 billion, a gain of 3% to 6% versus 2023. America revenue is anticipated to range from $1.135 billion to $1.165 billion. Airports revenue should be in the $345 million to $360 million range. Europe-North revenue is projected to land between $635 million and $655 million. Looking at things on a consolidated basis, adjusted EBITDA should come in between $550 million and $585 million. For AFFO, our guidance is $75 million to $100 million. We're looking at capital spending landing between $130 million and $150 million, since we're staying committed to investing in our U.S. digital operations, along with keeping corporate CapEx lower. Beyond that, we've got cash interest payment obligations coming of $448 million for 2024 and $408 million for 2025. The main driver behind the higher cash interest payments expected in 2024 is the timing gap in interest payments related to the CCOH 9% senior secured notes that were issued not long ago, plus the refinanced portion of the term loan. During the first quarter, we expect $100 million in cash interest expense to be paid. This guidance is built on the assumption that we won't refinance or take on any additional debt. Before I return the call to Scott for his closing remarks, I want to thank him for the kind words, camaraderie, and support he has shown me over the years. I also want to express my appreciation to the entire Clear Channel team for their hard work and dedication in pursuing our vision. We have made substantial progress toward our objectives, and I believe we will continue to deliver in the year ahead and beyond. I would also like to congratulate Dave on assuming the CFO position. I have worked with Dave for about 10 years, more closely since the separation from iHeartMedia. I am confident he will excel in this broader position with the organization. The handover has gone seamlessly, and I'm eager to keep collaborating with Scott and Dave, plus our Board and advisors, in a consulting capacity as we stay focused on advancing our plan. With that said, I'll hand things back over to Scott.

Scott Wells

executive
#5

Appreciate that, Brian. As we look forward, our attention stays on generating profitable growth, reinforcing the balance sheet, and showing even more of the operating leverage this business offers. All of that ties back to our top priority, which is bringing leverage down across the coming few years. Our guidance makes clear that after a disappointing 2023, we anticipate growth in America. A rebound across certain important markets, along with putting our particular growth initiatives into action, ought to deliver that pickup. Our commitment is to leave Europe and Latin America at valuations that match the caliber of those assets, while we simplify operations and zero in on our U.S.-based assets, which carry higher margins. The efforts already undertaken to boost our financial results in Europe-North leave us operating from a strong position. Since both of these processes are quite active right now, we'll share updates whenever we're in a position to do so. I want to say how thankful I am for everything our team across the company is doing. Operationally and financially, we're advancing well as we keep up our disciplined chase of cash flow growth. With that, I'll hand the call to the operator, and Justin Cochrane along with Dave Sailer will be joining us on this call.

Brian Coleman

executive
#6

Kevin, thank you. Earlier today, we put out a press release about a refinancing deal through which the company plans to issue new senior secured notes in order to pay down part of the company's Term Loan B facility and to push out the maturity on what remains of that facility. Please be aware that we are not able to say anything more about these transactions right now. Also, although the company still intends to present at JPMorgan's 2024 Global High Yield and Leveraged Finance Conference on February 27, 2024, the company will no longer make a webcast or a replay of its presentation available on its investor website. I'll now hand the call back to the operator for Q&A. Thank you.

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#7

I only had two things. I was wondering, if you land at the middle of the Americas revenue guidance, ought we to observe operating leverage coming through and margin expansion showing up?

Brian Coleman

executive
#8

Yeah. As revenue growth keeps coming, my view is that you should anticipate margin expansion in the business. Dave, I'm not sure whether you've got anything else to add, but that's roughly what we are seeing and what we're projecting.

Dave Sailer

executive
#9

I believe that's right. What I mean is, if you consider the margins in our Americas business, once revenue rises, the flow-through will be somewhat greater, since the final dollar brought in is clearly more beneficial than the initial one, so you'll notice a modest gain in margin there.

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#10

Great. Moving on to my second point, airports have really been turning in outstanding results lately. Could you walk us through what's fueling that growth, plus how big a role broader ridership patterns play when it comes to digital conversions, and then the shift in budget share as well?

Scott Wells

executive
#11

Yes, Cameron. That one's mine. I think with airports, several factors are at play. Obviously, we won the New York, New Jersey Port Authority contract during COVID. We were in negotiations on that in the early part of 2020. Operations began in 2021. And we've finished build-outs that we're now lapping — across a number of the airports, we're in the process of lapping them. The most notable one, Terminal A, went live at the start of 2023, out of <<inaudible>> Newark, went live at the start of 2023. So the first lap of that significant new inventory would have been Q4. So I'd point to that contract effect. As for growth across our overall portfolio, we're lapping the kind of remarkable growth that came from the New York build-outs. But the overall portfolio has also delivered very strong performance. That clearly ties to strong air travel. And I think it also ties to the market's movement toward really high-quality, really well-defined audience delivery. We've witnessed that in the America business at the super premium end of that spectrum. So many factors feed into it. One last thing I'd highlight, I guess: it isn't only the large advertisers — the local teams have been performing really well. And the local teams, working together with our roadside local teams, cracked the code on cross-selling between those businesses a couple of years ago, and that has only sped up. And we're beginning to do some fairly innovative things, thinking about almost a sponsorship type of model in different geographies, especially where we have roadside and airport inventory that's pretty interesting. So in terms of how we're selling as well, we're doing some fairly innovative things. All of those, I think, are the factors.

Steven Cahall

analyst
#12

Scott, perhaps I could build on what Cameron asked initially and make it a bit more specific. In the Americas during '23, I believe you saw site lease expenses rise in a somewhat unusual manner. I'm simply attempting to determine whether anything else in the Americas is similarly nonrecurring in 2024. You've generally described this business as roughly 50% — fixed costs, if I recall correctly. So when we consider revenue growth for the Americas in 2024, is there a solid approach for thinking through fixed costs compared with variable costs? And additionally, I believe you mentioned cost reductions, or cost optimization, that you're evaluating in the press release. Might you give us a bit more detail on where those could appear? Would that be within Airports or within the Americas? Is this a matter of proactively removing certain corporate costs as you progress toward the divestitures? And last, is there a solid approach for thinking about EBITDA ranges for either Europe-North or LatAm, given that those now serve as valuation basis and divestiture scenarios?

Scott Wells

executive
#13

All right, Steve. I'll attempt to address each one, though I'm certain you retained the list in case we overlook any of them; regarding the one-offs, I genuinely believe we're at last reaching a point where America will be a fairly clean year. That slight increase has now been lapped. I'll let Dave address our position relative to onetime abatements, though those have mostly washed out; where 2023 is concerned, a few items might still be lingering, yet nothing of that magnitude. Dave, would you like to discuss operating leverage briefly?

Dave Sailer

executive
#14

Yeah, definitely. If you look at the Americas, take that big contract we mentioned — it's already cycled through. So moving into 2024, sure, there might be some minor items here or there, but nothing in my view is really going to shift your underlying structure when it comes to site leases and abatements. On the Airports side, it's somewhat different — those are still coming in gradually. So for Airports, margins are going to be a bit higher; they were elevated in 2023, and they likely will be again in 2024. After that, my expectation is that they'll phase out over the course of 2024, and once that happens, that stretch will be finished as far as site leases go for Airports when it comes to abatements.

Scott Wells

executive
#15

Then the next thing raised concerned trimming expenses, and I genuinely believe that the biggest savings you're going to observe from us will come during the coming 12 or 18 months, likely leaning more toward the back half of that stretch, since undoing things takes time. Still, it will tie back to company-level costs connected to the divestitures we've been describing, and as we've said previously, at least $30 million in savings. Nothing we've come across makes us doubt that's a reasonable ballpark to mention. Then regarding the outlook for Europe-North and LatAm, given all that's currently in motion, I don't believe we're in a position to provide those figures right now. Yet if you consider how large those operations were — I mean, you have a solid new 12 months in the K, and you'd assume their growth is — Europe will actually pull back somewhat, in my view, compared with what we witnessed in 2023. For LatAm, the 2023 growth might be a bit nearer to what we're seeing. Those aren't the sort of things — simply given how it goes when you shift things into disc ops and all of that, the guidance gets incredibly messy once you begin drilling into the subsegments. We simply felt that wasn't the right call. Eventually, before too long, it'll be a far easier business to discuss. So I'm not sure — Dave or Brian, whether either of you wants to add anything about Europe-North or LatAm.

Brian Coleman

executive
#16

No, no. I think that covers it.

Jonnathan Navarrete

analyst
#17

This is Jonnathan filling in for Lance. My first question concerns National sales and how it was made up in America and Airports — that came in stronger than 4Q of the prior year. So since there were certain worries about National across '23, did National improve near the close of 4Q or closer to the start, and does that pattern persist in '24 up to now?

Scott Wells

executive
#18

Thank you, Jonnathan. Sure — if you've heard several of our calls, you're aware that I tend to get a bit prickly about National, since what it actually tracks is the channel through which the big advertisers come more than anything genuinely National in the sense that syndicated radio or television operates. Still, within that large advertiser category, we certainly did observe some gains around the start of Q4; and it lined up with the advertisers making use of the programmatic tool set. It was among the big advertisers employing the programmatic tool set that we first noticed it. And we've watched that carry on into the current year. Yet it isn't really — National is somewhat a weak label for it; it truly isn't — I believe one of our partners sums up National as Airports plus New York and L.A., and that doesn't genuinely capture National the way other segments, I think, conceive of it. Even so, what we refer to as National is doing better than before and appears to be on a solid trend line.

Jonnathan Navarrete

analyst
#19

Understood. Along those lines, should we also anticipate the usual quarterly seasonality stacking one on top of another? Or could there be — perhaps some sort of catch-up related to National that happens at some point in Q1 and Q2, which might disrupt that normal seasonal pattern?

Scott Wells

executive
#20

Yeah. I can't say with 100% certainty how to frame this catch-up notion, since our figures come from hundreds of campaigns, and I doubt many marketers start their day thinking, alright, I need to make up ground with the out-of-home folks. What you should probably keep in mind is that last year was extremely uneven. January and February were really difficult for us. March and April improved. May and June were somewhat weaker. Q3 stayed fairly rough the whole way through; then once September arrived, things began improving; and Q4 turned out to be quite a solid quarter. So when you consider how the business — last year was simply very uneven, and my hope is we avoid a repeat, particularly that kind of, hey, we're going to disappear from June through Labor Day pattern that so many of those big advertisers adopted. But it isn't up to me to state exactly what they'll do. As for our guidance, we don't truly construct it advertiser by advertiser. We build it far more by examining the market, examining where inventory stands, examining what we observe locally and nationally, what's going on with our principal client investment when it comes to key accounts. A great many factors feed into it. We don't simply build it from a national court forecast or a local forecast. I don't know, Dave, whether there's additional detail you'd like to add regarding how we arrive at that guidance.

Dave Sailer

executive
#21

Right. And I don’t — I believe you hit on the majority of it, but the additional topic I mentioned is simply the geographic angle. If you recall where we stood a year ago and how Scott described the way the year unfolded, some regions, clearly, came in softer while others came in firmer. So when we move into this year, all of that factors into how we build our guidance regarding which regions we expect somewhat greater momentum, especially as we enter the early portion of 2024. So I suppose that — my view isn’t that this is some kind of rebound; it’s more a question of where things strengthen across particular regions, and even particular verticals too.

Jonnathan Navarrete

analyst
#22

Understood; for my final question, I want to ask about that litigation payment. According to the 10-K, a payment of $13 million occurred in October, and the remaining amount should be paid at some point—or, as I understand it, through several installments across '24. So can we anticipate, say, equal amounts in each of the 4 quarters? Or might one quarter carry a larger portion of that $13 million?

Scott Wells

executive
#23

The only thing we've stated, I believe, is that those payments are going to be completed prior to the conclusion of 2024; and my sense is that we likely haven't provided further detail on that.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#24

Brian, I'm definitely going to miss hitting you with questions during these calls and at our conferences, even if you won't miss that nearly as much.

Brian Coleman

executive
#25

Appreciate it, Aaron.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#26

So I have a few things I'd like to ask. Yeah, absolutely. There are a few items I want to bring up. I suppose, to start, I just want to get some clarity on what you said regarding margins. With all the variables you mentioned. Should we expect — is it going to be a fairly steady progression across this year as we move toward that 25%, 26% level that your guidance suggests? Or are those elements, or the volatility from last year, going to create some quarter-to-quarter fluctuation?

Dave Sailer

executive
#27

Yeah, certainly, on a quarterly basis, our margins are going to vary from one quarter to another, likely somewhat lower in the earlier part of the year and then they strengthen as the year progresses, simply because the second half brings in more revenue, and that pushes your margins up. But I believe that 25% figure you mentioned probably is reasonable. Of course, it plays out differently among our segments across America, Airports and Europe; but on the whole, I'd say that's accurate. I mean you're going to see a bit, as I said earlier during this call, you'll still be receiving relief in the airport segment, so that will be somewhat higher in '24, and I expect that will taper off once you move beyond 2024 from that release cycle.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#28

Aaron, thanks for that. On the administrative front, apologies in case I overlooked this, but what's the right way to frame cash taxes for the current year?

Brian Coleman

executive
#29

Much the same as prior periods, I'd say — cash taxes stay pretty small, driven mainly by foreign and regional sales plus local taxes here in the U.S. There's an election we take advantage of that keeps our federal income tax obligations to a minimum, and that's what we'd anticipate. With all of that said, Aaron, potential asset sales aren't part of this picture. We've stated our belief that sales in European North wouldn't draw any material cash taxes. That naturally depends on how those sales get carried out. As things stand today, though, no meaningful shift in our cash tax payments or the range is something I'd foresee.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#30

Okay, that's excellent. And for my last question — thanks for making the time. You recently shared some updates regarding your Board. I'm curious if that signals any change in the way the company runs from one day to the next, or perhaps in the strategic path ahead for Clear Channel, past the Americas-focused approach you've been emphasizing.

Scott Wells

executive
#31

Thanks, Aaron. I wouldn't say that — I mean, listen, our Board is — it's a Board that presents real challenges. Having a solid variety of viewpoints around the table is extremely important. That, I think, is the right way to interpret the moves we've made. Given our capital structure and the position we occupy within the media landscape, this business demands that you balance quick thinking with a longer view. You must combine a strategic long-range vision with significant flexibility, which allows us to pursue initiatives such as the refinancing currently in progress. Hopefully luck stays on our side as that effort unfolds. Consequently, having new viewpoints on the Board matters greatly, as does having individuals who grasp the environment in which we function. That essentially captures everything we are aiming for with the Board.

Richard Choe

analyst
#32

I wanted to circle back regarding how strong the Americas were in Q1. What portion of that comes from digital programmatic patterns, and what portion is perhaps simply the recovery you mentioned when it comes to areas such as Northern California and L.A.?

Scott Wells

executive
#33

Thank you, Richard. All the individual components are fairly interconnected. When you consider the opening quarter we had a year ago, the difficulty really wasn't as much in America as it was in Airports, especially during the early stretch of that quarter. Still, no segment of the business began last year well. So getting off to a robust start is extremely, extremely beneficial. Programmatic certainly is performing well. Yet interestingly enough, during last year's first quarter, programmatic also did quite well. Therefore that alone isn't the explanation. I genuinely believe some of the development efforts we've put into certain emerging verticals matter — we have a couple of sizable new clients acquired directly who are launching in Q1. So multiple elements are feeding into this. And honestly, moving beyond the point where we initially noticed problems in Northern California during the latter portion of 2022, which truly showed up at the start of 2023 — we're now lapping that. And our figures aren't big enough that this wouldn't influence them. So I'd say it's a mix of all these things. I wish there were one easy answer, and I'd just do far more of that easy answer. Instead, it's several factors combined.

Richard Choe

analyst
#34

You brought up pharma as a solid source of expansion. Does that lean mostly toward Americas, or Airports? Or is it beneficial for each?

Scott Wells

executive
#35

At present, the bulk of that momentum sits in America. My view is it might carry over to airports. Yet the key opportunity in pharma for us involves medications with extremely wide usage. That suits the roadside locations even better than airports, since airports serve a more divided set of customers; therefore, I'd say it clearly tilts toward the roadside operation.

Jim Goss

analyst
#36

I have a few questions regarding Airports to start. The recovery in air travel appeared to be progressing quite nicely, yet it looked like it was driven more by leisure than by corporate trips. So I'm curious whether that mix shift favoring personal over business travel remains the case. Also, does that have an effect on demographics, and possibly on pricing, plus the approach behind the advertising you'd run?

Scott Wells

executive
#37

Thank you, Jim. That's a solid question, and several factors feed into it. To begin with, my view is that the recovery continues to lean more toward personal travel than business, though you've started to notice international travel, and that includes international travel in Asia, beginning to pick up, which frequently — well, I believe one of the major trends, and I've definitely come across quite a few articles discussing it, involves folks combining work trips with leisure trips, taking family along during a longer commercial journey and then adding a vacation onto it. I think certain of those dynamics are at work. Still, we've clearly observed business travel making a comeback. It likely hasn't fully returned to its pre-pandemic level. Yet I'm uncertain how effectively we've ever truly — how reliable the measurements surrounding that really are. Regarding what that means, when it comes to the buy, a great deal hinges on the customer — on the client, the one you're referring to, the advertiser in question, since we have B2B-focused advertisers who aim at specific airports, specific terminals inside airports, or they might pursue the private jet FBOs. And we also have B2C offerings. As for the B2B side, frequently, they sort of enjoy the double benefit because they could be heavily concentrated on paying for that business traveler, who represents a subset, since many individuals traveling for personal reasons are likewise business decision-makers. Consequently, you capture both. Thus it isn't a straightforward pricing conversation. Typically it relates heavily to the scale you're pursuing, the number of airports you're pursuing, how deeply inside those airports you wish to reach. Numerous factors contribute beyond merely passenger counts and merely the personal versus business mix. Nevertheless, those trends are certainly assisting in supporting the outstanding performance we're witnessing in Airports. I trust that addresses your question, at least somewhat.

Jim Goss

analyst
#38

Yes. That's great. It helps to have some of that perspective included. I also wanted to ask whether there might be any airports coming up for bid that could be available and that you'd find appealing. And then, perhaps somewhat connected to that, do the lengths of the contracts have a bearing on how you approach CapEx decisions and strategies in those places?

Scott Wells

executive
#39

Yes. Dave, would you like to handle the CapEx — well, you could address the bid as well, since you have visibility into it.

Dave Sailer

executive
#40

Right, no. What I mean is, in the case of a contract with a longer term, absolutely, that's going to be included, simply because it provides an extended window to generate revenue from those assets, so — and that's true if you're signing a deal for 10 years. It also hinges on how big the airport is and what inventory is available; yet typically, you'll likely invest somewhat more in CapEx when the deal runs longer than you would, say, over 5 years. Regarding agreements that are nearing expiration, I mean, if you consider airports throughout the U.S., I mean, there are facilities reaching that point constantly. So we go after them actively — we'll examine every single airport. Is it logical for it to become part of our portfolio? Do we believe it aligns with the strategy we're pursuing in our Airports division? And we will certainly take a look at them; and those that are logical, we're clearly going to proceed. And some airports we sense don't quite match our portfolio, and we'd skip them; but we're always assessing them whenever they arise.

Scott Wells

executive
#41

However, when we look ahead at the coming 12 months, we don't see anything significant on the renewal front. One thing that's interesting — and it isn't something we discuss much — is that while our airport results keep improving, the number of airports we operate has actually shrunk. That's because our attention has gone toward locations with a stronger network effect, locations where we can also generate roadside sales, and similar considerations. So over the past several years, we've been reshaping our airport footprint, genuinely working to direct that capital toward the spots where we believe the return outlook is strongest.

Jim Goss

analyst
#42

All right. Perhaps one last item. You singled out San Francisco specifically as one of those markets — not really for airports, but broadly speaking — that's been dealing with certain difficulties. I'm curious whether, when you consider that market along with several others across the nation that have been struggling, there's room for a recovery there. Could that kind of rebound help raise some of your domestic billboard revenue as well as your growth rates?

Scott Wells

executive
#43

Yeah, Jim, that is — it's a solid question. When you think it through — I don't believe you'll get some kind of post-COVID snapback type of situation that makes our figures simply explode upward. If that did occur, I think it would stem from wins we're achieving in certain verticals we're pursuing, or from advertisers changing how they behave, which is possible and does occur. My sense is it isn't really driven purely by a regional bounce back. Still, I do believe that much as during 2023, certain regional difficulties acted as headwinds for us, those same things could quite easily turn into tailwinds for us should the commercial climate in those markets improve, and should some of the fundamental problems be resolved, which I genuinely believe is happening, especially in Northern California. You're witnessing, I think, a degree of political will being applied along with certain actions aimed at pushing change in some of the dynamics that have held those markets back. And as someone who has been bullish on California for a long time, I wouldn't wager against our friends turning those markets around; so — yet I don't think it will make us all at once double our guides or anything of that sort. That's simply not — it's one piece of a far larger portfolio.

Jim Goss

analyst
#44

Understood. And Brian, I hope things go smoothly for you as you move on. You've dealt with quite a bit across these 20 years. So congrats on what you've achieved.

Brian Coleman

executive
#45

Thanks, Jim. I appreciate that.

Scott Wells

executive
#46

Thanks, Kevin. I appreciate that. Regarding what Jim just mentioned, the one thing I'd highlight is this: we're a business that faces issues with our balance sheet, and we face issues when site lease costs rise or similar situations arise occasionally. But we're a business that's driven to excel and that does things the right way. And I see this shift from Brian to David as simply an excellent leading indicator for all of us of our capacity to handle several complicated matters simultaneously. These 2 individuals have performed an absolutely remarkable job of working together and making the team's transition go extremely, extremely smoothly. And I want to draw our investors' attention to that, because it matters that our financial operations are seamless. We couldn't be going to market the way we are at this moment if we had a rough, chaotic transition underway. The fact that we managed this without disruption and are still in the marketplace and still operating speaks to the culture and the behavior of the company. So I simply felt it was worth pointing that out. And I thank all of you for your interest, and I look forward to updating you once we have additional information as 2024 unfolds.

Operator

operator
#47

Thanks. That wraps up the teleconference and webcast for today. At this point you're free to drop off the line, and we hope your day goes wonderfully. We appreciate you joining us today.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.