Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 9, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Communication Services Media earnings 61 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Executive

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. Joining this call are our CEO, Scott Wells, and our CFO, David Sailer. They're going to walk through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. and Clear Channel International B.V. performed operationally during the first quarter of 2024. We suggest pulling up the earnings presentation, which you can find under the financial section of our investor website, and following along as we go. Once we've covered the introduction and gone over our results, we'll take your questions, and Justin Cochrane, who serves as CEO of Clear Channel UK and Europe, will be on hand with Scott and Dave for that Q&A segment. Before we get started, I want to remind all of you that forward-looking statements about the company may be made during this call, including ones concerning future financial performance and strategic goals. Every forward-looking statement carries risks and uncertainties, and we can't guarantee that management's expectations, beliefs, or projections will come to pass, or that actual results won't deviate from what's expected. I'd ask you to look over the risk statements included in our earnings press release and in our filings with the SEC. We'll also be referencing some measures today that don't conform to generally accepted accounting principles. As part of the earnings presentation, we offer schedules that reconcile these non-GAAP measures against our reported results on a GAAP basis. Also, keep in mind that what's shared on this call reflects only management's views as of today, May 9th, 2024, and might not still hold true when a replay is heard. Please go to slide four in the earnings presentation, and I'll hand things over now to Scott.

Scott Wells

executive
#2

Hello, everyone, and thanks for spending part of your day with us. Leaving aside fluctuations in foreign exchange rates, our consolidated revenue for Q1 came in at $478 million, which represents a 9.3% gain over the same period a year earlier. A lot of the patterns observed during Q4 carried over into Q1. These results, consistent with the guidance we provided, mark a record first quarter for America, Airports, and Europe North, once you exclude sold markets and foreign exchange movements. Our attention stays fixed on executing the strategic plan, whose goals are boosting the profitability of our operations, prioritizing our higher margin US assets, and weaving the appropriate technology into our platform so we can better serve a wider array of advertisers. Within our America segment in Q1, digital kept expanding while print recovered strongly, propelled largely by gains in our local sales channel — secondary locations included — and that aided margins. Results were broad-based throughout most of our markets. Among verticals, the strongest growth came from business services, amusements, and media entertainment. Even with inbound demand sending mixed signals, we keep finding ways to proactively draw new national brands into the sector. Our national sales team keeps producing incremental revenue in pharma as well as CPG, and programmatic is doing extremely well, posting a double-digit rise in Q1, with exceptionally robust growth during the current quarter. To back these efforts, we keep strengthening our sales teams, among other things recruiting sales professionals straight from the key verticals we're going after. Our view is that this will pay off and generate incremental revenue. On the whole, we think we're playing offense effectively as we chase business through multiple channels. Take our RADAR data solutions, for instance: they keep delivering innovation to the out-of-home marketplace, creating opportunities with new advertisers and verticals by giving customers insights they previously could not get regarding how their out-of-home campaigns are performing. We're testing a new method in which customers begin receiving weekly updates about campaign performance, starting with how Clear Channel's media is generating visits to restaurants and stores that advertise in our markets. Delivering campaign performance data on a regular basis is an essential step toward matching the experience advertisers anticipate from digital media; we also keep innovating when it comes to out-of-home's effect on mobile app behaviors and how our media produces measurable performance. As an illustration, during Q1 we finished a study for a mobile audio entertainment platform showing that consumers who saw one brand's ads in our Airports had a greater likelihood of trying the app and engaged more deeply with the app's content. That's encouraging progress, and it underscores how important it is to harness data as a means of collaborating with more digital marketers and unlocking incremental budgets. Now, on Airports: that segment is still performing well for us, powered by ongoing momentum in a number of verticals. We're making the most of how premium our inventory is, using it to power campaigns for big brands that want to reach millions of travelers. We keep putting money into digital screens throughout our Airports, and that includes the ones in New York and New Jersey. Not long ago we brought in a combination of dynamic digital platforms that are extremely prominent, and these give us more premium inventory to sell in those important, high-traffic markets, which lets us capitalize even more on solid demand. Europe North keeps posting excellent results too, and the second quarter looks set to carry forward the powerful momentum from both the first quarter and last year, with the biggest markets — the UK, Sweden, and Belgium — still growing. Advertiser commitments tied to the European Football Championship have given second-quarter momentum a lift. What's especially notable is how strong the business has stayed while M&A work continues. Switching to the balance sheet: back in March, we told the market about refinancing our term loan along with the CCI BV notes, which pushed out our 2025 and 2026 maturities and gave us flexibility to support the M&A process in Europe. Dave will walk everyone through the specifics, though I want to say congratulations to the team for getting these transactions done at rates we view as favorable during a choppy market. On guidance, Dave will also give more detail afterward, but I should point out that we are reaffirming our full-year revenue guidance, which should rise mid-single digits compared with last year, leaving out foreign exchange rate movements. All in all, we feel good about how we performed. Beyond gains from the economy's overall expansion, we're noticing favorable effects at several levels from what we've invested in digital, in our sales teams, in our new website, and naturally in Programmatic and data analytics. Every one of these efforts is a good sign for our longer-term growth profile. When it comes to M&A, negotiations are underway to sell our Europe North segment, and we're still talking with prospective counterparties in LATAM. We'll bring the market up to date whenever we're in a position to do so. With that, I'll pass the call to Dave. As many of you probably know, Dave became CFO on March 1st. His transition has been smooth, and I'm eager for a strong partnership with him as we keep moving ahead with our strategic plan.

David Sailer

executive
#3

Thank you, Scott. Good morning to all of you. The backing I've received from every team as I moved into this new position has meant a lot to me. Turn to slide five, please, where you'll find a summary of our results. Just to remind you, Europe South sits within discontinued operations. Also, when we go through GAAP results, I'll cover our performance excluding changes in foreign exchange rates as well — that's a non-GAAP metric, and in our view it gives you better comparability for assessing how we're doing. Restructuring and other costs are part of direct operating expenses and SG&A expenses, and those get excluded from Adjusted EBITDA and segment-adjusted EBITDA. All the figures I mention are for Q1 2024, and unless I say otherwise, the percentage changes compare Q1 2024 with Q1 2023. So let's move to the reported results for the first quarter. Consolidated revenue came to $482 million for the quarter, which is a 10.1% rise. With foreign exchange rate movements excluded, consolidated revenue reached $478 million for the quarter, an increase of 9.3%. We had a loss from continuing operations of $89 million, which is better than what we saw a year earlier. Consolidated net loss, and that figure takes in the loss from discontinued operations, came to $89 million as well. Adjusted EBITDA reached $97 million, an increase of 53.6%. With foreign exchange rate movements excluded, adjusted EBITDA rose 53%. America and Airports are the main reasons for that gain. AFFO came in at -$16 million for the first quarter, which is a 62.6% improvement. With foreign exchange rate movements excluded, AFFO increased 61.6%. Let's go to slide six, covering the America segment's first quarter results. Revenue for America was $250 million, rising 5.8%, which shows revenue growth across every region. Billboard revenue went up, thanks to stronger demand and digital deployments, with gains in both print and digital bulletins. Digital revenue made up 33.7% of America revenue and rose 7.9% to $84 million. National sales represented 34.5% of America revenue and climbed 5.5%. Local sales made up 65.5% of America revenue and rose 6%. Direct operating and SG&A expenses held steady, coming in at $155 million in 2023. Compensation costs were higher, mostly because of more headcount and pay increases, but lower credit loss expense offset that. Site lease expense dipped a bit, which came from renegotiating a contract that was already in place. Segment-adjusted EBITDA was $95 million, an increase of 17.3%, and the segment-adjusted EBITDA margin was 38.2%, which is better than last year. The gain in segment-adjusted EBITDA margin came from the strong revenue performance along with the lower credit loss expense and a favorable revenue mix. Now look at slide seven for a rundown of first quarter results for Airports. Airports revenue was $77 million, an increase of 43%, with robust demand throughout the portfolio. Digital revenue made up 55.4% of Airports revenue and rose 44.1% to $43 million. National sales represented 55.2% of Airports revenue and climbed 25.5%. Local sales made up 44.8% of Airports revenue and jumped 72.8%. Direct operating and SG&A expenses rose 21.9% to $58 million. This rise mainly reflects a 21.4% jump in site lease expense, which reached $44 million, pushed up by greater revenue as well as an increase in compensation costs, mostly from higher sales commissions. Segment-adjusted EBITDA came in at $19 million, a gain of 204.6%, and the segment-adjusted EBITDA margin stood at 24.8%. That margin improvement stems largely from the quarter's revenue growth; let's turn to slide eight. To go through how we performed in Europe North, my remarks on Europe North concern results adjusted so that foreign exchange rate movements are excluded. Europe North revenue rose 5.9% to $136 million, on stronger revenue in the UK, Sweden, and Belgium, fueled by greater demand and digital deployments, though this was partly offset by losing a transit contract in Norway. Digital made up 52.4% of Europe North's total revenue and grew 9.1% to $71 million. Europe North direct operating and SG&A expenses dipped slightly to $121 million, thanks to a reduction in site lease expense, which fell 5.8% to $53 million, the result of that contract loss in Norway. Higher compensation costs partly offset this. Europe North segment-adjusted EBITDA climbed 92.5% to $14 million, while the segment-adjusted EBITDA margin reached 10.1%, better than the prior year. The first quarter is typically when segment-adjusted EBITDA is lowest, which makes margins more sensitive to swings in revenue and contract mix. Now to CCI B.V. on slide nine. Clear Channel International B.V., or CCI B.V., an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of the company and the borrower under the CCI B.V. term loan facility, covers the operations of our Europe North and Europe South segments, plus Singapore, which sits within Other. Singapore's financial results have historically been immaterial to CCI B.V.'s results, and this business's revenue and expenses shrank further in the first quarter of 2024 because of a contract loss. Since the current and former businesses in the Europe South segment count as discontinued operations, their results appear as a separate component of consolidated results in the CCI BV consolidated statement for every period presented and are left out of the discussion below. CCI BV results from continuing operations for the first quarter of 2024 versus the same period of 2023 are as follows. CCI BV revenue grew 3.8% to $140 million, up from $134 million. Apart from the $3 million effect of FX movements, CCI BV revenue rose 1.4%, since higher revenue from our Europe North segment, as I just noted, was partly offset by a contract loss in Singapore. CCI BV's operating loss was $7 million, against an operating loss of $18 million in the same period of 2023; now on to slide 10 and our review of capital expenditures. Capital expenditures came to $24 million during the first quarter, which was $9 million lower than a year earlier, driven by the timing of CapEx spending across both America and Airports; let's move on to slide 11. In the first quarter, cash and cash equivalents fell by $58 million — $193 million, largely driven by $127 million of cash interest payments, which encompassed an extra $48 million of payments tied to timing. To be specific, cash paid for interest in the first quarter rose $55 million versus the same period a year ago. Roughly $48 million of that increase stems from interest paid early due to timing, a consequence of the debt refinancing transactions in March 2024 along with payment of the first semi-annual interest payment on the CCOH 9% senior secured notes issued in August 2023. The rest of the increase reflects higher interest rates on the term loan facility. Liquidity stood at $389 million as of March 31st, 2024, a drop of $97 million relative to liquidity at the close of the fourth quarter, owing to the decline in cash and cash equivalents plus reduced availability under the receivable-based credit facility from lower net receivables at quarter end. Debt totaled $5.7 billion as of March 31st, 2024, up slightly from December 31st, 2023, because of the March refinancing.

David Sailer

executive
#4

Like Scott said, during the quarter we got debt deals done on favorable terms that strengthened our balance sheet — pushing out maturities that were coming up soon and lowering what we expect to pay in cash interest for 2024 by about $18 million thanks to the refinancing. On March 18th, 2024, we issued $865 million in aggregate principal amount of 7.875% senior secured notes due 2030, and we used part of those proceeds to prepay $835 million of borrowings outstanding under our term loan facility. At the same time, we made changes to our senior secured credit agreement. These changes included refinancing the $425 million that was left on the principal balance of the term loan facility, and pushing its maturity date out from 2026 to 2028. Then, on March 22nd, 2024, CCI BV signed a credit agreement consisting of two tranches of term loan, with a combined principal amount of $375 million, maturing in 2027. The money from that was used to redeem all of the outstanding CCI BV 6.625% senior secured notes due 2025. Our weighted average cost of debt was 7.4%, which is a slight improvement from where we ended the year. As of March 31st, 2024, our first lien leverage ratio was 5.38x, which is better than year-end. The credit agreement sets a covenant threshold at 7.1x. Moving on to slide 12, let's look at what we're projecting for Q2 and the entirety of 2024. Unless we're talking about capital expenditures and cash interest payments, all of our consolidated guidance, as well as Europe North guidance, leaves out foreign exchange rate fluctuations. For Q2, our consolidated revenue should come in somewhere from $547 million to $572 million, reflecting growth of 3%-8% compared with the same quarter in 2023. America revenue, we anticipate, will fall in the $290 million-$300 million range, while Airports revenue should be somewhere between $82 million-$87 million. As for Europe North revenue, we're expecting a range of $155 million-$165 million. Now let's turn to what we expect for the entire year. The revenue, Adjusted EBITDA, and CapEx outlook we gave back in February still stands. We've updated our figures for cash interest payments, loss from continuing operations, and AFFO to account for the refinancing that happened recently along with other new information. Consolidated revenue should land somewhere in the range of $2.2 billion to $2.26 billion, which would be a 3% to 6% gain compared with 2023. For America, we're looking at revenue somewhere between $1.135 billion and $1.165 billion. Airports revenue should come in somewhere between $345 million and $360 million. Europe North revenue is projected to fall between $635 million and $655 million. Looking at things on a consolidated basis, Adjusted EBITDA should be somewhere in the range of $550 million to $585 million. Our AFFO guidance sits at $80 million to $105 million. We're looking at capital spending somewhere between $130 million and $150 million, and we'll keep prioritizing investments in our US digital footprint. On top of that, we expect cash interest payment obligations of $436 million in 2024 and $425 million in 2025. If you compare 2024 with the prior year, the anticipated increase in cash interest payments largely boils down to the timing of when those payments fall on the calendar. For the second quarter, we expect to make $93 million in cash interest payments. This outlook assumes we won't refinance and won't take on any new debt. With that, I'll turn the call back to Scott.

Scott Wells

executive
#5

Appreciate that, Dave. So, looking at where we stand, we feel good about what's happening across the company and how tightly our team is sticking to the plan. Results are solid throughout the whole portfolio, and we continue to see things favorably ahead. Stateside, we're moving along well when it comes to putting those investments to work — the ones aimed at updating our platform and widening the pool of advertisers we're able to reach. Meanwhile, our dedication to trimming down the organization hasn't wavered, with attention centered on our America and Airports segments. All told, between the operational strides and the refinancings, we've cut back how much we're exposed to rate increases, kept the flexibility to hedge lower or refinance should rates decline, and opened up space for Adjusted EBITDA growth by pushing our maturities further out. Plus, when you look at our full year AFFO guidance alongside our discretionary CapEx, we anticipate coming near positive cash flow in 2024. From where we sit, that's some pretty solid movement. Huge thanks to everyone across the company for what they keep bringing as we chase growth this year. At this point I'll hand the call back to the operator, and Justin Cochrane will be joining us on the line.

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#6

Hi there, thanks. Scott, I found it intriguing—how America's results in national and local compare with what some of your competitors have posted. Could you talk a bit, perhaps from your perspective, about the reasons behind that divergence, plus anything else you can share regarding how you see the advertising market right now? And second, what would you recommend as the way for us to consider AFFO growth once 2024 has passed? Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#7

Thanks, Cameron. Yes, in all honesty, I believe numerous factors are at play here, and comparing ourselves to a rival is always tricky when we lack clarity on their calculation methods and their reporting choices. As we've mentioned — and I believe this remains fairly steady — what we refer to as national is connected to the largest agencies and the business those agencies place. That is the way we arrive at that metric. From our perspective, in all honesty, I believe a few observations stand out from our figures alone. When you compare America with Airports, within the roadside operation, national increased by 5 times the amount in Airports compared to America. I believe that highlights how difficult it is to treat national as one single category. It's a tough figure to draw comparisons with. In all honesty, I believe certain elements are moving through there that are likely different, especially when it comes to the pharma vertical. I believe we are achieving results in that area and are leading the way there, and our rivals likely don't have as much of that moving through. I don't have — in all honesty, I believe the sole additional item I would point to that is concrete is that you might remember from Q1 of last year, we experienced a fairly difficult Q1 last year, and that resulted at least in part from difficulties in California, especially Northern California; and that situation has settled and begun heading the opposite way. I won't claim it is entirely where it should be, but it sits in a much improved position compared to last year. And I believe that likely influences those figures too. Those are the items I would select. I don't know, Dave, whether anything comes to your mind?

David Sailer

executive
#8

No, no. I think that covers it.

Scott Wells

executive
#9

And then do you want to take the AFFO?

David Sailer

executive
#10

Absolutely. So, as you look ahead at AFFO, let's break down what goes into it. Take interest, for example — in March, we accomplished something I felt really good about: we extended the maturities on notes that had been scheduled for 2025 and 2026, moving them out to 2028, and a portion of the term loan was extended to 2030 through the notes we issued. But when it comes to AFFO, my sense is that many of the pieces — interest, maintenance capital — ought to land fairly close to this year's levels. The way I see it, growth in our EBITDA is what will really push AFFO up as we move into next year.

Scott Wells

executive
#11

Yes. And Cameron, you'd raised a question about the overall advertising sector. My apologies for omitting that from my opening remarks — I was attempting to connect to figures without knowing my starting point. So regarding the advertising sector, I'd describe it this way: the local side is still robust and fairly wide-ranging — business services, amusements, quite a few retail categories, quite a few verticals performing very well there; on the national side, entertainment is improving, media is improving, and I believe tech is improving. So several elements are trending favorably; we'd been hoping for additional activity in auto insurance during this year, and that hasn't materialized thus far. Plenty of discussions have happened, yet no meaningful orders. I'd say the wider healthcare category — leaving pharma aside — the wider healthcare category, which is partially local, partially national, but heavily cross-market, heavily sort of regional healthcare, that one hasn't been strong. So the market is mixed. What I mean is, we're attempting to describe it right down the middle and avoid getting overly enthusiastic about the relative Q1 results, while working to bring in incremental business as the year progresses; so that's roughly the finest picture I can provide you right now. I hope that's useful.

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#12

Definitely. Thank you both.

David Sailer

executive
#13

Thanks, Cameron.

Daniel Osley

analyst
#14

Thanks. We came away impressed by the margins throughout all segments this quarter, yet it caught us somewhat off guard that such strength didn't translate into an increase to full-year EBITDA guidance. Did timing play any role in what happened during the quarter, and could you broadly walk us through the margin pluses and minuses involving sales build-out, site lease negotiation, and contract losses? Thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#15

Let me take a portion of that, and then Dave can fill in certain margin specifics. Whenever we put together annual guidance, our visibility into how Q1 will land is fairly solid. So, honestly, what fascinates me is that the heart of the matter, especially across Europe and, somewhat, within Airports, is simply how Q1 represents such a tiny slice of the yearly total, which means percentages can turn flashy very fast. In Airports especially, that dynamic hurt us a year ago. This time around, it benefited us, and international likewise benefited us. So what I'd say is our visibility into Q1's outcome at the moment we guided was fairly solid, so we felt no real need to lift the guide right now. From our vantage point looking at the entire year, none of this was especially unexpected. Dave, I don't know whether you'd like to address the pluses and minuses portion of the question.

David Sailer

executive
#16

Yeah, no, definitely. If I look at the guidance, on the revenue side, Q1 came in inside our guide. But Q1, like Scott said, has a smaller EBITDA amount across each of our segments; so should you get a few one-timers swinging either direction, or a bit of favorability, that will have a larger effect on margins in the first quarter versus Q2 through Q4. If I break it out by segment, in America we were up 6%. The first quarter of 2023 was not the strongest. I would say the largest impact comes when growth is 6% and expenses are roughly flat thanks to a credit loss; we found savings there. We had some bad debt in last year's first quarter that clearly did not repeat this year's first quarter for America, and collections were in fact very strong. That's likely what's driving that increase. Airports is a different story; we had our difficult first quarter in 2023; and in 2024, we were up 43%, and we keep receiving COVID site lease relief, very much like what we received last year in the first quarter; so when you get that incremental revenue growth, it's really going to have a large effect on margins. And when you consider Airports going forward, since I know this question will come up, margins are going to be elevated in 2024, close to 2023, because site lease COVID relief will still trickle. And we aren't 100% sure which quarters it will land in, but we do expect to receive some. So we always describe our Airports business as a high teens business. As revenue grows, you'll reach the higher teens, perhaps around 20%, but this year, you'll be higher purely because of the relief you're receiving. And for Europe North, their EBITDA is smaller in the first quarter; they clearly grow across the year, and every quarter gets stronger; but with $7 million of EBITDA in the first quarter of 2023, they had very good top-line growth. We mentioned earlier the lost contract in Norway. So when your site lease declines and their expenses are roughly flat and they have top-line growth, that's really what's driving that margin impact. And particularly since the numbers are small, it's going to be definitely somewhat higher.

Daniel Osley

analyst
#17

Thanks.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#18

Thanks a lot. I have a few things to ask. First, considering the markets where you operate — and Scott, I believe you might have mentioned this already — I'm interested in your perspective on the media and entertainment sector, especially as we head into the latter half of the year and start to move past some of the effects from the strikes and other matters. Then I have a few additional questions. Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#19

Right. So I'd say media and entertainment clearly held us back during Q4. In Q1 it was performing reasonably well, though that came against weak comparables from Q1 of 2023. The strikes hadn't happened yet at that point, but it still wasn't a very strong quarter. As things ramp up, my expectation is that this segment keeps delivering. We aren't picking up anything that points to significant weakness, or what's the term I want? The streaming wars aren't happening anymore. That period marked a peak for media and entertainment. So it won't have the same energy as back then; however, with no strikes underway and a fairly healthy release slate, the film portion of media and entertainment ought to hold up well across the year. The streaming content side and the television side, in my view, are somewhat more unpredictable, and you really need to look at each company individually along with whatever product lineup they're carrying; so there will be gains and losses inside that. Still, I believe it will be a category that grows for us this year, Avi. On the top line, that's how I'd describe it.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#20

Thanks for that. Then regarding Europe North, despite a few ups and downs, it appears to be doing pretty well. I noticed remarks at the start about some positive momentum there; I'm just wondering whether that environment is affecting the process you're undertaking in that region, if it is at all, and what your thinking is on those assets. And then I've got one additional question, and thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#21

Right. I mean, my view is that what happens over the near term or short term isn't something I'd treat as directly shaping how this plays out. If anything, it backs up the conversation; each time results improve, the value those assets hold in our eyes rises. So that element does enter the picture. Even so, we've made it quite plain that turning into a business centered on the U.S. is what we aim for; thus the strong results — and here I'm reading a bit into your question, Avi, drawing on things you've raised with me before — have not shifted that aim in any manner whatsoever; and like I mentioned during the opening script remarks, at this stage we're negotiating with a purchaser; and I won't share anything further there, in case someone else wishes to pose a question about it. That's all you'll get. Still, the process keeps moving forward. In my view, solid results bolster that while we see it through, yet it won't alter the conclusion or the perspective regarding how our portfolio ought to be shaped going forward.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#22

Honestly, that seems like an ideal spot for me to wrap up. I'll hand things over now. I really appreciate everyone giving us your time.

Scott Wells

executive
#23

Thank you, Avi.

Lance Vitanza

analyst
#24

Hello, and I appreciate you fielding our questions — terrific quarter. Regarding that Norway contract you mentioned losing during the prepared remarks, might you share a bit more information? I realize this asset will eventually be eliminated, but I'm simply wondering: what exactly was this contract? Which company won it away from you? Was it a profitable contract? Did you choose to walk away, or did this loss disappoint you? And perhaps the key question: does it in any way affect your capacity to sell Norway? Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#25

I'll turn it over to Justin for his thoughts on Norway and that specific contract.

Justin Cochrane

executive
#26

Right, absolutely. Appreciate that, Scott. So the contract in question involved transit, specifically the Oslo Metro. For us, it was a fairly sizable deal, though the margin on it was fairly thin. A public tender process is where we came up short. That's just how it goes with any contract. You only put in a bid at the level you're prepared to offer to make the work worth taking on. The bid we submitted was one we felt very good about; the contract didn't end up ours. JCDecaux is the company that secured it. From there, we shift to our backup strategy and keep expanding the business. So as I mentioned, the margin on that contract was lower. Our intention is to swap it out for smaller contracts with better margins, and that effort is progressing nicely.

Lance Vitanza

analyst
#27

Thanks, that's helpful. Scott, you spent a good amount of time on Hollywood, but the Bay Area and Silicon Valley have also been a weak area for advertisers recently, though it seems to be coming back. How much of that business in that region has returned? Are we at 80%? 90%? And could you separate what you observed in Q1 from what you're seeing now in May, in case anything has shifted further? Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#28

Sure. So, our presence across the Bay Area is genuinely massive — stretching from Silicon Valley, up through San Francisco, over into Oakland, and out to the surrounding areas. And regarding the percentage we're getting back, I'd say it's been somewhat — well, San Francisco has always been a city of booms and busts throughout its entire history. COVID hit it really hard, but it did recover, and when that recovery happened, it was a genuine boom. Things came back very strongly during 2021 and 2022, right up until the later portion of 2022. After that, you had this whole story emerge around late 2022 going into early 2023 — downtown San Francisco, homelessness, lawlessness, shoplifting, retailers pulling out, that whole set of issues. Since that point, the city has taken several steps, among them getting several ballot measures approved, adding more policing, and pushing to clean up the streets. As for describing it as some percentage recovered, that's difficult for me to pin down, since it's nowhere close to reaching its full potential at this moment, yet growth has resumed and the trajectory is favorable. From what I can see, the tech sector specifically — that vertical within the city — is bouncing back quite well, and there's no question we're picking up positive signals coming out of that market. That said, my sense is we still need some time before national advertisers feel ready to jump back in. National advertisers have consistently played a major role in that media mix. It's a genuinely fascinating situation, because when you consider the locations of many of our street furniture assets across the city — those being among the properties that took the biggest hit — the neighborhoods of San Francisco are in fact performing remarkably strongly. When you look at the primary commercial strips in Noe Valley, the Marina, or Cow Hollow, those different districts, business is actually holding up quite strongly. Where we do see signs of a slowdown, part of that is perception and part of it is real. That said, I visit San Francisco roughly twice a year, and in my honest assessment, conditions there have improved a great deal compared with two years back. So the direction the city is moving in gives me confidence. I'm also encouraged that our team, especially the local group we have there, has risen to the occasion and is working hard to make up for the fact that national advertisers aren't showing the same level of activity in that market. In my opinion, San Francisco has good things ahead.

Lance Vitanza

analyst
#29

Great. Thanks so much.

Scott Wells

executive
#30

Thanks, Lance.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#31

Hi, everybody. Appreciate you bringing me onto the call. I have one additional question regarding how national advertising did, and clearly it was pretty strong during the quarter. Scott, I'd love to hear your perspective now that a number of ad-supported streaming services have recently launched, delivering video inventory that's more targeted. Would you consider that a possible headwind in any way for what you're doing in the U.S.?

Scott Wells

executive
#32

Not really. One reason I feel that way is that I see them as a massive danger to linear TV, and linear TV is already having a hard time. What I suspect may happen is that they could hold us back from taking part in the shift of advertisers away from linear TV to the extent we otherwise would have. In that sense, it's somewhat of a difficulty. On the whole, I don't view them as a threat specifically directed at us. They simply appeal to — and this is among the genuine frustrations here in the U.S., since that linear TV shift abroad, it holds true in LATAM; it holds true in Europe. We're watching dollars leave linear TV and flow into our assets in international markets at a level we aren't seeing nearly as much of here. We do see some of it here, yet the scale of it internationally is far greater. And many of the same brands are involved. So it's simply curious that brands are drawn to out-of-home more in other markets than they are in the U.S. Part of it is that they do favor the street furniture asset, which sits somewhat nearer to the point of sale; but when we examine it analytically, the impact of the roadside matches what street furniture delivers across many use cases. So it puzzles us somewhat that more of that linear TV money doesn't arrive here in the U.S. But that's how things stand. So I don't see it as a major threat. And in certain ways it's actually an opportunity, since they're advertising these ad-served businesses on our signs. So there's opportunity in that as well.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#33

Appreciate that context. Let me squeeze in one final question about how the capital structure looks. You've pointed out everything you've accomplished to push out maturity dates. For the coming 2 years, there's an obvious clear path. With rates where they sit right now, do you hit the brakes on that effort at this point? And on a connected note, beyond the business growing, are there other levers we ought to keep in mind across the near-term window that could speed up the deleveraging effort?

David Sailer

executive
#34

Based on what you're describing, when we extended those maturities, we were clearly very happy with how March turned out — moving the BV notes out to 2027, which of course connects to the European process Scott brought up earlier. That said, we'll keep watching the market at all times; that chance appeared in March, we took it, and from where we sit it worked out really well. Given where rates have actually moved since then, that opening is no longer there. Still, we'll keep an eye on the market. Should a chance arise to bring down our cost of debt, we'd certainly examine it. The economics, though, need to be compelling. When it comes to deleveraging, sure, extending our maturities from 2027 into 2028 genuinely hands us that runway on the EBITDA side to really expand the business. And as we work through the European process and those proceeds are generated, yes, a portion of them will clearly go toward the BV notes or the BV term loan in its current form. The rest of the proceeds — we have 18 months to reinvest them in the business, whether through CapEx or acquisitions; so I believe there will be choices at that moment to sort of evaluate it.

Scott Wells

executive
#35

Yes. And regarding the other aspect of what you're asking about—what to keep an eye on—I believe we've made it fairly evident that for the past 2 years, a great deal of our structuring work and deal creativity has been centered on Europe and on international divestitures. Once we get through those processes successfully, that bandwidth will open up for us in the U.S. There's substantial interest in this sector, and many different ideas come our way. And I think as we streamline and bring clarity to the business, our capacity to do something creative is strong; but I won't steer you toward what that creative thing could be, because you're quite aware that the range of options available to us is wide. You should simply anticipate that the creative energy we've been using to position ourselves for the divestitures we've been pursuing is energy we'll be able to apply to structuring things here in the U.S. downstream.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#36

Great. Thanks, Scott. Thanks, Dave.

Ted Rice

executive
#37

All right. Thank you. This is Ted filling in for David. There are a couple of things I'd like to ask. First, regarding the 2024 AFFO guidance. I just wanted to ask about where that upside is coming from, given that revenue and EBITDA are being held unchanged. Does that mainly stem from Q1 carrying through into the full year, or is there something else?

Scott Wells

executive
#38

Nope, nothing significant at all. Truly, nothing of consequence exists in that area. We're simply tightening up our projections. What happened was an adjustment to our deferred tax asset, and that adjustment essentially carries over into that figure. Looking at taxes broadly, the cash taxes we owe are quite small this year, concentrated mainly on certain international items plus U.S., local, and state obligations. Compared with what we paid out last year on a cash basis, I don't anticipate any substantial changes in what we're projecting for 2024.

Ted Rice

executive
#39

Understood, thanks. Then I'd like to ask about programmatic. I just want to ask what drove the strength during the quarter and what you expect going forward.

Scott Wells

executive
#40

Hey Ted, my apologies. We got cut off right when you began your second question. I'm not certain what happened. Something like a power surge took us off the line, but we're back now.

Ted Rice

executive
#41

Everything's fine. Excellent. Right, so what they were essentially asking about was how strong programmatic was in Q1, where that came from, and what you're anticipating for programmatic over the remainder of the year.

Scott Wells

executive
#42

So programmatic's actually been picking up steam quite nicely starting around September and October of last year. There are several things fueling that. One of the programmatic accounts that's growing at the moment is genuinely transitioning away from direct business. That's not a pattern we've really observed on a wide scale. So a portion of this is essentially money shifting from one pocket to the other. That's certainly one piece of what's happening. But I'd say the bigger picture is that The Trade Desk has brought mainstream out-of-home, and DV360 is currently in the middle of bringing mainstream out-of-home. What that boils down to is that the two largest omnichannel DSPs out there now include digital out-of-home within their core trading platform. That's how we end up getting considered. I believe that's at least one component of what's driving this. Beyond our client outreach, we've got a number of partners where we've enjoyed real success in attracting new advertisers into the category. So multiple factors are at play here. My sense is the growth rate won't remain as elevated as it's been over the past couple of quarters across the full year. Still, we do anticipate it being a double-digit growth rate; it simply won't reach the level seen in Q4 and Q1.

Jim Goss

analyst
#43

Okay, thanks. Clearly, the film advertising side is going to be very near-term. Having just returned from CinemaCon, there's plenty of excitement around 2025 and 2026 as film output comes back, yet the next pair of quarters look quite difficult right now. How significant a drag do you expect that to be, and how hopeful are you about the following year? Also, regarding the balance between small screen and big screen and how much each matters for your markets — my sense is it's mainly big screen, but correct me if I'm wrong.

Scott Wells

executive
#44

Thank you, Jim. Yeah, you're definitely right. Our orientation leans much more toward big screen. We do capture some small screen business, but it isn't the dominant piece of what we have. Your description of the release slate might be somewhat gloomier than what I'm hearing. Still, I won't argue that 2024 won't match 2025; so I believe this can be a positive category across multiple quarters for us. It isn't a huge portion of our book; so I wouldn't say it will determine whether 2024 succeeds or what 2025 might be. However, in a political year, we don't receive much direct political, even though we're pushing very hard on that front, but not much direct political is baked into our guide; so that could be upside for us in 2024 if we manage to break through there. Yet in a year featuring political, we'll see overflow arrive from people being squeezed out in the TV space or seeking alternative ways to reach audiences tired of the 17th political ad in a row during breaks in the sports they watch. So films can be a welcome growth driver in 2025. And I believe we share your optimism about how that release slate will shape up. And that ought to help offset some of the political comp we're building this year going into next year. But once more, it won't determine whether our business succeeds.

Jim Goss

analyst
#45

All right. Thank you. There's another topic I want to briefly address. If I understand correctly, you mentioned that airport margin is likely to be in the high-teens range for the business overall, though it can swing fairly widely. Could you perhaps elaborate on which drivers you consider significant — things like travel patterns, traveler counts, corporate versus leisure — and how those will influence the revenue line, plus what you believe could matter on the cost side?

Scott Wells

executive
#46

Let me begin with revenue, and then I'll hand it to Dave to go deeper on expenses. Over the past few years, we've genuinely transformed our approach to selling Airports; we've grown more focused on building experiences that are especially appealing to advertisers, whether that means sampling or other on-site experiences, or taking over various assets such as tunnels connecting terminals. We've carried that out across quite a few Airports; as a result, what you've witnessed during roughly the last 18 months is our steady improvement at monetizing those assets. I'm now pushing the team to bring some of that same mindset to our roadside assets; and we're beginning to see some trials of that nature unfold. Still, I'd say the driver — completing the build-out of New York was a major part of it. New York is mostly finished, though meaningful projects will remain as certain LaGuardia terminals and certain JFK terminals are completed, since renovation work continues there. So there ought to be additional upside simply from expanding that footprint; we've become far more strategic regarding where we place assets across different Airports. That has served as a tailwind behind what's happened. And you should expect that fairly consistently. And until we reach the point where the next major step back in Airports occurs, it will come when we lose a large contract, which at some point we inevitably will. Nothing we can currently identify appears to be heading in that direction. And we've been fortunate in securing direct extensions. But that's simply how that business works. Eventually, we will take a step back at one of the large Airports where we operate. That will be a headwind. Regarding actual travelers and whom advertisers aim to reach, we had done a really good job convincing people that even when travelers were pleasure travelers, they still constituted very attractive demographics within business decision-making; and as business travel has returned and is nearing its pre-pandemic level, that has been a bonus for us, because for certain Airports it delivers really strong uplifts as the business traveler returns. So that has formed part of the revenue story as well. Yet those represent the main factors — a somewhat distinct approach to sales, plus steady growth in what we offer digitally. The traveler keeps returning, and remains an extremely appealing premium prospect. Dave, would you like to address costs?

David Sailer

executive
#47

Okay. On the cost side, I'd say it's clearly less complicated compared with how revenue works. There are, of course, many factors behind the tremendous top-line growth we've posted across the past few quarters. But when it comes to expenses, in the Airports segment, site lease is the largest cost — that's what gets paid to airport authorities for the assets we hold in the Airports. And with that site lease, a number of our contracts, most of them actually, are percent rent. The bigger Airports carry a higher percent rent. At the smaller Airports, it runs a bit lower; so the mix of your revenue really plays a large part in determining what your margins will be; and at this moment, we're doing very well on all of those fronts, which is giving a real boost on the margin side. There are also a handful of Airports where it's a fixed MAG. Should you push revenue past that level, it flows straight down to the bottom line. We certainly saw that happen in the first quarter. Then I'd point back to the relief we keep receiving. We'll continue getting that through 2024, though to a smaller degree than we did in 2023. Those are two of the primary things really fueling it on the expense side. As revenue increases, you're going to see margin expansion. That's exactly what we've been witnessing.

Jim Goss

analyst
#48

Okay, thanks a lot. I appreciate that.

Scott Wells

executive
#49

Thanks, Jim.

Scott Wells

executive
#50

Alright, thanks Robin. And thanks to everyone who asked questions, and for bearing with us through that small technical issue. Apologies for that short stretch of quiet. We appreciate you sticking with us. We're feeling positive about the year, and we look forward to seeing all of you, or a lot of you, at events over the next few weeks. Take care.

Operator

operator
#51

Thanks. That brings today's call to a close. I'll go ahead and cut off your lines now. We appreciate you joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.