Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 31, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Communication Services Media earnings 55 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Eileen McLaughlin

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's call. Joining us are Scott Wells, who serves as our CEO, and David Sailer, our CFO. They're going to walk us through how Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings Inc; and Clear Channel International B.V. performed operationally during the third quarter of 2024. We'd suggest you pull up the earnings presentation for that same quarter — it's available in the financial information area of our investor website — and follow along while we speak. Once we've gone through the introduction and taken a look at our results, we'll open up the lines for your questions, and Justin Cochrane, who heads Clear Channel UK and Europe as CEO, will be sitting in with Scott and Dave for that Q&A portion. Prior to getting started, I want to remind all of you that forward-looking statements about the company may be made on this call, including ones concerning future financial performance and strategic goals. Every such statement carries risks and uncertainties, and nobody can guarantee that management's expectations, beliefs, or projections will come to pass, or that actual results won't end up differing from expectations. Kindly take a look at the risk statements found in our earnings press release and in our SEC filings. We'll also be referencing some measures on today's call that don't conform to generally accepted accounting principles; as part of the earnings presentation, we offer schedules reconciling those non-GAAP measures against our reported results on a GAAP basis. One more thing to keep in mind: what's shared on this call reflects only management's views as of today, October 31st, 2024, and might not still hold true when a replay is heard. Please turn to slide four in the earnings presentation, and I'll hand things over now to Scott.

Scott Wells

executive
#2

Hello, everyone, and thanks for making time to be with us this morning. For the third quarter, our consolidated revenue came in at $559 million, which was up 6.1%, or 5.7% when you strip out foreign exchange rate movements — consistent with the guidance we gave and with gains recorded in every one of our business segments. Within our America segment, growth showed up across every region, helped along in part by better national advertising. Airports keeps gaining from robust demand in every channel, while Europe North turned in yet another solid quarter, with increases across most of the portfolio. The advantages of our efforts to capitalize on technology spending and bigger sales teams in order to get the most out of our U.S. performance remain evident. Drawing on our digital know-how and our RADAR data analytics tools, we are pushing into verticals that historically have not turned to out-of-home to connect with their target audiences; take, for instance, the partnership with Circana we announced not long ago, which makes our radar platform even stronger and gives CPG advertisers who under-index in our industry a way to effectively get their message out through out-of-home while tracking how their campaigns affect household purchasing behavior. When it comes to the pharma vertical, we have arrived at a stage where we can share a few genuinely persuasive outcomes from campaigns we ran previously, and that is helping us open doors. Not long ago, we were a sponsor at Digital Pharma East, which ranks among the biggest pharma marketing conferences in the country. That was a first for us, and the response was encouraging. We are now sitting at the table with many pharmaceutical companies and their agencies, talking over possible campaigns for the year ahead. Turning to our domestic footprint, we are thrilled about the recent win of a sizable 15-year contract covering roadside advertising assets held by the New York MTA. That contract meaningfully grows our footprint across the New York tri-state area and boosts our capacity to provide market-wide programs to national and local advertisers in a way that complements one another, so we are making real headway on our plan as we keep scaling our platform in the U.S. and stay focused on broadening our revenue sources, which positions us well as we aim to finish the year strong and carry our momentum forward into 2025. During the quarter we are in right now, we continue to observe revenue growth in America. Our airports business is still strong, though we are now facing tougher comps, meaning the growth rate will moderate as a matter of course. Much like airports, Europe North likewise faces tough comps and may report roughly flat revenues for the quarter. As I mentioned on our previous call, we think we are turning the corner when it comes to cash generation. AFFO came in above discretionary CapEx during the third quarter, and we anticipate the same in the fourth quarter, with further improvement as we move into 2025; our view is that this opens the option to begin paying down our debt organically, which is a central goal in our push to enhance shareholder value. Regarding M&A, talks about divesting Europe North are still underway, and our dedication to leaving Europe at a valuation that mirrors what this operation is generating has not wavered. Also, you might have noticed that JCDecaux pulled out of its deal to buy our Spanish unit after choosing to retract its filing with the competition authority in Spain. From what we understand, the regulatory conditions went beyond what JCDecaux was prepared to accept. The positive side is that throughout this period, our Spanish operation kept delivering strong results, and we are in a solid position to take it back to market before too long. Finally, the process to sell our LATAM assets is still moving forward, and we will share additional details when the time is right; so on the whole, we are happy with how things are advancing across several areas, and I want to express gratitude to our entire team across the company, particularly those in Europe and Latin America, for their ongoing dedication to carrying out our strategic roadmap and chasing our long-term vision; with that, I'll turn the call over to Dave.

David Sailer

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Scott. Take a look at slide five, which gives you a rundown of how we performed. Just to note again, Europe South sits within discontinued operations. Also, when I walk through the GAAP figures, I'll cover our results without the impact of foreign exchange rate movements, which is a non-GAAP measure. Our view is that this gives you better comparability when assessing how we did. Restructuring and other costs are baked into direct operating expenses and SG&A expenses, but those costs are left out of Adjusted EBITDA and segment Adjusted EBITDA. Everything I cite is for Q3 of 2024, and unless I say otherwise, the percentage changes compare the third quarter of 2024 with the third quarter of 2023; so let's move into the reported results for the third quarter. Consolidated revenue came in at $559 million for the quarter, as Scott noted, which is a 6.1% gain. Strip out foreign exchange rate movements, and consolidated revenue rose 5.7%. The loss from continuing operations and consolidated net loss, the latter of which takes in the loss from discontinued operations, each came to $32 million. Adjusted EBITDA reached $143 million for the quarter, an increase of 2.6%, while adjusted EBITDA without foreign exchange rate movements climbed 1.9% versus the prior year. AFFO totaled $27 million in Q3, which is 9.1% higher than the prior year. Without foreign exchange rate movements, AFFO gained 5.5%. Let's turn to slide six for the America segment's third quarter results. America revenue came to $293 million, a 5% gain, as revenue rose across every region, fueled by stronger demand for digital and printed billboards alike plus the rollout of additional digital billboards. Digital revenue made up 36.1% of America revenue and grew 8.4% to $106 million. National sales represented 36.3% of America revenue and rose 8.4% on a comparable basis. Local sales made up 63.7% of America revenue and increased 3.2% on a comparable basis. Direct operating and SG&A expenses rose 4.5% to $165 million, partly because property taxes were lower in the prior year owing to a legal settlement, along with greater compensation costs and production expenses tied in part to higher revenue. Segment-adjusted EBITDA came to $128 million, up 5.8%, and the segment-adjusted EBITDA margin was 43.8%, a modest gain over the prior year. Now look at slide seven for a review of the third quarter results for airports. Airports revenue was $82 million, up 9%, helped by robust advertising demand led by the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey airports. Digital revenue represented 51.1% of airports revenue and edged up 0.8% to $42 million. National sales made up 58.6% of airports revenue and rose 8.7% on a comparable basis, while local sales represented 41.4% of airports revenue and increased 9.3% on a comparable basis. Direct operating and SG&A expenses rose 8.9% to $65 million. That gain stems mainly from site lease expense, driven partly by higher revenue. Segment-adjusted EBITDA was $17 million, up 9%, and the segment-adjusted EBITDA margin came to 20.6%, matching the prior year. Now we'll look at slide eight, where I'll walk through how Europe North performed. When I discuss Europe North, I'm referring to results adjusted to remove foreign exchange rate movements. Revenue for Europe North rose 8.6%, reaching $162 million, with gains in the majority of countries driven by stronger demand, above all in Sweden, though this was partly offset by losing a transit contract in Norway. Digital made up 58.1% of Europe North's total revenue and grew 12.4% to $94 million. Direct operating and SG&A expenses for Europe North climbed 12% to $136 million, reflecting higher site lease expense, property taxes, and compensation, along with increased rental costs for additional digital displays. Europe North segment-adjusted EBITDA fell 4.5% to $27 million, while the segment-adjusted EBITDA margin came in at 16.7%, down from the prior year. Let's turn to CCI B.V. on slide nine. Clear Channel International B.V., which I'll call CCI B.V., is an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of the company and the borrower under the CCI B.V. term loan facility. CCI B.V. covers the operations of our Europe North and Europe South segments, and before September 17th, 2024, it also covered Singapore, which sits within other. Singapore's financial results have historically been immaterial to CCI BV's results, and revenue and expenses for the Singapore business were reduced further in the first quarter of 2024 because of a contract loss. On September 17th, 2024, CCI BV sold its equity interest in the Singapore business to another indirect foreign wholly owned subsidiary of the company. Since the current and former businesses in the Europe South segment count as discontinued operations, their results appear as a separate component of consolidated net income in the CCI BV consolidated statement of income for all periods presented and are left out of the results that follow. Here's how CCI BV's continuing operations performed in the third quarter of 2024 versus the same period of 2023. CCI BV revenue rose 8.1% to $166 million, up from $154 million. After excluding the $4 million impact of FX movements, CCI BV revenue was up 5.4%, as higher revenue from our Europe North segment, which I mentioned earlier, was partly offset by a contract loss in Singapore. CCI BV operating income came to $5 million, compared with $9 million in the same period of 2023. Now let's move to slide 10 for our capital expenditures review. CapEx came to $31 million in the third quarter, down $2 million from the prior year. Next, slide 11. In the third quarter, cash and cash equivalents rose by $12 million to $201 million. Cash paid for interest in the third quarter fell $2 million versus the same period a year earlier. As of September 30th, 2024, our liquidity stood at $376 million. That's a drop of $29 million from where liquidity was when the second quarter ended, and the reason is the $34 million reduction in the revolving credit facility's borrowing limit that we announced earlier. Debt came to $5.7 billion as of September 30th, 2024, which matches what we saw in the second quarter. Our weighted average cost of debt was 7.4%, likewise unchanged from the second quarter. The first lien leverage ratio came in at 5.34 times as of September 30th, 2024. The covenant threshold in the credit agreement sits at 7.1 times. Let's move to slide 12 now, where we'll discuss guidance for the fourth quarter and for the whole of 2024. With the exception of capital expenditures and cash interest payments, all consolidated guidance and Europe North guidance leaves out foreign exchange rate movements. For Q4, we anticipate consolidated revenue landing somewhere between $628 million and $653 million, which works out to anywhere from a 1% decrease to a 3% increase relative to the equivalent stretch of the previous year. America revenue should come in somewhere between $308 million and $318 million, while airports revenue should fall somewhere between $111 million and $116 million. Europe North revenue should land somewhere between $185 million and $195 million. Now let's talk about our guidance for the entire year. Consolidated revenue should come in somewhere between $2.222 billion and $2.247 billion, which represents growth of 4% to 6% versus the previous year. America's revenue should fall somewhere between $1.141 billion and $1.151 billion. Airports revenue should land somewhere between $356 million and $361 million. Europe North revenue should come in somewhere between $648 million and $658 million. Looking at things on a consolidated basis, Adjusted EBITDA should land somewhere between $560 million and $580 million. For AFFO, our guidance is $90 million to $105 million. Capital expenditures should fall somewhere in the range of $130 million to $140 million, and we'll keep directing investment toward our digital footprint in the U.S. On top of that, we expect to owe $137 million in cash interest payments during the fourth quarter of 2024, plus $420 million across 2025. This guidance rests on the assumption that no refinancing happens and no extra debt gets taken on. At this point, I'll hand the call back over to Scott.

Scott Wells

executive
#4

Appreciate it, Dave. So to sum things up, the way business is trending stays favorable throughout our portfolio, and delivering the financial guidance we issued for the full year 2024 continues to be something we're on track for. Just like we mentioned at the start of the year, results for 2024 have been a bit uneven when you compare one quarter to the next, which comes down to how 2023 lines up. When we take the full year into view, genuine progress is visible, and the early renewal plus development work for 2025 has us encouraged. The reason is that we're gaining ground on broadening the pool of advertisers we're able to work with, boosting utilization throughout our platform, and getting the most out of revenue. On top of that, growing our footprint in New York via the new roadside contract makes the audiences we're capable of delivering even bigger. Executing our strategic plan is something we're dedicated to, and that covers carrying on with the sale processes tied to our international businesses. Growing cash flow organically and bringing down leverage on our balance sheet rank among our ultimate objectives. Evidence of our progress shows up in third quarter AFFO, which came in above our discretionary CapEx. As we mentioned, we're expecting the same thing in the fourth quarter, plus gains in 2025. At this point, let me hand things over to the operator, and Justin Cochrane will be joining us on the call.

Cameron McVeigh

analyst
#5

Hello, good morning. Is there anything else you can share regarding the New York MTA roadside contract? Perhaps why this is happening at this point, and is there additional economic detail underlying the arrangement? And then, second, might you expand a little on what's fueling the uptick in national ad spend? National outdoor has faced some strain across the last few quarters. So I'm interested, from where you sit, what's different now, and whether that shift is structural? Thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#6

Hey, Cameron, good morning. Appreciate the questions. I'm going to begin with the second one, actually, then circle back to the MTA, and after that I'll pass it over to Dave so he can discuss the contract itself in a bit more depth. Regarding the national ad spend backdrop, some factors that boosted us were within our control this quarter, such as our push in areas like CPG, like pharmaceuticals, like telecom. Other factors are simply arithmetic. I believe the two together drove the figure into the high single digits range. What I'd say is that it's certainly an improvement over a year ago, yet national ad spending isn't moving in any linear fashion. We keep observing a media and entertainment sector enduring substantial disruption, and it isn't recovering to where it stood before the strike. The, I think everyone knows about how competitive that space is and all the, various things happening there. That vertical still hasn't recovered. Then there's, I mean, it isn't awful, but it isn't wonderful either, and it's a significant vertical in our portfolio. Then you've got, gains and losses. Business services remains a very strong performer at the local level. Anyway, your question was about national, so I'll stop there on that topic; it's partly deliberate moves on our part, and it's partly just arithmetic. I'd say the underlying national market resembles the underlying national market we've observed across the last several quarters. It's uneven, things come in a somewhat episodic manner, things arrive a bit late. Still, there's money available out there, and it falls on us to go capture it. Which leads me to your first question, which I'll address second, which concerns the MTA, and you began by asking why now. To put it plainly, these are roadside bulletin assets. They're assets spread across the tri-state area on property controlled by the MTA. This is entirely above ground inventory, and it's all billboard and poster type inventory. It isn't shelters, it isn't transit assets as such. This contract got consolidated back in 2017, and we in fact held some of the properties before that. That isn't really relevant here, except to underscore that this is our core business. This isn't merely another kind of adjacency. What it does is provide a stronger footprint when we sit down to negotiate national contracts, and we believe that will carry over into other markets as well. For our New York operations, it should definitely be beneficial, both on the local and the national side, since it gives us the capacity to matter to a large group of advertisers for whom we previously lacked strong solutions. Before this contract goes live — which actually takes effect tomorrow, at the start of November — those were our core New York City assets. I suppose Monday is effectively the first day of real operations. What this will do is let us tell a far fuller story about the audience we're able to deliver in New York. It combines digital and printed assets. I'll hand it to Dave to walk through some of the contract specifics, but that's the strategic reasoning.

David Sailer

executive
#7

Okay, thank you, Scott. So, looking at it through a money lens, I suppose the place to begin is that this deal kicks off on the first of November, like Scott mentioned. There will no doubt be somewhat of a buildup phase while we settle in; clearly, that's a pair of months within Q4. Then at a broad view, when I consider this agreement, once we move into 2025, it should contribute roughly a couple of percentage points of expansion where revenue is concerned. It's really robust on the top line. Excellent properties, both digital plus printed ones. Like Scott noted, we already held a portion of this inventory earlier, so we know it quite well. This is a municipal agreement, the MTA contract. There is going to be a MAG tied to this deal. The rev share is extremely high. A small amount of capital recovery exists, however you'll be looking at a revenue share up in the high seventies. Where margin is concerned, it isn't the typical flow through, of the at-home segment, yet it's an absolute rise in our margin dollars. An agreement we truly can't wait for. When I think about Q4, you'll likely see a modest margin effect simply because you're building up the contract. Naturally, the MAG begins, and you must match that where revenue is concerned. There will certainly be, obviously, some top line expansion in Q4, plus a slight margin consequence in Q4. As I mentioned, once we get into the following year, you'll see that top line effect of a couple of points. There could be a small margin consequence as we move into 2025, although it's really more about the top line, it will be expanding the business.

Scott Wells

executive
#8

Right, and regarding that, I’m glad Dave brought it up — there could be some effect on margin. I realize operating leverage matters a lot to everyone tracking our company. It’s certainly going to take a hit while we take on this contract throughout the coming year. After it’s completely running and up to speed, you’ll see operating leverage return to a more typical level. I simply don’t want anyone to assume this will just pass through, or that 2025 will be a typical year when it comes to operating leverage, since this contract is large and, again, it’s just arithmetic, it will affect the margin percentages across that period. As the year progresses, we ought to see it settle, and then later years will appear more typical for operating leverage.

Daniel Osley

analyst
#9

Morning. Two things from me. To start, could you break down whatever political upside showed up during Q3, plus what you're expecting in Q4 — whether that comes through crowd out or direct dollars? And then second, what's the right way to frame airports' growth going forward? It looks like the port authority contract ramp is now fully lapped, and your Q4 guidance points to a low single digit growth range. Should we carry that forward, or are there factors that could push it either direction? Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#10

Thanks, Daniel. Starting with political — we've absolutely seen some political dollars arrive. That's shown up in our programmatic channels. It's also appeared in our direct channels. The money has come both from the campaigns themselves and from PACs. These aren't huge figures. Across the full year, we're talking a few million dollars in terms of impact. I don't believe you'll watch us swing up and swing down the way other local oriented media does. Political spending isn't really a major factor for our business. Still, we've managed to achieve some positive results in that area during this year. Once the fourth quarter concludes and everything is finalized — and remember, we operate in numerous competitive battleground states — we anticipate that the rate of increase in political ad income will be substantial for us. However, that growth will be measured against an extremely tiny foundation. I don't anticipate approaching you a year from now, asking for leniency and pointing to this as a justification. So ideally, that gives you a fairly solid sense of what political means for us. Regarding where airports are headed, I believe we've been indicating for some time now — Dave, please correct me if I'm wrong here — but my sense is we've been indicating for quite a while that once the Port Authority buildout reaches maturity and we have no further significant contract additions or subtractions, then the growth rate that out of home typically delivers above GDP across extended timeframes is likely the appropriate lens for airports. There are certainly initiatives underway aimed at strengthening what we provide and pushing further on innovation in our market approach. Over roughly the past six or seven quarters, this team has performed exceptionally well. I'd expect a small lull at that point. Over roughly the next two to three years, contracts will likely bring a mix of gains and losses. Nothing major is on the horizon or anything along those lines, but look at the airport business — COVID struck it incredibly hard. Rather than going through RFPs, many airport authorities chose direct extensions. In terms of contract stability, I'd say things have been somewhat artificially calm. Again, nothing that big is immediately ahead of us, though I think you'll start seeing that emerge across the next 2 years.

Daniel Osley

analyst
#11

Thanks.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#12

Thanks, and good morning. I have three things if that's alright. First, I'll begin with the balance sheet. Free cash flow, the way we see it, was positive in Q3, and the commentary indicated broader further improvements. Given those remarks and paying down debt organically through free cash flow, I'm just curious how you're thinking about weighing some discount that's available on certain of your debt against some earlier maturities. I have two more. Thanks so much. Do you want to field that one, Dave?

David Sailer

executive
#13

Appreciate the question, Abby; now, when it comes to free cash flow, I, I feel quite good about where we stand at present. I mean, during last quarter's call we signaled that our AFFO, covering our discretionary or slash growth CapEx, would be positive in the second half. W e were positive in, in the third quarter, and we're going to be positive in the fourth quarter. I can see that, advancing as we move into 2025; so I believe that's a, that's a solid milestone for the business. Regarding when you mention paying down debt, yeah, as we begin, generating, free cash for the business, without question, that's a clear opportunity or outcome from that cash. W e would examine the pricing of our bonds. R ight now, the prices are in fact quite strong if you, if you look throughout our portfolio of assets. I believe that's something we're going to get into as we get into the strategic initiatives and as those move forward. I think that's the discussion, where we're considering debt paydown from that angle first; then as we're clearly generating free cash flow, that's simply another favorable outcome, from that cash flow, do you put money into the business or is there a certain, are there ways that we can target our debt to pay that down? T hat's certainly top of mind.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#14

Thanks. For my second one, I'd like to examine the full-year guidance a bit further, along with what it suggests for you — and that, I believe, is somewhat lower in Q4. If you've already covered this, my apologies, but is there anything worth flagging on the cost side or elsewhere, broken out by segment, that could explain it? Then I have a final one, and thank you so much. I mean, when I consider the Q4 guide, when I consider it from a revenue perspective, I mean, across the whole year, America was around 4% to 5%, and 3% to 7% in Q4. At present, for airports and America — and I can say the same about Europe — in Q3, we posted record revenue for airports. We'll keep that going in Q4. Q4 of the prior year was the largest revenue quarter ever for airports, at $111 million. We aim to beat that. Looking at the guide, the percentage — yeah, it's likely not the high numbers we've seen across the past six to seven quarters. As we've discussed, once we lap those comps, that's going to have an impact on the growth rate. Then Europe North is coming off 13% to 14% growth in Q4 of last year. Again, Q4 last year was a record quarter; we're up against those comps and observing a bit of softness, I'd say, in the UK. I think as the government rolls out its budget and the discussions there, I think that's slowing growth somewhat in Q4 for Europe. That's likely, when you think about the guide's weakness in Q4, that's likely where I'd direct you. Yeah. On the cost side, there have been some taxes. Yeah, and increases in Europe especially. Yes, in the UK especially, that have had an impact. Do you have that? There are also a few new contracts ramping overseas. As you deploy costs, as you release certain assets, that's driving a bit there too. You always see that when new contracts are ramping. That's certainly helpful. I appreciate it. If I could finish on the Europe side, and thanks again. The Spain sale is on hold for now. I'm just curious whether it alters your thinking about the Europe process overall. Scott, you said you want a price that reflects the business's value. I think everyone can support that. Given how long this has dragged on, I wonder whether, rather than a sale, the company might be looking at a spinoff of the business, which may not deliver the same immediate cash, but perhaps lets you concentrate on the U.S. And consolidate every one of those properties into a single operation. That's what I'm interested in hearing your thoughts on. Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#15

Hello, Avi. Of course you'd pick the simple question. I appreciate it. Thanks for raising it. From what I gather, Spain is top of mind right now — I was just going through the notes folks submitted this week. It seems Spain is occupying people's thoughts in a few different ways. The first point I'd make is that this is simply one illustration of the regulated environment we operate within, and we must treat the regulatory obstacle before us with real seriousness. Both we and JCD felt confident, at the time we signed that agreement 17 months back, that it could be completed. Once you've signed, the burden falls on the purchaser to engage with the regulatory commission. For reasons that aren't clear, it failed to clear that obstacle. Some of you may remember that we made the Italy and Spain announcements simultaneously. Italy presented an identical situation — we were rivals in that marketplace. Whatever the cause — the way things played out, the scale of the gaps, the particular character of that regulatory commission — Italy sailed through, while Spain clearly did not work out. The regulatory dimension is simply something we can never treat as minor. The second thing I've noticed people raising on this topic is whether it means a strategic purchaser in Northern Europe is now off the table. My plea is that everyone remember strategic is a matter of perspective. It need not be someone running roadside assets — outdoor assets, rather; it could be a media firm. I wouldn't dismiss the possibility that strategic players exist who'd have interest in this business, beyond the obvious names in out of home advertising. Regarding your structuring question, Avi, we recognize this has dragged on somewhat, but we'd also counter that rates skyrocketed and a war broke out, alongside plenty of other turbulence across various markets. I give enormous credit to our European team for what Europe North has delivered, which we've highlighted over the last couple earnings calls. The Spanish team, even with a deal signed and considerable uncertainty surrounding precisely what shape the new business would take, simply kept their heads down and knocked it out of the park. That, to me, reflects the character and capability of this company — and I won't get ahead of myself speculating about how I might structure this differently from a sale process, until such time as I conclude a sale process isn't practically feasible. I'm nowhere near that point. I hope that answers your question without us diving into — I mean, you and I could toss ideas back and forth for hours about every neat possibility for pulling cash out of this and running it a different way. But since we're sticking with the declared plan of divesting the markets and following a process, I won't go down that road during our public earnings call. I hope that provides what you were looking for.

Avi Steiner

analyst
#16

Thanks, I always appreciate it. Many thanks to all of you.

Lance Vitanza

analyst
#17

Hey, everyone. I appreciate you taking my question. Staying on Europe North, the revenue strength caught me off guard, while costs clearly rose at a faster pace. Could you break that down for us — on the cost side, what's recurring and what isn't, and what does that actually mean for Europe North margins down the road? You brought up higher site lease expense, and I'm curious whether that came from unfavorable renewals or maybe some COVID abatements that came to an end? And connected to that, the Norway impact that you flagged — can you quantify it? Could you discuss what revenue and EBITDA growth would have looked like excluding that Norway contract going away? Thanks.

David Sailer

executive
#18

I'll take Lance's question first, then hand it over to Justin Cochrane to add more of the details. Look, we've got several contracts that are ramping, and those obviously raise cost, and you see that upfront; we also have property taxes in the U.K. that have gone up and aren't a one-timer; but I'd say the bigger piece is on the rental side, which will settle down over time. As far as margin goes, I don't anticipate significant shifts ahead, based on history and where we stand now. Look, the business grew quite nicely on the top line. Going through the details, the expenses — I'd say site lease is just the usual increases you're going to see. It can be somewhat lumpy from quarter to quarter. I'd probably highlight some of the rental costs; it's a bit on production. That'll likely run a little above normal. Then, the business is actually doing pretty well. Add in bonus from an incentive comp perspective, and that's driving some of that on the margin side. Justin, I don't know if you want to go into more detail, even from a contract standpoint.

Justin Cochrane

executive
#19

Yes, thank you, Dave. There are a few points I want to make. The situation in Norway, I think, is somewhat misleading. That contract brought in significant revenue, but its margin was quite thin. So there's no real impact of substance coming from it. As Dave mentioned, when you look at the margin for the core business compared with last year, it's essentially flat. A handful of minor one-time items popped up, yet none of them matter much, and I wouldn't anticipate any of them altering our margin picture as we move ahead. Without those items showing up this quarter, our margin would have landed close to what we saw a year ago. Nothing structural, in my view, has changed. My sense is that a few little factors caused the margin to dip a bit, and only during this quarter.

Lance Vitanza

analyst
#20

Thanks so much.

Justin Cochrane

executive
#21

Thanks, Lance.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#22

Hi everyone, I appreciate you letting me join. I have 2 questions. In the past, you've mentioned that cancellations tend to signal downturns in your business. As of the previous call, I believe you hadn't observed any significant activity there. Does that remain the case now? Any early signals from your advertising clients regarding commitments for early 2025? And second, regarding the national business in the U.S., as we move into the fourth quarter of 2024 and into 2025, are you experiencing any headwinds from all the streaming ad inventory that has launched this year? Do you believe that's partly why national has stayed choppy over the last 12 months, and something you'd anticipate persisting ahead?

Scott Wells

executive
#23

Thanks, Aaron. Yeah. No, those are a good couple of questions. Regarding cancellations, no, we haven't seen an increase in cancellation activity, and yes, the early 2025 discussions are quite encouraging. We're very early in that renewal season, but we're encouraged by how many parties want to renew and want to renew, possibly with larger commitments, so it's far, far, far too soon to guide on 2025, so please none of you ask me to provide what percentage we'll call for 2025, but I do believe that we're positioned well going into 2025. On national, the money exists. I think that's the key point. The responsibility falls on us to determine how to access that money, whether that's bringing an advertiser to an agency, bringing an idea to an advertiser and getting the advertiser to champion that to an agency, which we're doing more and more, or whether that's being especially creative in how we package solutions when we receive RFPs, which is the primary way much of the national gets done. You've heard us discuss the efforts we've undertaken in areas like pharma and CPG and beer. We're getting very near to bringing someone in to help us concentrate on automotive. That's a sector I think you'll hear us mention more as we proceed. We have existing relationships in telecom and in auto insurance that are important categories. Media and entertainment is an important category where we have relationships at the advertiser level; so we're looking to leverage those advertiser level conversations and help them all see how out of home can amplify what they're doing elsewhere. I can't really comment on cross pressure from all the various streaming inventory that's come online. I do think that, when I look across our global portfolio, I see us getting more TV budgets in every country other than the U.S. A portion of that, I'd chalk up to how many video choices exist in the U.S.; it isn't only the streaming players, though they're likely contributing something to it. As an industry, I truly believe we shouldn't hide behind the lack of video as a justification. That's a hurdle. What's true is that video gets magnified by our assets, and clever advertisers blend various ad formats to make their campaigns land as efficiently as possible. Proving that to them falls on our shoulders, and getting it accomplished is the goal—so that's where our national focus sits. I doubt things will get smoother in the near term, simply because of how frequently CMO turnover happens. Right now there are also plenty of CEO transitions occurring globally. Plenty of factors exist that push people to alter strategy and shift course. What matters most for us is having a seat with the right individuals, so that whenever those shifts occur, we're included in that discussion.

Aaron Watts

analyst
#24

Very helpful. Thanks, Scott.

Scott Wells

executive
#25

Thanks, Aaron.

Jessica Hastings

analyst
#26

Hi, this is Jessica Hastings sitting in for David Karnovsky. I just have one question about local; for you folks, it keeps outperforming the rest of the industry. Macro conditions have helped, but could you discuss whether other secular dynamics are at play, and how big categories such as legal or services are moving toward billboard? I'm trying to gauge how sustainable this is once you look past the economy. Thanks.

Scott Wells

executive
#27

That question covers a lot of ground. Legal has clearly been a significant vertical for us, no doubt about it. In our conversations with legal entities — and a moment ago I mentioned certain verticals we're targeting nationwide — legal is one we've pursued at the local level for quite a while; in our markets we have people who understand deeply the strategies various legal service providers are following and the ways we can complement them. We aim to do the same with categories such as auto dealers, restaurants, and retail, and we're working to varying degrees on going after those. The key point, I believe, is that the local advertising marketplace remains very much contested among local outlets and other local media, perhaps including things such as search, since it can present itself as intensely local, as can social. Competition in the local market is lively and vibrant. We're growing our teams at the local level. We're growing capabilities at the local level. We're training staff on selling alongside digital and on amplifying digital campaigns. Many efforts are underway to keep that portion of the business moving forward. Another aspect of local, I'd say, is that local agencies operate somewhat differently from national ones, the way large holding company agencies do. That opens up certain opportunities at the local level. The encouraging part is that we're an intensely local medium. We're a medium where people enjoy seeing their product supported at that local level and feel confident that we have a solid runway of growth opportunity there, simply considering how much advertising is spent locally and what our relative share of it amounts to.

Jessica Hastings

analyst
#28

Great. Thank you very much.

Patrick Sholl

analyst
#29

Thanks. Morning, everyone. I wanted to ask whether you could address the airport side, given the softer digital growth in that segment. And then, coming back to the MTA, I suppose when you add a contract that size and ramp it up, how do you approach limiting cannibalization from other assets in that market?

Scott Wells

executive
#30

Sure. So, Pat, I'll begin with digital growth at airports. Dave mentioned this a moment ago, I believe, but as far as our comp goes, we've set quarterly records in airports for several quarters running, likely dating back to early 2023. That space has been growing quite significantly for us. Regarding how digital and printed split in airports, what you've really observed, looking back at our digital growth across those periods, is that it served as the primary driver for a good portion of that stretch, and part of what you're seeing, I think, is simply some rebalancing. Just a few deals can push you either way here — if advertisers are pursuing domination on printed assets, that can make the printed figure jump. I don't have a play-by-play for each campaign, but consider what the advertiser is aiming to achieve: frequently they want to dominate share of voice in a given location. Printed assets are an excellent means of doing that. We see it happen. For years, I think people anticipated that printed roadside assets would contract as digital assets expanded. Digital assets have expanded, yet printed has maintained its position and in most quarters has posted some growth. This quarter, the roadside printed growth we had was quite healthy. So I'd attribute it partly to advertiser preference and partly to how campaigns are falling into place. I'm definitely not hearing anything indicating a problem with digital sales at airports. It was likely just a few print-heavy, share-of-voice-heavy campaigns that landed, Pat. That covers airport digital growth, and I hope it's clearer for you. As for New York inventory, the truth is our footprint in New York is disproportionately concentrated in Times Square and on large assets at choke points such as tunnels and bridges. Before this contract goes live tomorrow, we lacked a particularly strong run-of-market distribution. What this provides is a very healthy distribution along and around the I-95 and LIE corridors, so we really shouldn't anticipate much cannibalization from it. As I said quickly at the start, we ran some of these assets — not at all the entire portfolio we've just acquired, but roughly 20% of it — before 2017, when MTA consolidated and put that set of assets out to bid for the first time. These are regions we're acquainted with, and regions we understand thoroughly, yet there aren't many other assets of ours from which to shift things over. For us, this ought to be very largely incremental. I hope that addresses your questions.

Patrick Sholl

analyst
#31

Yes, thank you.

Scott Wells

executive
#32

Great, we appreciate both the questions and everyone's participation. I suppose the note I'd want to leave things on is this: during a period when the election has created uncertainty, and with continuing questions about where the country's macro direction is headed and what's coming next, when I examine our business, what I see is that in Q3 we're hitting records across every one of our main business lines. A healthy company ought to be regularly setting records, so I don't especially want to pound my chest about any of it, but I do want to point out that there's been this persistent worry about what might be waiting around the corner and where things stood. I won't claim there's no uncertainty out there, or that a recession or similar developments couldn't happen. Considering how this business has performed amid substantial unpredictability in certain areas where we've been making sales, that ought to earn us considerable trust in our capacity to deliver. To close, I simply want to express gratitude to the teams for everything they've accomplished on those fronts, which has put us in a spot where we're setting records throughout the portfolio. Hope everybody has a great Halloween and kicks off the holidays well, since from this point on, things only speed up. Thanks, all.

Operator

operator
#33

Thanks. That brings today's call to a close. At this point you're free to hang up, and we appreciate you having joined us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.