Constellation Brands, Inc. (STZ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 6, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Patty Yahn-Urlaub
executiveAppreciate that, Josh. Hello everyone, and thanks for joining us for Constellation's conference call covering the second quarter of fiscal '22. Joining me this morning are Bill Newlands, who serves as our CEO, and Garth Hankinson, our CFO. Just a quick note that reconciliations comparing the most directly comparable GAAP measure with any non-GAAP financial measures we discuss today can be found in our news release or are otherwise posted on the company's website, cbrands.com. For risk factors that could affect the forward-looking statements we're making on this call, please look at the news release along with Constellation's SEC filings. <<operator_script>> We appreciate that, and now I'll hand things over to Bill.
Bill Newlands
executiveThanks, Patty. Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining our Q2 call. Let's jump straight into talking about the quarter. A variety of pluses and minuses affected what we delivered in Q2, and Garth and I will take the time to go through each of them. That said, our business fundamentals are still solid, and demand from consumers for our brands — especially our core beer portfolio — is still strong. That's why we feel confident raising our EPS guidance for this year, which we laid out in today's press release and Garth will go over in greater depth soon. On top of that, during Q2 we bought back a meaningful amount of stock at prices we consider attractive, since we think Constellation shares are undervalued where they currently trade. Investors have shared some feedback with us on this subject over recent weeks, and we'll speak to the main themes coming out of those conversations in our comments. As we take you through how Q2 went and what we expect for the rest of the year, here are a few important points to hold onto. First, the momentum behind our core imported beer brands is a source of competitive advantage relative to others in the industry, since we're gaining the most share within the high end of the U.S. beer market. Modelo Especial keeps driving most of our growth, backed by robust consumer demand for Corona Extra and Pacifico, and we see that carrying on well into the future; we still think Modelo Especial specifically has a lengthy growth runway, thanks to household penetration that keeps climbing among non-Hispanic consumers along with sustained strong velocity. Now, we've obviously faced certain supply issues during this fiscal year caused by a handful of outside factors, chiefly the continued vigorous demand for our beer brands. We anticipate getting back to more typical inventory levels by the time Q4 ends. Even with those issues, we remain on course to produce a year for our beer business that beats expectations. Actually, how well we've done so far gives us the confidence to raise guidance for our beer business, and we now anticipate net sales growth of 9% to 11% along with operating income growth of 4% to 6% for fiscal '22. Our thinking is bolstered by recent 12-week IRI trends that show Constellation's beer business growing well ahead of both the high end and the entire U.S. beer industry. Second point. Turning to our hard seltzer business and extending what we just said, we hold a position unlike that of our rivals in this category, because our main growth comes from our core beer portfolio, and we don't depend on hard seltzers and ABAs growing in order to hit the medium-term growth targets for our beer business. The hard seltzer picture has changed a great deal over recent months. So we've reduced our growth projections for Corona Hard Seltzer, which produced a substantial obsolescence charge in Q2, reflecting our estimate of the full impact across the fiscal year. To make this clear, we still view hard seltzer and the wider ABA category as a significant part of the beer market. We also remain convinced that it matters to take part in this segment and capture our fair share, so that it complements growth in our core imported beer portfolio and preserves our standing as a leader in the U.S. high-end beer market. Looking ahead, our plan is to concentrate on competing there by providing meaningful points of differentiation and unique value to consumers. I'll say more about that shortly. Third, although our wine and spirits business faced challenges this quarter — several mainstream brands underperformed because of tough COVID comparisons, along with our recent route-to-market transition and supply chain difficulties for our imported wine brands — we still see the advantages of our premiumization strategy gaining traction. We're doing well in the high end of wine, which accounts for the vast majority of expected industry growth over the next several years, and we keep strengthening capabilities in emerging growth channels essential to long-term success, such as e-commerce and DTC. Fourth, we keep improving how we approach innovation, using a more consistent, strategic, disciplined and consumer-led method, with emphasis on high-growth segments that align with consumer trends. Our innovation agenda is built to complement organic growth, and we're creating sustainable products that are incremental to our business while further premiumizing our portfolio into margin-accretive price points. Over the years, we've managed to extend some brands into new spaces, recruit new drinkers and expand occasions, and we've struck a healthy balance between growth from the core and from innovation. Fifth, our capital allocation strategy hasn't changed since I took on the CEO role almost 3 years ago. Since then, we've made meaningful progress cutting debt and reaching our objective of returning $5 billion in value to shareholders by the end of fiscal year '23 through a mix of dividends and share repurchases. In fact, so far this fiscal year, we have bought back 1.4 billion of our shares; combined with our dividend, that means we've achieved nearly 60% of our 5 billion goal. To put it plainly, our shareholder value equation rests on outsized growth together with returning dollars to shareholders. A key capital allocation priority is to keep reinvesting in our beer business so we can keep pace with robust demand for our products. Despite early difficulties tied to building out a third brewery in Mexico, we have shifted to other capacity alternatives in that country. Our expansions in Nava and Obregon helped make sure we have sufficient production capacity for the medium term and will create much needed redundant capacity that better allows us to manage through unexpected events like those we've experienced these past 2 years. Our discussions with the Mexican authorities are ongoing as we finalize the blueprint for a brand-new brewing facility in the southeastern part of Mexico, one that will have sufficient water resources and a skilled labor pool available. Now, let's turn to a fuller conversation regarding how we performed in the quarter. Within that quarter, the Modelo brand family achieved depletion growth of 17%, and all by itself it propelled overall import share gains across IRI channels measured on a dollar basis. Ranked as the #2 beer brand by dollar sales across the whole U.S. beer category, Modelo Especial stands alone among major beer brands in expanding household penetration and is out front as the #1 share gainer within high-end brands. Modelo Chelada has grown into the #2 brand family in the Chelada segment, delivering depletion growth of more than 50% during the second quarter. Corona Extra keeps up its upward trajectory as the second fastest share gainer and the #1 loved brand in the import category, fueled by a return to growth in the on-premise channel, which right now accounts for roughly 11% of our beer business volume. Beyond what I said earlier regarding our hard seltzers, I want to talk about industry trends and our renewed strategy for this portion of the beer market moving forward.
Bill Newlands
executiveLooking ahead a bit, we expect some consolidation to happen among hard seltzer and ABA brands. The main reason is all the clutter from too many SKUs and brands flooding in, with plenty of newcomers lacking the sales pace or customer pull needed to justify keeping them on shelves. On top of that, we see this subcategory moving past the low-calorie, low-carb style and opening up to sharper value propositions for consumers, things such as richer flavor, alternative alcohol bases and functional advantages. We're already innovating along those lines with unique items such as Refresca and Limonada. Another thing we've learned is that people want bolder taste and flavor from their seltzers. We're also going to tweak how our seltzer lineup tastes and feels so it better matches what consumers are looking for as their preferences change, and we'll simultaneously introduce single-serve packs to reach the convenience channel, which is growing and represents our largest trade channel. On top of that, we still have a robust pipeline of innovation that hasn't launched yet. Looking at our wine and spirits portfolio, there are several clear examples showing how our innovation strategy works in practice; this segment continues to deliver growth from products introduced recently, including Meiomi Cabernet Sauvignon, Kim Crawford Illuminate, and the Prisoner Cabernet and Chardonnay, and each of those landed in the top 10 innovations for high-end wine in IRI channels for the quarter. Heading into our busiest sales stretch, we've got more consumer-driven new items lined up in wine and spirits innovation, including a broader SVEDKA ready-to-drink offering plus the debut of Woodbridge wine seltzers and box wines. Beyond innovation-driven expansion, we're gaining traction with our core wine and spirits lineup despite the headwinds mentioned earlier. We continue to push pricing higher to premiumize our mainstream range further, because those steps are essential to protecting brand equity and boosting profitability, which pays off for our brands over the long term. We're notching wins in a number of places where we're outperforming the U.S. wine market. Net sales for our high-end super premium plus portfolio grew at a double-digit rate in the quarter. When it comes to on-premise, the money we've put in is paying off — better wine selections at big restaurant groups are driving results. We're also making headway in important up-and-coming channels, including 3-tier e-commerce and direct-to-consumer, and those continue to power premium growth. In those spaces, at major accounts such as Instacart, Amazon and Albertsons, we're outperforming the category as online shopping comes roaring back because of the COVID pandemic. As an example, over the most recent 12 weeks Constellation's fine wine share has risen considerably, driven by robust gains for the Prisoner on Instacart and Robert Mondavi Winery on wine.com. Indeed, compared with 2019, e-commerce and DTC sales are roughly 3 to 4x higher, and they represent about 3% to 5% of our business, whereas before the pandemic that figure was 1%. Looking ahead, our emphasis will stay on establishing ourselves as a leader within e-commerce and DTC, since we expect those channels to account for a meaningful share of our overall mix down the road, and they should keep offering potential for premium growth. I also want to bring you up to speed on the U.S. harvest, which stands roughly 70% finished right now, and I'm glad to say our production facilities, wineries and tasting rooms have not been affected by the recent wildfires. During this quarter, our ventures work featured investments in HOP WTR, which is infused with adaptogens, plus Dos Hombres Mezcal, the artisanal brand from Aaron Paul and Bryan Cranston. HOP WTR is a zero-alcohol, zero-calorie sparkling water. It has adaptogens plus new tropics mixed in, giving health-conscious drinkers what they want: a perfect blend of usefulness and taste. In 2020, dollar sales in IRI channels for the nonalcoholic segment of total beverage alcohol rose almost 40%. Research from IWSR shows us that on a single occasion, 60% of consumers switch back and forth between no-alcohol or low-alcohol choices and full-strength beverages. Dos Hombres is a handcrafted mezcal brand that has won awards, founded by two co-stars of Breaking Bad, who came up with an outstanding liquid that gets regular acclaim from the trade as well as from shoppers. The overall U.S. Based on data from IWSR, the mezcal segment expanded by 14% during 2020, and mezcal in the super premium tier—anything priced over $30 per barrel—is expected to become both the biggest and quickest-growing portion of that category. Now shifting to Canopy growth: we take encouragement from the cannabis opportunity's recent inclusion in an administration draft bill, brought forward in July by Senators Booker, Wyden and Schumer. Over 90% of Americans support cannabis legislation for medical purposes, and two-thirds of that group also back legalization for recreational use; as a matter of fact, almost 2 out of 3 Americans already enjoy legal cannabis access, given that 37 states have legalized for medical use and 18 states for adult use. Although we're hopeful that federal laws will change during this congressional term, Canopy isn't sitting around waiting for that to happen. During their latest quarter, Canopy's American operations saw 91% growth compared with the same period a year earlier, fueled by strong shopper interest in their CBD and CPG offerings—this includes items bearing Martha Stewart's name, Quatreau drinks, retail locations and vape goods, plus BioSteel's newly launched RTDs. Looking ahead, Canopy's U.S. revenue is projected to expand considerably in the years to come, thanks to wider distribution and the rollout of additional products. When THC is eventually permitted across the United States, Canopy anticipates that its American division will deliver a much larger share of overall company performance. Canopy has built out a multistate plan for getting products to market, positioned for when legalization arrives, and it has tapped Constellation's ties with distributors to drive its U.S. business in non-THC products, with additional chances opening up once federal permission exists. On the whole, Canopy's advances leave us at ease, and we anticipate expansion along with the possibilities legalization would bring for that business; to wrap up, let me restate the key points we want you to take from this quarter. First, steady, strong demand for the imported beer brands we lead with hands us an advantage over rivals in the sector. Modelo Especial leads the way — it's the top share gainer within the beer category — and we believe there's plenty of room for it to keep expanding far into the future, since household penetration among non-Hispanic drinkers keeps climbing steadily and velocity remains strong. The near-term supply hiccup affecting our imported beer operations doesn't weaken our longer-term outlook at all. We anticipate getting back to more typical inventory positions by the close of Q4, and we remain on course to post a stronger-than-anticipated year for the beer business. Next, the hard seltzer category along with the wider ABA segment still strikes us as a significant part of the beer market. Moving forward, our intent is to compete there by delivering real differentiation and distinctive value to consumers, and we're excited about some innovation we have coming in that area. Third, the advantages of our premiumization playbook for wine and spirits keep materializing. We're posting solid results at the upper end of wine, and we keep building up our abilities in emerging growth channels that matter for long-term success, including e-commerce and DTC. Lastly, we keep refining how we pursue innovation, using a steadier, more disciplined, consumer-driven method aimed at high-growth segments that match consumer trends. This supports our organic growth while we create sustainable items that add incrementally to the business at price points that lift margins.
Bill Newlands
executiveAnd fifth—definitely not the least important—our formula for creating shareholder value is still built around exceptional growth paired with giving cash back to investors. Let me say again: when it comes to allocating capital, nothing has changed. We're still dedicated to delivering $5 billion of value back to shareholders before fiscal year '23 wraps up, using dividends along with share buybacks. Thanks to solid operating results and the cash we generated, we were able to buy back a substantial number of shares during Q2, consistent with what we promised, and that helped push our EPS outlook for the year higher. Meanwhile, we're still focused on putting money back into the business, especially in beer, so we can meet the strong demand for what we sell. With that said, I'll hand things over to Garth, who's going to walk us through the quarter's financial results. Garth?
Garth Hankinson
executiveThanks, Bill, and hello everyone. Without question, the second quarter delivered another strong stretch of marketplace performance for our beer segment. Because consumer demand for our leading beer brands has stayed powerful and consistent, we now expect to exceed both the top line and operating income targets we originally established for the beer business. Beyond that, the strong cash flow we produced allowed us to continue repurchasing stock during the quarter; and through September, we bought back 6.2 million shares of common stock, spending $1.4 billion. As a result, we've lifted our goal for full year fiscal 2022 comparable basis diluted EPS, and we now expect to finish in the range of $10.15 to $10.45. That forecast doesn't include the equity and earnings effects from Canopy. What it does include is the improved operating income projection for beer, as well as the reduced weighted average diluted share count — a figure driven by repurchases completed through September, though a higher tax rate for fiscal year 2022 partially cancels that out. Let's now go deeper into how Q2 went and what we expect for the entire year, and I'll focus mainly on comparable basis financial results. Starting with beer: net sales climbed 14%, driven by shipment volume increasing just under 12% and favorable pricing, with unfavorable mix providing a partial offset. During the quarter, depletion volume increased by more than 7%, driven by Modelo Especial and Corona Extra continuing to perform well, and by the on-premise channel's sustained recovery. Compared with Q1, depletion trends eased in Q2, a result of out-of-stocks caused by persistently strong consumer demand, as well as shipping days lost by some of our distributors due to severe weather events, including hurricanes and wildfires. According to our estimates, those factors trimmed about 2 to 3 points off Q2 growth. On-premise volume accounted for roughly 11% of total beer depletions in the quarter and posted strong double-digit growth versus the prior year, as Bill mentioned. Just to remind everyone, before COVID hit, around 15% of the beer we depleted came from the on-premise channel, while in the second quarter of fiscal 2021 that figure dropped to only 6%, a result of the shutdowns and restrictions tied to COVID-19 affecting on-premise locations. The number of selling days this quarter matched last year's count, and Q3 will see the same. Throughout Q2, wholesaler depletions continued to exceed cases shipped, so distributor inventory sitting on hand when the quarter ended was below what we'd typically expect. To address that imbalance, we anticipate that cases shipped will exceed cases depleted during the entire back half of this fiscal year. As a result, distributor stock levels should improve steadily across Q3 and Q4, and we expect those inventories to be back at typical levels once the fiscal year wraps up. Now, on to beer margins. Our beer operating margin dropped 530 basis points year over year, landing at 37.2%. Gains from better pricing, product mix and foreign exchange were outweighed by negative COGS, heavier spending on marketing and elevated SG&A. Several pressures drove COGS higher, and they are as follows: first, a $66 million obsolescence charge in Q2. Since we hit production constraints during the earlier part of this year, we stockpiled hard seltzer before the key summer sales window, relying on our strongest forecasts for fiscal year 2022. Given that the hard seltzer segment across the U.S. is decelerating generally, some of that anticipated growth will not materialize within the fiscal year, leaving us holding too much inventory. Next, brewery expenses have climbed because of wage inflation in Mexico, a larger workforce, and extra outlays related to expanding capacity. Finally, depreciation expense has increased, largely driven by the additional 5 million hectoliters at Obregon. To wrap up, our material expenses climbed, just like we expected they would, driven largely by commodities getting more expensive and inflation affecting what we pay for pallets, cartons, and aluminum; those COGS pressures were partially balanced out by beneficial fixed cost absorption. On the marketing side, spending measured against net sales increased 150 basis points, landing at 9.9 compared with the same period a year ago, reflecting our return to a typical spending pattern that puts greater weight on the fiscal year's first half. Keep in mind that during the first half of last year, marketing outlays were considerably reduced owing to sporting and sponsorship events tied to COVID-19 being called off and/or pushed back. And finally, the rise in SG&A was mostly attributable to legal expenses running about $12 million higher, plus increased compensation and benefits. To build on what was said before, for our beer business we're lifting the guidance on both net sales and operating income for the full fiscal year 2022. Our new target for net sales growth is 9% to 11%, which mirrors how well our core beer portfolio is doing along with pricing moves that came in above what we'd originally mapped out. On top of that, we're now aiming for operating income growth of 4% to 6%, and that points to an operating margin sitting somewhere between the low end and the midpoint of the 39% to 40% range we laid out. One thing to keep in mind: this revised guidance factors in every obsolescence charge and legal expense we took on during the first half of the fiscal year. For the fiscal year, we still anticipate that our gross margin will take a hit, since gains from pricing and our cost savings program are likely to be outweighed by a number of cost headwinds. That said, the composition and size of those headwinds differ from what we originally assumed when the fiscal year began. To start, we continue to project a sizable rise in depreciation expense, which started ramping up in Q2. Even so, a portion of that depreciation kicked in later in the year than we had planned. Because of that, our current estimate for total beer depreciation expense is roughly $250 million, which is about $55 million higher than last year, or $10 million lower than the estimate in our original plan. Second, we continue to anticipate significant inflation-related pressure on many cost inputs through the back half of our fiscal year, since commodity prices keep climbing — particularly for aluminum, diesel and pallets — amid a fairly unstable inflationary marketplace. Third, given that growth in the hard seltzer category has decelerated and new products within it are receiving reduced ACV levels, our hard seltzer SKUs are not expected to reach the volumes we had initially anticipated, which produces a beneficial mix effect relative to our original projections. Conversely, because the hard seltzer segment has slowed, excess inventory resulted in an obsolescence charge of about $80 million for the fiscal year to date. Remember that these write-offs cover the entirety of what we had tied up in hard seltzer obsolescence. Given that, no additional charges related to obsolete hard seltzer are expected from us over the rest of this fiscal year. Where marketing is concerned, our projection for the full year remains unchanged: spending should land somewhere between 9% and 10% of net sales, which is in line with the 9.7% of net sales we spent in fiscal 2021. Now, looking at Q3, everyone should keep in mind the difficult buying comparisons coming our way, as shipment volume faces a 28% comparison and depletion volume faces a 12% comparison. We also expect to carry out our usual annual brewery maintenance in Q3, meaning less throughput than Q2 because production must be halted for a few days. So for Q3, we're projecting low single-digit growth in shipment volume. Now on to wine and spirits.
Garth Hankinson
executiveIn Q2 of fiscal 2022, net sales declined 18%, and shipment volume came in at 36%. When you exclude the impact of the wine and spirits divestitures, organic net sales climbed 15%, driven by organic shipment volume growth of nearly 6%, along with favorable mix and price as well as smoke-tainted bulk wine sales. Strong mix, led by the Prisoner brand family, Meiomi and Kim Crawford, accounted for about 9 points of that organic net sales increase versus the prior year. Shipments were hurt by port delays affecting our international brands and by route-to-market changes, and depletions also suffered. Depletion volume declined 2% in the quarter, and it also ran into a difficult comparison against consumer pantry loading behavior, especially among our mainstream brands that grew strongly in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic. That said, as we head into the back half of the fiscal year, we think most of these challenges are now behind us, and we anticipate shipment volume and depletion volume will broadly align during the second half of fiscal 2022. Now turning to wine and spirits margins. Operating margin decreased 620 basis points to 19.7%, as mix benefits from the existing portfolio and divestitures, along with favorable price, were more than offset by greater marketing and SG&A spend, higher COGS and margin-dilutive smoke-tainted bulk wine sales. The COGS increase was driven by unfavorable fixed cost absorption and higher transportation costs. That unfavorable fixed cost absorption resulted from lower production levels in New Zealand due to a frost during their harvest season earlier this year, as well as lower production levels at our California wineries stemming from the 2020 U.S. wildfires. Lower grape raw materials and other cost savings initiatives partially offset these headwinds. Keep in mind that we're lapping lower SG&A spend in Q2 fiscal 2021 because of COVID and a much smaller business following the divestitures, which creates significant marketing and SG&A deleveraging and pressures operating margins. For the full fiscal year 2022, the wine and spirits business still expects net sales and operating income to decline 22% to 24% and 23% to 25%, respectively. That implies an operating margin of approximately 24%, which is flattish versus the prior year on a reported basis, reflecting considerable margin expansion on an organic basis. Once you exclude the wine experience divestitures, organic net sales should increase in the 2% to 4% range. Looking at Q3, remember that we are lapping $20 million of unfavorable fixed cost absorption from the prior year caused by lower production levels stemming from the 2020 U.S. wildfires. We expect that favorable overlap to be partly offset by continuing increases in transportation costs and additional unfavorable fixed cost absorption tied to the New Zealand frost. On top of that, we still expect marketing and SG&A deleveraging stemming from the wine and spirits divestitures. Because of that, marketing and SG&A should remain a meaningful drag on operating margins in Q3 fiscal 2022. Fiscal year-to-date corporate expenses came in at approximately $170 million. Now let's move on to the remainder of the P&L. Turning to corporate expenses, for the fiscal year to date they came in at approximately $170 million. Looking at corporate expenses for the fiscal year so far, they landed at roughly $117 million, which represents a 7% climb compared with the same period a year ago. That rise mostly came from spending more on consulting services along with compensation and benefits, though a favorable foreign currency impact partially offset it. Our current projection for the entire year's corporate expenses sits near $245 million, with the growth in compensation and benefits being the main driver. On a comparable basis, interest expense for the quarter was down 4%, landing at about $96 million against the prior year, largely because average borrowings were lower. For fiscal 2022, we're now looking at interest expense somewhere between $355 million and $365 million. That modest reduction from what we guided previously comes from redeeming higher interest rate debt earlier than planned, plus the $1 billion of senior notes we issued in July at appealing rates. Our Q2 comparable basis effective tax rate, once Canopy equity earnings are excluded, was 21.8%, compared with 16.9% in last year's Q2. The main factors there were the timing of stock-based compensation benefits and a higher effective tax rate on our foreign businesses. For the full fiscal 2022 year, we now anticipate a comparable tax rate — again excluding Canopy equity and earnings — of about 20%, up from the 19% we guided before. That bump stems largely from foreign earnings being taxed at a higher effective rate than we'd initially projected. I'd also point out that stock-based compensation tax benefits should be weighted toward Q4. Consequently, our Q3 tax rate should exceed our full year estimate, coming in around 21%. Additionally, we now expect 2022 weighted average diluted shares outstanding to be roughly 192 million, which reflects the September year-to-date share repurchases we already discussed. Turning to free cash flow — our definition being net cash provided by operating activities minus CapEx — we brought in $1.2 billion during the first half of fiscal 2022, flat versus the prior year, as strong operating cash flows were offset by higher CapEx. CapEx came to $353 million, including about $295 million of beer CapEx, mainly from expansion initiatives at our Mexico facilities. Our full year CapEx guidance remains $1 billion to $1.1 billion, with approximately $900 million of that targeted at Mexican beer operation expansions, unchanged from before. On top of that, we still anticipate fiscal 2022 free cash flow landing between $1.4 billion and $1.5 billion. That figure reflects operating cash flow of $2.4 billion to $2.6 billion along with the CapEx spending I just outlined. To wrap up, I want to reiterate that although we faced our share of challenges in the first half of this fiscal year, producing a number of puts and takes that affected our results, our business fundamentals stay strong, and consumer demand for our products — especially our imported beer portfolio — remains robust, giving us solid momentum as we move into the back half of our fiscal year. Having said that, Bill and I are now prepared to answer any questions you may have.
Dara Mohsenian
analystTurning to beer revenue, I have a detailed question first. With all this volatility and the hard comparison in Q3, could you update us on where September depletions stand right now? Also, for the quarter, do you still anticipate depletions coming in higher than the low single-digit shipment rate you referenced? Or does that become difficult against the tough 12% depletion comp? Then, second, on the longer-term side, you lifted this year's revenue guidance. How much of that comes from underlying demand strength and depletions versus shipments, maybe versus getting more supply in place through the rest of the year, versus pricing? And regarding pricing, you've publicly sounded more aggressive about pricing expectations going forward. A — am I getting that right? And second, is the main purpose here to counterbalance rising commodity expenses? Or does it signal greater assurance about picking up share in the market, or that conditions among consumers make it feasible to raise prices at this point?
Bill Newlands
executiveAbsolutely, Dara. I'll give that a try. And should I leave anything out, Garth is able to jump in afterward. As for September depletes, our expectation is that they'll line up pretty closely with the trends we've seen so far this year. September is almost completely finished for us. Bear in mind, we're up against a 20% gain from September a year ago. That makes for quite a strong beginning to the quarter. We think depletions will keep running higher than shipments, for the reasons Garth mentioned in his remarks. So for that period of time, we'd anticipate depletions coming in above that level. Pricing right now is still fairly solid. Like we've said, we expect to be a bit ahead of our normal algorithm, and that's mostly because we're taking pricing on certain SKUs that we hadn't planned on earlier in the year, rather than doing anything unusual to grab extra pricing beyond what we'd already mapped out. Garth, is there anything you'd like to add?
Garth Hankinson
executiveNo, when it comes to depletions for this quarter, growth in depletions is definitely going to be greater than growth in shipments during the quarter. But looking at it in absolute terms, shipments are going to be higher than depletions, and that puts us in a stronger spot when it comes to inventory.
Bill Newlands
executiveYeah. Just remember, like we've mentioned, the stock we have sitting with our distributors is under the level both we and they would prefer to maintain consistently; so as we bring those inventory positions back to where they ought to be by the close of the fiscal year, we'd anticipate replenishing a portion of that.
Bonnie Herzog
analystAll right. I'd like to follow up on the outlook you provided. If I run the numbers and take the middle of your revised full-year beer forecast, it implies a pretty sharp drop in the latter six months. For example, based on your updated guidance, second-half beer shipment volumes grow around 4% to 4.5%, income rises 3%, and beer margins come in at 39%, compared with 40% beer margins in the first half — and that first half did include the $80 million obsolescence charge you flagged. So I'm trying to figure out how much conservatism you've baked into the new FY guidance, especially where margins are concerned, given that you said there won't be any further charges in the second half. You brought up the incremental pricing move, and you also flagged a number of other things that should help; so I want to make sure there isn't something else I'm missing, or that something has shifted.
Garth Hankinson
executiveAppreciate that, Bonnie. Let me try to take you through the margin picture, all right? Like you said, we've got certain factors working against us and certain ones working in our favor, right? So let's just look at the favorable side. Naturally, as we said during my opening remarks, depreciation gives us somewhat of a lift purely because it kicked in later in the year than we had anticipated, which makes it a positive overall. And like Bill just walked through, we're doing more — we're applying higher prices to a wider set of SKUs than what we had initially intended. That puts us over the top end of the range, which helps us overall. Seltzers are also giving us a favorable mix, another plus. The better outlook for core beer is a plus as well — those are the positives — yet the negatives we've discussed throughout the year remain. Depreciation is trending below what we projected, but it's still going to rise during the back half. We're also still up against higher costs for commodities — aluminum, diesel, natural gas, wood — and that pressure carries into the second half. At this point, we believe that the forecast we gave you factors in every one of those higher costs. So in our view, those are handled. That said, we keep seeing these pluses and minuses come up, and we remain confident about the profitability projection we shared. Also worth remembering: although seltzers will give us a blend-related lift, we will still be selling them, and as we've said before, they pull margins down.
Nik Modi
analystI've got two questions. The first one is very brief, and it concerns the seltzer reformulation. Bill, I realize you likely prefer not to share excessive specifics before it hits shelves, but is there going to be a shift in calories or sugar content? That's all I'm wondering about. Then, on a wider note, Modelo is obviously performing strongly. The data reflects that among non-Hispanic shoppers. Yet when we examine certain numerator figures and various cohorts, what stands out is that Corona seems tied to some of those demographic groups where Modelo is faring far better. You're noticing those figures worsening. So I just wanted to understand the incrementality of Modelo when you consider Modelo and Corona side by side. And do you ever consider that perhaps a different merchandising approach could be used rather than placing the two brands directly adjacent to each other, in order to lessen some of that cannibalization?
Bill Newlands
executiveSure; regarding your first brief item, there won't be a drastic alteration to how our seltzer is currently formulated. When it comes to Modelo and Corona, clearly, those two brands interact, just as you'd anticipate; nonetheless, as we've stated previously, Nik, and I'm certain you're well aware, our household penetration for Modelo remains considerably lower than Corona's, not to mention it trails other brands that — that it goes up against. So although it's accurate to say that when Modelo expands or when Corona expands, it does come at the expense of some of our brands; we still view it as mostly favorable given that growth trajectory; and as we've discussed previously, Modelo, it keeps increasing velocity. There's plenty — still plenty of room to grow distribution. The household penetration, which I mentioned moments ago, stays a huge opportunity for that. And we began advertising to the non-Hispanic community only about 3.5 years back. So we're truly only at the beginning with Modelo and the chance it offers; so although you'll keep seeing some interaction, and obviously, I believe the notion of separating those at retail to some extent holds some potential, I believe, on the whole, we remain concentrated on growing our footprint for both of those brands. As you likely observed, Corona Extra had a really strong quarter; and it simply demonstrates the continued strength of the core Corona franchise alongside outstanding results from Modelo.
Lauren Lieberman
analystRegarding Corona Extra, I want some more detail, because you brought up that the brand grew depletions by 5% and how that splits between the on-premise bounce-back and tracked channels — or actually off-premise, I should say. I also hoped you could compare Nielsen/IRI with the off-premise trends you saw overall, including untracked outlets. Finally, is there any news on Pacifico? I'm always curious to learn where things stand with that brand, whether you're gaining ground or not.
Bill Newlands
executiveAbsolutely. So about 50%, give or take, of the growth we recorded for Corona Extra is attributable to the on-premise reopening. On earlier calls, we've talked about how, several quarters ago, when the first COVID pandemic situation was at its worst, our business dropped to just 3%. Today, that number sits at 11%. Obviously, since Corona ranks among the most beloved brands in this segment, the growth you'd anticipate as on-premise venues reopen has been significant—but don't overlook this: Corona Extra has also performed strongly in retail. Turning to Pacifico, our view remains that it represents yet another major opportunity. Think of it as a smaller-scale Modelo. It's developing in a very similar way to what Modelo did, say, 20 years ago with extensive growth profile on the West Coast and as it's starting to filter East. We've been putting more money behind Pacifico than we used to. This quarter we ran into a bit of trouble with brown glass, and that hurt Pacifico somewhat, and Modelo Negra got hit too. Still, these are just the usual supply chain headaches we're sorting out. It hasn't changed anything — it only held back what we think will be yet another fantastic brand for us down the road with Pacifico.
Chris Carey
analystRegarding hard seltzers — you'd initially intended to put a fairly substantial amount of money behind this year's launch. With the category having decelerated, are you now able to recapture any of that planned spending? Or is it already committed? And presumably that could set up a favorable narrative as we head into fiscal '23. Also, you said there's a plan to double capacity for your ABAs; so how do you think about shifting that capacity over to beer? Clearly, a new brewery in Southeast Mexico is under consideration. Given the capacity you'd have, does this push back that new build-out at some point?
Garth Hankinson
executiveYes. Appreciate the question. Let's take the capacity item first, okay? As we said last spring, we were putting money into 5 million hectoliters of ABA capacity. That continues on schedule and ought to come online earlier in our fiscal year 2023; it remains a key initiative for us since, as Bill laid out in his prepared remarks, even though the seltzer category has decelerated, the ABA segment within beer is still a dynamic and meaningful piece of the high end, and it's a space we must compete in. And with dedicated ABA capacity, we free up capacity for our core Mexican beer portfolio. So that proceeds as planned. Then additionally, regarding the investment you brought up in the first part of your — in your question, we did say we'd spend $60 million this fiscal year behind Corona Hard Seltzer. The bulk of that spend was scheduled for the first half of the year. So it has been spent, and whatever wasn't spent is being redirected to invest behind our core Mexican beer portfolio.
Bill Newlands
executiveRegarding the final portion of what you asked, the sole additional point I would make concerns whether any delay might result in our plans for investment in the Southeast. We remain engaged with the Mexican government, as I mentioned. Our view is that the Southeast is extremely likely to be the location for our next brewery site. And because demand has been robust, as we have stated, we will keep investing in order to support our business. So no significant shift in our timeline is something we would anticipate. Demand has come in above what we projected. As we have mentioned on earlier calls, we need to build some redundancy into our system. A brewery located in the Southeast will be a core component of that strategy.
Vivien Azer
analystCould you share your thoughts on how on-premise performed during the quarter — did you notice any shift or weakening tied to the Delta variant? Also, from a broader industry angle, are you seeing any shifts in what consumers choose to drink across TBA, any movement between categories now that people are basically heading back into bars and restaurants?
Bill Newlands
executiveSure; on-premise varied quite a bit. I risk sounding like yes, no, yes, no and yes, no — it mostly came down to geography and whatever was happening in specific markets. So we might say state X is improving and we're seeing more on-premise activity, yet if another market hit a wave of COVID challenges, things moved in the opposite direction. So essentially — I don't think there was one big answer to that question. The movements during the quarter were really localized. Again, taken as a whole, on-premise did better than the previous year, and it keeps growing as a share of our business, though it remains below pre-pandemic levels. Hopefully that helps. Giving a true aggregate is very difficult because it's composed of many individual answers rather than one overarching trend across the marketplace. On your cross-category question — I think the big thing you observe there is that premiumization keeps going. Whether you look at ready-to-drink and our ABAs, people keep premiumizing. You see it in wine, where the higher end keeps outperforming the mainstream part of the business, and you keep seeing that in spirits; so I think that's an overarching trend you see. What we've observed over a long stretch of time is this: people now prefer selecting from a variety of drinks based on whatever specific moment they happen to be drinking in, and compared with how things used to be, they're less inclined to stick with just a single kind of product during any given occasion. Hopefully that answers your question.
Kevin Grundy
analystThanks. Bill, I'll follow up on that earlier question, though I want to focus more narrowly, I suppose, on wine and on the industry at large, since people have been talking in the market about the recent deceleration. It isn't just confined to the on-premise, and we've all looked at the Nielsen figures. So the point you made is very much understood. Clearly, premiumization remains a force, and it's broad-based across total beverage alcohol. Yet even looking at a 2-year average, the trend here is slowing. So I don't know how much you can add beyond what you said before. At this stage, do you see this as temporary, this deceleration we're observing in the category? Could there be a larger dynamic at work — perhaps harder to measure — involving ready-to-drink beverages, in a manner that wine hasn't faced previously? If you could address that. And Garth, as a final point, though I believe it matters: is 30% still the operating margin goal for the wine segment? And is fiscal '24 — meaning across the coming couple of years — enough of a timeline for removing the stranded overhead? Any thoughts you have would help.
Bill Newlands
executiveI believe you have to remember that, when it comes to the higher end of the wine business, you're also witnessing what I'd describe as channel evolution, including things like 3-tier e-commerce and direct-to-consumer. For us, those are roughly 3 to 4x what they were in 2019, and today you're seeing them represent about 3% to 5% of our business, compared with 1% previously. So part of what shows up there reflects a shift in how the consumer actually obtains the product, and that may or may not mirror some of the IRI/Nielsen data, since those channels don't capture it. Some of it involves 3-tier e-commerce. The direct-to-consumer channel, though, definitely isn't captured, so that dynamic is partly at work. And naturally, nearly all of it skews toward the higher end. That's where you find that consumer purchasing behavior. So I do believe there are ebbs and flows in all of it. I think during COVID you likely saw more consumption behavior at home, so you're probably facing a somewhat tougher comparison against the prior year. So as we hopefully return to something closer to normalcy, I think you'll keep seeing the long-term trend, which is that the higher end of the business continues to outperform, making it a strong growth play for that sector. Garth?
Garth Hankinson
executiveSure. Regarding wine margins, the goal remains 30%. We've consistently stated that following the divestiture of the low end, roughly 2 years would be needed for us to reach that 30% operating margin. So, once we reach the conclusion of fiscal 2023, wine ought to be within that vicinity. Clearly, movement toward it is happening. We're advancing well. As previously mentioned, several initiatives must move forward for us to arrive there: pricing mix, footprint optimization, and smart design-to-value selections. And as I noted, we're advancing well, and we're confident about hitting 30% by the close of 2023.
Rob Ottenstein
analystThank you. I have a few things I'd like to ask. To start with, it's clear that our depletions took a hit because inventories were low. Could you help us understand what depletions might have looked like had our inventory levels been where they should be? Also, word I'm getting is that Corona was affected the most. Is that accurate?
Bill Newlands
executiveThat's a somewhat difficult thing to respond to, since a year back we were quite choosy about which products we made, while in the current year we've been making every SKU. The only problem has been that demand has outpaced what we can supply. Our rough guess is that we gave up somewhere around 2 to 3 percentage points because of this situation. Still, most of the time, when a shopper wants our brand, they might struggle momentarily to locate one particular SKU, yet locating our brand itself isn't a problem. So that's likely the right lens through which to view it.
Rob Ottenstein
analystGreat. Now for my second question: when you run a diagnostic on what went on with Corona Seltzer, I believe I caught you saying that flavor was a problem — that the consumer is after more of it. So how do you see it — was the taste simply not distinctive enough? Or does the trouble lie in having a brand tied to beer? Or do other elements play a role, on top of the obvious fact that the sector has cooled somewhat? I'd just like to hear a bit more of your diagnostic on where things stand.
Bill Newlands
executiveWell, I'd place greater weight on that final point you made — namely, the sector shifted considerably relative to what everyone had expected. I suspect we sat somewhat toward the cautious side next to certain rivals in terms of what they figured would happen as this year arrived, with a few of them forecasting growth beyond 50%; we anticipated a smaller figure; yet even so, we got it wrong. That, then, is the core problem. Add to that the reality that we built inventory ahead of time, which — once more, at that moment it was a matter of production scheduling and, as we saw it, the correct call then — later proved not to serve us particularly well either. Still, bear in mind that in spite of all of this, since it represents a fairly modest share of our overall growth picture, it adds to our growth. It isn't the bulk of our growth. The bulk of our growth remains the strong demand for our core beer portfolio, and that's where we anticipate it will stay. So turning to the formulation: we've just — clearly we conduct extensive consumer research, and we monitor how consumers see things. And what we've discovered is that consumers want somewhat more flavor and somewhat more distinctiveness in their sell-through preferences, and we intend to meet those consumer needs.
Sean King
analystAs you peer deeper into the future on profitability, and factor in the different longer-dated exposures plus the hedges you've got in place right now, is the second half of fiscal 2022 the right benchmark to use when we think about margins for fiscal 2023?
Garth Hankinson
executiveTo be candid, the right way to look at profitability over both the near term and the medium term matches up with the long-term growth algorithm we follow, and under that algorithm we'll turn in margins in the range of 39% to 40%. As we've said on every single call, those are best-in-class margins, and we offer no apologies for that. In a given fiscal year, profitability might come in a bit above that range when conditions are favorable. In some years, it might land a bit under that range, purely because conditions are too unfavorable. Across the medium term, however, the right way to think about them is as sitting between 39% and 40%. This framework also guides how we think about fiscal 2024.
Nadine Sarwat
analystI'd like to return to Pacifico, since you mentioned the difficulties with brown glass that came up. Clearly, this quarter that brand experienced softer Nielsen off-trade numbers. And I saw that in the release you didn't mention its depletion figures. Could you share those, and perhaps explain whether anything besides the glass problem you already flagged was going on?
Bill Newlands
executiveOf course; for that brand, depletion growth came in at a mid-single-digit rate this quarter; and clearly, it was held back. Absent any supply chain problems tied to brown glass, we would have anticipated a larger number.
Andrea Teixeira
analystI'd like to return to what was said about depletions and shipments. According to you, depletions ought to rise faster than the low single-digit shipments forecast for 3Q, and that suggests a quarter-over-quarter pickup in 3Q versus the 12% two-year stack posted in Q2. With harder comparisons ahead, if depletions climbed by roughly the same 12% in last year's third quarter, does that two-year acceleration come mainly from on-premise, while at-home slows yet still expands? Is that how we should frame it? Put differently, ought we to assume depletions expand at about mid-single digit when you stated — I believe you stated it forcefully — that third-quarter depletions would also exceed shipments? Then, a related point and simply a clarification regarding pricing: should we assume roughly 2% price/mix realized already in 3Q? And how are elasticities behaving thus far?
Garth Hankinson
executiveSure. On Q3 shipments and depletions specifically, here's what we stated — in growth terms, shipments rise in the low single digits while depletions rise more than that. We also stated that measured by volume, depletions — shipments would exceed depletions, meaning we've moved inventory closer to normal levels by the close of our fiscal year; regarding pricing, our standard pricing algorithm delivers 1 to 2 percentage points of gain annually. With the pricing climate we face this year, we can act somewhat more aggressively on products where we'd normally not apply pricing. So pricing will be applied to those SKUs. Consequently, we'll land a bit above our 2% for this year.
Laurent Grandet
analystYes, thank you for taking the question. I want to revisit the seltzer segment. To start, what sort of expansion do you anticipate for that segment? What really interests me is the reasoning behind that view, looking ahead about 12 months. Then, as you said, consolidation will happen as slower-moving SKUs get removed. Might there be a danger for Corona seltzer — the white can, I mean — given that this SKU has performed well below the segment? So is there a chance you would give up ACV there? Last, how do you intend to capture your rightful portion of the seltzer segment, particularly as a Mexican brand, with Topo Chico turning much more national at the start of next year and also bringing out a margarita-flavored item with more flavor than the SKU? I want to grasp your approach there.
Bill Newlands
executiveSure. If I got the first portion of your question right, bear in mind that beer overall has been about even during a period when we've climbed about 8%; therefore a sizable gap exists between how the total category performs and how we perform. We are dramatically beating the category. As for what we want in seltzer/ABA, several points apply. To begin, we'll direct our efforts toward places where we believe we offer differentiated items that stand apart. Looking at what we currently have, I'd point to Refresca and Limonada as 2 illustrations of that — they serve particular needs and aren't what I'd call need-to products. We also have, as we mentioned in our scripts, certain innovation agenda items that we expect will stand apart and deliver unique value too; thus we still think this will be a contributive piece of our growth, yet definitely not the biggest piece; our core beer portfolio will remain that.
Bill Chappell
analystApologies for spending more time on the seltzer topic. I suppose there are 2 items — 1 easy, 1 broader. Two quarters back, as you mentioned, we had plenty of market research. You and everyone else felt very confident about the market, and it looks like the summer was soft, yet the category didn't appear to be a passing trend or finished. But in shifting marketing and advertising and transitioning to more focused SKUs, that seems to be what you're observing. So I guess, is that what you're observing? Do you view this as a small niche that's here to stay? Or do you — and everyone was somewhat mistaken, that it would become something bigger? Or is this merely a pause for the category? Then the second question: with you shifting advertising and marketing toward your core beer portfolio, does that cause — I know it's small — seltzers dropping sharply over the next 2 quarters and generating headwinds for your beer growth?
Bill Newlands
executiveSure. Regarding the category, here's how we see it. We continue to believe the overall ABA space will be a growth category. Whether the seltzer subsegment within beer is going to — how much of that will come from the seltzer subsegment is still unclear. Honestly, it clearly will be far less than what everyone expected entering this year. But once again, for us, it's a fairly small percentage of our total play. So we don't depend entirely on doing well in seltzer. In fact, we anticipate hitting our algorithm via our core beer business. As for whether this will restrain our growth in beer if seltzer struggles, not really. I mean, the reason we could lift our guidance is mostly because we can produce more beer. And we can produce more beer since we're producing somewhat less seltzer, which is margin-accretive, and it's a very high-growth category; so I understand there's a negative aspect and a positive aspect to that response, but the truth is it's consistent with what we've always witnessed, which is our core beer portfolio from Mexico keeps dramatically outperforming the industry, and we remain the leader in the high end and high-end growth; so will it be any different ahead? I think a bit is still unclear; we'll take more of a watch-and-see approach than we did previously. My sense is that people perhaps got somewhat carried away regarding seltzer; and honestly, that segment's growth has decelerated quite a bit; so I believe we'll likely be far more careful when it comes to what we anticipate there, while we keep capitalizing on our excellent lineup of flagship beer brands.
Bill Newlands
executiveOkay, thank you so much, and I appreciate everyone being on the call with us today. Even with certain difficulties that weighed on what we delivered this quarter, as is evident, our confidence stays high regarding the strength and the foundational drivers of our company. Within the industry, our beer segment especially keeps serving as a leading engine of growth, and at the same time we keep witnessing the gains from premiumization in wine and spirits taking effect; we stay optimistic about how our potent lineup of brands that connect with consumers will perform going forward, and that gives us solid momentum as we move toward the back half of our fiscal year. We have our following quarterly call set for early January. So we hope everyone has a safe, happy holiday season. Please keep in mind to savor some of our excellent products while you celebrate, and please stay safe. Thank you for being on the call.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. We appreciate everyone joining us. At this point, please feel free to hang up. That brings an end to the call for today.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Constellation Brands, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Constellation Brands, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Constellation Brands, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.