Constellation Brands, Inc. (STZ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 6, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Joe Suarez
executiveThanks, Darryl. Hello everyone, and welcome to Constellation Brands' Year-End Fiscal 2023 earnings call. Joining me this morning are Bill Newlands, our CEO, and Garth Hankinson, our CFO. Just a reminder that reconciliations comparing the most directly comparable GAAP measures with any non-GAAP financial measures we discuss today appear in our news release or can otherwise be found on the company's website at www.cbrands.com. For risk factors that might affect forward-looking statements made during this call, please see the news release and Constellation's SEC filings. After the call, we will also post in the investor section of our company's website a set of slides containing key highlights from the prepared remarks Bill and Garth share today. Before I hand things over to Bill, consistent with previous quarters, I'd like to request that each person be limited to one question, which will help us finish on time. Thanks in advance. Now, here's Bill.
Bill Newlands
executiveThanks, Joe. Morning, everybody. It's a pleasure to share that in fiscal 2023 our team turned in yet another strong year, lifting net sales by 7% and comparable operating income by 3%, even with the heightened inflationary pressures we contended with all year long. Net sales and comparable operating income reached all-time highs of $9.5 billion and $3 billion, respectively. IRI and Boston Consulting Group named us the top growth leader among large CPG companies for calendar year 2022, and among sizable CPG firms we stand alone in having earned a spot in their top 10 ranking for 10 straight years. Strong execution of our strategy powered these results — a strategy focused on continuing to build powerful brands that people love, introducing consumer-led innovations that tackle emerging trends while consistently shaping our portfolio for profitable growth, deploying capital with discipline and balanced priorities, and operating in a manner that benefits both business and the world. Here's how each segment measured up against these objectives in fiscal 2023. Our beer business posted yet another year of double-digit net sales growth along with its thirteenth straight year of shipment volume growth, all while keeping best-in-class margins. We widened our lead as the number one high-end beer supplier in the U.S. and as the leading share gainer in IRI channels, with dollar sales up 12%. Depletions rose by almost 27 million cases, and net sales and operating income growth landed well above the initial top end of our guidance range. Momentum keeps building for our anchor brands. Modelo Especial held onto its place as the top share gainer and the number one high-end beer brand in the category, with depletions up 9%. Corona Extra ranked as the third-largest share gainer and the number three high-end beer brand in the category, with depletions up almost 4%. Pacífico picked up significant momentum as a top 10 share gainer in tracked channels, delivering depletion growth above 30%. A number of consumer-led innovations across our Modelo Chelada franchise acted as growth catalysts in fiscal 2023. Our Arándano Gose flavor and new variety pack brought more than 1.6 million new cases of depletions to our Chelada brands. Our new Limón y Sal 12-ounce 12-pack helped more than double depletions of that flavor to over 5.6 million cases; in tracked channels, the Limón y Sal 12-pack ranked as a top- 15 new package SKU and the variety pack as a top 10 new brand. We keep investing in our beer business, putting over $800 million into capital investments in fiscal 2023, which backed the ongoing expansions of brewing capacity at Obregón, the continued development of our new ABA alcohol production line at Nava, and the early stage work at our new site in Veracruz. To fulfill our water stewardship pledge, we recently collaborated with local officials and water authorities on a project that upgraded water infrastructure in Zaragoza, the city close to our Nava facility, enhancing water access for the majority of families in that town of roughly 13,000 residents; this represents merely one of many initiatives we have in progress across Mexico under our water stewardship commitment. Looking ahead to fiscal 2024, we will keep prioritizing investments behind our core brands, Modelo Especial, Corona Extra, and Pacífico; we hold the view that the essential growth catalysts for these brands, such as awareness, distribution, and demographic upside possibilities, stay as robust as they have ever been. We are enthusiastic about multiple consumer-driven innovations now entering the market, among them Modelo Oro, which surpassed both external and internal benchmarks in three test markets where we piloted it during the last fiscal year, and Corona Nonalcoholic, which tackles the swiftly expanding betterment trend. We will likewise keep building momentum for our Chelada franchise by launching a second 12-ounce 12-pack for our top-selling traditional Chelada flavor, along with the new spicy watermelon flavor, Sandía Picante. We will keep allocating capital to boost our brewing capacity so we can satisfy the expected sustained strong demand for our products, in both the near and long term. Switching topics. Our wine and spirits business has evolved from a U.S. wholesale operation, primarily serving the mainstream segment, into a global omni-channel competitor with a portfolio focused on higher-end offerings; this strategy is succeeding, since the strength of our higher-end brands drove our outperformance versus the broader market. Weaker demand for our mainstream brands caused a 2.1% volume decline for our wine and spirits portfolio in IRI channels, yet we beat the 2.6% volume decline for the combined U.S. wine and spirits categories in fiscal 2023; we kept concentrating on growing our consumer-preferred higher-end brands within our portfolio. Our Aspira portfolio, encompassing our fine wine and craft spirits brands, produced double-digit shipment growth; furthermore, it considerably surpassed the fine wine and craft spirits segment, propelled by The Prisoner Wine Company, which generated depletion growth nearing 10%, and our craft spirits portfolio, which reached depletions growth nearing 29% in U.S. wholesale. Moreover, these brands produced thrilling consumer-driven innovations, including The Prisoner's Blindfold Blanc de Noir, Casa Noble's Ultra Premium Marqués Tequila, and our Mi Campo ready-to-drink cocktails, which remain in early phases of their life cycles, yet are adding to our broadened presence at the higher end of the market. In the meantime, our Ignite portfolio kept driving momentum for our premium brands, like Meiomi and Kim Crawford, which generated depletion growth of 5% and 7% respectively, each gaining share in their respective segments; we kept supplementing the growth of our core premium products with innovations that expand the offerings of these consumer-preferred brands. Take Meiomi's latest red blend, for instance — it's still the second-best-selling wine SKU from the time it hit shelves, while Kim Crawford's Prosecco ranked as the top new wine brand at number two. Turning to our Ignite portfolio, gains from our upper-tier premium labels were canceled out by the mainstream wine and spirits brands we still hold, specifically Woodbridge and SVEDKA, both of which saw drops relative to the U.S. market. Our attention stays on getting these brands back on stable footing and bringing them back to life. As part of pushing our strategy forward — reshaping the wine and spirits portfolio toward the higher end — we sold off a number of leftover mainstream labels and brought in a smaller premium wine brand along with a ready-to-drink cocktail brand. Worth highlighting: the My Favorite Neighbor portfolio, which we picked up fairly recently, is posting significant growth and beating what we first anticipated. Broadly speaking, in fiscal 2023, net sales for our wine and spirits business fell a bit less than 4%, though much of that stemmed from the recent sale of mostly mainstream brands I mentioned a moment ago. Even with our higher-end brands doing well, net sales on an organic basis were down 2%, largely because demand weakened for our mainstream brands — a reflection of the ongoing consumer-led premiumization trend I brought up earlier; we kept building momentum behind our higher-end brands and kept speeding up our results in key channels, including direct-to-consumer and international markets, where net sales rose 29% and organic net sales rose 4%, respectively.
Bill Newlands
executiveAs we look ahead, there's a chance to keep expanding DTC internationally through putting money into our premium wine, fine wine, and craft spirits brands that are leaning their growth toward DTC and international routes to market. It's worth noting that in fiscal 2023 our wine and spirits business achieved operating margin expansion, which further proves the value of its strategy and represents more movement toward its medium-term targets. All told, we're finishing the year in wine and spirits on solid footing, and I stay confident about that business's pathway. Because our beer, wine, and spirits divisions turned in strong results, we returned close to $2.3 billion to shareholders during fiscal 2023 via dividends and share repurchases. On top of that, we demonstrated we can act on opportunistic buybacks, repurchasing roughly another $300 million worth of shares in Q4. Adding those figures to what we've paid out since fiscal 2020, dividends plus buybacks now exceed $5.4 billion altogether — comfortably beyond the $5 billion target we set. Looking ahead, we plan to stay disciplined and continue executing on our capital allocation priorities. Looking at fiscal 2024, the earnings and cash flow we expect should move us nearer to the net leverage ratio goal, which would help fund dividends consistent with our target payout ratio. It would also let us continue putting capital toward added beer brewing capacity and hospitality investments within wine and spirits, while allowing us to seize chances for further share buybacks and small acquisitions that fill gaps. To wrap up, we remain dedicated to driving real progress on our company-wide ESG objectives. Those include reducing our Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions 15% by fiscal 2025, measured against a fiscal 2020 baseline, and returning over 1 billion gal of water to local watersheds. We're also focused on making water more accessible and better in quality for the communities in which we operate, from fiscal 2023 through 2025. For our team, water stewardship has been especially important. So I'm happy to share that the fiscal 2025 target we set for water restoration has already been exceeded. Later this year, we plan to share new goals for our water stewardship work, plus additional key areas tied to our continuing pledge to protect the future strength of the communities where we operate and the environment around them. Our ESG disclosures have gotten a major upgrade too — we've added references that line up with the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board framework and taken into account what the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures has recommended. Going forward, our aim is to keep moving toward weaving ESG more completely into how we plan for the core business, setting goals that are deliberate, concrete, measurable, and bounded by time, backed by strong strategies and operating plans we can track our progress against. In our view, this strategy is the best way to look after what matters to the company, its investors, its other stakeholders, and the communities around us, since it aims to weave ESG into how we run things and to make sure we can plainly meet the pledges we have made. In closing, we delivered another strong year, with record net sales as well as comparable operating income, despite the major hurdles inflation posed over that stretch. These outcomes came from executing our strategy effectively, and we continued to make solid progress on all fronts. Creating brands that customers adore, pairing expansion of our main offerings with innovation guided by consumers, allocating capital carefully while weighing competing needs against our organization, and persisting in operating in a manner that benefits both business and the world. Now that another powerful year of executing our strategy is finished, we hold considerable confidence in our capacity to keep generating momentum in fiscal 2024. Having said that, I'll now hand the call over to Garth.
Garth Hankinson
executiveThanks, Bill. Morning, everybody. Our fiscal 2023 turned in another strong showing, since we kept executing hard against the plans for operations and the strategic efforts we've laid out. Even with the cost-of-living squeeze hitting both our sector and shoppers, we once more proved how durable our flexible operations, premium labels, and tough-minded colleagues are; we anticipate that same drive and commitment will carry our momentum forward into fiscal 2024. Let's walk through what full-year fiscal 2023 delivered and how we see fiscal 2024 shaping up. As usual, my remarks will center on comparable basis results. I'll begin with how the beer segment performed in fiscal 2023. Net sales rose $713 million, or 11%, coming in above the top end of the range we had guided to. The main engine behind that was healthy shipment expansion of roughly 7%, with robust demand persisting throughout our portfolio, which added $464 million in net sales from additional volumes. We also got a lift from pricing that came in above the typical 1%-2% yearly pricing algorithm we normally run. As we've said before, the extra pricing moves we took during fiscal 2023 came about because of cost pressure throughout the value chain stemming from inflation. We rolled out bigger price increases and adjusted pricing in select markets sooner than our standard timetable. Depletions for the year climbed beyond 7%, which, as Bill Newlands pointed out, came from ongoing robust gains in our biggest brands — Modelo Especial, Corona Extra, Pacífico, and the Modelo Chelada brands. On-premise depletions rose 15% versus a year earlier, and on-premise volume made up roughly 12% of overall depletions in fiscal 2023, closing in on the mid-teen volume share seen before the pandemic began. Consistent with earlier guidance, shipments and depletions tracked closely together in absolute terms. Now to the beer segment's bottom line. Operating income rose 6%, also landing above the top end of our guidance range. That gain mostly came from a $492 million boost out of net sales growth and produced an operating margin of 38.3%, matching the implied range we had given. As we anticipated and flagged throughout fiscal 2023, inflation headwinds weighed on operating margins; within the import side of our beer segment, which accounts for almost all of COGS, raw materials and packaging costs climbed about 16%. That stemmed mainly from inflationary forces, working out to an 8% rise per case. Part of this reflected lapping the seltzer obsolescence charge from fiscal 2022, since stripping out any obsolescence effect, our raw materials and packaging costs would have risen 20% in absolute terms and 12% per case. Keep in mind that those two cost lines, obsolescence included, made up slightly more than 55% of the import portion's costs in fiscal 2023; we also recorded a 12% increase in freight costs versus the prior year, chiefly from extra shipment expenses, partly offset by efficiency programs. On a per-case basis, freight expenses rose 5% and represent slightly less than 25% of what we pay to import. Labor and overhead went up 14%, largely because of the money we've put into brewery capacity. On a per-case basis, those two were 7% higher and made up slightly under 15% of import costs. Beyond that, beer business operating margins took a hit from depreciation climbing $41 million, or close to 22%, which is nearly all tied to our investments in brewery capacity. Marketing spend grew $55 million, or almost 9%, reflecting added investment in sport sponsorships. Our other SG&A rose $48 million, or roughly 14%, due to extra sales support meant to match the momentum behind our beer brands. Keep in mind, though, that even with marketing investment above the prior year, it stayed inside our 9%-10% range measured as a share of net sales. With all that said, it's worth noting we still turned in best-in-class margins for the beer business in fiscal 2023. Turning now to wine and spirits. To start, remember that in fiscal 2023 we sold off a group of mostly mainstream wine brands from the wine portfolio. In my comments today, I'll talk about top line on an organic basis as well, which leaves out what the divested brands contributed. As Bill mentioned, even with strong results from our higher-end wine and spirits brands, organic net sales fell 2%, which put us inside our guidance range. Setting aside the divestiture's effect, the net sales drop came mostly from mainstream brands, which ran into tough market conditions and were up against the prior fiscal year's inventory build. Strong growth from higher-end brands partly made up for that decline, as those brands outperformed in the U.S. within the higher-end category for wine and spirits alike and across the total U.S. wine market. Our higher-end brands also grew strongly in our emerging, fast-expanding direct-to-consumer channels and in international markets. Looking ahead, we expect the portfolio to keep shifting toward the higher end, and we expect those higher-end brands, channels, and markets to fuel faster top-line growth. Organic shipments fell by under 8%, while depletions dropped 3%. As I just mentioned, that volume decline cut organic net sales by $148 million, coming mainly from mainstream brands, while mix and price—mostly from higher-end brands—added $111 million to organic net sales. Wine and spirits operating income—excluding gross profit less marketing for brands that left the business after their fiscal 2023 divestiture—rose 2%, and operating margin climbed 80 basis points to almost 23%, again on that same exclusion basis. That margin gain came from a $12 million lift via net sales flow-through, as favorable product mix got support from lower grape costs and a strong New Zealand harvest. Savings from other cost-reduction efforts also contributed, mainly through decreased grape expenses, which helped to counterbalance some of the rise in logistics and material costs. Thanks to improved investment approaches that sharpened our emphasis on the best return prospects, marketing spending became more effective, delivering a $20 million boost to operating income. Offsetting these gains in part was $17 million in additional SG&A due to a larger workforce, as we keep making strategic investments in our expanding DTC channels. With future mix enhancements and productivity efforts, we stay in a strong position to keep growing margins in our wine and spirits business over time. Turning to the remaining parts of the P&L. For fiscal 2023, corporate expense for us comprised roughly $270 million in SG&A and $20 million from unconsolidated investments tied to our ventures portfolio. Altogether, this came in at $290 million, the low end of our guidance. Inside the SG&A component of corporate expense, our DBA program—short for Digital Business Acceleration—made up $47 million. To reiterate, we launched this multi-year DBA initiative during fiscal 2023 and anticipate comparable investments continuing into fiscal 2024. Interest expense rose 12% for the year to about $400 million, finishing at the top of our guidance range.
Garth Hankinson
executiveThe main factor behind this rise was how we financed the stock reclassification that occurred during Q3 of fiscal 2023, plus the effect of climbing interest rates on roughly 15% of our debt that carries variable rates. On a full-year comparable basis, our effective tax rate — setting aside Canopy equity earnings — landed at 19.2%, compared with 17.5% a year ago, since we cycled past favorability in fiscal 2022, largely because of greater stock-based compensation activity. Free cash flow in fiscal 2023, defined by us as net cash provided by operating activities minus CapEx, exceeded the top of our guidance range, reaching $1.7 billion. CapEx amounted to $1 billion, with more than $800 million of that invested in our beer business. CapEx finished under our guidance, mainly because of timing shifts in spending on certain materials and equipment tied to our Mexico brewery investments at the Nava and Obregón facilities. At the close of fiscal 2023, our Mexico brewery operations carried a total nominal capacity of about 42 million hectoliters. That figure comprises 32.5 million hectoliters at Nava and 9.5 million hectoliters at Obregón. This marks a 1 million hectoliter increase at Nava compared with the capacity we described a few months back. Once again, that gain stems from our ongoing productivity efforts, which have unlocked extra production flexibility within our breweries' existing footprint. Just to remind everyone, we mentioned earlier in the year that those initiatives had freed up an extra 1.5 million hectoliters of capacity at Nava, along with 0.5 million hectoliters at Obregón. Because we unlocked 2.5 million hectoliters of productivity capacity at Nava in fiscal 2023, we've tweaked slightly the ramp-up schedule for the new ABA line we're building there, and I'll get into that in a moment. Moving on to fiscal 2024 guidance: we're expecting comparable basis diluted EPS between $11.70 and $12.00, leaving out Canopy equity and earnings. For our beer business in fiscal 2024, the goal is net sales growth of 7% to 9%. Building on what Bill said before, we anticipate continued robust growth in volume, powered mainly by our Icon labels—Modelo Especial and Corona Extra—plus NextWave offerings including Pacífico and the Modelo Chelada lines. For the entire fiscal 2024 period, we look for shipments and depletions to move almost in lockstep, whether measured in raw figures or compared against last year. Keep in mind that while recent years saw swings in the timing of our quarterly shipments and in growth rates versus the prior year, caused by harsh weather and effects tied to the pandemic, we anticipate fiscal 2024 shipment timing will return to a more conventional seasonal rhythm. About 55% of our fiscal 2024 volumes ought to go out during the first half, meeting peak summer demand for our products. Additionally, if you examine each quarter individually—particularly the year-over-year growth figures—we continue to expect that both shipment and depletion comparisons will fluctuate, which is consistent with past patterns, because we are balancing inventory volumes in line with seasonal trends throughout the year as well as our routine Q3 brewery maintenance. With that said, we do not foresee any additional lapping volatility in our Q4 shipment growth rate similar to what occurred in fiscal 2023. Regarding pricing, our current plan calls for average annual pricing to remain inside our 1%-2% algorithm. We recognize that consumers will likely continue facing challenging macroeconomic conditions for the foreseeable future, and that our price increases across the past two fiscal years exceeded this algorithm. Throughout this year, we will continue monitoring inflation trends and possible downturn dangers so that our pricing stays appropriately calibrated to sustain the forward drive of our brands. Additional news on this topic will come during upcoming quarterly calls. Turning to operating income growth, our beer segment aims for 5%-7%, which points to roughly 38% in operating margin for fiscal 2024. As previously mentioned, we continue to anticipate that inflationary COGS pressures will weigh on our beer operating margin. The bulk of those pressures stem from year-over-year changes in packaging and raw material expenses, which collectively amount to an average high single-digit rise in absolute terms for those inputs within the import side of our beer business. Even though certain input prices have come down from their highest points, the majority are governed by contract provisions calling for yearly resets tied to historical pricing information, and several continue to sit well above where they stood before the pandemic. Looking ahead to fiscal 2024, we anticipate that packaging and raw materials for our imports will represent roughly 55%-60% of costs; beyond that, we expect freight to make up about 20%-25% of costs, with an absolute year-over-year rise in the high single digits as we keep encountering annual volume and contractual increases. Labor and overhead should come to about 15% of costs, showing a high-teens absolute increase, mostly because of more headcount and training connected to our investments in brewery capacity. Regarding our beer segment, we're looking at roughly $35 million to $40 million in added depreciation. That's because we keep starting up more brewing capability from the investments we've made, especially at Obregón, during fiscal 2024. As we mentioned before, the extra capacity that productivity efforts freed up at our current Nava site gave us more room to maneuver when it comes to phasing in our new ABA line. So we're now planning to devote somewhat more time to fine-tuning that added ABA output, which will help us serve the robust expansion of our Modelo Chelada brands. With that in mind, we expect the ABA line to be ramping up during Q4 of FY 2024. On the other hand, we've managed to move up the timeline for our next 5 million hectoliter investment at Obregón, bringing it to Q1 of fiscal 2024. What allows us to do this is relocating the brewery and packaging equipment that we had originally intended to use in Mexicali. Now let's discuss operating margins. We plan to implement a number of productivity initiatives to help offset inflationary pressure. The expectations we provided for our beer business COGS in fiscal 2024 factor in operational efficiencies and cost-saving measures. Among these initiatives are benefits from our ongoing hedging program and contractual negotiation efforts, as well as those from our fiscal 2023 DBA program. On that point, it's worth noting that within fiscal 2024, only about 25% of our beer business COGS are subject to contractual pricing adjustments, and for roughly 10%-15% of COGS, we expect our hedging program to lower our exposure to those adjustments. Beyond that, we anticipate delivering efficiencies in marketing and other SG&A, including an even stronger emphasis on directing those kinds of investments toward our Icon and Next Wave brands. Though still somewhat under our medium-term operating margin target, we expect our fiscal 2024 efforts to nonetheless produce best-in-class results for our beer business, and we expect every quarter in fiscal 2024 to deliver operating margins higher than this latest quarter's result. Now to the outlook for our wine and spirits business. For fiscal 2024, we are targeting organic net sales that are relatively flat, within 0.5 percentage point of fiscal 2023 net sales, excluding $38.5 million of net sales from the brands divested in fiscal 2023.
Garth Hankinson
executiveWe anticipate carrying on the robust expansion of our premium wine, fine wine, and craft spirits labels, along with our DTC channels and international markets; these areas of our company should help counterbalance the challenges we foresee in our mainstream U.S. wholesale brands, which confront difficult market circumstances because of the persistent consumer-driven premiumization trend. In contrast to our beer segment, we anticipate that our wine and spirits division will ship roughly 55% of our fiscal 2024 volumes during the second half. That aligns with the seasonal pattern of demand for our wine and spirits products. Even more significantly, notwithstanding ongoing inflationary strain, we are aiming for operating income growth of 2%-4%, not counting $19.5 million of gross profit, minus marketing tied to brands that were divested in fiscal 2023. That suggests an operating margin gain of no less than 40 basis points. The main drivers of margin improvement for fiscal 2024 consist of further mix enhancement, especially through our more thoroughly optimized portfolio, propelled by sustained expansion of our higher-end brands from continuing consumer-driven premiumization trends, lasting growth momentum in our higher margin direct-to-consumer channels and select international metro areas, chiefly via our Aspira portfolio brands. Added innovation with new consumer-led products that assist in expanding our higher end offerings and steadying our mainstream brands. Lower marketing expenditure relative to net sales with optimized investments increasingly concentrated on high growth, high return areas. Further SG&A cuts and cost management efforts. As with our beer segment, we anticipate that about 25% of our wine and spirits business COGS will be subject to adjustments during fiscal 2024. Shifting to expectations for the remaining P&L in fiscal 2024. Corporate expense, encompassing only the SG&A portion, should come to roughly $270 million. We expect to benefit from the ending of certain compensation and benefits that will not be owed in fiscal 2024 after Rob and Richard Sands retired from their executive positions under the reclassification agreement shareholders approved in fiscal 2023, though this will be offset by inflationary pressures and merit-based salary increases. Interest expense should total approximately $500 million for the year. That represents a 25% rise over fiscal 2023 and stems mainly from the additional interest expense linked to financing the reclassification. The comparable tax rate, excluding Canopy equity and earnings, should be near 19%. Completing the P&L, we foresee about $40 million in non-controlling interest benefits and weighted average diluted shares outstanding are projected at roughly 184 million. Shifting to cash flow, we anticipate fiscal 2024 free cash flow to fall within $1.2 billion-$1.3 billion, which mirrors operating cash flow within $2.4 billion-$2.6 billion and CapEx of $1.2 billion-$1.3 billion. CapEx includes about $1 billion to back our Mexico brewery investment, with most of the rest supporting our wine and spirits hospitality updates. To conclude, I want to restate that our refreshed capital allocation priorities, which we introduced and covered during fiscal 2023 and earlier by Bill, stay the same. Our dedication to a sound financial base stays firm, and that means keeping an investment-grade rating as we progress toward the goal for our net leverage ratio. We return value to shareholders in two ways: dividends that match our payout ratio objective, plus step-up buybacks of shares that at minimum offset dilution, while we stay ready to seize chances for further repurchases. We keep fueling expansion across our operations by putting capital to work in our beer brewing ambitions and in our wine and spirits hospitality investments. And finally, we pursue smaller acquisitions that could close gaps or strengthen the portfolio we already hold. This robust, disciplined approach to allocating capital, paired with outstanding execution, should, in our view, let us become a top-tier generator of shareholder returns for the foreseeable future. With that, Bill and I are glad to take your questions.
Andrea Teixeira
analystThanks. Morning. Could you share what has changed lately that gives you assurance regarding the beer sales growth guidance of 7%-9%, especially given the widespread slowing in consumption that retailers pointed to during March? On a connected note, do any patterns exist involving shipments before the Cinco de Mayo kickoff of summer versus depletions as we head into the first quarter and across the full year? If I may also fit in a question about pricing, you brought up the 1%-2%, and I realize a number of competitors chose simply to hold firm. Considering the situation you faced going into the fall last year, if your plan is mainly to handle pricing during the fall. Thanks.
Bill Newlands
executiveAppreciate the question, and good morning. There are a few reasons we feel confident about that 7%-9% range. To begin with, the year kicked off very strongly in markets such as Texas and Florida, and both of those posted double-digit gains during the first month of the year. We recognize that California's situation has been difficult, but let me share what has me genuinely enthusiastic about California. During Q4, our distribution growth — or effective distribution — rose 3.6%, Q4 against the prior Q4. Our simple distribution, even with a very broad market capability in that state, climbed 2%, while our draft panels increased by more than 9%. For me, that signals we are well positioned for when California returns to its usual weather pattern, compared with what we experienced this year. We're quite comfortable. Naturally, we wouldn't hand you this guidance if we felt any other way, but we're quite comfortable that we'll land within that 7% to 9% range we mentioned today. Carter, would you like to address the pricing point?
Garth Hankinson
executiveYes. Like we mentioned during our prepared remarks, we feel good about where pricing stands under our 1%-2% algorithm. And, you know, clearly we'll keep doing things the way we have on pricing, which gives us room across the year to watch how the macroeconomic picture, inflation, and any recession effects—possible recession effects—are hitting our consumer. It lets us keep an eye on what competitors are doing and, you know, gives us room to move quickly whenever we see a reason to make a pricing move. That's going to be something—as I noted in my prepared remarks—that if we do make any changes during the year, we'll share updates on those through our usual quarterly calls.
Kevin Grundy
analystThanks, and good morning, everybody. Let me start with a quick clarification. Bill, I don't know whether you're able to weigh in on how depletions trended in March. Given how much California matters, my guess is things are tracking somewhat under the level we saw in Q4. Could you address that? The bigger thing I want to ask about is the Oro launch, and perhaps you can build on that with your outlook and any thoughts on the danger of cannibalization. Then, importantly, some framing for how this rollout should be viewed next to the Corona Premier launch from a few years back, and how much incremental spending is involved? If my memory serves me — and Garth, jump in if I've got this wrong — I think the incremental investment supporting that launch landed somewhere between $35 million and $40 million. Still, having some additional background on that would be useful, so thank you both. I appreciate it.
Bill Newlands
executiveOf course. Having just said at CAGNY that I'd stop talking about depletions, I don't want to contradict myself, so I'll avoid commenting on March depletions in any detail, other than to say the results were roughly in line with what we expected. As I noted earlier when answering Andrea, both Texas and Florida posted double-digit gains. California, on the other hand, definitely had a tough start to the year. It seems reasonable to say that rain, snow, or flooding becomes very uncommon in California once May, June, July, and August arrive. Just as we've observed on numerous other occasions when a specific market gets disrupted, we anticipate that this too will fade with time. Now, regarding your question about Oro: we've stated that we intend to take a very measured approach to Oro's rollout. I'm happy to report that our beer group has performed exceptionally well in securing distribution in the marketplace. We're only about three weeks into that initiative, as everyone's aware, yet the cannibalization numbers coming out of the three test markets have left us quite encouraged. Incrementality came in at more than 60% across those markets, and that's something we feel really good about. Our view is that it addresses an unmet need, especially for our core Hispanic consumer, who's been seeking another option beyond the light beer choices already out there. We're genuinely optimistic, though we plan to roll it out in a way that's both sensible and approachable. Anyone who tuned into March Madness probably noticed our media push kicking off around that tournament, and that rollout is going to get a lot more backing throughout the summer months.
Dara Mohsenian
analystHey, guys.
Bill Newlands
executiveHey, Dara.
Kevin Grundy
analystHi, Dara.
Dara Mohsenian
analystRegarding beer depletion, could you talk a little about what you're observing in the on-premise channel? Compared with Q2 and Q3, the gap seemed improved when it came to on-premise and certain smaller store on-track channels versus track channels. I'd just love an update on that; beyond that, do you believe there are any wider macro effects showing up in your portfolio? Perhaps give us some update on trade down overall in beer and what's happening there, along with any consequences for your business. Thanks.
Bill Newlands
executiveAbsolutely; when it comes to on-premise, that segment keeps expanding, just as we mentioned during our prepared remarks. We're still witnessing an acceleration in on-premise, which we consider quite positive. We haven't fully returned to the level we'd call normal—the place we occupied prior to the pandemic—but we keep moving forward on that front, since we're observing more and more frequently that consumers are getting out into the marketplace and enjoying on-premise; we stay optimistic. As you know, our growth trajectory within the on-premise space keeps speeding up, because I believe a great many on-premise accounts are increasingly seeking brands that connect reliably with consumers. Clearly we possess those, and that reflects very favorably. As an illustration, take a thoroughly penetrated market such as California, where draft handles for our business rose 9% during the fourth quarter of last year. In my view, that's an excellent indicator of the potential that remains for us in on-premise. Regarding your inquiry about trade down, we've noticed very minimal trade down affecting our portfolio. To be sure, a bit has appeared, but it generally happens at price points beneath ours. Certain consumers are expressing some worry regarding broad inflationary and macroeconomic conditions. For the most part, that has taken place at lower price points than those where our brands compete; this aligns pretty closely with what we've observed concerning the sheer loyalty our brands command. That's the advantage of holding consumer-preferred brands within our portfolio.
Rob Ottenstein
analystThanks a lot. One more question, picking up on some of what Garth said in his guidance and remarks. Maybe I just didn't track it, but I believe you were referring to productivity steps that could help us reach the margin goal. You went through it fairly fast, or, well, you touched on hedging programs and how much is hedged or isn't, and I'm sorry, I lost the thread there, but I was attempting to figure out how hedging connects to productivity and what precisely your point was meant to be.
Garth Hankinson
executiveOkay, Robert, I appreciate that question. First off, as Joe mentioned when he started his comments, right after this call wraps up we're going to put some slides on our website that deal specifically with efficiency, the productivity efficiencies, and hedging. What I'd say about that is it works the same as it does in any year — we've got particular productivity targets, efficiency targets, and savings that help us counteract cost pressure tied to inflation. That's exactly the same as every other year. What I was getting at with that remark is that the increases I mentioned earlier are net of those efficiencies. On the hedging side, the point is simply that we keep a pretty strong hedging policy and program going. Usually, we can only hedge somewhere around 10%-15% of whatever sits in our cost of goods. We're hedging against those items at this time. As we move into this year, we're right where we'd typically be when it comes to the percentage of commodities that are hedged.
Nik Modi
analystYeah, thanks. Good morning, everyone. Just a few follow-ups.
Garth Hankinson
executiveHello.
Nik Modi
analystMorning. A handful of quick follow-ups. I'm interested, Bill — you brought up certain distribution wins that have occurred in California. I was simply hoping for some background regarding how you see resets, plus what you're observing in a wider sense, particularly across markets where your share position trails what it is in California. Question two is this — there's clearly been plenty of chatter among trade folks concerning other brewers perhaps undoing certain prices or running promotions, giving back part of the latest rounds of increases. I'd just like some background on how you approach this in principle: if something like that took place, would reacting become necessary, or wouldn't it? I'd really appreciate your background and viewpoint there.
Bill Newlands
executiveSure thing, Nik. Appreciate you asking. When it comes to resets, we're performing really strongly in those situations. To me, it comes down to straightforward sound business, since our portfolio accounts for over 80% of the growth across the entire beer category, so it only makes sense that retailers would give us more shelf space rather than the competition. As you know, like we mentioned during our prepared remarks, Modelo is the top growth driver, Corona ranks as the third growth driver, and Pacífico sits among the top 10 growth drivers. These brands call for additional shelf space, and we're quite lucky that our team is dedicated specifically to that particular subject.
Bill Newlands
executiveWhen it comes to pricing, like Garth mentioned, we take a close look at elasticities across our brands, and I've brought this up many times before. We're extremely conscious of wanting to retain our consumer. Our approach to pricing through the years has been to stay sensible and approachable so that we hold onto our consumers. This year, within our standard algorithm, we're going to raise prices in the 1%-2% range, as Garth pointed out. We should see, and we expect, no reversal of any pricing scenarios on our part this year, since we've been judicious and sensible about keeping the consumer engaged with us as we've moved pricing previously. We'll keep monitoring that closely as the year progresses, just as we always do. On a monthly basis, you know, we look at elasticities along with drivers and drags, which all of you have heard about from Jim Sabia over time. We find absolutely no reason to roll back pricing in any market, because we believe we were very appropriate in what we've done historically, which ought to let us be right back in our algorithm moving forward.
Bonnie Herzog
analystOkay, thanks. Morning, everybody. My question concerns the free cash flow outlook you gave of $1.2 billion-$1.3 billion for this year; that figure sits, as you know, quite a bit beneath what you've typically generated. Perhaps you could walk through the main positives and negatives that will affect free cash flow in this year. You've finished your buyback objectives so far along with your $5 billion target for returning money to shareholders, yet no fresh return target was announced. I'm curious about how you view your capital allocation priorities moving ahead, and also what would be reasonable to expect regarding cash returned to shareholders during this year and afterward. I'm asking with an eye toward the CapEx requirements, your leverage goals, and so on. Thanks.
Garth Hankinson
executiveThank you, Bonnie. Beginning with free cash flow, the right place to begin is operating cash flow, correct? Operating cash flow has declined somewhat this year compared with last year. A few things mainly cause that. First, there's the rise in interest that I mentioned during my opening remarks, essentially a 25% climb year over year, and that mostly mirrors the debt and interest tied to the collapse, plus, to a smaller degree, the remaining floating rate debt sitting on our books. On top of that, we'll face greater cash needed for taxes in the coming year because of USAT and certain non-recurring tax benefits we enjoyed in FY 2023, and then, to an even lesser degree, some working capital shifts. Going further down, we'll keep making substantial CapEx investments, as you've heard. That's really... Those elements are what shape the free cash or operating cash flow and free cash flow ranges we laid out previously. Regarding the shareholder, returning capital to shareholders via share repurchases, we still have close to $1 billion remaining under the board authorization we already have for buybacks. As we said in our remarks, at minimum, we will repurchase solutions across the year, but we'll stay agile and ready to capitalize on market conditions, exactly as we did in Q4, when, as Bill pointed out in his remarks, we bought back aggressively nearly $300 million in shares, you know, once we spotted what we deemed dislocations in price. That approach will carry on through the year. We genuinely appreciate having that flexibility. It's clearly going to remain an extremely vital piece of our capital allocation, you know, strategy.
Peter Grom
analystHello, and good morning to everyone. I hope all is well with you. I want to ask about how pricing is being phased and your remarks about keeping an eye on how the consumer is doing. You gave quite a bit of detail when answering the questions from both Andrea and Nik. So, assuming you have no intention of reversing price increases, could you describe the steps you might consider if conditions were to worsen? Would that amount to simply setting prices at the lower end? So the main thing I'm trying to get at is this: suppose the pricing picture shifted in a meaningful way — what would that do to your capacity to hit the margin goals for beer? Is there somewhere else you could push harder, or does it get tougher to get there? Thanks.
Garth Hankinson
executiveHonestly, the question packs in a lot of downside hypotheticals, and from where we sit, those aren't scenarios we expect to materialize. Take a look at the track record of our beer business — our method on pricing has stayed remarkably steady through the years, coming in at 1% to 2% annually, again and again and again. Over the past two years, as everyone is aware, we moved well past that level as a way to protect ourselves against the severe inflationary forces that every consumer business has had to deal with. Our view is that we're now well situated to return to our usual pricing lift of 1% to 2%. This conclusion comes from extensive analytics and the many elasticity evaluations we perform continually; we have a high degree of confidence in it, and we believe it will be the right approach throughout this fiscal year, which ought to let us deliver on everything we've committed to. As a quick add-on to that point, I want to mention something I brought up at CAGNY — the strength of Modelo's share in California and Nevada, its two best-performing markets, where we saw double-digit figures. I'm happy to share that we're now at four states, with New Jersey and Texas joining that group. This goes to show once more that beyond California, our growth trajectory still offers a huge long-term opportunity for the business, and it reinforces what we just discussed regarding our capacity to price within the 1%-2% algorithm.
Chris Carey
analystHello, everybody. I've got just a pair of quick questions. Garth, regarding your beer margin outlook, you provided plenty of excellent specifics. I believe you're aiming for operating margins that are flat or thereabouts for the year. Is there a way to set expectations for growth margin versus operating margin? I mention that given productivity initiatives, which I imagine could affect both line items. I'm simply wondering whether you have anything to say on that. Second, wine spirits just posted what I consider its strongest operating margin in several years, but the guidance seems to suggest you're surrendering much of that. Is this merely caution, or is there something absent from the bridge concerning the premiumization that has genuinely supported that margin structure? I ask with reference to earlier margin targets for the wine and spirits segment overall. Thanks for addressing beer margins along with wine and spirits margins.
Garth Hankinson
executiveYes. Regarding wine and spirits margins, once more I'd point you to the deck that will be posted on our website following this call. We are in fact projecting wine margins to rise by no less than 40 basis points year over year. That information will be visible on the website. Concerning operating margin, or gross profit margin for beer, all the headwinds we confront in beer during the coming year will land in gross margin and not further down the line. As we've stated, we will keep handling our marketing and SG&A spending efficiently and concentrate on the initiatives with the greatest returns and highest priority, and we will handle that efficiently. The biggest drag for us, as we've mentioned for several months, will simply be the inflationary effect, and that once again will flow through COGS, along with some added depreciation across the year.
Nadine Sarwat
analystHello, and thanks. Good morning to everyone. Let me return to what was said about beer margins. Should I use the middle of your top-line and operating income projections for beer, that figure lands slightly under the 38% you originally mentioned, as I recall. Did something specific shift unfavorably compared with what you previously told us? Or is this simply a matter of rounding? And as a second question on margins, considering last year's margin levels and what your guidance implies for this fiscal year, ought we to continue viewing 39%-40% as the medium-term margin for the business? Would applying that to fiscal 2025 be reasonable? Thanks.
Garth Hankinson
executiveI must apologize, since the connection cut out at the end there. I didn't catch the-
Bill Newlands
executiveMy impression is that the latter portion of that was asking whether we anticipate reaching it during fiscal 2025. Your audio cut out — sorry about that — yet I believe that is what she asked. Please continue.
Garth Hankinson
executiveI think, as you work through the figures we gave you, you know, when we mentioned 38% operating margins, that's roughly a 38% operating margin. As you look at the different points across our range, you'll arrive at different results for what that margin will be. We have complete confidence that we will achieve operating margins of approximately 38% for our beer business. When it comes to the outlook ahead, we've only given our outlook, our margin outlook, for our beer business for FY 2024; we aren't providing any guidance for years beyond that. At this stage, that isn't something we normally do. That isn't part of how we operate. Of course, the largest factor again this year for FY 2024 is again mainly caused by inflation and the inflation we are observing, which I described in my scripts, plus some additional depreciation. Offsetting that, we will keep taking pricing the way we have. As we stated previously, we'll be within our 1%-2% range on pricing. We keep generating incremental volume, which helps offset fixed overheads and depreciation as we grow into our larger footprint. We will carry on with the efficiency drivers I referenced too. That's where things stand for FY 2024. We'll discuss FY 2025 as we get nearer to the end of the year.
Bryan Spillane
analystHi there. Appreciate it, operator. Morning to you. Morning, everybody. I wanted to revisit the wine and spirits topic for a moment. Garth, perhaps you could share some thoughts on the way SVEDKA and Woodbridge are impacting margins, and possibly how margin expansion is trending there? My reason for asking is that their share of volume is far bigger than their share of revenue. My guess is that their margins sit below the average. I'm simply attempting to figure out whether achieving volume stabilization, or volume growth, for those two brands matters a great deal when it comes to lifting margins in that area. Or is that actually not much of a factor? Basically I'm trying to get a handle on Woodbridge, SVEDKA, and the more distant effect on profitability within wine and spirits.
Garth Hankinson
executiveYes. You're completely right that because of how large those brands are, they create somewhat of a pull on our margin profile overall, owing to the price points where they compete and, as a result, the margin profile they carry, which sits under the average for the whole business unit. On the bright side, the wine and spirits team has fairly bold revitalization plans ready for both brands, allowing us to steady those brands and keep beating the price segments in which they compete. So, as those efficiency gains keep coming and we revitalize those brands, we anticipate being able to hit our margin targets as we have set them out.
Bill Newlands
executiveThank you so much. Fiscal 2023 proved to be a monumental year for Constellation Brands. We posted record net sales along with comparable operating income, and we were honored for a 10th year as a CPG growth leader, even as some of the most severe inflationary headwinds in recent memory hit both our company and consumers. Our beer business beat our original projections and kept its lead in share gains, growth, and margins, even with some ups and downs over the year as we cycled past distortions in our performance from earlier periods and worked through incremental pricing actions beyond our yearly algorithm, which were meant to offset cost pressures throughout the chain. We hit numerous other transformational milestones as well, among them our move to a single- share class structure plus other key corporate governance improvements. We began construction work at our new brewery location in Veracruz, made further refinements to our wine and spirits portfolio, and kept making headway on that business's strategy. Finally, our business performance, combined with our disciplined and balanced capital allocation priorities, let us hold onto our investment-grade rating even with the extra financing tied to the transaction for our shift to a single- share class structure, exceed our share repurchases and dividend cash returns target by more than $400 million, and keep expanding our beer production capacity while carrying out small, growth- accretive M&A. As we turn toward fiscal 2024, we stay focused on delivering sustainable growth and value creation for our shareholders by executing our annual plan and by continuing to push our strategic initiatives forward. We feel confident about sustaining momentum across our beer portfolio through strong volume growth and targeted pricing moves; we're bullish about how our wine and spirits business will perform going forward as it keeps advancing its strategy. We remain dedicated to our capital allocation priorities and our ESG efforts. Thanks once more, everyone, for being on the call; we hope you'll decide to celebrate your Cinco de Mayo and Memorial Day with some of our excellent products. We can't wait to talk with all of you in late June on our next quarterly call. Thank you so much. Have a wonderful day.
Operator
operatorThat brings today's call to an end. Thanks for joining us. You're free to hang up now. Have a good rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Constellation Brands, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Constellation Brands, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Constellation Brands, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.