Constellation Brands, Inc. (STZ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 5, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Joe Suarez
executiveThanks, Darryl. Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining Constellation Brands' Q2 fiscal '24 earnings call. With me today are our CEO, Bill Newlands, and our CFO, Garth Hankinson. Just a note that reconciliations comparing the most directly comparable GAAP measures with any non-GAAP financial measures we discuss today appear in our news release or can be found on the company's website at www.cbrands.com. For risk factors that could affect forward-looking statements made today, please see the news release and Constellation's SEC filings. After this call, we'll also post in the Investors section of our website a set of slides highlighting the prepared remarks Bill and Garth are sharing today. Before I hand things to Bill, consistent with prior quarters, I'd ask that each person limit themselves to one question, which will help us wrap up on time. Thanks in advance, and now here's Bill.
Bill Newlands
executiveAppreciate that, Joe, and hello everybody on this morning's call. Glad to have you with us for our Q2 fiscal '24 discussion. When it comes to the main highlights from the second quarter, it's my pleasure to share that the team has once more produced a strong all-around result. To start with, our beer division was out front, ranking as the top share gainer, with share momentum building through the important summer holiday period. We'll keep putting money behind expansion for this business, since the team is pursuing chances to capture added awareness, more shelf space, and greater household penetration for our brands over the back half and further out. Next, our Wine and Spirits Business keeps moving forward on its path toward capturing the complete advantages of its transformation. Focused spending behind our biggest Wine and Spirits higher-end brands is producing above-market results within their respective categories, which partially offsets and helps lessen the pressure coming from our mainstream brands as those brands keep reshaping the mix profile of our portfolio. And lastly, our ongoing discipline regarding capital allocation priorities helped produce a robust overall result for the quarter and positions us for fiscal '24 to be yet another steady year of profitable growth along with shareholder returns; with that said, allow me to give a bit more detail on the main performance drivers from the quarter. As I mentioned, our beer team has once again turned in outstanding results. We didn't just hold onto the top share gainer spot through the whole pivotal summer season, we also built on our leading position starting with Cinco de Mayo to become the number one share gainer in tracked channels over the 4th of July holiday, even though that holiday lands just a bit past the close of our second quarter. I'm happy to add that we sped up our share gains even more around Labor Day. Modelo Especial stayed the primary engine behind our powerful performance, posting double-digit volume growth in tracked channels along with an 8.6% rise in depletions, which reinforced its standing as the leading brand throughout the entire U.S. beer market and in dollar sales fiscal year-to-date. The wider Modelo brand family turned in incredible results as well, with Cheladas notching 50% volume growth in tracked channels and a depletions increase above 40%, while Oro keeps building on a strong launch, growing its share gains within the overall beer category and delivering in line with what we planned for the fiscal year. Past Modelo, our Corona Extra and Pacifico core beer brands likewise kept up their strong showing. Corona Extra posted steady low single-digit growth in depletions and tracked channel volumes and ranked as the number six share gainer in the category, while Pacifico hit 15% depletion growth, tracked channel volume growth of roughly 27%, and stood as the number 11 top share gainer in tracked channels. Our beer brands keep connecting really well with consumers, and that fueled demand during Q2, supporting double-digit growth in net sales and operating income for our beer unit. Because of that, we now feel confident enough to move our fiscal ’24 guidance for beer net sales and operating income up to the top end of the ranges we first gave — meaning 8% to 9% and 6% to 7% growth, respectively. That said, keep in mind that within beer we said just 45% of the year’s total volume gets shipped during the back half, matching how U.S. beer demand normally swings by season, plus how we schedule brewery maintenance. Past fiscal ’24, we still see plenty of room to sustain momentum in beer, especially given how durable several big consumer trends are — things like premiumization across beverage alcohol that shoppers keep pushing, the Hispanic population here in the U.S. continuing to grow faster than average, and our beer team’s nonstop push to close remaining distribution and awareness gaps across our brands while creating and expanding new, exciting products that track consumer-led trends. We can’t wait to share more about that strong outlook at our Investor Day coming up on November 2. Now turning to Wine and Spirits. That business keeps progressing toward its goal of becoming a daring, innovative leader in the higher-end market. During Q2, our biggest premium wine labels, Meiomi and Kim Crawford, beat the category segments they compete in within U.S. tracked channels. Each one grew its share of the overall line category. Our biggest Fine Wine & Craft Spirits labels, the Prisoner Wine Company and our Mi Campo tequila brand, likewise beat the luxury wine and higher-end spirits category segments they play in. Worth noting: every single brand I just named also posted strong depletion growth rates in Q2. Wine and Spirits also keeps pushing ahead with renovating its mainstream labels to tackle the headwinds those category segments have faced over the last several quarters. There’s definitely more to do here, but in U.S. tracked channels, Woodbridge’s year-over-year dollar sales decline got better versus Q1, and SVEDKA’s overall share stayed fairly steady compared with Q1. Even so, Wine and Spirits kept dealing with softer demand, mainly for our mainstream labels, which mirrors the ongoing consumer-led premiumization trends we’ve mentioned before, and that hurt overall performance in Q2. Even with that, we’re holding guidance for the full year and still expect fiscal ’24 organic net sales to stay roughly flat and operating income growth of 2% to 4%. During our outlook discussion for fiscal '24, we described the year ahead for wine and spirits as split into two distinct halves. The second half is expected to account for 55% of planned volume, and operating performance should pick up speed across the remaining months thanks to several other important drivers. We anticipate gains from the quarterly shipment and depletion rebalancing moves we've taken this year, which are more proactive compared with the lone downward shipment adjustment made in Q4 of last year. On top of that, we look for a lift in our direct-to-consumer channels and better mix stemming from additional ASPIRA shipments that follow seasonal patterns, along with the advantages of price increases implemented recently. In the end, we also foresee operating margins accelerating considerably, driven by the stronger sales trends just outlined and the positive operating leverage they generate. Before wrapping up, I'd be remiss if I didn't call attention to how steadily we've executed against our capital allocation priorities. Progress continues toward our reduced net leverage ratio of roughly 3 times, reflecting a 400 basis point decrease since the rise tied to financing our Class B common stock reclassification last November. Notably, because we've actively managed the added debt from that reclassification, we're now positioned to record lower interest expense than we originally expected for fiscal '24. Consequently, we now expect higher reported and comparable earnings per share, excluding Canopy, landing in the ranges of $9.60 to $9.80 and $12.00 to $12.20, respectively, for the full year. Regarding cash returned to shareholders, our dividend payout ratio in the second quarter stayed in line with the 30% target.
Bill Newlands
executiveDuring Q2, no further buybacks were made, though $35 million has been spent so far this year, which aligns with what we set out to do — at minimum, canceling out dilution. On top of that, work on our brewery expansions is moving forward on schedule, Veracruz included, and we keep advancing and launching these sites, using the adaptability our modular strategy provides. Prior to wrapping up, on this second quarter call I'd like once more to draw attention to the fact that our annual ESG Impact Report will arrive in just a few weeks. Through this report, we aim to offer a thorough look at our approach, efforts, goals and results as they relate to urgent environmental and societal matters that matter to our company, shoppers, communities, team members and wider stakeholders. Specifically, as mentioned on our past two calls, the goal of returning 1.1 billion gallons of withdrawals to local watersheds has already been exceeded, and we're eager to show the efforts within our beer business responsible for the bulk of that success, plus reveal additional information about our fresh target in the upcoming ESG impact report. I'd encourage everyone to set aside time to go through this report once it's out, and it will be accessible via our company website. To wrap up, here are four key points I want to share from this quarter. To start, our beer business keeps beating the industry, and its faster pace since the year began has made us comfortable enough to move our fiscal '24 outlook to the upper end of our original net sales and operating income growth projections. Equally important, our confidence in the long-term potential of our higher-end brand portfolio remains just as strong. Second, our Wine and Spirits strategy keeps paying off, and we anticipate net sales growth and operating income growth for that segment to build up across the rest of fiscal '24; looking ahead to future years, we expect our Wine and Spirits business to pick up further steam and deliver better outcomes. Third, we keep executing our capital allocation priorities, staying disciplined and balanced to generate value and returns, and we're dedicated to extending the steady record we've built through these priorities in recent years. And last, fourth, we're glad to be bringing more of these key subjects to you at our Investor Day, happening in four weeks; with that said, I'd like to hand things over now to Garth, who'll walk through our Q2 financial results in greater depth. Garth?
Garth Hankinson
executiveThank you, Bill, and good morning to all of you. The results we posted for the second quarter demonstrate that we keep executing our strategic initiatives with discipline and that we remain relentlessly focused on delivering growth while improving how we perform. As Bill mentioned, we turned in another strong quarter, with net sales and operating income both rising at a double-digit rate in our beer business, while our Wine and Spirits business put up solid results across its biggest premium, fine wine and craft spirits brands, which partly offset the category headwinds hitting our mainstream brands. We likewise keep producing robust cash flow and continue to act on our consistent and balanced capital allocation priorities. Now we'll take a closer look at what we delivered in the second quarter of fiscal 2024, and my focus will be primarily on the numbers as presented on a comparable basis. To kick things off, net sales for the beer segment climbed 12%, which works out to $253 million more than before. Driving most of that was an 8.7% bump in volume, since appetite for our Beer brands gained momentum across the opening six months of the fiscal year; pricing that went our way contributed as well, tacking on $59 million to the overall net sales gain. Before we go on, a quick note on pricing: for this fiscal year, we continue to anticipate that it will account for between 1% and 2% of the growth in our net sales. That comes from two things combined — the carryover effect of the sizable pricing moves we made during the third quarter of fiscal '23, plus the specific pricing steps we're implementing in fiscal 2024. When it came to the second quarter of fiscal '24, beer shipment volume and depletions tracked each other closely, and I'm glad to share that our inventory levels are in good shape to back the ongoing expansion of our brands. During the quarter, beer depletion growth came in at 7.9%. That number mirrors a solid summer selling period. It was fueled by sustained consumer interest in our industry-leading beer portfolio, as evidenced by share gains that keep accelerating. It also reflects how we carried out our distribution and marketing plans, which included stretching our category leadership through the crucial summer months, along with continuing favorable outcomes from our Shopper-First Shelf initiative. And lastly, it reflects quicker share gain growth in both our core and emerging markets. Before I move on to how the on-premise side performed, I'd like to briefly address a significant recent shift in what we're observing within the off-premise channel. Many of you are aware that historically, volume growth in Circana tracked channels has surpassed depletion growth by a variance in the low single digits. Lately, however, the gap has grown to the mid-single-digit percentage area. The reason is that independent retailers that Circana's data doesn't include have been sluggish about rolling back the extra price increases they applied on top of the pricing moves we made in October of fiscal '23. Our read is that this has led some consumers to move their purchases away from those independent retailers toward chain retailers, which are offering consumer prices that are more competitive. Although this change in the variances doesn't affect the total demand for our brands, we keep watching how the channels are performing and intend to share additional updates or insights when appropriate to square tracked channel data with our overall results. Keep in mind that roughly 50% of our total beer volumes are captured by Circana. Turning now to the on-premise segment: depletions came in basically level compared with a year ago, representing roughly 10.3% of total beer volume. Keep in mind that although keg supply saw a few modest interruptions during Q2, the sequential decline from Q1 to Q2 mostly mirrors the usual seasonal cadence observed in prior years. The key point is that despite some near-term turbulence, we are making and delivering tags right now and firmly anticipate making up for the effects of those interruptions as fast as we can. As we look toward the back half of the year, roughly 45% of volumes, per Bill's remarks, will be shipped in that period, since it represents our softer volume stretch. On top of that, Q3 shipment volumes tend to be more restrained because of scheduled maintenance work. Finally, on the pricing side, we will begin lapping the benefit from substantial incremental pricing moves implemented in October of fiscal '23. Even so, as previously communicated, we firmly anticipate that shipments and depletions for the entire year will end up broadly aligned, on both an absolute and a year-over-year growth footing, once fiscal year-end arrives; with respect to selling days, those were unchanged versus a year ago for the quarter, and note that for the rest of fiscal '24, Q3 sales days will match last year, while Q4 will gain one additional selling day. Now, turning to beer margins: in Q2, operating margin fell 60 basis points, landing at 39.9%. The main cause was persistent inflationary pressure within COGS, where we absorbed an overall cost rise of about 17%. The biggest contributors to those higher costs were packaging and raw materials, extra costs tied to a voluntary product recall of certain kegs for quality assurance, plus greater depreciation, which totaled $12 million, or a 24% increase. To counter the inflation and depreciation headwinds, we keep pushing cost efficiency and operational productivity efforts throughout the company, which have produced meaningful and lasting gains. We saved $30 million net in Q1 from those efforts, and in Q2 we added about $20 million more in net savings. On top of cutting costs, we got some margin help from a couple of other places: marketing expense came down $4 million, or 2%, mostly because we divested our craft beer business — marketing was 7.1% of sales for the quarter — and SG&A expense dropped $3 million, or 3%, mainly due to favorable foreign currency effects. As for Q2, our marketing spend as a percentage of net sales came in outside the 9% to 10% algorithm we'd shared before. As is typical, part of this comparatively lower percentage in Q2 reflects the business's strong volume, and hence net sales performance, owing to category seasonality. Yet the effect of cutting back on marketing stemming from the craft beer exit we mentioned earlier has pushed that percentage down even more. For the entire year, because of the craft beer divestitures and our ongoing emphasis on making sure our sizable marketing investments go toward the portfolio areas with the greatest returns, we now anticipate landing nearer the bottom of the 9% to 10% of net sales range we previously stated. Given how much faster the Beer Business has grown since the year started, we're moving our fiscal '24 expectations up to the top of our original ranges, which works out to an expected 8% to 9% rise in net sales growth along with a 6% to 7% expected gain in operating income growth. Turning now to our Wine and Spirits Business. Consistent with reshaping that business toward a higher-end portfolio of offerings, we keep gaining from the strong results of our biggest premium wine, fine wine, and craft spirits brands. Meiomi, Kim Crawford, The Prisoner Wine Company, and Mi Campo, which, as Bill pointed out, beat the matching categories in tracked channels and produced solid depletion growth.
Garth Hankinson
executiveAlthough we're happy with how those top-tier premium brands performed, total organic net sales for Wine and Spirits fell 11%, mostly because of the category pressures we keep confronting tied to how our bigger-volume mainstream labels, Woodbridge and SVEDKA, are doing. Work is already moving forward on our plans to renovate Woodbridge and SVEDKA, and the leadership team for Wine and Spirits can't wait to provide updates on that progress during our next Investor Day. On an organic basis, shipments dropped 15%, while depletions were down roughly 8%. Keep in mind that roughly 55% of Wine and Spirits sales are expected to land in the back half of the year, when we also anticipate that consumer-driven premiumization will keep shifting the mix toward the higher end, which supports what we think will be a meaningful step-up in the growth trajectory of the business over the rest of the year. Wine and Spirits operating income — excluding the gross profit less marketing of the brands that left the business after being divested — declined 12%, and operating margin fell 10 basis points to 18.2%, again on that same exclusion basis. The margin contraction came mostly from volume declines in our mainstream brands, partly offset by cheaper material costs, largely thanks to sustainable packaging projects, savings in the supply chain, and reduced marketing spend as we keep prioritizing the higher-return areas of our portfolio. Looking ahead, we still anticipate that the Wine and Spirits Business will substantially strengthen its net sales growth trajectory over the balance of the fiscal year via a mix of bigger contributions from our higher-end portfolio plus additional pricing moves; we expect this pickup in net sales growth, together with our ongoing cost cuts and marketing efficiency efforts, to also underpin our operating income growth targets. Because of that, we stay confident about the wine and spirits outlook for the year, and our guidance for that business for fiscal '24 is unchanged. Let's now move on to the remaining parts of the P&L. Corporate expense came in at about $67 million, a 19% reduction overall versus the prior year, mainly from lower spending in the second wave of our digital business acceleration program, reduced headcount-related costs, and lower compensation and benefits after our reclassification transaction. Interest expense for the quarter was around $111 million, up 17% from the prior year, due to higher weighted average interest rates on the adjustable-rate portion of our debt, which represents about 5% of our debt obligations, and higher average borrowings from financing the share reclassification. Even so, we now anticipate interest expense for the full year to be roughly $460 million, about $40 million below our earlier guidance, thanks to refinancing actions on some of our higher interest debt and faster-than-expected deleveraging throughout the year. We closed out the quarter with a net leverage ratio of about 3.2 times, leaving out Canopy equity earnings, and we expect to keep moving toward our target of three times over the next several quarters. Our comparable effective tax rate, excluding Canopy equity and earnings for the quarter, came in at 17.8% compared with 20.3% a year ago. For fiscal '24, we still anticipate the comparable effective tax rate, excluding Canopy equity and earnings, to land at roughly 19%. Turning to free cash flow, which we define as net cash provided by operating activities minus CapEx; for the second quarter year-to-date of fiscal '24, free cash flow came to $1 billion, down 15% from the prior year, driven by a 34% rise in CapEx investments tied to capacity expansions at our Nava and Obregon facilities and the building of our new brewery in Veracruz. As of Q2, our newest additional brewing capacity project at our Obregon facility is fully commissioned, and we now have roughly 47 million hectoliters of capacity across our two breweries. Looking ahead, we remain on track to bring our ABA facility online at Nava near the end of this fiscal year. And the development of our additional expansion at Obregon and our third brewery site at Veracruz are progressing as planned. We continue to expect fiscal '24 free cash flow in the range of $1.2 billion to $1.3 billion, reflecting operating cash flow between $2.4 billion and $2.6 billion and CapEx of $1.2 billion to $1.3 billion. Our comparable EPS for the quarter, excluding Canopy equity and earnings, was $3.80, and because of the continued profitable and disciplined growth we have seen this year, we are raising fiscal '24 reported EPS guidance to between $9.60 and $9.80 and comparable EPS guidance, excluding Canopy equity and earnings, to between $12 and $12.20. And finally, our announced dividend of $0.89 a share will result in roughly $163 million returned to shareholders for the quarter. In closing, I'd like to say that our entire team keeps executing and delivering against our strategic priorities; we showed solid execution in the first half of fiscal '24, and as we enter the back half of the year, we plan to stay disciplined as we seek to drive long-term profitable growth and enhanced shareholder value. Our management team is excited to meet with many of you this coming November as we lay out our medium and long-term ambitions and vision for Constellation Brands at our Investor Day; with that, Bill and I are happy to take your questions.
Vivien Azer
analystHi, thank you. Good morning.
Bill Newlands
executiveYou bet.
Vivien Azer
analystSo clearly, we've seen a really robust first half of the year. A lot of people have been asking me why the upward adjustment to guidance wasn't a bit stronger. And Bill, you obviously walked through some of the elements to keep in mind on the shipment side, plus the pricing overlap that Garth mentioned too. But is there anything additional you could share regarding how you see the category performing in the back half that could have contributed to a bit more conservatism? Thanks.
Bill Newlands
executiveNo. Our outlook for the back half remains quite favorable. What matters most for our back half is typical seasonality. Just 45% of our business comes in the back half, and Q3 is when we handle our maintenance, which always puts some limits on Q3. And we're up against pricing from a year ago that largely won't repeat, along with the usual sales build ahead of price increases that happened once again in Q3 last year. But keep in mind, if you look at the takeout data in tracked channels, our four-week figures line up very closely with the 52-week figures. This is a continuing growth story that we have a great deal of confidence in, and that's why we lifted our expectations for the year in beer; we anticipate a very strong second half.
Andrea Teixeira
analystThanks. Morning. I wanted to check whether you could say something about how the shelf resets in this category are big, what you're observing among consumers, I get the CAG circumstance and consumption in the on-premise. Just picking up, clearly, on the market share movement and you benefited and you've put in lots of effort over a very, very long stretch regarding those shelf resets. So if you could speak to that, how you view it as you head toward the spring resets in the big boxes and also what's going on in the on-premise? Thanks.
Bill Newlands
executiveSure; we definitely anticipate a robust reset window. You know, a few limited resets happen in the fall. The bulk of them happen in the spring. Our confidence about that comes mainly from the pure velocities we get across our key brands. No, when it comes to hitting velocities, our portfolio can't be beat. And those have stayed steady year-on-year, which gives us plenty of confidence in our capacity to keep achieving shelf set gains. Retailers know this very well, and they see where growth and velocity originate and that will serve us strongly to our benefit when those resets take place.
Nik Modi
analystYes, thank you. Good morning, everyone.
Bill Newlands
executiveHi, Nik.
Nik Modi
analystBill, I wanted to ask — hey, how's it going? I was hoping you could share some thoughts on systems and supply chain volume. The reason I'm asking is that a lot of your growth is now coming from areas that weren't really fueling your growth, say, 5 to 10 years back. So having the right volume in the right location at the right moment calls for some tweaking and likely some systems overhaul. So I just — I was curious whether A, that's a fair point to raise; and B, if so, what you're doing on the inside to ensure you can truly have the most optimized supply chain?
Bill Newlands
executiveSure. A few things come to mind here, Nik. As you're aware, several years back, we had absolutely no redundancy built into the system; today we do, and that definitely gives us far more flexibility when it comes to our operations footprint to accomplish a number of things. First, it ensures we can keep pace with the growing demand we consistently observe in our business, and in a situation where something is ramping up faster than we had expected. We're able to respond to that. I think, A, that's quite strong. Second, as you're aware, we put some substantial investments into our digital business efforts, and those are truly delivering returns when it comes to our supply chain capability too. That has considerably sharpened our capacity to ensure we've got the right supply chain capabilities across the entire supply chain; so, I'd say both of those have been absolutely essential. In fact, and I know you'll be present — you'll have an opportunity to hear about this in some depth at our Investor Meeting on November 2nd. We believe this is a key factor that's been vital to our ongoing ability to sustain and satisfy the major demand increase we've witnessed, and we'll cover that in considerable detail on November 2nd.
Dara Mohsenian
analystHi, good morning, guys.
Bill Newlands
executiveHi, Dara.
Dara Mohsenian
analystSo, only a couple of fast clarifying questions. Regarding the gap in the mid-single digits compared to Circana data that you observed during this quarter when it comes to depletions, do you believe that persists? Could it narrow back toward a low single-digit gap down the road? Conceptually speaking, what's your take on that? Also, in what you said responding to Andrea's question about shelf space, is there a bigger chance this year than in a normal year, simply because ABI's business is clearly dropping off unexpectedly following the spring reset; so, do you view the shelf space chance as bigger than usual, simply because of those dynamics? And there could be larger shifts, even if your business doesn't go up against them as directly head-to-head?
Bill Newlands
executiveYes. Of course, Dara. Regarding the first item, the matter of whether the mid-single digits persist, I believe that's still to be determined. As Garth mentioned at Barclays, and as we stated in our prepared remarks, it's higher than it typically has been, so whether it returns to the standard we normally observe, which is roughly lower single digits, is still to be determined, and clearly, it's something we monitor closely. As for the shelf sets, yes, we believe this will be a fantastic chance for us for every reason I gave before, which is our velocities are unmatched. And we absolutely anticipate being able to grow our presence. That likewise affects some of our new product development. When you consider Oro, well, Oro has gotten off to a terrific start, quite consistent with what we had anticipated. And that additionally provides an opportunity to grow our shelf presence since we anticipate that, using that brand as an illustration, it will receive additional shelf space. The final thing I'd mention, and I must highlight Chelada’s, since Chelada's has simply been incredibly hot. And our extra sizes and variety pack in those — within that specific category, once more, provides an opportunity beyond the core beer set to obtain additional shelf space too. So we must consider this quite broadly since we anticipate gaining both in what I'd describe as the core beer shelf and the ancillary beer shelf too, with items such as Chelada.
Gerald Pascarelli
analystThanks a lot. This is a question about the macro picture. Bill, a lot of people ask us about student loan payments; after a pause lasting three years, those are set to start up again this month; so what's your thinking on what effect that will have, perhaps the chance of consumers trading down, given that some of your beer products carry premium price points? Any insight would be terrific. Thank you.
Bill Newlands
executiveYeah. That's another item, I'd say, where the jury is still out. Something we observe as significant with our brands is how strongly consumers stay loyal to them. If you look at Modelo, for instance, we skew heavily toward the Hispanic community, and that community shows enormous loyalty to Modelo. Same goes for Corona. Corona draws from a far wider demographic base, yet we keep saying it's the most loved beer, and that's the truth. I believe that matters enormously. Consumers are constantly deciding where their discretionary income will go. And the power of a brand matters enormously in how those decisions get made. So to address your specific point, we don't know yet, though we have a great deal of confidence in our capacity to watch our brands keep building momentum, purely because so much loyalty is tied to them.
Nadine Sarwat
analystHello, two things from me, if you don't mind. Let's go back to Modelo Oro. Are there any fresh figures you can provide, particularly regarding cannibalization? Also, how would you describe that additional consumer? Then my last item concerns that voluntary ad product recall. Could you put a number on what it did to the quarter, on both the top line and margins? Thanks.
Bill Newlands
executiveOf course. Like I mentioned before, Oro only represented a handful of SKUs for us, yet it has gotten off to a very strong beginning. Cannibalization levels came in below what we'd expected and, honestly, below what we saw in the 3 test markets we'd run at the outset. So that leaves us quite encouraged. One area where we're experiencing outsized gains for that specific Oro sub-brand is among Hispanic consumers. We've been really happy with how Oro has performed in key, sizable Hispanic markets, and as we keep expanding it, you'll see more SKUs arriving next year, which we think will help maintain that brand's momentum. And should cannibalization levels remain consistent with what they've been, that will beat our original expectations. Garth, would you like to take the second one?
Garth Hankinson
executiveCorrect — regarding that CAG recall, every bit of the hit landed in cost of goods, tied to freight and the scrapping of items, plus what it originally cost us to make the product; for the quarter, it simply did not amount to a material swing for us. The 10-Q will lay out somewhat more granularity on this, and that's where you'll locate it.
Bryan Spillane
analystThanks, operator. Good morning, everyone.
Bill Newlands
executiveGood morning.
Bryan Spillane
analystSo perhaps a bit of context here — and this might partly follow up on something asked earlier — but we keep hearing lots of questions regarding demand elasticity and how much inflation consumers will tolerate. Could you give us some context covering your beer segment as well as wine and spirits, specifically what sort of economizing behavior you might be noticing? Once more, is it things like purchasing more through chain convenience rather than independents, or the packaging decisions people are making? Just as you look ahead, where do we stand on economizing behavior and how might you need to adapt or adjust to it?
Bill Newlands
executiveYes. So I believe this demonstrates that our judicious approach to pricing has been exactly right. We've stated all along — actually, we fielded questions on this during earlier calls sometimes about why we weren't raising price more. Our stance has always been 1% to 2% per year; we went slightly above that across the past couple of years, yet 1% to 2% is how we consistently view it, and we view it market-by-market, SKU-by-SKU. The reason behind that is pretty straightforward. Retaining your consumer is far easier than having to win them back after losing them. In this specific situation, as you mention, people are cautious. What we're observing is fewer — rather, more trips, yet slightly lower purchasing per trip compared with what we previously saw, which basically means folks are exercising a bit more care regarding what they do, given the inflationary environment that's out there. What matters most for us, I believe, is that despite there being more trips, they're taking more trips to buy more of our brands, even if they spend somewhat less on any given trip, and again, that connects to what I said in response to the earlier question, concerning our brand loyalty and the steady consumer dynamics that truly benefit us over the long term. So once more, the key piece there, I believe, is that our judicious pricing approach over time will serve us very well when you're in a consumer environment where people feel somewhat more worried or somewhat more anxious regarding the inflationary environment. And I believe that will benefit us going forward.
Chris Carey
analystHello, everyone. Garth, could you share your thoughts on where inflation has landed versus what you'd anticipated at the start of the year — the pluses and minuses? My question ties to what you said about marketing falling near the bottom of the usual range across the whole year. I'm also eager to hear how you see gross margin performance this quarter compared with what you'd expected, plus any color on the back half of the year. But — in any case, at a broad level, I'm simply after some understanding of how costs are trending compared with your prior thinking, and perhaps you could describe how this performance is shaping up, once more, versus what you'd been expecting going in? Thank you.
Garth Hankinson
executiveYes. Thank you, Chris. Well, to remind everyone, we anticipate roughly 38% for our beer operating margin this fiscal year. That figure hasn't moved. Regarding Q2 specifically, Q2 has traditionally been our higher — our highest margin quarter because of the volume tied to Q2. So during the year's back half, clearly, inflationary pressures that have persisted throughout the year will keep affecting us. Some easing in inflation is showing up, as anticipated, as the year has progressed. Sadly, though we've witnessed a bit of relief on inflation, we've also watched a strengthening peso kind of remain firm. Consequently, whatever gain we got from inflation has truly been canceled out by the peso's strength. And then once more, in the year's latter half, since volume historically is lower during that period, there will be a hit, clearly, to fixed cost absorption along with COGS and marketing, plus additional depreciation from what we brought on over gone midway through the year. And then, as Bill mentioned during his remarks, it's scheduled maintenance that we normally perform in the year's second half, along with the overlapping and the pricing advantages from last year. So taken together, I mean, those are roughly the elements that will drive that 38% margin across the full year.
Bill Newlands
executiveHello, Lauren.
Bill Newlands
executiveI think come back again.
Rob Ottenstein
analystExcellent. Many thanks. Could you provide a bit more granularity around your productivity efforts — which particular areas you've tackled and are aiming at? Also, might this be a multiyear undertaking involving system optimization? Thank you.
Bill Newlands
executiveThank you, Robert. Yes, I'd characterize our cost savings and efficiency initiatives as definitely multiyear by nature. As we obviously relayed earlier in the year during Q1, we'd removed $30 million, and then in the current year, an additional $20 million for this quarter — I should clarify, an additional $20 million; we're constantly examining approaches to sort of demonstrate productivity and generate efficiencies within the business, whether via supply chain and procurement or operations. Illustrations of that across time have included items such as double stacking rail cars and utilizing plastic pallets, optimizing where inventory is located, as Bill mentioned when answering a question earlier, enhanced purchasing regarding raw materials, through superior contract management and negotiations, plus more effective and efficient deployment of our marketing spend. So this is absolutely something the organization concentrates on year over year. And certainly, we'll provide far more detail regarding our cost savings initiatives for both our beer and our Wine and Spirits businesses at our forthcoming Investor Day.
Filippo Falorni
analystMorning, everyone. Bill, you said the most recent four-week trends have looked really solid and in line with the prior 52 weeks. Could you share a bit more detail about how the business performed in September? Then, on the industry side, one of your competitors said at its Investor Day that September has been especially weak for the industry, especially the last couple of weeks, since you're up against the shipments made ahead of last year's price increases. So some insight into how shipments fell into September and into Q3 would be useful. Thanks.
Bill Newlands
executiveSure. Looking at the latest Circana data covering four weeks, our total beer business rose 13.7%, which lines up closely with the 52 weeks. That's the point I was referring to in what I said earlier. Of course, as we also pointed out, we anticipated some degree of tightness early in the quarter we're now in, simply because we're lapping the October price increases from a year ago, plus some of the prebuilding retailers do before any price increases take effect. None of that is a surprise to us. And as we've stated, the reason we lifted our guidance expectation for beer is that we anticipate a very strong back half of the year even with a few of these headwinds that clearly remain.
Andrew Strelzik
analystMorning, and thanks for the question. I'd like to ask about capital allocation, specifically share repurchases. You mentioned, I believe, that no buybacks happened this quarter, yet you remain on pace to meet your goal of offsetting dilution for the year so far. What I want to know is: how much appetite exists for repurchasing beyond that level, especially considering the business's momentum and the strength of cash flow being generated? How do you view this today compared with your thinking early in the year, and going forward? Thanks.
Bill Newlands
executiveSure. Capital allocation, clearly, is a topic we'll cover in more depth at our Investor Day coming up. Broadly, though, for this fiscal year, as we said when the year began, our plan was to at minimum repurchase enough to offset the dilution that took place across the year; however, this year we're also focused on bringing our leverage ratio back down to our 3.0 target, from the elevated level it reached because of the reclassification. With that said, we aim to stay flexible and agile whenever conditions permit. It's something we keep evaluating. And as a reminder, we still have $800 million left under the authorization from our current board. So should we choose to become somewhat more active, we're able to do that.
Lauren Lieberman
analystHi. Can you hear me?
Bill Newlands
executiveWe do.
Garth Hankinson
executiveWe can.
Bill Newlands
executivePart two.
Lauren Lieberman
analystAlright, great. My apologies for whatever just occurred—I'm not sure what went wrong. Anyway, moving swiftly: my question concerns expansion within the wine sector. Considering what you said regarding Woodbridge and SVEDKA—which clearly aren't wine—plus how the premium labels have done, when you look at what lies ahead, covering not only the latter half of this year but also the following year and beyond, what's your outlook on growth for wine as a category, and how wine stacks up against beer and spirits? I suspect we'll hear more during Investor Day, but I'd love a sneak peek at your thinking on wine's longer-term growth trajectory. Thank you.
Bill Newlands
executiveAbsolutely, Lauren. What we're seeing is a tale of two cities. The bottom tier of our portfolio—what we call mainstream—has faced considerable difficulty. It's declined by a mid to high single-digit percentage, which is clearly a hurdle for us given that we remain heavily engaged in that segment, even after shedding quite a few labels that competed there. So my response regarding that part of the business differs greatly from what I'd tell you about the premium side, where names such as Naomi, Kim Crawford, High West, and Booker, along with similar offerings, are all beating our targets and forecasts by a wide margin while picking up share. You're correct—we'll address this at Investor Day. Another factor I keep in mind: beer gets roughly 45% of its volume in the latter half, but wine is the exact reverse. Wine does 55% in the back half. Beyond that, an outsized share of our revenue stems from ASPIRA, which ties far more closely to vintage launches—those tend to land in the second half, which once again tilts our business toward the later months rather than the earlier ones. One more point worth flagging, and I believe it matters: earlier this year we stated we'd chosen to even out shipments and depletions across all four quarters, rather than concentrating them in Q4 the way we did the prior year. That decision introduces some difficulty during the opening stretch of our fiscal year, yet it sets us up for a substantial upside in the back half, since that spike won't repeat itself as it did previously—no more lopsided shipment volume in last year's fourth quarter. Instead, we'll be comparing against a far more favorable situation this time around. Taking everything together, the wine business has undeniably encountered headwinds, yet it mirrors what we observe in beer's premium segment. The upper tier of the category is far more robust, and our brands competing there are delivering excellent results relative to typical category performance. You're correct that we'll be covering all those topics far more thoroughly at our investor discussion on November 2.
Bill Newlands
executiveI appreciate it, and once more, I want to thank everyone for being with us on this call. We feel really good about what we achieved during the opening six months of fiscal 2024. Just like we expected, our beer segment picked up even more momentum across the portion of the year when demand is at its seasonal peak, producing outstanding results. Within our Wine and Spirits lineup, the premium end of our portfolio kept beating the market and expanding in tracked channels, and we anticipate that side of the business growing faster once we get into the back half. Taking everything into account, our confidence in the guidance for the entire year hasn't wavered, and we've narrowed the projected growth for beer toward the top end of where we first set the range, while also lifting our total EPS forecast thanks to pushing interest costs down through the steps we took on debt ahead of time. Before I finish, I'd love for you to mark your calendars and listen in to our Investor Day coming up on November 2nd, since that's when we'll lay out our freshest thinking on where the business is headed over the medium term. More information about joining that event is available on our Investor Relations site, ir.cbrands.com. Once again, thanks for being here today, and we hope to see nearly all of you — maybe every one of you — on November 2.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. That brings today’s teleconference to a close; we’re grateful that you joined us. You’re welcome to disconnect now. Have a great rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Constellation Brands, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Constellation Brands, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Constellation Brands, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.