Constellation Brands, Inc. (STZ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 5, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Staples Beverages earnings 66 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Joseph Suarez

executive
#1

Ahead of handing things over to Bill, as we've done in previous quarters, I'd appreciate it if each person would stick to a single question, since that will let us wrap up the call on schedule. Thank you in advance — and Bill, over to you.

Bill Newlands

executive
#2

Thanks, Joe, and congrats on the new role. Good morning, everyone, and happy New Year. Welcome to the Q3 fiscal 2024 call. I hope your holiday season was wonderful and that you got to enjoy some of our great products with family and friends. There's a lot to cover today, so let's begin with the quarter's key takeaways. First, I'm happy to say our beer business once again turned in very strong results, and the momentum built as Q3 went on; for our beer portfolio, depletions grew more than 8%, and the finish to November was especially impressive. We topped Thanksgiving beer sales in U.S. tracked channels, and momentum kept building in that final week of the month, which reflects both continued robust consumer demand and replenishment following this year's earlier Thanksgiving holiday. And for yet another full quarter, we posted leading share gains in tracked channels, expanding by more than two points in the U.S. beer category and by close to three points in the higher end; that makes 55 straight quarters of depletion growth for our beer business and the 10th leading share gains. Second, consistent with our steady, disciplined, balanced capital allocation approach, we bought back $215 million of shares in Q3, while keeping our net leverage ratio, excluding Canopy equity in earnings, at 3.2 x, the same as last quarter, and we continued returning cash via our dividend and pushing forward organic growth investments at our Obregón Brewery and our new brewery site in Veracruz to add production capacity for our beer business. Third, as we said at our recent Investor Day, over the last few months our wine and spirits business, like others throughout the industry, has faced a broader marketplace deceleration. Given these and other near-term headwinds, we are again revising our fiscal 2024 organic net sales guidance for wine and spirits to a decline of 7%-9%, and the operating income guidance for that business, excluding gross profit less marketing of brands divested last year, to a decline of 6%-8%, which I'll discuss in more detail shortly. Naturally, these revisions don't please us, and both our leadership team and our wine and spirits teams stay fully committed to lifting this business's performance and hitting its medium-term targets; also, as we announced earlier today, Robert Hanson has chosen to step down as President of our Wine and Spirits business in a few weeks, at the close of the current fiscal year. We've begun a process to find a successor for that role, and I will step in to lead wine and spirits on an interim basis, while of course keeping my Chief Executive oversight of both the enterprise and our beer business. Even with those adjustments and shifts in leadership, as we mentioned during our latest Investor Day, we still hold the view that across the medium term, net sales growth for our wine and spirits unit ought to speed up to 1%-3%, while operating margins should climb to 25%-26%. This expectation rests on the major transformation we've carried out in recent years—work aimed at bringing our portfolio more closely in line with wider premiumization patterns driven by consumers, broadening our omni-channel reach, and moving into select markets abroad. On top of that, for fiscal 2024, our guidance for enterprise comparable EPS, leaving out Canopy, is still anticipated to stay inside the range we gave earlier: $12-$12.20. And looking at the medium term, we still anticipate low double-digit EPS growth, just as we laid out at Investor Day. Let's now walk through these main points for Q3 with more granularity. As I mentioned, our beer team turned in standout results yet again. Modelo Especial drove the momentum, posting depletion growth of roughly 12% and holding onto its place as the top share gainer in tracked channels, which reinforced its standing as the leading beer brand in the U.S. market—a position it has now reached on a 52-week basis. The wider Modelo brand family likewise posted extraordinary results. Cheladas saw depletions rise by approximately 22% compared with the prior year in Q3, and measured on a rolling 12-month basis, the full collection of Chelada flavors and pack sizes hit the 20 million case mark—more than 350% above what that group of brands was delivering merely five years back in fiscal 2019. In addition, Modelo Chelada Especial, our original flavor, recently introduced in a 12-pack, 12-ounce format, ranked among the top 15 share gainers in Circana during Q3, and we're eager about what lies ahead for our new Chelada flavor and pack size launches. Within the Modelo family as well, Oro kept up its robust first year of national expansion, landing as a top five share gainer in the high end for a third quarter; we anticipate further growth prospects for Oro as awareness builds and we roll out new pack sizes in the coming fiscal year. Past Modelo, our core beer brands Corona Extra and Pacifico carried on with solid Q3 performances. Corona Extra kept depletion growth at roughly 1%, whereas Pacifico turned in an excellent 19% gain. And on a rolling 12-month basis, Pacifico likewise crossed the 20 million case threshold, doubling the volume it had five years earlier; furthermore, in tracked dollar sales, both brands stay among the top 10 share gainers throughout the whole U.S. beer market. Our beer brands plainly keep connecting strongly with consumers, and I feel tremendous pride in and gratitude toward our entire beer team for their steady, strong execution. Against that background, we stay confident in our fiscal 2024 net sales growth guidance of 8%-9%, and when it comes to operating income guidance, we now anticipate 7%-8% growth from our beer business for fiscal 2024, as we capture added benefits this year from the marketing effectiveness steps we talked about at Investor Day. Looking out over the medium term, we continue to see meaningful chances to keep delivering net sales growth of 7%-9% within our beer business. That's underpinned by the fundamental drivers around distribution, innovation, and demographics, plus the consumer-led trends we also talked about at our recent Investor Day. We also see room to keep delivering best-in-class operating margins of 39%-40%, backed by savings and efficiency efforts spanning our cost of goods sold, marketing, and broader SG&A. And finally, we keep supporting growth in beer through modular investments in brewing capacity along with productivity initiatives, which unlock additional production upside. Turning to wine and spirits. As mentioned earlier, that business is operating within a wider marketplace deceleration. As we've said in recent quarters, we're actively working to tackle mainstream headwinds hitting our two largest volume brands, Woodbridge and SVEDKA; however, we expect those efforts to stretch past fiscal 2024. More broadly, even though we're keeping a disciplined approach to pricing across our portfolio, the competitive environment is now adding pressure through more aggressive discounting and price points beyond mainstream. Once again, we view the wider deceleration in these higher-end categories as temporary, and we've kept executing strategic pricing actions rather than making reductions the way certain competitors have; on top of that, we decided to adjust some aspects of our U.S.

Bill Newlands

executive
#3

Agreements with wholesale distributors, with an emphasis on enhancing mix, inventory, plus sales execution at the state and channel levels. Working closely with our biggest distributor partner, we're making sure the portfolio keeps moving forward on our ambition to lead at the higher end, and also on bringing our mainstream brands back to life. Turning to international, though we saw a decline this quarter because of the softer conditions in more mature markets that we mentioned before, inventories in Canada — our biggest export market — appear to be returning to normal now after the destocking tied to recent regulatory changes around inventory, so for that market we expect supply and demand to be better balanced moving ahead. Crucially, even with these near-term headwinds weighing on organic net sales, disciplined pricing and cost savings work delivered better margins for wine and spirits in Q3. Looking past these shorter-term obstacles, we stay focused on generating growth for our higher-end brands. As we discussed at Investor Day, our wine and spirits business has built a sturdier base over the past several years to push toward those goals. Since fiscal 2019, the count of fine wine and craft spirits brands in our portfolio has doubled, and we've put money into and grown our presence in faster-growing DTC channels along with select international markets; now that our structural transformation is firmly completed, I want to thank Robert Hanson for everything he has contributed across many years, starting with his initial role as a non-executive board member; we wish Robert well... and all the best in his future endeavors, and we look forward to announcing who our next wine and spirits business president will be soon. Finally, let me stress once more our steadfast dedication to a consistent, balanced, and disciplined capital allocation strategy. As we said at Investor Day, we keep aiming for a strong balance sheet that upholds our investment-grade rating, and we're progressing toward a net leverage ratio of 3x, which should be reached during fiscal 2025. We expect to keep a dividend payout ratio at roughly 30%, which supports ongoing growth in dividend per share consistent with our earnings expectations. From fiscal 2024 through fiscal 2028, we intend to put about $5 billion into growth and maintenance CapEx, mainly directed at expanding brewing capacity for our beer business. We keep repurchasing shares when opportunities arise, with $215 million bought back during Q3, leaving another $2.6 billion available under our current share repurchase authorization. And last, we keep evaluating tuck-in, gap-filling M&A possibilities against very stringent deal criteria. To wrap up, let's revisit the main points from this quarter. First, our beer portfolio and team reliably produce industry-leading results, and as laid out at Investor Day, we see substantial opportunities to sustain similarly robust growth through the medium term. Second, we stay dedicated to returning value to shareholders by consistently executing our balanced and disciplined capital allocation priorities. Third, within wine and spirits, our priority is achieving growth in net sales while improving operating margins. We'll do this by capitalizing on a portfolio that's been reshaped to skew toward the higher end, along with a stronger DTC channel plus international footprint and capabilities. And finally, and this matters, for fiscal 2024 we still anticipate enterprise comparable EPS guidance, Canopy excluded, staying inside the $12-$12.20 range we gave before. Looking at the medium term, we keep expecting EPS growth in the low double digits, consistent with what we laid out at our Investor Day. With all that said, I'll pass things over to Garth now, and he'll walk through our financial results in more detail. Garth?

Garth Hankinson

executive
#4

Thanks, Bill, and good morning to all of you. My review of how we performed financially, as is typical, will largely center on comparable basis results and walk through our P&L. That said, starting this quarter, we'll go over enterprise results first and then business segment detail, so we can better speak to how we performed versus the outlook given at our Investor Day at those different levels. Starting with net sales, for the quarter our enterprise-wide top line rose 1%. That came from solid beer net sales growth of 4%, partly offset by an 8% decline in wine and spirits net sales. On an organic basis, wine and spirits net sales were down 7%. During the quarter, beer depletions exceeded 8%, which Bill already noted. Summer's year-over-year momentum kept going into autumn, and that was supported by consumers continuing to show robust demand for what we offer. Additionally, depletion volumes picked up speed specifically toward the close of November, since we extended our lead across major holidays thanks to excellent results over U.S. Thanksgiving. Within the on-premise channel, depletions rose slightly — around 1% in Q3 — and made up approximately 11% of overall volumes, because we could restock following the keg issues last summer and have begun generating growth along with improving draft performance in on-premise. In beer, our shipment volumes were up 3.4%, and we got favorable pricing a little over 1%, since we began lapping the higher pricing moves from last fall. A packaging mix shift partially offset those volume and pricing gains. Taken together, those year-over-year shipment, pricing, and mix changes drove the 4%, or about $77 million, increase in beer net sales for the quarter. Over in wine and spirits, organic net sales declined 7%, due to lower shipment volumes stemming from the category headwinds mentioned earlier and our process change designed to bring shipments and depletions into alignment. Just a quick note before we get into it: like we mentioned on earlier calls this year, we've moved to adjusting shipments every quarter so they line up with depletions, rather than the old approach of making just one adjustment a year in the fourth fiscal quarter. In our view, that change in process is part of why the first three quarters of fiscal 2024 have looked less favorable by comparison. Now let's talk about operating margins. In Q3, operating income across the enterprise was up 7%, while operating margin climbed 170 basis points to 32.3%. The main driver there was a 7% gain in operating income for our beer business, which in turn lifted beer business operating margin by 100 basis points to 38.5%. On top of that, enterprise-wide operating margins got a boost from corporate expense coming down 13%. Gains in our beer segment and lower corporate costs helped, but they were partly canceled out by a 5% drop in operating income for wine and spirits. Even so, that segment's operating margin improved 60 basis points, reaching 25.4%. When you set aside gross profit and brand marketing for businesses we've sold off and that are no longer part of our portfolio, wine and spirits operating income was down 4%, and operating margin climbed 80 basis points. Let's go through those factors in more detail, starting with beer. The improvement in operating income and margin there stemmed from benefits and cost of products sold, as we continue to pursue cost efficiency and productivity savings. On the cost side for the quarter, we generated roughly $55 million in total savings. Marketing expense declined $11 million, a 6% drop, driven by timing shifts in when we spent. For context, marketing was 8.7% of net sales during the quarter. SG&A came in $4 million lower, largely due to reduced legal costs, though that was partly offset by increases in compensation and benefits, and we saw $6 million of favorability tied to the divestiture of our craft beer business. Those gains were partially offset by $12 million of unfavorable foreign currency impact, as we continued to see a stronger Mexican peso rate versus a year ago, including the effect of our multiyear hedging positions. On top of that, in line with what we projected for the entire year and our guidance, elevated expenses for packaging and raw materials remain a challenge, producing a $17 million drag during the quarter. Capacity expansions have additionally driven an $11 million rise in depreciation. Our corporate expense came down by $10 million this quarter, driven largely by reduced spending on third-party services, particularly within our digital business acceleration investments, though higher compensation and benefits partially counteracted that decrease. If you strip out gross profit and marketing tied to brands we sold last year, our wine and spirits operating income margin came in higher than the prior year. Volume softness and an unfavorable mix were outweighed by several factors: cheaper logistics and warehousing, better SG&A results thanks to less spending on outside consultants, reduced pay and benefits, more favorable input costs from our savings programs, and a smaller marketing outlay as we continue steering our promotional dollars toward more efficient, higher-return activities. Interest expense for the quarter landed at approximately $104 million, reflecting larger average borrowings and a higher weighted average interest rate. Keep in mind that about 5% of what we owe carries variable rates. To build on what Bill shared, we closed out the quarter at a net leverage ratio of roughly 3.2x — that figure leaves out Canopy equity and earnings — and we're still on course to hit our 3 x goal during fiscal 2025. When you set aside Canopy, along with Canopy equity and earnings, our comparable effective tax rate came in at 18%, compared with 18.8% a year earlier. Comparable EPS landed at $3.24 for the quarter once Canopy equity in earnings is excluded, which shows how steadily the business is growing and works out to an 8% gain. Now turning to free cash flow — our definition being net cash provided by operating activities minus CapEx. Through the first three quarters of fiscal 2024, free cash flow came to $1.4 billion, a 10% decline, driven by a 33% increase in CapEx spending tied to expanding our existing Obregón site and constructing our new Veracruz brewery. As we approach the end of fiscal 2024, our enterprise comparable EPS guidance, which excludes Canopy equity and earnings, remains $12-$12.20, and here's what underpins that. To begin with, we still expect net sales growth of 8%-9%, while our beer business operating income growth expectation has been raised to 7%-8%. During previous calls this year, plus at our recent Investor Day event, we noted that for beer net sales in fiscal 2024, our outlook remains unchanged: pricing of 1%-2% along with volume growth in the mid- to high single digits. We also continue to anticipate that second-half shipping volumes will represent about 45% of the total for the year. Bill has already explained what's behind the raised guidance for our beer operating income growth, though it's also worth mentioning that we still anticipate a beer operating margin of roughly 38% across the full year. Next, regarding the wine and spirits segment, our revised outlook is for organic net sales to fall somewhere between 7% and 9%, while operating income should drop 6% to 8%, leaving out any effect from the wine brands we sold off, which no longer show up in our numbers.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#5

Bill has already covered what’s driving those revisions as well. Third, when it comes to corporate expense, our full-year expectation is now roughly $260 million to $270 million, and that range’s lower bound is a bit below what we had previously anticipated. In a similar vein, we now anticipate slightly less interest expense, at about $450 million. Finally, and just as importantly, we still expect our comparable effective tax rate, with Canopy excluded, to come in at approximately 19%. ..; and even after an additional $215 million in share repurchases were completed during the third quarter, we continue to project weighted average diluted shares outstanding of about 184 million. Moving past the P&L, on free cash flow, our expectation for fiscal 2024 is a range of $1.4 billion to $1.5 billion, which reflects $2.6 billion to $2.8 billion of operating cash flow and $1.2 billion to $1.3 billion in CapEx; to wrap up, we keep producing industry-leading results in our beer business and stay confident that we can hit the stated EPS targets for this fiscal year, even with incremental category headwinds weighing on our wine and spirits business. Looking further out, we remain enthusiastic about the ongoing chances to create shareholder value over the medium term, which we aim to do by seizing the considerable growth opportunities available to our beer business, carrying out our consistent, disciplined, and balanced capital allocation priorities, and improving performance in wine and spirits, aided by the major transformation that business has gone through and the steps we are taking to strengthen it. For existing and prospective shareholders who haven’t yet had a chance to go through our recent Investor Day presentations, we encourage you to view them on our investor relations website, ir.cbrands.com, so you can get more insight into our medium-term view on these matters; with that, Bill and I are ready to take your questions.

Nik Modi

executive
#6

Thank you. Good morning, everyone, and Happy New Year.

Bill Newlands

executive
#7

Same to you.

Nik Modi

analyst
#8

Alright, Bill — could you perhaps give us a bit of background here? Clearly, you've shared a couple of mid-quarter updates, one over at the Analyst Day and another during the Morgan Stanley conference, covering both the beer side and the wine and spirits side. And clearly, the numbers landed somewhat differently. So my hope was that you might offer us some perspective on what, you know, precisely transpired that drove part of that gap, and whether some of the clarity or the framing you gave us regarding the discrepancies between scanner data and your actual results — you know, how ought we to be thinking about that, since I'm certain that's going to be something every one of us will need to start considering, you know, across the coming couple of weeks.

Bill Newlands

executive
#9

Absolutely. Thank you, Nik, and once more, a happy new year to you. As we mentioned during our prepared remarks, we are clearly quite happy with how our beer business performed in Q3, and we're especially encouraged by the significant pickup and the momentum that emerged beginning in November. What's curious is that the gap between Circana and our own figures shifted right around the moment Garth finished his remarks at the November conference; it's always fascinating how that happens. As we've pointed out, roughly 45% of the volumes in our beer business should land in H2, which matches that business's typical seasonal pattern. Turning to Q4 in particular, we anticipate that shipments and depletes will come in at roughly 20%-21% of our overall fiscal year volumes. At the same time, we expect to keep generating mid- to high-single-digit volume growth each year, which aligns with the depletion results we've delivered now for more than a decade. And that also lines up with what we've stated before: 1%-2% average annual pricing growth, which backs the 7%-9% yearly net sales algorithm we've committed to delivering over the medium term. Regarding wine and spirits, we are, quite clearly, revising our guidance downward once again — that wasn't a choice we made casually, and we're definitely not pleased about it. We ran through many different scenarios and in the end concluded that this adjustment was genuinely necessary to capture several things: the wider deceleration across the category, plus other elements that weighed on our performance, such as shortfalls against our earlier U.S. wholesale projections that we're working hard to close together with our distributor partners, and crucially, all while ensuring we hold an appropriate inventory position through the rest of this year, putting us in a solid spot to deliver sequential improvement in fiscal 2025. Naturally, as I mentioned, these revisions don't make us happy, and neither our leadership team nor our wine and spirits team feels good about them, yet we remain dedicated to lifting that performance over the medium term, and we expect our net sales and operating margin targets to stay in line with what we presented at Investor Day. As you've likewise observed, I'll be stepping in to lead that business on a temporary basis, and I'll be devoting considerable time to the wine and spirits division while we move through the search to name a new leader — something we've already begun, looking at candidates both inside and outside the company. As you likely understand better than most, I devoted a number of years of my career to the wine and spirits categories, and I'm eager to collaborate more closely with that team during this interim period, especially as the business shifts its attention toward strengthening operational effectiveness and marketplace execution so it can build on the reconstituted higher-end portfolio and organizational structure we established across the past few years. Yet in the end, and I would, I'd like to, Nik, restate this one more time... For fiscal 2024, our guidance for enterprise EPS is still anticipated to stay inside the range we gave before, which is $12.00-$12.20, and looking at the medium term, we keep expecting growth in EPS at a low digit rate, the same as we laid out at Investor Day. I hope that provides you with a solid sense of those items you inquired about.

Bonnie Herzog

analyst
#10

Okay, thanks. Morning, and happy New Year to everybody. I'd like to dig a little deeper into the beer margins. Bill and Garth, you lifted the guidance for beer operating income growth for the fiscal year, yet that still points to extremely low op margins in Q4. So what I'd really like is a clearer picture of what's driving that, and honestly, how much visibility do you have regarding things like marketing spending, commodities, hedges, and so on, for the remainder of this fiscal year; and then maybe some color on how margins ought to phase in the next fiscal year would be useful too. Thanks.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#11

Right. So Bonnie, regarding your question about the upcoming fiscal year — clearly, we're going to provide that guidance during our April conference call. When it comes to margins for this year, though, they're clearly moving along the path we anticipated and matching what you observed in Q3. That marked the first instance of year-over-year margin gain, which is precisely what we projected when the year began. Our consistent position on margins — and this connects to our comments on volumes, shipments, and depletions — is that 55% of our activity happens during the first half, with 45% falling in the second half. As for Q4 specifically, addressing your question, it's consistently among our lightest shipping periods, so margins come in lower simply because less volume moves through our facilities. Beyond that, depreciation expenses keep climbing, which we mentioned in our prepared remarks. Even so, as I mentioned, we anticipate Q4 margins this year will exceed those from the prior year, extending the pattern of annual improvement. And clearly, we're confident in our capacity to return to that 39%-40% range, as we thoroughly explained at our Investor Day.

Kaumil Gajrawala

analyst
#12

Hello everyone, and good morning. At this point your depletion is dropping — for the quarter, if I understand correctly, you posted 8%, and the run rate came in around 8% as well. People are anticipating fairly strong shelf space gains come April. Would you be able to provide some background on what kind of bump in depletion that could translate into?

Bill Newlands

executive
#13

Okay, so here's my take on it. Like we mentioned before, the 8.2% we achieved during the quarter made us quite happy, and November wrapped up on a really strong note. And of course, as you'd probably anticipate, that momentum from late November carried over into December; so we're really enthusiastic about our capacity to keep posting outstanding depletions as we head further into this calendar year and before long into the next fiscal year. What matters most to me is that we keep picking up share. Those two share points of improvement you observed across the total category, close to three within the high end, remain the best in the industry and honestly represent a speeding up compared with the share gains we'd posted earlier in the year. So we feel quite good, once again, about 7%-9% top line, powered by a mid- plus single-digit growth profile, which, as you know, we've been saying we see the runway for that stretching well into the future; and absolutely, this quarter, and absolutely, what we expect for the remainder of the year lines up with that.

Bryan Spillane

analyst
#14

Thanks, operator. Morning, everybody. Bill, I'd like to circle back and ask a little about the management changeover in wine and spirits, and I suppose, what exactly are you seeking? What kind of qualities or, you know, capabilities do you figure are required? And then could you perhaps break out how much of the emphasis on wine, or how much of that improvement trajectory, is going to hinge on factors outside your control — meaning simply the category getting better — versus how much you'd say falls under your control, whether execution-related items or actions Constellation can take to make things better?

Bill Newlands

executive
#15

Sure. Appreciate the question, Brian. Here's how I'd put it: our overhaul of that business is mostly finished. As we've mentioned repeatedly by now, it's a dramatically different operation from what it was a few years back, despite the fact that we still carry a decent amount of business at the lower end. What I'd tell you is this — we're going to zero in on somebody who can deliver strong operating efficiencies along with marketplace execution; in our view it's essential that we step up our wholesale results in the United States, and we see ongoing chances for us to do quite well in DTC and international channels, since we've built up that business across the past 2 years. Every one of those items, I'd contend, sits firmly inside our control. Considerable effort is underway on the mainstream side of things, especially with SVEDKA and Woodbridge, to lift the results of those brands. My sense is you'll begin to witness that unfold in the new fiscal year, and we feel a portion of the softening that's shown up across the overall business is temporary and will swing back in our favor, because of the genuine momentum we've observed in our higher end offerings, such as Meiomi and Kim Crawford, plus The Prisoner, and Mi Campo, and similar labels. You know, I, I've always believed that a meaningful share of your outcomes truly rests within your own hands, and we're going to concentrate on those key elements that sharpen our business performance as we move into the new fiscal year.

Nadine Sarwat

analyst
#16

Hello, everyone. I appreciate you taking my questions. I have two parts. First, it's clear you've reported very strong beer depletions for this quarter, but when we look at 2023 across the entire industry, U.S. beer has come in below the historical ±1% that has characterized the last decade. I'd really like to hear what you think and what you've observed about the reasons behind that. Any important conclusions you can offer regarding consumer health, and what do you anticipate for the industry overall in 2024? Then lastly, to return once more to wine and spirits, it's encouraging to hear you restate that medium-term growth algorithm you shared at Investor Day. But could you possibly provide additional specifics about where that confidence in delivering it comes from, especially after today's guidance reduction? Any components you can outline. I value the initiatives you brought up, but the distance between this fiscal year's guidance and that medium growth algo is now fairly wide, so any insight would be welcome. Thank you.

Bill Newlands

executive
#17

Certainly. Let's begin with the beer market as a whole. One thing we've observed, and it has picked up somewhat, is a growing divide between the lower end and the upper end of the beer market. The upper end remains where the momentum is, and we remain the leader there, picking up nearly three share points during the most recent period. That is partly the result, I believe, of a few factors. First, we have such a solid foundation with the Hispanic consumer, for whom beer stays an essential element of their consumption habits. Our brands enjoy strong brand loyalty, and that is extremely valuable to us going forward. But another thing we've also observed — consider the light beer category. Although there has been considerable movement inside that category, among brands, the sector as a whole is not particularly healthy. It is down; and we have pointed that out consistently. So the key thing, when you consider the beer sector overall, is to view it as split in two. The lower end has struggled and has faced volume-related pressure, yet the upper end keeps performing strongly, and we are lucky to be the leader at the upper end. Regarding wine and spirits, what I would prefer to do on that specific topic, since I am about to conduct a major deep dive into that business, is that we will follow up with you and provide further specifics on where we expect our progress to happen in that business when we hold our next earnings call at the start of the new fiscal year. Here's how I'd put it: our attention is going to be locked in — really, really locked in — on getting things done and collaborating tightly with the partners who distribute for us, so that through our distributor network we beat the categories we compete in. That's going to matter a great deal to the success we keep building from here on out, and it's going to be a vital piece of where my hours go.

Chris Carey

analyst
#18

Hi, good morning.

Bill Newlands

executive
#19

Morning. Hi, Chris.

Chris Carey

analyst
#20

Garth, that beer savings figure you mentioned — I think it was $55 million — is substantial, especially when you consider the savings goals through fiscal 2028 that you presented at Investor Day. So my question is, are you accelerating savings into fiscal 2024 from later years, or is it more that you're simply getting more capable at generating savings in the short term, and maybe we ought to consider the possibility of exceeding those targets, or perhaps just gaining greater confidence that you'll be able to reach them eventually? I'm just attempting to understand the context around your self-help potential in beer gross margin, which was really robust this quarter.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#21

No, yeah, Chris, thanks for asking, and I suppose the brief response is no, nothing is being pulled forward from future years into FY 2024. What I do believe is that this year you're witnessing an ongoing evolution of a few factors. First, as we explained at Investor Day, there's the transition we've made from constructing breweries to running them. As a result, we're becoming more efficient and performing better across an end-to-end supply chain, and that's what provided our confidence — not only for this year, but also for the cost savings objectives we presented at Investor Day. We're also seeing gains from our digital business acceleration initiatives, which have been paired with the discipline we're establishing throughout an end-to-end supply chain, and that has produced considerable savings across a wide range of procurement-related areas. So once more, this is somewhat of a new capability we're developing — really more of an expansion of an existing capability — as we continue shifting from builders to operators.

Dara Mohsenian

analyst
#22

Hello, everyone. There are two quick follow-ups I have, and they relate to what Nick asked about. To start with beer, I want to get a sense of how strong things were and what depletions looked like as the quarter wrapped up — does that reflect more of a fundamental trend? Did any of it come down to timing? Is that pattern holding into December? When we see that 8% figure for the quarter, should we treat it as a genuine read on the underlying business, at least over the near term, recognizing that it isn't the guidance — but how should we interpret it? I realize it's hard to address the difference relative to scanner data. Of course, it fluctuates, but do you have any particular perspective on where that might go from here? Then I'd also like to ask about wine, if I could follow up on that.

Bill Newlands

executive
#23

Dara, go ahead and ask that now, please. The reason is that typically after you've posed your question, you won't get another chance to speak. So what is your question about wine?

Dara Mohsenian

analyst
#24

All right. So I suppose if you simply take a look, the feedback regarding the revision proved useful, along with the transformation of the portfolio over a longer horizon, but honestly, to put it plainly, that segment has delivered roughly years' worth of letdowns. Following Analyst Day, we've seen quite a substantial downward adjustment within a brief window. Therefore I was hoping to get a bit more detail regarding the reaction, Bill, plus your thinking on possibly running that operation in a different way when viewed through a strategic perspective over the long haul—maybe with more emphasis placed on productivity, or whichever adjustments come into play. But how are you approaching the idea of operating that unit differently, and possibly where it belongs within the portfolio, particularly when set side by side against what is clearly a very appealing beer operation, as this morning once more demonstrated from the standpoint of both expansion and margins?

Bill Newlands

executive
#25

Okay, so we'll start with the first item, which is mainly about the depletion numbers from the quarter. Naturally, an earlier Thanksgiving tends to give a bit of a lift, since it lets retailers replenish shelves afterward. But let's be clear, the sell-through we saw around that holiday was outstanding, and you wouldn't see such strong restocking without an outstanding sell-through period. And we're clearly happy to observe, without getting into details, that a robust November is carrying over into December just as we anticipated, since the fundamental trends in our business are still very strong. Like I mentioned in response to an earlier question, our real share gains have picked up speed throughout the year, which I view as quite encouraging too, given our ongoing momentum in that business. When it comes to wine, as I've said previously, what worried us most as we exited this quarter was making sure we finish the year with the right inventory level, and that we get ready to collaborate closely with our wholesale distributor partners to speed up that business moving forward, so we're winning in the categories and channels where we compete. There's plenty of work ahead of us there, but we still believe the strategic efforts made over the last few years to shift our portfolio much further toward the premium end will deliver returns. And once more, as I mentioned to Nadine a moment ago, I'll return with more detailed thinking. We'll conduct, as you'd expect, a rather thorough examination of that business, and I'll share additional thoughts by the time we reach our next call.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#26

And Dara, regarding those discrepancies between Circana and depletions — like you pointed out in your question — drawing comparisons between the two can be somewhat tricky. Look, for the rest of the year, or at minimum the remainder of the year ahead, we'll provide updates on this whenever we deem appropriate, but my sense is you still need to assume that gap sits in the mid-single digits. With that said, let me kind of bring everyone back to what we said at your conference last month: in our view, that syndicated consumer takeaway data is really the best tool for assessing long-term trends, plus relative performance. Just to remind you, when it comes to our own business, Circana captures only 50% of our total volumes, and there are definitely gaps between the volume growth reported by various tracked channel data providers; and, importantly, certain things simply aren't captured as such when it comes to differences in time periods — meaning shifts can occur between key weekends or holidays from one period to the next, which makes it hard to link depletions with the Circana data. So again, this isn't — we don't use the syndicated consumer takeaway data the way that you do, and that's why we say it's not necessarily the best way to gauge our business.

Andrea Teixeira

analyst
#27

Thanks, operator, and good morning to all. Given what you just said about how the quarter unfolded and what's coming in Q4, I'm curious why you didn't lift your top-line outlook for the fourth quarter. And the other thing I wanted to ask about, when we look toward spring, how much of a boost do you anticipate from shelf resets driven by business momentum — would that put you on track for that kind of 7%-9% algorithm? Thank you.

Bill Newlands

executive
#28

Let's take the second one first. We felt pretty good about the smaller adjustments that happened on shelf sets during the back half of last calendar year, but as we move into spring resets, we do anticipate some give and take that exceeds our growth profile. You'll see that we absolutely expect to close out the year performing very strongly. As Garth mentioned, and I believe I said in my remarks too, we lifted the low end of our guidance. So in fact we've increased what we expect on the income side. Naturally, that flows through to improved cash and other items, as Garth pointed out. So what I hope you take from this — what we were trying to convey — is that our business keeps delivering precisely what we told you it would: on the beer side, 7%-9% top line growth, along with solid bottom operating growth to match. And I'd say our depletion rate as we exited Q3 clearly shows that strength.

Rob Ottenstein

analyst
#29

Thanks a lot. I have a couple of things to ask. The first one is about pricing. You've mentioned 1%-2%, and for this period it came in at 1%. There seem to be two pieces here. To start, what's the overall pricing climate like across the beer business right now, based on what you're seeing? And next, since your approach to pricing is somewhat irregular — much of the country sits at 0% while selected regions might be around 4% or 5%, which then blends into that 1%-2% average — could you share some detail on when your price hikes actually land? From what I understand, your biggest rivals are taking prices up late in January and early in February, so where does your timing line up with theirs? That covers my first question. My second question concerns something I've been hearing and reading about on the innovation front: Corona Sunbrew. Sunbrew's Citrus, I believe, has gotten off to a solid start, and I'd love to hear a bit more about it. Thanks.

Bill Newlands

executive
#30

Alright. Of course, I won't discuss what competitors charge, but here's my take, Robert. We stated from the start — and honestly, both Garth and I have had some of you push back on this at times — that our view was 1%-2% was the correct strategy. That's what we've practiced across the long term; we ran somewhat above that during the extremely inflationary period near COVID, something we openly admitted and recognized. Still, I return to our consistent position: holding onto our consumer matters greatly. Losing them and then needing to win them back costs far more than simply keeping them from the outset. Over the long term, the 1%-2% formula has shown itself to be quite dependable for us, and we intend to stick with it. Certainly, in other categories, you can observe companies being cautious with pricing, which I think simply shows an awareness of where the consumer might or might not stand across different categories. On the innovation front, Sunbrew is on its way. We're planning to focus our discussion primarily on it during our introduction for that product, happening at the start of March. So I won't reveal everything about it, but we're especially thrilled about it; we believe it will be a... Once again, another highly compelling new product launch for us, following the very successful Oro launch and the very successful Aguas Frescas launch that took place in Modelo, which, as you're aware, is likewise set to expand in the years ahead. So keep watching for that one. That said, we're quite confident it delivers a strong opportunity within the Corona franchise.

Lauren Lieberman

analyst
#31

Thanks a lot, and good morning. I realize there's been plenty discussed already, but could you spend a moment on the better cash flow projection for this year? It represents quite a significant shift, and it's encouraging. So I'd like to hear what's mainly behind that upward revision to the outlook. Thank you.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#32

Yes, thank you, Lauren. So clearly, several factors are behind the movement in cash flow. And I believe that witnessing cash flow rise simply provides additional proof of how strictly we oversee the company's cash. Naturally, among those factors would be items such as the gain in beer margin, or rather, the beer operating income Bill mentioned during his comments. There will, of course, also be some positive movement in the tax, taxes I brought up during my comments, plus some other favorable items regarding, you know, tax rate or taxes and similar matters. Those, however, are the main factors.

Joseph Suarez

analyst
#33

Morning, everyone, and a happy New Year to you. Let's revisit the on-premise side of the beer business. Garth said, I believe, that it was up roughly 1% for the quarter. Is there still more ground to make up related to that keg problem you had? Then, looking ahead to the coming fiscal year, we've heard plenty about the chance to pick up share in off-premise, but could you speak to how well positioned you are to win tap handles and secure additional distribution in on-premise as well? Thanks.

Bill Newlands

executive
#34

Absolutely. As we mentioned, we faced a short-term effect involving kegs, mostly during Q2 of this year. Still, it's worth noting that in the prior year, Modelo Especial and Pacifico ranked as the first and second biggest share gainers in draft, even with those short-term challenges. That continues to be a strong opportunity for us. Consider this: Modelo Especial sits at number five in draft, yet it's the top beer by dollars in this country. However, at this moment, it's definitely not number one in the on-premise. Once more, a big opportunity. Interestingly, Corona Extra holds the number one spot for packaged beer on-premise, but there's still room to grow on the draft side. So we keep believing draft will be an opportunity for us, acting as one of our growth drivers moving forward. And Pacifico serves as a great illustration. Despite being the number two gainer, when you look at the genuine acceleration that brand has, I think opportunities remain for both Modelo Especial and Pacifico, especially in the on-premise, and I certainly hope to see both brands keep their number one share gainer status as we move into this calendar year.

Gerald Pascarelli

analyst
#35

Thanks a lot, appreciate the question. I wanted to ask about your measured and non-measured channels, specifically in beer. So if we take a look at Nielsen, your price mix at retail is moderating. Right now it appears to be tracking right at the midpoint of your 1%-2% target. So when we set that against non-measured channels, I'm just wondering whether you've observed any short-term easing on pricing, and if you haven't, would you perhaps anticipate that trends might line up a bit more closely as we move through the near term? Thank you.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#36

Broadly speaking, I'd say yes, those typically do reflect one another. On that specific point, we don't observe much divergence across channels. That said, you know, there are some really large markets that generally aren't captured by some of those tracked channels, New York being a notable example; so, you know, from time to time you do, you do see some differences, but going forward we don't anticipate anything significant regarding how the tracked channels compare with the non-tracked ones; and the moderation you mentioned really comes down to lapping the incremental pricing we implemented in Q3 of last year.

Bill Newlands

executive
#37

For sure.

Peter Grom

analyst
#38

Thank you, operator, and good morning to everybody. I hope things are going well for you; so Garth, perhaps I didn't catch it, but are beer depletions and shipments still expected to come in about the same for the entire year? And then I, I believe someone said that fourth-quarter shipments would represent roughly, you know, 20%-21% of what we ship across the full year. Does that same quarterly pattern apply to depletions too? Just, you know, quarterly mix has shifted quite a bit over the last several years, which has led to differing growth rates, you know, when comparing depletions with shipments. So I'm just trying to get a handle on how we ought to view it, particularly when it comes to the fourth quarter. Thanks.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#39

Yeah. Yeah; so regarding shipments and depletions, yes, for a full year those two should be mostly aligned with each other. That's how we run the business annually, every year. And when it comes to Q4 timing for shipments and depletions, yes, each of those falls within that 20%-21% range that Bill mentioned before.

Andrew Strelzik

analyst
#40

Thanks a lot for fielding my question. What I want to ask about is how things look on the beer side when it comes to competition and promo activity. You folks have discussed what you anticipate for shelf space gains come springtime, the bigger gap that now exists between light beer and premium beer, and also a few of the pricing trends over in wine. So I'm just wondering what you're currently observing throughout the competitive landscape, how you think that will play out as we move through this year and into the next one, and perhaps whether there are any plans, programs, or levers you'd pull if conditions were to heat up? Thanks.

Bill Newlands

executive
#41

Sure. The, you know, the..; our expectation is that things on the promotional front will stay pretty much in line with the norm. On that subject, we aren't anticipating anything dramatic. A good chunk of this, I believe, traces back to something we've said many times — namely, that the velocities our brands achieve are excellent; and clearly, when all is said and done, retailers really want to carry brands that are centered on delivering fantastic velocities along with sales per point of distribution. At our investor day, we told everyone that when it comes to sales per point of distribution, we're dramatically ahead of our rivals, and I believe that will keep working in our favor, particularly given how strongly loyal consumers are to our brands. As we've mentioned many times as well, with our measured pricing moves of 1%-2%, we don't, we don't retreat on price in the market, and I believe that matters too. So whenever we make those pledges of one-two, that's exactly what we follow through on.

Bill Kirk

analyst
#42

Hi there, just one quick thing from my side, and it might be for Garth. I caught what was said regarding beer packaging and material costs coming in $17 million higher. To me, that looks like the smallest year-over-year rise we've seen in quite a while. So, going forward, is that the modest level of inflation you'd anticipate? Or could we actually see deflation in those items during calendar 2024? And then, on a separate note, it'll likely show up in the 10-Q later, but during the period, was the transportation cost line for beer down versus a year ago?

Garth Hankinson

executive
#43

Okay, so like we mentioned, throughout the entire year, we expected to begin seeing the upside of inflation cooling off as the year progressed. And clearly, that showed up in Q3. Now, looking ahead, you raised the question about whether this represents a bottom or if it's inflationary in character. What I'd tell you there is that during our Investor Day, we provided fairly solid specifics regarding the factors we anticipate over the medium term that will bring us back to our 39%-40% operating margins. That encompasses low single digit inflation, net of our cost savings initiatives. And of course, there are a few other offsets that can occur, such as depreciation, but those truly are the factors going forward. And then logistics was somewhat favorable in Q3 too.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#44

Hey, I appreciate you fielding my question. Hey, I just want to ask one thing that builds on what was said about beer speeding up in November and on into December. If I'm not mistaken, 12 months back you'd begun noticing a deceleration caused by California weather, and the price hikes had only just gone into effect. There was a certain amount of elasticity. So was it more favorable comparisons, I suppose, that you observed which produced that acceleration, or is that a major factor? Or perhaps the comps weren't impacted by last year's weather and price increases to the degree we'd thought?

Bill Newlands

executive
#45

Well, as you frequently are aware, many elements contribute to why acceleration shows up. I believe you've identified a few. I believe California weather came in better than it had 12 months earlier. You saw Thanksgiving arrive a bit sooner than it had 12 months earlier. I believe each of those points holds true. What I'd stress, though, is that our takeout concerning our business, concerning Thanksgiving, proved especially robust, and the share gains achieved in that stretch matched the best we witnessed at any point during the whole year, which once more simply reflects the brand's strength. There are gains and losses throughout the year, as you're aware, from assorted factors that arise; but when you witness that sort of share acceleration we've been observing in roughly the 2-point range across the total category and the 3-point range at the high end, that simply reflects the ongoing strength of our beer business, no matter the possible gains and losses that naturally arise across a year.

Bill Newlands

executive
#46

Thank you so much, and I appreciate everyone being here on today's call. Once again, we're quite happy that the beer segment turned in a robust Q3 and remains positioned to land at the upper end of the net sales and operating income guidance we originally gave for this fiscal year. Industry-leading results keep coming from our beer portfolio, and we foresee a lengthy stretch of opportunities ahead to keep generating solid growth. When it comes to wine and spirits, we are entirely dedicated to delivering net sales growth and lifting operating margins consistent with the medium-term outlook for that business, as we take advantage of its reshaped, higher end leaning portfolio along with a strengthened DTC and international footprint. Looking at capital allocation, we keep steadily carrying out our balanced and disciplined set of priorities: preserving our investment-grade balance sheet, reliably giving cash back to shareholders via our dividend, and making opportunistic share repurchases beyond what's required to offset dilutions, all while pushing forward organic investments to add production capacity for the beer business and putting surplus cash toward smaller acquisitions that close portfolio gaps — though always with a careful and prudent mindset. Taken together, we stay confident about the full year, and we continue to anticipate that enterprise comparable EPS guidance for fiscal 2024, excluding Canopy, will stay inside the range we previously stated of $12-$12.20. Looking at the medium term, we still anticipate low double-digit EPS growth, just as we laid out at our Investor Day. Thanks once more to everyone for being on the call, and I hope you all have a safe, happy, and prosperous New Year. Thank you again for joining us.

Operator

operator
#47

Thanks for joining. That wraps up the call for today. We’re glad you took part. At this point, you can hang up your phones. Have a wonderful day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Constellation Brands, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Constellation Brands, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Constellation Brands, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.