Constellation Brands, Inc. (STZ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 11, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Staples Beverages earnings 65 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Snehal Shah

executive
#1

Thanks, Rob. Hello everyone, and good morning as we kick off Constellation Brands' conference call covering earnings for the close of fiscal year 2024. Joining me today are Bill Newlands, who serves as our CEO, and our CFO, Garth Hankinson. Just a quick note that reconciliations comparing the most directly comparable GAAP figures with any non-GAAP financial measures we talk about during this call can be found in the news release issued today or are otherwise posted on the company's website, www.cbrands.com. Also, whenever comparable earnings per share numbers come up for fiscal 2024 and earlier fiscal years, that means earnings per share calculated on a comparable basis, which leaves out Canopy equity and earnings, unless we say otherwise. For risk factors that could affect forward-looking statements shared on this call, please check the news release along with Constellation's SEC filings. After this call wraps up, we will also post in the Investors section of our company's website a set of slides containing key highlights from the prepared remarks Bill and Garth are delivering today. Before I hand things to Bill, and consistent with what we've done in prior quarters, I'd ask that each person stick to one question, since that helps us finish today's call on schedule. Appreciate it in advance — and now, Bill is up.

Bill Newlands

executive
#2

Thank you, Snehal, and hello everyone on this call. It's good to have you join us for the earnings discussion covering the close of our fiscal '24. To kick things off, I'll share some key highlights from the fiscal year we just completed. To begin, I'm happy to share that fiscal '24 marked yet another period of robust results for us. Comparable earnings per share rose by almost 9%, and we stay committed to hitting the medium-term goal we've laid out — namely, comparable EPS expansion in the low double-digit range going forward. Fueling that expansion was a 5% lift in net sales across the enterprise, along with healthy operating leverage that pushed comparable operating income up 7%, which works out to an enterprise comparable operating margin of almost 33%. Thanks to these results, Constellation Brands once again earned the title of #1 growth leader among large CPG companies, as named by Circana for calendar year '23 — a distinction we've now claimed in 5 of the last 7 years. No other CPG company of scale has appeared in their top 10 ranking for 11 straight years besides us. With this sustained momentum as we enter fiscal '25, we feel even more confident about hitting the targets we set out at our Investor Day last November: keeping enterprise net sales growth between 6% and 8%, achieving an enterprise comparable operating income margin of 33% to 35%, and producing low double-digit comparable earnings per share growth — all of which we plan to accomplish during fiscal '25. Turning to our segments, fiscal '24 performance came mostly from beer, where net sales and operating income each grew by more than 9% and 8%, respectively — both ahead of what we had expected at the start of the year. That momentum produced our biggest dollar share gain for any full fiscal year, as we picked up 2 points of dollar share in the U.S. beer category. We also hit a major milestone when Modelo Especial became the top beer by U.S. dollar sales. Beyond that, within all of beverage alcohol, our beer business gained more dollar share than anyone else, taking 1.1 points and accounting for close to 70% of the sector's total dollar growth. This stands as a genuinely outstanding accomplishment for our whole beer team, working alongside our distributor and retail partners, as they generated volume growth for a 14th year in a row — yet another amazing point of differentiation among CPG companies. In wine and spirits, we ran into a string of near-term category headwinds during fiscal '24, yet we still believe our approach is the right one. We've just elevated Sam Glaetzer to the role of President of Wine and Spirits. He brings well-rounded expertise and a strong record as an industry veteran, with close to 30 years in the wine and spirits space and a proven ability to drive commercial and operational efficiency and effectiveness. Sam was also central to carrying out the business transformation across the past several years, heading up our worldwide end-to-end supply chain optimization efforts and constructing a best-in-class farming, winemaking and distilling network, matched to what consumers want while creating a targeted international route to market to bring about incremental growth for the business over the medium term. Now that the strategic transformation of our Wine and Spirits portfolio is mostly finished, Sam is positioned well to guide our team in pushing a stronger emphasis on execution, along with generating growth and better profitability. Toward that goal, our Wine and Spirits team has pinpointed a number of immediate steps to assist in improving our year-over-year top line performance, which I'll get into in greater detail soon. Third, we keep achieving outstanding cash flow generation and put that cash to work in a disciplined and balanced way, supported by our steady capital allocation priorities. In fiscal '24, we produced $2.8 billion in operating cash flow, and we managed to lower our net leverage ratio by almost 0.5 point while giving back more than $900 million to our shareholders via quarterly dividends and share repurchases. We also keep investing prudently to back ongoing growth, with total capital expenditures of almost $1.3 billion in fiscal '24, the bulk of which went toward capacity additions for our beer brewing operations. And fourth, we kept delivering on our environmental, social and governance goals, which I'll cover in greater detail soon; with that setting the stage, let's shift to a more thorough look at our fiscal '24 performance, beginning with our beer business, which in spite of some tough weather during our fourth quarter, increased depletions by 9%, giving us our 56th consecutive quarter of depletions growth. For the full year, we kept widening our lead as the #1 high-end beer supplier in the U.S., posting top share gains throughout the total beer category, supported by a nearly 14% rise in dollar sales and almost 11% volume growth across tracked channels. And as we expected, we secured low double-digit percent incremental shelf space this spring while adding a further 21,000 resets via our shopper-first shelf program in fiscal '24; all these factors were major contributors to driving growth in our beer business, combined with the strength of our portfolio's iconic brands, beginning with Modelo Especial, which raised depletions by almost 10% and held onto its leading spot as the top share gainer, and as mentioned before, the #1 overall beer brand in U.S. tracked channels. Corona Extra lifted depletions by nearly 1% and kept its place as the #3 high-end beer brand in the U.S; and Pacifico posted depletion growth above 17% as it hit the 20 million case sold milestone and stayed a top 10 share gainer throughout the total beer category and the #4 share gainer in the high end. As we keep extending what our famous labels have achieved, we're likewise gaining solid momentum from targeted new products that match trends driven by consumers around premiumization, flavor, and betterment. Depletions for our Modelo Chelada lineup grew 30%, and it also went past 20 million cases sold, holding the #1 Chelada position in the category, backed by the release of Sandía Picante, a new flavor, plus additional pack size options. We're eager to keep capitalizing on that momentum during fiscal '25 by introducing 2 more flavors, Fresa Picante and Negra con Chile. With its nationwide rollout, Modelo Oro created a robust base for the brand, climbing to a top 5 share gainer throughout the entire beer category and the #3 share gainer within the high end using merely 2 SKUs. Because of that favorable response and continuing shopper desire for betterment items, we're adding 2 additional Modelo Oro SKUs in fiscal '25: an 18-pack along with a 24-pack. Remaining inside the Modelo brand family, the new Aguas Frescas variety pack took the #1 new FMB place in Nevada, its test market. Thus, in fiscal '25, we'll grow its rollout into another 20 markets for this authentic liquid that matches flavor trends driven by consumers and showcases our project, our nitro technology; within our Corona brand family, we rolled out Corona nonalcoholic, which holds the leading dollar share gainer spot in the rapidly expanding nonalcoholic beer segment. Regarding fiscal '25, we're testing Corona Sunbrew in chosen Eastern markets. This new refreshing beer gets brewed using actual citrus peels along with a splash of actual citrus juice.

Bill Newlands

executive
#3

Our beer segment performed very well during fiscal '24, and that showed up in our capacity to keep margins at industry-leading levels by offsetting lingering inflationary pressures through savings on costs and efficiency programs. We kept putting money into that beer segment too during fiscal '24, spending roughly $950 million on capital expenditures, which backs our ability to satisfy the persistent strong appetite we're seeing for our brands by growing brewing capacity at Nava and Obregon along with the continuing construction at our new Veracruz location. Turning to fiscal '25, consistent with the blueprint shared at our Investor Day in November, we anticipate the beer segment staying inside our net sales growth algorithm of 7% to 9%, with operating margins improving steadily, aided by operating income growth of 10% to 12%. Now to Wine and Spirits. Mostly because of the tough market conditions mentioned before, our Wine and Spirits segment experienced drops of about 8% in both organic net sales and operating income, yet it still finished inside the revised guidance range we gave. Although we don't anticipate the persistent difficulties in the Wine and Spirits category to fade right away, especially within the mainstream and premium price segments, we've pinpointed a number of areas to boost how our wine and spirits segment performs in fiscal '25. These include, though aren't limited to, redirecting our focus inside our premium and above brands so we more reliably generate growth in our most scaled and central offerings—particularly Crawford, Meiomi, The Prisoner, High West and Mi Campo—while speeding up extra tactical investments aimed at reviving the equity and bolstering demand for Woodbridge, our biggest mainstream brand, and making sure we keep backing the transformation of other meaningful brands in our portfolio, for example SVEDKA, Vint by Robert Mondavi, Ruffino and Lumina. Remember that these eleven labels make up three-quarters of net sales and over 80% of volumes in our Wine and Spirits segment during fiscal '24, which is why we plan to direct more attention and funding their way. Getting on the same page with our U.S. wholesale distributor partners about clear priorities is one more crucial area we're zeroing in on, so we can boost results in our largest markets and channels. As we mentioned on our prior call, those priorities involve a sharper focus on bettering mix, inventory and sales execution; we'll additionally be putting more money into media spend and price promotions plus making adjustments to our own sales capabilities so we can better assist our distributor partners' execution and go-to-market efforts; and much like our beer segment, we'll keep concentrating more widely on efficiency opportunities to generate operational and sales excellence throughout our Wine and Spirits segment. That covers the operational and supply chain initiatives we highlighted at our Investor Day, as well as improvements to the business's organizational structure so it can have a more effective and competitive operating model. Looking ahead to fiscal '25, within Wine and Spirits we expect net sales to stay roughly flat, with operating income falling somewhere between 9% and 11%. The sales execution focus I just mentioned should help keep the top line for Wine and Spirits on an even keel, though our operating income guidance factors in added spending on media, promotional pricing, and sales capabilities, along with continued inflation affecting some cost of goods sold and the comparison against distributor contractual payments and lower incentive compensation from fiscal '24. As we mentioned, we stay dedicated to advancing this business in the years ahead toward the medium-term targets that were shared at our Investor Day. Turning to capital allocation, we keep delivering on the priorities and targets we have stated in fiscal '24. As was noted earlier, we strengthened our balance sheet further by bringing down our net leverage ratio, backed by our robust earnings performance and disciplined debt management; we gave cash back to shareholders and directed the bulk of our capital investments toward brewery expansions to support growth in our beer business, and we keep pursuing tuck-in gap-filling acquisitions that fit with consumer-led trends and round out our portfolio. In fiscal '24, we made substantial strides toward our environmental, social, and governance objectives as well. Regarding governance, refreshment steps taken by our Board resulted in the addition of two new independent directors, each possessing robust financial expertise; we've also just shared news of the election of Chris Baldwin as a new independent Board Chair, a leader who comes with wide-ranging senior leadership know-how in the CPG industry; on top of that, staying true to our commitment to environmental stewardship, given that our original water restoration goal had already been surpassed in fiscal '23, we established a fresh target of returning over 5 billion gallons of water to critical water sheds near our operations throughout the period covering fiscal '23 and '25. The aim here is to guarantee that people and companies in the area have enough water available and can actually get it, something we see as vital for creating communities that last and prosper. And finally, during fiscal '24 we rolled out a pair of fresh environmental pledges — one focused on reducing waste at our most important operating sites, the other on making packaging more circular. In closing, fiscal '24 marked another year of robust results and meaningful advancement on our strategic priorities, and we anticipate carrying that momentum forward into fiscal '25. We're confident we can continue delivering shareholder value and honoring our commitments. That includes reaching low double-digit comparable EPS growth through high single-digit net sales growth, plus best-in-class margins for our beer business. It also means navigating category challenges and lifting the growth trajectory of our Wine and Spirits business through stronger execution, while preserving our capital allocation discipline and our dedication to operating in a manner that benefits both business and the world. To close things out, I'd like to express my gratitude one more time to every one of our team members throughout Constellation, and to our partners in trade, for the effort and commitment they've shown in getting us to yet another year of results that lead the industry — and my sense is that we're set up nicely to carry that momentum forward into fiscal '25. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Garth, who can walk you through our financial results and outlook in greater depth.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#4

Thank you, Bill, and good morning to all of you. As we normally do, I'll concentrate my remarks primarily on the comparable P&L figures, beginning with the enterprise level before moving into segment-level information for fiscal '24. After that, I'll cover our fiscal '25 outlook and expectations in that same manner. Let's begin with net sales. At the enterprise level, we posted growth above 5%, coming in slightly ahead of the 4% to 5% range we had guided to for fiscal '24; the driver was the powerful showing from our beer business, where net sales rose more than 9%, above our 8% to 9% guidance. As Bill mentioned, we had another strong year in our beer segment when it comes to depletion growth, which came in at 7.5%, and the portfolio's strength carried us across every month. Depletions in off-premise channels increased by over 8%, accounting for roughly 89% of the total volume we deplete. The remaining portion comes from on-premise, which grew by more than 1%. With the incremental shelf space we gained this spring — a low double-digit increase that we told you about at Investor Day back in November — we expect to keep building momentum in off-premise. We also believe there's still opportunity to grow on-premise via additional draft handles, particularly for Modelo Especial and Pacifico, in the fiscal year ahead. I'll cover fiscal '25 in greater depth in a moment. During fiscal '24, our beer segment's shipment volumes increased 7.4%, while pricing came in favorably at 2%. Those gains from volume and price were partially counterbalanced by the sale of our craft beer business and a shift in product mix that worked against us. When you combine the volume, price and mix effects, beer net sales for fiscal '24 grew by just under $700 million. Regarding selling days, we picked up 1 extra sell day over the course of the year, which occurred in Q4. The impact on our volumes was negligible, because on an absolute basis, shipments and depletions matched up at over 99% for the full year. Now, on the Wine and Spirits side of things, net sales were down 9% as reported and 8% organically. That organic decline for Wine and Spirits came in inside the reduced guidance range we'd given of a 7% to 9% drop, and it was driven largely by weaker U.S. wholesale results, particularly for our mainstream and premium brands. Like Bill mentioned, we're working alongside our U.S. wholesale distributor partners to turn things around in our largest markets and channels in fiscal '25. Beyond that, in our international markets, fiscal '24 net sales declined 7% due to destocking, with Canada — our biggest export market — standing out. Turning to the fourth quarter, our overseas business posted a 14% gain in net sales, with Canada accounting for the bulk of that improvement as stock levels there began normalizing. A 10% increase in net sales through our direct-to-consumer channel helped make up for some of the decline in U.S. wholesale and international markets. Now I'll turn to operating income and margin. On an enterprise-wide basis, comparable operating income climbed 7%, landing at the upper end of the 6% to 7% guidance range, and comparable operating margin expanded by 50 basis points to reach 32.6%. This was driven by our beer segment, which delivered operating income up just over 8% and an operating margin of 37.9%. Enterprise-wide margins also got a lift from corporate expense, which declined 11% — a reduction of $30 million — largely on lower spending for third-party consulting related to our DBA project. Partly offsetting that strong performance was Wine and Spirits, where operating income — excluding gross profit less marketing for the brands that were divested and left the portfolio — fell 8%. That decline landed within our lowered guidance range of 6% to 8%, and operating margin came in flat year over year at 22.2%. To walk through the margin drivers in greater depth, let's begin with beer. Operating income went up while operating margin dipped slightly by 40 basis points, reflecting an absolute rise of roughly 12% in overall COGS. Within that COGS increase are the effects of higher volume plus close to $205 million generated by cost savings initiatives during fiscal '24. Looking at each cost of goods sold line item in dollar terms, factoring in both higher volumes and the savings we achieved, the changes compared with last year were as follows. Raw materials and packaging represent the middle of our 55% to 60% range for total COGS, and they increased 16% on an absolute basis. Logistics makes up slightly over 20% of total COGS and was 3% higher, because a substantial portion of the benefits from our cost reduction program came from that area. Labor and overhead accounted for just under 15% of total COGS and were up 19%, which we tie to building activity at our Veracruz brewery. Depreciation, which is the remaining portion of total COGS, increased by roughly $37 million, a result of additional capacity that started operating in fiscal '24. Now on the marketing side: compared with the same period last year, our spending in dollars climbed by about 2%. When you look at it as a share of fiscal '24 net sales, marketing landed near 8.5% — slightly below the 9% medium-term algorithm we target. That gap stems partly from letting go of our craft beer brands and partly from cost savings we picked up by bringing in our new media agency. Then there's SG&A, which sits at approximately 5% of net sales and was up around 8%, driven by adverse foreign currency movements plus greater compensation and benefits costs. Those increases were partially offset by gains tied to the craft beer divestiture and by lower legal fees. With that, let's continue. Turning to our Wine and Spirits segment: the operating income margin—once you back out gross profit minus marketing for the brands we sold off in last year's divestiture—came in level with the prior year. Volume softness and an unfavorable channel mix were fully offset by better COGS, which got a lift of almost $40 million from our cost savings programs, along with favorable pricing, reduced other SG&A costs, and lower marketing spend. Interest expense for fiscal '24 landed at about $435 million, a 9% increase from the year before, reflecting both higher average borrowings and higher weighted average interest rates. We wrapped up fiscal '24 with a comparable net leverage ratio of 3.2x — that figure excludes Canopy equity and earnings — and that puts us in a strong spot to reach our roughly 3x goal in fiscal '25. On a comparable basis, our effective tax rate, again leaving out Canopy equity and earnings, was 18.5%, versus 19.2% a year earlier. Comparable EPS for fiscal '24, excluding Canopy equity and earnings, climbed almost 9% from the prior year to $12.38, landing ahead of the $12 to $12.20 range we had guided to. Now for fiscal '24 free cash flow, which we calculate as net cash provided by operating activities minus CapEx: we brought in just above $1.5 billion, beating our guidance range of $1.4 billion to $1.5 billion. Our free cash flow declined by 12% compared to last year. The reason was a 23% rise in CapEx spending, which came from expanding our current sites and building our new Veracruz brewery. During fiscal '24, we raised total nominal capacity at our Mexico brewery operations from 42 million hectoliters to roughly 48 million hectoliters. This happened because of modular expansions that started up over the summer and reached full ramp by year-end, plus additional capacity we unlocked via our optimization initiatives.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#5

Staying true to how we prioritize uses of capital, we returned cash to shareholders once more, spending more than $900 million on dividends along with share buybacks. Beyond that, during fiscal '24 we completed deals to fill gaps in our portfolio, including a tuck-in purchase of a luxury wine brand founded by a woman and a Black entrepreneur that has demonstrated a solid record of success, plus a venture investment in the fast-growing nonalcoholic category. Having said that, I'll now walk through what we expect for fiscal '25, beginning with net sales. Across the enterprise, we're aiming for net sales growth of 6% to 7%, which includes a target of 7% to 9% growth for our beer business and net sales somewhere between a 0.5% decline and 0.5% growth for our Wine and Spirits business. That beer top line projection should mainly be delivered through ongoing robust volume gains across our portfolio. Once more, we look for this to stem from distribution of our biggest brands, helped by gains from spring shelf resets, the strength and ongoing backing of our consumer base, and innovation through brand extensions, new-to-world products and additional pack sizes. Turning to beer volumes. We expect fiscal '25 shipments and depletions to move closely together on an absolute basis, just as in prior years. In the same way, we anticipate the pattern of our shipments and depletions, measured by share of annual volumes from both a quarterly and half-year standpoint, to be roughly consistent with fiscal '24; as for Wine and Spirits net sales, we look to substantially counter persistent category headwinds through the sales and marketing execution efforts Bill described previously. We also anticipate mix-related gains thanks to stronger results from our higher-end brands. Even so, we keep expecting overall volume growth to stay under pressure, largely because of demand headwinds in the mainstream and premium price segments, which represent a significant portion of our volumes. On top of that, from a net sales standpoint, we foresee unfavorable lapping of bulk sales throughout fiscal '24. Looking at cadence, we likewise expect quarterly and half-yearly shipments and depletion shares of the full-year total to line up fairly closely with fiscal '24. For fiscal '25 operating income, we're projecting comparable enterprise-wide growth of 8% to 10%, which mirrors 10% to 12% operating income growth in our beer business, a 9% to 11% operating income drop in our wine and spirits business, and a modest rise in corporate expense to roughly $260 million; within our beer business, we look for operating income tailwinds from volume growth and beneficial pricing. Those tailwinds, we believe, will be partly offset by ongoing input cost inflation, with an absolute rise in COGS, including volume growth, cost savings programs and our multiyear hedging actions, in the high single digits. Across each component, we expect the following percentages of total COGS and absolute increases. Packaging and raw materials should represent 55% to 60% and rise mid- to high single digits. Logistics should account for about 20% and climb mid-single digits. We estimate labor and overhead at around 15%, a rise in the high teens mostly due to merit salary increases tied to the business's strong operational performance, plus added headcount, mainly at our Veracruz brewery where construction continues. The rest of COGS, depreciation, should see a mid-single-digit rise, roughly a $20 million step-up, a bit less than recent years because of prior depreciation on the packaging line at the ABA facility that ran throughout all of fiscal '24. Beyond COGS, we project marketing expense at about 8.5% of net sales, below our unchanged medium-term algorithm of 9%. This shift in marketing expense as a percent of net sales for fiscal '25 stems from a change in how we allocate marketing investment, with a broad focus on maximizing value. That reallocation prioritizes our biggest brands to sustain their momentum, then our next wave brands with high-growth potential, and finally careful, deliberate spending behind our innovation pipeline. Savings also come from efficiencies tied to the new media agency partnership we announced in Q3 of fiscal '24. To finish the beer operating margin drivers, we expect SG&A at roughly 5% of net sales, consistent with the medium-term algorithm shared at our Investor Day. Taken together, that points to beer operating margins near 39%, as our beer business keeps producing best-in-class operating margins and year-over-year gains as we approach our medium-term targets. Turning to our Wine and Spirits business, operating income: we expect total COGS to rise mid- to high single digits, due to less favorable fixed cost absorption from lower volumes plus higher seller overhead and blend costs, partly offset by favorable logistics and packaging costs under our cost savings initiatives. For marketing and other SG&A expense as a percent of net sales, we anticipate 9% and 10%, respectively, each a bit above our medium-term outlook, due to adjustments in our marketing, pricing and sales investments meant to drive top line growth, partly offset by organizational structure changes, both points Bill mentioned earlier. We also expect headwinds from unfavorable lapping of contractual distributor payments and lower compensation and benefits in FY '24. With that, this implies Wine and Spirits operating margins compressing to about 20% in fiscal '25 as we keep navigating category headwinds and reset investment in certain marketing and sales activities; we believe our sharper focus on execution and planned cost savings can deliver margin improvement over the medium term toward the targets laid out at our Investor Day in November. Corporate expense should rise slightly as we keep investing in the business while cutting third-party fees more broadly. Our interest expense should come in at roughly $445 million to $455 million, with higher weighted average interest rates being the main driver, and we're looking for our comparable effective tax rate to stay where it is, at about 18.5%; noncontrolling interest should land near $35 million, and for fiscal '25 we anticipate weighted average diluted shares outstanding of around 183 million, which includes share repurchase activity. Taking those assumptions together, reported EPS should fall somewhere between $13.40 and $13.70, while comparable EPS should come in between $13.50 and $13.80, which works out to a 10% increase at the midpoint versus a year ago. Turning to cash flow, free cash flow for fiscal '25 should land between $1.4 billion and $1.5 billion, and that reflects $2.8 billion to $3 billion in operating cash flow, net of $1.4 billion to $1.5 billion in CapEx spend, mostly tied to expansions at our existing breweries plus the construction still underway in Veracruz. We're anticipating roughly $3 billion in remaining CapEx spend spanning fiscal '25 through fiscal '28, with fiscal '25 expected to be the heaviest spend year as work continues on our greenfield site in Veracruz. And as we said at Investor Day, we expect free cash flow to step up, producing a cumulative $7 billion to $9 billion between fiscal '26 and fiscal '28.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#6

In closing, fiscal '24 came to an end with robust performance, fueled by the outstanding growth that kept coming in our beer segment, where the flagship brands hit fresh records for cases sold and share of the market. Difficult conditions in the market confronted our Wine and Spirits unit during FY '24, yet we have pinpointed critical steps to sharpen how we execute and how we perform. Turning our attention to fiscal '25, our confidence is high that we can deliver on our plan, producing solid enterprise results in line with our medium-term targets, carry out our capital allocation priorities, and pursue value creation for shareholders. We appreciate the support you have given us all through fiscal '24, and we look forward to sharing updates on our progress and success in fiscal '25. On that note, Bill and I are glad to take your questions.

Nik Modi

analyst
#7

I've got 2 fast questions. A lot of people have been asking me about gross margin, so I'd love your take on whether any one-time items could have hit beer gross margin in this quarter. Then, for the second part — regarding shipments in this quarter, could you provide some context on how much could be tied to things like the Aguas Frescas rollout into wholesale or gearing up for certain shelf easements? That would be useful.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#8

Sure, Nick, I'll take a shot at both. Starting with gross margins — like we said in the press release, we recorded some write-off of a bad accrual tied to bad receivables during Q4. That reduced our Q4 operating margin by roughly 100 basis points. Clearly, gross margin would have taken a hit too, and for the entire year it cost us roughly 30 basis points, once again at the operating profit margin level — on the Q4 effect from the Aguas Frescas launch, it was extremely, extremely small; honestly, it was mostly the overall strength of the portfolio that propelled Q4.

Dara Mohsenian

analyst
#9

I'd like to discuss beer depletions. That roughly 7% figure for the quarter, once you strip out the additional day, is quite a strong outcome given the weather. Could you share any insight into how things have trended during March and April now that conditions have returned to normal, or perhaps how significant a headwind January proved to be within Q4? Just offer us some feel for the underlying trajectory. And regarding market share, you brought up the shelf space gains being outsized this year following Bud Light's difficulties. What degree of positive effect do you anticipate from that? Also, could you set that against the possibility that Bud Light's performance improves and you experience some direct consequence for your brands?

Bill Newlands

executive
#10

Sure. Naturally, our March outcomes factor into how we view the full year. That said, I'd describe March as entirely in line with what we had anticipated. It's important to remember that March contains 2 fewer selling days while April has 2 additional ones, so our internal approach treats those 2 months as a combined plan. That being said, March came in very comfortably strong, just as we had expected, and we believe it puts us on track for a truly solid year, matching what we communicated at the Investor Day in New York. As I also mentioned in my script, we achieved low double-digit growth in our shelf sets this spring, exceeding our growth algorithm, which is precisely what we anticipated. And without question, that will be among the added values in how we deliver for the full year. However, as we've stated and as you're all aware, incremental space generally does not carry the same velocity as what comes from existing velocity, since it represents marginal returns. All that said, we're quite pleased with the improvement in our shelf position. We've argued for many years that our brands genuinely merit it. They've averaged above $50 million per SKU in dollar return. And it certainly mirrors what I'm confident all retailers are witnessing, namely that our brands are fueling the category's growth.

Bryan Spillane

analyst
#11

So I suppose, taking a step back, this morning we heard that question a few times, and perhaps what's really being asked is this: at the enterprise level, we return to essentially being on algorithm for the year, yet in a year when Wine and Spirits comes in below beer — at least when it comes to operating profit growth rate, maybe somewhat quicker than usual, with a bit of assistance from below the line on interest expense; so is that simply a coincidence, right, that a gap can exist from Wine and Spirits under delivering while other offsets were present? Or did that outcome come more from the adjustments you all may have made to get there — like accelerating some cost savings or tapping into certain tax credits? So I think people are just trying to figure out how much tweaking, or how much work, was needed on your end to close that gap, or if it just happened to line up that way.

Bill Newlands

executive
#12

No, Bryan, we don't manipulate the figures. What those figures showed was really strong performance in our beer business. Like we've mentioned, we've faced some difficulties in our Wine and Spirits business. As you're aware, we've just brought in a new President for that Wine and Spirits business, and that person's priority is going to be execution. Looking ahead, several factors will make this upcoming year somewhat of a reset when it comes to the bottom line, since we're going up against a number of onetime items from the prior period. Even so, that won't keep us from hitting the enterprise-wide results we promised in New York, which we're reaffirming today. We anticipate continuing to post best-in-class performance. During my remarks you heard that, once again last year, we ranked as the #1 growth company in Circana large companies, matching what we've achieved in 5 of the last 7 years, and that — more than anything else — is what truly fuels our business's success.

Lauren Lieberman

analyst
#13

I was just wondering — you provided plenty of detail and context regarding Wine and Spirits. But I'm simply asking, because within the industry we've been hearing more about — during the prior quarter you mentioned promotional pressures. Several other producers have discussed retailers cutting back stock, observing increased inventory control on the distributor side. I'd just like to hear how you see the promotional landscape and, sort of, the current situation regarding stock levels throughout the system, recognizing that visibility inside a 3 tier setup is difficult, but I'm just interested in your perspective on system inventory online.

Bill Newlands

executive
#14

Yes, absolutely. We did observe a certain amount of inventory drawdown over the last fiscal year, especially in Canada. Inventory realignment in Canada was fairly significant. And without question, we've witnessed some of that in the U.S. too. What I believe matters most for us to keep concentrating on is that we've implemented quite a few changes; our attention will go toward those 11 brands that truly are the largest contributors to our success. That represents something of a shift. Honestly, in earlier times we'd likely spread our efforts too thin, like peanut butter, and now our attention will go toward those brands we think possess genuine long-term growth potential. We're additionally going to increase promotional spending somewhat compared with previous years, especially for labels such as Woodbridge, since that plays a significant role in the consumer dynamic. Considerable effort and research has been conducted over the last few months to ensure we grasp every consumer dynamic surrounding our key brands, and we will act on those dynamics throughout the coming year. And I believe that reflects an improved pipeline that you're seeing this year, while recognizing there will be something of a reset at the bottom line.

Chris Carey

analyst
#15

Garth, thanks for laying out your views on where margins are headed for the entire year. Could you maybe go a bit deeper on what exactly is behind the inflationary pressure on commodity inputs, first of all? And second, when I add everything up, it seems as though you might be counting on a bit of sales leverage, or else you need some additional cost reductions on the G&A line, to reach that low double-digit figure for the division across the full year; so perhaps give us some context there. Thanks for addressing commodities, and maybe also some of the assumptions behind how you arrive at the full-year operating profit figure.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#16

Sure; regarding beer margins, I believe that — above all, we should recognize that when you consider the last 2 years and the global supply chain disruption we witnessed, plus the heightened inflationary conditions we've contended with, the margin improvement that begins in the latter portion of our fiscal '24 and continues with substantial margin gains in FY '25, bringing us close to the bottom of our target range, that is quite an achievement. Looking ahead to FY '25, we'll encounter comparable favorable and unfavorable forces to those of recent years. The favorable ones, once again, will be volume-based growth stemming from the power of our brands, along with our standard pricing approach. Among the challenges, or unfavorable forces, is that although commodity prices have clearly retreated from their peaks, they remain above their long-term norms, or their recent historical norms. And a few commodities have proven somewhat stubborn in their strength, so to speak, or haven't declined nearly as much as we'd hoped. So those remain in front of us. Beyond that, we have the strong peso, which we'll keep working to manage. Thankfully, we're hedged at roughly 80% against the peso as we go into the year. So we'll handle that well. And as we've discussed at length, both during this call and at Investor Day, we have this year, as well as had last year, a vigorous collection of cost-cutting efforts that will deliver benefits to the business. So taken together, we believe there's rather meaningful margin expansion ahead, margin growth in FY '25, as we progress toward drawing nearer to our midterm growth algorithm — or midterm margin algorithm.

Kaumil Gajrawala

analyst
#17

I've got just one brief follow-up regarding the shelf space topic. You've already picked up quite a bit of shelf space. Could you perhaps give us an idea of how much additional space you're anticipating as we look ahead to this spring? And then second, it seems the strategic — or I suppose the valuation — review of Wine and Spirits has wrapped up. How much did you weigh divestitures as part of that, whether for portions of that business or perhaps for the entire thing?

Bill Newlands

executive
#18

Sure. Like I said, Kaumil, during my main comments, we anticipated getting low double-digit shelf space, and that is in fact what we're receiving in spring resets. Clearly, it differs everywhere depending on the situation, but that's approximately the aggregate total; and once more, that's at minimum as much as we anticipated. We're quite happy with how that turned out. When it comes to the Wine and Spirits business, we've said this on several occasions. Someone who drinks across all 3 categories — beer, wine and spirits — spends 6x as much as a person who drinks in only 1 of those 3 categories. So we keep believing it matters that we're reaching substantial extra consumer occasions and consumer spending by having the ability to compete in all 3 of those categories.

Nadine Sarwat

analyst
#19

I have two questions that tie into each other. First, clearly your beer volumes grew quite strongly this quarter. How would you describe the U.S. consumer's health right now? Are there any indications of trading down or a behavioral shift? My second question also concerns the consumer. A few of your peers in the industry have pointed to dry January as a bigger obstacle this year. Others are pointing to differing consumption habits among younger consumers of legal drinking age. So I'm quite interested to hear what you're seeing regarding those trends, and whether consumer behavior has changed at all.

Bill Newlands

executive
#20

Absolutely, Nadine. Our consumer's health makes us quite happy. As we've stated on many occasions, the loyalty to our brands across the franchise is outstanding. That matters a great deal, I believe. Combine that with the fact — and Garth has brought this up several times — that our pricing approach in recent years has been prudent, which differs somewhat from choices others have made in CPG. Still, we believe it's essential for keeping that consumer base, considering how powerful the loyalty is across our franchises. Another key point: the high end, the sole area where we compete in beer, keeps showing a rising buy rate; that once more demonstrates that consumers keep premiumizing, and we're ideally situated to capitalize on that. As for any shifts in consumer behavior in January and beyond, something we've pointed out a few times is betterment; in our wine business we've taken several steps to introduce light or lighter offerings such as Illuminate and Kim Crawford, plus Bright within Meiomi. In the same way, our Corona nonalcoholic got off to a fantastic start; it ranked as the #1 share gainer within the nonalcoholic category. That, I think, mirrors some evolution in how consumers act, or among those who worry about serving as the designated driver yet still wish to savor a superb tasting beer. Going forward, we'll keep stressing betterment trends through several of our product offerings, and we certainly anticipate Corona nonalcoholic continuing to expand in this upcoming fiscal year too.

Drew Levine

analyst
#21

This is Drew Levine, filling in for Andrea. So we have two questions if that's all right. First, circling back to something asked earlier, Bill, could you perhaps discuss how depletion trends looked in California compared with the rest of the country during the quarter, and how they moved as the quarter went on? Then one for Garth: I believe you referenced about $200 million in beer cost savings for fiscal '24. That seems to suggest a fairly significant increase in Q4. So could you perhaps describe some of the projects that delivered benefits, and how we ought to think about cost savings in fiscal '25?

Bill Newlands

executive
#22

Andrea, your voice dropped quite a bit since the last time you posed a question. Jokes aside, our trends were extremely, extremely robust, truly nationwide. A notable example — let me use Pacifico — depletions for that brand rose 17% for the year. And clearly, California is the big stronghold. Modelo Especial remains the #1 brand in California; yet we're also enjoying really strong results nationwide, in places such as Texas and Florida. As for secondary markets, we've consistently said they'll be a key component for us, and a great many of them posted double-digit gains over this past year. So we were quite happy to see a broad-based growth profile for our business as we wrapped up the year, and we believe we're positioned to keep that going in fiscal '25. Garth, I think the second one is yours.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#23

Regarding the approximately $25 million in cost reductions generated by the beer segment across the year, indeed, that built progressively as the year unfolded. We came out of the starting blocks extremely robustly in Q1. And once more, it escalated as we moved through the year. That escalation as we progressed through the year was really driven by 2 things. First, we discovered or implemented fresh initiatives during the year, but beyond that you gained from what was nearly a compounding standpoint for those efforts that had begun earlier in the year too. The types of initiatives we launched last year involved procurement in the sense of assorted RFPs concerning raw materials, which let us tackle a portion of the excessive hikes we witnessed across the prior 2 years because of worldwide supply chain interruptions along with the inflationary climate. There were several logistics programs involving railcars and double stacking, plus a variety of operational efforts that were in motion.

Rob Ottenstein

analyst
#24

To start, can you remind everyone how much of your expenses are denominated in pesos, on a gross dollar basis? That would be helpful. Then, turning to the scanner data — this is Circana — your price mix has sat well under the beer category across roughly the last 4, 12 weeks. I'm trying to figure out why that is. Most of the other players moved on pricing either before or after the Super Bowl; so what's the timing for your price increases this year? And again, why does your apparent realization in the scanner data come in below the market and most of the other big brands?

Garth Hankinson

executive
#25

Yes. So on the first one, regarding how much of our costs for the beer business are peso-denominated, roughly 20% to 25% of our costs carry peso denomination. And as I said, as we enter this year, we're hedged at about 80%.

Bill Newlands

executive
#26

When it comes to price realization, as you're aware, much of what shows up in these sorts of metrics hinges on the timing of when pricing increases or pricing actions were implemented. We've consistently stated that our pricing algorithm is 1% to 2%. And across the full year, we still anticipate 1% to 2% in pricing actions. As you're also aware, Robert, we handle this on a SKU-by-SKU market-by-market basis, so the timing of when that actually appears gets reflected in different time frames throughout the year. I don't believe that's something we're worried about or any sort of ongoing trend. And as we've mentioned, throughout the year, we expect to achieve 1% to 2%, just as we communicated we would.

Filippo Falorni

analyst
#27

My question is about the beer category as a whole and how you're viewing things now that we're nearing the anniversary of that big share swing tied to the Bud Light uproar last April. Obviously, your company was expanding at this pace long before that uproar, yet some worry that you may have picked up share because of it. So could you speak to whatever effect you're seeing on your company and what your thinking is as we lap those effects?

Bill Newlands

executive
#28

As we've consistently stated, when it came to that uproar, we likely weren't the one reaping the largest benefit. Still, I'd once more emphasize a point I made before: our brand loyalty is remarkably robust, and our focus is entirely on the high end. Right now, that's precisely where category growth is happening. And it's lucky for us that this is the space we compete in. Factor in that throughout this spring reset program we've recorded a substantial rise in share growth through our shelf space, and we believe our position is excellent, though we recognize we're coming off the largest share increase ever recorded in Constellation Brands' beer operation: 2 points across total beer and 2.6 points within the high end. That's a gain with no precedent, and I believe it demonstrates just how powerful our brands are.

Gerald Pascarelli

analyst
#29

Circling back to wine for a moment, Bill — the drivers you walked through in your prepared remarks really helped. That said, judging by where trends stand right now, it seems like the guidance for the year landed higher than people anticipated, and certainly higher than what we had modeled. So with 2 guide downs having happened last year, I'd love it if you could offer a bit more color on how confident you feel this early in the fiscal year about hitting flat revenue performance. Also, does your guidance factor in an assumption that the wine category will finally begin turning around from where it sits now at some point this year?

Bill Newlands

executive
#30

Well, clearly, Garth and I have put in a great deal of time alongside our Wine colleagues across the past few months, taking a close look at what we viewed as absolutely essential. Several factors play into reflecting better performance. First, we intend to collaborate far more tightly and strengthen our selling skills in support of our distributor network. My sense is we've become far better aligned on our aims and what we expect — from distributors toward us and from us toward distributors — compared with the position we were in coming out of last year. Second, we've sharpened where we're placing emphasis. Roughly 11 key brands likely weren't receiving the proper degree of prioritization across our portfolio as a whole, and we've made drastic changes on that front. Third, we're pursuing cost efficiencies inside the business, and we believe those opportunities exist. As you're aware, that paid off enormously last year in our Beer business; and we're directing some of those same resources toward our Wine and Spirits business, the ones that drove that highly impressive outcome last year. So there are multiple pieces we're setting in motion, while acknowledging this will be something of a reset year, especially where the Wine business's bottom line is concerned. Still, as we've stated, we believe the strategy is sound. It's the right one. It will carry us to our medium-term algorithms down the road. And right now, everything comes down to execution. And I believe Sam Glaetzer and the rest of the team will stay laser focused on executing against our strategy.

Carlos Laboy

analyst
#31

Could you go into more detail about how on-premise activity looked as you closed out the period, and even more crucially, how it looks right now?

Bill Newlands

executive
#32

There's been some notable ups and downs, I'd say, depending on which window you look at. That's part of what we experienced. For a short stretch this year, keg-related problems came up, and those are completely resolved at this point. On-premise momentum remains solid, and we're especially eager about where things stand as we approach Cinco — clearly the next major moment for us, and one where we've traditionally performed very strongly and picked up meaningful share in both retail and on-premise settings. So our outlook on the on-premise being a key contributor to our results this year is quite positive. Modelo, Corona Extra and Pacifico are each gaining share in that channel, and we anticipate that ongoing share growth will carry through this fiscal year.

Bill Newlands

executive
#33

Thanks, Rob, and I appreciate everyone who spent time with us on the call today. Before we finish, I'd like to express gratitude once more to our Constellation teammates and our trade partners for another impressive year of results in fiscal '24. Because of your steady commitment and rigor, Constellation has stood as a top-performing growth leader among CPG companies for 11 consecutive years. In recent times, no other company can make that claim, and that accomplishment makes us very proud. Looking ahead to fiscal '25, we feel confident about our capacity to keep building on this momentum and to unlock more shareholder value through low double-digit EPS growth, driven mainly by our beer business, which should deliver high single-digit net sales growth along with best-in-class operating margins, plus sharper attention to commercial and operational execution within our Wine and Spirits business, all while keeping our disciplined approach to capital allocation and remaining good stewards of the environment and the communities where we operate. With the important summer selling season nearly here, we hope you'll enjoy some of our great tasting products during your celebrations, and we can't wait to talk with you again on our next quarterly call. Thanks so much, and have a good day, everyone.

Operator

operator
#34

This will conclude today's conference. Thank you for your participation. Have a wonderful day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Constellation Brands, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Constellation Brands, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Constellation Brands, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.