Constellation Brands, Inc. (STZ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 10, 2025

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Staples Beverages earnings 52 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Joseph Suarez

executive
#1

Thanks, Kevin. Morning, everyone. Wishing you a happy new year, and glad to have you on Constellation Brands' Q3 Fiscal '25 Conference Call. Joining me today are Bill Newlands, our CEO, and Garth Hankinson, our CFO. Just a reminder that reconciliations comparing the most directly comparable GAAP measure with any non-GAAP financial measures we discuss on this call appear in our news release or are otherwise posted on the company's website at www.cbrands.com. For risk factors that could affect forward-looking statements made on this call, please see the news release and Constellation's SEC filings. After the call, we'll also post a series of slides in the Investors section of our company's website featuring key highlights from the prepared remarks Bill and Garth share today. Before I hand things over to Bill, consistent with prior quarters and as Kevin just mentioned, please limit everyone to 1 question per person, which will help us finish on time. Thanks in advance, and now here's Bill.

Bill Newlands

executive
#2

Thank you, Joe, and I'd like to welcome everyone to the earnings call for our third quarter of fiscal '25. Following our usual practice, I'll begin by touching on several important items about the quarter and what we expect for the rest of the fiscal year. To begin, consumer demand growth for our beer portfolio showed sequential improvement during Q3, which consequently produced a slight increase in depletions growth compared with Q2. This pickup was aided by the extra marketing dollars we put to work behind our core brands in Q3, a response to the weaker macroeconomic environment that started weighing on consumer spending over the summer. Let me remind you that generally soft spending and consumers' persistent pursuit of value have been the main near-term constraints on demand growth — affecting not just our portfolio, but likewise the rate of dollar sales growth for total beverage alcohol. Even so, beverage alcohol's portion of overall consumer expenditures is roughly stable. Consequently, we think its more modest growth rate also mirrors the spread of value-seeking habits throughout consumer goods more broadly. With that as the backdrop, and considering near-term uncertainty over whether consumers will return to more typical spending patterns in Q4, we've decided to revise our fiscal '25 outlook for the beer business, with net sales growth now expected at 4% to 7% and operating income growth at 9% to 12%, which still produces an operating margin of about 39%. Even with this sensible revision to our beer business guidance, our updated fiscal '25 comparable EPS range continues to deliver double-digit growth from the midpoint through the high end, and that figure incorporates other changes to our outlook that Garth will walk through in greater detail in a moment. Next, even though consumer demand was softer because of macroeconomic headwinds, our beer business kept beating the overall beverage industry in dollar sales growth in Circana tracked channels across the 12 weeks that ended December 1; and at the total company level, we again delivered dollar sales growth that surpassed the total CPG sector, bringing us close to 12 years as a CPG growth leader. Third, we keep executing well on our main initiatives within the beer business. On distribution, we've now locked in over half of the additional 500,000 points of distribution that we set as our fiscal '24 to fiscal '28 goal for our core brands at Investor Day, with a meaningful share of those gains coming during the present fiscal year; regarding innovation, the depletion growth contribution from our new liquids and pack formats launched during the past couple of years sits inside the 20% to 40% range we gave at Investor Day. That said, among our high-end light beer offerings — which take in Modelo Oro on the innovation side along with our longer-established Corona Light and Premier brands — we're encountering headwinds tied to competitive pricing, especially in large pack formats. Also, when it comes to our Chelada labels, we're running into headwinds on how quickly consumer demand is growing in the convenience channel, since our Cheladas are heavily represented there, thanks to that channel's core buyer base and the fact that the mostly 24-ounce can size leans more toward C-store retailers. So with that in mind, we're actively pursuing ways to tackle the competitive landscape in the high-end light beer segment, and we keep chasing distribution chances for Cheladas, backed by our continuing investments in wider marketing for those brands, such as English language linear TV advertising for the first time, plus our recent moves into 12-ounce can 12-pack formats. We also kept generating substantial demand within our portfolio from consumers who just reached legal drinking age, and we're glad that a bigger slice of our dollar sales this year came from 21 to 24 year olds, since they've been making more store trips and spending more per trip across our brands. In fact, the portion of spending from this group within our dollar sales is almost double what the beer category sees, and that portion has increased at over double the pace of the category and the high-end segment compared with last year. Finally, we also kept consistently delivering on our capital allocation priorities. On a comparable basis, we held a 2.9x net leverage ratio in the third quarter, still a bit under our 3x target; we pushed our brewery capacity investments further ahead and gave back almost $220 million to shareholders via share repurchases and over $180 million in dividends in Q3; that takes our total year-to-date cash returns through share repurchases to roughly $670 million, or to more than $1.2 billion, once you include both repurchases and dividends. So with that, let's dig more fully into how our beer business performed. In the third quarter of fiscal '25, depletions for our beer business rose 3.2%, which again marked an acceleration from last quarter even with ongoing consumer economic weakness. Shipments climbed 1.6%, which, as we mentioned on our prior earnings call, fell short of depletion growth because of the effect of planned maintenance work at our breweries during the quarter. Financially speaking, the business posted net sales and operating income growth of roughly 3% and 2%, respectively, which factored in disciplined incremental pricing taken in the fall, consistent with the 1% to 2% pricing expectations we gave for fiscal '25, an additional $40 million in cost savings achieved in Q3 as our end-to-end supply chain team's relentless focus on driving savings and efficiency keeps delivering major benefits to the business, and incremental marketing spend for the third quarter that we announced in early September. Now let's shift to how our biggest brands performed. Modelo Especial saw depletions rise by more than 3% and held onto its spot as the top share gainer in U.S. tracked channels. We still see a long growth runway ahead for Modelo Especial, since major opportunity remains across key metrics like awareness, distribution and household penetration compared with competitive brands. Corona Extra’s depletions were down roughly 1%, yet the brand still grew its dollar share and ranked among the category’s top 10 gainers. Our confidence in Corona Extra’s future expansion remains strong, since it is still the beer brand Americans love most and it has reacted favorably to the added marketing investment made in Q3, especially tied to the World Series. Pacifico posted yet another period of exceptionally robust depletion gains, at close to 20%, and held its place as the #4 dollar share gainer throughout the entire beer category. In its home base of Southern California, we keep fueling this brand’s momentum — there it already ranks as the #3 beer brand while still rising at a double-digit pace. Meanwhile, we are deliberately taking Pacifico into major metropolitan areas nationwide, following the same careful playbook used for Modelo Especial, aiming to match growing recognition and consumer pull with suitable distribution growth so that long-term expansion stays sustainable. Depletions for our Modelo Chelada brands rose by about 4%, and Limón y Sal stayed among the top 15 share gainers in the category. As mentioned previously, our Chelada brands confront a difficult consumer environment within the convenience channel, but we view this as merely a short-term obstacle and anticipate these brands will get back to a growth trajectory closer to what was outlined at Investor Day.

Bill Newlands

executive
#3

Overall, as we look forward, our goal is to keep building on the sequential acceleration in volume growth that we've seen across our core brands. We'll do that by making further progress on the business's key volume growth drivers: greater distribution, innovation led by consumers, and drawing new legal drinking age consumers to our brands, along with continued incremental marketing investments in Q4. Now turning to wine and spirits. As we announced last month, our choice to divest SVEDKA extends the steps we've taken over the past several years to bring our wine and spirits portfolio in line with shifting consumer preferences and expanding market sectors, with a focus on higher-end brands. With that in mind, we're happy to announce this morning that the transaction has closed. And we look forward to keep driving growth in our higher-end craft spirits portfolio, which posted a depletion increase of roughly 9% in the third quarter. On the other side, the effect of persistent consumer demand headwinds in the wine category, especially in the lower-priced segments, plus retailer inventory destocking, remain the main causes of a 16% year-over-year decline in wine and spirits shipments, which in turn primarily drove the 14% and 25% drops in net sales and operating income for that business. Our fine wine portfolio, though, achieved depletion growth of 6%; and our largest premium wine brands, Meiomi and Kim Crawford, delivered depletion increases of more than 7%. That aligns with our focus on delivering growth and improving margins by driving our higher-end brands and operating efficiencies, while also seeking to deliver value from our mainstream brands. Against that backdrop, the business remains focused on continuing to advance in several areas. First, the tactical pricing and marketing support actions we're taking in selected markets to accelerate our top 10 largest brands; second, with better alignment with our distributor partners to help improve performance in our largest markets and channels; and third, cost savings and operational efficiency initiatives to drive leverage to the bottom line; given the continued consumer demand headwinds noted earlier, we've updated our fiscal '25 outlook for the wine and spirits business to net sales and operating income declines of 5% to 8% and 17% to 19%, respectively. To close, we continued to manage a softer consumer backdrop stemming from macroeconomic headwinds and expect to deliver a very solid fiscal year supported by our continued progress against the key growth drivers of our beer business and our proactive actions to improve the performance of our wine and spirits business; and with that, I'll hand the call over to Garth, who will give you more details on our financial results and outlook. Garth?

Garth Hankinson

executive
#4

Thanks, Bill, and hello everybody. My remarks, as always, will center mostly on comparable enterprise numbers, along with the specifics of each business segment. Let's begin with how the enterprise performed. During the third quarter of fiscal '25, enterprise net sales came in roughly level against the same period a year ago, since softer growth in beer was canceled out by a downturn in wine and spirits. Reported enterprise operating income matched the previous year, while on a comparable basis it fell 2%, as gains in beer plus a favorable corporate expense line were outweighed by the wine and spirits decline. Comparable EPS for the quarter landed at $3.25, essentially unchanged from a year earlier, because the drop in comparable operating income was offset by gains in unconsolidated investments stemming from the shift in our Canopy ownership to exchangeable shares, together with a more favorable comparable effective tax rate. Before turning to segment specifics, I want to update you on our enterprise guidance for fiscal '25: we now anticipate enterprise net sales growth between 2% and 5%, comparable operating income growth between 6% and 9%, and comparable EPS ranging from $13.40 to $13.80. These revised enterprise guidance targets capture adjustments to the net sales and operating income growth targets for both segments that Bill mentioned earlier, plus a handful of other updates I'll walk through in greater detail soon. Now let's dig into the business segment details for the quarter, beginning with beer. Net sales rose 3%, an increase of $64 million, powered by beer shipment volume growth of 1.6%, a price uplift of 2%, or $39 million, from targeted actions taken during the fall, and a 30 basis point headwind from unfavorable mix, as consumers kept gravitating toward value-oriented larger pack sizes, especially in cans. Beer depletions climbed 3.2%, quicker than in Q2, yet still mirroring the ongoing consumer dynamics Bill described. As for selling days, they were flat in the third quarter; and remember, for the full year there will be 1 less selling day, which already occurred in Q2. Our on-premise depletions rose nearly 5% and made up over 11% of our total volumes, helped by Modelo Especial and Pacifico as the top 2 dollar share gainers in draft and by Corona Extra holding onto its top spot in packaged on-premise. Off-premise depletions increased nearly 3% and represented approximately 89% of our total volumes. Among off-premise channels, independent retailers not captured in Circana data posted a lower growth rate, largely because of convenience and liquor store channels in most of our top 10 markets, along with independent grocers in California, our top state. In those important states, jobless figures for overall and Hispanic shoppers stayed higher than the nationwide level, and we still think that's a primary short-term reason behind the somewhat weaker depletion growth we've recorded in those markets across the past two fiscal quarters. That said, as Bill mentioned, though it's unclear if buyers in those states and channels will return to more typical purchasing patterns soon, we don't see these patterns becoming a long-term structural problem; with that said, turning to our outlook for the full year on top line drivers. Although third quarter beer shipments lagged depletions because of usual seasonality and scheduled upkeep at our breweries, our expectation for the full year remains that absolute shipment and depletion volumes will be quite close together; and on a full year basis as well, as Bill mentioned, we now anticipate net sales for our beer business landing between 4% and 7%, including 1% to 2% from pricing. Turning to beer operating income and margins. Operating income rose 2%, and we saw a 60 basis point — a 60 basis point year-over-year drop in operating margin, down to 37.9%. The gain in operating income came from greater gross profit, partly offset by higher marketing spending. The gross profit improvement mostly stemmed from the net sales drivers already mentioned plus a $40 million gain from ongoing cost savings and efficiency programs, partly offset by an absolute COGS rise of almost 1%, not counting those savings. Marketing expense came in at slightly above 10% of net sales for the quarter, reflecting the added marketing moves Bill talked about. For the full year, we still expect marketing expense to be roughly 8.5% of net sales. Other SG&A expense was 5% of net sales, matching our unchanged full year guidance. Looking at fiscal '25 for the full year, on operating income, we now expect our beer business to expand by 9% to 12%, while our operating margin outlook stays the same at about 39%. Turning to wine and spirits. Net sales fell a little more than 14% in the third quarter, mostly because of a shipment volume drop exceeding 16%. That volume decrease mainly reflected the continuing category headwinds in wine, especially in the U.S. wholesale market amid softer consumer demand, along with retailers continuing to destock inventory. Even with these ongoing difficulties, we still expect better organic shipment volume growth in wine and spirits during the fourth quarter, since we anticipate more fully capturing the advantages of the pricing, marketing and distributor efforts we started at the outset of this fiscal year, while also gaining from the business's usual seasonal patterns. On top of that, retailer inventory destocking has largely begun to level off, which we believe will bring extra tailwinds supporting demand growth going forward. As Bill mentioned, for fiscal '25, our projection now is that organic net sales for wine and shipments will fall somewhere between 5% and 8%. That reflects ongoing volume challenges within the wine category, and it leaves out $23 million in net sales tied to the SVEDKA divestiture that closed recently. The wine and spirits business saw operating income drop by $32 million, which brought the operating margin to 22.1%. The main factor behind that decrease was lower overall shipment volumes. When it comes to marketing expense for the wine and spirits segment, it represented slightly above 11% of net sales and stayed higher than our medium-term target, since we keep boosting investments in our biggest brands — and the large majority of those are for our higher-end labels. Other SG&A came in at more than 14% of net sales, which aligns with our medium-term targets. Consistent with the changes we made to our net sales expectations, we now anticipate that fiscal '25 operating income for the wine and spirits business will be down 17% to 19%. That figure excludes $10 million of gross profit less marketing for the SVEDKA brands, which are no longer with the business after being divested. Moving on to the rest of the P&L. Corporate expense came to $63 million in the third quarter, a 3% drop that stemmed from reduced compensation and benefits, though that was partly offset by greater consulting services costs and higher depreciation from relocating our corporate headquarters. With that reduction, we've revised our fiscal '25 corporate expense outlook to $250 million. Interest expense was unchanged versus a year ago, landing at $104 million for the quarter.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#5

Looking at the entire year, because we keep seeing favorable conditions from reduced average borrowings along with capitalized interest adjustments, our expectation for fiscal '25 interest expense is now $410 million. Our comparable effective tax rate came in at 16.3%, versus 18% in the same quarter a year ago, and we still anticipate a full-year comparable tax rate of roughly 18.5%. To finish up on free cash flow, which we calculate as net cash from operating activities minus capital expenditures: we produced $1.6 billion in free cash flow year-to-date for fiscal '25, which represents a 13% increase over the prior year. Thanks to this robust cash generation, we've been able to reach and stay at a net leverage ratio that is below the target we set, give back more than $1.2 billion to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases up through November of 2024, and keep moving forward on our brewery investments in a disciplined and agile way. Turning to what's left of fiscal '25, we now anticipate delivering annual operating cash flow between $2.9 billion and $3.1 billion, along with free cash flow between $1.6 billion and $1.8 billion — both exceeding our original targets — and to keep putting that cash to work through a balanced, thoughtful approach to capital allocation; regarding our brewery expansions, and because of the agile modular method we use for these projects, we've moved the completion and planned start-up of our newest addition at our existing breweries in Mexico from the end of fiscal '25 to fiscal '26. As for our new brewery in Veracruz, timing is still on track, with the first phase of that facility expected to be finished by late fiscal '26 or early fiscal '27. Although the timing change for the existing breweries expansion has pushed some of our beer CapEx that we had previously expected in fiscal '25 into fiscal '26, we still expect to spend approximately $3 billion in CapEx across fiscal '25 through fiscal '28; in closing, we achieved strong progress on our strategic initiatives during this quarter and keep a solid growth trajectory for the enterprise; we remain committed to investing behind the momentum of our brands, driving operational efficiencies, maintaining cost discipline, and delivering strong cash generation while still executing against our capital allocation priorities, just as we have for the past several years. We'll keep watching closely the subdued spending and value-seeking patterns that have emerged across our consumer base, along with the economic factors driving that behavior, as well as other potential macro shifts, especially any changes stemming from possible tariff policies. As we always do, we'll aim to balance our obsession with consumers and our commitment to creating value for our stakeholders as we concentrate on executing against our strategy and stated priorities. Thank you everyone for your ongoing support as we near the end of fiscal '25. With that, Bill and I are now glad to take your questions. Thank you.

Dara Mohsenian

analyst
#6

Bill, I'd like to pull back a little and look at what's driving the weakness you're observing on the beer depletion side. If you had to break that down between the near-term consumer softness you highlighted, with the restrained spending and the bargain-hunting behavior you brought up during the call, versus certain longer-horizon worries around health and wellness — be it GLP, demographics, the aging of the beer brands in your portfolio, cannabis, and so forth — what's your take on whether you're feeling any strain from those more lasting, longer-horizon factors as opposed to the near-term dynamics you referenced? And pulling it all together, how could that shape the way you approach long-term beer revenue growth guidance?

Bill Newlands

executive
#7

Sure. The way we see it is that these near-term moves have lasted somewhat longer than we'd expected, yet we still don't view them as structural in any way. We don't view them as long-term problems tied to this business; we've observed a bigger rise in unemployment — 31, even though the overall unemployment rate held fairly steady, 31 states actually recorded a jump in unemployment, and that always has an effect. You might also have come across an interesting Wall Street Journal piece roughly 1 week back that illustrated the breakdown of consumers' spending among those earning $50,000 a year and under, and that's a segment of our business. The crucial point here, I think, as you examine this, is something I mentioned in my remarks, which is that alcohol's share of the consumer basket stays consistent. The basket overall is down, but our percentage of that basket stays the same. And I think that matters. We would anticipate emerging from this trough, and we certainly hope that will occur in the nearer term.

Kaumil Gajrawala

analyst
#8

So perhaps I could just say a little about how capital gets allocated. Given the slowdown we're seeing, how do you figure out the proper level of CapEx to put toward new capacity? And since it's macro, we truly don't know how long this lasts — maybe Veracruz gets delayed, or some of that CapEx gets pushed out. Then, on top of that, when you consider what those investments return and what risk there is to those returns, how do you weigh deploying that capital against simply repurchasing a far bigger quantity of shares?

Bill Newlands

executive
#9

Yes. A few things, I'd say. I'll begin, and then check whether Garth has anything to contribute there. Something we've stated repeatedly is that every one of our expansions right now is modular, so we can move them forward or hold them back based on whatever specific effects show up in the marketplace. Garth, I think, has made it quite plain that over the past several years our priorities for allocating capital have been steered very consistently. As you pointed out, we kept purchasing a substantial number of shares during this quarter — $220 million. From our Board of Directors, we still hold $1.9 billion in authorization for buying back shares; therefore our area of focus seems fairly obvious, and you should expect that to keep going. Garth, is there anything you'd like to add?

Garth Hankinson

executive
#10

No. I think it's just a few small items, Kaumil, honestly. And like Bill mentioned, our strategy has always been — and remains — highly flexible, highly modular. During my comments, we laid out that we are shifting some of the capacity that was going to come online this year over to next year. So once more, that's merely one illustration of the steps we've taken and will keep taking. As Bill pointed out, we've still got $1.9 billion of authorization remaining under the share repurchase program we currently have; and something we've discussed before is the cash flow inflection coming our way across the next couple of years, and we're enthusiastic about what that brings. And when we consider where the next dollar gets deployed and how it's used, we'll take a highly disciplined approach. One point I believe deserves mentioning, as Bill said, is that our capital allocation priorities have had our full commitment. Our sizable obligations tied to brewery expansion in Mexico are almost finished. Per what we said in our prepared remarks, we've just completed 2 quarters at or below the leverage ratio we target, and we've pulled back on M&A. So looking ahead, I'd say the way we deploy capital, with a lean toward giving capital back to shareholders, will probably stay the same.

Bonnie Herzog

analyst
#11

All right. So I had, I suppose, a few things about the guidance you just updated. To start, you reduced your projection for full year beer net sales growth, which is logical, but you also made the range wider, and only 2 months remain in the year. And I do get that there's plenty of uncertainty, but I'm just wondering why you wouldn't have clearer visibility into your shipments, particularly when you consider the spring reset that's coming. Then second, which key drivers would land you at the bottom end of that range rather than the top end? Based on everything you said, Bill, I'd assume that if unemployment among your core demographic gets worse, that definitely puts you at the bottom end; but have you included the effect of those terrible California fires?

Bill Newlands

executive
#12

Sure. What — as you'd anticipate, when we settled on this particular range, it accounts for risks we perceive that might possibly happen, and those would cover items such as unemployment, possible tariffs, that sort of thing. And the upside is simply the reverse of that. The upper end accounts for a scenario where conditions get better and some of these macroeconomic headwinds begin moving the other way, and then you'd see improvement across a wider range. I think the best way to frame it is that there's been a great deal of volatility; it's been extremely volatile relative to historical trends; and we felt it was prudent, given everything we can see right now, to widen the range somewhat. As for the fires, it would be quite accurate to say that our thoughts go out to everyone impacted by these fires in Los Angeles. Our priority continues to be making sure our people are safe. And past that, we are in the middle of making donations to help both the victims and the efforts of those on the ground. Certainly, how that ends is not clear right now. But certainly, that had already started. And I think our — you should view our guidance as reflecting that specific unfortunate situation too.

Lauren Lieberman

analyst
#13

Turning now to wine and spirits. I'd say it's reasonable to describe that segment as stuck in a continuing downward pattern of estimate cuts. You mentioned a few bright spots, so perhaps you can say more about what has failed to work out as intended? Which parts of the turnaround effort could use adjustments, given that the gap seems to widen and, from an outside view at least, there aren't many indicators of things settling down.

Bill Newlands

executive
#14

Of course. At the start of the year we told you it would require 9 to 12 months, and that is roughly where we stand now. In Q3, I believe you noticed a few encouraging signals. Meiomi and Kim Crawford gained 7%. Within our craft portfolio, depletions rose 9%. The toughest pressure remains on the cheaper portion of our business. That cheaper portion is struggling; however, the step we took involving SVEDKA stands as a key illustration of how we keep steering our business toward the premium side, since we think the upside for growth, margins, and profit is stronger there than in the cheaper portion; that work is ongoing. We stay hopeful that a number of these vital brands — the top 10 brands we are concentrating on — will keep improving, just as Meiomi and Kim Crawford showed.

Bryan Spillane

analyst
#15

My question, I think, really centers more broadly on the beer segment overall, and whether my read of the figures is correct — that during calendar '24 we will ship roughly the same volume as we did back in 1990, correct? The segment, in other words, is clearly ailing. So I suppose there are 2 things I want to ask about that, or perhaps 3. First, would you concur with that assessment? Second, what is going to reverse it — why would it turn? Hard seltzers appeared to deliver a modest lift, and even that has now worn off. So from where you sit on the category side, what do you believe is required to make that turn happen? And third, could you remind us what amount of volume growth across the entire U.S. beer category serves as the foundation for your medium-term sales targets?

Bill Newlands

executive
#16

Certainly. As you note, it's clear the beer category overall has not been especially robust. What I'd say is that the distinctions worth keeping in mind when it comes to our own business are these: we have, without interruption, delivered results better than that category. With Modelo, our conviction remains that substantial room to grow exists. Awareness, penetration within households, and similar measures all still represent enormous upside. And as the distribution picture showed you, we have already passed the halfway mark toward the distribution expansion we laid out on Investor Day; so I'd call all of that encouraging. On top of that, consider the growth upside you're seeing from brands such as Pacifico and Victoria — honestly, both have posted powerful double-digit growth trajectories for those businesses. Those businesses carry a somewhat different demographic makeup. So they offer some solid opportunities; and beyond that, look at items such as Corona Sunbrew or Corona Non-Alcoholic, which once again place us in somewhat different opportunities and circumstances compared with where we've been previously. Bear in mind, once you total all of that up, Bryan, we keep growing faster than CPG and have done so for more than 1 decade. So yes, although the overall category has presented some difficulties, we have, without interruption, beaten not just the category but also the CPG sector for literally more than 1 decade, and we keep expecting that we'll be capable of doing the same as we move forward.

Rob Ottenstein

analyst
#17

Great. Just a couple of quick follow-ups. First, could you give us a sense of — and this applies to the beer side as well — what your internal inventories look like for beer, and how your distributors might compare against what would be considered typical levels for this time of year? Then second, what do you anticipate for calendar 2025 when it comes to shelf space gains, relative to previous years? Any sort of percentage would be helpful.

Bill Newlands

executive
#18

Sure. Our inventories are pretty much in line with what we've seen historically. We — in case any order disruptions occur, as you'd expect, we're carrying somewhat more on this side of the border than has historically been the case, and we'll likely keep doing that until we fully understand how everything shakes out, but that's simply sound business. Honestly, it doesn't affect ongoing inventory levels. Given the outsized double-digit gains we achieved in shelf positions during the past calendar year, we would expect that the year ahead would probably be a more normal one, in which we have consistently outperformed and added shelf presence, mainly because we've outperformed the category, both at the high end and across the overall beer category collectively; so although we haven't attached an exact percentage to that yet, Robert, we would expect to keep gaining shelf because, frankly, we've earned it.

Andrea Teixeira

analyst
#19

I've got a follow-up about volume. But honestly, what I really want to know is how we should be thinking about tariff exposure. Obviously, I get that you're doing lobbying work around certain raw materials sourced from American farmers. Still, going by your long-term framework, suppose a tariff actually got put in place — would volume be the priority for you? Put differently, would you accept weaker pricing because of elasticity? Or would you treat that 39% to 40% as the operating margin target we're committed to, accepting an early hit but refusing to back away from it? Then, as a second part, I remember Bonnie raising this — the volume range struck me as really wide. With only about 45 days remaining, it looked like somewhere between minus 5% and plus 9%, assuming my math holds up. I do understand the puts and takes, and that visibility is limited. That said, what would actually push you down to minus 5%, considering that from what we can tell, volume is still growing in the track channel?

Bill Newlands

executive
#20

Sure. First, a small correction on that last item: our projection for beer volume growth was 4% to 7%. It wasn't negative — it's 4% to 7% plus. So let's just be clear about that specific point. As for the tariff

Andrea Teixeira

analyst
#21

Regarding just this quarter — my apologies, only for the quarter — I think the range is actually quite broad for the quarter as such, meaning Q4.

Bill Newlands

executive
#22

So to keep answering what you asked, when it comes to the tariff situation, we have several what-if cases, which is what you'd anticipate, and it's genuinely too soon to speculate on what could or couldn't take place. As you'd anticipate, there are many permutations we've gone through, and of course we'll modify our strategy based on which terms — based on how things unfold down the road.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#23

And Andrea, let me quickly add to what you asked about Q4, okay? As Bill mentioned when he answered Bonnie earlier, we recognize the range at this point is somewhat broader than what we normally have at this point in the calendar year. The reason for that is to recognize there could be ongoing risk at the lower end, depending on macroeconomic conditions and whether they get better, remain the same, or deteriorate, but there's also upside at the upper end too. When we consider those macroeconomic risks that might materialize, clearly, as we've discussed during this call, unemployment is what worries us most, though other factors exist too. Luckily, today's print on unemployment looked favorable. So with luck, that keeps going and works in our favor as we move through Q4.

Filippo Falorni

analyst
#24

I'd like to ask about beer margins. Clearly they declined versus a year ago this quarter, but with the advertising bump you mentioned, when you look slightly forward regarding the beer margin opportunity, could you discuss what's possible from pricing, commodities, and also the FX factor considering how weak things have been lately?

Garth Hankinson

executive
#25

Yeah. So far as beer margins go. Honestly, our view on beer margins hasn't really shifted across the past several years. The proper lens for our beer margin profile, we believe, is that 39% to 40% range. In any single year, we'll enjoy tailwinds from incremental volume, additional throughput across our footprint, clearly very aggressive cost savings initiatives we run annually, plus the pricing actions we implement. Working against those in any single year will be ordinary inflationary pressures. Clearly, as we expand our portfolio and our production footprint, we carry more, the depreciation that arrives. And then clearly, drags can emerge related to fixed overhead absorption while you're growing into that capacity. So overall, all together, we still believe 39% to 40% is the correct range for our beer margin, recognizing that in any single year, we might face more headwinds and could drop under 39% as happened in '23 and '24, when we saw outsized inflation. But some years could bring more tailwinds as occurred in '22, and we could deliver beyond 40%. So those are the puts and takes, and that's why we believe 39% to 40% is the correct range.

Robert Moskow

analyst
#26

My understanding is you mentioned that competition on price within the light beer category has begun to intensify. What I'd like to find out is — I'm not sure I caught whether you addressed it. Are you planning to push promotions harder? And broadly speaking, if industry volumes are soft across the board, is it still possible for the industry to achieve the kind of pricing it typically gets? Or could there be a danger that a portion of it has to be marked down further than usual?

Bill Newlands

executive
#27

That's something we're looking at right now — the light beer question, as you'd imagine. 1% to 2%, as you're aware, we approach it market by market, SKU by SKU. So with that in mind, I'd say the answer is still yes. Those chances keep coming up, though we pursue them in a selective way. This isn't a sweeping, across-the-board market shift. It means examining specific markets, reviewing velocities and growth profiles in those markets, and figuring out where those openings exist. The same logic holds for pack sizes. Perhaps there's something you can do with single serves compared to bigger packs, or the reverse. So our view is that 1% to 2%, which we've delivered quite consistently over the years, is still the correct approach, since large fluctuations are a negative; and that's the thing we've worked to steer clear of. In fact, as you're aware, we steered clear of it throughout COVID. We stayed far more steady with our 1% to 2% algorithm, and in our view that's more consumer-friendly than doing the opposite.

Peter Grom

analyst
#28

I wanted to ask about the beer guidance for Q4, but also a few modeling items. First, on shipments versus depletions, Garth, I believe you said you still expect them to be pretty closely aligned for the full year. I just want to confirm I heard that correctly, because that would suggest shipments coming in somewhat below depletions during Q4. And then compared with the tracked data, you saw the gap return to the low single-digit range this quarter. You mentioned softness in nontracked channels could be causing that; so should we anticipate this gap going forward?

Garth Hankinson

executive
#29

Yes. So regarding shipments and depletions. For the full year, we expect them to be largely aligned. That — you heard that correctly. As for the gap between Circana and our depletions, look, I'll say what we say pretty much whenever we have this call, which is, we don't rely on Circana data to track our depletions. Obviously, we understand that's the data point you have to use, but Circana definitely has limitations. For one thing, it only captures roughly 50% of our sales activity. So that's something you have to factor in. And there's been a lot of volatility, obviously, over the last several years when it comes to that gap and how wide it has gotten; and for those questions about what causes that gap, those are best suited for Circana and not necessarily answered by us.

Steve Powers

analyst
#30

I'd like to return to the CapEx topic that Kaumil raised earlier on this call; in your response, you pointed out that the expansions currently underway are modular in nature, and so, I suppose, that effectively gives you discretion regarding CapEx. That seems intuitive when it comes to expansions in Northern Mexico. However, my understanding of the Veracruz commitments is that they are somewhat more fixed. So could you address whether that impression is accurate? And then, perhaps more broadly, of the beer CapEx you've laid out going forward, how much of it would you characterize as genuinely discretionary through fiscal '28?

Bill Newlands

executive
#31

Let me take the first part of that. Yes, as Garth mentioned, we expect to open Veracruz in approximately 18 months, a little less, which is precisely on the schedule we had anticipated. All of that has been incorporated into our anticipated supply requirements. What I meant by modular was that if we need to add more down the road at Veracruz or at Obregon, for instance, we might — we have the ability to accelerate or decelerate further capacity expansions as needed, going forward. I think that's the advantage of where we stand today compared with a time several years ago, when frankly, we were simply trying to keep pace with demand. We're in a far better position today, which lets us proceed with capital expenditures to build out our facilities in line with what we see the business delivering.

Garth Hankinson

executive
#32

Bill, the one point I would tack onto that is this: when you’re considering Veracruz and the reality that it’ll be starting up within the same window we talked about earlier, you should keep in mind that the initial module to begin operations there amounts to just 3 million hectoliters. That means, relative to our total production footprint, it’s a fairly modest portion.

Bill Newlands

executive
#33

Alright. Thanks, operator, and thanks to everyone for being on the call today. To wrap up, during Q3 we kept navigating a softer consumer environment stemming from macroeconomic headwinds, yet our beer segment's expansion continued to beat the overall beverage industry's performance. And on a dollar sales basis, we likewise surpassed the entire CPG sector as a company. Beyond that, we kept reliably executing on our capital allocation priorities, which included giving back an additional $220 million to shareholders via buybacks during Q3, taking our total cash returned through share repurchases so far this year to roughly $670 million. As we look forward, we've sensibly reduced our growth forecast for fiscal '25 because of near-term uncertainty about when consumers will return to spending that's more normalized. Even so, we still anticipate another strong year, with our updated comparable EPS range continuing to produce double-digit growth from the midpoint and higher, supported by ongoing progress on the key growth drivers of our beer business and our proactive steps to boost performance in wine and spirits; and with that, we wish everyone a happy New Year and thank you once more for being on the call.

Operator

operator
#34

Appreciate it. That brings today's conference call and webcast to a close. At this point you're free to drop off your lines, and we hope the rest of your day is great. Thanks for joining us today.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Constellation Brands, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Constellation Brands, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Constellation Brands, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.