Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 10, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorHello everyone, and thanks for joining us on the line. I'd like to welcome you to Crédit Agricole's conference call covering results for the fourth quarter and the full year 2021. Right now, everyone attending is in listen-only mode. Once the speakers have finished their presentation, we'll open things up for a question-and-answer session. <<operator_script>> Please note that this conference is being recorded today. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll turn the call over to today's speaker, Philippe Brassac, the Group's CEO. Sir, the floor is yours.
Philippe Brassac
executiveOkay, thank you very much, and good afternoon, everyone. This is Philippe Brassac here. To begin with, I really appreciate all of you joining us. It’s a real pleasure to walk you through our key results and figures for the fourth quarter as well as for rule 2021. Hearing your questions will be very interesting for me, and I will be at the rule meeting, but the one takeaway I want to leave you with is just the fact that we managed to bring together so many banks around these very interesting and very strong results. That was possible because they were completely tied to this enormous operation — a successful effort to protect and rescue the economy from the fallout of this COVID crisis. And of course, in the years ahead we choose to steer these shifts — moving from mobilizing beyond the crisis to mobilizing beyond the transitions that are useful and necessary all around us. So I’ll stop there and naturally hand things over to Jerome Grivet to present our results and, of course, try to respond to your pertinent questions. Jerome, please.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Philippe. Good afternoon, everyone. I'll begin right away with the numbers. And if we take the group figure first, you could put it this way — as you can see on this page, for this quarter and for the full year of 2021, we are posting the highest results Crédit Agricole has ever published in terms of stated net income, which comes in above €9 billion for the full year, again on a stated basis. Turning to the underlying net income figures, net profit stands at €8.5 billion for the full year and €2.3 billion for the quarter. What's interesting is that, for both the quarter and the full year, we've managed to maintain a very significant positive jaws effect, with revenues rising much more sharply than the cost base, and the cost of risk is significantly lower. Finally, the cost income ratio at group level improves by close to 2.5 percentage points, and solvency at group level improves further as well, with the CET1 ratio now at 17.5%. If I move now to CASA's figures on the next page, you see more or less the same trends, with a net profit — stated net profit for the full year — above €5.8 billion and above 1.4 for the quarter, and on an underlying basis close to €5.4 billion for the full year and again €1.4 billion for the quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNow, regarding the specific items for this quarter—they're close to nil, actually minus 7 million, so essentially nothing. But it comes from a mix of very large positive one-offs, which were pretty much all tied to the CreVal acquisition in Italy—the final positive impact from that deal, including badwill recognition and DTA recognition. And, to sum it up briefly, we've put the largest portion of that positive one-off toward strengthening the future recurring profitability of Crédit Agricole Italia. We'll revisit this topic later. So globally, this results in nearly nil specific items. Once again, we see very positive jaws between revenues and costs, both on an underlying basis and also restated for scope effects; we have a substantial decrease in the cost of risk, and overall a sharp gain in net profit. The cost income ratio has declined. Solvency has declined—we'll return to that as well later—but it remains significantly above the <<inaudible>> requirement, and profitability is very strong, exceeding 13% in terms of return on tangible equity. Turning to Page 7, I'd highlight two key messages. First, having achieved the financial target of the 2022 medium-term plan, we're now prepared to give the market new targets, and we'll hold an Investor Day on June the 22nd this year to update the market with new medium-term targets—2025 medium-term targets.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe second key point is that we will ask the general assembly meeting to approve a dividend level of €1.05 per share — and once more, I'll go into somewhat more detail about how we arrived at that figure. Let me now move to Page 8, where we analyze how our revenues have evolved. There are, I'd say, two or three main takeaways on this page. The first takeaway: revenues are slightly higher both for the full year and for the quarter versus 2020, but what's interesting is that they are also markedly higher, and even more so, versus 2019 — keep in mind that 2020, in revenue terms, was also a very good year. The second interesting item here is that when we restate the revenue evolution for the scope effect — the main component of that restatement being the fact that CreVal was consolidated only in the middle of 2021 — we keep seeing a sharp rise in how the top line of revenue is developing. And then the final interesting point is that what you can observe is that this full-year revenue improvement is spread across all business lines; every business division managed to grow its revenues in 2021 versus 2020.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMoving to Page 9 and the cost evolution, you can see that costs matter less here than the revenue picture I just walked through on the prior page. And it looks even more moderate if we once again restate the cost evolution excluding the scope effect. What that shows is that, restated for scope effect, costs rose just 4.3% Q4 on Q4 and 3.5% full year on full year. That increase breaks down across IT investment and expenses, higher variable compensation, ForEx impact and other items. Even so, with and without scope effect, we still delivered a very significantly positive jaws effect for both the quarter and the full year. Turning to Page 10, we wanted to offer a somewhat broader horizon regarding our ability to generate revenues. Looking back over the last five years, what we see is that consistently, each quarter, we've been able year after year to raise the level of the revenues. That's the first point. And in fact, average revenue growth across the last five years was around 5%, while the cost increase averaged 2.5%, which means we've managed to improve gross operating income by 7.5% year-after-year.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd naturally, that brings a really meaningful reduction in the cost-to-income ratio, which has fallen 5 percentage points from 2017 to 2021. Turning to risks now — I mean the underlying cost of risk, so that leaves out the one-off items we booked in Italy via the reinvestment of capital gains and the bad will recognition tied to the CreVal acquisition. So when we talk about underlying risk, what this page shows is that the risk level has actually come down very substantially, for the quarter as well as for the full year, compared with 2020 — that holds true for both Crédit Agricole S.A. and Crédit Agricole Group. Risk is also well below the assumption we'd built in when we presented the previous medium-term plan: 40 bps for the Crédit Agricole S.A. perimeter and 25 bps for the Crédit Agricole Group perimeter overall. And perhaps the last and most interesting point: each quarter this year, we kept nudging up Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisions slightly — in other words, with a view to writing back provisions purely because the macro-economic scenario has improved.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAs you're aware, our methodology blends the impact of the macro-economic scenario with certain local forward-looking elements. And in fact, whenever the macro-economic scenario produced write-backs of Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisioning in a given quarter, we counterbalanced those write-backs by raising the local forward-looking component. That brings us to the situation shown on Page 12, where our coverage ratio of non-performing loans by provisions improved across the year while the level of non-performing loans declined relative to last year. And inside the overall stock of provisions we hold, we substantially raised the portion tied to Stage 1 and Stage 2 between 2019 and 2021. And in fact, on the CACEIS perimeter, one third of the €8.9 billion of provision consists of bucket one and bucket two provision. That figure has grown by €1 billion since 2019. And on the Group perimeter as a whole, the rise comes to €2 billion between 2019 and 2021, and that amount represents close to 40% of the €18.9 billion of provisions, meaning we hold close to €7.5 billion of bucket one and bucket two provision across the entire Group perimeter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat brings us to how net profit has evolved, which is laid out on Page 13. Once again, what stands out is a substantial rise — a sharp jump in net profit — for both the quarter and the full year, comparing 2020 with 2021. There's also a meaningful increase when you set 2021 against 2019. And perhaps a final point on this page: interestingly, this improvement in total profit comes more or less from two engines. The first is, naturally, the drop in cost of risk. But the second, which is nearly as significant as the first, is the growth in gross operating income. For the full year, gross operating income rose by €1.2 billion, cost of risk fell by €1.4 billion, and altogether that produced a €1.5 billion improvement in net profit. On Page 14, we show once more this comparison between our return on tangible equity — 13.1% for the full year 2021 — and the average of our peers in Europe. And once again, we've kept a very, very substantial margin above the average of our competitors. Let me now turn to some highlights of what we achieved in 2021, and in fact since the start of this medium-term plan.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveBeginning on Page 16, I’ll give a few highlights regarding further developments in our business model — the customer-focused banking business model. We have been improving our efforts, and we continue to do so, with many examples shown on this page. We have kept enhancing the digital experience for our customers, and we have kept advancing our human project — that is, empowering every team locally, as close to the ground as possible. All of this is leading to a further improvement in customer satisfaction. Once again, we have provided some examples for the regional banks of Crédit Agricole, for LCL, and for CACF. And this improvement in customer satisfaction is itself fueling further growth for us. Regarding commitment to our societal project for the Group globally, again, we are providing here on Page 17 a few examples of the various actions we have been taking — both to support our customers’ own energy transition efforts, whether corporate or individual customers, and also to shift our own financing books from, I would say, brown assets toward a greener set of assets. And I’m pleased to say that a study by Bloomberg stated that we were the only one among 30 big banks globally to have a larger green loan book than a brown loan book.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat study came out slightly earlier last year. And finally, we're also offering a few illustrations of how we're committed to inclusivity and to supporting every group that needs help — whether that's families, customers who are over-indebted, or all the young people. Page 18 is just a recap of what we presented to the press on December 1 last year. We laid out a set of markers showing our commitments on climate, on the agricultural and agri food transitions, and on strengthening social cohesion and inclusion. So on this page we're providing the list of those items. What's interesting is that we've committed to providing regular updates on how we're progressing against the achievements described on this page. Page 19 is just a reminder of all the achievements under these medium-term plans. First, as I mentioned at the start of this meeting, we've now hit every financial target we originally set for 2022. That's true for net income, which now sits well above the €5 billion threshold. That's also true — and has been true — for the cost income ratio for several stable quarters now.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat also holds true for return on tangible equity, which came in above 11%, and for the distribution policy, where we stuck strictly to our 50% commitment even though we had to skip the dividend in 2019. Then there's the CT1 ratio, which sits well above the 11% target. The switch mechanism has been fully unwound. Originally, we committed to unwinding half of it by the end of 2022, but our financial capacity actually let us complete that more fully and sooner than planned. That should help fuel CASA's profitability next year. And if you look at all the strategic operations we carried out over the last three years, I think it's fair to say we've been quite agile in reshaping our setup around every opportunity and every necessity. We closed eight new significant strategic partnerships. We completed a significant number of acquisitions totaling €4.3 billion, while also managing to dispose of certain assets for a total of €2.3 billion. So overall, the impact of this acquisition, net of the disposal, represented 50 bps of capital consumption over the course of the medium term plan. On Page 20, you'll find a wrap-up of all the initiatives we undertook last year to adapt our car financing business to the customer's new behavior and to what I'd call the new standout in this business.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe partnership with Stellantis has been fully reworked; it will be operational at the start of 2023, but the key principles are now settled, and CACF is set to become Stellantis's exclusive partner for building out their long-term leasing across all their European branches. We will hold 100% of FCA Bank's shares. And through FCA Bank we're going to build a fresh multi-brand car finance model throughout Europe. We've also launched from zero a long-term rental business aimed at the group's retail banking customers, with a target of 100,000 vehicles by 2026. Turning now to the key points for each business line specifically, I'll begin with asset gathering and insurance activities on Page 22 — sorry — just 2 important items there. The very steep rise in assets under management worldwide was driven both by the Lyxor acquisition, naturally, and by a favorable market effect plus substantial inflows, and this division's profitability keeps improving for the full year and for the quarter. On the insurance side, Page 23, it was a highly active quarter commercially, with a record for income premium in Q4 2021.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe saw very good activity in both life insurance and non-life operations, along with a really strong quarter on the profitability side, even though revenues took a hit from two things. The first is the declassification of the La Médicale disposal, which is now accounted for under IFRS 5 given that the sale is imminent. The second element is that once again this quarter we recorded a significant amount of capital gains, helped by the low corporate tax rate, and that let us bring down our financial margin so we could keep reinforcing the various provisions on our books while at the same time producing the targeted level of profit. On Page 24 we provide some longer-term elements on how insurance business profitability has evolved. What's interesting to note is that over the last eight years, we managed to grow net profit by roughly 4.5% to 5% per year, even though revenue growth was only 2% per year. So this illustrates perfectly that when it comes to insurance activities, looking at profitability on the top line alone isn't enough — you really have to go to the bottom line to fully appreciate the profitability.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the upper portion of this chart, we show that within the life insurance activity we have managed to keep maintaining a very significant margin between the yield on the asset books we hold and the profit-sharing rate paid out to our customers, while at the same time driving the insurer's profit, plus a steep rise in the policyholder participation reserve, which is assisting us going forward. Turning to asset management, Amundi released its results yesterday, so you have probably had the chance to review them. I think a few remarks will suffice. First, the 2 trillion threshold for assets under management has now been surpassed. Once again, that stems both from very strong inflows and, naturally, from the Lyxor integration at the end of 2021. From a financial standpoint, net profit is up very substantially despite a degree of normalization in performance fees this quarter. Moving now to the large customers division on Page 26, perhaps just a handful of highlights on the asset servicing business: we see robust growth in assets under custody and assets under administration, along with a steep increase in the top line.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo that's a solid improvement in CACEIS's net profitability. Turning to page 27, there are a few highlights on CACIB, and I think this quarter once again shows just how resilient CACIB is. You know that across the board for everyone operating in this market, FICC business came in weaker this quarter than in the same quarter of 2020. To some degree that was less true for CACIB than for certain competitors of its. Even so, the modest decline in capital market revenues was more than offset by a very buoyant level of activity in CACIB's financing businesses. And all in all, given that the cost of risk has been pushed almost all the way down to zero this quarter, CACIB's net profit stands at a very high level and is rising sharply compared with 2020. I'd add that this very low cost of fee level this quarter was achieved even though we've been taking a sort of overlay Bucket 1 and Bucket 2 provision across the board, and particularly at CACIB — but CACIB accounts for close to €50 million of overlay provision this quarter. In the specialized financial services division — consumer credit, leasing and factoring activities — we're seeing more or less the same trends, i.e.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe saw really strong commercial momentum during Q4. And that held up even with a few headwinds. The first one, on the consumer credit side, is that Europe's car market is still getting held back somewhat by those bottleneck problems. So everything tied to financing of new cars is taking a hit. Even so, production has risen and outstandings are higher than they were at the end of last year. As for leasing and factoring, activity was extremely dynamic this quarter as well. All of that together produces revenues that are markedly higher, a cost of risk that has come down, and net profitability that is up quite substantially across these businesses. Turning now to French retail banking, LCL, we had another solid quarter on the commercial side, with customer capture for the full year above 300,000 new customers. Books grew for both loans and customer assets, which drove revenue up quite substantially — 4.5% for the full year and 3% for the quarter. The cost base remains very well managed, roughly flat versus 2020.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRisk costs have come down, and profitability is climbing sharply. In Italy, naturally, this quarter takes some interpretation given that travel is currently being folded into our structure. Last quarter was essentially the story of bringing CreVal in from a commercial standpoint — that is, gradually getting all the CreVal operations trained up to sell the various products and services the group produces. The numbers, obviously, reflect the CreVal integration. If we look through these figures and try to gauge how Crédit Agricole Italy's historical base performed, what emerges is that revenues declined, clearly hit — among other factors — by the disposal of a very sizable non-performing loan portfolio, €1.5 billion. So naturally that produces a lower revenue level, all else equal, and across Italy we keep observing some pressure on the interest margin. Even so, fees and commissions are trending positively. The cost base is higher — up, though in reality restated for a large contribution to the Italian deposit guarantee fund — the cost base is flat.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRisk costs are coming down. As a result, net profit on the legacy perimeter is roughly flat for this quarter and improving substantially across the full year. Turning to Crédit Agricole in Italy, on Page 31 — once again, these Italian operations keep delivering a very substantial contribution to Crédit Agricole SA's net profit, at roughly 13% of that total. That works out to €750 million in net profit generated in Italy. On this page we give you a summary of all the elements tied to the CreVal acquisition and integration, and what it shows is that across two steps — the second quarter and the fourth quarter of this year — we recognized total net bad will of close to €500 million, plus certain DTA adjustments, positive DTA adjustments, and that funded a set of operations aimed at boosting Crédit Agricole Italia's future profitability as we go forward, including the launch of a next generation HR plan. That is a redundancy plan that will help us shrink and upgrade the staff in Italy, along with the financing of the NPL sale and the strengthening of the remaining — the provision tied to the remaining loan book we hold in Italy.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNow for the remaining international banking and retail banking operations outside Italy—so the four entities shown on this page—what we see is that normalization keeps moving forward after 2020, a year marked by the effects of the pandemic. As a result, we are returning to profitability levels we enjoyed before the pandemic, with net profit at 40% for the full year for this business division. The corporate center is considerably higher this quarter, reaching a very low positive figure of €26 million for the quarter alone. That reflects further improvement in the virtual components of the corporate center, with better management of the CASA balance sheet—CASA only—and also stronger performances from the businesses booked within the corporate center. That is the case for the private equity business, for instance, and there is also growth in revenues from the payment services entity. The non-recurring, or more volatile, portion of the corporate center is improving this quarter as well, with certain inflation swaps producing positive revaluation plus dividends received from entities outside the group. Allow me to wrap up this review of the different businesses with the regional banks of Crédit Agricole, where we will see broadly the same trends as those observed at LCL, with a substantial level of customer capture—plus 1.2 million new customers this year alone.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe saw a sharp expansion of the balance sheet, with customer assets at 6% and customer loans at 5%, and nearly every loan category posting significant gains. The equipment rate for regional bank customers keeps rising in insurance products, including among other non-life insurance products. So this is producing a very strong improvement in what the regional banks contribute to results — to the group's net results. Let me turn now to solvency. On Page 37, you can see how the group's solvency has evolved and how Crédit Agricole SA's solvency has evolved. At group level, solvency improves again this quarter, moving from 17.4% to 17.5%. And at CASA level, solvency is quite significantly lower, but in a very explainable way, falling from 12.7% to 11.9%. So that's a decrease of around 80 bps. And that decrease is entirely explained by two elements: first, the switch unwinding, which accounts for around 60 bps of impact on the CET1 ratio, and the extra distribution above the normal dividend that is regularly provisioned quarter after quarter. This quarter, we also have the consequences of two elements.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTo start, the buyback executed during the quarter involved roughly €500 million in shares purchased, which will be canceled. Then there's the ex-part dividend of €0.20 per share, tied to repayment of the 2019 dividend. In this quarter, we also saw some negative effects from various M&A deals closed during the period — specifically CALF's acquisition of Olinn and the purchase of Linxo. Moving to the dividend discussion on Page 38: we restate our commitment to distribute 50% of net attributable results in cash. And in this quarter — this year, rather — we're adding another €0.20 as we keep repaying the skipped 2019 dividend. We paid €0.30 in 2020. Now we will pay €0.20. That leaves a further €0.20 remaining before this 2019 skipped dividend is fully repaid. On liquidity, Page 39, I believe there isn't a great deal to add — conditions remain very ample and very comfortable; the only point is that we've begun examining the wind-down of the TLTRO mechanisms and every consequence of the gradual exit from the various quantitative easing monetary policies, so that we can be sure our liquidity position stays very strong going forward.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding Page 40 and market funding, what I can tell you is that in 2021 the market funding program was carried out without any difficulty. And we continue to stay ahead of the curve in 2022, with a significant amount of different categories of debt already issued on the market since the start of the year in very good condition. So let me now wrap up by restating that this year's results were very good, with high profitability and high solvency, but those results need to be assessed within a series of good performances we've delivered over at least the last five or six years, with a very regular set of — a very regular capacity for growing the top line, very good cost discipline, and all in all very prudent risk management. Thanks again. And let me now take your questions.
Operator
operatorThanks. <<operator_script>> The first question today will come from Giulia Miotto, who is on the line from Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead. Your line is open.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystYes. Hey, morning there, Jerome.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMorning to you, Giulia.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystHello there, two questions if I may. First, unless I'm wrong, I noticed a few headlines this morning coming out of an interview that mentioned possible additional moves in Italian M&A consolidation. So could you bring us up to date on that, essentially whether anything has shifted, whether you're seeing any opportunity, whether you're currently examining any particular target, and so on. Then my second question concerns asset quality. So I believe every bank is reporting that asset quality is really much stronger than they had anticipated when COVID began. So why are our Stage 1 and Stage 2 still going up? And in your view, when might we see some reversal of the COVID overlays, if at all — is that a 2022 or perhaps a 2023 topic? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks. Let me begin with the first question you raised. I believe you're talking about certain headlines that came out following an interview I did on Bloomberg TV earlier today. To quote my own words accurately, what I said was that the majority of our strategy in Italy consisted of continuing to grow organically, and that we were prepared, just as we had been in the past, to seize opportunities. So from that standpoint, nothing has changed. Our focus remains on organic growth, that approach is delivering results, and we remain open to opportunities should they arise and should they satisfy all of our criteria — I'd say nothing has changed. On asset quality, yes, asset quality remains very strong. You have observed the decline in the share of NPL on our balance sheets. We are — I would describe us as structurally just as prudent. That is the reason we have taken every step available to us to avoid releasing Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisions this year. And in fact, the plan is not to boost our future results by releasing this 3 billion Stage 1 and Stage 2 provision — 3 billion, pardon me — Stage 1 and Stage 2 provision that sits on our books at CASA, and 7.5 at group level; the plan is to retain these Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisions so that we can deploy them, should a moment arrive when there is a need to cover greater losses.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat is genuinely how we look at it. Naturally, we will comply fully with every accounting regulation and standard, but whenever there is some room to maneuver, we will apply it in the direction of prudence.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystMuch appreciated.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next question is from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler. Go ahead, your line is open.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystYes. Good afternoon, gentlemen. Clearly, you're delivering on that plan, and it's worked out very well. I have another question about the plan's ESG pillars, if I may. Of course, you'll recall that there were 3 pillars: human, society, and clients. Within that framework, will we see that carried into 2022? Those pillars — where do the priorities sit? Do we keep going down that road, or will they evolve in some way? And perhaps you could share a view on which has been the biggest success and where you think there might have been room to do better — that's the first question. The second concerns the dividend and the payout. It must be said that among all the French banks, you've been the most innovative and the most loyal when it comes to capital distribution, especially through this pandemic. Broadly speaking, without giving anything away, since we'll have things to get through, what is your philosophy on capital returns? Thank you.
Philippe Brassac
executiveWell, thank you, Jacques-Henri. I'm afraid my answers will disappoint you a little bit — and probably whenever your questions touch on what I'd call medium-term matters. I'll defer those answers to the June 22 meeting, since of course we have to finalize all our IDs and deliver a complete plan by that date. Still, let me attempt to give you some pieces of an answer. First, on the three pillars, the medium template we will be updating — this is not a change to the group project. The group project remains. It forms, I would say, the framework for everything we do, and we will keep it that way. That means we will hold to our price on this, and we will hold to those three pillars, as you call them: Projet Humain, Projet Sociétal, Projet en — that is certain. But we must regularly feed those three pillars with fresh IDs, fresh initiatives, and fresh action plans. That is what will be presented on June 22 this year. And perhaps more importantly, I believe this is a moment when we must accelerate massively on some of those items.
Philippe Brassac
executiveAnd I’m referring in particular to the energy transition and the climate transition, since what we clearly observe is that this can no longer simply be a nice extra you tack onto everything else. At this point it has to be completely integrated into how we carry out our activities. And if anything is going to shift, it will likely happen this way. It will come about by turning these priorities, to some degree, into the true engine driving future growth of our businesses. But once more, we’ll provide a far more detailed engine. Turning to the dividend, once again, for now we are holding to our policy, which is a 50% payout, plus — since we want to remain loyal to our shareholders, all of our shareholders — plus repayment of the dividend that was skipped in 2019. So we are sticking with that, which means that in 2021, with respect to 2020 performances, we paid 50 plus 30. In 2022, with respect to 2021, we will pay 85 plus 20. And normally in 2023, with respect to 2022, we’ll pay something plus 20. And for the time being that will be our dividend policy. And if we have anything further or additional to say about this policy, it will come in June.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystThanks, Jerome.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next question is from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America. Your line is open — go ahead.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystHello there, and good afternoon to everybody. I have two questions, if you don't mind. First, regarding IFRS 17, could you provide an initial sense of the possible effects? Ideally we'd have some clarity on this before June. So would part of the PPE be used by you to soften that effect, and what sort of capital impact should we expect from the first application? Are we under the levels other banks have already disclosed, or can you say something about the magnitude of just the initial elements, please? Second, on rate sensitivity. Looking at your reporting, you have consistently shown quite limited sensitivity to a 100 basis points shift — partly a shift. Yet in your pillar three first half results 2021, you showed a fairly significant increase, €1.3 billion, which puts you among the highest in Europe for sensitivity. Could you explain what has changed — is it a methodology change? Is it simply a one off, and perhaps you have a provisional figure to share with us for the full year. Thank you very much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat's a tough one to answer. Let me begin with IFRS 17. As you're aware, during 2022 we're preparing our accounts under both IFRS 4 and IFRS 17, with IFRS 17 purely for internal purposes. That means, quarter after quarter, we'll be in a better position to identify the differences between the IFRS 4 and IFRS 17 accounts. To put it briefly, the first thing to note is that over the long term there is no difference. It's really a matter of timing when it comes to recognizing profit tied to insurance activities. So ultimately, the assessment of an insurance business's profitability should not differ between IFRS 4 and IFRS 17. Second, as we refine our assumptions and refine our ability to make the best use of all the technicalities and all the optionalities embedded in this new regulation, we agree that, revenue wise or profit wise — shall I say — our profile should come very close to the profile we currently have under IFRS 4. Initially, this will carry a certain capital cost, because it would require us to set aside some future results in this famous consumer service margin, or client service margin.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis might affect our sovereignty somewhat, though given where we currently stand, it would be entirely manageable. So the IFRS 17 transition is definitely going to be a very, very significant undertaking. Operationally speaking, we actually have many teams that have been working on this matter for two or three years now, and we're devoting a great deal of money to it. That's probably not the optimal use of our funds, but that's just how it is. Still, they shouldn't have too large an effect on our overall profitability. And this ought to be quite manageable. Turning now to the rates. Actually, providing rate sensitivity is always — for the future it's always a very, shall I say, hazardous calculation. So what we've given in the pillar three documents is an assessment built on very strong assumptions. The first is that it reflects the outcome of developments over three years' time. So it isn't two, it's three years out. The second very strong assumption is that all rate movement passes through 100% into the various assets and immediately — 100% and immediate, which is also a strong assumption.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat you need to remember is that, on the whole, we should be capable of handling the rise in rates just as we have handled the drop in rates. In 2022, for now, it is certain that we have already built in a negative effect from the rate increase — namely the higher remuneration of the regulated savings accounts — and for LCL, that will mean an impact of around €50 million on the NBI across the full year of 2022, which is not massive. The remainder will hinge on our ability to protect the average cost of our liabilities outside the regulated costs and to gradually reprice the new loans we will book with higher hedge, because as things stand long-term rates have risen by 60 to 70 bps over the last six months while home loans rates have kept going down. So this has to stop, and we have good signs indicating that we are at this inflection point, and after that everything will hinge on the capacity to — obviously, reprice these new loans.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystAlright, thanks. I wasn’t aware that the impact was over 3 years. I thought that was just the first-year effect.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNo, no — that was a 3-year impact.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next question is from Guillaume Tiberghien at Exane. Your line is open — go ahead.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystYes. Morning — afternoon. Thanks for the presentation. There are two things I want to ask. First, regarding the resolution fund: a competitor of yours in France appears to be pointing to a 10% to 15% rise for 2022, while another mentions roughly a 30% to 40% increase for 2022. So what guidance can you offer us? Second, on the SFS and the Stellantis JV: is it unfair to suggest that, between the point when you halt the current partnership and run off a portion of the book, and the point when you build a fresh book from scratch, there will be a bit of a stretch in 2022 during which revenues may not be all that strong and costs will rise in order to establish the new partnerships? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks for those two questions. On the resolution fund, that's an area where bad surprises tend to come up regularly, so I'll be very cautious. I believe I don't have the exact number at hand. That said, I think our budget includes a modest rise in the 2022 contribution compared with 2021, though not at the size you're describing. And I genuinely don't see why it would reach that size this year, but then again, surprises there usually run unfavorable. On Stellantis and the restructuring tied to the partnership, keep in mind that from day one the long-term leasing pyramid will grow, since TSA's former long-term lease will be merged with the leases that were FCA's former long-term visa. So on day one, that will be a larger activity. The name was free to move. Thus, from day one, the long-term activities will be larger. And the loan book inside FCA — so the traditional financing book at FCA is being kept up and may even grow this year. That means the one-off will only begin at the start of 2023, with an average book duration of three or four years.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI wouldn't rule out a small negative effect, perhaps in the very first quarter, but it won't be very significant. What we see ahead is that long-term leasing will actually grow much faster than traditional car financing. So that's a bet we're making as well.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystAlright, thanks.
Philippe Brassac
executiveGlobally speaking, that's going to serve as a stronger growth driver going forward.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next question is from Delphine Lee at JPMorgan. Go ahead, your line is open.
Delphine Lee
analystHello, good afternoon, Jerome. I have two questions for you. The first concerns French retail. You referred to the effect on <<inaudible>>, so I'm curious how we ought to view the sales revenue outlook for 2022, given all the different elements involved. Some color on that would be great. The second is about capital and the 11% CET1 target you've set for 2022. You obviously hold a fairly sizable buffer over that level. I mean, do you plan to take any action on it, or will you essentially retain that buffer at this point, leaving us to await the new plan to learn how the excess capital might be redeployed?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure. I’ll begin with your second question, Delphine, and clearly you’re correct. For birth, we are above 11%, that is certain. And we will wait for the new medium-term plan in order to lay out precisely what the new trajectory is, keeping in mind that some moving pieces remain from a regulatory standpoint. We still have a few impact items due in 2022, probably around 20 bps to 25 bps of impact. There is also still the effect of the transition to 17, which I mentioned a little earlier, and that is expected to have some impact on solvency as well. Then there is the final text on Basel IV. The initial text on Basel IV is, I would say, digestible for essay, with the strong assumption that the output floor will bite only at the highest consolidated level, but of course we remain cautious until the final version is seen. So all these moving pieces, plus the fact that we intend to publish this new medium-term plan on June 22, are leading me to postpone a precise answer. On French retail, what we can say is that we know the negative impact from Israel, that is certain and already embedded, and it will be in the region of €50 million net from the benefits of the different hedges that we have, but those do not fully cover the impact.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAs we understand it, beginning July 1, the 50 bps advantage on the LCL will be gone as well. So the LCL is among the gains tied to this TLTO premium across CASA globally. Between 2021 and 2022, we stand to lose roughly €200 million in revenues related to the TLTO — that is entirely mechanical, mechanical, and there is no way around it. Within the LCL perimeter, what will be there to counter these negative factors, namely the volume effect — will we keep witnessing a steep rise in volumes, and at present there is no slowdown. The second factor is, as I mentioned earlier, the pace at which we reprice new home loans that we will extend to our customers. The third item is, naturally, the ongoing further improvement in the equipment rate of our customers, supported by a wider selection of products and services and offers — and bear in mind that during the last quarter, for instance, revenue growth at LCL was driven more by fees and commissions than by the interest margin. So this will, naturally, be a highly significant factor. And at the CASA level overall, bear in mind that ahead of us for 2022, we have those negative effects tied to deliver into TLTO, yet we also have favorable elements that are already embedded.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe'll get the complete twelve-month benefit from bringing CASA into the fold. That could amount to as much as, say, €300 million in extra revenues. We'll also see the whole-year impact of the switch mechanism unwinding. Compared with 2021, that could mean a further €120 million to €130 million in additional revenues. And then, naturally, there's a full year of what will be merged with AMUNDI, which should likewise contribute roughly €200 million in extra revenues. So all of this is to say that what 2022 turns out to be depends on what we make of it. We're entering the year facing certain headwinds, but also some tailwinds—substantial tailwinds. And so the ball is now in our court to deliver yet another solid operational performance.
Delphine Lee
analystAnd when it comes to the culture decline in 2022 for well LCL, or let's say the CASA level, how much would that amount to?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGlobally, CASA is going to account for roughly €200 million, and that amount is split across LCL CASA itself. So the corporate center, CACIB <<inaudible>> as well. So it's distributed among all the businesses, based on how much each contributes to the eligible credit. So really, that's spread across all businesses, nearly every business.
Delphine Lee
analystThanks a lot — that’s great.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. Matt Clark from Mediobanca has the next question. Go ahead, your line is open.
Matthew Clark
analystHi there. So I have a couple of questions. First, regarding the credit loan portfolio: you entered the COVID crisis with fairly high exposures to oil, aircraft, and other sectors that were seen as risky. Yet in practice, your cost of risk there stayed very low throughout the crisis. Looking back, how do you see that? Does it show your risk management was right and you simply continue as before? Or was it somewhat a lucky escape, and perhaps you should consider de-risking or adjusting your exposures over the medium term? That's my first question. My second question returns to Stellantis: for 2024, do you view these transactions as net positive or net negative?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSorry, which transaction are you referring to?
Matthew Clark
analystStellantis, once the SG&A runoff gets going — because my thinking had been that shedding meaningful volume at a time when you have to keep the franchise intact so you can grow with independent partners would force you to carry the cost base, and that would create fairly sharp negative operating leverage. So my guess is that your 2023 target stays intact, but for the consumer division in 2024, would it come out net positive or net negative? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright, I'll begin with what you asked about our oil and gas exposure. There are actually 2 aspects to your question, I believe. The first one concerns risk management. Looking at our track record in this business — given the expertise of the teams, given how we structure our operations — we have never experienced a meaningful level of cost of risk here. So this is certainly not down to luck. It comes down to expertise. It comes down to knowhow. It comes down to truly being able to identify which counterparts are the good ones and how to structure the transaction, and overall, from 2012 through 2019, the average cost of risk in this business ran at roughly 7 bps per year — that's the cost of final losses, not the cost of risk in provision book terms, but the actual cost of final losses. So what this business faces now is not a risk problem but a transformation problem. That's the key point. And we are here to accompany our customers, as I mentioned earlier, through their energy transition.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat we plan to achieve with this business is essentially to serve as an engine and a catalyst for advancing the energy transition among all the stakeholders, both when it comes to energy consumption and when it comes to the ability to supply clients with energy through a de-carbonated approach. That is truly the core of it. It is therefore an enormous transformation, yet it is not a question of risk. And once more, where risk is concerned, we are not particularly worried. Turning to Stellantis, the operations of the new FCA Bank — meaning this new bank that will carry out its activity by targeting small car makers lacking their own captive financing entity, or by targeting independent car dealers throughout Europe — the rollout of this new business model has in fact already begun. And you may have noticed that FCA Bank has already entered into a new partnership with VinFast, which I believe is a Thai car maker — or Vietnamese, pardon me, a Vietnamese car maker, one that produces electric cars competing with Tesla. So we will serve as the exclusive provider of car loans to VinFast's clients in Europe. And we will leverage this FCA Bank setup, which we know very well, since we have been contributing to building this setup in order to grow the business.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThen there's another instance you might have come across: we acquired a stake in the capital of a dealer — an independent car dealer by the name of BYmyCAR, a French company with a European outlook. The aim, naturally, was not for us to turn into a car dealer ourselves, but rather to strike an exclusive partnership with that dealer so that we would be the sole supplier of car loans to its customers. So we are definitely already at work, I'd say, on building up the books of the new FCA Bank, starting at the beginning of 2023. And we feel genuinely confident about how this business will develop.
Matthew Clark
analystIs it wrong for me to just look at this in big-picture terms, though? You're giving up a very successful, mature business and picking up a lot of kind of startups, perhaps from — just from a timing standpoint, that would….
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAbsolutely. There is a very profitable, solid business that is going to begin its runoff, and we are going to be interested in that runoff at the beginning of 2023, and at the same time — and actually with a start that is going to be earlier net — we are building up the new business, not on a blank sheet, because actually there is already a whole series of partnerships, which are kept within FCA Bank, which existed before the restructured version of the partnership and which we are going to keep. So it's really more transformation than really a startup.
Matthew Clark
analystAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next question is from Pierre Chedeville at CIC. Your line is open — go ahead.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes, good afternoon. My first question is fairly boring, but it concerns Page 39. I'd like to get a better grasp of what you said regarding your interest rate sensitivities and what might lie ahead. When I look at your excess of stable resources, it stands at €279 billion, and if I subtract the TLTRO, you're currently, as you note, above €100 billion of excess, which is your target. Could you remind us why this target of €100 billion was chosen and what it corresponds to? And I'm rather surprised that with €100 billion of excess, your NSFR at group level, or credit, which we call SA, is only just above 100%? Is it exactly 100% or just above? And why don't you provide the precise figure? And could we imagine that, since we know it's a kind of sterilization in the present rates environment to hold such excess, you might reduce this leeway? And when we look at the figure on the left, your deposits at central banks, and when you know that you're penalized by 50 basis points on more than €200 billion, if we imagine that in your scenario of an increase of 100 basis points, it would be, in my view, a significant rise in your net interest margin, much more significant than the negative impact and leeway, so I'm not very clear on that regarding your sensitivities.
Pierre Chédeville
analystCould you clarify that a bit more? I know this is boring…
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay. Pierre, I think it might be worth stepping back and looking at the Group's balance sheet more broadly, not just the liquidity reserves, since that's the only piece we're evaluating here. Just a handful of points in response to your question. First, one of the features of the Group we have to contend with is that we're composed of multiple entities. Take NSFR, for instance: we must satisfy NSFR requirements at the Group level, at CASA level, at CACF level — so at several levels. That means, on a consolidated basis, we are, I'd say, pushed toward holding larger reserves than would apply if we consisted of just one legal entity facing a single requirement. That's why we can occasionally seem to carry a wider excess of reserves on every front. Second, naturally, the ID is that once TLTRO no longer delivers this 50 bps advantage we currently enjoy. The plan is not to keep reserves at such an elevated level, because at present, when you hold €160-something billion of TLTRO growings, and when you place that same amount with the ECB, you get a 50 bps benefit — naturally, as soon as the end of H1 2022 arrives, things are going to shift.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThese numbers will, of course, be adjusted once the TLTRO premium comes to an end. So those are the key pieces, and we are certainly getting ready for the new paradigm that will apply after the TLTRO benefits finish — something we may have already heard about. We have heard the ECB discuss it, with the possible introduction of a higher tiering level, which would help us too. Keep in mind that within cash and central bank deposits, a certain portion escapes the penalty because it benefits from the tier, naturally. So the reality is more complicated than just a question of €240-something billion or €227 billion in deposits. It is, I would say, a more complex management task, but you are definitely right to point out that this balance sheet and this kind of reserves suit the current period, and that will shift once the TLTRO benefit ends.
Pierre Chédeville
analystCould I ask one more thing, and this one's about the business side?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, of course.
Pierre Chédeville
analystOn Spain — when you had the joint venture with Bankia, it made sense to me: setting up a JV in consumer credit because you could benefit from its network. But what I really don't get is why you'd do it on a standalone basis in a Spanish banking sector that's very mature, as you know, and very competitive. And I'm not sure what your competitive advantage is for gaining market share there, and your ambition surprises me quite a bit, because when I read your press release, you say you want to be a leader in Spain in consumer credit ahead of Santander. That ambition is quite surprising to me. So can you explain exactly what you want to do there, and why you think you're relevant in this market? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLet me revisit where this initial partnership came from and how it developed. The way it began was that we had certain partners — retail partners rather than banking partners — operating across Europe, Apple being one example. Because of that, we required a setup and operation in Spain so we could fully cover the perimeter where those partners were prepared to work alongside us. So the origin point is that an operation in Spain was necessary for us. We then identified this potential partnership, though it was terminated early owing to a change of control at our partner. And we concluded that the startup we had begun building was enough to serve as the foundation for an entity of our own in Spain. As things stand right now, it isn't absolutely massive — a few million euros of revenues and a few million euros of cost each quarter. So it's absolutely tiny, but we believe we have the capacity to develop it and to reach break even quite rapidly, and then to develop the business properly. We currently have around €300 million of outstanding.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe believe hitting 1.5 billion in two years is quite achievable. So at the same time, we’ll be able to build a business ourselves in Spain leveraging our knowhow, since the key asset we possess is the knowhow of CACF teams. And that knowhow can be put to work in Spain and then also using this setup to serve our pan-European partner better in retail activities within the long channel businesses.
Pierre Chédeville
analystThanks. That’s very clear.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next question is from Kiri Vijayarajah at HSBC. Your line is open — go ahead.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystThank you. Yes, good afternoon, Jerome. I have a couple of questions. First, on capital: now that you've unwound the switch, is there a bigger incentive to perhaps leverage up the insurance company and optimize the RWA consumption there? Or do you think it's more or less pretty well optimized already, and maybe the insurance supervisor might not view too favorably any change to the insurance company's capital structure? Then my second question goes back to the whole Stellantis, I think Slide 20, and specifically that 1 million target you have for the fleet in the long-term leasing business by 2026 — I think I saw 700,000 in the presentation — that's a right starting point pro forma today for the size of that fleet. So to get to 1 million, is all of that going to come from organic growth? Because of course, some of your competitors in that field also have some quite ambitious growth targets there. So I'm just trying to understand how you're going to get to that 1 million fleet size, please? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes. I'll begin with Crédit Agricole Assurance's capital position. Crédit Agricole Assurance genuinely enjoys a very robust solvency level. It sits well above the 200% threshold. And it's fair to say we could draw a bit more on that solvency cushion to optimize RWA consumption at CASA. This elevated solvency level at CAA has been achieved, among other factors, because for two or three years now, the participating reserve I mentioned earlier has been factored into how solvency gets calculated. So that means it's neither strictly capital nor subordinated debt — rather, it's an internal reserve that accounts for a portion of solvency. So we don't want solvency to drop too low. But we definitely will keep optimizing the capital structure of the insurance operations. We'll probably also deploy a small share of this solvency to adjust Crédit's career asset portfolio to the current environment, so as to optimize the yield on the asset book and adapt to how rates are evolving. Still, the point is that we do have some room to maneuver on this front.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding <<inaudible>> and the long-term leasing entity, our starting position is that roughly 650,000 cars are already in place, split about evenly between leases on one side and free to move on the other. So in four or five years, what we need to accomplish is a 50% expansion of this portfolio, and that will come about organically. It isn't easy, but given how quickly this business is moving, it looks to us entirely achievable.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystThanks a lot. That’s helpful.
Philippe Brassac
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next question is from Flora Bocahut at Jefferies. Go ahead, your line is open.
Flora Bocahut
analystYes, thank you, and good afternoon. I have a couple of questions about Slide 10, which shows a rather impressive evolution. My first question concerns the coming 12 months, given that we are obviously starting from a high base and without getting into the next plan and the 25 horizon, just thinking about the next 12 months here. The two questions are, first, about the level of activity. You mention on the slide that activity is buoyant in many of the businesses. At this stage, do you see any indication that growth could slow in some of the businesses, or anything pointing to deterioration there? And then on the cost side of the equation, is there any reason to think we might see negative surprises on cost specifically this year in 2022, particularly given the inflation we are seeing? Or are you confident that you can stay on this path with cost savings, volatility gates? Thank
Philippe Brassac
executiveWell, Flora, predicting what lies ahead is obviously quite hard. Perhaps I can offer a few points to help frame how we see our ability to keep moving forward. First, as I mentioned, we enter this year with certain negative factors, yet also with several strongly favorable factors that will come through during 2022, which should lift the top line and which already incorporate all the scope effects I referred to earlier. And those favorable factors outweigh the negative ones by a wide margin. So we began the year, let me say, benefiting from the transactions we carried out during 2021, and those will work in our favor in 2022. As for our ability to manage — sorry — as for, first, the activity level we are seeing right now, meaning after the close of 2021, well, I lack exact numbers since it is far too soon, but I am not detecting any genuine indication of deterioration. I am not detecting any indication of a slowdown in appetite for credit. I am not detecting any indication of — of a decline in people's willingness to spend and to invest. So truly, there is no cause for us not to keep enjoying a solid level of activity.
Philippe Brassac
executiveNaturally, we recognize that 2021 represented a catch-up period, given the especially strong growth seen in France of plus 7%. What we anticipate for 2022, for instance, is GDP growth in France that is more moderate, at 4%. So following a catch-up phase, you do of course get some deceleration, yet moving from 7% growth down to 4% does not amount to a recession, nor is it a distressed situation. We therefore hold great hope when it comes to our activities continuing to develop. On the cost base, naturally there is some degree of inflation. We observe it across the board. We observe it in every purchase we make, and so forth. Yet up to now we have managed, I would say, to keep it under control and to steer clear of any kind of loop that would seriously harm our profitability. So naturally, the jury remains out regarding how inflation will evolve. And should you subscribe to the theory of a one-off inflation that does not begin fueling a loop between wages and prices, then we can be confident that we will keep monitoring the cost base closely.
Philippe Brassac
executiveShould a genuine wage-price loop emerge, the situation becomes tougher, and at that point the issue turns to whether we can maintain a certain equilibrium between how the top line moves and how the cost line moves. However, as things stand right now, we aren't observing that either.
Flora Bocahut
analystThat’s great. Thanks a lot.
Philippe Brassac
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. The following question is from Omar Fall of Barclays. Your line is open — please go ahead.
Omar Fall
analystGood afternoon, and thank you for taking my questions.
Philippe Brassac
executiveHello there, Omar.
Omar Fall
analystThere are just a few items I want to raise. First, picking up on what I believe was Delphine's question regarding how scope effects hit revenues: once you strip out <<inaudible>> and TLTRO, you're looking at above €23 billion in revenue for 2022, along with everything else. So what do the scope effects amount to? Likewise on the OpEx side, from whatever scope effects remain, could you help us with our modeling? My second question is simply to walk us through how the business performed in Italy. Also, apologies if I missed this, but what was the size of the NPL disposal impact? Even excluding that, it strikes me that both NII and fees look somewhat slower in years only compared with the prior quarter. Any thoughts on that, and maybe an outlook for that business in particular, would be fantastic.
Philippe Brassac
executiveAlright. So, looking at the three main scope effects we have, the first one — the switch and winding — carries no cost with it. That roughly €130 million of NBI doesn't create any extra expense as far as CreVal goes. If I recall correctly, their cost-to-income ratio was somewhere around 60% to 65%. That means the starting point is perhaps an extra €200 million in cost against the €300 million of revenues. But naturally, we're already at work on all the synergies, and we've booked some restructuring costs within the PPA to fund these cost synergies. So we will deliver cost synergies, and where Lixo is concerned, it's broadly the same picture. From Amundi's standpoint, the clear idea is to integrate Lixo without having to fully integrate — or at least not all of the costs tied to Lixo. So this is — and again, if my memory serves, Lixo's cost-to-income ratio sat in the region of 65% to 70%, which compares with the roughly 50 to 50 at Amundi.
Philippe Brassac
executiveTherefore, the thought is to return to 50 as quickly as we can — it was Lixo 70, 22 to be exact. I was slightly under that in reality. So that is, so purely this will be relative in terms of gross operating income as early as 2022. And then moving on, from, to the NPL, your question concerned the revenue dynamic in Italy. Is that correct?
Omar Fall
analystYou've got that right.
Philippe Brassac
executiveYes. Obviously, the fourth quarter came in somewhat softer than Q4 of 2020, and that period was truly a rebound quarter. I recall the, the progression of the, the lockdown in Italy — during 2020's fourth quarter, activity rebounded. So comparing the, the revenues of 2020 with those of 2021 is a bit difficult. Then naturally, we felt this effect from the, from the NPL disposal, and overall, in the fourth quarter of 2021, net interest income declined, and afterwards there was a slight rise, though fees and commission went up.
Omar Fall
analystAll right, thank you.
Philippe Brassac
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. Guillaume Tiberghien from Exane has the next question. Go ahead, your line is open.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystThanks. Apologies for the follow-up. I'd like to return to the TLTRO and be somewhat provocative, because when the TLTRO came in, the bank said we shouldn't assume this is a net benefit to revenues, since if it feeds through to a group's overall funding cost, which is then used to derive the revenue margin, that one generates in total with your customers. So why is it so mechanical on the way out when it wasn't so mechanical on the way in? Thank you.
Philippe Brassac
executiveIt's really quite straightforward, because if you fund the loan with the cheap resource that matures in 1.5 or 2 years, while that loan is going to run for five, six, or seven years, then once the cheap resource goes away, you're left holding the loan. You're glad to have that loan, glad to have the customer behind it, but even so, the cheap resource gets, so to speak, contaminated, and you have to swap it out for one that costs more. So I stand by what I said about how the TLTRO was implemented: it formed part of our funding and, taken as a whole, it helped us bring down our total cost of funding. When the TLTRO premium ends, our overall funding cost will rise, with no automatic impact on the yield of our loan book. That's why the effect is such a mechanical one, but naturally, the plan is to substitute this TLTRO resource down the road with other resources whose cost we will try to optimize. And the thinking is that once we have this outlook of a higher cost of our resources, a higher average cost of our resources, then to keep the two in balance we need to work gradually on repricing the loan books.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystThanks.
Philippe Brassac
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. Tarik Mejjad from Bank of America has the next question. Your line is open — go ahead.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystMy apologies. Right as we get to — the call, but very, very briefly. Your remarks on management and the COVID provisions or overlay caught me off guard. In Q3, as I recall, you said you were now prepared to let some of them go rather than keep accumulating and raising the coverage ratio. And now it sounds like you're saying you still need to be prudent and apply them to losses down the road. Did I get that wrong, or did you change?
Philippe Brassac
executiveNo, definitely not. But Tarik, you know that from the time the Q3 accounts came out until today, a new variant of the disease has appeared, plus some additional developments, I'd say, that genuinely led us to take a cautious stance.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystEveryone’s returned to the office, and everyone’s returned to their lives. So ordinarily, it was no…
Philippe Brassac
executiveThat isn't true across the board. And certainly when we made the various calls on the 2021 year-end accounts a few weeks back, plenty of questions remained regarding how Omicron would develop and what would unfold, and so forth. So bear in mind that at the moment we finalized those accounts, uncertainty ran quite high. And in France, we were discussing several hundred thousand new infections per day.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystSo what do you think at this point? I mean, at this stage, we — the outlook — and you're putting out some of those, right?
Philippe Brassac
executiveFrom a pandemic perspective, things are looking up. Even so, we still have a substantial number of people in the hospitals. So from where I sit, it isn't 100% finished, even if some restrictions have been eased. So really we're being prudent, you know — we are prudent. It shouldn't surprise you if we take prudent measures.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystAlright, thanks.
Philippe Brassac
executiveThanks. I believe that was the final question, if I heard correctly, and with that, we had a second round of questions from those same participants. So, I'd like to thank you for all your questions and for your attention this afternoon. And we'll be talking or seeing each other again quite soon. Bye-bye, thank you.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate everyone joining us. You're all free to disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.