Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 30, 2025

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 73 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone. I'm the conference operator. We're glad to have you on this call for Crédit Agricole's First Quarter 2025 Results Conference Call, and thank you for joining. Just a reminder that everyone is in listen-only mode for now. Following the presentation, you'll have a chance to ask questions. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'd like to hand the conference over to Mr. Jerome Grivet, Deputy Chief Executive Officer of Crédit Agricole S.A., who oversees Steering and Control. Sir, please go ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Good morning or good afternoon — I'm not sure which, since it depends on the time zone where each of you is. I'm glad to walk you through today's results. Let's move straight to Page 4 of the presentation. I realize analysts have a packed schedule today, and I don't want to drag this out. So I'll begin right away with the main takeaways from these results, where you can see that Crédit Agricole S.A. and the Group are reporting a record level of revenue this quarter. On top of that, Crédit Agricole S.A. is delivering a very high return on tangible equity. The cost income ratios are stable or up somewhat, yet in both cases they remain at a very competitive level, and the cost of risk is likewise stable at a moderate level. One more point on this page: solvency ratios are improving very significantly across both perimeters. We'll go into somewhat more detail about why we're seeing this substantial improvement in the return of the CET1 ratios. Final point on this page: as in every quarter, we've kept growing our businesses, wrapping up progress on various strategic operations — whether that's the joint venture created with GAC in China for car leasing, the closing of the partnership between Amundi and Victory Capital in the USA, or the completion of our investment in Banco BPM, which now represents 19.8% of the capital in Banco BPM.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#3

The next page gives you more detailed numbers on each of these items. As I mentioned, revenues have risen sharply — 5.5% higher for the Group worldwide, surpassing €10 billion, and up 6.6% at Crédit Agricole S.A., reaching €7.3 billion. Gross operating income has also climbed in both scopes: 3% higher, exceeding €4 billion at the Group level, and 4% higher at €3.3 billion for Crédit Agricole S.A. One last point: pre-tax income has increased fairly substantially — 1.6% for the Group and 4.6% for Crédit Agricole S.A. And this quarter there is a very particular factor at play: the impact of a French tax increase — a one-off hike enacted by the French legislator — which is hitting the Group and Crédit Agricole S.A. quite heavily. That will keep affecting us through the remainder of the year, but in the first quarter alone we are absorbing more than half — five-eighths, in fact — of the full estimated tax, and that amounts to over €200 million for the Group and over €120 million for Crédit Agricole S.A., which explains why, despite pre-tax income being higher, we ultimately land with net income after tax that is lower in both scopes.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#4

Moving to Page 7 of the slideshow, regarding activity levels across all the Group's businesses, we see that revenues in the CIB activities are hitting a new record. Net inflows at Amundi are also very strong, with a record level of assets under management — €2.25 trillion in assets under management. Premium income at Crédit Agricole Assurances has also reached a record, close to €15 billion this quarter, up 20% compared to Q1 2024. Loan production in France through the retail network keeps recovering relative to the first quarter of 2024. It's slightly lower than Q4 2024, but there's a seasonality effect, and in fact what we're seeing on the ground now in March and also in April is that the rebound is continuing compared to the same period of last year. In the Consumer Finance business, we've observed a slight decrease in new loan production, but the level in absolute terms remains high, and it's mainly driven by a certain decline in the level of Car Financing activities.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

Finally, on the International Banking side, we keep seeing a solid pace of new loan origination. Moving to the next page, as I mentioned in my introduction, this converts into a record level of revenues. Over on the right side of that page, you can observe the path Crédit Agricole S.A. has been on for the past eight years. Topline growth has been steady and regular, averaging plus 5.6% across those eight years. And when we look a bit at how the topline evolved across the different business divisions this quarter, what stands out is a very sharp rise in revenues for the Asset Gathering Business division, which is partly tied, obviously, to the scope effect and the Degroof Petercam integration, though organic growth has been very significant as well. The same holds in the Large Customers division, with record revenues at CACIB, as I noted, and good momentum at CACEIS too. In the Specialized Financial Services division, revenues are up as well, continuing the trend we had already observed in last year's fourth quarter — pardon me — at CAPFM.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

And the only place where we’re seeing a modest drop in revenue levels is within the Retail Banking business division — that’s largely because of a particular base effect in international Retail Banking activities, above all in Egypt, where back in Q1 2024 we had recorded a very high revenue level tied to very strong rate movements and a high level of activity in forex businesses. Then, in the Corporate Center, revenues are up as well, helped — among other elements — by the impact from the valuation of our shares in the capital of Banco BPM. Moving to the next page, we have some indication about how the cost base has evolved, and I know you’ve already asked the team quite a significant number of questions on how our cost basis has evolved, so I want to spend a few minutes on this point and on this page, actually. If we begin with the bar chart on the right-hand side of the page, what you can see is that we actually start with an increase of €322 million in the cost basis, but €138 million of that comes from scope effects and from integration costs, so those are non-recurring. And then €72 million comes from the IFRIC impact — so all the taxes that we have to account for in the first quarter of the year — and they are quite significantly up this quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

It actually turns out that in 2024, an adjustment was needed during the second quarter, and that won't be the situation this year. So there's also, so to speak, a base effect, and that is what's driving this sharp rise in IFRIC costs this quarter. That therefore leaves us with just €130 million of, I'd say, economic growth in the cost base, €105 million for staff costs — including an adjustment to the provision for variable compensation tied to the very high activity level at CACIB and at Amundi — plus an increase of close to €40 million in IT investment costs. So overall, an economic evolution of 3.2%, which would compare with a topline evolution of roughly 4% — 4.1% to be precise — if we restate the topline for the scope effect. So still, if we try to assess economically how the cost basis evolved relative to the topline evolution, those effects would be positive. On the next page, we have some elements concerning the cost of risk. In a nutshell, the cost of risk is stable at a moderate level. On the Crédit Agricole S.A perimeter, €413 million of cost of risk in the first quarter of 2025, compared with €400 million in the first quarter of 2024.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

Thus a quite modest change, along with 3.4%. And what becomes apparent is that regarding cost of risk measured in bps relative to the outstanding, we remain highly stable as well. And much the same holds across the group's global perimeter, 27 bps of cost of risk relative to the outstanding. Once again, extremely, extremely stable, with no meaningful change. The NPL ratios likewise hold steady, 2.3% on the Crédit Agricole S.A perimeter and 2.1% on the Group perimeter. And coverage of these NPLs by our various provision categories remains elevated and even rises on the Crédit Agricole S.A perimeter. Turning to business divisions, what becomes apparent is a modest rise in the Consumer Credit business, CAPFM, driven chiefly by certain international subsidiaries located outside Italy. Cost of risk at Agos in fact shows no worsening this quarter. And overall, it is a moderate cost of risk by the standards of the Consumer Credit business. What also becomes apparent is that cost of risk keeps falling at Crédit Agricole Italia and at LCL too. It rises somewhat for the regional banks, yet that stems mostly from technical effects that push up the IFRS 9 provision, so there is no worsening in the incurred cost of risk.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

And it’s still quite low at CACIB when it comes to CACIB’s financing operations. In fact, this quarter we even saw a net reversal of provision, largely thanks to some synthetic securitization. That feeds into how net profit has moved, which is shown on Page 12. Starting once more on the right-hand side of that page, looking at net profit: as I mentioned, it’s a bit lower, down 4% from Q1 2024 to Q1 2025. But again, that is more than accounted for by how the corporate tax level has evolved, including €123 million from this specific tax surcharge we’re required to pay in France. If you look at gross operating income, it is in fact higher, up 4%, or plus €129 million. And on the left-hand side of the page, that shows the movement in net profit before tax, net income before tax. What you can see there is an increase of 4.6%, or plus €127 million. And that gain is mostly coming from the Asset Gathering and Large Customers division. Net profit is roughly flat in the Specialized Financial Services division and in Retail Banking activities, and likewise at the Corporate Center level.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

On the next page, there is some indication about how the solvency ratio at CASA has evolved. Let me remind you that 11% remains the target, and indeed this quarter we see a sharp rise in the CET1 ratio, up 40 bps from 11.7% to 12.1%. And of course there is a technical factor behind this situation that gets explained. It is the first application of CRR3. So you could take the view that, at the end of the day, Basel IV turns out to be a positive for us — which is not the case. I want to be clear about that. But we already began feeling Basel IV's negative impact some time ago, with the TRIM exercises that were a front-loading part of Basel IV implementation. Then you will recall that in Q4 2024, we had the prudential consolidation of Leasing activities, which represented a significant hit to our solvency as well. And ahead of us at CASA, the application of the Fundamental Review of the Trading Book is also going to come, possibly in 2026 or maybe later. So this positive impact in Q1 2025 has to be read — assessed, I would say — within the global landscape in which we have already had some negative impacts and possibly will have some additional negative impacts going forward.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

On top of that component, we also have retained earnings contributing 21 bps to the ratio. The solvency used up through organic growth of the business line accounts for 9 bps of ratio. Then there are certain technical items — including phasing, the final stage of the IFRS 9 phase-in, along with some smaller regulatory effects, M&A and various other things — which add a further hit of 10 bps. That leaves us at 12.1% for this quarter, but I'd like you to keep in mind that right at the start of April, certain items will consume roughly 30 bps. So the launching point for the second quarter, I would say, is closer to 11.8% rather than 12.1%. The items set to affect the second quarter are the closing of the Victory Capital transaction, which for the Group translates into a significant holding in a financial company that must be deducted above the franchise — and that will indeed be the case. The same applies to our investment in Banco BPM, since at the beginning of April we converted our derivative into actual shares. Once again, this also partially exceeds the franchise. So it too will be partly deducted from our CET1 ratio.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

That pro forma number comes out nearer 11.8%. And finally — though this isn't part of that 11.8% — we expect to wrap up and complete, perhaps by the end of Q2 or possibly the start of Q3, the deal with Santander to repurchase their 30% stake in CACEIS's capital. That too would have an effect of perhaps close to 30 bps on the CET1 ratio. But once more, that isn't a concern given that we still hold to a target of 11%. Finally, we have already set aside €0.28 per share in dividend at the close of the first quarter of this year. On the next page, you'll see the same movements for the Group as a whole. And once again, the same factor accounts for a shift running in the same direction, from 17.2% at the end of last year to 17.6% at the end of March. The pro forma figure at the start of Q2 is less affected than was the case for Crédit Agricole S.A., since the threshold — the franchise — is far higher at group level than at CASA level. So we can say that at the start of Q2 we are likewise near 17.6% for the Group. Finally, regarding the Group's liquidity position, there is little to report.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

Naturally, we're discussing the close of Q1 here. That means this predates all the market upheaval set off by certain threats concerning tariff regimes around the world. Even so, liquidity conditions have not shifted much — they remain very robust throughout the second quarter, with no threats at all. That said, by the close of the first quarter, our reserves had improved. Our various ratios, LCR and NSFR, had improved too. And we still hold a customer deposit base that is ample, highly diversified and very secure. Finally, we offer here on Page 8 through 16 — pardon me — a few updates regarding our transition plan, which remains structured around the very same three pillars: namely, speeding up the growth of our financing toward renewable and low carbon energy sources. And we keep raising our financing to this sector very substantially. You'll find the figures shown on this page, with quite steep increases relative to the 2020 comparison base. We keep assisting our various customer categories with their own transition. And we are extending a great deal of financing to our customers dedicated to helping them transition, whether individuals, SMEs or large corporates.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

And finally, we keep reducing — though that covers just the first two components. Our financing for carbon-based energy sources continues to go down. And in fact, we're now at very low levels relative to where we started in 2020. So let me wrap up simply by reiterating that the results we're publishing this quarter are very positive, with revenues once more higher and hitting record levels, alongside a cost income ratio that remains very competitive and very substantially under the 58% target, or ceiling, that we've committed to respect over the course of this medium-term plan. Our cost of risk remains very moderate. And although net profit is affected by the surcharge on corporate taxes that has been introduced in France, we're publishing a return on tangible equity that is close to its highest level ever, close to 16%. And I'm glad to say that next time you'll have the pleasure of hearing this presentation from Clotilde, whom you know very well. Thanks for listening, and I'm ready now to take your questions.

Operator

operator
#15

Thanks. <<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America. You have the floor.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#16

Morning, Jerome — hello there.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#17

Hello there, Tarik.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#18

Thank you for confirming your role, and I'm eager to collaborate with Clotilde once more. So, to begin with, regarding the — I mean, regarding costs, apologies for returning to that topic. I mean, yes, granted, you have nearly 16% ROTE, so that has to stay in our thinking. Even so, we are seeking greater cost efficiency at this point. And now, I suppose you're getting ready or beginning to get ready for the new plan. Which areas do you believe require additional effort, or if it's a cost matter, might it perhaps be revenues that will come in more quickly? But when it comes to cost, which areas do you feel have more to deliver and more to address? And the second question concerns capital. The 44 bps Basel IV has a positive effect in Q1. I grasp how this works, but is there a danger that you foresee some reversal of it next quarter, or is this a definitive final effect from Basel IV? And finally, you — I believe in the Bloomberg interview this morning, you said that you will wait until the BPM offer period ends before deciding.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#19

I’d really like to get clear on what exactly you meant by that, and what you can share with us about the situation in Italy as it stands today. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#20

On the first point about how costs are evolving, you brought up the fact that we need to remember we're reporting a return on tangible equity of 16%, which is entirely correct, and thank you for noting it. But you should also bear in mind that we're reporting a cost income ratio of 55%. So without question, the cost income ratio is the best way to judge cost efficiency, and the cost income ratio we're reporting sits very significantly below the level we've committed to. So without question, I'd say cost efficiency is not a problem in the various businesses of Crédit Agricole S.A. Even so, it's a constant effort to work on the cost base and to continually assess what cost level is appropriate and consistent with the level of revenues. And that's something that can't be decided globally at the level of CASA as a whole. It has to be continually reassessed at the level of each business line. You know that this has clearly been one of the keys to our ability to improve the cost income ratio very significantly over the course of the last 10 years, namely decentralizing responsibility for monitoring the cost base, and we will keep doing that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#21

Naturally, I can't tell you in advance—before we present the medium-term plan—where we will raise or cut the cost basis. That will hinge on how much revenue each business can generate. But as you know, our stance on managing the cost base will stay the same: responsibility for managing it gets decentralized to the heads of the businesses, and each business head is held accountable for hitting the cost-income ratio we consider appropriate for their business. On capital evolution, yes, 44 bps of impact on day one of CRR3 is higher than what we had in mind. You know that we always couldn't. So initially we were probably targeting half of that. That is where we guided the market, and we end up with a better improvement than expected. But we do not foresee any reversal at this level. Put simply, we are now operating in a new environment, with new ways of compounding the risk-weighted assets across the different categories of risk—whether credit risk, equity risk or operational risk. And so we will certainly have to learn over time how the calculation of risk-weighted assets in the different businesses is going to evolve under this new framework.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#22

That said, there is no reversal as such of the 44 bps of positive impact we are posting this quarter. One final point on BPM. What I told Bloomberg, and what Philippe Brassac also said during the press conference we held on the results, is simply logical. It happens that we own close to 20% of a bank that is subject to an offer, which opened only two days ago, last Monday. So, of course, before the offer period ends, we will have to make a decision, whatever decision we are able to take. But this is not a passive approach on our side. We will have to take a positive decision, which could be to contribute or not to contribute. And by definition, that decision has not been taken yet, because we need the maximum amount of information available before taking a decision. So that is the only point I wanted to stress. By definition, as a shareholder of BPM, we will have to take a decision. That decision is not taken, and it is going to be taken, whatever the sense of that decision, before the offer period ends.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#23

Thanks a lot, Jerome.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#24

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#25

Delphine Lee from JPMorgan has the next question — go right ahead.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#26

Yes. Morning, Jerome, and thanks for taking my question. My first one concerns French Retail. I’m just wondering when you see net income inflecting? I think you said previously that a small increase was expected in 2025. So I’m just wondering how confident you are about achieving this and when we can see that. My second question is about capital. Sorry if I missed this, but with that 44 basis points, what was the surprise coming from on the impact of Basel IV? And then also, I mean, it looks like you’re running much closer to 12% rather than 11%. And would you consider changing your dividend policy to reflect that? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#27

Thank you, Delphine, for that question. Regarding French Retail, we've stated it before and we'll say it again: an inflection point should emerge for the net interest margin, or net interest income, at some stage during 2025. As we're all aware, that hinges on a number of factors — and let me remind you of them. The first, naturally, is where short-term rates stand. That's because, as you know, our global hedging portfolio consists of swaps under which we pay the long fixed rate while receiving the short floating rate. Consequently, what comes in on that side will, of course, be driven by how short-term rates move. It will also hinge on how customer deposits break down. At present, the mix of customer deposits has more or less stabilized, though naturally that still needs confirmation. Beyond that, it will also hinge on the asset side — starting with volumes. What we observed is that new loan volumes during this year's first quarter rose relative to the first quarter of 2024, yet came in slightly lower than in the fourth quarter of 2024.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#28

So we’ll need to watch how things develop during 2025. It will also hinge on how new loans get priced, and as you’re aware, in France the competition is extremely intense. At the same time, we’d all like to see improved pricing on new home loans, and all of us must act in line with what the competitive landscape shows us. As you know, historically we typically saw fixed-rate home loans with 20 years of maturity priced at roughly 100 bps over the 10-year treasury rate in France, the OAT. That is no longer true, since the 10-year OAT sits at 3.20% and that’s more or less where new home loan pricing stands. So competition is intense. And of course we have to operate within this competitive market, because it also matters for growing our business model, bringing in new customers, and then being able to build a global relationship with them over time. So it will depend, but definitely every element is pointing toward this stabilization of net interest income during 2025. On the capital side and the impact of Basel IV, there is no single surprise.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#29

As it turns out, we were cautious when evaluating each of the various pieces of the impact. So by being cautious and conservative across every part of the calculation, the outcome we reach is more favorable. Yet there isn’t a particular — we did not overlook any particular item when assessing all of that, and the gain arises simultaneously from the equity risk weighting, from the credit risk weighting, and even though, as we anticipated, there was a substantial rise in the risk weighting tied to the operational risk components. Consequently, the effect is distributed, in terms of lowering the RWA level, across Large Customer activities, Retail Banking activities, and of course Asset Gathering activities as well, given the risk weighting of the carrying value of the Insurance activities. Very little shows up in the Specialized Financial Services division, which is more or less unaffected by Basel IV. That division was affected at the end of last year by the prudential consolidation of the Leasing activities. And the final point regarding the dividend policy: it is far too soon to say what we will include in our new medium-term plan. Still, my best guess is that we will once again discover that a 50 to 50 policy, under which we retain 50% to fuel our development and distribute 50% to our shareholders, makes sense.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#30

I appreciate it.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#31

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#32

Our following question comes from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler Cheuvreux. The line is yours.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#33

Yes. Good morning, everyone, and obviously, congratulations to all. I had completely missed that, but then I went to bed very early last night. The two questions, I suppose. The first one, yes. On the SFS division, Consumer Finance in particular was a little bit disappointing, hard to predict once again. Obviously, one of your competitors went in for a huge restructuring in that business. Are you comfortable that we're dealing with some cyclical issues that you mentioned in your slides, particularly cost of risk at international subsidiaries and also on the equity accounting? So, if you could give reassurance about the trajectory of that business, that would be great. And then coming back to the plan, interestingly, obviously, back in 2022, your ROTE was clearly above 12%, which you've consistently beaten. So, I'm not going to ask you to tell me you're going to reach 15% or 16%, but more accurately, the one thing you've done very well is to increase the EPS and the ROTE on the back of your inorganic growth. Could you actually, even in generic terms, put inorganic growth and the uplift in profitability into your targets for 2028? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#34

Thank you, Jacques-Henri. Turning to Specialized Financial Services, it's evident this business is going through a tougher stretch than what we saw three or four years back. The sharp rise in risk we had to absorb beginning in 2023 is clearly playing a role, and that drove a substantial jump in refinancing costs for this business — costs that took a long and hard time to pass on to customers. That pass-through is now underway. So we will keep seeing a better margin level as time goes on, and that began this quarter and even in last year's fourth quarter. We don't expect any massive restructuring, because we are constantly reshuffling our setup and reshuffling our cost base to adjust as fast as we can to how the business's parameters evolve. So we observe some competitors restructuring more, let's say, intensely, but that's probably partly because they began doing so considerably later than we did. We have continually, again, been reassessing the setup to try to adjust to how revenues might evolve. So of course we'll give further details in the medium-term plan, but rest assured we are not merely sitting here waiting for interest income to get better.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#35

We're constantly revisiting how we're set up. On the medium-term plan's financial targets, you already have the answer. What we're prepared to disclose at the end of the year, we won't be disclosing right now. So we'll see precisely where we land. But as far as inorganic growth goes, it's hard to build a medium-term plan around the premise that we'll capture every inorganic growth opportunity we want, in the businesses, in the geographies, at the pricing level, at the profitability level that we dream of. Inorganic growth comes down to opportunity, comes down to being able to seize opportunities. So it also comes down to being strong on our own, because inorganic growth is, I would say, simply the positive sanction of the winners of organic growth. So we will keep targeting our plans on organic growth and organic development, and we're ready to seize inorganic growth opportunities should they arise, and should they arise with parameters that fit our standards and criteria.

Operator

operator
#36

Stefan Stalmann from Autonomous Research has our next question — go right ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#37

Hi there, Stefan.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#38

Yes. Morning, Jerome. Morning. I'd like to ask, please: do you actually intend to hold your BPM stake at fair value through the P&L, or are you thinking about reclassifying it, say, into equity, assuming you retain it? Second question: Slide 14 says the regional banks apparently purchased roughly €500 million of Crédit Agricole shares during the quarter, yet I can't find that on Slide 40, where the share count owned by Rue La Boétie remains unchanged — could you perhaps give a little color on what happened there? And the last one, please: in the regional banks' results, Insurance distribution fees were down 4% year-on-year. Is that because something changed in how you share revenue with the regional banks, or is there an actual decline in Insurance contracts sold through the regional banks?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#39

Alright, thank you. Let me begin with our stake in Banco BPM. From the start of April this year — the point at which we gained access to all the shares through the end of Q1, partly held in derivative form — we now directly own 19.8% of BPM's shares, which works out to roughly 300 million shares. From the outset, half of that stake has been run through P&L and will keep being run through P&L. A portion of it is hedged, though, so the volatility hitting the P&L will stay limited. The other half — the half we could only access at the beginning of April, when we received authorization to convert our derivative position into shares — will be accounted for against equity via OCI. So it won't directly move the P&L. The changes in valuation will, of course, affect capital and OCI, but not through P&L. One last point: another element will also work in our favor, namely the dividend level that BPM plans to pay.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#40

And you know their intention, I believe, is to pay roughly €0.60 per share in May. So naturally, we'll have access to the dividend that BPM pays. Regarding the operation SAS Rue La Boétie announced back in, I think, February. They announced that they intended to buy up to €500 million of shares in CASA's capital. But they've said this could run until probably the start of May. So it isn't completed yet, and definitely it wasn't completed at the end of March. And it was a maximum amount. So it's not certain that even at the beginning of May, when their program ends, they will have bought all of those shares. So that's information that will be updated with Q2 numbers, but it was simply a maximum. So my understanding is that their purchase program is still going on, still in progress on the market. And the last point concerns Insurance fees paid to the regional banks. So minus 4%, 3.9% to be precise. I think there's a base effect at play in Q1 2024. Some positive adjustments that were paid on top of the normal level back in Q1 2024.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#41

So I get that apart from this base effect, there's a rise in the insurance fees paid to the regional banks of roughly 7%, which is a high level, tied to the high level of policies sold and premium collected. But it is definitely up, and it lines up perfectly with how well this business is doing.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#42

Thanks a lot, Jerome — I really appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#43

Giulia Aurora Miotto from Morgan Stanley has the next question — go ahead, please.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#44

Yes. Hello. Morning to you, Jerome.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#45

Hi there, Giulia.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#46

There's a question I have about tariffs and macro uncertainty. You folks haven't set aside any provisions. Do you intend to? Are there any overlays? And on a wider level, what effect do you anticipate this macro uncertainty will have on your business? My sense is SFS is especially affected this quarter — on the Auto Consumer Finance side, I believe. But I'm not sure, for instance, whether you also expect an impact in CIB or in other areas? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#47

Okay, thank you. It's accurate that we haven't specifically factored in an overlay tied to the tariff discussion. However, the first thing you should keep in mind is that inside the loan loss reserves we hold — €9.4 billion at CASA level and €21.4 billion at Group level — a very large share of those provisions are in fact IFRS 9 provisions, meaning provisions linked to performing loans. If I'm not mistaken, that's roughly 30% to 35% for CASA and even nearer to 40% for the Group as a whole. So we have, permanently — and this is something specific to the group — a very high level of provisions that don't cover specifically incurred risks, but rather fall into different categories of overlays. The second thing is that when we calculate and when we update the level of our overlays each quarter, we do so by factoring in certain economic scenarios, a blend of differing economic scenarios. And in Q1 of this year, within that blend, again, if I'm not mistaken, the adverse — the economic adverse scenario, which isn't a tariff-specific scenario, but which is an adverse scenario where growth is plummeting and where by definition the cost of risk is increasing.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#48

This adverse scenario makes up nearly 50% of the overall weighting among the different economic scenarios we're using. So to some degree, definitely, even without factoring in a specific tariff scenario, the adverse economic scenario is, I'd say, contributing significantly to the level of overlays on our books, and I think at least at this stage we don't need to factor in a specific tariff overlay. So how has the current situation affected our business so far? Actually, not very significantly. What's going on in the Car Financing business is tied much more to the economic backdrop in Europe, to the fact that certain consumers are somewhat puzzled by some uncertainties, technical uncertainties concerning electric vehicles, for instance. Also, some difficulties were triggered for specific European carmakers by how European regulation on cars and CO2 emissions has evolved. So all these elements are contributing to the lower level of production of new Car Financing in Europe. And on top of that, as you know, we also have a significant Car Financing business in China, where competition is fierce, and in fact the sales of GAC, our partner, were somewhat impacted by the overall competition in China.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#49

There's nothing particular tied to the tariff matter or the tariff situation — it's much more about local conditions in Europe and China.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#50

Thanks so much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#51

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#52

Matthew Clark from Mediobanca has the next question. Go ahead, please.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#53

Hello. I have a few additional questions regarding capital and Banco BPM, if I may. First, I would like to verify whether the TRIM effect you mentioned earlier is already included in the CRR impact you provided this quarter, or if it is still expected in later quarters. As I recall, it was roughly €4 billion or €5 billion of risk-weighted assets that we have been anticipating for several quarters now. Second, regarding Banco BPM, could you provide the P&L impact in euro million terms arising from the revaluation of both your synthetic and cash stakes during the first quarter? That would be useful. Lastly, on Banco BPM, you indicated that your cash stake will be partially hedged going forward to reduce P&L volatility. Will the portion held through OCI also be hedged? Should we expect some kind of over-hedging P&L effect in future periods, or will the part held through OCI remain unhedged? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#54

Thank you. Starting with TRIM: as you know, that was an effort carried out globally, under ECB oversight and supervision, and it has been underway for the past three years — four years, I would say. So each quarter, on a regular basis, we were required to reinforce and tighten various models. That exercise now lies entirely behind us, meaning no additional TRIM effect should be anticipated. Still, I can't claim we'll never receive fresh requests or demands from the ECB regarding different models down the road, since they hold a permanent right. And I can tell you they do use that right to oversee and review our models. So TRIM in particular is finished, yet routine ECB supervision of our models will persist over the long run. Turning to BPM, I'd say roughly — I don't have the exact figures at hand — but I'd put the P&L impact, the revenue effect from BPM valuation this quarter at probably around €300 million, versus approximately €200 million in Q1 2024. Just bear in mind that during Q1 2024 we held only shares, so taxation on that re-evaluation was quite limited, while in Q1 2025 part of it was purely the re-evaluation of the derivative, and derivatives are taxed at the standard corporate tax rate.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#55

When it comes to revenues, the gap would land somewhere around €100 billion — €100 million, though likely somewhat under that once you factor in varying tax levels, if you're trying to gauge the net effect on profit. As for hedging, we've only set up one hedge covering a portion of the shares we hold, and we run that through P&L. There are no particular hedges on the shares we carry in OCI.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#56

Got it, Jerome — that's very clear. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#57

Chris Hallam from Goldman Sachs has the next question. Go ahead.

Chris Hallam

analyst
#58

Yes. Good afternoon, and I have two questions as well. Unfortunately, they also concern BPM and capital. So could you help me grasp what the most recent capital ratio effect of the BPM stake is? I’m aware there’s a 30 basis points headwind stemming from the increase in the stake, but I’ve somewhat lost track of the overall figure once deduction thresholds and so on are taken into account. So what is the overall effect on the CASA CET1 ratio right now? And then, as you said, a decision needs to be made there. Several different choices are available to you. If you conclude that releasing part or all of that capital is the best route, you’re already at 11.5% pro forma, 50 bps above your target. Then you’d get the tailwind from the BPM capital release. So given that, how would you approach managing that excess capital position, and how does that flexibility to redeploy capital feed into the formulation of BNPP, that is, where would you want to direct incremental investment across the businesses? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#59

Thank you. Regarding the BPM capital impact, pinning down an exact figure is hard for a couple of reasons. First, a portion of that capital effect hinges on how the shares are valued. As you're aware, for the shares held in our portfolio, the very fact that we hold them as an investment is what triggers the capital deduction — and the deduction we must take depends precisely on the share's valuation. So it shifts from one day to the next. The second element that makes this technically tricky to answer is that we operate a global franchise allowing us to risk weight the participation, the significant stakes, and beyond which a deduction is required. That means we can choose whether the franchise gets allocated to a single stake, say Victory 1 or BPM 1, or whether we spread it evenly across all participations, in which case we also deduct the same proportion from each stake above the threshold. So the answer isn't clear-cut — forgive me for going into some detail here — but the answer isn't clear-cut. Broadly speaking, and not as of the end of Q1, of course, but now that we hold the shares, I'd say roughly the total capital consumption tied to the BPM stakes — that is, the 19.8% stake we hold in BPM's capital — would come in around 40 bps to 45 bps of CET1 ratio for CASA.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#60

But once more, it hinges on the share price and on certain internal rules, I'd say, that we might establish regarding how we use the franchise. Then, on your second question, suppose we hold surplus capital at some moment—what would we do with that surplus? Obviously, that too is something we might address during the medium-term plan presentation, yet we won't discuss surplus capital. Right now, it's far too soon to argue about that matter. So at present, our capital position is very ample, we'll keep producing results that will add to that capital position, and we'll see at the end of the year, when we present the medium-term plan, when we set the distribution rate, and so on and so forth, and when we begin, when we fix the dividend level.

Chris Hallam

analyst
#61

Alright, thank you so much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#62

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#63

Our following question comes from Pierre Chedeville at CIC. The floor is yours.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#64

Yes. Good afternoon, Jerome. There are no further questions left. I would say, perhaps one question as we reach the conclusion of the strategic plan and the conclusion of Philippe Brassac's governance. I recall that when he introduced the plan, he was extremely enthusiastic about establishing two divisions, Crédit Agricole Transitions and Energies and Crédit Agricole Health and Territories, and he was equally enthusiastic about launching an offering for insurance for SMEs, and more broadly for companies. What would you say now, at the close of the plan, concerning whether this division succeeded or not, because you never discuss them? My second question concerns home loans. Of course, you mentioned that we are on an ultra-competitive level playing field, I would say, but we observe that one of your peers is pulling back from this business because he regards margins as too thin. And another one, and here I am referring to LCL, not Caisses Régionales, which is entirely different. The other one appears, on the contrary, to be accelerating, seems to be accelerating strongly on home loans. I wanted to know where you stand at LCL? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#65

Thank you. When it comes to CAST and CATE, I'd say the initial moves for those two new ventures really have worked out, simply because the businesses are now up and running. The operating entities are in place. They've begun working across various service areas. In fact, we keep the market updated on a regular basis about what we're doing, which acquisitions we've completed, and so forth. What I can say, though, is that in both divisions we now have operational activities that are start — that have begun selling their products and services to our customers. Naturally, in terms of the numbers, it isn't moving the needle yet, and we didn't expect the needle to move during the last plan or the current medium-term plan, but it's absolutely certain that we will set new targets and be more precise when we present the new medium-term plan concerning those new activities. But once more, let me repeat that we truly have begun to operate concretely in those two businesses. As for home loans, we're neither in the accelerating camp nor in the retrenching camp, because we simply believe that given the business model we developed, we need this offer, we need it to be competitive, and we don't do stop and go, because the profitability we earn on a home loan at any given moment is either good or bad.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#66

Home loans are among the worldwide services we aim to offer our customers. You have to judge how profitable a relationship is by looking at the client over the long term, rather than by looking at the product over the short term. That’s why we don’t want to adopt the stop-and-go approach that some competitors have been using for many, many years. So at LCL there’s no stop and go, no speeding up just because it might be expected to deliver a better yield at a particular moment, and no major slowdowns just because selling home loans would be less appealing.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#67

On the insurance side…

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#68

On insurance, the situation is the same. This isn't a brand-new business, since it falls within the insurance activities, but we've rolled out corporate P&C insurance and we're growing those operations. We're patient, and that patience is one of the keys to Crédit Agricole Group's success. We have time, so as of now, once again, this doesn't make up a huge portion of the €14.8 billion in premium income posted by Crédit Agricole Assurance in the fourth — first quarter of the year, but it has certainly begun to account for a meaningful level of activity at Pacifica, the Group's P&C insurance company.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#69

Alright, thanks so much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#70

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#71

Our following question comes from Flora Bocahut at Barclays. Kindly proceed.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#72

Thank you. Hi, Jerome. I actually have three questions for you. First, we've recently heard remarks from DSSM <<inaudible>> and even from a few ECB governors about their readiness to simplify regulation, as they put it. So have you already observed any concrete evidence of that occurring, and do you believe this could actually have an impact? Second, a question about the yield curve steepening, since the way you characterize the macro hedge at LCL makes me think this is in fact signaling that a steeper curve is a headwind. So could you elaborate on whether the curve steepening is a positive or a negative for Crédit P&L? And finally, a quick question about U.S. dollar exposure. I'd imagine it isn't much for Crédit Agricole, so the headwind effect here from the weaker dollar. I suppose perhaps in the financing operations of the CIB, I would assume you have a fair amount of U.S. dollar denominated revenues against euro costs. So is this negligible or something we should be aware of? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#73

Is there any indication that the regulation is being simplified? To be frank and blunt, no. There is no sign. There is no sign of genuine simplification of the regulation, and this is not in the hands of the ECB and DSSM. Regulation is clearly in the hands of lawmakers. And lawmakers are considering, but nothing concrete for the time being, to simplify or to ease a little bit the constraints for smaller players. But I think that large banks, as we are, are completely outside of their scope of reflection as of today. And when it comes to the ECB itself, so it's much more supervision than regulation, there's no move in the direction of simplification as of today. We continue to have a lot of reporting. We continue to have a lot of requests. And so there's nothing that we can note in terms of easing of the supervision. Steepening of the yield curve. Globally, if you assess, if the steepening of the yield curve is only through a decrease of short-term rates, it's not representing a very significant and very positive impact, because the yield of the loan book is not going to change, is not going to improve if long-term rates continue to be where they are and it's clear that the hedge portfolio is going to yield less.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#74

Right at that time, the expense tied to certain dated customer resources we hold—a term deposit, say—or the price of market funding we raise to supplement those customer resources will likely come down as well. So overall, it isn't a negative, though it won't be hugely positive either. The ideal scenario is a steepening driven by short-term rates holding at their current level while long-term rates rise meaningfully—which happens when the economy is improving sharply, and that isn't where we are today. So clearly, from the yield curve steepening we're observing right now, we anticipate neither much benefit nor much harm. Turning to U.S. dollar exposure, there are two effects worth examining. The first concerns solvency, and we aim to be as immunized as we can by holding capital position components whose proportions match those of the dollar-denominated risk-weighted assets, so that we stay as neutral as possible with respect to forex movements. Then, regarding P&L, we incur costs in dollars and we generate revenues in dollars.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#75

Obviously, our dollar revenues exceed our dollar costs. So naturally, should the dollar’s value fall, the conversion of those revenues—or the net profit in dollars converted into euros—will contract somewhat. That effect isn’t massive, and we routinely sell the dollars generated by day-to-day operations, meaning we don’t carry significant dollar exposure on our books. So yes, naturally, a weaker dollar would be somewhat negative, though not massive.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#76

All right, thanks a lot.

Operator

operator
#77

Sharath Kumar from Deutsche Bank has the final question. Go right ahead.

Sharath Kumar

analyst
#78

Thanks for taking my questions. Apologies, this has already come up. So is there any updated thinking regarding the interim dividend decision? Could you confirm whether that proposal has gone to the Board, and if the decision is positive, might it be applicable to current day profits already? The second point is a clarification on capital versus the 11.8% pro forma CET1 ratio you referenced in your slides. I would anticipate a further 30 basis points of impact from the asset services acquisition. So when do you expect that transaction to close? Also, are there any other material items we should be aware of regarding the capital trajectory? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#79

Thanks. On the interim dividend, as I mentioned during the Q4 call last year, we have no strong preference either way on that question. Should it become standard market practice, we could certainly adjust, but as of now nothing has been decided. What we observe is that certain French corporates already do this, and a few European banks too, yet it isn't widespread. There are some administrative costs involved, since we'd need to assess and formalize the H1 results a bit more. So — but should it become standard market practice, we could adapt easily, so I'd say it isn't a political decision. And nothing at all has been decided on that front. Regarding capital, it's entirely clear that pro forma, with the transactions completed at the start of April, we stand at 11.8%, and we expect a 30 bps hit stemming from the CACEIS acquisition. That could occur either at the end of Q2 or the start of Q3. So right now, we still target the end of Q2, but we can't entirely rule out the start of Q3, because we are gathering a huge number of administrative approvals to secure these transactions, and some of them are taking — could take longer than anticipated.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#80

We’re doing everything we can to try to get it finished by the end of Q2 — that would be better and more clear cut. But if that isn’t possible, it would be the beginning of Q3, and we’ll keep you informed.

Sharath Kumar

analyst
#81

I appreciate that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#82

Thanks. That was probably the final question. So thank you everyone for being here at this meeting. As for me, this will be my final meeting serving as the main speaker, I’d say. I’d always be very glad to see each of you over the weeks, months and quarters ahead. So this isn’t a goodbye, but rather a shift in role, and I’m glad to pass it over to Clotilde beginning with Q2 numbers. So have a good rest of the day, everyone, and see you soon. Bye-bye.

Operator

operator
#83

Thank you, everyone, for being with us. That brings the conference to its end, and you're free to hang up your phones now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.