Creative Newtech Limited (CNL) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 17, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to Creative Newtech Limited's Q4 FY '24 Earnings Conference Call. Forward-looking statements may be included in this call, and those rest on the company's beliefs, opinions, and expectations as of today. Such statements do not come with any guarantee regarding future performance and carry risks and uncertainties that are hard to foresee. <<operator_script>> Kindly be aware that this conference is being recorded. Right now, I'd like to turn the conference over to Mr. Ketan Patel, Chairman and Managing Director of Creative Newtech Limited. Thank you, and the floor is yours, sir.
Ketan Patel
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Creative Newtech Limited earnings conference call for the fourth quarter and full year ended March 31, 2024. First, I want to thank all of you for making the time to join us today. Joining me on this call are Mr. Abhijit Kanvinde, our CFO; Mr. Vijay Advani, Wholetime Director; and Adfactors, our Investor Relations team. I'm pleased to report that we ended the financial year on a strong note. Creative expansion has continued amid the dynamic shifts in the market, backed by its efficient business framework and a selectively crafted product lineup. The past year has been particularly eventful for us, with several of our initiatives now bearing fruit. I'd like to use this opportunity to quickly recap the major business updates and milestones we achieved during this fiscal year. To begin with, on an overall basis, we grew our top line by 24.15% and profit by 77.08%, even though our March quarter-on-quarter was negative by around INR 90 crores. That came about because of a decline in enterprise business. Our enterprise business is an opportunity business, and our minimum benchmark is 20% ROCE. We are also in a period of transition in which we want to focus on high-growth, double-digit profitable businesses.
Ketan Patel
executiveTurning to Honeywell — starting from a base of roughly INR 80 crores, we pushed that business up by over 100%, reaching INR 170 crores. Through Secure Connection, our subsidiary based in Hong Kong, we announced the worldwide launch of the next generation of Honeywell-branded Soundbars. That launch highlights how committed we are to bringing cutting edge audio solutions to customers across the globe. We're confident these soundbars will <<inaudible>> the way people experience sound. In our view, this product category holds immense potential for adoption among the masses and will grow into a significant revenue stream on its own. We also rolled out our new range of car air purifiers. The air purifier business is a multi-decadal growth opportunity business. Since it's still a newer category, not much data is available, but we believe the opportunity is as huge as how air conditioners opportunity was there 30 years back. Today, almost more than INR 1 crores AC are now sold in India. As a leading brand in air purifier category, it is our responsibility to create the market also. Beyond that, we launched almost another 50 SKUs for different geographies. Honeywell is going into a robust business for us, and we expect it to contribute incrementally to our top line as well as our profits.
Ketan Patel
executiveOur brand licensing business also grew, thanks to adding CyberpowerPC — a significant milestone for the company overall. Cyberpower, Inc. is a major U.S. gaming system player. This licensing deal gives us access not only to leading-edge technology but also puts us side by side with a worldwide leader in gaming innovation. Thanks to this partnership, we can address rising demand for high-performance gaming computers, equipment and accessories in the India market. By customizing what we offer to match the distinct preferences of Indian gamers, we are positioned to seize a meaningful share of this thriving industry. We aim to establish new benchmarks for gaming experiences via <<inaudible>> offerings and to establish Creative as a frontrunner in the Indian gaming ecosystem. On geographic expansion, we have launched several initiatives to spread our network across overseas markets as well. Working with Secure Connection, we teamed up with Trigon LLC to distribute our range of Honeywell products in the United Arab Emirates. This collaboration will make sure our Honeywell products portfolio reaches customers efficiently in that region, which is a high-margin area for us. We are also delighted to have partnered with PT Bintang Mas Rezeki Nusantara, a top technology product distributor in Indonesia, to improve consumer experiences by drawing on their extensive distribution network and Honeywell's innovative product offerings, which helps us build a strong presence in the Indonesian market.
Ketan Patel
executiveAlso, as we keep pursuing our selective approach of bringing niche products into the portfolio, we've signed several new brands during the past few months — names such as Dahua, pTron, Nokia, Dahua, and Holoware, among others. We have a number of brands in the pipeline that are under evaluation. The momentum we're carrying into the new fiscal year leaves us optimistic about the near future, both on the distribution side and on licensing. Honeywell's business is expanding in a way that aligns with our strategy of raising the share of revenue we get from licensing, which for us is the higher-margin business. Our fruitful partnerships with leaders such as Cyberpower Inc. and Palred Electronics highlight our capacity to build strategic alliances and take advantage of emerging market trends. Going forward, we will stay focused on capturing more such segments and growing our presence in key growth areas, with the aim of delivering sustained value to all stakeholders. In the coming year, we want to simplify how we report segmental revenue, since our business is mainly split into 3 categories: licensing business, distribution Business, and enterprise Business, which sits within distribution. I now hand the floor over to Mr.
Ketan Patel
executiveAbhijit Kanvinde will now walk you through the quarter's and the full year's financial highlights.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveThank you, sir, and good afternoon everyone. I'll walk you through the key points from our consolidated financial results, and after that we'll open the floor for your questions. Our financials are reported in accordance with Ind AS guidelines. Turning to consolidated Q4 FY '24 results, total income came in at INR 320.44 crores, down 20.48% year-on-year, as relatively muted sales in the enterprise business segment offset growth in FMSG. That said, we continue to see demand for a number of key brands, including Samsung, Cooler Master and Honeywell, among others. On segment performance for the quarter, FMSG contributed 24.69% of revenue. FMCT accounted for 18.98% of revenue, while the enterprise business made up 56.31% of revenue. Quarterly EBITDA was INR 28.05 crores, versus INR 11.49 crores in the same period last year, a rise of 144.05% year-on-year. The EBITDA margin for the quarter came in at 8.75%, up 590 basis points compared with the corresponding quarter a year ago. Operational efficiencies and a higher contribution from Honeywell helped us improve the margin. PAT for the quarter was INR 20.36 crores, compared with INR 6.45 crores in Q4 FY '23, a year-on-year increase of 215.55%. During the quarter, we carried out a slump sale of our Ckart division for a consideration of INR 10 crores, and the company earned a profit of INR 9.9 crores on this transaction, which is included in other income for this quarter.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveFor the quarter, EPS came in at INR 15.11. Now turning to the consolidated results for the full year. Total income for FY '24 was INR 1740.91 crores, which represents 24.15% growth year-on-year. Healthy demand across products such as Samsung, Cooler Master, Honeywell ViewSonic drove this, along with additional support from growth in the retail sector. EBITDA — EBITDA for FY '24 came to INR 69.22 crores, compared with INR 45.12 crores in the same period last year, marking a 53.42% increase year-on-year. EBITDA margins for this year were 3.98%. Improved operational efficiencies, together with a strong contribution from Honeywell, helped drive the improvement in growth as well as in margins. PAT for FY '24 arrived at INR 48.25 crores versus INR 27.25 crores in FY '23 — a year-on-year growth of 77.08%. EPS for FY '24 is INR 32.58. The Board of Directors has recommended a dividend of INR 0.50 on a face value of INR 10, subject to shareholders' approval. That covers everything from our side. We can now open the floor for questions.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Deepa Shah, an Individual Investor.
Speaker
unknownNice work on those solid results. I just wanted to ask whether we’ve got any fresh partnership lined up in the pipeline for the years ahead?
Ketan Patel
executiveMrs. Shah, normally we continuously assess brands and products throughout the entire year. And the process takes at least 3 to 4 months before a brand can be signed. So that's a process spanning the whole year. At present as well, we are in talks with a couple of brands regarding trade terms, and if both parties like all the conditions, then we'll move forward with that.
Speaker
unknownIs there any particular goal we have in mind, like a set number of brands we need to bring into the portfolio each year?
Ketan Patel
executiveTypically, each year we have a chance to bring 2 to 3 brands into the portfolio. And when choosing brands, we also apply a few internal criteria: is it an experiential brand, does it generate a solid amount of sales in the country where it's present, will it have manpower years — all those sorts of criteria are in place, and we follow them. Normally, our thinking is that since we're in the technology business and technology becomes obsolete every 2 to 3 years, our business from new-age products ought to be at least 30% to 35% on a rotation basis. So the moment a product — a brand — turns 3 years old, we move it into the old brand bucket. So if that brand is doing INR 100 of business, then we'll need INR 30, or 30% of business, coming from a new brand. That's the internal criteria we follow.
Speaker
unknownAll right, so regarding how these brands are marketed — is that handled in-house by Creative? And what sort of percentage does that represent on the expense side? Relative to revenue? Or do the brands do it themselves?
Ketan Patel
executiveOkay, two points regarding the money that brands pay through us. Since many brands don’t have a presence in India, they rely on a local partner here to handle their marketing payments — that’s the first thing. Second, some brands — Samsung, for instance — have their own marketing operations and wouldn’t need a company like ours to market for them. And then there are brands such as Cricut, an experiential printer that can cut, emboss, print, and write on all sorts of surfaces. When a brand of that type enters this market, they typically arrive with a brand strategy they want us to carry out, and our in-house team handles the execution. In some cases the brand brings its own marketing and PR agencies to build things up, so those agencies manage the top-line execution while we handle below-the-line work — going into the market, road shows, and the rest of it — that’s how it works. But apart from Honeywell, there isn’t a single other brand where we spend anything out of our own pocket on marketing.
Speaker
unknownUnderstood, sir. And one final question about Ckart, if I may. Since we've sold Ckart, what was the particular reason behind that? And what percentage of revenue loss should we anticipate from it in the year ahead? And how will this affect — basically, how is it going to impact our financials?
Ketan Patel
executiveAlright, so there are 2 or 3 points here. First and foremost, we won't see any revenue loss, because Ckart was really more of a go-to-market engine — we used it so people could place orders directly on our site. Before the sale of Ckart, we already had another software in place that helps us take orders from customers and helps our field team go to market and take orders — that's already there. The main reason behind Ckart was that the marketplace was a big opportunity, and a B2B marketplace definitely had a lot of traction. But the success metrics for a B2B marketplace are very different from the success metrics for a physical brand and distribution company. The investors in our company, primarily those who like physical businesses, really want good PAT, good goodwill rotation, good EBITDA — that's the situation. If we had to build the Ckart business, it's all about the lifetime value of the customer, the cost of acquiring our customers, it's about earning a lot of money to get these customers, and we were in a dilemma, but then we decided that we — our balance sheet can't afford to burn money for the business.
Ketan Patel
executiveSo Honeywell and CyberPower are already established there, and both of those are high-margin operations. We simply wouldn’t have had the time, nor did we have the resources, to grow that business ourselves. And as you know, if you don’t take advantage of an opportunity within a certain window, that opportunity will disappear. We received a solid offer, and we decided to move forward with it. That’s the rationale. But to repeat once more: where our revenue and profitability are concerned, there will be no loss in that area.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our following question comes from Deepak Poddar, who is calling in from Sapphire Capital.
Deepak Poddar
analystYes, can you hear me, sir?
Ketan Patel
executiveYeah, <<inaudible>> we can hear you.
Deepak Poddar
analystTo start with, I just wanted to get clear on the fact that this INR 10 crores of other income came from the sale of the Ckart division. Even so, I believe we reported other income of roughly INR 15 crores, around INR 15.5 crores. So where does that remaining INR 5 crores come from?
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveAll right. That one — I'll accept it.
Ketan Patel
executiveSince that was unclear, Abhijit is going to handle this question.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveSo ordinarily, if you look at total other income for the quarter, it came to INR 16.9 crores, and INR 10 crores of that was Ckart. The remainder — the big pieces were foreign exchange gains at INR 4.5 crores, and there was some FD that came to roughly INR 22 lakhs, okay? And we had some <<inaudible>> drawback of about INR 97 lakhs. So export incentive was INR 97 lakhs, gain on transaction INR 4.5 crores, and the rest goes to other interest and other income.
Deepak Poddar
analystRight. So the bulk of that figure — roughly INR 14.5 crores — comes from Ckart as well as the rate on foreign exchange gains, is that correct?
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveIt's INR 4.5 crores, not INR 14 crores.
Deepak Poddar
analystNo, so I’ve included the Ckart too.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveCorrect.
Ketan Patel
executiveThe FX gain here is, well, <<inaudible>>, but what happens is that on any consignment you import, customs imposes a 1% charge. That means you've got to figure the dollar at 1% higher. Yet at the point you remit, it's actually 1% lower. So for that reason, because of the statutory requirement, we're obliged to record it as a foreign exchange gain, when in reality it's simply a component of cost of goods.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveYes. That falls under cost of goods, but according to Ind AS, that's how you're required to report it.
Deepak Poddar
analystGot it, got it. Understood, understood. You mentioned all the brands we've recently partnered with around equipment and the many more we're considering, so how should we view growth if I look ahead 2 to 3 years?
Ketan Patel
executiveAll right. So what's happening right now is that following the government's Make In India push, plenty of Indian brands are emerging, correct? Take, for instance, a company named Holoware. They make commercial PCs that go up against players like HP, Dell and Lenovo. This is a product manufactured in India — 54% of the PC components are now produced in India. So these technology firms have this opportunity, and they're seeking someone with all-India reach who can help them scale and bring products to market. So that's one thing — those kinds of brands are approaching us for that. For example, 2 companies, Palred, which was mainly an online business, now wants to move into off-line, and they came to us, and Holoware did as well. Then, looking at brands such as Cricut and Ruark, worldwide demographics favor India, correct? 75% of our population is millennials. The China Plus One strategy. So deglobalisation, right. That works in our favor too. So all these brands genuinely want to come into India. And most of them are premium and are focused on — delivering a great experience to consumers, because millennials value life experiences above everything else, correct?
Ketan Patel
executiveSo brands of this type are now looking to come into India. All of these are new-age brands, with devices that are always connected to the Internet, and they help today's consumer either consume content, create content, or share content and be part of that community. So an opportunity with that kind of brand is emerging.
Deepak Poddar
analystRight, right. But with these new opportunities in mind, what kind of growth should we expect from us over the next 2 years — maybe some CAGR growth?
Ketan Patel
executiveSo, Mr. Poddar, basically we have 2 businesses. One is the market entry business bringing brands into India. And the second is our licensing business, which is the Honeywell business. And we see a huge opportunity — and that's our aspiration — that each year, we can grow by at least 25%, 30%. And our aspiration is that every year, at least for the next 4, 5 years, we kind of increase our PAT by 40% to 50%. That's the aspiration.
Deepak Poddar
analystSo over the next 4 to 5 years, top line grows roughly 25% to 30%, and bottom line grows around 40% to 50%, correct?
Ketan Patel
executiveYes.
Deepak Poddar
analystAll right, that's crystal clear. Just one final question: how does the margin compare between licensing and distribution? My assumption is that licensing carries a considerably higher margin rate.
Ketan Patel
executiveRight, so with licensing, the gross margin typically sits at around 35%, 36%. In distribution, it ranges between 7% and 10%, based on the product mix at any given moment — that's the story. But neither business can survive without the other, since distribution really amortizes the cost, boosts our visibility, gets a foot in the door, and helps us observe market trends — that's how it is. So if you can build a solid licensing business on top of distribution, that's a great opportunity. At Honeywell, up to now — and now we also have CyberpowerPC, the U.S. #1 esports gaming PC brand, which has come here. They sell online, they sell via Amazon, and they sell through Best Buy, and similar channels are available here, and we've just tied up with them and that business. So that will be our second brand in licensing. So the aspiration is that once Honeywell reaches the threshold of, say, INR 270 crores to INR 280 crores, you would then have one more licensing brand. That's the aspiration.
Deepak Poddar
analystRight, right. And at this point, how does our revenue split between licensing and distribution look?
Ketan Patel
executiveAt the moment, it’s — so we achieved 17%, 50%, correct? Broadly speaking, licensing accounts for roughly 11% to 12% of our business, and the goal is to gradually grow that licensing segment to around 25% to 30% over the coming 2 to 3 years.
Deepak Poddar
analystOver the next 2 to 3 years. And that's the thing that's going to drive your PAT, correct? What I mean is, top line growth comes in at 25%, 30%, so your margin has to go up.
Ketan Patel
executiveRight. And we're pretty confident about that, because we now have a handle on launching products, and in the air purifier category we've witnessed a solid level of traction, and in home audio, particularly soundbars, we're also seeing good traction. And now we've got partners in the remaining countries as well. The licensing business isn't only for India — it covers 38 countries. So at this point we're already in some other countries too. We're already in the Middle East, we're already in Indonesia, we're already in Singapore. So that's also going to help us grow the business overall.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our following question comes from Jyoti Singh with Arihant Capital.
Jyoti Singh
analystJust to confirm on that top line, sir, our guidance is for 20% to 25% growth, and on the bottom line we're expecting 40% to 45% growth.
Ketan Patel
executiveYeah, that is what we're aiming for.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveAspiration — that isn't the guidance.
Ketan Patel
executiveOn to estimates.
Jyoti Singh
analystYes, that's an estimate. And sir, I just wanted to get a handle on this new brand backed by the government, made in India — how are we viewing that opportunity as we move forward over the next 3 to 4 years?
Ketan Patel
executiveAlso, the government has its own procurement site post Make in India, named GeM — Government e Marketplace, correct? On that platform, total business worth INR 3 lakh crores took place last year. And electronics forms a significant portion of that area. Now, on that platform, you cannot list products that come from places where your borders meet. Products from neighboring countries sharing a border with you are not allowed. So that presents a big chance for Indian brands to genuinely, genuinely expand within that segment. And thanks to the PLI as well, many brands are going to grow. So the opportunity is enormous. It all hinges on our manufacturers and brands actually scaling up.
Jyoti Singh
analystAnd sir, regarding that other segment—Honeywell happens to be our largest customer—so is there anything else either in the pipeline or under active discussion that we should be expecting?
Ketan Patel
executiveAt the moment, we’ve had Honeywell, and now Cyberpower has come in. So right now those are the 2 only ones sitting on the plate in the licensing space.
Jyoti Singh
analystAll right, so are there any other major brands we’re anticipating or currently in active discussions with, sir?
Ketan Patel
executiveNo. Not in licensing. Distribution, yes — but licensing, no. You brought up something like Honeywell; Honeywell is the brand we license. So at present, nothing in that licensing area.
Operator
operatorMoving on, our next question comes from Pooja Thakkar, who is calling in from Seven Island PMS.
Pooja Thakkar
analystSir, one question from me. Creative recently entered into a brand licensing deal with Cyberpower, Inc for gaming computers. So what sort of opportunity do you see in India when it comes to this gaming computer?
Ketan Patel
executiveYes. Like I said earlier, India's millennial population — 75% of our population is under 35 years of age. And they like a lot of online interaction, they prefer a lot of — they also play a lot of games where a big community is playing a game, right? And they play games with people they don't even know. The company we tied up with has almost market share, and alongside them there's another company called iBUYPOWER. So together they've given the license for India. Combined, they hold a 66% market share. And combined, they do almost $1 billion of business. On data, IDC says gaming overall is growing at a pace of 23%, 24%, and esports gaming is also now part of the Asian games too. So it's a huge opportunity. Second, we have first mover advantage today. If anybody wants to buy a gaming PC, there's no single website that comes to mind, right? And the websites that do exist also don't have configurators where you could configure your PC right from scratch. They don't have frames calculator because that's a very important aspect for games.
Ketan Patel
executiveOn top of that, you also need partnerships involving NVIDA, Intel, Microsoft, and AMD. So with our partner, every one of those tie-ups arrives ready-made as well, and on top of that they serve as our technology partners. They have therefore spent 25 years in this business. So how to construct a strong website, how to market on a website — all of that too they bring to the table. What we contribute to them is the on-ground logistics and the know-how of the Indian market. And we have recruited the finest team from the industry, people who have been in that business. And I believe we will be live on that side by 22nd of this month as well. So by the next quarter, we'll be able to tell you how we are tracking on that.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Rohan Patel, who is with Turtle Capital.
Rohan Patel
analystSir, can you hear me okay?
Ketan Patel
executiveYes, Mr. Rohan, we can hear you. What is the name of your firm? Turtle Capital, correct?
Rohan Patel
analystYeah. Yeah. So how large is the Honeywell opportunity for us right now? It's a big brand — it's a mass brand, right? So can we expect Honeywell to become an INR 5 crore — INR 500 crores business for us within 5 to 6 years?
Ketan Patel
executiveAbsolutely, that’s certainly what we’re aiming for—the Honeywell business should reach INR 500 crore within the next 2 to 3 years. And I’ll explain why: if you look at the categories overall that we’re in, right, in the Honeywell space, we’re in the air purifier category. Air purifiers represent a very large opportunity. In my opening remarks I said it’s similar to where air conditioners stood 30 years ago, right? Last year, 1 crores air conditioners were sold in India alone. So air purifiers are a multi-decadal opportunity. And if air purifiers perform well too, it could be close to that. The second category is the Honeywell Passive business. Honeywell Passive is our networking cable business. And if you look at Indian counterparts as well, they would do around INR 800 crores, INR 900 crores—just one brand is doing INR 800 crores to INR 900 crores in that classic business, right—plus we have audio; audio again is INR 2 billion to INR 3 billion—meaning INR 25 crores—an INR 25,000 crore opportunity for that. In the audio space, the Honeywell brand <<inaudible>> isn’t so great. But I’m sure the opportunity is so huge that we can really make some dent in the Honeywell space.
Ketan Patel
executiveSo when we look at all of this, if we have strong products and the right skill set, we can perform very well—and on top of that, India isn't our only opportunity. We also have another 38 countries as opportunities. So yes, that's the reason we aspire to reach INR 500 crores in Honeywell.
Rohan Patel
analystOn the Cyberpower side — have we actually begun production of CyberpowerPC?
Ketan Patel
executiveRight, so let me just clarify that we won't be manufacturing — we'll be assembling the PCs. Essentially, you visit a website, choose your budget and the kind of PC you're after, and then you begin selecting components: cabinet, power supply, motherboard, a cooler, hard drive or memory, the type of monitors, the type of keyboard, the type of mouse — all of it. And it keeps showing you what the performance of that PC will be. Then, once you place your order, your custom-made PC gets assembled in a small factory and shipped straight to you. Plus, you get a 3-year warranty, 5-year warranty, on-site warranty — all of that comes with it.
Rohan Patel
analystRight, I get that millennials and younger people make up most of India, but gaming culture there is still at a nascent stage. It isn't that big compared with the U.S. or China. So what steps are you taking with Cyberpower to boost penetration or build a gaming ecosystem?
Ketan Patel
executiveSo Rohan, what exactly is a gaming PC at its core? There's also a sizable creator community, correct? Your first — so your customer has 3 avatars, right? The first consumer avatar is young millennials who are looking to play games, right? That's avatar number one. The second avatar is the creators' community. So folks doing animation, people who create — make ad films, make products, they need a high-performance PC component, right? So yours is someone who needs to do stock trading, he needs faster desktops for HFT trading. Someone mining crypto, right? So all of this calls for high-performance computer components. Gaming is the fastest and it has the best computer components. Today, with the boom of AI, right, all these machines, because they have an NVIDA graphic card, all these machines can go toward building a large LLM network. So that too is part of it. So gaming, as you can see, so the core component in the creator community, the core component in crypto or high frequency trading or anywhere else would stay the same. So it's a very huge, huge opportunity in that space. Second, we already have the ecosystem, because we run a brand called Razer, which is an Apple of gaming, we run a brand called Cooler Master, it's also a big brand for us.
Ketan Patel
executiveWe’re genuinely very enthusiastic. And we’ve also observed that at Cooler Master. A lot of our power supplies aren’t purchased by PMS; instead, server companies buy them, so many units go to those building their own servers for data centers and other purposes. That space therefore presents a huge opportunity.
Rohan Patel
analystOn the consumer side, CyberpowerPC has a really broad base.
Ketan Patel
executiveThat's right.
Rohan Patel
analystAnd one more question — how much will CyberpowerPC contribute to your top line over the next 3, 4 years? I mean, building a market is going to take some time, so...
Ketan Patel
executiveRight, correct. So when we first started planning, we also aimed to reach somewhere near $80 million to $100 million in that area within 5 years. But there's still a lot we're learning. And, you know, India is quite a different market compared with other places. So I'll be in a better position to answer that in a couple of quarters. Second, that sits within our subsidiary, and I don't run that business. A gentleman named Vishal Parekh runs it. So as time goes on, we'll be able to give you a clearer picture. And let's launch on 22nd May, and then we'll see how it goes.
Rohan Patel
analystAlright, and then one final question. So, as of FY'24, what share does Honeywell contribute?
Ketan Patel
executiveSo you're saying this year refers to '24 and '25?
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveFor 2025 and 2026.
Ketan Patel
executiveThe current year stands at 12%, which puts us at INR 180 crores in.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveWe recorded INR 170 crores.
Ketan Patel
executiveINR 170 crores, within an overall business of...
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveWe posted INR 1,713 crores.
Ketan Patel
executiveYeah, so roughly INR 1,700 crores, 10%.
Rohan Patel
analyst10%. All right. All right. And what did it come to in FY '23? An absolute figure would be fine.
Ketan Patel
executiveBack in — last year, 2023, we posted INR 1,375 crores — I mean, INR 1,375 crores — and it was INR 80 crores.
Rohan Patel
analystWe recorded INR 80 crores.
Ketan Patel
executiveSo it came in at just about 5%. Specifically, 5.8% to 5.9%.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Following that, we have a question from Akash Jain at GT Financial Services. Then we'll take one from <<inaudible>>, an Individual Investor.
Speaker
unknownSir, I've got a few questions for you — can you hear me?
Ketan Patel
executiveYeah, yes. Mr. <<inaudible>>, we can hear you loud and clear.
Speaker
unknownI just wanted to get a bit of clarity — are there any new markets or regions the company is targeting when it comes to expansion?
Ketan Patel
executiveAt the moment, no. Right now, since we operate in 38 countries, our priority is to consolidate and firmly establish that footprint before expanding further for Honeywell. So of those 38 countries, we've still only reached 12 countries — 12, 13 countries. We want to build on that and then go further.
Speaker
unknownRight, got it. And in the market as it stands today, what's your plan for growing that?
Ketan Patel
executiveTypically, when you look at staffing in a given country — right now in the Middle East we have the Middle East Sales Director, a GCC sales Director, the passive components sales person, and a marketing team on the ground as well. Once that team is set up, the next step is bringing distributors on board. We verify that every certification needed to launch product in that country is in place, and then we move forward. For the Middle East, all of our certifications are in place and all of our staffing is in place. The same holds for Singapore. Singapore is a smaller market in terms of — but if you want to reach Southeast Asia, it's a highly strategic market. In Singapore we have Christina, our Director of Southeast Asia. Under her leadership, we opened up Indonesia and Thailand. Now Malaysia has been opened up, and Singapore has been opened up. So that's the plan. We've also observed that this continues — countries with larger populations are ones we want to enter. Then Egypt and Turkey and South Africa, those countries really emerge, and Saudi Arabia emerges. We have a person in Saudi Arabia as well. But in Egypt and Turkey, there's a huge issue when it comes to exchange.
Ketan Patel
executiveSo assuming we find the right partner who's prepared to pay cash and take the material onto their own books, we'll go there. Egypt — in any case, we've only just begun; we secured an order in Egypt with Amazon as well. And when it comes to building a consumer brand, these days you'll certainly build it online, correct? You need a certain number of reviews, you need a certain amount of glance use, and then the brand gets built. So we've devoted considerable time on Amazon at present to see most of our product — air purifier, more than 3,000 BUs, suppressors more than 3,000 BUs, audio we're building that space. Once those reviews begin coming in, you'll then have good traction in the times ahead. So once we get the right skill set where manpower is concerned, and if we get — our certification is nearly complete, but in certain spaces it's that — those are the certification, then you must transfer the certification over to the distributor. So once we get the right distributors, we'll move forward.
Speaker
unknownUnderstood. And sir, when it comes to cutting costs, are we <<inaudible>> adopting any technology so we can stay competitive?
Ketan Patel
executiveAt the moment, in terms of what we’re able to do within our own area — things like having the right ERP software, the right systems and processes, the right website builders, and the right sales management tools — all of that sits in our space. As things stand right now, AI is used only the way, say, a KG student would use it: to generate content for your social media, to generate content for dealer postings and all of that, and our marketing team handles that. But on the question of whether we’re doing anything at the forefront of cutting-edge technology when it comes to our system processes and cost cutting — currently, no.
Speaker
unknownAll right. Understood. Understood. Then, sir, a final question from me. How do you see the upcoming quarter shaping up, and what about the full fiscal year ahead? Are there particular strategic milestones or goals you're aiming to hit?
Ketan Patel
executiveLike I said in my earlier answer, each year we aim to expand the top line between 25% and 30%, and the bottom line in a similar way — roughly 40% to 50%. That's essentially what we're focused on.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Jyoti Singh with Arihant Capital.
Jyoti Singh
analystSir, my question concerns the margin side. What should we expect going forward?
Ketan Patel
executiveI’ll have Abhijit handle that question.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveSo, taking the distribution business as a whole, margins there — as Ketan said — sit somewhere between 8% and 10%. And the overall margin in — I mean gross margins and overall margins — for the Honeywell business runs from 34% to 38%. The Enterprise business likewise delivers a margin of about 1.5% to 2%, and that's the gross margin we're talking about. So this is always a blend across these 3 businesses. As you know, whenever we raise the contribution from Honeywell, our margin structure should improve. Right now, at consol level, we're at PAT margins of 2.36%. I'm taking out the extraordinary after-tax profit from Ckart. So we're at almost 2.36%. I want to reassure you that going forward, over the coming years, our aspiration is to grow Honeywell. And if that comes to pass — and we're working very hard toward it — if it does, then within 2, 3 years, the PAT margin we're looking at is in the range of 4.5% to 5.5%, 6% — that's our <<inaudible>>.
Jyoti Singh
analystWhich segment does that 1.5% to 2% apply to, just so I understand?
Ketan Patel
executiveNow, regarding the enterprise business segment—typically for my business, examining things on a gross profit margin basis wouldn't get us very far. We rely on an internal ROCE measure, and when we assess any business, it comes out at 20%.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveAt the moment, return on capital employed for the company sits at roughly 23%.
Ketan Patel
executiveSo anything that can get us a ROCE of around 20% counts as a good business.
Jyoti Singh
analystThese figures are guidance on the gross margin side, not on the EBITDA margin side.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveNope.
Jyoti Singh
analystAnd regarding what we should expect for the EBITDA margin, sir? We've estimated somewhere in the 7% to 8% range.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveToday, yes, we'd want to go from 4.5%, 5% up to nearly 8% — that's 8% to 9% — that's the <<inaudible>>.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our following question comes from Manoj, who is an individual investor.
Speaker
unknownCan everyone hear me?
Ketan Patel
executiveYes, Manoj, we can hear you.
Speaker
unknownTo start, congratulations on a really great set of numbers. So I just wanted to ask: if we take out the other income from the sale of the Ckart, then our profit margin would come in lower. So what levels of EBITDA margin would you consider sustainable?
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveOkay, Manoj, so as I mentioned, at the consolidated level we reported a PAT margin of 2.82%, and an EBITDA margin of 4%. If you take out the post-tax effect of the profit coming from Ckart, then your margin as a percentage — the consolidated margin as a percentage — comes to 2.36%, okay? And EBITDA wouldn't drop that sharply. So it would be roughly 3.6%, 3.7%. So my point there is that we're aiming to take this EBITDA up to nearly 7%, 8%, 8% or higher, and PAT from the 2.36% level to 4.5%, 5%, yes. That has been the aspiration. So what you need to remove is this INR 7.71 crores from the EBITDA impact, yes, to arrive at that figure.
Speaker
unknownOkay, that's fair. Sir, my final question concerned the rationale for the share swap agreement that raises our stake in Secure Connection Limited — if you could address that, it would be great.
Ketan Patel
executiveIn Secure Connection, we had an investor who came in early in that area. And when we consolidate, obviously the minority share would come out, correct? And it wasn't bringing him any value, plus it wasn't a tangible holding for him — that was the situation.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveSee, what actually happens in a closely held company or a private limited company is that if it is not listed, providing an exit to a shareholder becomes very difficult. You will appreciate, right? So this person saw an opportunity, and he got, I think, 2, 2.5x his investment overall in 4, 4.5 years. He saw an opportunity — please appreciate, our entire Honeywell business, okay, which is profitable business, <<inaudible>> wherein our subsidiary, Secure Connections Limited Hong Kong, yes? So any improvement in the holding by Creative Newtech Limited will flow more money to the consolidation and ultimately to the shareholders. Do you agree?
Speaker
unknownYes.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveSo here's what we did: we structured our investment in phases — three tranches was the plan, though in the end it came to two. Getting the investors, the existing ones, on board was a herculean task, and we completed it across two tranches. So we moved our stake from 52.5% up to 77.5%, if I recall correctly. As a result, just two shareholders remain now — one is <<inaudible>> and the other is Mohit Anand.
Operator
operatorOur next follow-up question comes from Akash Jain at GT Financial Services.
Akash Jain
analystCan everyone hear me?
Ketan Patel
executiveYes, Akash, we can hear you now.
Akash Jain
analystSir, our other income did go up thanks to the Ckart sale, but total income for the quarter still dropped by roughly 28%. So what caused that?
Ketan Patel
executiveYou mean the top line?
Akash Jain
analystCorrect, sir — we're talking about total income, aren't we?
Ketan Patel
executiveWhen you refer to income, do you mean turnover or profit?
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveThere are 2 parts to total income. First is sales — revenue from operations — and the second is other income. So the growth in revenue, okay, has been — I'm referring to consolidated numbers — and revenue growth from operations went from INR 1,376 crores to INR 1,713 crores, all right? Other income, as you'd expect, rose from INR 9.49 crores to INR 23.28 crores. If you set aside close to INR 10 crores of that, okay, then other income here comes to INR 9.49 crores, and it's 10-point something, INR 10.28 crores, roughly, yes. What has declined within other income from operations, if you'd like to check, is the export incentive — income from export incentive. Last year, there was income on export incentive of INR 16.53 crores. This year, it is INR 7.5 lakhs — sorry, INR 7.5 crores, my apologies — INR 16.53 crores to INR 7.5 crores. Why has it dropped despite our turnover in enterprise business exports increasing? The reason is that the incentive calculation structure has changed. It is ad valorem now, and previously it was worked out on a per piece basis. So I — if I export something, I used to receive the per piece export incentive.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveWith ad valorem, we’re aware that the rates are lower, which means the incentive calculation for us has come down. So does that answer your question?
Akash Jain
analystYes, sir. And what was it that caused EB's revenues to fall so significantly?
Ketan Patel
executiveEB is a highly opportunistic business, you know. If we can't achieve a 20% ROCE, we simply won't pursue that work, since our capital is limited and we'd rather direct it toward high-margin business. During JFM, traction across the EB business was weaker overall and we weren't able to hit the ROCE, so we chose not to go after that business. That's the only situation. And broadly, since that business carries a gross margin of between 1.5% and 2%, we only take it on when it's an opportunistic opportunity.
Akash Jain
analystAll right, and sir, my final question is this: it appears that pTron — pTron looks like a brand with high volume and low margins.
Ketan Patel
executiveThat's right.
Akash Jain
analystSo what kind of effect is that going to have on our revenue and on our margins?
Ketan Patel
executiveWith pTron, we already have a committed margin in the double digits — it sits between 10% and 12%. This is an online-only brand. They're keen to enter the channel. And since they're an Indian company, the supply chain overall is much shorter. So in pTron, we believe our ROCE will come in close to 32%, 33%. That makes it a good business to be in, provided we can push higher volumes. So our view on pTron is that if we can hit INR 30 crores in the first year and INR 100 crores the following year, it's a good business to be in.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveAbsolutely. Absolutely. And we've only just begun with pTron. Things need time to settle down. But that's our aspiration.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, we'll treat this as the final question. At this point I'm handing the conference over to Mr. Ketan Patel, Chairman and Managing Director of Creative Newtech Limited, for closing remarks.
Ketan Patel
executiveThanks again, everyone, for joining us on this quarter 4 and FY '24 earnings call. Should you have any additional questions, you can reach out to Adfactors PR, or you're welcome to contact us directly. We look forward to connecting with you again next quarter. Many thanks.
Abhijit Kanvinde
executiveThanks a lot. Appreciate it.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it. Speaking for Creative Newtech Limited, that brings this conference to a close. Thanks for being with us — you can go ahead and disconnect your lines now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Creative Newtech Limited transcript — plus 133,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Creative Newtech Limited earnings transcripts and 133,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Creative Newtech Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.