Direct Line Insurance Group plc (DLG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
December 23, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Amanda Blanc
executiveGood morning, everyone. Thank you for joining us at such short notice, especially at this time of year. We're delighted to have released the 2.7 Announcement this morning, formalizing our recommended offer for the acquisition of Direct Line Group, or DLG. And I'd like to thank the DLG Board for their engagement over the last few weeks. Today's presentation will include the key aspects of the announcement. I'll start with the highlights of the transaction. Jason and Owen will talk through the opportunity for U.K. Personal Lines, and Charlotte will then cover the details of our offer and financials, and there will be plenty of time for Q&A. Let me start with today's key messages. Over the last 4 years, we've transformed Aviva into a high-performing business with a consistent customer-centric strategy and real performance momentum. And we are excited about the opportunity that DLG presents to accelerate this momentum and deliver enhanced shareholder distributions. There's a compelling strategic case for this transaction as we create a leader in U.K. Personal Lines and accelerate our capital-light growth. And the financial case is just as strong, supported by GBP 125 million in cost synergies, which we anticipate will deliver 10% run rate EPS accretion and material capital benefits over time. Most importantly, we have confidence in our ability to execute and unlock the full potential of a combined Aviva and DLG. Aviva is a very different business today to the one I inherited. We've achieved a huge amount and established ourselves as the U.K.'s leading diversified insurer across Insurance, Wealth and Retirement. Our performance for customers and shareholders is testament to that. Quarter after quarter, we've proven that we can deliver. We have big ambitions for Aviva's future with no shortage of growth opportunities. And the acquisition of DLG further accelerates our trajectory. Now moving on to the transaction itself. Our offer values DLG at GBP 3.7 billion, and I'm pleased to say that this offer has been recommended by the DLG Board. For DLG shareholders, it represents a significant premium to the share price. With a balanced mix of financing, it will deliver meaningful cash consideration upfront. It will also allow them to participate in upside through Aviva shares. The benefits are just as attractive for Aviva shareholders, creating value from the start and enabling greater capacity for distributions. And this value creation is underpinned by a strong rationale. We are creating a leader in U.K. Personal Lines, powering our capital-light growth and expanding both our customer base and what we can do for them in line with Aviva's strategy. Together, we can accelerate DLG's plans, delivering GBP 125 million in cost synergies. That is over and above DLG's existing commitment for GBP 100 million in cost savings. We will also unlock material capital benefits over time. The transaction is consistent with our capital management framework and disciplined M&A criteria and ensures that we maintain financial strength. I am really excited about what DLG will bring to Aviva and what we can achieve together. This is truly a win-win for both Aviva and DLG customers and shareholders. So let me elaborate on these points, starting with the strategic rationale. As I've said, bringing together Aviva and DLG will establish a leader in U.K. Personal Lines with over 18 million policies in force. All customers will benefit from our increased scale and strength, be it competitive pricing, faster claims and stronger supply chains or more products and services. We will have an even more impressive portfolio of brands, including Direct Line and Churchill and attractive new products like Rescue and Pet. We will be able to engage with more customers directly through the retail distribution channels. And with greater operational scale, we will drive further efficiency gains for our customers. Beyond this, our priority will be to deliver the best of Aviva to all customers from our digital offering with the next-generation MyAviva app to a broader suite of products and services across Insurance, Wealth and Retirement. Moving now to the impact on our capital-light portfolio, which, as you know, is a core element of Aviva's strategy. This is important because it allows us to deliver more growth and higher returns for shareholders by investing to accelerate in these businesses. Our U.K. GI business had a Solvency II ROE of 22% at half year '24, and this transaction will drive further improvement here. We're already making great progress here organically. We are majority capital-light today, and we'll be approaching 70% in 2026 with our current plans. And with this transaction, we will be able to go much further in changing our earnings mix as we deliver synergies. Turning now to why we have confidence that we can successfully integrate these businesses. We have all the right ingredients. We built a track record on M&A, managing multiple disposals in quick succession and enhancing our capabilities and scale through a series of strategic bolt-ons. Our performance has been consistently strong. We've been beating our targets, including delivering over GBP 750 million cost reduction one year early. Our Personal Lines team, led by Owen, has proven that they can deliver impressive performance in challenging market conditions. Importantly, the integration will be contained within this business, supported by dedicated resources. And we've been improving customer experience with our transactional Net Promoter Score up 5 points this year alone. A large part of this is due to our fantastic and highly engaged colleagues and their relentless focus on customers. We know DLG's colleagues share this customer focus, and we're looking forward to welcoming them into the group. I am excited by this deal and committed to delivering great outcomes for customers and shareholders. To conclude, I'd like to further reinforce our commitment to deliver superior returns to shareholders. As you've seen, our track record here is rock solid. We've always had a very high bar for M&A, and we've been disciplined with this transaction to ensure it creates value for all shareholders and maintains Aviva's financial strength. On day 1, we'll operate at the upper end of our working range on cover ratio before any synergies, and we'll remain near our guidance on debt leverage. Over time, this transaction will allow us to enhance our dividend policy and unlock greater capacity for shareholder distributions. We expect to rebase the dividend per share upwards and resume capital distributions at higher levels. Charlotte will provide more detail on this later. I'll now hand over to Jason and Owen to talk more about the opportunity. Over to you, Jason.
Jason Storah
executiveThanks, and good morning, everyone. As Amanda said, we have a fantastic opportunity here. I'm very excited about the capabilities that DLG brings from established brands to distribution strength in retail, complementary product offerings, customers and of course, the fantastic talent in DLG's colleagues. And I'm equally excited about the performance improvement potential that we can deliver together. We will accelerate DLG's strategic plans and go further to deliver greater efficiency gains from and upside from increased operational scale combined with our technical capabilities, pricing sophistication and underwriting discipline. With the balance sheet strength of Aviva, we'll be able to invest in the business to accelerate growth. And we're building on very solid foundations in our Personal Lines business. We have excellent technical bench strength and the numbers over the last 3 years highlight just how strong the team is. We're delivering significant growth in premiums, tracking at over 20% per annum, and that's largely been driven by the attractive retail segment, which has grown by 43% year-on-year, but this growth hasn't just been driven by inflation. We've added over 1 million customers in less than 2 years with double-digit growth in retail motor policies this year alone. Through all of this, we've been highly disciplined in underwriting, maintaining our combined ratio around the 96% mark throughout the market cycle and continuing to improve expense ratios. And this means that we've now met or exceeded all of the 2024 ambitions that we set for ourselves at the Personal Lines focus in January 2023. I am really proud of Owen and the team who have driven the impressive transformation of this business over the last 4 years. They've successfully navigated challenging market environments and delivered strong profitable growth right through COVID and periods of high inflation where others have struggled. We've transformed our customer claims journey and leveraged the benefits of auto repair capabilities in-house with Solus. And this has resulted in a material uplift to our Net Promoter Scores. They've integrated multiple acquisitions across high net worth and home and launched new partnerships with major banks. They've successfully put Aviva on price comparison websites, shifting our distribution to now majority retail. And they've built Aviva Zero, our fastest-growing PCW proposition from the ground up in just 6 months, and we've now sold over 1 million policies since launch. They've established leading data, AI and now Gen AI capabilities. And their list of achievements just goes on. So I know this is the right team to invest behind, and I'll now pass to Owen to share some details on the benefits of this deal.
Owen Morris
executiveThanks, Jason, and good morning, everyone. The acquisition of DLG would expand our opportunity in what is an attractive market for Aviva, and I'd like to start there. The U.K. P&C market is one of the largest in Europe, and it's growing. That in itself already presents a clear organic growth opportunity for Aviva, and we've proven that with our underwriting discipline, pricing sophistication and claims capabilities, it is a profitable one. And with DLG, we'll be able to respond more effectively to the structural trends and challenges of this market, whether that's strong competition across a fragmented landscape, the scale of PCWs or the need to continue investing behind brand, technical capabilities and regulatory compliance. And importantly, we will be able to deliver better outcomes for our customers. As Jason said, the benefits of this transaction will come from the highly complementary nature of our businesses. Let me bring this to life for you with just a few examples. DLG's brands will extend our reach with customers. For example, the addition of Direct Line to Aviva's brands will boost our presence across retail channels, and Churchill will strengthen our position in lower-cost segments. As well as enhancing existing lines, DLG will bring new products and accelerate our progress in SME direct. We have already seen a material uplift in our Net Promoter Scores and optimizing our Solus auto repair capabilities with DLG Auto Services and Green Flag Roadside Assistance will further transform clients journeys. Our combined distribution mix will shift by nearly 20 percentage points towards retail across PCWs and direct. This is really important because it enables us to engage directly with customers. And as you can see, it is a more profitable and growing segment of the market. And finally, we'll have a much greater opportunity with our collective customer base. All customers will benefit from our increased scale and strength, be it competitive pricing, faster claims and stronger supply chains or more products and services. They will have access to fantastic Aviva customer capabilities like our next-generation MyAviva app, which Cheryl took you through at the recent Customer In Focus session and so much more that only Aviva can do. So hopefully, you share our excitement on what we can deliver for our customers and shareholders as a combined group. I'll now hand over to Charlotte.
Charlotte Jones
executiveThanks, Owen, and good morning, everyone. I'm very pleased to discuss today's fantastic news. This is a great deal for Aviva and for Direct Line. We are really excited about the opportunities for the combined group to accelerate our growth momentum. The transaction represents an excellent strategic fit, as you've already heard, and it offers a really compelling financial rationale, about which I'm delighted to share more details. I'll start by covering the key terms of the recommended offer. The offer is for 270p per share with dividends payable to DLG shareholders of up to 5p. The transaction will deliver material capital synergies and GBP 125 million of incremental run rate cost savings, which will be embedded over 3 years from closing. We expect the transaction will be EPS accretive in the first full year post-completion, including the impact of restructuring costs and deliver around 10% EPS accretion on a run rate basis. This enables us to increase shareholder distributions through an upgraded dividend policy. We anticipate the transaction will close around the middle of next year, following the completion of required shareholder and regulatory approvals. I'll now unpack the financials a little further. The recommended offer price values the group at GBP 3.7 billion and means Direct Line shareholders will own about 12.5% of the enlarged group. We believe the transaction is highly attractive for DLG shareholders, offering a 73% premium to the undisturbed price, with consideration evenly split between cash and newly issued Aviva shares. The equity component enables DLG shareholders to participate in the future value upside from holding Aviva shares, not otherwise available on a stand-alone basis. The cash component of GBP 1.75 billion will be funded entirely through internally available resources. The transaction will also deliver material upside for Aviva's shareholders with significant cost synergies leading to around 10% run rate EPS accretion, substantial capital synergies and growing distributions. I'd now walk through -- sorry, I'd now like to talk about the synergies to be unlocked from this transaction. As I said already, we have identified GBP 125 million worth of cost synergies. These are represented in a quantitative financial benefit statement or QFBS. Under the takeover code, the plans that underpin the QFBS have been reviewed and corroborated by our reporting accountants. These synergies are incremental to the GBP 100 million of cost savings already identified by Direct Line, meaning total savings of at least GBP 225 million compared with their 2023 cost base. Broadly, the incremental synergies split into three categories. Firstly, head office and central functions. This is the biggest component of the synergies and includes removal of plc and shared services and de-duplication of management roles. Secondly, insurance operations, where we will see benefit from increased efficiency and scale of bringing the groups together. And thirdly, IT and systems, where we will consolidate certain IT platforms. We expect integration costs of around GBP 250 million to achieve these savings. These will be substantially incurred in the first 2 years. And we anticipate the savings to be fully embedded 3 years after closing and delivered broadly evenly in each of the 3 years. And it's not just significant cost synergies. The transaction is compelling from a capital perspective as well. We have a robust capital management framework with which this transaction is consistent, and it is a testament to the financial strength of the group that at completion, the pro forma cover ratio remains at the top end of our 160% to 180% working range after absorbing a transaction of this scale. And this impact at completion reflects the mechanical calculation of bringing two balance sheets together. That means it doesn't include the impact of any of the capital synergies, which will materialize over time. Let me explain what these are. Combining Direct Line's GBP 1.1 billion solvency capital requirement, or SCR, with Aviva's provides diversification benefit in two ways. Firstly, today, the diversification benefits from the mix of risks in our broad U.K. General Insurance business are substantial in the calculation of the U.K. GI SCR. Therefore, bringing Direct Line's largely Personal Lines business into our broader U.K. GI business will create a significant diversification benefit to the stand-alone capital requirement of Direct Line. This will appear at the U.K. GI level. Secondly, at the Aviva Group level, our complementary portfolio means there is substantial diversification benefit within the group SCR. You may recall in our disclosures at the half year, we reported GBP 2.3 billion of diversification to bring the capital requirement down to GBP 7.8 billion for the group. This arises because of the non-life risks and geographic mix diversifying well with the life risks. Therefore, the additional non-life risk coming from combining Direct Line will increase this group diversification benefit. It represents a further material capital benefit when compared with a stand-alone DLG capital requirement. So bringing these two together, the capital benefit from diversification that will emerge is significant. Next, let me turn to leverage and liquidity. We expect a limited impact to leverage from the transaction, principally because we are funding the cash component from internal resources. Our current leverage ratio is 29%. And whilst we anticipate a small uptick to around 31% to 32% upon completion, it will return back to below 30% over time. This is in line with our existing leverage guidance that we aim to be under 30%, but are happy to operate slightly above 30% for short periods. We also expect central liquidity to remain above GBP 1 billion post completion, in line with our capital management framework. Now I will cover what the transaction means for shareholder distributions. We have been growing ordinary dividends over the last few years with the cash cost of the dividend growing annually by around 5%. As well as the dividend cash cost growth, we have had a regular cadence of returns of capital to shareholders, having done GBP 300 million of share buybacks in each of the last 2 years. In combination, these have given DPS growth of around 7%. Now we remain committed to growing dividends and sustainable returns of capital. And I'm pleased to say that the strong financial benefits to be delivered from this transaction enabled us to take this one step further to raise dividends and increase buybacks. Let me explain. Now given the capital and cash generated from the acquisition, we expect to declare a mid-single-digit dividend per share uplift following completion. This will be applied to the higher share count. Our guidance of mid-single-digit growth in the cash cost of the dividend then continues, but from this uplifted level. As the cash component of the transaction will be funded from internal resources, we don't expect to announce another GBP 300 million buyback when we report our full year 2024 results at the end of February. This represents a pause in our regular buyback program, but we maintain the guidance for regular and sustainable returns of capital and anticipate these will resume alongside our full year '25 results in '26. And going forward, the level of buybacks will allow for the increased share count arising from the transaction to maintain the DPS growth. There's a slide in the appendix that helps to illustrate this. That covers all the financials. I will briefly cover the key points on time line before finishing. Now that the transaction has been announced, we will proceed with the publication of the Direct Line Scheme Document. This contains all the information DLG shareholders need in order to vote and will be available shortly after we publish our full year '24 results. Aviva and Direct Line will publish their full year '24 results in February and March, respectively, and we expect the Direct Line shareholders to vote on the transaction in March. There is no required vote from Aviva shareholders. Finally, we anticipate the transaction will close around the middle of 2025, following receipt of all the required regulatory approvals. And with that, I'll hand back to Amanda for closing remarks.
Amanda Blanc
executiveThanks, Charlotte. So before moving on to Q&A, let me share some final reflections. Over the last 4 years, we've transformed the performance of Aviva and proven our ability to deliver quarter after quarter. Now is the right time to accelerate with M&A. And with DLG, we have a fantastic opportunity to do just that. As a result, Aviva's investment case will become even more attractive as we unlock the full potential of the combined group. We will improve our position as the U.K.'s leading diversified insurer with a steeper capital-light trajectory. We will bring the best of Aviva to even more customers. We will step change already strong organic growth, extending our track record of delivery. And by doing so, we will enhance our capacity to deliver shareholder distributions. So I'm sure that you can see why Charlotte, Jason, Owen and myself and the rest of the team are confident about this transaction and excited to welcome DLG customers and colleagues to Aviva. So we're going to move to Q&A now.
Amanda Blanc
executiveFor those of you on the call, you will have been sent details on how the Q&A is going to work by the IR team earlier. So please raise your hand in the meeting or send an e-mail and we will get to you. [Operator Instructions] So the first question is from Andy Sinclair of Bank of America.
Andrew Sinclair
analystWell done, a lovely deal and well done, especially getting it done just before Christmas. Three for me, please. First was just on the cash. Nice to see lots of cash being upstreamed from the subsidiaries or part of the subsidiaries to fund this deal. Just to understand, after the deal, will there be a desire to rebuild that flexibility within the subsidiaries? Or is that really just kind of extra fat that was sitting in there that's not going to be needed so we can keep those subsidiaries at slightly thinner levels? That's question one. Question two was just on the reinsurance agreements within Direct Line, how that differs from Aviva. I realize no numbers on that today, but just qualitatively, how do you think about those opportunities going forward? And third was just about the enlarged group's bargaining power for acquisition costs, just how -- when you are engaging with PCWs with other distributors that you use, you have a pretty sizable market share. Anything allowed for in terms of negotiating power going forward or anything you consider that in the future?
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. Thank you. Charlotte, do you want to pick up the first two and maybe Jason and Owen, the second -- the third?
Charlotte Jones
executiveYes. So thanks, Andy. I mean I think on the cash, the management of cash across the group is something that we spend a lot of time on and have some flexibility. So we will be upstreaming the cash into the center. And then the objective will be to maintain about GBP 1 billion of cash centrally, and that's all consistent with the capital management framework. If you remember at Q3, we said that we had about GBP 1.7 billion at the center at that time. And it's always a little bit dynamic, reflecting the timing of remittances from the business, the timing of external dividends and when we're paying debt. And that is the flexibility we have. So we will be pulling that up, and it will -- we've got a plan to do that. I think the important thing to remember is that this transaction itself is very cash and capital generative. So that in itself will do quite a lot of the rebuilding over time. On reinsurance, I'm not really going to talk specifically on that today. We would, of course, be running the two companies independently through this reinsurance renewal round in January. I think once we get through to completion, we will look at the two together. Obviously, through the due diligence process, we've had line of sight of the reinsurance, and we're comfortable with that. Jason?
Jason Storah
executiveGreat. So I mean, just on bargaining power, I think what you're getting at is the broader scale synergies and data that we're going to have to be able to benefit from going forward. So I mean, a few obvious examples. I'll let Owen talk about PCWs, but the obvious space to talk about is claims between our Solus network and DLG's repair network, the additional scale and capability that's going to give us. I think we really look forward to that. Similarly, there's a lot of overlap between DLG's claims providers and our claims providers. And again, just expanding our relationship with those key claims providers and looking at what that means going forward, we think there's lots of upside. But Owen, just on PCWs or anything else?
Owen Morris
executiveYes. Look, we have an excellent relationship with PCWs, and we work really well with them and have done for a good number of years. And we look forward to working with them in that in large context. And I think just expanding that point more generally, I think, look, this is great opportunity for us to be more efficient for customers. And I think that's what I'd come back to. I think this deal gives us a great opportunity to do that.
Amanda Blanc
executiveSo the next question is from Dom from BNP.
Dominic O''mahony
analystAmanda. Congratulations from me also to you and all your colleagues. Three questions as well, if that's okay. Firstly, just on the baseline for the financials. You've given us this 10% EPS accretion figure, which is very helpful. I think on my sort of back of the envelope, this implies a baseline for the stand-alone Direct Line roughly in line with the 13% margin ambition and obviously, your incremental synergies on top of that. Is that a fair assessment of how you're projecting the financials forward? Second question is just coming back to the synergies. Clearly, at this stage, you're not yet quantified revenue or capital synergies. Charlotte, your explanation of the SCR synergy is super helpful. I wonder if you could qualitatively give a view of some of the things on both the operating revenue side and on the capital, perhaps the own funds things that you can do? And if I can just ask an adjacent question to that. It looks from your slide that you're expecting capital synergies to improve leverage. So does that imply that you've got own fund synergies in there? And then the third question, was really just on the reserving. My guess is that, that was one of the areas of focus for your due diligence. Given inflation impacts over the last year or so, reserve additions have been an important topic for the sector. Did you observe any areas of weakness? Conversely, put it completely the other way around, Aviva reserves, I think, at a relatively strict best estimate level. So is there any implicit prudence in the Direct Line balance sheet that can be released.
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. Thank you. Those feel like three questions for the CFO.
Charlotte Jones
executiveExcellent. Thanks, Dom. Look, I think in terms of the baselines for the -- around 10% EPS accretion, I mean, I think you won't expect me to give any new profit forecast on this call. But obviously, anything that's sort of factoring in direct lines projections is consistent with consensus because if it wasn't, then we would have to explain. So I think you can assume that that's the way we've constructed. And the EPS accretion of 10% is following the GBP 125 million of expenses being realized. So that's kind of over that 3 years. So it's sort of 2028 beyond when that 10% accretion comes through. But there would be accretion we see even in the first year following the transaction close. In terms of synergies, not yet quantified. As you say, I've tried to give as much guidance as I can on how we see the capital synergies coming through. The other areas would be in reinsurance. There would be some revenue areas and other things like that, that we can't factor in things to do with claims costs. All of those are not quantified, but they're certainly in mind. And they are the sort of things that as we step into the integration, we'll be able to talk more about. In terms of leverage, I think your question was around we move above the 30% in the first instance and then expect it to be able to come down. Because we are funding this entirely from internal resources, the step-up in leverage is really coming from the GBP 610 million of debt that DLG has that doesn't count for solvency, but of course, it does contribute to leverage. We will -- we have flexibility in our debt plans over the next few years. And of course, this transaction is capital and cash generative. So the combination of those 2 give us a clear line of sight to getting below 30%. And then on reserving was your last question. I mean, really, there's very little I can say. This was a deal done in the public markets under the regulations of the takeover code. Obviously, we operate in some of the same markets as DLG as a PLP. And so we have a good idea of how they operate outside-in. So we did a lot of outside-in analysis, and then we did a focused level of due diligence consistent with the takeover code requirements and into the areas that you would expect an insurance company due diligence process would do, and we were granted good access to management to supplement that analysis. But that's all I can really say. Clearly, the pricing and the deal structure today is very similar to what it was before we entered into that due diligence phase. So I think you can read that it was comfortable.
Amanda Blanc
executiveThanks, Charlotte. Thanks, Dom. Rhea from Deutsche Bank.
Rhea Shah
analystCongratulations as well on this deal. So 3 questions for me as well. The first one, if you could just talk a bit about customers. I mean, your tNPS score has increased over the years. But what are you expecting, especially in the first year of integration for this to progress like? And do you have any expectations of attrition to your policies on both books again in the first year? The second question is around technology. So are you planning on putting the DLG brands onto the MyAviva app over time? And then third, around capital. When do you expect to complete the Part VII merger? Will it be in the first 12 months of -- after completion?
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. Thanks. So I'll pick up the first 2, Charlotte, you can pick up the second. And if I miss anything, Owen and Jason, let me know. So on customers, yes, we have seen our tNPS number increase significantly this year. And that has been the investment that we've made into the customer proposition. So putting more people on the phones, building more digital propositions, looking at the claims process to make sure that they are operating well for customers, utilizing the Solus repair network to make sure that we get the customers basically in an Aviva network so that they are actually getting the best possible experience. Obviously, they're also benefiting from the supply chain and the size and scale of Aviva. So -- and we're able to pass some of that on through pricing. And in the -- if you look at our efficiency ratio, we've managed to continue to improve the efficiency ratio. So we actually see that this is really, really good news for both sets of customers because we'll be able to continue to invest in the business and continue to deliver on all of those great claims process, great digital processes and people in contact centers. But we'll also, through scale, be able to pass on some of that benefit through -- whether it's through the pricing and through the indemnity spend. So we are really, really excited about that benefit to our customers. And that's before we even get into offering customers all the other opportunities that Aviva has, whether that's the wealth products, the travel products, home products, whatever it is. So we feel really good about that. On technology, integration into the MyAviva app, and it's good that we don't have the Chief Technology Officer in the room, is relatively straightforward because it's through an API integration. And obviously, the app has been rebuilt this year. And the app is performing incredibly well. If we look at our online experience scores in the app, they're significantly higher than they were in the old MyAviva app. And when we rebuilt the app into this new technology platform, it is much easier to integrate APIs from other areas. So that we believe that, that is a reasonably quick win opportunity for us to be able to do that. And of course, it also means that any investment that Direct Line might have had to build an app would not now need to be made because they can take advantage of the MyAviva app. On capital, Charlotte?
Charlotte Jones
executiveYes. So on capital, as you -- as I've said and as you've repeated, we -- the capital synergies are not going to accrue on day 1 following completion. That is just the mechanical bringing together of the 2 balance sheets. And the time line from then is -- I can't be incredibly specific, but we have a successful track record of doing things like this. We need reg approvals on certain aspects. And as you say, there'll be a Part VII to do as well. So the mechanisms are a Part VII, as you rightly say, which is the legal transfer of policies. We would expect that to be 18 months or some sort of time frame around that, but it's, again, difficult to tell. Naturally, as the policies come up for renewal, they're likely to be renewed within Aviva rather than DLG. So you'll sort of start to see more of the policies coming on to our balance sheet. And then we can undertake reinsurance arrangements where DLG transfers some of the obligation risk from its policies to Aviva. But again, some regulatory hurdles to get through there. So it will be over time, but we have a decent line of sight. We know what the work package looks to do, and we're confident that it will deliver.
Amanda Blanc
executiveAndrew Crean from Autonomous. Andrew, are you there? Okay. We'll come back to Andrew. So you can tell that we're live, you see this is how it works. So William Hawkins from KBW.
William Hawkins
analystCan you hear me?
Amanda Blanc
executiveYes, we can.
William Hawkins
analystAn exciting transaction. Congratulations. On Slide 22, please, what are the addressable costs from which you're reducing the incremental GBP 125 million, please? And where might you go further? I mean it just seems to me that the GBP 40 million and the GBP 25 million in particular seem very small given that there's massive overlap. And I think it's implying that there's still GBP 400 million of costs from DLG that you won't be addressing. So I'm just trying to understand what's sticky in the cost base that leads to actually quite -- what seems to be limited synergies against the massive overlap you're talking about? And then the second question, again, this has already been touched on briefly, please. But is there any risk of revenue dis-synergies from this? Again, I'm really not sure in the Personal Lines market. I can imagine that each individual customer doesn't sort of focus on moving when 2 portfolios come together. On the other hand, presumably, this transaction could lead to an awful lot of market competition. And as you step up, you could suffer from that. So what thoughts have you given to revenue dis-synergies from the combination? I'm so sorry, I'm going to add a third. Are there any regulatory issues that we need to be aware of that are substantial in this transaction? Again, I haven't seen any reference, but I don't know any large portfolios you need to address or whatever to satisfy the interest of other stakeholders.
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. Thank you. It wouldn't be a question if there weren't 3 questions. So Charlotte, if you do one. Owen, do you mind doing 2, and I'll pick up 3?
Charlotte Jones
executiveYes, that's fine. So look, I think what I was trying to say or was articulating when I sort of set out the GBP 125 million of cost synergies is that has been through the review and corroboration process by the reporting accountants that requires, therefore, evidence and track record. So read into that what you will, but that is the basis on which the number is compiled and relatively short period of time of due diligence that was able in order to support that. So I think that's the first thing to mention. I think in terms of the addressable cost base, at the Capital Markets Day in the summer, DLG disclosed an addressable cost base of around GBP 650 million. But there have been various moving parts since then, given the inflationary environment and their own cost program of GBP 100 million. But I think if you think of it, it's sort of in the 20% range. And then I think I would just say that there are other potential value levers within and beyond the cost base that we haven't quantified at the moment.
Owen Morris
executiveYes. So in terms of dis-synergies, I tend to think about them actually as synergies. So if we think about trading each of the brands, which we certainly intend to trade very hard, Direct Line and [indiscernible] and Aviva and all of those, the brand suite, you think about that and then you think about, well, if we add in some of those extra capabilities around pricing and claims that we can get from the sort of shared data and shared capabilities. And then on top of that, think about the shared sort of 18 million to 20 million customers that we can then market more products to. I think actually, there's a real prospect of some improved synergies. But look, we need to work that through as we get into it. But yes, I'm more thinking synergies rather than dis-synergies if you think about it in that context.
Amanda Blanc
executiveThanks, Owen. And on the regulatory side, so as you would expect, we've notified the relevant regulators, which includes the PRA, the FCA ahead of the approach, and we continue to have an open and constructive dialogue with them, and we'll keep you updated as we go along on that. We expect the Competition and Markets Authority will review the transaction. You would expect that from a deal of this size, but we remain confident that we can get this deal done. We're going to try Andrew CreanCrean again. Andrew? Can you hear me? No, no. I'm confident it's going to be third time lucky for Andrew. So in the absence of Andrew, we're going to go to Farooq.
Farooq Hanif
analystHappy holidays and Merry Christmas to everybody. So as you'd expect, 3 questions, hopefully, not too long. One of the things that you said in your customer session, Amanda, was that it's easier to cross-sell to a non-life customer than to a life customer. Can you talk about your thoughts around the DLG customer base and what you can do to get the kind of average holdings up to the sort of level that you've seen for the rest of the platform and just kind of the time line around how you're going to do that? Second question is to go back to the GBP 2.3 billion of diversification benefit. Just to help us all out, what percentage is that of the -- sorry, undiversified group SCR roughly, so we can sort of have a go at maybe applying that? And then the third question is really around pricing. When you looked at your technical capabilities, and then you said you're aware of how DLG is approaching it in the market, is the implication here that basically everything is going to go on to your pricing platform as soon as possible? Or do you think there are kind of advantages that you can gain from DLG's technology and pricing that will sort of make 2 plus 2 equals 5 when you put them together?
Amanda Blanc
executiveYes. Okay. Thanks. So I'll pick up the first one, Charlotte, the second one and Owen, do you want to pick up the pricing one. So obviously, if you go back to our customer Infocus session, which we did in October, we talked there about the mechanisms that we've set up -- well, first of all, the 40% of our existing new business sales come from existing customers, so our current new business sales from existing customers. So we start from a very, very strong position there. And we would seek to replicate clearly any techniques that we've used in our own book to be able to do that. But I think we also said in October that we were at the very start of that, and there's plenty more opportunity for us to go there. So I do think that there will be an opportunity for us to be able to look at -- even giving the DLG customer base access to the MyAviva app means that they get to see the breadth of what Aviva has to offer, but also the opportunity for us to talk to customers about prevention to be able to handle claims, those sort of things increasing customer loyalty that you don't have if you just -- sort of only have really a sort of monoline proposition. So nothing is obviously built into these numbers for any opportunity that comes from that, Farooq, but we do genuinely see that as being very compelling as we look to the future. The other thing, obviously, since we spoke in October, we talked about having a single view of customer, and we've been able to implement that in Aviva, and we would be looking to bring all of that benefit to this new customer book. So we genuinely feel that this is actually really, really good news for customers, both in terms of the efficiency of the operation that's delivering for customers, the pricing sophistication Owen we will talk about in a second, but also the breadth of proposition that customers will have from Aviva. So we're super excited about that. Charlotte on the diversification.
Charlotte Jones
executiveDiversification, yes. So just remember, Farooq, there are 2 stages to the diversification that I was explaining, the piece at the GI level, which is the sort of -- which is the commercial and GCS combined within the Personal Lines. That's not visible in the level of -- that amount of diversification is not visible in the disclosure. The disclosure shows the GBP 2.3 billion, which is the piece at the group level, which is the non-life into the life and the geographic of Canada. That GBP 2.3 billion is included -- so the net effect of including that GBP 2.3 billion at the half year was GBP 7.8 billion. So the gross is GBP 10.1 billion. So it's around 25%, but that is just the group piece, not the bit that's within GI. So when you think about the Direct Line, all Personal Lines, firstly -- and that's -- so it's GBP 1.1 billion is pure Personal Lines. So as it comes into GI, it's now mixing with commercial and GCS. So that's likely to go down from that diversification perspective. And then the fact that our SCR is largely driven by our life risk. So whenever you add more non-life risk, you get a diversification benefit. So even though it will have come down in that first stage from GBP 1.1 billion, what's left is then still a further diversification when you get up to the group level.
Owen Morris
executiveYes. Look, on pricing, it's something we take incredibly seriously and work really hard on. And I think that's both at the sort of technical machine learning optimization type level. It's across press release classes with things like traffic density modeling, windstorm modeling. And then it goes up to sort of portfolio level tracking and making sure that we're getting our rating at the right strength. And finally, I guess, the last bit that we've done pretty well over the years is just have that senior view that says what actually is happening a little bit further out, things like inflation and just making sure that we steer the ship well. And I think when you put those things together and then you look at what DLG are good at, which is a lot of things. They've got a very good data set, some very competent people in some of their teams. Look, when we bring that together, do I think we can get 2 plus 2 is 5? Yes, for sure.
Amanda Blanc
executiveNasib from UBS. Can you hear me, Nasib?
Nasib Ahmed
analystCan you hear me?
Amanda Blanc
executiveYes, we can.
Nasib Ahmed
analystI also got 2 questions, just the benefit of being one of the last ones. Firstly, on kind of a follow-up from Farooq's question. UKGI, I think you did an Infocus Day a couple of years back, and you had a number more than 50%. Is that the number that we can kind of benchmark against for Direct Line? I appreciate margin diversification for every non-life risk added will be less, but is that the right kind of number to look at? Second question on IRR. There's no IRR number in the release today. You've given one for AIG and Probitas in the past. Is this still more like Probitas or AIG from an IRR perspective?
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. Charlotte, would you like to speak of those?
Charlotte Jones
executiveYes. So look, you're right that, that was disclosed back in -- I think it was the Commercial Lines in focus session, and we talked around the 50%. I mean it's -- things have developed and moved on, but it's a reasonable thing to start with. On IRR, we haven't. We've given a lot of other metrics. Look, I would say this is a great deal. It's covered by the takeover code, which restricts a number of the things that we're able to talk about and quantify. Hopefully, you've given -- you've got some clear understanding of how it affects EPS accretion. The costs that we can see real line of sight on have been subject to that review by the reporting accountants and the capital benefits. But it is harder for us to be able to give because of the nature of the takeover code and what we're permitted to do. But I think everything that we've said shows you just how financially compelling this is.
Amanda Blanc
executiveLarissa from Barclays.
Larissa van Deventer
analystCongratulations from my side as well. It's a very nice present to get this close to the end of the year. I was going to go for 2, but let's go 3. [ There is 2 ] question that I was going to ask but maybe 3. So on follow-up of Farooq's question. On the combined ratio, I wouldn't expect you to give any targets today. But in the last 2 years under IFRS 17, your Personal Lines have been more profitable than the Commercial Lines. Is it reasonable to expect that to continue and improve? The second one is on debt covenants. Are there any debt covenants in DLG that will be triggered as a result of the change in control? And the third one in the order of benefits, you've been very clear, thank you on what would drive those. Are there any -- can you -- are you able to speak to the order of benefits as to which ones are likely to happen in year 1 and then which ones are likely to happen later? If you are able to add color, that would be very much appreciated.
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. Thanks, Lisa. Charlotte.
Charlotte Jones
executiveYes, that's fine. So look, I think on combined ratio, we've got the group ambition to be sub 94% in the medium term, and we talk about that on every call. And we're confident that we've got the stand-alone Aviva business would be achieving that ambition over time. As you rightly say, we aren't setting any new ambitions today, but our priority is, as we combine the 2 businesses to continue to improve the core over both businesses. And I suppose things that would be helpful from that with Personal Lines predominant business and in particular, DLG is bringing the focus even more towards the retail business, which typically has a better margin and therefore, would be supportive of an improvement in the core. But ultimately, what is our ambition? It is to be consistently outperforming our peers over the cycle. It's to look at it. The core is always there as a guidance, but ultimately, it's about driving operating profit and all the cash and the capital that a business like this brings. But I think the direction of travel on the core will be helped by this. And in terms of change of control, I mean, all I would say is refer back to the due diligence statements. We've done the due diligence that we've -- that you would expect us to do. It's limited in the -- being under the takeover code, but we're comfortable with what we're seeing. And then in terms of benefits and the timing and the categorization of those, I suppose if you think about the 3 categories, we said that the first category, the head office and central functions, that's probably going to be around 50% of the savings. And it mainly comprises of the deduplication of PLC and head office functions as well as consolidation across a number of central functions. So some of that will come relatively quickly after closing. Some of it will take a little bit longer. We will just be very thoughtful on our integration planning and working that through. When I think about the insurance operations, which is around 30% of the savings, that's claims handling, it's operation and trading. We will need to again be careful on ensuring continuity through beyond the closing of the transaction. But some of that will start to materialize relatively quickly. And then on technology and systems, which is around 20%, the focus there is on the consolidation of the IT systems across back office and support functions as well as consolidating some of the support teams. Whereas broader questions are on technology and front -- the front-end IT and how we're bringing that together on a best of both approach will take longer. So I think it's -- we've -- when we've done the work on timing, it's sort of evenly spread across the 3. Some of it will be more quick to emerge. Some of it will take longer. And I think, for instance, the levers on cost that can be actioned fairly quickly might be some of those things in the head office area, whereas it will take more time to implement changes to IT platforms and do any migrations.
Amanda Blanc
executiveAll right. We're going to try Andrew Crean again. Andrew?
Andrew Crean
analystWell done, well done. Listen, I've got a couple of questions. Firstly, what is your estimate of the market share that you have in motor, home and travel combined? And secondly, I just wanted to get a bit more of a handle on the cost savings. If I take out the headquarters costs of GBP 50 million, the rest of the cost savings are what GBP 65 million? I just want to get a sense of what the combined sort of Personal Lines cost base is because from what I remember, you're at about GBP 350 million in U.K. Personal Lines ex commissions. I don't know how much of the GBP 650 million is in that area. But I just wanted to get a sense of what is the combined Personal Lines cost base, which you're targeting the GBP 65 million cost savings from.
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. Thanks, Andrew. I'll pick up the first one, and Charlotte, if you pick up the second one. So on estimates around market share. So Andrew, you'll remember that I think the last time that we disclosed our market share was at the Infocus session, which was in 2023. And obviously, it may have moved a little bit since then. So at that point, our motor market share was 8% and 12% for home. I actually don't have the travel one here. So -- but we can come back to you on that. So that's where we were at that point.
Charlotte Jones
executiveYes. And look, on the synergies, so yes, 50% of the GBP 125 million is coming from the sort of head office type and the rest is in the other 2 categories. I haven't got a combined PL cost base. In fact, I don't know that we've recently given that because it's sort of combined with the GI. So I haven't got those numbers to hand, Andrew, I'm sorry.
Amanda Blanc
executiveAnd now we're going to Steven Haywood from HSBC.
Steven Haywood
analystJust 2 questions. I see on the Solvency II ratio, the 160% to 180% is going back to your kind of previous target from the sort of around 180%. Obviously, does this give you a bit more flexibility in the deal acquisition? And does it give you sort of more flexibility with interest rates probably coming down next year as well? And the other question is just on Direct Lines management. I wonder if you can say anything about what you're planning to do with Direct Lines management team going forward?
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. I'll pick up the second one. Charlotte, do you want to pick up [ solvency one ]?
Charlotte Jones
executiveYes. So look, our range has always been 160% to 180%, but we've, over recent times, operated above the 180%. But I think the capital management framework, which supports that 160% to 180% goes through extensive stress and scenario testing for different environments. And that is the working range, and it always has been. So for this transaction to -- on day 1, which is just the mechanical bringing together of the balance sheet and none of that diversification benefit showing plus the effect of the Direct Lines debt, which doesn't count as solvency at the group level to remain at the sort of top end of that 160% to 180% range is a testament to the financial strength and resilience of the group. Then I think really important to remember that this transaction will be cash and capital generative. And then those capital synergies that we've spent some time discussing will come through. So I think overall, we're very comfortable with what this does to the balance sheet. And as I said, the 160% to 180% range is supported by extensive stress and scenario testing. So we're very comfortable with it.
Amanda Blanc
executiveAnd on your question around the management team. So first of all, I just want to say that we've been very pleased with the engagement that we've had with the team over the last 2 weeks. And I just want to thank them for the effort that they've made to get us to today's point. So just what can we say that's not been said in the 2.7 statement? I mean, first of all, we massively recognize the talented workforce of DLG, and we know that, that's going to be critical to the success of this acquisition. So bringing together the 2 teams with very strong aligned cultural values, DLG employees will clearly benefit from being part of a larger, more diversified combined group. We see that as really positive for both sets of colleagues. And I've not really got anything more to add on specifics other than that at this point.
Charlotte Jones
executiveLast question...
Amanda Blanc
executiveAnd the last question is from Michael Huttner from Berenberg.
Michael Huttner
analystCongratulations and it's more than [indiscernible] fantastic. I would say amazing deal. Two questions completely outside of the box, I'm afraid. One is Ogden. Can you give us a feel for the numbers? And in particular, sorry, Ogden -- sorry, the Ogden benefit. Does that play a role in funding some of the restructuring costs? Maybe just some feel for how you see that. And then the last one also very out of the box. Amanda, you've done an amazing track record now. I mean, doubly amazing. When is the next deal?
Amanda Blanc
executiveWhat Charlotte think about Ogden, I'll deal with that. I mean like it's the 23rd of December, we've just announced the biggest deal that we've done. I mean, look, I genuinely feel that we've got quite a lot on our plate to make sure that this is a success. We are actually, actually determined that we are going to make this deal a success. We can see a really clear line of sight around the benefits to customers, the benefits to shareholders. And there's a lot of different work streams that we have to deliver on. And I think we've really proven in the last 4 years that we're able to do that. The deals that we've done on AIG and Probitas and Succession have all progressed really well and really been additive to Aviva. Obviously, this is the next level of being additive, and we're just really excited about it. So it is an out-of-the-box question. And look, we are really focused on this. Well, this and obviously our [ turkey dinner ], which is only now like 48 hours away. We definitely -- if we got a Turkey, which is doubtful at this point in time. On Ogden, Charlotte.
Charlotte Jones
executiveOn Ogden, look, I mean, I think, obviously, the change has come through. And I think on our Q3 earnings call, we talked about if Ogden ended up being where we anticipate it will be, which was in line with the other parts of the U.K., which it did, then the number for us in terms of reserve change was GBP 30 million or GBP 40 million. So that's factored into our -- that will be part of our full year '24 numbers. DLG will do the same assessment on theirs, and that will be reflected within their '24 numbers. So it's kind of behind us and done. And compared to the sort of materiality of the numbers that we're really talking about here, it doesn't play a big part.
Amanda Blanc
executiveOkay. So look, I think that is all of the questions. Thank you. I just want to just thank you so much for obviously jumping on a call this morning. I imagine that many of you had your Christmas jumpers on and you were sort of raring to go off somewhere exciting. But we do really, really appreciate your time. We appreciate the questions. Obviously, follow up with the IR team if you have anything more that you would like to ask. And I guess it just leads me to say, have a fantastic Christmas, have a very, very successful 2025, and we very much look forward to speaking to you in the new year. Thank you, everyone.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Direct Line Insurance Group plc transcript — plus 256,000+ transcripts from 12,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Direct Line Insurance Group plc earnings transcripts and 256,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $24.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Direct Line Insurance Group plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.