Dole plc (DOLE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 15, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
James O'Regan
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for being with us on this call covering the fourth quarter and the entire 2021 fiscal year. Here with me today are Rory Byrne, our Chief Executive Officer; Johan Linden, our Chief Operating Officer; and Frank Davis, our Chief Financial Officer. A live webcast of this call is running on our website, and a replay will be accessible once we finish. We'll walk through presentation slides as part of our comments today, and you can find those in the Investor Relations area of the Dole plc site. Be aware that today's comments will contain some forward-looking statements covered by the federal securities safe harbor provisions; they speak only as of the moment they're given, and the company explicitly disclaims any duty to update or revise any forward-looking statements. A variety of factors, including the ones laid out in our SEC filings and news releases, could cause actual results or outcomes to differ materially from what may be expressed or implied. The earnings release, financial report and related materials covering the fourth quarter and full year are posted on our website at doleplc.com/investors. You can also find information about the use of non-GAAP financial measures in the Notes section of that release, which further provides a reconciliation to the most comparable GAAP measures of adjusted EBITDA, adjusted net income, net debt and adjusted earnings per share. The specifics of our statutory forward-looking statements disclaimer appear in our SEC filings and in the presentation slides we'll be discussing today. With all that said, I'm happy to hand today's call over to Rory.
Rory Byrne
executiveI appreciate the chance to speak, James, and I want to welcome everyone who has joined us to go over what we achieved in the fourth quarter and across all of 2021. On this call, I will share some perspective regarding how the business performed throughout 2021, along with what we expect for 2022. Johan is going to provide an operations update, talk about synergies, and offer his thoughts on certain strategic efforts being pursued throughout the group. Then, to wrap up, Frank will walk everyone through the financial review. Our 20-F document, which we will submit to the SEC in due course, includes reported financials for Dole plc, among them the first complete quarter of consolidated financial information. Reported numbers will also be referenced today, though our earnings press release along with our investor presentation also contain pro forma financial information, showing what Dole plc's results would have looked like had the merger, IPO and refinancing all taken place on January 1, 2020; that approach matches the pro forma financial information laid out in the Form F-1 filed with the SEC alongside the IPO. As we mentioned during our first earnings call in December, 2021 represented a transformational year for the group. Slide 6 shows how the transition played out from Total Produce plc to Dole plc following the purchase of the remaining 55% of Dole Food Company. Revenue has grown by more than two times, climbing from $4.3 billion on a reported basis for 2020 up to $9.3 billion on a pro forma basis for 2021. In fresh produce, we are now unmistakably the global leader, with revenue nearly 2x bigger than the next largest player in this category. Adjusted EBITDA has also risen substantially, going from $251.5 million on a reported basis for 2020 to $393.6 million on a pro forma basis for 2021. And lastly, our overall scale and global footprint have expanded considerably, with total assets up 148% from $1.9 billion in 2020 to $4.7 billion in 2021; our strategic asset base now covers more than 114,000 acres of owned land and other land holdings, above 160 distribution and manufacturing facilities, 75 packing houses, 12 cold storage facilities, 5 salad manufacturing plants and 13 vessels. Last July, we completed the IPO of Dole plc successfully, along with a refinancing and syndication of $1.44 billion in new credit facilities. All of the roughly $400 million in net proceeds raised through the IPO went toward strengthening our balance sheet; and the refinancing has produced yearly interest cost savings exceeding $40 million. With a net leverage ratio of 2.87x, which sits under our targeted level of 3, the group is well positioned to deliver long-term sustainable growth. Generating substantial free cash flow is our focus, so we can fund further development of the group and return value to our shareholders. Moving to Slide 7. On a pro forma basis, the group turned in strong results for the full year, with revenue growth of 3.5% and adjusted EBITDA growth of 5.9%, consistent with the guidance we gave during our Q3 earnings call. Our group's results delivered double-digit improvement in adjusted EPS, as adjusted EPS rose 11.8%, moving from $1.33 per share up to $1.49 per share. We're also happy to report a quarterly dividend of $0.08 per share today. For our group, 2021 was an exciting year filled with positives, though it also brought a fair amount of complexity, including the effects of Hurricanes Eta and Iota on Honduras and Guatemala, worldwide supply chain strain, the arrival of meaningful cost inflation, and, to close it out, the product recall along with temporary plant shutdowns in our value-added salads business in December. Against that background, and compared with a strong prior year, we feel very good about the way we steered through these difficulties and about the full year result. The breadth of what we offer in products and services, our extensive geographic reach, and our strategic asset base let us more than counterbalance these difficulties and produce robust full year performance along with earnings growth. We're also extremely lucky to have a committed and resilient workforce across our company, and I want to express my thanks to each of them for their considerable contributions, particularly given the unique conditions created by the COVID-19 pandemic during the last couple of years. Our team excels at reacting to and surmounting obstacles, and our 2021 results clearly confirm this. Our sector has kept expanding, especially in categories where Dole plc holds an established leadership position, including bananas, pineapples and value-added salads; we keep concentrating our efforts on growing our presence in the faster-growing categories, including berries, avocados, exotics and organic produce. Over the last 3 years, every one of these categories has grown more quickly than the industry average; this industry growth stems from the megatrend of health and wellness together with the clear sustainability credentials that fresh produce offers. Consumers increasingly care about their physical and mental well-being; and they are moving toward plant-based, vegetarian and vegan diets as a means of bettering their health and lowering their own carbon footprint; we believe these trends give our company a solid foundation for growth. For the current financial year, our strategic priorities include managing pricing within a complex economic environment, delivering on our integration and synergy goals, actively seeking out value-enhancing M&A opportunities and, of course, rebuilding profitability within the Fresh Vegetables segment. I'll give more detail on these later in the presentation. But for now, I would like to hand you over to Johan for the operational review.
Johan Linden
executiveThanks, Rory, and good morning to all of you. Let's move to Slide 9. As we talked about on our previous call, working with our customers during 2021 to tackle increasing inflation by negotiating higher prices was of essential strategic importance. In Fresh Fruits, we put through price increases in North America during November 2021; and in Europe, we've observed price adjustments since January. We're pleased with the solid performance our Fresh Fruits segment turned in for 2022, but at the same time we're keeping a very close eye on how the conflict in Ukraine is impacting the sector. It remains premature to say how this war might affect our company, though we're monitoring developments closely and keeping in close contact with both our suppliers and our customers so we can work through whatever challenges come up. Our direct exposure is minimal. Also, we have no operations or facilities in either Ukraine or Russia. In Fresh Vegetables, after we raised prices over the summer, the value-added salads recall delayed our plans for a second round of price adjustments. Even so, negotiations are underway right now, and we anticipate those increases will roll out fast. Since the season runs shorter and sourcing locations keep changing, our diversified business sees pricing shift more often. As a result, in 2021, the operating environment proved difficult, yet we found ways to respond to the specific pressures that came up and hold our margins where we wanted them throughout the year. We look for the diversified business to follow a comparable path in 2022. Turning to synergies: we continue to make solid headway on our near-term goals. We have observed a number of recent noteworthy happenings in the key avocado and berry segments, among them stronger cooperation among companies that used to run separately, plus certain focused investments meant to back our expansion strategies; when it comes to bananas, we keep seeing improved teamwork throughout Europe, with wins in how we are building the French market and expansion in our plantain operation. Companywide, we are strengthening our growth — collaboration across the group — and I am glad that this is already delivering gains amid what remains a complicated worldwide logistics landscape. Now on to investments. For the group, 2021 was a pivotal year, featuring multiple major investments that we anticipate will serve as a foundation for the business going forward. During our previous call, we mentioned that we received two new ships, the Dole Aztec and the Dole Maya, last summer. These vessels serve the U.S. Gulf region and their performance has been excellent. For our company, having this full fleet of ships remains hugely important strategically. It shields us from the most severe global supply chain difficulties, since we can control our own schedules and expenses, and it also helps because our commercial cargo operations have expanded—particularly when shipping capacity around the world is tight. Now for an update on production: I'm pleased to report that we completed the replanting of 2,900 acres of bananas in Honduras by the end of 2021. A hurricane had destroyed those acres in the fourth quarter of 2020. That leaves only about 200 acres still needing replanting in 2022 to wrap up our recovery program. Moving fast on that reinvestment mattered a lot, not just for our big workforce in Honduras, but it's also beginning to pay off, with yield bouncing back nicely and cost efficiencies starting to appear in early 2022. That's a key step toward offsetting some of the other cost pressures inflation has brought us. Now to Slide 10. Let me add some detail on the value-added salad recall and the plant suspensions. In December, we shared news of a voluntary recall involving every packet salad produced at our salad facilities in Bessemer City and Yuma, and we shut down operations at those two locations due to a potential Listeria health hazard. As our investigation moved forward, we concluded that the contamination likely originated outside our processing plant — in all probability from a single piece of harvesting equipment that had acquired Listeria from the surrounding natural environment. Because of that finding, we needed to launch another voluntary recall in January, this time for salads that contained items harvested with that equipment. Genetic testing eventually confirmed the harvest equipment was in fact the source, but finishing that testing took time, which forced us to adopt a conservative return-to-operation plan involving test and hold procedures on finished products. As a result, we ran at reduced capacity and disposed of significant amounts of finished goods through mid-February. We're now back at full capacity, and we're glad the investigation confirmed that the industry's leading food safety practices were in place within our plants. We've taken further steps to develop more protocols for sanitizing harvest equipment, and we're pleased to once again be leading the industry forward on these efforts. We took the lessons from our investigations and used them to overhaul and improve our procedures and rules, which should cut down on how much time our facilities might spend shut down in the future. The additional legal and cleanup work drove up expenses we had no way of anticipating last December. For phase two, we're looking at about $15 million in unusual, non-recurring charges — that includes getting rid of tainted inventory and packaging, paying customers back, direct labor, and more cleaning and sanitizing. On top of that, we figure adjusted EBITDA for the whole of 2022 will take a hit of around $25 million, mostly because of temporary sales losses, the way fixed costs get absorbed, and pushing back the price hikes we need to offset inflation. Looking ahead, we anticipate that those nonrecurring expenses and the effect on adjusted EBITDA will no longer be with us as Q2 gets underway, and we anticipate a solid rebound in the core business. Also, we began working with customers in late February to implement higher pricing. Because available capacity across the industry remains so constrained, the category is expanding strongly, and consumer behavior up to this point provides no sign of being influenced by the recall incident, we feel sure we can recover the short-term volume we shed as a result of the recall. With that said, I'll hand it to Frank for the financial review.
Francis Davis
executiveThanks, Johan. As Rory said at the start, the financial details we're discussing today, and that appear in our press release, include results put together on a pro forma basis, showing what Dole plc's earnings would look like if the merger, IPO and refinancing had all taken place on January 1, 2020. That approach matches the pro forma financial information in the Form F-1 filed with the SEC in connection with the IPO. Moving to Slide 12. First, I'd like to talk about how transformational the merger with Dole Food Company and the creation of Dole plc has been for Total Produce plc. Thanks to that merger, Dole plc is much bigger than legacy Total Produce in terms of both scale and geographical footprint. Reported revenue rose 48.5% to $6.5 billion for the full year 2021 versus 2020, and it rose 113.7% when you compare pro forma revenue for the full year 2021 of $9.3 billion against reported revenue of $4.3 billion for 2020. Reported adjusted EBITDA rose 15.3% to $290.1 million for the full year 2021 versus what was reported for 2020, and it was up 56.5% when comparing pro forma adjusted EBITDA for the full year 2020 of $393.6 million against reported adjusted EBITDA for 2020 of $251.5 million. Total assets have grown substantially, by 147%, to $4.7 billion after the merger. As Rory noted, Dole plc turned in strong results for the full year 2021, with pro forma revenue up 3.5% to $9.3 billion compared with pro forma revenue in 2020, with gains across all segments. Pro forma adjusted EBITDA rose 5.9% for full year 2021 to $393.6 million. Diversified Fresh Produce — EMEA and Fresh Fruits were the main growth drivers. The full year 2021 pro forma revenue and adjusted EBITDA came in line with the guidance we gave during our Q3 earnings call. Now let's look briefly at Slide 14. On a pro forma basis, adjusted net income came to $141.2 million for full year 2021, an 11.8% increase versus full year 2020. That was mainly driven by the rise in pro forma adjusted EBITDA and a pro forma reduction in the pro forma effective tax rate. Since these results are prepared on a pro forma basis, they don't highlight the benefit of the roughly $40 million reduction in annual interest expense that the refinancing achieved. Looking at each segment in more detail, starting with Fresh Fruits. During the year, we dealt with cost pressures stemming from supply chain effects caused by Hurricanes Eta and Iota in Honduras and Guatemala in November 2020, as well as from industry-wide inflationary pressures. Still, despite those challenges, the division turned in a strong performance for the year, with revenue and adjusted EBITDA both growing. Fourth quarter pro forma revenue was up 6.9% versus the prior year, mainly because of higher banana prices in North America and continued growth in commercial cargo. When we look at the entire year, pro forma revenue was up 2.9%, and that came from better banana pricing across North America, along with stronger pineapple pricing in both North America and Europe, plus really solid performance in commercial cargo. In Q4 of 2021, pro forma adjusted EBITDA fell 10.3% compared with the same quarter a year earlier, and most of that decline showed up in Europe because of inflationary pressure that we didn't manage to offset until the new 2022 contracts reflected our pricing. Over in North America, those price hikes Johan mentioned earlier did help counterbalance pressure on input costs, and they also helped against rising transportation and handling expenses. Across the whole year, pro forma adjusted EBITDA rose 21.6%, mostly thanks to the higher revenue I just described. Now shifting to Diversified Fresh Produce — EMEA, this segment delivered a robust 2021. As we flagged on the Q3 earnings call, reorganizing our Dutch operations, a rebound in food service channels, and our ongoing emphasis on delivering superior service to customers all fed into that strong growth. Pro forma revenue rose 4.3% during the fourth quarter of 2021 and was up 5.4% for the entire year. In Q4, pro forma adjusted EBITDA climbed 1.9%, and for the full year it went up 24%, supported by the recovery in our Dutch businesses, strong trading right across the segment, and food service channels continuing to bounce back as European governments eased COVID-19 measures. We also got a boost from favorable foreign currency translation over the fiscal year. That said, right now we're projecting some foreign currency translation headwinds for the coming financial year, after European currencies weakened against the U.S. dollar. Let's move on to Diversified Fresh Produce — Americas and Rest of the World. Pro forma revenue for the fourth quarter of 2021 rose 0.8% compared with the prior year. For the full year, pro forma revenue was 3.8% higher, mostly because of increased revenue from berries and, to a lesser extent, growth in the South American export fruit business. Fourth quarter pro forma adjusted EBITDA jumped 42.6%, largely on the back of a strong beginning to the Peruvian grape and Chilean cherry seasons. On the same basis for the year, adjusted EBITDA dipped slightly, by 1.4%, and that decline was mostly attributable to adverse weather hitting the Chilean grape season early in the year, plus inflation and logistics pressure that some of our North American businesses dealt with. Partly offsetting that was good underlying progress in the business, with continued growth in berries, in the Chilean cherry business, and in kiwi, along with a rebound in apples and pears following the difficulties of the previous year. And last, turning to Fresh Vegetables on Slide 18 — this division has faced a tough year; beyond the factors we laid out during the Q3 earnings call, it took a further hit from a voluntary salad recall in December, which Johan has gone into in more detail. That was the main reason behind an 8.5% drop in pro forma revenue for the fourth quarter of 2021. Across the entire year, pro forma revenue rose 1%, which came from greater volumes overall and pricing within the value-added salad segment, fueled by robust market demand along with an improved product mix being sold. A loss was recorded in Q4 stemming from the recall's impact, and for the whole year because of soft packed vegetables markets, inflationary pressures, and the December recall. As previously confirmed, we're back running at full capacity and have implemented pricing increases, so we anticipate better results throughout 2022. Now I'll turn to capital allocation and leverage. Together with our July IPO last year, we wrapped up a refinancing and syndication of $1.44 billion in new credit facilities successfully. Through this refinancing, we were able to significantly reduce our cost of capital and annual interest expense by paying off costly debt inside Dole Food Company. Following this refinance, the yearly interest expense savings and additional free cash flow amount to roughly $40 million. Our approach to capital expenditure centers on putting money where we find the biggest chance for profitable growth, in order to back our already solid market positions in core products. Normally, we anticipate capital expenditure to match our yearly depreciation expense of about $120 million. This may shift based on our position in the reinvestment cycle and for particular larger capital assets like vessels. During 2021, capital expenditure reached roughly $190 million as we carried out several strategic investments, among them the final payments upon delivery of 2 new vessels. In Q4, we kept up our investments in Honduras through the rehabilitation programs that followed Hurricanes Eta and Iota, and by now have successfully replanted more than 2,900 acres of banana farms; we're happy to announce today a cash dividend for Q4 of 2021 amounting to $0.08 per share, payable on the 12th of April to shareholders of record on 29th of March 2022. Lastly, we remain committed to keeping leverage inside our goal level of 3x adjusted EBITDA. As of the fourth quarter's end, our net leverage ratio stood at 2.87x; at this point I'd like to give the floor back to Rory, who will walk you through our full year 2022 outlook in greater detail.
Rory Byrne
executiveThanks, Frank. So, when we look at the whole year, our revenue target sits between $9.6 billion and $9.9 billion. As Johan explained earlier, the value-added salads product recall hit us hard, and right now we expect it to drag down our targeted adjusted EBITDA for 2022 by roughly $25 million. On top of that, currencies, which Frank already described, could shrink the translation of euro earnings into U.S. dollars this year. Apart from our value-added salad business, underlying trading across all our other businesses has matched what we expected for the beginning of this year. When we weigh all of this together, our full year guidance for adjusted EBITDA comes to between $370 million and $380 million. On the other financial metrics, we're aiming for CapEx of about $125 million, which aligns with our yearly depreciation charge. We also anticipate annual interest expense of roughly $45 million, which reflects the full year interest reduction of more than $40 million from the refinancing, along with an effective tax rate between 25% and 28%. Turning to the macroeconomic picture, the conflict in Ukraine right now and the sanctions in Russia that followed caught everyone off guard. It's really hard to say with any precision today how this might affect global trade flows, cost inflation and foreign exchange rates, or how far it could hit our business. We're clearly paying close attention to all of these matters and will do whatever it takes to limit any possible impact. Now to Slide 22. I'll wrap up by laying out our strategic priorities for 2022. Clearly, our main priority is rebuilding profitability in the Fresh Vegetables segment, especially within our value-added salads business. Demand in the sector remains strong and industry capacity stays tight. That, together with the price increases we need, makes us confident profitability will come back during 2022; we keep focusing on integrating our businesses. After Dole plc was created, our management teams and people have carried on working ever more closely side by side. This integration and collaboration matters greatly strategically, particularly as we try to hit the targeted synergies we laid out when we did the IPO. Another key part of our strategy is growing our presence in faster-growing categories, like berries, avocados and organic produce, and also introducing the Dole brand to new customers, above all in new markets throughout Europe; we're likewise still actively pursuing synergistic and value-enhancing M&A opportunities. Our industry is one that's both fragmented and expanding, and we feel we're in a strong position to seize whatever opportunities it might bring our way. On top of that, during '22 we'll wrap up a fresh, combined framework of sustainability goals along with a materiality assessment, and we'll publish Dole plc's inaugural sustainability report as well. To wrap up, we're extremely happy with everything the company accomplished across 2021. That includes merging with Dole Food Company, forming Dole plc, getting listed on the New York Stock Exchange, and finishing a refinancing worth $1.44 billion. The group turned in robust financial results in 2021, and once more I want to express my gratitude to every one of our people for the enormous contribution and commitment they made — none of this could have happened without them. Just before we take questions on the call, I'd like to mention that earlier today we shared news of an upcoming shift in Dole's management team. Frank Davis has let us know that he has chosen to retire and leave both his Board seat and his role as CFO, effective the 30th of June this year. Frank joined the group back in 1983, and it has been a real privilege for me to work so closely alongside him for a great many years. He played a major role in our success, and he will absolutely be missed. He has more than earned the right to a retirement that's happy, healthy and enjoyable. We wish him all the best going forward — in the future. Jacinta Devine, who serves as our Company Secretary and as Finance Director of our Ireland and U.K. businesses, will step into the CFO role and join the Board once Frank retires. Given her more than 25 years of experience within the group, I'm fully confident this transition will go smoothly. With that said, I'll give the line back to the operator, and we can open it up for questions. Thank you.
Adam Samuelson
analystAlright, so for my first question, I want to confirm I've got a handle on the way you're describing the 2022 outlook. The $25 million hit from salads is part of it, correct. What wasn't clear to me, though, is how you're accounting for market uncertainty stemming from Russia and Ukraine. Could you perhaps walk us through the inflation-related factors — bunker fuel, fertilizer, logistics more generally, and the FX assumptions baked into the EBITDA guidance? And then maybe also share what you're monitoring most closely that could put additional pressure on your outlook as we watch how markets develop.
Rory Byrne
executiveSure, Adam, I'll handle that one. This is Rory speaking. Right, so we've incorporated our expected result for 2022. The $25 million known effect in the VA — and essentially the remainder comes from the FX translation effect Frank described, driven by the dollar strengthening versus European currencies. As for the other elements around inflation, like Johan laid out in his presentation, we've implemented the required actions, mainly on pricing, throughout the group to address it. There's a bit more to come, hopefully, on the VA side, given the delay in rolling out some of the second round of price increases caused by the Listeria recall. Turning to the macro geopolitical picture, we've simply pointed out that we're moving into unfamiliar territory. Predicting today what medium- or long-term consequences that scenario could bring for trade flows or for cost inflation is extremely difficult. Suffice it to say, we're observing volatility in fuel; we might see the freight market ease with extra capacity now on hand due to the absence of trade flows into Russia especially. And then there's FX uncertainty, particularly around translation and whether the dollar will move against the major European currencies, one way or the other. So our forecast rests on what we know today, and we haven't factored in any meaningful adjustment, though we have flagged that uncertainty exists surrounding the macro geopolitical situation. So I'm not sure whether that makes things clearer for you, Adam.
Adam Samuelson
analystThat's useful. And perhaps — I realize there is a pricing effect that offsets things, and it works both directly and indirectly. Still, could you assist in simply framing how, as we monitor conditions outside the company, you're thinking about the degree to which your costs react when fuel, fertilizers, and certain essential purchased raw materials used in your operations shift — not only the produce you source from outside suppliers?
Rory Byrne
executiveSure. Take fuel — the markets where it matters most to us are in North America, where fuel hits hardest, and for that region we've got variable provisions written into our contracts. When it comes to Europe, we don't have that — variability there is smaller; we do some hedging, and there's still some fluctuation involved. As you're aware, fuel has risen and fallen over recent times. At the point when we made our pricing changes, we factored in typical, expected inflation rates for input costs, including fertilizer. So calling any additional effect on our business stemming from that geopolitical circumstance is premature, Adam. And our hope is that, given the various alternatives available to us for handling a number of these fluctuations, the guidance figure we provided stands, subject to that major caveat. That said, no one can predict the duration of this invasion. No one can predict its longer-term ramifications, and that's what we're pointing out right now.
Christopher Barnes
analystFrank, congratulations and all the best as you move into retirement. What I'd like to do is probe a bit further on the revenue outlook. You're aiming for growth in the mid-single digits. Could you perhaps break that down between what you anticipate from price and what you anticipate from volume? For instance, do you see volumes increasing in '22, considering the magnitude of price you've already implemented? Also, could you possibly give us more detail about what you expect across the segments — fruit, vegetable, and diversified?
Rory Byrne
executiveYes, Christopher, thank you. We don't break the guidance out in any finer detail than that. And clearly, our emphasis is more on profitability than on the revenue outlook. There will be some variability tied to production seasons; with diversified, we'll see greater volume and lower price or the reverse, based on how the production cycle turns out, so projecting with any reasonable precision is genuinely quite hard; but what matters most to us here is profitability, our profit figure. The revenue figure comes from summing the parts, guided by our historical assessment of where we stood, given the conditions we understand today, and given the price increases already known and fed into our system. Past that, we don't go into finer detail or separate things out by division, price, or volume. And clearly, the EBITDA and the earnings figure are what we care about most.
Christopher Barnes
analystAll right, that seems reasonable. I'm wondering if you can give us a feel for how growth might lean across the various segments—just at a high level, without splitting volume and price apart.
Rory Byrne
executiveSure. As before, we don't disclose figures for each segment individually; and looking back at our track record through the years, there can be some fluctuations among those segments, yet by the end they usually deliver the appropriate growth figure for us; and supply and demand conditions vary somewhat from one market to another; and once more, splitting that out at a subdivision level doesn't strike us as wise. That's how we approach it. The total has consistently come together. Our attention stays on every one of our separate divisions. Within each of those divisions, we have the growth we believe is attainable. And the guidance we've provided, I'd say, is quite thorough, spanning a variety of financial metrics. In our view, that hands analysts and investors a solid base of information for assessing our stock.
Christopher Barnes
analystAll right, that's reasonable. And I suppose my final question concerns chances for additional pricing from this point forward. I believe you said something is coming in Fresh Vegetables. But considering that inflation across many areas really hasn't eased up as much as we'd hoped or anticipated back in December — back when you initially added price in North America — do you foresee that? And you've already reset the contract in Europe, yet we're picking up from other European peers — not specifically in Fresh Produce, but in CPG generally — that the situation is shifting because of the inflationary climate, and that there may be room for more than one round of pricing. Are you observing the same pattern? Or any thoughts you might have...
Johan Linden
executiveRory, allow me to take a crack at that, I think it's fairly — when you look at Diversified, which represents slightly more than half our business, pricing there is dynamic throughout the entire season. So in that segment, you will — and you witnessed that we performed well in 2021 when it came to adjusting to price increases in Diversified, and we anticipate doing likewise in 2022. So that covers more than half the business. After that, there's the Vegetable business, which in revenue terms accounts for an additional, say, 14%, 15% of what we do, and we're currently moving ahead with a price increase there. And Fresh Fruits, the remaining 1/3, we likewise just put through price increases that were carried out late in the prior quarter and at the start of this year. But as we also stated in the script at the outset, we recognize the greatest strategic importance in being prepared to raise prices again should conditions shift; however, at this moment we are essentially just coming off price increases. And so as things stand, we feel at ease.
Ben Bienvenu
analystRegarding the recalls on value-added salads, what's typically observed following incidents such as these when it comes to demand being destroyed or customers being lost? And which steps do you pursue in order to rebuild that level of trust with your customers and with consumers concerning these items? I realize these occur somewhat often. Still, I'd like to hear how you view the aftermath.
Rory Byrne
executiveJohan?
Johan Linden
executiveYeah. So as far as consumers go, this latest recall hasn't changed their behavior at all. We've been watching one another on social media and everything like that, and basically there's nothing there. So we don't believe anything needs to be done with the consumers, obviously. Their behavior when it comes to value-added looks the same right now as it did in the middle of last year. On the retailer side, we haven't lost any of the large contracts we hold because of this. What we've lost is individual SKUs and individual divisions, which is how we get ourselves back to normal operations. And we expect to recover that volume over the coming couple of weeks, the coming couple of months. So there's been no significant customer loss or consumer — customer retailer loss, but there are some SKUs we need to claw back. And it's really about — just talking with retailers, demonstrating to them that we're back up and running and that we have the capacity. But we feel fairly optimistic heading into Q2 here.
Ben Bienvenu
analystAll right. All right, excellent. For my follow-up, I want to ask about M&A. Your leverage has come down under the target range. I realize you want to fold M&A into how the business grows, and you've pulled that off effectively going back decades. If we consider how open the market is to M&A — whether possible targets would be ready to sell, and whether valuations sit in a range you'd find acceptable — what's the state of that market? Also, can you offer any read on how you expect this to play out given the geopolitical developments currently happening?
Rory Byrne
executiveYes. Ben, I'd say that's a fair question. Here's my take: there may be certain opportunities that emerge from the current geopolitical landscape, and we intend to monitor that closely. Beyond that, companies carrying meaningful revenue exposure to Russia — which, as Johan noted, is quite limited in our case — could create some openings as well. On the macro side, another thing I find noteworthy is the disconnect between how public and private markets are valuing things. A lot of businesses in our space have continued to trade at solid levels over the past few years, and whether they're in similar categories like the Diversified. As for inflation, they're managing it. Price increases are coming through. They're passing them along. To be clear, when it comes to sellers of businesses that are performing well and being run effectively, we haven't observed any drop in what they expect to receive. That creates something of a difficulty, since valuations in the public markets and those in the private markets aren't really aligned right now. Still, given how many possibilities exist, we intend to stay financially disciplined so we pursue the correct ones. Certain particular chances might emerge because of the geopolitical situation as it stands today. We'll keep watching and observe how things develop. When the moment is right, we think our position is strong enough to capitalize on such chances as we move forward.
Roland French
analystCongratulations, Frank. Perhaps we could begin with the salads division. You've put a number on the effect at the EBITDA line — $25 million flowing through the P&L, if I recall. Could you give us some detail on the volumes that were lost, or perhaps the sales that were lost? I'm simply attempting to figure out how many weeks or months that business has perhaps been — I suppose not absent from the market, but working to restore volumes. And then, perhaps connected to that, which processes might shift from this point onward, specifically regarding that preemptive approach to possible future outbreaks. Then my second question concerns the fixed price contract — if I remember correctly, Johan said during the Q3 stage that those contracts were expected to incorporate other costs into the matrices. So I'm just curious whether those extra costs have made their way into certain contracts, and what they might involve. And finally, any detail or remark on how supply stands in the banana category. I'm aware that last year brought a great deal of volatility during '21. So I'm just wondering whether that has settled down.
Johan Linden
executiveDo you think we're able to recall every one of the questions?
Roland French
analystI can say those again.
Johan Linden
executiveLet's begin with value-added. The timeline: we closed the plant just before Christmas. Roughly one-third of capacity was taken out at that point. That continued — including all the startup issues — until around mid-February. So during that window we had about 1/3 of our capacity offline, and at present we're running at full capacity again. Every retailer we served previously is being served, though we're still working through bringing back individual SKUs and individual divisions. Our expectation is that this will be resolved as we move into Q2. That covers volumes. On fixed price contracts: yes, we have some, but only a very small number where we've managed to add indexes that weren't there previously. Keep in mind, though, that in the North American market for our tropical fruit — bananas — we already have a handful of surcharges in place. What we've focused on is securing indexes in Europe, and we do have them, but they're quite limited and won't affect our business in its current state. I believe that was the second question; now for the third one, the supply situation. The entire situation with Russia is a new development from a supply standpoint. They purchase major volumes across several fruit and vegetable categories. Naturally, they're also significant — we're talking bananas here. Their presence in Ecuador is very large, and this will affect Ecuador and its ability to ship that volume to Russia. As things stand currently, about 2/3 of that volume can still get onto ships and reach Russia by some means, while 1/3 is stranded. That means a supply/demand imbalance is going to emerge. However, much of that fruit lacks the proper certifications, and it also doesn't have the shipping capacity needed to reach alternative destinations. So at least for now, what we're seeing is more a problem for some independent farmers than any effect on the market in its present state. Of course, a portion of this volume will also arrive in the market and will then affect the open fruit we hold, but our open fruit position isn't that large. Don't forget, nearly 80% of all volumes entering Europe for bananas are on fixed-price contracts.
Roland French
analystThat's helpful detail. If I circle back to what I asked earlier about salads — specifically the processes and procedures that may have been mandated or, I suppose, came about internally after the Listeria outbreak and the product recalls — is there anything worth highlighting there?
Rory Byrne
executiveYeah, I believe there is. First off, I'd like to point to the positive side, which is that when this took place, the guidance we received was that the authorities thought the problem was with our — inside our facilities. That caught us off guard, since we're aware that our plant operates with practices that lead the industry. And up to that point, our plant had never had such a problem. Later it emerged that we did identify a problem involving one individual piece of harvesting equipment, and today there are various new procedures in place for dealing with that type of equipment. This will bring about changes for the industry as a whole, not just for us. So we're seeing new, shall we say, cleaning protocols — to put it a bit too simply — related to the harvest equipment; those are already in place, and in fact we've invited the entire industry to learn from them; we held the Food Safety Summit. So that's being rolled out throughout the industry. And second, going forward, what we'll typically do is this: if we get a hit showing some kind of bacteria — Listeria, say — we will now perform additional whole genome sequences — sequencing on that bacteria, so we can put that big data to use and check whether some other correlation exists that might line up with another supplier or other facilities. That way we'll lean on big data a bit more to spot correlations, so we can determine faster whether systemic problems exist anywhere. But I'd also like to point out that the entire process, along with how we worked with the authorities, went extremely well. I think our standing with the FDA and CDC has grown as a result — thanks to our openness, our transparency, the manner in which we collaborated, the seriousness with which we treated this, and the fact that we did in fact locate the root cause. So we feel that given this credibility and what we've learned, it's quite — it's much less probable that we'll face those drawn-out closures down the road. We feel that should anything comparable occur again, we'll simply take that line down, conduct the investigation, and not the plant.
Ken Zaslow
analystIs my voice coming through?
Rory Byrne
executiveYes, Ken, we're able to pick you up.
Ken Zaslow
analystI've got two things to ask. First, regarding 2022 — as I look ahead to 2023, will that $25 million be entirely recovered? Is there any reason at all it might not return? And after that, do we simply carry on? In other words, is this purely a one-time matter that hits 2022 only, with everything shifting once 2023 arrives? That's my first question.
Rory Byrne
executiveThat's our expectation, Ken. Yes, without a doubt.
Ken Zaslow
analystGreat. Could you discuss whether any price elasticity has shown up as a result of any of the price increases you've made?
Rory Byrne
executiveUp to this point, demand hasn't responded negatively at all to those higher prices, no.
Ken Zaslow
analystGreat. And then my final question is, could you give us a worldwide overview of any key crop — either those that are actually beating expectations or coming in below expectations.
Rory Byrne
executiveI believe we have our usual items to mention there, Ken. Banana volume, like Johan mentioned, is somewhat more steady given the effect of the 2020 hurricanes. Bananas, pineapples, clearly the macro political situation may cause some imbalance between supply and demand; however, no other significant weather events exist right now that will have any sort of — of our supply that will lead to any significant supply chain availability or logistical variations that we know of at this time.
Ken Zaslow
analystGreat. I'll just slip in one final one, and this is likely an easy question, but what's your take on why public and private valuations diverge? And that's all from me.
Rory Byrne
executiveThat's a fair question, Ken, and I sure wish I had the answer. I mean, I think public markets perhaps take — and as of late, maybe they're taking a shorter-term view of things; and private markets, whether that's other buyers or private equity, are beginning to do the reverse and take a longer view that this is a wonderful sector to be in. It's inexpensive. It's steady profitability. So I think that explains why they value it somewhat more highly in the private markets, yes?
Rory Byrne
executiveYeah. Thanks so much, and I appreciate everyone joining us today. Clearly, we feel great about the major milestones we hit during 2021 — completing the IPO, securing the refinancing, and beginning to merge the 2 businesses into what will be the top fresh produce company globally. The single isolated event in our value-added salad operations is something I'm not happy about, but as Johan explained, we believe we've responded with numerous measures and numerous actions. With any luck, that matter is now behind us, and we can push ahead through '22 and enjoy another strong '22. So, many thanks to all of you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Dole plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Dole plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Dole plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.