DSV A/S (DSV) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 4, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and thank you for joining the conference call on the 2024 Annual Report. This is <<inaudible>> from Chorus Call, your operator. <<operator_script>> Please note that this call is being recorded. <<operator_script>> Recording this conference for publication or broadcast is not permitted. At this point, I'm happy to turn things over to Jens Lund, our Group CEO. Please go ahead.
Jens Lund
executiveThanks a lot, and welcome, everyone, to our conference call covering the full year 2024 results. We'll follow the usual format. Michael and I will walk through the presentation, and after that we'll move on to the Q&A session. So let's go straight to Slide #2. There you can see the agenda for today's call, along with the forward-looking statement. Please make sure you read it carefully. And as you do that, I'd suggest we move quickly on to Slide 3. There we can discuss some of the highlights from 2024. Overall, we saw a solid performance from our company this year. For the third quarter in a row, we have now outgrown last year in terms of GP as well as results. So I think that's a solid performance, and the commercial approach we've put in place has ensured growth across all the business areas. I also think things are going well when it comes to the Schenker transaction and how we're progressing on the regulatory approvals. We have also guided for next year at a range of DKK 15.5 billion to DKK 17.5 billion.
Jens Lund
executiveOverall, we believe we've gotten off to a strong beginning in '25, and that view rests on solid results for 2024. I'll return a bit to productivity when we get to that idea, if we jump ahead to the next slide, Slide #4, where it's clear we've actually succeeded in growing both the GP and the EBIT, and the marginal conversion ratios come in somewhat above the average conversion ratio, something we've also observed previously. I think we still feel some pressure regarding inflationary pressure on wages and the cost base. That, I'd say, is tapering off now. We're moving into a more normal scenario. But naturally, as all of you can recall, when inflation ran higher, wages went up, and that has sort of also been true in 2024. Looking at productivity, we now handle 16% more jobs per FTE. And looking as well at the fact that we've managed to grow our GP — our largest division, which accounts for more than 70% of our EBIT, is rock solid in what we're producing here.
Jens Lund
executiveAnd we're really confident that this development can keep going in 2025 as well. Moving to the next slide, Slide #5, you'll see the air freight figures. Here, our GP has grown versus the same quarter last year. Our volume has grown too. On volume, we believe we've outgrown our addressable market. As for yields, I'd say they've stayed fairly stable all year. Compared with the same quarter last year, though, they're slightly lower. We expect the volumes we can deliver in DSV next year will also outgrow the market. We have solid pipelines with our customers that indicate we will — for the full year we don't know it. But for the start of the year, of course, we do know it, and we're on a good path to keep driving volumes forward. Moving to the next slide, Slide #6. We can also take a look at ocean freight. And here, of course, we see a significant development in gross profit. Some of that comes from volume growth.
Jens Lund
executiveHere, it's also our estimate that we've grown faster than the market. We have at least some market data available, and PS has reported as well. And those figures have been closer to the 3%, 4% range. Based on the numbers we have available here, that's also a significant outperformance. But as you can also see, the yield is impacted by the Red Sea situation. Over the last couple of quarters, we've had a yield of approximately 4,900, whereas early on we had a yield closer to the 4,500 range. So that has had an effect on the GP. I think we'll see a higher yield level at least as we go into the year, and then we'll see how the whole situation globally plays out depending on what the container rates do as well. So I think those were the comments on Ocean freight, and then we come to Road. Here in Road in the quarter, we've had a weak result, and I think that's fair to say. There have basically been a couple of explanations for that. There's kind of a one-off adjustment in the U.S. where we had to provision for some <<inaudible>> stuff we had to take care of. So that's been the one adjustment.
Jens Lund
executiveThe second adjustment is a bit more structural in nature. We are, obviously, operating in a European market whose economy isn't growing. A great deal of added complexity comes from different kinds of reporting and so on, and that also saps the energy of many companies across Europe, since they must concentrate on it. That places considerable pressure on the transportation market in Europe. And given that volumes aren't really rising much, transport and logistics companies are under strain. I believe we'll witness that strain for a number of quarters, until the market adjusts to the new norm, so to speak; among the sectors hit especially hard are ones such as automotive, though other industrial firms are affected too. And of course, weak consumption on the retail side isn't helping us in Europe either. So I don't think anything is wrong with our Road company or its activity, but we must rightsize to the market, and the market must adjust as well. And then we'll likely reach a situation in which we return to normal levels.
Jens Lund
executiveWe already anticipate seeing some improvement in Q1, since a number of the adjustments we've made won't be present anymore once the next quarter arrives. So overall, the outlook for the Road side is a bit different this time around, and we're confident that we'll push productivity back up and that results will return to the levels we saw previously. Then on Solutions, I think we've expanded solutions considerably over the year. In the most recent quarter, development has been flatter. I think that's also somewhat tied to what's happening in Europe broadly. And then we have focus. Looking at the pipeline, we're in a solid position to bring in new volume. So growth is something we'll also see in '25. But there has been a pause here in Q4. And then, naturally, we've added extra capacity, and we've also had some capacity added. I think that shows up in the numbers. It's not falling off a cliff. But naturally, we must make sure that the capacity we have available and the volumes we produce, they match.
Jens Lund
executiveIf not, that'll show up right away in the figures. And that's partly what you're seeing with the Solutions division as well. But on the whole, one more point I'd make: we're putting a lot of emphasis on the ROIC discussion right now, since we've put too many resources into solutions, which has meant the ROIC has been falling, and that's a serious issue we have to tackle. Just on Solutions, these activities are essential, especially for a lot of our bigger accounts, because they essentially make sure we can provide more end-to-end service to many of our larger customers. Even so, we have to watch how we use capital, and rest assured this sits very high on the agenda. Then let's move to Slide #9. We have the NEOM JV. It's fair to say it has developed much more slowly than we anticipated. There is some activity, but it's taking a great deal of time. There's plenty of red tape across many aspects of NEOM, so going forward, we probably won't necessarily keep it as a specific item in our quarterly updates, as it were, until it has a relevance, a significance, that makes it relevant for these calls.
Jens Lund
executiveWhat I can say is that we comply with the code of conduct and everything else required of us to remain compliant. After that, we'll cut back the resources we have in NEOM, so that we can be sure the capacity we've put in place lines up with demand on the NEOM project. So that's about all we can say regarding NEOM at this point. Now I'll give my voice a bit of a rest and pass things to Michael. He'll walk through some of the details on the financials and so on. So please go ahead, Michael.
Michael Ebbe
executiveThank you, Jens. Don't stay retired for too long. Yes, if we turn to Slide #10, there are the customary highlights of the P&L, and just a few points I want to stress that are worth calling out. Clearly, the robust growth Jens discussed, particularly in Air & Sea. That shows up in revenue, where we posted close to 20% growth on the top line, driven by volume but also, as was specifically noted, by the freight rates. Some have brought up 2024 versus 2023 a bit when it comes to the results. And we've addressed that before. Jens also pointed out, we're pleased to see that during the second part of 2024 we actually recorded an EBIT increase in fixed currencies against the same period last year. So we're on a solid path there. The cost base, which Jens touched on briefly, is affected, naturally, by inflationary pressure, salaries, licenses also feeding into this. So you could say the cost initiatives we've put in place, you can't observe them fully in the cost base. You have to keep in mind that this also flows through to the GP level and depreciation level and so forth.
Michael Ebbe
executiveIf you're after specific figures, you'll also need to reach out to Investor Relations on that point. One last item regarding the cost base in Q4. Naturally, we're keeping an eye on what lies ahead with the Schenker acquisitions too. So with an integration, it's possible that we should — we haven't booked every cost stemming from that. Interest costs, needless to say, are affected by the successful share capital increase we completed in autumn of last year. Share buybacks — we ran those until September, when we halted them because of the Schenker acquisition. And clearly, that gives a positive effect. Yet it's fairly well offset by the equity offering we saw. The tax rate keeps sitting at roughly 24%. So turning to Page #11, I believe most of you have already read that our working capital is up, rising by DKK 4 billion. That actually matches the DKK 4 billion we see in the MC division. So it has plainly had an effect on volume growth, and it is plainly affecting working capital at year-end. Naturally, we should also mention once more the cash flow we got from the equity offering, and likewise from the bonds we issued so that we'd be ready to finance the second transaction when we reach closing.
Michael Ebbe
executiveNet working capital, as I mentioned, has been affected — you could say — by the big rise in Air & Sea. Then there's the temporary piece, you might say, where a bit more than we had anticipated got tied up in the property, which hopefully will be released here in the first quarter, at least part of it. Our ambition remains to get to 3% long-term net working capital, but of course things also need to settle down somewhat and, as you say, help with constant volume. The gearing ratio — you've never seen that before. It's 0.0. You have to keep in mind that this is because we carried out the share capital increase. So if you adjust for that, our gearing ratio would be around 1.7, which is more or less what we normally said we would guide toward. Then on the next page, Page #12, you can see the allocation to shareholders. As I said earlier, normally we do the share buybacks and decide on them each quarter. Given the Schenker acquisition and integration, we have posted. So that's the situation. And we did buy share buybacks in 2024. And then imported. I think, yes, and then there is a proposed dividend of DKK 7 per share, which our Board also recommended yesterday.
Michael Ebbe
executiveYou could say our capital allocation policy remains unchanged. The halt in share buybacks stems from—again—the Schenker acquisition. And naturally, once we're inside our guided range, we'll resume that. But above all, we need to get Schenker in place first. The next slide is also on Page #13. Jens already touched on this a bit. This is our guidance for 2025. Naturally, we must guide on the premises we have right now, meaning this is DSV standalone, excluding Schenker. We've guided the range of DKK 15.5 billion to DKK 17.5 billion EBIT before special items. We expect the global Air & Sea freight market to grow around 3% in 2025, in line with the forecasted GDP growth visible across different sources. Jens also spoke a little about our yield. We assume slightly lower yields in 2024 for both Air & Sea. Jens touched upon it before. Much the same applies to the Road business, predominantly in Europe, obviously, which is impacted by the market. And the things Jens talked about. So we expect flat to single-digit growth.
Michael Ebbe
executiveAnd then, naturally, there's plenty to say on that topic. We've given a range of DKK 2 billion. That, of course, mirrors the uncertainty out there — the macroeconomic and geopolitical backdrop is still unpredictable. Each morning we get up, fresh developments appear, particularly across the sea, that big body of water. So I believe that covers it. And once more, that's our view of the 2025 outlook. Moving to the next slide, Page 14, I can handle that one too. This concerns the Schenker acquisition. As mentioned earlier, the financing is secured. We've issued shares worth DKK 5 billion and bonds worth DKK 5 billion. Our core banks have committed DKK 3 billion to us. So once we reach the approvals stage, we ought to be capable of funding the whole transaction. We're continuing to push hard for the remaining approvals. Right now we're at 33 of 36 approvals, though obviously nothing is settled until that final one arrives. We still anticipate that this can — that it will take place in Q2 2025. And once closing happens, we'll naturally share more specifics on how we view the transaction and how 2025 might develop, including a few remarks on the synergies.
Michael Ebbe
executiveYou'll need to hang on until the closing before we can get to that. Yes. So I believe this is our final slide. What we'd like to leave you with here is that we're pleased to see our earnings have rebounded — you could say the strategy is working pretty well, with 3 quarters now of above-market growth, fantastic so far. We remain on track for the Schenker closing. And as Jens said, guidance for next year stands at DKK 15.5 billion to DKK 17.5 billion, with a tax rate of 24%. That's what we're guiding for the coming year. Then I suppose plenty of you have questions. So let's move to the Q&A.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Dan Togo Jensen at Carnegie, on the line. Please proceed.
Dan Togo Jensen
analystOn your organic growth, it's obviously good to see that you kept growing faster than the market in Q4, and you expect that to carry on into '25. Could you say a bit about how you view organic growth while the Schenker integration is underway? Will you keep outpacing the underlying market? And then, so to speak, what have you put in place to support organic growth in that area? That's the first question.
Jens Lund
executiveYes. I think when you look at organic growth during an integration period, it typically comes in a bit below what you'd normally achieve. I think that has indeed been the case. And of course, when we buy a company, we also typically factor in that we'll actually lose a little revenue as well. I think the assumptions around that are probably the same. What may be somewhat different this time versus the last time we acquired companies is that we've become much stronger in DSV and in how we organize and approach the market with our customers. That's mainly thanks to much clearer customer segmentation and a far more structured way of approaching individual accounts. So I think these initiatives will help us keep developing these accounts through an integration phase as well. I also think we can offset the volume loss on Schenker by applying the same approach. I think it's fair to say that given how this has worked in DSV this year, we can't help being a little bit optimistic about applying this approach on the Schenker side too.
Jens Lund
executiveRelative to earlier deals, on a DSV standalone basis — and we can talk about what that might look like — we ought to be able to achieve a bit when it comes to expanding the business we already have, and beyond that we should hopefully handle the integration in a way that means we shed fewer volumes than was the case previously. On that basis, I think we can state that this will essentially turn the Schenker transaction into a business case that is even more appealing. That, then, is what we aspire to. <<inaudible>> prior to this.
Dan Togo Jensen
analystMy apologies, I missed what you said at the end there.
Michael Ebbe
executiveMy sense is that our starting position is stronger now than it has been before.
Dan Togo Jensen
analystAlright, yes, that sounds good. Then one question about something you mentioned, Jens, in your presentation — rightsizing the Road business. Does that refer to FTE, or does client pruning fall under it as well? How should we read that?
Jens Lund
executiveI think if you take a look at the Road business, on some products we're up nearly 10% in volume. We're talking about the international group business here. Then there are certain activities within certain segments where, perhaps, we aren't able to deliver — how should I put it — the results that would justify keeping those activities going. So I think we'll move toward, what can I say, a situation where we concentrate on the business areas where we've made progress, and then we'll try to cut back our exposure to the areas where we've had less success. So I think that is going to happen. It's a gradual process, this is how you go about it. Then I think if you look at, for instance, here in December, of course it's affected by, let's say, the automotive industry shutting down for a longer stretch of time. The way our contracts with them are structured is historical, and this is where we then carry the full exposure. That will, for example, affect our results as well. So we have to find a different approach, because we can't have capacity sitting available that isn't being paid for, as an example.
Jens Lund
executiveHaving that kind of resource on hand when there's no need for it, and then not getting paid for it, just isn't workable for us. So that's possibly something we'd examine. And there are various areas of that kind where we'll step in and make adjustments for the new market conditions we're seeing.
Operator
operatorAlexander Irving from Bernstein is up next with a question. All right, then, we'll move on to the following question. Cristian Nedelcu from UBS has the next question.
Cristian Nedelcu
analystLet's take the first one on Road and Solutions. Your Q4 EBIT comes in about DKK 200 million below where it was a year earlier. So as we look at 2025, how should we frame EBITDA for Road and Solutions against '24? The second one touches on the Schenker underlying, and I realize you can't give any guidance, but we're in a world where ocean rates are declining, and you laid out a difficult market for the first half. When you did your due diligence on Schenker, were there elements that gave you confidence that the profitability they delivered in '24 represents the new normal, or that GP per unit isn't excessively high across the last few quarters and could fall more meaningfully? So any reassurance you came across in that due diligence that DKK 1 billion of EBIT is the underlying profit starting point there.
Jens Lund
executiveI think if we look at the Road and Solutions business, basically those two together will deliver figures similar to what they did in 2024, maybe slightly better on Solutions -- on the Solutions side. I think that's basically what we expect from these businesses. When it comes to Schenker, I mean, it's difficult for us to comment on their figures. They have published some biannual number. I think that is the public information that is available. Of course, we have a business plan, a business case and we've done our diligence on that. And I don't think the numbers that you've seen reported on the biannual part are out of the ordinary. I think that's what I can comment on that. We will be able to give a little bit more clarity. Of course, there's always things that are debatable when you report and is it a recurring item or not, but as I said, basically it's a sound company that reports sound results.
Cristian Nedelcu
analystThen the second one, perhaps a brief technical question. Your cost base, as I see it, rose in 2024 by roughly DKK 800 million compared with the prior year for your P&L. At a high level, how should we view '25 against '24 regarding the cost base? I realize there are several moving pieces in play there, but yes.
Jens Lund
executiveI think — if we look at it, obviously, as I mentioned too, we went through a stretch of high inflation, and naturally the wage adjustments during the year largely mirror that. Beyond that, there have also been considerable cost hikes on IT licenses. And then one more item we should keep in mind: the new EU reporting requirements, which have added a figure in the 3 digits when it comes to the extra costs we incur to produce those reports. Bear in mind that DSV has 400 units filing in 80 countries. When you must gather the figures for that kind of reporting, it's a wide-ranging and extremely expensive effort. So I think that deserves a mention as well. There has been a great deal of pressure on many of these fronts. My sense is the inflation pressure will subside. The IT licenses, I suppose, will keep going up. But at this point the reporting requirements are baked into our baseline. So they will still generate enormous cost. And, I mean, we struggle to grasp, how should I put it, what the value actually is.
Jens Lund
executiveStill, I have no doubt we'll keep talking about this more down the road, and after that we'll find out how everything turns out.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Robert Joynson at BNP Paribas Exane.
Robert Joynson
analystJens and Michael, I've got 2 questions for you. First, regarding the volume picture right now: you said both Road and Solutions hit normal seasonality in Europe in Q4. Could you go a bit deeper on that? Maybe also give some color on what you're observing when it comes to consumer spending? And are you beginning to see any signs of headwinds from inventory destocking? That's the first one. Second, on the Red Sea possibly reopening from a shipping standpoint, are you starting to get any signals from the container shipping lines that they might go back to using the Red Sea route again in the months ahead?
Jens Lund
executiveWhen we look at how volumes have developed, I think, as I mentioned, we've observed longer shutdowns in the market, and that certainly had a significant effect on what we delivered in December. For January, our expectation is — how should I put it — a month of normal production, so the volumes we generate then ought to come in as expected. On the destocking front, my sense is that if anything is happening right now around tariff risk, it may be that someone is attempting to move more volume through, though that isn't really something we've managed to detect in the numbers. Broadly speaking, you're aware that destocking has occurred if you look a bit further back. There has clearly been destocking. We also see it in the utilization rates for our warehouses, which historically sat at 89% or 90% utilization across our multi-client facilities. At present, we're operating at 83%. That tells you most customers have in fact trimmed their stock levels somewhat. I think money is now getting cheaper in certain parts of the world. So those calculations could differ as well, since the interest rate has declined — not in the U.S., but definitely in Europe.
Jens Lund
executiveThat could also prompt a different view of things among the folks running supply chains. Regarding the Red Sea, my sense is it hasn't loomed large — you're kind of part of the discussion at the moment. People, I think, are waiting to find out what will really take place. What's driving the market right now, I'd say, is the new alliances, and there's a situation where volumes didn't need shifting into one alliance or another. And it looks like they're competing somewhat at the moment to fill the vessels. It's perhaps not as volatile now as it was right at the start, but in my view this is a very competitive situation right now, where everyone wants to be sure they secure the locations they need under the new setup, so that's likely the main driver at present. And as you can see, rates have eased somewhat as a result. But it's difficult to say what will really happen. So for now, we keep monitoring it. And of course, customers are contracting a bit shorter because they really don't want to be caught out by a long-term arrangement.
Jens Lund
executiveSo that's where things stand with the Ocean piece, I'd say.
Operator
operatorOur next question is from Alexia Dogani at JPMorgan.
Alexia Dogani
analystI've got a couple of questions too, if I may. First off, could you bring us up to speed on where things stand with the regulatory approval timetable for Schenker? Around Christmas time, I believe you mentioned being 50% through the process. What's the current position? Obviously, everyone is waiting on the U.S. authorities and the European Commission to finish their reviews. Could you walk us through where things stand regarding the procedure in these 2 countries? I did hear your remarks about Schenker's performance so far. That said, my understanding is you may have some visibility into how it's performing month by month. Could you at least tell us whether we ought to expect an H2 Schenker performance comparable to how these reperformed, particularly in light of roads and important segments of them? That covers my first question. My second one concerns cost performance. In Air & Sea, I believe costs were somewhat inflated, possibly because you're retaining some costs ahead of integration. Could you help us quantify how large those costs are, perhaps? And in a similar vein, if you could shed some light on the DKK 800 million cost improvement plan: is it fully embedded? Should we anticipate some kind of drop through becoming more visible in 2025?
Alexia Dogani
analystTo clarify what you said earlier about the Red Sea and yields coming in a bit lower — does that assume you don’t expect the Red Sea situation to be resolved in ’25?
Michael Ebbe
executiveI suppose I'll begin. There was some trouble figuring out whether that counted as 2 questions. Still, I'll try to handle part of it, and then, Jens, you can pick up from there. On Schenker, I believe the update is accurate: we currently hold 33 of the 36 regulatory approvals. Of the 3 still outstanding, as you noted too, Alexia, one is the U.S. and the other is the European Commission. Our dialogue with them is very good, and we hold frequent virtual meetings. We also meet in person so we can address all the questions they raise. So things are proceeding as before, and I'm not sure this is much of a secret, but I don't think they are rewarded for acting quickly — they are rewarded for avoiding mistakes. So they have plenty of questions, and naturally we answer them and keep moving forward. We are therefore still aiming for Q2, as we said at the outset. Perhaps I can speak to cost performance, and then, Jens, you can cover the remaining points on Schenker and rates. It is accurate that costs have risen slightly. I think Jens has already mentioned this — the salary inflation and the license costs we have observed.
Michael Ebbe
executiveAlso, one more point: during Q4 we saw Air & Sea expand. Keep in mind as well that Air & Sea productivity rose 16% on average. But naturally, that's something we've already taken into account. And as Jens mentioned earlier, when we look ahead to '25, expect a stable to slightly inflationary increase. That's the scenario I'd pick.
Jens Lund
executiveOkay. Now, regarding Schenker's performance — I mean, it's Schenker, and I believe there are particular areas and particular verticals where they perform very well. Tech is a real strength for them. That vertical is a strong one, and it has an effect across all the relevant business areas that generate volume in tech. So I'd describe that as an area where they're doing well. I think they also carry some exposure to Europe, so they'll likewise be feeling some pain from industrial companies and the automotive areas too. They probably also have — how should I put it — a situation comparable to what we have here at DSV. So I think there are a lot of similarities when you look at the numbers, and you can read that across to the Schenker side too. I think that's what we then have to tackle when we integrate the 2 companies, so that we have the right capacity available for this sort of new market situation. Then on the Red Sea — I didn't mention anything about the yields on the Red Sea, but if we take Ocean freight, I think we've also told you that 70% of our GP is fee driven. So it's not necessarily because we consolidate and do procurement and all these things.
Jens Lund
executiveSo I believe that — when it comes to our yield or our GP, the situation is very stable. The Red Sea, as I mentioned, it's on the rates. In my view, the rate decline isn't really being pushed by the Red Sea. What's pushing it is the 4 new alliances. So that's what has been driving rate levels up to now, until they stabilize. So I think that's where we stand at present. As you know, MSC has its own alliance, and then there's the Germany alliance too. So new big alliances that carry significant size in the market. Of course, that creates some volatility at the moment. And where it ends out is hard to predict. If we then look at the — the Red Sea, I think people are waiting to see what the impact will be. And that's also how our customers contract, because nobody can really predict what is going to happen. There have been so many scenarios that, even looking at our own team that follows this, it's hard to say what the outcome will be. And I think that's how our customers stay contracted.
Operator
operatorUlrik Bak from SEB has the next question.
Ulrik Bak
analystAnd 2 here as well. About Road—your conversion ratio obviously fell fairly sharply in Q4 compared with Q3. So it would really help to get a sense of how much of that came from the one-offs and how much was driven by the market. And in that same vein, how much recovery in the conversion ratio should we expect given the price increases you're putting through. And just to add, it looks like you'll be exiting some business. So once we're on the other side of that, should we potentially see better conversion ratios or better margins in this division. That's my first one.
Jens Lund
executiveWhen I look at the conversion ratio, and thinking about last quarter, my estimate would be that roughly half of the effect you're seeing is likely tied to more one-off factors — it could be 40% to 50%, at least that portion is the one-off piece. And then, naturally, there's the conversion rate. So I don't believe we should fail to return to the figures in Road that we normally deliver. That said, I think 2025 will be a tough year for us. And naturally, we'll shift more of our selling toward the areas that perform well for us, and then, probably, as some contracts elsewhere reach expiry, we'll lower our exposure in those areas. Naturally, we'll continue producing for automotive, but there may be situations where, if contracts haven't delivered a return, we have to walk away from them at the end of the day. So that's what I can say on that point.
Ulrik Bak
analystThat's great. Now, my second question is about Solutions. You mentioned that profitability has taken a hit from reduced utilization as we bring new capacity online. So where would you say we are in the cycle at this point? And regarding what you said about concentrating on the ROIC level for this division, what actions are you planning in order to protect that or make it better in '25?
Jens Lund
executiveWe're already working to cut back the capacity we've got in place and to consolidate. That effort is ongoing. We'll also take a look at how we fundamentally handle the way leases on the facilities are run. So I think that's -- and then, naturally, with the construction projects, we try to lessen, how should I put it, the effect of not being able to fund them during the construction phase. So we may scale that back somewhat too. Those would likely be the levers we'll pull to head in that direction. And then fundamentally, we now have an internal list of sites that don't produce, how should I put it, a satisfactory return on invested capital. And then fundamentally, for some of those sites we have either a recovery plan or an exit plan. So I think that's a structural way of tackling this topic. The thing about this is it takes some time, but hopefully we should see gradual improvement, so that quarter-on-quarter we can see ourselves getting into a better state.
Operator
operatorMuneeba Kayani from BofA has the next question.
Muneeba Kayani
analystYes. First, on the 4Q performance: when you lifted guidance alongside your 3Q results, did November and December for Road and Solutions end up coming in softer than you had originally anticipated? And second, a few days ago you announced some Board changes. Could you speak a bit more about that and what brought those changes about?
Jens Lund
executiveYeah. I believe you're correct that, fundamentally, as I mentioned too, December proved to be a difficult month since shutdowns lasted longer and occurred more frequently than anticipated. And I think that was likely somewhat apparent in the November volumes as well. So I think you're exactly right on that point. Regarding the Board changes, I mean, at minimum the goal is for us to bring in a Board with greater international representation, and naturally, considering that we purchased a German company, I think it matters that we gain some expertise there that also grasps the German market along with all the German stakeholders. So I think those are essentially the changes we're pushing forward on the Board.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Lars Heindorff, who is with Nordea.
Lars Heindorff
analystI have a couple of questions too. First, could you help us get a slightly better handle on what drove the revenue figures in Road and Solutions? In Road, you posted revenue growth of 9% in Q2 and 10% in Q3, and then it fell to 2% in the fourth quarter. In Solutions, growth went from 17% and 20%, respectively, down to 0 growth. Is that simply a result of the closures you mention? Did the market really deteriorate to that degree between the third quarter and the fourth quarter? Or what are the components in terms of volume and price as well? That's my first one.
Jens Lund
executiveYeah, I think you've got it right, Lars — the volumes they have, or how you'd put it, the activity level has clearly moved. It also comes down to — let's say, in Solutions — when contracts get implemented and what's going on with each individual contract too. And then there are some pretty big fluctuations. When I look at the pipeline going into next year, I believe we'll return to growth again. So hopefully what we reported in the fourth quarter will just be a blip. That's essentially all I can say about that. But on the Road side, for instance, the shutdown is substantial — I think that's a fair way to describe it. And naturally that affects some of what we do in Solutions as well. I'd also say that on the Solutions side, perhaps at the end of the year we didn't quite see what we'd expected on the retail side either. So things have definitely been somewhat slower. As I explained, our occupancy ratio in the warehouses is lower, and the number of order lines — plus the size of those order lines — matters a great deal.
Jens Lund
executiveThat's playing a role here too. So maybe we send out a greater number of order lines, yet each shipment could be somewhat smaller. I think every one of those factors contributes to this downward trend. So we need to watch for it to level off, and then make sure the pipeline holds enough so we can push things ahead in '25.
Lars Heindorff
analystWas there any meaningful shift from Q3 to Q4, whether in market volume growth or in market pricing?
Jens Lund
executiveYeah, as I explained — what can I say — we probably saw lower volume in the fourth quarter because of the shutdowns and certain dynamics as well. It can also be particular customers doing particular things too. So I think that's the explanation we have.
Lars Heindorff
analystOkay, moving to the second item, which concerns net working capital. Michael, you brought this up during your presentation as well. Could you tell us what represents a sort of ongoing, normal level, in terms of what sits in the property versus what reflects more operational items? What should net working capital be on a normal basis?
Michael Ebbe
executiveAs I mentioned earlier, the largest effect on net working capital, you could say, comes from the growth in Air & Sea that we've seen, driven by both rates and volume. That's DKK 4 billion versus the same period last year. So naturally, that has to stabilize. Then there's what you might call a temporary hold-up in a property project, which is also affecting net working capital at year-end. Clearly, we're working hard to get back on track with the 3% range for net working capital. That's what we believe we can achieve, and most likely it will take a little while — not necessarily in the first quarter — but that's what we need to do.
Operator
operatorMarc Zeck from Kepler Cheuvreux has the next question on the line.
Marc Zeck
analystI've got two questions, if I may. The first one is probably tied more to what's happening right now in global trade. If I understand it correctly, and with the latest, let's say, friction between China and D.S., that pushed D.S. to scrap the de minimis tax exemption, or tariff exemption, on goods. Will that have any effect on your air freight operations down the road, or is the volume you move not connected to, or not driven by, any de minimis exemptions at all when it comes into D.S.?
Jens Lund
executiveI think this is really a two-part question. What I'd say is that our volume on these platforms is quite limited. They themselves contract capacity to a very large extent. That doesn't mean we don't necessarily have something in the gateway here or there, but it's really immaterial. So when you look at this market, how does it work? I think it's fair to say they have a disruptive business model. It's a marketplace where a manufacturer producing a certain commodity can present that commodity on a marketplace that makes it visible to a buyer in another country. And then they cut out the local commodity buyer in China, they cut out the wholesale, they cut out the retailer. They cut out all of these parts. And what that means is, let's say you want to buy a T-shirt and it normally costs, let's say, $50, then perhaps you can buy it for $10 instead. And of course, you can then put some duty on it and then it costs $15. Then if the consumer still looks at it, they will still save $35, if you look at it. And I think that's the dynamic that drives the e-commerce part.
Jens Lund
executiveAnd once that starts, it's genuinely tough to halt. Beyond that, my sense is these portals are about to get swamped with cargo as well. A lot of Chinese manufacturers have relocated outside China into other jurisdictions, too. From those locations, they may end up generating the volume. As I said regarding Ocean Freight, Vietnam—not China—is now the biggest origin point for shipments into the U.S. I expect the same pattern to play out here. A new norm will emerge, and then things will carry on. As far as we're concerned, though, whatever we do on this front isn't material.
Marc Zeck
analystOK, fair enough. Moving to the second question, again about Road. I suppose what came up was discussed far more intensely than before. To really get a handle on what's happening: does the automotive sector essentially give you a baseload volume for your <<inaudible>> business? And is that partly why the leverage, or the operating leverage, came out negative in Q4? And looking ahead to next year, I don't see much improvement in the unbilled motive industry, or on the tariff uncertainty, which is still going on. So can you substitute this baseload volume — if it truly is baseload volume — with other industries? Or, if the European automotive industry is permanently impaired, does keeping that group business really make sense when the baseload volume is there?
Jens Lund
executiveThis isn't part of the group's business. It's a dedicated operation tied to the factories we're discussing. But when you run that kind of operation, you need to have capacity on hand. Take rail volume, for instance — you pay for the rail whether you use it or not, and that could be the case here, if we get very specific about it. There are other areas with similar situations too. If they then shut those factories down for a longer stretch, you run into this problem. That's also what I explained — we contracted in that way, for example, and that had been the norm. Now, of course, things are more volatile, so we have to work out how to address this. What can we produce, and where do we take on exposure that we don't get paid for? So — but don't confuse it with the group's network. It's separate from, what can I say, milk run activities — the type of activities you basically do for this. And that's not the only place where shutdowns have occurred.
Jens Lund
executiveBut of course, that's a space where you'd have considerable capacity of the kind I'm referring to at this moment. So I hope that's clear for you. There's nothing sort of — overlap with our group's network is quite limited. Many kinds of cargo make up the group's network, and it isn't really tied to milk run activity.
Operator
operatorPeter Sehested of ABG has the next question.
Peter Sehested
analystIf we have the time, I think I'll just go with one question then. On the Schenker integration — could you share some high-level thoughts about the 2 integration components? First, IT. Second, what's possible on the warehousing side as well, in that respect — so on IT, you mentioned that Schenker has some very large IT tech clients. And assuming they're actually the global distributor for one of those, and they're probably very, very tied to their Tango system — could you give us some preliminary thoughts at this point on how we should view the IT integration competitor piece? I think the last one you completed in 12 months, but it seems this time we'll have to have some much tougher discussions, since you're dealing with clients that may be strategic for both you and Schenker. And on the warehousing — sorry, the Road and Solutions side. I mean, do we simply look at where the sites are, as you're shutting something down? You might close warehouses, consolidating them. But I think it's all — so my question is: will there be a sort of overall optimum parcel that you're trying to solve when you combine those 2 warehousing/terminal real estate businesses?
Peter Sehested
analystAnd how should we think about that—either conceptually, to gauge the potential for revenue synergies here? Sorry.
Jens Lund
executiveYes. There are a few complicated elements here. Let me take your last question first, just so we can close that out. You're right that, as I mentioned, this actually isn't — it isn't a threat. What it is, is a chance for us now to rightsize the 2 companies by bringing them together at the activity level currently seen in the market. So we work out what's required, and then in essence we're able to rightsize that. That's a standard part of the exercise: what capacity do we need, and then fundamentally, how should our infrastructure look at that point, and what do we have versus what do we need to develop, if that turns out to be the case. Then we've got the right tool for a highly productive staff, so they can deliver good service to our customers. So that's the one point I think is definitely spot on relative to what you're asking about. That's what we're going to do. On the IT side, I think what we have at DSV that is exceptionally strong is our integration platform. From there we integrate to the customers. We're already integrated with many of the customers. We haven't seen Schenker's customer list, but we do, of course, have a pretty good idea who our competitors are on the various customers.
Jens Lund
executiveWe're already integrated with a lot of them, so those flows can be shifted over to DSV. And honestly, our system is strong enough that we can build an integration to the Schenker platform quite quickly, and then send the volumes back into their system. That gives us both time and flexibility to plan how we want to produce those volumes going forward. I think that's also — we've actually backfilled, what can I say, other systems over the years when we've acquired companies. And I think with Schenker we'll be able to do this as well. It's a common methodology within our company. So I think that should work out. Actually, I think many of the customers you're alluding to, we produce volumes for them too. Our exposure is just smaller, but it's a similar type of activity. So I think the integration we have will also be able to cater for the things that Schenker does. Otherwise, we have — we will have — we've hired almost 250 extra people to do integration. We probably have in DSV and Schenker all together that we can sort of make available for the integration task as well another 250 people.
Jens Lund
executiveWe'll have 500 people, and then we'll have a road map so we prioritize the most important things. Then you asked about the timeline — given that Schenker is somewhat larger than, for example, the last acquisition we did <<inaudible>>, it will probably take a little more than 12 months this time, because there are more countries, more customers, and more activity. But I don't think it will take more than 2 years to do the same thing on the Air and Ocean side — and I specifically say Air and Ocean here — so then basically, it should be integrated. It should be functioning as one company, and the planning, the plans for that, and the capacity we need should be in place. And I think we might find that we have many overlapping customers, where we may have less volume than Schenker, also where we have more, but we can utilize basically the integration platform we have. This is our strength, our integration platform. It has an enormous value.
Peter Sehested
analystI just want to add on to what I asked first — what, roughly, how long would it be before you get to, say, an optimal network configuration across the road and logistics real estate infrastructure?
Jens Lund
executiveOn the road side, I'd say it usually takes around 3 years or so to reach that point. So naturally, you tackle the most critical items first. But there may be situations where you need to build something. Still, you'll capture plenty of benefits early on, and then, naturally, with contract logistics, if consolidation into some large facility is truly required, that could take somewhat longer—though a lot of things can be accomplished quite fast. Thanks so much for tuning in. I believe we've gone past our time. So many thanks for your interest, and thanks to all the DSV employees who are likely listening as well. Thank you for what you did in '24. It's genuinely appreciated. We're set for '25. I think the company is well positioned. And we look forward to talking with all of you on our next quarterly call. Thank you so much. Have a great day. Take care.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, that brings us to the end of the conference. Thank you for selecting Chorus Call, and thank you for taking part in the conference. You can now disconnect your lines. Goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete DSV A/S transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to DSV A/S earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in DSV A/S or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.