Edison International (EIX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 27, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Sam Ramraj
executiveThanks, Michelle, and good afternoon to everybody. Pedro Pizarro, our President and Chief Executive Officer, and Maria Rigatti, our Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, are the presenters on today's call. Additional members of the management team are also with us. You can find materials for today's call at www.edisoninvestor.com, including our Form 10-K, the prepared remarks from Pedro and Maria, and the teleconference presentation. Our regular business update presentation will be sent out tomorrow. We will be making forward-looking statements on this call regarding the outlook for Edison International and its subsidiaries. Actual results could differ materially from what is currently expected. Key factors that might cause different results appear in our SEC filings. Please review those carefully. Certain outlook assumptions, along with a reconciliation of non-GAAP measures to the closest GAAP measure, are included in the presentation. When we get to the question-and-answer session, kindly restrict yourself to one question plus one follow-up. Pedro, I'll hand the call over to you now.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThanks, Sam, and good afternoon to all of you. Edison International today announced core EPS for 2019 of $4.70, versus $4.15 during the prior-year period. The rise in core EPS stemmed mainly from the 2018 General Rate Case being approved along with increased FERC revenues; those gains were partly counterbalanced by greater wildfire mitigation expenses and a larger number of shares outstanding. Maria is going to walk through our financial results in greater depth when she speaks. Our view is that SCE and California enter 2020 facing a wildfire risk profile that looks quite different from what we saw in the two preceding years. Edison specifically applauds the State's work on suppressing wildfires and the better coordination that now exists among utility, state and local emergency management personnel; in addition, the State's passage of Assembly Bill 1054 brought stability to the financial condition of California's investor-owned utilities; we have been gratified by how the AB 1054 regulatory framework has continued to be implemented; that encompasses last year's issuance of our safety certification, the selections made for the new California Catastrophe Response Council and Wildfire Safety Advisory Board, and the 2020 to 2022 Wildfire Mitigation Plan we filed not long ago. We also take encouragement from the CPUC's prompt approval of SCE's 2020 Cost of Capital application and the proposed schedule for SCE's 2021 General Rate Case. Even so, plenty of work still lies ahead; where SCE is concerned, that specifically means securing decisions on proceedings still pending before the CPUC. Those include the Grid Safety and Resiliency Program settlement, SCE's Wildfire Expense Memorandum Account application, the capital structure waiver application tied to how we accounted for our 2017 and 2018 charges, and the litigation across the various phases of SCE's 2021 GRC application. On top of that, during 2020 SCE anticipates continuing to collaborate with legislators, regulators and communities to enhance public safety power shutoff, or PSPS, related operations. Simultaneously, we continue advancing our vision of a sustainable and clean energy future. I'll say more on that subject later. Over the last year, SCE carried out aggressively the comprehensive wildfire mitigation strategy set forth in our Grid Safety and Resiliency Program and 2019 Wildfire Mitigation Plan. Since 2018, SCE has put in place over 500 miles of covered conductor, in excess of 480 micro weather stations and more than 160 high-definition cameras spanning 90% of high fire risk areas, which represents our effective saturation point for cameras; we managed to exceed the compliance targets contained in our 2019 WMP across many areas as we strive to lower wildfire risk as rapidly as we can. We likewise finished enhanced inspection of the entirety of our overhead infrastructure located in high fire risk areas across the first 5 months of the year. Previously, such work would have taken place across a 5-year period. The 2020 to 2022 Wildfire Mitigation Plan SCE filed recently will push our risk-prioritization approach further ahead. Included in this plan are ground-based and aerial inspections of higher-risk transmission and distribution assets going beyond standard inspection cycles, which builds upon what we learned from our comprehensive enhanced overhead inspection program during 2019. Additionally, our strategy involves making infrastructure more resilient, strengthening our ability to maintain situational awareness, and improving how we operate, all while leveraging analytics and technology. Within this plan are particular measurements designed to give the public and other stakeholders visibility, and they will let the CPUC assess how SCE is performing. As part of our filing, SCE has put forward a proposed outlay of roughly $3.8 billion covering capital as well as O&M across the plan's 3-year span. Parts of our service area encountered numerous days last October when wildfire danger was heightened, characterized by strong winds, insufficient moisture and parched vegetation. Throughout those stretches, SCE applied our PSPS procedures to shield the public against the danger of electrical equipment igniting a fire. Following those PSPS incidents, patrols uncovered more than 40 effects caused by the harsh circumstances, among them harm to equipment and tree limbs coming into contact with power lines; this reinforced how vital preventive de-energization is as a protective step when weather turns severe. SCE recognizes that PSPS may create difficulties for our customers and communities; we mounted a broad community outreach campaign to assist customers in getting ready for such situations. We have taken lessons from what we experienced and are striving to strengthen our wildfire mitigation and PSPS resilience abilities. Safeguarding the public, our customers, employees and first responders remains our top priority. SCE has likewise devoted considerable time to informing customers, communities, and state and local government officials about our PSPS efforts, so they can see the enormous quantity of work and data analysis behind how we make PSPS decisions. With more mitigations put in place, we anticipate shrinking the reach and effect of PSPS, yet PSPS must stay in our toolkit for lowering wildfire danger when weather is severe and Fire Potential Index readings are high. I'd like to turn now to an update regarding our accounting reserve tied to the 2017 and 2018 wildfire and mudslide events. As you may remember, during the fourth quarter of 2018, SCE booked a gross liability of $4.7 billion representing the low end of the estimable loss range for those events; we routinely re-evaluate this reserve, which encompasses our internal evaluation of damage estimates, known and expected third-party claims, litigation proceedings and risks, and prior experience litigating and settling wildfire related claims; in our most recent evaluation, we raised the estimated losses for claims tied to the 2017 and 2018 wildfire and mudslide events by $232 million, bringing the gross estimate to $4.9 billion. Although this estimate is arrived at on an aggregate basis, certain factors we reviewed during the assessment led to a substantial rise in some loss estimates, while others led to a substantial drop. In addition, we reduced our accrued liabilities by the $360 million settlement reached during the fourth quarter with a number of local public entities; these adjustments resulted in a revised pre-tax accrued liability of $4.5 billion for the 2017 and 2018 wildfire and mudslide events. Once we adjusted that gross liability to account for $1.6 billion in remaining insurance coverage and $149 million tied to a FERC regulatory asset, the net after-tax charge stemming from these events comes to $1.98 billion — a $157 million rise over what we had previously estimated. Now I'd like to give you an update on how our operational and service excellence work is going, along with a handful of the key non-financial metrics our Board relies on when it gauges our performance. Safety for our workers and our communities is where operational and service excellence begins; it ranks as a major priority throughout our company and sits right at the top of our core values. Results for worker safety in 2019 were mixed. We had no employee fatalities, yet three workers in our contractor workforce lost their lives. And our hearts continue to go out through their families and loved ones. Serious injuries among SCE employees in 2019 dropped by over 50% compared with 2018, but our rate of injuries leading to days away, on restricted duty, or transferred — what we call the "DART" rate — came in worse than our target. Importantly, though, we did successfully finish an enterprise-wide safety culture training program that our employees have reviewed strongly and that lays the foundation for long-term improvement.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveWhen it comes to making the public safer, our objectives are linked to carrying out the wildfire resiliency steps laid out in our GSRP and the 2019 Wildfire Mitigation Plan. As I mentioned before, we moved forward considerably on those fronts. Customer satisfaction and system reliability, along with other important measures, came in below the targets we had set. Maintenance and repair work tied to wildfire mitigation, putting in new equipment to strengthen our electric system, and PSPS de-energizations that protect our communities when fire weather is dangerous all weighed heavily on how we performed. On top of that, we brought in more digital technologies to reshape processes throughout our business and to boost both the quality and efficiency of what we do. To illustrate, we introduced new mobile solutions that back up our improved overhead inspections, and we applied robotic process automation to make outage notifications to customers better. Sustainability remained a priority for us, especially tackling climate change. By 2030 we are committed to supplying 60% renewable power, and 100% clean energy by 2045 — goals that rank among the most aggressive anywhere in the industry. During the last quarter, I shared news of the release of our Pathway 2045 white paper, which demonstrates that the shifts needed throughout California's economy to reach the state's 2045 carbon neutrality goals will be profound; our focus is on doing our part, for instance by speeding up transportation electrification. Right now, SCE is carrying out the biggest electric truck and transit utility initiative anywhere in the country, installing charging infrastructure to serve roughly 8,500 medium- and heavy-duty vehicles across 870 sites by 2024, under our $356 million Charge Ready Transport program; in addition, we are waiting on CPUC approval for our $750 million Charge Ready 2 application, which would support more than 50,000 passenger vehicle chargers; that may sound like a lot, but we think it represents only a sliver of the new technologies and infrastructure California's economy will require in the years to come, which makes the case even stronger for utilities that are resilient and financially sound. In closing, we are committing substantial near-term investment to grid hardening and resiliency. Meanwhile, we keep seeing considerable long-term investment opportunities in our business tied to meeting California's 2045 climate goals. We have a robust capital program for the next few years that, if it gets approved, will put more than $5 billion annually into infrastructure replacement, transportation electrification, transmission infrastructure and wildfire mitigation. As you can see, we maintain an ongoing emphasis on safety and resiliency, operational excellence and strategic advancement of policy objectives. Our near-term priorities for improving safety and reducing wildfire risk will make possible the reliable and resilient grid required to move faster toward the state's clean energy goals and realize our Pathway 2045 vision for California, including greater use of zero-carbon resources and widespread electrification of the economy. With that, Maria will provide her financial report.
Maria Rigatti
executiveThanks, Pedro, and good afternoon, everyone. In my remarks today, I'll address results for the fourth quarter and full-year 2019, along with our forecast for capital expenditure and rate base, plus 2020 EPS guidance and the financing framework. As we've noted, comparing 2019 to the prior year on a year-over-year basis carries less meaning because of when the 2018 GRC decision landed. Kindly go to Page 2; for Q4 2019, Edison International posted core earnings of $0.99 per share, an amount $0.05 above the equivalent period a year earlier. Looking at the table on the right, you'll note SCE's core EPS variance came in at positive $0.07 versus the prior year. The main driver was $0.17 of greater EPS from SCE core activities, partly offset by $0.10 of dilution stemming from more shares outstanding. A handful of items explain most of the EPS variance at SCE. First, revenues came in higher, producing a positive variance of $0.32; the primary drivers were $0.19 of increased CPUC revenues, mostly reflecting the GRC escalation mechanism and reduced income tax benefits returned to customers through our tax balancing account, which gets offset within income taxes. FERC revenues generated a positive variance of $0.13, owing to greater expenses, growth in rate base, and a higher ROE following the 2019 settlement of the 2018 Formula Rate proceeding. Greater O&M expenses dragged year-over-year EPS down by $0.03. That was mostly the result of more spending on wildfire mitigation. I'll say more on that topic when we get to full-year variances. In the quarter, we booked a $0.05 charge for the self-insured retention tied to our wildfire insurance, mainly associated with 2019 wildfires; we classified this charge as core so we stay consistent with our treatment of deductibles for expenses that insurance covers. Greater net financing costs from additional borrowings produced a negative $0.03 impact. We also saw a $0.07 reduction in income tax benefit, which chiefly reflects tax benefits captured via our tax balancing account, as mentioned earlier. EIX Parent and Other recorded a negative $0.02 core variance for the quarter. That was mostly attributable to $0.07 of greater interest expense from additional borrowings, partly offset by a positive $0.05 variance at Edison Energy stemming from the 2018 goodwill impairment. Kindly go to Page 3; on a full-year basis, Edison International core earnings per share rose $0.55 to $4.70 per share; this figure includes a $0.59 improvement in core earnings at SCE, partly offset by $0.04 of greater EIX Parent and Other costs. Although the full-year and fourth quarter earnings analyses line up pretty closely, I'll call out a few areas. You'll observe a positive $0.20 impact from applying the 2018 GRC decision retroactively, which was recorded in Q2; in addition, we have positive $0.13 in FERC revenues tied to SCE's 2018 Formula Rate settlement, which includes $0.10 that we recorded in the third quarter. To wrap up the year, we saw a favorable income tax variance of $0.14, mainly tied to benefits returned to customers via the tax balancing account, which had no effect on earnings. Turning to wildfire mitigation work specifically, across the full year we booked $519 million of expenses into the related memo accounts. For $400 million of that spending — the portion bearing the closest resemblance to past precedents — we recorded regulatory assets. As you're aware, a regulatory asset gets recorded only where objectively verifiable precedent for recovery exists. For the remaining $119 million, pre-tax, no regulatory asset was recorded, and I'd like to give some added context on these amounts, which show up in O&M expenses for the year. The magnitude of this mitigation push differs from anything in our history, and certain activities lack any historical precedent. Over the course of the year, we needed to bring on more crews, more project management staff and additional human resources to carry out our wildfire mitigation programs; we also managed and sequenced the work so risk could be reduced as fast as possible, which likewise pushed costs higher. The greater volume of work that produced rises in crew, human resource and execution costs across high fire risk areas also produced higher costs in areas not designated as high fire risk. We lack precedent in which incremental cost effects within one program or geography generate incremental costs elsewhere; therefore, regulatory assets were not recorded for every cost incurred, especially those incremental costs in non-high fire risk areas. Even so, through separate tracks of the 2021 GRC, SCE is pursuing full recovery of these costs. Page 4 presents SCE's capital expenditure forecast. It covers CPUC-jurisdictional GRC capital expenditures, certain non-GRC CPUC capital spending and FERC capital spending. Between 2020 and 2023, our forecast is for a robust capital program of $19.4 billion to $21.2 billion; that's roughly $200 million above our prior forecast, driven mostly by greater spending on wildfire mitigation. In January, the CPUC lengthened the GRC cycle, adding a fourth year for SCE and other large utilities. Consequently, SCE must file an amendment to its 2021 GRC application adding an attrition year for 2024; we await further direction from the Commission regarding when this amendment is due. Page 5 presents SCE's rate base forecast. Under the capital expenditure levels sought in the 2021 GRC, total weighted-average CPUC and FERC jurisdictional rate base rises to $41 billion by 2023. Covering two rate case periods, that amounts to a 6-year compound annual growth rate of 7.5% at the request level. To generate a range of outcomes, management applies a 10% reduction to the rate base forecast, drawing on our historical experience with previously authorized amounts and other operational considerations. At that level, SCE's rate base forecast shows a compound annual growth rate of 6.6%. On pages 6 and 7, you'll find the guidance we're providing for 2020, along with the main assumptions you'll want for modeling. Just as we've done before, we'll start with earnings from rate base. That figure captures the CPUC-jurisdictional rate base that was authorized in the 2018 GRC, plus the ROE and capital structure the 2020 Cost of Capital decision recently approved; we reached a settlement in the 2018 transmission rate case, and that rate stayed in effect through early November 2019; even so, the case that followed hasn't been resolved yet, so we needed to assume something about the FERC ROE for 2020. FERC's method for setting ROE has shifted several times in recent years, as you're aware, and it's still not settled — right now FERC is weighing rehearing requests concerning the MISO Order. Our view is that approaches yielding FERC ROEs below those at the state level will lead to investment choices that aren't optimal. For the moment, our guidance assumes a 2020 FERC ROE roughly on par with our CPUC ROE of 10.3%. One more point: when determining revenues, FERC has traditionally relied on recorded capital structure. For 2020 that's projected at 47%, and it gets no benefit from the CPUC exclusions tied to AB 1054 or other items. Using the actual 2019 weighted average share count of 339.7 million, those elements produce a rate base EPS outlook of $5.17. Now let's turn to SCE operating and financial variances, which are additive to rate base earnings.
Maria Rigatti
executiveWe're looking at a net contribution of $0.20, and that's below what came through in some prior years. A few things are behind this. First off, the CPUC cost of capital ruling went into effect January 1, as I noted before, and both the embedded cost of debt and preferred equity got trued up to actual, so the financing benefits we used to get came down. On operations, we continue to hold down costs, which in the end benefits our customers; even so, $0.14 in costs related to wildfire mitigation work outweighed other items, such as AFUDC, more than it typically has. Like I mentioned earlier, we'll pursue recovery of those incremental costs, which we book in wildfire memo accounts. Having acknowledged that, absent any prior example to reference, we aren't factoring in the possibility that the accounting criteria for deferral will be met. We anticipate that in 2021 the burden tied to wildfire mitigation efforts will be eliminated, given that those expenses are part of the 2021 GRC revenue request. Additionally, we've factored in $0.02 tied to anticipated energy efficiency earnings. Shifting to the right side of the chart, SB 901 and AB 1054 contained specific elements that don't get recovered through rates. Within our 2020 guidance, we call attention to the annualized interest expense cost linked to the wildfire insurance fund contribution, along with the non-recovery of disallowed executive compensation; combined, these create a total drag of $0.10. To wrap up, regarding EIX Parent and Other, we anticipate a total drag of $0.41. That figure includes holdco and other operating expenses, which remain at the roughly $0.01 per month pace we previously communicated, amounting to $0.14 for the year. The remaining $0.27 reflects the after-tax interest cost, which incorporates the anticipated effect of the $400 million debt issuance that forms part of the 2020 financing plan. When it comes to share count dilution in 2020, there are two components. The first component is the full-year impact of shares issued in 2019, which translates to $0.30. The second component is the impact tied to the $800 million equity issuance in 2020. That adds a further $0.09 of dilution to the 2020 EPS guidance we're giving you. In a moment, I'll walk through the 2020 financing plan tied to the debt and equity assumptions we've built into that guidance. Taking it all together, our 2020 EPS guidance comes to $4.47 per share, with a range of $4.32 to $4.62 per share. That band is a bit wider than what we've used before, which gives us room for the many items being worked out through proceedings outside our standard General Rate Case. If you'll go to Slide 8, we'll talk about the reasoning behind our 2020 funding plan and our longer-term outlook. What we want to do is lay out the specifics for 2020 and give you a framework that shapes how we think about the longer term. Over the last couple of years, we've had to deal with a number of unusual matters that shaped how we approached financing, one being the contribution to the Wildfire Insurance Fund. One constant has been the sheer amount of capital required to harden the grid and prepare for a clean energy future. As we've said previously, SCE expects to spend approximately $5 billion annually on capital projects over the next several years. Carrying out those capital programs while maintaining investment grade ratings at both SCE and EIX sits at the heart of our framework. That principle guides our 2020 financing plan and will continue to guide us over the longer horizon, given that we target a long-term FFO-to-debt ratio of 15% to 17%. We also anticipate a time when that ratio will help support an upgrade, once the rating agencies’ perspective on wildfire risk and their overall California view keeps getting better; this longer-term ratings framework affects our near-term financing plan. First, we are putting substantial sums toward wildfire mitigation and wildfire insurance, and those sums are not yet recovered through rates. Although we anticipate the Commission will start tackling some of those sums this year, and although such spending adds operational risk mitigation, these items will keep pressuring our near-term credit metrics until the proceedings wrap up and the balances come down. Next, while virtually no payouts have been made on claims from the 2017 and 2018 incidents, some rating agencies are assigning us imputed debt that reflects their own estimates of what those claims will cost. Given this approach and these considerations, our 2020 holdco financing strategy includes $800 million of equity, of which $600 million is designated for SCE's growth capital requirements. The remaining $200 million continues the equity plan we announced in 2019, which we anticipate wrapping up this year. We have the flexibility to address this entire equity requirement through several avenues, including our ATM and internal programs. As noted earlier, the plan also includes $400 million of debt. Throughout 2019, we invested a substantial amount of capital to meet our customers' requirements, and we anticipate that trend will continue. In light of the utility's rate of expansion, our dividend payout ratio, our present credit ratings—supported by the equity issuance planned for 2020—we foresee only limited equity requirements to support our continuing capital expenditures beyond 2020. Regarding expenses tied to wildfires, this financing approach also depends on the cost recovery we have requested for the memorandum accounts, the liability amounts currently recorded on our balance sheet related to the 2017 and 2018 wildfire and mudslide incidents, and SCE's capital structure waiver request being resolved promptly. If those wildfire-linked projections shift in a major way, we'll revisit what our balance sheet needs to look like, applying the identical approach that shaped this year's and last year's strategies — in other words, we'll work to keep our investment grade ratings intact, and how we handle financing will serve that same objective. That's everything I had to cover.
Sam Ramraj
executiveMichelle, could you please start the Q&A portion now? Just a quick note — we're asking everyone to stick to a single question plus one follow-up, which gives each person waiting a chance to speak.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHello, Praful.
Praful Mehta
analystThanks so much. Hi, guys.
Maria Rigatti
executiveHi.
Praful Mehta
analystApologies — I was on several calls at once, so if I ask something you've already covered, my bad. What I'd like to get a handle on is where things stand with the wildfire mitigation work: how would you characterize your feeling about 2020 compared with 2019, when it comes to what's actually being done on the ground? And on the wildfire side, with all the risk involved, how do you see the Wildfire fund holding up in terms of being sufficient?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSure, thank you, Praful — yours is the opening question, so I can say you aren't repeating anything. Regarding the preparations I brought up in my remarks, quite a bit of effort has gone into them. We believe that definitely helps keep pushing things forward when it comes to mitigation and bringing risk down. What matters, though, is that this isn't only about what we're doing — it's also about what the state is doing, along with other entities. And honestly, there's more awareness statewide now regarding preventing fires and being ready for them. So on our previous earnings call, I think I noted that as we got through most of 2019, one of the main elements in the picture — beyond our own efforts, the early phases of things such as covered conductor or replacement, and the effect of PSPS that we observed — I already said in my remarks that following the large October wave, we logged more than 40 instances of problems that might have become ignitions but didn't, thanks to our use of PSPS; yet I noted on that call that we'd witnessed an extraordinary shift in the state's ability when it comes to suppressing fires; plus the effect of the governor's moves to boost the state budget for more firefighters and equipment, and faster response, which mattered a great deal in 2019. Looking ahead to 2020 now — I'm not sure if you know this, but in his budget proposal for 2020, the governor discussed adding yet more firefighting resources, I think 625 people, across the coming 5 years, with a sizable portion of that coming in 2020. So the point is that it isn't solely our efforts — the State's work in areas such as fire suppression contributes too. As for giving you a quantitative answer on the funds, that's more difficult. Let me remind you that while AB 1054 was under debate, the state — I believe via the governor's team — produced analysis indicating a 94% probability that the fund would last at least 10 years, assuming various things. I think that included an idea that across those 10 years, utilities and others would keep getting better at reducing risk. So I'm not able to give you a quantitative figure for what that translates to, like what percentage of risk gets reduced, but what I can say is this: our position this year is considerably stronger than it was 1 year ago or 2 years ago. That being said, the risk isn't zero, and my view is that it will never reach zero, given how things actually are in California.
Praful Mehta
analystUnderstood. Understood. That response was, as usual, quite thorough, so I'm grateful for it. Now, turning just briefly to the equity question, we hear about the $800 million requirement; however, when I consider the road ahead beyond the 2020 period, do you foresee a continuing need for equity tied to SCE's equity requirements, or do you intend to hold holdco debt roughly level? What's the right way to frame the equity requirements that will persist after 2020 as we move forward?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes. Praful, it's Maria here. What I believe we're attempting to present for each is essentially that framework in which, over the long run, our targets will be those metrics — 15% to 17% FFO to debt. When we consider the capital program tied to the capital program, at those levels we in fact anticipate minimal equity ahead. I'm trying to nail down a highly specific figure, so this isn't a very numerical answer, but for that we simply don't truly anticipate any need for meaningful fresh equity. On a separate note, we did — I mentioned just now, we also established particular assumptions regarding wildfire matters, be it recovery on minimal accounts, the magnitude of liabilities connected to those wildfires, the capital structure waiver. Should we observe substantial shifts in those areas, we will reassess our balance sheet requirements, once more inside that 15% to 17% metric framework.
Praful Mehta
analystUnderstood. Thanks, everyone. There are plenty more questions I have, so I'll rejoin the queue. I appreciate that.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHey, thank you, Praful.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHello, Steve.
Steve Fleishman
analystHey there, good afternoon. I've got a question about that capital structure waiver request. My understanding is PG&E has something comparable. Can you bring us up to speed on whether there's any way to tell when that's probably going to move forward? Also, is there genuine pushback against it, or is it simply a matter of waiting for a response?
Maria Rigatti
executiveLet me give a bit of background here. Back in February of last year, when we recorded the charge, we submitted that filing. What we sought through the capital structure waiver involved two items — first, that the charge itself be left out when calculating our capital structure. Second, any debt tied to paying liabilities or claims would likewise be left out of the capital structure until the commission decides whether we'll be granted recovery for it. That request has been sitting pending for some time. Various comments have come in from interveners, and a number of those have been around for a while. In fact, certain interveners stated they believed our request had not yet ripened at that point, since we remain in compliance with the 37 month average. During our cost of capital proceeding, the ALJ essentially delayed it somewhat. After the decision came, we were each asked to respond to a specific question, and not every one of those was especially pertinent to us. A portion of them had more to do with PG&E, mainly concerning whether a fixed date ought to be established at which the waiver ceases to apply. There were also particular consequences for customers. We submitted those comments — I believe they weren't part of your reply comments — in response to those; after that, the commission established a deadline, or rather their regulatory processes require them to deliver a decision by August. Naturally, they can exercise discretion about whether to push that back; that's where things stand as of now; we have no date for when we'll get an answer. As long as we haven't received the waiver, we'd be considered in compliance; and if you take our current figures and work out where we stand, even calculating it without the waiver, we satisfy the 37 month rolling average.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right. Then I have one more item. If we examine the 2020 variances — sorry, I mean the ones tied to SCE, as you noted, the incremental wildfire amount of $0.14, ideally there would be a recovery during 2021, and you've gotten through the GRC. On the financial operating side, apart from the $0.32, not that exact figure necessarily, but it's been sitting there for quite some time. So my assumption is that some portion of it ought to keep persisting?
Maria Rigatti
executiveA lot of items fall into that category; financing benefits are among them, and those genuinely shift periodically. This year they would have moved since we modified the embedded costs of debt and equity as a result of the capital — cost of capital proceeding decision. Each year, whenever a new rate case comes along, benefits get returned to customers. So we keep working to truly control our expenses, since that generally assists us regarding system average rate and the way we carry out all of our capital plans too. Thus we can indeed handle things across those areas. However, the mix will look different at various points, and it's possible for things to rise and fall simply because we're beginning a fresh rate case cycle.
Steve Fleishman
analystGreat. Thank you.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThanks, Steve.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystHey, good afternoon.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHey, Julien.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analyst<<inaudible>> hi there. So I'd like to dig a bit deeper into the credit metrics, and get a handle on that 15% to 17% FFO-to-debt metric. First, where do you stand right now? And second, how much latitude do you see around that metric? Say, across a range of scenarios, and particularly when it comes to some of the imputation matters you already brought up. Let me put it in simpler terms: how are you approaching the possibility that the rating agencies impute some amount of liability? And how do you view the latitude you have at present, more or less on a continuing basis? To revisit what Steve raised earlier regarding the fluctuations you're seeing and how things might appear once adjusted to a more typical baseline — I'll hand things over to you now.
Maria Rigatti
executiveAll right. So I believe the initial matter to address is our level of comfort with those liabilities being imputed — I assume that's happening ahead of the termination — and whether recovery will actually come through. Naturally, we've been engaged in a great deal of continuous dialogue with the rating agencies on this topic. And as I see it right now, since — once more, much like the obligation we have to record the charge without being able to offset it with a regulatory asset — there simply isn't a President in this situation. From what I can tell, until there's evidence of real expense recoupment, the rating agencies won't loosen their stance and stop assigning that debt weight. As the commission makes further moves, that dialogue can probably keep going with them, but at this moment their position stands. That's simply how it is. As for how we stack up against our mentoring, let me be completely candid: at present, our metrics are somewhat strained. A big part of that comes down to this: we aren't seeing same-period recovery for those wildfire mitigation costs or for the wildfire insurance, since a large share of those dollars are tied to capital, yet we also have a substantial amount tied to O&M, which typically would be recovered much faster — basically right away. I believe we've been talking about this and keeping up a dialogue with the rating agencies on it too. And my sense is that they get it. As I mentioned near the end of what I said before, the financing approach rested on a few key assumptions, and one of them was that we'd get those account balances back on schedule. If it starts looking like things are heading another way, then we'll need to take another look at that plan.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystUnderstood. Let me see if I can get a quick clarification on that. Based on what you just described, is it essentially the case that the $0.14, for example, of income related to wildfire mitigation costs? Is that what you mean by timely recovery here, mainly within those variances? And then second, returning to your earlier comment, are you hinting at securitization, or when you consider what would make you comfortable here, is it simply a matter of being able to successfully draw on this newly established fund?
Maria Rigatti
executiveSo on that last part, I'll ask you to clarify; but regarding your first question, on the $0.14, it isn't only the $0.14 — I recognize nobody has looked at our 10-K yet, but if you do, we're actually under a cover at present of roughly $868 million. So the $0.14 that appears in 2020 guidance represents the amounts that don't have a regulatory asset recorded against us. As of the end of 2019, we're already partly in — there are items for which we do have regulatory assets on the books as well. Cash paid out that we hadn't yet collected totals approximately $868 million; so it's all of the above.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystThat makes sense. Then the other item there was simply, when you mentioned that the credit rating agencies had to become comfortable here, was that regarding your capacity to access the front end and actually pull that off successfully?
Maria Rigatti
executiveNo, no. I’m not becoming comfortable with the cash flow from these <<inaudible>> accounts and so on, being timely; that’s the whole thing.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystAll right. To feel at ease, there’s really no need for you to draw on the fund or the securitization.
Maria Rigatti
executiveCorrect, none at all.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystAll right, my apologies. I wasn't trying to …
Maria Rigatti
executiveTo put it plainly, Julien, my sense is that confidence regarding California generally ought to build as time passes, and that will tie back to each of the elements you mentioned, though my remark was intended in a much narrower sense.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYeah, and I want to be sure this comes across clearly. At one point, if your FFO-to-debt landed between 15% and 17%, that would have pointed to a better credit rating than what you'd get now. What's happening is that a discount gets factored in based on how California risk is perceived. Our expectation is that, as time goes on and they observe AB 1054 being implemented steadily, with the machinery in place, that this also shows up as lower wildfire risk overall. We'd like to think that, over time, there will be some reassessment of the credit rating that a range like that suggests.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystExpectations, guys.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYes, thanks, Julien.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHello, Paul.
Paul Freeman
analystHey, thanks a lot. I believe you've clearly updated the lower-bound projection regarding wildfire risk. When do you think — at what stage might an estimate for the upper bound become available?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThat remains quite difficult. As we keep examining every relevant detail, I think, like I said during my remarks, we considered a wide array of elements while performing our evaluations; and just as I noted when we made this adjustment, certain items rose considerably, while others dropped considerably; so it's still hard for us to envision how we'd establish an upper bound; perhaps we won't ultimately be in a position to establish one. But, to illustrate, if we keep witnessing the resolution of these unknowns via either further settlements or litigation down the road in the regulatory proceedings, then once those components come together, you might — we would likely do what happened here, meaning that, with the $360 million settlement, that ambiguity is removed. And at this point we recognize — the spread could be tighter. We establish what the lower bound could be for the liabilities that remain; but to be straightforward with you, because of how these wildfire matters work and all their complexities, I can't say for certain whether we'd reach a stage where we could establish a strict 75% probability threshold under accounting standards, the upper end of the range. Maria, do you see that differently at all? Does that make sense, Paul?
Paul Freeman
analystYes. My assumption is that once you're actually disbursing those claims, you'll record an NOL that's at minimum equal to the write-off you booked back in 2018. Could you give us a sense of how long it might take for that NOL to show up?
Maria Rigatti
executiveWhen the charge was taken, we recorded the associated tax effects. Perhaps what you're really asking is when we'll start paying cash taxes? At this point — though naturally, future developments will shape this too — our current estimate is that EIX turns into a cash taxpayer at some point around 2027.
Paul Freeman
analystGreat; and perhaps that's my final question. In the past, regarding AFUDC, you've mentioned executive compensation, advertising, and charitable giving as offsets. Up to now, the sole offset I've heard about is executive comp. So is it fair to anticipate that the rest of the equity AFUDC should be recognized?
Maria Rigatti
executiveWe might be slightly missing each other's point here, but when we gave the walk for the 2020 guidance, we had all of those included — I'm aware that in the past, we tended to list a whole range of items sitting in those bars on the right side. That bar, which is a $0.20 net benefit, contains everything you just referenced; so it's not that they've disappeared. They're simply all in there. We pulled a few out to offer a bit more detail. And then to the right of that, AB 1054, SB 901 items, I'd describe those as more recent matters; they weren't part of what we historically talked about. But following the legislation, we recognize those are items we cannot recover, as the legislation specifies.
Paul Freeman
analystThen, looking ahead roughly 24 months past 2020, should we be thinking there won't be any significant offsets to that?
Maria Rigatti
executiveWhat we aimed to accomplish in putting that chart together was to point out items you may want to factor in, items that are recent; namely the SB 901 and AB 1054 matters, plus certain things we believe won't carry forward since, for instance, the added wildfire mitigation expenses for which we presently lack a rig asset, given that those will be folded into our 2021 GRC revenue. We'll keep doing what we've always done, working to control our costs, generating headroom that in the end helps our customers. So I'd say our method for running the business going forward remains unchanged. Our goal was simply to provide you with greater visibility into a few of these recent elements.
Paul Freeman
analystGreat. Thank you.
Michael Lapides
analystHi. I’m attempting to pose a question that simplifies things, which is: how do you think about the route toward what constitutes a normal earnings power, and how long does that take, roughly, and what are the main things that must occur to get you there?
Maria Rigatti
executiveSo I think one factor, Michael, is that what we’ve observed over the past few years is that more items are occurring outside the general rate case; we’ve always had balancing accounts, and those are actually beneficial. They’re quite constructive when it comes to things like visibility, etcetera. But what we have now, on top of the balancing accounts, which generally are cover amounts, that either have already been reviewed or we have substantial history with them when it comes to recovery — now we have a lot of memo accounts. And the memo accounts help us steer clear of a retroactive rate making issue, but they don’t truly give you visibility regarding when costs will hit. And we don’t yet have, in certain cases, the ability to say that they’re all probable of recovery or that 100% of them are probable recovery, because we lack historical precedent. So I think that we — and that was really what drove how we established the 2020 core earnings guidance. So you could begin to see some of those things more specifically. As we get into the next general rate case, and then you’ll see some of that — that variability fade because we will have things included in our revenue requirement, as opposed to now, where the ’18 and ’19 costs tied to wildfire mitigation are in a one track that gets decided in 2021, while the 2020 cost are going to be another track that gets decided after that. So I think we do need to move through and get into the next rate case cycle to have somewhat less variability and somewhat — a bit more clarity; but again, that’s why we tried to set up the guidance line the way that we did.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveAlso, Maria, let me mention something else, perhaps viewed from another perspective. A portion of the inconsistency you've noticed stems from our having gone through an extraordinary stretch of determining how to handle a significantly distinct form of wildfire danger, or greater degrees of risk, compared with what we grasped 3 years back. Consequently, many of the remarkable actions you've witnessed from our team demanded reliance on the <<inaudible>> () accounts, and so forth. Those actions have likewise recharacterized what work the utility must perform at a certain expense, which afterward has to be recouped. My expectation is that, as the wildfire mitigation plan process brings greater maturity, along with 1 or 2 additional years of hands-on experience, that ambiguity will keep shrinking where comprehension is concerned. Alright. This is the — this is the way we conduct utility operations today in a setting where wildfire risk is far greater. And that, as Maria pointed out, means greater predictability for both our company and investors regarding the sorts of investments and cost recovery items incorporated into rate cases and other proceedings. Thus they employed the terminology somewhat, shifting away from the new normal toward something that is genuinely normalized and stabilized.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. Then there’s another item I wanted to ask about — the settlement, that 360 you’re paying in municipals. I’m just wondering, how does that compare as a percentage of the initial ask, or the damages and claims they originally filed?
Maria Rigatti
executiveIt comes to roughly one-third of what they — their initial hope or expectation, I suppose.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. So what they submitted came to slightly more than $1 billion, and the resolution came at 360.
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes. Understood.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. All right, thanks a lot. That's very helpful.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveAppreciate it, Michael.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveJonathan, good to have you back in the circuit here.
Jonathan Arnold
analystAlright, thanks. It's good to be speaking with you again. Thank you, Pedro. I'm just wondering — and I realize you may not want to go here — but I'm curious if you could offer any insight into the sorts of items that have shifted within the accruals. You mentioned they moved — significant movements. Could you get any more granular, just so we have a clearer picture of how the process works?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYes. Unfortunately, no. The reason being, there are many components and pieces in there. From a disclosure standpoint, we've given the net amount; but we don't anticipate that we'll be giving all the components, certain parts on a continuing basis; so that's why I think the guidance has been to simply keep it at a high level; this won't answer your question, but you can picture the things that are in there and I won't — won't be in a position to share which ones increased or which ones decreased or which ones stayed flat. But this includes that the spreadsheet, so to speak, of items that we monitor include things such as, the size of claims, actual claims being filed keep shifting around. Additional facts that are being uncovered in the discovery process, it's those sorts of things that are the underlying elements across each of the cases; and then you have to add one more layer of complexity. Remember, it's not just one big set of cases. It's really individual action across all the different events; and so a lot of detail underneath each other. So it's a pretty massive, complex thing. And that's why rather than try and not do a justice, we're just keeping the disclosure to investors at a high level.
Adam Umanoff
analystOnce we look at the 10-K, should we expect anything different in how you generally describe your role in the different ignitions?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveI can't think of anything. As far as details on those events go, nothing materially new is being disclosed.
Maria Rigatti
executiveWhat's somewhat different now is that they've made it past the attorney general keeping that remark. Aside from that, though, we didn't — I'd say, to put it briefly, the iconic sign we're <<inaudible>>. Our position remains that our client had a role. Regarding the other ignition in the 2017 fire, we continue to hold the information in the air surrounding it, and the same disclosure from last quarter is what we'll see.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSo there isn't anything fresh that we have to share, but Maria, your point is valid. Perhaps you could say a bit more regarding the attorney general, if you would.
Maria Rigatti
executiveRight. So throughout the year, as we moved through this process, we now know that the California attorney general's office has wrapped up its review regarding Thomas. And there aren't — no criminal liability charges are going to be brought. And the evaluation will keep going.
Jonathan Arnold
analystAll right, excellent. Thanks for sharing that. I simply wanted to get some clarity regarding one of the earlier questions. It seemed as though there was an implication that you might be drawing on the fund. So I just want to confirm that I was discussing something entirely separate from the fund, correct?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThat's right, we have no intention of accessing the funds. During 2019, a handful of wildfires occurred within the area we serve. Mostly, we absorbed a modest charge related to a self-insured retention tied to those fires. However, that falls comfortably under our own commercial insurance coverage. Correct, there's no need for us to activate the fund, and to state it plainly, nothing has happened that would meet the criteria or call for doing so.
Jonathan Arnold
analystYeah. You were just mentioning the normal rebound <?>
Pedro Pizarro
executiveCorrect.
Maria Rigatti
executiveCorrect. Yes. Ok.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThanks, Jonathan.
Paul Patterson
analystHey, good afternoon.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHi, Paul.
Maria Rigatti
executiveHello.
Paul Patterson
analystMany of the things I wanted to ask have already been covered, so only a single item is left for me. In your 10-K, you touched briefly on how competitive things are for transmission projects. Our understanding was that the Diablo Canyon Gates project <<inaudible>> power. And I believe you said, regarding Mesa, that some portions of it could be somewhat out. I'm curious whether you could give us a sense of this — I'd assume, based on your ROE guidance and all of that, what sits in your plan is regulated projects. But what are you all observing when it comes to what takes place with the sort of for 1000 stuff that’s happening?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes. So in California, the planning regarding extra transmission that could be needed for additional solar, additional wind, whatever else, in order to reach the higher renewable — the higher green energy standard, that hasn't begun yet. Until the <<inaudible>> completes its transition planning, I believe it won't be evident yet precisely which projects will be necessary, what's required; so I think some time remains still to pass. I mean, you clearly know very well that, apart from those projects already sort of tied to our own facilities, such projects would typically go out for bid, and parties would take part and attempt to secure them on a competitive basis. But at this point, I think additional work is still needed to figure out which facilities are required.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveAlso, when what's required at a site is enhancing a line that's already there, we basically hold a right of first refusal over it. But in the case of a completely new line, that situation goes through the entire quarter <<inaudible>> process.
Paul Patterson
analystAll right. So, regarding when <<inaudible>> will put out that revised — the details concerning what their intentions are in relation to …
Pedro Pizarro
executiveOur understanding is that they haven’t kicked off that wide-ranging planning effort as of now. And that is likely something they’re considering with an eye toward roughly the 2030 period — that sort of horizon and, in fact, a milestone sale. From where I sit right now, I don’t believe we can provide a schedule.
Paul Patterson
analystOkay. Thanks so much.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYes. Thanks, Paul.
Sam Ramraj
executiveWe appreciate everyone being with us on this call. Should anything remain unclear, feel free to reach out by phone. That brings the conference call to an end. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone being on the call today, and we're grateful that you took part. At this point, you're free to hang up.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Edison International transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Edison International earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Edison International or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.