Edison International (EIX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 27, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Sam Ramraj
executiveThanks, Michelle, and hello everyone. With us today are Pedro Pizarro, our President and Chief Executive Officer, and Maria Rigatti, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Other members of the management team are joining us as well. I should note that our executives are participating in this call from various locations, so please be patient with us should any technical issues come up. The materials for today's call can be found at www.edisoninvestor.com, including a Form 10-Q, prepared remarks from Pedro and Maria, and the teleconference presentation. Our regular business update presentation will go out tomorrow. On this call, we'll be making forward-looking statements regarding the outlook for Edison International and its subsidiaries. Actual results may differ materially from current expectations. Key factors that could lead to different results are described in our SEC filings, and we ask that you read those carefully. The presentation contains certain outlook assumptions as well as reconciliations of non-GAAP measures to the closest GAAP measure. During the question-and-answer session, we ask that you keep to one question and one follow-up. I'll now hand the call over to Pedro.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThanks, Sam, and good afternoon to everyone. Edison International today announced core earnings per share of $1.67 for the third quarter of 2020 — that's $0.17 higher than the same quarter a year ago. The gain came mainly from increased CPUC-related revenue tied to the 2018 GRC escalation mechanism, along with reduced expenses from regulatory deferrals connected to wildfire mitigation work, though equity share dilution partly offset these. Given how strong our results have been so far this year and how confident we feel about the full-year outlook, we're tightening the 2020 guidance range to $4.47 to $4.62, lifting the bottom end by $0.10. Maria will go through our financial results in detail in her remarks. We continue to deal with the extensive impacts of COVID-19 on how we operate, on the people we serve, and on the places where we live. At the same time, we recognize that a changing climate is bringing about weather patterns never seen before and destructive wildfires throughout California, and right now the State is in the midst of another demanding fire season. Our thoughts are with the families and communities that have suffered, and we feel deep appreciation for the first responders who have put in such effort to bring the fires under control and protect both the lives and the property of Californians. Here at Edison, safety remains our highest and most important priority. SCE continues implementing steps aimed at reducing the danger of wildfires, working hand in hand with nearby first responders and emergency management officials, and maintaining frequent communication with its customers to raise awareness and promote readiness. As for California's legislative landscape, COVID-19 caused this year's session to be shortened. Legislators concentrated on the State's pandemic response and on lessening wildfire danger. A set of bills was signed by the Governor that build upon the State's spending on firefighting staff, along with technology and fuels management efforts. I'm also glad that 2 issues SCE pushed for — clarifying the AB 1054 insurance policy year and securing the chance to securitize revenue under collections and bad debt expense stemming from COVID-19 in 2020 — were both taken up by the Legislature, which passed Assembly Bill 913 unanimously. Throughout this fire season, we've witnessed near-record numbers of firefighters deployed to contain major wildfires across the State, with more than 19,000 first responders at the peak — the most since 2008. CAL FIRE crews, US Forest Service teams, and personnel from numerous cities and counties did exceptional work this year, even though major lightning-caused wildfire complexes and COVID safety requirements stretched them thin. That performance demonstrates the value of efforts made over the last couple of years to greatly increase firefighting capacity and improve modeling and forecasting of how fires spread, allowing better placement of ground and aerial resources. SCE's efforts to reduce wildfire risk complement the work of State and local agencies; for example, SCE has boosted its own awareness of conditions, along with that of local fire authorities, by installing 161 cameras. During late September, SCE provided $2.2 million to the Orange County Fire Authority so it could secure the largest heavy-lift helitanker anywhere in the world for this fire season — a helicopter capable of flying at night and dropping 3,000 gallons of water. That aircraft worked through the night and continued into today battling the Silverado fire in Orange County. As of this morning, per the Orange County Fire Authority's report, the blaze has burned over 11,000 acres, is 5% contained, and no structures have been destroyed. Tragically, 2 firefighters suffered serious injuries while combating the fire. Yesterday, SCE filed an electric safety incident report, or ESIR, concerning the Silverado fire. According to ESIR, nothing was happening on a nearby SCE power line, and there was no proof of fallen lines prior to the time the fire was reported to have begun. Even though SCE's probe is still in its early phase, I want to note that initial results suggest a lashing wire attached to a telecom line owned by a third party and situated under an SCE power line may have touched the SCE line above it, possibly sparking the fire. That being said, it is too soon to reach any firm conclusions. I have said before that covered conductor is the most effective and fastest way for SCE to reduce public safety risk by stopping ignitions that can cause catastrophic wildfires. SCE is still on schedule to hit or surpass the goal of 700 miles of covered conductor installed, which was set in the 2020 Wildfire Mitigation Plan. During the last year, our utility significantly upgraded its Public Safety Power Shutoff (PSPS) program. SCE has improved how it communicates and coordinates with Government and communities, and has gotten better at sectionalizing circuits, so that fewer customers are affected when a preventive de-energization is started. In addition to our work to help lower wildfire risk, the company keeps working to resolve litigation related to wildfires. As we mentioned on September 23, SCE settled all insurance subrogation claims connected to the Thomas and Koenigstein fires, and the Montecito Mudslides. Using that along with other data, we were able to move our accounting reserves from the bottom of the estimable range up to a best estimate, which gives investors more clarity on this matter and on our related equity need. Now, on regulatory actions at the CPUC, we're quite pleased to see timely decisions continuing and progress on our key filings as originally scheduled. That marks a meaningful improvement in action and progress under President Batjer's leadership. We commend the Commission and its staff for their ongoing efforts to keep proceedings on schedule, even with the challenges of the new remote working environment during the pandemic. In this quarter, the CPUC issued decisions in several of SCE's key filings. We've also secured the 2020 Safety Certification, gotten the Charge Ready 2 program, and had the WEMA application approved — that one authorizes $505 million for wildfire insurance cost recovery and backs keeping insurance treated as a reasonable cost of service. In addition, a proposed decision came through on our first AB 1054 CapEx securitization application, and we're seeing prompt movement on track 1 of the 2021 GRC proceeding. On top of that, SCE has arrived at a settlement-in-principle that would clear every outstanding issue in track 2 of the GRC. SCE joined a large group of other parties in filing its 2020 integrated resource plans. One central aim of this IRP is helping California meet its GHG reduction targets for 2030 and 2045. In the plan submitted by SCE, the commission was urged to set a 2030 target at 38 million metric tons, which would put California on a viable course toward meeting its decarbonization objectives. SCE additionally reaffirmed and underscored a substantial CAISO system capacity requirement of 5,400 megawatts across the 2024 to 2026 period, stemming from retirements of power plants that are already planned. As a way to address this, SCE proposed that the commission amend its methodology for reliability planning — including an increase in the planning reserve margin — so that it reflects more accurately how the state's electricity market is evolving and protects system reliability; such recommendations are consistent with what the CAISO, the CPUC, and the California Energy Commission concluded in their recent preliminary root cause analysis concerning the August rotating outages. During the past month, an executive order was signed by the governor which speeds up the schedule so that every new vehicle sold in California becomes emission-free by 2035. Such an order aligns with the Pathway 2045 effort of ours, in which electric vehicles hold a crucial role for achieving carbon neutrality. It makes me proud that Edison has been regarded as a thought leader on this subject. I want to emphasize how critical it is that we make the investments required at present to ensure a grid that is strong, safe, reliable, and resilient and that is capable of supporting the economy's expanding electrification. That opens up major chances to invest in meeting greater power demand and a more intricate grid—covering more distributed energy resources, larger shares of renewables, and energy storage. Just as importantly, our analysis shows this shift will also be affordable, since more efficient electric motors and appliances will reduce customers' overall costs across every energy commodity by one-third by 2045. With that, I'll pass it to Maria for her financial report.
Maria Rigatti
executiveThanks, Pedro. For the third quarter of 2020, Edison International posted core earnings of $1.67 per share, which is $0.17 per share higher than the same quarter a year earlier. The main driver of that gain was greater CPUC-related revenue stemming from the escalation mechanism under the 2018 GRC, along with reduced expenses tied to regulatory deferrals for wildfire mitigation work; equity share dilution partly offset these benefits. Given how solid our results have been through the first 9 months of the year, we are again tightening our guidance range by lifting the bottom end of our 2020 EPS estimate. I'll go into that further later in my remarks. Page 2 shows SCE's key EPS drivers on the right-hand side. There are four things I'd like to highlight that explain most of the variance. First, EPS increased $0.43 because of higher revenue. Revenue tied to the CPUC contributed $0.25 of that gain, driven by the escalation mechanism in the 2018 GRC decision. FERC and other operating revenue came in at a negative $0.05 variance, mostly due to the true-up for the 2018 Formula Rate case that we booked last year. We also saw a favorable variance of $0.23, largely associated with the balancing account for the GSRP settlement that was approved in April. That said, expenses connected to this variance offset it. Second, O&M showed a favorable variance of $0.08, primarily from recognizing lower wildfire mitigation expenses as a result of deferrals to regulatory assets. Third, income taxes subtracted $0.13, largely because we captured fewer tax benefits through our tax balancing account. Last, SCE's EPS for the quarter came in $0.16 lower due to dilution from a larger share count. Page 3 shows SCE's capital expenditure and rate base forecast. CapEx is unchanged from last quarter's forecast for 2021 through 2023, with a slight increase for 2020. We also revised the rate base forecast, mainly for Charge Ready 2 and GRC rebuttal testimony. We continue to see meaningful opportunities to expand rate base over time, driven by investments in electric infrastructure, and our strong capital program of $20 billion to $21 billion across this period reflects that. That requested level works out to a 7.6% compound annual growth rate for rate base over two rate case periods. Once we trim the total capital forecast by 10% — a haircut reflecting what we've seen with amounts approved in the past plus other operational factors — the bottom of the range still points to solid rate base growth of 6.6%. Kindly go to Page 4. Track 1 of the 2021 GRC proceeding has remained on timetable, and every associated brief was finished in the course of the quarter. A decision is what we're waiting on now, and our expectation remains that it arrives in first quarter 2021. As we've noted previously, SCE's core business will require only minimal equity to support our continuing capital expenditures program past 2020. Once the GRC gets final approval, we’ll be in a position to put numbers on those levels. Page 5 gives a summary of where SCE’s filings stand regarding cost recovery for incremental wildfire mitigation in 2018 and 2019. SCE received CPUC approval in April for the GSRP settlement, which allowed recovery of $476 million in capital along with $123 million of O&M. That decision authorized a revenue requirement of $159 million, which took effect in rates on October 1. The rest of the approved capital costs will be recovered through securitization of amounts related to wildfire mitigation, as permitted by AB 1054. In September, approval was granted for the WEMA application that sought recovery of $505 million for wildfire insurance costs. That amount now sits in rates and will be recouped over the coming 24 months. Notably, the CPUC's ruling observed that SCE had behaved reasonably and prudently in buying insurance coverage. The Commission further acknowledged that insurance against wildfire liability offers meaningful protection to customers facing third-party legal claims brought under the inverse condemnation doctrine, as well as allegations of negligence. Through these rulings, SCE can recover about $665 million in cash across the next 2 years, which further bolsters its balance sheet and credit metrics. Separately, the CPUC has recently come out with a proposed decision concerning SCE's request to securitize the GSRP capital mentioned earlier. When that financing closes, it will boost the cash position by roughly $335 million. SCE and every intervenor have arrived at a confidential settlement-in-principle that addresses all matters in Track 2 of the 2021 GRC. Once a definitive agreement is signed, a motion seeking approval will be submitted to the CPUC. SCE anticipates a proposed decision regarding the track 2 settlement during Q1 2021; the settlement's impact will be recorded after the commission takes action, and we do not anticipate any negative effect on earnings. I'd like to call attention to several other pending filings and upcoming applications tied to wildfire mitigation costs. To begin, a decision on our CEMA filing concerning certain drought and restoration costs is expected in the first quarter of 2021. We expect to submit a WEMA filing within the coming months covering excess insurance premium costs from July through December 2020. We'll also file our GRC track 3 in the first quarter of 2021, and a proposed decision should come about twelve months afterward. Regarding other regulatory developments this quarter, the CPUC gave approval to SCE's Charge Ready 2 program, which backs roughly 38,000 light-duty EV charging ports. That program ranks as the biggest light-duty EV charging initiative run by an investor-owned utility anywhere in the U.S., and it will contribute about $400 million to SCE's rate base by 2026. Moving to guidance, Pages 6 and 7 lay out our revised 2020 guidance along with the main assumptions you'll need for modeling. I want to point out that, by lifting the bottom of our full-year 2020 EPS guidance range, we are again tightening that range, now to $4.47 to $4.62 per share; doing so also pushes the midpoint of the EPS range up by $0.05, to $4.55. Our earnings assumptions are largely unchanged from the prior quarter, though a pair of items drive most of this upward adjustment. First, we now expect SCE earnings to land $0.04 higher than we had assumed before. Of that, $0.01 comes from better rate base earnings, and $0.03 comes from SCE variances related to the timing of financing activities as well as operational items. Second, our forecast for EIX Parent and Other is $0.01 better than our prior estimate; those items, together with our strong performance so far this year, leave us increasingly confident in the narrowed 2020 EPS guidance range. Last month we put out a news release regarding the September 2020 subrogation settlement, and we noted in it that we expect to issue roughly $1 billion of equity to invest in SCE, which would let the utility debt finance wildfire claims payments. Since then, many of you have asked about when that equity issuance will occur. As we told you, we'll give an update on the fourth quarter 2020 earnings call. When the equity issuance happens will depend on when future claims resolutions and payments above insurance occur. That wraps up our remarks.
Sam Ramraj
executiveMichelle, could you please start the Q&A portion? Just a quick reminder that we ask everyone to keep it to 1 question plus 1 follow-up, so that all those waiting in line get a chance to ask theirs.
Jonathan Arnold
analystGood afternoon, guys. Thank you.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHi, Jonathan.
Maria Rigatti
executiveHello, Jonathan.
Jonathan Arnold
analystI'd like to pose one question regarding the September announcement, which, clearly, has been referenced just now. And in particular, regarding the $6.2 billion that now sits in your accrual, Pedro, could you give us a sense of roughly what share of that has effectively been resolved or agreed upon, and then how much remains subject to estimation or extrapolation — just some directional indication of how you got to that figure as the estimate, rather than the low end as things stand?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveCertainly. Thanks, Jonathan. Maria can supply the figures on that. But as far as the categories go, you've already seen the major announcement, the various settlements we've announced, 1 last fall involving the public entities, and now the subrogation parties in this most recent settlement. Beyond that, I believe we've shared that settlements have also been reached with a number of private parties, private plaintiffs, though those are modest compared with the thousands of plaintiffs across the individual cases; so on that basis — and we can likely provide the exact figure we disclose as being included in the settlements. But when it came to developing the best estimate, what we did was this: you now have the advantage of those major settlements under our wings, all right, and behind us. And then, on top of that, working through discovery on the remaining claims, we're further along in discovery, we believe we grasp the facts at hand better, and what our arguments would be; we understand some of the counterarguments that different classes of plaintiffs might raise. And that simply gives us a stronger ability now to shift from the low ends to the best estimate. Assumptions do remain within it. And we disclose that the ultimate outcome could come in higher or lower. We aren't able to disclose an uncertainty band around it, Jonathan; but our hope and expectation is that, by now shifting from the low end to a best estimate, we're no longer talking about sitting at one edge of the roadway — we're now right down the middle of the roadway. And I know investors will likely be making assumptions or holding their own expectations about what that uncertainty band might be. Again, we're not in a position to communicate that; but what we've provided is our best estimate, or best sense, of what a final outcome would look like, benefiting not only from things we've locked down, but from facts we now understand better through the litigation process. Maria, I don't know whether you want to give — if you have a convenient sort of percent.
Maria Rigatti
executiveYeah, I think the one thing that might still be outstanding from your question, Jonathan, is that you were, I believe, asking which part of that figure is the subject. The way I read it, the subject is the subrogation claims settlement that we reached, and that comes to roughly $1.2 billion.
Jonathan Arnold
analystI understand that, Maria. What I wanted wasn't simply the overall split between known and estimated amounts.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYes, Maria, so I suppose the response to Jonathan's question is to take that gross figure of more than $6 billion, and then direct him to the settlement we just signed for $1.2 billion, along with the settlement from last fall, which came to roughly $1 billion — the claims, or $1 billion of the settlement, amounted to about a third of that; so in round numbers — Maria, you likely have a more exact figure, around $1.5 billion, $1.6 billion.
Maria Rigatti
executiveWell, Jonathan, I suppose the simplest answer is to point back to what's sitting on our books today, which is the total recorded liability. Roughly $1.2 billion of that figure relates to paying the subrogation claims. On your question about what's known versus what isn't, every one of those factors was weighed as we arrived at our best estimate. I'd refer you to what Pedro said earlier regarding the process we followed and so forth. At this stage, we aren't attempting to split things out across each category of claims payment. You can appreciate the reason for that.
Jonathan Arnold
analystAlright, got it. And could I just — as a related matter for my follow-up, the equity that you mentioned you'll discuss with us during the fourth quarter, would you be willing at all to comment on how interested you might be in tapping the ATM facility you currently have in the period between now and then? And then — and also, what's the reasoning behind, well, waiting until you actually have to pay claims? Why not simply get this dilution out of the way? So that, for a better — for lack of a better way to put it, 2021 becomes the baseline that won't be diluted any further.
Maria Rigatti
executiveSo, with respect to both of those questions, I believe your first one, about my thoughts on what I'll say regarding approaches or tactics or tools, I think we enjoy considerable flexibility where the tools are concerned, and all options, I think, remain open to us, spanning the full range, to methods we've used previously, ATM, and so forth; so I think plenty of options exist for us on the tools front. And we'll figure that out as we get closer to the moment when we will be issuing the equity; and I think your second question, about roughly why wait, I think we've explained previously that, given how these processes operate, we have revised our best estimate. But that doesn't mean cash is flowing out the door at this very moment. In fact, regarding the subrogation settlement we announced last month, really — the majority of it was covered by insurance. So we're really going to stick with that pattern of where — when cash is actually needed. And that will factor into our decision regarding when to issue the equity.
Jonathan Arnold
analystAll right, that's fair. Thanks.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveLet me sharpen one point here, Jonathan, since I may be reading too much into your question — there could be a suggestion in it that things might occur within some particular window; the truth is, we simply have no idea how long it will take to resolve the claims that remain. As we've consistently said, claims like these frequently end in settlement, though settlement isn't a requirement. When settlement does happen, certain ones have moved faster — as you witnessed with the public entities settlement and the subrogation claims. Still, nothing assures us that the outstanding claims left will settle within a comparable period; resolution could stretch considerably longer; and should we eventually proceed all the way through litigation, our expectation would be a process spanning multiple years. So I think what I hear in your question is the notion: well, if you need it by X time, why not proceed and issue the equity a bit sooner. Yet we can't say whether that would be a bit sooner or a great deal sooner, since we genuinely don't know the timeframe, Jonathan.
Jonathan Arnold
analystAll right, that's fair. I understand. I really appreciate all the assistance.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThanks.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHello, Julien.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystGood afternoon, everyone, and thanks so much for making time for this. So, if I may turn to the Silverado Fire — hope you don't mind — I appreciate the opening remarks. Could you help lay out, to the best of your understanding, how the liability statutes work when it comes to third parties, like those who might be tied to the telecom lines in this situation? And beyond that, I realize everything is preliminary, but how should we think about your direct exposure if the fact pattern you both just referenced — a third party causing the fire — gets confirmed, and, most importantly, if inverse condemnation turned out not to apply to the utility, given that, at least as best I can physically grasp what you're describing, this wire essentially flew up from below and actually made contact with — or presumably sparked — your own wires there. Sorry for the longwinded question. I just want to be very clear so we're sure we understand the statute here.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSure. Honestly, the response I have to give isn't going to satisfy you, since the fire continues to burn. At this stage our knowledge is quite limited. Consequently, even the legal treatment that would eventually govern the situation—I won't call it a statute—remains uncertain. I realize your attention is likely on questions such as whether inverse condemnation might be available. Yet even on that point, its availability depends on the specific facts of a given case and will in the end be resolved by a court. Thus we have been engaging in speculation when it comes to offering a view on whether a doctrine like inverse condemnation would be triggered in this situation. In the same way, with respect to liability that other parties might bear—I believe you grasp the situation about as well as we do at this moment, correct. We mentioned that we know this could have happened—that the lashing may have risen and been carried up into the power line. So on that specific segment, we're above it. That means there could be some potential liability on the part of that third-party telecommunications carrier. If the utility can demonstrate that such clauses existed, then it would be in a position to seek a contribution from other parties that bear responsibility. So that is definitely a possibility in this case. But it is simply far too soon to reach any conclusions whatsoever, Julien. So I likely need to stop there.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystOkay, that's fair enough. Let me put a somewhat simpler question to you, if that's all right?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveOf course.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystHow do you view your capacity to secure insurance going forward? I ask given the state's ongoing heightened wildfire activity, though admittedly that hasn't been directly connected to utility issues but instead to wider environmental conditions?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYeah, I'll take this one first, and Maria can likely fill in even more detail—I'd frame it by noting you saw we successfully obtained coverage for this calendar year; the market is tighter than previously, and the premium and amount disclosures you've seen regarding recoveries we pursued show pricing for that product is considerably higher than 3 or 4 years ago. I wouldn't want to guess what conditions will be like when we next go out to market. We'd anticipate product being available, I think, but that's the discovery process each time you enter the insurance cycle. Maria, anything to add there?
Maria Rigatti
executiveSure, Julien. I think the market has been difficult, and it has stayed difficult for a couple of years. We have been able to secure the capacity we wanted, though the price kept climbing higher and higher. Naturally, that creates a problem for our customers. You might know that in our 2021 GRC, we actually began trying to look into other options that could have helped bring costs down — funded self-insurance, things of that sort, balancing accounts — so that whether pricing moves favorably or unfavorably, we are not left exposed, and our customers would not carry an unfair burden if things turn out better than we had forecast. So I think this is simply something we keep watching, and we keep working hard to bring it into our program at the most affordable price for our customers.
Pedro Pizarro
executivePerhaps one more point worth making, Julien, and it could be useful — again, some of this is speculative; yet even so, I believe it matters to consider the fire season we have experienced up to now, which has again been historic. We regarded 2017 and 2018 as historic, but when it comes to acreage burned, more than 4 million acres have burned statewide, and over half of that resulted from lightning strikes. What I am getting at is something I think I already said during my prepared remarks. The fire suppression work has been extremely robust. And I will speculate a little here, though it is impossible to prove a negative. Still, I would venture a fairly confident guess that had this fire season occurred 3 years ago, before the state substantially expanded its firefighting resources and capabilities, we could be witnessing a very different scale of damage across the state, irrespective of the fire's cost. We could have seen far more damage from the lightning-caused fires; and had there been utility-caused fires, we could be seeing greater damage arising from those too. So my hope is that when insurance carriers review their risk profile for California, they — I am certain they will factor in some of the climate change related weather conditions, winds, et cetera, that contributed to the large fires this year; but I also hope they would examine the other side, the fire suppression work that helps lower the risk envelope for everyone. And likewise, I hope they would examine the efforts of all the utilities, certainly our utility in carrying out the wildfire mitigation plan, the risk is not zero, the risk will never be zero; but I believe the risk today is very different from what it was 3 years ago. As we — and we will keep changing, as we keep hardening the system, as we keep using PSPS responsibly and similarly.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystUnderstood. Thanks, guys. I'll circle back on that offline.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSure thing. Hey, appreciate it, Julien.
Michael Lapides
analystHi everyone, appreciate you letting me ask. There are a couple of items I'd like to raise. First, I just have a question regarding payment levels tied to the 2017 and 2018 wildfires. If I run a quick back-of-the-envelope calculation — and I'm sure there's more in the queue, so I'll follow up offline — but with the $6.2 billion accrual, you've paid out roughly $1.6 billion. You've got somewhere between $1.5 billion and $2 billion of insurance remaining, and you're getting around to $225 million on FERC recovery. So that works out — it's pretty rough — to cash out of pocket somewhere in the $2.5 billion to $3 billion range from the 2017 and 2018 wildfires. Am I roughly in the right area on that, Maria — the forward tax benefit?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes, that's roughly correct. Now I need to walk through the math a bit; I went through it fairly fast. We had roughly $6.2 billion, or probably — I'd say $2.5 billion feels a little low to me when I go through the numbers. If you're going all the way from the beginning, you're not — if you take every one of the charges, including those already paid for the evidence of the settlements back here.
Michael Lapides
analystI'm just thinking through the cash that goes out from here, so that's the $6.2 billion, but you've already paid roughly $1.6 billion of it. And you've got some insurance skill to collect, so I don't recall what that figure is, the math works out to $2 billion, but I believe you've collected some already.
Maria Rigatti
executiveIf you're all thinking about the — if you're thinking about going forward, that's probably around — right about $3 billion.
Michael Lapides
analystAll right, thanks.
Maria Rigatti
executiveWithin the best estimate — that's what the best estimate includes.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. Pedro, I'd like to probe the mood in California regarding utilities — a big publication up in Northern California today carried what struck me as a pretty scathing story about one of your competitors, or perhaps that ran last night. And it feels as though there's been comparatively little noise from Sacramento and other public officials about the limited role utilities play in wildfires and in wildfire mitigation, and maybe that's down to our first season being just ahead. Still, could you speak to how you handle public perception from this point on, and that sentiment, and how it shapes things and sort of carries over to policymakers and the coordination with them?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveGood question. I'll do my best not to spend the entire remainder of this earnings call answering it. Honestly, we could fill a whole afternoon with this topic. Incidentally, regarding your earlier question, I'm glad you raised it — your question was likely along the same lines as Jonathan's, both aimed at getting a sense of the numbers' scale, so I hope that clears things up for everyone. As for tone and appearance, I won't offer any view on the publication you just named or on other utilities. But I think — let me make two points. I'll offer one general remark, and then something more specific regarding Edison. One overall point—especially regarding the 2020 wildfire season up to now—is that lightning-caused fires account for more than half the acreage that has burned. Everyone has witnessed the challenges surrounding firefighting and, honestly, the tremendous work firefighters and others have put in. I believe people increasingly recognize this isn't simply a matter of what starts a fire; rather, it involves a combination of elements—climate change, weather patterns, ground fuel, all of that—along with where houses have been constructed, which together create the danger the state faces and is attempting to address. That probably shifts the overall tone somewhat. Let me add one more point regarding our utility. Across this whole period, one aim has been to — here are a few examples of what we've done. We've aimed at being genuinely transparent, Michael. So when problems emerged in our system—and we went through the wildfire experiences of 2017 and 2018—you saw how open we were whenever we found that our equipment might have played a part in starting fires. The reason is that I want the public to be able to trust and have confidence in the Edison company: being upfront, working hard not just to make improvements and lower wildfire risk for our communities, but also being transparent about occasions when something may go wrong. The truth is, we function under a standard of prudence rather than one of perfection, since our system includes 1.5 million poles spread over 50,000 square miles, and 27% of that 50,000 square miles is territory at high risk of fire. Another effort we've made involves — there are two additional things we do. The second one has been striving very hard to keep learning developer wildfire mitigation plans and to make them better. Actually, prior to the WMP idea coming into being—and honestly, before the Thomas fire hit us in 2017—we had already started on the Grid Safety and Resiliency Program. We saw that the risk profile had shifted considerably, both physically and on the regulatory side, because of the one country fires in fall 2017 plus the instability event involving the regulatory framework at the CPUC San Diego Gas & Electric decision. That set off our initial pass at fundamentally rethinking our approach to wildfire risk across our system, and that work led to the GSRP filing. We have kept at it ever since. We make an effort to keep our communities informed about all of our work in this area. Item three, and the final one I’ll mention, is that although the bulk of our focus goes to this short-term issue and these risks, we’ve continued to watch the long-term picture closely. That's the reason you've seen us continue to focus intently on issues like Pathway 2045 and what California needs to do to confront climate change — partly because we're witnessing climate change effects appear through wildfire, so managing wildfire risk matters, but we also have to assist the state in handling the long-term risk, which means taking action on climate change, and partly because tackling greenhouse gas reduction turns out to demand a robust utility serving as a key partner alongside the state, with a sturdy grid to support gaining access to clean energy and electrifying the economy. I think that over the long haul, the requirement for a robust utility—one that helps the state achieve its climate objectives—is built into the very structure here, correct? That's among the reasons to ensure the utility is able to have a compact keeping it sound. It's among the reasons state government got behind AB 1054. And it's among the reasons you witnessed unanimous approval for AB 913 this year. So I've gone on a bit at length here, but we truly give this a lot of thought regarding what we're doing in the near term—yet how do we approach the long term? And what's the way we show the state and the public that we're eager to be a partner—and that we have to be a solid partner over the long term—so that California can remain the wonderful state we all love living in?
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. Thanks a lot, Pedro. Really appreciate it.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSure thing. Thank you, Michael.
Maria Rigatti
executiveMichael, quick note on this — since I was jotting things down on my scratchpad while Pedro walked through it, I believe…
Michael Lapides
analystI'll let Maria take a moment to go through some figures.
Maria Rigatti
executiveRight, the figure you probably want is closer to $3.5 billion to $3.7 billion. And if you'd like, we can walk through how I worked that out offline.
Michael Lapides
analystThat's excellent. I'm glad to hear it, and I'm looking forward to staying in touch, Maria. Thanks very much.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThank you, Michael.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHello, Steve.
Steve Fleishman
analystHey there, good afternoon. So I've just got one technical question about the lashing wire—and I suppose this covers the telecom wires and electric as well. Is it the telecom company that's responsible for managing and servicing their own wires near your poles? Or is that something you have to handle too?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveGenerally speaking, they're the ones responsible for managing their equipment. It becomes even more complicated in this case, since you can have several telco companies making use of the assets under Joint Pole Agreements. In some instances, they might have a designated space on the pole for them, but they can then make that available or dedicate it to other telco providers through a transaction. So it really is their responsibility—maintaining the physical assets is on them. That being said, whenever we go out and inspect our facilities, we're looking for any hazards that could interfere with the electrical system. And so although we don't perform detailed inspection of their telco assets, if we spot something—and we definitely keep an eye out for any hazards that the telco assets might pose to the electric system—we report those to the telco companies.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right. Then one more thing about the GRC. It — how — you sound like you're feeling fairly confident about Track 1's timing, by early next year. Is there any possibility of resolving GRC Track 1 the way you did Track 2, or should we expect that one to run through the entire litigated process?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes, we're quite far along now. I mean, we — the only thing remaining for us is really the ALJ issuing a proposed decision, and after that there could be oral arguments. So I won't claim you can never do something like that. But in terms of Track 1, we are quite far along. Track 2, on the other hand, obviously we were much earlier then and hadn't yet been through many of the different piece parts of the proceeding when we reached the settlement in principal.
Steve Fleishman
analystSo you'll hold off on giving 2021 guidance until that happens — the GRC outcome — the same way you've done it previously?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes, Track 1. That's right.
Steve Fleishman
analystYeah. All right. Thanks.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSteve, Steve, Steve, our door is always open whenever parties wish to talk things over. That said, I believe Maria put it well — this particular one is quite far along already. Many thanks.
Steve Fleishman
analystThanks.
Jeremy Tonet
analystHello, and good afternoon.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHey there.
Jeremy Tonet
analystTurning now to the Blue Ridge fire. I was just wondering whether you could tell us if any EIX assets sit near the point where the Blue Ridge fire started, or whether that isn't the situation?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveJeremy, thanks for asking. I think the brief response I can offer is that no ESIR has been filed by us for Blue Ridge. And as things stand right now, we don't perceive any grounds that would require an ESIR to be filed.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood. That's really useful. Thanks.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSure. Happy to help.
Jeremy Tonet
analystWhen we think about potential changes to how California plans its system, how should we think about incremental capital chances for EIX in the years ahead — just a wider question on that?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYeah. No, great question. I'll try to keep it short. On that point, I think certainly the near-term thesis I mentioned, right. So the procurement needs we expect statewide for the 2024 to 2026 timeframe — I would guess a lot of that will continue being met by competitive generators in the state. The state has generally favored that approach. There's always a possibility for utility involvement; we've told investors before that we don't see SCE putting capital into traditional generation. At this stage it simply isn't our core business; we're satisfied with the generation already in rate base. Still, we don't intend to put fresh capital into new generation, given how active the third-party market is here. We also have ample chances to deploy capital into the wire system. Storage is somewhat different, since it could very well be a component of that, and not only the midterm procurement. Storage clearly plays a major role in California's trajectory toward 2030 and 2045. As a reminder, our Pathway 2045 study indicates that statewide, at the bulk power level, there will be a requirement for 80 gigawatts of additional renewables along with 30 gigawatts of additional storage. While I'd anticipate third parties will handle a substantial share of storage development as well, we've definitely observed interest in statutes that keep options open for utility involvement in storage. In our present rate case, you've seen that we included provisions for a modest amount of capital—not a large sum, but some capital that was earmarked. Maria, if my memory serves me, I believe the figure was roughly $60 million—but please verify that $60 million for me, okay—regarding possible utility involvement in storage; and the situation where storage becomes a more probable candidate for utility ownership would be when it can serve a more central function in grid operations; take, for instance, the 20 megawatts of batteries we installed at our Mira Loma Substation a few years back. Looking at the larger picture, when we consider what's needed in the near and midterm, and also the longer-term energy transition, the major capital investment opportunity here is ensuring we have a robust grid capable of interconnecting clean energy resources with the growing number of users throughout the economy as electrification expands. We're seeing load, which had been generally stagnant over the last decade, rising by 60% by the time we reach 2045. We do see a significant need to invest capital in the wire system, and beyond potential upside opportunities in areas like the Charge Ready 2 program, other such chances could arise as conditions change. I hope that answers your question, Jeremy.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood. Understood. That's much appreciated. And if I may squeeze in one final question, what is your present expectation for customer rates across the planning period, with the kind of incremental recoveries being authorized as anticipated?
Maria Rigatti
executiveWhen you look at the rate case we have underway now, the GRC, particularly the Chapter 1 <<inaudible>>, if everything were to be approved, which clearly never occurs, the typical monthly residential bill would rise to roughly $13 on average. For our care customers, it would go up to about — I believe it's around $8 per month.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood. Many thanks for that.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThank you.
Ryan Levine
analystGood afternoon.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHey, Ryan.
Ryan Levine
analystWith the blackouts California has experienced over the past few months, could you speak to potential investment opportunities tied specifically to blackouts — in transmission and storage — that might tackle some of the issues from recent months and lower the risk in future seasons?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYeah. Thanks for asking, Ryan. Much of my response, in broad strokes, echoes what I just told Jeremy. I don't believe we currently have a sharper read on which particular piece of equipment could assist with that. Keep in mind that the rotating outages weren't caused by the transmission or distribution system itself. The cause was insufficient supply. So a great deal of the emphasis is therefore on the near-term procurement that SCE pushed for and the CPUC approved last year. Recall that they approved roughly 3,000 megawatts of procurement covering the 2021 to 2023 timeframe. Of that — and this is a statewide figure — I believe SCE has completed around 2,700 megawatts of procurement for that period, largely by keeping certain existing generators running for a few additional years, which has happened alongside the State Water Resources Board extending retirement timelines because of the once-through cooling restrictions; so I'd say that covers a lot of the very near-term steps. Over the midterm, which is what I mentioned earlier, we foresee a statewide requirement of about 5,400 megawatts of resources beyond current contracts across the state; so part of that might be satisfied by existing plants again extending their operating lives, part might come from new resources, and part could be combinations of added storage that deliver greater effective capacity. So I think that could be something where some portion might ultimately be pursued through the utility rate base. And certainly I'd expect a large portion of it to go through competitive processes; on transmission, I can't really identify any specific transmission deficiencies that would have played a role in the rotating outages. But as we consider the system, adding new resources will of course then create needs for transmission interconnection if those resources land in locations that already have wire connections; and so, again, I don't think I have anything specific to offer on the near term. On the longer-term view, looking ahead to 2045, in our Pathway 2045 white paper, where we attempt to attach a dollar figure to resource needs — that 80 gigawatts of renewables and 30 gigawatts of storage — those new clean energy resources, by our estimates, a rough estimate, come to roughly $175 billion of new investment needed statewide. Once more, a lot of that work could be handled by outside parties, and the associated transmission-related bulk power system spending across the state through 2045 is going to come to roughly $70 billion. So a considerable amount of investment need lies ahead. And I believe utilities will have to cover some share of it.
Ryan Levine
analystThank you.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThanks, Ryan.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveHey, Paul.
Paul Fremont
analystHi. So I suppose the first thing I'd like to ask is whether you could share a bit more detail on the Bobcat Fire; and I think there were some press reports regarding the Bobcat Fire suggesting that perhaps vegetation or tree branches made contact with the transmission lines. Could you give us any kind of update on that?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveI don't believe there's anything significant that's new past what's already been reported. But to summarize it, we've reported that this fire began September 6, and the reported start time was 12:21. There was a relay operation on our system, on a 12 KV circuit, 5 minutes earlier at 12:16; however, one of the high-definition cameras we have in that area observed or captured the fire's initial stages and picked up smoke as early as 12:10 PM. That's 6 minutes before any activity showed up on our circuit; and that was 11 minutes ahead of the fire's reported start. The US Forest Service is conducting an investigation. They took out a 23-foot section of overhead conductor from the area of interest. And from what we understand, they also removed and kept some tree branches; so that hints they might be examining whether vegetation played a role in igniting the fire. We don't know whether the US Forest Service is additionally considering other potential causes of the — for the fire, or whether this equipment is the only thing they're focused on. SCE is conducting its own review. It's still very early here; we will definitely be examining any number of possible causes. The bottom line, Paul, is that it's far too early. And we've reached no conclusions either way regarding causation at this point.
Paul Fremont
analystThen my second question: regarding the Track 2 settlement, you said you aren't expecting any negative earnings impact. Could you say more about that — relative to what, exactly?
Maria Rigatti
executiveLet me put a caveat on all of it by saying that, since the settlement goes into considerable detail, the intent was only to keep people from thinking there was anything improper in the settlement. We see no effect on earnings or anything of that kind; we would defer some of the costs as probable of recovery. I just wanted to make that clear — this matches what we've thought previously.
Paul Fremont
analystOkay, so that isn't at all a signal about future EPS?
Maria Rigatti
executiveNo. The point was more to make clear that — well, I suppose it does indicate things won't negatively affect earnings. But really it was meant to highlight something we'd mentioned before: that we were deferring costs, and this settlement addresses several of those costs we've been putting off.
Paul Fremont
analystOkay, thank you very much.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThanks, Paul.
Sam Ramraj
executiveWe appreciate your being with us today. Also, if any additional questions come up afterward, feel free to reach out by phone; that brings this conference call to an end. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.
Operator
operatorThanks, everyone — that brings today's conference to a close. At this point, please feel free to go ahead and disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Edison International transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Edison International earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Edison International or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.