Edison International (EIX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 3, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Sam Ramraj
executiveThanks, Dexter, and hello, everyone. Joining us on the call today are Pedro Pizarro, our President and Chief Executive Officer, and Maria Rigatti, our Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Other members of the management team are also with us. You can find materials for today's call at www.edisoninvestor.com, including our Form 10-Q, the prepared remarks from Pedro and Maria, and the teleconference presentation. Our regular business update presentation will go out tomorrow. On this call, we'll be making forward-looking statements regarding the outlook for Edison International and its subsidiaries. Actual results might differ materially from what we currently expect. Key factors that could lead to different results are described in our SEC filings. Please review those carefully. The presentation contains certain outlook assumptions, along with a reconciliation of non-GAAP measures to the closest GAAP measure. <<operator_script>> I'll now hand the call over to Pedro.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveThank you, Sam. At Edison International, core earnings per share came in at $1.07, up against $0.79 during the same period last year. Our 2022 core EPS guidance range of $4.40 to $4.70 is being reiterated, along with our longer-term EPS growth rate of 5% to 7% through 2025, which yields core EPS of $5.50 to $5.90. Maria is going to walk through our financial performance during her remarks. For the past year, I've kept you informed about the significant wildfire risk reduction achieved at SCE. Compared with pre-2018 levels, SCE calculates that the likelihood of losses stemming from catastrophic wildfire has dropped by 65% to 70%, and further investments will keep bringing this risk down. Looking across all 17,000 circuit miles of distribution lines within SCE's high fire risk area, the grid hardening measures taken by the utility target roughly 10,000 miles located above ground, while the remaining 7,000 are already underground. Wildfire covered conductor program stands as the foundation of SCE's grid hardening measures. One major advantage is the speed at which wildfire risk comes down. By the close of the first quarter, SCE has more than 3,200 miles of covered conductor installed. That's almost twice the amount covered at the same point a year earlier. SCE keeps pushing this program ahead and anticipates having covered 40% of its overhead distribution lines, or 4,000 of its 10,000 miles within its high fire risk areas, by year-end. The utility keeps adapting and refreshing its wildfire mitigation plan so it builds on field successes and learnings. Above all, SCE's WMP can be acted on right away, and carrying it out delivers genuine risk reduction today, and every day SCE hardens its grid. Beyond that, SCE is getting ready for this wildfire season by giving priority to its inspections and vegetation management programs. SCE directs its annual inspections toward equipment accounting for 97% of total wildfire risk in 2022 and intends to speed up completion of the vast majority of these inspections before September 1. As of today, 166 cameras give visibility into about 90% of high fire risk areas; and <<inaudible>> installations in 2022 and beyond will expand coverage to nearly all of the utility's HFRA, improving early fire detection. SCE is boosting installed weather stations by over 10% and applying machine learning to further improve forecasting and target PSPS events with greater precision. All these efforts combined give SCE confidence in its capacity to mitigate wildfires tied to its equipment. Shifting to wildfire-related settlements. SCE achieved substantial progress in resolving claims from 2017 and 2018 wildfire and mudslide events. During the first quarter, SCE resolved more than $700 million of claims. Fueled by this progress and given SCE's present assessment of claims, the utility raised the best estimate of total losses by $416 million, bringing the total to $7.9 billion. I want to share the 2 factors behind this revision. First, during the quarter, a handful of exceptionally large claims were settled based on new information that emerged during settlement negotiations. And then second, with the Woolsey Fire statute of limitations deadline getting close, SCE experienced an increase in the count of plaintiffs filing claims that was larger than anticipated. After reviewing its estimate, SCE concluded it made sense to change the best estimate, and that revised figure now accounts for new provisions tied to potential exceptionally large claims down the road. Altogether, the utility has now settled more than 80% of what its best estimate projected as expected losses, and it keeps moving forward at a steady pace on resolving the remaining claims. Let me make this clear: SCE right now intends to pursue full cost recovery from the CPUC for claims payments, and that excludes any amounts it can recover from insurance or FERC, or that are foregone under the agreement reached with the safety enforcement division. One question that keeps coming up from the investment community is: at what point does SCE plan to submit that filing? Given how settlements are currently progressing, SCE expects to submit its initial cost recovery application by late 2023. I hold a strong conviction that SCE ran its system in a prudent manner and will present a robust case in that filing. The factors SCE will weigh when determining when to file are laid out on Page 4. One more action worth pointing out is SCE's recent legal challenge to inverse condemnation in the Thomas and Koenigstein fire litigation; as we've noted in prior discussions, SCE will always look for chances to contest the doctrine of inverse condemnation. Along those lines, in April, the utility submitted a notice of appeal to the California Court of Appeals contesting inverse condemnation. Matters such as this typically require 1 to 2 years before reaching a conclusion, and we'll update you on any significant developments; turning to the regulatory side, SCE just filed its application for the 2023 CPUC cost of capital, seeking a return on equity of 10.53% while keeping its authorized equity layer at 52%. As we've described ever since the Pathway 2045 vision was published, electrification across the whole economy is required to achieve California's policy goals. SCE will serve as a crucial enabler of the clean energy transition, and we'll put substantial capital into its infrastructure. Our view is that the ROE SCE has requested will help draw in that capital, which is needed to satisfy its obligations to deliver safe, reliable and resilient service and to support the state's climate change adaptation and decarbonization objectives. On a separate note, SCE is waiting to learn whether the cost of capital mechanism will be in effect for 2022. We've laid out SCE's pending cost of capital applications on Page 5. To wrap up, let me say we firmly believe Edison International represents the best investment vehicle for taking part in California's clean energy transition. SCE's strategy for wildfire mitigation has delivered positive results across the last 3 wildfire seasons, and the utility is rapidly hardening the grid each day, which benefits both our customers and our investors. As an electric-only wires-focused utility, SCE's continued investment in the grid will bring about an electric-led future by incorporating clean resources while improving resilience and broader climate adaptation. Electrification across the whole economy is the most affordable route to reaching California's climate goals. Having said that, Maria is going to walk us through the financials.
Maria Rigatti
executiveThank you, Pedro, and good afternoon to everyone. During today's remarks, I'll cover our results for the first quarter of 2022, our projections for capital expenditure and rate base, the cost of capital application filed by SCE, and our guidance for 2022 EPS. Edison International's core earnings for the first quarter came in at $1.07 per share, representing a gain of $0.28 per share over the prior-year period. This year-over-year improvement in core EPS largely reflected the adoption of the 2021 GRC final decision during the third quarter of 2021, partly offset by interest expense tied to higher borrowings. Turning to Page 6, the key first quarter EPS drivers for SCE appear on the right-hand side, and I'll walk through a few of them. On the 2021 GRC, authorized revenue came in $0.35 higher, and there are two things driving that. The first is the escalation mechanism for 2022, which accounted for $0.18 of the variance. The second is that SCE had no final GRC decision in last year's first quarter, so it was booking revenue at 2020 levels — that timing difference added $0.17 to the year-over-year Q1 revenue growth. Other CPUC revenue was up $0.51, mainly tied to approval of GRC Track 2. Following that approval, SCE recognized revenue for costs that had previously been deferred to minimal accounts. Keep in mind that this revenue increase was fully offset, largely by recognition of $0.46 of O&M stemming from the Track 2 decision. Turning to EIX Parent and Other: the core loss came in $0.06 larger for Q1, largely because of preferred equity dividends from the issuance made last year. Let's now turn to SCE's forecast for capital expenditure and rate base. On Page 7, you'll see SCE's revised capital plan, which incorporates its forthcoming GRC Track 4 application, set to be submitted on May 13. Funding for 2024 — the third attrition year under SCE's 2021 GRC — is what Track 4 addresses. Beyond seeking a revenue increase tied to both the GRC attrition mechanism and inflation, SCE intends to put forward the continued installation of covered conductor, going past the more than 5,000 miles it expects to have in place by the close of 2023. I want to build on what Pedro said before about SCE's wildfire mitigation plan. You can act on it right away, and doing this work delivers genuine risk reduction both now and every day SCE makes its grid more resilient. On Page 8, you'll see that our capital forecast still points to projected rate base growth of 7% to 9% between 2021 and 2025. That forecast captures SCE's present thinking on what will be requested in GRC track 4, the 2025 GRC and other applications. We still believe there's strong potential for SCE to keep deploying capital and to keep achieving 7% to 9% rate base growth through 2025. Now, about the outlook — on pages 9 and 10 you'll find both our 2022 guidance and the main assumptions you should use for modeling. Our core EPS guidance range for 2022 stays at $4.40 to $4.70, and we're reaffirming that. SCE is booking revenue using the cost of capital it currently has authorization for, and once the final ruling in the 2022 cost of capital proceedings comes through, it will be reflected in whichever quarter that happens. Pedro mentioned this already, but we still don't know whether the cost of capital mechanism will apply in 2022. After the CPUC issues its final decision, we'll return with a guidance update capturing any ROE changes as well as our view of how the rest of the year shapes up. The 2022 financing plan for EIX is part of our guidance as well — it's identical to what we presented three months ago, with no revisions. Nothing about our plan changes because of the updated best estimate for total expected losses. Also, remember that the money behind those claim payouts comes from debt that SCE issues. I want to add some further detail regarding 2 recent SCE filings with the CPUC. To start, SCE asked the CPUC to lengthen its capital structure labor mechanism connected to the 2017 and 2018 wildfire and mudslide events. As you may recall, a waiver had previously been approved by the CPUC that lasted through whichever came first: May 2022, or the point at which the 2017 and 2018 events were resolved. Under that waiver, SCE doesn't have to count specific debt-related costs when calculating whether it meets the 52% equity ratio authorized by the CPUC. SCE wants that waiver to remain in place until the CPUC finishes ruling on the remaining cost recovery applications tied to the 2017 and 2018 events. Until the CPUC decides on the newly submitted applications, the existing labor provision continues to apply. This preserves SCE's ability to raise financing in a way that works well for both customers and shareholders. Also, when SCE filed its 2023 cost of capital application, it requested a 10.53% ROE, matching what it had requested in its off-cycle application submitted not long before. That ROE falls at the top of the reasonable range that SCE's expert witness calculated. Our view is that SCE put forward compelling reasoning in support of what it asked for. It's also worth recalling that when the CPUC last ruled on SCE's cost of capital, it determined the company's ROE ought to sit at the top of the range. If SCE's timeline is adopted, a final decision would close out the proceeding before the year is over. Turning to Page 11, I'd like to restate the growth opportunities behind solid core earnings expansion between 2021 and 2025, and to call attention to EIX's capacity to deliver a double-digit total shareholder return over that stretch. The common dividend, which right now offers a yield of roughly 4%, is a central piece of our total return story. We've built a solid record with dividends going up for 18 straight years, and I'm excited to keep that momentum going. The 5% to 7% EPS growth comes from SCE's major capex opportunities, which include putting money into grid safety and reliability. That rate base growth is sustainable because of the spending needed to lower wildfire risk, plus investments for replacing infrastructure and supporting load growth. Keeping things affordable matters too, and I want to point out that among California's large IOUs, SCE offers the lowest system average rate. A big reason for that is the strong cost-management culture we've maintained, which has been central to this utility for over ten years. Those are all the points I wanted to share. I appreciate it.
Sam Ramraj
executiveDexter, please open the call for questions. <<operator_script>>
Shahriar Pourreza
analystPedro, to start with, regarding those first filings that came in during '23 — clearly that's a strong beginning toward getting things resolved, and it clearly suggests you'd be submitting paperwork on several occasions to obtain recovery. What's the approach for dividing up the tranches? Does it hinge on what share of value has been settled? I'm just looking for some clarity on how you see the process working. How much time might the recovery — the regulatory recovery — actually require? And should you lack 90% of claims settled, would you still submit a filing in late '23? And beyond that, why wait at all — why not submit earlier, in '22, given that these would arrive as step functions?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveShar, much of that is a fair question. We've told you previously that we anticipated the CPUC and churn would want us to be substantially finished with any particular case prior to submitting for cost recovery. So — and we've likewise stated previously that we view the 2017 Thomas Koenigstein, along with similar cases, as 1 bundle, while treating the Woolsey case from 2018 as its own separate bundle. So it seems natural to me that you'd expect us to treat those as distinct cost recovery packages. And so we discussed being — what we believe must be no less than 90% finished, that applies to whichever one of those packages, prior to us then submitting the application. Our — just to ensure our intention was communicated plainly, given the present track and pace of the litigation and settlements, we would anticipate the soonest bundle reaching that 90% plus level by the close of '23. So that sets our expectation that we'll submit a filing in late 2023. But once more, that rests on staying on the track we've been following. And if we — we don't anticipate that happening; right now we anticipate being there by late 2023. But should something occur that pushed us significantly off that track, I can't say what it would be. Another wave of COVID that genuinely caused shutdowns or anything along those lines — you may remember that the initial stretch of COVID truly brought the pace of discussions to a stop. Don't expect that to occur, but that's the sort of thing that could bench, knock the timing past like 2023; don't presently expect that to be the situation.
Shahriar Pourreza
analystAnd then, I suppose the driving force here was that people keep asking us about it — since you've got 80% basically wrapped up already, it looks like it's "substantial." So why wait to file, though it does make sense. That makes sense, Pedro. Then perhaps one thing for Maria. When we consider the possibility of additional cost increases as that remaining 20% gets settled, what would set off bringing more equity back in, given how we think about balance sheet capacity? Are the other rating agencies at ease with where the metrics stand and with the path you all are on? How are those talks proceeding? What do you figure their level of patience is, given the prospect of several filings for recovery?
Maria Rigatti
executiveSure. Thanks, Shar. Broadly speaking, I'd say our financing framework sits at 15% to 17% FFO to debt. Right now, I believe we're close to those figures. Heading into next year, I'd describe us as likely landing near the midpoint of that band. Above all, what the rating agencies care about is our risk reduction, and that comes first in every conversation we have with them. So we've managed to stress to the rating agencies that 65% to 70% risk reduction stemming from the grid hardening, and we keep discussing with them the robust support that comes from AB 1054. All of those elements are truly integral to what we talk about with the rating agencies. As you know from what we've said already today, the shift in the best estimate at present isn't leading us to alter our financing plan. We remain on schedule with the financing plan we announced in Q4 for 2022. If we proceed, subject to any changes — other changes in the estimate, it's really going to hinge on the timing, where we stand, and so forth. But given that we're in a solid position with our metrics, I believe we'll keep having productive discussions with the rating agencies.
Shahriar Pourreza
analystThat's the topic I was hoping to dig into with you, Maria. Should costs keep climbing, your belief is that the cushion on your balance sheet, or your thresholds, is sufficient to avoid going to the equity markets. That's the driving motivation.
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes; we've also set out our longer-term equity plan, which tracks the company's growth. And as we progress into that 15% to 17% range, that simply provides us with additional balance sheet support.
Steve Fleishman
analystTurning to the prudency matters, do either of you, Pedro or Maria, have a sense of how much time adjudication could require?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYes. That's tough to forecast ahead of time. Let me say — to begin with, everything hinges on presenting a compelling case. So when we submit our filing, we anticipate our team will have assembled a very compelling case. And as you might expect, the team has been at work on this throughout. After you enter a CPUC proceeding, it's difficult to gauge how long that takes. I'd note that CPUC proceedings often run, at the quickest, perhaps 12 months or 18 months, while others may stretch out somewhat longer. So we'll simply need to wait and observe, and once we've filed and once we've seen the initial round of intervenor responses come in, we'll have a clearer sense of the possible duration.
Steve Fleishman
analystAnd then just to follow up on that, regarding the revision to the estimate this quarter, you brought up unusually big claims as well as the statute of limitations expiring for Woolsey. Is there any explanation — why couldn't those same things occur once more, I suppose? Are there any additional statutes of limitations for any of the fires that haven't yet passed?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSo regarding the 2017 and 2018 matters, the one remaining statute of limitation state is this Woolsey state that I <<inaudible>>. To your wider question, as time goes on, that count of uncertainty keeps getting smaller, correct, since we have additional settlements completed and you heard that 80% figure. As you will notice in our disclosures, we recognize it's possible further changes may arise because the truth is each case is unique. And honestly, fresh insights and new types of cases, and so on, can emerge. During this specific quarter, as we said, we achieved strong progress, Steve. But honestly, there were a handful of outlier cases in which the final claims came in much bigger than what we had anticipated given the neighborhood those were located in, what you would predict for a typical case in those areas. And so one point you heard me mention is that we have now established provisions not just raising the reserve for what we have observed, but we also included a provision in the reserve at this point, now anticipating some of that previously unanticipated, correct? Given the experience we had, we've added provision for possible other extremely large individual claims surpassing what we had at first believed might be a typical claim size. So we attempted to learn from the ongoing information we've received and make a provision for that. But ultimately, under GAAP, would place on you what we think is our best estimate right now.
Maria Rigatti
executivePerhaps I'll mention just one more item, Steve, since I believe it matters as we work through the best estimate process. Each quarter we're examining it, and it will — this is going to remain among the largest categories where management exercises judgment; yet when I reflect on it, I likewise reflect on everything we've achieved that has gotten us here. We began with the public entity settlement. Then we moved to the TKM subrogation settlement. After that we entered the Woolsey subrogation claim settlement. During that span, the attorney general has concluded both inquiries, covering Woolsey as well as TKM; in the most recent quarter alone, Q1 2022, we completed $700 million in settlements. So, that is what has gotten us here, to the point where we made the revision. Yet it is also what has gotten us here regarding our ability to point toward late 2023 for a prudency review and the filing of an application. Thus I believe all of that also plays into how we considered the quarter and how we regard what lies ahead.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveI think also, Maria, and basically, we keep taking uncertainty off the table.
Ryan Levine
analystTwo questions, if I may. Where do things stand with the battery supply chain and getting it built out? And is August 1 still a date you consider achievable? And then, thinking bigger picture, how do you see resource adequacy shaping up for the rest of the year?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSure. I'll begin there. And in fact, I can hand things to Steven Powell, who manages here and serves as CEO of the utility. The way I'd frame the main point is that Ameresco, as you're aware, serves as our contractor on the SCE 535-megawatt utility storage project. We're operating alongside them per the contract. The building out of the entire supply chain has faced limitations, which shouldn't surprise you, given circumstances and especially in China. We can see a possibility that part of the project comes on line by August 1. But Steve, I'll pass it to you for additional commentary on this.
Steve Powell
executiveOkay, Ryan. As we discussed earlier, some of that heightened delivery risk has indeed materialized. Right now, given the delays on the project, we're working with Ameresco to bring as many megawatts online as we can. Currently, we anticipate as many as 300 megawatts could be online in August, though that remains contingent on continuing COVID-related and shipping constraints from China. Here on the ground, though, progress is happening. Regarding the wider battery supply chain and really your second question about resource adequacy, looking ahead to this summer, we believe the state is in a somewhat stronger position capacity-wise than it was during the past two summers. We are absolutely concentrated on getting our batteries online and making sure any other projects come online in time for summer. Even so, plenty of caution remains as we head into summer, and considerable effort is going toward making more resources available. Looking past this year, as you know, the state is aiming to bring over 11,000 megawatts of resources online by 2026, and SCE's share of that comes to roughly 4,000 megawatts. So we keep procuring resources for '23 and '24, and next we'll turn our focus to '25 and '26. We're handling everything from interconnection to locking down supplies, together with all our third parties, to make sure the state has enough resources for reliability — that's SCE's responsibility, along with the other lowering entities in the state. So this summer, we'll be in a better position than the last few summers.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveAnd Steve, I want to give a great deal of credit — not just to other load-serving entities such as SCE, but also to the CPUC, the governor's office. I believe everyone is highly focused on continuing to bring down the risk in California.
Ryan Levine
analystLet me ask one more question, if I may. Regarding recovering those costs, assuming the filing happens toward the end of 2023, what's your current thinking on how the money would be used?
Maria Rigatti
executiveHi Ryan, Maria here. Clearly, once we recover those amounts, we've got some delevering ahead — SCE has taken on quite a bit of debt to fund the claims payments, and EIX has also issued debt to shore up the balance sheet. So once we're past all that, we'll determine what to do next regarding the use of proceeds.
Sophie Karp
analystSo, as a follow-up on this battery project — right, I believe your equity requirements for this year came in somewhat higher to cover what this project costs, compared with the roughly 250 run rate you'd mentioned for other periods. Given the possible delays on this project, should we anticipate that figure dropping? Or is that not something we should expect?
Maria Rigatti
executiveSophie, our intention remains to put the entire capital plan to work this year. As a result, there would be no effect on our financing plan.
Sophie Karp
analystCould you also expand a bit on why you filed that inverse condemnation challenge, which came up in your prepared remarks? What I'm asking is, where might this lead? And with the possible results, what might the effects be on the ongoing legal matters or the state's framework? How ought we to look at this to help us put it in context?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSophie, I'll hand that question to Adam Umanoff, who serves as our General Counsel.
Adam Umanoff
executiveThus the utility was presented with a chance to reach a settlement with one specific plaintiff, and that now allows us to bring the question of how inverse condemnation applies to investor-owned utilities before a California appellate court; and as we've noted previously, our view is that the law as it stands is misguided in holding that investor-owned utilities ought not to bear strict liability for damages stemming from wildfires started by their equipment. And there's a disparity in how courts apply strict liability to investor-owned utilities as compared with the reality that we must demonstrate prudence in cost recovery proceedings before our regulator. So should we prevail on appeal, strict liability would no longer apply to us in a wildfire case; instead, plaintiffs would have to establish that we acted negligently in constructing and operating our equipment in order to seek damages. That would mark a substantial betterment of the liability exposure that investor-owned utilities face in California.
Sophie Karp
analystSo does that only cover earlier instances of wildfire damage, or would it also cover things going forward?
Adam Umanoff
executiveGoing forward is the only way it would apply. Practically speaking, for matters already settled, we're stuck with the existing statutes we currently have; none of those would be reopened. Yet even for active matters that haven't been concluded, a victory on appeal would establish new law. And pending matters would fall under that law. However, an appeal tends to require a fair amount of time. Therefore, a prompt ruling from an appellate court isn't something I'd anticipate.
Sophie Karp
analystOkay. So if you'd like, would that more or less substantially reduce the necessity for the existing, I suppose, wildfire framework in this area?
Adam Umanoff
executiveWell, on one hand there's the matter of what liability the utilities bear, while a distinct matter involves recouping expenses in a wildfire matter through a prudence examination, which would continue to occur under AB 1054.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveI believe — Sophie, to put it differently, what inverse condemnation essentially concerns — and I'm the one here who isn't a lawyer, so keep that in mind — is that it gives plaintiffs yet another path to bring claims and impose surcharges on the utility. The core of AB 1054, the piece we consider most significant, involves reshaping the prudence standard that governs how utilities pursue recovering costs or covering fire-related damages they've incurred; so if inverse condemnation were eliminated, that could lower the potential risk faced by utilities. Yet once a utility does face that exposure, AB 1054 focuses entirely on the mechanics of how the utility initially covers those damages — specifically, tapping into the fund — and then, even more crucially, how it builds its argument over time for cost recovery by showing prudent behavior. That matters, in my view, regardless of which scenario plays out, and we're pleased to have such a solid piece of legislation.
Jonathan Arnold
analystLet me just ask one quick thing about those bigger claims you're referring to, Pedro. If I heard you right, some cases you've already encountered turned out far larger than anticipated, and on top of that, you've set aside money for others that could also arrive bigger. Could you offer any additional detail? Are these claims that you basically know are headed your way, where the claimants have already been identified, and it's merely a matter of the size they'll reach? Or is it instead that fresh claims keep appearing that you never had on your radar? I'm not sure, so anything you can tell us would help.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSure. As you can probably guess, Jonathan, there's nothing I can say regarding anything sitting on the other radar, since that would involve active litigation or settlement discussions; so perhaps an illustration of one case, without going into any specifics, might work — these are personal property cases, correct? And that's mostly where we've encountered some of these larger-than-expected cases. So, as I said before, the way we initially develop an estimate was: we grasp what the neighborhood looks like. We grasp what the typical home value is. We set provisions for the typical contents value in that typical home; yet not every home is typical, and we're aware of that, right? And I believe the typical take spend into account. It's going to end up a bit greater, meaning we'll be a bit lesser. However, during the quarter that just ended, we encountered quite a few instances that were unusually big, and to give you one illustration—let me first verify that Adam won't mind me mentioning this while I'm talking. There was an instance involving a single household policyholder who, as it turned out, kept an extremely costly assortment of automobiles inside the garage, far exceeding the type of vehicles that residents typically own in highly desirable areas. This particular situation was out of the ordinary, essentially a collection of museum-level quality containing a great many cars. That's really tough to forecast ahead of time. When we put together our best estimate, we never planned or set aside capacity for a garage holding an incredible car collection of that scale. So at this point, the reserve covers what we're paying out, and it also factors in—through statistical analysis—some figure, and I won't get too detailed here either, since the litigation is ongoing—but we've now built into the provision an amount for a handful of other unusually sizable cases sitting in that remaining tail we're still working through. Does that help paint the picture, Jonathan?
Jonathan Arnold
analystI believe that's right. Thanks for addressing that, Pedro. And if I could just build on that last point in my follow-up — is my understanding correct that the revised best estimate stands at 7.9? You have 1.3 that remains unresolved, which in round numbers is actually nearer to 85%. And if you keep going — clearly you settled $700 million during this quarter, and based on what you're describing regarding timing and that 90% target, it seems you'd have to be expecting a fairly significant deceleration in how quickly these get resolved?
Maria Rigatti
executiveJonathan, this is Maria. I suppose what I'd say is, a slowdown is possible, since naturally, as cases move forward, people might choose to come in at a slower pace. That said, I believe a couple of factors are at play. It's 90% plus. We'll find out what falls within that remaining 10% or so. How complex those cases are could shape timing, independent of the amount. There are a couple of additional items tied to the litigation that we're monitoring as well. One involves where the intervener case concerning the safety enforcement division settlement stands. So we factored in a few litigation-related items. The settlement process for individual plaintiff claims, certainly. A few other elements will also shape our timing. Still, we believe, drawing on all these various pieces, that we'll be submitting our first application by late 2023.
Michael Lapides
analystI'm just wondering, could you remind me — your compound growth rate for EPS, which is 5% to 7% annual growth — that doesn't include any outcome from the $5.2 billion cost recovery, correct?
Maria Rigatti
executiveThat's right; it assumes no recovery.
Michael Lapides
analystThe assumption there is zero recovery, which means the expansion of your rate base still outpaces the expansion of your EPS, and — my assumption is that whatever proceeds came in, no matter the size, would in most cases be directed toward paying down debt and would consequently lower interest expense?
Maria Rigatti
executiveRight, so the growth of our rate base is greater than the growth of our earnings, in part because of the investment needed to achieve that growth under the EIX financing plan, but on top of that, the debt tied to those wildfire claims payments holds back the growth rate. As a result, if we do receive recovery and can shrink those amounts and bring that down, then we would definitely end up with reduced interest expense.
Michael Lapides
analystJust wondering — if proceeds came in, would every dollar go toward reducing the debt sitting at the utility? Or might you consider directing part of it to pay down some capitalization up at the holding company level?
Maria Rigatti
executiveSure. Well, a combination of approaches is possible, right? The utility's dollars are certainly there. EIX chose to use press in the prior year since it offers more flexibility. Looking ahead 5 years, there will be a chance for us to call it, reset it, or whatever. So to the degree we receive the recovery, we're able to pursue a mix of things.
Gregg Orrill
analystI had a question — apologies, this has already been addressed. Could you walk us through the recovery process, so to speak? In what way does it enter the rate base, those extra covered conductor miles beyond the 4,500 mark?
Maria Rigatti
executiveCertainly; under GRC track 1, covered conductor was approved for us, and that includes a balancing account permitting us to reach the 4,500 mile threshold. Beyond that threshold, an application would be submitted by us, and the commission would examine whether the amount is reasonable. Going past the 4,500 is something we're already considering. And at the time we file our — by the close of '23, we'll have roughly 5,000 plus; an application will therefore accompany that. Then under track 4, covering 2024, further covered conductor miles will be put forward by us, and approval will come through track 4.
Richard Sunderland
analystI just wanted to return to the financing outlook, since there's now that late 2023 target on the wildfire liability application for cost recovery. During that period — from today until late '23 — how much capacity do you have to absorb additional claims without needing corresponding additional equity?
Maria Rigatti
executiveI think I'll return to the perspective on our balance sheet. At present, our framework generally sits in the 15% to 17% FFO to debt range, typically near that 15% mark. As we head into next year, we would also typically expect to move further into that band, that range. You're aware we just announced a revision to the estimate and haven't needed to alter our financing plan. We remain committed to the financing plan we disclosed on the Q4 call. As we progress into the following year and our balance sheet strengthens, yes, we'll have greater room and greater opportunity to absorb whatever might occur. We are absolutely reaffirming our financing plan for 2022; however, because of all the fluctuations and volatility in the market, we actually took out a term loan at EIX to give ourselves additional time and additional flexibility to actually carry out that plan. So we're really focused mainly, Richard, on flexibility and on executing as well as possible.
Richard Sunderland
analystSo if we're just talking about the mechanics of it, the figure to remember is really that 15% to 17% band, and I suppose shifts inside that band, rather than, let's say, the midpoint, represent the outlook for the time being?
Maria Rigatti
executiveExactly. What I'd say is that band of 15% to 17% is the band, and the band is what we're going to use.
Richard Sunderland
analystThen, on a different note, a quick housekeeping item. I noticed the 2024 rate base came down slightly, while 2025 remains the same. Are there any drivers behind that adjustment worth mentioning?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes. That's a fair question. This really isn't tied to how we're executing on capital. Our capital plan, if you look at it, is pretty — extremely, extremely near where it stood at the time of our Q4 call. What shifted in 2024 comes down to, I'd describe it as, 2 quite wide categories, largely involving timing — both the timing of applications and the timing of when we modify or receive approval to modify certain working capital items that affect rate base. So you'll notice a difference in '24, but '25 is unchanged.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystSo, returning to the point where we began this Q&A session, could we discuss a bit the fresh details that emerged while settlement talks were underway, which prompted your wish to settle? Just — could you expand as far as you're able regarding exactly what caused that shift at this juncture?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveJulien, I believe I addressed that fairly thoroughly when answering Jonathan's question, correct? That question touched on which extraordinary cases existed; and I'd say that ties into what you're asking, what might have pushed us to settle matters we believed were much bigger than what our earlier analysis would have suggested. So I doubt I have much to add on that front. Perhaps I can just restate the key points, and we've mentioned this before too, Julien. We're nothing if not consistent on these calls; and the truth is that every one of these matters, it's a separate matter and it's one by one by one by one among thousands of matters and give plenty of credit to our team; they've performed well alongside the internal group and with outside assistance and attempting to wrap our heads around this uncertainty from the very start and carry out mapping of the regions that were affected and have an understanding of what sorts of households are in each neighborhood that was affected and is considering the heartbreaking toll on far too many families; and so producing a number of estimates that resulted in the best estimate. At the outset, you may remember, we didn't give you a best estimate. We could only give you a low end of the estimate range since we remained at such a substantial portion of the uncertainty that we couldn't produce the best estimate. As we gained more experience, we moved forward and we could shift to the best estimate. But frankly, there have been learnings and surprises along the way and not — we aren't surprised that surprises occur, right? But this sort of complex, extremely large matter. And so once more, returning to what I told Jonathan, or in answering Jonathan's question, we saw — and I think the largest driver this quarter was seeing a small number of very large cases that went well beyond the scope of what we had anticipated, making — taking a reserve for those cases that we've now settled, taking an additional reserve amount, expecting that we might find further surprises in the remaining tail. And then, naturally, the second major factor I noted in my prepared remarks was also adjusting for the number of plaintiffs that we're seeing. That's about all the color we can give you at this point, Julien, but it's been, I think, a very deliberate process on our team's part around this, very methodical. And that's simply how the numbers work — and honestly, how the probability curve plays out over thousands upon thousands of cases.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystPedro, let me see if I can get some clarity here, and perhaps split this apart from what Jonathan asked. I follow what you're saying about the differing settlement fact patterns in the quantum matter, and that this could be what's producing a different estimate. But the interesting nuance might be: why settle at all? What is it that prompts a decision to settle? Is it just a matter of knowing where the mark-to-market stands and letting the bid ask get resolved? Or is there fresh information pushing the settlement — if you can tell the two apart?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveYes. I believe the finest way to respond to that is, once more, everything gets handled individually. Let me describe the most extreme scenario. That one hasn't shown up for us so far. Yet if a given plaintiff came forward with a demand so far out of left field that it defied any logic behind settling, my view is we wouldn't settle in that situation, correct? That could be a matter we'd ultimately choose to bring before a jury trial. So I don't believe there's any broad, major development or shift indicating our stance on settlements has changed. These have truly been decisions made from the bottom up, one case at a time, along the lines of, "All right, we grasp the fact pattern here; we grasp the points that favor us. We grasp what our argument could deliver for us. We have a rough idea where a jury could land. We have a rough idea of the ongoing expenses involved in pushing a <<inaudible>> toward litigation, which, incidentally, carries its own expenses, correct — simply the legal process plus additional attorneys fees and similar items." And so we keep reaching those conclusions on an individual basis there. If what you're really asking is whether there's anything else you know about or we know about, or whether something broader or something is shaping how we approach settling in a way that differs from a quarter ago, then the response is no. Does that answer your question, Julien?
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystYes, certainly.
Sam Ramraj
executiveThank you for being with us. That brings this conference call to a close. Enjoy the remainder of your day and keep safe. You are now free to disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Edison International transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Edison International earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Edison International or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.