Edison International (EIX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 27, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Sam Ramraj
executiveThanks, Fran, and hello to all of you. Joining us on the line today are our President and Chief Executive Officer, Pedro Pizarro, along with Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Maria Rigatti. We also have additional members of the management team with us. You can find the materials that accompany this call at www.edisoninvestor.com. That includes our Form 10-Q, the prepared remarks from Pedro and Maria, and the teleconference presentation. Our regular business update presentation will go out tomorrow. On this call, we'll be making forward-looking statements regarding the outlook for Edison International and its subsidiaries. Actual results may differ materially from what we currently expect. The important factors that might lead to different results are described in our SEC filings. Please review those carefully. The presentation contains certain outlook assumptions, along with a reconciliation of non-GAAP measures to the closest GAAP measure. <<operator_script>> Pedro, I'll hand the call over to you now.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveOkay, thank you very much, Sam, and good afternoon to all of you. Three financial points are where I'd like to start. First, because of how well EIX has done through June, we have confidence in our 2023 core EPS guidance range of $4.55 to $4.85. Second, we stay completely confident in, and deeply dedicated to, hitting our long-term EPS growth objective of 5% to 7% across 2021 to 2025. Every known business headwind is included in this target, though possible tailwinds are not, and those could mean meaningful upside. Number three: because SCE's GRC application for 2025 is so strong, and because of other places we can invest, we're guiding to EPS growth of 5% to 7% across 2025 through 2028. That puts us on a course toward a possible $7 per share in earnings for 2028. The engine behind it is growth in rate base, driven by the vital investments required to keep California's clean energy transition moving ahead. And it matters that by taking these steps, SCE will hold onto its cost leadership position, plus the lowest system average rates of any California investor-owned utility customer for as far out as we can see. That pledge makes us extremely proud, and I'll have more to share on it shortly. Now for what's happening operationally. Two main points I want to leave you with. First, SCE occupies a strategic position that lets it put significant money into making the grid more reliable, more resilient, and more ready, which is what its 2025 GRC application lays out. Second, thanks to the grid hardening work it has already completed successfully, SCE stands ready for this year's wildfire season. I'd also like to stress that sustainability sits at the heart of all our efforts, since Edison International continues to lead when it comes to the clean energy transition. If you'd flip to Page 3. SCE submitted its 2025 GRC application on May 12. The biggest-picture goals are making sure we deliver the maximum in reliability, resiliency and readiness. Reliable, meaning it can serve what customers need both now and going forward. Our system can withstand challenges, safeguarding the public and preserving grid reliability, while being prepared to enable the broad shift toward electrification and reduced carbon emissions that California requires to hit its ambitious greenhouse gas reduction targets. Those GHG reduction targets aren't merely aspirational goals; they're woven deeply into the core of California's key legislative and policy structures. Keeping in mind what actions will cost over the long run as we face the worldwide climate crisis, SCE's GRC mirrors the pressing need for the state to quickly electrify huge portions of its economy, which is experiencing the quickest surge in electricity demand seen in many decades. To achieve these aims, SCE sought a 2025 base revenue requirement totaling $10.3 billion. That works out to $1.9 billion more, which is roughly 12% of what we had in total rates for 2024. On a system average basis, it also means rates go up 9%, while the typical residential customer's bill rises 10%. For hitting California's climate targets for 2030 and 2045, the stretch from 2025 through 2028 is going to matter enormously. Wildfire mitigation will keep getting major investment from SCE as we deal with the wildfire risk that remains across the system. On top of that, we need to accelerate work replacing infrastructure, getting back to the proactive replacement levels we've seen historically so reliability stays protected. Operational excellence and keeping things affordable for customers — you'll find those two themes in every application SCE files and, frankly, in how this company operates each and every day. Because the people paying for grid upgrades are the customers themselves, we keep looking for ways to find efficiencies and return that money to them. SCE has expanded what it can do with artificial intelligence and has been bringing technology deeper into how it operates; the company began, back in 2018, directing technology at a few of its most pressing problems, including reducing wildfire danger and improving data quality. Within the T&D aerial inspection effort, SCE has introduced several computer vision algorithms that review images and identify flaws — a broken crossarm, for example, as well as other hazards that could lead to outages or ignitions. At this point, the utility relies on its imagery, additional data, and these algorithms to create further forecasting models that can spot and clean up asset information, which allows the grid to operate with greater efficiency, enhances modeling of how fires spread, and makes the ranking of grid hardening projects more precise. Taking that further, and embracing technologies such as AI, RPA, and mobile offerings even more, SCE is intensifying its work in customer experience, integrated grid planning and execution, and generating efficiencies throughout its support organizations. Consider, for instance, the ability to foresee what a customer needs prior to receiving their call, then either resolving it in advance or guiding them toward the cheapest and most efficient option; leveraging voice and visual recognition alongside inspections so that surveys get completed automatically and inspections stay on target; and deploying generative AI to generate initial drafts of items ranging from correspondence to replies for data requests. It fills me with real pride that SCE has been an early adopter of emerging technology that pushes forward its objectives around operational excellence and affordability. Moving along to Page 4 now. Here's a brief status report regarding the 2017 and 2018 Wildfire and Mudslide Events. SCE is finalizing the TKM cost recovery application and intends to submit it during August. I want to restate something: SCE is going to seek complete cost recovery from the CPUC, less whatever has already been recovered or given up under its deal with the Safety and Enforcement Division. SCE will make a robust and persuasive argument that it operated its system with prudence, and that granting full recovery of costs is in the public's interest. Turning to this year's fire season, SCE grows increasingly confident about cutting down on wildfires linked to its equipment. Across the past two years or so, the company has been putting in covered conductor at a rate of about 100 miles each month. Since this initiative began roughly 4.5 years back, SCE has now replaced close to 5,000 circuit miles of bare wire with covered conductor. Along with the CPUC-endorsed grid hardening measure, SCE finishes 360-degree inspections of its transmission and distribution structures that account for as much as 99% of risk every year ahead of peak fire season, then carries out repairs and replacements. SCE keeps up its robust vegetation management programs, examining 1.6 million trees throughout the service area each year and typically mitigating approximately 850,000. A majority of those trees sit in zones with elevated fire danger. During 2023, SCE intends to examine more than 130,000 trees capable of falling onto SCE's electrical equipment in the areas of greatest risk. Let me now share several evidence points demonstrating how effectively all of this is performing when it comes to lowering ignitions and the harm they cause. Along completely covered sections, no ignitions have occurred because of covered conductor failure. Across 2021 and 2022, structures destroyed dropped by 98% and acres burned fell by 92% relative to 2017 and 2018. Page 5 displays these figures along with many other statistics. Just as it has done since 2021, SCE applies a stringent insurance industry modeling method to gauge the likelihood of losses stemming from catastrophic wildfires against the thresholds AB 1054 sets forth. When SCE's latest mitigation figures are run through the North America wildfire HD model from Moody's RMS — widely regarded as the best in the field — the result is an 85% reduction in the likelihood of catastrophic wildfire losses compared with levels before 2018, as shown on Page 6. Notably, the portion tied to public safety power shutoffs continues to decline, and it now accounts for only 10%.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSince 2018, SCE has moved swiftly to strengthen its grid, and by the end of this year, 76% of distribution lines located in HFRA are expected to be hardened — as shown on Page 7. Starting in 2025, SCE expects to begin scaling back covered conductor, its flagship mitigation measure, and to have mostly wrapped up its targeted undergrounding work by the close of 2028. At the same time, California keeps directing significant money toward forest resiliency and fire suppression, covering CAL FIRE crews and aerial resources. We were glad the approved state budget kept $2.7 billion — that's 98% of the original proposal — allocated over a 4-year span, for vital investments that bring forests and wildland health back so the threat of catastrophic wildfires continues to fall even under extreme climate conditions. As a sign of how committed the state is, CAL FIRE's total budget for 2023 to '24 comes to $4.1 billion — double what was first enacted in the 2017 to '18 budget — and over that same period CAL FIRE's staffing is up 74%. Edison International remains at the front of the clean energy transition, and we continue to carry out our strategy along with our net zero commitment. With climate change continuing to challenge the globe in ways we've never seen, I'm confident our team has the strength to steer this shift in a way that's both affordable and effective. We're paving the way toward a future in which electricity comes entirely from carbon-free sources, reshaping our system for a changing climate and assisting customers in achieving net-zero emissions. The journey ahead is lengthy, yet what we achieved in 2022 demonstrates both how urgently we feel this matters and how deeply we remain dedicated to sustainability. I'd encourage everyone to look through our 2022 sustainability report, which lays out our achievements, our targets and our long-term ESG commitments. Allow me to highlight a handful of those commitments, which you'll find on Pages 8 and 9. During 2022, we provided customers at SCE with 45% carbon-free electricity, put in place EV charging infrastructure that lets customers bring on over 500 medium- and heavy-duty electric vehicles, and either installed or signed contracts for upwards of 1,800 megawatts of energy storage. When the year closed, SCE's energy storage portfolio stood at over 5,000 megawatts. That ranks among the biggest anywhere in the country. Our people keep building alliances both at home and abroad to tackle climate change, and we feel proud to be out front on these efforts and partnerships as well as in backing our stakeholders. A clean-electricity-powered future has arrived. We therefore are completely prepared to turn that future into something real. And we'll accomplish it in a way that's reliable, affordable and sustainable. So, I'll hand things off to Maria now.
Maria Rigatti
executiveThank you, Pedro, and hello to everyone this afternoon. During my remarks, I'll go over our results for the second quarter, the EPS guidance for 2023, and share a bit more perspective regarding what we expect for core EPS growth over the long term. Turning to Q2 of 2023, EIX posted core EPS of $1.01. On Page 10, the quarterly variance analysis comparing year over year shows SCE's earnings for the second quarter rose by $0.13. Within the main drivers, GRC attrition year revenue escalation contributed an additional $0.19 compared with a year earlier. On top of that, higher FERC and other revenue contributed $0.04, while balancing account interest income rose by $0.10. Working partly against that growth, interest expense climbed $0.16, pushed up by elevated interest rates tied to funding wildfire claims payments. At EIX Parent and Other, the variance was negative $0.06, largely reflecting greater holding company interest expense. On the whole, we're happy with how we performed across the first half of the year, and we have confidence in hitting our full year core EPS guidance of $4.55 to $4.85, which appears on Page 11 and which we reaffirm today. Next, I'll cover SCE's capital expenditure forecast, which is shown on Page 12. After SCE filed its 2025 GRC in May, we rolled out our 2023 through 2028 capital plan spanning $38 billion to $43 billion. This is supported by spending covered under SCE's 2021 and 2025 general rate cases. Through the 2025 GRC cycle, which runs until 2028, we forecast annual capital deployment in the $8 billion range — twice the level seen just 6 years earlier. More than 85% of SCE's investments go toward its distribution grid. Those are critical for achieving reliability, resiliency and readiness targets that underpin the broad electrification and decarbonization required to satisfy California's greenhouse gas reduction goals. You might wonder, "How do you intend to fund such a significant step-up in CapEx?" The overwhelming majority will come from cash generated by operations along with debt, and between 2025 and 2028, we anticipate our equity needs will be met through internal programs, which generally generate roughly $100 million of equity each year, amounting to about $400 million across that period. Our expectation is that this financing plan keeps us inside the 15% to 17% FFO to debt range through 2028. Keep in mind, this financing plan doesn't factor in possible cost recovery from the legacy wildfire proceedings. I'd like to point out that SCE's capital expenditure forecast excludes meaningful additional capital deployment opportunities. At minimum, there's $2 billion of potential investment that SCE will seek through stand-alone applications during the next couple of years. As you may remember, submitting stand-alone applications in California is common when major projects remain in early stages at the point GRC testimony gets developed. Let me offer some historical context. Page 13 shows that SCE has secured approvals for stand-alone applications covering roughly $3 billion of capital spending across the past 2 rate case cycles. Discrete applications have driven significant growth historically, and our expectation is that this will persist going forward. To finish up my remarks regarding upside opportunities, a transmission plan CAISO approved not long ago pinpointed 17 projects that would upgrade facilities SCE already has. Because we are the incumbent transmission owner, these projects amount to no less than $2.3 billion in FERC transmission investment for SCE. That same CAISO plan also pinpointed $3 billion in competitive projects located in Southern California that SCE can pursue. Now let's look at Page 14. The GRC request from SCE backs rate base growth of roughly 6% to 8%, beginning at a 2023 base of $41.9 billion, which on its own is almost 20% greater than just 2 years earlier. Growth in rate base through 2028 comes from the essential grid infrastructure required to support California's leadership in the shift toward a carbon-free economy. Page 15 reflects how we are progressing in carrying out the parent company's 2023 financing plan successfully. During the quarter, SCE and the parent both issued debt, and each transaction landed comfortably below our average projected refinancing rates by 2025, which strengthens our confidence further about hitting our 2025 EPS guidance. Page 16 gives an update regarding the CPUC cost of capital mechanism. Since the Moody's Baa Utility Bond Index is trading far above the deadband with just 2 months left in the annual measurement period, chances are the mechanism will trigger. In our view, an upward ROE adjustment makes sense because today's interest rate environment has pushed up the utility cost of capital, matching what has happened across the broader financial markets. After it triggers, SCE will submit an advice letter to put the adjustment to the 2024 ROE into effect and to refresh the cost of debt and preferred equity. On an adjusted basis, the CPUC equity ratio stays at 52%, which aligns with the proposed decision that came out yesterday afternoon to extend SCE's capital structure waiver for 2 years, or until final decisions are reached on cost recovery for the 2017 and 2018 events. I have talked before about our operational excellence program and mentioned that we would provide updates as things developed. Ideas generated by SCE employees have uncovered O&M savings for customers that already appear in the GRC request. We put in relentless effort to keep developing these ideas and to uncover further benefits for customers no matter where we are in the GRC cycle. I am glad to offer a few concrete illustrations of our effective push to find efficiencies, which appear on Page 17. Beginning on the left, in May the CPUC gave approval to SCE's expanded wildfire self-insurance program, delivering roughly $160 million in yearly savings for customers, with room for even larger savings over time. When it comes to work planning, we have put our wildfire mitigation plan into practice successfully year after year and have kept discovering better approaches. As an illustration, SCE inspects roughly 216,000 structures in high fire risk areas on a programmatic basis each year, both from the ground and from the air, something that separate teams used to handle in the past. By merging ground and aerial inspections into one 360-degree inspection process, we've transformed the program. That cuts field driving time, improves safety for field personnel, and boosts both overall quality and the customer experience. From this effort, we anticipate close to $55 million in cumulative O&M savings. When it comes to procurement, we're finding ways to buy better successfully. Not long ago, we took another look at the prescription benefit provider within our healthcare plans and changed vendors, capturing roughly $50 million in cumulative O&M savings while keeping benefits and service for our employees at the same level. Those are merely representative examples that plainly show the value our team can uncover and implement within a short period. Such opportunities to deliver savings to customers excite us, and we'll keep sharing further examples with you down the road. Now to our financial commitments. Our confidence in the 5% to 7% EPS growth rate guidance from 2021 through 2025 stands. I restate our management team's unwavering focus on delivering that growth. Also, for the 2025 to 2028 period, we anticipate continued core EPS growth of 5% to 7%, which offers a pathway toward $7 earnings per share potential for 2028 shown on Page 18; so you can better understand this pathway, we've also included some key sensitivities on Page 25 of the appendix. We view this long-term EPS growth as highly achievable for 3 primary reasons. First, SCE's strong rate base growth serves as the core driver for this earnings trajectory. Second, the headwinds we've navigated across the past couple of years will have largely stabilized by 2025, permitting a simplified growth story through 2028. Those past headwinds encompassed the cost of financing wildfire claims payments, driven by both the increase in legacy wildfire reserves and higher interest rate environment, the reduction in CPUC ROE and issuance of preferred equity at the parent to strengthen the balance sheet. With those in mind, you can see that the midpoint of our 2025 guidance offers a stable platform for a strong long-term growth trajectory. Third, this growth is achievable even without incorporating a few key items; we can achieve this growth at SCE's current authorized ROEs and rate base forecast without factoring in the additional capital, potential I mentioned earlier or upside to the cost of capital by 2028. Furthermore, we haven't incorporated potential cost recovery in the legacy wildfire proceedings, which clearly presents substantial upside value to our long-term earnings power and credit profile. Given these factors, I want to underscore, we view 5% to 7% growth as highly achievable. We firmly believe we can achieve our targeted growth, both for 2025 and 2028, based on SCE's significant investment to ensure the grid is reliable, resilient and ready for California's economy-wide clean energy transition; that concludes my remarks. Back over to you, Sam.
Sam Ramraj
executiveFran, please open the call for questions. <<operator_script>>
Ryan Levine
analystRegarding your growth outlook over a longer horizon, what would you call the greatest danger to hitting that 5% to 7% target through 2028? And on the funding side, you pointed to a few billion dollars of potential upside — if that actually comes through, how do you plan to pay for it?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes. Ryan, this is Maria. Good to hear from you. On your first question, what I'd really like to zero in on is — you're asking about risk to that 5% to 7% growth. In our view, it's very achievable. We also believe that as we go forward into the '25 through '28 stretch, the narrative and the profile become far simpler. We've gotten through a number of headwinds during the '21 to '25 stretch, we've handled them, and we're restating our 5% to 7% growth rate. And as we enter the following stretch, you'll notice many of those items, since they've settled down, genuinely let us concentrate on the core drivers of our business, which, honestly, are rate base growth. So when you ask about whether we get — whether we capture these additional possible CapEx opportunities, some of which we'll file for within the coming year or so, what the equity program would have to look like. My sense is it truly — we'll need to examine that at the point the dollars actually begin to arrive, because we always aim for that 15% to 17% FFO to debt range, the financing plan we showed you in the earlier remarks today fully supports that 15% to 17% FFO to debt; and as that other capital shows up, based on where we sit within that range, it will determine whether we require additional equity. So I think we'll find out once those dollars come through the door.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveRyan, Pedro here. I want to emphasize that initial question. There's such an obvious and powerful requirement for building out this infrastructure. Considering what the SCE team has accomplished, they've done well to capture that within the general rate case filing. As Maria mentioned, we'll have additional components where the requirement will be equally compelling; so for me, it definitely concludes at that point, since it has to be for infrastructure that's plainly necessary for reliability, resiliency, and readiness. That represents the major opportunity in front of us, and that's the reason we have such confidence.
Ryan Levine
analystGreat. If I may, one more question. Regarding the outlook for O&M costs, you mentioned some vendor changes. On a wider level, what are you observing when it comes to inflation pressures throughout your supply chain; and is there any detail you can provide about your view on O&M cost?
Maria Rigatti
executiveSure. Perhaps Steve Powell can speak to what we are seeing with certain vendors. Steve is the utility's CEO, Steve?
Steve Powell
executiveAbsolutely. Many of the suppliers we partner with are under contracts spanning several years. As those deals approach their conclusion, we routinely return to the market to renegotiate. Over the past 2 years in particular, we've observed increases in labor costs and on the materials side as well. The worldwide supply chain bottleneck, I'd say, has stretched out timelines for receiving everything from customer meters to transformers to switch gear, and that too is pushing expenses higher. So — our team is continuously staying ahead of all of that in order to build up inventories. All of this is being factored into our general rate case, and within that rate case we have inflation adjustment mechanisms to account for it. So these are matters for which we possess the mechanisms to manage via our rate case, and we're always exploring various approaches to collaborate with our suppliers so that the cost of the services comes down.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveI believe that when you take an even more extended view, we're going to begin witnessing advantages throughout the whole economy as well. For instance, the CHIPS+ Act, correct? Plus the emphasis the federal government has placed on restoring manufacturing supply domestically. So that isn't something happening next year. Therefore, to properly address the question regarding the short term, yes, but I also have confidence that over a longer horizon, supply chains are going to react to market signals, and what comes from the CHIPS+ Act along with the other infrastructure bill, and so on, in terms of restoring manufacturing for critical component supply within the U.S., is going to be beneficial.
Shar Pourreza
analystI'd like to get a feel for this. Clearly, recovery of claims costs, a CCM trigger, and CAISO transmission chances — that's quite substantial. It comes in increments, so I'm wondering whether we should view these possibilities, if they pan out, as adding to that 5% to 7% growth rate. Or might we see a step-up increase if some of them make it into the plan?
Maria Rigatti
executiveLet's walk through a few of the items you brought up, Shar. The CAISO chances are substantial, as you noted — $2.3 billion for the projects where SCE holds the incumbent transmission owner position. Most of that spending probably lands after 2028. So that's a matter of runway, correct? You brought up the CCM trigger. We firmly believe that with 2 months remaining, as I've said previously, it's very likely the CCM will trigger. And we feel it's completely backed by what's happening across the broad financial markets; we aren't depending on the CCM trigger for our 5% to 7% growth trajectories. So we'll work through that process as we work through that process. I'd add that once we reach 2028, we'll be in another cost of capital cycle entirely. So you'll notice some interplay there. Then regarding recovery of claims costs, as Pedro mentioned earlier, we've been fully prudent, and we'll make a strong case for cost recovery when we file our application in August. The proceeds from that, naturally, would go toward paying down existing debt at SCE; and so you'd see, without question, it would benefit our earnings profile because interest expense currently hitting the bottom line would be authorized for recovery, and our credit metrics would also improve. So I think you'll see plenty of improvements from all of those things, and we'll take them as they come.
Shar Pourreza
analystGreat. Then, Maria, clearly, one of the companies operating alongside you in this state is getting nearer to divesting a portion of its regulated Genco. A great deal of interest appears to exist there. It looks like interest is broad. Your CapEx is substantial. The stock continues to trade at what is, in a sense, a fairly attractive discount. Apart from depending on equity markets, do you perceive other effective methods to finance this capital increase, particularly should you anticipate the step-up?
Maria Rigatti
executiveTo begin, regarding the equity financing plan introduced for '25 to '28, our internal program is essentially what we mean. Roughly $100 million annually is what that program typically delivers. That gives you a sense of its size. As for examining additional opportunities, past that, for alternative financing structures, we will definitely monitor with interest the developments up in the north, though a regulatory process must be completed; therefore, for us, at this moment, it is simply something to observe.
Pedro Pizarro
executiveFor my part, Shar, the key point is this: as Maria took you through how robust the capital plan is and how strong the growth rate is, we believe we can accomplish all of it using just the internal programs. So I'd say that's a solid, forceful statement about how little equity we need and how manageable we anticipate this being.
Gregg Orrill
analystNice work. Regarding the transmission CapEx you mentioned coming from the Cal ISO awards — in what way does that mechanism get refreshed as time goes on? What's the frequency of those? Ought we to anticipate additional CapEx being recognized?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveWe'll have Steve address how the Cal ISO handles its planning.
Steve Powell
executiveOkay, so the California Independent System Operator brings these projects into being, refines them, and gives them the green light via its transmission planning process, and going forward they'll be releasing revised plans on a consistent schedule; there's a 20-year outlook they use to lay out the major projects that have to be built over a long horizon. In the most recent one, roughly $30 billion in projects were pinpointed as necessary across the coming 20 years; at this point they're moving through the work of putting together those 10-year plans. And as of now, they're advancing through the process under the plan that's currently approved, handling the assignment of incumbent projects on one track. So we're aware that there's $2.3 billion in projects on our plate that must be completed. Meanwhile, they conduct their competitive process for projects that are open to competition. Under the present plan, in this 10-year cycle, 3 projects are being put out to bid, carrying a value of approximately $3 billion according to their preliminary estimate. Those bids are going to be due later in the fall, in September and October, and the awards will come next year. They'll keep moving along that path. Another plan has been worked up and issued, another 2 years out, and after that they'll keep cycling through as they spot new projects emerging on the horizon that fit within their long-term outlook.
Angie Storozynski
analystLet me start with those operational variances, just so I've got this straight. If you're seeing — if there's upside on earnings tied to the cost of capital, or from any other driver, should I be assuming that some of it gets offset by those operational variances? And I get that AFUDC makes up a large chunk of that. But still, is there a piece of it that moves up or down based on how much you basically need in order to hit your earnings targets?
Maria Rigatti
executiveAngie, great question. Let me perhaps take a step back for a moment. Over the years, we've handed you certain information so you can sort of reason through our business and how our operating model works — we've grouped things into a handful of separate line items. One of those is the operational variances you just brought up. Yet when we look at our business beneath those 4 line items, there are far, far more items that we're actually managing. So going forward, as we think about '25 through '28, we've attempted to give you extra information at a finer level of detail that we hope will — let you gain deeper insight into our business. Take, for instance, what we've discussed within that 2025 operational variances bucket. We've discussed AFUDC, we've discussed the timing of regulatory approvals, we discussed operational efficiencies, we've discussed depreciation. And we've provided some insights into that. As we move ahead between '25 and '28, you'll find the sensitivities actually go straight to, okay, so what's the sensitivity around AFUDC? And you'll see that since our capital program is expanding so quickly and so strongly, once we reach 2028, AFUDC sits at roughly $0.45 rather than landing in the $0.30 to $0.35 range as it did previously. We've handed you certain depreciation sensitivities you can factor in. Honestly, once we reach 2028, we don't really view the timing of regulatory proceedings or O&M variances as the major drivers for that portion of the model, so to speak. So that, I think, is how we're attempting to give you that extra information, along with all the other sensitivities folks enjoy asking us about, such as interest rate assumptions and that sort of thing. So hopefully that's a finer-grained approach to how we think about our business.
Anthony Crowdell
analystA single fast thing regarding Slide 4, which addresses how the TKM events get applied. Could you share whatever you're able, about how long that application process will take to unfold? Then, to be more precise, what kind of part — do you sit down with parties in advance, or is there any feedback you can offer about talks happening at this moment with any of the intervenors regarding the application?
Pedro Pizarro
executiveSure. Appreciate it, Anthony. We plan to ask for — our expectation is that we'll seek an 18-month timeline for the proceeding. For something of this nature, we feel that's a suitable length of time. At a very broad level, prior to submitting any application, we'll sit down with a variety of stakeholders as fits the situation. Really, I'd say those amount to listening sessions more than anything else. So I doubt there's anything we'd come back and share, and it likely wouldn't be fitting in any case, but just know that we're making certain people grasp the foundational case here, correct? Having reviewed all the evidence, we're confident we acted prudently, and we're giving insight into how strong our argument is, along with the process at hand. And crucially, the necessity of a fair result in these matters. We understand this isn't solely about securing recovery of costs that we consider properly recoverable. We also understand this sends a powerful message regarding California's ongoing dedication to financially sound utilities. Thus we will — you'll find our application addresses numerous topics concerning the reasoning behind this, not just regarding the case's merits, but also how vital it is that this serves as yet another crucial move in reinforcing the robustness of California's regulatory framework.
David Arcaro
analystLet me just handle a small logistics point first. I was curious whether you might share any guidance regarding equity requirements looking ahead to 2024. It appears we have solid visibility there; still, I'm wondering if there's any particular financing we ought to watch as we move through '24.
Maria Rigatti
executiveMy expectation is that during 2024, we will likewise depend on our own internal initiatives.
David Arcaro
analystAll right, understood. So it ought to be, I suppose — and that's roughly the same $100 million pace?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes, that's what we've been seeing.
David Arcaro
analystAlright, understood. And next, thinking further out, I suppose the expansion of the rate base slows down when you examine — if I simply examine rate base expansion from '25 through '28, it's closer to 5% to 7%. I realize it's still early, but — and that roughly corresponds with EPS growth in the 5% to 7% bracket. In your view, does that become constrained? Or is it probable that rate base expansion will simply accelerate as time goes on, with additional CapEx plans being recognized?
Maria Rigatti
executiveI'm not certain I completely grasp what you're referring to by type. Could you elaborate on that a bit?
David Arcaro
analystAbsolutely. I suppose that in the past, there's been a discrepancy between how fast the rate base grew and how fast EPS grew. And looking ahead, it seems like the planned rate base growth basically lines up with EPS growth. Is that just something that happens early on, or will we begin to see that discrepancy get larger as time goes on?
Maria Rigatti
executiveNo. I appreciate you asking for that clarification. Yes, we feel quite good about EPS growth of 5% to 7% alongside rate base growth of 5% to 7%. A number of the developments we've been experiencing — the coming 5 years aren't the same as the prior 5 years, correct? So previously, that discrepancy did in fact get larger, because of the matters we were handling as we went from a smaller level of — wildfire claims debt, for instance, to a bigger level, and because the interest rate environment shifted on us during that time. Once we reach the '25 through '28 timeframe, matters have settled down. At the close of this quarter, we now had $6 billion outstanding on wildfire claims debt; so all of that is accounted for within that timeframe. Consider even what we're refinancing related to wildfire claims debt across that 5-year stretch — that debt was in fact issued in the more recent interest rate environment; so the average of it — the average rate on the debt we're refinancing is already roughly 4.6%; so you're seeing many things largely settle down. Another development you're going to begin to notice, I think, is that at the parent company, our costs are clearly rising more slowly at this point, and we'll be aiming to refinance some of the outstanding maturities using a more efficient vehicle. I think you watched us do that earlier this year, as an illustration, when we required equity content securities. We shifted away from preps into junior subordinated notes. One more factor that I think supports keeping those 2 figures, EPS and rate base growth, moving in tandem is that you'll observe AFUDC rising fairly sharply across that timeframe, and that plays a role as well.
David Arcaro
analystUnderstood, that's quite useful. Apologies in advance if I'm covering ground already discussed, but regarding operational variances specifically, I notice AFUDC climbing across the '25 through '28 window. Is there significant movement in the remaining operational variances category when comparing the '25 figure as you've characterized it against whatever it becomes by '28?
Maria Rigatti
executiveCorrect. We've built in a sensitivity related to depreciation as well. Those depreciation variances have come up in prior discussions. Now you can observe that we're explicitly flagging it so people are able to perform some of that analysis on their own when we adjust CapEx, moving from the request case into the range case — you'll notice we relied on numerous simplifying assumptions. Consequently, in the lower CapEx scenarios at the very least, a 15 — an assumption regarding a $0.15 depreciation adjustment is required. That variance therefore stacks on top of the remaining figures you'd derive concerning rate base growth. Looking ahead over time, the additional items we've referenced — namely regulatory proceeding timing alongside O&M efficiencies — simply don't strike us as a major factor by the time we reach 2028.
David Paz
analystRegarding those growth rates, could you speak to whether you'd land at the low end, or in the lower half, of your growth rate if ROE stays at 10.05%?
Maria Rigatti
executiveThroughout the whole range — 5% to 7% — we're assuming 10.05%. Every one of our scenarios, then, has that baked in.
David Paz
analystAll right. And apologies if there's a slide I'm overlooking here, but what amount of cash recoveries are you anticipating other than GRC and the TKM, which I realize you're not counting on, but beyond those proceedings, what level of cash recovery through '28 is — embedded in your plan? For example, I think you had $1 billion of recovery in 2024 on the slide earlier this year, if I recall. Any indication of what we should expect for cash recoveries through '28?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYes. So actually, across the last 2 years, we've recovered $3 billion in cash from these memo accounts that people have previously heard us discuss. Over the coming 2 years, we anticipate recovering roughly $2 billion from those same categories of accounts. And just to restate and clarify something you may have referenced, we aren't assuming recovery on any of the '17 and '18 wildfire legacy claims.
Nick Campanella
analystAnd I apologize if this slipped past me too, but recognizing that you've restated '23 along with that 5.70% midpoint for '25, could you just help us understand how we should frame '24? Will you land inside that 5% to 7% band?
Maria Rigatti
executiveYeah. So before we issue formal guidance for 2024, there are several moving pieces we intend to examine. We've still got our track 4 items that need to be settled. There are additional regulatory filings. Honestly, I expect we'll be monitoring interest rates, and we'll be watching whether the CCM might trigger. So once we provide guidance, that update will come with it. Now I do want to stress once more that the CCM trigger does matter, yet it doesn't matter when it comes to our '21 through '25 or our '25 through '28, 5% to 7% EPS CAGR.
Nick Campanella
analystFor sure, and I suppose that leads nicely into this. My question is a lot like the one Anthony got, only about the CPUC process, specifically the CCM trigger — could you take us through how the timing would go? Clearly, my understanding is you submit an advice letter during October, hoping to get a result before the year ends, but how do you expect that to unfold?
Maria Rigatti
executiveRight. What happens is that after the measurement period closes — meaning September 30 marks the finish — then during October we'd submit an advice letter, a Tier 2 advice letter, and that routes it to the Energy division, which has the ability to disposition the letter. Should anyone wish to protest, they're allowed to do so. If a protest comes in, the Energy division then decides whether it remains the body that dispositions the letter, or whether the matter gets sent to an ALJ or to the wider commission. Given where things stand today, our view is that having the trigger fire is entirely reasonable. Keep in mind that the shifts in interest rates happening at present are essentially the core reason the commission put a CCM, or cost of capital mechanism, in place 12 or 14 years back. The purpose was to handle movements within a 3-year cost of capital proceeding, whenever the interest rate market and the interest rate environment shifted. So that's what we'd keep pushing for. Beyond that, we think — much like 2022 — that no extraordinary events are present. The market is behaving as it does, and we're moving in the same way as the broader financial market. So we'll proceed through that process when we file the advice letter.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystTo circle back on what was asked before, I'd like to get a bit more clarity. You mentioned sensitivity around depreciation. Could you walk through how that plays into the earnings variances for '28? I understand the sensitivity itself, but I'd like to grasp how it would actually factor in here, and where it would originate?
Maria Rigatti
executiveOf course. The sensitivity we gave you appears on the appendix page and shows a range of possible outcomes. Two separate components are at work there; we hand you the capital forecast connected to our request — the one submitted in the general rate case — and in doing so, we draw on plenty of general rate case data that lets us assemble it. When we show you the remaining points along the curve, where we lower CapEx simply to give you a bit more visibility into how rate base would look, we rely on some highly simplifying assumptions. So in translating those reduced CapEx levels into rate base, we've adopted simplifying assumptions regarding when the CapEx gets spent. We've also adopted simplifying assumptions regarding which category of CapEx is trimmed. As a result, once you reach the bottom of the capital range, that depreciation variance shows up once more. So at the lowest CapEx level, a $0.15 adjustment becomes necessary — you will have to make a $0.15 adjustment. That closely mirrors the depreciation variances we reference throughout the rate case cycle, when CapEx comes in somewhat different from what's baked into your actual authorized amount. The second component of the sensitivity we gave you involves a request we filed in the general rate case and — plus we put forward a depreciation proposal. We recognize that results on that can sometimes differ; therefore we've likewise supplied a sensitivity showing what would happen to earnings and, in the end, how rate base is affected. In other words, what would happen to earnings if our depreciation proposal gets altered from what was requested. Those are the 2 items.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystAnd then, just to ask one more thing very fast, regarding the equity capital ratio, with the waiver in place. At the utility level, where does that stand right now? And through the forecast period, what do you expect it to be at '25 or '28? And in the end, over what kind of time frame do you expect it to return — presumably after the proceedings wrap up — to get back to authorized levels?
Maria Rigatti
executiveThe proposed decision we got yesterday, then, extends the waiver for our capital structure. So I suppose the simplest response to what you're asking is that because of the waiver, we are at 52%. Take that forward. For the '17 and '18 legacy wildfire claims and debt, we are not assuming any cost recovery. So if we take that forward and that doesn't come through, then at the end of that process we would need to put forward a plan to bring ourselves back into conformance with the authorized capital structure. A plan that we consider suitable could be proposed by us. There are a number of things we could do. We could begin by proposing that the differences be excluded, since this isn't rate based, correct? So we exclude this permanently from our capital structure. There is some precedent for that. On the SONGS settlement, we know we received that sort of treatment. On the amounts disallowed in the SED settlement, more recently, we had that same treatment. So that would be one approach we would take. To be in conformance, that would be our plan. At the other end of the spectrum, we could also simply move that debt up to the parent company, and then we would propose a time line over which we would do it; and as we did that, we would not be impacting — to support all of those claims, we've already issued the equity. So it could be a little bit more expensive, but it would be within our current credit metrics. And just as a reminder, the equity ratio is actually measured over a 36-month period.
Sam Ramraj
executiveAppreciate everyone being here. That wraps up this call. Enjoy the remainder of your day, keep yourselves well, and you're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Edison International transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Edison International earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Edison International or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.