eDreams ODIGEO S.A. (EDR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 31, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David de la Roz
executiveMorning, everyone, and thanks for being here for our presentation of first quarter fiscal year 2024 results, covering the 3 months that ended 30th of June, 2023. I'm David de la Roz, Director of Investor Relations at eDreams ODIGEO. As usual, the results materials — the presentation and our results report — are available in the Investor Relations section of our website. At this point I'll hand things over to Dana Dunne, our CEO, who'll walk you through the first part of the presentation. Thank you.
Dana Dunne
executiveThank you, David. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate you being here. The main points from the results presentation today are that eDO keeps delivering robust expansion across subscribers, revenues and profit. As a matter of fact, our cash EBITDA grew by more than twofold over only 1 year, while the cash EBITDA margin gained 9 percentage points compared with the first quarter of FY '23. That takes our cash EBITDA margin up from 9% in Q1 '23 to 18% in Q1 '24. We also gained 1.5 million subscribers during the last 12 months, including 375,000 in Q1 '24. All told, we remain on track to hit or beat the targets we set for ourselves for FY '25. Today we'll walk you through the main elements of this strong performance. That covers: one, highlights of eDO's results; 2, the Prime model, now proven a success, and a review of our excellent first quarter FY '24 results; 3, an explanation of the disclosure improvements we've made so our subscription model can be understood more clearly; 4, our investment highlights, and we'll finish today's presentation with some closing remarks on our long-term fundamental growth potential stretching well beyond FY '25. Please turn to Slide 4, which summarizes how we performed in the first quarter of fiscal year 2024.
Dana Dunne
executiveLike we said, our profit margins are up a lot, and that comes from how strong the Prime model is and from Prime members maturing. Cash EBITDA has also more than doubled compared with a year earlier as a result. And the most important thing: we're on track to hit or beat the target we set for ourselves for FY '25. A few of the main highlights for today's presentation: first, during the first quarter of FY '24, the power of the eDO Prime model kept driving major gains in profitability. Cash EBITDA came in at EUR 29.4 million, over twice the EUR 14 million we reported in the first quarter of FY '23, and the cash EBITDA margin improved by 9 percentage points year-on-year. Cash marginal profit was EUR 52 million. That's a 55% increase year-on-year, and the margin improved by 10 percentage points in just 1 year as well. Prime's share of cash marginal profit already reached 65% of the Group's total, and at this point subscription is what largely drives our results. That's why we've changed how we report internally, as a subscription-led business. And going forward, our reporting segments will be Prime and Non-Prime. Second highlight. eDO Prime miles is now firmly established as a success.
Dana Dunne
executiveDuring the first quarter of FY '24, we hit 4.7 million subscribers. That represents a 48% rise compared with the same quarter a year earlier, even though the industry shifted toward more normalized seasonality patterns. Starting in the first quarter of FY '23, customers were booking nearer to their departure date because of the Omicron catch-up effect, and that is no longer occurring in the first quarter of FY '24. After the period ended, we brought in another 200,000 members, bringing us to 4.9 million subscribers. Prime cash revenue margin. This is a new quarterly reporting KPI. It likewise demonstrated quite substantial improvement, rising 46% compared with the first quarter of FY '23, and that aligns with the growth in Prime members. In addition, Prime's share of total cash revenue margin exceeded 50% in a single quarter for the first time since we launched Prime in 2017. Prime's share of cash revenue margin climbed from 41% in the first quarter of FY '23 to 57% in the first quarter of FY '24. Third highlight. eDO remains well on track to meet or exceed the FY '25 targets it set for itself. That is because, on the Prime members side, our quarterly net adds run rate is ahead of the implied run rate required to achieve the FY '25 targets.
Dana Dunne
executiveAnd Prime ARPU is, as we guided, moving toward the mid-EUR 70s and will then converge with our FY '25 guidance of roughly EUR 80 per user. During the first quarter of FY '24, Prime ARPU came in at EUR 75.5 per user. As for cash EBITDA, our Q1 FY '24 results showed that a higher share of year 2 plus Prime members delivers a very favorable effect on margins, doubling year-on-year. The figures we reported today reaffirm that we remain well on track to hit our self-imposed target of more than EUR 180 million in FY '25. Fourth highlight. Over the longer term and beyond 2025, eDO has strong fundamental growth potential. That stems from how attractive our area of travel is. We will keep benefiting from robust online consumer leisure travel, where a structural shift is underway from offline to online, along with convenience and the desire to travel. We will also benefit from eDO's capacity to raise household penetration further in the markets where we currently offer Prime, given today's low penetration levels. In addition, we will bring Prime into new markets, going from 10 markets to many more markets. We will move into new customer segments, and we will launch further products and services under Prime.
Dana Dunne
executiveTo sum up, Prime has shown itself to be a success and is now solidly established. It produced meaningful improvements in profit margins, and those will keep coming. We think we have the right model, the right people, and the right structure to capture and deliver the exciting opportunities for creating shareholder value that lie well, well, well ahead of us. If everyone could now please turn to Slide 6 of the presentation, I'll walk you through the Prime model. Back in 2017, we launched our Prime subscription program. Before that, we were just like every other travel company. We were a transaction-based company, with a transaction-based relationship with our customers. In fact, the subscription model has been shown to be highly successful in other industries, such as Costco for supermarkets or Netflix for video streaming, and many other companies in many other industries as well. However, in travel, nobody had done it until us. Today, we have proven it is successful, with us having almost 5 million subscribers and adding around 1.7 million subscribers every year, and with good healthy margins. So the company we were back in 2017 is not the company we are today. We are no longer a transaction company like all other travel companies.
Dana Dunne
executiveSo instead, at this point over 50% of the company's top line and profit margins are being driven by subscription, and we get all the advantages that come with being a subscription business. What that gives us is far greater certainty and predictability in our results, less exposure to outside forces, stronger customer loyalty, and so on and so forth. The subscription portion already accounts for more than 50% of the company's results, and it keeps growing larger with each passing day, month, and year. So as of today, we truly are a subscription company, and that's how we manage and operate the business. If you'd turn to Slide 7. Tied to our being a subscription-based company is the fast expansion of our subscriber base. As a matter of fact, Prime members remain on track to hit or beat our guidance of 7.25 million members by the end of March 2025. Measured on a run rate basis, we're running ahead of the pace needed to reach our Prime member target. Keep in mind that net adds of Prime members are shaped by seasonality, and especially in the first quarter of FY '24, since the industry shifted toward more normalized seasonal patterns. For instance, Prime member net adds in the first quarter of FY '23 got a positive lift from the Omicron catch-up effect, as more people sought to book their travel nearer to their summer departure date.
Dana Dunne
executiveThat drove the bump in net additions. Still, during periods with stronger seasonal volume, we ought to see larger net adds — the fourth quarter being one example. Turning back to the Prime member goal for FY '25: we remain on course to hit or surpass 7.25 million Prime members by the close of March 2025. Given the outstanding progress achieved, that objective is entirely within reach. Alongside our current plans, we'll keep expanding the Prime addressable market, rolling Prime out in additional countries to push our run rate even higher. That leaves us fully confident about reaching or beating our FY '25 target. Kindly move to Slide 8. Cash EBITDA is tracking toward our goal of more than EUR 180 million for FY '25. As Prime members mature, profitability has strengthened considerably over the past fiscal year. During the first quarter of FY '24, the cash marginal profit margin kept climbing. It rose to 31% from 21% in the first quarter of FY '23 — an improvement of 10 percentage points. Cash EBITDA likewise improved markedly. In the first quarter of FY '24, the cash EBITDA margin more than doubled, reaching 18% compared with 8.8% in the first quarter of FY '23.
Dana Dunne
executiveThat marks a gain of 9 percentage points, comfortably ahead of the margins we posted in the first quarter, second quarter, third quarter, and fourth quarter of FY '23. Moving to Slide 9 now. As a reminder, for the Prime versus Non-Prime comparison, we continue to believe examining the business on a trailing 12-month basis is more meaningful, since Prime is an annual subscription offering while seasonality patterns weigh heavily on the Non-Prime side. The KPIs we reported today demonstrate robust growth and meaningful marginal profit uplift as Prime members mature. Further evidence that we truly are a subscription company comes from the healthy expansion in cash revenue margin and cash marginal profit, which produced a 50% cash revenue margin and 59% cash marginal profit for the 12 months ending June 2024, all generated by Prime members, compared with 41% and 53% only a year earlier. With a considerably bigger share of Prime members now sitting in the second year and later years of their membership cohort, Prime's profitability keeps climbing. I'll now hand things to David, who will walk you through our outstanding first quarter FY '24 results and the disclosure enhancements.
David Corrales
executiveThanks, Dana. Everyone, please go to Slide 10 in the presentation, where I'll walk you through the financial results in greater detail. During fiscal '24's first quarter, we achieved robust cash EBITDA growth and meaningful margin gains as Prime members mature. In Q1 of fiscal '24, cash revenue margin is 5% above the level seen in the same quarter a year earlier. Cash marginal profit and cash EBITDA rose 55% and 110%, respectively, from the first quarter of last year to the quarter we have just reported. Subscribers increased 47% over the last year, reaching 4.7 million. Furthermore, 57% of our cash revenue margin and 65% of our cash marginal profit in the quarter now come from Prime members. As we guided, Prime member maturity is the key profitability driver, and that has produced these strong profitability improvements as more Prime members renew. Cash marginal profit margin rose to 31% in the first quarter of '24, up from 21% in the first quarter of '23 — a 10 percentage point gain. Cash EBITDA margin more than doubled in the first quarter of '24, reaching 18% compared with 9% in the first quarter of fiscal '23.
David Corrales
executiveCash EBITDA came in at EUR 29.4 million for the first quarter of '24, which is up 110% year on year. If you'd please turn to Slide 11 of the presentation. Our revenue margin, excluding adjusted revenue items, reached EUR 157.5 million. We've applied a new estimate for revenue recognition on Prime subscription fees — something we'll walk through in detail in the next section of this presentation — and it carries a catch-up effect from the past. That's the reason we reduced the revenue margin by EUR 7.9 million, since this amount doesn't reflect the Prime revenue of the current period. Adjusted revenue margin rose 8% to EUR 157.5 million, mainly driven by a 65% increase in Prime revenue margin, which followed the successful expansion of the Prime member base. Those Prime revenue margin growth rates were offset by the non-Prime revenue margin, which fell 23% compared with the first quarter of '23. That quarter — the first quarter of '23 — got a positive impact from the catch-up of Omicron booking. Variable costs were down 8%, on lower variable cost from Prime members, driven by a more mature Prime member base. All in all, the first quarter of '24 continued the improving trends we saw in fiscal '23, along with significant improvements in profitability, as more Prime members renew their membership.
David Corrales
executiveHigher personnel costs were the main factor behind a EUR 3 million rise in fixed costs. Adjusted EBITDA therefore came in at EUR 20 million, which is a substantial improvement. In the first quarter of fiscal '24, adjusted net income was EUR 1.1 million. Moving on to Slide 12, I'll walk you through the cash flow statement. Despite the shift toward more normalized seasonality patterns, we closed the first quarter of fiscal '24 with positive cash flow from operations of EUR 18.3 million, largely because the Prime member base expanded successfully, driving higher EBITDA. In the first quarter of '24, working capital showed an outflow of EUR 9.3 million, again chiefly as the business moved toward more normalized seasonality patterns. In the first quarter of '23, the larger working capital inflow got a positive boost from a catch-up effect tied to Omicron bookings, which produced a volume increase between March and June '22 that exceeded the volume increase between March and June of '23. Our liquidity position has been managed well, thanks to our strong business model and active management. Throughout the pandemic, liquidity has stayed stable and more than sufficient.
David Corrales
executiveBy the close of June 2023, our liquidity stood at a robust EUR 198 million. During Q1 of 2024, we invested EUR 10.8 million — that's EUR 3.9 million more, reflecting the capitalization of our software. Cash consumed by financing came to EUR 5.2 million, versus EUR 34.8 million in Q1 of 2023. That difference is largely tied to the June 2023 payment of the government-sponsored loan totaling EUR 3.8 million, the EUR 30 million repayment of the Super Senior RCF during Q1 of 2023, plus the settlement of refinancing-related costs of EUR 3.4 million, also in Q1 of 2023. Now, if you'd kindly turn to Slide 14, I'll walk you through why we made these changes and the additional enhancements to our disclosures, so you can properly gauge us and our subscription model. Since subscription drives the bulk of eDO's performance results, we chose to revise the reporting breakdown so our subscription listing is better reflected. Looking across the last 4 years, the shift from transaction to subscription business is evident. Prime revenue margin climbed from 4% to 55% of total revenue in Q1 of 2024, while marginal profit rose from 2% to 57%.
David Corrales
executiveStarting with Q1 of '24, the Group is going to report Prime versus non-Prime across revenue margins, variable costs, marginal profits and adjusted EBITDA, and it'll do so quarterly rather than just showing last-12-month numbers. Alongside that Prime/non-Prime split, the Group will begin disclosing revenue by timing of recognition, so it lines up with the new reportable segment. And third, to better align the financials with how the subscription service has evolved, the Group has decided to shift the Prime revenue recognition base away from usage-based recognition toward a gradual model. If you'd turn to Slide 15 now, I'll walk through each of these disclosure changes in a little more detail and explain the rationale. As you know, before this change the Group defined its segments as the different markets it operated in, because that was how information got reported internally and how strategic calls were made — things like launching new services, setting pricing strategies or putting money into marketing. But now that the majority of the Group's revenue and profits come from subscription, that's no longer how we examine information to assess performance and make operating decisions.
David Corrales
executiveIn the Group's view, separating Prime from non-Prime within segments better captures how the leadership team assesses operating performance. Starting with the first quarter of fiscal '24, segment reporting shows Prime and non-prime as the new segments. Comparative disclosure has been restated so it reflects this segment change. For the Prime segment, then, this means the profit and loss measure that Prime users generate. Where cash revenue margin for Prime is concerned, it covers items including, though not limited to, Prime fees collected, GDS incentives and commissions earned from bookings made by Prime users, ancillary services that Prime members buy, and so on. As for the non-Prime segment, it means the profit and loss measure that non-Prime generates. Please turn now to Slide 16. Because of the segment reporting change, a fresh revenue breakdown built on revenue recognition is now more suitable. Prior to the change, through the fourth quarter of fiscal '23, the Group disaggregated revenue from contracts with customers by revenue source, namely diversification revenue, Classic customer revenue, classic supplier revenue, and Advertising and Metasearch. After the Group's operating segment change and the anticipated product evolution, management concluded that the earlier revenue disaggregation no longer remained relevant; instead, a revenue disclosure built on the uniqueness of the revenue recognition method, alongside the Prime, non-Prime dimension, is more suitable.
David Corrales
executiveWe’ve grouped revenue according to how alike the economic factors are and how similarly the timing of revenue recognition works, and that makes it simpler to connect revenue with operating KPIs—these are the 3 new parts of the breakdown. First, Gradual, which is revenue recognized gradually across the service agreement period and mainly involves recognized subscription fees, the service of cancellation for any reason and Flexi Ticket, and airline over-commissions. Transaction Date, the second type of revenue, is revenue recognized at booking date and mainly involves service fees, ancillaries, insurance, incentives other than airline over-commissions and other fees. And Other, a residual category, mainly involves advertising and metasearch revenue, tax refunds, and other fees. Please turn to Slide 17: we’ve also made a further change in estimate regarding recognition of subscription fees, which aligns with how the prime product has evolved and how relevant the service is for subscribers. As a result, the accounting estimates for recognition of subscription fees have changed from revenue recognition based on usage to revenue recognition based on the gradual model. The change we implemented aligns with the standards of other subscription businesses and helps investors and sell-side analysts better understand the business as a subscription company.
David Corrales
executiveThis revenue recognition change has no impact on any cash metrics—none of them—but it does affect how subscription fees, revenue margin, and adjusted EBITDA are recognized through the P&L. Our view remains that the cash metrics are the best lens for understanding the subscription business, and this change leaves those cash metrics untouched. We've been talking about cash metrics for quite a while and will keep doing so, as other subscription businesses do. Looking at the chart on the left-hand side, you can see a substantial rise in adjusted EBITDA, even under the former accounting estimate. That chart presents pro forma adjusted EBITDA for the first quarter of fiscal '24. The reported figure is EUR 20 million, and the figure had we not changed the estimation of revenue recognition of subscription fees would be EUR 16.2 million. Either way, the increase from the previous year is very substantial. In the next 2 slides, 18 and 19, we'll walk you through how our figures look on a quarterly basis under the new accounting decision. Kindly turn to Slide 18. On the left-hand side, growth in cash revenue margin came from the successful expansion of the Prime member base and was partly offset by the decrease of non-Prime, which in the prior year got a positive impact from the catch-up of Omicron bookings.
David Corrales
executiveLooking at the right-hand side, when we break out cash revenue margin by the timing of revenue, the rise in gradual revenue margin — up 34% — tracks the strong growth of the Prime business, since subscription fees make up a substantial portion of gradual revenue margin. Meanwhile, the decline in transaction data revenue margin stems from lower non-Prime bookings, because the first quarter of fiscal '23 got a positive boost from an Omicron catch-up. Please turn to Slide 19. Cash marginal profit is still growing rapidly, with meaningful gains in profitability. In the first quarter of fiscal '24, cash marginal profits for Prime rose to 35% from 27% in the first quarter of fiscal '23. That works out to a 9 percentage points improvement in just 1 year, as Prime's cash marginal profit weight over total expanded 13 percentage points, from 52% in the first quarter of '23 to 65% in the first quarter of '24. Cash marginal profit margin for non-Prime also expanded 7 percentage points, from 17% in the first quarter of '23 to 25% in the first quarter of '24, as we keep focusing on the most value-added non-Primes. As you can see, our business has evolved tremendously, moving from a transaction business to a subscription business.
David Corrales
executiveSo because of that, it makes sense for our reporting to shift away from the style typical of a transaction company and toward something better suited to a subscription business. At this point I'll hand the presentation back to Dana, who will walk through our investment highlights and offer some closing remarks on our ambitions from fiscal '25 onward.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks, David. Over the next 8 slides, I'll walk through some extra data about eDO and try to sum up why we're an appealing company for investors, and we think there's plenty of room for our valuation to expand. Let's go to Slide 21. Reason one: subscription is a better business model, as other companies such as Costco and Netflix have shown. And our Prime members remain on track to hit or surpass 7.25 million members by FY '25. Let's move to Slide 22, reason two. eDO has proven it can grow its membership base, penetrate markets and win new customers, and we expect that to keep going as the market recovers. Now to Slide 23 of the presentation. Reason three: in travel, eDO is the global flight leader, excluding China, and we use this to drive our success and give us a competitive edge versus others. Let's turn to Slide 24, reason four. We hold pole position in an attractive market and enjoy the first mover advantage. Now Slide 25 of the presentation, reason five. eDO stands out when it comes to profitability and growth. This subscription model is getting better in other industries, generating both long-term high growth and solid profitability.
Dana Dunne
executiveThat's the situation for subscription-based businesses like Netflix and Costco, among others. And at the same time, we're not merely replicating — we're innovating; pushing the model to new heights and accomplishing things nobody else has achieved. Kindly go to Slide 26 in the presentation, the sixth reason. From the earliest days, eDO has been seen as an AI leader in Europe, consistently one step ahead. Kindly go to Slide 27 in the presentation, the seventh reason. We're positioned very well, financed well, and well on track to hit the FY '25 targets we set ourselves, which as a reminder are: Prime members above 7.25 million members, Prime ARPU of roughly EUR 80, and cash EBITDA greater than EUR 180 million. If you would kindly go to Slide 28. I'd like to wrap up by emphasizing the robust underlying growth potentially past FY '25. The potential over the longer term past FY '25 is enormous. Prime right now exists in only 10 countries, yet as a transaction model, we operate in 44 countries. So over time, we'll keep growing clients across many additional countries. Furthermore, inside every country where Prime is offered today, we're far from the normalized household penetration for Prime.
Dana Dunne
executiveThat's going to drive substantial growth. In other product categories where subscription introductions have been around far longer, household penetration in Europe can run from 20% to 60%, depending on the product. Right now, across our top 6 markets, average penetration sits at just 27%. Third, a lot of successful subscription programs have developed into more segmented customers — offers segmented by customer and by product segment. That gives us considerable market growth opportunities too. Taking everything together, with the pivot to our subscription model, eDO is now a far better-quality business. It brings loyalty and repeat customers, which means a business that is increasingly profitable and predictable. We're posting strong underlying profitability, and the growth potential is enormous. All of this will produce superior shareholder returns and excellent customer service, while at the same time transforming and revolutionizing the industry.
David de la Roz
executiveThanks, Dana. Now we'd like to open things up and take your questions.
David de la Roz
executiveWe'll respond to the questions that were submitted to us in writing during the webcast. Questions will be taken on a first come, first serve basis. We're also attempting to group together questions that are similar in nature. If we don't have enough time to answer webcast questions, the Investor Relations team will ensure they get answered afterward. So, I'm going to look at the question list at this point. The first group of questions is from Nizla Naizer at Deutsche Bank. The first question reads, regarding the competitive environment, have any of your larger global peers taken the subscription route, and how do you see the recent news about Google Flights highlighting when it would be the best time to book flights on a certain route? Does that remove some traffic that might have come directly to your website? Dana, would you like to take this one?
Dana Dunne
executiveSure. Yeah, absolutely. So, there are 2 parts to this first question. Part 1 was about global competitors heading down the subscription path. And again, it depends on what we mean by global competitors, but just for focus and <<inaudible>>, I know TripAdvisor launched a subscription program several years ago. And I think they did it for probably around 2 years <<inaudible>> made public in their disclosure about it, and then they pulled back since after about 2 years. And I think that, you know to kind of paraphrase and they said that they like the subscription base. I think it's a good opportunity, but it wasn't working in the way in which they wanted to work for them. <<inaudible>> So, there has not been any further pursuit from them. And I don't think that you see a material pursuit from any of the other global competitor today. This subscription model is very difficult to replicate. We have now 6 years. And actually, I would say, actually even, we've been working on this for over 6 years, subscription. And it requires an awful lot of effort, awful lot of insight and some prerequisites as well to be able to really do it and do it extremely well.
Dana Dunne
executiveWe began with flights. At this point we actually offer flights, hotels, and cars that come with packages, et cetera. So over that stretch of time we've made a great deal of progress. That makes it very hard, and it's a massive endeavor for anybody else to genuinely try to surmount. On the second part of this question, I believe it concerned Google and Google Flights, regarding a new feature they have that spotlights the optimal moment to book on a given route. And I think the question is whether it pulls traffic away from people coming straight to our website. The answer is -- to put it in a single word, no, it does not. It isn't among the main forces behind customer choice at all, and beyond that, let me tie it directly to our business: we're more of a subscription than a transaction business. As a result, our reliance on these kinds of channels is lower on average than other companies. And I think, in fact, you've witnessed that we've seen a substantial decrease in marketing costs once the customer decides becomes a Prime customer. So you observe that as we move into year 2 plus, with more and more Prime customers and subscribers approaching that first booking, the margins are highly appealing for us there.
Dana Dunne
executiveAnd finally, since a great many of our first-time subscribers arrive through referrals alone and word of mouth. And I believe we've also told investors that customer satisfaction and the net promoter score are extremely high for Prime, so we gain from that too. David, you have the filed now.
David de la Roz
executiveAlright, Nizla's second question is whether we can provide some detail on prime churn — has it shifted or remained steady across the last 4 months, and does it differ between markets? Well, as we've mentioned on several occasions, we disclosed churn just the one time to give people reassurance, and we don't observe the overwhelming majority of other B2C subscription programs doing that. That said, speaking more qualitatively, churn has been trending slightly better. As you're aware, we track customer satisfaction and net promoter score constantly, and those are 2 really key variables for us. Right now, these KPIs are genuinely outstanding. And while we can of course still improve, based on these figures we have no concern about churn rising in the near term. The third question is, I understand the subscription pivot leads to the new reporting structure, but could you give us some detail on how overall bookings did in Q1? Well, let me remind everybody that what we've discontinued is no longer relevant to us. In fact, those items risk creating confusion about what actually drives our numbers, since we're a subscription company, and so we're adding other disclosures that are far more relevant for a subscription company.
David de la Roz
executiveTake Prime, for example — we don’t disclose its bookings, since that would only create confusion; it isn’t what moves our results. To address what you asked, at a broader level, we keep gaining share and continue trading very positively. Even so, we won’t be revealing aggregate bookings or how many Prime bookings there are on a recurring basis. Francisco Ruiz of Exane BNP has the next batch of questions. First: once seasonality is back to normal, how should working capital behave during the year? I’ll handle that one. Directionally, an inflow is what we should see, because gross sales are expanding as anticipated and volumes remain higher than in earlier periods. That applies to the full year in aggregate. That said, as you know, this can be affected by quarter-to-quarter seasonality, and there’s one more factor for the full-year total — especially given our March fiscal year-end, where the seasonal pattern has shifted somewhat compared with the prior year.
David de la Roz
executiveIn 2023, Easter fell during the first week of April, while this time it lands in the last week of March. So we gain 1 additional week of vacation time inside the quarter — that final quarter. As we've said before, and I'm glad to say it again, when people are on vacation, they aren't booking vacations. They're simply on vacation. So vacation stretches such as Easter week usually amount to a weak booking period. That one landed in April '23, and the following cycle will land in March '24. The second question concerns the Prime subscription. It asks whether you could give a sense of whether new Prime members come from new geographies, or whether you're also seeing good growth in geographies where the product is more mature, like France. In fact, we observe fairly comparable performance across geographies. For total members, the largest factors are the size of the country and when Prime was launched there. But I think people should remember — and we've disclosed these figures previously — that the relative penetration of Prime members against the number of households in a given country remains quite low compared with other subscription products.
David de la Roz
executiveWe said previously that France, our most established market, sits below 5% penetration, versus ranges of — depending on which subscription product you examine for B2C — between 20% and 50%. So it remains quite early. Thus we keep seeing solid subscriber growth in both mature and newer markets. On the third question: under the new segment reporting, would the revenue margin for Prime members simply equal average Prime members during the period multiplied by ARPU? That isn't quite how it works — there are 2 differences from what you asked. First, ARPU is calculated on cash revenue margin rather than revenue margin. So ARPU includes the entire subscription fee, irrespective of the accrual elements in the P&L. And the second point is that it relies on the last 12 months of reporting. So it isn't Prime numbers for the period; you have to build in all 4 quarters for that to be right. The next batch of questions comes from Andrew Ross at Barclays. The first asks, regarding the removal of gross bookings disclosure, what is the best way to model your working capital if you don't disclose the gross bookings?
David de la Roz
executiveSo, we actually do report gross bookings, and those figures are still available in the notes to the financial statements. Then the second question asks whether the count of bookings from Prime members isn't a key metric for grasping the lasting value of the offering in driving your ARPU. They want a reminder of why we consider subscription income a relevant metric when you're accounting for discounts on flights and still earning a mark-up on ancillary items through Prime. How can confidence be built that Prime's value is sustainable when the frequency isn't known? All right, that is a completely fair question, and I'm really glad it was raised. But what matters most to hold onto is that we are now unequivocally a subscription company. And transaction volume doesn't dictate how profitable the subscription model is, and we've laid this out several times, but I'm happy to walk through it once more. Sure, additional transactions will lift the ARPU, but we've also noted that this is purely revenue, not profit. We've further noted that we don't generate significantly more profit, or any meaningful extra profit, from a Prime member with 3 bookings compared with one with 2 bookings, or one with 4 bookings compared with another with 3 bookings.
David de la Roz
executiveAt the profit level, we tend to equate things, right? It has to be—our goal is for it to be a genuinely excellent deal for Prime members. So past the second booking, we aren't earning extra money, given the customer mix model. How engaged subscribers are with a subscription service—which I believe is where you're heading—can be seen perfectly clearly through 2 metrics. The first is how Prime members evolve, and the second is profitability. If engagement fell or churn rose, that would show up as either fewer members, lower margins, or both declining. But those 2 metrics will let you observe it. And we've made the decision to stop reporting the prime booking, since it's a KPI that pins investors to a transactional business mindset. And I think we really need to get away from that mindset, because it isn't what explains our business. On the other hand, we continue to provide bookings for the non-Prime business, which is the residual transactional business that we <<inaudible>>. From the customer's perspective, we've shared at times—not each quarter but on a regular basis—customer satisfaction figures, NPS Net Promoter Scores, which have demonstrated that customers are highly satisfied with Prime and show a strong willingness to recommend Prime to friends and family.
David de la Roz
executiveMoving forward, we'll keep sharing that periodically, just as we've done before. Andrew's third question asks for commentary on how you'd expect trends to play out across Q2, Q3, and Q4 — and whether we still expect an acceleration in the back half of the fiscal year as comps normalize. Well, a couple of things on that. We're providing extremely detailed guidance 18 months out, and nobody else in the market is doing that, right? And I think that gives you a North star that's very interesting. Another point I'd make — let me, for instance, point to the new disclosures we're beginning to provide, and the revenue breakdown in particular. We have the one where we split revenue between gradual revenue, transaction-date revenue and other. The first 2 categories are the really important ones. If you look at the data we've disclosed for the last year, you'll see gradual revenue rises every quarter, and that's because it's the one driven mostly by the number of Prime members, and Prime members increased every quarter. On the other hand, you'll see that transaction-date revenue is one with more variability, because it's the one that depends on seasonality, right?
David de la Roz
executiveExpect that behavior pattern to keep going in the future. Gross revenues should rise each quarter, whether it's Q2, Q3, or Q1, and transaction date revenue, you should expect, will show more variability, correct? As a reminder for everyone, Q3 is the year's weakest seasonal stretch. So between now and then, we'll be entering quarters where transaction date revenue alone moves downward, and after that Q4 will pick <<inaudible>> up again from a seasonality standpoint. Carlos Trevino of Banco Santander has the next batch of questions. First, can you expand on what caused your working capital outflow in Q1? Was it entirely due to lower bookings at quarter-end versus the inning, or are other factors at play? No, that's really the main driver. In the comparable quarter a year earlier, March to June of '22, you'll recall there was upward seasonality because the Omicron wave hit the population mainly from December of '21 through February of '22. So in the periods that followed, bookings people would typically have made in January and February for summer departures were not made, and instead they occurred in the April to June of '22 quarter.
David de la Roz
executiveThis year, seasonality patterns went back to being more normal, since thankfully no new COVID strain emerged that changed how people behaved. In January and February, customers were booking for the summer the way they usually do, so you didn't see that extra pileup of reservations spilling into the April-to-June window — bookings that customers normally wouldn't make during that stretch. That's the part that's fully effective. The second quarter — could you go into more detail about how business has been trending in July and August? Should we be expecting normal seasonality for the second quarter of fiscal '24? Dana, do you want to handle that one?
Dana Dunne
executiveSure. So Q2 is the summer quarter, correct? That means July and August, and honestly, I'd say both months have turned out quite strong — not only for us, frankly, but for the industry as a whole. There are a couple of key points I'd like to highlight. First, from the leisure customer's perspective, we're seeing how important leisure travel is, even in what you might call a sub-optimal economic or macroeconomic climate, right? And clearly, over the past 12 months there have been worries — inflation and other macroeconomic issues, for instance. Yet what we've observed is that leisure travelers have started — and continue — to travel. That doesn't actually surprise us, and I think we've tried to share data before showing that, if you look from 1980 to 2020, right before COVID struck, amid plenty of macroeconomic shocks too, leisure customers still traveled and genuinely want to travel. And what they've attempted to do with discretionary income is cut back on other discretionary categories ahead of travel. So we definitely see a good one there.
Dana Dunne
executiveThe other point we’re noticing is that seasonality is coming back. So seasonality is now showing up, and as David mentioned, for instance, looking ahead into Q3, we’d expect the usual seasonal pattern: Q3 isn’t as strong in absolute terms as Q2, while Q4 is much stronger in absolute terms than Q3. That’s the standard seasonal aspect of our business and of the travel industry.
David de la Roz
executiveAlright, thanks. Our next batch of questions is from <<inaudible>>. First up: in their view, growth beyond fiscal '25 will stem from, one, growing Prime inside the European markets where it already operates; 2, widening what the product lineup offers; 3, taking a fully functional Prime program into additional markets. Is there any news on that effort, particularly the push into hotels? Dana, would you like to handle this one?
Dana Dunne
executiveSure, absolutely. Look, I believe Chad raised this point prior to my closing remarks. So I did actually cover the bulk of the growth picture on that. Let me briefly recap the growth first, and then hit a couple of items I may not have gotten to. The growth really spans, let's say, several dimensions. First, I mentioned the expense lines across the existing European markets, where we discussed penetration averaging roughly 2.7%, and other subscription-based products sitting at 20% to 50%, 60% to even — there's substantial headroom for us to grow there. Second, obviously, is moving into new markets, where as a transaction-based business we operate in 44 countries. On the subscription-based side, we're in 10 countries. So clearly there are many more geographies available to us, and that directly ties to the increase in our total addressable market. Third is broadening what we offer product-wise. Prime has — we launched Prime as a flights-only subscription program. After that we added hotels, then we added cars, and we added dynamic packages too.
Dana Dunne
executiveWhat we've seen is that Prime's offering is genuinely a travel product, not merely one for flights. Customer satisfaction levels come in very strong and high, and in fact satisfaction is considerably higher when someone belongs to Prime and uses one of those 4 Prime products than when they don't. So on the whole, we're seeing really solid growth on the product side in that dimension too. And then, finally, from a customer segmentation standpoint: other subscription-based businesses do offer segmented tiers, and that delivers meaningful, healthy growth as they work to reach new or adjacent customer segments. So we definitely have solid opportunities there as well. All told, there are very large growth opportunities in front of us across these 4 dimensions. David?
David de la Roz
executiveYes. The same investor's second question notes that margins in our non-Prime business appear to be rising, and asks what's driving it — longer, more complex trips, reduced performance marketing spend, or lower performance marketing prices? I'll take that one. As we mentioned a few times, I believe, on today's call, we pointed out that Q1 of the prior year was somewhat of a normal quarter, and there was a very high volume of bookings with — some bookings that ought to have been made in January and February actually took place much later, which we refer to as the Omicron bookings. And when we look at what we've achieved on the non-Prime side this quarter compared with last year, essentially we're getting more selective, right, and we're making fewer bookings with a higher revenue margin per booking, and marginal profit margin. The third question asks, when do you expect to announce financial targets for post fiscal '25? I think I'm almost going to say, nice try. We've provided super detailed guidance, which at present is 18 months out, that no other company does. We're very comfortable staying with that one. And even when we do give guidance beyond fiscal '25, you'll be the first to know.
David de la Roz
executiveTom Bushey from Sunderland Capital has the next batch of questions. He says they value the discussion about how the business has shifted since 2017 and the new metrics. Given that you've now demonstrated a stable business with high growth that generates substantial cash, what's your present thinking on buybacks as a way to capitalize on the stock being undervalued? I do agree with you that ours is a cash-generating business, and that thanks to the subscription model, we'll keep being one and actually produce more cash as time goes on. And because of this over the last year, we've been able to pay off all outstanding bank debt, including what we had drawn under the revolving credit facility and the government-sponsored loan. And we now have a good liquidity cushion, made up mostly of large availability under the revolver rather than cash in hand. To make an investment into our own securities, we first need discretionary cash on the balance sheet, which, given that we're about to enter the low seasonality period of the year in winter, will happen at the end of the fiscal year. It is at that point that the Board will decide what to do, and we'll make the best use of discretionary cash to invest in cash security.
David de la Roz
executiveGabriel Megias from Bestinver has the next question. You gave non-Prime bookings for Q1 of '24. What was that figure for Q1 of '23? Actually, we don't disclose that number. What I can do is indicate the direction. On a directional basis, non-Prime bookings in fiscal '24 have been lower than in fiscal '23, reflecting the dynamic we were observing, but we won't disclose non-Prime bookings retroactively. Starting now, we will disclose them going forward. There's another question from <<inaudible>>, the CEO of <<inaudible>>. Could you repeat the current Prime household penetration of the <<inaudible>>, which is 2.7%? Guilherme Macedo of Caixabank has the next questions. First is a clarification about the new reporting. Will Prime subscription revenue be accrued in an exactly linear fashion over the year? Yes, it will accrue gradually. Second, will accrual of Prime variable costs keep the previous reporting criteria? The answer is absolutely, yes. Costs have always been accrued and will keep being accrued according to when they are incurred. Taking them in order: marketing cost when we purchase the clicks to bring people to our website, merchant costs when they are incurred in the transaction, customer service costs when they are incurred, et cetera.
David de la Roz
executiveThere's really no difference at all in how the costs accrue on our income statement. The subscription revenue is the sole thing that shifts. So what might that mean for EBITDA seasonality? In terms of EBITDA seasonality, I would say it will likely look pretty similar. Since if you look at it — I mentioned a point earlier, and if you look at the breakdown, which I think is helpful for everybody, of gradual revenues versus transaction date revenues, you're going to have gradual revenue on both — mostly from subscription fees, which rises quarter-after-quarter, and you're going to have the transaction date revenues, which seasonality affects. So if I take a long view here rather than a very short one, as the Prime business grows increasingly larger than the non-Prime, you're going to see far less seasonality in our business from a P&L standpoint. You'll still have some seasonality on the balance sheet side, swings on the working capital side of things, but the P&L should become more and more regular over time.
David de la Roz
executiveOur next question is from Ankit Gupta at Goldman Sachs. What should we expect for marketing costs next quarter? Will they be similar to 1Q? Yes, we do expect that. The real driver of how marketing cost evolves is the growing seniority of our Prime members. The more Prime members we have in their second and subsequent years, the less marketing costs will include. So the patterns are going to be <<inaudible>>. The next question is whether you have any targets for leverage metrics. We're very happy to see how the leverage metrics have evolved. In fact, if you look at how they've moved over the last 12 months — 12 months ago, leverage was measured under our covenants, or net leverage over cash EBITDA on a last 12 month basis, and it has fallen from 6.5x to 3.5x, which is 3 turns in just 12 months, which I think is quite remarkable. But again, that's on the last 12 months measure. If you take just the last quarter and multiply it by 4, you would actually be below 3x. If you take our public guidance on cash EBITDA from March of '25, which is EUR 180 million, you would actually be below 2x.
David de la Roz
executiveSo this is a business whose leverage is going to sit under 2x, according to the public guidance we've given. Our next question is from <<inaudible>>. If I heard you right, you mentioned that past the second booking by a Prime member, no money is made at all. Can you expand a little on the reason that happens? Did you structure the subscription fee so that a target return gets locked in during the first 2 bookings, and after that target has been hit, members receive the entire advantage of the discounts? Well, let me make that clearer, hopefully, by pointing to the model that serves as our inspiration. The model inspiring us is the one Costco uses. Some of you might know it as investors, and likely quite a few of you know it as customers. For an investor, that model is of course -- well, it's one where Costco collects a subscription fee for the ability to shop on their premises. And then the prices on the actual goods that people buy carry only a small margin added on top, so that Costco can offset the cost of running the business it operates.
David de la Roz
executiveAs a result, every extra purchase made by customers generates revenue, yet it generates almost no profit. And honestly, Costco's overall profit level is very predictable—you simply take the count of their subscribers and multiply that by the subscription fee, and that gets you to the profit they ought to be earning. That also means, from the consumer's perspective, they are aware that the best possible deal they will get comes from Costco, since Costco is essentially returning to consumers nearly everything aside from what it absolutely must keep to cover costs. That is the very same thing that occurs—and that is how we set prices on transactions and how we think about the amount of, say, giveback we must provide to our subscribers when they make their second booking, their third booking, and their fourth booking. They will get the best possible deal with us, correct? And that is what we want them to know and how we want them to come back. We do not price differently based on whether it is a first transaction, a second transaction, or a third transaction. So it is not the case that you get a better deal on the second versus the first, or the other way around, and that you get a better deal on the first versus the second.
David de la Roz
executiveIn the first, second, third, fourth, and so on, you receive an outstanding deal. Yet a major distinction exists between the first and every remaining one: the first is the only one that carries a subscription fee on our side. The next question—and in fact the final one in the queue today—comes from Mathews Alfredo of Spread Research. Could you remind us which countries Prime is already in? And which additional countries do you intend to enter this year? Prime is currently in 10 countries, including France, Italy, Germany, Spain, Switzerland, Portugal, the U.S., Canada, the U.K., and Australia. We are present, however, in another 34 countries with the transactional model only. We feel very positive about the opportunity ahead of us. We will open a new country, but we do not disclose which until the moment we have already done it, because it would be interesting information for our competitors that we don't feel we should provide to them. So that's the last question we have. And with that, I would like to thank everyone for joining us today.
David de la Roz
executiveBefore we wrap up, I'd like to let you know that our conference call for the first half results of fiscal '24 is scheduled for Wednesday, 15th of November. Until then, we'd be very glad to take your questions through our Investor Relations team or via the investor e-mail address, investors@edreamsodigeo.com. Have a wonderful day, and a great end of August. And we look forward to seeing you in person soon, or mostly on the 15th of November.
Dana Dunne
executiveThank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete eDreams ODIGEO S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to eDreams ODIGEO S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in eDreams ODIGEO S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.