EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 13, 2020

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Utilities Electric Utilities earnings 26 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and thanks for holding. This is Emma, the Chorus Call operator speaking. I'd like to welcome all of you and thank you for being with us on EnBW's conference call for investors and analysts covering the Q3 results 2020. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll hand the conference over to Ingo Peter Voigt, who leads Finance, M&A and Investor Relations. The floor is yours.

Ingo Voigt

executive
#2

Yes. Thank you so much, and good afternoon to everyone, speaking here from Karlsruhe. Thanks for being with us on this Friday afternoon for the investor and analyst conference call covering EnBW's figures for the 9 months of '20. We hope all of you are well and healthy, even during these times that remain unusual and challenging. As usual, our CFO, Thomas Kusterer, is here with us, and he will lay out the following topics: our climate neutrality strategy, which we published on October 6; and the key effects on how we performed and where we stand in the first 9 months of '20, amid the life and circumstances of the COVID-19 pandemic. Following that, we look forward to hearing your comments and questions. So with that, I'll hand things straight over to Thomas, who will walk you through the relevant figures and slides. Thomas, the floor is yours.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#3

Ingo, many thanks. Ladies and gentlemen, I'd also like to welcome you to today's conference call. Allow me to begin with the key messages for 2020 so far. First, I want to address a topic of great importance for EnBW today and even more so going forward — our climate neutrality strategy, which you'll find on Slide 3. As most of you are surely aware, we have been repositioning our business portfolio since 2013. Back in 2012, only 19% of total installed capacity came from renewables. By the end of this year, that figure will climb to 40%. That shows the clear focus and concrete implementation of our sustainable corporate strategy. On top of that, even before the Coal Exit Act, we voluntarily let go of roughly 40% of our conventional power generation capacity, for environmental and economic reasons. Building on this consistent repositioning and today's political and regulatory environment, we have formulated and now adopted a comprehensive package of concrete measures for environmental, economic and social sustainability. We have a clear implementation plan to reach our climate neutrality target. Beginning in 2018, we will cut emissions by 50% through 2030, down to a maximum of 8.8 million tonnes of CO2.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#4

The whole EnBW Group will have zero net emissions, and be climate neutral, no later than the end of 2035. The coal phase-out is, naturally, the biggest piece of the emissions reduction. EnBW currently has 4.6 gigawatts of installed coal-fired generation capacity. By 2030, we will have cut our coal capacity by roughly 2.5 gigawatts. The remaining approximately 2 gigawatts gets decommissioned from 2030 to 2035. Those units are our newest, most flexible and most efficient hard coal plants: RDK 8 in Karlsruhe, our stake in GKM 9 in Mannheim, and the lignite plant at Lippendorf. Fuel switching from coal to gas is also necessary if we are to keep providing district heating securely in the future while further cutting our Scope 1 emissions. Beyond that, lowering emissions from our vehicle fleet, canteens, buildings and so on matters, though it will surely be a smaller part of our push toward net zero CO2 emissions by 2035. Decarbonizing gas and, ultimately, hydrogen availability will be important for fully decarbonizing power generation. As things stand, we expect hydrogen availability to rise substantially during the second half of the 2030s. To further shrink our Scope 2 footprint, we will buy green energy to cover grid losses.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#5

By the close of 2035, we will reach climate neutrality across Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions—that means climate neutral in electricity generation, heat generation, and our network business. Beyond 2035, any unavoidable residual emissions may be offset through the purchase of recognized offsetting allowances. Still, our clear priority is avoiding CO2 emissions. Offsetting will serve only as what you might call a last resort. Let's return to Slide 2 and take a quick look at our other key messages. During October, we issued a senior bond with a volume of EUR 500 million. Because demand was strong, we secured attractive terms: a 10-year term maturity and a coupon of 0.25%. This marks EnBW's third issuance in the current financial year, following a EUR 500 million senior bond fund at the beginning of April and a EUR 500 million green subordinated bonds in mid-June. Continued expansion of our Renewable Energy segment forms part of our sustainable corporate strategy. Our first commercial solar park, Weesow-Willmersdorf, is the biggest solar farm in Germany that runs out subsidies. In October, we already connected 27 megawatts to the grid. The total capacity of 187 megawatts is to be fully operational by year-end.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#6

On top of that, final investment decisions are already in place for 2 additional large-scale solar projects, each roughly 115 megawatts, located in Brandenburg. So even with the COVID-19 pandemic ongoing, we keep moving forward with our growth projects. Thanks to the large share of stable cash flows in our operating business, our business model remains robust and predictable. During the first 9 months of 2020, that allowed us to lift adjusted EBITDA above EUR 2 billion. That works out to a rise of over 20%. At the same time, our Sales segment is presently feeling a moderate negative effect from the COVID-19 pandemic. We anticipate this will last through the end of the year. As a result, we are making a slight adjustment to our guidance for the Sales segment for this year. Even with the expected COVID-19 pandemic impact on portions of our operating business, EnBW is keeping its existing earnings guidance for the current 2020 financial year on a full year basis. I will cover this in greater detail at the close of the presentation. But before that, let's examine our 9-month figures in detail. I'll begin with a quick look at adjusted EBITDA and group net profit on Slide #4. At group level, adjusted EBITDA rose by 22% to EUR 2.063 billion, primarily for the following 2 reasons.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#7

First, the complete impact of our two fresh offshore wind farms, Hohe See and Albatros, plus elevated wholesale market prices. Group net profit fell during the first 9 months. That is tightly tied to how our financial assets performed, chiefly the mark-to-market valuation of securities. As a result, adjusted group net profit went from EUR 507 million in the first 9 months 2019 down to EUR 367 million this year. Let's now examine in more detail how our 4 business segments performed across the next 2 slides. Starting on Slide 5 with our Sales segment. During the first 9 months 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic produced a moderate negative effect on adjusted EBITDA in the Sales segment. Yet adjusted EBITDA for our Sales segment came in at EUR 216 million, which is 3% higher than the figure for the first 9 months 2019. Plusnet, our nationwide telecommunications company, has been adding to earnings since the beginning of the third quarter 2019. During the COVID-19 pandemic, though, and after adjustment for changes in the consolidated group, segment earnings are 11.3% lower. EnBW subsidiaries sold smaller volumes to B2B customers. Consequently, quantities bought in advance had to be resold into the market at a lower price.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#8

During the first 9 months, adjusted EBITDA for our Grids segment came in slightly lower, down 2.5%. Earnings from the distribution grids fell versus the same period a year earlier, driven by reduced volumes, largely as a result of COVID-19. Meanwhile, revenue from electricity and gas transmission grid usage was up. On the whole, the COVID-19 pandemic did not have a significant impact on earnings performance across the first 9 months. At EUR 1.030 billion, Grids remains the business segment delivering the largest earnings contribution. Moving on to Slide 6 and the Renewable Energy segment: adjusted EBITDA rose sharply, up 88% to EUR 586 million during the first 9 months of 2020. Our 2 new North Sea offshore wind farms are making a substantial contribution to earnings. Hohe See began operations early in the fourth quarter 2019, and Albatros followed in the first quarter of 2020. Beyond that, the Valeco portfolio — onshore wind farms and solar parks in France — has been adding to earnings since the third quarter of 2019. Additionally, wind conditions at both our offshore and onshore wind farms were more favorable than in the prior year period. And hydropower electricity was sold at wholesale market prices higher than those of the previous year.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#9

Let me close with a few remarks on our Generation and Trading segment. The favorable trend carried on through the first 9 months. Adjusted EBITDA rose 66%, reaching EUR 376 million, for two reasons: first, we sold our electricity at wholesale market prices that were higher than in the first 9 months of 2019; second, greater volatility in wholesale markets enabled our trading activities to deliver an extra positive earnings contribution. Those 2 effects did more than compensate for the lost earnings contribution from our Philippsburg 2 nuclear plant, which was decommissioned at the end of 2019 as planned. That takes me to retained cash flow on Slide 7. Retained cash flow climbed to EUR 1.114 billion, driven chiefly by the following 2 effects: higher cash EBITDA and lower income taxes paid during the reporting period. At our AGM on July 17, the second half of the dividend was paid out on July 22, following an advance dividend payment of EUR 0.35 per share on May 14. Because of this, cash flow took a hit of nearly minus EUR 95 million in the third quarter of 2020. Net debt, shown on Slide 8, was up by nearly EUR 1.118 billion as of September 30, 2020, versus December 31, 2019.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#10

Allow me to walk through what drove this development. Our working capital rose by EUR 878 million, primarily due to these effects: first, trade receivables went up substantially in connection with the Renewable Energies Act. The EEG bank account held by our transmission grid operator fell by over EUR 900 million, from EUR 289 million as of December 31, 2019, to minus EUR 680 million at the close of September 2020. Because of the COVID-19 pandemic and the accompanying fall in electricity demand, along with the sharp drop in electricity spot prices, the EEG levy set for 2020 did not cover the corresponding expenses for Renewable Energies. Second, the mark-to-market valuation of our noncurrent securities declined by nearly EUR 200 million. Furthermore, the slight decrease in the interest rate on pension provisions had a modestly increasing effect on net debt. This exceptional rise in the EEG payment in 2020 is of a temporary nature. At the start of June, the federal government decided to cap the EEG levy as part of its economic stimulus package, aiming to relieve pressure on electricity prices. In October, a decision was made that the EEG levy would be lowered to EUR 0.065 per kilowatt hour in 2021 and to EUR 0.06 per kilowatt hour in 2022.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#11

The gap between what the EEG levy cap allows and what was actually paid out under the EEG for 2020 through 2022 is going to be borne by the federal budget. As a result, at the start of 2021 the EEG accounts kept by our transmission grid operators will be brought into balance, and that should give our working capital position a considerable boost. Now, moving to Slide 9, I'd like to walk you through the outlook we have for the financial year we're currently in. The COVID-19 pandemic weighed on the group's adjusted EBITDA only modestly, and only during the first 9 months of 2020. When it comes to our earnings guidance for the whole of 2020, it stays an order for adjusted EBITDA both at group level and across the 3 segments: Grids, Renewable Energies and Generation and Trading. Where the Sales segment is concerned, as I noted at the start of this presentation, we are revising our guidance from the original figure of between EUR 325 million and EUR 400 million down to a range of EUR 275 million to EUR 325 million. The reason, as I said earlier, is that adjusted EBITDA in the Sales segment is right now being hurt by the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. Looking at 2020, adjusted EBITDA in the Grids segment should come in at the levels seen in 2019. Revenues from the use of grids, we expect, will stay flat.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#12

Additional earnings from greater investment in projects under the national electricity and gas networks development plan will drive this. Within the segment, the negative impacts on adjusted EBITDA from the COVID-19 pandemic should be offset. As already mentioned, adjusted EBITDA for the Renewable Energies segment will rise significantly in 2020. The main reason is our offshore wind farms Hohe See and Albatros, which are contributing to earnings on a full-year basis for the first time. New offshore and new onshore wind farms and solar parks also had a positive effect on earnings. Some of these were already completed in 2019. Others are scheduled to be commissioned or acquired during 2020. In our forecast, we can already assume that wind yields will match the long-term average. In 2019, wind conditions are slightly lower. As a result, earnings in 2020 are expected to be somewhat higher than in the previous year. In the Generation and Trading segment, we expect an improved result in 2020. The reason is that in 2020 we supply our electricity at higher wholesale market prices than in the previous year. The decommissioning of Unit 2 of our Philippsburg nuclear power plant at the end of 2019 will have a counteracting effect.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#13

So because of that, our guidance for adjusted EBITDA at the group level still holds, in the range of EUR 2.75 billion to EUR 2.9 billion. On a like-for-like basis, we still anticipate earnings coming in EUR 350 million to EUR 500 million higher than the original strategic target under the EnBW 2020 strategy, which was EUR 2.4 billion by 2020. With that said, I'd like to pass things back to Ingo so we can begin the Q&A session.

Ingo Voigt

executive
#14

Yes. Thomas, thanks a lot for those thorough remarks and comments. With that, I’ll turn things back to the operator so we can open up Q&A.

Operator

operator
#15

<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Andrew Moulder at CreditSights.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#16

Actually, I have a few questions. First, could I ask about yesterday's court case involving Vattenfall, where it apparently won a review of the compensation law covering nuclear plant closures? Could you perhaps comment on that? What does it mean for you? Does it mean anything at all in your case? Or could you just say what it might mean for you and possibly for the other nuclear generators in Germany? Second, regarding the Coal Law, RWE said on its conference call yesterday that the law had not yet been signed or finalized. So could you also give me an update on exactly where things stand with the Coal Law? When will it be signed, and when do you expect it to actually take effect, I suppose? Do you expect signing by the end of the year? And then perhaps a couple of questions specifically about EnBW. On your guidance, you've cut the Sales segment quite significantly. If I look at the midpoint, I'm probably looking at a reduction to roughly EUR 300 million from around EUR 360 million.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#17

So I suppose what I'm really asking is whether there's anything improving elsewhere in the other segments that offsets that? Or is it simply that your guidance range is wide enough that a EUR 60 million drop in sales can be absorbed without any change to your guidance? And last, I know you touched on working capital and the EEG payments, and I have a rough sense of how it works. But could you walk through it once more, please, just to clarify how it's affecting your working capital? How soon do you expect that to be recovered? Will you get it back — all of it back next year? Or do you have to wait until the end of 2022, when the government — when those caps are in place on the EEG? I know that's several questions, but thank you very much.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#18

Andrew, thanks a lot for actually posing those questions. Let me begin with Vattenfall from yesterday. Honestly, it doesn't truly affect us, since the key issue involved residual volumes that Vattenfall couldn't utilize. That situation doesn't apply to us. So we don't anticipate any sort of impact on us. Still, we need to examine it closely. But as things stand right now, that's honestly how we see it. Second, on the Coal Law, it's true that it hasn't been signed yet. And we're actually in dialogue with Berlin and the others. So I can't provide you with a detailed timeline on that. True, we're nearing year-end. But I can't offer a detailed -- a better answer than that, honestly. We're in discussions. On the guidance, true, we're referring to roughly -- that's actually our underlying assumption, EUR 40 million to EUR 50 million in sales, so the impact we anticipate from COVID-19. And true, our guidance is wide enough that we still assume we'll remain within the guidance at group level. And on the EEG account, we assume -- and that's the discussion we're currently having with our government -- that we'll be reimbursed and we'll get -- and the payment will be balanced -- the account will be balanced in January, starting in January and then over the course of 2021.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#19

The largest portion, though, will even out in January of next year. So our assumption is that come January, we will see a meaningful decrease in our working capital.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#20

My apologies. So would that reduction in working capital happen by the close of this year, or does it land in the first quarter of next year instead?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#21

That will happen in January of next year.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#22

All right. Do you have a number, maybe, for where you think working capital will land by the end of this year? I realize it swings quite a bit with EnBW, but any idea where it could be?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#23

To be honest, that's—well, it would be—it's actually a pretty tough quarter to call, because I mean, we have to watch how the weather plays out and what that actually translates to for our volumes by year-end. No—but I don't anticipate it being at a materially lower level than what we're seeing right now, given each year count on its own. Yes?

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#24

Right, okay. So it won't be quite as high as the EUR 878 million we're seeing at the 9-month stage. That level is going to come down.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#25

I'd figure there are going to be some offsetting items in that. My expectation is that we'll still see the EEG bank balance go up, and we could have — we could see certain other decreases elsewhere in working capital. That's the reason I'm somewhat hesitant about handing out guidance, since much of it hinges on how the EEG bank account evolves.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#26

All right, great. And by the way, it's a sunny day here in London. I'm aware that Karlsruhe is normally sunny.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#27

Today isn't actually sunny. Still, we're doing everything we can so that it will be sunny again the next time. To be honest, it could get better. Okay. Thanks, Andrew. Thank you, Andrew. And with that, I'll hand things back to the operator.

Operator

operator
#28

<<operator_script>> It looks like we don’t have any more questions right now. I’ll turn it back to Ingo Peter Voigt for some closing remarks.

Ingo Voigt

executive
#29

Yes. Thank you so much. Thanks to all of you for listening. And thank you, Thomas, for your remarks and comments. And of course, we invite you to join our next call on the full year figures '20, which will take place on March 25, 2021. And with this, as Thomas has indicated, the weather could be better. We wish you a nice weekend, and we look forward to seeing you on our next call. Stay safe and healthy.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#30

Thank you all, and goodbye.

Ingo Voigt

executive
#31

That’s all from me. Thanks, everyone.

Operator

operator
#32

Ladies and gentlemen, that brings the conference to a close, so you’re free to hang up your phones. Thanks for being with us, and we hope the rest of your day goes well. Goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.