EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

March 25, 2021

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Utilities Electric Utilities earnings 46 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for holding. This is Sophia, your Chorus Call operator. Welcome, and we appreciate your participation in EnBW's Investor and Analyst Conference Call for Full Year 2020. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'd like to hand the conference over to Ingo Peter Voigt, Head of Finance, M&A and Investor Relations. Please proceed.

Ingo Voigt

executive
#2

Many thanks, and good afternoon to you all on this Thursday. A very warm welcome, and we appreciate your joining us today for this investor and analyst conference call covering EnBW's figures for '20. What an extraordinary year it was — the year COVID-19 broke out across the globe. Given these times that remain unusual and difficult, we hope all of you are doing well and staying healthy. As usual, our CFO, Thomas Kusterer, is here with us, and he'll walk you through today's presentation. The main themes for this year's presentation are the key developments in financial year '20 — the final year of our 2020 Strategy — the effects of the coronavirus pandemic, our forecast for '21 and, naturally, our strategic outlook. Following that, we look forward to hearing your comments and questions. With that, I'll hand things straight over to Thomas to take you through the relevant figures and slides. Thomas, the floor is yours, please.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#3

Ingo, many thanks. Good day, everyone, and I'd like to echo Ingo's welcome to today's conference call. To kick off the presentation, I'll start with the key messages on Slide 2. Our operating KPI, adjusted EBITDA, stands at EUR 2.8 billion, which sits comfortably inside the forecast range of EUR 2.75 billion to EUR 2.9 billion. Besides our Grids business, Renewable Energies was the other major earnings driver this year, largely thanks to our 2 new offshore wind farms, Hohe See and Albatros, with a combined capacity of 640 megawatts. Even with the coronavirus pandemic, 2020 proved a reasonably good year for us in business terms. Our business model demonstrated that it is robust and flexible in a crisis. The pandemic had no significant effect on our group operating earnings in 2020. That's chiefly due to the industry our company works in, the stability coming from our portfolio approach, with a high share of stable cash flows in our operating business. And as an operator of system-critical infrastructure, we are naturally equipped to handle a crisis. Against the backdrop of our investments, mainly, as I mentioned, in Grids and Renewables, we issued 3 bonds in 2020 — 2 senior bonds with a volume of EUR 500 million each and a green subordinated bond also with volume of EUR 500 million — to refinance Valeco, the French wind and solar power company we acquired in 2019.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#4

Today, in our EnBW Green Bond Impact Report 2020, we've published sustainability performance data, details on use of proceeds, and additional information covering these and all other EnBW green bonds. Beyond that, one new element: for the first time we built sustainability aspects into our EUR 1.5 billion syndicated credit facility. Borrowing costs are now linked to how EnBW performs on sustainability. Having turned several bonds -- green bonds -- sustainable, we have now also made our syndicated credit facility sustainable, and that fact underscores our strategic orientation along with our sustainable financing strategy, which are tightly connected. Only a few weeks back, in the around 4 auction held by The Crown Estate in the U.K. for awarding seabed rights, EnBW and BP obtained 2 large and highly attractive areas of 1.5 gigawatts each in the Irish Sea. Together, EnBW and BP will develop these offshore wind farms off the coast of Great Britain through a 50-50 partnership. There will be more on this at the end of the presentation. This major project shows how we consistently evolve our business model on the basis of sustainability criteria. Climate action forms a central part of that. Our aim is to be climate neutral by the end of 2035.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#5

This target was announced back in October 2020. I'll also touch on it again at the close of the presentation. As you're aware, 8 years ago we released our EnBW 2020 Strategy. From that point on, guided by what the energy transition in Germany demands, we've systematically reshaped the company around measurable targets. Those goals from our 2020 strategy have been delivered almost 100%, and many were reached ahead of schedule or even surpassed. The next slide is the strategy slide we've displayed on every occasion since 2013. With today's presentation, that slide finally becomes a thing of the past. During the past fiscal year, we successfully wrapped up our 2020 strategy. This transformation of the portfolio rested on the following key milestones. Between 2013 and 2017, we filed to decommission 9 conventional power plant units and reduced carbon-intensive power generation by roughly 40%. Simultaneously, we grew wind power more than eightfold, to approximately 1,900 megawatts today. On top of that, we've established a foothold in new business areas. For instance, we hold the German market leadership position in fast charging infrastructure for electric vehicles. And the Valeco and Plusnet acquisitions in 2019 reflect our ambition to expand the business beyond the horizon of Strategy 2020.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#6

While transforming the portfolio, we also put a wide range of efficiency measures into practice in a systematic way. By the close of 2019, we had lifted efficiency by roughly EUR 1.4 billion calculated on an annual basis. That equates to approximately 1/3 of all controllable costs. If we go back to 2012, the operating result stood at EUR 2.4 billion. Our goal was to get back to that level by 2020. We got there already in 2019. At EUR 2.8 billion, adjusted EBITDA for 2020 actually sits more than 15% above the original target we had set. Grids and Renewable Energies together made up 78% of operating earnings in 2020. The target in this area was at least 70%, and that has considerably reinforced our risk-return profile. That takes me to Slide 4. We likewise pursued the nonfinancial targets set out under the EnBW 2020 Strategy with determination, consistency and discipline. In this area as well, we met the target for our KPIs at almost 100%, in some cases ahead of schedule or even beyond target. One key target within our portfolio transformation has been the share of generation capacity attributable to Renewables. In 2020, at 39%, that number fell only just short of our target of more than 40%. A central metric on the path toward carbon neutrality is CO2 intensity. The CO2 intensity of electricity generation produced by EnBW came to 372 grams per kilowatt hour in 2020.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#7

We set out to cut emissions 15% to 20% versus the 606 grams per kilowatt hour we recorded in 2015. We went well beyond that goal, achieving a 39% reduction. And that happened even though transmission system operators redispatched our power plants more and more often in 2020. The chief drivers were, first, the shutdown of fossil-fueled plants, most of which, given their system relevance for keeping supply secure, had to go into the grid reserve; second, developments driven by the market; and third, the effects of the coronavirus pandemic, which weighed on demand for nearly the entire year. Let me show you on Slide 5 how we dealt with the coronavirus pandemic. To begin with, as an operator of critical infrastructure, we have always been thoroughly prepared for a possible crisis so that we can supply our customers safely, securely and reliably 24/7. Electricity supply reliability is measured by the System Average Interruption Duration Index, or SAIDI for short. In 2020, the average outage duration per end customer came to just 15 minutes. Taking early and consistent steps to protect our operating and field personnel made sure the coronavirus pandemic caused no staff shortages that would have slowed fault finding and repairs in our grids.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#8

We also kept customers out of trouble by reconnecting electricity and gas for people whose energy supply had been cut off. Customer satisfaction at EnBW rose 14% to 132 points in 2020. Throughout the coronavirus pandemic, EnBW was seen as a dependable energy provider. To safeguard our workforce, we set up a task force at the start of February 2020. When it comes to how work is organized, we've taken many steps so that full teams have been available at all times. For key units, we have the facilities to physically separate teams under strict safety measures. Since early March 2020, a large share of our workforce has been working from home. As of today, we still have more than 10,000 employees working from home. And as things stand today, this situation will without a doubt last until early summer. Looking back, investments in IT and digital infrastructure made before the pandemic clearly paid off. With stable systems and processes, our business continuity is fully secured. Beyond that, over the course of the pandemic, we kept expanding programs for our employees, including things like virtual sports programs. Our employee survey at the end of 2020 shows that our workforce views very positively how the company has handled the effects of the coronavirus pandemic.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#9

The people engagement index — a new KPI we brought in during 2020 — lets us reach conclusions regarding employee motivation and commitment, and satisfaction too. On a 0 to 100 scale, our score came to 83 points. That counts as a high score relative to other companies. We likewise work continuously with trainings and programs aimed at minimizing workplace hazards that might cause accidents or work-related illnesses. The 2020 focus here was the coronavirus pandemic and the impacts it brought. Our occupational safety KPI is lost time injury frequency, or LTIF for short. Accidents per million hours worked declined slightly in 2020, going from 3.8 to 3.6. In a nutshell, I believe it is fair to state that we are conscious of our social responsibility and act accordingly, with foresight. Ladies and gentlemen, let us now move into our financial review of the past fiscal year, beginning on Slide 6. Adjusted EBITDA rose 14% year-on-year in 2020, reaching EUR 2.781 billion. We therefore fully met our guidance range of EUR 2.75 billion to EUR 2.9 billion. And that came despite difficult conditions, including those tied to the coronavirus pandemic. This underscores our stable and robust business model. The 3 segments — Grids, Renewable Energies as well as Generation and Trading — each delivered results within their guidance range.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#10

Sales came in above the revised guidance for Q3, and they also finished 2020 inside the original guidance range. So all 4 segments' contributions to adjusted EBITDA fall within the guidance range. One notable point is the big jump in the Renewables share, which went from roughly 20% to 30% of total adjusted EBITDA. Now let's examine our 4 business segments in somewhat more detail, beginning with Sales on Slide 7. Adjusted EBITDA rose in the Sales segment, climbing 3% to EUR 335 million. Plusnet added to earnings for a full year for the first time, after having been acquired in the third quarter of 2019. Once we adjust for changes to the consolidated group, earnings show a 7% decline. Because of COVID-19, EnBW subsidiaries sold considerably lower volumes to B2B customers. Correspondingly, volumes that had already been contracted had to be sold off. On the other hand, the result relating to other periods went up thanks to adjustments in the energy-related provisions. The net effect is that we beat the revised guidance and closed within the original guidance range. Turning to how sales volumes developed: 2020 electricity sales fell 3% to 34.3 terawatt hours versus the prior year, while gas sales rose 19%, reaching 217 terawatt hours.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#11

B2C electricity sales came down just modestly, by 0.5 terawatt hours, even though the market has stayed tough and we're also dealing with the coronavirus pandemic. On the B2B side, the pullback from commodity business under the EnBW and Watt brands was completely carried out by the close of 2019. Consequently, B2B electricity market sales volumes declined merely slightly, by 0.5 terawatt hours versus the year before. B2C gas sales fell by just 0.3 terawatt hours, notwithstanding the persistently difficult market conditions. Meanwhile, B2B gas sales rose by roughly 34 terawatt hours versus the prior year, thanks to VNG's acquisition of Gas-Union. Now let's move to our Grids segment, Slide 8. Within Grids, our biggest segment, which delivers around half of our operating result, adjusted EBITDA stood near the prior year's level, at EUR 1.347 billion. Earnings from distribution grids saw a small volume-driven decrease. Higher revenues from electricity and gas transmission grid usage almost fully compensated for that. The driver was greater investment in grid supply, security and reliability. As a result, the coronavirus pandemic's effect on Grids earnings in 2020 was only moderate.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#12

As the slide shows, electricity transmission volumes fell 5% in 2020, while gas transmission volumes are almost at the prior year's level. On Slide #9, I'd like to talk about how our Renewable Energies segment developed. In Renewable Energies, adjusted EBITDA went up substantially — by roughly 2/3 — in the first year, meaning fiscal year 2020. Once you adjust for the effects of changes in the consolidated group, mainly our Hohe See and Albatros offshore wind farms and the Valeco acquisition, the increase came to 6%. That considerable earnings improvement stems largely from Hohe See starting operation in the fourth quarter of 2019 and Albatros in the first quarter of 2020. Valeco has added to earnings since the third quarter of 2019, so last year was the first time it contributed for a full year. Conditions at our onshore wind farms were likewise better than a year earlier. Beyond that, electricity from our hydro power plants was sold on a forward market at wholesale prices above the prior year's levels. Consistent with the higher earnings, generation volume also rose considerably — close to 1/4 — versus the prior year. Our generation mix changed in 2020 as well: over 30% of renewable energies produced came from offshore wind, and 17% from onshore wind.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#13

Now, moving on to segment four, Generation and Trading, which you can see on Slide 10. In 2020, adjusted EBITDA rose by a moderate 3.7%. On the one hand, we sold our electricity at higher wholesale market prices; on the other hand, trading activities contributed positively to earnings thanks to greater volatility in the wholesale markets. As a result, we more than offset the closure of Block 2 at the Philippsburg nuclear power plant at the end of 2019. Let's now look at 2 of our segments through a sustainability lens on Slide 11. The EU taxonomy — a classification system that defines environmentally sustainable business activities — is a key element of the EU Green Deal. Back in 2020, we already launched a project to implement the EU taxonomy requirements concerning climate change mitigation. To deliver even more transparent and comprehensive information consistent with our sustainable profit strategy, we have chosen to adopt the future reporting requirements early for some parts of our business, even before the EU taxonomy becomes mandatory. As a first step, for 2020, we are concentrating on the 2 segments Renewable Energies and Grids, and reporting on their respective business activities.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#14

In the years ahead, we’ll expand EU taxonomy reporting so it covers every group activity and segment. In our integrated annual report 2020, we published for the first time the required information on revenue, OpEx and CapEx in environmentally sustainable activities for Grids and Renewables. Beyond what the EU taxonomy requires, we also disclosed adjusted EBITDA figures. As the slide shows, relative to all EnBW Group activities, the environmentally sustainable proportion for 2020 comes to an 18% share of revenue, a 26% share of OpEx and a 60% share of CapEx. And environmentally sustainable adjusted EBITDA makes up 65% of the group total. All results of our project, plus further information on the EU taxonomy, were released today in a detailed publication. That brings me to how our retained cash flow developed on Slide 12. Retained cash flow rose to EUR 1.639 billion, driven mainly by 2 effects: higher cash EBITDA and lower income taxes paid in a reporting period. Turning to the next slide, Slide 13, for a brief look at our KPI, internal financing capability. To keep good credit worthiness while transforming our portfolio within our 2020 strategy, we introduced this performance indicator in 2017.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#15

Back in 2020, we slightly surpassed the target of more than 100%. And at over 99.2%, we also managed to hit our goal of balanced internal financing capability — an average of roughly 100% across the 2017 to 2020 period. Now that our 2025 strategy has begun, we're moving into a growth phase. So internal financing capability will be replaced by debt repayment potential, meaning the ratio of retained cash flow to net debt. This KPI ought to let us grow earnings in a controlled way within our financial targets, while keeping a solid investment-grade rating at all times. On Slide 14, I'll comment on how net debt developed. As of December 31, 2020, our net debt rose by more than EUR 1.5 billion versus December 31, 2019. Let me walk through the key drivers behind that with this waterfall chart. Working capital went up by EUR 718 million, driven mainly by the following effects. Trade receivables rose significantly in connection with the German Renewable Energies Act. The corresponding bank account of our transmission grid operator fell by more than EUR 900 million, from EUR 286 million as of December 31, 2019, to a negative balance of almost EUR 630 million as of December 31, 2020.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#16

Because of the coronavirus pandemic, the resulting fall in electricity demand, and a substantial drop in electricity spot prices, the levy under the Renewable Energies Act that was granted for 2020 did not cover the corresponding expenses for Renewable Energies. Still, this exceptional rise in related payments during 2020 proved to be only temporary. On January 11, 2021, the bank account balance was settled by means of an additional payment of EUR 765 million from the Federal Republic of Germany. Second, the lower interest rate for pension provisions had a raising effect of nearly EUR 580 million on net debt. We will now move to the proposed dividend for financial year 2020 on Slide 15. Consistent with our dividend policy, we target a dividend payout ratio between 40% and 60% of adjusted net profit. Adjusted net profit came to EUR 683 million in financial year 2020, which is 13% under the prior year figure. That resulted from a decline in the market valuation of our securities relative to the prior year figure, which lowered the financial results. Given the unusually high market valuation of securities in financial year 2019, those effects were excluded when calculating the 2019 dividend payment.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#17

Back in 2019, we applied a 40% dividend payout ratio to the recalculated adjusted net profit. As a result, last year's dividend payout ratio came to 40%. Now for 2020, we're again targeting a payout ratio at the lower end of the range we've specified. That bolsters our balance sheet and lets us keep moving at full speed with transforming the company. So the dividend proposed for 2020 is EUR 1, and the total payout amounts to EUR 271 million. The resolution on profit appropriation — and with it the dividend payout — will be decided by the Annual General Meeting on May 5. Given the continuing pandemic, the Executive Board and the Supervisory Board have resolved, under the COVID-19 Measures Act, to once again hold this year's AGM as a virtual meeting. Turning to Slide 16, let's look now at the current fiscal year. At the start of 2021, we reorganized our business portfolio into 3 strategic segments, and our portfolio approach still applies. Smart Infrastructure for Customers, which covers electricity and gas sales, billing services, and also e-mobility, telecommunications, broadband, photovoltaics and storage; System Critical Infrastructure, which primarily absorbs our electricity and gas transmission and distribution grids; and the third segment, Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, with renewable energies, conventional power generation and our trading activities.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#18

For 2021, here's how we see adjusted EBITDA shaping up across our 3 new segments. Within Smart Infrastructure, our expectation is adjusted EBITDA of EUR 300 million to EUR 375 million. So with a challenging market environment as the backdrop, and the coronavirus pandemic still ongoing, we anticipate stable earnings at the same level as the prior year. Similarly, in System Critical Infrastructure, we're forecasting earnings at the prior year level. Adjusted EBITDA should land between EUR 1.3 billion and EUR 1.4 billion. Even with the coronavirus pandemic, we assume grid revenue will rise slightly, driven by returns from high investments in electricity and gas grid projects in line with the respective network development plan. In Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, we expect growth of 8% to 15%. That places adjusted EBITDA in 2021 between EUR 1.375 billion and EUR 1.475 billion. Renewables, which we keep expanding, will account for the largest share of this, at about EUR 900 million. Assuming wind yields in 2021 match the prior year long-term average, we expect earnings above 2020 levels. We also expect our trading activities' performance in 2021 to be in line with the prior year's earnings contribution.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#19

Looking at the group as a whole, we're expecting operating results to rise by 2% to 7% in 2021, and that translates to adjusted EBITDA somewhere between EUR 2.825 billion and EUR 2.975 million. Ladies and gentlemen, this takes us to Slide 17, where we lay out our strategic forecast. Through our EnBW 2025 Strategy, we've set a goal of lifting adjusted EBITDA to EUR 3.2 billion. Each of our 3 strategic segments should make a substantial contribution to that earnings growth. Within Smart Infrastructure for Customer, investment is concentrated on electric mobility, telecommunications, broadband, photovoltaic and storage. We intend to keep growing our fast charging infrastructure as a way of advancing electric mobility. On the telecommunications and broadband side, we'll be extending our network infrastructure and broadening the services we offer. Beyond that, we're aiming to keep expanding in the German home storage market for solar power. When it comes to System Critical Infrastructure, we'll carry on constructing our transmission grid for electricity and gas, along with our distribution grids. We'll continue systematically upgrading our electricity distribution grids to meet future challenges, so they're well prepared for electric mobility and electric heat. Lastly, the third segment, Sustainable Power Infrastructure, concentrates mainly on expanding renewable energies.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#20

When it comes to our photovoltaic project, we're aiming for a portfolio of 1.2 gigawatts in total by the end of 2025. Back in 2019, we took the investment decision to build Germany's largest solar farm without government subsidies. Our solar farm in Weesow-Willmersdorf fed its first kilowatt hours into the grid in 2020. And the next 2 large-scale PV projects — also in Brandenburg and also without government subsidies — are already under construction. Altogether, those 3 solar farms will have a total installed capacity of around 500 megawatts. Beyond that, we plan to expand wind power generation capacity considerably. Our goal is to raise that capacity to 4 gigawatts by 2025. A major milestone here is our He Dreiht offshore wind farm, which is due to enter operations with 900 megawatts at the end of 2025. The final investment decision will be made in 2023. On top of that, as I already mentioned, we secured a total of 3 gigawatts in offshore wind projects with BP in the U.K. As for timing, implementation of this huge renewal project will follow on from our 2025 -- from our 2025 strategy. Let's go to Slide 18 to take a closer look at this project. EnBW, together with BP, was jointly awarded 3 gigawatts in seabed rights off the coast of Great Britain by The Crown Estate in the U.K.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#21

To be exact, we obtained 2 sizable zones measuring 500 and 320 square kilometers, where two 1.5 gigawatt offshore wind farms are planned in the Irish Sea. Those zones are reckoned to rank as the most valuable in England and Wales's first offshore wind leasing round in 10 years. Given how close they sit to one another, we anticipate strong synergies between the 2 sides. Through the BP and EnBW partnership, 2 leading energy firms combine deep operational know-how with expanding renewable portfolios. BP, headquartered in the U.K., holds deep and trusted ties throughout the energy spectrum — ranging from the North Sea oil and gas supply chain to an industry-leading trading organization that brings energy to market. We expect final investment decisions in 2026. Moreover, we presume the Irish Sea offshore wind farms will be brought successfully into operation as of 2028. Allow me to finish by gazing further out to 2035 on Slide 19. We keep setting equally ambitious goals, including climate neutrality by 2035. As an energy company, we are able to contribute with particular effectiveness to climate action. As I have just demonstrated, we keep growing our renewable energy activities.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#22

Looking at the end of 2025, those are expected to make up 50% of the mix for our generation. We'll be out of conventional generation based on coal by the close of 2035. Across the group, our goal is to cut greenhouse emissions in half by 2030 against the 2018 base year, and to reach climate neutrality in our own emissions no later than the end of 2035. Certain group companies, Energiedienst among them, are climate neutral already. And from the start of 2021, Nexif B.V. has ranked among Germany's first emission-free distribution grid operators. Our view is that a business is fit for the future only when it shows social responsibility and carries a clear, ambitious sustainability agenda. Ultimately, what's at stake is our license to operate, and so the future economic success of our company is tied closely to how we perform on sustainability over the long term. With that, I'd like to pass things to Ingo so we can begin our Q&A session.

Ingo Voigt

executive
#23

Thanks, Thomas, for those thorough remarks and comments. With that, I'll now turn things back to the operator so we can open up the Q&A session.

Operator

operator
#24

The operator has provided instructions, and the first question comes from Andrew Moulder at CreditSights.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#25

Yes. I need to ask about those U.K. leases. I mean, clearly, a very high price was paid there. My recollection is it was around EUR 230 million, and you have 2 of them. So that works out to EUR 230 million on your side and EUR 230 million for BP, I assume. Where did that figure originate? I mean, was it largely driven by BP's desire to enter the offshore renewable space, since that number is far above all the others? And I also wonder what happens should you fail to secure a CFD for the wind farms at these sites? Does that mean you would essentially walk away? Or do you believe you could run them on a merchant basis? So that is really my first question. I have just 2 more. Second question, regarding working capital, obviously, EUR 700 million or so this year, but you said that you have had settlement of the EEG Bank account in February, I believe. So does that mean that, broadly speaking, as we reach the end of the first quarter, your working capital is essentially 0?

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#26

So the working capital movement — is it fair to say that the EUR 700 million has now been reversed? Then one last thing from me. You mentioned a 2025 target and referred to EUR 3.2 billion — did I miss something there? My understanding was that your goal was EUR 3 billion, and I had been planning to ask why it isn't higher. Now you've clearly raised it to EUR 3.2 billion. Is this a new target? And what gives you greater confidence in the EUR 3.2 billion versus the EUR 3 billion you laid out at the 2019 Capital Markets Day?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#27

Okay, Andrew, if you'll let me, I'd like to take your third question first, then move on to your second one, and after that get to the first.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#28

Yeah, I think that makes things easier.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#29

To be clear, we had consistently stated—including last year—a figure above EUR 3 billion, and today we're simply giving a somewhat more specific number: EUR 3.2 billion. So this isn't us raising our ambition; it's about being more exact regarding what we aim to deliver by 2025. On your working capital question, yes, you're correct. That EUR 700 million will reverse by the close of the first quarter. We received reimbursement of, if I recall correctly, EUR 765 million, and I believe that came on the 11th of January, if my memory serves me. So yes, you've got that exactly right. On the U.K., and from outside in, a relatively high payment of EUR 231 million. Andrew, since you're based in the U.K., you may have come across Phil and Kirstie and possibly know their TV series. What holds true for, say, real estate likewise holds true for offshore wind: it comes down to location, location, location.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#30

Phil and Kirstie? I remember thinking, who on earth is he referring to? Phil and Kirstie — right — location, location, location.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#31

You can call me Kristie — well, actually it's Kirstie, of course. You've got it right: it's Kirstie. Location, location, location is what matters most. And that holds true here as well when you examine this auction process. For offshore wind, the key value drivers are the expected wind yields, along with construction and operation costs — and therefore distance to shore and water depth. Another factor is how quickly a permit is expected to be secured, and given the site specifics we see here, we assume that for our sites compared with the sites on the East Coast of the U.K.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#32

Apologies — could you repeat that?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#33

Actually, when you consider items such as Habitats Regulations Assessment and the like, we feel more confident that that side is smooth. There are also consented zones for offshore wind on the East Coast, and we see no kind of implications there. So, given the overall location, we believe it is more preferable to be on the West side rather than the East side. That said, we ran calculations upfront for all relevant sites. And to be very clear, the award values now published fully conform to our expectations regarding amounts that can be paid for the respective seabed. So it is not what you just indicated, that it might have been due to BP. On the contrary, it is what we have calculated, and Andrew, you know how we operate. We are not known to overpay, and we are normally also known — and that is also true in that case — for being very precise in calculating how — what we can bid in a case like this, and that is what we have done. So we are extremely confident that even with the high payment of EUR 231 million, we have a valuable site here on hand, and we are able to have an economic viable project here, let's say, in 2026 or in 2028, when it's hopefully on the grid.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#34

I mean, even looking at the awards here, there was another offshore wind operator that also won a project in bidding area 4. Sure, I can see theirs is much smaller than yours at 480 megawatts, but they paid only EUR 45 million for it.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#35

And paying more wasn't something I would have done. It sits directly behind our location. Winds come out of the West. So compared with us, conditions differ entirely. Plus, naturally, these are larger sites, which brings synergies. We hold a cost edge over the smaller site as well. So really, this doesn't conflict with what I said a moment ago — in fact, it matches what we would have anticipated for each of those sites.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#36

Sorry, may I ask just one more thing? Specifically about the EBITDA trajectory. E.ON, I believe, mentioned yesterday that as their nuclear output ends at the close of 2022, they will offset that loss. Consequently, no decline in EBITDA will actually be visible from nuclear generation concluding at the end of '22. Does the same hold for you—meaning we won't observe an EBITDA decline from '22 to '23? Or will a drop appear since your nuclear generation shuts down at the end of '22?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#37

Honestly, it's basically the same thing E.ON said yesterday. Between 2022 and 2023, when Neckarwestheim II — our final nuclear plant — stops operating, we can offset that. So no drop in our operating result will show up here.

Operator

operator
#38

<<operator_script>> At this point, we have no more questions. I’ll now return the call to Ingo Peter for his closing remarks.

Ingo Voigt

executive
#39

All right. Thank you so much. Thomas, I appreciate your responses and the thorough remarks you provided. Everyone, our upcoming call will cover the Q1 figures for '21, and that takes place on May 10 this year. Once again, as ever, should any additional questions come up, please feel free to phone us or send us an email. We will do our best to support and help you wherever possible. With that, we wish all of you a very pleasant afternoon, and thank you to each person for joining today's call. Goodbye.

Operator

operator
#40

Ladies and gentlemen, that brings the conference to a close, so you’re free to hang up your phones now. Thanks for being with us, and enjoy the rest of your day. Goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.