EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 12, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by. Welcome, and thank you for joining EnBW's Investor Analyst Conference Call Q3 2021. <<operator_script>> I'd now like to hand the conference over to Marcel Münch, Head of Financial, M&A and Investor Relations. Please go ahead.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHi everyone, this is Thomas Kusterer, and I'll begin now. Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you for being with us today for this conference call with investors and analysts regarding EnBW's Q3 2021 results. First off, let me introduce Marcel Münch, who assumed the role of Senior Vice President, Finance, M&A and Investor Relations at EnBW on September 1. Marcel, would you like to share a few words?
Marcel Münch
executiveYes. Thanks, Thomas. Absolutely. Since joining EnBW in 2014, I ran our M&A team for the past 4 years, and now I'm excited about the broader responsibilities ahead. In taking this on, I know I can rely on a trusted team that I'm very familiar with. Moving forward, we'll keep concentrating on executing our EnBW 2025 strategy. In that regard, ongoing and consistent dialogue with investors matters a great deal to me. With that in mind, I look forward to meeting many of you in person as soon as conditions allow. And for today, well, you're all familiar with how this works — Thomas Kusterer will now walk you through today's presentation on EnBW's results in Q3 2021, and a Q&A session will follow. So without further delay, I'll hand things back to Thomas.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveMarcel, many thanks, and I'm genuinely pleased to have you with us in your new position. Let me begin with the key messages on Slide 2. During the first 9 months of 2021, adjusted EBITDA came in slightly under the prior year by roughly 4%, which once more demonstrates the resilience of our business model. At the close of Q3, we continue to observe certain temporary adverse effects in the 2 segments, Sustainable Generation Infrastructure and System Critical Infrastructure, and we anticipate these will reverse by year-end. In addition, we are pleased to confirm that the COVID pandemic has produced no significant financial impact over the course of this year. Given the first 3 quarters and recent market developments, our earnings guidance for the full year 2021 remains unchanged. As of September 30, 2021, net debt stood EUR 3.5 billion below the level at the end of 2020, primarily driven by a substantial decrease in working capital. There will be more on this later in the presentation. Before we dive into the details of our Q3 results, let me address 2 highly relevant topics. First, market prices and volatility. When spot and forward commodity prices in Germany reached unusually elevated levels at the beginning of October, our risk-based and forward-looking liquidity management once again showed that we are well prepared even for such exceptional situations.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveWe satisfied every liquidity requirement with room to spare — those requirements were temporarily elevated because of security margins that had to be posted without drawing on our syndicated loan facility. In the meantime, the markets have eased somewhat. Still, we'll naturally be keeping a close watch on how things develop further. Second, I'd like to bring you up to speed on how we're progressing with our climate neutrality goals. As you're aware, our aim is to lower carbon emissions by at least 50% by 2030 and bring them down to net 0 by 2035 at the latest. Not long ago, we made the decision to register block 7 of our hard coal power plant in Karlsruhe for decommissioning no later than mid-2022. That shows we're moving forward steadily with our coal phase-out plans. Whether the unit may actually be shut down, or whether reserve power plant requirements apply in the event it's judged system relevant, is a call for the Federal Network Agency to make. Along the road to climate neutrality, we regard natural gas as a bridging technology that carries real weight in accompanying the build-out of renewables and delivering the Energiewende in Germany. Arrangements are already in place for 2 fuel switch projects that will move first from hard coal to natural gas over the midterm and, over the longer term, to green gases as an alternative to hydrogen.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSo with that in mind, we intend to swap out the coal plant we operate at Altbach, close to Stuttgart, for a low-emission CCGT facility that would generate power and heat while cutting CO2 emissions by roughly 63%. That puts this location on track to be fully coal-free by 2026, which would deliver an immediate and meaningful reduction in our CO2 output. As for our fuel switch projects, final investment decisions will come at a later date. Our sustainable financial instruments — green bonds in particular — are already helping us along the road toward climate neutrality. Over 1/3 of the bonds we have outstanding are green. The money raised from the EUR 500 million green subordinated bonds we issued in August is earmarked for constructing wind farms, solar projects, and growing our fast-charging network for e-mobility. Over the last 9 months, we've made substantial progress on this front. We already run Germany's largest fast-charging network, and our goal is to broaden that leading position. We act with responsibility and sustainability. And we keep working steadily to strengthen our CSR profile further. In October, ISS ESG said it now gives EnBW a B score, which was not higher than before. That chiefly mirrors our improved environmental management. It places us within the top 5% of multi-utilities.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveWith that said, I'll move on now to the financial information covering the first 9 months of 2021. On Slide #3, you can see how adjusted EBITDA and group net profit developed during the first 9 months of 2021 versus the prior-year figures. As we noted earlier, adjusted EBITDA at group level fell by roughly 4% to EUR 1.970 billion, primarily due to the following 3 factors, which we had already observed in the first half of the year. Those are higher personnel expenses, driven mainly by grid expansion; lower wind yields, also in the third quarter; and temporary negative valuation effects in Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, resulting from significantly increased electricity prices. Still, it's important to note that these will partly reverse toward year-end as contracts enter delivery. Adjusted group net profit attributable to the shareholders of EnBW AG almost doubled, reaching EUR 730 million. One positive contributor was an improvement in the financial results, largely from our financial asset management, stemming from a gain on marketing securities to market compared with a large expense in the same period last year. Investments made with an optimum risk-reward ratio benefited from the positive market trend to an above-average degree during the first 9 months of this year.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveEquity markets and illiquid investments were positive contributors in this area. Now, on the slides that follow, let's examine more closely how each of our 3 business segments performed. I'll begin with Smart Infrastructure for Customers, which is on Slide 4. Adjusted EBITDA for this segment rose significantly, by 37%, in the first 9 months of 2021 versus the prior year's figures, reaching EUR 297 million. Two main factors drove this development: better earnings in the commodity business across all our sales companies, and a favorable earnings trend at our subsidiary SENEC, among the top 3 providers of home storage systems for solar power installations in Germany. This business segment now represents 15% of the group's total adjusted EBITDA. That takes me to our largest business segment, which represents roughly 50% of EnBW's adjusted EBITDA: System Critical Infrastructure, on Slide #5. Adjusted EBITDA in this segment fell by around 4% to EUR 991 million in the first 9 months of the current fiscal year, compared with the prior year level. The reduction in earnings stemmed from higher personnel expenses, mainly attributable to the necessary grid expansion. Higher grid revenues were not enough to fully offset these additional expenses.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLet me now go into more detail on what is likely the single most significant factor for this segment regarding investments going forward and the returns they generate. As you know, 3 weeks ago the Federal Network Agency released the permitted regulatory equity return rate covering electricity and gas grids for the fourth regulatory period. Those new rates take effect for gas grid operators starting in 2023 and for electricity grid operators from 2024 onward. For new assets, the return on equity will be set at 5.07% before corporate tax, versus 6.91% at present. The new return on equity applying to all assets, at 3.51% before corporate tax, is roughly 1/3 lower than the level today. We are right now reviewing the Federal Network Agency's decision documents with great care and reserve the right to take further steps. Looking at returns on grid assets throughout Europe, this leaves Germany considerably behind countries like Italy, France and the U.K. That said, reinforcing and expanding electricity and gas grids — the backbone of our energy infrastructure — is essential for the energy transition. What hangs in the balance here is the restructuring of the energy system, sector coupling and, in the end, whether we as a society achieve our climate goals at all.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveWhat this means is that grid system operators have to keep being given enough financial headroom. And we anticipate that the Federal Network Agency will factor this important point into its upcoming deliberations and decisions. Last, let's move to Sustainable Generation Infrastructure on Slide #6. This business segment accounts for 43% of the group's overall adjusted EBITDA in the first 9 months of 2021, versus 2020 adjusted EBITDA in this segment, which declined by 11% to EUR 853 million. Let's look more closely at the 2 parts of the segment, Renewable Energies on one hand and Thermal Generation and Trading on the other. Adjusted EBITDA in our renewables business fell by 7%, chiefly because of comparatively weak wind conditions relative to the prior-year period and to the long-term average. Available wind came in significantly under expectations in 6 out of 9 months across Q1 to Q3. This impact isn't unique to our renewables fleet at EnBW but hit all offshore wind operators, particularly in the North Sea, and also in the Baltic Sea, along with onshore wind operators throughout Germany equally. In the second part of the segment, Thermal Generation and Trading, adjusted EBITDA declined by 18% owing to temporary negative valuation effects, which, as already noted earlier, we'll keep partly reversing toward the year-end as the underlying trading contracts enter delivery.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat brings me to how our retained cash flow developed, which you can see on Slide 7. EBITDA fell 8% over the first 9 months of 2021 versus the same stretch of 2020, and retained cash flow was down almost 20%, landing at EUR 893 million. Beyond the drop in EBITDA, this mostly reflects a larger dividend payout — EUR 1 per share versus EUR 0.70 a year earlier — along with higher interest paid. Turning to Slide 8, I'll walk you through how net debt moved during the first 9 months of 2021. As of September 30, 2021, net debt was down roughly 25% to EUR 10.8 billion, measured against December 31, 2020, driven chiefly by the effects below, on top of our retained cash flow. The first two of these produced a substantial cut in working capital. First, security margin payments we received in the trading business rose considerably, tracking commodity price moves in 2021. Second, receivables under the German Renewable Energies Act came down, largely because EnBW collected payments under the act. At September 30, 2021, the balance on the matching bank account stood at plus EUR 674 million, versus minus EUR 629 million at year-end 2020.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAnd third, the pension provision discount rate went up, moving from 0.75% to 1.25%. Conversely, we kept investing heavily throughout our core business segments. Within System Critical Infrastructure, we spent roughly EUR 870 million, primarily to expand transmission grids, though also for expanding and renewing distribution grids and for building out grid infrastructure for electric mobility. In Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, we put about EUR 530 million into the renewables business, chiefly offshore wind power following our successful United Kingdom bid, along with construction of large-scale solar farms in Germany. Growth projects accounted for 73% of total gross capital expenditures across the first 9 months. Let me now go into detail on the outlook for the full year 2021 as set out on Slide 9. As I noted at the start of the presentation, our guidance for adjusted EBITDA for the full year 2021 stays valid, for the group as well as for the 3 business segments. For Smart Infrastructure for Customers, we anticipate adjusted EBITDA between EUR 300 million and EUR 375 million. Given the strong performance during the first 9 months of 2021, we anticipate earnings landing at the upper end of that range.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFor System Critical Infrastructure, we're looking at adjusted EBITDA in the range of EUR 1.3 billion to EUR 1.4 billion. Grid revenues should rise modestly compared with last year, driven by returns on the larger investments we've made. Both the electricity and the gas network development plans include these projects. How our earnings actually come through by year-end will hinge heavily on what the weather does in the fourth quarter. Turning to Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, we anticipate substantial growth, with adjusted EBITDA for 2021 landing somewhere between EUR 1.375 billion and EUR 1.475 billion. Adding more renewable generation assets will lift earnings relative to 2020. Our Q4 2021 forecast for wind yields — and therefore generation volumes — assumes the long-term average. As I noted earlier, wind yields over the first 9 months fell short of both the prior year and the budgeted level, reflecting weaker wind conditions. That drag, however, will be more than outweighed by how our trading activities are currently performing, and we expect them to stay very solid through the rest of 2021. On top of that, the negative valuation effects that temporarily hit our Q3 figures will, as I mentioned, partially reverse further as we move toward the end of the year and contracts enter delivery.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSo at the group level, we're forecasting adjusted EBITDA to rise further in 2021, landing in a range of EUR 2.825 billion to EUR 2.975 billion, versus EUR 2.781 billion in 2020. With that, I'll turn things over to Martin.
Marcel Münch
executiveThanks, Thomas, for taking us through the presentation. At this point, I'd like to ask our operator, Nairobi, to please get today's Q&A session started.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question comes from Andrew Moulder at CreditSights, who is on the line.
Andrew Moulder
analystMarcel, welcome — glad to see you stepping into this position.
Marcel Münch
executiveHey there.
Andrew Moulder
analystSo now I actually have a few questions. I hope you won't cap me at 2. Many analysts have been inquiring about year-end net debt at various companies, and every one of them has shown great hesitation when it comes to providing a number for year-end net debt. I'm wondering whether you could perhaps give us a sense of where you expect your year-end net debt to land, taking into account the shifts you're observing in the commodity market? That's roughly my first question. My second question: you had a substantial working capital inflow, which I assume relates largely to margin payments, variation margins. To me, that would suggest you're generally short on both gas and power, since that's what produces an inflow rather than an outflow given how prices have moved. So maybe you could confirm that? And would you also say a bit about liquidity? Because I know you mentioned you've been handling it quite well through the risk-based forward-looking management model you use. But how are the banks responding to this entire situation?
Andrew Moulder
analystSo, I mean, are they coming across as really accommodating and ready to boost facilities if that becomes necessary? Or are they taking a hard line and, sort of, not believing that things are going to change? I mean, I'd just appreciate a bit more detail on how tough it has been to manage liquidity given these truly extraordinary circumstances. And please, I just had 2 additional questions. You mentioned RDK 7 shutting down in 2022. My assumption is that RDK 8 isn't really scheduled to close before 2038. So I'm just curious how you view the potential, sort of, coalition agreement that could result in coal plants being closed by 2030. And last, you brought up the regulated returns. What I really wanted to ask is whether that has any effect on the 2 major transmission lines you're involved with, SuedLink and ULTRANET — I mean, presumably, if those returns turn out very low, that might cause some delays to them, and I think they're actually pretty essential for the energy transition. So could you maybe comment on that? And sorry for all the questions.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, as always, your questions are genuinely welcome. Let me attempt to address them in the same order you raised them, and please help me out if I fail — if I don't manage to cover all of them the way you'd like them answered. So, net debt at year-end — I mean, we appear to be somewhat more forthcoming than others. We anticipate roughly EUR 10 billion in net debt by year-end, okay, though naturally it depends a bit on how the market develops, but that's the approximate figure we foresee for net debt at year-end. Your second question concerned the reduction in our working capital. And yes, just as you pointed out, half of that is in fact very closely tied to derivatives. So, cash inflows from margin payments received. And the remaining 50% is largely tied to the Renewable Energies' bank account. We received payments under the Renewable Energies Act. So that accounts for the other 50%. That's roughly speaking, but those are essentially the figures. On liquidity — and you were hinting at a potential situation at the start of October when we saw that extreme market movement and liquidity needs. In fact, yes, the banks are being extremely accommodating.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveTo be honest, we didn’t require any support from our banks at all. Everything we already had available — the cash bank lines and so on, along with the CP market — was actually enough to meet the liquidity needs we had on that very date, and to be open with you, we could have carried on even past what we had to post that day without actually having to draw on our syn loan facility.
Andrew Moulder
analystMy apologies, Thomas — mind if I jump in with a question about what exactly you're doing with those funds? You're bringing in a lot of cash, but as I understand it, that money will have to be repaid, I suppose, by the close of — well, by the close of this year and likely across the years that follow. So is it simply sitting there on your balance sheet? Or are you putting it to work and then planning to borrow once more at the point when repayment comes due?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSo essentially, it's sitting on the balance sheet. We ensure it's accessible in the near term. And in any case, we require adequate cash for our trading operation. What we actually do is examine market volatilities. We run a range of scenarios, and we aim to cover this through liquidity and bank lines over both short and long horizons, so we can respond to the relevant market moves. That's why I say our fairly prudent approach to liquidity management has shown itself to work in this experienced situation, and that's our way of handling it. Does that address your question, Andrew?
Andrew Moulder
analystRight, right, that sounds fine. One item, though, went unanswered. I just want to make sure: are those margin shifts happening because you're short both power and gas? Or is it only gas that you're short, with no short position in power? That part wasn't entirely clear to me.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveI mean, since we sell our generation forward in electricity, we're structurally short in electricity. Of course — but at the same time, of course, we're purchasing commodities such as coal and gas, plus CO2 certificates. So that's really why we saw such a large move at the start of October, because electricity prices rose and, at the same time, CO2 prices fell. Combined, that resulted in a fairly significant outflow so that we could cover the initial margins and the variation margins that we had because of the exchange.
Andrew Moulder
analystRight. OK, that's clear.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAlright, so your fourth question was really about RDK 7 and 8. Yes, we do indeed assume that RDK 8 will be running for a longer period. It's our newest hard coal power plant. That said, under the plan currently in place in Germany, coal is being phased out. If I remember correctly, RDK 8 is scheduled to be shut down at the start of the 2030, not '38. I believe it's 2030 or 2031. I'm not entirely certain, but somewhere around there. So that is what we actually expect for RDK 8 — to be shut down, or closed, under the present plan and the present exit plan in Germany.
Andrew Moulder
analystAll right, that caught me a bit off guard. I mean, RDK 8 was only brought online a couple of years back. What's the reason for shutting it down ahead of schedule? Wouldn't you have preferred to run it for as long as you possibly could? Or did the legislation not permit that?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat's not permitted, in fact. That is the strategy. In fact, it's an unambiguous strategy for shutting the plant down. And I believe — actually, not just believe, I'm certain — that RDK 8 is scheduled to be closed by 2030. And one thing I should remind you of: certain lignite plants have permission to keep operating for a longer period, which means hard coal facilities had to be closed sooner. From a CO2 standpoint, that's certainly not what you'd expect, yet that is how the arrangement actually works. And that is what has been agreed with the government.
Andrew Moulder
analystAll right.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYour fifth question concerned regulated assets and regulated returns, and you referenced SuedLink and ULTRANET. What you were really asking is whether that lower return affects these 2 lines. Actually, Andrew, no — those 2 lines under construction in the midst of the approval process are unaffected, and at this point we assume SuedLink will be commissioned by the end of 2028. So the decreased returns have no impact, yes.
Andrew Moulder
analystWhat's the reason for that? Won't they feel the impact of the lower returns, or do those reduced returns still leave you with an adequate return on those 2 assets?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveUnder the German Networks' plan, we actually are required to construct it. There is therefore no alternative. As a result, these lines must be built within both the Networks' plan and the development plan, and we are obligated to do so. And in fact, we were completely aware that a decline is coming. We therefore anticipate a reduction in equity returns. That said, the 5.07% we are seeing at present falls short of what we had expected and assumed would be the appropriate return. That is certain. Conversely, as I said a moment ago, we are required to build these lines, and build them we will.
Andrew Moulder
analystOkay, sorry—I don’t mean to take up too much of the call, but that comes across as somewhat unfair. Even if you don’t think that return is sufficient, you still have to build them. So at what point do you actually look for a return on these?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveRight, Andrew — that’s exactly why we’re going through the documents the Networks agency just sent us in detail, to determine whether any additional steps are required. But that’s something we have to examine before we can say anything further about it.
Andrew Moulder
analystCould it be that, since there's a requirement to construct these 2 assets, they might actually fall outside the existing regulatory return?
Frank Mastiaux
executiveNope.
Andrew Moulder
analystNo? Okay. All right. Great. Thank you very much, and thanks — good to hear you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAppreciate that question, actually. And thank you, Andrew.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> We have no further questions right now. Marcel Münch, I’ll return the call to you for closing remarks.
Marcel Münch
executiveYes. Thanks to everyone for joining today's call and for the interest you've shown in how EnBW is developing. And Thomas, thank you for your comments and answers. We're looking forward to presenting our full year figures 2021 on our next call, which is on March 23, 2022. In the meantime, if any further questions come up, please feel free to reach out to our Investor Relations team. Until then, stay safe and healthy, and we'll talk to you soon. Bye-bye.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, that brings the conference to a close, and you're free to hang up your phones now. Thanks for being with us, and we hope the rest of your day goes well. Goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.