EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 12, 2022

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Utilities Electric Utilities earnings 33 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you for remaining on the line. I'm Fransi, the Chorus Call operator handling this session. Welcome, and thanks for being with us on EnBW's Investor and Analyst Q2 2022 Results Conference Call. <<operator_script>> It's a pleasure to be with you, and at this point I'll hand the conference over to Marcel Mint, Head of Finance, M&A and Investor Relations. Sir, the floor is yours.

Marcel Münch

executive
#2

Thank you. Good day, everyone, and welcome — we appreciate you being here for today's conference call with investors and analysts covering EnBW's Q2 2022 results. Our CFO, Thomas Kusterer, will soon walk you through the details of our results and put them into perspective. Following the presentation, we look forward to hearing your comments and questions. So with that, I'll hand things directly to Thomas, who will take you through the relevant slides and figures. Thomas, over to you.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#3

Thanks, Marcel. Good day, everyone, and welcome from me as well. I'd like to begin with a look at Slide 2. The tragedy of the war in Ukraine continues, and its effects can be felt and seen in politics, in the economy, and in our own personal lives too. As a provider of system-critical infrastructure, EnBW is naturally also impacted by these developments. Adjusted EBITDA for the first half of this year came in nearly level with the prior year. We saw negative effects from the curtailment of Russian gas supplies and in our customer and Grids businesses. Those were almost entirely offset by positive effects in Generation and Trading. As things stand today, we still expect adjusted EBITDA for the full year 2022 of between EUR 3.25 billion and EUR 3.175 billion nonetheless. However, I want to flag that uncertainty overall around statements about future developments is higher right now than it normally is. So we are continually monitoring and assessing the conditions for what they could mean for the EnBW Group. With interest rates rising, a further reduction in our pension provisions had a positive effect on net debt. Pension provisions have fallen by roughly EUR 2.1 billion since December 2021.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#4

Before we go further into the Q2 numbers, I'd like to address the present circumstances and what EnBW has been doing about them. Over recent weeks, we've held discussions with many investors, analysts, and banks in order to lay out where things stand regarding natural gas procurement more broadly and how that affects both the EnBW Group and VNG, our subsidiary. Our central point: the exposure stemming from VNG's supply agreements for Russian gas was, and remains, manageable. And what has unfolded over the past weeks needs to be viewed against the backdrop of our business model overall, which is robust, diversified, and defensive. As a fully integrated utility, having a diversified portfolio lets us stay stable even when times are volatile. Our base of highly stable cash flows as a grid operator is very solid, and our integrated lineup spanning the whole energy value chain is a major advantage and a stabilizing force in this environment. During 2021, roughly 70% of our earnings came from regulated grids and renewables. In competitive areas of business, including sales and generation, EnBW hedges its margins as much as 3 years ahead. On top of that, when it comes to adjusted EBITDA, our exposure to coal and merchant gas businesses is limited.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#5

During 2021, those activities made up, in aggregate, under 10% of our adjusted EBITDA. Beyond the cash we generate from operations, we can draw on a range of financing options so that we always keep liquidity at a comfortable level. At June 30, we had roughly EUR 6.5 billion of operating cash and cash equivalents available within EnBW Group. During July, we issued our <<inaudible>> loan in a volume of EUR 500 million, well above the EUR 300 million volume that had originally been targeted in the term sheet. We managed to price all process at the low end of the indicated range. On top of that, committed and uncommitted credit lines under EnBW's syndicate loan across EnBW Group added a liquidity buffer of over EUR 7 billion, which can be accessed on short notice in the event of potential unforeseen market development. Early in July, both rating agencies, Standard & Poor's and Moody's, underscored our very stable positioning and stressed the advantages of our integrated business model. Standard & Poor's affirmed our rating at A-, with the outlook remaining stable. Moody's, meanwhile, released a detailed credit update on EnBW, leaving the rating unchanged at Baa1 with a stable outlook.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#6

So EnBW remains among the highest-rated integrated utilities in Europe. Both agencies align with our goal of keeping solid investment grade ratings. Those ratings came out amid an economically and politically volatile climate, which leads me to our exposure to Russian energy supplies, shown on the next slide. Understandably, gas procurement has drawn public scrutiny in recent months. EnBW's Trading division buys gas for its customers on the wholesale market, yet holds no direct import contracts with Russian counterparties. VNG, an EnBW subsidiary, has 2 supply contracts for Russian gas that delivery restrictions affect. Those contracts amount to roughly 100 terawatt hours per annum. That equaled about 20% of EnBW's total gas procurement in 2021. The costs from delivery restrictions that are expected to remain at VNG as of today are included in EnBW's half year financial statements, using the best possible estimate and factoring in the loss mitigation measures of the Energy Security Act. Our adjusted EBITDA for the first 6 months of 2022 reflects a charge of EUR 545 million in total. Thanks to our forward-looking liquidity management and a solid financial position, VNG and EnBW have always been able to comfortably meet the liquidity requirements stemming from extraordinary market movements and volatile gas supply.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#7

Our gas procurement is becoming more diversified, and that effort is progressing nicely. EnBW spans the entire LNG value chain, from buying and shipping through to regasification. A few illustrations of this: at the close of March, we concluded a memorandum of understanding with Hanseatic Energy Hub covering regasification capacity of no less than 3 billion cubic meters of natural gas, with a planned LNG terminal in Stade. In June, Venture Global LNG and EnBW jointly announced that 2 long-term contracts had been executed, under which Venture Global will deliver 2 billion cubic meters of LNG annually to EnBW. To round out the supply picture, a brief word on coal and nuclear too. Diversifying where our hard coal comes from began back at the end of 2021. Over the past month, EnBW has substantially increased its purchases of non-Russian coal. In the meantime, we succeeded in moving entirely to alternative sources. So as things stand, EnBW no longer has any exposure to Russian coal supply. Our thermal generation units are at present operating at full capacity so as to stabilize the overall energy system. That trend got underway last year already and carries on in 2022, meaning we do not anticipate lowering our CO2 intensity this year compared with last.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#8

With the war in Ukraine as the backdrop, what we must do now is guarantee supply security while not relegating climate protection to second place. So let me assure you that all of us at EnBW stay completely dedicated to our sustainability targets. Come 2025, our goal is a 15% to 30% cut in CO2 intensity measured against the 2018 baseline. Come 2035, we intend to reach climate neutrality in our emissions. The resilience of our integrated business model helps us get there. That naturally leads me to the discussion about possibly extending nuclear power use in Germany. As we see it, nothing has changed. After the 2011 decision to phase out nuclear power, we pursued a long-term strategy of dismantling our nuclear plants, and we have stuck with it consistently from then on. The legal framework unambiguously excluded electricity generation at German nuclear plants past December 31, 2022. That holds for our Neckarwestheim II plant as well. The Federal Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Action has now tasked the 4 German transmission system operators with carrying out a second stress test, in which Germany's power supply security is to be studied under very specific conditions, factoring in the situation in France too.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#9

We should have those results shortly. Now, moving on to how we performed across the first 6 months. I'd like to kick things off with a quick review of adjusted EBITDA and adjusted group net profit, which you'll find on Slide 4. Across the first 6 months of this year, versus the equivalent stretch in 2021, adjusted EBITDA came in 4% lower at EUR 1.424 billion. Curtailment of Russian gas supplies at our subsidiaries — and the steep replacement costs incurred for the gas volumes we no longer received — along with greater network reserve expense, all weighed on the figure. Higher earnings contributions from Renewable Energies and from trading activities largely made up for that. I'll walk through the specifics shortly. Adjusted group net profit attributable to EnBW. AG shareholders fell by nearly half a million, reaching EUR 300 million during the first 6 months of 2022. That drop in net profit stems chiefly from a weaker financial result, driven by IFRS 9 losses on marketing securities marked to market, which stood higher as of the reporting date. Now let's examine our 3 business segments closely, beginning with smart infrastructure for customers on the next slide. Adjusted EBITDA for this segment — which made up 8% of our overall operating result — was cut nearly in half, landing at EUR 115 million across the first 6 months of 2022 relative to the prior year period.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#10

The primary driver behind this drop in earnings is higher procurement costs. Starting October 1, 2022, those elevated procurement costs will result in an average price increase of roughly 31% for household electricity. Since the levy under the German Renewable Energy Act will stop being passed through, the price will subsequently be about 15% above prior periods. On Slide 6, the system critical infrastructure segment accounted for roughly 40% of our total earnings in the first half of 2022. Adjusted EBITDA fell 9% year over year to EUR 588 million. The cause of this earnings reduction is a substantial rise in expenses for network reserve, redispatch included. Reserve power plants get deployed at the transmission system operator's request to safeguard system stability. During the first half of the year, EnBW's reserve power plants were called upon far more frequently, and at markedly higher cost than planned versus the same period a year earlier, with corresponding extra expenses incurred to ensure security of supply. Those additional expenses will, however, be fully reimbursed in later periods through the incentive regulation system. Moving to Slide 7, let me address sustainable generation infrastructure, our biggest business segment in the first half of 2022, which delivered nearly 60% of our overall results.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#11

Adjusted EBITDA for this segment rose sharply, up 17% to EUR 852 million during the reporting period versus a year earlier. Over in Renewable Energies, adjusted EBITDA climbed by over 40% to EUR 547 million, driven mainly by these 3 factors: first, selling electricity from renewables at prices above the fixed tariff set under the German Renewable Energy Act; second, the new solar farms we brought online; and lastly, wind conditions during this year's first 6 months came in stronger than the prior year's levels. Turning to Generation and Trading, adjusted EBITDA for the first half of 2022 fell 12% to EUR 305 million against the same period last year, largely because of lower gas volumes from Russia, which our subsidiary VNG had to buy on the wholesale market at greater expense. Temporary valuation effects from derivatives also weighed negatively. Those effects will keep partly reversing down the road as the underlying trading contracts move into delivery. Conversely, higher market prices helped, and for the full year 2022 we anticipate today's elevated market prices will benefit thermal generation and trading.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#12

Now let's take a quick look at how our retained cash flow developed, on Slide 7 (sic) Slide 8. Retained cash flow came in at EUR 792 million, a slight decline of 5%, driven mainly by a higher dividend payment than in the first 6 months of 2021. That takes me to net debt on Slide 9. At June 30, net debt stood at roughly EUR 7.5 billion, which is 14%, or EUR 1.3 billion, under the level at the end of 2021. Along with our retained cash flow and a small net movement in working capital, 3 effects largely drove this. First, net investments came to around EUR 1.1 billion, and about half of that was attributable to investments in our grid infrastructure. In addition, we put some EUR 300 million into our renewables business to complete our solar parks, Alttrebbin and Gottesgabe, and to secure the lease option off the coast of Scotland to develop a 2.9 gigawatt offshore wind farm together with BP. And roughly EUR 150 million went to investments in our segments smart infrastructure for customers, predominantly for rolling out our e-mobility fast tracking infrastructure. Second, repayment of 2 subordinated bonds with a nominal value of EUR 725 million and USD 300 million, respectively, at the beginning of January 2022 caused net debt to increase by about EUR 500 million.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#13

Finally, pension provisions saw a substantial decline of roughly EUR 2.1 billion, driven by a considerable rise in the applicable discount rate — from 1.15% at the close of 2021 to 3.35% as of June 30. Now let me walk you through our full-year 2022 outlook on Slide 10. As I noted at the start of the presentation, our earnings guidance for 2022 at the overall group level is still unchanged. That said, it has been restated: the war in Ukraine, together with elevated market volatility and the risk of a gas shortage, heightens overall uncertainty around statements concerning future development. So we keep monitoring and assessing conditions for their potential effect on our business, both as a group and at our subsidiary VNG in particular. As previously, adjusted EBITDA in smart infrastructure for customers is projected to surpass the prior-year figures in 2022. Elevated expenses for network grid reserve and redispatch, needed to keep supply secure, are anticipated to persist through the second half of 2022. Given this, we expect adjusted EBITDA in system critical infrastructure to come in below our forecast range. For adjusted EBITDA in sustainable generation infrastructure in 2022, our outlook was growth of between 7% and 14%.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#14

Because market prices remain elevated, we now anticipate that adjusted EBITDA will come in above the forecast range we gave earlier. Given the uncertainties that persist and the volatility across the 2 segments — system critical infrastructure and sustainable generation infrastructure — we chose not to provide an updated forecast range for either of those segments on its own. That said, at the group level overall, we still expect earnings to rise by plus 2% to plus 7% in 2022, between 2 — between EUR 3.025 billion and EUR 3.175 billion. With that, I'll turn things over to the operator so we can begin the Q&A session.

Operator

operator
#15

<<operator_script>> Our initial question comes from James Sparrow at BNP.

James Sparrow

analyst
#16

I wanted to ask a follow-up about the gas situation. Specifically, on Slide 3, where you mention the EUR 545 million impact — does that represent essentially the whole-year effect running through to the first of October? Or is it the impact on EBITDA only up until July? So have you set aside some kind of provision for the remainder of the year? Or, to put the same question another way — I know S&P in their recent update mentioned losses in the mid-single-digit range from gas supply. Is that still a reasonable figure to keep in mind through the start of October? And does that EUR 545 million number include it?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#17

James, the EUR 545 million figure is actually a full-year impact as we see it today. That said, when you look at our half-year report, we also say that depending on future developments — meaning prices, the level of supply from Russian gas and so forth — there may be an increase. And in our half-year report we stated that it might be up to an additional EUR 1.3 billion. However, as of today, we don't actually see that; that's not the number we're looking at. At the half year, we reflected what we currently see on a full-year basis. Does that answer your question, James?

James Sparrow

analyst
#18

Yeah, I believe that's right, yes. So that's your best guess for the full-year effect, and put very simply, if we carried it through to 1 October, it's roughly EUR 5 million per day. Does that more or less get us to the same place as well? Those figures seem broadly consistent to me, but I was really just double-checking.

Operator

operator
#19

Andrew Moulder from CreditSights has the next question. Mr. Moulder, you might need to unmute your phone.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#20

Is my voice coming through?

Operator

operator
#21

Now we do.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#22

Yes.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#23

I need to ask about German nuclear, because of all the discussions we've had with E.ON and RWE during the past few days. I realize you'd rather not weigh in on whatever the government may choose. But purely hypothetically, supposing they chose to prolong the operation of the nuclear plants, what could you actually do at this moment? For example, could GKN II run until the middle of 2023 before it requires refueling? Or is it a matter of merely 3 months or 2 years, or something like that? So could you describe precisely what you could do straight away if they chose to extend the nuclear lifetimes? That's sort of my one question. And may I also ask about the LNG you mentioned. You referred to the Stade terminal, and you also referred to the agreement with Venture Global. When will those actually take effect? So when will you be receiving -- I believe you said it was 3 million -- 3 bcm from Stade and 2 bcm from Venture Global, or perhaps it was the reverse, but when will you be receiving those volumes? Is that right away?

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#24

I assume that's not from Stade. But does that happen right away, or is it next year? And then maybe last, regarding your guidance, you mentioned that smart infrastructure for customers would be above last year. But I'm not certain whether that's a bit too optimistic given the high procurement costs we're seeing. I mean, if those keep rising — admittedly, you'll be able to pass through some of the ones you've already incurred, but you perhaps will have more costs that you can't pass through. So do you still think it's realistic to expect that segment to actually be better than last year?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#25

Andrew, I’ll take your questions in the sequence you raised them, and I’ll begin with nuclear and Neckarwestheim II. What you’re really asking is how long we think we can keep that power station operating with no refueling. Honestly, it’s a matter of a couple of weeks, not months, because we had effectively been preparing since 2011 to shut the plant down at the end of 2022, and that means the fuel level is fairly low by the end of December. So with no refueling and no changes to the core, we won’t be able to keep the station running beyond a couple of weeks.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#26

Quick question on that point — you mentioned you're not making changes to the core. Could you actually adjust the core and shift the fuel around, which might let you beat a couple of weeks? Or is it really that we're looking at roughly 2 weeks into January, and after that you'd have to shut it down for, say, 12 months until refueling is done?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#27

Right, that's essentially what we're just now getting ready to assess — I'd say it's closer to 4 to 6 weeks, which is our present view absent any additional changes. And once we get clearer information on what the stress test shows, we'll dig further into the specifics. Still, under the existing setup, it amounts to a couple of weeks. We are able to extend how long this power — in theory, we can extend the lifetime of the power station.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#28

And as far as the refueling goes, what's the actual timeframe for that? Is it genuinely going to be roughly another year? Or is it going to be...

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#29

I’m sorry, but I’m not able to provide an exact figure here. On LNG, Andrew, when we discuss the venture capital contract, that agreement is set to begin in 2026. And with respect to Stade as well, our current assumption is that Stade will be ready as early as 2026. So it’s possible that both the contract and Stade will be available in 2026.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#30

Okay, so let me just pick up on that quickly then — the 35 terawatt hours you're getting from Russia right now, that agreement runs out at the end of this year. So how are you replacing it?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#31

Actually, that's something that has to be swapped out if we intend to compete in the market.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#32

Given how compressed this month is, do you still believe you can pull that off without much trouble?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#33

Right now, that’s how we’re viewing it: we’ll be able to obtain it from a range of sources available in the market. At present, we’re examining numerous options — the wholesale market price is what we can use. We’re also exploring ways to diversify our future supply. And we’re confident we’ll manage to do that. If not, then there’s less supply we can provide to our customers.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#34

Right, okay. So I mean, clearly that hasn't been contracted since the year on...

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#35

No. No, that isn't the case.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#36

Okay, good. That's fine.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#37

And actually, on that last question of yours, I could use your help with it. What was it again...

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#38

Regarding smart infrastructure...

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#39

Okay. <<inaudible>> What's the reasoning behind expecting we'll land at or a bit above last year's figures? Well, actually — and I'm not certain — I believe I mentioned during the presentation that household customers will see a price increase on October 1 this year. That ought to let us reach a sales segment level that's on par with the prior year, or a touch higher than it.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#40

Okay. And are German customers still fairly content? Well, not content, but still fairly reasonable when it comes to accepting price increases?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#41

So basically, what we're doing with that October price increase is simply passing along the extra costs we're currently facing. And of course, prices in Germany really are rising — that applies to electricity and to gas alike. So that's definitely something all of us will need to keep an eye on going forward. But as you know, electricity prices have gone up sevenfold since the start of 2021. At their peak, gas prices reached 20x the level we saw at the beginning of 2021. So at a certain point, even EnBW — with our solid, forward-looking procurement strategy — has to pass those price increases through to the market.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#42

Alright, alright. Okay. And if you'll permit me, maybe just one more question. You're going to need to impose a single-question rule like E.On and RWE do. But regardless, since I'm still allowed, we're seeing quite a lot in the press here in the U.K., actually, about droughts in Germany and about how the Rhine's level is really very low. And the barges that would deliver coal to coal-fired plants can't actually make it up the river — I mean, is that a genuine problem? Or is it just the U.K. press sort of exaggerating it? And how big an impact do you think that could have on security of supply in Germany?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#43

Yes. No, it's a subject we're discussing right now. The Rhine's water level is extremely low, and that's actually already affecting deliveries via the Rhine. But all our power stations do have rail access. So we always have the option of switching to rail. And so it shouldn't be an issue, at least not as far as we can currently see for next winter. At EnBW, we have sufficient coal storage right now, and we have enough transport capacity available to make sure we have enough coal to get us through the winter. But you're absolutely right, the level — the water level in the Rhine is extremely low.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#44

Right. Okay. Sorry — just one point from what you mentioned in your remarks there. You said you have sufficient coal storage to kind of get you through the winter, and you expect <<inaudible>>. What sort of low...

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#45

No. Sorry, on that point I was being precise — we do have sufficient cold storage and contracted coal, and the transport capacity is there, so we can be sure we have enough coal to get us through the winter.

Andrew Moulder

analyst
#46

Okay, so what kind of load factor is being assumed for your coal plants there? Are we talking about 80%, or is it more like 20%?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#47

Like I mentioned, they're running at full capacity right now. And our assumption is that this will continue through the winter.

Operator

operator
#48

At this point we have no more questions, so I'll return the floor to Marcel Munch for some closing remarks. Go right ahead.

Marcel Münch

executive
#49

Thanks, Thomas, for your answer and comments, and thank you to everyone on the call for making the time. We hope all of you get a well-deserved break over the summer, and we look forward to seeing you again when we present our figures for the first 9 months of 2022 on our next conference call on November 11. Until then, all the best. Goodbye.

Operator

operator
#50

Ladies and gentlemen, that brings the conference to a close, and you're welcome to hang up your phone now. We appreciate your participation, and we hope the rest of your day goes well. Take care.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.