EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 12, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and thanks for holding. This is Natalie, the Chorus Call operator for this event. We're glad to have you on the EnBW Investor at Analyst Conference call covering the first three months of 2023. For the recorded presentation today, everyone will be in a listen-only mode throughout. After the presentation, we'll move to a question and answer session. Should you wish to ask something, just press Star then one on your phone. For operator assistance, please press the Star key then zeero. At this point I'll hand the conference to Marcel Münch, Senior Vice President of Finance, M&A and Investor Relations. Please go ahead.
Marcel Münch
executiveGood day, everyone, and welcome. We appreciate you being here for today’s conference call with investors and analysts regarding EnBW’s results for the first three months of 2023. Our CFO, Thomas Kusterer, will walk you through the specifics of how our business has developed in just a moment. After that, as usual, we’re eager to hear your comments and questions. So without further delay, I’ll turn things over to Thomas. Thomas, the floor is yours.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks, Marcel. And hello everyone, a very warm welcome from my side as well. Earlier today, we released the final numbers for the first three months of 2023, which confirm what we told you on May 4th — that we anticipated adjusted EBITDA at group level of EUR 2.8 billion, a figure well above the prior year's. I'll come back to that shortly. First, let me walk you through a few things that have happened at EnBW since our last investor and analyst conference call. After we published our 2022 results at the end of March, S&P came out with an upward revision of EnBW's credit ratings outlook to stable, reaffirming our credit rating at A minus. According to S&P, EnBW has a solid record of delivering on its strategy on time or ahead of schedule. From the agency's point of view, several aspects matter here: our strong financial performance, our faster coal phase-out — now planned for 2028 — and the CO2 reduction path approved by SBTi, marked by alignment with a 1.5 degree pathway for our own emissions that SBTi has approved, plus the addition of an SBTi-approved reduction target covering our indirect Scope 3 emissions. Recognizing this advantage of our integrated setup, S&P believes EnBW's transformation will place it among the strongest integrated European utilities over the long term.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLadies and gentlemen, as we laid out on our previous call, the energy transition’s triangle is what determines whether the transformation of the energy system succeeds. That means growing renewables along with grid infrastructure and simultaneously ramping up low CO2 dispatchable power generation. On March 31st, EnBW started its EUR 1.6 billion fuel switch investment program for the 1st of 3 new gas-fired power plants in Baden-Württemberg. Our aim is to phase out coal-fired power generation entirely in the Neckar, central Neckar region by 2026 and to cut carbon emissions significantly. By the mid-2030s, all fuel switch sites are expected to run on hydrogen. That will lower carbon emissions further, making the plants part of a climate-neutral electricity generation infrastructure with a high level of security of supply. In Stuttgart-Münster, two Siemens gas turbines will be installed with a total electrical output of some 124 megawatts. When they are delivered in 2024, they will be able to handle a blend of up to 75% hydrogen, the potential upgrade of the plant to 100% hydrogen. Currently, on the German-Swiss border, our subsidiary, Energiedienst, is building the largest production capacity of green hydrogen in Southern Germany. From 2025 onwards, up to 720 metric tons of green hydrogen per year will be available to supply industrial and other customers in the border region of Germany, Switzerland, and France.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThrough issuing requests for proposals covering these volumes, EnBW has already begun the initial move toward selling hydrogen as a future energy carrier. Building a hydrogen infrastructure nationwide matters enormously to how competitive Germany's economy stays and is essential if we are to hit our climate goals. Along the whole value chain, across a range of hydrogen projects, we are methodically assessing hydrogen's potential. Let me say a few words about the final shutdown of nuclear generation in Germany, which happened on April 15th, 2023, when EnBW took Unit 2 at Neckarwestheim offline as one of the last 3 plants in the country. To put it precisely, I believe we were the final nuclear station in Germany to be cut off from the grid. Under a brief lifetime extension in 2023, Neckarwestheim 2 generated its final 1.9 terawatt hours of power. Since we had already been granted the license to dismantle Neckarwestheim 2 at the start of April, EnBW now stands as the first nuclear plant operator in Germany to secure every license needed to dismantle its full fleet of nuclear power plants. As of today, our expectation remains that taking apart the two stations at Neckarwestheim, along with the two units at Philippsburg, will require roughly 10 to 15 years altogether.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLadies and gentlemen, at this point let's take a closer look at the numbers for the first three months of 2023. I'd like to begin with operating earnings, which you'll find on slide three. At EUR 2.8 billion in adjusted EBITDA, we delivered a very strong performance during the first three months of 2023. That represents a rise of roughly 140% versus last year. The gain came mostly from a strong showing, chiefly in thermal power generation and trading activities. On the back of that adjusted EBITDA development, adjusted group net profit rose by nearly EUR 1 billion. The higher adjusted EBITDA is mainly offset by higher adjusted income taxes, which came in around EUR 400 million above last year's level. Now let's go deeper into our operating segments, beginning on slide four. In Smart Infrastructure for Customers, adjusted EBITDA stabilized, moving from minus EUR 60 million to zero in the first three months of 2023. That earnings improvement resulted from lower seasonality in procurement prices than in the prior year. Versus the previous year, adjusted EBITDA in our System Critical Infrastructure segment, on slide five, rose by 62% to EUR 585 million. Two effects largely drove that increase.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFirst, revenues grew substantially because of higher investments in expanding the grid. Second, this year's grid usage charges reflect the costs anticipated for grid reserve and redispatch. Turning to slide six, I'll address Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, the segment where earnings rose the most versus 2022. Adjusted EBITDA climbed considerably, reaching EUR 2.351 billion in the three months of 2023, up from the equivalent period a year earlier. Let's examine more closely what drove the results of this segment's two components, beginning with renewable energies. There, adjusted EBITDA fell slightly, by 3.6%, to EUR 282 million. That modest earnings decline stemmed chiefly from lower power prices than in the three months of 2022, which cut earnings from direct marketing of renewable power generation. In thermal generation and trading, adjusted EBITDA jumped sharply during the three months of 2023. Versus the first three months of 2022, adjusted EBITDA from thermal generation and trading climbed to EUR 2.069 billion. For one thing, hedges we had entered into mean generation volumes are sold at prices substantially above last year's. For another, we booked sizable positive valuation effects on trading transactions.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFinally, the volatility that remained in commodity markets proved quite advantageous for our trading operations during the first quarter. Turning to slide seven and how net debt evolved, I'd like to begin with some remarks on how our retained cash flow developed. Relative to the first three months of 2022, retained cash flow in Q1 2023 increased by EUR 2.2 billion, reaching EUR 3.083 billion. The main driver behind this gain was a rise in adjusted EBITDA, particularly at Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, as I described a moment ago, along with cash-relevant effects within our non-operating results. In Q1 2023, that improvement in retained cash flow was for the most part offset by a working capital increase of approximately EUR 3.1 billion. Roughly half of that rise was fairly temporary in character and stems from the three effects below. A rise in receivables stemming from the rollout of the electricity and gas price brakes. Other energy-related seasonalities, chiefly the build-up of inventories for carbon allowances tied to generation at our power plants in 2022. In addition, we finished Q1 with gas storage levels above average and therefore higher inventory. From a security of supply standpoint this was a positive development, and it resulted from lower natural gas consumption overall over the past winter.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFinally, net cash investments came to EUR 711 million. Roughly EUR 365 million went into System Critical Infrastructure — expanding capacity, renewing the distribution grid, and delivering the Electricity Network Development Plan. A total of EUR 275 million was put toward Sustainable Generation Infrastructure. Renewables received over EUR 200 million, chiefly our offshore wind farm He Dreiht in the German North Sea, on which the final investment decision was made in March. The remainder was largely directed to our fuel switch project in Baden-Württemberg. Adding up all of these items, net debt stood at approximately EUR 11.5 billion as of March 31, 2023, roughly EUR 700 million higher than the December 2022 level. Ladies and gentlemen, to wrap up today's presentation on slide eight, I can confirm that, as things stand today, we are keeping the prior guidance for adjusted EBITDA for the full year 2023. One main factor is that Q1 results benefited from sizable valuation effects, and how those evolve will hinge on market price movements, so they could at least partly reverse. For the Smart Infrastructure for Customers segment, our adjusted EBITDA forecast is EUR 400 million-EUR 500 million, as we anticipate volatility easing and the market going back to more normal levels.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFor System Critical Infrastructure, we anticipate a substantial rise, with adjusted EBITDA landing between EUR 1.6 million and EUR 1.9 million. As noted earlier and already visible in our Q1 figures, the adverse impact from 2022 related to grid reserve and redispatch won't carry into 2023, because the empirical value from 2022 has been incorporated into the 2023 revenue cap. Anchorage revenues should also climb modestly, driven by the substantial investments in projects within the electricity and gas grid development plans. Turning to Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, we foresee adjusted EBITDA rising to a range of EUR 2.9 billion to EUR 3.2 billion. First, the renewable energies business should come in flat versus last year at more than EUR 1 billion. Second, we anticipate a considerable earnings improvement in thermal generation and trading during 2023. Given the large proportion of regulated business and margins hedged as much as three years ahead in our competitive areas—sales and generation—our group-level full year guidance for 2023 calls for a significant earnings increase to between EUR 4.7 billion and EUR 5.2 billion. With that, I'll pass things to the operator so we can begin our Q&A session.
Operator
operatorThank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we're going to start the question-and-answer portion at this point. If you'd like to pose a question, you can do so by pressing star and then one on your touch-tone phone. Should you want to take yourself out of the queue, just press star and then two. For those of you on speaker equipment today, please pick up the handset before you make your selections. Anyone with a question can press star and one right now. Give us a moment for the first question, please. Our first question comes from Andrew Moulder of CreditSights. Please go ahead.
Andrew Moulder
analystHello, Thomas and Marcel. It's good to talk with both of you, and thank you for the results presentation. A couple of questions related to the results first. On the networks side, after hearing the E.ON presentation a couple of days ago — or perhaps it was last week — they placed quite a lot of emphasis on redispatching costs and on the recovery of those costs, and in particular they stressed that this was really only a timing effect and that it would actually reverse over time, over a period of three years or so. I'm just wondering, within your networks EBITDA, how much of that stems from redispatching recoveries, so to speak, or from excess recoveries this year, and how much of it will reverse, I suppose, in later years? Second, on the generation and trading part of the business, EUR 2.1 billion sounds like, you know, a great result. I'm just wondering how much of that is actually attributable to generation, where you've sold power at higher hedged prices, and how much of it comes from the volatility you've seen in the trading business. Sort of how much is not really tied to your generation but is more tied to trading, rather than simply selling power at higher hedged prices.
Andrew Moulder
analystOkay, so for my last question, what I really wanted to ask is this: everyone keeps discussing power generation and power plants being hydrogen-ready. You mentioned that your hydrogen plants could potentially handle a blend of as much as 75%, or at least you said the turbines were capable of that. So I'm wondering whether that applies to everything else in the plant and all the equipment too. If it all can handle up to 75%, then you're essentially saying that at the very first commissioning of those plants, they'd be able to take a hydrogen blend of up to 75%. What I'd like to know is how much it would cost to upgrade that to 100%. I mean, compared with what the plant costs at up to 75%, is it an additional 20% or roughly that? And lastly, I believe I raised this on a previous call, but I'm not sure whether you have anything further you can share on where power prices would need to be for generating power with hydrogen to be economic rather than generating with natural gas. Those are my three main questions, more or less. Thank you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHi, Andrew. It's genuinely good to speak with you once more. Let me begin with your first question, which concerns redispatch and how we recover those costs. I believe we need to break this down, actually: the 3-year window during which we are reimbursed for 2022 redispatch and network reserve expenses is one piece of the answer. That does not actually apply to 2023. In 2023, actually, those expenses are reimbursed right away. In practice, we have already received, within the first quarter's grid revenues, a portion of it, and that sits within our non-operating EBITDA. This will actually be offset by costs as this year unfolds, when we will need to request capacity for redispatch and network reserves going forward to stabilize the grid. It differs, 2023 versus 2022. For 2022, we will be reimbursed in 3 years' time, 2025 to 2027, across a 3-year span, 2025 to 2027, for the redispatch and networks reserved. In 2023, it is actually reimbursed immediately within the revenues applied. That is the first question. The first answer. Is that okay with you, actually, Andrew? Is that clear, or?
Andrew Moulder
analystRight, that's good. I mean, from what E.ON said, I thought I understood that the money they were receiving in 2023 was actually calculated based on 2022 power prices. Since power prices have come down a lot, they were over-recovering in 2023, and that would need to be given back over time. Is that not how it works for you?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveActually, it isn't about the power price. It's really about the expenses incurred in 2020. That's the basis. The basis is the expenses actually incurred in 2022, because the underlying assumption was that it could happen again in 2023. That's the baseline, and that's the basis. You can request reimbursement on a monthly basis. However, you should make sure you don't get over-reimbursed, because that would be negative for us. We are actually extremely cautious about how much money we're asking for in that context.
Andrew Moulder
analystOh, okay. Alright. That clears things up.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAll told, on a full-year basis it should come out to a net zero effect. In Q1 it was positive, and at this point we're working out how much of it we'll need over the next couple of months to ensure we don't end up over reimbursed, with the full-year picture in mind, correct?
Andrew Moulder
analystYeah. All right.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveMoving to your second question, which concerns generation and trading and the EUR 2.11 billion result in that segment. Versus the prior year, the gain there amounts to EUR 1.4 billion. Most of that comes from valuation effects, a reversal of the valuation taken a year earlier. As you know, in Q4 of last year, wholesale market prices stood well above where they were in Q1. You mentioned it yourself, 2023. So we booked a reversal of negative valuations in Q4 2022, and now we see a positive effect in Q1 2023. That covers the first point. And here's the good news. Thanks to higher hedge levels, we managed to lift our underlying earnings. We were also in a position to do so. Our trading managed to take advantage of market volatility. All of that sits in electricity, roughly speaking, around EUR 400 million, with approximately EUR 100 million in the gas sector. That sort of answers your question. I certainly hope so.
Andrew Moulder
analystRight, I suppose that's fair. So what you're really saying is that valuation effects account for the bulk of the improvement, rather than actual selling strength in the market?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYes. That's exactly right. When you look at the approximate figures, an increase of EUR 1.4 billion versus the levels of the prior year, roughly EUR 500 million of that is genuine improvement in the underlying operating business, and the remainder comes from valuation. As you're aware, that depends heavily on how power prices develop going forward and on how the micro market for these derivatives plays out over the course of the year. Yes.
Andrew Moulder
analystRight. I suppose that sort of brings us to the point of why, even with such a strong first quarter, you didn't actually raise your guidance. Okay. That's great.
Thomas Kusterer
executivePrecisely, Andrew. That is precisely why. Right? And actually, on a third question, this one about hydrogen — yes, you're absolutely correct there. Being 75% hydrogen ready means, in practice, that starting on day one it would be feasible to run on 75% hydrogen as fuel. That said, I think all of us recognize that this is theory, since the volume of hydrogen simply isn't available at that moment. What we assume, in fact, is that it will take at minimum until the start of the 2030s before hydrogen in substantial volume is available for our power stations. Your follow-up on that was, in fact, what additional cost is involved in making it 100% hydrogen ready? To begin with, that is already covered within our investment in the power plant, and it isn't substantial. In the final investment decision for the power station, this conversion is already covered, and it isn't substantial.
Andrew Moulder
analystOkay, could I just ask a quick follow-up on that?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAbsolutely.
Andrew Moulder
analystYou've got the plant at 75% ready. Now, regarding the gas grid that would carry gas to the plant — would that also be at 75%? I mean, from what I've mostly seen, the discussion is only about a 10% or a 20% blend.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveIt's closer to 20%. That's the reason I said it's really 75% ready — meaning that if hydrogen becomes available, it could handle 75%, and that's good news. At the same time, the grid infrastructure underneath has to be upgraded so that 75% or even more can flow through the pipes. The pipes themselves aren't really the issue; it's more all the other grid components, actually, that need reinvestment.
Andrew Moulder
analystIs there anything on what power would need to cost if hydrogen were used to generate it?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveWell, as you mentioned, a lot hinges on power prices. If you were producing it in Germany, at least in the German power market — that matters. And second, the question of power prices. You also have to factor the CO2 price into that equation, not just the other elements. For it to become truly economically viable, I believe the cost of producing hydrogen has to decline substantially. Right now, what we're doing is participating in projects throughout the entire hydrogen value chain, from production through to sales. It's really about being on a learning curve and having a hand in everything so we're sure to be in the market if and when that market becomes economically viable. Again, Andrew, from where I sit, I believe Germany will, to a great extent, import hydrogen down the road. We won't be capable of producing hydrogen in significant volumes, at least not over the next 15 to 20 years here in Germany. Hydrogen will need to be imported, and the real question is where it gets produced and at what cost. That remains entirely unclear. I think on the economics side, when it comes to hydrogen, there's a great deal to be learned, and it will take a while before we can genuinely discuss economics here.
Andrew Moulder
analystAll right, that's excellent. Many thanks, Thomas. And thank you, Marcel.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks for joining us.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, just a quick reminder — if you’d like to ask a question, press star and one on your phone. Please hold for the next question. It appears we have no more questions at this point. I’ll now hand things back to Marcel Münch for closing remarks.
Marcel Münch
executiveYeah. Thanks, Thomas, for that.
Operator
operatorSorry about that. A follow-up question just came in—
Marcel Münch
executiveOh, all right.
Operator
operatorAndrew’s turn once more — Andrew, the floor is yours.
Andrew Moulder
analystYes. Thanks. Apologies — I didn’t want to cut in before everyone else had gotten a turn.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks for that, Andrew — good to have you with us.
Andrew Moulder
analystYes, sorry. I’ve just got a couple more follow-up questions, if that’s all right.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAlright.
Andrew Moulder
analystA lot of proposals have been floating around in Germany, things like capping power prices, boosting renewable generation, and making it simpler to build and plan renewables along with the entire authorization process. I'm not really sure that anything concrete has actually been decided at this point. Perhaps I've missed it, but could you give me — and maybe everyone else on the call — an update on where things actually stand regarding German legislation, both on price caps for industrial customers and on laws aimed at speeding up renewable development? And for my second question, I just wanted to check in on where you are with the TransnetBW transaction and whether there's any further news you can share on that. Thank you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, I'll actually begin with your second question, the TransnetBW process. This process is well on track. I think I can be candid about the fact that binding offers have come in, and at present we are evaluating those binding offers. Yeah, let me phrase it that way. I think within the next couple of weeks, we'll actually be in a position to give more information about the overall process. I can't share more information with you at this point in time, Andrew, but bear with me a couple of weeks and we'll have more clarity around that.
Andrew Moulder
analystThanks.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn the German legislative front, honestly, Andrew, I believe nothing has slipped past you. When it comes to renewables, we saw laws enacted last year — the so-called Easter Package plus subsequent legislation — aimed at accelerating renewable expansion. To be candid, we are actually observing some on-the-ground improvements. Not as far as we would like on speeding up approvals, though, since getting the permitting process done and securing permissions remains the bottleneck. Some headway is visible there. That said, we must pick up the pace substantially if the country is genuinely to hit the renewable targets we set for ourselves through 2030. On price caps for industrial customers, frankly, I'd say it is very early days after the discussions. Of course it makes sense that the government is weighing how to shield the German economy from high power prices. At the same time, everyone, I believe, clearly grasps that if we want a system with cheaper electricity going forward, there is just one route to that: expanding renewable energies, boosting flexible power generation, and growing transmission along with distribution networks.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveTo be clear, one point stands out. That can only occur if the risk-return relationship is appealing enough to draw in international capital, and I believe that is understood. Regarding price caps for industrial customers, as I just mentioned, from my viewpoint it is even lower than an initial proposal, and we will have to watch how those discussions evolve in the future. We are monitoring it. As I just noted, we must make sure the energy transition takes place, and takes place quickly. I think politicians recognize this, and those who do not yet should recognize that this is absolutely necessary over the long term. Does that address your question?
Andrew Moulder
analystYeah, that covers it. I mean, that's roughly how I understood things stood with the situation.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat's correct.
Andrew Moulder
analystThat's exactly what I was looking to verify. Thanks so much.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveNo, definitely. Thanks, Andrew.
Operator
operatorAt this point, we have no further questions, so I'll turn things back over to Marcel Münch.
Marcel Münch
executiveI'll take another crack at it. Thomas, thank you for the answers and the comments. And thanks to everyone on the call for spending the time with us. We're very much looking forward to welcoming all of you back when we present the figures for the first six months of 2023 on our next conference call, on August 11th. Until then, take care, and goodbye.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, that brings the conference to a close, so you're free to disconnect at this point. Many thanks for being with us, and enjoy the rest of your day. Goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.