EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 13, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Marcel Münch
executiveGood day, everyone, and welcome. I'd also like to thank you for being with us on today's Investor and Analyst Conference Call covering EnBW's results for the first nine months of 2023. Thomas Kusterer, our CFO, will start things off as usual, walking you through how our business developed over the first three quarters and giving an update on what we expect for the rest of the year. After that, we're eager as always to hear your comments and questions. So without further delay, I'll turn things over to Thomas.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks, Marcel, and hello everyone, a warm welcome from my side as well. As was mentioned earlier, group-level Adjusted EBITDA rose 65% to EUR 4.9 billion during the first nine months of this year, as of October 31st. Given the substantial earnings growth in the third quarter, we therefore adjusted our 2023 guidance for Adjusted EBITDA at group level to a range of EUR 5.9 billion to EUR 6.5 billion. Later in this presentation, I'll give you a few more specifics about the main factors behind that revision. At EUR 6.5 billion, the liquidity position of EnBW Group was still very comfortable as of September 30th, 2023. On top of that, we still have undrawn credit facilities totaling over EUR six billion available to us. That's a quick summary of the financial situation. Ladies and gentlemen, as you're aware, here at EnBW we concentrate on all three sides of the energy transition triangle: growing renewable energies, strengthening and expanding grid infrastructure, and scaling up low CO2 dispatchable power generation. This mirrors our unique setup as Germany's only fully integrated utility. We keep executing this strategic agenda, and several developments in recent weeks demonstrate that.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveTo start with, the deal to bring in long-term investment partners for a minority stake of up to 49.9% in TransnetBW — one of Germany's four electricity transmission grid operators — has now closed. Last week, KfW, the German state-owned bank, exercised an option to pick up a further 24.95% stake in TransnetBW. Those terms match what was offered at the end of May for another minority stake of the same size by a consortium of more than 30 banks, insurance companies, and pension funds from Baden-Württemberg. This transaction, which we have now completed successfully, backs the essential expansion of grid infrastructure in Germany. On the expansion of renewable, of renewables, we achieved meaningful progress in managing merchant risk at our 960-MW offshore wind farm, He Dreiht, which, as you'll remember, receives no subsidy and will begin operation at the end of 2025. In August, EnBW signed a 20-MW long-term power purchase agreement with Deutsche Bahn. At the start of November, a further long-term contract, for 100 MW, was signed with a subsidiary of Deutsche Telekom. Contracts with financially very solid off-takers — Fraport, Evonik, Salzgitter, and Bosch — were already in place. So, at 455 MW now, EnBW has already secured roughly half of He Dreiht's capacity through PPAs.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn top of that, we're advancing the expansion of dispatchable generation with low CO2 emissions. After construction kicked off in spring on a new gas-fired power station in Stuttgart-Münster, building work at the Altbach Deizisau site got underway at the beginning of November. Work on our third gas plant, in Heilbronn, should begin at the start of next year. These modern H2-ready gas-fired plants will cut CO2 emissions by around 60% right away, and later they will run in a climate neutral way on hydrogen. Last, as the operator of Germany's largest quick-charging network, EnBW has set the standard for e-mobility. In September, EnBW became the first company to hit the milestone of 1,000 quick-charging stations nationwide. Ladies and gentlemen, let's now take a closer look at the figures for the first nine months of 2023. I'll begin with operating earnings on slide three. At EUR 4.9 billion in adjusted EBITDA, financial performance was very strong across the first nine months of 2023. That's an increase of some 65% versus the restated figures for last year. As in earlier quarters of this year, the rise in adjusted EBITDA came mostly from higher hedge prices and from the fact that last year's nine month figures took a negative hit from the curtailment of Russian gas supplies and the resulting costs of replacing the shortfall at our subsidiary, VNG.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAs a quick reminder, so that the economic success of our segment, Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, is reflected even more accurately, starting in the first half of 2023, EnBW is reclassifying temporary valuation effects on hedging transactions out of adjusted EBITDA and into non-operating EBITDA. The prior year figures have been adjusted to match. On the basis of the adjusted EBITDA development, adjusted group net profit likewise rose significantly, by roughly EUR 1.3 billion relative to the corresponding period in 2022. Let's now go deeper into our operating segments on Slide four. Adjusted EBITDA for smart infrastructure for customers came in at EUR 225 million, which is therefore below the prior year level. The drop is largely due to charges connected with the deconsolidation of BMP, a green gas supply and sales company within EnBW Group, along with the associated write-downs on receivables. On a pro forma basis, excluding these negative one-off effects, earnings for the sales business would have been significantly higher than the previous year, despite a continued reduction in gas sales volumes caused by milder weather and saving behavior, given lower churn rates and lower seasonality in procurement prices. Versus the previous year, adjusted EBITDA of our segment system-critical infrastructure on Slide five rose by 49% to around EUR 1.4 billion.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat rise came mostly from a pair of effects. First, revenues grew substantially because we invested more in expanding the grid. Second, because revenue caps are higher, this year's grid usage charges already capture the expenses we expect for grid reserve and Redispatch to keep supply secure. More specifically, the revenue caps at our transmission grid operator, TransnetBW, now cover in full the planned 2023 expenses for grid reserve and redispatch, which was not the case the year before, when lower earnings stemmed chiefly from higher costs for grid intervention and grid reserve. That prompt earnings recovery highlights how stable the regulated grid business is, which gives us steady cash flows. Moving to Slide six, I'll discuss the sustainable generation infrastructure segment. There, earnings rose more than anywhere else relative to 2022. Adjusted EBITDA climbed substantially, to nearly EUR 3.5 billion across the first nine months of 2023. In thermal generation and trading, adjusted EBITDA rose steeply versus 2022, hitting almost EUR 2.7 billion. Chiefly, that reflects our success in locking in higher price levels by hedging the generation margin ahead of time.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveRegarding 2023, we were already fully hedged by the close of last year. As of September 30, our hedge position stands at 90%-100% for 2024, 50%-80% for 2025, and 10%-40% for 2026. On top of that, the equivalent period a year earlier had taken a sizable hit from cuts to gas deliveries out of Russia. That factor is gone now, because every supply contract with Russian counterparties ended as of the close of 2022. Naturally, output at the nuclear plant Neckarwestheim 2 was lower than a year ago as well, given that its final shutdown happened on April 15, 2023. Generation was further reduced by an outage at one of our facilities in Heilbronn. Adjusted EBITDA for renewable energies slipped modestly, down 6.4% to EUR 786 million. Results from run-of-river generation went up, and bringing additional wind farms and photovoltaic plants online contributed positively too. Those gains, however, were outweighed by weaker prices in the direct marketing of power produced from wind and photovoltaics. Turning to Slide seven, I'd like to briefly address how our retained cash flow developed across the first nine months of 2023. Beginning from a markedly higher adjusted EBITDA of EUR 4.9 billion, we recorded cash outflows of close to EUR 600 million for income taxes and EUR 281 million for covering pension nuclear liabilities.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFunds from operations exceeded EUR 3.8 billion, and that was also well above the prior-year figure. When you factor in higher declared dividends of EUR 669 million, retained cash flow reached nearly EUR 3.2 billion, which is more than EUR 950 million above the equivalent 2022 periods. That takes me to Slide 8. I'd like to walk through the key effects on how net debt developed. Over the first nine months of 2023, retained cash flow was mostly offset by two items. The first was a rise of roughly EUR 1.6 billion in adjusted working capital, driven largely by a smaller positive margin balance and by reverse effects from trade accounts payable carried over from the year before. The second was net investment of about EUR 2.3 billion, concentrated mainly in the two segments that follow. Through capacity expansion, renewal of the distribution grids, and delivery of the electricity network development plan, investment in system-critical infrastructure rises by more than EUR 1.4 billion. Within that segment, sustainable generation infrastructure spending was chiefly tied to our He Dreiht offshore wind farm in the German North Sea and to our fuel switch project in Baden-Württemberg. On top of that, the discount rate used to calculate our pension provisions rose from 3.7% to 4.1%, which reduced pension provisions by almost EUR 300 million.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveBringing all of those effects together, net debt stood at EUR 11.2 billion as of September thirtieth, 2023 — that's a rise of 3.6% from the level at the end of December, 2022. Ladies and gentlemen, on slide nine let me wrap up today's presentation with our revised outlook for Adjusted EBITDA for the financial year 2023, at both group and segment level. For Smart Infrastructure for customers, we've lowered the Adjusted EBITDA forecast from between EUR 400 million and EUR 500 million to between EUR 350 million and EUR 450 million, largely because of the adverse effects tied to BMP, the green gas supply company, which positive earnings developments elsewhere cannot fully offset. In System Critical Infrastructure, we still anticipate a significant increase over last year, with Adjusted EBITDA between EUR 1.6 billion and EUR 1.9 billion. As already outlined, the adverse effects in 2022 for grid reserve and Redispatch no longer apply in 2023, and grid revenues will rise thanks to higher investments in projects associated with the electricity and gas grid development plans. Last but not least, the earnings increase we expect in Sustainable Generation Infrastructure is decisive for the upward revision of our forecast.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFor renewables, we expect results to stay roughly flat versus last year, with Adjusted EBITDA of approximately EUR 1 billion. In 2023, we anticipate greater generation volumes thanks to more favorable weather and a modest rise in the count of renewable energy plants. That said, those gains will be outweighed by prices coming down relative to 2022. Ongoing turbulence in commodity markets should drive a significant lift in earnings from thermal generation and trading. Taking everything together, we now see group-level adjusted EBITDA surpassing our initial guidance of EUR 4.7 billion to EUR 5.2 billion. Rather, we currently expect earnings between EUR 5.9 billion and EUR 6.5 billion. With that, I'll turn things over to the operator so we can begin our Q&A session.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, we're going to start the question-and-answer portion at this point. If you'd like to pose a question, you can press star then one on your touchtone phone. Should you want to drop out of the queue, press star then two. Those of you on speaker equipment today, kindly pick up the handset before you make your selections. Anybody with a question can press star then one right now. Please hold a moment for the first question. Our first question is from James Sparrow with BNP Paribas. Go ahead, please.
James Sparrow
analystYes, good afternoon, everyone, and thanks for taking my questions. There are really two. First, obviously, these are very good set results and a very positive outlook. I just wonder whether you could talk a little about whether you can give any sort of guidance on how much the exceptional conditions in thermal generation and trading might continue through into next year, and whether this has changed any of your approach to funding, given the effectively EUR 1 billion additional of EBITDA you seem to be getting from them. And then the second question is a bit more general, relating to the Transnet sale. Obviously, there's a lot of different stuff in the German press about potential German transmission consolidation. Most of us on this call are following the TenneT situation. But I'm just curious as to what you — if you can give any sort of indication of how you think this could eventually play out. There's talk of consolidation, the German government being a minority shareholder. I guess my question would be, are the synergies to be had from combining the German transmission grids, even if they're still majority-owned by people such as yourselves?
James Sparrow
analystIs there any advantage to combining without needing, you know, complete legal consolidation? Thanks.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHello, James. Good afternoon. I'm actually speaking to you from Karlsruhe, and I appreciate the question. Let me begin with your first point about that unusual market situation you mentioned, and of course the extra operating results and cash flows that we took on during this year. In fact, we already had a fairly solid hedge level in place for 2024 as of last year. So to some degree, and we had also already hedged a portion of our 2025 output. So to some degree, we'll likewise see beneficial effects in the next year and the one after that. Clearly not to the same degree that we're going to witness it this year in 2023, since we were fully hedged by the close of last year already for 2023. So, yes, we'll see that impact. On the other side, you're surely aware that power prices fell considerably over the course of 2023, rather fast and rather sharply. So that runs counter to what I just mentioned about the 2022 impact. And as for Transnet, yes, I'm tracking the same conversation you are, James, when it concerns consolidation and the talk about TenneT. I think, actually, if a consolidation of the transmission grid operator could be sensible from the standpoint of the German government, if it truly makes sense from a synergy angle, I'm not so sure, frankly, because I believe the German transmission grid operators are pretty efficient at present.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSo that’s something that has to be observed. Still, when it comes to politics, I’m not going to debate it. Does that address what you asked?
James Sparrow
analystI suppose as much as possible, though I mean, I guess just a follow-up on that point. Would you, you know, be interested in selling out, selling down that remaining 50%?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveJames, we're on the verge of closing that 49.9%. We've just signed a contract, and assuming all goes according to plan, the transactions with both partners will be closed by the end of this month. For the time being, we're pleased with how things stand, and anything beyond that remains to be seen.
James Sparrow
analystAll right, that's fair. Can't fault me for giving it a shot. Appreciate it.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat's not right at all.
Operator
operatorJust a reminder that if you'd like to ask a question, you can press star then one at this point. It looks like there aren't any more questions right now, so I'll turn things back over to Marcel Münch for some closing remarks.
Marcel Münch
executiveThanks, Thomas, for the answers and comments. I'll assume that the thorough presentation and Thomas's earlier remarks have addressed most of the questions that might have come up. So, thank you all for making the time to join today's call. We look forward to welcoming you again when we present our figures for fiscal year 2023 on our next conference call, which takes place on March 27, 2024. We now wish you all the best in the run-up to year-end and look forward to seeing and hearing from you again in next year's conference calls. Until then, all the best, and goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.