EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 27, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Marcel Münch
executiveGood afternoon, everyone. Thank you for being with us on today's conference call, where we'll cover our results for fiscal year 2023 as well as our outlook for 2024 and beyond. It's a pleasure to welcome our new CEO, Georg Stamatelopoulos, along with our Deputy CEO and CFO, Thomas Kusterer, who will take you through our presentation before we begin the Q&A session. <<operator_script>> With that, I'll hand the call over to Georg.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveThank you so much, Marcel. Good afternoon as well from where I am, and a warm welcome to each of you. As Marcel noted earlier, I stepped into the CEO position at EnBW a short time ago — I truly feel it is a privilege to have been selected for this job, and I care deeply about the work and the mission of our company. I have now spent nearly 15 years at EnBW, and I take pride in how well we have managed the group's transformation up to this point. In my new role, I want to keep pushing this forward with all my energy, drawing on what I have learned in the energy sector. All of this is aimed at shaping our company's future alongside a highly dedicated and seasoned EnBW team. Naturally, I look forward to our discussion today, where we will examine last year's results and share our expectations for the year ahead. In a market that keeps shifting and is always changing, I am pleased to tell you that EnBW has delivered yet another year of robust growth. Our operating performance was outstanding, landing at the top of the earnings guidance range that we raised in October. Beyond that, we achieved solid advances on key elements of our strategy as well as our ESG targets.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveWe’re keeping up our strong momentum in pushing the energy transition forward — growing renewables and grids, and constructing dispatchable power plants that are hydrogen-ready and much needed. I’d like to use this moment to thank all of our teams for the outstanding work they’ve done carrying out our strategy and meeting our targets. Those financial results mirror the dedication and commitment they keep showing. Let’s turn now to Page 4 of the slide deck. For EnBW, 2023 was a very good year, and here are a few headline numbers. Adjusted EBITDA rose 60% to EUR 6.4 billion, which helped lift adjusted net profit to EUR 2.8 billion. Higher earnings, chiefly from power generation, plus the absence of negative one-offs that hit our business in 2022 because of the war in Ukraine, were the main drivers of that year-on-year improvement. 2023 was also an exceptional year for investments, which came in at almost EUR 5 billion. To move the energy transition ahead in Germany, we invested mainly in grids and renewables. At the same time, during 2023 we succeeded in bringing long-term first-class co-investors on board for some of our most important projects. Ladies and gentlemen, let’s go to the next slide.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveNow let me go into more detail about how we're making progress in pushing the energy transition forward. In this area, we place significant emphasis on a well-balanced portfolio with a clear route to climate neutrality. Consistent with our integrated setup across the whole energy value chain, we successfully expanded our renewables portfolio by commissioning solar parks and wind farms in Germany and in France. Installed renewable energy capacity grew by a further 300 megawatts, reaching 5.7 gigawatts. On top of that, our electricity distribution and transmission grids now extend to an overall length of 148,000 kilometers. We also reinforced our leading position in the e-mobility business as the operator of Germany's largest fast-charging network, with more than 1,100 fast-charging locations throughout the country. In addition, EnBW's HyperNetz now gives our customers seamless access to over 600,000 charging points across 17 countries. As Slide 6 shows, we are delivering on our decarbonization pathway toward phasing out coal in 2028, 10 years ahead of the current legal deadline in Germany, and toward achieving climate neutrality by 2035. Let me start with the share of renewables in 2023. As I already noted, our renewables portfolio grew to 5.7 gigawatts. As a result, the renewable share of EnBW's installed capacity climbed to 47%, and in generation to 48%, respectively.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveIncreased output from wind and solar, greater hydropower generation, and reduced use of our coal-fired plants all helped cut our own CO2 emissions by 37% versus 2022. Our transformation journey has been recognized by the science-based targets initiative, which confirmed it 1 year ago. We are well on track, and we will be climate neutral by 2035 where our own carbon emissions are concerned. Rest assured, we are working hard on every relevant sustainability topic. This was noted at the start of 2024, when CDP lifted our climate rating from B to A-, meaning we have climbed into the leadership tier. As Slide 7 shows, our lighthouse projects clearly support our ambition to push the energy transition forward. Let me give you a quick update on where these major projects stand — all of them are now under construction. In our grid business, construction of SuedLink has begun, and our aim is to have CODe in 2028. The 700-kilometer underground high-voltage transmission line is the biggest energy transition project to date and will in time run right across Germany. In our offshore business, we made further headway with He Dreiht, our 960-megawatt offshore wind project in the German North Sea.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveWe've started manufacturing every component, and we expect installation offshore to begin in May this year. Roughly 50% of the capacity of He Dreiht — which ranks among the biggest offshore wind farms built without subsidies — is already locked in through long-term PPAs. He Dreiht should be commissioned by the end of 2025, and it will immediately double EnBW's offshore portfolio to nearly 2 gigawatts. Lastly, construction is underway on our 3 flexible low-carbon fuel-switch projects in Baden-Württemberg. These new combined cycle gas turbines, with 1.5 gigawatts of total capacity, replace coal-based generation, are set to enter operation in 2026, and will help balance supply against demand, thus adding to supply security in Southwest Germany. Every one of them satisfies the European Union taxonomy criteria for hydrogen-ready gas-fired plants, and from the middle of the 2030s onward they're expected to run on green hydrogen. With that, we'll hand things over to Thomas, who will give you deeper insight into the 2023 numbers and then the outlook for 2024.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks a lot, Georg — and actually, good afternoon from my end as well. As Georg mentioned a moment ago, EnBW delivered very strong financial results in 2023, with robust earnings that came in at the upgraded guidance we had issued. Group adjusted EBITDA came to EUR 6.4 billion, which is 60% higher than the prior year. That leaves us well placed to handle bigger investments in the energy transition successfully over the years ahead. We'll pursue this independently, and also alongside partners. During 2023, we brought on board long-term Tier 1 partners — KfW and a consortium led by saving banks — for minority stakes amounting to 49.9% in our TSO TransnetBW, plus the consortium of Allianz Capital Partners, AIP and Norges Bank for 49.9% in our offshore wind project He Dreiht. We also successfully issued green bonds that meet the requirements of high-quality and strong ESG investors, in order to finance our growth. All in all, EnBW has a rock-solid financing structure and a strong balance sheet, with high credit ratings underpinned by our integrated setup and strong financial performance. Looking ahead to 2024, we expect to deliver robust earnings as well. That said, earnings will come in below 2023 because of falling energy prices and a normalized market environment.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveEven so, our stable earnings outlook lets us keep putting money into climate-friendly energy supply and infrastructure. Let’s now go through the details, beginning on Page 10. In October, we raised our 2023 guidance for adjusted EBITDA at group level from EUR 4.7 million to EUR 5.2 billion to a range of EUR 5.9 billion to EUR 6.5 billion. The EUR 6.4 billion for the group, adjusted EBITDA ended up at the top end of the adjusted forecast range and well above both the original forecast and the prior year. This was driven mainly by favorable trends in our segment, sustainable generation infrastructure. One metric that matters a great deal to us is the earnings contribution from regulated or quasi-regulated low-risk activities. Those take in our grids as well as renewal business and represent EUR 2.8 billion in adjusted EBITDA in 2023, a strong rise of some 31% versus 2022. Although the earnings share came to 45% in 2023 thanks to very strong results in Thermal Generation and Trading, we expect it to climb back to a level above 70% from 2024 onwards. Let’s now look at our business segments, starting on Slide 11 with sustainable generation infrastructure, where we delivered an adjusted EBITDA of EUR 4.6 billion.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveTurning to renewables, adjusted EBITDA there was unchanged year over year at EUR 1.1 billion. Gains from Heilbronn plants and approximately 300 megawatts of added wind and solar capacity were canceled out by weaker realized power prices from wind and solar. The big force behind the segment's substantial earnings growth was Thermal Generation and Trading, which posted adjusted EBITDA of EUR 3.6 billion, driven chiefly by better margins on selling output from our power plants and by the absence, unlike 2022, of negative one-offs tied to curtailment and termination of gas supplies from Russia. Going forward, I want to stress that our conservative hedging approach remains unchanged. So at the close of 2023, we stood at nearly 100% hedged for 2024, 60% to 90% for 2025, and 20% to 50% for 2026. Within System Critical Infrastructure, adjusted EBITDA rose 68% to EUR 1.8 billion, supported by greater grid revenues. To be more precise, that reflected larger investments in grid expansion and the inclusion of elevated grid reserve costs, among them redispatch, to preserve supply security in 2023 grid charges.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveDifferent from the prior year, when those costs weren't completely included in the corresponding grid charges. Our third segment, Smart Infrastructure for Customers, posted adjusted EBITDA of roughly EUR 240 million, which came in significantly below the year-earlier level due to 2 one-off effects. The first was the deconsolidation of a gas supply subsidiary plus associated write-downs on receivables, and the second concerned incidents at a handful of solar home storage units at our subsidiary, SENEC. Older storage systems that could be affected by such incidents are going to be replaced starting in summer 2024. Setting these one-offs aside, underlying performance was solid, especially from the B2B business at our subsidiaries. Ladies and gentlemen, let's turn to the next slide. Gross investments came to EUR 4.9 billion in 2023. That was 56% higher than the prior year's figure and considerably above any single year in EnBW's history. Roughly 1/3 of our gross investments went into the segment Sustainable Generation Infrastructure. This mostly covers investments in our offshore wind farm He Dreiht and our 3 hydrogen-ready fuel switch projects. More than half of our gross investments were made in the segment system critical infrastructure. As in earlier years, the emphasis was on expanding and modernizing our electricity transmission and distribution grids.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThe rest of the investments were allocated to our segment, Smart Infrastructure for Customers, primarily toward expanding our high-speed charging infrastructure further. Overall, 87% of the CapEx we expanded was taxonomy-aligned, and that represented a rise of 4 percentage points more relative to the prior year. At EUR 2.2 billion, divestments during 2023 came in significantly above the level of the earlier year. This stems in particular from reducing minority stakes and from bringing financial partners on board for TransnetBW and He Dreiht, as I already mentioned. Those partners will also share forthcoming investments with us jointly. Consequently, net investment for 2023 came to EUR 2.7 billion. Now that I've covered our investments, let's turn to funding activities. A well-balanced portfolio of debt financing instruments gives us flexibility to target various markets and investor groups at the most opportune moment, which lets us secure highly favorable financing conditions. Over the past year, we made further progress in diversifying our financing instruments and raised the equivalent of roughly EUR 1.7 billion in the euro and Swiss franc markets, along with EUR 1.5 billion through green bonds at the end of last year. In addition, we issued a further EUR 500 million in green hybrid format at the start of 2024.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThis shows how strongly we are positioned in the Eurobond and Swiss market. Looking forward, we anticipate average annual long-term funding needs in the capital markets of EUR 2.5 billion to EUR 3 billion, refinancing included. Sustainable finance forms an integral part of the strategy for growing our corporation. As of today, we have issued green bonds totaling EUR 5.5 billion, meaning that half of all bonds we have outstanding are classified as green. In the future, the proportion of our sustainable financing instruments will keep rising, in line with our inherently sustainable investments. Now let's look at retained cash flow, which came to EUR 4.8 billion in 2023. That significantly surpassed the prior year. Higher cash relevant operating earnings mainly drove the increase, and higher taxes and dividends declared partially offset it. As Slide 18 illustrates, net debt rose slightly in 2023, by about EUR 900 million, reaching a level of EUR 11.7 billion at year-end. Against a very strong retained cash flow. We had net investments of EUR 2.7 billion, as I mentioned a few minutes ago, and we recorded a rise in adjusted working capital of roughly EUR 2.3 billion, mainly driven by a lower positive margin balance.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn top of that, the pension discount rate went down from 3.7% to 3.15%, and that drove pension provisions up by roughly EUR 500 million. That gives us a debt repayment potential of 41% in 2023, well above our long-term target of more than 15%. Given the strong earnings and our positive outlook, we're proposing to raise the dividend for 2023 to EUR 1.50 per share. If the AGM approves it, that's a 36% increase versus the prior year and works out to a payout ratio of some 15% of adjusted group net profit. Over the long run, though, we still aim to pay out no more than between 40% and 60% of adjusted group net profit. The moderate payout ratio for 2023 strengthens our balance sheet and means a larger profit share is available to finance future investments. That takes me to Page 19 and our outlook for 2024. Let's begin with the business segments. In Renewables, as part of Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, we'll benefit from new capacity additions in wind and solar and from the reclassification of all pump storage power plants to renewables in line with the categorization under the EU taxonomy.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThermal Generation and Trading, which is also part of Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, should deliver a very strong performance in 2024. Earnings, though, are going to come in below 2023 because realized power prices will be lower. For System Critical Infrastructure, earnings will rise year-on-year, driven in particular by the investments we are making. Within Smart Infrastructure for Customers, operating earnings should go up moderately, as we expect a negative effect from 2023 to largely go away. Overall, at group level, adjusted EBITDA is projected to land between EUR 4.6 billion and EUR 5.2 billion. With that, I'll hand it back to Georg for a snapshot of our ambition for 2030.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveThomas, thank you so much. Ladies and gentlemen, our EnBW 2025 strategy gives us a really solid foundation, and we'll keep building on it through 2030. By the close of this decade, we're targeting adjusted EBITDA in the range of EUR 5.5 billion to EUR 6.3 billion. With at least 70% of that adjusted EBITDA coming from low-risk activities, our portfolio will stay balanced across all 3 of our segments. Moving to a climate-friendly, decarbonized energy world calls for substantial investment. Between 2024 and 2030, our gross investments will total EUR 40 billion. Let me assure you that expanding grid infrastructure for electricity and gas, hydrogen included, growing renewables, and developing low-carbon dispatchable generation will still account for by far the biggest portion of what we invest in the years ahead. Through this investment, EnBW will push the energy transition further forward. In doing so, we intend for more than 85% of our CapEx to meet the strict sustainability criteria of the European Union taxonomy, meaning it is taxonomy aligned. A meaningful share of our investments will be financed by bringing partners on board for selected projects and activities. As a result, we expect net investments of roughly EUR 22 billion through 2030.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveWith that in mind, it's worth pointing out that we've already locked in nearly 50% of the cash inflows we expect, particularly from our partners on the He Dreiht offshore wind project and at TransnetBW. Through 2030, net investments will be funded mostly out of retained cash flow. Ladies and gentlemen, one last point we want to raise, because it's vital to making the energy transition succeed. Big projects come with big investments, and that means we and our partners require a stable framework and environment. And by stability, I mean going beyond a single legislative period. The energy transition has to be planned and carried out across a timeframe much longer than that. At EnBW, we welcome the first key points of the German power plant strategy having been published. It's very encouraging that the German government has settled on a system-friendly expansion, which is necessary on top of growing renewable energies. Further clarity is now needed. The same holds for hydrogen and for a clear framework so the hydrogen market can be ramped up successfully in the near future. At the same time, renewables and the grid must be expanded at high speed.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveWith that, I'd like to turn it over to Marcel.
Marcel Münch
executiveYes. Thank you, Georg and Thomas. Ladies and gentlemen, we'll begin the Q&A portion now. <<operator_script>> As I mentioned, we want to allow you a few additional seconds to register and add your names for Q&A, so please bear with us briefly. We can see Andrew on the list — Andrew Moulder. Andrew, if you'd like to go ahead and ask your questions, please do.
Andrew Moulder
analystMarcel, are you able to hear me?
Marcel Münch
executiveYes, you can. We hear you loud and clear, Andrew.
Andrew Moulder
analystAll right. I've got a few questions here, and I suppose the first concerns gross versus net investment. EnBW is an important company, sure, but it isn't a huge one. So when I look at EUR 18 billion of potential partnerships and divestments across that stretch of time, that strikes me as a very ambitious target. Could you give us a bit more color on precisely how you plan to achieve it? I believe you said some of this has already been done with He Dreiht. So what portion is already complete? A little more clarity there would help, please. On top of that, EnBW carries a fairly significant amount of minorities, something the rating agencies have flagged before. My concern is that entering into so many new partnership arrangements will push those minorities even higher and could place pressure on your ratings. So some additional reassurance on that point would be welcome. And perhaps my last question, which you probably won't answer, but I'll ask it regardless. Andreas Schell — the press release was rather cryptic, stating that the main reason for his departure was a difference in strategic ambitions for the group, and so forth.
Andrew Moulder
analystTo me, EnBW's strategy looks pretty reasonable, but I'm just curious—what did he intend to do differently that you aren't doing? That's all from me.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, good to hear you. Let me begin with your third question. And truly, I think we'd rather not get into too much depth about why Andreas Schell is departing the company. I think all the statements were made in the press release, and in any case that's more a matter for the Supervisory Board than for us. But on your first 2 questions, I'd like to go into a bit more detail. You mentioned the EUR 40 billion gross and the EUR 22 billion net investments. Indeed, with He Dreiht, the 49.9% minority stake we sold, and also TransnetBW above -- a bit above 50%, of this EUR 18 billion difference, are already locked in through these 2 partnerships. So the remainder -- actually, the remainder is EUR 9 billion, and we feel very comfortable that these divestments can be achieved. I mean, 2030 is quite a long way off, first of all, and second, this is our normal business. That's what we've always done. We always bring partners on board, as you know, with our offshore wind parks and now also with our grid expansion. So we're quite confident that we can actually deliver on that.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn the minority stakes question, that's a valid point, and we're examining it. The rating agencies are examining it too. Still, we're quite confident in our ability to hold our ratings around that level — A- to AB+. That range is one we're fairly comfortable with, even as minority shares rise. Does that address what you were asking, Andrew?
Andrew Moulder
analystYes. Yes. No, that does. Perhaps I could just ask one additional question.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAbsolutely, happy to do that.
Andrew Moulder
analystNaturally, I inquired about Andreas, yet I also want to congratulate Georg on stepping into the CEO position. And there's one thing I want to ask him. Before this, he led the Sustainable Generation business. So really, I just want to ask about those hydrogen-ready gas plants. I believe I've raised this point previously, but given his expertise in that area—generation—how realistic is it, honestly, to think hydrogen will ever serve as a fuel source for a power plant.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveLet me respond to that. Right now we’re already putting in 3 hydrogen-ready turbines — 2 close to Stuttgart and 1 in Heilbronn. Those units can operate on 100% hydrogen. We anticipate that second fuel switch — if you’d like to call it that, with the first being coal to gas and the second gas to hydrogen — will come around the middle of the 30s. And we’re quite pleased that the German government didn’t restrict hydrogen to green hydrogen only, but also allows blue and Turkey's hydrogen to be used in these machines. I think we have to keep in mind, when we talk about these power plants, that they will be filling the gaps that renewable generation leaves behind. In Germany we expect 80% coverage from renewables by the year 2030. And already, that remaining 20% translates into only a few operating hours for these plants. And I think that is realistic. Even so, we need this dispatchable capacity. Without it, the system can’t operate. And when you examine the technological options available to us, you arrive at hydrogen or other green gases. Those molecules are necessary in order to make the energy transition happen.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveIt won’t succeed with batteries alone or with pumped-storage hydropower plants by themselves, and I’m highly confident that, ultimately, we’ll also handle the second fuel switch to hydrogen.
Andrew Moulder
analystAll right, let me just ask one quick follow-up, since the technology itself isn't really what worries me — I have no doubt that it can be done. What concerns me more is the economics of actually putting hydrogen to use, meaning where power prices would need to land for generating electricity from hydrogen to make economic sense.
Georgios Stamatelopoulos
executiveYes. But this is precisely what we're currently talking about with the German government regarding the power plant strategy. As you've heard, or probably have heard, the German government intends to bring in a capacity market regime by 2028. We expect that our fuel switch projects will qualify to take part in this market. And there are also some discussions about financing the CapEx of new machines — not the 3 projects we're currently doing, but new machines, to get a subsidy or support from the German government to build the additional power plants that are necessary. And for sure, we also expect that, for the limited amount of hours these plants are going to come into operation, there will be a free price policy to let them, for limited times, earn this amount of money in the market.
Marcel Münch
executiveThanks, Andrew. Sharon Venezio is now with us in the Q&A backlog. So, Sharon, would you like to go ahead and ask your question? I realize you submitted it in writing too, but I'm hoping your camera and mic are both working.
Analyst
analystMarcel, I believe we've got a bit of an echo here, since I'm still able to pick up remarks from the earlier question carrying on.
Marcel Münch
executiveAll right. You’re coming through loud and clear, so...
Analyst
analystLet me go ahead and cover that. I have a few questions here. I believe you mentioned having charging points in 17 countries. Assuming I heard correctly, could you explain the reasoning behind such broad coverage rather than concentrating on regions where you have an integrated presence across everything? My second question concerns transmission and distribution, plus electricity and gas assets. Could you give me a sense of how the asset split breaks down relative to your fixed assets, or perhaps a regulatory asset base? I'd simply like to understand what those relative proportions look like, please?
Marcel Münch
executiveSharon, I’m not sure we quite got your second question — the one about the grids, I think. Were you asking for the regulated asset-based number?
Analyst
analystI realize I can't give you the exact figure, since I've attempted this before and never managed to obtain it. Still, if you could provide it purely as percentages, roughly across your grids — how much is electricity transmission, how much is gas, how much is distribution, and what does distribution look like, including gas distribution? Even a percentage would be extremely useful.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSharon has it clear now. I don't actually have those figures on hand at the moment, but we'll get you the numbers on how our regulated business splits, as you just referenced. On your first question, the 17 countries don't actually mean we're putting up our own charging infrastructure across 17 countries. Those are partnerships that let our customers use our EnBW charging system to charge in 17 countries, and I believe that's 600,000 charging points in total. So when it comes to our own charging infrastructure, our focus is very clearly on Germany here, and Austria.
Marcel Münch
executiveAre there any further questions? I'll wait just another second or 2 to see whether anyone else still registers. It appears that isn't the case. So again, Georg and Thomas, thank you for your answers and comments, and thanks to everyone on the line for taking the time. We very much look forward to welcoming you again when we present our results for the first 3 months 2024 on our next conference call on May 14. Until then, all the best, and goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.