Endeavour Silver Corp. (EDR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 2, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorThank you for holding. I'm the conference operator, and I'd like to welcome everyone to the Endeavour Silver Corp. call covering financial results for full year 2022. <<operator_script>> Please note that this conference is being recorded. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll hand things over to Galina Meleger, Vice President of Investor Relations. Please go ahead. Please go ahead.
Galina Meleger
executiveThanks, operator, and hello everyone. Before we begin, I'd like you to review the cautionary language in our MD&A concerning forward-looking statements, along with the risk factors related to those statements. Both our MD&A and financial statements can be found on our website at edrsilver.com. Joining us today are Dan Dickson, CEO of Endeavour Silver; Christine West, our Chief Financial Officer; and Don Gray, Endeavour's COO. After Dan's prepared remarks, we'll open the line for questions. Dan, over to you.
Dan Dickson
executiveThanks, Galina, and hello everyone. I'll try to keep today's call short since all the details came out in today's news release, but I want to be sure I cover some key points for our investors. Endeavour Silver delivered a solid 2022 against what you could call a tough cost backdrop. Output came in above guidance, and that helped ease the upward pressure on costs. Inflationary pressure hit every kind of input across the whole mining sector, and we felt it just the same. We kept derisking Terronera and moving it forward. Ideally, a financial package would be finished by now. However, factors beyond our control have pushed that into this year. I'm confident we'll have clarity on this matter shortly. We remain excited about the Pitarrilla project acquisition, which both strengthens our position in Mexico and advances our strategy of delivering industry-leading. On a consolidated basis, we produced 9 million ounces of silver equivalent metal, with silver and gold output each beating the top end of guidance by 17% and 4%, respectively. That marks the second consecutive year we've significantly surpassed production guidance. Guanaceví was a star performer once again, contributing more than 70% of consolidated production, with silver and gold grades well ahead of plan.
Dan Dickson
executiveIn fact, at Guanaceví we saw record throughput grades — they averaged 512 grams per tonne of silver and 1.44 grams per tonne of gold — and in Q4 the plant's average throughput came close to 1,300 tonnes per day. On the whole, the mill did well, with recoveries averaging a touch under 86% for silver and a bit below 90% for gold, which shows consistency and stability at the somewhat higher throughput. Performance at our operating mine Bolañitos is holding steady. Silver output went up, offset by a decline in gold production. We keep looking at ways to extend mine life at Bolañitos and we are mindful of Bolañitos in the current landscape. The operating team has done a good job hitting their targets. Our strong operating performance made for robust financial results, especially in Q4: as gold and solar prices strengthened, we were able to capitalize on the higher prices by selling most of the silver inventory. As a result, revenue climbed 27%, a 10-year best, driven mostly by volume. The higher revenue fed through to increased cash flow, with mine operating earnings of $51.5 million, up 42% from 2021. Operating cash flow before working capital changes came to $54 million, again up 68% compared to 2021. And at the site level specifically, Guanaceví delivered mine free cash flow before taxes of $30 million, while Bolañitos contributed just over $1 million.
Dan Dickson
executiveFor the year, our earnings came in at $6.2 million, or $0.03 per share. I'm especially happy that we managed to deliver operating costs per ounce that are fairly consistent with guidance, even with inflationary pressures affecting the whole industry. We closed out the year with cash costs of $10.65 per ounce, roughly 7% above our guidance, and all-in sustaining costs of $19.97 per ounce, which sits below the low end of guidance at $20 per ounce. That said, inflation across the industry has been challenging and remains so. Our direct cost per ton rose 16% versus the prior year, as we experienced cost increases across many of our key inputs. Luckily, higher grades at Guanaceví offset those direct cost increases, but cost control will remain a key focus for the company as we move forward. Our financial performance produced a strong balance sheet at year-end. We held cash on hand of $84 million, with no long-term debt other than normal course equipment leases. Working capital came to roughly $94 million, including unsold volume carried at cost of $6 million that has a market value of $50 million. Over the past year, we were extremely busy and productive at Terronera, getting the site ready for full-scale construction.
Dan Dickson
executiveWe used $41 million of our own existing cash for initial development, and we're still working to confirm a viable debt package. Over the year, the product team notched up a number of accomplishments. The complete mobile mining fleet, made up of 30 units, is now on site. Every piece of major plant equipment has been preordered, and most of it is due to arrive during the first half of 2023. Road access upgrades spanning 7 kilometers are well along. That work is going to boost slope stabilization and drainage, and it will also improve transportation access. We started building the permanent camp, we started excavating the plant site, and we started first portal access. We're optimistic and excited to give the market full details of the financing package before long and to announce a formal construction decision. The Board has approved a further $26 million in development expenditures for Q1 2023 as we keep moving the project forward. At the start of 2022, we began putting our 3-year sustainability strategy into action, and it rests on 3 pillars: people, planet and business. We launched or expanded numerous initiatives to further embed sustainable practices throughout our organization and to create real value for our stakeholders.
Dan Dickson
executiveWe carried out a number of measures aimed at boosting employee development, engagement and inclusion, and the results across the company have been positive. Beyond that, we expanded our community investments in Mexico, in line with our priority areas of education and employability. During the past year, we put substantial time and effort into the whole organization to gain a clearer picture of the possible risks and opportunities tied to climate change. Those are covered in our inaugural climate disclosure report, which comes out next week and follows the TCFD framework. It is still early days when it comes to integrating climate initiatives, but we are striving to be thoughtful and diligent as we work out the most effective steps for us while our understanding grows of how climate change initiatives affect our company. Above all, our perspective on climate change is not focused on risk alone. Great opportunities also lie ahead of us. The world is starting to appreciate how important metals are for supporting the shift to a low-carbon economy. The products we supply sit at the very start of the supply chain for essentially everything that modern society needs and uses. I'd encourage you to read our climate report once it is published next week. As for 2023, our production outlook remains strong, with another year of robust grades from Guanaceví.
Dan Dickson
executiveOur production target is 8.6 million to 9.5 million ounces of silver equivalent, and the midpoint would represent a fourth straight year of output growth. With greater consolidated throughput plus the ounces we produce, we project unit costs of $10 to $11 per ounce for cash costs and $19 to $20 per ounce for all-in sustaining costs, comparable to 2022. At Guanaceví and Bolañitos, we intend to put more than $35 million into sustaining capital so we can optimize performance and get the most out of output. Naturally, everyone is aware that this company was built through the drill bit, and for 2023 we are looking to invest $10 million in exploration, with the biggest share, $3 million, going to Pitarrilla, while Parral carries a $1.5 million budget. I want to stress how enthusiastic we are about the idea of creating value through exploration and moving both Pitarrilla and Parral forward. Each is expected to progress through economic studies in early 2023. For us, Pitarrilla's scale and impact will matter a great deal. In December, we confirmed an indicated resource of almost 600 million ounces of silver, along with substantial amounts of lead and zinc. This year, we intend to extend a historical ramp to gain a better understanding of the feeder structures we identified in the deposit.
Dan Dickson
executiveAs exploration keeps delivering positive results, our eventual aim is to find a business case for modeling an underground operation at Pitarrilla. To wrap up, the year ahead will be another busy one. I'm quite enthusiastic about what lies ahead as we keep working our growth pipeline, especially now that silver demand is starting to gain strength. That, I believe, concludes my prepared remarks for today. We'll now take questions from the lines. Operator?
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Heiko Ihle of H.C. Wainwright.
Marcus Giannini
analystHello, everyone. Marcus Giannini here, calling in on Heiko's behalf. You mentioned — right — you mentioned that controlling costs is a major priority for this year, especially business improvements. Since we're in March now, could you give us some detail on precisely where you anticipate efficiencies and what portion of that has already been folded in year-to-date? And perhaps, if you could briefly mention any cost improvements you've already observed, that would be great.
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. I mean, that's a tough one to answer, since last year we experienced rising costs everywhere. I mean, cyanide and power were major factors at Guanaceví’s steel operations, and at Bolañitos with TCs and RCs, power costs too. For us, it really boils down to ensuring that daily, weekly, and monthly, we are going over our cost reports, going over the inputs coming in, especially at Guanaceví. At Guanaceví, we have substantial pumping that takes place, which effectively uses and costs a lot of power and money. We’ve observed a slight reduction in kilowatt-hour costs at Guanaceví and Bolañitos. As for real improvements, we believe we perform quite well at Bolañitos; it’s at Guanaceví where we can do better with waste management, handling our waste, handling the tonnes, being more efficient from a productivity standpoint and moving tonnes. I’m not sure whether we’ve seen that materialize yet as of March 1, 2023. It’s something that will take time over the year. And there aren’t large cuts available. The inputs we require, or the inputs we require, the inflationary pressures on those have persisted.
Dan Dickson
executiveThat slowdown showed up in Q4, and our hope is it carries on through 2023. Still, as management, it falls to us to keep watching it closely, and we'll keep trimming expenses wherever possible.
Marcus Giannini
analystAlright. Great. Yeah. Clearly, there are plenty of moving pieces in that. Now turning to Terronera. You have more than $80 million in cash on hand and working capital of just under $94 million. If it meant reducing a capital raise and completing construction at Terronera, how low would you be prepared to let your balance sheet go?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. I mean, I think the crucial element there is that we're seeking a debt financing package, and that package would fall somewhere in the range of $100 million to $120 million. The initial feasibility study for Terronera comes in at $175 million. We understand that once we do secure that debt package, we'll probably provide the market with an update on where those capital costs stand. But to address your question, ultimately what we'd like to see, and what we more or less have available just for the 2 operating assets, is a cushion of somewhere between $30 million and $40 million. I think we can reach that point if we get that debt in place.
Marcus Giannini
analystAll right, great. Yes, just a final quick question. Given that you took on $3 million in smelting and refining costs, do you have any view on how those costs will trend in 2023? My assumption is that the prices are fixed ahead of time by contract?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. We renew those concentrated contracts, the offtake agreements, on an annualized basis. I think the key piece there is the relatively similar, a little bit lower for Bolañitos. The key piece of all that, when it comes down to it, is the energy cost at refineries. And as those kind of oscillate, it does impact us. I think for the year, we have, like I say, it's about similar to a little bit lower at Bolañitos. Of course, Guanaceví <<inaudible>>.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Jake Sekelsky at Alliance Global Partners.
Jacob Sekelsky
analystDan, you mentioned pushing Pitarrilla and Parral toward the economic study phase. Do you have any sense of what the timeline looks like for those two?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. I mean, some of that visibility is also tied to where we're exploring. So at Pitarrilla, we've got a plan for 5,000 meters. And really, those drill meters will take place once the ramp extensions are finished, which we expect to be done midyear, so the beginning of Q3, and then we'll drill. Ultimately, for Pitarrilla, the studies would happen in 2024, simply given the scale and scope of Pitarrilla. For Parral, we'd actually had a plan in place to begin economic studies in 2022, just -- but with the acquisition of Pitarrilla that pushed it back a bit. This year, we're drilling close to 3,000 meters at Parral, and that drilling has met our expectation as we move towards economic studies at Parral. So start that -- those studies at the end of the year, possibly with publishing early 2024.
Jacob Sekelsky
analystAll right, that helps. Now, regarding how you handle inventory during this year—clearly, you did well capitalizing on elevated silver prices during last year's fourth quarter. Silver prices have declined in the current quarter. Should we expect a comparable strategy from you specifically when it comes to managing inventory?
Dan Dickson
executiveYeah, that's probably a fair way to frame it. As we move into the Terronera build, our flexibility narrows somewhat, and a lot depends on the state of our balance sheet. Earlier in the year we completed some sales when we reached the 24 on solar. But as you noted, we've since come down to the 20 handle. We'll see what March brings. Our balance sheet is clearly in very good shape, so we do have that flexibility for roughly the first 6 months. Then, as the year progresses, we'll determine how we proceed.
Operator
operatorCraig Hutchison of TD Securities has the next question.
Craig Hutchison
analystOne — just a question about Terronera. So once that financing package is secured, based on the work you've already completed and the commitment to spend here in Q1, what's the timeline to first production? How long will the construction period last?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. In the end, within that feasibility study, the construction or production timeline runs 2 years. Our aim, by being able to move it forward, remains commissioning by the end of 2024. So effectively a full year of production in 2025. But hopefully, should everything go well — knock on wood — we could obviously have first pour in the back half of 2024, perhaps commercial production at the end of 2024.
Craig Hutchison
analystAll right, thanks. Do you have anything more specific on when the revised permits might come through — any detail at all on that front?
Dan Dickson
executiveNo. As every one of our listeners and investors is aware, Terronera holds all of its permits, thanks to our permitting team. And with the feasibility study, we possess the approvals needed to begin construction, and obviously we've moved a great many things forward. There are amended permits that give us operational flexibility, so we don't really require those permits in order to build. But across the 12-year mine life, we're after various kinds of flexibility, one of them being a staging area that we want to move out 300 meters. We've submitted a great deal of the material. In fact, we still have some items left to submit. We've genuinely enjoyed strong communication with the permitting departments and the various authorities, since there's a number we have to work through — SEMARNAT, CONAGUA. And everything has been progressing, and over the last, I'd say, 3 months, we've received approval for smaller permits. So all of that continues, and I'll repeat that we hold every permit needed to start construction and ultimately reach operations. It's simply a matter of amending permits for operational flexibility.
Craig Hutchison
analystDo those permits count as amendments? And does that factor into the due diligence the financing groups are carrying out?
Dan Dickson
executiveYeah. They sure are.
Craig Hutchison
analystOkay, and about Guanaceví — regarding those royalties, which are clearly pretty elevated in Q4 — should we expect roughly similar dollar amounts in royalties for the rest of this year, given that you're sort of back in those same areas at Porvenir and so on?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes, I’d like to be a bit cautious about that. In Q4, royalties are elevated specifically on what we sold during the quarter. So in absolute terms, we sold more than 1 million ounces of silver. And under the contract, royalties would be recognized when the sale occurs. So as we stand now, with silver at $20 — between $20 and $25 silver — we pay a 13% royalty. And the timing of that doesn’t necessarily match up with when it’s produced versus when it’s sold. So Q4 carries an elevated royalty, but on an annualized basis, we’re producing a similar amount from that area, which we call El Curso, and that area is subject to the slightly scaled royalty with Frisco.
Craig Hutchison
analystAnd let me squeeze in one final question. Regarding Bolañitos, how confident are you about the reserve extensions — enough to sustain a comparable mining rate there next year?
Dan Dickson
executiveWhen you look beyond 2024?
Craig Hutchison
analystYes. Just to give us a sense of how much longer you expect the reserve life to be extended here?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. We possess assets capable of being turned into reserves. I mean, obviously at present Bolañitos is basically running at breakeven. And there are several reasons for keeping a mine going at breakeven. First of all, clearly, the optionality that Bolañitos and that output provide. Second, proportional distribution of our costs. Third, we have skilled people there who, if Bolañitos ever stops operating someday, we want to be sure we can retain and shift over to Terronera, which would be coming in. But we do anticipate, and are confident, that Bolañitos' life can be extended. We're reaching the stage where we're hitting concession limits. So it's not 3 years or 2 years we're discovering, it's 3 months or 6 months at a time. Our exploration team keeps having some success. We simply have more work to do on that exploration. So confidence level? I am confident. I wouldn't claim I'm leaping with delight, and I'm not compressed, so somewhere between those two. Never did we have a reserve life beyond 2 years at Bolañitos across the last 16 years. And I can tell you our exploration team has performed very well there.
Dan Dickson
executiveWe’re surrounded by plenty of concessions that still hold substantial opportunities, and we simply need to work our way through them.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Mark Reichman at NOBLE Capital Markets.
Mark Reichman
analystI have just a few questions. You've already provided your 2023 guidance, and from a production perspective it appears fairly flat versus 2022. So my sense is that grade and price are going to be the major factors. When you consider next year and whether it winds up below or above 2022, what would you identify as the main variables for bringing that cost down? You've already given your guidance on cash cost and all-in sustaining costs. But if you proceed with this financing package and interest rates have risen, then you would incur the extra interest expense. Still, which variables do you believe could make 2023 a stronger year?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes, certainly. We published the 8.6 to 9.5 range. And for us, I think whether we can beat that plan or land at the top end of it really depends on our operating team at Guanaceví and, when you get right down to it, our operating team at Bolañitos as well. The El Curso <<inaudible>> area of Guanaceví. I'm not sure whether we'll top the grades we achieved in 2022. But I think there's a chance to remain somewhat above those grades, or right at them. I think we're in a really good position. We did a great deal of development in 2022, and that will bring us some efficiencies this year. But ultimately, the reason we issued our 2023 guidance is that we expect that's where we'll land. I'd point to 2021 and 2022 — we raised guidance 2 years running, and in fact we came in above that raised guidance. But we'll see how this year plays out.
Mark Reichman
analystOkay, so I believe Terronera is on a lot of people's radar. You mentioned production — a construction decision within the next few months. When you look at — when you discuss the financing package, what do you see — what is the main thing holding it up? The largest obstacle to get past? Is it securing a rate that works? Or is it those permitting matters? What do you figure would be the key step forward in getting that financing package locked in? And how early in the year do you expect you'd be taking on additional debt?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. I mean, when you boil it down, this is a financing project. The crucial part of project loan financing is ESG, and ultimately bringing commercial banks—some major banks—on board from an ESG perspective. What that requires is an Equator Principles and ESOP report. That covers more than a hundred different specific reports. Over the past year we've spent time documenting a great deal of that and establishing processes and procedures to satisfy those Equator Principles. So terms aren't the issue. We know what those terms would be. The issue is the timeline for getting through that due diligence and project loan financing. A bank will typically bring in an external engineering firm to handle that due diligence and write reports and effectively take apart our feasibility study or our plans. All of that has happened and has been completed. As I say, I won't necessarily get into what happened this past year at this point, but there were things outside our control, yet it has been progressing. Our team has actually done a really good job on it. As I said at the outset, I expect clarity in relatively short order on that.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our following question is from Lucas Pipes of B. Riley Securities.
Lucas Pipes
analystDan, I'd like to circle back on Terronera as well. My understanding is that the 2021 feasibility study indicated CapEx of $175 million. Clearly, the situation has shifted considerably since 2021, unfortunately. You did note that some offsets to inflation might exist, but speaking roughly, should we be thinking around $200 million? Is that <<inaudible>> the appropriate ballpark? Or do you believe you can hold it under that figure?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. Lucas, honestly, that's a completely valid question. Two short responses to <<inaudible>> are in the correct range, though I can perhaps provide a bit more specifics on that. In the end, we finished that report in March 2021. And I believe it carries a July 2021 date. We released it and ultimately submitted it in September 2021. I think our engineering group and our development group, together with the outside engineers, did a solid job of capturing some of those inflationary pressures that began emerging in 2021. But naturally, no one gets that exactly right. And I mention that because our mobile fleet sits fully on site with 30 units. When you stack what we paid against what that feasibility study contained, we are precisely on target. The 12 key components we've bought for the plant align fairly closely with what our feasibility study showed. There are shifts, however, and there are items we haven't finalized. And in the end, what we've been examining across the last 1, 1.5 years while we work through this financing package and move Terronera forward is optimization stemming from that feasibility study. So the move from 1,700 tonnes per day to 2,000 tonnes per day has been evaluated and has been examined over time.
Dan Dickson
executiveThat can help counter a portion of the inflation-driven expenses we've encountered, both from a capital perspective and on an operating per-ton basis as well. So we've been favoring a bigger plant and, in the end, greater output from the mine as a way to counter part of that inflationary cost. Once the detailed financing package is finalized, we're going to -- we will inform the market of where we expect the capital to land and what size Terronera will be. It's not significantly different. But as you say, higher throughput will assist in countering some of the inflationary pressures we've seen.
Lucas Pipes
analystThanks, Dan — that's really useful. One of the earlier questions touched on 2024 all-in sustaining costs, and I'd like to follow up and perhaps be a bit more direct. I realize it's early, but from a directional standpoint, should we be expecting all-in sustaining costs to decline in 2024? Or is the current level perhaps the best ballpark figure for the years ahead?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. I mean, ultimately, Lucas, we issued '23 guidance since we’ve got clarity there. When it comes to 2024 all-in sustaining costs, that really hinges on where things stand with Terronera. Guanaceví and Bolañitos are mature assets. We pretty much know how their costs have trended. They stayed quite comparable for roughly 12 years, until these last couple of years, when they’ve risen notably. And as I mentioned, I don’t believe that’s unique to Endeavour Silver. I think it’s what we’ve observed throughout the entire mining sector. We’re attempting not to provide guidance for 2024. I’d always just say that if you look at Guanaceví and Bolañitos, they’d be comparable. We know what we’ve got. We know where we stand. But several factors feed into that, and on an all-in sustaining cost per ounce basis, it’s great that Guanaceví will matter. Naturally, our resource grades are quite close to what we hold in reserves, so that could persist. Yet if Terronera can come online in 2024, and the timing of it starting up in 2024, that will heavily influence our consolidated all-in sustaining costs. I think once we get to next year, we’d likely provide guidance on our current operations.
Dan Dickson
executiveAnd from there, we’ll steer Terronera on its own track, depending on when construction wraps up or when we anticipate it wrapping up. That’s likely the clearest answer I can give you right now regarding next year. We’ll see how we do this year. Hopefully we land in line or perhaps even surpass it. If we manage that, it would be a good sign for 2024.
Operator
operatorThat brings the Q&A portion to an end. Dan Dickson, I'll hand the conference back to you for any closing comments.
Dan Dickson
executiveAppreciate it, operator, and thank you to every investor and listener joining us today. As I mentioned during my prepared remarks, I expect 2023 to be an extremely active year for Endeavour. Naturally, advancing Pitarrilla and Parral matters a great deal to our pipeline. That said, if we're able to reach a formal construction decision on Terronera fairly soon, that should serve as the next catalyst for everyone. Many thanks, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's conference call. You can disconnect your lines at this point. Thanks for joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Endeavour Silver Corp. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Endeavour Silver Corp. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Endeavour Silver Corp. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.