Endeavour Silver Corp. (EDR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 7, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone being on the line. I'm the conference operator speaking. You're joining the Endeavour Silver Corp. call covering financial results for the third quarter of 2023. Just a note that everyone is connected in listen-only mode today. This call is being recorded. Following the presentation, we'll open things up so you can ask questions. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll hand the call over to Galina Meleger, Vice President of Investor Relations. The floor is yours.
Galina Meleger
executiveThanks, operator, and good morning to all of you. Before we begin, I'd ask everyone to review the cautionary language in our MD&A about forward-looking statements, along with the risk factors tied to those statements. Both our MD&A and the financial statements can be found on our website, edrsilver.com. Joining us on today's call are Dan Dickson, CEO of Endeavour Silver; Christine West, our Chief Financial Officer; and Don Gray, Endeavour's COO. After Dan's formal remarks, we'll open the line for questions. Dan, over to you.
Dan Dickson
executiveThanks, Galina, and hello everyone. Let me start off by saying we made our way through a tough third quarter. Not only did we face challenging market conditions that sent the Silver Miners Index down by almost 20%, but our cornerstone mine, Guanaceví, also had a hard operating quarter. Lower throughput, much lower grades, non-routine expenses tied to repairs and maintenance, and increased operating development all led to escalated costs on a per-unit basis in Q3. Macro factors like the ongoing industry-wide inflation pressures and a strong Mexican peso amplified costs even further. Although the headline for this quarter is our elevated costs, we've put corrective measures in place to get Guanaceví back on track and to keep issues from persisting that affect productivity. Naturally, no one likes to go through a lackluster quarter, but it's a chance to learn and improve, and that's exactly what happened for us, as our new VP of Operations is taking steps to sustainably improve Guanaceví's operating performance. I'm happy to report that we're seeing a significant improvement in mine productivity this quarter. Naturally, over the past quarter, we kept advancing the Terronera project. Terronera offers a clear path to margin expansion, repositioning the company to achieve significant free cash flow once the mine is in production.
Dan Dickson
executiveLet's go into more detail on production for this quarter — or rather, for the year. For Q3, consolidated silver equivalent production fell 14% compared with a year earlier, landing at 1.9 million silver equivalent ounces, which takes us to 6.5 million silver equivalent ounces for the year to date. Even though the quarter's numbers keep us on pace to land inside this year's production guidance range, Q4 leaves a bit of room for a setback. At Guanaceví, several factors explain the production shortfall. As you may remember, we talked about starting changes to our mine plan and infrastructure aimed at better working conditions for employees through improved ventilation and better water management. To deal with these conditions, we temporarily altered mine sequencing. What that meant was mining stopes with lower silver and gold grades until we could adequately address the temperatures and the water in blows deeper in our mine. In the end, these issues could have been handled better so that production wasn't affected. At the same time, more sill development during Q3, done to open additional stopes, further affected the quarter's mine outlook. For Guanaceví, the sequencing of sill development will remain a focus so that a stable production schedule is ensured both near term and long term. Although the temporary changes have gone on longer than we expected, conditions have gotten better and mine output has risen.
Dan Dickson
executiveGiven what the mine was experiencing, management saw a good chance to take an extended plant shutdown so we could deal with parts of the plant that needed more time than our usual maintenance shutdowns allow. A significant amount of maintenance gets done across every section of the plant — crushing, grinding, thickeners and the filter press — so that we keep throughput steady down the road and reduce the risk of an unplanned downturn. With plant maintenance wrapped up in early October, the mine and the plant are both running at or above capacity. Those events combined during the third quarter meant quarterly silver and gold production fell by 22% and 13%, respectively. That works out to a shortfall of almost 400,000 ounces of silver versus prior quarters and our annual mine plan. But as I mentioned, we're back on track, and Q4 should meet plan. Our other mine, Bolañitos, held steady. Higher gold output was offset by weaker silver output in Q3. Bolañitos looks like it's still pushing hard to hit or exceed its targets, including mined and processed tons. Our safety programs and results have been excellent at both operations. Now on to our financials.
Dan Dickson
executiveRevenue came in at $49.5 million, and cost of sales was $46.7 million, which gave us operating earnings of $2.7 million along with mine operating cash flow of $10.6 million. Once exploration, G&A and other investment expenses are factored in, we posted a net loss of $2.3 million, or a loss of $0.01 per share. Cost of sales for this quarter rose 35% versus the same period a year earlier. There are several things driving that — a stronger Mexican peso, greater labor, power and consumable costs, and higher royalty costs — but a big part of the Q3 story was low production at Guanaceví, which weighed on costs on a per unit basis. Guanaceví generated $6.7 million in operating cash flow. That said, after capital and exploration expenditures, Guanaceví came in at negative mine free cash flow of $1.3 million. It has been quite a while since Guanaceví failed to post a positive free cash flow quarter. So far this year, Guanaceví has generated $12.2 million of mine free cash flow, and Bolañitos stayed slightly above breakeven. On the operating cost side, pressure has shown up in several areas. Our direct cost per ton climbed 23%. More operating development, together with higher energy costs, increased labor from reshifting the workforce, and higher costs from <<inaudible>> ore, had the biggest impact this quarter.
Dan Dickson
executiveEven though the Mexican peso softened during the back half of Q3, it stayed strong, averaging 17:1 for the third quarter. Recently the peso has turned around, yet it remains 10% higher than what we budgeted for. Once again, every one of these elements results in elevated costs across the board. For the quarter, cash costs came in at $17.95 per ounce and all-in sustaining costs at $29.64 per ounce. Year to date, we've posted a cash cost of $13.08 and all-in sustaining costs of $23.41, and both figures exceed the original guidance we gave in January. As we look toward the remainder of the year, keeping costs in check stays a priority while we strive to boost the efficiency of our operations. We are taking a close look at our purchasing practices to identify where and how improvements can be made. At present, although we anticipate better cost metrics, extra maintenance work tied to the plant shutdown carried on through the first week of Q4, and greater operating development is expected to persist into Q4. In addition, cost pressures stemming from macro factors will persist. That said, management expects Q4 cost metrics to improve, since productivity and production should return to historic levels. As of September 30th, cash on hand stood at $41 million and working capital at $76 million.
Dan Dickson
executiveIn the quarter, we brought in $23 million in gross proceeds via the ATM, and after the quarter closed we raised an additional $17 million allotment so that funding is sufficient for developing Terronera. On October 10th, we signed the $120 million project financing agreement with SocGen and ING Capital to fund Terronera. Under the project loan's requirements, the Company will mainly self-fund development using cash on hand prior to drawing on the facility. Accordingly, the Company anticipates drawing on these funds in 2024. Given the project spend schedule, we anticipate being fully committed on the project capital costs in early Q2 2024. Turning to more detailed information about Terronera's construction: at the close of Q3 we hit 38% completion, and by year-end we expect to be close to passing the halfway mark. Through the end of Q3, we had spent $95 million on direct development. Project commitments came to $160 million, equal to 69% of the $230 million initial CapEx budget. With the $120 million senior secured debt facility executed, we are well positioned to meet the budget's financing requirements. In the quarter, we made notable progress across a number of key areas.
Dan Dickson
executiveWe have finished building our permanent camp, which means our workforce can now be housed in full, and beyond that, work on the process plant has moved ahead considerably, with surface construction having passed 42% completion. Should you wish to view photographs showing how construction is advancing, I would suggest heading to our website on the Terronera page. Allow me to go over a few recent items. Notably, since the rainy season arrived during Q3, our construction safety protocols were adjusted. The emphasis was placed on visibility along with maintaining project growth. It pleases us that the substantial upgrades made over the last year assisted in preserving site roads, which stayed in solid shape and reachable. Consequently, neither equipment access nor material deliveries to the site were impacted while the rainy season was underway. In addition, steps to control visibility were strengthened. Turning to recruitment, our workforce keeps expanding, with on-site personnel and contractors now numbering more than 520. Engineering work overall stands at almost full completion. The bulk of equipment has been acquired at this point, and delivery of every major plant equipment item is set to finish by year-end. In Q3, the request for bid proposals covering the mill construction contract reached near completion, encompassing structural steel, mechanical, piping, electrical and instrumentation. Mine development continues to be our critical path.
Dan Dickson
executiveBy the close of the quarter, more than 1,300 meters had been finished, and advance rates are picking up speed now that Portals 2 and 4 have gone through the fault zone and ground conditions have gotten better. Over the quarter, Portal 1 hit its design elevation, which means mine development events are now at the forefront at Portal 1, 2 and 4 — the incline and decline directions. Earthworks at the plant site, along with concrete work and rebar installation, are in progress. Concrete work and rebar installations are continuing in the SAG and ball mill grinding areas, the coarse ore stockpile and the flotation areas. Concrete work has also begun for the primary crusher, and excavation work has started in the tailings thickener area. And finally, on the community side, we remain focused on supporting the municipality through projects such as upgrades to our roads, our local landfill and communication infrastructure. Looking forward, our main priorities stay the same: moving our mine development forward, keeping concrete work for the mill platform on schedule with electromechanical contractor mobilization in early 2024, which represents the next major phase of construction for Terronera. And beginning excavation on the filtration and LNG power plant areas and the TSL <<inaudible>>. That concludes my formal comments for today. Don Gray, Christine and I are happy to take any questions you may have.
Dan Dickson
executiveOperator, I’ll hand it over to you now for the Q&A.
Operator
operatorOur first question is from Heiko Ihle at H.C. Wainwright.
Heiko Ihle
analystIt's good to see mine operating cash flow before taxes hitting an 8-figure number, even though this quarter was clearly a tough one. Picking up from there, you had a productive shortfall, obviously because of mine sequencing changes needed to concentrate on better access and ventilation. As your release notes, part of that maintenance work wrapped up in September, and it's November now. So with all that in mind, which of the effects stemming from the mine sequencing changes do you expect to persist for the rest of the year, or perhaps even carry into 2024? To put it another way, more simply: has your Q4 expectation shifted compared with two months ago, and what meaningful impacts should we be modeling out?
Dan Dickson
executiveApologies, Heiko. Good to hear from you. Your question got a bit muffled at the end there. I'm not certain I caught it correctly.
Heiko Ihle
analystSo the real question here is this: given what's been happening at Guanaceví, do we expect those changes to carry on for the rest of the year, or will most of those effects be behind us? Let me put that another way. Has your Q4 outlook for that site shifted at all compared with where it stood roughly two months back?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. That's a completely reasonable thing to ask, and it's good to hear from you, Heiko. At the end of the day, the purpose behind the changes we implemented is to boost ventilation and to strengthen how we handle our water. We're seeing more inflow at the El Curso concession than had been anticipated roughly a year back. So we're putting those changes in place. And ultimately, both our throughput and our mine output rose here in Q4. We anticipate that the bulk of the work carried out during Q2 and Q3 will stick. So we not only expect Q4's production throughput — the mine's production output and, in the end, the throughput moving through the plant — to hit plan, which comes to roughly 1,200 tons per day, but those changes ought to serve us well through 2024 and beyond. And I'd note that a portion of this was avoidable; the reality is we could have handled it more effectively last year, ensuring we stayed ahead on our ventilation program and our water inflow program. That's something we failed to do. We're capable of doing better there. It's simply that everything arrived somewhat simultaneously, and in the end that hurt our production here in Q3. And that hit to production in Q3 was clearly reflected in our financial results and, ultimately, in our cost metrics at Guanaceví.
Dan Dickson
executiveIt’s not something I’d describe as fully in the past. Ventilation and water management remain in progress for us. We anticipate finishing that work in Q4. Still, when all is said and done, our output has risen. Given that increase in output, we will at minimum hit the production plans we’ve set.
Heiko Ihle
analystThat seems like a completely reasonable reply, and it’s comforting too. It’s an entirely separate matter. In two weeks you’re hosting a visit for Terronera, and of course we’re eager to be there. According to the release you put out today on the site, construction there stands at 38% complete. Looking back at your previous release about the site, it said procurement work remains on schedule, with the majority of long-lead major equipment expected to arrive by year’s end. And that was 1.5 weeks ago. So what precisely is still outstanding, and where is it located? Is it a custom and a shift? Is it the suppliers? Is there anything worrying you, or that perhaps ought to worry us? I presume the response is no, but I simply wanted to confirm.
Dan Dickson
executiveNo, there are always issues that worry us. What comes to mind immediately is some hold-ups in <<inaudible>>. We didn't anticipate those. I wouldn't go so far as to label them critical items, though they are important ones, since each piece of equipment and every part counts when it comes to getting the plant up and running. As I mentioned, all the key components for the mine and the key components for the plant ended up being ordered fairly early, and the bulk of that is arriving this year. We're now working through smaller equipment. At the moment, we're processing ATCs on steel. That will be delivered out to suppliers, and that expectation is coming. But across the next year, until we reach production or start up the plant, there will always be small items, and managing them is our job. And unforeseen items always arise that we must handle. Right now, things have been fine. So nothing critical has occurred, but something will come up, and handling it will be our job.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Lucas Pipes of B. Riley Securities.
Lucas Pipes
analystTo start, I'd like to ask something that builds on what we discussed regarding Guanaceví. Then, thinking ahead to 2024, what effect do you expect the steps you've implemented to have on both output and the cost structure? Thanks a lot.
Dan Dickson
executiveAbsolutely. As far as 2024 goes, guidance will be released in January, but at Guanaceví we've now been operating for 18 years. Capacity at the plant stands at 1,200 tons per day. At this point, it's fairly straightforward to assume that we can achieve 1,200 tons per day in 2024. In the end, the steps taken during Q3 give us confidence that a 1,200 ton per day operation is achievable. Should we be able to hold our production profile, that would let us hit guidance on the cost side, and our all-in sustaining cost is anticipated to land between $19 and $20 this year. Next year that will likely be somewhat higher owing to inflation factors, though we'll provide that guidance in January.
Lucas Pipes
analystThanks for those remarks — much appreciated. Then I have a question about Terronera. Regarding your minimum targets for cash and liquidity while development work is underway there, is there anything particular we should bear in mind as we model cash flow across the next few quarters? I'd value your view on that. Thanks.
Dan Dickson
executiveAbsolutely. I believe keeping a certain amount of liquidity matters. At present, we hold $76 million in working capital, and that is the figure we focus on when assessing our liquidity — particularly as we go through this development phase with Terronera. It's worth noting that we must use our own cash first before we are able to draw on our debt facility. And we anticipate using our cash down not to zero but to a particular level — likely $20 million, $25 million — before drawing on that facility. And once we begin drawing on that facility, hopefully our cash will grow through performance at Guanaceví and Bolañitos, and we'll see that in 2024.
Operator
operatorTrevor Ward, a private investor, has the next question.
Trevor Ward
analystGood morning. I’m on the line from Hawaii. I’m fairly new when it comes to buying common stocks, and I purchased a sizable — a sizable stake in Endeavour. So right now I hold 40,000 shares with an average cost of $3.10. What I’m wondering about, with all this jargon and these numbers, is — for me the bottom line is this: say over the next year, and then looking further out, when should I expect Endeavour to actually turn a profit and pay a dividend?
Dan Dickson
executiveWell, Trevor, you're fortunate to be in Hawaii at the moment. We're up here in Vancouver. So I sure wish I were in your spot. As for Endeavour Silver, where we stand today in terms of growth, we're putting money into our Terronera project. And Terronera will lift us from 9 million ounces of silver equivalent to 16 million ounces of silver equivalent produced each year. That kind of scale ought to boost our earnings. And we have posted positive earnings through the years. This quarter on its own, naturally, we lost $0.01. Clearly, that's not where we want to be. We want to be profitable, regardless of what the silver price is or what the gold price is. And I believe Terronera will get us there. On the dividend side, thanks to Terronera, that will come later on. I wouldn't call it the near future, since we also have the Pitarrilla project lined up after it. Our aim is to move Pitarrilla forward. Pitarrilla would be a project of significant scale that still requires plenty of work from us, but we feel confident about it. Still, whatever capital and cash flow Terronera generates, we'll likely plow back into the Company.
Dan Dickson
executiveSo unfortunately, if a dividend from Endeavor Silver is what you're after, it likely won't be arriving anytime soon. But the silver price could move, and ultimately, putting money into Endeavour Silver means you're putting money into silver, so that could shift, and I hope it does. Still, as I say, at present, right now, given where we stand with silver at $23, I don't foresee a dividend in the near term until we're fully invested in and have exploited what we hold with Pitarrilla, Parral, and our other exploration programs.
Trevor Ward
analystAlright, so I have just a few more quick questions here. A little while back, I saw — I watched an interview with you folks and your projection, and at that point your assumption was that silver would reach $30 an ounce by the end of 2023. So quickly, what's behind that projection? And then also, maybe a quick brief explanation of how the international silver market operates. And then, the last question before I say goodbye is, what's your current position? And can you tell me, since you've been in this position, what's your current holding of stock? And when was the last time you bought or sold the stock?
Dan Dickson
executiveSure, and you've raised quite a few points there — the broader market as well as where I personally stand. As for my own position, I think I own roughly 400,000 to 450,000 shares in Endeavour. My purchase price is likely somewhere in the $4 to $5 range, and my carrying price would be — the most recent occasion I acquired stock was probably around May or March of 2022, last year. But I've probably said enough about myself. Regarding my comment that silver would reach $30, I can't say which YouTube video or interview you were watching, but I have made that statement before, and in the end it would depend on the level of the gold price. If you examine the historical gold-to-silver ratio, over the past 35 years it has averaged roughly 35:1. At the moment gold is a touch under $2,000 — perhaps at that point it was $2,100. So to reach a ratio — currently, I believe we're at 86:1 — to reach a ratio comparable to what history has shown us, that would lift silver into the high-20s and eventually to $30. We did reach $29 silver a couple of years back now, and we've fallen considerably from that level since.
Dan Dickson
executiveAnd I mean, these have been really unpredictable times. With interest rates going up, silver's price hasn't done well. But oddly enough, gold has hung in there quite nicely. I view that as a good sign for silver's price. I think if gold breaks above $2,000 and $2,100, eventually silver always trails along. It's only a matter of the delay and how long that delay lasts, and at times that delay is six months, at times it lasts for one year. So when I forecast or project that silver would hit $30, I don't think I've never — I haven't said that, I probably did perhaps depending on where the gold price sits. And then in the end, how the silver market functions globally, that's a massive question. I mean, it's a big market. More than 800 million ounces get produced and sold. It's sold via various exchanges in the United States, China, all over the place. So, I don't think I'll dive into that at this moment, Trevor. But I'm glad to address those questions via our info line. Call our IR, and we'll walk you through it at another point. But I'll turn now to the next question, operator.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Craig Hutchison at TD Securities. You have the floor.
Craig Hutchison
analystI wanted to ask whether you could bring us up to date on Pitarrilla and what the milestones look like. I'm aware there were some ground control issues. Still, could you share any milestones regarding the exploration work there and the possibility of an updated PEA?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes. No, that's an excellent question, Craig. Thank you. In the end, we had hoped to be drilling at Pitarrilla during this quarter. As you mentioned, we ran into some ground problems, the fault we're working through, we support it. But in the end, rock falls keep happening in the old pattern that existed there. So we're doing a parallel add, and we've taken that drill program and in the end moved it into an added advance this year. So drilling at Pitarrilla won't happen until January, possibly February of next year. That still lets us complete that PEA or begin economic studies on Pitarrilla next year. But we want to make sure we get it out complete, get the drilling finished on what we believe are some feeder zones, and then in the end view this project as potentially the next development project after Terronera. And that would be, as I said, starting to make those economic studies, hopefully midyear to end of next year.
Craig Hutchison
analystAlright, and I have one more question. Regarding the debt funding, there is a condition that you must provide cost overrun funding in cash or via a letter of credit of as much as $48 million. How should we interpret that? Is it mandatory? Would that turn into something like a restricted cash requirement that you would have to keep for a set period, or how should we simply grasp that $48 million condition?
Dan Dickson
executiveYes, and that's a fair question — a good one, actually. The structure is really split into two tranches. The first $60 million out of $120 million is accessible to us, along with cost overrun funding of $24 million. In the end, it wouldn't be restricted. That said, it's more or less handled as though it were restricted cash. Then, naturally, when the following $60 million of the $120 million comes through, another $24 million is needed. At that point we'll assess our position on the project construction side and whether all $48 million of overrun funding will be needed, and we'll make that assessment together with the independent engineers. So we'll get to that at some point, I suppose, midyear in 2024. But to your question — is it restricted? Possibly yes.
Craig Hutchison
analystOkay. And then, just as a possible follow-up, I suppose, would it be reasonable to say that regarding the ATM facility, you have additional work to do this quarter, simply to kind of raise your cash position ahead of that drawdown?
Dan Dickson
executiveAbsolutely, that could happen provided the market permits it. Naturally, we want our performance to meet expectations, and that has an effect on our balance sheet. That said, I believe our balance sheet is in excellent condition. At quarter end we held more than $41 million in cash, along with $76 million of working capital. There are a few levers available to us over the longer term. We had roughly $18 million tied to Terronera that we hope can be brought current fairly soon. That adds further funding capacity — nearly $96 million in working capital once that is included. So I think we are in a very solid position, though it is something we must keep in mind as we move through development and with these markets, so we will be, and I think we are managing that well.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up our Q&A portion. Dan Dickson, I'll hand things back to you for any closing comments.
Dan Dickson
executiveThanks, operator, and thanks to all of you for joining our Q3 call. Once more, I believe it's worth pointing out that management is working to resolve some of the cost issues at Guanaceví. I think that will be accomplished by getting our output up to where we expect it to be and on plan. Thank you, everyone. I look forward to our Q4 call and the financial release for 2023, and to talking with everybody again in March 2024. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's conference call. You can now disconnect your lines. Thanks for joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Endeavour Silver Corp. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Endeavour Silver Corp. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Endeavour Silver Corp. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.