Ferroglobe PLC (GSM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 2, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Beatriz García-Cos Muntañola
executiveHello, everybody, and thanks for being on this call covering Ferroglobe's results for Q4 and the entire 2020 fiscal year. Here with me are Marco Levi, who serves as our Chief Executive Officer; Gaurav Mehta, our Transformation Director and EVP of Strategy and Investor Relations; and Jorge Lavin, our Group Controller. Prior to sharing a few prepared comments, I will read a short disclaimer. Kindly navigate to Slide 2 right now. Any forward-looking remarks management makes on this call reflect present expectations. Details about risk factors that might lead actual outcomes to diverge significantly from such forward-looking remarks appear in Ferroglobe's latest SEC filings along with the exhibits attached to them, all of which can be accessed through our website, www.ferroglobe.com; furthermore, today's discussion mentions EBITDA, adjusted EBITDA, gross debt, net debt and adjusted diluted earnings per share, all of which are non-IFRS measures. You can locate reconciliations for these non-IFRS measures within our latest SEC filings. Let's move to the next slide, please. On this call today, we will begin by going over the highlights for Q4 and the full 2020 year, along with our business and the operating environment. After that, I will share further specifics regarding our financial performance and the main drivers underlying our results. And last, we will give an update concerning our transformation plan. Right now, I would like — I would now like to hand things over to Marco Levi, our Chief Executive Officer. Next slide, please.
Marco Levi
executiveThanks, Beatriz, and good morning or afternoon, everyone. For Ferroglobe, 2020 was a year that defined us and, in many respects, an extraordinary one. On one side, the world was grappling with difficulties brought about by the global pandemic. That meant our fairly recently assembled senior leadership group had to take drastic steps and revamp internal procedures so decisions could be made quickly; it altered how we ran our assets and pushed us to broaden and speed up what we were doing to cut costs. On the other side, there was the unambiguous, essential objective of crafting a plan to turn the company around and moving that agenda ahead even as we dealt with an operating environment unlike anything before. In numerous respects, the difficulties we faced, especially in the pandemic's earliest stages, brought to light weaknesses in our business as well as chances to unite the team around driving change. Taken together, our financial results fell short of what we had hoped to deliver, yet we regard 2020 as a success on many fronts. We changed management at multiple levels and began reworking portions of the organization to produce results and stress accountability. Even with sales dropping 30% compared with 2019, we got back to positive adjusted EBITDA in 2020; that demonstrates our capacity to run this business and strengthens the case for what the asset base can achieve. Beyond that, we kept the business running while keeping cash under control. This has been a key area of attention for the company, and we achieved meaningful progress in operating with no interruptions throughout a turbulent stretch. We managed to refinance our 3-year account receivables securitization program, which freed up some cash that had been trapped previously, while also bringing our financing costs down. And finally, we now possess a strong multiyear strategy and a clearly defined road map for turning this company around; we've covered our turnaround plan on recent calls and have just published projections, and we give further specifics on how value will be created. Looking forward, 2021 is going to be the pivotal year. Not only has the operating environment been improving steadily over the past few months, but we are also making considerable headway on critical priorities. So we are definitely beginning the new year on a positive note. A few weeks ago, we updated the market on our progress regarding a proposed financing, which tackles the maturity of our senior unsecured notes and tackles the injection of new capital into the company. By reaching this milestone in the financing process, we are moving toward making sure we have the resources to carry out our turnaround plan. What's more, it is validation, since the strategy underpinning our business plan shows a clear path toward value recovery that financing partners recognize. As for the turnaround plan itself, we finished most of the preparatory work in 2020. Right now, we are in the execution phase across every value creation area. I'll go deeper into this later in today's presentation. Now let's turn to Slide 6. For the entire year, we brought in $1.14 billion in sales. That's a 30% decline from the $1.62 billion we generated in 2019. The main reason is the unexpected way COVID-19 hit our volumes and pricing across every product we make. Our net loss for full year 2020 came to $194 million. That figure includes a $36.8 million impairment charge tied to the Niagara plant. By comparison, full year 2019 had a net loss of $296 million, which included a $134 million goodwill impairment charge. And finally, we got back to positive adjusted EBITDA. For the year, adjusted EBITDA was $32.7 million, versus negative $29.2 million in 2019. Again, that swing really shows how dramatically we changed things to tackle our costs. In the same way, for full year 2020 we got back to positive operating cash flow, bringing in $154 million over the year. In Q4, the company brought in $322 million in sales. That's a 22% rise from the $263 million in sales we had in Q3. Our net loss in the fourth quarter was $84.1 million, compared with a net loss of $46.8 million in the quarter before. Adjusted EBITDA in Q4 was positive $5.7 million, which is a drop of $22.2 million from what we reported in Q3. All in all, Q4 saw larger sales volumes and somewhat higher prices, combined with much higher costs — some of which won't repeat — and that led to margin erosion in the quarter. The bigger shipped volumes in Q4 reflect better end market demand, especially toward the end of the quarter. We also kept working on bringing battery levels down. Gross debt went up by $31 million in the quarter, mostly because of the bond coupon accrual. We finished the year with gross debt of $473 million and net debt of $341 million. Cash on hand was $132 million at year-end. With the refinancing of our 3 year securitization program, there was a cash release of the previously trapped cash in the SPV structure. So even though total cash is lower quarter-over-quarter, the unrestricted cash available actually went up after that financing, rising from $78 million in Q3 to $130 million at year-end. Next slide, please. Over the next 3 slides, we'll go through pricing and volume trends, earning contributions and market observations for each of our key products. Starting with silicon metal on Slide 7. Ferroglobe's realized average selling price for silicon metal was $2,260 per metric ton, roughly flat versus $2,248 per ton in the prior quarter. Index pricing in the U.S. climbed gradually by about 2.6% in the quarter, while the European index rose 7.5% over that same stretch. A lot of the pricing recovery showed up late in the quarter, as low inventories throughout the value chain, together with strong demand in both the U.S. and Europe, propped up pricing with some upward pressure. Looking at the volume trends chart at the top of Slide 7, you can see silicon metal shipments rose 7% versus the prior quarter, reaching roughly 55,000 tons. In our silicon metal business, EBITDA weakened quarter-over-quarter, and that was mainly the result of higher costs. Higher winter electricity unit costs in France hurt our silicon metal production, and greater specific energy consumption at a few locations played a role as well. On top of that, planned production curtailments led to less fixed cost absorption. And lastly, we incurred some one-off power-related penalties, which came from a reduction in production tied to COVID-19 relative to our energy commitments that had assumed a healthy production profile. Broadly speaking, the market tightness seen at the end of 2020 has continued into the start of 2021, with U.S. and European indices posting steady improvement. Following a fairly weak demand picture for much of 2020 because of COVID, activity has picked up throughout the industrial sector, and we are observing that in our sales into the chemical and aluminum end markets in both the U.S. and Europe. This better demand arrives at a moment when inventory levels are low across the value chain, alongside logistical barriers, higher domestic consumption, and limited Asian imports into our markets.
Marco Levi
executiveJust to remind everyone, when the index moves, realizing that benefit takes time. On the whole, how things have started this year is working in our favor. As for the silicon trade case we've been pursuing, on February 23, the U.S. Department of Commerce set final duties reaching as high as 160% on silicon metal brought in from Bosnia, Iceland and Kazakhstan. The next step is a vote by the International Trade Commission on whether to uphold the preliminary ruling that these imports harm the U.S. industry. That ITC vote is set for March 24. On Malaysia, the investigation continues. So far, commerce put preliminary duties of 7.21% in place at the end of January. That rate could rise in the final determination, which is set to be announced on June 17. Let's move to the next slide. Now to silicon-based alloys on Slide 8. In the quarter, the average selling price dipped slightly, by 0.4%, to $1,528 per metric ton, compared with $1,534 per metric ton in the third quarter of 2020. Even with that dip, Ferroglobe's average realized price for silicon-based alloys continues to sit above the U.S. and European indices; that reflects the weighting of our higher-margin specialty ferroalloy products, which made up roughly half of shipments in the fourth quarter. In the quarter, sales volumes rose 35%. Silicon-based alloys sales volumes came to roughly 57,000 tons in Q4, around 15,000 tons more than the prior quarter. That gain is mainly driven by ferrosilicon sales, which have gotten a lift from steel capacity coming back online, particularly blast furnaces in Europe. On top of that, our ferromanganese sales also got better thanks to granular recovery throughout the global automotive and market. EBITDA for our silicon-based alloys business got a positive lift from prices, volumes and cost in the quarter. We saw a cost improvement of $8 million from better fixed cost absorption; that gain showed up in both France and Spain, which had earlier been hurt by lower production after steel demand in Europe slowed in the second and third quarters of 2020. Taken together, these factors lifted EBITDA contribution from this segment to $7.1 million in Q4, versus negative $1.9 million in the third quarter. As the pricing trends graphs show, pricing in the U.S. and Europe kept rebounding steadily through the second half of 2020. Broadly, ferrosilicon pricing is getting a boost from inventory rebuild along the value chain and from a recovery in steel demand. Next slide, please. Now on to manganese-based alloys. In the quarter, the average selling price climbed 2.2% to $1,031 per metric ton, from $1,009 per metric ton in the third quarter of 2020. In the quarter, the ferromanganese business saw a 4.4% rise in realized prices, while realized silicon manganese pricing came in 1.7% higher. Shipments during — in the fourth quarter were up 58%, a gain of roughly 24,600 tons over the prior quarter. Just like what happened with certain other items, inventories of manganese alloys sat at depressed amounts right as buying interest began to strengthen. For Q4, this segment's EBITDA contribution came in at negative $0.1 million for each metric ton, compared with a positive $13.1 million during the third quarter. The quarter's results got a boost of $3.1 million from volumes and another $1.5 million from pricing; meanwhile, costs produced an unfavorable net effect of $17.8 million across the period. Roughly $12 million out of that figure stems from the possible earn-out payment tied to our manganese alloy facilities in Norway and France. On top of that, we were hurt by diminished plant efficiency as well as greater absorption of fixed costs. At this point, I'd like to hand things over to Beatriz so she can walk through the financial results in greater detail.
Beatriz García-Cos Muntañola
executiveThanks, Marco. Moving on to Slide 11. We saw $321 million in sales for Q4, which came in 22% above the $2,063 million recorded in the previous quarter. The driver behind this sales growth was a 29% rise in shipments, and that was enough to more than compensate for a 3.5% drop in the average realized selling price throughout our portfolio. Cost of sales went up 36% during the quarter. The main reason is the variable cost tied directly to the higher shipment volumes in the quarter. On top of that, it also reflects a $12 million charge from the mark-to-market of the earn-out liability for the manganese assets. As for the roughly 75% rise in other operating expenses, or about $20 million, there are 3 main explanations. In Q3, we picked up a $5 million benefit from an R&D project in France. That was a one-time item. So that same benefit is absent this quarter. We also recorded a $6 million accrual tied to the possible purchase of CO2 emissions rights, based on current pricing. And lastly, what remains is largely due to increased transportation and logistics costs, driven by greater volume activity as well as higher freight rates, since broader industrial activity has recovered. Higher sales gave us a net gain, but that was partly offset by increased costs, and the result was that our operating loss for the quarter improved to negative $26.2 million before adjustments, versus negative $38.8 million in the prior quarter. Adjusted EBITDA came in at positive $5.7 million, down from $22.2 million in Q3. Keep in mind that the results we're presenting are unaudited. On November 16, 2020, the Tribunal Superior de Justicia of Galicia rejected FerroAtlántica's claim seeking to separate the metallurgical plants at Cee and Dumbría along with the related hydroelectric power plants. The accounting impact of that ruling has been factored into the Q4 results. We are still discussing this accounting impact with our external auditors, and it could change. Next slide, please. On a quarter-over-quarter basis, adjusted EBITDA did fall, going from $22.2 million in Q3 to $5.7 million in Q4. A few key elements explain this, and I want to call out specifically some items that are nonrecurring and that you should factor in when evaluating our normalized EBITDA threshold. During the quarter, we got a boost from volume pickup late in the year, and we also saw better pricing across the portfolio. Beyond that, there was a negative impact of $9.4 million that also stems from energy costs. This is specifically tied to a $5.8 million penalty in France, where we used less energy than we had contracted because of unplanned production curtailments in Europe. Conversely, we gained a $3 million energy compensation last quarter, stemming from energy providers' inability to secure minimum energy levels of stakes. As in the prior quarter, we took a significant mark-to-market adjustment connected to a potential earn-out liability linked to certain manganese assets. On the P&L side, Q3 showed a gain of $7.5 million, while Q4 came in at negative $2.2 million. So the quarter-over-quarter swing works out to roughly $10 million. Because manganese alloy markets underneath are so fluid, that liability could shift again from one quarter to the next, which would introduce some noise. So when assessing quarterly performance, people need to take that into account. In a similar vein, we saw a $5 million gain from removing a liability connected to an R&D project in France. Within the bridge, that one-off benefit booked in the previous quarter shows up as a negative; and finally, we keep moving forward on its cost reduction. This quarter, that added $5 million. Let's go to Slide 13; across the entire year, adjusted EBITDA went from negative $29.2 million in 2019 to positive $32.7 million in 2020. Cost was the biggest driver behind that swing, coming from better production cost. Above all, we keep pushing initiatives designed to change the raw material mix so we save money while not sacrificing the final quality of what we produce. On top of that, by cutting capacity and operating our strongest assets at greater utilization, we picked up additional gains in overall production costs; and finally, weak industrial activity meant we paid less for raw materials and other key inputs. Sharp price drops across every one of our core products hurt us on a year-over-year basis. And as I noted on the previous slide, we've stayed highly disciplined about corporate expenses, watching both discretionary and nondiscretionary spending. The net effect was a $13.5 million gain in 2020. Please move to the next slide. Now on Slide 14. I'll walk through our balance sheet more closely, since we've improved both total available cash and working capital. With markets this difficult, those gains matter a great deal to our business. At the close of 2020, cash and restricted cash came to about $132 million, versus $147 million in the preceding quarter, and although the overall cash figure declined, what matters most for the company is the available cash balance, which can be tapped with no restrictions. Over the quarter, our available unrestricted cash rose by $25 million, going from $77 million at the close of the third quarter to $103 million at the close of 2020. On refinancing, the earlier account receivable securitization facility in Europe — the special proposed vehicle structure backing the financial — disappeared once that facility was refinanced. That freed some cash that had previously been restricted. Gross debt rose by roughly $31 million across the quarter, mostly tied to the accrual for the semi-annual bond coupon payment. Net debt went up by $46 million during that same stretch. The reason is lower accounting cash, since the SPV trapped cash is no longer consolidated, as I mentioned before. At year-end 2020, total assets stood at approximately $1.4 billion, a modest $34 million decline from the prior balance at the close of Q3. In Q4, Ferroglobe saw its working capital get better by $15.3 million, mainly because we focused on bringing down inventories of raw materials and finished goods throughout the portfolio. Let's go to the next slide. We've laid out all the quarterly details for 2020 on this slide, but I want to start by directing your attention to the Q4 2020 number. Cash flow from operating activities came to $3.5 million for the quarter; the negative $0.6 million of reported EBITDA was offset by what we did on working capital, producing net cash inflows of $13.5 million, and the largest piece of that came from cash freed up out of inventory. Cash flow from investing activities was negative $14.2 million, since capital expenditure picked up over the winter months during some planned outages, mostly in Europe; and finally, cash flow from financing activities came in at negative $4.7 million for the quarter. During that quarter, we refinanced our earlier account receivable securitization facility, swapping it for a new factoring facility in Europe; that produced roughly $19.7 million of cash release when it closed. On top of that, every cash movement tied to the refinancing is treated as bank borrowings and payments within the cash flow summary; taken together, free cash flow was negative $10.7 million in Q4. Across the full year, cash from operations reached positive $8.9 million, while free cash flow reached positive $122 million. Next slide, please; let's now move to Slide 16. We brought working capital down by $15 billion in the fourth quarter; that decrease came from a $65 million write-down in inventory along with a $63 million rise in accounts receivable, and it was offset by a $30 million increase in accounts payable. The favorable effect from inventory was partly offset by a strengthening euro against the U.S. dollar. Moving to the chart on the right, and as I noted, our cash balance finished the year at $132 million, versus $147 million in the previous quarter. Slide 17, please. Over the quarter, both gross debt and net debt went up. The rise in gross debt comes from accruing the semiannual coupon payment under the existing senior notes. In the same way, the drop in total cash had an adverse impact from the quarter-over-quarter change in net debt. Next slide, please; regarding our earlier account receivable securitization program in Europe, we closed a new facility on October 1. That new facility differs somewhat from the earlier securitization program and is set up as a factoring facility. This supports better advance rates and removes the SPV structure we had before. Because of that, we managed to release $19.7 million of cash at closing, which had previously been restricted inside the SPV structure. Lastly, the proposed financing discussions we mentioned in our earlier announcement on February 1 are still ongoing, and we're hoping to share more news about them before long. Right now, I'd like to hand things over to Marco, and he's going to give us an update on where the strategic plan stands.
Marco Levi
executiveThanks, Beatriz. Moving on to Slide 20. I'd like to spend a few minutes giving you an update on our strategic plan. Right now, we've officially moved out of the planning and preparation stage of the strategic plan and into the execution stage in every value creation area. The bottom-up analysis we did while in the preparation phase played a key role in validating the assumptions and financial targets we've set. As we move further into execution, we're also going further into our organization. We're not only bringing in more of our employees across the company, we're also training them and giving them the tools to drive the change needed to deliver improvements in their own areas. In the same way, the company is making a huge effort to close gaps in the business, including internal communication. These are points of engagement with our workforce to make sure the entire organization clearly understands what we're trying to accomplish with the turnaround plan and what it means for them. Now I'll give a quick update on where things stand in each value creation area. On footprint optimization, we aim to adjust our installed capacity around the world by removing capacity that is excess and uncompetitive. So far, we've finished restructuring our Mo I Rana facility in Norway and our Niagara facility in the United States. With Mo I Rana specifically, we decided to idle 1 of the 2 furnaces. In doing that, we've acted to lower the cost structure, especially fixed costs, so that in the near term we can effectively treat it as a smaller facility, while keeping the option open to restart the second furnace. Our Niagara facility has been idled since the end of 2018. Because of our wider focus on shedding installed capacity and concentrating on the most competitive plans, we've made the decision to permanently close this site. Several options for what we do with the property are being reviewed right now; for 2021, we have additional actions to take, and we'll share updates as we start execution in other areas. The continuous plant efficiency value creation area extends our key technical metrics program. Under the strategic plan, we have a lengthy backlog of specific initiatives, centered on raw materials, general efficiency improvement and a reduction in energy consumption. Some combination of these initiatives will be rolled out at our facilities globally this year. Most recently, we finished our first pilot project at <<inaudible>> facility in France; this was a successful 2-week on-site pilot to test and learn ahead of a global rollout. What sets the program apart from how we've done KTM previously is the preparation and planning that comes before the actual execution. In addition, we've launched a process aimed at employee training and engagement to build a culture centered on operational excellence and a workforce that constantly seeks ways to move forward to remain competitive. So while this kind of involvement is now being introduced across every part of the strategic plan, it's been especially evident in how efficiently our plants are running — above all because it brings in our employees directly, along with the facilities, and gets teams from plants in different parts of the world working together. The SG&A cost reduction plan is basically a continuation of what we've been doing to cut corporate overhead, extending it past the head offices. So far, we've done well at putting the internal infrastructure and processes in place so we can set particular targets and monitor how we're doing against them. One clear place where our efforts are paying off is discretionary spending, and we're putting steps in place so that costs don't gradually creep back up; by establishing a centralized procurement group, we've upended the way things were historically run and decided, with the goal of achieving cost savings and greater efficiencies. Right now, the new centralized procurement organization is completely operational and most <<inaudible>>. We understand this is a very different method of working, and we've devoted time and resources to training our employees so they can operate within this new structure. Since there are enormous opportunities to achieve cost savings spanning dozens of raw materials, consumables and logistics expenses that we bear, we must be systematic and methodical as we determine the main areas to concentrate on, and we've established priorities for the current year. Already, this new organization is delivering some encouraging results after the first round of tenders was launched in freight and logistics. We're confident that this reorganization will generate substantial value down the road, and we'd look at possibly extending the rollover time. And lastly, we're pursuing commercial excellence via a number of initiatives throughout the portfolio, all intended to strengthen our strategic alignment with key customers while getting the most out of our commercial network. We'll accomplish this by enhancing planning between commercial and production, using data analytics, and strengthening our market intelligence capabilities so we can take advantage of market movements. Currently, we're in the middle of overhauling existing processes and creating new ones to back this initiative. In a market environment such as the one we're seeing today, with demand growing, being more systematic and organized on this side of the business matters greatly if we're to get the most out of our potential. Apart from the EBITDA drivers, we have a separate work stream devoted to releasing cash by improving working capital. So far, we've set up 3 distinct teams, concentrating on inventory management, account receivable and accounts payable. As Beatriz pointed out, we're starting to see some of the benefit show up on the inventory side. On the whole, I commend our organization's effort at every level; we began this journey last year, in the middle of the global pandemic and facing a very difficult backdrop. Although we're carrying solid momentum into the launch of this initiative now that it's in the execution phase, we recognize the year has just begun and there are some quite challenging items still in front of us; we take pride in what we accomplished during 2020 to move the company forward operationally, strategically and financially. And we're eager to deliver against the new target set for this year. I definitely anticipate continuing to keep our stakeholders informed about this journey across the quarters ahead. Right now, I'd like to request that the operator please open the line for questions.
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystTo start with, given how silicon metal and ferrosilicon prices have strengthened lately, how should we think about the timing for that better pricing to show up in the income statements?
Marco Levi
executiveThanks for asking that — this is Marco Levi. Regarding silicon metal, in cases where we hold price agreements that are indexed, the delay runs one quarter. It's also the case that fixed yearly pricing applies to a big portion of what we do. As a result, an increase in the index price doesn't flow through to every silicon sale we make. Our alloys business remains much more indexed, and the lag there spans 2, 3 months.
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystSure. Regarding silicon metal, how does it split between the index and the annual contract?
Marco Levi
executiveSo roughly 70% falls under annual contract, though not the entire 70% carries a fixed price across the year.
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystAll right. Could you also discuss what the contracting landscape looked like compared with the prior year? Did your pricing rise, fall, or stay the same? Obviously, the steel situation at this point in the year differs greatly from twelve months earlier. So if you could just describe how that environment stands?
Marco Levi
executiveYeah. So, as you're aware, my time with the company has been brief — roughly one year; yet during this period, I've witnessed a great deal of pricing swings. Perhaps I should — let me use silicon as a starting point. At the outset of last year, silicon prices were at solid levels. Subsequently, because demand was weak during the second and third quarters, the index price dropped to an exceptionally low point. We're observing market prices in Europe even under EUR 1,500 per metric ton, just as a benchmark. Naturally, this affected every negotiation for the new year, since pricing began at EUR 2,000, declined to EUR 1,500 at minimum for the indexes. After that, it failed to bounce back in Q3, and the rebound — we're only noticing a rebound during Q4. Consequently, the choice was either to negotiate contracts with reduced volumes, committed volumes for 2021 at prices equal to or below 2020, or to direct more business toward metallurgical silicon, which is inherently a spot business. So the approach has involved attempting to secure the best achievable price for the year while ultimately avoiding a commitment covering the entire volume.
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystAll right. I've got something to ask regarding European CO2 credits. How much of the CO2 emissions you expect for 2021 is already accounted for? And after that, how many dollars' worth of credits will you need to spend in order to be covered for your 2021 CO2 emissions?
Beatriz García-Cos Muntañola
executiveYes. Thanks. Nick, for asking. Beatriz here. Right now, a portion of the CO2 allocations we require is already sitting on our balance sheet, if that answers what you asked. It's true that at present we must buy a certain quantity of CO2 rights. And what we're attempting to — what our plan is, to try to offset as much as possible of the new allocation using the new purchases we still have to complete. Looking at the timing, this seems difficult right now, but that's our plan or what we're striving toward.
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystOut of the emissions you had in 2021, what portion do you already hold credits for? And after that, what amount will need to be spent before all of your European production can be completed?
Beatriz García-Cos Muntañola
executiveYes. As I said earlier, a portion of those is already sitting on our balance sheet, expressed as a percentage, which is perhaps something I'm able to share, though not as a dollar figure. And once more, timing is the problem here, since the new allocation won't arrive until June 2021, while the CO2 has to be bought back by April — before April ends, correct? So roughly speaking, I can tell you that today, some of it is already recorded on our balance sheet. It is accurate that an extra quantity still needs to be repurchased.
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystLet me ask this — regarding that $30 million you monetized, which I think happened at the close of Q2 or the start of Q3, what share of your 2021 emissions did it represent?
Beatriz García-Cos Muntañola
executiveSo, it's 2 — the 2 processes are linked, but here's how I'd frame it. The allowances we sold in 2020 were tied to 2020 consumption, correct? Those set to be handed out in 2021 would rest on the upcoming allocation — on how much our plants would be used going forward. So linking the two, 2020 and, as we say, 2021, isn't something I'd do, if that answers your question.
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystAll right, but you did disclose that a CO2 accrual of $6 million was accounted for. So with that $6 million accrual, or because these things cost more at present, you'll nonetheless be paying out $6 million beyond what you otherwise would, plus some extra sum on top. So it's possible you'd be spending — suppose you sold $10 million during the prior year, does the worth of those CO2 credits now come to $16 million? Should that be our mental model?
Beatriz García-Cos Muntañola
executiveWell, you have to look at — my feeling is that the finest way to address what you're asking is by examining how CO2 prices have moved across the past 12 months; so indeed, prices have climbed starting at, let's say, EUR 27 and kept rising to — reaching as high as EUR 40. Currently, we sit at EUR 36 per EOA, correct? Yet this market swings a lot, and over the last 2 months, investors showed considerable appetite for it, which explains why prices went up; at this point it seems they've been easing off. So we're at a reduced price point; therefore we're tracking and shaping our plan to buy back the rest while closely observing how the market develops.
Marco Levi
executiveAnd if I could just add one thing, how much we have to buy back during this year also hinges on where we stand operationally and on the fresh credit allocation for 2021; so there are two variables in play here, correct?
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystRight; and then I'd like to ask about those asset closures. If you leave the Niagara facility, does that bring about any liabilities tied to environmental remediation? And then, do you have any idea what the costs of exiting in cash will amount to?
Marco Levi
executiveYeah. Should it come to closing Niagara, we've already put the figure at a couple of million dollars, nothing beyond that; however, at this point, we aren't anticipating taking that facility fully offline. There are a few other possibilities we're evaluating.
Nick Jarmoszuk
analystYes. And a last thing regarding what it costs to produce. Are any inflationary pressures showing up on the manganese, silicon metal, and ferrosilicon fronts? And could you discuss how well those can be passed along?
Marco Levi
executiveWell, the — certainly, certain raw materials are climbing. On the market side, manganese ore went up somewhat from Q1 to Q4 of last year. Coal is rising, a bit higher compared with quarter 4 of last year. Those are the 2 primary items that come to mind. Beatriz?
Beatriz García-Cos Muntañola
executiveYes, I agree with, nothing to add.
Brian DiRubbio
analystPerhaps we could begin with capital expenditures — what's the amount you plan to spend during 2021?
Beatriz García-Cos Muntañola
executiveOur CapEx level for 2021 is set to rise relative to 2020, though figures aren't something we disclose. What I can say is that both our CapEx expenditures and our business expense are going to increase in 2021. During 2020, the CapEx we spent came to $30 million. In 2021, we're going to exceed that number — I'd say, well above it.
Brian DiRubbio
analystAll right. Let me try putting it a different way. Is $30 million the amount you need just to keep things running on capital expenditures? Or did you come in under that figure? I'm simply attempting to get a sense of how big this could be.
Marco Levi
executiveNo, no. Two years running now, our CapEx has come to roughly $33 million to $34 million; and that figure is what lets us run the asset footprint we have today safely. Within that CapEx, essentially none of it goes toward growth, nor toward process improvement, though when it comes to the KTM initiative I brought up in my remarks, some CapEx will be required from us to bring in new technologies involving particular assets.
Brian DiRubbio
analystAll right, that's useful. Now regarding inflation — or cost inflation specifically — could you help us understand which headwinds you're encountering when it comes to freight, and in fact not just shipping itself but the availability of shipping? I've been hearing about certain log jams in logistics.
Marco Levi
executiveSo, as you're aware, our presence in Asia is rather limited. And indeed, we're seeing a certain amount of inflation tied to some ancillary raw materials we must procure, primarily for the foundry operation, which we source from Asia. Those are the chief inflationary expenses we're observing; so we — what I'm pointing to here is — this shift toward buying magnesium, yet at this point it isn't anything truly enormous or particularly meaningful.
Brian DiRubbio
analystAll right. And so regarding that centralized procurement team you set up, at what point should we begin to observe the actual advantages coming from it?
Marco Levi
executiveDuring this year.
Brian DiRubbio
analystYou mean during this year?
Marco Levi
executiveDuring this year, correct. Correct, it's more — let me say — the ramp-up is going to be gradual, since the majority of those supply agreements got negotiated in Q3 and Q4 of last year, covering this year. So our initial focus was on centralizing the organization. At this point, though, we're working on capturing some values — for instance, when purchasing certain services, or when buying spare parts for the plant. So benefits should begin to show up this year, but I'm expecting a significant impact in 2022.
Brian DiRubbio
analystAll right. And my last one — I realize you mentioned index prices are climbing, and there will be somewhat of a delay. When ought we to begin witnessing a more significant bounce-back in volumes? Would that kick off during the first quarter? Or could it be...
Marco Levi
executiveActually, a volume recovery is already visible in quarter 4, isn't it? When you examine the volumes, for our commercial segment during Q4, they came in considerably above Q3 levels across all 3 major value centers, and we hadn't been doing any destocking. Our price stayed steady, or very nearly steady. So — and Q1 bears out this pattern. The — simply to frame expectations, the thing is, we had been operating at a given rate; and quarter 4 caught us off guard. So demand rose. And — yet our inventory dropped considerably. Consequently we entered the year holding very low inventories; and with demand continuing to be strong, we find it hard to match demand since we began with low inventories.
Marco Levi
executiveAlright, Martin, if nothing else is coming in, that wraps up our call covering the fourth quarter and the full year 2020. Like I said when we started, there are encouraging things happening and important market shifts worth watching. What we delivered over this past year isn't where we intended to land, yet even with the pandemic's unexpected effects, we moved the needle considerably on getting back to positive EBITDA and started tackling several essential gaps aimed at turning this business around and bringing us back to profitability. Appreciate you joining once more. We're eager to hear from you when we hold the next call. Have a great day.
Operator
operatorThis brings today's call to a close. We appreciate everyone taking part. Attendees, you are free to leave the line at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ferroglobe PLC transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Ferroglobe PLC earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ferroglobe PLC or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.