flatexDEGIRO SE (FTK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 13, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorYes. Good morning, everyone. A warm welcome from my side here out of our office in Frankfurt, together with Achim Schreck, my colleague, who's heading IR. In the call as well as my colleague Muhamad Chahrour, the CFO is joining us from the Sofia office. We are happy to share with you a bit more details on our half year figures. And like always, I will start with a rather brief and general introduction and then hand over to my colleague, Muhamad Chahrour, who will then run you through our presentation. And yes, let me briefly start with the geopolitical situation, and I don't want to spoil your day, but we all know we are in tough times. There was a war in Europe and with interest rate hikes and inflation going up and everyone fearing recession. So very, very challenging times. However, we are very proud that we could show that our business model is a very robust one and that we have great clients. What does that mean? If we look at the first quarter, our clients only topped with respect to the assets under custody with us 2% and then within the second quarter altogether, year-to-date the assets of our clients only dropped 13%.
Operator
operatorYou're all aware that many indices around the world fell by more than 20%, and the share of our tech industry declined by 30% to 40%. So what does that show? It shows that our clients are, as we've always put it, better than average and financially well educated. They aren't young kids on the block who are 20 years old; instead they're mostly in their late 30s and early 40s and have lived through crises of this kind. And they aren't faring too badly. Obviously, I don't need to say much about book losses and realized losses. So where our clients' trading activity is concerned, we're seeing fairly normalized times. And by normalized times, I mean the period before COVID. If we look back at our company's history, in the 10 years prior to COVID, our clients traded on average in the range of 34, 35 trades during fairly low-volatility periods, and that's somewhat what we saw in the first and second quarter of this year. That said, I think our top line has gone down slightly, but we're very proud that the bottom line rose and that we were proud to present a half year profit that already exceeds last year's full year profit.
Operator
operatorI believe that's a really compelling point, and it sets us apart from many other neobroker companies that continue to lose money and aren't profitable. As you're aware, we are highly profitable. That said, let me quickly address where we stand on marketing. Once more, we're quite proud that this year we renewed our partnerships with both Borussia Moenchengladbach and flatex in Germany. And we announced just recently that we'll take on the same main sponsorship role with Sevilla in Spain — in Sevilla, clearly, we'll promote under our DEGIRO brand, which is the one tied to and responsible for international growth. In Germany, we keep using flatex for sponsorship purposes. One important thing to note is that our sports sponsorship activities sit entirely within this year's budget. The total we've spent this year on both Sevilla and Gladbach comes to no more than 20% of our overall budget. So it's very healthy, fully in line, and for us a great opportunity — particularly when you consider that since we began with Gladbach in Germany 2 years ago, the relevance and awareness of our brand — brand awareness — has already risen by 300%, and it keeps climbing.
Operator
operatorThen this morning, a very well-known journalist said that we perform so strongly that flatexDEGIRO adds a new client every minute. Honestly, gaining one client each minute strikes me as a fantastic message, and it ought to reassure you that our marketing budget is being directed the right way. So that covers marketing. Next, let me turn to some of the discussion, rumors, and recent press coverage regarding capital allocation and M&A. Consider this — you know that our cost per clients stays below EUR 100 per client. Doing the math, if we bring in 1 million clients, that means a marketing budget of EUR 100 million. You're all aware of how certain competitors value their clients, and purely for calculation purposes — and yes, I know it's early in the morning — if we were to buy 1 million clients, the price per client would likely be at least EUR 1,000, with some at 2,000, 3,000, 4,000, and 5,000. But just for calculation purposes, let's take the 1,000. Buying that number of clients would cost us EUR 1 billion. So from a shareholder value standpoint, I think we'd all agree that would make no sense at all.
Operator
operatorAt this point, we have no interest in paying too much for anything, and we won't pursue growth through M&A right now. That's because in Europe, our organic growth outpaces 3 of our rivals combined, and we achieve it at such a low cost per client acquisition that we believe this is the correct path forward. Even so, should any chance for inorganic growth arise, we would certainly examine it. We also have the proper resolutions in place to raise capital by up to 50%, if needed. That said, we currently see neither any need nor any opportunities. Turning next to our capital allocation position. Coming out of last year, we already hold EUR 220 million. Adding this year's first-half net profit, it's quite evident that we will surpass EUR 300 million in excess cash by year-end. We've been asked repeatedly what we intend to do with that sum. The obvious answer is that we are evaluating whether to launch share buyback programs, a dividend, or some combination of the two. That is what we will be doing during the second half of the year.
Operator
operatorAs you're all aware, a shareholder resolution would be required for that. That means an extraordinary shareholder meeting is necessary. And clearly, if we were to buy our own shares, we'd need the regulator's approval within a regulatory environment. So all of this is under review and in process, and we'll notify you accordingly once matters are ready to be notified. But we believe that's what you expect management to do, and management is on top of things and is doing this. This is a bit of a general introduction. As I said, I'm quite proud that our clients aren't getting that nervous and that our clients know what they're doing, and I'm also proud that our employees are working so hard, and we're still hiring people. A lot of our competitors have to lay off people. Here, again, we distinguish ourselves from the rest of the pack. And Mu will now take over and shift gears and run you through the presentation. Thank you so far, and over to you, Mu.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThanks a lot, Frank, and good morning to all of you. I appreciate you being on today's analyst call covering our preliminary half-year numbers. Indeed, the first half we just went through was quite difficult, particularly if you set it beside the prior 2 years, which represented the very highest levels ever for retail brokerage. That's something we're all conscious of. We repeatedly sought to give the market a crystal-clear signal that beating last year on trades is definitely not what we intend to do this year, considering the jump we saw last year. Even so, our aim is, and will remain, to expand our customer base and to preserve our clients' trading activity at as healthy a level as we can. And finally, to keep enhancing how well our business model monetizes. Let me briefly recap a few points here. Yes, growth carried on, though not at the pace of client acquisition we delivered across previous quarters. Even so, it remains enormous growth that leads the industry. And once more, I'd really like to stress that drawing a comparison between Q2 2022 and, say, Q1 2021 or Q2 2021 makes no sense at all, considering the circumstances, the climate, and the optimism we enjoyed last year in the first half — precisely the reverse of what we're seeing now and have seen across the last 6 months.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveEven so, we achieved steady and sound growth. As I mentioned, monetization matters a great deal. We keep raising — or rather steadying — our revenues. We succeeded in maintaining fairly strong profitability. I'm aware that many concerns arose about how operational leverage would appear given the lower volume of trades. We'll address that, or talk it through, shortly too. Cash generation — Frank brought that up. And clearly, the ongoing effort to gain market share. I'll say a few things about that as well. Let's begin with client additions during the first half: 282,000 clients. To give a bit of perspective — that's a huge figure, especially when set against 2020, our first year post-merger and the COVID year; we literally surpassed that count from the first half of 2020. As I noted, 2021 presents a very tough comparison. Yet when you look at the first-half figures across Q1 and Q2 against the average we typically saw in Q2, Q3 and Q4 of last year, we are fully in line. And as all of you are aware, Q2 tends to be a comparatively soft quarter, much like Q3.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveEven so, close to 300,000 clients. We'll also get to the quality of those clients in a moment, because it's a subject we keep coming back to together: what kind of clients are we actually winning? And you know my long-standing trade-off — it isn't merely the count of clients, it's far more their quality. And what we've observed with plenty of competitors and peers in the market who lean more toward lower-quality clients, so to speak — whether by age, by assets under custody, or by activity — is that those clients in particular have been pulling back from markets now. Their trades literally drop to 0, which luckily hasn't been the case for our clients. How does the gross figure of 282,000 convert into a net figure of 226,000? First, we saw organic churn of 27,000 clients during the first half, which annualizes to roughly 55,000 — 54,000 clients. Set that against the 2.3 million total clients we had at the close of this half year, and you can see we're talking about churn of give or take 2.5%.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveRetention is still extremely high — customer loyalty is exceptionally strong, and that loyalty clearly underpins both our revenue and our profitability. We carried on with the B2B off-boarding at a figure slightly above 20,000. A further portion of that swing is set to occur during this year's second half. And finally, through the merger of DEGIRO Austria into flatex Austria — the 2 brands and the 2 businesses — we ended another 9,000 clients owing to documentation that was insufficient for AML and KYC purposes. In short, we finished with 226,000 net new clients, which, once again when set against our 3 listed peers in Europe — Nordnet, Fineco and Avanza — exceeds their net growth by 50%. That is the point I would really like to stress once more. Benchmarking matters a great deal at all times, yet benchmarking against the correct figures matters even more. And what our teams deliver here, month after month, quarter after quarter, half year after half year — with brilliant marketing, and we will get to that too, with brilliant marketing — is growth beyond the market growth of 3 peers. And none of this comes from living off investors' money or from living off one funding round after another, but literally from producing high profitability, irrespective of the fact that we spend 3x, 4x actually the marketing of many peers outside.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThat strong customer gain showed up across every market, though primarily in the first 2 markets — the core ones: Netherlands, Germany, and Austria. Once again we added a bit more than 80,000 clients, which works out to roughly 17% year-on-year growth in the core markets across the last 12 months. In our growth markets, we saw about 40% growth over that same 12-month stretch. So if we set aside, so to speak, the new stock hired during the first half — and even so, that is very substantial and sustainable growth of roughly 130,000 clients. The research markets are the research markets, with 11,000 — sorry, 110,000 client adds since June of last year. New customer accounts in the first half came to only about 15,000, negligible. But as we mentioned earlier here, we are also pursuing a strategy of considering discontinuing certain countries so as to keep mental focus on core and growth markets. And profitability in these countries is always a given. We never have to pay for countries. So every one of them is breakeven. But even so, in order to focus mental capacity on our growth in core markets, we are currently discussing reducing one or another of these markets. Turning to trading activity.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAs expected, the second quarter was shaped by considerable uncertainty, with retail activity in capital markets falling sharply after Q1. Retail flow literally hit bottom—a floor we haven't seen much over the last 10 years—which is obviously also reflected in the number of trades with our clients. But again, when you benchmark this against other peers, it's relatively stable. In the first half we had EUR 38 million transactions. The second quarter dropped to EUR 16 million. Compare that with the second quarter of 2022 versus Q3 2021, for example, at EUR 18.2 million. You see here as well, yes, there is a backdrop. But it was by no means risky or threatening to us in any way—much more in line with what we're seeing in the market, with what's happening in the markets. This translates into an annualized trading activity of 30 trades in Q2 2022. And what you see here again is that this is literally a normalization effect across the whole market. A year ago we were discussing that, and I was saying we expect a mean reversion over the next 2, 3 years—I did not expect it to happen that quickly, to be honest.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAnd what we’re seeing at present is a steady, loyal client base that keeps trading with us no matter what’s happening in the markets, or no matter the fact that the markets have more or less less invested liquidity. The thing that supports us is, and will keep being, the quality of the clients we bring in. And on that point, we remain in a very, very good position and with very good quality when it comes to the portfolio. I mentioned that trading activity has normalized. And if you actually look from Q3 2021 onward, so across the last 4 quarters, trading activity on a monthly basis sits somewhere between 7.5 and 9 trades per month, which by the way is very comparable to what we saw in 2019 and to what we saw in 2014. And this is actually the first time we’re providing these numbers, but I think it’s very helpful here to show also a certain level of — where the new normal and the old normal used to be. What we see very clearly is that Q1 2020 through Q1 2021 were absolute outliers. And that’s something we have to respect from an operational perspective and from a strategic perspective — that we will return to a normalization effect.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveSure — we did have years such as 2015 and '16, and those were shaped by elevated trading activity. But you also have to remember the backdrop in '14 and '15: we were dealing with the sovereign crisis. There was a great deal of volatility stemming from selling prices, from decision-making around Brexit, from the Trump election. So many forces were at work driving capital markets, without any degree of war fears, uncertainty, inflation, or interest rate hikes. Our customer base's activity is still quite healthy. In Q2 2022, we once again saw activity from roughly 35% of all accounts — approximately 750,000 accounts were active and traded — which again gives a very good sense of what is happening despite this enormous pressure on capital markets. What we observe is that trades per active customer account have also fallen. So it isn't the case that activity declined only because people stopped trading; even the active traders are trading less, with fewer opportunities, fewer movements, and less short-term certainty. Conversely, the share of U.S. volume rose slightly versus last quarter. And what we see there is, let's say, a somewhat positive outlook on the U.S. capital markets following the very, very difficult first quarter for U.S.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveshares. Then there's the final one of our 3 variables: revenue per trade. When we began, and when we took over DEGIRO and launched this flatexDEGIRO journey, we made a promise. On many, many calls we committed that over the coming years we would succeed in enhancing the monetization of the business model. That's given the fact that DEGIRO transactions were sold to clients at a relatively cheap price. To phrase it that way. And at the end of last year we implemented our price changes, which are now taking effect more and more, and would take even greater effect the more trades we execute. During half year 2022, our average revenue stood at EUR 5.31 versus EUR 4.27 in half year last year. So we raised revenues per trade by literally 25%, and that is a very, very strong message. -- all while customer growth continued, by the way, and while trading activity stayed very solid, robust and healthy. Ultimately, that is the evidence of the price power you hold as a market leader. And if you apply it diligently and if you apply it the right way, that will definitely also support growth in the financial growth, so to speak, over the coming years.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAnd I think we can promise — and we always have — that this is very likely not the final price we'll do. Let's see how things go across the coming half years, years, and the next time around. In the second quarter, despite trading falling roughly 30% versus last year, our revenues held up really well, declining by only 7%. Nearly EUR 210 million in revenues was generated in the first half of 2022. Something I also find quite interesting, and I'm glad to point out, is that when you compare Q2 2022 with Q2 2021, we actually beat 2 of last year's quarters. Q2 revenues outperformed both Q2 and Q3, which traces back to improved monetization, arguably. But I think it's also a great achievement for the whole team to literally outpace the drop in trading activity through optimized monetization. Efficiency indicators line up very much with what we expect for this year: on annualized revenue of EUR 419.3 million, assets under custody at the end of the half year stood at EUR 38 billion, a drop of 13% — 1-3 — versus the end of last year, compared with the indices Frank just mentioned, which fell by more than 20% and 30%.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThis demonstrates how steady our clients' assets are, and it also demonstrates the deep and lasting confidence those clients place in both us and the brokerage industry, reflecting their strong financial literacy and their keen appetite for investing and trading. Revenue, so to speak, works out to 100 basis points of margin generated on the assets we hold, which lines up very closely with where we stood in 2019, prior to COVID and the new stock hype. Turning to the profitability of the business: EBITDA rose fairly strongly to EUR 89.1 million in the first half, essentially in line with what we had anticipated over recent months. Clearly, one factor matters a great deal here — we no longer built any provisions for long-term incentive plans. In fact, we released, on the slide number, approximately EUR 7 million in revenues thanks to the long-term incentive plans and the way the share price moved. All things considered, though, for this year, even setting aside share price movement, we expect to build at most somewhere near EUR 12 million to EUR 13 million in provisions, which obviously did not occur in the first quarter. So on profitability too, as we just saw with revenues, we can see how they outperformed Q2 and Q3 '21.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveOn EBITDA, we genuinely beat Q2, Q3 and Q4 of last year. Again, that's proof of very, very substantial profitability and growth, and profitability. The solid adjusted EBITDA, even with higher marketing spend, still came in at EUR 81.8 million. So after adjusting for the release of provisions of roughly EUR 7 million, EUR 7.3 million, we still land at EUR 81.8 million of operational EBITDA generation. As I said, despite the marketing spend we had, we will keep up the marketing spend. We'll keep going in a diligent way. We'll keep going in terms of the budget we began this year with. And the reason for that is that we clearly believe, truly believe, that what your secret in the market is that while a lot of participants, traders, investors, savers are pulling out of the market because they are rather first-time users or second-time users. The people who are left, the retail clients who are left in the market are the...
Operator
operatorSorry to cut in. The speaker will return in a moment.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveI think I'm back. Sorry, the line dropped me. So to return to the point — and we're going to keep going with this very diligent and straightforward marketing effort. We believe that the residual retail clients who remain in the market and are still trading are the hardcore traders and investors we are looking for, the ones we have focused on throughout the last 15 years of our history, and that we will pursue — with brand awareness campaigns and with the sponsoring. But also with conversion marketing, and to make sure we win here the best quality clients in the brokerage sector. The adjusted EBITDA margin pre-marketing has been relatively stable in Q2 2022 at 47.3%. So here, we also managed, if you would normalize for marketing expenses and for the growth, to continue with a very solid EBITDA margin in the high 40s. This is what we always aim for. This is what we will continue to aim for. And in the first half 2022, it's actually even at 55.7%. I mentioned expenses on marketing and especially on brand awareness in marketing. And we are developing our business that should last for decades and not for quarters.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe're not here to put faith in gimmicky concepts or profits over the short term. Our mission is plain: to bring capital market access to the retail public. That is what we'll keep doing. We'll stay focused and give every person in Europe — the 250 million non-brokerage clients — a chance to enter the capital markets. And yes, times are difficult right now. That comes with the territory. We had the last 2 years. We had wonderful times. This year is a fairly weak one. But once more, mean reversion will come. Mean reversion moves in both directions. So hopefully we'll also see mean reversion after this year. That means we must keep being visible, building trust, building brand awareness, building loyalty among our clients. And what stands out clearly is how effectively we've grown brand awareness in literally every one of our core and growth markets. With the sponsorship now in Spain — Spain matters enormously to us. It's the group's third largest portfolio market, the duo's second largest portfolio market, with close to 25 million clients. The goal is plain: to expand this market substantially in the years ahead.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveMoving on to our efforts in Spain. We see that market as quite mature and ripe for penetration, which is also why we've invested so heavily in sponsorship. The plan is to keep building strong brand awareness so that if the market normalizes within the next 12 to 24 months, we're visible from day 1 rather than continuing to operate as a hidden champion. I discussed the sports sponsorship with Sevilla. Once again, very, very careful decisions were made over weeks and months to find the right club. As you know, Sevilla plays in the Spanish first league and has qualified for the Champions League. So with DEGIRO, we'll have the opportunity to be visible not only in 38 league games in Spain — our second most important market in the digital portfolio — but also in at least 6 European Champions League games, which will help carry the euro across Europe and across very, very different nations. We also hope to leverage and scale the Sevilla sponsorship through synergies we've learned over the last 2 years with Borussia, so that we get a much faster kickstart with Sevilla — a very, very traditional club, very successful at European level, very down to earth, very solid, and very comparable to Borussia Moenchengladbach.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe're really glad to have this new partner with us as we build out the Spanish market. That's all I have personally, or from our team. Many thanks for joining today's conference call. Now I'd like to pass things over to the sell-side analysts for a Q&A session. Thank you.
Operator
operatorOur first question comes from Ian White.
Ian White
analystI’d like to ask 3, if I may. First, could you clarify what you’re seeing in the data that specifically makes you confident about a cyclical recovery in the second half of 2022? I suppose, looking at the guidance you issued a couple of weeks ago, it embeds a fairly strong rebound in new client wins and total trade during the second half. I’m just interested in understanding what underpins your confidence in that near-term cyclical recovery, please. Second question, on dividend and capital return capacity. Could you walk us through the binding constraints there, which I suspect relate to the bank’s capital requirements. So what is the binding regulatory constraint there? And how much regulatory headroom do you have as we sit here today, for example? And then just finally, sort of third question. Could you remind us what defines a churned client and a new client in your view, please? Is that someone who, for example, has closed their account, withdrawn all of their assets, not traded for a certain period of time? Could you just clarify those definitions for us, please?
Frank Niehage
executiveLet me begin with the broader picture, then I'll pass things to Mu so he can change tack and walk through some additional specifics. What makes us so confident about the second half of the year? Clearly, none of us can predict how geopolitics will unfold. With luck, the conflict in Ukraine will come to an end. With luck, the ECB will adopt the correct steps to combat inflation. And figuring out how to combat inflation isn't rocket science. All you need to do is raise interest rates sensibly. That said, we aren't the ECB, and we aren't politicians. But when I recall how our clients acted during the 10 years prior to COVID — and all of you would agree those were fairly normal times with low volatility — our clients traded somewhere between 33x and 35x per annum. You might even view that as a flaw — and if we take that experience and extrapolate it across the last 10 years, and then examine how clients acted during the first half year, it looks very, very similar. And if we assume they'll keep acting that way and trade within the 33x, 35x per annum range, then you can multiply revenues per trade in the second half, and from that you can work out the result we anticipate.
Frank Niehage
executiveAnd yes, that gives us a sense of comfort where our clients are concerned. And there's no panic among our clients. They're fairly seasoned and level-headed, actually. And take people doing saving plans, for example — when they've been saving through certain indices that stood at 2,500 at the start of the year and have since fallen to 2,000 or perhaps 1,800, they simply keep saving at a reduced rate, yet month after month they carry on. So we don't anticipate that activity slowing any further. I believe that leaves us feeling comfortable. And looking at our churn rate, it has consistently been at a record low — it wasn't within that 2% churn range.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveRegarding this year, yes — annualizing that figure gives you 2.5%.
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. So it's still pretty low. And again, that doesn't come as a surprise. Our clients are very loyal. And yes, that gives us comfort, but then I'll hand things over to Mu for the other questions. Mu, would you like to take that one?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThanks, Ian, and thanks for the question. First off, I don't think this is really about being overconfident in a cyclical recovery starting in the second half. There are two things you should keep in mind — we should all keep in mind. The second quarter is typically among the weakest quarters, the second and the third. So you could very well say that the distribution of trading activity, in a ceteris paribus world, is more or less 50-50 between the first half and the second half, because we usually have a very strong fourth quarter. Now, what we saw is that our clients did, even in a very, very weak second quarter, 30 trades on an annualized basis, which works out to 15 trades per client on a half-year basis. Multiply that by 2.3 million clients, and we end up with roughly 30 million to 33 million trades that should be done with this existing client base in a weak quarter. And if we add that up to the 38 point-ish million, even if we continued like in Q2 — again, the third quarter, generally a quarter with the lowest trading days, by the way — add the environment that we have, considered more or less to be some kind of relatively low case, we would end up north of 70 million to 75 million transactions.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThat's essentially the mathematical derivative we consider. Restrictions on dividends and overall capital allocation—please let us avoid diving too deeply into specifics, since these kinds of steps require various regulatory approvals. Right now—and this is what makes our management approach to recent capital allocation exciting—we're thinking about what to do with the cash already sitting on the balance sheet, which is clearly also required for CET1 and Tier 1 requirements. At this moment, we are 100% CET1 financed. Our Tier 1 therefore equals CET1, with no AT1 whatsoever. So there are various scenarios and various possibilities that we'll now look into and think through. And once we have the robust and fundamental information we need to share with the market, we will share it with the market. What is the churn client? Quite simply, the churn client is a client that has no legal client relationship with us. In other words, a client that terminated accounts. That's also why we provide the activity levels of accounts, to make clear how much activity our client base has.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveA churn client is, quite literally, a client that is no longer with us. I hope that answers your questions.
Ian White
analystLet me just ask a quick follow-up about capital or distributable reserves. What I'm getting at is this — looking at the leverage ratio at the end of 2021, was it 4.4%, somewhere around that ballpark? On my math, if I look at the company's total asset base for 2021, that would suggest roughly EUR 30 million to EUR 40 million of distributable reserves as of 2021. And then obviously, there are some retained profits from 2022 still to come. Is that roughly the right way to think about how large any capital return could actually be, as opposed to the roughly EUR 300 million of net cash the group has right now? Am I looking at it the right way?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveYes, exactly — you've got the right idea there. That's the correct lens to use, though as you know well, specific measures and specific instruments exist that could even push that figure higher. As I said earlier, we're fully CET1 financed. To keep our leverage ratios and CET1 ratios where they are, we hold no AT1 on the balance sheet. The regulator does permit you to bring in certain AT1 instruments as well. That's why I keep saying your mathematical way of framing it is exactly right. Still, I think we should do our homework, build a solid grasp of our profits and our requirement. Our CET1 requirement is comparatively high, and the anti-cyclical buffer is being built back up again post-COVID. The leverage ratio is certainly another matter we need to examine. And through this extensive operational review, we'll arrive at a point — if we reach that conclusion, make the decision and secure the approvals to proceed — where we inform the market of what the potential firepower could be. But it truly is the correct way to approach it: asking how we can unlock future profits and profitability, and how we might perhaps identify a strategic route to redistribute excess cash generated by high profitability.
Ian White
analystUnderstood.
Frank Niehage
executiveYeah, perhaps I could add 1 more remark. Are you able to hear me? One additional point. Clearly, and it goes without saying, anything we undertake is going to comply fully with laws and regulations as well as all the relevant requirements. And clearly, we'll look for the German regulator's approval before doing anything. So anything we do will be compliant, fully approved, and consistent with our business model. That's a given.
Achim Schreck
executiveModerator, could we take the next question now, please.
Operator
operatorWe'll go ahead and take the next question.
Benon Janos
executiveI've got 2 questions. First, a quick follow-up about revenues, and then I'd like to move to the full-year revenue guidance. As you said, Q2 and Q3 tend to be weaker than the historical average. Even with all the macro drivers, are you seeing newer customers who are on average less active than the customer cohorts from before the pandemic? And it looks like revenues in Q3 and Q4 would need to come in at least 15% stronger than Q2 on average — if you exclude the one-off reversal in Q2 — to keep the lower end of the guidance. And given activity could be weaker over the summer months and disposable income is under further pressure, how confident are you that activity will pick up in Q3 and Q4? Second, on the adjusted EBITDA margin and costs, do you see any flexibility in the cost base during the second half of the year? That's all from me.
Frank Niehage
executiveMu, would you like to take that one?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThanks. Yes, thank you. I'm just noting the question. So to your point: clients in newer cohorts are less active than those in the existing client base. There's, I think, a very good chart showing how client cohorts behave over their lifetime. What it shows is that, broadly, we get a fairly comparable return on the CAC we spend across all cohorts — which simply means that the more you spend on a cohort, the more active that cohort ends up being. So yes, the 2020 and '21 cohorts are indeed somewhat less active than a 2014 or '15 cohort, where we also spent considerably more, and on top of that there's clearly a dilutive element. When you grow very substantially in hype markets — in a positive environment — you obviously also dilute the average. So that's a given. Still, the most important thing is this: after 12 months of a client's lifetime, we still generate a 100% return on our investment. And over the years — taking the 2014 cohort, just from memory — with the 2014 cohort over their lifetime, still with us and still trading by the end of 2021, we generated a 2,800% return.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThis is precisely where we say we aren't going to track things quarter by quarter for each cohort; instead, we consider the lifetime value of that cohort. And every cohort we have, with the exception of the last one — since we only had half a year's time there — shows a triple-digit percentage in returns, or even a 4-digit percentage in return. So we still feel very comfortable with the clients we won over the last 2 years. And we'll update that slide, and then we'll also have more data on that point. Revenues. Revenues have to be higher in Q3 or Q4 in order to come up and to end up at our guidance compared to Q2. Allow me that sentence again. Please, let's stop benchmarking Q2 for the whole year. You're taking historically the weakest quarter of all time with all brokers in the world to try to derive a 4-year perspective, which doesn't make sense from our perspective. Q2, again, is the quarter with the lowest trading days, the number of trading days, because you have most bank holidays globally in this quarter, which, per se, reduces the activity. Q3, as I said, is awfully similar to Q2.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThis was a soft quarter, though Q4 has traditionally been an extremely robust one. Let me frame it positively: if we hit the same revenue in the second half as we did in the first half — pardon me, I mean the second half matching the first half — we'll land precisely at the midpoint of our guidance. That's something we are 100% confident about as of today. On adjusted EBITDA flexibility within the cost base — again, adjusted EBITDA carries a 0 with us when it comes to cost adjustments. The sole item we adjust for is provisions built up or released under long-term incentive plans. That cost-base flexibility stems mainly, strangely enough, from marketing. Personnel expenses too, but there's no reason for us to shrink our workforce. In fact, we're bringing people on board and intend to keep growing headcount because we believe in our long-term strategy. The same holds for marketing. We don't approach marketing purely through a conversion lens. We're building a company here for 15 years, and we'll keep going for the next 15, or perhaps 20, maybe 30, maybe 50 years, to develop Europe's leading online broker. And if we look at the U.S., Charles Schwab needed 70 years.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveInteractive Brokers needed 50 years to establish itself as the market leader in the U.S. That's why I don't think any newcomer can come into the market thinking they'll take over the European market within a few years. It's not possible. It comes down to wealth. It comes down to trust — people handing over their money for you to trade with, to hold in custody. That's not something you can just hear, as you sometimes say — with all due respect, we aren't a food delivery service. If the pizza isn't good, you switch to a different restaurant or a different delivery service. We're a service where our clients' wealth is what matters. So the flexibility we have, which is marketing, is flexibility we won't use simply to optimize profitability by 2% or 3%, despite the most challenging half year in our company's history. We managed to generate EBITDA margins above 40%. We managed to grow our customer base. We managed to grow our revenues per trade on an annual perspective, which is 3 big tick-boxes in our long-term strategy.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Marius Fuhrberg.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystThree questions from me too. The first is about the loan book. How did it develop, particularly with markets having declined recently? And did you run into any problems there, given the higher losses in certain portfolios where some clients drop below the threshold they must provide for? Or is everything fine on that front? Second, given the adjusted EBITDA margin you guided for 2022 B2B at the 2021 level, and in H1 you're now a bit under 40% — I believe that's right. Assuming we get some recovery in trading activity, that ought to provide enough operating leverage to hit your guidance. But if that doesn't happen, would you consider pulling the cost lever to still meet your guidance? From your last remark, I'd assume you would prefer to keep investing in marketing and client acquisition rather than hitting that guidance? And my third question concerns your plan to launch crypto trading in Q3 — do you confirm you're on track there? Or is everything still proceeding as planned and set to be introduced in Q3?
Frank Niehage
executiveYes, Marius, Frank here. I'll begin with the first question about the loan book and the last one as well, and after that I'll pass things over to Mu. So regarding the loan book, you know that we use extremely conservative LTVs, and very low LTV. So all of it is in line and in order, no issues whatsoever. And historically, the write-off quarter for the loan book was 0.07%. So practically nothing, and that continues in the same way. So as long as we don't encounter situations like via card once more, where stock drops to 0, we don't foresee any issues, and at least we haven't heard of that happening. So that's all good and in line as expected. Regarding crypto, we've announced that we've signed an MOU with Boerse Stuttgart, and we're now exploring further details. Obviously, crypto is at the moment rather experiencing cool days and a cool time, some call it the winter of crypto. Why is that? I mean, if you look at Bitcoin, it came down from 60,000 to below 20,000. And obviously, if you're aware how much energy is required to create new cryptos. I think if you ask anyone in the population, and not only in Germany, is there a great need for new crypto?
Frank Niehage
executiveOr is the bigger worry really how people will make it through the winter months, steer clear of freezing, and at the same time guarantee sufficient electricity for industry to keep manufacturing and prevent letting go of every second or third worker? My sense is nobody requires cryptos right now. So for us, that isn't — I'd say our strategic priority #1 is normal course of business once the MOU has been signed. And now we're working alongside Boerse Stuttgart on the specifics and the mechanics of doing it, though we aren't hurrying. And meanwhile, you're aware there's that draft regulation known as MiCA — markets and crypto assets. And until that becomes genuinely clear, we aren't in a rush either. So I'd say our project on that front is normal course of business, and we'll let you know whenever there's news or when we're set to begin. But I believe right now, clients aren't desperately in need of cryptos. And with that, I'll pass things to Mu.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThanks, Frank. Marius, I appreciate your question about the adjusted EBITDA margins. What you're seeing here is that the adjusted EBITDA margin came in at about — it was 40.4%, a bit over 40%. One thing to remember is that when you calculate adjusted EBITDA, you take adjusted EBITDA divided by revenues, but you also have to obviously reduce revenues by the release of the provisions of EUR 7.3 million. So you take the EUR 81.8 million and divide it by EUR 202 million, and that gives you 40.4%. So it's already at a very stable level. And our guidance was very clear. We expect the adjusted EBITDA margin to come in somewhere in line with last year's margin. But again, we see this as a long-term story, and we've been performing for 15 years, and we'll keep performing with our teams and the best effort, and provide the best service and the best products at the best price to our clients. When it comes to short-term profitability and P&L, we will not hit the brakes in a way that hurts us on the longer tail and on the long-term development of our business. So expect — or we expect the margin to be in line with last year's margin, but we will not save EUR 2 million or EUR 3 million in marketing in order to, at the end of the year, optimize our margin by 0.5 or 0.8 percentage points.
Achim Schreck
executiveMoving on to the next question, please.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Christoph Greulich.
Christoph Greulich
analystI have three questions, if I may. First, regarding revenue per trade — it declined a bit in Q2 versus Q1. Could you tell us what drove that change? Second, a quick follow-up on the full-year margin guidance. Do you believe that guidance is achievable across the entire revenue guidance range, or does it instead line up with a particular point within that range, say the midpoint? And finally, on the guidance of 600,000 to 700,000 gross customer adds, what would that translate to on a net basis?
Frank Niehage
executiveMu, go ahead.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveChris, I appreciate the questions. On the first one — revenue per trade, and why it’s lower versus Q1 — let me move to that slide quickly. Here we go: from 539 down to 520. That has a very straightforward explanation, actually. When trading activity falls, it typically affects equity and ETP trades most, right? So the impact of lower transaction activity is bigger on the higher-priced, higher-revenue products than on ETFs, where clients have savings needs and simply keep going with those savings needs. And as you know, our savings needs are very low-profitability products that we offer to clients. So your average gets diluted automatically because you drop. When you drop, the decline is mostly in high-revenue products and much less in low-revenue products. Those are the two main reasons for that. The margin guidance is a margin guidance that we will hit within the bracket we have guided of EUR 400 million to EUR 440 million. And from my perspective, it will be reached at both ends. I don’t see a specific point in the range where we will reach the EBITDA guidance. And by the way, we didn’t provide any adjusted EBITDA guidance specifically. We said it will be somewhere around the last year’s guidance.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThat also leaves room to move by 1 percentage point either way, and we just have to accept that when taking a long-term view. How does customer growth contribute? And how much of that will carry through to the net figure? So for this year, overall, we're assuming a natural, organic churn of roughly 50,000 to 55,000 clients if we annualize the half-year number. And roughly another 50,000 to 60,000 terminated B2B2C clients. That comes both from discontinued B2B offerings and from merging further businesses. So what we're doing right now follows the completed Austria merge between flatex and DEGIRO, and now it's the flatex and DEGIRO Netherlands merge, because as you know, we used to have a business in the Netherlands under the flatex brand. So here too we assume roughly 60,000 additional discontinued client relationships. So altogether, we deduct approximately 120,000 from gross adds, which will then carry through into net adds.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Benjamin Kohnke.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystSorry to circle back to the marketing complex, so to speak. So perhaps beginning with Frank. My apologies — I joined a bit late — but did I hear you right that roughly 20% of the overall marketing budget goes to football and sponsorship? I ask because I'd be curious whether you feel at ease with the level of investment overall in what I'd call branding initiatives, which typically are the kind where the payoff shows up only somewhat later. And you mentioned that you gauge success through customer awareness, which makes sense. I'm just wondering what measures you're using? And if you could sketch a bit of a trajectory, perhaps since Borussia started, that would be great — and it would obviously be great if you keep providing those figures as we go forward, now that Sevilla has been added? And a second question on that subject. Mu, I mean, correct me if I'm wrong, but it sounded somewhat like you're ready to raise your game when it comes to marketing around performance marketing — if I understand you correctly, you believe the customers you're winning in a tough market environment are actually very good customers.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystWith that in mind, I wanted to ask whether you still see the EUR 80 per customer as being at the higher end of the CAC guidance—or of the guidance you've currently provided. Do you remain comfortable with that overall? And let me ask one final question. You've brought up several times the strong success in ETP trading, or your ETP offering. I was wondering whether there's any way to build further on that front—to add more partners, so to speak, and potentially even increase your, let's say, prices or the distribution fee on that. Any insight there would be helpful.
Frank Niehage
executiveYes, I'll begin with those first 2 questions. First of all, you're correct — sports sponsorship accounts for 20% of the budget, and I consider that a pretty healthy figure. We favor a sensible blend across affiliate marketing, sponsorship, and whatever else the situation calls for. And as we've consistently stated, the cost to acquire a client ought not to go above an annualized EUR 100 in total, and that's a commitment we'll maintain. If my memory serves, on a relative basis versus our competitors, that stands as a record low. So we'll keep it that way. We also put a 0 measurement in place prior to launching Borussia. From that point on, we've reviewed it each quarter. Our brand awareness has climbed 300% over that period. So it's been quite a success, though frankly it doesn't shock me, since it was what we anticipated. What matters even more now, with awareness having risen so substantially, is converting those with no awareness of us into new clients — that's the challenge for the second part, so to speak. But the first step always has to come before the second. With that, I'll pass it to Mu for the other question.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveYes. Thanks, Frank. So, in light of the current environment, actually, yes, we can assume the CAC will be — in the first half it was around EUR 100, and we accept that. And I think that will also hold for this year, give or take the guidance we see, which by the way is very much in line with some other years we had in the past, where there were cohorts with EUR 115 as CAC. So given on the one hand that we intensify our brand awareness marketing, that obviously drives CAC, because taking CAC as a metric, we simply divide the number of clients by the marketing by the number of new clients, which is a very simple mathematical function and does not distinguish about efforts like the 20% of our budget that goes into brand awareness. So this is something we feel very confident and comfortable with and will continue to be roughly — or give or take, EUR 100 for this year. Plus, keep in mind, all the tailwind customer adds have dropped away. I think this is something that very often is also forgotten when we think about it compared to the last 2 years.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveDuring the past few years, we enjoyed many windfall client additions that came to DEGIRO and came to flatex, driven by strong awareness of capital markets and strong interest in capital markets. This year, that entire tailwind has disappeared. So winning clients now literally takes hard work. They don't simply show up because people are talking about stocks at a barbecue, drilling into the barbecue about stocks, right? These days, at a barbecue, people talk about inflation and about interest, which makes achieving that zero-cost customer add more difficult and therefore pushes the CAC higher. Regarding your last question, ETPs. The ETP offering is a very solid offering for our business. Over the last 4, 5 years, however, we have reduced the dependency on ETPs from 50% to roughly 20% of our total revenues. We launched the ETPs in France, the Netherlands, and Germany on the DEGIRO side only 6 months ago. And yes, we will keep thinking about additional markets and additional products, but again, in a very sensible way. There are markets where we don't have them yet, such as Italy and Switzerland, for example, where we are, however, active in our client base and where we are discussing with our product partners how to roll out such products.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveBut once more, on this point, it’s something that needs to be done carefully, one step at a time. There’s no hurry—you’ll find the correct approach for doing it. And if we find the correct approach, we’ll go ahead with it. Take Italy: regulation on ETPs was only recently amended there, which now lets you offer OTC ETPs without paying dreadful taxes. Previously, that wasn’t possible. So these developments are opening up more and more flexibility as well when it comes to offering these products in additional countries.
Frank Niehage
executiveAlright, Benny — just one broader point from my end. To start with, the management team is always, and will continue to be, fully on top of things. What does that mean? Should we discover that something is going wrong and costs become necessary, we have the flexibility and the ability to act. What does that mean? Naturally, we don't disclose any specifics regarding our sponsoring partners, and we honor our contractual obligations. Of course, but we stated clearly that we are doing this year with Sevilla, since Gladbach wasn't represented internationally in the coming season, whereas Sevilla is, and it's a fantastic team, and we consider it an honor and a privilege to be the new sponsor. And we also announced that we hold an option to extend. At present, though, we are the sponsor for just the next season. So should we find that anything and everything we anticipate is heading in the wrong direction, we would need to be a sponsor for longer than 12 months. So perhaps that helps you grasp what degree of flexibility exists, should it be necessary. That said, we don't begin something in order to halt it after 12 months, but we do have the flexibility and the right to do so.
Frank Niehage
executiveIf needed, sure. But clearly, we'd rather keep going and build on the successful brand awareness of DEGIRO, not just in Spain, which is our strongest growth market. It was over 250 million -- 250,000 clients already. And we want to enjoy the international presence of Sevilla, but we're flexible on that. Then regarding Borussia, we've expanded and extended our contractual situation for the next 5 years. But we're main sponsor for only the next 2 years. So we're flexible here as well. And obviously, there's a big difference between what one would pay for being main sponsor and then only cosponsor or digital sponsor. And you can rest assured that we've negotiated our position in a way that we're flexible and that's to the advantage of the firm. So all in all, we feel very, very comfortable with those situations. And if necessary, we can act flexible. And this is what you'd expect from management. But as Mu said, and clearly share their view, we don't see any reason to cut costs now or stop doing marketing because we're growing profitable and we're growing in the right direction, and we feel comfortable with what we've started. However, the EUR 50 million budget, we also feel comfortable with and is not excessive in our opinion, especially again, if we compare how much money our peers do spend on marketing, especially the neobrokers.
Frank Niehage
executiveSo once again, we see that it's correct, and we're at ease with it. Yet if a change were required, we would be able to make one.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Mengxian Sun.
Mengxian Sun
analystI’ve got just 2 questions on my end. The first one concerns your marketing expense, or order CAC. So originally, you consistently stated that your target was EUR 50 to EUR 60 for acquiring new customers. Then, during the last quarter, you raised that figure to EUR 80, and now you’ve increased it once more to EUR 100. My question is simply this: what is the upper limit for your marketing expense on customer acquisition? And when do we expect marketing expense to return to the historical level, or to the long-term targets you’ve cited of EUR 50 to EUR 60? The second question is whether you can provide a breakdown of the EUR 38 billion in assets under management. Specifically, how much of that is deposits, and how much is invested in securities?
Frank Niehage
executiveI’ll take the final question first, and then I’ll leave the first one for Mu. So, in my view, it’s just the EUR 38 million in securities.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveIt was not clear.
Frank Niehage
executiveMu, apologies for interrupting you. Please continue.
Muhamad Chahrour
executivePlease proceed. Alright — EUR 35 billion in securities, plus a further EUR 3 billion is...
Frank Niehage
executiveAll right. So then the cash flow has to be subtracted. Right. That said, we could describe most of it as securities. Cash consistently sits around EUR 3 billion, and of course it fluctuates, but securities make up the bulk.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveTo address that point: regarding CAC, EUR 50 to EUR 60 was never the definition of our long-term CAC. We entered this year with guidance to expect roughly EUR 50 million to EUR 60 million, coming off the prior year, without anticipating what is unfolding and what will unfold across these 6 months. I believe none of us anticipated the current environment and the challenging conditions. That is also why, just a couple of weeks ago, we added the historic CAC figures to our portfolio and our corporate presentation deck. What becomes very clear is that historically those numbers always sat roughly between, let's say, EUR 70 and EUR 110. So over the last 10 years, excluding the last 2 years, the average was an upper EUR 80 CAC. And as I said earlier, in response to Ben Kohnke's question, this year we are back at a level with 0 tailwind in customer acquisition. Every single customer must be acquired actively, and no longer by good fortune — people joining DEGIRO or flatex because they had a great conversation with friends or family at the barbecue.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveSo clearly, what that means is the budget remains unchanged, yet the count of new customers—gross adds—goes down, and that pushes CAC higher. That's exactly why CAC is more of, obviously, in the end, an endogenous variable. Our focus is on the budget. We have a budget in mind—the budget we've put in place—that we try to maximize in order to grow clients. And on top of that, we're ramping up brand awareness more and more, though we also didn't have much of that in prior years, apart from now, for the last 2 years, with Borussia, but now also with Sevilla, with the documentary, with a lot of investment into financial literacy as part of our long-term strategy. What's the upper limit when it comes to CAC? Historically, I can tell you there was 1 year that stood at EUR 115. And that year is among the cohorts that rank as the best cohort we ever won in our history. So would we also work to spend EUR 105, EUR 110 for a cohort? I'd say, yes, absolutely. I don't feel—we don't feel, so to speak, reluctant about taking a sensible, long-term view on marketing expenses, as long as they end up generating the right return on investment.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAnd provided that holds, we can also accept EUR 100 in client acquisition costs. We certainly won’t go to EUR 150 or EUR 200. I doubt that. That was never our strategy. It will never be our strategy. But we now see it as consistent with what we had historically — not what we had over the last 2 years, and, frankly, not what we expected for this year at the start of the year, before we knew how the first 6 months of this year would turn out.
Operator
operatorThat seems to be all the questions, sir. The line is yours.
Frank Niehage
executiveYes, then we'll leave it there — thank you all for spending the time and posing those questions, they were very helpful. Many thanks. Let's hope, and keep our fingers crossed, that this war ends sooner rather than later. And hopefully things return to normal as soon as they can. We wish each of you a good day and good health. And bye-bye.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAppreciate it, everybody. Enjoy the rest of your day. Take care.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete flatexDEGIRO SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to flatexDEGIRO SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in flatexDEGIRO SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.