flatexDEGIRO SE (FTK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 28, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and welcome to the analyst call covering flatexDEGIRO's preliminary figures for 2022. I'd like to point out that this call is being recorded, and throughout it your lines will remain in listen-only mode. You will, though, have a chance to pose questions once the call concludes. To register a question, simply press star one on your telephone keypad. Should you need help at any time, press star zero and an operator will assist you. At this point I'll turn things over to your host, Mr. Frank Niehage, CEO, who will open today's conference. Thank you.
Frank Niehage
executiveGood morning, everyone. I'm glad to have you join us for our preliminary earnings call for 2022. Before anything else, I need to begin by offering an apology on behalf of my friend and colleague, Muhamad Chahrour, who is absent because his father passed away and the funeral takes place today. All of us here in Frankfurt extend our condolences to him. So joining the call today is my new colleague, Dr. Benon Janos, our CFO, and of course Achim Schreck, our Head of IR, as usual. The three of us will divide the presentation between us, and I'll begin now. Let me give you a quick summary and a sneak preview of what we've prepared for today, since there's a great deal of information, and I'd like to offer 6 key takeaways from the CEO perspective regarding the presentation. First, where things stand with the regulator. Second, the strength of our financials. Third, our progress on ESG. Fourth, greater transparency going forward. Fifth, improved profitability thanks to cost discipline. And finally, our guidance arrives quite conservative and cautious given the geopolitical situation, inflation, and the interest environment. Naturally, we've factored in today only the status quo as far as actual interest rates are concerned. Let me begin with the situation of our regulator.
Frank Niehage
executiveThe 44 audit has wrapped up, and the project we need to address the findings is progressing as planned. A misdemeanor proceeding has concluded; it concerned incidents from 20 and 21. From an accounting standpoint, the fine is non-material. Having a special representative appointed lets BaFin adjust and post capital measures, and we wouldn't need to wait for a regular follow-up audit in 12 to 24 months. Project teams are pushing ahead on all relevant findings at full steam, with a clear emphasis on form over substance — actually, more form over substance. Two audit firms have cleared our project plan. And lastly, our relationship with the regulator is good. Second, we delivered robust financials in 2022, even though it was one of the toughest years for our industry given the geopolitical situation, inflation, and interest rate hikes. Still, we exceeded EUR 400 million in revenues. We surpassed EUR 183 million in EBITDA, and for the first time in our company's history, we exceeded net profit of over EUR 100 million. As I mentioned, 2022 was a very challenging year. On the commercial side, we brought in over 460,000 new client accounts and settled 67 million transactions.
Frank Niehage
executiveAssets under custody fell just from EUR 43 billion to EUR 39 billion, even though the major indices fell far more, as all of you are aware. That speaks to our clients and demonstrates what kind of clients we have. Third, ESG — environmental, social, and governance. Over the last 12 months we worked very hard to improve. We did so before the audit results came out. Thanks to feedback from several conversations we had with you, our shareholders, we were able to enlarge the management board from 2 to 4 members. We raised the supervisory board members from 3 to 4, and more is to come at the next annual general meeting, which takes place in June. Our ESG rating has improved considerably. With respect to Morningstar, we reached a top 5 position out of 146 companies. Obviously some other ratings have not all been updated yet, but obviously that does not mean we are at the end. We will keep improving here and there and more is to come. Fourth. Going forward we will focus more on transparency. Already today we have given you three new KPIs. The number of new accounts, the number of trades, and the assets under custody.
Frank Niehage
executiveWe'll be doing this on a monthly basis from here on. Fifth, cost discipline will drive improved profitability. As we've already stated, guiding trades is something we'll stop doing, since during these challenging times it simply isn't serious anymore. As I noted, we've rolled out monthly KPIs, which gives you greater transparency. We've also made the decision to discontinue sports sponsoring going forward, even though it worked very well for brand awareness — you'll see that later in our presentation. Brand awareness rose considerably over the past couple of years, but our future focus will lean more toward conversion. The Sevilla sponsorship ends in summer, and in 2024 we'll become co-sponsor of Borussia Mönchengladbach, continuing in that co-sponsor role until 2027, as contractually agreed. As a result, the marketing budget will drop significantly in the years ahead. My colleague, Dr. Benon Janos, will give you further details later. We'll still outgrow our competitors, but with a stronger emphasis on profitability. Higher interest rates will add substantially on top of all of this. Once again, my colleague will share more details. Let's shift gears now. I'm happy to hand things over to Dr.
Frank Niehage
executiveNext, our CFO, Benon Janos.
Benon Janos
executiveGood morning. If we look at the U.S. market as an illustration, the S&P 500 ended 2022 with a loss of 19.4%. That ranks as the seventh worst performance for this index going back over 90 years. 2022 is on par with the Great Depression, the 2000 dot-com bust, or the 2008 great financial crisis. And to make things worse, bond investments this time around also dropped substantially in value because of the sharply rising interest rate environment, which further dampened interest in trading and investing. Even so, flatexDEGIRO managed to produce its second-best financial year in terms of revenue and its best year in terms of reported net income. We saw muted customer trading activity across the industry, with roughly 67 million trades within our group in 2022. At the same time, in the second half of 2022, and especially in Q4, we saw a first positive effect from higher interest rates. Our customer base kept growing at double digits, and we continued to see net cash inflow onto our platform. At EUR 407 million, we saw a decline of approximately 3% from the reported 2021 revenues of EUR 417 million. A more accurate picture, which excludes positive one-off effects of approximately EUR 38 million from releases under the long-term variable compensation plan, gives adjusted revenues of EUR 369 million, which in turn represents a 12% decline from the reported 2021 revenue figures.
Benon Janos
executiveI'll come back to this with more detail shortly. Adjusted revenues of EUR 369 million break down into EUR 272 million of commission income, EUR 72 million of interest income, and roughly EUR 25 million of other income. To show how muted trading has been in Europe, we've charted daily average revenue trades per customer and set that against industry trends. Our trajectory across the year lines up with what other European peers are reporting. A strong 2022 Q1, with almost 22 million trades, gave way to two spring and summer quarters of 16.2 million and 15.3 million trades respectively, then a further drop in Q4 to 13.6 million trades. Yesterday, for the first time — and we'll get into this later — we published January trade numbers of 5.3 million. That's up 25% month-over-month. For the month of January, it's down 28% year-on-year. A similar, though not identical, pattern shows up in our customer growth figure of 462,000 additional accounts on a gross basis. A seasonally strong Q1 with 185,000 net additions was followed by three similar quarters of gross additions, was followed by three similar quarters of approximately 90,000 gross additions per quarter, producing a customer account growth rate of more than 20% versus the end of 2021 or the beginning of 2022 respectively.
Benon Janos
executiveWhen we break down how accounts grew, net customer growth looks like this: ordinary churn came to minus 53,000, which works out to a retention rate of nearly 98%, and that still left us with 409,000 net customer account additions. All told, we off-boarded 73,000 customers, reflecting, 1, the closure of the DEGIRO Austria brand. 2, the discontinuation of the flatex brand in the Netherlands, as well as, 3, the exit from the Norwegian. 4, Hungarian market for our brand, DEGIRO. On top of that, 5, a number of B2B accounts were also terminated after ending of the respective business relationships. That leaves us with a resulting net customer account growth figure of 336,000 clients, which puts us above comparable peers in Europe. Commission per trade began at EUR 4.26 per trade in Q1, and fell to EUR 3.90 in the fourth quarter. You can see this in the smaller percentage of high revenues transaction compared to, for example, savings plans. The latter tends to be more stable throughout the year, given more regular automated executions. So in a less active trading environment, the relative share of such constant savings plans increase. The slide reflects the organic decline of -18% in our brokerage business, with adjusted EBITDA of EUR 145 million for 2022, compared to EUR 177 million in 2021.
Benon Janos
executiveThe two EBITDA figures shown here have been adjusted for one-off personnel costs tied to long-term variable compensation, and for 2021 they were also adjusted for personal expenses connected with the flatexDEGIRO Bank and DEGIRO B.V. merger. Our marketing spend in 2022 came to EUR 49 million. Across both 2021 and 2022, marketing expenses landed in the EUR 45 to 50 million range, propelled by producing and distributing the Europe-wide documentary, True Stories of Investing, along with additional campaigns to raise brand awareness. How marketing expenses evolved over the course of 2022 demonstrates our ability to scale our marketing spend back on fairly short notice depending on the market environment. That is something we will keep doing in 2023. I'll come back to this point later. Turning to brand awareness, we have managed to raise it successfully across our key markets, and we now regard this portion of the group marketing efforts as accomplished, finalized, and finished. Let me offer a remark on how our assets under custody have developed. At flatexDEGIRO, assets under custody fell from EUR 43.8 billion to EUR 39.5 billion at year-end 2022, a decline of only -10%. Securities overall dropped from EUR 41 billion to EUR 36.2 billion, while clients' cash deposits rose from EUR 2.8 billion to roughly EUR 3.2 billion.
Benon Janos
executiveA stabilizing factor for securities under custody was the euro's decline against the US dollar in 2022. Let me at this point refer, for a second time, to the January 2023 figures we published yesterday, which show total assets under custody at the end of January 2023 of EUR 43.5 billion, and of that, EUR 3.5 billion in cash. Gross cash customer inflows of EUR 13.4 billion in 2022 were offset by EUR 7.5 billion of normal withdrawals, giving a net cash inflow figure of EUR 5.9 billion. Roughly EUR 5.2 billion was reinvested into financial markets on our platform, bringing the number down to approximately EUR 0.6 billion. Of that EUR 0.6 billion, about a third can be attributed to a reduction of our margin loans outstanding, with the remaining EUR 0.4 billion representing the positive cash under custody development from end of 2022 versus end of 2021. Let us now move onto our strategy going forward. Despite all challenges, we delivered a financially solid 2022. What is the underlying outlook for our 2023 guidance and our midterm ambition? After 14 years of sustainable growth, 2 years of an abnormally bullish brokerage environment during COVID, the meme stock hype and zero interest rate policies, only to be followed in 2022 by the worst year with respect to retail brokerage sentiment in our history, we focus towards a strategy of higher profitability growth.
Benon Janos
executiveOn one hand, that involves refining what we offer and how we price it, and growing our share of the market by drawing on our strengths and know-how, while also bringing in long-term trading clients across continental Europe. On the other hand, a major part of this strategy will be concentrating on our margins as we mature through our corporate evolution. That covers tighter monitoring of operational costs, lowering our cost base via operational improvements, along with general cost management. We want to make sure we are getting the most out of our margins and are well placed to deliver sustained margin improvement. Together with customer growth, our strategy will also center on delivering higher profitability to our shareholders. The product and marketing strategies we put in place, plus the prevailing environment, made possible unusually strong periods of client growth in 2020 and 2021. Since 2020, our customer base has grown by almost 200%. We recognize that the environment has shifted. Looking ahead, we must place more priority than before on the quality of growth, the quality of our products and services, and on improving the overall client experience. We continue to have faith in the secular trends of digitization and rising financial literacy, particularly in the underdeveloped continental European markets, where our positioning is very unique.
Benon Janos
executiveThe pace differs from what we previously projected. First point from today's outlook session: the Vision 2026 targets of extremely high growth that we set out two years ago — 7 to 8 million clients — have been reworked in light of the changed environment and will be officially abandoned. Our Triple P strategy — platform, product and price — was central to the sustainable success we achieved previously. That set us apart from rivals and will keep shaping where the company goes next. Customer growth that is long-term yet sustainable, discipline on costs, and margins to match. We will keep expanding the Pan-European best investment platform. Across the last three years, we succeeded in establishing flatex and DEGIRO as the quality broker in most growth markets, with substantial sums put into brand awareness and indirect marketing, as the brand awareness overview shown a few minutes ago illustrated. Going forward, we will direct our marketing spending primarily toward targeted marketing and pull marketing. This means using our data and analytics to lift conversion in existing markets and to invest more effectively in drawing trading-oriented clients — which brings us to the second point. Our marketing strategy will shift toward more targeted marketing.
Benon Janos
executiveSo because of that — and Frank Niehage already mentioned this — flatex/DEGIRO is going to stop the main sponsor brand awareness activities with European football clubs. That means football-related marketing costs will come down beginning in 2024, and it results in the largest single digit million cost saving each year. After years of investing in building our brand, we're going to concentrate on bringing in and keeping high quality clients. Putting our products and platform first, and rolling out products that already exist into new geographies, is a key low-hanging synergy that pays off over the long run on both customer growth and margin. Third takeaway: we intend to push our operational margins up toward the benchmark margins of established and mature local European players. The market is generally expected to grow midterm at the speed of high single percentage. We intend to grow our customer base 1.5 to 2 times faster than our benchmark peers, because we have the advantage of our distinctive footprint in 16 countries, which lets us allocate marketing spending efficiently across those geographies. For more than a decade, both brands, flatex and DEGIRO, have been price leaders when it comes to quality brokerage services. We have always focused on maximizing the value we deliver to our clients by offering an exceptionally broad range of products and services.
Benon Janos
executiveWe’ll keep working on refining how we set prices and generate revenue as well. At the time we bought DEGIRO, we made clear that a proper balance had to be struck between expanding and earning a profit. During 2020 and 2021, with conditions so favorable, expansion clearly took priority. Then in 2022, we gained from products we had recently launched and from raising prices in selected cases at DEGIRO. Our fourth point is that we’ll examine further which product and pricing approaches make sense in order to strengthen margins and create lasting value for shareholders, while still giving clients the strongest investing experience available in the market. Across the last 2 years, revenue per trade went up from roughly EUR 4 to over EUR 5, and our medium-term goal is to move it closer to the EUR 6 range. Starting January 1st, we raised margin loan pricing at DEGIRO and flatex by 1 percentage point apiece, which only partly mirrors the ECB interest rate situation. In earlier years, at the start of each year we gave guidance for total trades in that year. Management can affect business metrics like customer growth or monetization incentives, yet clients’ trading activity is extremely hard to predict reliably. Market conditions, investor sentiment, and other outside factors may heavily affect trading volume and liquidity, as has been visible in each of the last 3 years in a row.
Benon Janos
executiveSince we can't reliably predict what clients will do, the fifth takeaway is that we'll stop giving guidance on trade numbers. When we get to the 2023 guidance in a minute, there's obviously an underlying assumption about trade number that we use to derive revenue guidance. Let us be very clear on this point. That 2023 figure is a variable dependent on the current environment, and it is not a formal guidance or estimate for trade count, either for the full year or over the mid-term. Before we finish discussing the top-line drivers, one more item on transparency. Because we no longer forecast client and transaction numbers, we'd like to close with the sixth takeaway, which we already flagged. As of yesterday, we will disclose monthly commercial numbers, including the gross account growth figure for number of transactions, assets under custody, among other items. We hope this lets the market follow and understand the development of our top-line drivers better. It also aligns with peer benchmark standards and strengthens governance. These numbers will be published on the third working day of each month for the prior month. I'll now briefly hand things over to Achim Schreck, our Head of Investor Relations, who will share a few more facts about our monthly reporting going forward.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks, Benon, and hello from me too. As we said earlier, since we're not giving guidance on trade numbers anymore, we think it's fair to the market—and useful—to share the monthly development of those commercial KPIs. That means not only the latest month and the one before it, but also a 13-month overview, which we think will help everyone get a better sense of seasonal patterns and how things develop across the year for all the KPIs mentioned—customer account growth on both a gross and a net basis, plus how our assets under custody are developing, including the split between securities and cash held by clients, along with current levels of the margin loan book. On top of that, trading activities—again broken out in what we see as a very relevant way for assessing the business: high revenue trades, so products such as stocks and bonds, versus lower revenue trades like ETFs and savings plans. As Benno mentioned, we'll publish those figures each morning on the third working day following month-end. You'll have that data available in line with peer publication as well.
Achim Schreck
executiveBenon, I'll turn it back over to you.
Benon Janos
executiveOne last point before we get to guidance. Since our business is now at a mature stage, we can direct marketing spending carefully toward the markets where we're most affected, which lets us make sure we're getting the most out of every marketing dollar and cutting back on investments that underperform. In recent years, we put substantial money into building brand awareness. The moment has come to capitalize on that and concentrate on conversion. Let me restate that second takeaway. Once the contracts expire, we've chosen to end our primary sponsored brand partnerships with Borussia Mönchengladbach and FC Sevilla, and that will save a significant EUR single-digit million amount each year from 2024 onward. Guidance. Our 2023 revenue guidance rests on an assumed trade number of 65 million transactions and is based roughly on trading activity from Q2 through Q4 of 2022. That assumed trade number could come in higher or lower, depending on external factors. Probably half of the analysts will agree with that figure, while half are somewhat more optimistic. Once more, we have no explicit control over that number, but we still want to offer a perspective. If we assume a trade number of EUR 65 million and forecast a commission per trade of EUR 4.10, then we expect commission income of approximately EUR 265 million.
Benon Janos
executiveOn top of that, we'll be monetizing client deposits at both ends. For margin loans, we're assuming an average volume of EUR 900 million. With an expected average yield of 4%, that adds another EUR 36 million. For the short-term dated treasury portfolio, we assume an average of EUR 2.5 billion, with an average yield equal to the current ECB deposit rate of EUR 2.5 million, which contributes EUR 62.5 million. Both the margin loan book and the treasury book are assumptions only and may fluctuate with trading activity, customer deposits, and customer growth. The same applies to yields, which as of today appear to be trending upward, and possible rate cuts may not be fully reflected. The year is long, and we could also see interest rate cuts later in the year. Adding other operational income of EUR 15 million from our B2B brokerage business, we expect total revenue of EUR 380 million for 2023. For informational purposes, we assume costs of goods sold remain at 17%-19% of total revenues. Deviations could also arise here based on assets under custody and therefore cost of custody, along with various exchange fees that may change.
Benon Janos
executiveWhen it comes to 2023, our guidance for operational expenses — that covers personnel, marketing, and general and administrative costs — sits in the EUR 150 million to EUR 160 million range. That figure reflects a tighter marketing budget as well as structural cost savings. Thanks to these steps, we'll be able not only to keep building a solid regulatory framework but also to run a cost-effective business model that produces more sustainable results. The marketing budget for 2023, expected to land at roughly mid 30 million EUR, is a major contributor to those operational cost savings — considerably below 2022, when we came in close to EUR 50 million. To clarify things and head off any surprises after the Q1 results, we want to flag, as we usually do, that the quarterly split of the marketing budget in 2022 is similar to 2022, meaning 40% to up to 50% of the 2023 budget gets spent and allocated in Q1 of 2023. That's given the seasonal high client interest at the start of each year in changing his or her brokerage provider or opening a new brokerage account. At the same time, we'll keep investing in areas of regulatory importance. With all that said, we'll be working toward growing our margins. The number of trades is a key margin driver, since each additional trade brings in an incremental more than EUR 4 in commission and converts into 80% bottom line margin.
Benon Janos
executiveTransaction counts aren't something we can directly steer. That said, after the first 2 months of live business and with our attention on operating costs, we're confident that 2023 will already bring a margin improvement over 2022. On those assumptions, our expectation for 2023 is an adjusted EBITDA margin of 40% plus, together with an adjusted profit before tax margin of 30% plus. The adjustments, as ever, cover solely the building and releasing of provisions for long-term variable employee compensation — nothing beyond that. Now let me pull together the assumptions behind this year's guidance. To begin with, trading activity is beyond our control and hinges largely on outside factors. The trading figures from January and February back up the assumptions we've made. We've put certain operating cost measures in place that will help margins expand over the medium term, and the first effects should show up this year. Across recent weeks, we've examined where things stand with diligence and we see clearly the areas where our strategy needs sharpening. We've enjoyed 15 successful years. Among the leading mature online brokers, we're a Pan-European player with plenty of additional potential ahead of us. We'll keep seizing market opportunities as they arise. Still, our day-to-day attention will stay on what we can control.
Benon Janos
executiveWe achieved solid, high-quality customer growth along with robust margin generation, all while reinforcing governance across our regulated business. Many thanks for listening. At this point, we'd like to begin the Q&A session.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, just a quick reminder — if you want to ask a question or make a contribution on today's call, go ahead and press star one on your telephone keypad now. If you'd like to withdraw your question, press star two. Our first question is from Marius Fuhrberg at Warburg Research. Please go ahead.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystOkay, hi everyone, and thanks for taking my question. I’ve got a few from my side. First, regarding BaFin: the appointment of a special representative by BaFin — should we view that more as an indication of how severe the special audit that was conducted was? How should we think about what the specific role of this special representative is? Second, also on BaFin, what’s your expectation on risk mitigation for the DEGIRO margin loans, and when will they be usable again, or what’s your schedule on this? Another question on marketing: you mentioned that you plan to have about EUR 50 million in marketing. Looking at last year, this breaks down to customer acquisition costs of around EUR 106 per additional customer, whereas in previous times this was rather in the area of around EUR 50. Should we expect this figure to remain that high, especially for 2023, or how do you look at that? Lastly, just for confirmation: when you say that you’re growing stronger than peers and all the figures you compare to competitors, you refer to listed competitors. Am I wrong? Am I right there? This does not include probably your main competitor, Trade Republic, which is private, right?
Frank Niehage
executiveAll right, Marius, thank you for those questions. I'll begin, and then I'll pass things over to Dr. Benon Janos. Regarding where things stand with BaFin, here's what you need to understand. Under the ordinary course of business, following an audit 44, the earliest a follow-up audit would occur is in 12 to 24 months. That is how the normal procedure works. Because we have a special representative auditor arriving by the end of the first quarter, there is an opportunity to modify the imposed measures together with BaFin sooner rather than waiting for that follow-up audit. Secondly, the special representative auditor will look at how we have improved on those findings and will of course take samples and report back to BaFin, which will then reach a conclusion on whether the measures stay in place or can be removed. I believe that covers everything on your... The second part concerned what this means for the margin loans. On the margin loans, should the auditor and BaFin jointly conclude that the measures can be lifted, then our 75% risk-weighted view on DEGIRO's margin loans would no longer apply, and we would be able to return to the old view, under which there are 0 risk-weighted assets.
Frank Niehage
executiveClearly, that would release EUR 75 million in regulatory capital. Benon.
Benon Janos
executiveGlad to take the second set of questions. Regarding marketing spend, you noted in your question that we intend to invest EUR 50 million during 2023. What we actually expect for 2023 is closer to the mid EUR 30 million range — so roughly EUR 35 million or EUR 36 million. And yes, you're correct that our targeted marketing efforts should bring down the customer acquisition cost for each new account; with the initiatives and figures we've shared, we anticipate that cost will fall. Your last question concerned how we stack up against competitors. My colleague, Achim Schreck, can wrap that one up, but let me begin by saying that whenever competitors and peers have reported their numbers properly, we're glad to draw on them. A lot of them — especially the privately held ones — just don't make public data available, and that makes it difficult to put a precise figure on any such comparison. Achim, please jump in as needed.
Achim Schreck
executiveYeah. No, absolutely. Right. Naturally, comparing data requires dependable official figures—that's point one. The other thing we want to be clear about, certainly, is that the new brokers both inside and beyond Germany aren't who we'd regard as our primary market peers, since they target an entirely different kind of customer. We've emphasized for a long stretch, and again in the presentation just now, that we concentrate on high-quality clients—individuals with trading experience and a profile unlike those peers—which we think also justifies comparing ourselves instead to the listed peers. Sure.
Frank Niehage
executiveNext question, please.
Operator
operatorIan White from Autonomous Research is on the line with the next question. You may proceed.
Ian White
analystHello there. Thank you for the presentation and for fielding my questions. I have just a couple from my end, please. Could you walk us through the progress achieved so far regarding the additional hiring that I believe was referenced in the December update, in connection with the special audit's findings? Are you able to give us a sense of the total extra costs needed to remediate those special audit findings, and whether they sit within your 2023 guidance, please? A sense of that would be helpful, I think. Then second, just some sensitivities concerning commission revenue per trade. Could you tell us what percentage of trades in 4Q were regular investing trades? And what the average commission revenue per trade was there, please? Just so we can understand how that might shift if activity were to recover. Thank you.
Frank Niehage
executiveOkay, and thanks for the questions, Ian. I'll begin. On the hiring front, we've brought in a new head and a new deputy for regulatory reporting, and we've added more staff there as well. A new head of internal audit has also been hired, along with a deputy. More staff will be added. We've also appointed someone to run internal controls globally across our group and have hired people reporting to that person. Headcount in the compliance department has gone up too. Overall, the key positions have been filled. The individuals who were responsible in the past for those findings that formed part of the misdemeanor proceedings have departed from the company. In my view, we've made great progress. The total added cost, I'd say, comes to a single-digit million figure — a mid-single-digit million figure — as a result of those proceedings, the fine, and the additional cost. From where we stand, that is reasonable, and that addresses the first part of your questions. I'll hand over to my colleagues for the other part.
Benon Janos
executiveYou asked specifically about the share of higher revenue trades in the fourth quarter, if I got that right, and that figure is 71%. What we don't do is disclose how many high revenue trades there are in absolute terms, nor the absolute value of a high revenue trade versus one that isn't a high revenue trade. Hopefully that answers your questions.
Ian White
analystThat's useful. Regarding the second point, I was trying to get at the... I'm just considering the flip side of that figure. In 4Q, 29% of the trade was essentially regular monthly investing trades. My understanding was that those are charged at roughly EUR 1 per transaction. Is that correct, please? Thinking about the sensitivity from there.
Benon Janos
executiveWe don't reveal that figure. That assumption isn't incorrect — depending on how many savings plans there are, and plenty of them come at zero cost, the number could in fact be somewhat lower. We don't track that number properly, nor do we communicate it.
Ian White
analystUnderstood. Thanks.
Frank Niehage
executiveMoving on to the next question.
Operator
operatorRight now, we don't have any questions coming in. One last reminder: if you want to ask something, press star 1 at this time. Marius Fuhrberg from Warburg Research is on the line once more with the next question. Go ahead, please.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystI have just one quick follow-up question. About the new monthly figures you're now publishing, which I really appreciate. In the transaction share you report for cash products as well as ETF and funds, there's a shortfall from reaching 100% of, more or less, 10% previously. Would it be fair to think those 10% relate mainly to ETP trades?
Benon Janos
executiveHello, this is Benon Janos. Hi there, Marius. No — those aren't ETP trades. They cover every other type of trade: CFDs, Forex, and so on. ETP trades would fall under the cash product.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorOur next question is from Christoph Blieffert at BNP Paribas Exane. Christoph, please go ahead.
Christoph Blieffert
analystGood morning, and thanks for taking my question. My first question concerns pricing. We've noticed that Baader Bank has now put in place a monthly service fee of EUR 3. Since competitors are raising their prices, are you planning to lift your own pricing and to enhance monetization further as the year goes on? Second, on deposits. Deposits per client are fairly low at your bank. Why haven't you been more aggressive with the deposit rate and used higher rates on deposits to attract new customers? My third question is about capital. Could you remind us of your SREP requirement and of the minimum capital ratio that you would feel comfortable with going forward? Thank you.
Benon Janos
executiveOn your first question about pricing, you mentioned a monthly service fee. We have no plans to roll out a monthly service fee. I want to be quite clear and open about that. But, as was alluded to earlier, we do intend, naturally, to grow monetization. During the presentation, we provided a couple of examples. As a reminder, perhaps on one of them, we are raising, and have already raised, the prices on our margin loans by 1%. That is plainly far below what has happened in the interest rate environment. Yes, we intend to keep monetizing the platform, though not through introducing a monthly service fee.
Frank Niehage
executiveSure, Christoph, glad to take that second question. Why aren't we being more aggressive on deposits? To start with, flatexDEGIRO's clients are equity-driven, not fixed income-driven — that's always been the case. Second, we had significant inflows last year, even though the interest rate environment had already shifted, and in our history we've never paid interest, since our clients use that cash to trade and, as I mentioned, they're more of an alpha or equity-driven type of client, not interest-driven. We have no plans to introduce interest on the trading deposit. At the end of the day, as I said, clients aren't fixed income-driven, and we provide account services and safe custody account services at no charge. Some of our products carry no trading fees. That's part of our business model, and we don't intend to change it. Even without changing that, we're seeing a lot of new clients come in and a lot of cash coming in from our clients, which validates our story. For the last part of your question, I'll hand it back to Benno.
Benon Janos
executiveThe final question was about the SREP figure, and that comes to 5% at the group level. All the details on it will be made available, as we always do, through our Basel Pillar 3 transparency report, which comes out at the end of April.
Christoph Blieffert
analystJust to clarify, you mentioned that your SREP requirement is 5%?
Benon Janos
executiveYou've got that right.
Christoph Blieffert
analystRegarding the CET1 side?
Benon Janos
executiveCould you clarify what you're referring to exactly? You mean the total capital ratios?
Christoph Blieffert
analystYes.
Benon Janos
executiveWhat about the overall cap? At the close of 2022, our total overall requirement came in at 15.56%.
Achim Schreck
executiveAlright, that’s very clear. Thanks.
Operator
operatorBenjamin Goy from KBW has the next question. Go right ahead.
Benjamin Goy
analystMorning, gentlemen, and thanks for taking my question too. This is a follow-up to the previous speaker, generally on the topic of price increases. Benno, from your presentation it sounded like you're focused more on potential price hikes rather than, say, winning extra customers through price cuts. It seems the experience was good with raising handling fees at DEGIRO, for example — obviously, the introduction of FX fees. Are there any plans to adjust pricing upward further in your underlying product offering? That would be my first question. Second — it's a bit hard to grasp, or rather intangible, when you elaborate or allude to product innovation or further improving your product offering in what I guess is a rather commoditized market. If you could maybe give some sort of, I don't know, sneak preview, or elaborate a little further on what you may potentially be thinking about when you talk about further product innovation, product adjustments. Maybe lastly, potentially related to that as well, perhaps a quick update on partnerships — and I guess the robo is the one that's most advanced. I mean, maybe if you want to say a word on crypto as well, and arguably, you know, still crypto winter, but just generally I wanted to get an understanding of how partnerships work on your platform.
Benjamin Goy
analystIf you’re seeing solid adoption—or adoption in line with what you expected from your client base—and if there are, you know, plans to keep adding partners moving forward. Thank you.
Frank Niehage
executiveOkay, perhaps I'll begin with your question that's a bit on the intangible side. For the robo-advice offering, we've now launched the friends and family phase. That's proceeding according to plan. As for crypto, we aren't rushing things given what we'd call these crypto winter times. When it comes to additional product innovation, we want to give clients in both our core markets and our growth markets the ability to trade ETP products. We've already begun that work, and further developments will follow. Naturally, we prefer to announce once everything is confirmed and we're actually launching it, rather than ahead of time. Meanwhile, our strong emphasis is on the internal 44 enhancement tied to the findings we've identified. We're putting substantial effort into settling the issues that were identified concerning DEGIRO's margin loans, so that regulatory capital can be freed up. That's where our attention lies, and we remain focused on it, and we'd like to report back once it's been resolved, after the fact. I'll now hand things over to Benno.
Benon Janos
executiveOkay, so I'll take the first part of your question, which is about price increases and how we run the platform. You said that we sort of have no plans to bring in new clients. Well, that's obviously not really the situation. We still intend to grow, and new clients will keep adding to the business and revenues we already have. On price increases, we don't intend to do anything revolutionary like bringing in a service fee, which I already ruled out earlier. It will be an evolutionary move that lets us take part in the broad trends from the inflation environment we're in and the general inclination toward raising prices. I'm glad to give you one example. You also asked about product innovation. Our exchange-traded products business at DEGIRO is in the process of being ported into other geographies, and we are rolling that product out right now. Whereas previously, clients in ex-countries can benefit from those transactions. Coming this year, we will add a few more countries, for example, Italy, to be included in that. Having 16 countries and a broad shelf of products lets us position them as needed and as demanded by the local customer base.
Benjamin Goy
analystExcellent. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorOur final question is from Mengxian Shen at Deutsche Bank. The line is yours.
Mengxian Shen
analystHello, and thanks so much for taking my questions. Most of them have already been covered, so I’ll finish with just one more about expanding the business geographically. You said that you exited Norway—could you share what your focus will be for the next year? I’m hoping to get a sense of whether any additional off-boarding activities are expected to take place next year. Thank you.
Frank Niehage
executiveAppreciate the question. There aren't any additional markets we intend to exit. Our attention is on those 16 markets. In Norway and Hungary, the currencies differ from the euro. Sure, simplification appeals to us, but the primary driver was that client wins in those two countries were limited, particularly when set against the other 16 markets. So to concentrate and streamline, we exited, and the client count there was small. Achim, the figure is yours.
Benon Janos
executiveSix thousand across the two countries put together.
Frank Niehage
executiveYeah, 6,000 across both countries put together, so that wasn't really much. Keep in mind that Hungary and Norway were already in when we bought DEGIRO. Not much has happened over there across the last couple of years. So we're focusing on the remaining 16 countries, and there are no plans to change that for the time being.
Mengxian Shen
analystAlright, thanks a lot.
Frank Niehage
executiveThanks. With no more questions coming in, I'll pass things back to your host for the close of today's conference.
Benon Janos
executiveYeah. Thanks, everyone, for spending some time with us, and many thanks to you, and we hope each of you has a great day. Bye-bye.
Operator
operatorMuch appreciated for being on the call today. You can go ahead and hang up now. Hi there. Am I coming through clearly?
Benon Janos
executiveHello.
Operator
operatorHi everyone.
Benon Janos
executiveHello there.
Operator
operatorHi everyone, this is Ben. We’ve now returned to the host room. From where I was, the sound came through extremely clearly. The audio quality was quite crisp. I have to say, that went pretty well. We had about 12 or 13 participants today. I’ll send you the list right after this call — you should get it in around 10 to 15 minutes.
Benon Janos
executiveAll right, excellent. Thanks a lot.
Operator
operatorAll right. That's completely fine. Don't give it a second thought. Yan.
Benon Janos
executiveRight.
Operator
operatorWe’ll talk later, all right?
Benon Janos
executiveAll right. You're handling the second one today as well?
Operator
operatorI’m not certain. No, I’m unable to view it on my.
Benon Janos
executiveAlright.
Operator
operatorMy listing.
Benon Janos
executiveAlright.
Operator
operatorProbably somebody else will handle that. All right?
Benon Janos
executiveAlright.
Operator
operatorOkay, thank you, Yan, for spending time with us, and enjoy the remainder of your day.
Benon Janos
executiveThanks to you as well.
Operator
operatorWe’ll talk with you on the next call. Bye.
Benon Janos
executiveYes. Goodbye.
Operator
operatorTake care. Appreciate it.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete flatexDEGIRO SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to flatexDEGIRO SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in flatexDEGIRO SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.