flatexDEGIRO SE (FTK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 25, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and thank you for joining us for the flatexDEGIRO Preliminary Results Half Year 2023 Analyst Call. I'd like to point out that this session is being recorded. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll turn things over to our CEO, Frank Niehage, so he can get today's conference underway. The floor is yours, sir.
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. Good morning, everyone. Frank Niehage here. A warm welcome to our half year preliminary results 2023. Warm greetings from Tegernsee, where we are marking the 10th anniversary with <<inaudible>>. The team is present here at the trainings camp. With us are my Management Board colleagues, Dr. Benon Janos, Stephan Simmang, Muhamad Chahrour and myself, and of course our Head of IR, Achim Schreck. A very, very warm welcome from Tegernsee. We're glad to speak with you today about very robust numbers, and before we get into details, a personal note. We also had to announce today that, unfortunately, Muhamad Chahrour has made his own decision to leave the firm by end of this year. As professionals, we prefer to focus on the firm's result first, and then, Muh will give you a bit more detail at the end of this call regarding his personal motivation, which I regret on one hand, but I have to respect, and you will see on the personal side, why there are reasons that he will and has to leave us. However, let's please begin with the firm first. Let's begin with our highlights. I will always start as usual and then hand over to Muh, and he will shift gears and drill down into commercial and financial aspects more in detail.
Frank Niehage
executiveI’m glad to reaffirm the guidance we’ve given, even though conditions are quite difficult. Obviously, the geopolitical situation in Europe, the interest rate hikes, and high inflation will affect—and are affecting—our business. Even so, we are confirming guidance, and we also have a strongly positive view of the second half because of the steps we’ve taken, and we’ll provide more detail on that very soon. I’ll begin as well with the regulatory backdrop, and let me take a brief moment on where things stand regarding our German BaFin regulator, and after that I’ll discuss the UP level, PFOF, which will also have a serious effect on our industry. Let me begin with the BaFin matter that is well known. We are very encouraged that we have made the process fully automated and have developed and implemented the credit risk mitigation techniques, and that took hard work, but we worked very closely with BaFin and our special auditor, and we have submitted all the relevant information. So on our side, the work is complete, which is very good news, and the process is running and has been implemented. It is now for the commissioner to take his samples, review everything, and report back to BaFin.
Frank Niehage
executiveWe feel quite good about the fact that by the end of September we'll receive feedback on this, and we hope that afterward we'll be in a position, and permitted, to apply the credit risk mitigation once more, since for a time we weren't allowed to. Naturally, we keep focusing on the other findings and continue working through them. What matters regarding bringing on new staff, putting new processes in place, and running that project has already been accomplished. So it's live and operating. And let me note that following an audit, it's standard practice, and it takes over 12 months to 24 months to address those findings that drive improvement, and that is exactly what we're doing. You already know the good news regarding the SREP. Our capital requirement came down by 75 basis points. Again, an initial step in the right direction. Broadly, we'll keep enhancing this overall situation wherever we can. So those are the encouraging developments on our German situation. Let me turn to the EU level. Again, from where I sit, good news — and why is that? To me, the PFOF ban is what makes the single market deal work. The single market demands fair rules for everyone, which in the past and right up to now has not been the case in certain countries such as the Netherlands and the U.K., where you aren't permitted to receive a payment for order flow, while in others you are.
Frank Niehage
executiveFrom where I sit, the EU is heading in the right direction and will end up applying identical rules to all of us. As usual, a transition window runs from January 2024 through 2026, during which member states can opt for a different arrangement. That said, it makes no difference to us, since more than 99% of our revenues, as we have consistently stated, do not depend on any payment for order flow. So in my view, that's positive news for our industry. Broadly speaking, it's good news for us and good news for our clients. Why? Because with no impact, we won't need to raise prices—say, on the 4,500 ETF and saving plans, the way it's being discussed in the media here. And we'll keep going, particularly in Germany, with our price model at flatex EUR 5.90 per trade, which has stood for over 20 years. We have never changed that, and we won't change it. So once again, this is news pointing in the right direction. Naturally, we'll keep monitoring the retail investment strategy and report back whenever there are any changes or effects on our industry. That covers the regulatory environment.
Frank Niehage
executiveLet me go back over governance once more. As we’ve consistently stated, our governance will keep getting better and evolving, and at the Annual General Meeting—something you’re all well aware of—Britta Lehfeldt was appointed. That brings us to 5 Supervisory Board members, and we’re glad to be even more diverse than we were previously, and all of us look forward to working successfully alongside Britta Lehfeldt, as we already began doing at the bank. And the vote at the general assembly during the Annual General Meeting was positive. So once again, as we’ve always said, we’re moving in the right direction when it comes to governance. Of course, let me also point to a few business matters. Clearly, we’ve strengthened our ties with the ETP partners, and we’re very happy and proud that JPMorgan is now our platinum partner. The collaboration is excellent, and we’re delighted about that partnership—everything is on track and running smoothly. Quite a long time ago, we said we were working on a digital wealth product, and we’re pleased that our partnership with Whitebox—whom we’ve known on the B2B side for many, many years—is now live on the B2C side too, and flatex wealth has launched and gotten going this month.
Frank Niehage
executiveWhat we're aiming at here is potential new clients—people who don't make those decisions on their own but prefer to go with a managed strategy. And our hope is that government clients, who haven't been trading at all for a long, long time, might, rather than doing nothing, opt for an alternative when they consider what that wealth management product could offer. So we wish this well. And I'll go on to the adjustments. We made these particularly at DEGIRO. We raised the rate on our loan product. And obviously, interest rates went up over recent months, so we made adjustments here too regarding our credit product and improved it. And we did a little on the commissions for U.S. trades and local trades. All of this together will have a big impact in the second half, and we're looking forward to that. Once again, in Spain, Rankia awarded us Best Stockbroker for the seventh consecutive time. So again, a great tradition that we try to carry on. And again, positive highlights so far, and we promise to work harder on it and bring up more of this going forward. So in general, this is, yes, at the beginning—now we'll shift gears, and I'll hand over to Muh as always.
Frank Niehage
executiveMuh, you have the floor — go ahead.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thanks for being on today's call. As Frank mentioned, I'd like to start by taking you through the financial specifics for the first half year, and after that I'm asking for 5 minutes to offer a brief personal note regarding this morning's announcement. Turning to the commercial performance of the company, we have to acknowledge that, given the circumstances and the environment we faced, we have kept managing our customer growth very, very well. In the first half we raised the count of customer accounts by 186,000 clients, with an annualized retention rate of 98.1%, which equals a churn rate of 2%. Net growth came to 162,000 accounts. As you'll recall, we forecasted for this year 1.5 growth, a customer account growth of 1.5x to 2x our European peers. In fact, account growth in the first half ran at 2.1x the relative growth of our peer average. The relative share of customer account growth per month follows the seasonal patterns below. On Slide 11 we show what the seasonal pattern looked like across the years 2016 until 2019, to just actually adjust for the COVID years and the new stock years.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWhat we're seeing is basically that we're right in line with historical patterns when it comes to seasonality: strong customer growth in the first quarter, which typically falls off in the second quarter, and then in the third and fourth quarters it usually rises again. So we're absolutely in line on seasonality, and also, in terms of the absolute number, in line with the figures we forecasted. The second key point — actually, not the second key point for us when it comes to customer growth; the most important point is how assets under custody are developing. If we look back 3 years, 4 years, the absolute number of customers was usually the thing that mattered most. Here we really see the importance of highlighting what the assets under custody development looks like. As of June the 30th, we hit an all-time record of EUR 47.8 billion in assets under custody, split into EUR 44.2 billion in securities and EUR 3.5 billion in cash. So what we're seeing is really 2 things. The first is that our net cash inflows remain positive, at EUR 2.9 billion in the first half.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAltogether, we saw cash coming in of approximately EUR 6 billion and cash going out of EUR 3 billion. The difference, then — that EUR 2.9 billion — represents net cash inflow. It's quite interesting: we keep stressing this point again and again — we aren't a savings bank; we're a transactional bank. We're an online broker. And the proof of that is that clients put 91% of the EUR 3 billion in net cash inflows into securities. So actual cash growth came to just EUR 0.3 billion out of the EUR 3 billion total net cash inflow. Turning to trading activity: as I just noted, it fell relative to Q1. Seasonality plays a part in that too. Q2, as I mentioned on our first quarter call, should show weaker transaction activity — first, because there are generally fewer trading days, and second, because historically Q2 has been the weakest quarter when it comes to transaction activity. We're fully in line with the trading activity of what I'll call our most admired peers, Nordnet and Avanza. And there too, you can see the declines between Q1 and Q2.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveSo the patterns are — flatexDEGIRO's pattern tracks a market pattern entirely, with nothing idiosyncratic — and I stress this because, as you'll recall, the quality of our growth has very often been questioned. And if that quality were inferior to our peers', we would literally have to witness sharper declines in activity, yet because it lines up perfectly, it at least confirms the quality matches our peers'. Let me just mention this: activity moves with seasonal patterns. Looking back through history, typically 26% of all transactions took place during the first quarter, while 23% of the year's transactions occurred in the second quarter. That's precisely the point I made. Historically, it's the weakest quarter. Our first quarter came in slightly stronger than past years. The second quarter sits fully in line with the historical seasonal pattern. So we feel quite good about the remaining 6 months of this year, and about our forecast and guidance, which we'll get to shortly. Turning to the commercial side — most of you have obviously read it — adjusted revenues then rose 8% quarter — year-on-year — sorry, quarter-on-quarter.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThey fell 8%, and the main reason is that Q1 versus Q2, we're missing 3 million transactions that were completed in the first quarter but didn't occur in the second quarter, plus 3 million transactions at EUR 4 of revenue per trade — actually slightly above EUR 4, but using that for the math. That works out to a revenue decline of EUR 12 million. The decline isn't as large as the EUR 12 million — it's just EUR 7 million. The explanation for that is, clearly, better monetization — substantially better — on one hand, and on the other hand, with a much larger impact, the higher interest rates on deposits in the second quarter versus the first quarter. Commission income lines up much more closely with what I just described, or what I just referred to — a drop of roughly EUR 12 million, EUR 13 million. That's what accounts for the decline from Q1 to Q2. A similar decline shows up between Q2 and Q2, because in Q2 2022 as well, we were — we had 16.2 million transactions, so again a delta of 3 million.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveInterest income has hit an all-time high, clearly powered by 2 mechanisms. The first, as I mentioned, is the deposit — the deposit facilities that are gaining more and more interest gearing each month, so to speak. And on the other side, Frank brought it up at the 1st of July; obviously, it isn't reflected in Q2. But as of the 1st of July, we've raised the margin loan interest rates with DEGIRO, and that will likewise have a substantial effect on interest income in the second half. The commission for trade remains fairly flat within this range of roughly EUR 4, with a slight uptick to EUR 4.17 in Q1, 2023. The decline from Q1 to Q2 is mostly explained by the fall in transactions. 3 million fewer transactions also means a significant drop in high-revenue transactions. That's point number one. And point number 2 is that certain — some account fees get charged in the first quarter and then also fall out in the second quarter. But looking at the second quarter and taking more of a monthly perspective, June, which was the first full month with the newly implemented fees on the DEGIRO side, delivered a revenue — sorry, delivered a commission per transaction of north of EUR 4.20.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveSo at this point, we're fully aligned with our expectations for the second half going forward. And clearly, April as well — a really weak month — had a dilutive impact on Q2 commission per trade too. So as things stand, Q3 will be, let's say, split the the quarter that confirms the price increases on both sides, interest income as well as commission income. And like I said, June has already given us some transparency regarding commission per trade and interest income. We had — last year, sorry, not on the last call, not last year — we had a discussion about elasticity following price increases. And I know some of the covering sell-side analysts have questioned and challenged the elasticity that comes out of price increases with DEGIRO and, let's say, at least built a correlation between price increases and transaction activity. And to clear up this myth, we're providing this slide that shows literally the index trading of U.S. stocks at flatex and DEGIRO starting in the first calendar week of 2022. So what we're showing is literally that we index, for the brand flatex and for the brand DEGIRO, the number of transactions in the first calendar week of 2022 and have sketched, so to speak, both graphs through the most recent week and the development of the trade in U.S.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveTurning to stocks. The reason we focus on U.S. stocks is that our pricing changes at DEGIRO were mainly made with regard to U.S. stocks. The proof we wanted to show you is that the fee adjustments at DEGIRO had no impact on transaction activity on the DEGIRO side. Because we made no changes on the flatex side, it serves as the ideal benchmark for how activity developed. As you can plainly see, both graphs are moving at precisely the same magnitude. In fact, during recent weeks, the DEGIRO line sits above the flatex line, meaning that activity — the activity index at DEGIRO — is actually higher than at flatex. Here's what we did over the last 18 months: first, we raised the FX fee at DEGIRO from 0.1% to 0.25%, with nothing changed at flatex. In December '22, we raised the handling fee at DEGIRO from EUR 0.50 to EUR 1, with nothing changed at flatex. Then in mid-May 2023, we moved the U.S. commission from EUR 0 to EUR 1, with no fee change at flatex — and what we observe is in fact a parallel trend in our trading activity. So to reiterate, the decline in activity is not an idiosyncratic outcome; it is genuinely market-driven and shaped by the environment in which we — in which every mature online broker has to operate.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveNow on the loan side, things look somewhat different—and honestly, they're coming in better than we expected. We took the same approach with margin loan changes. The blue line here is DEGIRO once more, and the orange one is flatex. As you're aware, with DEGIRO we already acted last year—at the start of this year, on the 1st of Jan, we raised margin loan rates for DEGIRO clients—and then we did it again on the 1st of July, and we also indexed margin loan usage at both flatex and DEGIRO. What we're seeing is that even before—or actually, let me flip that around: since we raised the margin rates for DEGIRO, volumes have picked up. And here too, DEGIRO volumes have risen, or rather come back literally to the level we had in 2022. With flatex, we're still 10 percentage points lower when it comes to volume. The long and short of what I want to show you here is that there's no significant—statistically significant—elasticity in the volumes of the DEGIRO loan amount, given that we changed the rate at DEGIRO and left the rate at flatex unchanged.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveTurning now to the OpEx side. I believe it's worth calling out the main OpEx driver, and that is clearly marketing expenses. We committed to cutting marketing spend over the course of the year. In fact, marketing fell considerably from Q1 to Q2, by approximately EUR 9 million. In Q1, we stood at EUR 17.2 million. In Q2, we stood at EUR 8.3 million. For the remaining year -- for the residual 6 months, we've budgeted approximately EUR 11 million, which brings the total to roughly EUR 36 million. That would be equivalent to a reduction in marketing spend versus last year of EUR 30 million, or 25%. We anticipate a further substantial decline in 2024. Because in 2023, we still carry the Sevilla sponsorship, which went perfectly well with winning the European League, obviously, but also affected the one-off costs, since we had -- as is usual in these contracts -- a bonus clause for winning the European League, which kicked in, to the surprise of many, many people, and which will fall away next year. So we expect next year's marketing cost to be even lower than the EUR 36 million we anticipate for this year. As I mentioned, the Sevilla FC sponsorship ended on a superbly high note, winning the European League, a great success, especially not only from a sporting perspective, but also from a brand awareness perspective for our brand DEGIRO and for the flatexDEGIRO Group.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe've shown here a bit the volume of DEGIRO web searches during the final match on a regular Wednesday compared with the final Wednesday, which indicates a significant increase. Overall, a very, very successful sponsorship agreement, a sponsorship engagement that is now ending. Thanks to Sevilla FC, to the entire team, to all the people at Sevilla for having us as a sponsor and for the wonderful hospitality we experienced and the strong support across all media channels, whether social media, TV, and finally, obviously, winning the European League. Last but not least, on some figures regarding OpEx, I think it's important to point out that we had certain non-recurring effects, one-time effects on our OpEx side. We mentioned this in the first quarter. We paid all our employees EUR 3.3 million of a one-time tax-incentivized inflation compensation. This was a tax incentive offered by the German government, under which we were able, so to speak, to pay a net amount as a gross amount to our clients, so without any taxes and without any social contributions that we have to bear, and we took advantage of this. And this was capped at, if I'm not mistaken, EUR 3,000 per employee, and we have made use of this scheme.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAlso, as I just said, on the marketing side, we incurred an extra cost because Sevilla FC won the European League in the second quarter, and that is definitely a non-recurring item. Finally, we referenced the EUR 1.1 million fine imposed by BaFin in Q1. And there is another legal dispute we are currently involved in with the Italian competition authority, where we had a EUR 4 million fine prepayment in Italy. That is based on a claim from a competitor. And this claim did not come from a client, did not come from any regulatory body. It came literally from a competitor in Italy and not only against us, but again, also some other competitors in the market. We are following this -- obviously, this legal dispute with very, very high diligence and are supported, obviously, by a worldwide known legal firm. We have appealed this decision. As both we, but also our legal support is very high probability to win the appeal and also an information that was interesting to find out that only 14% of the, so to speak, spoken penalties and fined by the competition authority only 14%, 14% came into effect after decisions were appealed in front of the court.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveSo we truly see no basis for this fine here. None of our arguments were heard, and this is something we will now take before the — or actually, we already have taken it before the court in Italy so it can be decided at a court level. So despite all these one-off effects, adjusted EBITDA reported in the second quarter was quite positive at EUR 34 million, which represents quarter-on-quarter growth of 13% year-on-year growth, quarter-by-quarter of 24%. But despite much, much lower transactions, which I think demonstrates the cost discipline we began this year, and that will obviously become much more visible over the coming next 2 quarters. Accounted EBITDA is also relatively stable in Q2, at EUR 29 million. So what you actually see is that we built EUR 5 million of — so we released EUR 5 million of SARs provisions. And that — sorry, we built EUR 5 million of SARs provisions between — or during Q2, which brings adjusted EBITDA down from EUR 34 million to EUR 29 million. Moving a little to the full year perspective. Frank mentioned it, we are absolutely confirming our guidance at the end, which was EUR 380 million of revenues, 40% of EBITDA margin, 30% of EBT margin.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveOur assumptions have largely held steady. Customer account growth running at 1.5x to 2x ahead of peers continues. We have revised the number of settled transactions in our assumption base. We entered the year assuming 65 million. That figure now stands at 58 million transactions for this year. The reduced assumption on the number of plays is offset by a higher commission per transaction of EUR 4.15 across the full year. For the average interest rate on margin loans, the assumption is now adjusted to 5%. The average rate on remaining cash under custody has been revised to 3.5%. Costs will most likely gain from the mix, since we conduct less equity trading than expected, and settlement costs will come down as well. So on one hand, we will <<inaudible>> see an effect on cost. And on the other hand, clearly, because interest income makes up a larger share of total revenues, we will also see a positive effect on the relative cost. OpEx was covered and marketing was covered. So looking at both P&Ls, the actual P&L for H1 and the implied P&L for H2, we see roughly the same commission income in the second half, and a 10%, 10%, 12% increase in interest income.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveOther income should be mostly steady, likely easing somewhat because of contracts we've ended. We certainly anticipate cutting OpEx further, as we said, and we're targeting an adjusted EBITDA margin in the high 40%s and an adjusted EBT margin in the high 30%s for the second half. Combine those 2 P&Ls across the full year and you'll find it's roughly what we guided for the full year. That's all. Regarding the preliminary facts and figures, thank you. Thank you. Warm -- thanks from the entire Board to our colleagues for a successful first half year despite the environment in which we operate. Before we open the Q&A session, let me take 2, 3 moments to describe and share a couple of things about my decision that we announced this morning. As all of you have read, I am preparing to bid farewell to this exceptional organization that has been my professional home since 2015, and obviously for me it was literally a home as well, where I spent more time than actually with my own family over the recent 8 years, 9 years.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveLooking back at how this company started—just a small online broker in Germany—it's amazing to see what it has become: the leader across Europe. For me personally, the trip has been unbelievable, full of endless hurdles; we had big dreams. Many lessons came our way that formed me both as a person and, honestly, as a leader. When I think back on this period, I feel deep gratitude and pride. I must say, serving, developing, and leading this company has been a privilege. I'm extremely thankful and grateful for the trust—and that the Supervisory Board, with Frank, gave me <<inaudible>> so very early on, back in 2015. Leaving a role I've cherished for so long—first as CFO, then as a Digital CEO, then as Deputy CEO and COO of the Group—is without a doubt bittersweet. And rest assured, this was a very hard choice for me, one I approached with diligence and gave the necessary time to reach. I know I'm surprising many and perhaps even disappointing some with this decision, but I'm convinced that change is an integral aspect of growth—something I've always preached to colleagues and to employees.
Muhamad Chahrour
executive<<inaudible>> I'm feeling a lot of excitement and optimism about what this next professional chapter will look like once my remaining time with flatexDEGIRO is done. And the break — a personal break, during which I'll handle private matters concerning my family. It was also personally a hard year given the losses our family suffered over the last 12 months, losing my father-in-law and losing my own father. So I'm taking time to reflect on a few things and to recharge <<inaudible>> so that I can hopefully, quite literally, pursue the next professional destiny. Now, I want to express my deepest appreciation to all of you — colleagues, employees, the Supervisory Board, investors, clients, analysts, stakeholders, regulators, business partners, family and friends. Your support throughout this <<inaudible>> years was, and has always been, a driving force behind what we've accomplished, and also behind my own personal accomplishments. And we've built great relationships, delivered exceptional results, and created — I'm very sure — a very lasting impact in the online brokerage industry. Together we have developed the European market leader. And although I will keep supporting specific internal topics and projects, this is my last IR call for flatexDEGIRO. I think that's very, very important.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThere's also a point I firmly believe in, which is to have a very low and consistent transition, particularly when it comes to communication with the capital market. I suppose I'm glad to pass the Investor Relations responsibility along to our CFO, Benon Janos. And I'm quite certain that Benon, Achim and, of course, Frank will keep answering all of your questions at least as well as Achim and I have tried to do. One final personal remark, Frank: I'm deeply thankful for the mentorship, the guidance and the knowledge you've so generously shared with me. Your support has certainly helped shape me into a better person and a better leader. And I know this is a disappointing step, but I have absolutely no doubt that this company will keep driving and delivering. We have a superb management board that now numbers 3 people again, and hopefully it will grow to 4 at the end of the year, once the regulator gives approval, with Christiane joining as the CHRO in the Group. And I have no doubt this company will keep thriving and delivering. I'm genuinely excited to watch the development from the sideline, so to speak, as a shareholder. Yes. That's it.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThanks so much, everybody, for the wonderful ride we've been on, and for all that we've shared across so many years. And once more, a thank you from me personally as well to every one of the long-standing and early investors over the past 8 years — we've had so many conversations and exchanges together during that time — and thank you too for the backing that turned flatexDEGIRO into what it is now. Goodbye.
Frank Niehage
executiveThank you very much, Muh. Before we open things up for Q&A, I'd like to make a brief comment. Obviously, I very much regret that you're going to be leaving us — it was a successful journey that we had together. Unfortunately, we share the same experience: you lost your father this year, and I lost my father this year. Without going too much into private details, I have a great deal of understanding on the private side — that you will take care of more of your family and take as a vertical to digest those things, and that I respect. And I hope everyone else will expect that — should respect that. With respect to the company, we've run this business at the Group management board level for a long, long time, and for many years alone, the 2 of us. Now we are 4. I'm rest assured that Benon, Stephan and I will continue to run it successfully. And as you said, subject to BaFin's approval, which is expected by end of the year, Christiane will join with respect and the effect of 1st of January. So then we are back to 4%. I'm also happy that you continue as a shareholder and will support us.
Frank Niehage
executiveI also appreciated your remark that you won't go on to work for any competitor, and given that you've worked with the market leader and grown this business into European market leadership, I appreciate that a lot. And for your personal belongings and your personal life, I wish you all the luck you've deserved and whatever you expect. And I trust that when you return to the professional environment, you will keep being very successful. And I wish you all the best for that as well.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThanks a lot, Frank.
Frank Niehage
executiveThanks so much for all those wonderful years. And at this point, we'll take your questions.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Today's first question is from Ian White at Autonomous Research.
Ian White
analystI appreciate you taking the call, and thank you for taking my questions. To begin with, I want to offer a quick congratulations to Muh on a highly successful tenure, and thanks for your assistance during the time I spent at <<inaudible>> flatex. So, if I may, just a few questions, please. First, on the matter of the Italian Competition Authority: could you elaborate a bit more on that? What precisely are you alleged to have done that countermand the guidelines, or whatever the Competition Authority has in place? Why have you decided to prepay this fine if you believe that, in the end, you will succeed in your challenge against it? And does EUR 4 million represent the maximum potential liability here, or might it go beyond that? I'm just wondering whether you could give a bit more detail on that issue, please? Second, on the question of the retail investment strategy, I appreciate that, basically, you don't add PFOF in your business. However, my understanding is that you do receive rather significant payments from the ETP providers, and, as far as I understand it, the commission's proposal is that third-party payments would be banned.
Ian White
analystCould you give us a bit of detail, please, on how you view the dangers to your revenue stream coming from the ETP providers? Basically, is that at risk if the commission's proposals move ahead as they were drafted earlier this year? And then just one last thing, I was wondering whether you could tell us the total CapEx for 1H '23, please?
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. Let me begin broadly with Italy. The antitrust authority there has handed down a final fine of EUR 4 million. That amount is the final figure—it cannot go any higher. Second, under Italian law you must pay the fine up front, whether or not it is justified. Obviously, the Italians have a business model <<inaudible>> invented here, because they always impose fines and they collect the money. Then only if the parties involved go to court and contest that ruling do they have to return the funds. We have examined all publicly available information on this, and there were more than 20 cases, where the outcome is that no more than 14% of the total sum imposed had to be paid and was legally justified. So obviously, we have appealed to the court, and we trust that we will get either the full amount or at least a large portion of that fine back, because we believe, in general, that we behaved and complied with what market standards are in Italy, but I don't want to prejudice the legal court here, and we leave it to the judges to decide that in the end. Yes, this is, in general, a comment, and maybe Muh, you want to mention a bit more about the details if necessary.
Frank Niehage
executiveOn the PFOF situation, I think you technically need to draw a distinction between commissions that investment banks pay to brokers and other parties for ETP products. As I understand it, that isn't part of PFOF — that's a separate matter altogether. Yes. And Muh, perhaps you'd like to weigh in on the other aspects or provide a little more detail, if needed.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveYes. Ian, first off, thanks for the kind remarks, and to address your points. So the telling point was exactly as Frank put it. So it is what it is. You must prepay the fine. It works differently in, I believe, most and not even every European jurisdiction — you pay once you have the final decision. In Italy, you have to pay fines upfront and then you still have the option to appeal. Regarding the ETP topic as well, I think we began — we already started 2 years ago changing the structure of the ETP settlement toward a more OTC arrangement between us and the product partners. And beyond that, there are 1, 2 strategies sitting in our drawer, so to speak, for what to do if for whatever reason an ETP ban were to come, which does not — which as of today is not the case. But in the Netherlands, for instance, you have seen some players who then use white label solutions to bring ETPs to the market, so we could do the same, if needed. As for the — your question, I think it was the last one, about CapEx, allow me to say that we will provide all the balance sheet details and cash flow details and P&L details in the report that is going to be published mid of August.
Ian White
analystCan I just revisit that first item for a moment — apologies if I've missed it somewhere, but what exactly is the accusation being made against the company, please? What's the alleged wrongdoing that this preliminary fine has been imposed for? Could you give us a bit of detail on that, please?
Frank Niehage
executiveYes, absolutely. Absolutely. Sorry about that, Ian. The reality is that the bulk of this fine concerns a topic that seems absurd to us, and frankly to the industry as well. We've talked it over with various regulators, Ian, and none of them can make sense of it either. The subject here is the Auto FX. So, when clients hold positions in their account and they purchase an Apple share on NASDAQ, we obviously have to convert the currency. We can't settle with the prime broker in Europe instantly in another currency. We need dollars in order to buy Apple. And the default setting — which, in fact, is the global default — is for that conversion to happen automatically. That said, the client also has the choice of opening a U.S. dollar account with us, but that requires opening a second account, a second reference cash account, into which he can then move U.S. dollars. And the claim is that, by offering the Auto FX as a standard product, we are in a sense putting clients at a disadvantage. Now, we have of course examined the entire European market, and literally half of that market doesn't even provide a U.S. dollar account, so clients there are pushed into automatic FX conversion.
Frank Niehage
executiveAnd every one of those offering FX accounts includes automatic FX conversion as a standard default. Now in Italy, as we mentioned, a competitor kicked off this whole debate with us — and not just with us, but with 1, 2 other players as well — and the funny part is that this same competitor itself gives its clients Auto FX as a default, so it's an absurd discussion, and that's the <<inaudible>>, which accounts for the vast majority of the fine.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveLet's move on to the following question.
Operator
operatorNext up is Christoph Greulich from Berenberg.
Christoph Greulich
analystYes. I have three from my side, please. First, regarding the U.K. business. It appears that you stopped onboarding new customers there a few months ago. Yes, maybe you could just tell us the reason for that? And then, since the U.K. has been classified as one of your growth markets, yes, if you could roughly quantify the impact that had on the Group's customer growth in Q2? Then second, just on the future transition on the management team, are you planning to find a successor for the COO role? Or is the plan to distribute most responsibilities among the existing members of the management team? And then, just on the PFOF evolution, the recent news flow, what are your expectations for how this might shape or change the competitive landscape?
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. Let me start briefly with the U.K., and then perhaps Muh can provide a bit more detail if needed. We've temporarily halted onboarding U.K. clients, since we're in discussions with the U.K. regulator regarding the new license situation, and I'm confident we'll come back on that soon and change it — as I said, it's temporary. And I believe the impact wasn't that big, to my understanding, but maybe Muh wants to comment in a little more detail. Regarding the COO position, as I mentioned earlier in my personal note, Muh and I have run the Group management board — just the 2 of us — for almost 8 years, and it was very successful. Now we have 4 members here. The company has grown. Temporarily, we'll be 3 soon. We will be 4. So we'll continue to take over and divide among ourselves here the responsibilities Muh has had, and we trust that we do that well. Anything else, we'll comment on as soon as the Supervisory Board has reached a different view. If not, we'll continue like that, which, for the time being, is a situation. Muh is available until the end of the year anyway.
Frank Niehage
executiveAlso, as of January 1st, Christiane Strubel will be coming on board. And then we have, once more, 4 head, and I believe that will be sufficient and will work out fine. But I'm glad to pass things to Muh.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveYes. Let me — hi, Chris, regarding the U.K. business, I think it's worth explaining the reasoning here as well. So this really is just a temporary situation. As you know, we actually stopped marketing in the U.K. 2 years ago, since the temporary regime came in. And if you look at client numbers — last year, we brought in 7,000 gross new clients in the U.K. So the effect wasn't large. We still see it as a strong growth market. But we're waiting for the final licensing, which will hopefully come through over the next weeks, at the latest in Q3, and then we'll restart onboarding. The main reason is that we want to avoid the transition to this new entity that we've implemented during the onboarding phase. That's why we halted it as well. But in our discussions with the regulators, we also reached the conclusion that it makes sense to stop and make the transition. And once we have the new licensing, we'll be able to reopen onboarding again. On your last question, Frank, the PFOF discussion advantages — potential advantages...
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. I mean, like I said, we believe in one market with rules that are fair to everybody. So my hope is that this becomes more transparent and fair going forward, since we don't rely on PFOF revenues. There's no negative impact on us, yes, apart from with neo-brokers, whose business model has been built on PFOF. And obviously, this will affect the industry, and I strongly believe that we're going to benefit from it. And as you always know, we've taken the time to strengthen our organization, to do our homework. We work hard on the learnings from the audit. So I think we'll head into a bright future, and we'll look into organic and unorganic growth. And obviously, the competitors, some of them, especially the neo-brokers, have to reinvent their business model when they can no longer receive payments from the stock exchanges. And in Germany, there's the Federal court rule, as you're all aware of, which does not allow market participants to increase fees via general terms and conditions with 2 months notice, and then it's going to implement it thereafter as it used to be 20 years, 30 years ago, which was the common practice that has no longer -- is no longer valid.
Frank Niehage
executiveBefore any change like that can happen, written consent has to be obtained from the clients. And clearly, clients aren't happy about it when they were pitched on the idea that they wouldn't have to pay a thing. So that will be a challenge. Perhaps that's also why the commission is granting a 2 years transition period, so there's enough time to speak with clients. That isn't something we have to do. In Germany in particular, we've held our EUR 5.90 steady for 20 years — it hasn't moved and won't move as far as equity trades go — and our ETF savings plans products, I believe, come to 4,500. There's no reason on our side to alter anything. So this won't affect our clients. Still, I think the industry will feel an impact.
Operator
operatorOur next question is from Andrew Lowe at Citi.
Andrew Lowe
analystOnly a handful of questions from me. Pages 18 and 19 struck me as interesting, since they showed higher charges at DEGIRO. I'd be interested in whatever views you have about pricing going forward at flatex, where your fee structures have stayed more stable? Second, given that a number of inactive customers sit on your platform, I'm curious about what regulatory challenges this involves — for instance, how do you make sure your KYC remains up to date? We ask because one of your Nordic peers said recently that a regulatory obligation to keep KYC current is the reason they are closing active accounts. So I'm curious about your thinking there? And last, just a clarification. Did I hear you correctly that June commissions per trade matched your expectations for the second half of the year, with your guidance implying EUR 4.25?
Frank Niehage
executiveThe reception made it hard for me to catch every question clearly. The one point I did grasp was the reason commission per trade went down. Muh will be glad to address that. Muh, please go ahead.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveYeah. I was listening really carefully. So I'll do my best to answer. So the first thing, I believe it was about Slide 18 and 19, DEGIRO and flatex — if I'm remembering correctly, you were asking something along the lines of whether flatex has price changes or whether there are strategies related to flatex price changes. Did I get that right?
Andrew Lowe
analystHey there, apologies. I’ve moved off the headset. I’m hoping my voice comes through more clearly for you now. Yes, exactly.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveIt's a bit louder. Yes, go ahead.
Andrew Lowe
analystYes. Are you able to hear me at this point?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveYes.
Andrew Lowe
analystYes. All right. That's fine. My apologies for that. So, yeah, essentially the question is: what opportunity exists to raise prices at your flatex brand going forward?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveRight, understood. The key thing about flatex is that it operates in Germany and Austria — jurisdictions where, following the most recent court ruling, price changes require the client's active consent. That's the highest German court decision, and it makes raising prices genuinely hard, since customers must actively agree to them. Incidentally, that issue will get quite interesting with the PFOF debate for neo-brokers, because many people tend to say, fine, they no longer do any PFOF, so they can simply nudge fees up a little or charge a bit more. The catch is that active clients must actively consent to price changes — meaning price increases. That's why, at flatex, we don't foresee any price changes in the near future. As for — I believe the second question concerned KYC and the BaFin audit...
Andrew Lowe
analystApologies—let me jump in here. The BaFin audit wasn’t really the specific subject. It was simply a question about the types of regulatory challenges and KYC-related obligations that come with having a large number of inactive customers on your platforms. And the reason I raise that is that one of your Nordic peers said recently they’re required to keep this KYC data current, which is why they’re proactive about closing inactive accounts, whereas you appear to take a somewhat looser approach in allowing...
Muhamad Chahrour
executive<<inaudible>>. Regulators have significantly increased their KYC demands in recent years. And obviously, we are doing our utmost to comply 100% with all of these requirements, actually. Indeed, every account will become in the future — so to speak — a non-terminated account, and inactive clients with perhaps outdated documents will find Re-KYC a bit more challenging down the road, et cetera. In the Nordics, you are absolutely right, and the Nordic peers already — they have chosen to shut down inactive clients, since closing inactive clients is far more cost efficient, particularly when it is a zero account — a euro account. So neither cash nor securities, rather than Re-KYC. This is something that will also be discussed here with us and the management board over the coming weeks and months, and might obviously also result, with regard to our client pool, in offboarding old clients when offering them is much more efficient than Re-KYCing them.
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. Perhaps just one remark here. The flatex wealth product is another effort aimed at inactive clients, since some of them may simply lack direction, and that is why they are inactive. And when the choice is between doing nothing—which yields 0 revenues and 0 returns—versus a solid conservative strategy delivering 3% to 4%, or 5% return, whatever it may be, that could serve as an alternative. More initiatives are on the way in which we target inactive clients. Yet should nothing work, making that move could be the ultimate step, as the Nordics have begun to do. We are engaged on this, we are watching it closely. And we will ensure we stay very compliant.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThen on your final point — that was about the commission for each trade, if I have that right. If I recall correctly, you were asking how we view the guidance for the EUR 4.25 as we move ahead, is that correct?
Andrew Lowe
analystThat was only a clarification—June commission per trade stood at roughly that level.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveYeah, absolutely. That's exactly what we said. After the most recent price adjustments, we expect the commission per trade to rise to EUR 4.20, EUR 4.25 going forward. So because of the first half, when this pricing mechanism wasn't in place, the average for the full year will of course be diluted toward the lower end. But starting in July, the commission per trade should definitely climb to around EUR 4.20, EUR 4.25 per trade.
Operator
operatorNext up, we have a question coming in from Simon Keller at Hauck Aufhauser.
Simon Keller
analystI've got 2 questions. First, how is the proportion of active customers developing compared with total customers? Second, what kind of customers have you brought in lately? Could you cluster them more as day traders or as buy and hold ETF investors?
Frank Niehage
executiveThe proportion of active customers for Q2 hasn't been published yet. We'll include it when we update the corporate presentation, but we're glad to share the figure now: it's 30%. So that's fairly stable relative to Q1. That's the first point. And second, regarding what kind of clients we brought in during the first half — to run that sort of analysis, we always need a bit of time, clearly. So we'll certainly provide that information as well, and then again in the cohort analysis. But in the kind of environment we're in as of today, where clients aren't really — so the mass market isn't really receptive to online brokerage, the clients we're winning tend to come from an experienced base — not a day-trader base, but rather active trading customers. The averages for the new clients we brought in, in terms of trading activity, look very similar to the existing base. So it isn't the case that we're now only winning clients who place 500 trades per year, nor are we winning clients who place no trades at all.
Frank Niehage
executiveRegarding the mix of clients, if you will, it remains highly steady when it comes to the base of clients we already have.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThat covers that response. Let's take the next question.
Operator
operatorMoving on, our following question is from Christoph Blieffert at Exane BNP.
Christoph Blieffert
analystESMA recently said that money generated from securities lending ought to go straight to the retail client instead of being retained by the bank or broker. Could you comment on how securities lending affects your revenue line?
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. To answer that, Mr. Blieffert, our default position is that we have not offered securities lending up to now. As a result, there is no impact on us.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveMoving on to the next question, please.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> It looks like we don't have any more questions right now. So, Mr. Niehage, I'll turn it back to you for any additional or closing remarks.
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. So thank you very much, everyone, for spending time with us this morning. We'll keep working hard. We're anticipating a stronger second half. Thanks again, Muh. Benon Janos is going to take over now. I'm confident that with his 20 years of experience at Goldman Sachs, he'll handle it very well and try to match Muh's performance. And all of us look forward to staying in touch with you. Should you have any additional questions that you weren't able to raise today, we're glad to speak with you afterward, or you can email us or give us a call. Have a great day and all the best to you. Bye-bye.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveTake care. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThank you. That brings us to the end of today's call, ladies and gentlemen. You're welcome to disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete flatexDEGIRO SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to flatexDEGIRO SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in flatexDEGIRO SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.