Harley-Davidson, Inc. (HOG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 28, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Shannon Burns
executiveHello, everybody, and good morning. The slides that go along with today's call can be found at investor.harley-davidson.com — just select the Earnings Materials box located in the middle of that page. Within our remarks, we'll be making forward-looking statements, and those carry risks that might make actual results come out materially different; among other things, those risks cover matters we've pointed to in our most recent earnings release along with our SEC filings. Any obligation <<inaudible>> on this call is disclaimed by Harley-Davidson. With me this morning are our President and CEO, Matt Levatich, as well as our CFO, John Olin. Matt, let's get started.
Matt Levatich
executiveThank you, Shannon, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to report that our results for the fourth quarter and the full year came in as we anticipated, and they point to greater stability in the business, thanks to the incredible work our employees and dealers have done to get people riding and to steer through the difficulties of a business environment that keeps changing. Over the course of 2019, we made substantial strides with our More Roads plan — putting money to work, developing our capabilities, and hitting key milestones — which keeps us positioned to get back to meaningful growth in 2021; there is plenty for us to take pride in and plenty ahead to be excited about. More Roads represents a key piece of the broader company transformation effort that's been going on for most of the last 10 years. That transformation started with a focus on manufacturing, which includes the multiyear manufacturing optimization initiative we've been running lately, centered on folding our motorcycle assembly plant in Kansas City into our enlarged facility in York. That initiative is almost finished, and we anticipate ongoing annual savings of roughly $70 million in 2021. John will go into more detail on that shortly. We've also reworked product development, which lets us take an innovation-led approach that cuts time-to-market by 30%, sharply expanding our ability to broaden the product lineup and thereby reach and inspire more people. That takes in electric products, motorcycles in new segments and sizes, and even e-bicycles. Our proactive stance on innovation is also reinforcing our leadership in the Touring and Cruisers segments, producing a historically high 72.4% market share in the U.S. for those segments, which is 2.5 percentage points above 2018. We've brought industry-first innovations to market, such as touring traction control with advanced ABS and H-D Connect, which links rider and motorcycle seamlessly; we're also out front in electrifying motorcycles with class-leading products created alongside our new team and our EV development center, LiveWire labs in Silicon Valley. The innovation and growth efforts we've pursued under More Roads have also sparked smart, targeted acquisitions such as StaCyc, along with new collaborations like QJ in China. All of this transformation, investment and effort has let us come out with product processes that are more flexible, responsive and efficient from design through build — processes we keep refining and evolving alongside our customers' changing needs. We're now deep into the last transformation phase: a thorough overhaul of our marketing and go-to-market capabilities so we become a customer-creation company, generating demand and delivering growth by shaping our position in markets worldwide; we are turning into a company that excels and exists not merely to build great bikes, but to build riders; this pushes us past simply what someone is riding toward why people ride, and how our insights can deliver targeted experiences and strengthen commitment to riding. We're changing our mindset and deliberately guiding and nurturing our culture to seek agility, with deeper skills and capabilities aimed at customer creation. We've challenged how the whole company is structured, bringing in new talent and arranging resources so we can move quickly in these new directions. We intend to keep pursuing fresh avenues for growth, which includes introducing new business models, making strategic acquisitions, and forming new partnerships. This year, our More Roads goals involve a substantial amount of difficult work when it comes to rolling out new products. Once more, we will elevate our standards and achieve impact and access when we introduce our initial new middleweight motorcycles, the Bronx Streetfighter, along with our Pan America Adventure Touring models; additionally, we intend to bring a new small displacement motorcycle to market in China and to broaden beyond motorcycles by launching Harley-Davidson e-bicycles. What we're doing is magnifying the tremendous strength of our brand while utilizing and growing our know-how to provide more value to our customers. When it comes to our distribution — the way we distribute also encompasses additional regional distribution centers, more points of access, and a global dealer network that is even more robust. Signs of this transformation are also showing up in the metrics we use to gauge performance. Our 2020 guidance swaps out heavyweight unit shipments and instead makes revenue the main performance metric. Revenue does a better job of capturing our all-encompassing push to magnify our brand and cultivate a culture of customer creation, one that produces dedicated riders. Growth in revenue, propelled by a broader product lineup, a renewed strategy for apparel, and a stream of creative new services designed to inspire, cultivate, and involve people in riding. We discussed this change last quarter when we modified our long-term international growth target, moving from tracking the percentage of motorcycle volume to tracking the percentage of HDMC revenue. Back then, we also refined and ramped up our U.S. growth target for 2027, pushing ourselves to enlarge the overall number of U.S. riders by bringing in more riders and keeping more riders annually. Throughout 2019, we observed movement in the correct direction; we ended 2019 with 3.1 million Harley-Davidson riders in the U.S., which is 55,000 more total riders compared to 2018. Over the course of the year, 527,000 riders became part of the Harley-Davidson brand, which is nearly 25,000 more than the number who joined Harley-Davidson in 2018. The count of individuals who became part of Harley-Davidson in 2019 shows the strength of the brand and our enhancing abilities. Even so, we recognize that additional effort is required to meet our target, which underscores how essential our broadened focus and actions are to make riding matter to a greater number of people. The insights we possess on rider migration indicate that we must attract people, develop their confidence and skills, and sustain their riding throughout the pivotal early years of their riding experience. Right now, we are trying out and creating particular programs and initiatives that support new riders and encourage and cultivate all riders to keep riding with us. We understand that we have to keep enhancing and increasing the count of new joiners and boost retention rates so that by the end of 2027 we have 4 million total riders in the United States. And this represents the appropriate challenge at the appropriate moment to fuel ongoing reinforcement of our customer creation abilities as the concluding phase of our ten-year transformation as a company. We aimed to achieve a great deal in 2019, and we delivered on our promises — showcasing our stepped-up efforts to realize More Roads growth and our long-term goals. In summary, during 2019 we established our position as a leader in motorcycle electrification by introducing LiveWire, our inaugural electric motorcycle, along with IRONe for children. Leading the charge in electrifying motorcycles means developing a wide EV lineup, fueled by the skill and expertise of our EV product development team, which grew considerably that year. We brought out impactful new models and equipped our class-leading model year 2020 motorcycles with sophisticated technology, enhancing the riding experience; additionally, we enlarged our Thailand facility to support the ASEAN markets, boosting customer reach through more competitive retail prices. We enhanced and broadened our worldwide e-commerce and digital abilities, increasing visibility and availability of our offerings; during 2019, 75% of those buying Harley products on Amazon had not previously been Harley-Davidson customers. Lastly, we moved forward with good to great dealers, achieving strides toward our goals for customer experience and conversion. Those dealers taking part in our U.S. dealer operations consulting engagements experienced on average an almost 6% rise in motorcycle retail sales compared to dealers who had not yet joined the program.
Matt Levatich
executiveWhen you look beyond America, we started rolling out more robust dealer programs during the latter six months of the year, and that contributed to a notable uptick for retail sales in developed markets, which wrapped up those six months higher than the prior-year period. We remain aligned with what we told you to expect when the More Roads plan kicked off, putting capital to work in ways that position us for the growth objectives we intend to hit in 2021 and afterward. Two years into this effort, our fresh offerings, improved dealer network, expanded reach and stronger brand promotion are cultivating and proving out essential competencies and strengths. And although rivalry and obstacles remain fierce, we've met that test throughout, earning our place through performance and producing value for shareholders, all while steering through today's conditions and pushing our strategy forward. Stability is what we're generating in this business, and it shows in how we've been able to soften the effects of tariffs, move away from incentives that erode value and use HDFS as a vital strategic resource that supports business results. Harley-Davidson has stood for 117 years, yet it bears little resemblance to what it was prior to the downturn, nor is it what it was just 3 years back; almost everything about the way we operate has been overhauled. And though plenty of work remains in our More Roads pursuit of truly mastering the art of bringing in customers, one thing stays absolutely evident: riding is, and always has been, the heart of it all. Our goal is to make riding count for a greater number of people and to cultivate dedicated riders. Looking at where we are right now, growth isn't some far-off destination for us — it's just around the bend, and 2020 is the year that decides things. My eyes are on what's next, and I take confidence in the effort that has built our base for the 12 months in front of us and the path we're traveling over the long haul. Thanks for staying on this ride with us; at this point I'll hand things to John so he can walk through the quarter's and the full year's financial results and our outlook. John?
John Olin
executiveThanks, Matt. Our fourth-quarter earnings left us encouraged, and we're still seeing the pace of our U.S. retail sales declines ease. Across the quarter and all of 2019, we achieved meaningful strides under our More Roads to Harley-Davidson plan. You'll find a recap of our Q4 results on Slide 10. Motorcycle segment operating loss narrowed in the fourth quarter, helped by reduced year-over-year SG&A and the beneficial effect of our manufacturing optimization initiative, though this was partly counteracted by fewer shipments, greater year-over-year tariffs and an unfavorable mix. Financial Services operating income fell 7%. Consolidated net income rose compared with the prior year. For the quarter, earnings per share came to $0.09. When you set aside what we spent on the restructuring plan and the effects of the tariffs recently imposed by the EU and China, adjusted EPS came in at $0.20. Our approach remains one of focus and discipline regarding inventory, aggressive cost control, generating cash through operations, and providing strong returns to shareholders over the long run. Now, if you'll look at Slide 11, global retail sales of new Harley-Davidson motorcycles were down 1.4% in Q4 compared with the same period a year earlier — a meaningful bettering of the decline rate from last year's fourth quarter, which saw a 6.7% drop. Here in the U.S., Q4 retail sales fell 3.1% year over year, which is an improvement in the rate of decline compared with what we've seen in recent quarters. During Q4, Harley-Davidson's retail sales benefited as the industry's rate of retail sales decline moderated compared with the prior year, and as H-D achieved significant market share gains. For the quarter, international retail sales were up 0.5%. Retail sales in emerging markets continued to increase, whereas developed market retail sales fell modestly. After a challenging second quarter, momentum returned in the third and fourth quarters, driven by our ongoing rollout of stronger dealer programs, spending to amplify the brand via greater marketing, the debut of our model year 2020 motorcycles, and vigorous management of motorcycle supply into the dealer network; looking ahead to 2020, we expect persistent headwinds in the U.S. Along with mature overseas markets, our strategy for navigating these industry headwinds is to focus on cultivating loyal customers and to keep moving forward with our More Roads to Harley-Davidson initiative. We believe our future roadmap is a strong one, and we're pushing ahead on it with great urgency. Turning to Slide 12, let's take a closer look at the U.S. market. During the fourth quarter, Harley-Davidson's retail sales were down 3.1% compared with the same period a year earlier, even as retail performance improved and H-D captured significant market share gains. It was encouraging to see the pace of our retail sales decline continue to ease, because that fourth quarter represented the smallest drop in the U.S. over the past 12 quarters. During the fourth quarter, retail sales across the industry fell 5.6%. While that drop was significantly smaller than the one seen in the fourth quarter of 2018, it did represent a sequential increase compared with the third quarter of 2019. Looking at the entire year, the industry's pace of decline has gotten substantially better, going from an 8.7% decrease in 2018 to a 4.1% decrease in 2019. For the full year, Harley-Davidson's retail sales were down 5.2%, which is an improvement relative to the 10.2% decline recorded in 2018. In our view, the shrinking year-over-year rate of decline resulted from improved industry performance, our focus on stronger dealers, and greater marketing investment. During the quarter, 50.4% of new bike registrations went to Harley-Davidson — an increase of 1.0 percentage points. That happened despite a mix shift that keeps working against us, moving toward segments we aren't in today, though we'll enter them before this year is over as part of executing More Roads. In the segments where we do play, Touring and Cruiser, our Q4 market share was really solid, up 3.9 percentage points. We also made sure not to flood the dealer network with new bikes during the quarter. As a result, at quarter-end, U.S. At retail, inventory is down about 1,500 motorcycles year over year. In our view, that kind of market discipline is important for protecting value for customers and dealers alike, and ultimately it should drive better retail sales of new motorcycles. Turning to Slide 13, international retail sales for the fourth quarter were up 0.5%, helped by gains in emerging markets while developed markets dipped slightly. Emerging market retail sales increased 2.2% in the quarter compared with a year earlier. Growth in our ASEAN markets and in China drove those gains. Partly offsetting that strong performance was weaker demand in India. In developed markets, retail sales declined 0.5% for the quarter. In our developed markets, we saw strong performance in Japan, Southern Europe, and Australia, though Canada and Northern Europe were weaker. Across Europe for the full year, our market share came in at 8.9%, which is a decline of 1.4 percentage points from the prior year. Two factors hurt our market share: we were up against last year's strong Softail results, and we had lower sales of our street motorcycles stemming from the Street recall. When we look at the details of our More Roads plan, it strengthens both our confidence in and our dedication to the significant opportunity that international markets hold for Harley-Davidson. That plan leverages the power of our brand, our products, and our distribution to generate sustainable growth abroad. Turning to Slide 14, our fourth-quarter wholesale motorcycle shipments declined 7.0%, landing close to the middle of the range we had guided. Compared with last year's fourth quarter, the overall family mix moved away from Touring and toward Cruiser motorcycles. Now Slide 15: Motorcycles segment revenue for Q4 fell 8.5%, which trailed the 7.0% drop in motorcycle shipments. On a per-bike basis, average motorcycle revenue came in $504 lower, reflecting a less rich product mix and unfavorable foreign currency exchange, though higher pricing compared with a year ago partly offset that. Moving to Slide 16, gross margin for the fourth quarter declined because of lower shipments, a less rich product mix, unfavorable currency and higher manufacturing expense. Product mix in Q4 was unfavorable by $9.7 million, and that was driven by the shift in family mix. Currency headwinds totaling $8.0 million, caused by a stronger U.S. dollar, put pressure on gross margin in Q4. When we look year over year, the 2018 hedge gains are now behind us; in Q4, reduced absorption resulting from lower production and shipments, along with higher tariffs compared with a year ago, hurt manufacturing expense, although $15.5 million in savings from implementing our manufacturing optimization initiative largely made up for that. On Slide 17, operating margin as a percent of revenue for Q4 was higher than last year, helped by favorable SG&A and restructuring expenses, even though a lower gross margin partially offset that. On the selling, general, and administrative side, we saw a big decline versus last year. That reflects the fact that recall-related charges have now anniversaried, plus our ongoing cost discipline and aggressive investment posture, with additional dollars going toward marketing and our More Roads initiative. In Q4, restructuring costs totaled $0.7 million — an improvement of $18.7 million year over year. We continue to keep profitability and robust cash generation front and center. Our aim is to squeeze more leverage out of what we've built and expand our capabilities so we can keep delivering earnings, cash flow, and ROIC in the top quartile among motor companies. Turning to Financial Services, operating income for the fourth quarter — you can see this on Slide 18 — came in at $58.9 million, a 7.0% decrease from the same period a year ago. We saw a $4.2 million increase in net interest income, which came from stronger receivables compared with the prior year along with better yields on interest rates, though this was partly counterbalanced by greater interest expense. On retail motorcycle loans, the provision for losses reached $4.0 million, a negative result in Q4, caused by an additional $2.3 million in credit losses as well as growth in our credit reserves.
John Olin
executiveOur operating costs rose compared with the previous year, partly because depreciation climbed following our spending on a fresh loan management platform that went live in January 2019. Turning to HDFS, its operational results appear on Slide 19. Retail originations in Q4 fell 5.9% from a year earlier, largely because new bike sales were weaker. HDFS kept a very robust market share, at 63.7%. When the quarter closed, HDFS held $363.2 million in cash and cash equivalents, plus $1.77 billion of liquidity accessible via bank credit and conduit facilities. In Q4, HDFS brought in EUR 600 million through an MTN and distributed a $40 million dividend to Harley-Davidson, Inc. Slide 20 shows that our 30-day-plus delinquency and credit loss figures both increased year over year, even after we had gotten beyond the start-up efficiencies tied to rolling out our new loan management system. For retail motorcycle loans receivable — loan receivables on balance sheet — the 30-day delinquency rate at year-end stood at 4.39%, which is 27 basis points above 2018. The annual retail credit loss rate for receivables on balance sheet came to 2.0%. The full year 2019 loss rate rose 24 basis points, mainly because of the LMS effect across the first 3 quarters of 2019. Q4's loss rate climbed 10 basis points, chiefly from 2 factors: first, a driver linked to our strategic push to build riders, encompassing programs like First Time Buyer and dealer paid no money down. Although certain of these loans might push delinquency and credit loss metrics upward, they are prudently underwritten, and we anticipate that added revenue from such programs will exceed the elevated expected risk. Softer motorcycle prices at auction form the second driver behind Q4's higher loss rate. The rest of Harley-Davidson, Inc.'s financial results are summarized on Slide 21. Our balance of cash and marketable securities at year-end was $833.9 million. Operating cash flow for the full year reached $868.3 million, a decline from last year caused by greater working capital and reduced net income. On liquidity, the company maintains, and plans to keep maintaining, at least 12 months of projected liquidity needs in cash and/or committed credit facilities; we think the charts on Slide 22 show that over time we lead in ROIC at the motor company and in return on equity at HDFS, and that we are plainly the leader in generating cash and returning it to shareholders. Among the 5 objectives steering our business strategy and execution through 2027 is achieving superior return on invested capital, measured by motor company ROIC landing in the top quartile of the S&P 500 and by best-in-class returns on equity at HDFS. Slide 23 shows our recent record of returning cash to shareholders. During the fourth quarter of 2019, we paid a dividend of $0.375 per share and bought back 87.7 million — I'm sorry, $78.7 million of our stock. Delivering superior value for our stakeholders remains a top priority. We follow a strong, disciplined approach when making investment choices. Once we've put money into the business, our plan is to give back surplus cash to shareholders through rising dividends and buybacks. Slide 24 summarizes our multiyear manufacturing optimization. Full year results were better than we had anticipated, with realized savings totaling $32.2 million and costs incurred of $43.0 million in 2019. By the close of the fourth quarter, our manufacturing optimization investment is essentially complete. We still anticipate ongoing annual savings of $65 million to $75 million following 2020. Turning to our 2020 full year guidance on Slide 25. For 2020, we anticipate Motorcycle segment revenue of roughly $4.53 billion to $4.66 billion, which is down 1% to up 2% compared to 2019. As Matt noted, during 2020, we're now offering revenue guidance rather than shipment guidance. This change reflects the fact that revenue gives a far more comprehensive picture of our business, since the breadth of revenue growth drivers in our More Roads plan aren't captured by motorcycle shipments. Those revenue drivers include items like small displacement motorcycles, electric bicycles, electric 2-wheelers for kids and a broadened push to expand access to our general merchandise offerings. To help bridge the switch to revenue guidance, we anticipate 601+cc and LiveWire worldwide motorcycle shipments will be down modestly to up slightly in 2020; we anticipate H-D's U.S. retail sales will be lower year-over-year amid lower U.S. industry retail sales, but will keep moderating as the year goes on. During 2020, we anticipate worldwide retail sales will get a positive lift from a sharpened focus on growing committed riders and our investment in stronger dealers; model year '20 and model year '21 motorcycles, including our entry into the dual and sports segments with Pan America and Bronx models in late 2020 and expansion of the international dealer network. That said, we anticipate those positive sales effects will keep running into strong headwinds, including a declining U.S. new bike industry, a relative shift in rider preference toward segments where we don't currently compete, but will enter by the end of this year and a marketplace crowded with highly competitive promotions, incentives and discounts; we anticipate continuing to aggressively manage the supply of retail inventory; even so, we do anticipate year-end worldwide retail inventory will rise moderately amid dealer fill of our new middleweight motorcycles and with the replenishment of our European dealer inventory, which was reduced at the end of 2019 in anticipation of low tariff motorcycles shipping from Thailand. For 2020, motorcycle segment operating margin as a percent of revenue is anticipated to land between 7% and 8%, up from 2019 operating margin of 6.3%. We anticipate gross margin will rise in 2020 amid lower year-over-year EU and China tariffs and strong operational productivity, including roughly $23 million in incremental manufacturing optimization savings. But we anticipate that unfavorable motorcycle mix will partly counteract these gross margin improvements. For 2020, the effect of recent tariffs from the EU and China should come to roughly $30 million, a substantial decrease from the $97.9 million in tariff impacts during 2019. That figure encompasses EU tariffs of about $20 million, stemming from sell-through of high-tariff inventory along with tariffs on our Trikes and CVO models, which we'll keep producing in the United States. Beyond that, we anticipate roughly $15 million in Section 301 Tariffs. Although we'll keep working to take costs out of our SG&A spend, we do anticipate it rising in 2020 because of greater investment in our More Roads plan, since we lapped $34 million of 2019 recall benefits, mostly from supplier recall cost recoveries that we don't anticipate happening again. During 2020, our investment in our More Roads plan reaches its peak as we complete product development and intend to launch our new middleweight motorcycles, electric bicycles and a small displacement motorcycle in China. Lastly, we don't anticipate any restructuring costs in 2020, which will look favorable next to the $32.4 million of charges taken in 2019.
John Olin
executiveFor HDFS, we anticipate that somewhat greater revenue during 2020 will mostly be cancelled out by an increased credit loss provision along with bigger interest expenses as we refinance low-rate MTNs. Even though we're up against last year's elevated losses tied to the LMS system rollout, credit losses should come in a bit higher; we foresee that 2020 credit losses will be impacted partly by worse loss experience across certain financing programs. During 2020, we'll be implementing CECL, the new accounting standard covering credit losses. Consequently, we anticipate a one-time bump in the allowance for credit losses somewhere between $70 million and $110 million, offset by a decrease to retained earnings after taxes. This fresh accounting rule won't affect the economics or cash flows of the HDFS business; even so, we do anticipate greater earnings volatility stemming from CECL. To assist our investors in better grasping shifts in HDFS' provision expense, we'll start reporting actual year-over-year credit losses alongside reserve changes. Capital expenditures for 2020 should land somewhere between $215 million and $235 million; we anticipate our full year effective tax rate will be 24% to 25%. Turning to the first quarter of 2020, we anticipate Motorcycle segment revenue falling between $1.09 billion and $1.17 billion, which is down 2% to down 9% compared with the prior year. Motorcycle segment operating margin as a percent of revenue is likewise projected to decline by roughly 2.5 percentage points. First quarter gross margin should remain flat, thanks to favorable tariff effects and better productivity, though we anticipate — which we expect to be countered by unfavorable mix. SG&A should rise as we lap roughly $28 million of 2019 favorability tied to recall recoveries. To sum up, we encountered and surmounted numerous challenges during 2019. In particular, we've got a plan to offset most of our recent EU and China tariff impacts and achieved meaningful progress on our More Roads plan. As we head into 2020, we're quite encouraged by the momentum we've built over the past year on retail sales trends, yet we also acknowledge the considerable headwinds still in our path. Over the longer horizon, we're tremendously excited about our 2020 More Roads milestones, which will reinforce our current business and open up sustainable growth that will carry us in a fresh direction and generate substantial value through 2022; we remain dedicated to fueling long-term growth for the company and robust returns for our shareholders. Thank you. And now let's take your questions.
Craig Kennison
analystMatt, my understanding is that you mentioned 527,000 riders who came into the brand, along with a net addition of 55,000. That suggests, then, a loss of 472,000. What I want to know is: why are those individuals choosing to depart? And on a connected point, if the overall rider count is rising, should growth in P&A eventually follow? Is that relationship a strong one?
Matt Levatich
executiveYes, Craig, thank you. You've raised the right issue, and it's a fair one. What we saw compared with the prior year was a retention rate that was very much the same. So when new riders came in, those who departed also went up, as you noted, producing a net gain of 55,000. From the rider migration database, we hold a great deal of insight regarding the profile of those exiting and their reasons for doing so, and the largest single factor—where our attention is concentrated—is that early-stage rider. These are individuals who raised their hand, devoted the time, spent the money, learned how to ride, bought a motorcycle, yet intend to leave the sport inside the first 3 years, since they have not yet developed the confidence required to become what we term a committed rider. That represents the biggest single factor behind that exit figure, and so the sole focus of our work on building rider commitment is figuring out how to truly nurture those early-stage riders; the programs I mentioned that are currently in motion are quite specific, programmatic actions we are taking to tackle that biggest single factor among those early-stage exiters. And indeed, as we drive an increase in total motorcycle participation, we ought to anticipate a return to growth in P&A and apparel sales too.
Sharon Zackfia
analystFrom an outsider's perspective, honestly, it's quite difficult to assess the changes underway based on the figures we can see? And I realize you touched on certain items during your prepared remarks. If we rewind to — I believe it was several years back — when the transformation strategy was first announced, could you assist us in determining where you may have exceeded your own expectations for this stage versus where things might be falling a bit short? That way we could establish a baseline before what appears to be a larger anticipated surge in 2021?
Matt Levatich
executiveAbsolutely, Sharon, thank you. Matt here. I'm glad you asked. What I'd note is that the net gain in riders during 2018 came to 26,000, if I recall correctly. Then in 2019, the figure reached 55,000. So progress is happening, yet — as I said earlier in my comments — we must step up the pace. That's exactly the reason behind the focused initiative I brought up when responding to Craig. We established objectives spanning 10 years, and the specific goal there involves growing the count of riders across the U.S. to 4 million. Right now it stands at 3.1 million, so obviously, we must speed things up considerably to bridge that distance. We also have quite targeted programs already running that we're currently piloting toward that end; we feel positive about them; and one difficult aspect of this transformation is that it genuinely pushes against the company's culture, extending even into the dealer network. For over 100 years, we've risen each morning telling ourselves that our purpose is producing outstanding motorcycles, and we excelled at doing so. Waking up and declaring that we must now create riders is a substantially different kind of challenge; it calls for distinct skills, distinct capabilities along with distinct mindsets, plus a different cultural outlook, and our culture is extremely strong, it matters greatly, and in order to move that culture, we are — we're making highly intentional moves around talent, around organizational structures, and through deliberate attempts to continually remind everyone connected to the brand that our mission goes past merely making excellent bikes, it's genuinely about getting very adept at generating riders and creating customers, as I noted earlier; and put simply, among all the transformations we've undertaken — and those have been extremely substantial and extremely tough, whether discussing manufacturing or product development — this particular one ranks as the biggest, since we're rethinking what we exist to accomplish, and that demands each of us to operate differently within the company and also throughout the dealer network. So we're fully engaged and plenty of work remains ahead, which is evident in the figures, we must move faster and we're introducing additional elements into the equation to make that happen.
Tim Conder
analystMatt, if you don't mind, perhaps you could dig into a few of the particular initiatives that got underway during 2019, and then perhaps a few fresh ones you might be launching during 2020, all aimed at pushing that churn rate down even more. You're delivering positive movement on a net basis, which is encouraging; but as you noted, that remains the central priority across the initial 3 years of riding. Then a quick second question for John regarding HDFS. John, now that we've moved beyond the one-year mark since the platform transition, would you expect those delinquencies to flatten out, despite your comment that they may have ticked up somewhat during Q4 because of certain new initiatives?
Matt Levatich
executiveAll right. I'll kick things off. Broadly speaking, we've identified 4 focus areas, drawn from what we've learned about rider retention and ridership. So — and we've got assorted pilot efforts running during Q1. During the prior year, we introduced a few kind of interim offerings, not quite as involved as riding academy, letting folks simply experience a brief sort of 2-hour walkthrough, enabling them to engage first gear, plant a foot on the pegs, cross the parking lot, and start sensing — beyond the jump-start we'd already been providing — what riding genuinely feels like, all to ease them along the path toward more serious learning. That continues today, and we've layered into the blend, at least in concept or notion, particular initiatives focused on riders, recruiting riders — meaning we harness current riders' enthusiasm to cultivate the following generation of riders. Riders recruiting riders, riders coaching riders — which assists those individuals at that early stage in building the confidence, skills, and capabilities required to completely savor riding. Plus we give riders across differing experience levels a chance to expand their experience on their own turf and their own terms, rather than, so to speak, being confined to particular programs. Number three is riding anywhere anytime; this tackles certain practical hurdles folks face, like "I don't have a bike," or "I don't have the gear," or "I don't have someone to ride with," I don't know — "I can't find the time to do it." So we're testing various approaches to see whether we can remove some of those hurdles. And number four involves truly cementing rider commitment, and our research tells us that riding epic journeys — something as straightforward as your first overnight ride — tends to genuinely cement the power of riding as a kind of transformational personal experience. Thus that riding epic journeys concept concerns how we assist people, once again, in going deeper into the passion all of us share for riding. Those are the kinds of programmatic themes or concepts, if you like, for which we currently have dedicated in-market tests running, and we'll start reporting on them as the year progresses.
John Olin
executiveAnd Tim, regarding your follow-up — John here. You asked whether we anticipate credit losses plateauing in 2020. Broadly speaking, the response is affirmative. As we noted in our prepared remarks, a modest rise in credit losses is anticipated, though not on the scale of what occurred this year — just a modest rise — and that will be counterbalanced by higher revenue at HDFS.
Adam Jonas
analystFirst off, I genuinely value and admire the way you lay out the difficulties — honestly, some of this stuff is pretty intimidating, whether it's e-bikes, getting new riders involved, or shifting the culture at a company that's been around for 117 years. That's a really deep kind of change. You're obviously extremely aware of all this, and you're making a lot of genuinely brave attempts here. That said, I suppose <<inaudible>> we're talking right now during what you could call the biggest U.S. economic upswing — one of the biggest expansions ever and one of the strongest equity bull markets in history. So if we were dealing with these issues in a recession, that'd be one thing, but the economy is genuinely roaring, isn't it? Alright, so let's say that during this next year—something you've called a pivot year, and I think the folks listening in would agree with that description—these initiatives fail to deliver the results you're anticipating, and of course there's no certainty they will succeed. In that situation, would the leadership team and the Board of Directors look at strategic alternatives, perhaps even selling the company, as a way to protect this remarkable franchise and brand and to get the most value possible for shareholders?
Matt Levatich
executiveThank you, Adam. What I'd say is that the board constantly keeps in mind the goal of maximizing shareholder value, and it evaluates every decision along with the company's overall strategy. As a board, we're clearly very connected to how the company is performing operationally and to its strategy, and we'll keep assessing that. There are many growth avenues for us beyond simply getting more riders in the United States. One clear example is what we've put into the middleweight platform and what it could deliver, since it opens the door for us to reach most of the heavyweight market that sits outside the United States. To prepare, we've been building out dealer distribution locations, pushing stronger dealer programs, and setting up the Thailand plant — all of which gets us ready for a powerful and substantial payoff from that middleweight platform investment. So regardless of what happens in the U.S. When it comes to putting money into ridership, we've got growth paths that fit into our overall plan. EV is a second one. It isn't only that riding an electric product is remarkably easy—we're also putting funds toward securing our spot as the top name in two-wheel electrification, since that's plainly where automotive offerings are headed as time goes on, and the resulting products are phenomenal. So every one of these items belongs to the strategy. I'd add that it matters for this organization to push itself regarding how we turn into a customer-creation company right here in the United States. If we don't get that right, it could turn out that this is a really tough, long-lasting issue to fix. Even so, we're fully committed to it, since it matters that we commit — that we alter how we present ourselves as an organization and build the capabilities required for it. At the moment, what stands in our way is significant: it's not just that people are beginning to ride motorcycles; they're also leaving, for many different reasons, some of which I mentioned earlier. But we're — this isn't — the way we talk about competition today is not the same as it used to be. What we're truly fighting for is people's scarce time, their scarce dollars, and their commitment. That term gets used often by us; dedication is growing harder to come by when people decide how to spend their hours; you can observe this across numerous other sectors that demand a great deal of time before someone truly becomes immersed in doing something, and that's precisely what our work targets. In our view those efforts matter greatly — building skill and capability for the business regardless, should this obstacle turn out to last longer than what we're aiming to accomplish. Meanwhile, we also have plenty of additional growth platforms we're putting money into.
Jaime Katz
analystJaime, I appreciate the question. On the timing of those additional displacement bikes launching in late 2020 — I'm wondering whether the fourth quarter will carry more of that weight than the third quarter, since the full-year picture really hinges on when you expect to bring them to market. Also, could you shed some light on what adjusted operating margins — specifically motorcycle operating margins — you're assuming in your outlook? I understand the figure you've given is 7% to 8%, but my sense is that if you back out those tariffs, it lands nearer 9%.
John Olin
executiveThanks, Jamie. John here. About the launch — I believe what you're pointing to is 2 middleweight motorcycles that take us into segments where we don't compete today, specifically the dual segment with Pan America and the sports segment with our Bronx motorcycle. Those arrive near the end of the year, and we'd anticipate some shipments, mostly in the United States, along with some retail sales in the U.S., and not much on the retail side in our European markets at that point, given how long shipment takes. Your second question concerns operating margin. Our guidance sits at 7% to 8%. You mentioned 9%, I believe, factoring in the tariffs. When we look at the overall guidance of 7% to 8%, that figure incorporates tariff favorability as well as manufacturing optimization favorability — though a couple of offsets work against that. That's likely why your number comes out somewhat higher. So let's walk through it for a moment. On tariffs, to be very clear, we had $98 million embedded in our 2019 actuals. Looking ahead, we expect that to be $35 million. In the prepared remarks, I believe I said $30 million; on the piece of paper it read $35 million, and $35 million is correct. So Jamie, that amounts to $63 million of year-over-year favorability as we begin coming off the tariffs, thanks to the actions we've taken. The second piece is productivity, which includes our manufacturing optimization. Breaking that down, there are 3 components. First, a restructuring component that won't repeat next year — that's $33 million of favorability. Second, a temporary inefficiency piece embedded in our 2019 performance — that's $10 million, and it turns favorable next year since we won't carry those inefficiencies forward. And finally, the whole point of doing this is to capture savings going forward; we had $32 million of savings in 2019, and we expect an additional $23 million. Those 3 components, Jamie, total $66 million. So when you combine those 2 items, we actually have roughly $129 million in tailwinds heading into 2020, and that's obviously above — it works out to slightly more than 2.5 percentage points, and that sits above where our guidance stands. So I believe what you're really asking is, why is it 7% to 8%, and there are 2 factors that will bring us down from the 9% you referenced. The first is this unfavorable mix. We experienced unfavorable mix in 2019, and it was mostly caused by touring shrinking as a portion of our total mix. This is something we've discussed for a couple of years now, and it reflects consumer preference shifting toward motorcycles other than the ones we produce, and that's clearly what's driving our investment in More Roads. We anticipate that trend carrying on into 2020, so there will be a mix headwind that might not be reflected in your models. The other factor involves SG&A. There are 2 components of SG&A that will come in higher. The first is, once again, lapping what you'd call a onetime or non-repeating item tied to the supplier recoveries and recalls. That's a $34 million headwind as we head into 2020; and then the second component is the spending on our More Roads and product development — within the 5-year period we refer to as our More Roads plan, 2020 is the peak investment period. The reason for that is quite simple: we're bringing out a lot of new and different products, which demands a great deal of engineering investment, and product development spending tends to be at its highest before a product launches; and then the second component is our More Roads investment to launch those products, plus the go-to-market spending needed to make sure everyone understands those products and the consumer benefits. So we'll reach a peak on that spending, and SG&A will be up somewhat more than what we're seeing in the investment analysts' models. So taking those 2 together, we do expect operating margin to land between 7% and 8%, all-inclusive.
Joe Altobello
analystJohn, I'd like to revisit something you said earlier regarding used motorcycle prices at auction being softer during the quarter. Could you perhaps give us a sense of how that's been trending recently? It seems the spread between new and used pricing has grown somewhat, and how are you viewing that as we head into 2020?
John Olin
executiveWhen we examine pricing overall, we've generally spoken about 3 levels; what's taking place at auction, what's taking place with pricing services that supply data to consumers and dealers, and then finally what's taking place within our dealer network; so Joe, you inquired about the first one, which is at auction. We've now witnessed, following 9 quarters of improvement, a flat quarter in Q2, and 2 quarters where we've been down slightly in terms of auction prices in Q3 and Q4. Moving on from that, the pricing services experienced about 8 quarters of increased pricing direction; but during the last quarter, we had them split. One service was projecting higher prices while the other projected lower. And then the third level of how we examine used bike prices is what's actually transacting within our dealer network. And with that, we've had 10 consecutive quarters of used bike prices rising, which is very good news. And again, this quarter — in the fourth quarter, they rose. So we've got a bit of a mix here. We're keeping a close eye on what's happening at auction because that typically ripples through to the dealer network; but at this point, we are seeing improving used bike prices in our dealer network.
Gerrick Johnson
analystI'd like to discuss Neil Grimmer leaving. At the Analyst Day, he stood out. His presentation was excellent, in my view. I'm curious about who takes his place. Also, is the brand development strategy being altered?
Matt Levatich
executiveGerrick, that one's mine. Sure. I — the reasons we brought Neil aboard still hold true right now, and I'm in the middle of searching for a brand President to fill the role, and everything accomplished during his time here and afterward is built into the approach we follow for growing committed riders; so we're pushing hard along that path, and we have a strong team already in position carrying out that effort, and for now, I'm heading up that group and ensuring its efforts are completely aligned as we bring products to market here in the United States and across the globe; so it's steady as she goes; we require that kind of leadership for the tasks ahead so we can get truly proficient at customer creation. And the moment we find that talent, we'll be thrilled to put them before our investors.
David MacGregor
analystDavid, a question regarding the overseas segment: you mentioned retail sales slipping a bit across developed markets. What I want to know is whether credit access from traditional lenders in those areas is shifting in a way that created a drag on growth there?
John Olin
executiveThanks, David — John here. Across both our developed and international markets, nothing has changed when it comes to credit availability. Keep in mind that HDFS is essential to how we obtain credit in those regions, and they truly know their way around collaborating with outside providers. As you're aware, underwriting happens only in Canada and the United States for us; even so, they operate alongside us, and credit availability in those developed markets remains unchanged. Beyond that, we feel great about the sales results we posted in international markets during the back half of this year. Following a first half that was down roughly 6.6%, the back half brought growth — so thank you, David.
David MacGregor
analystAnd as a quick follow-up, John. You had several promotions during the quarter, I believe — the extended warranty promotion, plus some other items. How do you think riders reacted to those efforts? And what does that indicate about how you'll steer your promotional efforts moving ahead?
John Olin
executiveThanks, David. In fact, promotions were quite minimal for us in this year's fourth quarter. We didn't have many last year, either. The extended warranty program counts as one, though it's been more of an ongoing offering; we've provided it for multiple years now. It simply gives someone who visits during the coldest part of winter an extra couple of months of coverage, so they aren't burning through it while the bike sits in the garage or in storage; so that hasn't really been a primary force behind promotional efforts, but once again, it's stayed steady across the past several years. Broadly speaking, as you're aware, starting in this year's first quarter, we've been dialing back our promotions and incentives. We did run a finance offer during the third quarter, considerably smaller than the one from 2018's third quarter. Yet in this year's fourth quarter, we had no significant promotions or money-off deals. We did have some in 2018's fourth quarter. We had a private offer running then. No meaningful financing offers during the fourth quarter. So — and this is how we're proceeding from here. We've shifted those dollars toward building and amplifying the brand, and we've been quite happy with what we've seen.
James Hardiman
analystMany of the things I was going to ask have already been covered, though I did want to come back, John, to what I believe was Jamie's question about margin; the specifics you provided around the bridge were quite useful; even so, I have 2 questions on that subject. First, I believe you refer to them as warranty recovery benefits of $34 million. I don't recall hearing about those previously, so perhaps you could give us — or help us grasp when those landed in 2019? Presumably, once we move ahead into 2020, we'd want to remove those benefits from our figures; from what you're saying, part of that may have already occurred during the first quarter. So could you help us with that timing? That's the first one. Then there's the EU waiver, which clearly was a significant drag in 2019, and as I remember, it was supposed to become a solid positive in 2020. When does that take effect? And how much does it help shipments and margins?
Matt Levatich
executiveAlright. The first question concerns the timing of supplier — mostly supplier recoveries. If you look back to Q4 of 2018, we had 2 recalls, totaling $55 million. During the first quarter of 2019, a supplier recovery of $28 million came in. That would have appeared in the K and was discussed on the call back then. Across the year, mostly in the second quarter, James, we also released other recall reserves of roughly $6 million. So those 2 items won't repeat in 2020, and instead will act as a headwind, and once again, together they come to $34 million. And yes, 24 — $28 million of that, which we addressed in the first quarter, will land and be a headwind during the first quarter of 2020. The second item concerns the EU. We had been waiting for a decision from the EU, and it arrived later than expected. Because of that, during the second quarter, we reduced some of our shipment volumes, since we intended to bring inventories down at year-end in anticipation of lower-tariff inventory arriving from the plant in Thailand. That isn't the sole reason we reduced them, as there's also some weakness in international markets. So that has now happened; and the company performed extremely well, and our team in Europe performed extremely well in bringing inventories down. All told, international inventory fell by 3,000 units. We had anticipated roughly 2,000 from Europe, and we achieved slightly more than that; so in 2020 we will aim to rebuild inventories, and that forms part of the revenue drivers behind our range of down 1% to up 2%, as we rebuild that inventory with lower-tariff bikes coming from Thailand. So that's really a reallocation of revenue rather than a margin effect. On top of that, we incurred higher costs because of that postponed decision, and those costs will be lapped. My recollection is that it was around $5 million, so 2020 should see a benefit from that, and that benefit is baked into the 7% to 8% operating margin guidance we've given.
Greg Badishkanian
analystLiveWire shipments came in below what was anticipated, largely because of certain production problems that occurred some time back. Could you discuss the — perhaps how sales momentum is trending for that line? Plus ongoing excitement and how enthusiastic consumers are, along with dealers?
Matt Levatich
executiveMatt here. I — there are — a few points; we've returned to the rate we had planned, and reaching that rate required time while we sorted out those initial supply chains, and we are incredibly thorough and careful to guarantee that each motorcycle reaching the market is flawless from the customer's viewpoint. The initial responses have been terrific. From the standpoint of underlying demand, it's difficult to determine, for 2 reasons; first, preorders are still being fulfilled, and second, it's winter. So we'll gain much greater clarity regarding underlying demand for LiveWire once more inventory exists across the dealer network during spring, when the spring selling season gets going. One element of our approach with the LiveWire launch involved setting up a one-to-one white-glove process in which different individuals across the company, in engineering, in customer service, people with deep product knowledge, maintained one-to-one connections with initial purchasers. And responding to their inquiries, measuring their excitement and interest, and that forms part of what we're hearing from first owners, and what we're hearing is simply incredible; so we're hugely satisfied with how the press responded and how the first owners responded. We're processing the pre-orders. We're at planned rate. We're expanding inventory within the dealer channel. We're also expanding availability beyond the United States. We have phase 2 dealers joining in the U.S. this year. So there's plenty of reasons for optimism around LiveWire. And we'll learn far more once the spring season arrives and there's availability to satisfy what amounts to instantaneous demand.
Shannon Burns
executiveOkay, thank you all. A recording and the presentation deck from this session can be accessed through harley-davidson.com, and if you want the audio version by phone, dial (855) 859 to 2056 or (404) 537 to 3406, and those lines stay open through February 11. The passcode you'll need is 6026039. We're grateful for your stake in Harley-Davidson. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's conference call, everyone. We appreciate your participation. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Harley-Davidson, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Harley-Davidson, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Harley-Davidson, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.