Harley-Davidson, Inc. (HOG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 28, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Automobiles earnings 60 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Company Representatives

executive
#1

On the call with us are Jochen Zeitz, our Chief Executive Officer; John Olin, our Chief Financial Officer; and Shannon Burns, our Director of Investor Relations.

Shannon Burns

executive
#2

Hello, everybody, and welcome. The slide deck for today's call is available on investor.harley-davidson.com — simply select the Earnings Materials box located in the middle of that page. Within our remarks, we'll be making forward-looking statements, and those carry risks that might lead to actual outcomes differing materially. Among the risks are items we've outlined in our most recent earnings release as well as our SEC filings. Harley-Davidson takes no responsibility for revising any information shared on this call. With me today are our CEO, Jochen Zeitz, and our CFO, John Olin, and all of us are connecting from various places. Jochen, over to you.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#3

Thanks, Shannon, and good morning, everyone. Today I want to walk you through what I've seen so far, the first steps I've taken, and where I intend to steer Harley-Davidson. Before that, though, I want to recognize the historic moment we're living through and say how privileged I feel to be part of a company that has demonstrated such remarkable resilience when times are tough. Community is at the core of Harley-Davidson, and we pay tribute to those who are ill, to the people delivering care and comfort, and to those laboring endlessly to bring this awful pandemic to an end. Every one of us has felt the effects of this crisis, yet I'm certain we'll come through it. With the proper focus, and with the changes I mean to carry out quickly and with dedication, I'm confident we'll come out of this stronger. Having watched things closely for the past 2 months, I can see plainly that this is a pivotal moment in our history, one that demands major changes at the company. Here are my main takeaways: First, for the foreseeable future, COVID-19 has reshaped our reality in dramatic fashion, and this crisis has piled onto circumstances that were already difficult. A solid plan is in place to safeguard our customers and employees and to manage our resources carefully, and I take pride in how our team has responded. Across the areas below, we're taking action: Above all, we keep moving fast, in step with government efforts, to safeguard the health of employees and the Harley-Davidson community. Restrictions have been put in place, sanitation practices strengthened, and events called off. By closing facilities and temporarily halting manufacturing operations, we're able to put workplace protections in place and build a thorough plan — one that incorporates precautions and guidance from public authorities — to protect employee health. In a measured way that keeps employees safe, we are gradually restarting production, and everyone whose role permits it will still be required to work from home, which keeps the number of people at each facility down; as for the broader community, our foundation gave to the United Way's COVID-19 relief fund, and via our "United We Will Ride" efforts, we're donating the proceeds from the custom LiveWire Auction and using our channels to link riders with relief opportunities, letting them make a difference where they live. Last week, Jason Momoa helped us launch these efforts with a powerful video, kicking off our COVID-19 relief work. Second, this year we're keeping roughly $250 million in cash by cutting capital and non-essential spending — freezing hiring, lowering salaries, and doing away with merit increases. Other cost management steps were also put in place, like retiming when new products launch. On top of that, we've paused discretionary share repurchase and cut our Q2 cash dividend to $0.02 per share, down from $0.38 per share in Q1. Given how uncertain the COVID-19 crisis is, we see these as prudent moves. Third, our liquidity remains strong, with close to $2.5 billion on hand at quarter's end. In recent days, we've strengthened our cash reserves, reworked our credit facilities totaling $1.42 billion, pushed out the maturity on our 364 day loan facility, and we're currently talking with large U.S. banks to obtain another $1.3 billion in liquidity. And lastly, given the COVID-19 crisis, it matters that we lighten the load for dealers and riders. Our dealer assistance is tailored to what each region specifically requires, and it covers things like financial help for Motorcycle inventory, postponing certain credit payment due dates, and loosening warranty and training requirements. Although these steps bring short term relief to dealers, we do anticipate the network will shrink during this crisis. So going forward, we'll focus on optimizing that network and boosting dealer profitability. Turning to our riders, plenty of dealers are still open to provide service support, and we keep selling Parts & Accessories and General Merchandise through online channels. Together with our dealers, we're making home delivery of new Motorcycles possible wherever it's allowed. And for riders dealing with the impact of COVID-19, HDFS is working to keep them riding. Having had a great many discussions with our management, employees and other stakeholders, a few more things have grown clear to me. To start, our product, our riders and our dealers give us enormous strength. Even so, there are challenges we must tackle that this crisis has made more obvious, such as the considerable complexity throughout the organization that we need to reduce. Our team is skilled and diligent, yet leadership has grown somewhat cut off and excessively centralized, which makes it slow to react. Decisions need to be made faster. Over the past years, following numerous rounds of cost reductions and reorganizations, I've noticed that morale has taken a hit. People feel frustrated because some cost cutting efforts have aimed at making fundamentally inefficient things more efficient. Because of that, we must rekindle the soul and culture of Harley-Davidson. On top of that, our organization has gotten used to promising too much and delivering too little. We need to establish attainable plans and sensible goals. In reviewing our strategy, I recognize that pieces of the More Roads plan are sound in principle, yet obviously our strategy requires renewed focus so it fits better with what we're capable of and can do, and it also needs updating in light of our new reality. We'll keep growing past traditional products and markets; even so, we've placed too much emphasis on new riders and new market growth while neglecting critical profit sources. We've made headway with our product line and, to a certain extent, our customer base, but profits trail behind and our expectations don't make sense, particularly considering the economic conditions we're probably going to face, since the ripple effect of COVID-19 will likely stay with us for a while. We've kept pushing ahead with the most promising parts of More Roads, but our strategy has to be reevaluated. Based on everything I've seen and assessed, I've reached the conclusion that significant steps are necessary — we must rewire this company right now across priorities, execution, our operating model, and strategy, all to generate sustained profit alongside long-term growth. The Rewire is what we're naming this effort, and it serves as our playbook over the coming months, pointing toward a fresh 5 year strategic plan that we will present once there's enough visibility into what lies ahead. Let me walk through several key pieces of The Rewire. To begin, we'll strengthen what we're already great at while achieving a better balance as we expand into new spaces; returning attention and power to our brand and company matters more than ever now, beginning with dealers, customers, our strongest products, and dedicated team members across the globe. HDFS additionally holds a strategic edge, with a track record that will assist us in steering through this crisis. We're reassessing our approaches for attracting new riders and growing ridership. Next, we put priority on the markets that count; we will put money into the markets, products, and customers delivering the greatest profit and potential. That involves growing from our solid position in the U.S. We'll concentrate our focus, time, and energy on the most essential countries and market segment capable of moving the needle for us right now; we will also carefully pursue the long game by pinpointing select strategic markets that might not add to enterprise profitability soon, yet remain vital for what's ahead.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#4

Additionally, we're going to streamline how we cover the market and remove expenses from that operation. As our third step, we're going to revamp how we introduce products and arrange our lineup, aiming for greater simplicity and the strongest possible effect. We're pushing out introductions by six to 12 months to match where we now stand and to let our schedule of launches line up with the beginning of the riding season — something that hasn't happened in our company's recent past. Over time, we'll make our launches less complicated so they fit better with what our dealers can handle and what our company's resources can support. Starting there, we'll grow our profitable iconic heritage motorcycles to get our current riders excited. We're still dedicated to Adventure Touring, Streetfighter, and pushing ahead with what we're doing in Electric. As we sharpen where we put our attention across what we offer, aiming to get the most out of value and profit, we'll keep letting our customers and dealers guide us through their feedback. Then, we'll grow our Parts & Accessories and General Merchandise operations to reach their full potential; across these areas we're putting together a thorough plan centered on opportunities in assortment and distribution, getting the most from its channels, enhancing e-commerce abilities and boosting gross revenues and margins for the company as well as dealers; we'll match this plan up with our Motorcycle plan so we can present it to the market realistically. And last, we'll tweak and bring into line our organizational setup, cost setup, and the way we operate, so the organization is positioned for steadiness and achievement. We're putting together a blueprint for achievement — a company that's more concentrated and agile, matched with a suitable cost setup that's been adapted to the market's new circumstances after the crisis. We'll also revamp how we operate to boost empowerment, diversity, and accountability when it comes to important choices. Basically, our updated organization would carry less complexity, have a keener focus, and be capable of deciding more quickly. We're setting up the proper central and new regional structures that are commercially driven to create the right emphasis on dealers and selling; we'll also raise the profile of Motorcycle Management inside the organization and refine our marketing approach and how we carry it out so we can achieve a greater effect with a better process for going to market. The Rewire is in motion and we've made moves on every one of these essential playbook pieces, with additional ones being worked on. I've brought up a few of the major moves we've already made to let the organization keep advancing. Other moves made lately include putting the organizational superstructure in place with three new senior management people named to important positions; we're elevating talent that understands the company, our dealers, and our customers. To deliver the right sales emphasis, we've set up a new commercial entity, which includes a streamlined regional sales structure, plus refreshed Parts & Accessories and General Merchandise operations. To draw on expertise and a historical perspective while we refine our strategy, I've brought in our senior leaders from outside the executive team and set up a CEO Roundtable made up of chosen dealers and former Harley-Davidson leaders. The team is working hard, bringing new energy to the business, and we'll share more on our progress when we give our Q2 update. To wrap up, achieving our goals ahead means we must keep joining forces. Right now, as one worldwide Harley-Davidson family, we stand together backing our relatives, pals, and fellow riders during this crisis, which we hope concludes before long. My thanks go out to the entire crew of staff, dealers, and riders for contributing to remaining safe and well. Above everything else, their health and wellness matter most. Even though when this pandemic will finish is unclear, the essence of Harley-Davidson remains. It serves as a warm guiding light that glows past the present moment. To me, this represents a tremendous chance to rework the business and place us onto a route toward tremendous achievement down the road. We confront our circumstances with determination, and I trust we'll emerge from this more powerful than before. We'll bring Harley-Davidson back to life, and we'll unite behind the mission we've just declared. Beyond constructing machines, we represent the eternal quest for adventure, liberty for the spirit. And at this point I'd like to hand things over to John so he can go over the quarter's financial outcomes.

John Olin

executive
#5

Appreciate that, Jochen. Slide six contains the overview of what we delivered in Q1. Operating income from the Motorcycle unit declined compared with a year ago in the quarter, due to fewer shipments and adverse foreign exchange, partly countered by solid production efficiency, reduced tariffs relative to last year, and the benefit of lapping the prior year's restructuring charge. Operating income at financial services dropped 60.9%, the result of changes to our loan loss provision stemming from COVID-19 plus the effect of a new accounting pronouncement. As a result, consolidated net income came in below the previous year. Earnings per share for the quarter landed at $0.45. Even with the COVID-19 crisis, our long-term priorities stay the same: disciplined inventory management, aggressive cost control, cash generation from operations, and strong returns for shareholders. Turning to slide seven, worldwide retail sales of new Harley-Davidson Motorcycles in the first quarter fell 17.7% against last year. Early in Q1, retail sales got off to a robust start around the world, but they were heavily constrained once consumer worries and government actions tied to COVID-19 moved through the majority of our global markets; starting in Asia, then Europe, and ultimately the U.S., Canada and portions of Latin America. Beyond this near-term crisis, we believe our brand distribution and innovative products give us an excellent foundation for long-term success. We think the Harley-Davidson rewire initiatives—focused on getting more value and profit out the door—will leave us much stronger in the future. Turning to slide eight, let’s dig into the U.S. numbers. Compared with a year ago, first-quarter U.S. retail sales fell 15.5%, even though earlier in the period they had climbed to a quarter-to-date gain of 6.6% by the middle of March, helped by better dealer execution and fresh model introductions. Then, during the second half of March, HD retail sales fell off a cliff, driven by anxious consumers and the fact that about half our U.S. dealers were temporarily closed for motorcycle sales because of COVID-19. During this quarter, Harley-Davidson captured 48.9% of new motorcycle registrations, which represents a decline of 2.2 percentage points. Several factors drove this: rivals engaged in heavy promotional pricing, we were up against last year's financing promotion from HD, and there was an unfavorable shift in sales mix — moving away from categories where we currently play toward ones where we aren't yet present, though we will enter those with Pan America and Bronx Motorcycles. Additionally, our share declined even within the categories where we are active. Due to COVID-19's effects, U.S. retail inventory finished the quarter roughly 1,600 Motorcycles higher compared to the same point a year ago. As we work through this crisis, we'll take aggressive steps to control the flow of Motorcycles to dealers. Slide nine shows that our international retail sales fell 20.7% during Q1. Fear about COVID-19, along with dealers shutting down, moved from Asia into Europe, then Canada, and Latin America. In EMEA, every market dropped sharply, finishing 28.4% lower. The Asia Pacific region declined 5.3%, dragged down by decreases in China and South Korea, though growth in Japan and India provided some offset. The values 7726817 (as in: 5) 859 to 2056 or (404) 537 to 3406 until May 12. The ID is 7726817. And thanks, Shannon and John, and thank you for your time. Now looking at Latin America, Mexico and Brazil both retreated, leaving us with a 21.5% drop for the quarter. In Europe, our Q1 market share came in at 7.6%, which was 1.3 percentage points lower than the same period a year ago. The unfavorable move in our sales mix toward non-HD segments, along with heightened competition, hurt our market share; looking at slide 10, wholesale Motorcycle shipments during the first quarter fell 10.0%. COVID-19-related interruptions at our manufacturing operations weighed on shipments. Compared with last year's first quarter, overall family mix moved away from Touring and Sports toward Street Motorcycles and Cruiser Motorcycles; on slide 11, Motorcycle segment Q1 revenue totaled $1.1 billion, a decline of 8% on the back of a 10% drop in Motorcycle shipments. For Motorcycles, the average amount brought in for each bike was up by $599. That came from a better mix of products sold, fewer incentives offered to buyers, and improved pricing compared with a year earlier, though currency exchange worked against us to some degree. Turning to slide 12: gross margin for Q1 came in lower. The reasons were fewer units shipped, a mix that wasn't as strong, and adverse currency exchange, with some help from a drop in manufacturing costs. On the product mix side, Q1 saw a $3.4 million unfavorable impact, which came from a change in the mix across families plus an unfavorable mix within Parts & Accessories. Currency exchange took $10.8 million off Q1 gross margin. The foreign currency effect was negative, largely tied to the U.S. dollar getting stronger. During Q1, our manufacturing costs came in better than expected thanks to gains in productivity, reduced tariffs, and the fact that we were up against some one-time inefficiencies from the prior year — though this was partially counterbalanced by weaker absorption of fixed manufacturing costs. If you look at slide 13, operating margin as a share of revenue for the first quarter declined compared to a year ago. That drop came from a lower gross margin and increased SG&A, which reflected the lapping of recall recoveries from the previous year, and it was mostly offset by our disciplined approach to managing costs. Profitability and cash flows stay at the top of our priorities. Now shifting to our financial services segment on slide 14 — as we mentioned during the last quarter, we implemented CECL on January 1, 2020, which is the new accounting standard for credit losses. So because of that, we recorded a $100.6 million one-time bump to our allowance for credit losses, and the other side of that entry was a decrease in retained earnings after taxes. This new accounting rule won't change the economics or the cash flow of our HDFS business. That said, as we've talked about before, we do anticipate that adopting CECL will bring more volatility in earnings, and that's definitely what happened in the first quarter of 2020. HDFS posted first quarter operating income of $22.9 million, which is 60.9% lower than the prior year. The first quarter provision for loan losses across both retail and wholesale was $44.9 million worse than the prior year. Two things drove the provision higher. The first was an $8.9 million bump from greater actual credit losses, and the second was a $36 million addition to our allowance for credit losses. Those actual losses climbed mainly because of COVID-19 — auction prices came in lower, repossessions slowed down, and consumers made delayed payments toward the end of the quarter. The values 7726817 (as in: 5) 859 to 2056 or (404) 537 to 3406 until May 12. The ID is 7726817. And thanks, Shannon and John, and thank you for your time. Two sources produced the $36 million increase in retail and wholesale credit reserves. First, COVID-19's economic effects, specifically how they shape what we expect from customers when it comes to repaying loans. Second, adopting the CECL accounting pronouncement meant we changed our reserves so they now reflect the projected COVID-19 impact across the full life of loans in our portfolio. Slide 15 covers HDFS's operational results. Retail originations for Q1 fell 10.8% compared with the prior year, pulled down by fewer new bike sales. HDFS's market share held roughly steady at a very strong 64.3%. When the quarter closed, HDFS held $1.05 billion in cash and cash equivalents, plus $1 billion in liquidity accessible via bank credit and conduit facilities. Turning to slide 16, our delinquency rate for accounts 30 days or more past due improved, falling 36 basis points once we got beyond the early problems that came with rolling out our new loan management system in January of 2019. That said, we believe the COVID-19 crisis delivered a slight blow to delinquencies toward the end of March. For Q1, the retail credit loss rate came in at 2.73%, an increase of 51 basis points compared with a year earlier. As we mentioned before, the rise in first quarter losses was driven primarily by the effects of COVID-19. On slide 17, we lay out the rest of Harley-Davidson's financial results.

John Olin

executive
#6

At the close of the quarter, our cash plus marketable securities came to $1.47 billion. During the quarter we raised how much cash we hold as a safeguard, given the uncertainty the crisis has created. Operating cash for Q1 was negative $8.6 million, and the reason was lower net income this year versus last year. The charts on slide 18, in our view, show that over time we lead on ROIC at the motor company and on return on equity at HDFS, and that we have proven leadership in generating cash. Slide 19 shows what we return to shareholders. During the first quarter of 2020, our quarterly dividend was $0.38 per share. Everyone knows we didn't buy back any shares at our own discretion during the quarter. Turning to the outlook, which you'll find on slide 20. In the 8-K we submitted on March 26, we withdrew all guidance since we couldn't be sure how severe or how lengthy the pandemic would turn out to be. As Jochen mentioned before, the COVID-19 action plan shown on slide three centers on four key areas. I'd like to expand a bit on two of those: number one, keeping cash on hand, and number two, bringing in more liquidity. What we're concentrating on is holding onto cash and increasing liquidity so that we can get through this difficult period. When the pandemic hit, we had a very solid balance sheet and 12 months of liquidity. To hold onto our cash, we've done several concrete things. The first and most important is trimming anything that isn't essential and pulling back on what we planned to spend on capital projects in 2020. Even so, we kept our focus on funding New Motorcycles, including Adventure Touring, Streetfighter and Electric. Beyond that, we're delaying cash going out the door wherever it's sensible to do so. Meanwhile, we're trying to lock down our supply chain and make sure parts are available, so the plants can restart as quickly as we can manage. As for liquidity, we finished with $2.47 billion available, and that figure includes $1.47 billion of cash. At this moment, talks are underway with two large banks aimed at obtaining another $1.3 billion in liquidity. One of those deals is expected to close before this week is over; past that point, we anticipate carrying out capital markets transactions during the weeks ahead. Our estimated consolidated liquidity stood at $2.28 billion as of the close of business on April 24. Going forward, two MTN's come due during the rest of the year — a $450 million one in May, plus another worth $350 million in June. If we assume zero motor company revenues, and factor in neither extra liquidity nor any mitigating steps, our belief is that liquidity on hand will be enough to keep operating through the end of the year. Our credit ratings are still all investment grade, and the commercial paper markets remain accessible to us. In addition, HDFS has historically served as a cash generator for the company during periods when motorcycle sales decline, as we saw in the Great Recession. HDFS brought in roughly $200 million in net cash over the past six weeks. Beyond that, we have substantial headroom under our debt covenants. The HDFS covenants cap the debt-to-equity ratio at 10:1. At the close of Q1, that ratio was 6.6:1. Given our balance sheet, along with strong cash and available liquidity, we believe we are equipped to manage the challenges created by COVID-19. Thank you. At this point, we're ready for your questions.

Greg Badishkanian

analyst
#7

Thanks a lot! So, there are two things I want to ask about. First, from what I gathered, retail sales came in strong, up 6.6% before COVID hit. That would have ranked among the best quarters in quite a while. So, what was behind those results, and what can you carry over once COVID passes? Also, did I miss it — I didn't catch a U.S. quarter-to-date figure for April. I'm curious how those trends looked for you, since I believe some other power sports companies, Polaris for instance, appeared to improve somewhat in April. Was it the same story on your end?

John Olin

executive
#8

Appreciate it, Greg, John here. Yes, Greg, when you look at it, the quarter split into two distinct halves; first came a 10 week stretch, followed by a three week stretch. During those initial 10 weeks, retail sales performed quite strongly for us, and as we noted, the U.S. figure rose 6.6%. Greg, much of that came from initiatives we've been working on throughout the past year, focused on stronger dealers, and those keep gaining traction; we're seeing additional dealers get on board and clearly solid outcomes emerging from those efforts. Beyond that, we also launched multiple products during the first quarter, many of them toward the end of it, and those generated a decent chunk of sales too. Now, regarding — over those final three weeks, retail sales dropped off sharply for reasons everyone understands, and much of that, Greg, stemmed from dealers shutting their doors; when March began, roughly 4% of our dealers had closed, and that climbed dramatically by the time March ended, reaching 55%. Then across April, as things stand now, around 59% are shut. So dealer closures for new motorcycle sales appear to be leveling off, though retail sales have fallen alongside that. They're down considerably for April. Still, the decline isn't as steep as what we're seeing with dealer closures; in other words, retail sales are holding up better than the closures would suggest, and based on that, we'd say locations that remain open are selling at levels close to where they were a year ago.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#9

Greg, allow me to jump in — this is Jochen. You brought up the new models we rolled out during Q1. There were 4 fresh bikes, each centered on the heart of what we do: the 30th Anniversary Fat Boy, the Softail Standard, the Eagle Eye, and the Patriot. That lineup definitely gave our sales a lift across the opening 2 months.

Greg Badishkanian

analyst
#10

I appreciate that.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#11

Hey, good morning, and thanks for taking my question. This is really a multipart one about the CEO search. Jochen, to start, when you're sitting down with dealers, what is it they want in the person who will lead Harley Davidson next? And second, how should investors read the choice to actually go after a five year plan prior to bringing on the permanent CEO — and does that signal you're a candidate? Thank you.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#12

Thanks Craig. On the CEO search, honestly there is nothing to report right now. My attention is squarely on developing and implementing the plan for handling the crisis and making certain we come out of it stronger with The Rewire plan, which I also intend to implement and develop, obviously, since we're in the middle of that. So there is nothing really to add right now regarding the CEO search.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#13

When it comes to what dealers want in a new leader?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#14

Honestly, I have no idea what dealers want. What we want as a Board is clear, and those criteria are already set. So there's really nothing more I can say about that, and I'd add that putting together a five year plan is something a CEO always has to do, whether or not they're in an acting role, and from the start I've been very clear that I'm not an interim-CEO, but an acting-CEO, and while we work through our rewiring process and playbook, we clearly also need to review our current strategic plan and determine what remains valid and what doesn't. So developing a new five year plan is part of my duty as well, and that's what we're concentrating on right now.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#15

That's quite useful, thanks.

James Hardiman

analyst
#16

Morning, and thanks for having me on the call. I'd like to explore HDFS a bit more. I believe I mostly understand the situation with CECL. Could you perhaps help us understand — those added reserves, the figure of $36 million — what would the picture have been had the CECL standard not been applied? Clearly it's being magnified in that context. And my larger question, I suppose, is how should we view HDFS going forward? My assumption is that the $8.9 million of higher actual credit losses is something we'll be facing across the coming few quarters, but — assuming credit metrics don't deteriorate materially — we shouldn't be concerned that the $36 million figure will recur down the road. What's the right way to frame that?

John Olin

executive
#17

Thanks James, John here. As you pointed out, reserves went up by $36 million, and total provision rose $45 million, which consists of the two components you referenced: $8.9 million of actual losses, plus the reserve portion at $36 million. So CECL did produce or bring about a figure larger than it would have been otherwise; we estimate that out of that $36 million, roughly three quarters, somewhere around $17 million to $18 million, would have been present under the incurred basis — the incurred method the industry used before CECL. That leaves roughly a quarter attributable to CECL, and the CECL portion really has two components: one is simply the larger reserve, which represents about a 50% increase relative to what changes would have been historically, and the other is a seasonality adjustment, which is also new; seasonality was in fact favorable during the first quarter, and we'd anticipate some of that unwinding in the second and third quarters. So regarding that $36 million reserve, it was established at the end of March, and at that point we examine all available data, including things like the expectation of recession, how severe it might be and how long it might last; it also considers other economic data such as unemployment, GDP, and certainly used bike values — all of that gets incorporated at that moment on March 31, fed through the models, and the result indicated we needed to raise reserves by $36 million; and had everything stayed at those assumptions, we would have anticipated that to be the full extent of what was needed, covering the issues that COVID has brought about. But let me say this, James: from March 31 up to now, the economic figures have gotten worse — definitely when you look at joblessness, the outlook for GDP, and how deep this downturn will be as it emerges. So by the time the quarter closes and we have to re-mark, nobody can say what will happen. If conditions remain where they sit today, though, we'd anticipate yet another bump in the HDFS reserves once the second quarter ends. Once more, that's something we'll simply have to monitor, and it might likewise affect credit losses — the $8.9 million figure you brought up; we're keeping a close eye on it. HDFS has been quite aggressive in what they're doing. Their underwriting standards have been adjusted: LTVs are now restricted, payment-to-income is being tightened, the maximum amounts financed have been tightened, proof of income requirements have gone up, and underwriting in oil patch regions has also been tightened. So they're fully on top of it, but we'll keep reading the economy and make whatever adjustments are necessary going forward.

James Hardiman

analyst
#18

That's genuinely useful, thank you John. And I want to make sure I've got this right — that figure of $8.9 million, if the assumptions had been left the same as they stood on March 31, is that an item we'd be facing across the coming three quarters and more?

John Olin

executive
#19

No, I don't think I'm fully following you there, James. The $8.9 million represents the amount we wrote off.

James Hardiman

analyst
#20

Okay.

John Olin

executive
#21

Those loans are ones we don't anticipate recovering. We'll keep attempting collection efforts, but they've been charged off and are now in the past. Going forward, they have no connection to us.

James Hardiman

analyst
#22

All right. So we shouldn't take it that a similar rise in actual losses is going to occur in later quarters. That's already been captured within the higher provision.

John Olin

executive
#23

Even though we've written off those particular loans, we hold plenty of others, and when the next quarter comes we'll review which among them would be headed to write off, correct, and that depends on whether our customers can repay, on unemployment, and on all the other elements we brought up.

James Hardiman

analyst
#24

Got it. Okay, thanks John.

John Olin

executive
#25

Thank you, James.

Felicia Hendrix

analyst
#26

Hi! Can you hear me now?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#27

Yes Felicia.

Felicia Hendrix

analyst
#28

Alright. I suppose it's about time for a phone upgrade — my apologies. So, continuing along that same topic, and good morning, John — I had something to ask regarding the CECL-linked matter involving credit loss provisions. Based on how we happen to run the numbers, that $45 million rise in credit loss provisions simply appears somewhat on the low side; it amounts to merely a $10 million bump versus last year, so could you walk us through the assumptions underlying that shift, given the new CECL accounting standards? Our expectation had been that it would come in higher; and beyond that, I'm also curious what share of your customers right now sit on some sort of agreed-upon forbearance plan, and if so, would that get folded into your 30-day delinquency and annualized loan loss metrics?

John Olin

executive
#29

Thank you, Felicia. That $45 million provision — you noted it was up $10 million, and you'd anticipated a bigger figure. On a year-over-year basis the provision rose by that $45 million, and it consists of two components. First, the write offs we recorded totaling $8.9 million, and second, the larger reserve, which reflects the COVID crisis along with something of a boost tied to those CECL accounting provisions. So that's…

Felicia Hendrix

analyst
#30

John, my apologies — let me try that again, I didn't phrase it well enough. It's the credit loss figure I'm asking about — sorry, that $45 million bump in credit loss provisions — that's the piece you felt was, well, in line with the increase.

John Olin

executive
#31

Right, and that's pretty much the topic we'd touched on earlier. When the quarter closed, we marked everything based on what data existed as of March 31, and with the information in hand, booking $45 million was the correct figure. Since that point, economic data and the broader economy have deteriorated meaningfully — unemployment, GDP forecasts, that whole set of indicators. So Felicia, our expectation would be that, should conditions settle where they sit right now, then in the second quarter we'd need to record a further bump to that provision and set aside additional funds once Q2 wraps up.

Felicia Hendrix

analyst
#32

Okay, and regarding forbearances, are there any?

John Olin

executive
#33

No, we don't really take a look at forbearance, per se. What we do have is something we refer to as customer extensions. When customers come to us and they're having trouble paying due to COVID-19, we'll look to extend the loan. That's a standard practice for us, and we've applied it in regions hit by hurricanes and other natural disasters. We're using that same approach here, and it gives the consumer a bit of time to get themselves sorted out, and it certainly benefits our writers. So we are providing some extensions in that regard. I'm not sure — when you mention forbearance, whether you mean on the wholesale side. On the wholesale side, we actually haven't seen any losses in years, but in the downturn 10 years ago, we lost some dealerships, and we had some write-downs on those, and as you'll see in the financial results, we set aside $7.3 million of reserves on the wholesale side as well, since we'd expect losses going forward there as some of our dealers can't make it through this crisis.

Felicia Hendrix

analyst
#34

Okay, thanks.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#35

Hey everyone, good morning. I've got a few questions regarding Rewire. First off, why do you believe you've been coming up short when it comes to bringing in net new riders previously, and what will you do differently to boost participation by the time the quarter ends?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#36

Thanks Joe. That's a fair question. The figures for riders we brought in during 2019 and '18 — by the close of 2019, there were roughly $3.1 million Harley riders across the U.S. That's 55,000 additional riders overall compared with 2018, yet we also had — June, essentially twelve months of riders lost, leaving us with a net gain of 24,000 over the prior figure. I honestly can't explain why we failed to bring in riders. We've been trying out initiatives aimed at generating larger growth in overall ridership, with a focus on designing to speed up the path toward becoming a dedicated rider, which involves offering motorcycle access and one-on-one training to others, while additional efforts were built to keep current riders, including trading epic riders and rewarding those who already ride for the miles they cover, plus attracting newcomers to motorcycling. We'll assess all four of those initiatives at the earliest opportunity. Clearly not right now, since they're paused, and afterward decide within the Rewire program what we can execute well and improve upon, so as to both grow ridership through new riders and ensure that those — those on this board stay with us. So hopefully I can share further specifics down the road once we've shaped the Rewire program and can resume testing.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#37

No, that helps quite a bit. I just want to ask a follow-up on that, since, well, this probably isn't the way you'd have chosen for your time as CEO to begin — in the middle of a pandemic — but that's the situation; so given all that, are you thinking about eventually dropping the acting monitor title and formally becoming permanent CEO?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#38

Well, like I told you, Joe, honestly right now there's nothing further I can say beyond my earlier remarks. I'm concentrating on building out and putting the plan into action, and also on getting The Rewire program and playbook nailed down and rolled out while we work to reshape our upcoming new five year strategic plan. I had a fairly clear sense of what I was signing up for, so that part doesn't worry me, even though no one was able to foresee how bad the COVID-19 crisis would be. Back when I said yes to this position, I figured it would be a difficult right and — but I'm accustomed to that, so.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#39

All right, that's excellent. Thanks very much.

Gerrick Johnson

analyst
#40

Morning! Thanks. Jochen, hey there! You brought up making the dealer network more efficient. From what I understand, at least 4 dealerships have shut down over the past several weeks. So how do you intend to streamline the dealer base? What will the revised dealer base look like, and what steps do you need to take to reach that point?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#41

Well, like you mentioned, we actually had 5 dealers in the U.S. that weren't performing well; those shut down during the first quarter; internationally, we had 20 closures. As we emerge from the COVID-19 crisis, we don't know how this picture will shape up, so it's quite difficult to predict. During the Great Recession, roughly 100 dealers shut down, but we had no forecast. Naturally, we had some we were monitoring, watching closely, and we do that every day; then, as you know, when dealers leave, there could be chances to combine dealerships as some may be taken over by an existing dealer, others will disappear, and like I said, dealer optimization will matter as a result, so we're able to boost profitability for the dealers that remain going forward. Beyond that, I can't really provide much additional insight on that, but we're examining this quite actively and we have solid systems and plans in place to ensure that the dealer network gets strengthened in the future as we come out of this.

Gerrick Johnson

analyst
#42

All right, so here's another way to ask it: before COVID, had a strategy already been set for streamlining the dealer network, or does making the dealer base more efficient amount to a response to the COVID-19 crisis?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#43

Those two things are both at play. Clearly, whenever you examine your mapping and your current sales, which shift annually, there's always room to strengthen your dealer network. An ongoing plan therefore existed, though it's now being reworked and refined, and you know, there are additionally chances we must consider — you know, letting our dealers conduct online sales, something we built in response to mitigating this crisis, or our capacity to get bikes delivered you know through dealerships that have shut down. So further avenues exist for maximizing what current dealers can do in terms of selling, and that's what we're doing as well during the crisis.

Joe Spak

analyst
#44

Thanks a lot. So, regarding rewire — that initiative seems far more tightly targeted, unlike the earlier one, which I believe was meant to be wider in scope and more premium, and you clearly invested heavily in expanding internationally. To this point, at least, that feels like a welcome change. Still, I'm curious: you've put a great deal of money into widening the customer base over the past several years. How much of those prior investments do you view as something you can carry over or redirect now that you're starting The Rewire strategy?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#45

Yes, fair question. Definitely more focused, but as I mentioned during my remarks, that doesn't rule out pieces of the More Roads plan being folded into what we do next. A great deal hinges on how the crisis unfolds, along with The Rewire program we're building — and as development proceeds, we're also putting it into action; we'll definitely make certain that many of the investments already made, you know, end up delivering a beneficial outcome, though right now I can't or won't share specifics. What I did state, however, is that our entry into Adventure Touring, Streetfighter segments, and Electric — those 3 segments — is something we remain dedicated to moving forward, and they consumed a substantial portion of our product development spending. So work on them will keep going. Their launch timing, as I noted too, has been affected by the crisis, and we'll make certain we're prepared with a highly effective go-to-market process for every one of them.

David MacGregor

analyst
#46

Yes, good morning to all, and thank you for taking my question. Jochen, I was hoping you might revisit a few of the points you raised regarding The Rewire, both in your prepared remarks and in the press release. In those, you mention a cost structure that has been adjusted to fit the new market realities following the crisis. Clearly, that's a cost that ought to be tackled here, but it comes across as somewhat vague, and I'd like to hear you expand on it a bit and explain precisely what you're aiming to achieve. And perhaps, if I may, I'd also like you to share a perspective drawing on your experience as a Board member: how do you view what these assets ought to be delivering when it comes to target profitability levels or return on capital?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#47

Yes, thank you. Obviously, this crisis is affecting our sales, and that in turn will affect our cost structure. While we aren't in a position right now to pin down how large that effect will be — and I realize everyone would appreciate us offering some guidance — we just don't have sufficient visibility to put out a forecast, so at this moment I'm unable to truly answer your questions. Hopefully, once we reach the second quarter, we'll be able to — provided our visibility has improved compared with now and we're beginning to emerge from this crisis — start refocusing. But we definitely won't do so until we possess a clear picture, and that likewise pertains to your final question regarding target levels. All of this will form part of the rewiring program and playbook, along with our new five year strategic plan. Once that's in place, we'll then provide you with clear guidance on what we anticipate regarding return on capital and similar matters.

Brett Andress

analyst
#48

Hi there, good morning. I just wanted to get some clarity regarding the greater than 30-day delinquency rate you shared. You brought up some softer trends toward the end of March. So could you shed any light on where that rate stands at this moment, whether in April or as of the close of March? And the second portion of my question is whether you've also observed any rise in the less than 30-day delinquency rate.

John Olin

executive
#49

Thanks Brett, John here. Brett, regarding the 30-day delinquency rate, it was very encouraging to watch it decline by 36 basis points. But keep in mind much of that stemmed from what took place a year ago, and looking back to 2018, my sense is we remain roughly seven basis points higher, which is likely mostly attributable to CECL — pardon me, to COVID and the final couple weeks of payments that ended up extended. There's simply no method to achieve a flawless do to on that, yet across a two year span we're slightly lower and the primary factor behind that would be the conditions we're witnessing during the COVID crisis. The other element is that when you examine what's going on with less than 30-day delinquencies, we're noticing a greater number of those extensions I referenced before. So we have plenty of prime customers approaching us and explaining that, you know, they require a bit more time to make payment due to COVID, and consequently several of those had the timeframe stretched for that particular aspect. So that's the situation we're observing under 30-days, however I lack an inter-period delinquency metric for either less than 30-days or the 30-day plus category.

Brett Andress

analyst
#50

Got it, thank you.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#51

Hi everyone! Jochen, I'll give this a third shot — if the Board decides it wants to take away the acting title, would you want the CEO job at Harley? Could you be a candidate? If you'd rather not respond, that itself becomes an issue, since considering how broad this is, you know, that announcement and that strategy are so invigorating and have to be an enormous weight off the shoulders of your dealers, your employees, stakeholders, your investors. I realize you've served on the Board since 2007, so I'm telling you what you already know, but that is a massive, massive wide-open space and I just — and I'm not requesting that you say anything groundbreaking here, but could you even be a candidate?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#52

I'll take that as a compliment, many thanks, but like I mentioned, there's nothing more to say right now. That said, I will — I've come in at full speed and there's plenty of work ahead, and we are extremely, extremely committed to executing our plan and creating a fresh plan covering the coming 5 years. So you can feel assured about that.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#53

Okay, I suppose that's all I had to ask. It's simply that I'm hoping you can understand why that could be really aggravating, and that when the second quarter arrives and gives you a chance to tell us more about the plan, it would be fair to every stakeholder for there to be a leadership fix that lasts. And I'm hoping, I really am, that you're drawing on everything available, and I'm confident you are, so that by 2Q we can at least be in a stronger spot to address these questions. Thanks.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#54

Of course! Thanks.

Tim Conder

analyst
#55

Thanks; I had that noted too, so I'll second those remarks. Now, a question with several parts, regarding retail, John, can you share anything about how things have appeared very lately, say in March, as they come out of the oil patch regions, oil and gas, given the steep drop we've witnessed there; and then, I wanted to ask Jochen whether you can offer any further detail about the market refocus? It sounds as though perhaps Asia is stepping back, and is that a permanent or temporary shift in your launch schedule for your — the yearly new products. Thank you.

John Olin

executive
#56

I'll take the first question, Tim. When it comes to retail sales, honestly it's very hard to say right now, everything has fallen significantly. Nearly 60% of our dealers are shut, so everything is down. It's tough to distinguish what we're seeing in oil patch regions. We're still — we're definitely back to examining it properly, and several years ago we faced a comparable situation and for sure it impacted the motorcycle industry and Harley-Davidson sales. People who work in the industry and in those regions are excellent customers and we recognize where oil prices stand and that there could be a secondary impact from COVID, but also from the lower oil prices. And as I noted earlier, some of the underwriting adjustments we're implementing take those lessons from several years ago and apply them now; but I can't isolate, due to dealer closures and such, where we stand in oil patch states compared with others.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#57

And regarding your remaining two questions about where we're putting our attention market-wise — look, I'm firmly of the view that our emphasis has to be anchored to the markets at our core. Like I said before, a handful of these markets are the ones generating the most profit for us. The U.S. requires additional attention as we move ahead. Certain international markets too — and not only when it comes to profitability, but when it comes to what they could become. I believe we will absolutely pull back in some areas so that we can sharpen where we focus. As I noted before, this comes down to velocity, to concentration, to cutting down on complexity, all of which positions our company for a genuinely profitable future — and that includes keeping our attention on key markets. On the question of when we launch things, that schedule shift is here to stay. Like I said, we've moved our model year changeover timing from August to early Q1, which lets our launch calendar line up with the beginning of the riding season for the very first time in our history. To me that was completely logical, and I can't think of any reason we'd revert to how we used to do it — so it's permanent.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#58

Morning, everyone. John, I may have overlooked this, but could you share what our weekly cash burn rate stands at right now? And then, regarding that $250 million you're aiming for in terms of preserved liquidity, could you separate that into CapEx and whatever flows through the P&L?

John Olin

executive
#59

Thanks, Sharon. Looking at our total cash burn, excluding the $250 million we pulled out, we're sitting somewhere between $80 million and $100 million each month, correct — and that's fairly straightforward when you take $1 billion of SG&A, divide it out, subtract a couple hundred million dollars, and factor in the fixed costs at the plants needed to keep them operating, which run through cost of goods sold, without the dividend; the dividend being cut considerably. We also have some interest payments in there of — I'm not sure, $15 million per quarter. So with an overall burn rate somewhere between $80 million and $100 million per month, and again, as I noted earlier, considering the liquidity we currently have, the debt we hold that will come due soon, and again Sharon, under assumptions where we have absolutely no revenue. Our revenue has dropped very significantly during the first 3.5 weeks of April, but we still do have revenue; so under those assumptions, we have sufficient runway to reach the end of the year and a little bit into next year. So we feel quite good about that; we haven't separated the $250 million into its components, but it's mostly comprised of SG&A expense.

Jaime Katz

analyst
#60

Hello, good morning. I don't know whether you folks have separated this out, but shelter and place orders don't exist in every state. So might you provide any understanding about how dealers are performing, and in shattered versus non-shattered areas, if there's anything you can tell us there. Thanks.

John Olin

executive
#61

Jamie, it's quite hard, you know, to figure that out. Looking at it overall, we're able to observe that the dealers who are selling are doing better than the dealer closures we've got. And once more, as we're sitting here right now, 59% of our dealers are shut, yet our retail sales during the first 3.5 weeks of April aren't down all that much, so that does indicate that the dealers who are open are selling at levels from a year ago. But we lack an analysis, or we lack anything to tell you concerning precisely which states they're in.

Shannon Burns

executive
#62

Okay, thank you all. Today's presentation audio along with the slides can be accessed through Harley-Davidson.com, or by phone for the audio at 855 to 859 to 2056 or 404 to 537 to 3406, available through May 12. The identification number is 772 to 6817.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#63

Shannon and John, I appreciate it, and thank you for making time this morning — and for the interest you've shown, along with your investment, in Harley-Davidson. While the pandemic continues, safeguarding our employees' health and keeping the business strong will remain priorities for us. My belief is firm that Harley-Davidson Rewire will produce an organization that is simpler, one that is sharp and focused and reaches decisions more quickly. I'm eager to share additional details when we give our second quarter update. Everyone, stay well.

Operator

operator
#64

That wraps up the conference call for today, everyone. We appreciate your participation. You're free to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Harley-Davidson, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Harley-Davidson, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Harley-Davidson, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.