Harley-Davidson, Inc. (HOG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 26, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Shawn Collins
executiveThanks, everyone, and good morning. Shawn Collins here — I handle Investor Relations for Harley-Davidson. Glad to have you with us for the Q3 2022 earnings call. Slides that go along with today's call can be found online on the Harley-Davidson Investor Relations website. As is typical, forward-looking statements will be part of what we say, and those carry business risks that might make actual results come out materially different. Among those risks are matters we've flagged in our most recent SEC filings. With me this morning are our Chief Executive Officer, Jochen Zeitz, and our Chief Financial Officer, Gina Goetter. Also, Chief Commercial Officer Edel O'Sullivan will be on hand for the Q&A part of today's call. So with that, I'll hand things over to Jochen Zeitz, our CEO.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThanks, Shawn, and hello everybody on this call. We appreciate you spending time with us this morning. Harley-Davidson turned in a robust third quarter, and our results make us quite happy even with the supply chain difficulties we ran into, particularly during the early part of the quarter because of the production suspension. Our view is that we're positioned well to hit the guidance we've set for this year, and to handle and adapt to shifts in the market environment so we can fulfill our Hardwire Stage II plans. The Harley brand's strength and appeal keep expanding, and when times are uncertain, we believe it's brands with strength, backed by strong communities, that can produce superior outcomes. Harley-Davidson stands as the world's most sought-after motorcycle maker, a true example of a strong brand. In May, we laid out our goals for expanding in the years ahead, and we remain on track with our five-year Hardwire strategy, which rests on these pillars: profit, selective expansion and redefinition, leading in electric, growth beyond bikes, integrated customer experience, and inclusive stakeholder management. This quarter's numbers reveal that HDMC achieved revenue growth, as profitable unit growth combined with pricing produced a 24% rise. Likewise, we're quite happy with the robust operating income margin growth we've achieved, up 9.5 points to 17.9% compared with last year, which in our view is a clear sign that the right strategy is in place to produce long-term profitable growth at Harley-Davidson. On top of that, shipments rose 19% for the quarter as we mostly bounced back from the unplanned production suspension that hit early in the summer. We think the per-unit profitability Gina will discuss later demonstrates the success of our Hardwire strategy and its emphasis on our core segments. To get there, we think that since we are the most sought-after motorcycle brand and company in the world, we need to shift this industry's conventional obsession with unit counts and instead concentrate on revenue that is desirable and profitable, compared with the way things used to be. We feel particularly good about how profitable this quarter turned out, which aligns with the Hardwire strategy's priorities. There's one point I'd like to highlight: when we looked over the results for this period, we concluded that demand remained robust throughout, and the single largest influence on our retail numbers was supply. As inventory started moving through dealerships in a more typical way, we observed total retail beginning to improve, turning positive on a year-over-year basis across North America along with other important regions. So staying focused on profitability in our main segments, and following the momentum from a product launch that went well earlier this year, we introduced something new back in August during the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally. It's called Apex Factory Custom Paint, and it's available on 22 selected Grand American Touring models. This paint draws on Harley-Davidson's racing history, which goes back a century, and it pays tribute to the famous Harley-Davidson XR750 motorcycle. The work is done by our own teams at York and Tomahawk, and the craftsmanship is excellent — it really shows off what our specialists here in the U.S. can do. Riders have responded really well to these bikes, and going forward we're going to continue developing what we offer when it comes to paint. During the Hardwire presentation, we made a promise to introduce a range of motorcycles that fits with our approach of creating legendary machines which pay tribute to Harley-Davidson's heritage and its position as a leader. As part of the Icons Collection, a maximum of two models are released annually, and each one is manufactured in only one batch. Once that happens, the bike is never reintroduced or produced again. After the positive reception of our earlier icon, the Electra Glide Revival, we launched the limited edition Low Rider El Diablo in September. Taking cues from a custom styling movement on America's West Coast, the Low Rider El Diablo combines agile performance and sport touring capability with a bold paneled paint design that is done by hand. The bike's reception has been fantastic—it ended up as our top-selling motorcycle for Q3. We're looking forward to what the Icons Collection will do within the lineup as we approach Harley-Davidson's 120th anniversary next year. Back at our May analyst and investor meeting, we shared our goals under the growth beyond bikes pillar, placing greater emphasis on apparel and licensing as a fresh major force behind the Harley-Davidson lifestyle. Since then, we've been building up our core apparel and licensing expertise, and that means assembling a top-tier internal team that can carry this ambition forward over the long haul. Our A&L segment delivered a solid performance this quarter — apparel was up 41%, and licensing rose 26%. Looking ahead, we believe we can sustain expansion in this area of the business over the long haul, which will make our brand and our motor culture lifestyle even more appealing to both riders and people who don't ride. During Q3, we continued to move quickly on improving how customers and dealers engage with us. Here in the U.S., we're still rolling out our sold bike order process — it's running 300% above where it was a year ago, and 98% of the network has now come on board. Meanwhile, while we were dealing with interruptions in our supply chain that affected deliveries, we introduced additional features so that dealers and customers could see and communicate more clearly about where their bikes stand. During our Investor Day earlier this year, as we mentioned then, we started a pilot of the updated distribution approach that provides quicker product availability; this will drive growth under a leaner inventory strategy, helping profitability and boosting our capacity to satisfy what customers want in a particular bike. We also noted at the May Investor Day that Project Fuel, our facility upgrade initiative, had its official global launch, with 10% of the North American network enrolled for the initial phase. We're making a significant commitment to dealers around the world, and in the U.S. alone it comes to roughly $2 billion. That's a necessary move on its own — one that really should have been made sooner — and it reflects just how confident everyone here is about the health and earnings potential ahead for this business, across the customers we serve today and those we'll serve tomorrow, as well as every product line. Beyond that, we rolled out service business consultants and a new lead form for the service scheduler, with the goal of driving growth in service work performed within the network. The key point is that we didn't stop at North America. Over in APAC, we grew our customization kits offering, backed by a new digital experience, which delivered 30% growth in kits bought by dealers. Last, we remain incredibly proud of how flexible, adaptable, and collaborative our dealers have been while navigating a challenging supply year and testing out new methods. Their capacity to keep connecting with both our most devoted customers and new ones to sustain demand late in the season, their robust service footprint and technical know-how, and their spending on experience and community all prove that within all of powersports, our network is the strongest and most effective. In July, as a key piece of our Hardwire strategy, we marked one year since launching H-D1 Marketplace, our pre-owned platform. At present, the site carries more than 30,000 motorcycle listings, among them over 2,000 Harley-Davidson certified bikes, which makes it the top online destination for used Harley-Davidson motorcycles across the U.S.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveSince going live, the platform has logged nearly 3 million visits, giving our dealers and customers a clearer window into the pre-owned category. We recently introduced two new elements to the site: non-Harley-Davidson bikes, which widen our audience, and pre-qualification, which makes it simpler for shoppers to find and secure financing for a purchase. We'll keep investing in the platform and enhancing its features, so that through Marketplace, harley-davidson.com turns into the top destination for customers and motorcycle fans across the globe. As I mentioned earlier, our 120th anniversary arrives next year. We'll celebrate this milestone unlike anything we've done before, kicking off with a three-day rally held each year that we plan to build over the coming years into one of the largest Harley-Davidson gatherings and rallies, in North America and around the world, for our riders, their families, and fans right in our own backyard, our hometown of Milwaukee. The faster we move, transform, and innovate, the more crucial it becomes to remember our origins. It's our hope that Milwaukee and our Wisconsin roots — including Juneau, the Product Development Center, the Powertrain operations, and Tomahawk — continue to mean as much to us going forward as they always have, and that our presence here benefits not just our employees but our community and customers too. There's more to share. In the early part of the new year, we'll provide additional details on our plans, including an investment the Harley-Davidson Foundation intends to make, following our $10 million commitment to our museum campus, focused on our Juneau home and the Near West Side in Milwaukee. Leading in electric is central to our Hardwire strategy, and this September, we achieved a major milestone toward that objective. On September 27, LiveWire became the first all-electric motorcycle company to list on the New York Stock Exchange. Closing this transaction and the listing is a proud and exciting step toward our goal of establishing LiveWire as the most desirable electric motorcycle brand in the world. We believe LiveWire is well positioned to help shape the two-wheel EV market, and we're excited about what lies ahead. You'll hear more from us regarding LiveWire in the fourth quarter, when Ryan Morrissey, LiveWire's President, joins us to present. I'll now hand it over to Gina. Gina?
Gina Goetter
executiveAppreciate that, Jochen, and good morning, everyone. As Jochen mentioned, we delivered a strong quarter reflecting our focus on the fundamentals of the core business. Our Q3 results demonstrate a substantial increase in both revenue and operating income compared to a year ago, driven largely by a sharp rebound in global motorcycle production and wholesale shipments following the unexpected production stoppage in May that had weighed on them. We continue to navigate a volatile supply chain, though cost inflation started to moderate as the quarter progressed. More specifically, logistics rates declined and raw material inflation slowed as metal markets cooled. Looking more closely at our quarterly financials, consolidated revenue totaled $1.65 billion, representing a 21% increase over the prior year. HDMC wholesale motorcycle units were up 19% year-over-year, while revenue increased 24%, with a favorable spread driven by profitable unit mix and global pricing. Revenue for the financial services segment rose 3%, primarily due to higher finance receivables. Total operating income came in at $339 million, up 66% versus last year; at HDMC, operating income reached $258 million, up 164% from a year ago, with margins achieving record levels. The quarter's results were fueled by the recovery in unit production along with cost productivity and pricing that helped counter inflation; at HDFS, operating income of $81 million declined by $26 million, or 24%, compared to last year. That decrease stemmed from a higher provision for credit losses and increased interest expense. Total Q3 interest expense is up $60 million or 36% versus prior year. As we've noted in previous quarters, the credit loss rate continues to normalize as anticipated, and the loss reserve rate remains stable. Third quarter GAAP earnings per share were $1.78 compared to $1.05 last year, with the improvement attributable to the factors I already mentioned plus modest favorability in below-the-line items. Turning now to Q3 year-to-date results: total consolidated revenue was $4.6 billion, 7% higher than last year, and total operating income was $906 million, 9% above last year. GAAP Q3 year-to-date earnings per share of $4.68 compare with $4.06 for the same period a year ago. Global retail sales of new motorcycles declined 2% in the quarter. Overall retail results were hurt by low dealer inventory entering Q3 and remaining lean through the first half of the quarter. As Jochen pointed out, as the quarter went on, overall retail returned to year-over-year growth as inventory began flowing into the dealer channel more normally. Retail for the month of September increased 5% in the U.S. and 7% worldwide. All told, worldwide retail inventory of new motorcycles remains at historically low levels. Q3 average inventory was 22% above Q3 of the prior year, and sequentially, average inventory rose 12% from last quarter as production and wholesale shipments recovered from the May suspension. Dealers received encouraging news from that inventory build, and they continue to show healthy retail momentum. Strong pricing trends for new and used motorcycles persisted in Q3, just as they did across 2022 and 2021. To be specific, in the U.S., transaction prices on new motorcycles in Q3 landed inside the ±2 percentage point desirability threshold. Now on the top line, HDMC's total revenue was up 24% for Q3 and up 8% for the year to date. In terms of what was behind the quarter, 17 points of that growth was volume, helped by unit growth and recovery as well as expansion in apparel. Pricing and lower incentives contributed eight points of growth, which reflects MSRP increases globally and pricing surcharges in certain markets; beyond that, we saw strong price realization in apparel. Favorable mix in motorcycles gave us four points of growth, along with SKU mix in apparel. Finally, foreign exchange was a four-point drag as the dollar continued to strengthen during the quarter. The year-to-date revenue drivers are largely the same, although volume growth has been softer for the year to date, because Q3's gains were offset by the Q2 shortfall related to the production suspension. Turning to margins, gross margin for Q3 was 34.1%, compared with 26.7% in the same period last year. Improved volume, favorable unit mix, and pricing more than offset modestly higher cost inflation. Also in Q3, we were still lapping the unfavorable impact of the additional unexpected EU tariffs in 2021, which provided a tailwind to margins. Overall, supply chain inflation was +2% in the quarter, down from 4% in Q2 and 10% in the back half of last year. The moderation in inflation is primarily due to normalization in logistics, including lower expedited shipping costs, and to a lesser extent raw materials and metal markets beginning to come down from last year's peaks. Operating margin in Q3 increased to 17.9% from 8.4% in the prior-year Q3. That improvement came from the factors I just mentioned and includes higher operating expense, partly due to LiveWire. As Jochen said, since the Hardwire launch we've shifted away from a sole focus on unit growth toward a broader view of profitable revenue growth. The portfolio pruning we did during the Rewire, together with the pricing and incentive actions we've taken over the past couple of years to offset inflation, have raised our unit profitability above the low point in 2019. As we continue on the Hardwire path, overall HDMC revenue, operating income, and profitability per unit will remain our key measures. In Financial Services, segment operating income for Q3 was $81 million, down $26 million from last year. That decrease reflects a higher provision for credit losses and more interest expense. As expected, actual losses continue to drift toward more normalized levels. In the third quarter, HDFS recorded an annualized retail credit loss ratio of 1.5%, which is 66 basis points above the 0.84% ratio in Q3 2021. During the quarter, both the actual loss rate and the delinquency rate remained in line with what we had anticipated and with historical averages. Retail loan originations overall were up 3.3% in Q3, driven by gains in both new bike and used bike originations. Financing receivables at quarter end were $7.3 billion, up 7% from the prior year. Total Q3 interest expense is up $60 million or 36% versus prior year. Interest expense for Q3 climbed $16 million, or 36%, compared with the prior year. That increase was driven by both a larger average amount of debt outstanding and a higher average interest rate; beyond that, the retail allowance for credit losses came in at 5% as of the end of Q3, the same as it was in the first half of the year. All told, total Q3 interest expense rose $60 million, or 36%, compared with the prior year. Wrapping up on Harley-Davidson, Inc. financial results, we produced $575 million of operating cash flow over the first three quarters, down from $926 million in the equivalent period 12 months earlier. That decrease in operating cash flow stemmed from higher inventory as well as larger net cash outflows related to wholesale finance receivables. Cash and cash equivalents ended at $1.7 billion, which is $331 million lower than the Q3 level a year ago.
Gina Goetter
executiveIn Q3, we kept buying back stock, though we did so more slowly than during the first half, since our cash focus moved toward financing the LiveWire transaction. Roughly 400,000 shares were repurchased by us in Q3. Through the third quarter, taken together, 8.4 million shares have been repurchased. Turning to the remainder of 2022, as Jochen noted, we are reaffirming the full year outlook for HDMC revenue, HDMC operating margin, and HDFS operating income, and we still anticipate HDMC revenue growth of 5%-10%. Built into this revenue growth projection is the assumption that we wholesale and recover the units we lost because of the production suspension; it likewise reflects what is known today regarding how supplier challenges are affecting our business. As we work to offset cost headwinds throughout the supply chain, we expect revenue to keep benefiting from our global pricing actions. Our expectation for HDMC operating income margin remains 11%-12%. We believe the positive impact we anticipate from pricing will outweigh the cost inflation expected across the supply chain. In addition, the suspension of the additional EU tariffs realized in 2021 adds more than a point of margin growth. For HDFS operating income, we still expect a decline of 20%-25%. That decline stems mostly from the favorable allowance releases and lower credit losses in 2021. Finally, our capital investment guidance is being updated to $170 million-$190 million from $190 million-$220 million, reflecting revised project implementation timing. This is consistent with what we disclosed last quarter and embedded in our 2022 guidance of LiveWire. Last, when it comes to capital allocation, our priorities are unchanged: fund growth of the Hardwire initiative, which includes the capital expenditures already mentioned and financing the LiveWire transaction, pay dividends, and carry out discretionary share repurchases. This financial guidance incorporates the best supply chain cost forecast available to us right now. It presumes that logistics and materials will keep improving as we progress through the rest of the year. Overall, we expect costs to remain inflationary, yet we will get past the peak levels realized in 2021. With that, I'll hand it back to the operator so we can take your questions.
Robin Farley
analystMorning, and thank you for letting me ask. I'll actually squeeze in two very quickly. First, Jochen, could you describe how demand is feeling during this fourth quarter, in both the U.S. and the rest of world, and any shifts you've noticed, or how the dealers are feeling? Then for Gina, I was hoping you could assist us with the gross margin outlook. Fantastic gross margin that you had. Could we get a bit more detail on how to think about the fourth quarter, plus any preliminary thoughts you'd offer on how we should think about it for next year? Thank you.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveYes. Thanks, Robbie. On your first question, like I said before, we observed improvements in retail sales as the quarter progressed. So we think the decline in retail sales was mainly because of insufficient inventory availability at the dealer network. Once we reached mid-August, things began turning positive, and retail sales have stayed positive from then on. At this point overall, with more inventory on hand at the dealers, we feel pretty good about it. That's especially true for the U.S. and our Asia Pacific markets.
Gina Goetter
executiveMorning, Robin. Regarding your margin question — yes, it was a really strong quarter for margins, and the main drivers were the big unit recovery we saw plus a profitable product mix, and on top of that, the pricing moves we made in the market did more than cancel out cost inflation. That said, to get a true picture of this year's margins, you need to look at the year-to-date figures, since those capture both the Q2 shortfall and Q3 together. Even so, the narrative is still quite favorable. Year to date, we're looking at 2.5 points of margin improvement. Keep in mind that one of those points comes from the tariff comparison against last year — the extra EU tariffs that are still in there. Looking ahead toward Q4 and into 2023, bear in mind that our FX rate will worsen as we move through the rest of the year. That deterioration has already started flowing into the P&L, though earlier in the year it really had no material effect on margin. Once we reached Q3, and as we look at Q4 and beyond into next year, it will definitely carry a larger impact. On Q4 specifically, also remember that we're still carrying out the model year production changeover at the end of October. On the shipment side, we ship approximately — call it 60% of what a typical quarter looks like in Q4. That also drags on our margins. Year to date, we're in a genuinely strong spot and we feel confident about the guidance we provided, given what we know is headed our way in Q4. Turning to 2023 — considering the margin gains we've delivered over the last couple of years, we're genuinely proud of that progress. We included a chart in these materials this time showing profitability per bike, and you can clearly see how all our efforts on cost, on pricing, and on staying focused on that mix are reflected in profitability per bike; we expect that to remain with us as we head into 2023. We're right in the middle of budgeting, so we won't say too much about next year's outlook. Keep a few things in mind. First, our rule of thumb is that we'll take enough pricing to offset cost inflation. The second item is the FX headwind bearing down on us. It will be material for us next year, and we're still working through and figuring out how much of that pricing will be able to offset the FX for next year.
Robin Farley
analystThat's really useful. Thanks a lot, Gina.
Gina Goetter
executiveHappy to help.
Craig Kennison
analystHello, and good morning. I appreciate you taking my question too. Gina, I wanted to build on what was shown on slide 9, the part about HDMC profit per motorcycle. My assumption is that your parts and accessory operation is counted in there. To start, could you verify that for me?
Gina Goetter
executiveYes, that's exactly correct; parts and accessories are included.
Craig Kennison
analystAll right. In a sense, when you make fewer motorcycles, that business carries a better margin, so perhaps each bike brings in more money. I'm simply asking — this shift in direction is really striking. Where do you figure that measure can eventually land?
Gina Goetter
executiveIf you consider the guidance we've put out for our Hardwire two and returning to that mid-teens margin figure — well, that mid-teens margin figure was tied to profitability per unit around 2014, 2015. My sense is there's still room to move higher over time. Once more, when we consider 2023 and dealing with this FX effect, we'll need to bear that in mind for next year. Looking at the long term, as we reference that 2014 anchor, it's a solid target to reach and to keep out there.
Craig Kennison
analystCould you unpack that for us — what portion of the revenue comes from each motorcycle sold, what portion comes from an attachment rate tied to a bike purchase, and what portion simply flows in thanks to this fantastic community of riders who are constantly buying PG&A?
Gina Goetter
executiveThat's something we can dissect. We've already dissected it. At this point we aren't really making it public, though we do grasp that profitability on each bike is climbing because of the elements we mentioned, and our attach rate is stronger, with plans for it to grow even stronger going forward. Once we get into 2023, we can offer a bit more clarity around that.
Craig Kennison
analystGreat. Thank you.
Gina Goetter
executiveMm-hmm.
Joe Altobello
analystThank you. Hi, everyone. Good morning. I suppose my first question is about inventory. You had 30,000 units in dealer inventory worldwide. According to my calculations, that's roughly nine weeks higher than a year ago, yet you're about half of where you stood, let's say, three years back. So how far under the ideal level do you believe you are at this point, however you want to characterize it — units or weeks on hand, for instance?
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveJoseph, good morning. This is Edel. Your evaluation of where inventory stands is accurate. For us, I think what matters most is being able to begin the riding season as we head into 2023 with a far healthier inventory level; we recognize that during the last few quarters, and in fact perhaps even across the last couple of years, we haven't had the ideal amount of inventory in any of our markets to truly seize the start of the season and the potential for upside demand. It's good to see that this is improving as we move into the back half of 2022. Having said that, exactly as you pointed out, we keep recognizing how crucial it is for us, under our guiding principle of desirability, to maintain a restrained and sufficient inventory level. We have no intention of returning to historical levels that generated so many profitability challenges, for us as well as for our dealers. That's also a key part of what Gina was sharing in the earlier question. I definitely believe we're in a far healthier position now. We think this will let us begin the riding season from a much more comfortable spot, both in the domestic market and internationally. And overall, we still recognize the significance of a restrained inventory position that sits within a wider framework of desirability.
Joe Altobello
analystRight. What's the shortfall versus the ideal fleet size? In other words, are we talking 5,000 bikes? Or 10,000 bikes?
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveRight. That's going to be something that hinges on various factors. We keep a very close watch on it as we examine retail patterns across each market. Once again, our view is that the current level is a healthy one. Our belief is that, right now, we still possess what's required to launch the season successfully, and we'll keep watching it closely as we move into the new year.
Joe Altobello
analystAll right. Perhaps one thing to ask Gina. Assuming nothing shifts from where we stand now, might supply chain expenses turn into a favorable wind during 2023?
Gina Goetter
executiveWithout a doubt. Yes. Looking at how we performed in the third quarter, the supply chain began behaving the way we'd been anticipating, with logistics prices beginning to ease and middle markets returning to us. That's going to keep going. Such favorable winds will persist as we head into 2023. Still, labor remains an element we'll need to deal with in the coming year when it comes to inflation. That's a component that will keep affecting us, and the broader supply base on its own isn't particularly steady yet. Yeah, you know, there are gains and losses, but on the whole, the massive inflation we'd been experiencing in logistics and regarding raw materials is beginning to lessen.
Joe Altobello
analystOkay. Thank you.
Gina Goetter
executiveMm-hmm.
James Hardiman
analystMorning, and thanks for letting me join. One small point of clarity first. Jochen, you said retail has been running positive since roughly the middle of August. My read is that October is part of that. Could you touch on October specifically? And a quick follow-up to Joe's inventory question. Looking ahead to next year as this one wraps up, should we assume wholesale and retail units will mostly line up, or is there still some additional ground to make up during 2023? Thanks.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThanks, James. Yes, it did. October was included in what I said, so that favorable direction has carried over into the fourth quarter so far. As Edel noted, how much ground we make up hinges on how retail performs, correct? The major recovery certainly happened in the third quarter, given the production halt we experienced, which cost us somewhere between 10,000 and 12,000 units, and the bulk of that has already been made up during the third quarter. A modest amount remains to be recovered in the fourth quarter, amounting to a few thousand units. Beyond that, everything rests on how retail unfolds. We will definitely remain very nimble to ensure supply and demand stay nicely balanced and that we avoid flooding the market with too much product. In the current climate, projecting retail is, you know, a hard thing to do. We are definitely preparing for every possible scenario, yet what we have observed up to now, especially during October, points to a favorable direction.
James Hardiman
analystPerhaps just a single clarification point here, home market compared with abroad. Field stock levels seem better aligned now, in my view, than has typically been the case. Could you address your comparative ease regarding the domestic side against the international side, first? I'm not sure. Does one offer greater potential than the other?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveOkay, on the whole, we're pleased with where stock sits worldwide, and especially when it comes to the U.S. plus Asia. As for EMEA markets, honestly, nobody can predict at this moment which direction EMEA will take. Taken as a whole, we're satisfied with the stock position we currently hold.
James Hardiman
analystUnderstood. Thanks.
Fred Wightman
analystHi, everyone. Good morning. I wanted to examine the guidance for the whole year. I realize this issue tends to come up every time we report 3Q, but based on the guidance as it stands, there's a fairly broad span suggested for 4Q when it comes to sales and operating profit. Could you discuss what would push you toward the top of that span as opposed to the bottom? Is it mostly the retail momentum Jochen mentioned a moment ago? Is it the supply chain? What are the favorable and unfavorable factors involved?
Gina Goetter
executiveAbsolutely. Good morning; Gina here. Regarding what takes us to the upper end of the span: keep in mind, once more, that we stop production and shipping, or rather transition to the following model year, at the close of October. Essentially, what brings us to the upper end is that once those bikes are on the water for our international markets, they need to be able to hit an invoice within the current year. That is truly what's moving things from the 5%-10% at present. We have confidence in the production. We have confidence in what we're going to work to wholesale. We have confidence in the demand that exists. Now it's simply a question of whether we can get it shipped and invoiced in time in those international markets. From a pricing perspective, I think we continue to feel good about the pricing we have in market as well. On the margin side, what brings us to that upper end of the span is continuing to see the supply chain trends we observed in Q3 carry through into Q4.
Fred Wightman
analystGot it. Thank you.
Gina Goetter
executiveMm-hmm.
Gerrick Johnson
analystMorning, and thanks. I've got two things to ask. To start, you brought up better availability in the U.S. and APAC, yet not in EMEA. What went on in that region?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveNo, availability isn't a problem. I'm only pointing out that, as I see it, the economic picture right now in EMEA has, you know, yet to be determined. It's very tough to assess what's happening in the fourth quarter in any case. I would say confidence is definitely much greater in the U.S. and in Asia-Pacific, though where inventory availability is concerned, there's no issue.
Gerrick Johnson
analystOkay, got it. Parts and accessories declined and lagged behind every other segment. What caused that drop?
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveYes, with P&A there are a couple of separate forces at work. First, I'd say the supply issues persisted far longer in that category compared with motorcycles, and that's definitely still an area where we're carrying heavy back orders on certain categories that matter most for accessorizing a bike; so that's one force. The second force is definitely the attachment rate on new motorcycles. Basically, what I'm getting at is that the motorcycles we lacked availability for in Q2 when they arrived. A lot of those bikes had already been claimed and are moving off the floor so fast that the opportunity for pre-accessorization was somewhat reduced. So those are definitely the two factors driving P&A for the quarter. Now, if you examine the total retail decline against the decline in P&A, we're still generating somewhat better growth there. Pricing plays a role, naturally. We believe that once supply stabilizes, both for motorcycles and for those P&A categories themselves, we ought to see an improvement in that growth trajectory for the business.
Gerrick Johnson
analystAll right. That's great, Edel. Thanks. Gina, just one more question. You cut capital expenditures by roughly $25 million for project implementation. What exactly was delayed there?
Gina Goetter
executiveI wouldn't characterize it as anything being delayed, really. It's simply a matter of how some of those outlays fell across periods, based on the project's schedule. Nothing has been postponed or moved back like that. It's honestly more of an accounting matter regarding when costs will land or when payments will be made.
Gerrick Johnson
analystOkay, great. Thank you.
Gina Goetter
executiveMm-hmm.
Joe Spak
analystThanks. Gina, perhaps regarding what you said about logistics — when I think back to the prior quarter, my recollection is that you suggested it would stay level through the back half of the year; yet this quarter it declined. Now you expect another decline in Q4. I realize expedited is being used far less and ocean has fallen, but is the real driver simply a comparison against an extremely elevated level of expedite? We keep hearing about plenty of difficulties, rail among them. I'm simply interested in learning what you observe that makes you confident logistics can turn into a plus for the company.
Gina Goetter
executiveYes, Joe, fair question. On the comparison point you raised, that explains a great deal about Q3. Our Q3 in 2021 was exceptionally strong. Everything was seeing price increases, and on top of that we were shipping a great deal by expedite. Considering when our model year output occurs, expedited volumes normally began climbing during Q3 of the prior year while we readied items for the changeover. This year we aren't experiencing nearly as much of that expedited activity, which is the reason Q3 turned deflationary, falling 5%. Regarding your comment on lane rates and freight rates, indeed, we observe the same pattern. Labor costs in logistics remain elevated, but the change we're seeing — the steadiness in expedited shipping, or the discipline over it, I should say — that is what pushed Q3 lower and what we anticipate for Q4 too.
Joe Spak
analystAll right, that's useful. For my follow-up, I realize the press release noted that on the operating expense line, part of that rise compared with a year ago came from greater LiveWire spending, if I'm not mistaken. Could you possibly share what LiveWire's total outlay or overall loss amounted to during this quarter? And when I think about the upcoming quarter — I understand it's now a standalone entity, though you continue to consolidate it — should we also factor in elevated public-company expenses going forward that would begin affecting OpEx across the whole consolidated company?
Gina Goetter
executiveIt's no different from what we put into our guidance, or our outlook, for LiveWire or for Harley. Everything we discussed at Investor Day — that entire cost, or the infrastructure, was baked in. The main development at LiveWire involved personnel. As we carved the business out and began assembling that talent pool roughly year over year, our spending on that infrastructure exceeds what it would have been a year earlier. Beginning next quarter, when we publish our year-end results and examine Q4, we'll begin reporting the three segments the way we described. There will be the motor company excluding EV. There will be HDFS, the financing arm, and there will also be LiveWire.
Joe Spak
analystAll right.
Gina Goetter
executiveAll 3 of those components will begin coming into view.
Joe Spak
analystAll right. Could you provide the overall amount we put into LiveWire during this quarter, in absolute terms?
Gina Goetter
executiveIn absolute terms, regarding operating expense for the quarter, the figure came to approximately, let's say, $20 million.
Joe Spak
analystOkay. Thank you very much.
Gina Goetter
executiveMm-hmm.
Jaime Katz
analystHello, and good morning. What I'd like to understand is how demand for financing has shifted now that APRs are much higher throughout HDFS, and I have a follow-up question after that. Thank you.
Gina Goetter
executiveRegarding that, Jaime — good morning, this is Gina — when it comes to the desire for financing, we need to break it down and examine each category of customer or consumer. Among prime applicants, demand remains solid. Our loan volume is trending increasingly toward prime. Within the subprime tiers, we're observing fewer individuals stepping forward to request loans, and we've also grown stricter about which loans we approve; that mix shift shows up in a couple of ways — first, fewer subprime borrowers are expressing interest, and second, we are funding, and opting to fund, a greater share of prime.
Jaime Katz
analystAll right. So my read is that you're still providing funding for about — I'm not sure — 60% of those loans, or whatever figure you gave before. That really hasn't shifted in any meaningful way.
Gina Goetter
executiveCorrect. Through this year, our penetration has remained fairly steady, hovering right at 65%. That's 65% of all loans. If you return to the arithmetic, about 20% of people are buying with cash outright, and out of the other 80%, we're funding 65% of those.
Jaime Katz
analystGreat. One quick follow-up regarding the H-D1 change, where additional brands are being included. Could you discuss how that assists you in managing used pricing across the whole market, in a broader sense?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveWell, like I mentioned, our goal was to grow the marketplace so that eventually it turns into the top destination for all things related to bikes, and that's the reason we don't only want to provide H-D bikes, but instead give our dealers and customers a chance to list bikes of their own. In our view, this represents a logical extension of the H-D1 Marketplace, building on the interest and reach we are developing among our customers.
Jaime Katz
analystThanks.
Ryan Sundby
analystYes. Hi, good morning, everyone. Adventure Touring's expansion this quarter was truly remarkable. Could you expand a bit on what's driving that? Is demand solely responsible? Might there be some one-time element in that figure, perhaps related to market expansion? Given that units almost doubled during this quarter, can you help us consider where Adventure Touring might land in terms of its share of total units? Thanks.
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveMorning, Ryan. Thanks for asking. Absolutely, Adventure Touring is, from our perspective, an exceptionally robust product we've introduced to the market within a category people wouldn't typically have associated with Harley-Davidson initially; we take great pride in how it was developed. It also faced availability challenges during the early months of the year, just like numerous other product families of ours, and the rebound in Q3, I believe, has been considerable now that those supply-related issues have eased; this segment matters greatly to us. It's especially significant and prominent worldwide, yet it's also expanding quite robustly in North America, where we believe we possess the appropriate offering, the appropriate dealer network, the appropriate backing to make this yet another formidable competitor as that market keeps expanding. Our aim is to keep supporting not just the Adventure Touring product Pan America by itself, but additionally the ecosystem of experiences and consumers connected to it; we perceive tremendous growth potential across the globe where it's a well-established segment and in North America as it develops.
Ryan Sundby
analystGreat; so what are your thoughts on the share of overall units that might eventually account for you folks as time goes on?
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveI believe that changes alongside what the market's growth potential does; we have definitely set a priority on our stronghold categories, and that's going to keep going in the future. Adventure Touring, once more, is a hugely important segment around the world, and it's expanding in North America; we feel the potential is meaningful for it to become a key piece of our total lineup, both domestically and internationally.
Ryan Sundby
analystUnderstood. Appreciate it. Thanks.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveOne more thing — over in the U.S., the 1250, the Pan America, continues to hold the top spot for sales among motorcycles in its segment.
Brandon Rollins
analystMorning. A question I had was whether you could speak to the spread right now between used and new pricing, and what effect that's having on how affordable new bikes look from the consumer's standpoint? Perhaps also address how well things are going, or what you intend, when it comes to holding onto first-time purchasers who came into the industry while the pandemic was ongoing? Thank you.
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveOh. My apologies, Brandon. I'd begun talking while muted, so allow me to start that again.
Brandon Rollins
analystOkay.
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveWe were chatting — there may have been a gap there — and we were discussing the mix between new and used. The pricing gap, in my view, keeps running at a lower level than it has historically. Within our dealer network, we've definitely watched that new-versus-used balance shift across the year as availability has changed, and we expect that dynamic to persist ahead as new availability shifts and gets better. Still, it's worth pointing out — as Jochen mentioned in his earlier response regarding H-D1 — that both types of customers, the one buying new and the one buying used, matter for the growth of the whole business and form part of the broader riding ecosystem that we plan to build and to keep as a prominent piece of our narrative, our growth narrative ahead. As for your specific question about new riders who've come into the category and the sport during the last couple of years, we've discussed on this call across recent quarters the expansion in Riding Academy. We keep seeing very strong adoption rates and new riders of every kind coming into the sport. For us, it's really about constructing that ecosystem of experiences and that community extending past some of our traditional offerings such as HOG, to truly ensure those customers remain engaged in whatever way matters most to them. That happens both via digital touch points and via the incredible dealer network and the experiences they create all the way through to the rallies, and certainly in 2023, including our anniversary year events that have us very excited. Plenty of opportunities remain to keep driving that engagement that keeps those new riders riding.
John Healy
analystThanks for taking my question. A big-picture one. When I listen to what you've said, the thing that stands out most is the dedication to keeping production disciplined and being sensible about how much product gets pushed into the industry. Should that pan out, profit per unit — assuming you can deliver on some of these operational initiatives — ought to be better than anything we've seen in recent years, historically speaking. Can you walk us through what might stop you from executing that playbook? Because from where I sit, that opportunity looks like one where you hold a great deal of your own fate in your hands. I'm basically trying to game-theory what strikes you as the largest obstacles standing in the way of pulling that off. And second, it seems you've kept guidance for the HDFS business even with rates higher. I was curious what the offset there was, looking toward year-end. Thank you.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveWell, demand is always the greatest hurdle in that respect. When you're clearly positioned as the most desirable lifestyle brand rooted in motor culture, demand — and here I mean motorcycles specifically — is what shapes our thinking at all times. We want to be certain we plan manufacturing in line with that, naturally so we can capture demand, something that wasn't always achievable over the last couple of years because of supply chain challenges. Also that we stay agile enough to shift as demand changes across the next quarters; this isn't only a matter of managing demand or managing supply. Clearly, much more is going on, and H-D1 Marketplace, our digital drive plus numerous other initiatives are fully underway to ensure we widen the consumer base, the customer base, in the years ahead. A great deal is happening in this area, and it matters. We want to be sure our riders keep riding, that new riders are brought into the sport, and that overall we broaden our reach across different consumer profiles — which is also why you're seeing a bigger push in our apparel and licensing business, which has delivered nice growth, particularly this quarter. That's a major initiative for us in widening the consumer base, since not everyone who's a Harley fan rides yet. They may ride down the road, but they might simply be a customer who believes in the lifestyle, loves the lifestyle, loves the brands, and wants to be involved. So there's a substantial effort there that I think over the long term will also help us get people more into the culture, into riding culture, and ultimately become a rider and take the Riding Academy course. There are more opportunities at the Riding Academy too, not only for new riders. It could be skills riding and other things, Adventure Touring. We see plenty of chances in that area. Things like experiences, loyalty, and membership are avenues we're currently investigating. A great deal is going on. It isn't simply about, you know, seizing the demand and ensuring we remain the most sought-after while pricing stays up and inventory sits at a healthy level. A tremendous amount is taking place both behind the scenes and in front of them to genuinely get customers interacting with the brand at a very different level than anything we've witnessed before.
Gina Goetter
executiveJohn, there was something you asked about HDFS. Would you mind asking that again? I didn't hear the whole thing.
John Healy
analystI believe you folks kept your full-year operating income outlook for HDFS unchanged. Given what you originally anticipated, I'd imagine rates are working against you. I'm just trying to figure out what's balancing that out.
Gina Goetter
executiveYeah, fair question. Yes, interest rates are certainly moving in the wrong direction for us, and that's visible. You could genuinely begin to notice that flowing through the P&L in Q3 once you look at that interest expense line sitting considerably higher versus the prior year. That, incidentally, is going to remain a drag on us as we head into Q4 and into 2023. The counterbalance has come on the revenue side. Beyond the fact that, you know, our receivables in general have risen, every one of the additional revenue streams affecting HDFS has likewise been favorable. Consider items such as supplemental insurance, supplemental, you know, the credit cards — each of those revenue sources has been favorable in assisting with the offset.
John Healy
analystGreat. Thank you.
Gina Goetter
executiveMm-hmm.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up the question-and-answer portion, and we're now at the end of today's call. We appreciate everyone for participating. You're free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Harley-Davidson, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Harley-Davidson, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Harley-Davidson, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.