Harley-Davidson, Inc. (HOG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 26, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Shawn Collins
executiveThanks. Morning, everyone. I'm Shawn Collins, and I serve as Director of Investor Relations here at Harley-Davidson. The slides that go along with today's call can be found online on the Harley-Davidson Investor Relations website. As is typical, our remarks will contain forward-looking statements, and those are subject to business risks that might make actual results come out materially different. Among those risks are matters we've flagged in today's earnings release as well as in our most recent filings with the SEC. So with that, here for the first part of this morning's call alongside me are Harley-Davidson Chief Executive Officer Jochen Zeitz, Chief Financial Officer Jonathan Root, and LiveWire CEO Karim Donnez. Also, when we get to the Q&A portion of today's call, Harley-Davidson Chief Commercial Officer Edel O'Sullivan will join us, just as she normally does. So with that, I'll hand things over to our CEO, Jochen. Jochen?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThank you, Shawn, and good morning to all of you. We appreciate you being with us today as we discuss Harley-Davidson and LiveWire's third quarter results. I'll begin by walking through how the HDMC business performed during the quarter. After that, Karim will offer his thoughts on LiveWire, and Jonathan will take everyone through HDI's financials, HDFS included, and then we'll open it up for questions. As we wrapped up Q3 of 2023, it's evident that conditions in the broader economy have proven difficult for our riders around the world and, consequently, for us as a company, since rising inflation has made affordability harder while elevated interest rates have meant fewer customers moving through the upgrade pipeline. We're still dealing with the fallout from the unexpected production halt that occurred in June and July, which hurt Q3 by pushing back when certain in-demand models became available, and by shifting our inventory composition, particularly in North America. Against this complicated backdrop, our attention remains fixed on carrying out our 5-year strategic plan. The quarter's results show a 9% revenue drop at HDMC, partly offset by a 15% revenue increase at HDFS, which together produced a 6% decline in overall revenue for the quarter. Behind this performance was a 20% fall in wholesales stemming from the production suspension we announced in late Q2, disciplined dealer inventory management, and market conditions consistent with our most recent guidance; higher pricing and mix each helped offset some of that. For Q3 year-to-date, HDMC revenue has risen 2.1%, even with the difficult conditions we've faced this year. I'd like to share a few additional details behind these numbers, keeping in mind both our Hardwire strategy and what's actually happening in our sector at present. First, under our Hardwire strategy, we put priority on our Stronghold Categories — Touring, Softail, Trike, and CVO. The premium segment has taken a disproportionate hit this year as affordability and discretionary spending have turned into bigger concerns and as broader economic conditions have put the brakes on the upgrade cycle within these categories, especially for a platform that's been around as long as Rushmore in Touring. That said, it's worth noting we still command market-leading economics and hold more than 70% share across these highly attractive and profitable categories in North America; we think riders' desire for a Harley-Davidson Touring bike — the pinnacle of motorcycling — is as strong as ever, no matter what the deeply rooted counter-narratives suggest, and that standing apart from competitors plus a strong value proposition can still deliver growth even when the market is tough. Second, our retail volume in North America specifically has suffered from phasing out our legacy Sportster, which had been a share builder within the cruiser category; we see our RevMax platform, brought to market in 2021, as both distinctive and technology-leading, and we believe that when it's positioned competitively, customer adoption of the platform can expand over time. Third, we're staying committed to managing inventory and our dealer channel in order to safeguard desirability and profitability over the long term. With the market the way it is, we took steps all year to keep total inventory in line, working within what manufacturing can actually do. One thing to keep in mind: the halt in production late in Q2 made timing, mix, and channel distribution of inventory harder, and we spent the quarter dealing with that too. Another point worth making is that now that we wrapped up 2023 production at the end of last week, we expect the inventory we have on hand plus whatever shipments remain this year to carry retail volume through Q4 and into early 2024. We also know that when demand swings more unevenly, we have to run with inventory levels above those from 2021 and 2022. Finally, we put more money into marketing promotions — supporting loyal customers and dealers through a tough stretch, and steering inventory mix toward our strategic goals, especially since product showed up later in the year. That spending is above both 2021 and 2022, but it's worth stressing that the investment is targeted, limited, and balanced between driving traffic and helping close deals; it has produced a lot of learnings and tighter alignment with our dealer network. Even with all the difficulties this year, there are major bright spots to report. First, our CVOs have landed really well with the market, with sales in that category climbing 25% against the prior year, and showing solid sell-through. Dealers and customers alike are thrilled by how this product evolved in the most exclusive category we offer. Second, our Trike and Softails combined are posting retail gains as well, rising 12% for the year as of the end of Q3. We're adding capacity for the Trike line while pushing more production toward our best-selling models — Breakout in the Softail category is a prime illustration. Both cases prove that even in hard conditions, a strong offering paired with a great value proposition can generate growth. Across the quarter, every global region kept delivering robust profitability, fueled by sharp attention to mix management and expansion in our highest-margin categories. That reversal has added a great deal to our bottom line, and we see it as a firm foundation for profitable growth ahead. As a number of you have pointed out, on October third and fourth we hosted an in-person dealer forum in Milwaukee for the leadership of our North American dealer network — the first event of its kind. With about 80% of our North American dealer body there, the event had three objectives: first, to present exciting product developments to our dealer network. Second, to strengthen alignment around our plans and investments meant to maximize impact in 2024. And third, to get everyone energized and ready for what lies ahead in 2024. Across a day and a half, the topics we covered included new product reveals, plans for growth and profitability, aligning our go-to-market efforts, and updates on important programs such as membership and loyalty. The response to this gathering has been extremely favorable, with more than 90% of those attending expressing satisfaction regarding the information provided and the meeting as a whole, and with dealers pointing out how valuable this session was for making sure we're completely aligned as we move into the latter portion of our Hardwire strategy. As we've noted previously, we consider our dealer network to be the strongest, most exclusive and most powerful dealer body across the entire powersports industry, and it continues to be an essential competitive edge for fueling growth, handling inventory, and backing our customer experience. Before turning things over to Karim, I want to say that Harley-Davidson stays dedicated to its Hardwire strategy, emphasizing both profitability and desirability, and we'll do whatever it takes to reach our objectives. With that said, we're absolutely realistic that today's market conditions present difficulties, yet we'll keep zeroing in on the things within our control, which includes close examination of our OpEx and a push toward cost productivity improvements.
Karim Donnez
executiveThanks, Jochen. Morning, everybody. During Q3, LiveWire made a lot of significant strides as we keep pushing our product lineup forward and expanding where we sell. The biggest one: we kicked off manufacturing of the Del Mar at Harley-Davidson's plant in York, Pennsylvania. That marks a major step for LiveWire. Following several years of putting money into the S2 platform and developing the LiveWire battery pack, motor, power, electronics, and software internally, we think those outlays have delivered technology that leads the industry plus the ability to quickly adjust and improve the S2 platform, all while cutting LiveWire's reliance on outside suppliers. Initial buyers have begun taking delivery of their Del Mar, and those bikes are now being ridden in the U.S; riders who've gotten time on the Del Mar come away impressed at how it lives up to what LiveWire promises, thanks to excellent specs and a price that's easier to reach. With output climbing now, we anticipate higher volumes during Q4 as we place more bikes with more customers. Not long ago we shared Del Mar pricing for Europe, locked in delivery dates during Q1, 2024, and began taking reservations. Fourteen days back, we brought media and influencers from around the European market together for a Del Mar press event in Barcelona, generating early excitement ahead of the spring riding season. Our development groups are putting in serious effort to use the platforms we already have, STACYC and LiveWire, to grow the group's portfolio and give more riders more choices. As we approach the close of the fiscal year, our cash investments match our plan; we also anticipate hitting our latest guidance, reflecting demand and what we're currently producing each day. Thanks, and I'll now pass things to Jonathan.
Jonathan Root
executiveThanks, Karim, and good morning to all of you. This marks the fourth quarter in which we've reported under the new structure, with our three business segments: HDMC, HDFS, and LiveWire. During Q3, worldwide wholesale shipments fell 20%, which Jochen mentioned earlier — the result of the production halt we announced late in Q2, disciplined dealer inventory levels, and market conditions consistent with our most recent guidance. On top of that, we were up against a very strong growth quarter, one that rose 19% in 2022. Looking at Q3 revenue, better global pricing along with our ongoing emphasis on the core motorcycle mix — touring and cruiser bikes — helped partly offset the unit declines. That let us deliver steady margin performance on a year-to-date basis... Now to our third quarter financial results: total consolidated HDI revenue came in at $1.5 billion, a decline of 6% versus last year. Here's the breakdown: at HDMC, revenue was down 9%. At HDFS, revenue rose 15%. At LiveWire, revenue fell 45%. Total consolidated HDI operating income reached $209 million, which is $129 million below the prior year. Breaking that down: at HDMC, operating income of $175 million was 37% lower than a year ago. At HDFS, operating income of $59 million dropped 27% year over year. At LiveWire, an operating loss of $25 million matched what we expected. Third quarter earnings per share came to $1.38, down 22%, reflecting the factors just described. Turning to our year-to-date results: total consolidated HDI revenue was $4.8 billion, up 4% from the same period a year ago. Breaking that down: at HDMC, revenue rose 2%. At HDFS, revenue increased 17%; and at LiveWire, revenue fell 39%. Total consolidated HDI operating income came to $800 million, which is $105 million below the prior year. Breaking that down: at HDMC, operating income of $705 million compares with $709 million in the same period last year, reflecting a solid operating margin of 17.4% for 2023 year to date. At HDFS, operating income of $177 million fell 30%, and at LiveWire, an operating loss of $82 million matched our expectations. Year-to-date earnings per share of $4.65 compares with $4.68 last year. Global retail sales of new motorcycles dropped 16% versus the prior year; in North America, Q3 retail sales declined 15%, driven by how the high interest rate environment is affecting consumers' discretionary purchase decisions. What's more, discontinuing the legacy Sportster bikes at the end of 2022 continues to hurt non-core unit sales; in EMEA, Q3 retail sales declined 13%, driven by the planned shift in unit mix toward profitable core product segments. Core bikes now make up 80% of sales, up from 70% in 2022. During Q3, touring bike sales rose 10% compared to the same period last year. In Asia Pacific, third-quarter retail sales fell 24% year over year, representing a sequential drop from Q2 2023, when retail sales had risen 24%. The softness in Asia Pacific stemmed mainly from demand in China falling short of expectations, as the Chinese economy proved weaker than anticipated. In Latin America, Q3 retail sales dropped 11%, with Brazil's weakness partly counterbalanced by Mexico's growth. Looking deeper at our Q3 retail performance, we should note that the several-week production halt during June and July of 2023 hurt retail sales adversely, especially in the critical North American market. It pushed deliveries of high-demand units into the tail end of Q3 instead of earlier in the season. It also generated inventory distribution and mix difficulties within the channel. This restrained our preferred motorcycle mix relative to our expectations. Measured year over year, average inventory during Q3 increased by over 50% as we worked to widen product availability, in contrast to the extremely tight levels seen in 2021 and 2022. Dealer inventory remains below 2019 levels. We expect that current dealer inventory along with the remaining 2023 calendar year shipments will carry us through the remainder of Q4 and the start of Q1 2024. Regarding retail pricing, U.S. transaction prices for new Harley-Davidson motorcycles have stayed broadly within our desirability threshold of plus or minus two percentage points of MSRP on a year-to-date basis. For the HDMC segment, revenue fell 9% because fewer wholesale units were shipped in Q3. Wholesale units dropped 20% during Q3. Turning to the HDMC revenue bridge and the quarter's main drivers: 18 points of decline resulted from reduced volume at HDMC, chiefly due to the earlier-mentioned drop in wholesale motorcycle unit shipments. Three points of growth came from pricing, via both global MSRP increases and pricing in the parts and accessories and apparel and licensing businesses. Mix added six points of growth as we kept prioritizing our most profitable models and markets. Lastly, foreign exchange was flat in Q3. At HDMC, operating income reached $175 million in Q3, 6.1 points below the prior year, hurt by lower wholesale shipments and higher operating expenses. HDMC gross margin in Q3 came to 31.7%, versus 34.4% a year earlier. That 2.7 point, or 270 basis point, decrease resulted from the negative effects of lower volume, unfavorable manufacturing impacts, and foreign currency, which more than outweighed the positive effects of pricing and shipments... We saw more modest cost inflation, roughly 1% in Q3. Year over year, the slowdown remained largely attributable to logistics, including reduced expedited shipping costs and favorable ocean freight rates. Raw materials and metal markets have likewise kept moderating. For HDMC, the operating margin in the third quarter was 13.5%, compared with 19.6% a year earlier. That decline stemmed from greater operating expense, which included increased people costs as well as more spending on marketing. Looking at HDMC for the year-to-date period, operating income reached $705 million, versus $709 million of operating income in the same period a year ago. At 17.4% for the year-to-date period, HDMC's operating margin is roughly 50 basis points below the prior period. This modest reduction reflects negative impacts from volume, foreign currency, and supply chain costs, along with higher operating expense, partly offset by favorable impacts from increased pricing and better mix. Turning to Harley-Davidson Financial Services, revenue grew 15%, fueled by greater finance receivables and increased interest income. HDFS posted $59 million of operating income in Q3, a 27% drop from last year. The third-quarter decrease resulted from increased borrowing costs, plus a larger provision for credit losses tied to realized credit losses and a higher credit reserve. HDFS's annualized retail credit loss ratio for Q3 was 2.7%, versus 2.6% in Q2 of this year. Losses during the quarter tracked their usual seasonality pattern, with results matching expectations. Those levels stand against a 1.9% annualized loss for the full year 2022. Several factors tied to today's macroeconomic environment drove the rise in credit losses.
Jonathan Root
executiveAlso, our provision for credit losses in Q3 rose to 5.4%, compared with 5.3% in Q2 and 5.1% for fiscal 2022. Retail loan originations during the third quarter fell 15%, whereas commercial lending receivables climbed 39% to $1.05 billion, helped by better product availability than a year earlier. Quarter-end net financing receivables overall—retail loans plus commercial lending receivables—came to $7.7 billion, a 4% gain year over year. Interest expense for Q3 grew $23 million, or 38%, against the prior year. That rise came from a higher cost of funds, since lower-rate debt reached maturity and was refinanced at today's market rates. By the close of Q3, we had raised roughly $2.5 billion in the capital markets. Cash plus committed bank and conduit facilities gave HDFS a liquidity position of $2.5 billion. In our view, this leaves HDFS very strongly situated on both funding and liquidity. Turning to LiveWire, third quarter revenue dropped to $8 million from $15 million a year ago, reflecting fewer unit sales of LiveWire One electric motorcycles and STACYC electric balance bikes. In the third quarter of 2023, LiveWire started shipping Del Mar, the first motorcycle built on the company's S2 platform. LiveWire's $25 million operating loss matched expectations, attributable to planned development costs for advancing EV systems, work related to Del Mar, and expenses of standing up a new organization. The third quarter also brought a sequential reduction of $7 million in LiveWire's operating loss relative to the second quarter of 2023. To finish with Harley-Davidson, Inc.'s financial results, year to date we generated $707 million in operating cash flow, an increase of $132 million over the prior year. That operating cash flow gain stemmed from positive working capital activity, caused by a bigger inventory reduction across the first nine months of 2023 than in the same period of 2022. Cash and cash equivalents totaled $1.9 billion at the end, $148 million above the close of Q3 last year. This consolidated cash figure includes $200 million from LiveWire. Furthermore, over the first 9 months of 2023, under our capital allocation strategy, we repurchased 6.1 million shares for $226 million. Looking ahead to the remainder of 2023, we reaffirm our latest full-year guidance, calling for HDMC revenue growth of flat to +3% and an HDMC operating income margin of 13.9%-14.3%. We still expect pricing benefits and our supply chain cost productivity work to outweigh anticipated cost inflation and currency headwinds. At HDFS, our expectation remains an operating income decline of 20%-25%. During Q3, realized credit losses came in higher than Q2, with seasonality unfolding just as we anticipated. Our attention remains fixed on multiple initiatives already in motion so that we can steer the company effectively through the credit conditions we face right now, and that includes putting more money into collections as well as stepping up repossessions. We keep developing additional revenue streams, for instance licensing and trademark income along with insurance income, and that insurance income is still running ahead of what we saw during the comparable stretch a year ago. LiveWire still anticipates selling somewhere between 600 and 1,000 units, with an operating loss somewhere in the range of $115 million-$125 million. That projection factors in the revised timing for rolling out the new Del Mar electric motorcycle. Finally, when it comes to total HDI, our expectation remains capital investments of $225 million-$250 million, since we keep funding product development and efforts to improve our capabilities. Across the initial 9 months of this year, cost inflation has largely come in the way we anticipated, and we still look for roughly 1 to 2 points of inflation altogether for the whole of 2023, versus 4% during 2022. The main forces behind inflation remain labor and warehousing expenses, while we anticipate deflation and moderation in logistics, freight, and raw materials. We now anticipate $70 million in cost productivity for 2023 given the changed production environment. That figure is lower than the $100 million estimate we gave at the close of Q2. At HDFS, we anticipate that the drop in operating income will ease during the final quarter of this year as we start lapping the rate hikes and the loss normalization that got underway late in 2022. When we consider how to allocate capital over the rest of 2023, our priorities stay the same: finance the expansion of the Hardwire initiatives, which takes in the capital expenditures I noted earlier, distribute dividends, and carry out discretionary share repurchases. To wrap up, we feel good about how resilient our financial results have been, particularly our margin performance, given a complicated retail landscape. With that said, I'll hand things back to the operator so we can take your questions. Thank you.
Craig Kennison
analystCraig, hello, and thanks for the question. Between what we see in retail sales and in your HDFS portfolio, you've got solid visibility into where today's consumer pressure points sit. I'd like to know how you'd characterize the American consumer right now across income brackets and credit tiers, and also what the main chapters of your recession playbook would look like should a downturn actually arrive in 2024.
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveCraig, good morning, and I appreciate the question. Some of the signals you're pointing to regarding consumer health, I believe, surface across a few different measurements. First off, we clearly observe plenty of buyers staying on the fence, basically setting aside a discretionary purchase of this magnitude during 2023, and for a company like ours that relies heavily on an upgrade cycle with a particular cadence, that carries a rather significant effect. That's the first element, in my view. We know this from market research — customers simply pushing a purchase of this kind out of their thinking in a year such as 2023. Next, you find many buyers, perhaps even those with strong credit profiles, examining where rates stand and experiencing a degree of rate shock, telling themselves, "We won't pay rates at that level," partly because of the many years and many decades of cheaper rates. So that's the second area where it emerges. Then there's a third layer, possibly involving our customers who face more credit challenges, or those at a different, perhaps somewhat lower, income level. They focus on the monthly payment that comes out of it, especially once you factor in a trade-in that may be valued somewhat lower given what was originally paid in 2021 and 2022, and they don't see a way to genuinely stretch their monthly payment to accommodate an upgrade or a new motorcycle purchase. It comes down to an affordability ceiling within their month-to-month budget. So it appears in several distinct areas: folks taking this year off, folks unwilling to accept those rates, and then simply the struggle of possibly meeting the monthly payment. I'll let Jonathan chime in shortly with more on customer health, but regarding your second point about our recession playbook, that playbook is firmly anchored in our strategy, which is our plan to keep defending and safeguarding the categories that matter most and are most profitable for us. Our stronghold categories: Touring, Trike, CVO, and Softail. As Jochen said in his remarks, even during a tough year like this one, we've observed that wherever our value proposition is stronger and product innovation is present, performance tends to be comparatively stronger. That goal, then — our plan is to keep putting weight behind new ideas and product work within those Stronghold Categories. We'll keep collaborating with HDFS and with our dealers, the finest in the industry, giving them the proper equipment to bring to market so that every single person who wants a motorcycle can locate the ideal mix of considerations and the ideal machine for themselves. We'll keep leaning on other key pieces of our operation, such as pre-owned bikes, plus P&A and apparel, to guarantee that buyers keep coming through the dealership doors and keep getting the chance to connect with our brand, even when the economy is in a downturn.
Craig Kennison
analystThanks.
Jonathan Root
executivePrior to Jonathan stepping in, regarding how we approach a downturn, clearly we're going to examine OpEx and cost productivity closely. Those strike me as 2 areas where, given what's happening in the market, we can do better. That's something we're scrutinizing very intently alongside OpEx so that we're ready regardless of what we face. ... Alright, thank you, Jochen. Let me tack on a few additional points. Edel handled this well, I think, but given where our consumer health business stands, the consumer appears more stressed. From an HDFS standpoint, as we engage with that consumer, balancing payments across their portfolio takes somewhat more effort for them than previously. Looking at the segments, tension is greater in subprime than in prime. Throughout the HDFS business, over a number of years, we've been cutting back our subprime exposure, meaning the portfolio contains fewer subprime consumers than it did, you know, compared with the last few years. To give a bit of color on delinquency, delinquency is definitely somewhat elevated compared with the same period a year ago. Page 13 also shows and discloses this, where we detail what we're observing on the credit loss side as it trends upward. Along with that, we've made some provision changes to ensure we're protected going forward. Then, touching once more on the downturn approach, Jochen raised a couple of strong ideas, right? Ensuring we examine the OpEx side of our business so we can squeeze out costs wherever possible. We aren't halting there. We're pressing onward and making certain we consider the cost of goods sold side, digging deeply into it, to ensure we can reach targets; and finally, I think, from a downturn approach standpoint, when we consider HDFS and think about nearer-term steps available to us. Obviously, the portfolio you possess is the one you deal with. So, from the angle of what we do daily, it's really about ensuring we have the right collection staff on hand, that we pursue customers in a manner that's, that's fair and assists in bringing them current. And we also consider various technology tools we might deploy to assist our associates and assist our customers, so contacting customers through different methods. Thus, instead of relying solely on phone calls, we ensure text messaging is available, that email is utilized, and that we genuinely let customers engage with us through the channels they prefer. Then the final thing I'll mention is that our calls are actually put through an AI-driven process so we can really examine and confirm that we're at ease with how our collectors are dealing with consumers. So all in all, I believe that's a quite good question, something we definitely feel we are handling, you know, in keeping with the circumstances we find ourselves in. But once more, good question. Thank you very much.
Bob Ohmes
analystHi there, good morning, and thanks for letting me ask. I was wondering if Jochen and the rest of the team might share a few views regarding where dealer inventory stands right now — is it still off-kilter? Is there still a great deal of effort required before things look more balanced, meaning more trikes and fewer Sportsters, that sort of thing? Also, what kind of timeline are we looking at to bring the dealers to the spot you'd like them to occupy when it comes to the inventory mix? On top of that, how ought we to be thinking about backing dealer promotions down the road, and perhaps backing HDFS promotions too? Should we treat that as something hitting gross margin during Q4? Do you have any perspective on how that could carry over into the opening half of next year?
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveRobbie, thank you for asking. Let me begin with the inventory topic; without a doubt, all through Q3 we have been putting in effort to make sure we reach the proper level and the proper blend of inventory, just as you rightly point out within the channel; it's plainly no mystery that while we navigated some of the supply disruption Jochen mentioned, which surfaced both in our supply chain and in the broader timing of the units that are available at the dealer, that has produced some effect on our capacity to retail during the quarter. That stems from, as I noted, either a mix of when units show up or the assortment of units sitting in the channel. Although certainly there are dealers who feel uneasy about how much inventory they hold, especially considering what floor plan costs look like nowadays, I believe you'd discover across our network that a solid number of dealers would tell you their worries center more on the mix of the inventory in their possession. As you're aware, items such as Trikes and even our new CVOs, and when those units have arrived at their dealerships. So we are pushing through the rest of the year, as we finish up production of model year 2023, to make sure we concentrate on those units that are in highest demand, and that we steer a mix at the level of individual models and get closer to what we think will be needed in Q4 and even into the early part of the year. One thing worth noting: the inventory we currently hold, along with any leftover shipments of model year 2023, is in fact the inventory that backs our retails, largely into the new year. Turning to what you asked about the general amount of promotional activity and how we see that unfolding — we've been relying on several of these levers primarily to support our strategic inventory goals, making certain we keep that mix in balance along with certain difficulties that can arise in how inventory is spread across our network. In a lot of cases, these promotions represent sales incentives moved from where they otherwise would have sat in different formats. As a result, what we've observed so far is that the effect on our Gross Margin has been relatively restrained. Even so, we're genuinely working to make sure we bring in traffic, that we back our dealers and our most loyal customers under these conditions, and that we continue managing toward those strategic inventory targets. So what you'll see is that they're highly targeted and quite specific, focused on the families and models we regard as priorities. Perhaps one final remark more generally regarding the inventory matter. Given the current conditions, we've determined that running with greater inventory than what we experienced in 2021 or 2022 is required. It's simply that customer demand has become somewhat more tempered, and there's a bit more particularity around what buyers want, and without question even supply disruptions have increased our need to hold somewhat more inventory in the channel so we can satisfy consumer demand for the exact bike they're seeking. So I just wanted to mention that too.
Jonathan Root
executiveThat's quite useful. I appreciate it.
Joe Altobello
analystThank you. Morning. I'd like to build on the earlier remarks about dealer inventory, you know. You said those levels are high compared with 2021 and 2022. If I'm calculating correctly, I figure you're sitting at roughly 15 weeks of supply. My recollection is you finished last year at about 10 weeks. So, to make sure I understand, it, it sounds like that 15-week figure works for you on the whole, or do you believe it needs to, has to decline somewhat in the coming year, somewhere in the range of that 10 to 15 weeks?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveYes, Joseph, at this moment we're at ease with that figure. Clearly, we'll need to watch how the fourth quarter plays out, but every one of the impacts Edel referred to, you know, factors into this. And so, as things stand today, we believe the inventory level is fine.
Joe Altobello
analystAll right. Appreciate it.
James Hardiman
analystMorning, and thanks for fitting me in. What I'd like to do is try to connect where retail stands right now with the outlook, since I believe we're running roughly 9% lower year to date, and my sense is that's weaker than what you'd expected before, while HDMC is still guided to somewhere between flat and up 3%. Clearly pricing appears to be a factor here. You had a sizable lift in the third quarter, but it would help to connect those dots across the full year and, even more so, for the fourth quarter, given that the first three quarters are already behind us. My math implies roughly flat revenue for HDMC in Q4. So how do you arrive at that? What assumptions sit behind it for retail, ASP shipments, and so on?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveYes. Appreciate that, James. Here's how I'd frame it: we aren't giving retail guidance, and on the wholesale side, you've clearly run the numbers yourself, correct? What's important to keep in mind regarding retail, and we went through this in the script, is that over half of the retail drop comes from the Sportster being retired, correct? That carries a meaningful impact, and it will keep playing out until the Sportster is fully retired, which happens, more or less, at the close of the second quarter, and that aligns with our strategy. So keep that in mind as you assess retails and retail declines.
Jonathan Root
executiveRight, and the one thing I'd tack on when we consider the business — and you can see it in the year-to-date numbers — is simply how strong things have looked from a mix standpoint and a pricing standpoint; so clearly, you know, I realize there's frequently a lot of attention paid externally to units, units, units, and in terms of how we're operating the business, we're definitely striving to ensure we hold onto a pricing edge wherever possible.
James Hardiman
analystThat's useful. I'll jump into the line, get back in line. Thanks, everyone.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveI think, James, just to give a bit more background, when we make comparisons, there's frequently a mention of 2019, and apart from the reality that the setting is entirely different, with numerous elements, unlike today compared to 2019, such as, clearly, interest rates and, consumer sentiment, our HDMC, profitability moved from 9.1% to 17.4%, which is a rise of 8.3 percentage points. So that is, that is significant, and I believe, it is a, it is evidence, even in this present climate we find ourselves in, that the approach is delivering and, and, and the profitability exists. And that is on a year-to-date foundation, but it likewise holds for the third quarter, where we have observed a climb from 4.4% OI to 13.5% by comparison; so, kindly keep that in mind. That represents a 9.1 percentage point gain in operating income. So I think that is also the background as Jonathan stated, you folks are concentrating heavily on unit sales and all the rest. I think profitability is something that should not be overlooked.
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveMorning. Let me return to the topic of promotions briefly. You've got 3.99% with nothing down during the quarter, I believe, and after the quarter ends you move to 1.9% with nothing down. So how does the consumer react to those reduced rates, and should we think of that as the standard going forward for Harley? Thanks. Thanks for asking, Tristan. As we said, we face a number of possible difficulties when it comes to how consumers behave, along with differing strategic goals regarding our inventory — that's what shapes how we've built our promotional programs. We've tested and tried a few different tools to ensure we're covering multiple channels, at both the top and the bottom of the funnel. Let me begin by noting that a lot of these promotional activities also serve, in many respects, as traffic drivers. Above all, we want to make certain — again, in a climate where a discretionary purchase of this magnitude may not be top of mind for the consumer — that we're once again part of their consideration set. That's one extremely important element... even down to how far the promotion actually reaches or who it applies to; we've seen that the low APR has gone over well with our dealers and with our consumers. And at this point in the year, we typically observe consumers who may be seeking somewhat stronger creditworthiness and who want a genuinely attractive offer, and that's the group our promotions aim at. But above all, our work centers on a balance of bringing in traffic, building awareness, and ensuring we're once again in the consideration set — just as much as it concerns finalizing deals for the consumer at the dealership level.
Jonathan Root
executiveAll right, thanks.
Noah Zatzkin
analystHello, and I appreciate you answering my question. I was hoping you might give us some detail or assist in putting a figure on how much the halt in production affected shipments in 3Q, and what is your thinking regarding the effect on retail over that quarter? Would you anticipate that restarting shipments will act as a boost for retail in Q4?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveAs was stated in what we delivered, shipments are moving again, though they landed later in the third quarter than we would have liked. Consequently, several of the products we consider most desirable arrived toward the back end of the third quarter, which has definitely left a mark. Putting a number on the retail effect is rather hard, so I will not attempt it. Still, the disruption has clearly thrown off our mix somewhat, along with deliveries of the units we value most. That consequence is something we have clearly observed. As for what portion can be made up in Q4, that is still uncertain, though it is clearly our goal.
Noah Zatzkin
analystThat's extremely useful. Perhaps only one additional item — and I realize you aren't providing guidance for 2024. However, when it comes to HDFS, how are you approaching, say, a starting point for anticipated credit losses in the coming year, taking into account elevated rates? Thank you.
Jonathan Root
executiveYes, happy to address that. That's a solid question; at this moment we aren't discussing 2024 or giving 2024 guidance; we want to be certain we finish out this year and feel confident in whatever we say about periods further ahead. So we'll likely wait on that. What matters most to us, I believe, is that when we examine what we've shown — once more, in today's presentation — regarding what we observe for realized retail credit losses, those have definitely picked up pace; we believe we're beginning to lap a stretch that is somewhat simpler on a comparison basis than the situation during the first half of the year. The direction of the trend we're experiencing is favorable, yet likely not at the appropriate magnitude; therefore it will begin to decelerate somewhat as we get into the back quarter, or the last quarter, of the year. Still, when we think ahead toward 2024, we'll reserve that for a later call with you that is somewhat better informed and somewhat more precise.
Noah Zatzkin
analystThanks.
David MacGregor
analystMorning, everybody. My question is about LiveWire. It looks like you're still aiming for those 600 bikes at the bottom end of the range, and that would suggest a fairly big jump in shipments during the fourth quarter. So how sure are you about that 600-unit goal? Could you say what share of these bikes might already be spoken for? Did you change the planned price for the Del Mar because of some of the affordability concerns raised earlier on this call? And, importantly, how quickly does the operating loss react when unit shipments ramp up?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveMorning, David. Appreciate the question. Our confidence level is exactly where it needs to be for us to reaffirm guidance, correct? When it comes to the number of units, we have sufficient demand to meet the guidance. Production has restarted, and we're ramping up at this very moment, so we're quite confident that with the demand from pre-orders plus the capacity we have at York, we can hit that figure. That covers the first part. As for the second, we're holding to the pricing communicated previously.
David MacGregor
analystAll right. Could you discuss how quickly the operating loss reacts when unit shipments ramp up?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThe operating loss matches what was budgeted for the year in terms of investments. So right now, it's precisely the level we should be at.
David MacGregor
analystDavid S. MacGregor, Analyst: All right. What I'm hoping to do is get a feel for, as we move ahead and ramp up, how that operating leverage, that volume leverage, could shape up in 2024, 2025?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveWell, my answer will essentially match the one Jonathan provided a moment ago — on this call, we aren't commenting on 2024 or 2025.
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveMorning. I appreciate you taking the question. During the earlier portion of this call, you mentioned a dealer forum that took place in early October. Could you share a few of the subjects that came up there? The response from dealers that reached us was positive to an overwhelming degree, particularly regarding new products, and also certain initiatives you have underway for 2024. Thanks, Brandon. That's nice to hear. We felt it was a great session too. The primary goal was really about the business planning chance we have with our dealers. Sure, there was benefit in all of us gathering once more as a wider HDMC and dealer group, yet our primary goal was ensuring alignment as we head into 2024 regarding what must be done so that we, we enjoy a really strong, strong year; we think our network, as Jochen mentioned in his remarks, is, is truly a distinctive asset for us when it comes to its reach, its strength, its exclusivity; therefore the more we can align and guarantee that we are going, to market alongside one another on certain critical initiatives, the better. As for our main agenda items, we definitely included a portion focused on product, which, you know, we don't discuss our upcoming product plans, but clearly a very significant part of the session involved ensuring our dealers knew about some of what is scheduled for 2024 as they consider their own operations. After that we had a wide set of — we addressed a wide set of subjects concerning business alignment on several of our key initiatives, membership and loyalty, our apparel business, our wider omni-channel initiatives, how we approach profitability and growth. And once more, very, very extensive conversation about a major piece of the agenda centered on ensuring alignment in our go-to-market and in our marketing investments especially. Again, capitalizing on the strength of that network and the investments they contribute when engaging with consumers. So we felt it was a tremendously valuable session. It was a great chance as well to simply energize everyone around what has been, in many respects, a difficult year. So it was... I believe it will produce results as we move into 2024 with a far more aligned and energized network.
James Hardiman
analystExcellent. Thanks.
James Hardiman
analystHello, I appreciate you letting me ask a second question. Returning to the discussion about inventory, I believe I understand why stock levels would be greater than in 2021 and 2022, since those years saw quite thin supplies. What still puzzles me, though, is this: when we look at inventories against 2019, they've fallen by a smaller amount than retail has, correct? That means, based on my calculations at least, days on hand and weeks on hand are higher — considerably so, in fact — compared with 2019. And Jochen, when you arrived at the beginning, the signal appeared quite strong and unambiguous that management believed inventory levels were far too elevated as we exited 2019. So please help me reconcile these two points. It simply seems that a great deal of the work during those initial couple of years was directed at trimming the channel. Yet here we are now, in a position that's arguably worse than before, at least when measured by weeks on hand.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveYes. I'll ask Edel to weigh in on this too, regarding the comparison with 2019, though my view is that 2021 and 2022 cannot be measured against the current situation; for every reason I laid out previously, the conditions are vastly different. Buyers are more particular. There was a manufacturing halt that, well. And to deliver the correct assortment to our dealers, we must, by design, carry more stock when customers are pickier about which products they want. And we remain — I'll pass this to Edel now — well under where we stood in 2019. So, I realize your method of calculating differs somewhat from the approach we take regarding inventory reach, yet based on all our observations and all the feedback we receive, we believe we're positioned well at present.
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveYes, James, I believe looking back at 2019 as a benchmark matters. As Jochen pointed out, there are a few distinctions regarding our current position within the broader business cycle compared to 2019. So the first point I'd make is that without a doubt, we've been at work all quarter long—definitely from the time of the production shutdown onward—to ensure we're right-sizing our total inventory; and once more, the issue isn't so much the overall unit count, which remains below where it stood in 2019, but rather the composition of those units sitting in the channel. That's something we absolutely keep as a core tenet of our Hardwire strategies overall, so that we maintain sufficient representation. The second factor, and it truly shouldn't be underestimated, involves how the delay and the blend of what we managed to build—especially during the first portion of the quarter—affected our retail goals. So that's an area where we feel a good number of those units, the CVOs in particular, still hold potential for retail within the year; so that's worth factoring in as we consider the whole of 2023; but it's definitely an element we've been navigating through during the latter half of the year. The third item I'd flag, and this too represents a shift from 2019 in terms of how the year's rhythm has played out, is that we ceased building 2023 units this week. Naturally, we'll keep shipping them as they're completed and as we load plan, etc., matching them against dealer demand. But in essence, that's a major contrast with our 2019 business cycle, when we would have kept sending units deep into Q4 at roughly full strength. We're intentionally winding that production down as we prepare for 2024; and then the last thing I'd mention, and this is something we've definitely picked up this year after moving our model year to the start of the calendar year, is that we plan to be completely set for 2024 throughout every family, especially the ones where demand has run very high—Trike, as was referenced earlier in the conversation—and where we've frankly battled all year to satisfy that demand promptly within a business that's heavily seasonal. We want to be set for 2024. We want to be set for that ramp up. We think inventory plays a significant part in backing the start of the year, and viewed through that lens, our situation differs meaningfully from where we stood in 2019. So those are a few of the various factors we're weighing and balancing. So definitely we're working through it, attempting to get the mix right, since that's our top priority. Handling overall volume is clearly a big deal in 2025, of course, because dealers are facing that added expense, yet what matters most is making certain that, with production running on a different rhythm, we're set and ready when the season kicks off in a business that is extremely, extremely seasonal.
James Hardiman
analystMay I jump in and ask for a bit of clarity? Regarding this mix issue and Sportster being wound down — what's the SKU count compared with 2019? From what I'm hearing, the SKU count has actually fallen, which ought to assist in lowering inventories, right? Or is that the wrong way for me to look at it?
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveYes. By mix, I mean mix both inside families and among them. Take, for instance, the relative balance between our Softail family and our Trike family, against what sits within the Touring family; those are among the inputs. That balance is not exactly, or has not exactly been, what we would have preferred during Q3. And even inside something like our Touring family, 55% of our portfolio, there's a relative balance among some of our higher end, more complex units, our STs and our specials, against our base Road Glides and Street Glides. Every one of those individual units, because of supply disruption and then possibly even shifting consumer preferences and affordability over the course of the year, are units we attempt to correct. I should point out, all of this happens within the context of manufacturing realities. Changing, in a sense, the mix of a manufacturing facility during the year is not a simple job; it is gradual, and that is what we have been doing through the back half of the year to ensure we have the right combination of families, and then even models inside those families, to ready ourselves and to align more closely with where demand sits.
James Hardiman
analystGot it. I get why that's tough, so I'm grateful for the detail. Thanks, everyone.
Edel O'Sullivan
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up the Q&A portion — we have nothing else queued up right now. That brings today's conference call to a close. Thanks to everyone for being on the line, and at this point you're free to hang up.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Harley-Davidson, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Harley-Davidson, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Harley-Davidson, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.