Harley-Davidson, Inc. (HOG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 8, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Automobiles earnings

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Shawn Collins

executive
#1

Thanks. Morning, everyone. Shawn Collins here, and I serve as Director of Investor Relations for Harley-Davidson. The slides that go along with this call are available right now online at the Harley-Davidson Investor Relations website. As is typical, some of what we say will consist of forward-looking statements, and those carry risks that might make actual results come out materially different. Among those risks are things we've flagged in today's earnings release as well as in our most recent SEC filings. So, with that said, here with me this morning for the opening portion of the call are Harley-Davidson Chief Executive Officer Jochen Zeitz, along with Chief Financial Officer Jonathan Root and LiveWire Chief Executive Officer Karim Donnez. Also, for the Q&A section of today's call, Harley-Davidson Chief Commercial Officer Edel O’Sullivan will be with us; so let me hand things over to our CEO, Jochen Zeitz. Jochen?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#2

Thanks, Shawn. Morning, everyone. Appreciate you being on the call today. During 2023 — the third year of the hardwired strategy we've committed to — we achieved movement on several important pieces of our strategic plan. Although premium discretionary products took a substantial hit from the ongoing elevated interest rate climate along with worries about consumer confidence and affordability, we kept our attention on core products and markets and put money into the priorities that matter for the future. Our belief is that concentrating on the categories and geographies where we earn the most, while pushing innovation and advancing how customers interact with our dealers, would keep delivering gains for the business and positioned us to create long-term value. You can see that in the sizable bump in per unit profitability — $2,400 dollars per unit, or 185% — since 2019. Turning to Q4 retail results, retail performed above what we anticipated yet fell 11% against the prior year. Worth noting: globally we retailed a greater number than we wholesaled, even when you factor in the early release of 2024 units. That early shipment of 24 units, done for logistics reasons, opened the door for a bold shipping timetable for our new touring lineup in Q1, which is required to launch the season at full strength with the new models. Across Q4 we kept beating the market, picking up share in our core categories, with touring surpassing 75% market share in the US and large cruiser landing above 80%. Contrary to what some perceive, we still hold a dominant leadership position in these core profit focus segments — comfortably ahead of all competitors combined — and that showed up in strong gross margin results. Revenue dipped a bit for the year while we steered through macro conditions hitting retails and worked to handle dealer inventory and production difficulties. Even so, the combined effect of pricing and mix, incentive spend included, produced seven points of top-line growth, ending in a 1% revenue decline caused by currency headwinds. We stay focused on profitability, with an operating income margin of 13.6% in 2023 compared to the 6.3% profitability we started from in 2019 — on 34,000 fewer motorcycle unit sales and 6% revenue growth across that stretch. To us, that's the clearest evidence of our strategic direction and execution given current conditions; it reflects our multi-year pricing and mix choices across products and geographies, with core products now at 84% of our mix, up from 78% in 2019, plus the big rise in average profitability per unit I mentioned earlier — though Jonathan will say more about that later. Let me quickly cover the choice of our hardwired strategic pillars and how we delivered on them last year, beginning with pillar one, profit focus. We keep prioritizing mix, with worldwide growth in our core units of Trike, CVO, touring and softail outpacing overall retail performance. Last year we also brought out our new generation of road and street light CVOs. So with this product that really changes things, we’re fulfilling that fundamental pledge around innovation, which fits with how we concentrate on core categories, and that sets things up for the Grand American Touring launch we have this year. As we bring out our icons and enthusiasts in a way that matches our profit priorities, we’ve kept building on our dedication to rolling out motorcycles that fit our approach of boosting desirability through the Harley-Davidson legacy, and we also kept pushing to raise awareness for the King of the Baggers racing series with Moto America, and now we’re moving into performance touring with this new offering. Pillar two, selective expansion. We’re still making headway on our global partnership and our venture with Hero MotoCorp. That’s a strong illustration of creative participation models in geographies that matter, which fits into our selective expansion strategy. We’ve felt really good about how exceptionally the venture has been received, with over 30,000 reservations so far. We’ll keep examining chosen markets for small displacement offerings. Pillar three, lead in electric. LiveWire keeps breaking new ground in the EV segment via the S2 platform with Del Mar, as Karim will go into later. More than one year into our choice to center LiveWire as a standalone company in EV and center Harley-Davidson on our traditional combustion segment, it’s proving effective, with a clear emphasis on segmentation and execution for both brands while drawing on shared synergies. Pillar five; customer experience. With our commitment to improving the customer experience in keeping with our mission, alongside our fuel program, we keep putting money into reshaping our omnichannel capabilities and the pre and post purchase journey for customers. On top of that, we keep advancing our marketing approach, specifically to drive dealership traffic and engagement and to get better alignment on key messages with our dealer channel, as shown by our open houses, dealer sweepstakes and in-store rewards. We’ve made solid headway executing our distribution system modernization, with the first milestones around product visibility and recommended orders going live this year. Through our online platform HD1 marketplace, we’re now the top marketplace for used Harley-Davidson in America, and finally, we’re happy with how our refreshed membership offering is progressing, with over 700,000 members on the new platform so far, growing membership that had been shrinking for years by over 300,000 new members in just seven months. We also successfully established homecoming as another core annual event to bring the brand closer to new and existing customers alike in a way no other brand can in the motorcycle market. Turning to '24, I’d like to talk about our new model year launch and the outlook for the year. The Grand American Touring category came from the unique experience of the American highway and was invented by Harley-Davidson. Few products are as iconic and as tied to one specific brand. To put it plainly, touring is the heart of Harley-Davidson, our mission of timeless pursuit of adventure. Back in 2020, there was no plan for touring. We moved fast to make that change, and it turned into the first and one of the biggest priorities in our new hardwire plan. From our January launch, as you witnessed, we're now thrilled to tell you about what we consider the most thorough product development for the touring platform in more than 10 years. For '24, the street light and road light models sit at the heart of the Harley-Davidson Grand American Touring motorcycle portfolio and stand for the future of the segment. Equipped with the new Milwaukee 8117, both models deliver more power, greater comfort and less weight, and they're loaded with advanced technology, among it a new infotainment system, all presented in a bold new visual design that will reshape the Harley-Davidson Grand American Touring experience for many years ahead. This newest line-up isn't just the most advanced we've ever built — it also carries the greatest customization potential we've ever provided in touring. Also for '24, to mark 25 years of our custom vehicle operations, or CVO, we brought the CVO Road Light ST and CVO Pan America into the line-up, joining our new road and street light CVOs that were first introduced during homecoming last year.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#3

To kick things off with the CVO Road Light ST — this is the lightest, quickest, and most advanced performance Bagger that Harley-Davidson has ever built. It's pushing hot rod Bagger capability to a whole new level, and it connects to the performance movement that the King of the Baggers racing series helped us ignite. The CVO Road Light ST brings together a distinctive mix of parts that delivers strong value for riders with performance in mind, paired with West Coast custom styling like what you see in our Low Rider ST. We've also taken the CVO line outside Grand American Touring for the very first time by adding the Pan America CVO, which spotlights another touring space we keep pushing forward in — Adventure Touring. We've readied ourselves and are putting money into the '24 model launch, and we've made sure motorcycles are reaching the network at the proper moment for the riding season. Even though it's still early — we launched just two weeks back — we've already gotten a very encouraging first response from the network, media, influencers, and consumers alike, with strong teamwork on awareness and traffic driving efforts. Looking toward the years ahead, we're thrilled about what this line-up could mean for the brand. Our complete attention is on growing retails with these outstanding bikes, even in today's conditions. That being said, we're still early in the year, and it's difficult to forecast how much positive effect our new touring models will deliver given the present high interest and overall industry market situation. So, while the early read on our new model year launch has us very excited, we're offering wider guidance than normal in our outlook, because of the ongoing industry headwinds hitting our business. On top of that, inventory management will stay a central piece of our approach so we keep the proper balance for the network and the customer both, and looking to the year ahead, we'll handle inventory with caution, acknowledging that we think we're near the right levels in the network. Our aim will be to make sure we manage wholesales according to retail potential, so wholesales and retails stay in balance through some mix of retail levels and manufacturing adjustments, even when those are needed. To wrap up, in spite of the market's difficulties, we believe we've built the right product and solid foundations to achieve our future ambitions for the company. Thank you, and now I'll pass it to Karim to discuss LiveWire. Karim, the floor is yours.

Karim Donnez

executive
#4

Thanks, Jochen. Morning, all. We're glad to share that following a robust fourth quarter, LiveWire's branded yearly unit sales grew 21% compared with 2022. We closed out the year with units and operating loss both matching our updated guidance. Given the ramp-up needed for every new product we developed in-house, we feel good about the supply base settling down, plus the F2 powertrain being produced at Harley-Davidson's Wisconsin operations and the Del Mar being assembled in Pennsylvania. With early customers and the media both responding positively to the freshly developed, ground-up platform, 2024 should be an exciting year for LiveWire. Our teams at StaCyc and LiveWire keep working to broaden our portfolio and deliver additional choices to more riders; we think these new offerings, together with our move into new segments, put LiveWire in position to grow unit sales without raising spend above 2023. To speed up the route to profitability, we intend to lower product costs and keep managing cash cautiously, which our guidance reflects. Thanks; I'll now pass things to Jonathan.

Jonathan Root

executive
#5

Thanks, Karim, and good morning, everyone. I'll start on Page 5 of the presentation with a quick overview of the Q4 2023 financial results, then go deeper into each item afterward. At HDMC, worldwide wholesale motorcycle shipments declined 13% during the fourth quarter, reflecting our continued focus on dealer inventory levels and market conditions. HDMC revenue was down 14% in Q4, driven by reduced volumes, with better mix canceled out by pricing and incentive spending. During both the fourth quarter and the full year 2023, as Jochen pointed out, our priority remains centered on the touring and cruiser segments that form our core motorcycle mix; additional revenue information will be provided once we reach Page 8. Turning to our consolidated fourth-quarter results, HDI's total consolidated revenue came to $1.1 billion, representing an 8% decrease compared with the same quarter a year earlier. Breaking that down: at HDMC, as I mentioned, revenue was down 14%. Over at HDFS, revenue increased 15%, while at LiveWire, revenue climbed from $9 million in Q4 2022 to $15 million in Q4 2023. When you look at HDI overall, we had a consolidated operating loss of $21 million, and in the same quarter last year we posted operating income of $4 million. Breaking down 2023, HDMC recorded an operating loss of $44 million, a sharp drop from the profitable first three quarters, since Q4 has far fewer wholesale units than the other quarters. Lower wholesale volumes and increased incentive spending during the quarter hurt results. Over at HDFS, operating income came to $58 million, down 10% versus the prior year, while LiveWire's operating loss of $35 million matched what we expected. For the fourth quarter, we earned $0.18 per share. Now looking at how we did across all of 2023, consolidated revenue came in at slightly more than $5.8 billion, which represents a 1% gain over the previous year. Meanwhile, operating income totaled $779 million, marking a 14% decline from the year before. Earnings per share for the full year landed at $4.87 in 2023, compared with $4.96 in 2022. In the section that follows, we'll go into more detail about the specific profit and loss factors affecting each of our business segments. As I noted earlier, new motorcycle retail sales worldwide dropped 11% in Q4 relative to the same period a year ago. In North America, fourth quarter retail sales fell 9%, a result of the ongoing pressure that elevated interest rates are putting on consumers' discretionary buying choices. Also, the halt of older Sportster models after 2022 kept dragging down unit sales outside our main lineup. Across EMEA, fourth-quarter retail sales fell 22%, with softness in France and Germany behind that drop. Broadly speaking, the region is still getting hit by macro headwinds and weak economic growth. Moving to Asia-Pacific, retail sales for Q4 were down 10%, as Australia and New Zealand underperformed, though Japan and Thailand partly made up for it. That marks real progress versus the picture we laid out last quarter. Over in Latin America, Q4 retail sales climbed 46%, powered by increases in both Brazil and Mexico. As production conditions keep moving back toward normal, we're seeing much better product availability than the severely limited situation in 2021 and 2022. When Q4 wrapped up, dealer inventory was about 50% above where it stood at the end of Q4 2022, as we noted earlier. Heading into the spring '24 riding season, we believe dealer inventory is now at a generally suitable level, especially after recently rolling out the new model year '24 motorcycles, most notably the new street glide and road glide touring models. On the revenue side, total HDMC revenue dropped 14% for Q4 and declined 1% for the entire year. In the fourth quarter, lower wholesale unit shipments largely drove the revenue decline at HDMC. Looking more closely at what drove Q4, 14 points of the drop came from reduced HDMC volume, reflecting our response to current market conditions, our efforts to keep dealer inventory at sensible levels, and our preparations for the 2024 model year launch of the street glide, road glide, new CBO models, and more. Pricing and incentive spend accounted for seven points of the decline, because given existing market conditions, we opted to selectively promote high margin products to help our customers through the higher rate environment they face. On top of that, we decided to introduce some incentive programs, and that cut our revenue by about $40 million in Q4. Those incentives are meant to help move model year 2023 motorcycles into calendar year 2024 by giving dealers more support. We expect this to help boost retail results in 2024. Mix contributed seven points of growth since we continued focusing on our highest-margin models and markets. Finally, foreign exchange contributed one point in Q4. For the entire 2023 year, HDMC revenue declined 1%. The main full-year factors were: a seven-point decrease stemming from lower volume at HDMC, driven by an overall decline in wholesale motorcycle unit shipments; a three-point gain from pricing net of incentives, through both global motorcycle MSRP hikes and price rises across the parts and accessories and apparel businesses, along with the previously noted measures to support retail during the 2024 calendar year for remaining 2023 model year dealer inventory; mix, which contributed four points of growth since we continued focusing on our highest-margin models and markets; and finally, foreign exchange, which had a negative impact of one point as the dollar strengthened throughout the year. For the fourth quarter, which is usually the period where our growth margin is weakest across the year, that margin landed at 22.9%. That represents a decline of 360 basis points. The drivers were reduced volumes, pricing and incentive spending — all of which I covered in my remarks earlier — along with manufacturing costs. Together, those factors outweighed the gains we saw from shipment mix and cheaper raw materials. Our operating income margin fell 210 basis points, reflecting the same items I just mentioned, and also the fact that operating expense favorability hit 18% for the quarter. When it comes to cost inflation, things remain more moderate for us than they were in 2022. In Q4, cost inflation came in at a rate between 1% and 2%. When we look at the whole of 2023, HDMC growth margin landed at 32.3%, an improvement of 110 basis points versus the prior year, even though volumes were lower. Both mix and pricing contributed positively across the year, though lower volumes, supply chain and manufacturing costs, and foreign currency partly offset that. HDMC operating margin for the full year 2023 reached 13.6%, versus 13.9% for the full year 2022, roughly 20 basis points less once rounding is taken into account. That modest decline in operating margins stemmed from the factors already noted and was mostly attributable to elevated operating expenses from earlier in the year. Turning to Harley-Davidson Financial Services, Q4 revenue climbed 15%, fueled by greater commercial finance receivables and increased interest income. HDFS operating income totaled $58 million, a 10% drop from the prior year, yet an improvement over the trends we saw earlier in the year. The Q4 decrease resulted from higher borrowing costs, a larger provision for credit losses, and greater operating expenses.

Jonathan Root

executive
#6

Higher interest income helped counterbalance some of those added expenses. Compared to the previous year, total interest expense rose by $22 million, or 32%. As lower interest rate debt reached maturity and got swapped out for debt at current market rates, our cost of funds went up, and that drove the increase. During the fourth quarter, the provision for credit loss expense went up by $6 million, which stemmed from greater realized credit losses, though a favorable reserve change in absolute dollars partly offset that. Looking at full year 2023, HDFS' annualized retail credit loss ratio landed at 3%, versus 2.7% through Q3 '23. Those figures compare with an annualized loss of 1.9% for the entirety of 2022. A number of factors tied to the present macroeconomic climate and the associated customer and industry dynamics pushed credit losses higher. On top of that, the allowance rate for credit losses in Q4 stayed flat at 5.4% compared to Q3, yet it rose from 5.1% in fiscal 2022, since we carefully determine our loan loss reserves following CECL methodology. Total retail loan originations dipped slightly in Q4, by 1%, whereas commercial lending receivables climbed 42% to $1.06 billion, supported by better product availability than a year earlier. At quarter end, total net financing receivables — retail loans plus commercial lending receivables — stood at $7.5 billion, a 5% gain over the prior year. For all of 2023, operating income at HDFS reached $235 million, a decline of 26% compared with full year 2022, against our financial guidance of a 20% to 25% drop for the year. By the close of Q4, we had raised roughly $2.5 billion across the capital markets for the whole of 2023. Cash along with committed bank and conduit facilities gave HDFS a liquidity position of $2.2 billion at yearend; this strategy has placed HDFS in an exceptionally strong spot regarding both funding and liquidity. Turning to the LiveWire segment, fourth quarter revenue grew from $9 million in Q4 of '22 to $15 million in Q4 of '23, partly because of greater unit sales of Del Mar electric motorcycles. As Karim noted, LiveWire started shipping Del Mar, the inaugural motorcycle on their F2 platform, during Q3, and they are happy with how well the Q4 rollout went, with 482 units shipped. LiveWire's $35 million operating loss in Q4 matched expectations and resulted from planned development costs for advancing EV systems and efforts surrounding Del Mar. For the full year 2023, the $117 million operating loss aligned with guidance, reflecting the business's early stage nature and the electric motorcycle market overall. To close with consolidated Harley-Davidson, Inc. full year financial results, we generated $755 million in operating cash flow, an increase of $207 million over the prior year. Higher operating cash flow came about because of favorable working capital movement at HDMC, which reflected a reduction in inventory during 2023 versus a build-up of inventory during 2022. Cash and cash equivalents on a total basis finished at $1.5 billion, a figure $100 million above where things stood at the close of 2022. Within that consolidated cash total, $168 million came from LiveWire. Across the entirety of 2023, under our capital allocation strategy, we repurchased 10.2 million shares of our stock for $350 million; that exceeded the $324 million bought back during 2022, and taken together those two years add up to close to $675 million of share repurchases over the past two years. That equals 12% of our shares outstanding. On top of that, we've distributed $189 million in dividends across the last two years. Both of these moves together showcase the robust cash flow Harley-Davidson, Inc. produces, along with the dedication we hold toward giving capital back to shareholders. Turning to our financial outlook for 2024, as Jochen covered, we're enthusiastic about our new 2024 motorcycle line-up, yet we acknowledge that the broader macro environment, with elevated interest rates included, makes our customers' choices around buying discretionary products more complicated. Within HDMC, retail units should land flat to up 9%, translating to 163,000 to 178,000 retail units. At present, we feel dealers sit at appropriate inventory levels. Therefore, we anticipate retail units sold and wholesale unit shipments will advance in tandem on a balanced basis during 2024. That range would put wholesale unit shipments down between 1% and 10% against 2023, equivalent to 163,000 to 178,000 wholesale units. That leaves HDMC revenue flat to down 9%. For 2024, we anticipate an HDMC operating income margin between 12.6% and 13.6%. That's flat to down 100 basis points from where 2023 landed. Margin drivers include negative operating leverage stemming from reduced wholesale volumes, foreign currency, which should act as a headwind, mix, which should be slightly favorable, and pricing, which will be slightly down as we removed the surcharge and refine our pricing strategy. Finally, we anticipate some added manufacturing costs as we realign factory processes during the first year of production for the new street glide and road glide motorcycles. Over at HDFS, we anticipate HDFS operating income flat to up 5%. We expect the business to stabilize as it adjusts to the higher interest rate environments that started in 2022, with our borrowing cost easing in light of the anticipated Fed action. We also expect the retail and wholesale portfolios to reach balance and align more closely with the higher rate environment as the retail portfolio resets, thereby generating greater revenue, and we expect consumers to grow comfortable with the existing macro backdrop, and consequently we expect the loss rate will start to moderate in the second half of the year as compared to the second half of 2023. When it comes to LiveWire, the projection is for somewhere between 1,000 and 1,500 units sold, along with an operating loss falling somewhere in the $115 million to $125 million range. That aligns with the guidance we gave for 2023, even while we're delivering somewhere between 50% and 125% additional motorcycles. Then finally, on total HDI, capital investments are anticipated to land in the $225 million to $250 million range; that matches what we forecast for 2023, and we intend to keep putting money behind product development and building up our capabilities. Product innovation at the core continues to drive where we invest, along with manufacturing investments aimed at automating and bringing down costs as part of our productivity journey, plus the planned investment for LiveWire. Driving productivity so we can eliminate the $400 million in incremental supply chain costs that were encouraged in 2020 is one of the initiatives we identified under the Hardwire strategy. Toward that goal, roughly $50 million was delivered by us in 2022; roughly $70 million more was delivered by us in 2023, where our focus included cutting expedited costs along with other actions. Approximately $100 million in incremental cost productivity toward this goal is expected to be delivered by 2024, with attention on production efficiency, optimizing our logistics network, and optimizing supplier costs via consolidation and regionalization.

Jonathan Root

executive
#7

When we think about how we'll allocate capital in 2024, the things we're prioritizing haven't changed: we want to put money behind the profitable expansion of the Hardwire initiative, and that covers the capital expenditures we already talked about, along with paying dividends and keeping up our discretionary share repurchases. As we went over before, during 2022 and 2023 we gave back close to $865 million in capital to shareholders. At this moment in 2024, our plan is to repurchase an amount of common shares in dollars that's comparable to what we bought back in 2023. With that said, let's move on to Q&A.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#8

Morning, everyone. Appreciate you letting me ask something, and Jonathan, I want to thank you for those extra remarks — they really were quite useful. I'd like to ask about how dealers are feeling. Being a dealer right now is not easy. Margins are thin, and floor plan interest rates are sitting high. In certain situations you've managed to make project fuel work, but for dealers dealing with cash flow struggles, that kind of capital outlay is an enormous request. So with the leadership change, I'm curious how you might rethink the way you work with dealers and what other ways you could partner with them?

Jonathan Root

executive
#9

Thanks, Craig. Well, like you said, we must acknowledge that dealers had a difficult year last year. The broad increase in interest rates, which hurt demand, definitely produced far weaker profitability. Looking from 2021 to 2022, our network enjoyed record profitability, which was wonderful, and at minimum it assisted a lot of our dealers in cushioning the downturn we witnessed, yet we clearly factor that in whenever we make any action or decision regarding new product launch, regarding pricing, regarding fuel, and regarding every project we bring into the network. With that said, I'd tell you that dealer sentiment in general has gotten considerably better, and much of that stems from a new product launch and model year launch that has the network and the dealers excited and, as I noted earlier, that has already generated fairly favorable reactions from the media, from influencers, from customers who showed up early to purchase the product; so, we're attempting to strike the proper balance between ensuring facilities get upgraded while acknowledging that a lot of facilities haven't been upgraded in 20 years, at times even 30 years, and there's never an ideal moment for this, yet we definitely factor financial hardships in as much as possible when it concerns the fused facility or upgrade. All told, we've finished 20 facilities up to now. We anticipate roughly 75 will be finished by the close of 2025. We have more than 100 dealerships in process at every stage of completion, from agreement through full build, in North America by itself. So, all told, you could call it solid success, and please keep in mind that this program will run for more than 10 years. So we don't anticipate all of it happening; so certain dealers are prepared and eager to move, and they certainly go first in line. Certain ones may find it harder to do that, and we would factor that in, and it's a 10-year program. So we anticipate dealer profitability ought to be getting better, and on the whole, sentiment has gotten better. I believe the model year launch has definitely assisted, and at this point we're all getting ready and set for the riding season.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#10

Thanks.

Alex Perry

analyst
#11

Hello, and thank you for fielding my question. What I'd like to understand is how we ought to view the mix for '24. Should we expect a greater emphasis on touring and trike shipments during this year, with sportsters making up less? Also, how much longer will the promotional activity, sales challenges, and those headwinds from 4Q keep weighing on motorcycle gross margins? Thanks.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#12

So, with our new model year launch, we've made adjustments to our pricing. Specifically in touring, it matters that carryover products sitting in dealer inventory are positioned at competitive prices relative to our new offerings — that's the reason we took the step Jonathan described in his presentation. Regarding the actions taken so far, we feel good about them, and we simply must acknowledge that within our industry, the consumer environment for discretionary premium product has faced challenges stemming from elevated interest rates, and we've responded with appropriate measures. At this moment, then, we believe pricing is right, though clearly we'll stay flexible enough to make whatever changes the current environment demands. Turning to mix, our priorities — as you're aware, and as we've stressed under the hardwire Stage 2 strategy — involved moving further toward high value products, from cruiser to trike to touring, and the new product, or new model year launch, strikes me as obvious evidence of that. On Sportster, we still had a fair number of Sportsters across the network in 2023. We shipped none at all until the close of 2022 or afterward. So those ought to age themselves out of the network rather fast. Still, we believe that given the pricing on our entry price point products, like the Nightster, and stretching all the way to our new touring models, our prices are competitive and we currently have an exciting product offering in the market. That said, as I mentioned, the season remains young. We'll need to watch how matters develop. We need to ensure the network can work through the 23s as fast as possible, since our goal is lowering inventory within the dealer network — that's why we've stressed this, taken corresponding steps, and will keep doing so should it prove necessary.

Alex Perry

analyst
#13

Thanks for that. It's quite useful. Wishing you success ahead.

Fred Wightman

analyst
#14

Hi, everyone, I simply wanted to ask a bit more about what was said regarding dealer inventory. I get that at this stage of the year, you believe things look pretty solid, but could you discuss the split between current and non-current items, and how you expect that to play out given the bigger touring refresh coming for this model year?

Edel O'Sullivan

executive
#15

Morning, and thanks for raising that. Indeed, as you point out, we feel we've got inventory at roughly the right level across our network, and that holds true even when you factor in part of the earlier release caused by logistics-related issues during Q1, when we were scaling up the big launch of the Street Glide, the Road Glide, and the touring platform more broadly, plus it accounts for certain product arrivals slipping in 2023, something we talked about in an earlier discussion. Just as you mention, we see that inventory as valuable during Q1 for supporting retail. Naturally, while we scale up, some stretch of time passes before dealers are completely filled. So the '23 inventory, which right now makes up most of what sits in the network, gets put to appropriate use supporting retail while we scale up '24, and then, precisely as you also point out, as we progress through the earlier portion of the season and additional '24 units come online, our priority — and the place we've aimed our financial backing, as Jonathan noted — is bringing those '23 levels down and opening up ever more room for '24. We figure the '23s will act as a compelling entry price point too for riders who like certain features of the older technology, so they'll have a part to play down the road, and naturally, on the whole, we're keeping an eye on inventory levels; our thinking is that as '24 unfolds, we'd like to hold things at approximately a one-to-one balance, floor plan costs at our dealerships included. So all told, making sure we maintain that balance and clear through those 2023s as additional 2024s arrive in a category so crucial to us, Grand American Touring.

Fred Wightman

analyst
#16

Great, thanks.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#17

Thank you. Morning, everyone. You brought up a number of puts and takes for HDMC margins during 2024. My guess is the negative operating leverage you anticipate serves as the primary factor behind that. Could you put a figure on how large a margin drag that creates in the current year, and also how much comes from the additional dealer support you foresee this year, which I take it falls under pricing?

Jonathan Root

executive
#18

Absolutely, Joe, appreciate it. So when we look back at what happened during 2023, like we've discussed before, we introduced some initiatives that ended up weighing on our overall margin performance — and we made a point of highlighting that in the script and in the specifics. Roughly $40 million landed in 2023, and that actually works in our favor as we go about clearing retail throughout 2024, so naturally, looking ahead, with certain marketplace moves we've got planned to push retail in 2024, we were careful to align the revenue tied to getting those bikes out into the market with getting them sold in 2024. Another thing worth mentioning is that, if you look — Edel brought this up briefly — but when you examine where things stand on the retail side, Edel also did a nice job covering that, regarding the model year mix and what dealers are holding in inventory right now. So clearly, there are more '23s sitting in the network at this point, and we're bringing '24s in as things progress.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#19

Thanks, Jonathan — that's really useful. Let me build on that point about promotions and discounts. Once you began raising the level of retail spending, what degree of elasticity showed up in retail?

Jonathan Root

executive
#20

Okay, taking a look specifically at Q4, we had a good positive bump in retail during December, and then things got better sequentially as we moved from October into November and then December. I'd say that's partly tied to how many promotions were out there in the market. So when we put those promotions in place, we do see the market respond, and the important thing is going to be getting the right balance between carryover and new products, which we're trying to pull off and get done as fast as we can, already by late January with a launch of a new model year, so that the mix is solid, because not everybody's going to purchase new. Some people will go for used or carryover products. So I think the dealer network is definitely well stocked to handle whatever our customers ask for, and we're hoping to work through those '23 model year carryovers as fast as we can, as we've said, and we've got an aggressive shipping plan for '24s; so it's very early in the year right now, which is, like I said before, the reason our guidance is much wider than it typically would be, and the year got off to a fairly modest start for the industry overall, not only for us, but ever since we shipped our new '24s, we've seen a nice and meaningful improvement, which speaks to the new product and to our customers being excited about what we're offering with a new model year.

James Hardiman

analyst
#21

Morning, and thanks for the question. I want to build on what was said about guidance, and Jonathan, I really appreciate the extra detail regarding wholesale compared with retail. I believe your comment was that for retail in '24, flats rose 9% — could you walk us through what's mainly driving that? I realize that looking at an industry figure often isn't very useful, since you account for such a large share of the industry in particular segments, but I'm just attempting to pull apart, at a high level, how you view the demand environment against the gain from what sounds like a record wave of new products. And then perhaps you could also assist us with a few of the below the line items. Clearly you don't provide guidance on an EPS figure, but tax and share count, perhaps interest expense. My sense is that we ought to arrive at an EPS figure somewhere in the low to mid $4 range, though I'm unsure whether that's exactly right given the way you're looking at the below the line. Thanks.

Jonathan Root

executive
#22

All right, that's helpful. Thank you, James. I'll begin by addressing a few of the items you raised regarding what we observed below the line. It might be useful if either Jochen or Edel offered some brief remarks about how they view retail for 2024. If we begin with below the line, clearly 2023 showed considerable favorability compared with certain pension adjustments and similar items; that is the main factor behind what you're seeing on that front. Clearly, from an EPS standpoint, shareholders gain thanks to the emphasis we place on share buybacks, which we discussed a bit earlier today; so for us this is certainly a fairly significant consideration, I'd say, in how we return value to shareholders. Regarding retail, as you mentioned, the flat to up 9 roughly translates into $163,000 to $178,000. Jochen, James, looking back, you mentioned briefly that this range is wider than the one we typically see, for various reasons. But Jochen, would you like to add anything further on that?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#23

Honestly, there isn't a lot I can tack on beyond what I already laid out previously. The year has only just begun. At this stage, we truly need to move nearer to, and get into, the writing season. Our belief is that this product of ours is an exceptional one. The early response has been terrific, yet the broader climate when it comes to interest rates is definitely a headwind, something we felt quite strongly across all of '23, and we'll simply have to watch how things play out, how everything shakes out, and remember that our retail guidance is worldwide in scope. It isn't guidance solely for the US or for North America. On touring, even though we've managed to move the mix in international markets, profitability included, further toward the categories we focus on for profit, that shift matters most within the North American market. So the US market has to carry a great deal of the weight where retail growth in '24 is concerned, and we simply have to wait and see what can be achieved. The early signals at present, with the launch of our new model year, look favorable, though it is far too soon to offer anything more specific in the way of guidance beyond what we've already stated.

James Hardiman

analyst
#24

Thanks, that's quite useful. Jonathan, could I quickly slip in one point of clarification—can we somehow frame how the tax rate and the share count might look for 2024? Clearly those might move things around, and I simply want to confirm that everyone shares the same understanding.

Jonathan Root

executive
#25

Yeah, no, that's a really good question, and when we consider share count, clearly, we've discussed how we're dedicated to examining share buybacks, just like what we reviewed during 2023. So clearly, that pace is going to decrease as time goes on. So when it comes to buying back shares, we would likely make purchases across the quarters. Clearly not as a single large chunk at once, but I believe what's worth keeping in mind is watching how the share price moves, watching the dollar target we've established, and then simply considering how that will play out over the course of the year.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#26

James, I've tasked Jonathan and the finance team with the goal of providing EPS guidance starting next year. So put it on your calendar, and with any luck, we'll be able to make that happen.

James Hardiman

analyst
#27

Can't wait for that. Appreciate it, everyone.

Tristan Thomas-Martin

analyst
#28

Morning. I was hoping to hear your perspective on the pricing for the mild year '24 touring lineup. Take the '24 street glide, for instance — it costs more than a base street glide from '23. Yet in my view, its features line up much more closely with something like a street glide special, and there the '23 carries a higher price than the '24. So I was curious for your take on these shifts, the consolidation of models — is this simply a broader approach to tackling affordability, rather than outright cutting MSRPs or leaning too hard on promotions?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#29

Well, our aim was ensuring our new products stay competitive, and we're confident we've done that, judging by the early response from the market. As you correctly pointed out, we brought a number of key features and benefits that used to live in our ST and special models down into our mid-levels, and we raised pricing above the base level of our base models to account for that content, which is now standard equipment. On top of that, we provide plenty of P&A packages, letting our customer essentially reach a product sitting at the ST and special pricing level and features level. That's the goal we pursued by cutting the overall complexity of our touring setup at this point. So with our new pricing, I'd say we're getting the best of all worlds. It's competitive, yet it remains 24,999, and while that's above our base models, it sits below our STs and special. And once more, consider the pricing actions taken in the fourth quarter and on our carryover products, which had to account for the new pricing on our new models. So for STs and special, we had to provide support — and still must keep providing dealer support — to price them appropriately so they move out and sell, and I'd call that essentially the key decision we've made. So far it's proven very successful, and from the comments you'll find in online forums, people grasp that many more key features and benefits, which previously belonged to our STs and special, are now already built into our mid-levels.

Noah Zatzkin

analyst
#30

Hello, and thank you for allowing me to ask. I'd like to focus on LiveWire, if I may. As you look ahead across the coming years, what's your thinking regarding the trajectory for units and profitability? Also, has your medium-term outlook on this business and its opportunity shifted at all? Thanks.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#31

Thanks, Noah. I'd say that at this moment, when it comes to LiveWire, product innovation and cost improvement are truly where our attention sits. Reaching profitability as quickly as we can is what we want. That puts us in a solid position to seize the opportunity as the market evolves. So for now, our attention stays on the long-term vision of leading a two-wheel EV industry, again powered by innovation and performance in the near term, along with a robust internal plan to get to profitability as soon as possible.

David MacGregor

analyst
#32

Hello there, and good morning. I appreciate your time in taking my questions. I suppose I was hoping to build on what was said regarding LiveWire. Karim, might you expand somewhat further on the sort of experience during this quarter, along with how consumers responded to the ST Del Mar? During '23, 660 bikes went out. Might you discuss the retail sales picture and the way those may have increased over the course of the year, and you mention 126 dealers for this year. By 2024, what figure do you anticipate that reaching? Thank you.

Karim Donnez

executive
#33

Okay, thank you for that, and for the follow-up as well. So, where we stand right now, we're feeling fairly confident about the shipments we'll make in Q4, since the orders we've booked exceed what we've already shipped. That leaves us optimistic about retail and about conversion over the near term. At the same time, we're putting in serious effort to build out a retail engine and to back our dealers, and that's exactly why you saw us get to 126 retailers worldwide. Clearly, given how many bikes are involved, hitting success at retail is a very reachable goal for retailers; so what we're aiming for is, essentially, in 2024, to bring retail in line with wholesale. The team is therefore working diligently to keep retail momentum going and to support wholesale.

David MacGregor

analyst
#34

Appreciate it. Best of luck with that.

Jaime Katz

analyst
#35

Hello, good morning. My question centers on market share, which in fact went up from one quarter to the next, but I'd like to know where you're aiming to structurally push that over time? Or could it be that this 40% level represents the new normal, considering how consumer demand has moved toward other kinds of bikes? Could you help us think through the longer term on that? Thank you.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#36

Thank you, Jamie. Our concentration in this portion of the strategy has been quite evident, moving the mix toward what we focus on most, our core categories, correct? That means the tri cruiser touring, and that transition has shown itself to be highly effective. As we said before, our average unit profitability has risen from 1300 to $3,700. So, not being fixated on unit sales across the past several years benefited us regarding overall profitability, which went from 6.3% up to 13.6%; so remarkable improvement; that being said, clearly, we intend to expand our business, and we think that with our new model year '24, that chance exists for us, we have the proper foundation, yet we also require a more favorable economic climate, and by economic climate, I mean our industry plus elevated interest rates, which pose a difficult obstacle for a great many of our core customers. So I don't wish to dodge giving you an answer, however, our emphasis is on growth and profitable growth, and that is how we'll finish our hardwired stage two strategy by the close of '25. Whatever follows that, we'll take up when the time is right. We do examine market shares, yet we aren't fixated on market shares. I never have been and never will be, though naturally, it's gratifying to observe that amid this difficult climate, particularly during the fourth quarter, we managed to lift our touring share back to 75%, large cruiser 80%. That's dominant. Plus or minus 5%. That's the fluctuation you'll always witness across the year, likewise on a rolling 12 months forward, or backward, and I believe that's probably where we'll remain, yet we think there's a chance to capture market share, particularly in touring, and via our trike offering, since we have competitive and excellent product, and that ought to produce positive movement, definitely next year, should all our plans materialize, and ideally that continues into later years too, at minimum through the conclusion of our hardware stage two, which lands at the end of '25. The touring platform, as I noted, has been under development since 2020, and it's the initial refresh, and actually, it isn't a refresh, it's a total rebuild from the ground up in every way, and I believe the favorable responses provide us that chance, though it's somewhat early to say how enduring that will prove, but we feel quite good about it.

Brandon Rollé

analyst
#37

Thanks for fitting my question in. I just wanted to ask about your margin guidance — I believe you mentioned that extra manufacturing costs would act as a headwind to this year's guidance. Could you quantify how big that headwind is from those added manufacturing costs, and then share any further detail on the feedback you're getting for the model year '24 line-up? Thank you.

Jonathan Root

executive
#38

Thanks, Brandon. Let's begin with what you asked about — let's begin with what we're observing on the manufacturing side and some of the noise in there. So clearly, we've set a $400 million price target from a productivity standpoint. We described what we've witnessed across the past couple of years and where we expect 2024 to end up. So, roughly $100 million of positivity arriving in 2024 to help counter what we're seeing on the inflationary side. As you examine that movement over time, we clearly feel quite good about it. When you discuss some of the headwind we're facing, if we consider what that means for margins, clearly, based on where we land on an overall volume basis with our rather wide range, we want to ensure we're looking at shifting our retail and wholesale together. We clearly have plenty we must watch regarding structural cost, and as you consider a leverage or de-leverage effect, so I think from that angle, certainly some noise as we attempt to work through what that might mean for an overall leverage or de-leverage effect. And then when we think about manufacturing optimization, supply chain efficiency, as Jochen mentioned, this is a transformative launch given the significance of what we have with Street Glide and Road Glide that are now reaching our dealers. Clearly, when you have a very, very major change happening all the way from your suppliers through to what we ultimately move into our dealership, there's a lot of — there's a lot of just a lot of change and a lot of variability that can happen with that. We feel it's been a fairly smooth launch so far, but we certainly always want to ensure we're living in a world where we're not over promising to anyone, and I think beyond that, Jochen and Edel, do you have questions on or I'm sorry, you have some comments relative to the '25 model year reception.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#39

'24, I'm ahead of your schedule. '24. Look, there isn't a great deal more for me to say. Perhaps on the whole, I'd describe the response to our pricing approach as really positive, both for the carryover product and the new product. The choices we made in the fourth quarter, I believe, will benefit us in '24, and I think there's been a uniformly positive reaction to our new street guide road, with plenty of enthusiasm for our new CVO ST. We began the trend with performance and seized on a trend we noticed years back emerging, particularly on the West Coast, though in other regions of America too, and as I said during my speech, we've worked hard to advance that through our King of the Beggars race series and our race bike. So really delivering a performance dimension in our product is now demonstrated by our CVO Road Glide ST. A fantastic product, priced very well, and lots of excitement. I've been riding alongside a large group of influencers in Las Vegas, and there was simply a great deal of enthusiasm surrounding our new touring bikes. I don't want to overlook our first CVO ever beyond the touring category, our adventure touring bike, which also stands as evidence of our development and ongoing focus on growing the adventure touring market. So on the whole, we feel good about it, and likewise the pricing on our entry product, Nightster, which we've adjusted appropriately — a great product, particularly for new riders and as an entry bike; so we ought to see some positive movement there across the year overall, but as I mentioned, it's early days; we don't want to get too excited here. '23 was a difficult year and interest rates haven't moved, and the outlook certainly doesn't point to that happening during the prime riding season. So we'll need to balance our enthusiasm for the new product against the market's realities.

Brandon Rollé

analyst
#40

Thanks. And if I might ask a second question regarding what it costs to manufacture, could you separate what was spent initially to get the new touring production line going, as opposed to the extra manufacturing expenses incurred over the course of the year?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#41

What I believe we are able to state is that it represents the biggest amount Harley-Davidson has ever put into one single platform.

Jonathan Root

executive
#42

Right. And Brandon, I believe the positive thing here is that you're going to be hearing additional details from us as 2024 progresses, when we discuss our numbers and perform what has become our usual year-over-year comparison. So following our typical approach, we'll ensure we keep offering the breakdowns we're observing when it comes to revenue. Naturally, we'll go through the P&L and explain it, so what we can commit to is that across 2024, we definitely will be addressing this. And, as you'd expect, 2024 has a bit of noise in it when you examine certain items on a quarter-over-quarter basis and consider some of the shifts we anticipate seeing regarding, for instance, shipping units into the dealer network, and as you're aware, Jochen mentioned during his prepared remarks and I mentioned during mine, clearly achieving that alignment between retail and wholesale is something we consider extremely important. But yes, we'll be eager to discuss that with you over the course of this year.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#43

Yes. Well, once more, thanks to all of you for being with us today. Before we wrap up, I simply wanted to grab this chance to express our appreciation to Edel O’Sullivan for everything she has given to the company across the last three years, and to wish her the very best in whatever comes next. So thank you so much, Edel, and thank you everyone for spending time with us this morning.

Operator

operator
#44

Thanks, and everyone, that brings us to the end of today's call. We appreciate you being with us. At this point, you're free to hang up. Have a wonderful day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Harley-Davidson, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Harley-Davidson, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Harley-Davidson, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.