Harley-Davidson, Inc. (HOG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 25, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Shawn Collins
executiveGood morning, and thanks for joining. I'm Shawn Collins, Director of Investor Relations here at Harley-Davidson. The slides that go along with today's call can be found online on the Harley-Davidson Investor Relations website. As is typical, we'll be making forward-looking statements, and those carry risks that might lead to actual results differing materially. Among those risks are matters we've flagged in today's earnings release as well as in our most recent SEC filings. On the call with me this morning are Harley-Davidson's Chief Executive Officer, Jochen Zeitz, and our Chief Financial Officer, Jonathan Root, plus LiveWire's Chief Executive Officer, Karim Donnez. So with that, I'll hand things over to Jochen Zeitz, our CEO. Jochen?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThanks, Sean, and hello everybody. We appreciate you being here for the Q1 2024 results call. Harley-Davidson achieved a solid beginning to the year, matching what we had anticipated. Turning to retail during the quarter, we feel good about posting 6% growth across North America, which is our biggest and most significant market. During Q1, the effects of elevated interest rates continued to be felt regarding consumer confidence as well as affordability. Still, it's encouraging that customers remain enthusiastic about motorcycles even with these difficult conditions. Beyond North America, the Europe and APAC regions both came in soft, largely because of macroeconomic situations in those areas; still, it's important to mention that our '24 product didn't begin reaching international regions until March and is only now arriving in the majority of international markets. And with the riding season beginning to ramp up, we're thrilled for our riders and fans, whether in North America or elsewhere, to encounter the next era of Harley-Davidson touring motorcycles. As always, I'll now touch briefly on certain Hardwire strategic pillars and how we're delivering on them, beginning with Pillar 1, profit focus. When our hardware strategy was announced back in 2021, we committed ourselves to putting money into our core categories. Building on that promise this year, we introduced a new era of motorcycle touring by reimagining two of the most iconic motorcycles ever made, the Harley-Davidson Street and Road Glide, through the most extensive product redevelopment seen in well over 10 years. On the whole, we're quite happy with our new model year launch and especially our new touring lineup, which customers, dealers and media alike are responding to very favorably. One outlet captured the launch especially well. The motor company stunned the motorcycling world by releasing revamped versions of the Road Glide and Street Glide that were entirely different from their predecessors, a more modernized approach that rendered them superior to the previous generation in virtually every respect. With the completely redesigned Street Glide and Road Glide, we've set a new standard for this industry and for what the future of two-wheel touring and adventure looks like. These bikes deliver outstanding performance, industry-leading innovation, and a striking new design, and they represent the largest single-platform investment in the motor company's history. By improving every element of performance, technology, comfort, and style, we're confident we've built the most compelling touring motorcycles Harley-Davidson has ever brought to market. The response across our dealer network continues to be very positive, and as the riding season begins, we can't wait for our riders to get full access to the lineup. Part of our '24 launch and created to mark 25 years of custom vehicle operations, our CVO lineup grew with the addition of the all-new CVO Road Glide ST, representing the pinnacle of Becker Performance, along with the CVO Pan America fully kitted out for extraordinary adventures. The CVO Road Glide ST represents the lightest, quickest, and most advanced performance bagger Harley-Davidson has ever built. Drawing on our well-liked low ride AST offering, this CVO Road Glide ST blends West Coast custom styling with the performance direction we've sensed alongside the King of the Bagger Racing series. As one other outlet put it, the CVO ST ranks as the finest motorcycle Harley-Davidson has ever released. In 2024, we made price changes to the CVO Street and Road Glide models, which had their first showing at Homecoming a year ago and are now available in striking new colors. We've also introduced the CVO Pan America, the first adventure touring bike in the CVO lineup. All the qualities that have positioned the Pan America 1250 as a top choice for knowledgeable adventure touring enthusiasts worldwide remain intact, and the CVO Pan America comes equipped with an added collection of tough accessories designed to enhance the ride. Additionally, through Hardwire, we pledged to bring out a range of motorcycles that align with our approach of increasing appeal and continuing the Harley-Davidson heritage. So keeping that in mind, back in February, over at Daytona Bike Week, we showed off the latest models joining our limited edition Harley-Davidson icons line as well as the limited run enthusiast collection. Looking at the '24 icons models, we rolled out the Hydra-Glide Revival this year, which celebrates 75 years of that iconic motorcycle. For the design, we pulled inspiration from how the motorcycles look in the world of the upcoming movie, The Bikeriders, a film that follows a Midwestern Motorcycle Club's rise, told through the eyes of its members. It's headed to screens near you — the movie comes out in the United States on June 21 this summer. When it came to our 2024 enthusiast lineup, we honored both music and motorcycles by launching the Tobacco Fade Enthusiast collection, which comes in three models: the Low Rider ST, the Ultra Limited, and the Tri Glide Ultra. Customer reaction to these bikes has again been strongly favorable, arriving right as the riding season kicks into high gear. Turning to Pillar 3, leading in electric: LiveWire continued pushing the EV category forward by introducing the S2 Mulholland, a brand-new electric cruiser and the second model built on the S2 platform. The industry has responded very warmly to this bike, and Karim will share more details shortly. Another thing we're happy to share: during the most recent quarter, LiveWire moved into the top spot among U.S. makers of electric motorcycles built for the road. As the business sharpens its attention on what vehicles cost and what operations cost, it will bring its operations together in Milwaukee, at Harley-Davidson's historic headquarters on Juno Avenue. Now for Pillar 4, which is about growing past motorcycles: in February, working through HDFS, we introduced Harley-Davidson Flex Financing. This marks the first time ever that our company offers this kind of loan, giving riders another path to buy a Harley-Davidson motorcycle, since it blends appealing monthly payments, shorter terms, and more flexibility across the life of the loan. Customers can hand the motorcycle back once the term wraps up, all set to swap it for something new or move up to their next Harley-Davidson buy. Keeping customers front and center in everything we make and every experience we deliver is our pledge, and that's precisely what HD Flex accomplishes, giving them one more creative way to finance ownership so a Harley-Davidson motorcycle matches each person's own budget and way of living. Pillar 5, customer experience. Only slightly fewer than 100 days remain, and our second yearly homecoming gathering happens July 25 to 28. Last week, we revealed the complete lineup of performers, with top-billed acts such as the Red Hot Chili Peppers, Jelly Roll and Hardy. Tickets went on sale already, and we can't wait to join our community of fans, riders and their families in honoring our blend of motoculture and music. Hopefully plenty of you will be there too. Finally, Pillar 6, inclusive stakeholder management: on June 24, we anticipate officially revealing the new community park at our Juno Avenue headquarters. That undertaking, spearheaded by the Harley-Davidson Foundation, aims to link the company, our brand and our workforce more tightly with the surrounding community, underscoring our dedication to Milwaukee, our home town.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveWe're thrilled to give you a look at our neighborhood on the near West side. Before passing things to Karim for Lightwire, I want to walk through what we see for the remainder of the year. As we mentioned earlier in the year, for HDMC we're expecting retail units to be flat to up 9%. Looking at inventory, we think it's positioned appropriately as the riding season starts to ramp, and we still expect wholesale unit shipments to track dealer retail sales on a balanced basis by the end of '24; that range would mean wholesale unit shipments declining between 1% and 10% versus prior year. This will result in HDMC revenue coming in flat to down 9%. We expect HDMC operating income margin of 12.6% to 13.6%. That's flat to down 100 basis points from the '23 level. Let me go through the specific drivers once more: negative operating leverage from lower wholesale volumes. Foreign currency, which we see as a headwind. Mix, which we expect to be slightly favorable. Pricing, which we expect to be slightly down as we removed the surcharge and refined our pricing approach. And finally, we anticipate some additional manufacturing costs as we realign factory processes in the first year of production for the new Street Glide and Road Glide motorcycles. At HDFS, we expect operating income led to up 5%, reflecting retail and wholesale portfolios along with customers settling into the current macroeconomic backdrop. As you'll hear from Karim now, for the full year, LiveWire is revising its operating loss guidance and now expects an improved operating loss of $105 million to $115 million, compared to previous guidance of an operating loss of $115 million to $125 million. Finally, I want to reinforce our commitment to returning excess free cash flow to our shareholders. We intend to keep optimizing our returns through share repurchases and suitable dividend payments. You can see our commitment to capital returns since 2022 on Page 15. Since the start of '22 and through Q1 '24, we've repurchased $773 million in shares and paid out $214 million in dividends. That works out to nearly $1 billion in capital returned to shareholders since '22 and a share buyback amounting to 14% of our outstanding shares; we're planning to stay on a similar trajectory to this annualized rate throughout '24. Thank you. And now I'll pass it over to Karim.
Karim Donnez
executiveAppreciate that, Jochen. Morning, everybody. We're glad to share news of a strong launch for the S2 Mulholland across both the U.S. and Canada. Following the S2 Del Mar, this marks the second model cycle to be built on the S2 platform that LiveWire developed. That expands our lineup, giving LiveWire riders more choices. Market reaction has been favorable, with riders, retailers, and media all responding well to the Mulholland's timing and to the ability to pick the bike with a lower riding position. During the first quarter, LiveWire posted 117 units sold, which is an 86% gain versus the first quarter of 2023. Retail sales ran ahead of wholesale as the Del Mar moved into the channel, which made LiveWire, as Jochen noted, the #1 onboard electric motorcycles in the U.S; over in Europe, we started shipping the S2 Del Mar to our 4 priority countries as the quarter closed, and products are now offered throughout our network in that region; we have comparable plans for <<inaudible>>, with the first bike headed to Europe right now. Even as we intend to grow our market leadership, our teams are pursuing design engineering and sourcing efforts aimed at bringing product costs down. We also intend to cut spend and keep tight control of cash throughout the operations so our strategic investments deliver as much as possible. Toward that end, all of our operations will be centralized at Juno Avenue in Milwaukee, which includes moving LiveWire lab operations out of California, to enable energy and efficiency; we'll use this moment to streamline and take another look at the organization structure so we achieve simplicity in everything we do. Although we're holding the outlook for the revenue units, we now anticipate a $10 million improvement in operating while still directing the bigger share of expenses toward product innovation and market development. LiveWire is entirely dedicated to electrifying the sport through building the best product and providing a customer experience without equal. Thanks; and with that, I'll turn things over to Jonathan.
Jonathan Root
executiveThank you, Karim, and good morning everyone. I'll begin on Page 5 of the deck, where I'll give a quick summary of the consolidated financial results for Q1 2024, and after that, I'll walk through each business segment in more detail. First quarter consolidated revenue fell 3%, with HDMC revenue declining 5% and HDFS revenue rising 12% partly making up for that. Consolidated operating income for Q1 came in as we expected, dropping 29%, with a 29% decrease at HDMC, an 8% decrease at HDFS, and a $29 million operating loss in the LiveWire segment. The consolidated operating income margin for Q1 was 15.2%, which is a 545 basis point drop compared to Q1 of 2024. The lower consolidated margin mostly reflects a lower Q1 margin at HDMC, caused by reduced volumes, pricing, and related throughput. I'll cover the profit and loss drivers for each business segment in more depth in the next section. Earnings per share for the first quarter was $1.72. During Q1, worldwide retail sales of new motorcycles were flat year over year. In North America, Q1 retail sales rose 6%, mainly on the strength of the redesigned and all new Street Glide and Road Glide touring motorcycles, launched at the end of January. In EMEA, Q1 retail sales fell 11% because of softness in Germany and France. Broadly, EMEA remains negatively affected by macroeconomic conditions and geopolitical uncertainty, resulting in sluggish economic growth. In Asia Pacific, Q1 retail sales dropped 12%, driven mainly by weakness in China. That marks the third consecutive quarter of declines in the region, following 6 straight quarters of solid year-over-year growth in Asia Pacific; in Latin America, Q1 retail sales saw modest growth in both Mexico and Brazil. Dealer inventory at the close of Q1 was up roughly 26% versus the close of Q1 in 2023; we consider current dealer inventory and product availability to be in healthy positions overall as we head into the spring 2024 riding season. That matters given the recent launch of new model year 2024 motorcycles, particularly with the positive reception to our new Street Glide and Road Glide touring models. Turning to revenue, HDMC revenue declined 5% in Q1. Looking at the key drivers for the quarter, 7 points of decline came from lower wholesale volume at HDMC, largely because dealers were rebuilding dealer inventory in Q1 2023 after the lows they saw following the pandemic. Motorcycle shipments in the quarter, though below the prior year, were slightly ahead of 2021 and 2022 levels. 3 points of decline came from pricing, which includes the effects of the pricing surcharge elimination, other pricing actions on 2024 model year, and sales incentives. Mix added 4 points of growth as we continue to prioritize our most profitable models and markets. And last, FX came in even with the first quarter of the previous year. HDMC's gross margin for Q1 stood at 31.2%, versus 35.8% a year earlier. That 450 basis point drop came from reduced operating leverage along with the revenue items I mentioned earlier, plus ongoing modest cost inflation running between 1% and 2%. Most units delivered during the first quarters of 2024 and 2023 had been built in the fourth quarters just before those years, ahead of the new model year rollout. Output fell 24% during 2023's fourth quarter relative to 2022's fourth quarter, producing a greater fixed cost per motorcycle unit delivered in Q1 2024 versus Q1 2023. Other productivity gains, mainly tied to logistics during the quarter, helped counter the negative effect of reduced operating leverage. HDMC's operating margin reached 16.2%, exceeding our full year projections and matching quarterly expectations. Over at Harley-Davidson Financial Services, first quarter revenue rose $26 million, or 12%, fueled by greater retail and commercial finance receivables plus increased average yields as the portfolio gradually reprices from elevated base rates, pushing interest income upward. HDFS posted $54 million in operating income, a drop of $5 million, or 8%, from the year before. Higher borrowing costs, a bigger provision for credit losses, and greater operating expenses caused that Q1 decrease. Greater interest income partly countered these rising costs. Interest expense overall climbed $15 million, or 21%, year over year. That rise stemmed from a greater cost of funds as cheaper-rate debt reached maturity and got refinanced at prevailing market rates. During Q1, HDFS' annualized retail credit loss ratio hit 3.7%, compared with 3.2% on the same annualized basis in Q1 2023. Several elements tied to today's macroeconomic backdrop and associated customer and industry trends drove the credit loss increase. Additionally, the retail allowance for credit losses stayed even at 5.4% in the first quarter, same as Q4 2023. Retail loan originations overall grew 2% in Q1, while commercial financing activity climbed 22%, reaching $1.5 billion. Net financing receivables at quarter end totaled $7.9 billion across both retail loans and commercial financing, marking a 4% gain over the previous year. Turning to the LiveWire segment, electric motorcycle revenue declined in 2024's first quarter relative to the same period last year, even though unit sales rose during the quarter. That revenue shortfall stemmed mainly from product mix and the one-time adjustment tied to a shift in their retail partner strategy. Selling, engineering, and administrative costs stayed roughly even with the year-ago period. As anticipated, basic revenue dropped versus Q1 2023, largely because third-party brand and distributor volumes declined. The operating loss at LiveWire came to $29 million, matching what we had anticipated, since LiveWire kept putting money into new motorcycle models along with action initiatives aimed at bringing EV costs down. SG&A also held steady compared with the same period a year ago. To finish up with the consolidated Harley-Davidson, Inc. full year financial results, operating cash flow for Q1 reached $104 million, an improvement over the $47 million we saw in the prior period. That rise in operating cash flow stemmed mainly from reduced net cash outflows tied to wholesale financing plus favorable working capital movements relative to Q1 of 2023. We closed with total cash and cash equivalents of $1.5 billion, a figure $97 million below where it stood at the close of Q1 the year before. Within that consolidated cash total, $141 million sits at LiveWire. Also, consistent with our capital allocation strategy and our pledge to give capital back to shareholders, during Q1 of 2024 we repurchased 2.5 million shares, worth $98 million. Turning to the remainder of 2024, we continue to feel enthusiastic about our new 2024 motorcycle lineup, and, as Jochen mentioned, we are reaffirming our full year guidance, apart from the improvement we flagged in the LiveWire operating loss. I want to attach some unit figures to the 2024 outlook Jochen referenced a moment ago, and these match what we communicated on our previous earnings call, held in February. Over at HDMC, our expectation is that retail units sold and wholesale unit shipments will track one another on a balanced basis throughout 2024. We're looking at 163,000 to 178,000 retail and wholesale units, producing HDMC revenue that lands flat to down 9% against the prior year. Finally, let me address a few more items regarding capital investments and capital allocation. Our expectation for total HDI capital investments remains $225 million to $250 million. When we consider capital allocation for 2024, our priorities stay the same: funding profitable growth of the hardwire initiatives, which takes in the capital expenditures I just mentioned, paying dividends, and carrying on with discretionary share repurchases. With that, let's open things up to Q&A.
Craig Kennison
analystCould you talk a bit about how healthy the dealer network is? Across our powersports and marine coverage, we've noticed dealers dealing with excess inventory, thin margins, and then rates working against them too, which is a problem on the floor plan side. There's nothing particularly Harley-Davidson-specific here, but there's plenty of macro pressure. I'm just curious how you're feeling about the dealer network's health and whether Luke Mansfield, your new Chief Commercial Officer, is telling you anything different.
Jonathan Root
executiveCraig, this is Jonathan. Thanks for asking. I'll kick things off. So when it comes to dealers, I'd say if we look at dealers right now, from a Harley-Davidson standpoint, there's definitely enthusiasm about what's available. And I think there's an acknowledgment that customers are coming in, checking out our new Street Glide and Road Glide motorcycles, and then clearly the other 24 model years as well. So looking at how the year has begun, I think we feel pretty good about how that's shaping up. And I'd say dealer sentiment broadly aligns with that. The one worry that's probably worth being candid about is that when interest rates have risen somewhat, that definitely affects dealers and their health. So on our end, we devote a great deal of focus to the situation our dealers are in and the well-being of the whole network. We believe that's something crucial to keep a close eye on. And so from where they sit, there's some concern about what they're seeing on the floor plan side. As for us, as you heard Jochen mention during some of his opening remarks. We're keeping an eye on that equilibrium between what we're sending into the channel and retail throughout 2024. So we're backing them by keeping an eye on that. As you're aware, we also offer some targeted interest rate subvention for customers, on customer-facing programs only, for 2023 model year product. Right now, that clearly helps generate dealer traffic, helps draw in the customers who are more sensitive to rates, and genuinely helps them work through their inventory. And then clearly, as a company, we ensure we have some dealer-facing programs in place that truly support and strengthen their overall health. And so from that angle, I think it's something we remain tuned in to, something we definitely ensure we're examining, and something that — I think we have to make sure that, as an industry, we're responsive to as we go through 2024.
Craig Kennison
analystAs a fast follow-up, are there any stats you could provide regarding how new or present-year stock compares with earlier quarters.
Jonathan Root
executiveAbsolutely. When we examine the blend we hold from a unit standpoint, it genuinely appears somewhat distinct depending on where you look worldwide. So I think there are varying responses when you compare North America with EMEA, Asia Pacific, and Latin America. Naturally, when we launch the new model year, it reaches our North American dealers ahead of when it starts affecting international dealers. So, taking North America as an example, roughly 35% of dealer inventory consisted of 2023 model year or noncurrent model year bikes. As you travel worldwide, it appears somewhat distinct. From an EMEA viewpoint, we bring the 2024s to market later because of shipping times, homologation, and so on. So from an EMEA standpoint, it would appear closer to 70% — the same applies to Asia Pacific and Latin America; so at the close of Q1, they are likely nearer to 70%, 75% that are 2023 or earlier. So naturally, there's a cadence that moves across the globe. But likely, if you're speaking with North American dealers, there is probably a bit more discussion there, you would find that it's around 1/3 that are '23 and older.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveSure, Craig — Jochen here, with a bit more detail. We anticipate that model year '23 will be largely cleared out by the time the second quarter wraps up. In the U.S., the pace at which the '23s are being sold down matches our plan, and, as Jonathan mentioned, with fresh product arriving, the '23s are drawing down well. So once we reach the close of Q2, we ought to be very nearly — I wouldn't say fully out, since a dealer will always have 1 or 2 remaining, but a meaningful share of the '23s will be gone, judging by what we're seeing right now. And when you consider how we anticipate wholesale and retail to perform, clearly in Q1, as we prepared for riding season, we sent out more motorcycles than we sold at retail ahead of that riding season. For Q2, you should anticipate a closer balance between retail and wholesale. Then, during the second half, we'd anticipate retail surpassing wholesale. So that's a bit of detail on how we see the year playing out.
Joe Altobello
analystI just wanted to build on what Craig asked. It's less about inventory and more about retail. When I look at North America, that 6% retail growth in the first quarter — can you help us understand how it split between the model year '23s and the new model year '24s?
Jonathan Root
executiveSure. Thanks, Joe. That's a good question. Clearly, when you look across the first quarter and consider how model year affected the trajectory and path of sales. When the quarter began in January, we were mostly at 2023, because we didn't have the 2024s out until we were partway into Q1. So in January, it was probably around 75%, 80% that were '23 or earlier. Then as we progressed through the quarter, that percentage shifted so that by March, the majority were obviously 2024 related. There's also a slight difference when you look at some of those dynamics by family; so within touring, for instance, there was a somewhat higher percentage of customer interest in North America focused on the all-new Street Glide and Road Glide motorcycles. Based on the commentary we just discussed, if you look outside the U.S., it was certainly a significantly smaller percentage of '24s; and then, as you'd expect, we see that rising meaningfully as we get into Q2 and beyond.
Joe Altobello
analystThat's quite useful. As a quick follow-up, could you help us understand how things moved along during the quarter, perhaps including April? From a weather standpoint, January was clearly a difficult month, and the model year 24s still hadn't arrived. So what are you observing now that conditions are warming up? And to make sure I have this right, did flat Global Retail in Q1 match your expectations when you entered the period?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThis is Jochen. Right — as Jonathan and I said before, our international '24 model year only begins reaching markets in March, and in certain regions, certain margins — some markets didn't even receive the '24s until March was nearly over. So when you consider the U.S. market, or North America, during January, across the first 3 weeks there was very little, or in fact no, new product available. On the whole, the quarter got off to a weak start, something we'd already pointed out on our February call, and once the new product began entering the market, we witnessed a substantial uptick that carried on all the way through March. We now anticipate seeing a favorable effect from the new model year as it reaches the international market, though we recognize that the touring segment, important as it is, doesn't carry the same weight for total sales that it does in the United States, where it's the leading category. As for April, it's early yet, but taking everything into account, I'd describe it as so far so good; and definitely much improved versus what we saw at the start of the first quarter. So overall we feel positive about the quarter, and our unchanged guidance reflects that as well.
Fred Wightman
analystI'd like to pose one more question regarding how '23 and '24 differ. From what I understand, your past aim has been roughly 2% either way when it comes to MSRP realization. For '24, is what you're currently observing broadly consistent with that?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveYes, that's right.
Fred Wightman
analystAll right, and I'm aware that a reserve for dealer support was set up by you folks at the close of last year. My recollection is $40 million. Do you still consider that amount adequate to get through the remaining '23s?
Jonathan Root
executiveYes. Fred, it's Jonathan here. That's a good question. When we examine the financials in relation to the support needed to move those units at retail, clearly, most of the dollars were reserved during Q4. In certain select segments, we made the offer somewhat more appealing on a rate basis. Because of that, we recorded a dollar amount impacting our Q1 financials of roughly $18 million in Q1, and that shows up when you look at the price walks we published; but on the whole, we believe most of the dollars have clearly been reserved. Then, as discussed in the earlier question, as that inventory sells through and declines, from our standpoint, the exposure obviously shrinks as the units shrink.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThe effect you ought to see during Q1, and unit volumes are declining at this point, so that figure has come down, and most of it was already set aside in the budget ahead of time.
Alex Perry
analystI suppose this might be a follow-up to what was just asked, but could you discuss how HDMC gross margins came in relative to what you had anticipated once you factor in everything. And I guess as the year progresses, should we expect to begin seeing HDMC gross margins expand on a year-over-year basis? Or how much pressure should we anticipate from pricing and incentives.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveYes. I'll have Jonathan take that and explain the specifics. But on the whole, the first quarter came in as we had anticipated and we kept our margin guidance unchanged. So we believe the coming quarters will also unfold as expected, with gross profit margin improving as we go. So on the whole, we — nothing caught us off guard in the first quarter in terms of how gross margin came in, and we believe we can hit the targets we've established for guidance. Jonathan?
Jonathan Root
executiveAll right. Thank you, Jochen. Alex, I'll try to give you a bit more detail on what you asked about. In the first quarter, gross margin landed at 31.2%, versus 35.8% a year earlier. So clearly, when you look at it, that's a drop of roughly 450 basis points, and it came from reduced operating leverage along with the revenue items we cover on Page 7 of the deck. We've got additional materials on that. Clearly — when we consider gross margin going ahead, we do expect moderate cost inflation, somewhere near 2%; so roughly in line with what we saw a year ago, perhaps slightly higher from an inflation perspective, and definitely considerably lower than 2022. Stay with me as I unpack some of this, but most of the units we ship during first quarters; so consider 2024 and 2023, those got built during the fourth quarters just before, ahead of the launch of the new model year. To frame this properly, production volumes during the fourth quarter of '23 fell roughly 24% versus the fourth quarter of 2022, and that produces a greater fixed cost per unit on motorcycles that ultimately get shipped in those respective quarters; that negative effect from reduced operating leverage gets offset by productivity savings in the most recent quarter, which were mainly tied to logistics. There was also a bit of mix noise this quarter across motorcycle, P&A and A&L. And so the makeup, or complexion, among motorcycle P&A and A&L introduces some peculiarity when we examine the dollars, so favorable dollars alongside an unfavorable percent, which really captures the extra dollars from motorcycle mix alongside a declining mix from A&L and P&A, which normally carry favorable margins. So, good question. I'd say it's a peculiar situation in terms of where we stand. And then, as Jochen mentioned, when we carry that gross margin guidance through to, say, OI margin and what we expect there; we arrived at 16.2%, above our full year expectations and, as Jochen mentioned, consistent with expectations for the quarter. So hopefully that's a bit more color than you were after, but hopefully it clarifies where we are.
James Hardiman
analystI'd like to explore the retail side a bit further, and how Q1 fits into the whole year. Worldwide retail was clearly flat in Q1. Your annual guidance rests on 0 to 9. Many of us — or at least my own thinking — assumed you had a batch of new products during Q1, simpler year-over-year comparisons there, plus plenty of promotional spending; so I figured Q1 would end up being the year's best quarter. Could you take us through how you view the quarter-by-quarter pattern of what retail will eventually look like? What does it need to look like to reach your guide? And is any macro support required to get where you believe you need to be?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThanks, James. Predicting retail is always difficult, but one thing about Q1 worth factoring in is that the '24 doesn't reach the international market until very late in the quarter, or in certain markets not at all, as I said earlier; and that ought to help lift at least the EMEA region out of the negative territory we saw during Q1 toward something more balanced ahead. So that's helpful. Looking at Asia with China's weakness, though we anticipate some improvement, I'd say a significant positive turn is unlikely; we'll need to see how it unfolds. I'm more doubtful regarding the Asian market, but we've planned our budget with that in mind. Latin America has been positive; and for the U.S., looking at Q2, the comparison against last year is somewhat harder than in the back half. So you should perhaps anticipate that the North American market — whether it turns positive, or how positive, is unknown — we feel really confident about the market. But judging purely by comps, the back half is far simpler, easier comps than Q2. I hope that helps contextualize things a bit. In Q1, though, we certainly got no help apart from Latin America, which was positive albeit in small numbers from the international market. We hope that changes at least in EMEA, and we're confident for the rest of the year, which is — but we also must acknowledge that we're really just entering the writing season right now, and much hinges on Q2, which is why we haven't changed our guidance at this point in time. other than confirming our 0 or flat to 9%. But we feel comfortable about that. And hopefully, we'll have more to say at the end of the second quarter.
James Hardiman
analystThat's helpful context. Perhaps only to clear something up: since the new products are centered on touring, can we safely conclude that the U.S. market will beat the rest of the world quite substantially? Is there any way to reason that through for the year?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveWell, I'd rather not forecast what the international markets will say or will be capable of delivering. Still, I would say North America probably sees some outperformance across the whole year. I think assuming that is realistic.
Tristan Thomas-Martin
analystI'll just ask a couple of things. First, I'm kind of interested — from what I understand, weather appears to have affected dealers in certain areas based on some dealer checks, while other areas enjoyed nicer conditions. Is there anything you might point to regarding overall retail that's normalized for favorable weather? Also, I'm wondering about Flex financing. Has any uptake occurred? And are there any goals you've set for it?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveSure, favorable-weather retail — I'll add that to the way I talk. That's a nice phrase. Sadly, favorable-weather retail across the board never happens, I'm afraid. And we've definitely experienced some poor conditions during the quarter across every market. Consider California. The weather there has been awful, with flooding and rain essentially for the entire quarter. So that did not assist in pushing California into GEA. And here and there, winter storms and all of that <<inaudible>> as well; but I don't wish to act like a weather forecaster here. I'd say that on the whole, it definitely hasn't been helpful; which is why this is the moment that matters when it comes to writing season. We're happy that on the whole, in places where conditions were favorable, we witnessed solid momentum, and we're hopeful that such momentum keeps going. But on the whole, I don't believe it's been helpful, and when conditions were poor, the figures weren't all that impressive; when conditions were favorable, the figures were impressive. So — and that's certainly how it unfolded across North America during the first quarter.
Jonathan Root
executiveAbsolutely. Tristan, regarding your inquiry about HDFS Flex financing — when it comes to flex financing, we understand that introducing anything major on the product side essentially demands a complete retraining of the dealer network along with the sales process. With that in mind, our projections are quite modest concerning what kind of effect that would have on 2024. We genuinely believe it's going to require 12, 18, or perhaps as many as 24 months to bring the whole dealer network on board, get them fully embracing it, and then have salespeople throughout the entire United States truly grasp how to work that into the sales process, how to hold the right kind of conversation with the customer. So we're mindful of not wanting to drag out the sales experience for our consumers, yet we do want them to grasp optionality. The encouraging part, I'd say, is that a triple-digit figure of dealers have already completed one of those products and essentially sold it through to the consumer. So adoption is going to take time, but we're quite happy with what we're beginning to observe and the feedback we've received from the dealer body thus far.
Noah Zatzkin
analystThe bulk of what I wanted to ask has already come up and been addressed. Perhaps just a single item regarding HDFS. What's your level of comfort with how the book is holding up? And when it comes to annualized retail credit losses for the quarter, is there any basis to think those losses wouldn't roughly align with typical seasonality going forward? And then anything at all to <<inaudible>>.
Jonathan Root
executiveAll right. When we examine the HDFS business, we absolutely acknowledge how distinctive it is — the seasonal patterns inside our financial services operation are indeed somewhat particular when you compare them with the broader financial services landscape. On the whole, we genuinely believe it is tracing the trajectory we anticipated it would from a loss standpoint. As we give some thought to — attempting to address your particular question about what our thinking is quarter by quarter, our view is that it will appear fairly typical when it comes to seasonality. Consequently, just as you'd anticipate, Q1 is the largest quarter, after which you begin to observe a decline in Q2, Q3, and then it rises again in Q4. That kind of standard pattern is what we'd anticipate witnessing over the course of the year. When you translate that into what it means from an overall loss provision standpoint, it's definitely something we need to monitor quite closely given a number of moving dynamics. So when we review that portfolio, we take into account a wide range of characteristics, correct? When we consider customer delinquency, the proportion of those customers who ultimately progress to loss, plus a few other metrics related to that. Yet on the whole, we believe that is progressing as we'd expect it to. So the first quarter appears somewhat more — somewhat elevated as you transition into Q2, Q3. You observe a kind of normalization that comes after that stretch. And then as the year plays out, we anticipate being well reserved from an overall loss provision standpoint. So we're confident about that. And that sort of thing assists us in informing and maintaining the guidance we previously gave for HDFS.
Megan Alexander
analystIn much the same way, you've already addressed the bulk of what I had. Perhaps one small administrative item, then. I realize guidance on EPS isn't something you provide. Still, you enjoyed some pleasant upside beneath the line relative to, at minimum, whatever I believe the Street had modeled. Could you assist us in any way with simply how we ought to frame a few of those categories — the tax rate, interest income — looking ahead? Should 1Q serve as the proper run rate for many of these? Or did certain timing advantages factor into any of them? Whatever assistance you can offer would be appreciated.
Jonathan Root
executiveAll right. I'll take the first swing. And Megan, welcome; we're glad to see you starting coverage on us, I think. So welcome aboard team Harley-Davidson. When we examine and consider those below-the-line entries, we definitely benefited on taxes during Q1. So in thinking somewhat about how that shape appeared, there was a modest amount of upside in Q1. Across the full year, we likely won't sustain a tax rate quite that advantageous. So some caution is warranted there. I believe you noticed that it came in 2 to 3 points beneath last year's level. Then, turning to the remaining items in that bucket, clearly, when we consider the assets we hold to back retirement along with certain other such things landing in that below-the-line category, rates being higher and staying higher for longer might prove somewhat more beneficial than our initial budget assumed; therefore, we'll monitor how that unfolds depending on whatever path the Fed chooses. Those, though, are likely the largest — essentially the 2 biggest forces at work in that area.
Jochen Zeitz
executiveMegan, I'd also like to say welcome. And speaking for Jonathan, I give you my word that starting next year, EPS guidance will be provided by us.
Megan Alexander
analystPerhaps, to sharpen what I'm asking, so on balance, was the effect on 1Q neutral, and while — the tax rate will shift one way as we move ahead. Yet the pension items may prove somewhat better than your earlier assumption?
Jonathan Root
executiveRight; therefore we believe there might be some effect from that angle, indeed.
Jaime Katz
analystI want to see whether you two might provide some additional detail regarding the revised projection for LiveWire's operating loss. Assuming the first quarter came in on plan, what improvements do you anticipate during the remaining portion of the year?
Karim Donnez
executiveAs a result of moving the lab out of California and into Milwaukee, every LiveWire operation will be consolidated within Wisconsin. Considerable synergies and efficiencies throughout the business should follow from this; we therefore expect to cut roughly 10% of our workforce along with 15% of employee-related expenses. Ultimately, all of that backs the updated operating loss figure, whose guidance for the balance of the year reflects a $10 million improvement.
Jaime Katz
analystAll right. And I'm aware that one of the agreements with the union has recently been approved. Do we have any details about what kind of higher labor expenses we ought to anticipate, or similar items flowing through the SG&A line across 2024 and beyond?
Jochen Zeitz
executiveThe agreement essentially matches what we had budgeted and were hoping for. On the whole, we're genuinely happy it was approved on the initial vote, since that demonstrates quite wide support from both our union leadership and our workforce; it runs for 5 years; therefore there's nothing unusual that caught us off guard. So the result pleases us. Plus, with our new contract having been ratified in New York during the previous year and now this year in Wisconsin involving Tomahawk and PDC, we're fully covered for 5 years. So that result makes us very happy. And once more, the fact that this vote — the union vote — succeeded on the first attempt is something we're very pleased about. Still, nothing surprising, in my view — and that truly reflects broad alignment with our union leadership and our workforce, which is excellent.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of the Q&A portion. With that, we're wrapping up today's conference call. We appreciate everyone for joining in. At this point, you're free to disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Harley-Davidson, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Harley-Davidson, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Harley-Davidson, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.