Harley-Davidson, Inc. (HOG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 24, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Automobiles earnings 62 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Shawn Collins

executive
#1

Thanks. Morning, everyone. Shawn Collins here — I handle Investor Relations for Harley-Davidson. The slide deck that goes with today's call is available online over at the Harley-Davidson Investor Relations site. As is typical, we'll be making forward-looking statements, and those carry risks that might make actual outcomes come out materially different. Among those risks are the items we've flagged in the earnings release put out today, plus in the most recent documents we've filed with the SEC. On the line with me this morning: Harley-Davidson's Chief Executive Officer, Jochen Zeitz; our Chief Financial Officer, Jonathan Root; and from LiveWire, its Chief Executive Officer, Karim Donnez. So, I'll hand things over now to our CEO, Jochen Zeitz. Jochen?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#2

Shawn, thank you — and good morning, everyone. We're glad you could join us as we discuss what we delivered in the third quarter of 2024. The global landscape grew tougher as Q3 went on, and that held true for our business as well as for other discretionary purchases with big price tags. Worries about macroeconomics and politics, combined with the pressure that comes from high interest rates, dragged down both our sector and the people who buy from us, most notably where our main markets are located. As a result, sales of new motorcycles at retail around the world fell 13% during Q3. In North America the drop was 10%, while international regions together saw 18%. Looking at the U.S. through the close of Q3, Harley-Davidson's retail figure slipped 1%, a performance that still beat the motorcycle industry as a whole. On the whole, we're still seeing customers with higher incomes spending more than those with lower incomes. You can see that in our motorcycle mix, where CVO models have kept posting double-digit percentage gains all year long. Here in the U.S., through the close of Q3, our new Touring lineup drove that segment up nearly 10%, and we picked up over 4 percentage points of market share — beating the category, our other segments and the overall market. Over in EMEA, retail sales for Q3 fell 23%, with results varying from one country to the next. Macroeconomic conditions and geopolitical uncertainty have kept weighing on EMEA, resulting in weak economic growth. Looking at things through the lens of the motorcycle family, the strongest performers in that region were the Touring, CVO and Trike models. Moving to Asia Pacific, third-quarter retails declined 16%, driven by softer-than-anticipated results in Japan, which growth in Australia and New Zealand helped offset somewhat. And finally, in Latin America, Q3 retails rose 4%. Even with a difficult operating environment overall, the tremendous response from customers, media and our network keeps us excited about the fresh Touring lineup, including the redesigned, all-new Road Glide and Street Glide. Our view is that this highly differentiated Touring portfolio positions the company well for success in the years ahead, alongside the other plans we have in the motorcycle development pipeline. Turning to what lies ahead—and Jonathan will get into the specifics—because retail demand in Q3 came in below what we had anticipated, our full year '24 outlook is being revised. During Q3, we kept working to bring dealer inventory levels down, cutting our production units as retail softened. When the quarter closed, dealer inventory had fallen 13% compared with the close of Q2 of this year. Our commitment stands to keep lowering inventory levels and to support dealer health, in North America as well as our international markets, while we get ready for the new model year launch in '25 featuring a range of exciting new bikes backed by a strong marketing push alongside our dealer network. Now, a quick word on HDFS. Paired with Harley-Davidson Financial Services, we feel we hold a top-tier asset that backs our dealers and riders through economically solid stretches as well as tougher ones. Thanks to a robust quarter, powered by greater retail and commercial finance receivables, HDFS remained an enormously valuable asset for every one of our stakeholders. On the LiveWire front, as Karim will soon explain, we keep adapting to the broader end EV landscape, sharpening LiveWire's emphasis on achieving cost efficiencies and productivity throughout the operation. All told, even with the headwinds the industry faces, which have likewise hit our business across the second half of the year so far, we've moved forward on our Hardwire II goals. Beyond our Touring lineup, which we consider the clear best product in the industry, we're confident we also hold the right product coming through the pipeline over the next several years to deliver profitable growth. We're dedicated to making sure our dealers get that product at the proper moment and the proper price, while also offering robust marketing and sales backing, which we anticipate will drive profitability throughout the company and our network. We're putting in hard work to position ourselves for a strong '25 and feel good about our capacity to achieve meaningful progress in the New Year. Marrying our top-tier product and brand together with a top-tier dealer network makes for a potent recipe for success. Even so, we remain aware of external dynamics—such as reductions in interest rates and stronger consumer sentiment—that this sector requires in order to gain a much-needed boost. As we close out the year, maintaining tight oversight of expenses and driving further cost efficiency gains, together with sticking to a rigorous approach to deploying capital, continue to be our priorities. We feel certain that our approach with Hardwire is the correct one, especially when compared with competitors in the marketplace, and that our decisions to direct funds toward innovation and the key categories that we know our riders and dealerships value were the right ones to power Harley-Davidson's culture and business well into the future. Thank you. I'll hand it over now to Karim.

Karim Donnez

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Jochen. Morning, everybody. During the third quarter, conditions turned out to be tough for electric vehicle offerings, with adoption arriving roughly as expected amid political and economic instability around the world. Against that backdrop, so far this year LiveWire has sold more street-legal electric motorcycles at retail in the United States than any rival brand on the market. In the on-road EV category above 50 horsepower, LiveWire kept its number one spot during the quarter and across 2024, holding 69% of market share year-to-date. Naturally, LiveWire has enjoyed a number of high-profile moments, among them the Del Mar receiving MCN's Best 2024 Electric Bike award in September. Beyond that, in Paris this August, the S2 Del Mar gave us a worldwide spotlight, turning LiveWire into a household name. Even though retail sales beat wholesale for a third quarter in a row, we nonetheless fell short of what we had expected. Because of that, our full year guidance is being revised down to 600 to 1,000 motorcycle units. For the entire year, our operating loss guidance stays the same. What we're concentrated on is getting the business to the right size for current market conditions, putting out the finest EV products available, with a distinctive LiveWire look, sound and feel, and getting ready for growth later as the EV market grows. Going forward, we intend to watch expenses carefully and substantially lower the cost of our EV motorcycle products, cutting cash burn by a projected 40% in the next year versus 2024. Steps were already taken during this year looking toward 2025, including finishing a restructuring of laboratory shares in Milwaukee and relocating to Juneau Avenue; we've likewise simplified our organization, which brings roughly a 30% reduction in headcount as we enter 2025 relative to the beginning of 2024. Since we understand that the performance of our current lineup speaks to enthusiasts, LiveWire is also actively exploring ways to broaden its addressable market and boost overall access to the easy expense. With that in mind, I'm happy to confirm we intend to reveal a new product segment at EICMA in November, which we think will deliver extra revenue streams for the company over the medium term while substantially enlarging our present addressable market. Thanks to everyone. Thank you. I'll now pass things to Jonathan.

Jonathan Root

executive
#4

Thanks, Karim, and good morning, everyone. I'd like to begin on Page 4 of the deck, where I'll give a quick rundown of the consolidated financial results for Q3 2024. Consolidated revenue for the third quarter fell 26%, which came from HDMC revenue dropping 32%, partly offset by HDFS revenue rising 10%. Consolidated operating income for Q3 came in at $106 million, a 49% decline versus the same period a year ago, pulled down by a $120 million decrease at HDMC. Over at HDFS, operating income rose $17 million, while the LiveWire segment's operating loss grew by $1 million year-over-year. Consolidated operating margin for the third quarter stood at 9.2%, versus 13.5% a year earlier, with HDMC's operating income margin falling 720 basis points year-over-year and HDFS's operating margin improving 410 basis points. I'll dig deeper into the profit and loss drivers for each business segment in the section that follows. Third quarter earnings per share came to $0.91, a 34% drop from $1.38 a year ago. Turning the page to our year-to-date results, total consolidated HDI revenue reached $4.5 billion, down 6% from last year. Breaking that down: HDMC revenue declined 9%, HDFS revenue grew 11%, and LiveWire revenue fell 30%. Total consolidated HDI operating income was $610 million, $190 million below the prior year. Breaking that down: at HDMC, operating income of $491 million was 30% below the prior year, reflecting a 13.3% operating margin for the year-to-date period. At HDFS, operating income of $202 million rose 14% year-to-date; and at LiveWire, an operating loss of $83 million matched what we expected. Year-to-date earnings per share was $4.27, an 8% decrease, compared with $4.65 during the same period in 2023. As Jochen noted in his opening remarks, during Q3, consumers worldwide appeared to pull back from big-ticket discretionary purchases, with different factors at play in each region. As Jochen said, dealer inventory at the close of Q3 is 13% lower than at the end of Q2 this year, since we concentrated on bringing inventory down during the second half of 2024 both at home and abroad; we're putting priority on helping our dealers as they work to trim their inventory through the rest of '24; we anticipate dealer inventory will be roughly 20% below where it stood at the end of Q3 '24, so dealers will enter 2025 with inventory similar to how they started 2024. We're looking forward to a healthier environment in 2025, where, as Jochen said earlier, our focus is on boosting profitability across the Harley-Davidson dealer network and working more closely with our dealers to build and expand our grassroots marketing activations. We remain focused on keeping Touring, Trike, soft tail and CVO motorcycles available and in stock. We'll get into more detail on what we're anticipating for retail and wholesale motorcycles for the rest of 2024 in just a few minutes. Turning to revenue, HDMC saw a 32% drop in Q3. That mostly came from a 39% fall in wholesale units shipped during Q3, with 27,500 motorcycles shipped in Q3 of '24 compared to 45,300 motorcycles shipped in Q3 of '23. Let's focus on the main drivers for the quarter when it comes to revenue contribution. 32 points of the decline resulted from lower wholesale volume at HDMC, where motorcycle shipments fell 39% in the quarter and came in well below retail sales of motorcycles. 1 point of growth came from pricing, which includes the net effect of pricing actions on 2024 model year motorcycles along with overall sales incentives. 1 point of decline came from mix, as we compare against last year's introduction of all new CVO motorcycles, with more focus on Touring shipments during the first half of the year, and we finish out shipments for the rest of the motorcycle portfolio in the second half; and finally, foreign exchange was basically flat in Q3. In Q3, HDMC gross margin was 30.1%, compared to 31.7% a year earlier. That 160 basis point decrease came from negative impacts of lower volumes and negative operating leverage. There were a few positives in the quarter, including favorable net pricing, favorable foreign exchange, including hedging, and lower raw material and supply chain management costs as we start to accelerate our manufacturing and supply chain savings, which helped offset the 2% rate of inflation seen during the quarter; on the operating expense side, expenses came in $27 million lower than prior year, or 11%, as we continue to keep overall cost discipline and step up our efforts to manage OpEx productivity at HDMC. HDMC operating income was $55 million, which was $120 million below prior year because of the significant reduction in wholesale. HDMC operating margin was 6.3% in Q3 versus 13.5% a year earlier. For the year-to-date period, HDMC gross margin was 31.3%, compared to 34.2% in the prior year. That 290 basis point decrease came from the negative impact of lower volumes, negative operating leverage, moderate inflation and less favorable net pricing, which includes overall sales incentives. Those impacts were partly offset by positive impacts from favorable motorcycle mix and lower raw material costs and lower supply chain and manufacturing expenses, which I'll go into more deeply in comments about productivity. Finally, in the first 9 months, operating expenses were down by $13 million or 2% as we kept overall cost discipline thanks to actions we started taking in late Q2 of this year. HDMC operating income was $491 million, which was $214 million below prior year. HDMC operating margin was 13.3% through the first 9 months compared to 17.4% in the prior-year period. Ahead of moving on to the following slide, similarly to what I did back in July, allow me to provide a quick status report regarding our productivity cost program — one of the efforts singled out under the Hardwire strategy — through which we anticipate generating a $400 million gain in productivity. Just to remind everyone, the effect of leverage is now being excluded, though we are keeping our multiyear goal of $400 million that was shared previously. With leverage's effect set aside, we achieved roughly $24 million during 2022 along with $123 million during 2023. Through Q3 of the present year, we have achieved $84 million in 2024. Let's now move to Slide 10, covering the Financial Services segment. Over at Harley-Davidson Financial Services, Q3 revenue rose $26 million, which equals 10%, fueled by greater retail as well as commercial finance receivables, plus increased average yields as the portfolio keeps repricing gradually in line with shifts in Fed-based interest rates, something that is presently pushing interest income upward. Operating income at HDFS came to $77 million, which is $17 million greater, or 29% higher, versus the prior year. This Q3 gain stemmed from elevated interest income together with a reduced provision for credit losses, both partly counterbalanced by rising borrowing costs, whereas operating expenses stayed mostly level.

Jonathan Root

executive
#5

Interest costs overall climbed by $10 million, representing a 12% rise from the same period a year earlier. Higher funding costs caused this, since debt with lower rates reached maturity and got refinanced at today's market rates. During Q3, the annualized retail credit loss ratio at HDFS came in at 3.1%, compared with 2.7% on an annualized basis in Q3 of 2023. A number of elements tied to the present macroeconomic climate, along with associated customer and industry shifts, pushed credit losses higher. Additionally, the retail allowance for credit losses in the third quarter reached 5.5%, essentially unchanged from 5.4% at both the close of last year and Q2 of 2024; this mirrors our finest assessment of today's and tomorrow's retail lending conditions. Overall retail loan originations during Q3 declined 11%, whereas commercial financing activity rose 18%, reaching $1.2 billion. Net financing receivables at quarter end across the board, encompassing retail loans alongside commercial financing, totaled $7.8 billion, a 2% gain over the previous year. Moving to Slide 11 and the year-to-date figures for HDFS. Revenue grew $74 million, or 11%. Operating income at HDFS hit $202 million, an increase of $25 million, or 14%, over the prior year. This year-to-date gain stemmed from greater interest income, which exceeded the impact of increased borrowing costs, a larger provision for credit losses, and higher operating expenses; within the LiveWire segment, electric motorcycle revenue rose in the third quarter of 2024 relative to the equivalent period last year, thanks to greater unit sales of EV motorcycles during the quarter. Over at StaCyc, revenue for the electric bike business fell versus the previous year, something we anticipated given a decline in volumes from third-party branded distributors. Selling, administrative, and engineering expenses dropped $2 million, or 6%, in Q3 relative to a year ago. LiveWire posted an operating loss of $26 million, $1 million above the prior year, matching our expectations as LiveWire kept putting money into new motorcycle models and also carried out efforts aimed at lowering the total cost of sales for EV motorcycles; looking at year-to-date results for the LiveWire segment, revenue stood at $16 million, a 30% drop from last year stemming from weaker revenue at StaCyc. Across the year-to-date period, LiveWire moved 374 electric motorcycles, a triple-digit rise over the equivalent stretch last year; during that period, LiveWire's operating loss amounted to $83 million, consistent with what we had anticipated. Finishing with the consolidated financial results for Harley-Davidson Inc. We generated $931 million in operating cash flow across the first 9 months of 2024, climbing from $707 million during the same stretch a year earlier. Favorable working capital movements, driven by our emphasis on disciplined inventory management, plus a shift in wholesale finance receivables, shaped this operating cash flow improvement. Cash and cash equivalents in total finished at $2.2 billion, $366 million above where they stood at the close of Q3 the year before. That consolidated cash figure takes in $88 million over at LiveWire. On top of that, under our approach to allocating capital, and consistent with what we've pledged about giving capital back to shareholders, during Q3 we repurchased 4 million of our shares, spending $150 million on that buyback. That takes the cumulative count of shares repurchased across the 9 months of 2024 up to 9.5 million shares of Harley-Davidson common stock, for a total of $350 million, equal to 7% of the shares outstanding when 2024 began; against that, the first 9 months of 2023 saw 6.1 million shares bought at a cost of $226 million. Because retail demand came in weaker than we had anticipated during the first 9 months of the year, and we see that carrying on through Q4, we're updating our outlook for the whole of 2024. Over at HDMC, our expectation remains that by the close of 2024, retail units sold and wholesale unit shipments will be roughly in balance, and our new expectation is that retail and wholesale will land somewhere between 149,000 and 153,000 units, moving from the 163,000 to 168,000 units we cited at Q2 earnings. For the full year, we anticipate retail coming in somewhere between down 6% and 8%, shifted from flat to up 3% for the full year, while wholesale shipments for the full year should land somewhere between down 16% and 17%, shifted from down 7% to 10% for the full year; those reduced top line inputs mean our targets for full year HDMC revenue and HDMC operating income have to change. Revenue for the full year is now anticipated to land somewhere between down 14% and 16%, shifted from down 5% to 9% for the full year as given at Q2 earnings; for the full year, the operating income margin is now anticipated to land somewhere between 7.5% and 8.5%, shifted from the 10.6% to 11.6% range for the full year that we had guided to before. This downward revision stems from cuts to production and wholesale along with the leverage effect that follows. Our view is that these cuts leave the company better positioned for 2025. Turning to HDFS, our guidance for the whole of 2024 has been revised upward, and we now anticipate operating income landing somewhere between up 5% and 10% for the full year, shifted from flat to up 5% for the full year as given at Q2 earnings. Over at LiveWire, guidance for the whole of 2024 has been revised. Our new expectation is delivering somewhere between 600 and 1,000 electric motorcycle units, while the operating loss, somewhere between $105 million and $115 million, stays unchanged. And capital investment is still anticipated to land somewhere between $225 million and $250 million, which stays unchanged. Just to remind everyone, our priorities for allocating capital haven't changed: we put money behind the profitable expansion of the Hardwire initiatives, and that covers capital expenditures, dividend payments, and going on with discretionary share repurchases the way we laid out last quarter. In our view, this makes clear our operating discipline, the cash flow we generate as a whole, and our earnings power over the long term, and it's backed by our ongoing pledge to hit a 15% HDMC operating income margin by the close of 2025. With that said, let's begin the Q&A.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#6

Jochen, I'd like to know whether there are any themes that have emerged from the dealer conversations you've had lately. Also, what message are you giving to dealers? It seems like that message has shifted somewhat.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#7

Yes. Thank you, Craig. It's clear, and quite understandable, that dealer profitability is top of mind. As you've observed this week, the industry is going through a hard period, just like any discretionary business, whether that's marine, RV, or motorcycles. As you noted, we held our annual dealer forum in October, and that gave us a genuinely valuable barometer and chance to connect with our dealers, along with the many interactions our leadership team has with them all year. During the forum, we laid out how we, as a motor company, will back the network in '25. I believe the result is likely what left dealers feeling positive about what's ahead for us <<inaudible>> and they rated the outcomes and success of the forum overwhelmingly, with nearly 75% calling it very good to exceptional. That's a strong signal from a network, considering the extremely tough conditions we're facing, with dealer profitability at a level we obviously don't want to continue seeing; so the steps we <<inaudible>> new product lineup for next year and especially the co-marketing investments we'll be making, on top of other internal actions we <<inaudible>> will rise next year in robust fashion. As I said earlier, there's considerable strength in the single brand network, and we take pride in having <<inaudible>> network in the industry, and we want to ensure it remains the most profitable network too, and we're working hard <<inaudible>> That being said, I'd note the other networks are likely facing more difficulty <<inaudible>> our network has <<inaudible>> But I'd say we will definitely keep working very hard on the dealer network when it comes to profitability.

Megan Alexander

analyst
#8

I'd like to pose a few questions, if you don't mind, regarding retail. That 13% decline in 3Q — clearly, I believe there was some noise that had been well telegraphed, especially maybe during August. I think last quarter you mentioned July got off to a decent start; so first, could you maybe discuss the pattern retail followed across the third quarter and how you came out of it? And then how that shaped your guidance for 4Q — clearly, a broad range for the fourth quarter appears to be suggested; but it looks fairly comparable, I suppose, to what you reported in 3Q; so perhaps you could just sort of help us grasp the pluses and minuses surrounding that.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#9

Certainly, Megan; so Q3 began with a solid July and we finished up softer than anticipated, particularly in late September, which we figure is largely consistent with what we've been hearing from most. <<inaudible>> and power sports rivals and sectors overall and not only the U.S., but around the world. So we believe and we presume that the heightened macro and geopolitical uncertainty anticipated alongside shifts in interest rates, particularly North America and EMEA plus the forthcoming U.S. elections, certain weather occurrences in the U.S. <<inaudible>>

James Hardiman

analyst
#10

It sounds like the overall expectation for '24 is that retail will track wholesale. Given how soft retail has been, why do you still see that as the correct goal right now? And the larger thing I'm wondering is, looking ahead to 2025, how confident are you that further destocking won't be necessary next year?

Jonathan Root

executive
#11

Sure. James, it's Jonathan. Glad to kick this off and handle it. I think your questions are mainly focused on dealer inventory and how it ties into retail. That's a fair point to raise. Dealer inventory finished Q3 down roughly 13% versus the close of Q2. We'll stay focused on bringing dealer inventory levels down further during the last quarter of '24. So with that in mind, the thing you're probably getting at is, where will you end up? Well, our goal is to be down roughly another 20% from where we are now, which brings us to roughly the same levels as the close of last year. From where we sit, we keep prioritizing availability and inventory of Touring trike, Softail and CVO motorcycles; we look at our core categories, and we know those core categories are essential to the Hardwire strategy, and essential to the share growth we've delivered in the industry. So we want to be sure our dealers are positioned properly to sustain that. And then, as you mentioned, you have our commitment that by the time the year ends, we truly are doing everything we can to bring retail and wholesale into alignment, which is something we've discussed since the start of the year as part of our 2024 guidance. So I hope that's helpful.

James Hardiman

analyst
#12

Honestly, I'm not sure whether there's time for — I can't even come up with a second question, but I suppose what I want to ask is, what makes that the correct figure? Inventories holding steady across a 12-month period during which retail will decline in the mid-single digits. Typically, under those circumstances, we'd figure that stock levels would have to fall still more, correct, compared with how the year began, so that inventory turns stay unchanged. So does that set up a possible overhang when we consider cuts for the coming year?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#13

Yeah, James, I'm not sure whether my voice is coming through any clearer. It sounds like the line gave me some trouble. Our view is no; and we think we're going to be — even though the third quarter came in softer, we think the corrections we're putting in place during this year, along with the shipments we've got planned across the 4 quarters of the following year, will tackle that appropriately. Thus we're confident this is the correct course of action and a fairly sizable adjustment spread across the year.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#14

Following up on James's question — if my math holds up, you ended 2023 with 49,000 bikes sitting in the channel, and this year you're forecasting retail sales somewhere between 163,000 and 178,000 bikes. But now you're saying you'll wrap up this year with 49,000 bikes in the channel, which is flat compared to twelve months ago. I just can't see you projecting that same retail number for next year. So how do those two figures line up?

Jonathan Root

executive
#15

Alright, thanks Joe. The thing is, we probably don't want to get too deep into 2025 at this point. We don't believe right now is the appropriate moment to provide complete 2025 guidance about our direction. Still, when we consider everything we've shared and our trajectory, we clearly anticipate landing somewhere between 150,000 and 153,000 retail units, with overall wholesale units matching that same figure. Keeping those two figures aligned lets us put our dealers in a solid position both as this year wraps up and as we head into the first quarter of 2025. Once again, we'd rather not look too deeply into 2025. Yet as we head toward that stretch, there will likely be certain tweaks to how we ultimately spread things out across the quarters of 2025, and we'll be sure to go through those more thoroughly during the next earnings report.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#16

All right, that's useful. Perhaps one more question. You brought up how retail moved during the quarter. Did things improve at all in October after the Fed lowered rates? Or is it simply too soon to tell?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#17

Yeah. As we've stated before, we intend to stay cautious, and following our general approach, I won't discuss the quarter currently underway — meaning October's retail numbers — before we put out Q3, and that's how we'll handle it going forward. Turning back to what you asked about inventory, something to keep in mind is that the significant shift with Touring clearly won't repeat itself. We've got great Touring motorcycles out there, and those will roll over into the New Year. So keep that in mind regarding how good the inventory is that we're rolling over. Instead of an older platform being brought into the New Year, it's the newer platform going into the New Year; therefore Touring inventory quality is far superior to what it was a year ago, which is another point worth factoring in.

Robin Farley

analyst
#18

My question is somewhat along the same lines, regarding flat representing your inventory position, and I'm not sure what you're able to share concerning what you anticipate for a retail turnaround in the coming year. That said, perhaps I'll add a second one in case there's nothing further to say on the first; and regarding LiveWire, clearly the broader electric vehicle market is a tough place to be right now. So I suppose, when considering your long-term dedication to that unit, is there some threshold where, should it miss your expectations for yet another year under your multiyear plan, you'd reconsider the timeline for reaching profitability there and how long you'd tolerate those extra losses? I'm basically attempting to gauge whether, if these targets aren't reached, you're comfortable with losses comparable to this year's and for what period? That's the way I'm looking at it.

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#19

Yes. Thanks, Robin. Regarding '25 expectations, there isn't much else I can offer beyond stressing again that we're truly putting in tremendous effort to position ourselves for a strong '25, and we feel confident about our capacity to deliver meaningful progress in the New Year. I'd describe that as cautiously optimistic; we believe that pairing our best-in-class products with our best-in-class dealer network creates a genuinely powerful formula for success; yet naturally, we must keep in mind that outside elements, such as reductions in interest rates and stronger consumer confidence, are needed to give the industry a tailwind it has lacked for a couple of years now. So beyond that, our attention is, naturally, on sustaining our cost control efforts and our cost productivity improvements. Jonathan highlighted them, and we anticipate reaching our target of productivity gains totaling $400 million, alongside disciplined capital allocation, and we remain convinced that our strategy is the right one, particularly relative to others in the market; and that the choices we made back in 2020 and '21 to put money into innovation and into our core categories that we know our customers, our dealer saver have been the correct call. So I believe that's as much detail as I can provide for '25. As for LiveWire, I think we have taken — or LiveWire has taken, with Karim at the helm, substantial steps and has cut our cash burn considerably heading into next year. He mentioned that we're lowering the cash burn by 40% next year. Operating costs are declining. We're working — the team is working extremely hard to boost margin and manufacturing costs so that we can reach a far smaller number of units that must be sold to get to a breakeven or positive gross profit margin. Thus, the steps have already been implemented, and Karim, should you wish to list them again, go ahead. Yet we genuinely feel, right now, based on the information available to us, that continuing to put money in remains essential — though unquestionably with great caution, unlike the situation when this endeavor began and EV uptake looked completely different, both in automobiles and elsewhere. We think it matters to establish our position and LiveWire's position as a frontrunner in electrifying the sport, and to guarantee that Harley Davidson can obtain this technology at the right moment, should such a moment arrive. Naturally, one evaluates things 1 year at a time and observes how the business evolves. As things stand, these constitute the measures we are carrying out.

Fred Wightman

analyst
#20

Jonathan, I believe you made a remark basically restating that goal of a 15% operating margin for '25. Could you help us walk through the major components behind this year's operating margin result? I realize there's substantial deleverage tied to lower volumes; yet if you could assist us in thinking through the sizable elements needed to reach that mid-teens target, that would be useful.

Jonathan Root

executive
#21

Alright. That works; I'd say it's a solid question regarding the 15% OI margin. We've discussed it being achieved by the close of 2025. So consider roughly full year 2026; we feel quite good about the steps we're implementing and how we're handling matters within Harley's 4 walls and how that genuinely generates some gains. This year is definitely atypical regarding how much we're reducing shipments during the back half of the year; we also have some — I believe we've mentioned this somewhat, likely more often this year than we ever anticipated we would, concerning certain gaps between production and wholesale. And so as we progress into 2025 and 2026, we start to align the connection among production, wholesale and retail. Consequently, you clearly witness some of the advantages we get from a leverage perspective. So there's a fairly substantial effect from that angle. Cost productivity, for us, is something we believe truly produces a rather considerable degree of enhancement. So you clearly have our pledge to $400 million of cost productivity. And as you might remember from earlier this year, we actually stripped leverage out of that figure; so that's a genuine $400 million, not a sum that hinges on units. So you combine those 2 to observe gains; and then, furthermore, since we have portfolio shifts and product modifications and adjustments, there are certain areas where we think we can act quite precisely from a pricing perspective; so that assists. And then the remaining element I'd briefly mention is, we possess fairly robust operating discipline regarding OpEx and you genuinely observe that clearly reflected this quarter; so with certain measures we undertook last quarter that you ultimately see flowing into the P&L favorably during this quarter, you observe OpEx declining $27 million, for instance, in Q3, thus falling 11% because of the steps we implemented. So I believe if you examine the entire P&L, there are multiple contributing elements that provide us confidence in that 15% OI margin target.

Fred Wightman

analyst
#22

Alright. Then dealer support came up a few times. What I want to know is — does that phrase just refer to lowering shipments so dealers get some relief? Or does a separate mechanism exist for that?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#23

There are plenty of steps we've put in place to position our dealers for a good '25. During my remarks, I brought up the sizable marketing spend in the form of a marketing development fund, which will help dealers on the ground as they carry out their work in '25. We've also shown our network quite a few other initiatives, among them retail targets for next year that, from where we sit, can be hit, changes to the way we digitally push more traffic and leads toward our network, and how we expect our fuel facility upgrades to take shape across the coming couple of years; so these are numerous activities that don't revolve solely around inventory reduction, which, naturally, matters greatly too, particularly as we head into next year. Given rates trending downward plus all the remaining activities we've made public, the dealer network ought to be in a position to witness a substantial gain in overall profitability in '25, on top of, naturally, the product we rolled out at the very same time.

Alex Perry

analyst
#24

I was curious about what our approach should be regarding HDMC gross margins during Q4. Are we going to use promotional activity to reduce dealer inventory? Then, a small follow-up related to what we discussed last quarter. Could you give us any guidance on how we ought to approach gross margins for the coming year, particularly in light of certain production changes you've made public and the effort to remove some rising expenses from the company?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#25

I'll begin with a quick comment on promotions. At present, we're providing certain promotional assistance, primarily through interest rate support, in a way we consider consistent with the marketplace. In our main markets, though, we're less promotional than our rivals, who are putting forward offers that are more aggressive. Having said that, we're determined to hit our retail goal for Q4. And Jonathan can walk through a few of the promotions currently active in the market.

Jonathan Root

executive
#26

Absolutely. Alright, thank you, Jochen. So, I believe — Alex, when you're considering Q4, there are a few elements, and as you mentioned, you raised the question about margin and how margin will appear in Q4. There's a fairly significant decrease in wholesale shipments. So clearly, we've given you our expectations for where retail and wholesale will fall; and from that, you can tell it's a substantial reduction in shipments. Therefore, Q4 margin will definitely be under considerable pressure. As we proceed and examine — addressing the question about promotions, as we proceed and examine promotions, what we've observed is that from the consumer's standpoint, we believe our consumers react more strongly to rate promotions than to anything else. Several of our rivals have rate promotions and cash offers available. We've been quite deliberate about concentrating mainly on rate promotions, especially when you consider what we have regarding the current model year. So we'll keep some version of that going, perhaps, as we look at the rest of the year, to ensure that we are, once again, backing our dealers at retail — we believe it's essential to make sure we're providing them with campaigns that let them generate consumer traffic, assist in closing sales, and sort of provide something that's equitable for our consumers and beneficial for our dealers; and so I think you'll notice a continuation of a lot of what we've been doing.

Noah Zatzkin

analyst
#27

Okay, to begin with, regarding LiveWire — and I don't want to split hairs here — but I believe you said something about aiming to cut cash burn by 40% in the coming year. Would it be reasonable to conclude that this maps straight onto operating expenses, so I'm just trying to determine whether we might see something like $40 million to $50 million in reduced losses from LiveWire next year?

Jonathan Root

executive
#28

Absolutely. I'll kick things off, and then Karim can chime in. I'd say Karim is extremely, extremely focused on running the LiveWire business very tightly. What you observe on the cash side differs somewhat from where their operating income ultimately lands, since clearly there's depreciation as well as certain compensation-related items that feed into that part of the calculation. Karim, I'll pass it to you for the — to add a bit of color on some of that. But I believe, Noah, the key point is that cash burn accounts for 1 component of their P&L, and beyond that, they also have depreciation they work through plus certain compensation-related items; but with that, Karim?

Karim Donnez

executive
#29

Absolutely. Thank you, Noah. So, as Jonathan laid out, the cash burn clearly plays a direct role in how the operating loss comes out next year. Because of that, we also anticipate a major decrease in operating loss next year. That said, most of the steps needed to position ourselves for that large reduction next year are already behind us. We moved the entire lab out of California to Milwaukee; nothing remains in California now, and operating there was, as you'd expect, quite costly. On top of that, our total workforce is down 30% versus where it stood at the start of the year — and all of that is complete at this point. We restructured the organization while keeping a strong emphasis on innovation, making certain we can keep bringing forward products that are right for the market. One of those gets announced in 10 days at EICMA. And once again, we think those products will greatly widen what's possible for LiveWire. So we understand the difficult EV landscape we're in at the moment, though that doesn't apply to every segment; when you examine the various kinds of EV segments, there are in fact pockets showing solid, solid momentum in the EV market, particularly in Europe; so there's more news to come on that front; but the LiveWire business as a whole is already positioned for '25 to see a very substantial drop in cash burn and operating loss relative to the 2024 performance.

Noah Zatzkin

analyst
#30

If I could just fit one more question in about HDFS. First off, I suppose, what's your read on the health of the book, and then clearly, strong results this quarter. How do you view the way expected rate cuts interact with the capacity to generate growth there in the coming year?

Jonathan Root

executive
#31

Excellent question, Noah. Let's begin with the current year, then shift to a brief question about the next one; so when we examine what we're observing from a 2024 standpoint, the consumer definitely is somewhat stressed. The HDFS team is doing a fantastic job of controlling losses, managing the consumer and making sure they remain more or less on track, which I believe you can see in a relatively modest adjustment to our reserve, and we're essentially flat in reserves against the previous quarter and the previous year. So from the standpoint of consumer health, I'd say the outlook is quite favorable. That is what enables us to raise our outlook for the HDFS business for the year. As we head into 2025, as we've discussed, we're probably not prepared to guide in detail on 2025 at this point. But we're in an intriguing position where I believe we'll likely witness — we're actually working through the budget and that sort of thing; so I'm speaking somewhat off the cuff. But we're at a point where I believe we will ultimately see a bit of the debt portfolio resetting before we get a comparable reset in the retail portfolio; so matters have gone in a really positive direction for 2024. I think we face a somewhat challenging 2025 ahead of us before we progress into later years. But more to come on that topic, though I don't expect that 2025 for HDFS will appear as strong as 2024.

David MacGregor

analyst
#32

I suppose this was a fairly disruptive quarter when you look at the weather. What impact do you believe that had on your retail figures? Can you break out at all how much of that 13% decline could be traced to weather-related disruption alone? Then second, I would really like to hear your perspective — and I know it's a bit soon to be discussing 2025 — but what's your thinking when it comes to motor company market share in 2025?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#33

David, weather definitely created a more difficult retail backdrop, particularly as September drew to a close; that was also when Helene struck the East Coast, and we experienced some effect — a significant effect late in the period, with dealers having to shut their doors to get ready and then not being able to reopen right away; so that has definitely had an effect in the U.S., not really overseas, but definitely in the U.S.

David MacGregor

analyst
#34

And what about the market share for '25?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#35

At this point, we're not really going to say much more about '25. For next year, we believe our product lineup in Touring is strong enough to keep things going. As I said before, our CVO segment has been performing especially well. Across the quarters, we've recorded double-digit growth in our strong CVO Touring offering, which includes a CVO we've brought to the Adventure Touring market; next year we have a solid lineup. Beyond that, though, I think we'll need to wait until February to offer any indication. We definitely think we're well positioned to protect market share, perhaps pick up ground in certain segments, but that's — we'll see. And naturally, the broader environment plays a role there too. As you've observed, we've gained share in Touring and have been up in most quarters and significantly beaten the industry in that segment, which is a strong sign that innovation as part of our Hardwire strategy is truly paying off even in difficult times. So we remain confident that other innovations in our pipeline for '25 will deliver a similar benefit going forward, alongside additional steps taken with our dealer network to ensure they're prepared for it, and we bring in leads and traffic to that dealer network.

Tristan Thomas-Martin

analyst
#36

I just have something to ask regarding your wider lineup of products. As you mentioned, the updated Touring has done really well for you. I was curious, with certain challenges coming from the higher-priced offerings, and with general worries about what consumers can afford, have you considered going back to some lower-cost motorcycles?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#37

Sorry, could you say that again — going back to what?

Tristan Thomas-Martin

analyst
#38

So you're referring to more budget-friendly motorcycles, perhaps models priced below $10,000?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#39

That's right. We won't be discussing what our entry-level offering will cost in the coming year. However, you can be certain that we're tackling this, especially through our RevMax lineup arriving in '25. That being said, we have to hold off until the New Year before those prices become available.

Jaime Katz

analyst
#40

I'd like some clarification on what you said about market share. My understanding is that you claimed a gain of 4% in market share. Yet if I look at Slide 6 of your deck, neither on a year-over-year basis nor sequentially does the share for total Touring, Cruiser appear to have risen by 4%. So which area is it, exactly, where you've picked up share?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#41

The main place we picked up share is in Touring, and that segment was the top priority for the new products we launched this year. Each quarter, our share performance has beaten the industry by a wide margin. And when you step back and look at the business as a whole, our retail sales declined by a smaller amount than the industry did. So in that broader picture, we've nudged our share up a bit. That figure, though, takes in every segment; in Touring specifically, quarter after quarter, we've performed better — much better — than the market.

Jaime Katz

analyst
#42

Yeah, I get that. The thing is, the slide doesn't show it. All it shows is 73% market share for this quarter and 73% for the prior one. My other question is about taking another look at how the business is structured from an operating standpoint. There hasn't been a major overhaul in quite some time, yet it's obvious that shipment volumes are a lot different than what they might have been a decade back. So what kind of trigger would you want to see before deciding whether your capacity, labor utilization, or manufacturing footprint ought to be reconsidered at a far deeper level?

Jochen Zeitz

executive
#43

Well, you can be sure we're evaluating that all the time. And since we're currently building our budget, that's obviously a central factor, which is exactly why we've stressed so heavily that OpEx and cost productivity are a major driver. And we'll make certain that we're anchoring those operations in a cautious forecast moving ahead. So that's how it will be; we've already made changes to our OpEx base across the past 18 months, and we'll keep doing that given an expected market climate that has definitely been difficult this year, without a doubt. Having said that, I believe what we've got in our plans for next year is realistic and conservative, and that gives us confidence, as Jonathan pointed out, that through the cost productivity steps we're taking and a disciplined OpEx structure as we head into next year, we'll deliver the improvement we're after to hit our Hardwire Stage 2 targets when it comes to operating margin.

Jonathan Root

executive
#44

Yeah. And Jamie, I'd like to piggyback on that — clearly, we're still extremely dedicated to hitting that $400 million in cost productivity. Of course, getting there definitely requires a tremendous amount of effort when it comes to making sure everything is optimized on the manufacturing side, so we're grateful for the relationship we share with our unions. We believe they've shown a degree of flexibility and support that we truly appreciate. And I think that, working together, we've joined forces to drive something we believe will be very sustainable going forward. And once again, you have our firm commitment to delivering that $400 million we've been discussing.

Operator

operator
#45

That wraps up the Q&A portion — we have nothing else queued up right now. And with that, we're bringing today's conference call to a close. Thanks to each of you for being on the line with us. At this point, feel free to hang up.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Harley-Davidson, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Harley-Davidson, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Harley-Davidson, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.