Hongkong Land Holdings Limited (H78) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 30, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Michael Smith
executiveWelcome. Lots of familiar faces. I am super pumped. I'm really, really excited, and I'm really energized to be here today. And yes, experience is central. This is our new corporate slogan, and hopefully, you'll see it across our portfolio from this point forward. You're also amongst the first to see our new Hongkong Land corporate video, which contemporizes our 135-year-old brand. To me, it epitomizes what you'll hear about the new Hongkong Land strategy, ambitious, dynamic, distinctive and bold. I know most of you in the room, but for those of you who I don't, my name is Michael Smith, and I'm the Chief Executive of Hongkong Land. On stage with me is Craig Beattie, our CFO. A warm welcome to you all, and thank you for joining us this morning. Today, we'll be sharing with you a new strategic direction of Hongkong Land, one of Hong Kong's most iconic businesses with a 135-year legacy tied to the history of this city and the region. We'll go through the core pillars of the strategy, the financial targets we are setting ourselves and how we will create an organizational culture and talent bench that will drive execution of this plan. Ultimately, and most importantly, our aim is to drive improved sustainable growth and in turn, deliver top quartile returns for our shareholders. I want today to be interactive in a two-way dialogue. We'll have plenty of time for questions and answers, whether from the audience here or for those of you online. My first 6 months at the group has been hugely rewarding. I'm very proud of the way in which the team has rallied around the common cause of shaping the future of this great company. As someone who's worked in this industry for way too many years, I've held a deep admiration and respect for Hongkong Land. In my mind, it's the best of blue-chip Asian real estate companies. It has unique world-class assets and developments in three of Asia's greatest cities: Shanghai, Singapore, and of course, Hong Kong. When I became CEO some 30 weeks ago, I commissioned a deep-rooted strategic review of our business. Through that process, we spoke to the internal -- our internal colleagues. We conducted extensive interviews with our external analysts, share stakeholders, analysts, many of you in the room, investors, industry experts, other players, and we did extensive empirical and primary market research. Our aim was to be crystal clear about our competitive advantages, where we are strong compared to our competition and where we should allocate capital to deliver the best returns. The conclusion of that progress -- process is on the screen behind me. Our ambition is to be the leader in Asia's gateway cities focused on ultra-premium integrated commercial properties. And this ambition, this focus, this simplicity taps right into Hongkong Land's core DNA. We bought our first piece of land in Pedder Street just down the road in 1889. This is what we do best, and this is what we really want to continue to doing better. It's based on our 135 years of heritage of delivering world-class integrated commercial properties. There are a few companies that can say that and even fewer who can still push the boundaries through projects like Tomorrow's CENTRAL and our project in West Bund in Shanghai. We will pursue this ambition based on our foundation of clear competitive strength. We are a developer who adopts the highest standards of quality. We build really good buildings, and we manage them really, really well. That's our core competencies. We have a coveted portfolio of over 2,500 premium tenants across the region, there were 2,500 tenants in our portfolio some of whom include the world's leading global and regional corporations and the world's most prestigious luxury retailers. We have highly reputable strategic partners who are like-minded in their integrity and ethos, including our long-standing sister company, Mandarin Oriental, the world's most iconic 5-star hotel brand. We have a brand that travels across geographies in this region with high net worth customers who know us and trust us even through challenging economic times. When we take these strengths together, mapped against a comprehensive assessment of where the growth opportunities are across Asia, it crystallized the core elements of the new strategy we will pursue. Let me outline what those elements are. First, so this is our flywheel that was in our announcement. But firstly, we will strategically focus our growth. That means we will continue to invest in our core gateway cities, Hong Kong, Shanghai and Singapore, but we'll also look for new opportunities in other regional gateway cities. This is a process of following our tenants. If our tenants, if Mandarin, if a luxury retail brand wants to go to a new market, then we should be their capital partner in that new market within Asia Pacific. And we will put our capital into the segment that we know best, the ultra-premium integrated commercial property assets. Secondly, we'll bring in new capital from like-minded partners to invest alongside with us, delivering an improved return on capital. Thirdly, we will recycle up to $10 billion of our balance sheet to fund this growth. This is an internally funded strategy. We're not relying on external funds to achieve our goals. We will stop investing in our build-to-sell business, but are fully committed to completing all existing projects to the highest standards, ensuring continuity and quality. Importantly, achieving this ambition doesn't mean a major capital raise in either debt or equity. This pivot will be fully funded by recycling capital from existing businesses. Fourthly, we are evolving our capital allocation framework with more discipline and an absolute focus on creating shareholder value. That includes establishing our new investment committee at the Board, which we announced earlier this week, the majority of which are independent and highly respected members, including Ming Mei. Thank you all. Craig and I will now share more details of the pillars of our strategy and put flesh on the bone for how we're going to get there. Then we can get into some questions, which I'm sure you all have. Sarah has already asked a few.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveThanks, Michael, and good morning to everybody here. So let me delve a little bit more into some details behind the strategy. So as you can see here, we have four main pillars to the strategy, and I'll take a few minutes to go through each of these in turn. And it's important to note that the four pillars will operate in a continual cycle as we intend to recycle capital and reinvest the proceeds on an ongoing basis. What we'll talk you through this morning are the key points in that strategy and a more detailed information pack will be uploaded to our website following this meeting. So at the core of this strategy is the idea of growth delivered by focusing on our core capabilities, and that is about tapping into the DNA of this business that Michael mentioned, our strong brand and track record of building and managing ultra-premium commercial-led mixed-use portfolios. This is where Hongkong Land's future growth will come from. In terms of where we will invest, we're going to expand our presence in Hong Kong, in Shanghai and in Singapore. And at the same time, we'll explore new opportunities in gateway cities in Asia, diversifying our portfolio geographically. We're not going to go into a lot of details about the cities now, but we see gateway cities as places with blue-chip tenants and luxury customers places that clearly benefit from the flight to quality trends that are being seen in prime real estate markets around the world. And we already have clear examples of developing these projects today. Our USD 1 billion investment here in Hong Kong in Tomorrow CENTRAL, which will rejuvenate our retail offering and bring new office tenant amenities, helping to solidify our market-leading position in Hong Kong, and it's also boosting our economic moat around the central portfolio, providing earnings resilience. And in Shanghai, our West Bund project, which is well underway and has a total developable GFA of 1.1 million square meters. It's a huge project, will really create a brand-new commercial hub in Landmark in Shanghai. And we've already started opening the first phase of that development this year and more to come in the years ahead. And we're already looking at some new growth opportunities, and we look forward to updating you on those shortly. To fund this strategy and generate cash for new investments and shareholder returns, we will actively recycle capital from three main sources. The first is in the build-to-sell inventory wind down. This is a strategic pivot for our business, meaning that no new investments will be made in the build-to-sell segment across the entire region. As residential inventory is sold to end users, surplus cash will come back to us. And the bulk of this capital recycling will happen in the short to medium term. Let me be clear that we are committed to honoring all of our commitments on existing projects, so we will finish everything that we have acquired. And despite market conditions remaining challenging in some places, we've made good progress in continuing to sell our inventory and recycle capital. The second pillar is in divestment of commercial assets for sale, where we will look to divest our medium-term lease assets, which principally comprise lifestyle retail malls in China. These assets will take time to sell as we have several projects under development and leasing performance needs to stabilize before we maximize the proceeds. And finally, third and finally is in mature asset divestments. Here, we intend to become more flexible in recycling mature investment property assets into REITs and other third-party capital vehicles. We're fortunate that we have USD 32 billion of investment property assets on our balance sheet today, and that will grow further as we complete some of our projects in the Mainland. So we actually have a lot of recycling options across the group. While we are targeting $10 billion of capital over the next 10 years, the amounts generated will adjust from year-to-year with a greater share to be realized in the short to medium term. And we estimate $6 billion will come from the wind down of the build-to-sell portfolio and the sale of the medium-term lease assets and a further $4 billion from the recycling of existing investment property assets. Hongkong Land has got a really long track record of successful joint ventures. What will be different with this new strategy is that we will bring in third-party capital in a more disciplined and systematic way alongside Hongkong Land's own equity. We will also look to charge management fees to third-party capital providers during the development and asset management phases, providing Hongkong Land with a new source of recurring income. This approach will support our growth ambitions and also improve returns on equity. We intend to look at a range of third-party capital options depending on where an asset is in its life cycle. And we anticipate Hongkong Land will own a 20% to 50% equity stake in each capital vehicle whilst retaining management control. For our development assets, we will explore adding private funds to our traditional joint venture approach. Here, investors will earn a cash return from the development profits as completed assets will be sold into REIT platforms. Hongkong Land will both earn development profits from its sale to the REIT, but also developers management fees. Capital released from assets vended into a REIT or sold to a fund will be used to finance growth in gateway cities as well as rewarding shareholders through buybacks and growth in dividends. Overall, to achieve our earnings and dividend growth targets, we plan to increase our assets under management from $40 billion today to $100 billion by 2035. And additionally, and importantly, the proportion of third-party capital will rise from just over 20% to nearly 60% by 2035. To drive enhanced capital returns, invest in growth, we're also going to evolve our capital management principles, and there are four main areas here. First, our dividend. We aim for mid-single-digit annual growth in dividends per share, resulting in the doubling of our dividend by 2035 to $0.44 per share. And our projected growth in recurring income will underpin the dividend. Secondly, share buybacks. Here, up to 20% of proceeds from recycled capital may be reinvested in the buyback of shares, subject to investment returns and market conditions. Thirdly, our debt levels. As you all know, we're a prudent and well-managed group, and we will continue to align our debt with our projected annual earnings, ensuring any changes in recurring earnings or capital recycled are accounted for to maintain a strong balance sheet. And finally, our credit rating. We are committed to maintaining our investment-grade credit rating with no anticipated need for a rights issue to fund this new strategy. Altogether, these measures create a solid foundation for Hongkong Land's long-term growth, profitability and value creation for all of our stakeholders. Let me now hand back to Michael, who will go into a bit more detail about the corporate governance changes and organizational transformation before we get into your questions.
Michael Smith
executiveThanks, Craig. One of my goals has been to enhance our decision-making from the Board level to our management team, ensuring that the decisions that we take are aligned with our strategic goals. As you may have seen, we are continuing to make big and important changes at our Board level. We were honored to welcome Ming Mei, the founder of GLP as an Independent Non-Executive Director. Ming brings extensive expertise and experience in the Chinese Mainland market, but also in fund management. His list of LP relationships are very long, which will greatly benefit Hongkong Land. This is our third new INED appointment since 2022, so with Lincoln Leong, and Stuart Grant, who is from Blackstone and Brookfield, ensuring our Board is refreshed with a diverse range of skills and experience. Finally, as announced on Monday, we have a new Chairman, our Taipan, John Witt, in place for our Board. All these changes serve to strengthen our corporate governance and Board oversight. Operationally, we are transitioning to a sector-led organization and reporting structure, a shift that will be supported by the recruitment of new talent and the development of new capabilities. This change is not just about restructuring. It's about aligning our resources and expertise to better meet our strategic objectives. On the talent front, I'm pleased that we have secured a new Chief Investment Officer to enhance our investment and third-party capital capabilities. This is somebody I've worked with for the last 20 years, and she's a force of nature. She'll be a very good addition to the firm. Additionally, we have appointed a new Chief Corporate Officer to help manage our transformation objectives. In 2023, we introduced a minimum shareholding requirement for executive directors to better align management with shareholder interest. And looking ahead, we will announce a long-term incentive plan, which was part of our announcement for our senior leadership will be the first time in 135 years that we will genuinely be aligned to shareholder value, the senior management group. We are dedicated to running a best-in-class business with best-in-class partners, a best-in-class management bench, and all of these changes will help realize this vision. As I opened with our strategic ambition is to be a leader in Asia's gateway cities in luxury-based integrated commercial real estate. That means we focus on what we're good at, what we're known for and where we have unique strengths. Underpinning that ambition is our commitment to enhance capital returns to leverage new funding sources and to deepen strategic partnerships to deliver increased value to our shareholders. Of course, our success will be measured by shareholders assessing our ability to recycle and reallocate capital to drive profit growth, and most importantly, to enhance total shareholder returns. As you can see, we've set ourselves some very ambitious targets. In my 21 years of a real estate banker, I can't recall any other real estate company setting such ambitious targets. But on these fronts, we will double our profits before interest and tax. We'll double our dividends per share. We will grow our AUM to USD 100 billion in a geographically diversified manner with meaningful participation from third-party capital, and we will actively recycle up to USD 10 billion of our balance sheet. While this is a 10-year plan, we are hungry for growth now. For those of you who know me, I'm not a passenger on a train. I like to drive the train. So there's a lot of exciting initiatives that we hope in the short to medium term that we can announce to you. We're very focused on our core business at hand. We'll make sure that Tomorrow CENTRAL retains its vibrancy and attractiveness for business and shoppers. We'll also make sure that West Bund delivers to our very high expectations. In conclusion, this is a really exciting time for our business and for our shareholders. I believe that when we wake up in 2035, our business will be significantly different, but still rightly revered for its exceptional placemaking in Asia's leading gateway cities. Thank you for your continued support, and I look forward to the journey ahead. So let's get to the questions that I'm sure you have. Thank you. questions. I'll stand long enough. Okay. Maybe at the back.
Tsz Ho Wong
analystMichael, this is Sam Wong from Jefferies. I have two questions, if I may. First question is on the acquisition strategy, right? So how are you going to balance the quality of asset and the return? Because in the ideal world, we get both, right? But in reality, for any asset that is comparable with, let's say, the Landmark portfolio, we probably only get 3% cap rate. So how are we going to strike a balance between the two? And then secondly is on the dividend. So with regards to the mid-single-digit dividend target, right? So how front-loaded or backloaded it is? Because I would imagine for the first couple of years, it's more the investment period, right? So should we expect the DBS increment to kick in starting from the upcoming results? Or it's going to be more.
Michael Smith
executiveOkay. There's a lot of questions. So the first one, just so just go back to the first one. So you want us to explain how we are going to invest in this and grow earnings. Okay. So I think the third-party capital piece is really important to us. And the many years that I've had in real estate banking plus in my last job, getting enhanced returns through third-party capital is something that we haven't done before. So that's going to be a big focus of the business in terms of how we can uplift our returns on capital. But you're right, there will be a gestation period. It will take -- these are going to be world-class projects, and there will be a period of time. We are quite lucky that over the next immediate term, we have many assets in China that are going to be completing. So we have some of our Ring series. We have five Ring malls completing next year, different phases of West Bund, so chose is in 2026. So I think the USD 1 billion of rent that we currently get could go to $1.4 billion without doing anything over the short term. So that's very helpful in terms of how we can grow earnings and dividends on the back of that. On the second question, was around.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveYou're asking about the pace of dividend growth. So I think the way that we think about this is that ultimately, what's going to underpin the dividend growth is the growth in recurring income. Michael mentioned that even with our committed portfolio today, so once we complete Tomorrow CENTRAL, the West Bund project in Shanghai fully comes online, we're expecting actually quite solid earnings growth from there, an additional about USD 400 million in recurring income. So we're quite confident that we can start to grow the dividend in the mid-single-digit range in the near term actually. I think the capital recycling piece is also helpful because as we take capital back, there will naturally be a bit of a time delay between taking that back and reinvesting in new opportunities, and we will use that cash in the interim to either return some to shareholders, partly fund the dividend or pay down debt.
Michael Smith
executiveA $0.01 increase in dividend is $22 million. So I think that's something that we can do through all these different avenues, continue to drive the dividend growth over time. There's a few.
Wai Ming Liu
analystThis is Raymond from HSBC. I've got three questions. Maybe the first question is actually about your very ambitious targets as of great this year that like the company is going to improve the profitability, dividend to double in 10 years. So for our expectation, should we expect it's going to be front-end loaded or back-end loaded? This is the first question. And the second question is about the sell and build business. As you mentioned, there could be like $6 billion of recycling and some of that actually will be related to the like divesting or selling the existing inventory. So can you provide us more details of how should we expect? Would there be more like asset sales for the entire project or actually there should be more directly selling all the properties to the home buyers? That will be the second question. And the third question next, like what is actually about like the collaboration with your companies and the entire group. Should we expect like the more collaboration or partnership within your company with other sister company like Astra, [ Tacos ] or even the parent company?
Michael Smith
executiveJust firstly, we will be uploading a presentation, which will have a lot more slides in this. So for the analysts in the room who want to update their models, there will be a lot more coming through...
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveI think I can recall all three questions, so I'll have a go with it. The first one was about, I think, the phasing of the dividends and the earnings, right? I mean I think it's right to say that the doubling of earnings by 2035 is naturally going to be more back-end loaded because if you think about it, we mentioned already that with our committed portfolio, we've got some solid growth coming through. So in terms of the doubling of the incremental dollar, about 40% of that will come from what we're doing in Hong Kong and Shanghai and Singapore already. So I think in the medium term, you should expect to see that coming through. The remaining 60% of the growth will be made up of two parts. About half of it, we anticipate to come from our profit share from investing in new gateway assets, and that will naturally probably happen in the second 5 years of the 10 years. And the further half of the 60% is coming from projection in terms of management fees and the recycling gains from putting things into REIT. So a chunk of that will naturally happen in the second half of the decade. The dividend is a different story. I think here, we are looking for sustainable growth. So we are making a commitment to reward shareholders really commencing from the near term on that piece. So I think that was the first question. I must admit I've forgotten the second one.
Michael Smith
executiveWhy don't I get the second? So your question was around the residential development build to sell. Just in terms of that business model, if you think about any residential developer, you need to keep feeding it. So whatever profits are generated from residential development, you tend to have to use those profits and go out and buy more land. We're -- as you saw on that slide, across 55 projects across different parts of Asia. And in all of those, when the project is finished and we've sold the inventory, we'll go out and buy more land. The decision here is not to go out and buy more land. So we're not spending that incremental dollar in the future of going out and buying more residential build-to-sell land. And by doing -- making that decision as all of the inventory is winding down and coming back, that's the pivot. I mean that's really -- it's a great opportunity for us because that capital has never really come back. It's always been reinvested back into the business. So by making the announcement of no longer investing in that business enables us to bring back literally billions of dollars of inventory as it sells. I think that really underpins a lot of that capital recycling.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveA typical residential project naturally recycles within 3 to 5 years. So I mean, we've moderated our investment in the residential business generally in the last 2 years because of market conditions. So if you think about it, we're actually well through that sort of cycle. That's why I said earlier that we anticipate a lot of the capital recycling to be more front-end loaded from the residential piece because it will naturally come back. I think the third piece was on collaboration with the broader Jardine Group, Michael?
Michael Smith
executiveYes. So at our Board, we had a 2-day Board session last week, which was amazing. It was a really great endorsement of what we're talking to you about today. At that Board session, Laurent Kleitman, the new CEO of Mandarin Oriental and I presented together, which is I think the first time that we've been together in front of the Board, but it was a real commitment of how we're going to collaborate. So in terms of the group companies and Jardines, I think there's a huge opportunity for Mandarin Oriental and ourselves to grow together. That could be Mandarin branded residences. We're not getting out of the residential business. if it's part of an integrated complex and there's a Mandarin branded residence, we can transfer some of our residential development capability there. What we're not going to do is to buy an individual piece of land and build a condo. So it's a slightly different format. Our CRM programs, there's just a whole lot of ways that I think we can do more and grow each other's business. So that's probably out of the Jardine Group. Obviously, we do a lot with Jardines just in terms of everything else. But in terms of the entities within Jardines, I think there's a lot to do with Mandarin.
Unknown Analyst
analystJust want to get if there's a little bit more color regarding the USD 4 billion of capital that you plan to be recycled and maybe perhaps into REITs versus also the medium-term assets -- medium-term lease assets in China. Is that split between the two buckets out of that 4 trillion -- sorry, 4 billion. And related to that is, I think a common investor question this morning has been a lot of the Hong Kong REITs and also even Singapore REITs are trading at discounts to book value. Does it mean that you'll be prepared to sell at discount to book when you try to inject these into REITs or that may confine -- limit your choice of perhaps Singapore valuations a bit better compared to Hong Kong's valuations?
Michael Smith
executiveWhy don't I start and then you supplement. Firstly, we have USD 32 billion of IP assets. Many of our peers over the last 20 years have moved their IP assets into REITs. If you think of a place like Singapore, most of Orchard Road now is in REITs. I think we have one of the last $5.2 billion portfolios of office assets sitting in Singapore that are not in a REIT. So there are -- the fact that we've never done a REIT before gives us a lot of opportunity. There's a nascent REIT market in China. Ming Mei has GLP REIT, so he's already listed a REIT in China. He has a J-REIT. There's a lot of opportunities for us to look at the different REIT markets and see where the best opportunities are for us. But it's not lost on me that the NBFC One Raffles Link, we built that with Chongqing and Keppel. Their 2/3 are both now being put into REITs. And when they were put in REITs in 2012, they've both made about $250 million of fees on their assets. We haven't, and we've owned 1/3 of those. So just an observation, but it's not lost on us that that's probably not the wisest decision not being in a REIT.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveMaybe another observation just to round it out. I mean, I think as we all know, Hongkong Land is trading at about 70% discount to NAV, which kills us. So I mean, whilst the REITs in Singapore are trading at a discount, it's a narrower discount, as you know. So I mean, we're not under any pressure to do anything unless the market conditions are supportive. But I think there are opportunities to create value.
Michael Smith
executiveAnd my career has been a REIT evangelist, so Link REIT and [indiscernible] and a few others. So there's different many ways that we could think about doing REITs without having to sell at a discount. Sarah? This is [indiscernible]
Unknown Analyst
analystSo your stock price has opened up 10.5%...
Michael Smith
executiveOh, great.
Unknown Analyst
analystSo it's not quite as [indiscernible] Congratulations, and thank you for caring. I guess I just wanted to clarify, Craig, what you said before. So the REIT/funds plan might be sort of further down in the piece. And then maybe a question for Mike. Just in terms of how you think about -- I mean, you called out Singapore and those assets, and I think that makes a lot of sense. But how will you make the decision between -- I presume funds are going to give you a better price ever than a REIT unless things change substantially. So will we ever get a REIT? And then how will you decide which assets go in and which stay? So would we see, for example, Landmark go into a fund or a REIT? And would you let go of that? Or are some of them untouchable that's going to stay on balance sheet?
Unknown Executive
executiveIt's very good question.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveI think on the timing, I was talking about the phasing. I was referring more to profits. So in terms of the capital recycling and the establishment of third-party capital, we're starting that now. So I think we need to start that now, Sarah or else we'll never get to our double profit ambitions, frankly. So I think as a team, we're very focused on near-term events and priorities. So I mean, that's just to sort of maybe guide you a little bit as to where we're focusing our time and energy.
Michael Smith
executiveTo be -- in my mind, to be a good steward of capital, we should -- there should be no holy grails. There should be no crown jewels. The fact though with Tomorrow CENTRAL, we are spending a lot of money as our tenants to grow that. So there's a big development process that will be ongoing for that. But there are other parts of our portfolio in Hong Kong, we value every 6 months by Jones Lang. That valuation is out there very publicly. If somebody wanted to come and speak to us about that value or a premium, we shouldn't ignore it. So I think that's trying to answer the question is that there should be no holy grails. And our valuations are out there. Everyone knows what we expect to receive for our properties. Okay. I think you've been putting your hand up a bit.
Mark Leung
analystThis is Mark Leung from UBS. I think a few questions on my side is. I think, number one, we are still focusing on maybe great office, luxury retail, residential and hospitality. Just want to check what is the new yield on new development yield on cost we are expecting if we are started to invest in right now. I think that's the first question. And second question is regarding on the company because I think for asset-light model, it will require a lot of development opportunities, right? Do you see there's a lot of development opportunities in different Asian gateway city CBD areas. You mentioned maybe Shanghai, Hong Kong and Singapore. What kind of example of Asian gateway city you are looking at? I think my last question is, I'm not sure can maybe management can refuse or explain why we set the target maybe on AUM growth is above maybe $100 billion and why the profit is going to be double by that time. Is there any rationale behind, for example, what kind of management fee we are going to -- aiming to collect from a fund level, et cetera?
Michael Smith
executiveDo you want to answer that?
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveSo I think the -- in relation to the first point around returns, I mean, clearly, it depends on which location we're focused on. I mean, cap rates, people naturally tend to focus on the central portfolio being sort of very prime 3%. But if you look around the region, there are opportunities for higher yield. And I think as Michael mentioned, from our point of view, that type of return can be boosted by being more proactive in terms of how we finance the project and also look to recycle the capital during the project. Historically, Hongkong Land has acquired a piece of land, built the building and held it for generations and has created value over the long term doing that. But I think in this way, we will boost our returns by being more flexible about vending assets as we develop them into REITs or other platforms and then taking a yield there. So I think the returns will fluctuate depending on market conditions and the city that we look at because there are different return dynamics depending on where we're going. I think in terms of the cities that we're looking at, we mentioned the three that we're in today. I think in Hong Kong, we are investing in Tomorrow CENTRAL. And in terms of that incremental investment return that Hongkong Land is going to get from that is actually very compelling. I think we spoke about that at the time when we announced -- and in Shanghai, we've obviously invested a lot in West Bund, and we're starting to complete that in phases there. But I think in the other cities, I mentioned a little bit about blue-chip tenants and luxury customers in really key gateway cities. So it's not that much of a surprise that places like Tokyo and Sydney are kind of under review, but no decision has been taken. And so we just need to keep looking at those markets generally.
Michael Smith
executiveYes. Look, we're not naive about how difficult it will be to enter new gateway cities. Some of the -- if it's Tokyo or Seoul or Sydney, I mean, they're very well provided for by very large developers. But I think some of our unique opportunities is Mandarin Oriental. We know that Mandarin has one Mandarin in Tokyo. I think they'd probably like to have two. And if they had two, I'd love to be part of it. So I think there's opportunities for us to follow some of our luxury retail brands. We've had opportunities on the back of how well they know us here and how long we've had a relationship with them. So I think that follow our tenant strategy is something quite unique to us. But also, we're going to have some pretty good examples to show people. We're going to be able to show them Tomorrow CENTRAL, we'll be able to show them West Bund and we'll be able to show what we've done in Singapore, which are pretty good landmarks to be able to use as case studies as to why we think we're the right party to come into an urban regeneration area or whatever that might be. And then secondly, for us, there's also always opportunities for us to think about how strategically we can expand our core. We've got -- besides our core three markets, we've got a great project in Wangfujing in Beijing. If an adjoining site came up to that and we could add scale to that project, we would. So it's not just about buying a brand-new greenfield site. It's how we can build more from what we already have and maybe expand the focus that we have on that particular project. Did we miss a question? Was there three?
Unknown Analyst
analyst[indiscernible]
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveYes. So I'm not going to disclose the sort of management fees that we've modeled out there. But I think what we've done is we obviously know the fees that are typical in the market. So I think as I said earlier, we're looking to earn fees in a few ways. First of all, development fees. So as we find new projects that will be developed, we'll find capital partners that will pay us a fairly modest fee, I guess, in terms of on the asset value, but a fee nonetheless. We'll then also look to vend that completed asset into, say, a REIT or other fund structure and look to earn management fees throughout that period there. So actually, over time, as we build scale in this strategy, we are looking for a fairly reasonably sized management fee income stream to start to come through. So of that doubling of profit that we modeled out in the next sort of 10 years, I would say about 15% of that incremental dollar is sort of assumed to come from management fees.
Michael Smith
executiveMy intention is that we never do a joint venture again without getting paid for it. We provide all the expertise, all the branding, everything, and we're not getting paid for it. That just doesn't make any sense to me. So we're going to make sure we get paid for our worth.
Xinyuan Li
analystThis is Cindy from Citi. So three questions. One is on your long-term incentive plan. So is there any more color on the details of that? And I'm specifically curious about your mention of making to your share price. So exactly how does that work? Would you consider a share incentive plan? So this is the first question. And the second question is also on your portfolio concentration, say, with $100 billion AUM. We expect 70%, 80% still concentrating in Hong Kong, Singapore, Shanghai or a much more fragmented exposure by them? And the third question is on your third-party investment team. I think you mentioned earlier you have onboard a new Chief Investment Officer. How about the team set up? And when, say, do you say, plan to start, say, meeting with third-party investors and start to -- the whole process?
Michael Smith
executiveOkay. We purposely put the LTIP statement in the announcement, which is good. But we hope more is more. We really want to be aligned to everyone in this room. We want to be aligned to shareholder value creation and share price. So that's something that's never been put in place in Hongkong Land. And I think it's long overdue, and it's really going to make sure everybody knows that the days of us just focusing on dividend and not really worrying about share price are gone. We're all going to be absolutely committed. I've told the team that every morning, I want them to wake up and look at the share price and every evening wake up and all through the day, look at the share price. I mean that's what I want everyone to be driven by a real performance-based culture. And the LTIP will help us, I think, all on the same journey together to drive the share price. Sorry, the second question?
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveSecond bit is about a diversified portfolio. Maybe if I sort of answer that a little bit. I think you saw on the slide that we're aiming to have no greater than 40% PBIT coming from any one particular city, and there's a particular reason for that. When you look at the share price of Hongkong Land over the very, very long term, it's very much correlated to Hong Kong prime office rents. And a key part of this strategy is to really look to grow and diversify our portfolio so that we have a more balanced portfolio across different cities. And ultimately, we want to -- as much as we love Hong Kong, we would like our share price to be influenced by a range of factors rather than just one. So that's really where we're coming from about the diversification point. And then I think the final point was around team.
Michael Smith
executiveYes. So our Chief Investment Officer has left the company that she is current -- what she was previously, and she's announced that, and she's on gardening leave, and she will be joining in January 6. And then at that point, I mean, there's already some people we've got in the team that will be working with her, but she's got a big job ahead because we've got big ambitions. But I think she's up to it. And she's really good at doing what she does. She's got great relationships. And working with Ming Mei, he's on our investment committee. So our future investment committee is John Witt, Ming Mei and Stuart Grant, just a fantastic group of people that can help us drive that business.
Unknown Analyst
analystI have three questions. The first question is relating to -- is related to the China exposure. On one hand, you sell down your build to sell segment in China, mainly in China. But on the other hand, based on the principle, now this doesn't prevent you from investing in the key gateway city in China. So what should we think about the China exposure, say, after 10 years? Second question is related to the asset recycling. You intend to recycle capital up to 4 billion from the mature asset. Can you achieve this goal without, say, unlocking value of central portfolio or monetization of the central portfolio is the key to the asset recycling. The third question is relating to the investment mandate. You mentioned that you would like to invest in the key gateway city in the CBD. Based on this principle, would you invest in, say, in Hong Kong, in case of Hong Kong, outside of Central such as Causeway Bay?
Michael Smith
executiveOkay. And just with our China business. To be clear, we've made a decision to no longer be in the build-to-sell residential business across the region. This is not a China, although we do have a big exposure in China, this is not China specific. This is a pivotal decision away. We're not going to invest the incremental dollar in that business. We're going to complete what we obligated to complete to the same standards that we have always produced, but we're not putting the incremental dollar into that business. But in terms of China, West Bund is an USD 8 billion project. Suzhou has a Mandarin Oriental and a lot of luxury brands have already signed up. Chongqing also has a lot of luxury brands signed up. And Beijing, Wangfujing, we've had for 6 years. It's got a Mandarin and a whole bunch of really great retail tenants. So those are, in my mind, assets that qualify for luxury based or ultra, ultra premium that we will want to hopefully stay with forever. So we're not, by any means, leaving China. I think the addition of all of those assets is in excess of USD 10 billion or something thereabout. So...
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveYes, it's still a very meaningful portfolio, and actually, it's a core part of our future earnings. So I mean, I think you're right to say that it's Mainland China remains an area of focus, albeit in key gateway cities. So there are not many cities that we will proactively look to expand, but they're still an important part of it overall. I think the second point was around Hong Kong assets. And can you achieve the USD 4 billion without selling some of Hong Kong? I mean I think we've got USD 32 billion of investment properties, of which a large part is Hong Kong. But I think the 4 billion as a percentage up to 32%, it's about 13%. So it's not a huge number overall. I wouldn't expect us to be selling down our Hong Kong portfolio in a big way at all because if you think about it, the success, the economic moat that we have around the portfolio is created because of being together. So the way to think about it and what we tried to allude is with third-party capital is that Hongkong Land will continue to manage all of its investments going forward. We may choose to bring in some investors alongside us, but in terms of the proposition that we offer to our tenants and customers, you shouldn't expect that to change overall.
Michael Smith
executiveSorry, what was your third point? The third point was around...
Unknown Analyst
analystCauseway Bay.
Michael Smith
executiveCauseway Bay. Look, we have USD 24 billion in this portfolio. That's a big concentration. I think this is where our expertise where 1889 when we first started, this is our core business. We are helping our sister company Mandarin with -- for one Causeway Bay with leasing with the property manager, the asset manager, and we'll continue to help them in that regard. But that is their office building.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveI was going to make a comment about Central and Causeway Bay and CBDs, but I won't go there. Maybe, Michael, we should take a couple of questions online as I come through. I think just to be fair to everybody that's written in. Sirius from Bank of America, I think very similar question to you, Sarah, from you. Will Hong Kong portfolio be sold partially or put into a REIT? And I think we've answered that in the room already. A question from [ Hannah Mid at UTOP ]. How and where do you think you can be competitive in new markets outside of Hong Kong, Shanghai and Singapore? Are you just focusing on developments and how do you get scale in each city?
Michael Smith
executiveLook, it's a great question. Again, we're not naive. We know all these cities are very tough. We do have Beijing, and we've also got a great project in Bangkok. We bought the British Embassy many years ago, and we're partnering with Central. Hopefully, that will have a Mandarin residences. It will have a small office tower. It will have some very high-quality luxury retail tenants in there as well. So we're not -- that meets a lot of our -- even though it may not be deemed a gateway city, that meets a lot of our objectives of having an integrated ultra-premium property project. In terms of brand-new markets, we're going to have to study them. We're going to probably have to set up teams. If we're serious about Tokyo, we're going to have some -- a rep office and spend a lot of time understanding that market. But again, ideally, whatever Mandarin does next, we do with them in that city. So that sort of follow the tenant process into these new markets is really critical for us. And really, I think, provides a point of difference that not others may have.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveA good question here, which is not a surprising question from Wen Han at Principal Asset Management. Given that Ming Mei from GLP has just joined, Michael, will Hong Kong Land look to become a logistic properties and data center company going forward?
Michael Smith
executiveWell, I must say in my last life, we acquired about USD 20 billion of data centers and warehouses across U.S. and Europe. So I'd love the asset class, but it's not for us, just to be honest. We have no rule. There's no extension of what we do excellently. If we went into some sort of distant market and bought some warehouse land and told you all that it's Hong Kong land, therefore, it's amazing. It really doesn't echo the same as what we're trying to achieve here. So I also think those sectors are very late cycle. And pretty well everyone I know is a data center expert now. So there's just not a lot of upside for us. And we did with our consultants, look at every single asset class, every single geography. There may be some elements for us to get into some adjacent areas. In Westbound, we have a lot of office buildings, maybe we can convert one to medical office, and that could be something that could complete that ecosystem. We want to think about GBA, there's 110 million people and how GBA evolves over time and be nimble enough to see where the new opportunities are and be at the front of a sort of a new opportunity than rather being at the back end of a cycle. So we have sort of preserved in our sort of balance sheet and projections some capital allocation to being nimble and seeing what's the next thing that really we can go to LPs or go to ourselves and say, this is an extension of what we do best, whatever that may be.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveAny questions from the floor? Raymond. You got a fourth one.
Wai Ming Liu
analystQuestions here. Actually, just a follow up about the comments about the mature assets in your portfolio, which the analyst asked. So like as you mentioned, like Mainland China assets like your Suzhou upcoming Chongqing, those projects, great projects, great potential, become more. So for us, how -- what should we think of like the going forward fund or REIT formation? So should we think of like every asset in your existing portfolio can be put into the like public REIT or private REIT in the coming future or actually some of them only? This is the first question. And the second question is actually about the capital allocation, like because one of the questions you mentioned in the slide is about the buyback. You mentioned about approximately like up to 20% of the recycled proceeds can be paid as a buyback. Can you share a bit more detail on this one where from profit expectation from the asset sales or everything here, can you provide more guidance here? And the last thing is, can you share with us a bit more about like the current valuations of the China property development business here because there were some like impairment charges in the first half this year.
Michael Smith
executiveSo our medium-term lease assets, which have always been earmarked for sale, it's quite a substantial portfolio. That's like USD 3 billion when fully completed. So there's a nascent China REIT market. GLP just happens to have one of the best China REITs, I understand. So there's still, I think, a lot of progress that can be made in that framework, but it will take some time for us to complete and stabilize those assets. But if there was an opportunity to do a China REIT, we've got a great portfolio that's really well built and really well managed that we can sponsor into that. And if not, then it could be a private fund format. We'll have in total eight rings, I think Chongqing is now in place. It's its third anniversary Chengdu is now open and another five will open next year. It's a really neat little portfolio of assets that they really cater well to their local trade area. They don't cater well of our strategy. They're not part of an integrated complex. But as a stand-alone, they could be a great portfolio that could be REIT.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveYou were asking about impairment, I think, as well, which obviously was something that we did at the half year, which was really we reviewed our entire China build-to-sell portfolio given the challenging market conditions -- and you're right, there were a number of projects where we decided proactively to take some noncash write-downs on those. And the reason we did that was because as we continue to do, we adjust the pricing of our inventory to try and encourage sales and recycling. That was quite a comprehensive process, and we're not anticipating any further write-downs in the portfolio unless there are significant deteriorations in the market. But we're hopeful that with the stimulus that's happened in recent weeks and actually, there's been a bit of a positive uptick on our residential sales in the Mainland in the last 2 or 3 weeks. that will -- hopefully, that sort of sets us on the right way. But the whole objective of that was really just to get the capital recycled as proactively as possible.
Michael Smith
executiveThat Golden Week, the first week of October, we tripled the sales that we had done previously in the previous week. So the 1 week was 3x, it's come off again, but that first week was incredibly powerful for the residential sale market. Was there another question?
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveSorry, apologies. Yes. I mean I think the -- we've done a lot of analysis and research about driving shareholder returns. That's been a big part of this review. And the clear takeaway from that analysis is that actually for long-term shareholder return growth, Hongkong Land needs to grow its business. So we can do good things for shareholders like grow the dividends and buybacks, which we are doing, but that by itself is not going to create long-term growth. So our #1 focus is on growing the business. That's why we've outlined the key Gateway City strategy. That's why we're trying to double the profitability. It's really from growth. But I think we also recognize as part of our capital allocation framework that if we look at things, particularly where Hongkong Land share price is trading today, we can't deny that that's an attractive long-term investment for shareholders to think about that. So as we recycle the capital back, and we are focused on recycling the capital in the short to medium term, we are subject to share price and market conditions, looking to invest some of that in the buyback of our shares. So that's really how we kind of think about it. But it really is really driven by returns, Raymond. I mean there needs to be a compelling reason to buy back the shares over time, which we will continue to look at.
Michael Smith
executiveIt's not lost on us, though, to sell an asset at NAV and then buy back stock at a 70% discount. That's a great happy meal, right? I mean that's something that we should be really focused on if we can do that. And hopefully, we can do that.
Unknown Analyst
analystSo Hongkong Land, obviously, has always been known to be a great developer of premium assets. And are you -- since you have laid out this new strategy, do you plan to also acquire third-party asset that's already completed? Or do you still predominantly want to focus on development of new projects? And then the second question is $100 billion AUM, that's a very ambitious target. Would you want to acquire existing other people -- other managers to acquire AUM as part of that strategy?
Michael Smith
executiveYes, great questions. The first one -- the second one, no, I don't think we are in that marketplace. I think we want to organically grow. I think there's enough experience across myself, our new CIO, Ming Mei, that we can organically grow. I think we've got USD 32 billion of IP that can seed funds, both public and private. So I think we've got some unique points of difference that we should be able to organically grow that type of business. And our brand, I think, really does extend into it. Being a steward of third-party capital should be a lot easier for us to do than somebody who's never sort of done real estate before. Sorry, your first question was...
Unknown Analyst
analyst[indiscernible]
Michael Smith
executiveOkay. So look, I think our preference would be to develop. I mean that's what we do best. If our -- if we create REITs, those REITs may go off and do their own acquisitions and they'll have their own board and their own management teams, and we may control the manager or control a big chunk of the equity, but they will go off and do what they may need to do on their evolution and they may, but I think from our perspective, our model would much be better to develop to the quality that we develop. Maybe we bring third parties alongside that development process. We stabilize the assets and then we put those assets into captive vehicles. It's a pretty simple model that's been traded and tested by others, but we've got a lot of assets on our balance sheet, but we have a great development quality. We've got a great brand. I think if we put that together, it would be a really powerful business.
Karl Chan
analystI'm Karl Chan from JPMorgan. First of all, I like how you have our company logo on the picture over there.
Michael Smith
executiveYou noticed that. So you are our biggest tenant in Hongkong Central.
Karl Chan
analystSo just two quick questions. One is about acquisitions and other is about disposal. So for acquisitions, just curious, do you have any like preliminary list or target of acquisitions that you may want to make in the near future? And do you have like a premier list of say, third-party partners that we want to collaborate with? Or would that only be decided in the investment committee later? That's my first question. And the second question is on disposal. How do you think about the appetite in acquiring your assets in perhaps Mainland China like commercial assets? Are we already in touch in some potential buyers on the disposal? And what kind of cap rate that we are thinking about?
Michael Smith
executiveOkay. Look, just in terms of the -- I think we've done an amazing job. I've been on Board for 212 days and to be able to get to where we are now with quite a significant pivot, quite significant decisions made, full Board endorsement, rebranding, all of the things that we've achieved. So now we can get on with our day jobs after this, hopefully, and execute on the plan. Bringing our Chief Financial Officer on, I think, will be...
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveChief Investment Officer.
Michael Smith
executiveBringing the Chief Investment Office. And I think at that point, she's going to be able to bring along a lot of LP capital, particularly across this part of the world, a lot of sovereign wealth, a lot of insurance companies who we can at least start the debate and start the discussion is how we can collaborate. But look, we're not going to just wait for 12 months to do this. There's a lot of initiatives. As I mentioned that we want to announce as quickly as we can that supports what we're doing. I don't want this to be just a theoretical, this is who we're going to be. I want to be able to have announcements out on a regular basis saying, we said we'd do this and this is what we're doing. So that's really important. Your second question?
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveMaybe just on the investment committee side that you mentioned, I think that is an important part of it. So engaging and working with our investment committee is a key part of the strategy going forward. I mean a couple of weeks ago, we had 2 days with the Board, and we went through all the strategy. We went through some early ideas and the Board is fully supportive, but we do need to work through that sort of methodical process. So there's a few things in the pipeline, but yes, we'll need to go through that process.
Michael Smith
executiveAny from the...
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveOkay. I'll throw you this hot potato. Thank you. [ Highway from UOB ], talking about the collaboration between Mandarin Oriental and Hongkong Land going forward. And obviously, we're going to be working more closely together. Is there a possibility of the two entities doing something more concrete by merging?
Michael Smith
executiveGood question. Look, I think Mandarin actually was spun out of Hongkong Land many, many, many years ago. So we are and we continue to be incredibly close. There's a lot of areas of cooperation. Laurent has been on board for 12 months as an external hire. I've been on board for just over 6 -- we really want to collaborate. But that's what we want to do is collaborate. We think there's a lot of opportunity for us to be a capital provider as their business grows when an operating -- we already own four Mandarins. I think we own Jakarta, Macau, Landmark and Beijing. We're building five Mandarins. So we'll have 9 Mandarins on our balance sheet over -- by 2027. So maybe we can be third-party capital around that and maybe we can help them do other third-party capital. But that doesn't necessarily mean any type of merger. I think we want to elevate each other's businesses, and we think there's a lot of ways that we can do that.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveA couple of questions online from Alvin at CLSA, who's asking about the buyback and the timing of it. And I think I've addressed that question already. So hopefully, Alvin, you're happy with that. And then a question from Jagdeep and Naveen. It's a good question. Many of your industry peers listed in the region have also strategically pivoted towards introducing third-party capital and funds management. These companies have struggled to actually introduce new capital partners and grow AUM, particularly those with assets in China. What sets Hongkong Land's strategy and ambition apart?
Michael Smith
executiveIt's a great question. And it's a new business, and it's going to take a lot of my time and focus, our new CIO's focus. We wanted to get a lot of help from our investment committee, Stuart Brown and Ming Mei. I think our brand is quite unique, 135 years of history of being a steward of tenants, 2,500 tenants, USD 32 billion of investment property. I actually think by being late into this and having the team that we're going to assemble around us, we'll actually add. We know how important it is in Ming Mei, in particular, at the Board meeting that if we go and become a third-party capital -- steward of third-party capital, we have to be -- we have to asset manage, property manage lease even better than we do now. We have to really elevate because we're managing third-party capital. So I think there's a whole sort of cultural change and strategy change that we need to be part of as part of this journey. But we're not naive. And I've been around a while. I know how these things work, and I think we're going to make it a success.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveBut I think it's also a credibility. I mean, without touching too much on others, I mean, we have very strong pedigree and thinking operating prime, prime properties. So having a very clear strategy about why we -- who we want to be, but also having the existing relationships with many of our tenants and partners already in place is also very important. I think starting from that strong position really does help us stand out.
Michael Smith
executiveAs Sarah said, the good man of ultra-premium possibly. Mark?
Unknown Analyst
analystOther questions, maybe specifically for Michael because I think you have a really long experience in industrial and logistics data center in terms of how the asset-light is running. But for Hongkong Land, we are going to have a different asset class, right, maybe like retail and luxuries. What do you think will be the biggest challenges going forward for you to execute this kind of asset-light strategy?
Michael Smith
executiveNo, that's a great question. I think that the type of investor needs to be quite nuanced, right, because we need to have investors, LPs who want to come alongside us who really truly appreciate our brand and our expertise and what we can do. I think it's going to have to be much more longer-dated capital, maybe lower cost of capital that knows that we're building something unique, and we can sit there and show Hongkong Tomorrow CENTRAL and West Bund and what we've done in Singapore and so we can do this. And if you want to be part of this for a long-term journey, we should be your partner. So I do think it's the type of investor. I guess, logistics, other asset classes, they're more sort of high-yielding, higher total return. I think the investors that we're going to have to attract will have to be more longer-dated, more sovereign wealth type people who want to be associated with these type of quality projects. I think unless there is anything further, Craig and I are going to stay around. There is a little booklet that we're all going to hand you all so you can all put in your pocket, which is -- we had a branding consultant, DNCO, who we have taken from London, who's never worked in Asia before and has been fantastic, was responsible for the video, responsible for putting JPMorgan there, by the way. But she -- they had put this little booklet together, which sort of explains and encapsulates who we are, who we want to be, and hopefully, you can put in your pocket and take away and read about it. And we'll have thousands of them distributed, I think, is the plan. So I think you're going to be handing out of the door, right? But otherwise, we're going to stay around and happy to mingle and chat and look forward to the future. And thank you for attending.
Craig Alan Beattie
executiveThank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Hongkong Land Holdings Limited transcript — plus 256,000+ transcripts from 12,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Hongkong Land Holdings Limited earnings transcripts and 256,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $24.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Hongkong Land Holdings Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.