Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp. (MCB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 21, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 51 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#1

I appreciate that, Brittany, and I'm grateful for the introduction. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to MCB's first-ever public earnings call. If MCB is already on your radar, thanks for joining us. And if this is your initial look at MCB, welcome aboard. Greg and I will probably take a few additional minutes today to walk through how MCB performed during 2021, along with certain corporate developments we feel deserve attention. Looking ahead, though, our hope is that calls like this one can take on a more strategic character and spark dialogue about strategy, direction, opportunities, challenges, and so forth; so with that, let's get the meeting underway. At 22 years old as a company, and having posted profits across 21.5 years of operations, we've faced plenty of challenges; and I take pride in saying that we remain well prepared, which clears the path toward ongoing sustained performance. If MCB is familiar to you, you should — and if MCB is new to you, you should keep thinking of us as two companies rolled into one. To begin with, MCB is a well-diversified, core-funded organic growth company that aims to rank among the top performing middle market commercial banks. And then there's our Global Payments Group, or GPG, a well-established banking-as-a-service provider serving the fintech industry, with the objective of substantially disrupting and transforming retail banking. MCB feels very lucky to have enjoyed such a first mover advantage when working alongside fintechs. We set up banking as a service more than 10 years ago. Some might argue, and indeed some have argued, that we arrived a bit early. But it's gratifying to watch the industry catching up to MCB. So if our quarterly investor presentation isn't something you've seen yet, I'd urge you to pull it up online. It will provide a highly granular view of precisely what MCB is as a franchise. I'll now cover just a handful of full year financial highlights, which I see as partly the bedrock of MCB's consistent, long-term, and sustainable performance. Revenue during 2021 rose 27.3%. Non-interest expense climbed 17.2% year-over-year. I mention this because it matters. Since MCB has never stopped being a growth company, we have consistently devoted significant investment to technology and human capital. What's genuinely fascinating, and has been for several years now, is that these investments turn — these investments convert into a return on investment remarkably fast in today's environment. These investments today are really about sustaining growth along with the scalability and the efficiency of MCB. Our efficiency ratio fell to 48.3% from 52.5% year-over-year. It's worth noting that MCB is an organic (ph) growth company. We don't buy portfolios, loan portfolios, and the loan participations we do for other banks amount to an insignificant figure. Total loans rose 19% year-over-year. Asset quality remains very strong. Even though MCB has consistently been a growth-oriented company, our attention has shifted even more toward what we owe on the balance sheet. And MCB's core business strategy has consistently centered on operating as a branch-light franchise. Year-over-year, deposits climbed 68%, which equals $2.6 billion, and within that, DDA rose 112%, or $1.9 billion. For the full year, our total cost of funds came to 31 basis points, while the quarter stood at 28 basis points. Having scalable, inexpensive funding gives us considerable shelter in what we refer to as margin management. Turning to the banking-as-a-service group, GPG, revenues increased 94.3% compared with the prior year. Eight new fintech clients joined the portfolio during 2021, against six during 2020. In 2021, transaction volumes reached $92.5 million, a 70% rise year-over-year. The dollar volume underlying those transactions came to $22.1 billion, up 212% year-over-year; that alone reveals the kind of market share — early market share — that fintech is capturing from commercial banking. GPG's deposit growth year-over-year amounted to $1.5 billion, or 297%, and $104 million net of crypto, or 27%. Even though MCB moved early on banking-as-a-service, we sit in an ideal position to gain materially from the market share fintech keeps seizing from the biggest money center banks down to the smallest community banks. We anticipate fintech will keep outspending traditional banks on research and development and client acquisition; consequently, we will generate meaningful financial gains for MCB. Return on average tangible common equity for the full year reached 15.2%, affected by a successful follow-on common equity raise in late September 2021 that brought in $163 million net of offering cost. Without that capital raise, return on average tangible common equity would have come in at 17.1%. MCB has constructed an asset sensitive balance sheet, which over the past two decades has proven bulletproof, as we like to say, in guarding against extreme prolonged interest rate conditions. So, with great confidence in our asset quality, a higher rate environment will reward MCB's already strong earnings franchise. I want to share some corporate news during this initial call, since I believe it matters for our existing shareholders, the analyst community and possibly new shareholders to completely grasp all that we're working on, not merely the business lines. During 2020, we launched a major initiative exploring new technology solutions to replace our core; we completed an RFI and, more recently, an RFP, and ideally within the coming few months we'll reach a final decision. The result we anticipate is a genuine digital transformation of MCB, bringing a fintech client experience to our commercial bank clients along with more efficient technology integration with GPG's clients. There's much more to come on this later. We set up a portfolio management office for GPG in Louisville, Kentucky. Louisville, Kentucky looks like an excellent hub for the payment space. We're awaiting the opening of our loan production office in Lakewood, New Jersey. We've had a presence in Lakewood, New Jersey for a long stretch, and we hold substantial assets along with deposits under management there. Yet as its population grows, residential housing gets built out, commercial projects move forward, and businesses relocate, we keep seeing — and therefore anticipate — chances that pay off well for MCB. MCB is moving its Broadway Manhattan financial center over to the Northwest corner of 40th Street. I bring that up since this branch specifically is going to deliver a state-of-the-art, technology friendly experience to our retail clients. MCB has opened a loan production office in Brickell, Miami, Florida. MCB has conducted business in the State of Florida, and we hold substantial assets along with deposits under management there. Even so, we believe the state holds additional opportunity for us. At the same time, given how values have risen there, we believe the moment has come to exercise even greater caution regarding the growth we pursue in the State of Florida; so having what we refer to as boots on the ground matters to us for managing that risk too. MCB took on a 50,000 square foot expansion of our corporate offices at 99 Park Avenue. From a technology standpoint these offices are state-of-the-art, and they're built around bringing clients in to visit us. I'm happy to say that client meetings happen constantly. We have successfully negotiated loan term favorable occupancy expense with three out of our six retail locations besides our corporate offices; this initiative mattered for gaining some control over the next decade in our non-interest expense; to wrap up, I couldn't be happier with the scalable and sustainable growth company that MCB has been for many years. I take pride in the fact that we recognized banking's transformation taking root over a decade ago and got ready to work alongside it rather than ignore it. MCB stands well prepared to carry on the profitable organic growth of the commercial bank while delivering banking-as-a-service through our fintech industry, which keeps taking market share. I'll now hand the meeting over to Greg, who serves as our CFO.

Greg Sigrist

executive
#2

Mark, thanks, and good morning everyone. We finished the year strongly, posting $18.9 million in net income for the fourth quarter, equal to $1.69 per fully diluted share. Momentum has built as we continue leveraging our balance sheet's strength and growth to drive net interest income. Additionally, client transaction volumes in our global payments segment keep expanding, fueling impressive gains in banking-as-a-service revenues within that division. Deposits grew $978 million, or 18%, this quarter, mainly from non-interest bearing accounts, which comprised 57% of total deposits at year's end. Crypto deposits nearly doubled this quarter to $1.5 billion; retail and GPG's credit card related deposits also saw double-digit increases. Overall, our deposit mix stays nicely diversified with core accounts. Total cost of funds dropped 3 basis points this quarter to 28 basis points, helped by targeted deposit repricing. Loan originations totaled $411 million this quarter, up from a solid $313 million in the third quarter. This expansion was broad-based, particularly in owner-occupied, commercial real estate, and C&I. Our pipeline remains robust across the entire book. Looking ahead, we expect 2022 loan growth to match our historical rates. Several credit-related items changed this quarter. One involved charging off a shared national credit we'd heavily reserved for back in 2020, plus selling three other shared national credits at a minimal loss. We aimed to make all that clear in the earnings release. Also, we had one commercial real estate loan, around $10 million, on non-accrual at year end, and it paid off in January. Consequently, non-performing loans are now at a negligible level going forward. Another point: that single $10 million loan, which was in full payment deferral at year's close, shifted to principal-only deferral in January. So, full payment deferrals are behind us, and we're entering the new year with a very clean balance sheet and credit portfolio. We've made significant progress moving the securities portfolio closer to our 15% of total assets target. This quarter, we added $334 million to it, with most new purchases going into the held to maturity portfolio, bringing securities to 13.4% of total assets at quarter's end. Meanwhile, overnight deposits have impacted our net interest margin. This quarter, loan yields benefited from unusually high fees related to loan payoffs. Without those, loan yields would have remained around 465 basis points. Securities yields also increased due to late-quarter purchases, and we recognized $344 million in related gains. Beyond the additional buys we intend to complete, returns from our securities book should continue to strengthen going forward. The substantial excess cash we hold has suppressed our net interest margin, but we regard those liquidity reserves as a key driver of value for shareholders. In particular, net interest income was up 10% compared with the quarter before. Going forward, our strong liquidity position means we are set up nicely to deploy money into loans and securities. Then there's the lift we would receive from rising rates, given how asset-sensitive we are on the whole. With that in mind, I'd ask you to go to Page 15 in our investor deck, which shows our estimated sensitivities as of December 31st. At MCB, an upward parallel rate shock of 100 basis points works out to 7.7% in year one. That number assumes a static balance sheet — something that, naturally, never occurs in practice. The scenario likewise incorporates a conservative deposit beta of 70%. And if you believe the additional liquidity parked in the broader banking system will drive deposit betas down once rates begin rising — well, under an upward parallel rate shock of 100 basis points, a deposit beta of 20% would generate a 14.7% gain in year one. Non-interest income increased substantially this quarter, as banking-as-a-service revenue from GPG grew 34% for the quarter on far higher transaction volumes. Our capital levels remain very strong, with each capital ratio sitting comfortably above well capitalized thresholds. At year end, our Tier 1 leverage ratio was 8.5%, which does capture the benefit from our common equity raise in September. With the capital raise now successfully finished, we are focused on deploying that capital and our excess liquidity efficiently, with the goal of lifting return on average tangible common equity to the net fees levels or above; and with a fourth quarter ROATCE of 13.9%, we are progressing well toward that objective. Let me take a moment to highlight one additional priority for this year. The emerging growth company status we've had since our 2017 IPO will expire later this year, and we expect to become an SEC large accelerated filer. One significant result of these changes will be our requirement to adopt CECL in 2022, by the time we file our 10-K early next year. We've accomplished a good deal on that adoption. That work began before we could run it alongside the incurred loss model currently in use. As a result, we still cannot offer any guidance on what CECL will mean for MCB. Even so, the commercial portfolio we carry is high quality and shorter in duration, and over our 20 year history it has seen only a modest level of net charge offs. What we lack are longer duration portfolios or consumer oriented ones — the kinds that typically suffer the most once CECL is adopted. Separately, $344 million. We will get back to you at the appropriate time regarding what effect adoption is expected to have. Also, at this point I’m going to return the call to Mark.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#3

Thanks, Greg. As I mentioned at the outset, MCB is essentially the combination of two operating companies into one. We're fully confident that the commercial bank will continue to be counted among the top-performing institutions, and it will stay relevant as this industry continues to transform. Although we were quite early with the banking-as-a-service business, fintech is still in its very early innings, and we believe that our existing infrastructure, our industry knowledge and our strong working relationship with regulators, who will continue to materially benefit from the market share, fintech continues to take from the banks of all sizes. I'd now like to hand the call over to our operator for Q&A.

Alex Lau

analyst
#4

Hi. Good morning.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#5

Good Morning, Alex.

Alex Lau

analyst
#6

To begin with a commercial bank, I'd like you to clarify what you said regarding expanding loans at the historical pace. Since this is year two, MCB's loan growth has been just under 20% each year. Do you believe that growth rate can continue, and what would you call the historical rate? Also, you referred to robust loan pipelines. How does that stack up against twelve months ago? Thank you.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#7

Yeah. I'd say — I have no hesitation stating that you could gauge historical patterns as falling between 15% and 20%. As you're aware, Alex, we're extremely cautious, and the chances are available. Our pipeline is robust, and the starting point for Q1 annualized plainly shows that 20% is well within reach. My feeling is that should we opt not to hit 20%, it would be due to market conditions rather than a lack of opportunity before us.

Alex Lau

analyst
#8

Thanks.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#9

Hey there. Yes. Morning to you, sirs.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#10

Hello, Chris.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#11

Good quarter. So to kick things off, I wanted to focus on GPG growth in this quarter, which was obviously fueled by the digital currency channels, on both the fee side and the deposit side. I was just hoping to get some detail on what particular drivers were behind that outsized growth this quarter. And if there's any level of volatility in this quarter's growth that we should anticipate some pullback from as we move into Q1 of '22, or if this is fairly sticky going forward? Thanks.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#12

Yeah. Like I mentioned, Chris, we're at an industry stage that's so early — early innings, as they say in baseball. And I'd say nothing out of the ordinary happened in the quarter. It was pretty broad based. I pointed to Page 14 of our investor deck, where you can see the growth by-product set across the various fintech verticals; and then, naturally, I think the revealing story is actually on Page 13, which simply demonstrates just how much market share fintech is taking from banks. And we're only discussing the transactions running through MCB, not as an industry, so I would anticipate this could keep going. As I said in my remarks, I expect fintech to keep outspending in research and development and also now in client acquisition, since they are out in the market — grabbing market share. And I expect these trends to persist without any interruption actually.

Greg Sigrist

executive
#13

Yes, and Chris, one more point I'd like to make: clearly, if you examine how the revenue trends are moving, money coming in from those accounts holding crypto alongside a general purpose reloadable card rose during the quarter. We saw gains across several areas, but what matters most here, I believe, is remembering that this isn't merely a transaction account for folks moving into and out of crypto — it genuinely reflects activity in those accounts occurring beyond that ecosystem as well. So going forward, that's a point worth keeping in mind.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#14

Right, Greg. That matters a great deal, since when you examine certain firms we work with that might look like they're purely crypto, that isn't actually the case — they're broadening what they offer into a wider spectrum of financial services. And we bring those financial services to market on their behalf. So, as Greg noted, you'll find the revenue drivers at these companies growing beyond crypto too.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#15

Great. I value the detail you provided; and I just want to follow up on it — I especially appreciate what you said about long-term growth and how it's coming from several different places; but clearly, the big increase in the crypto segment this quarter stood out as really strong. And digital currency prices and volumes have been sort of declining since the beginning of the year here. So if you could just give us, like what the sensitivity is to the broader market when it comes to those revenues and deposits, that would be great?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#16

Chris, as we've discussed for a good while now, a correlation exists when investors believe digital assets will rise in value — deposits fall and transaction volumes climb, which means higher revenue. When investors believe digital assets will drop in value, deposits go up, transaction volumes increase and we bring in more revenue as a traditional trading platform. As you know, we settle those buy and sell of digital assets; so I have no forecast for where digital assets will settle in ‘22 when it comes to their value. The only thing I can say is that we're well positioned to diversify their product set or essentially be the beneficial owner of opportunity when there is volatility in the value of digital assets as a trading platform.

Greg Sigrist

executive
#17

Yes. And Chris, one more point I want to make regarding deposits. You might remember that during Q3, we experienced withdrawals late in that period — not so much from clients or FBO accounts, but rather, I believe, from corporate crypto cash leaving. That reversed fairly early in Q4. I think you're also attempting to capture the volatility on the deposit side, but as Mark mentioned, we haven't really observed any direct volatility tied to that segment since early in Q4. Part of this, I believe, connects to what was said earlier — it's not merely a holding pen for those moving in and out of currencies; it's also turning into a more fungible holding pen for individuals using a wider range of banking services. So once again, it links to the general purpose reloadable, if you look at where that deposit growth originated.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#18

That helps a lot, thanks. I'm going to step away briefly. Let Alex pose his question, and if I'm able, I'll return afterward.

Alex Lau

analyst
#19

Hi there. Alex here; keeping with GPG and pulling back a bit. Could you speak to the crypto GPR operation? What it involves and, more or less, what's driving it on both the revenue side and deposits? Also, given the Q4 uptick, how sticky are those deposits and that revenue, and does this form a solid foundation to build from as we move into 2022? Thanks.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#20

Our GPR offering mirrors the GPR offerings at the other businesses inside GPG that we serve. Such fintech firms enjoy quite powerful brand recognition, and customers show considerable loyalty toward them. Those firms chose to roll out a prepaid debit card, much like the one each of us carries in our wallet right now, which operates either on Visa or Master card rails. Consequently, if you hold a digital account with one of the exchanges we serve, you essentially possess a debit card plus an ATM card in your wallet, usable at any point of sale. Just as you and I rely on the ATM or debit card sitting in our wallet at present. That's the cross selling occurring from fintech firms possessing powerful brand recognition. Their customers want additional offerings from them — more banking offerings, retail banking offerings — beyond merely purchasing and selling digital assets. In my view, even though crypto has existed for a lengthy — considerably lengthier period than general fintech, I'd say they remain in the opening stages of discovering themselves along with the genuine use case and value proposition that digital assets hold. We believe in its potential. It's too soon for us to forecast where it's headed. We've occupied the crypto arena, so to speak, since 2012. And we've experienced only net expansion in deposits and the fees tied to them, so we'll track the industry. We're thoroughly ready and hold an excellent position alongside the finest crypto firms globally, not merely within this nation. So shortly — within the coming 1 or 2 years, we'll learn whether it keeps establishing itself as a value proposition within financial services.

Alex Lau

analyst
#21

Thank you, Mark. Moving to the question about how sticky those deposits were during the quarter, plus the revenue side. Does this serve as a solid foundation from which to expand as we move into '22? Thanks.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#22

That's a difficult one to answer, since this stands as our sole business line, and Greg, please correct me if I'm wrong here. It's genuinely connected to volatility. Broadly speaking throughout our franchise, we're a growth company, capturing additional market share. Crypto remains quite volatile; thus, as a trading platform, someone who — as a bank assisting with settling transactions for exchanges or trading platforms, we gain from volatility. So I suppose if you're an analyst or investor who believes volatility will increase, well then, deposits will remain sticky and fees will rise. If you think volatility will decrease and assets will gain value, deposits will flow out, yet revenues will climb. We're lucky to possess numerous other deposit verticals you know well, which will keep supplying low cost liquidity to fund the commercial bank over the years ahead.

Greg Sigrist

executive
#23

Yes, and I'd add that this applies beyond the crypto world too — it ties back to a point Mark raised in an earlier response. A number of the fintech companies, or rather some of the crypto businesses we partner with, are making deliberate efforts to expand their offerings into wider banking services. So I believe that, as we apply that same time element and look ahead to how far they can go, if they manage to build out those broader banking products successfully — they've already got the GPR card, along with that capability for their retail customers — and if they succeed in widening their platform, then I think that simply keeps making the related deposits and revenue streams more and more sticky.

Alex Lau

analyst
#24

Thank you. Also, when it came to customers, did you see any kind of concentration with regard to the growth during the quarter?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#25

Once more, given how nascent this sector truly is, my view is that concentration isn't really something that matters at this point. Some fintech firms are spending more than others, and acquiring clients plus converting them differs somewhat depending on that spending and how effective it is. So from a risk standpoint, the answer is no. That said, you obviously have certain leaders in the market right now. And they are plainly the ones driving revenue and deposit growth. However, looking at it through a risk lens, no, there's no concentration risk.

Alex Lau

analyst
#26

Appreciate it. I just have one more quick question, then I'll hand things over to Chris. When it comes to how fast GPG revenue is growing, it's been fairly uneven across this year, so what would be a reasonable yearly growth figure to assume for GPG revenue in the coming year? Thank you.

Greg Sigrist

executive
#27

Yeah. What I do is look at it through a base case and an upside case, Alex. For the base case, which as we've always described represents the worst case, that ought to be our longer-term growth rates from our longer-tenured history. That figure is likely closer to 15 to 20, or perhaps a bit above that range; however, should crypto keep maturing and establishing its identity, and should broader fintechs keep capturing market share from bigger banks as well as smaller community banks, that scenario is the upside one, and it's difficult to put a number on, correct. Still, that — in my view that's entirely positive. Yet even under the base case, the growth outlook remains quite strong.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#28

Right. Alex, like we discussed, the truly intriguing thing regarding fintech as a whole is that their footprint is at the very least nationwide, yet in nearly every instance it's worldwide; thus, my view is that we need 2 more years before we can count on the sort of reliable win rates everyone takes for granted in the conventional setting. As I keep mentioning, they remain so early in this game that should their approach to bringing on clients keep moving at the speed witnessed ever since they arrived on the scene, the expansion rates for this sector will be astonishing.

Alex Lau

analyst
#29

Thanks. I'll wait my turn and come back later.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#30

Hey there. What I wanted to cover was the strategy around deploying securities and handling liquidity in general — clearly, given how deposits rose this quarter, cash climbed further and now makes up 33% of assets. On the securities side, it was encouraging to see such a sizable deployment into the book this quarter, and you're approaching roughly 14% of assets. What's the thinking looking ahead, given you're nearing that 15% target for securities? Could that 15% figure end up being raised? Is this liquidity here to stay, and will deposit growth keep running strong? And longer term, what's the cash balance level you'd consider optimal?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#31

Yeah. That's quite a few questions, Chris. I'd say, looking at the securities portfolio overall, once we reach 15%, which ought to happen during the first quarter — I think you're also dealing with — because of the deposit growth we've seen, it's felt a bit like chasing a runaway train, though that's a nice problem to have. My expectation is we'll get to that 15%, possibly a touch above it, in the first quarter, and then things will pause. Another factor in play is where rates stand. The curves have clearly steepened, particularly in the segment where we've been purchasing, and that's genuinely beneficial; even so, I believe we'll stay disciplined regarding that deployment. Beyond that, with the surplus liquidity, we can expand the loan book — we cited historic rates. Despite fairly robust loan growth, reducing that surplus liquidity will take a while; so my sense is that once we reach the second quarter, around the middle of the year, that's when we'll weigh our choices regarding the surplus liquidity as to whether we add somewhat more to the securities portfolio. If we went that route, I'm sure we'd keep maturities short and wouldn't extend far on duration. As for the ideal composition down the line, I think given — our capacity to keep producing strong organic loan growth at high quality — in my head I aim for 10% to 15%. We'll maintain the balance sheet and preserve its liquidity, just to ensure we retain that firepower for the lending side.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#32

Great. And regarding the securities you folks are placing currently in Q1, what are those yields at now?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#33

Yeah. If you look back at Q4, much of it was because of the extremely volatile rate environment, as you're aware, during Q4. The majority of what we placed was near 150 basis points, and we maintained roughly four years of average duration. Much of what we're examining at present — and I'm certain you're speaking with other banks. You've likely noticed that portion of the curve has steepened 40 basis points since Q4; so a great deal of what we'd be considering sits at 190 basis points to 200 basis points as of now. But once more, there's been considerable volatility in the rate environment.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#34

Great. Thanks; and now switching topics to expenses. What portion of the total increase this quarter is directly connected to something like, revenue growth or compensation tied to revenue growth in this quarter? And then, what's your thinking regarding operating expense growth into 2022 and over a longer horizon?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#35

Yeah, on the compensation side, I'd say nearly all of it came from pay for performance given the strong loan originations we had, and that obviously turned into real bottom line results for us even during the quarter. On top of that, there's the GPG revenue scale we observed, and that's obviously a business with better margins. So my take is that what happened in the quarter was mostly what drove the growth. Broadly, going forward, you're aware that we're a growth company, so costs are going to go up. That said, like Mark mentioned before, we anticipate those investments paying off fairly fast, particularly when it comes to people and tech. Comp lines are set to climb in 2025, and we will certainly be adding headcount. Beyond that — and I believe Mark took you through this from an occupancy standpoint — the build-out is finished, and the bulk of that expense is already reflected in the run rate, though it could rise slightly. Core processing, meanwhile, will rise along with transaction volumes, and clearly the unpredictable piece there is whatever we decide to do with technology. Let me just tackle that head-on. As I see it, that isn't going to be an expense issue going forward. In my view, the money we put into it will stay within reason. As we move through this, we'll provide the figures in writing. More likely, though, that'll be a stretch during which we're covering two licensing fee streams at once. That said, on that front we also have control over our own fate, in terms of the way we roll things out and how we transition into that space. So my sense is it'll be quite manageable. The real constraint for us, I believe, will always come down to delivering positive operating leverage. So when you circle back and verify it, we'll keep pushing to bring the operating efficiency ratio lower as time goes on. Chris, what you could notice is a bit of fluctuation from one quarter to the next — particularly during Q1 — since, as you're aware, employer taxes must be replenished each first quarter. That causes a slight bump upward. Still, looking at the rest of the year, I genuinely believe our emphasis will stay on pushing that figure lower. Where it ultimately ends up is something I'm not in a position to guide you on. You've seen how much improvement we achieved in that area over the last year, or throughout the last 18 months. I cannot guarantee this rate will keep going the way it has, but our focus is entirely on getting a return from the investments we're making.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#36

Great, that's useful. And regarding the occupancy line overall, with the pair of LPOs you folks brought up during the prepared comments — how much are those expansion initiatives simply contributing to costs for the coming year?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#37

Yeah. The bulk of it is already reflected in the run rate. So should we increase from here for those initiatives, it amounts to five or tens of thousands of dollars, not hundreds of thousands of dollars each quarter. So I believe that line will see very, very little impact.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#38

Great. So let me squeeze in one more, and then I'll hand things back to Alex. I really appreciate the detail you provided on Slide 15 regarding margin sensitivity, or NII sensitivity, along with the extra color on deposit betas, but what I'm curious about is the balance sheet in its current state. Do you have a sense of how a plain 25 basis point Fed hike would affect NIM?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#39

Yeah; for that first — for the 100 basis points, it just doesn't scale perfectly because honestly, one wildcard in my view is going to be the loan floors, Alex. Roughly 30% of our total loans, I believe, are loans that have floors; and those loans with floors totaled about $1.1 billion; so about 30% of that won't begin rising off floors until you reach — I think it's 50 basis points up; so if you take that 7.7% first year impact with a higher deposit beta and you sort of — you tilt that somewhat toward the upside — once rates have gone beyond 50 basis. I think you can shape a curve that way, Chris. For this call, we haven't run the back of the envelope math for you, but again, rates need to rise at least 50 basis points before we begin to see — that's when we truly start lifting off the floors and capturing the benefit. That also helps precisely with this one thing, and that also helps tie in explaining the shape when you look at the first 200 basis points on that slide through 2023. That also helps explain, if the floors — their loans rising off the floor is what gives you that extra uplift for that second 200 basis points.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#40

Understood. But what I'm really getting at — let me make sure I've got this right, or put it more simply, and I do appreciate the detail on the floors. Yet setting aside the loan book entirely, just looking at how much cash sits on the balance sheet, my guess is that even a plain 25 basis point increase alone produces a fairly solid NIM lift, and that's before you even reach two hikes needed to lift those loans off the floor, correct?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#41

Yes. In practical terms, Chris, I'd say you've nailed it. Take that initial 225 basis points of rate movement — my view is the industry overall won't budge much when it comes to money market rates or rates on interest bearing deposits. So what you end up with is the earnings benefit from the excess liquidity, and personally, I don't expect to see much of a rise in deposit betas across those first 50 basis points.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#42

Good. Thanks for that context. I'll leave that one for you, Alex.

Alex Lau

analyst
#43

Hi there. When you strip out the effect of loan prepayments, what was the loan yield, and what yields are the new loans being added to the portfolio generating?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#44

As I believe I said during my prepared remarks, if you set aside the unusually high fees this quarter, the loan yield going forward has returned to the 465 range, which matches where it stood in the third quarter, Alex. Newly originated loans have been fairly in line with their historical pattern. So I'd say you're looking at roughly the 458 to 462 range. And each quarter we've seen a bit of prepay fees, which have stayed fairly steady throughout the year, and that's how you arrive at 465 on a run rate basis.

Alex Lau

analyst
#45

Thanks. Turning back to costs, we saw tech spending rise during the quarter. Could you share what that four increase amounted to and whether you anticipate this line item will keep climbing going forward?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#46

Yes, I'd say roughly three-quarters of that rise was simply tied to volume, Alex. What remained was likely some one-off items sitting in there; so with transaction volume holding at the same level, I'd say the run rate is likely somewhat lower than that, just for context.

Alex Lau

analyst
#47

Thanks. Now, turning to loans. Over the last year, how did loan growth split between your New York metro markets and markets outside of that, let's say Florida? And as you open that Florida office, how do you expect that mix to shift?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#48

I'd have to — we didn't separate it out for this meeting, but relying on, obviously, memory, recollecting, thinking about our loan originations. I'd have to say that the bulk of our originations and we can follow up with you on this in more detail. During 2021, the vast majority of what we originated was done outside Manhattan. There wasn't any particular rationale tied to Manhattan — it simply came down to where the opportunities presented themselves to us. So it's clear that most of the loans we originated — corporate, traditional C&I, healthcare, and commercial real estate alike — were located outside Manhattan, with a small portion in the boroughs, though predominantly beyond the metro area. And you brought up Florida — specifically, something about Florida. Remember, one of the main drivers behind opening a Florida office wasn't about chasing extra opportunities. It's essentially a way for us to manage risk, ensuring we keep a close eye on a market that's currently very hot, and we need to be extremely cautious in that space. So a portion of that spending goes toward risk management, not purely toward opportunities.

Alex Lau

analyst
#49

Understood. So, one final item from my side. In what way do you view the primary dangers associated with shifting onto a new core platform, and what is MCB's approach to tackling those so the risk gets minimized? Just to help us reason through it. Thanks.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#50

Yeah. I'll be in a stronger position to genuinely respond to that within the coming few months. Still, based on how it has been described to me, along with what I've now been shown throughout the RFI and the RFP process, I don't perceive the same kind of danger that showed up previously, and this bank has never gone through a significant conversion, or what folks refer to as rip and replace. Our plan does not involve a rip and replace conversion, which would carry greater danger of certain friction arising with that shift of operations. As it has been described to me, and as I've now been examining and studying, it's essentially an infrastructure core built on API, which lets you add best in breed products and services individually and plug in. I know I'm oversimplifying for the technology professionals listening, yet that's my way of viewing it. So I'm cautiously optimistic — I realize I can't say seamless — but I don't perceive any significant danger given how it has been described to me. Another thing I'll mention is that we set up a technology committee internally; one of our new directors brings substantial technology experience, and she serves as the Chair of that committee; other directors also sit on it, along with management. So we are completely involved in this process and the technology underpinning of this franchise, for clear reasons. So plenty of sets of eyes, both within and beyond the Bank, will be watching and managing this; and I believe we'll be the through this by the end of ‘23. Thus it isn't a ‘22 event. It is a second half of ‘22 and ‘23 event. I hope that provides us some line of sight.

Alex Lau

analyst
#51

That clears things up a lot, folks. I appreciate it, and I have nothing further.

Greg Sigrist

executive
#52

Thanks, Alex. We're grateful for that.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#53

Thanks.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#54

So, to wrap things up, I've got one last question here. Could you give me a bit more detail about how you're setting aside reserves for loans coming in right now, and roughly which way you expect that reserve-to-loan ratio to move going forward?

Greg Sigrist

executive
#55

Sure, so what I'd say is this — the cleanup we completed during Q4, and the ARRR (ph) ratio position sitting, I believe, around the mid-90s, that genuinely shows that on a blended basis we are putting reserves aside for newly originated loans, Chris, you're essentially back to a point where you can simply look at it that way right now; and moving ahead, provided macroeconomic conditions keep getting better or, honestly, stay flat rather than decline, I don't anticipate anything shifting in a meaningful way from now until we implement CECL.

Chris O'Connell

analyst
#56

All right, that covers everything from my side. Thanks.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#57

Wonderful, Chris. We're grateful for that.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#58

That's really all I have to close with — I truly appreciate everyone carving time from their schedule to be with us and learn how Met Bank did and where we're headed. Thanks once more, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#59

That wraps up the conference call and webcast for today. You can find a webcast archive of this call at www.MCBankNY.com. At this point, please disconnect your line, and have a wonderful day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp. transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.